George Papazov and Kirk Chisholm discuss hedging S&P 500 futures, retail gambling culture, and market liquidity drivers.
Summary
George Papazov and Kirk Chisholm discuss the structural shift in markets driven by Federal Reserve liquidity, noting that the S&P 500-to-Fed balance sheet ratio has been flat since 2008. Papazov details his use of S&P 500 futures with put spread hedges to manage tail risks, while Chisholm highlights the rise of a 'gambling culture' fueled by prop firms and retail speculation. The hosts contrast long-term value investing with the psychological demands of day trading, warning against the dangers of prediction markets and meme stock frenzies.
Episode sections
- 0:01 – 0:54
Introduction and Industry Shifts
Kirk Chisholm introduces guest George Papazov, discussing his transition from trading education to active trading and content creation, and noting the industry's shift toward quick profits over skill development.
- 0:54 – 2:06
Market Psychology and the 'Fed Put'
Papazov recalls the 2008 financial crisis and the unpreparedness of traders, leading to a discussion on the modern 'Fed put' dynamic where investors expect central bank intervention.
- 2:06 – 3:56
S&P 500 vs. Fed Balance Sheet Correlation
Chisholm presents a chart showing the S&P 500 divided by the Fed's balance sheet has been flat since 2008, suggesting market growth is tied to liquidity rather than organic growth.
- 3:56 – 8:46
Options Strategy: S&P 500 Futures and Put Spreads
Papazov describes his strategy of holding S&P 500 futures while buying put spreads for downside protection, rolling them every 50 points to manage risk and cap upside.
- 8:46 – 14:28
Risk Management and Tail Risks
Papazov discusses managing tail risks during geopolitical volatility, such as Trump's comments on Iran, by pausing strategies and using protective stops.
- 14:28 – 17:25
Trading Psychology and Stress
Papazov argues that trading stress is self-imposed by unrealistic expectations and emphasizes the importance of a structured plan and journaling.
- 17:25 – 20:04
Volume Profile and Order Flow Analysis
Papazov details his day trading strategy using volume profile and order flow analysis to identify entry points with tight stops and trailing targets.
- 20:04 – 27:13
Market Regimes and Investor Wisdom
The hosts discuss the difference between bull and choppy markets, warning against FOMO and citing historical examples like Enron to illustrate the risks of buying dips without due diligence.
- 27:13 – 33:21
Warren Buffett's Underperformance and Market Timing
Papazov and Chisholm discuss Buffett's historical underperformance during bubbles, noting his ability to hold cash and protect capital, which is not replicable by individual investors.
- 33:21 – 36:09
The Rise of Retail Gambling and Prop Firm Culture
Chisholm and Papazov argue that the market has become a 'gambling culture' driven by retail investors and prop firms that profit from trader failure through reset fees.
- 36:09 – 41:23
Social Media Communities and Information Quality
The speakers discuss the value of trading communities, advising against signal-based groups and recommending those that provide diverse data points for independent analysis.
- 41:23 – 43:03
Trading SP 500 Futures vs. Options
Papazov explains that SP 500 futures are his primary trading vehicle, while options are used for specific scenarios due to theta decay challenges.
- 43:03 – 47:39
Zero DTE Options and Gamma Exposure
Papazov notes that Zero DTE options provide valuable data on dealer positioning and gamma exposure, which can help identify support and resistance levels.
- 47:39 – 1:25:19
Day Trading vs. Active Management and Alpha
Barb Freeberg and Doug Hagrin discuss the difficulty of day trading and the potential for alpha in inefficient markets like small-caps and biotech.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| BitcoinBTC | crypto | neutral | Oh, I should have bought Bitcoin at 60 cents. |
| Gold | commodity | neutral | We went from 10 minute videos of gold on YouTube to now 30. second short reels. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
George Papazov started trading in 2001 and started his business in 2012.
George Papazov ·0:34
How to verify: Cross-reference with George Papazov's professional biography on his personal website or LinkedIn profile. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
George Papazov joined the trading desk at Scotia Capital in 2008.
George Papazov ·0:54
How to verify: Verify via George Papazov's LinkedIn profile or professional biography. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The S&P 500 divided by the Fed's balance sheet has been flat since 2008.
Kirk Chisholm ·2:29
How to verify: Calculate the ratio of the S&P 500 index value to the Federal Reserve's total assets (balance sheet) using data from FRED (Federal Reserve Economic Data) and S&P Global. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Value investing has been out of favor for 18-20 years, with performance exceptions in 2000-2002.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·3:30
How to verify: Review historical performance data of value vs. growth factor indices (e.g., Russell 1000 Value vs. Russell 1000 Growth) from 2026 to 2026 using a financial data provider like Bloomberg or Yardeni Research. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Papazov's put spread strategy involves a 50-point spread on S&P 500 futures costing ~$900 to maintain.
George Papazov ·6:12
How to verify: Calculate the cost of a 50-point put spread on ES futures contracts at the time of the interview using CME Group market data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Papazov uses a 3-point stop on ES futures, which is $150 per contract.
George Papazov ·18:55
How to verify: Verify the tick value of E-mini S&P 500 futures (ES) on the CME Group website (50 points per tick). A 3-point move equals $150. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Papazov had a $50,000 losing day on the NASDAQ.
George Papazov ·25:10
How to verify: This is a personal anecdote; verification would require Papazov's personal trading journal or tax records, which are not public. It is a claim of personal experience. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Trump started a war with Iran.
Kirk Chisholm ·25:44
How to verify: Verify via news archives from late 2026/early 2026 regarding US-Iran military conflicts or declarations of war under the Trump administration. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
CQG owns the trademark for the DOM.
George Papazov ·18:36
How to verify: Search the USPTO (United States Patent and Trademark Office) database for trademarks owned by CQG Inc. related to 'DOM' or 'Depth of Market'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Trading Technologies created the DOM.
George Papazov ·18:36
How to verify: Search historical press releases or product documentation from Trading Technologies International Inc. regarding the development of their DOM (Depth of Market) trading platform. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Warren Buffett lent his car to friends without insurance, a practice that would lead to jail time in 2026.
George Papazov ·27:13
How to verify: Verify via Warren Buffett's 2026 Berkshire Hathaway Annual Letter or biographies like 'The Snow Ball' which detail his early personal investment habits and risk tolerance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Berkshire Hathaway lost 18.9% while the Nasdaq surged 75% from 1998 to 2000, underperforming by 93.9%.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·29:40
How to verify: Check historical Nasdaq Composite index data (2026-2026) and Berkshire Hathaway Class A/B share price performance from Yahoo Finance or SEC filings (10-K) for those years. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceFairfax Financial lost 64% during the 1998-2000 period, underperforming the Nasdaq by 139%.
Kirk Chisholm ·29:55
How to verify: Check Fairfax Financial Holdings Limited historical share price data and Nasdaq index data for the period 2026-2026 via financial data providers like Bloomberg or Reuters. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Warren Buffett has been primarily in cash for the last five or six years (as of 2026).
Kirk Chisholm ·30:23
How to verify: Review Berkshire Hathaway quarterly 13F filings and annual letters from 2026-2026 to verify cash and cash equivalents holdings relative to total assets. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceProp firms now charge for sim accounts and reset fees, with some traders losing $30,000 on reset fees without withdrawing profits.
George Papazov ·34:39
How to verify: Search for current terms of service and fee structures of major proprietary trading firms (e.g., FTMO, Topstep) and review trader forums (Reddit r/Daytrading) for anecdotal evidence of reset fee costs. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Zero DTE options data provides insight into dealer positioning and gamma exposure (GEX), influencing futures market pinning.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·43:03
How to verify: Review academic or industry research on 'Gamma Exposure' (GEX) and its correlation with S&P 500 futures price action, particularly around expiration dates, using data from options analytics providers like S&P Dow Jones Indices or Bloomberg. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceMost active large-cap managers lag the S&P 500.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·47:59
How to verify: Consult SPIVA (S&P Indices Versus Active) reports published by S&P Dow Jones Indices, which regularly compare active fund performance against benchmarks like the S&P 500. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Alpha can be generated in small/micro-cap stocks, high-yield bonds, and biotech due to market inefficiencies.
Kirk Chisholm ·53:39
How to verify: Review academic finance literature on 'small cap anomaly' and 'value premium' (e.g., Fama-French factors) and check performance data of active small-cap funds versus large-cap indices. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Nasdaq surged 75% from 1998 to 2000.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·29:40
How to verify: Calculate the percentage change in the Nasdaq Composite Index from the end of 2026 to the end of 2026 using historical data from the Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED) or Yahoo Finance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Berkshire Hathaway lost 18.9% from 1998 to 2000.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·29:40
How to verify: Calculate the percentage change in Berkshire Hathaway Class A or B share price from the end of 2026 to the end of 2026 using historical price data from Yahoo Finance or Berkshire's annual reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the S&P 500 to Federal Reserve Balance Sheet ratio chart using FRED data for the M1 or M2 monetary base and S&P 500 index levels.
- Review Berkshire Hathaway's annual shareholder letters for 1999 and 2000 to confirm the 18.9% loss figure and compare it against Nasdaq Composite performance data.
- Analyze the fee structures of major proprietary trading firms to understand the 'reset fee' model and its impact on trader profitability.
- Check the latest Federal Reserve balance sheet reports to assess current liquidity levels and their correlation with recent S&P 500 movements.
- Research the performance of value vs. growth factor indices over the last two decades to validate the claim that value investing has been out of favor.
- Examine the terms and conditions of prediction market platforms like Polymarket or Kalshi to understand the house edge and payout structures.
- Review SEC filings for major asset managers to identify cash positions and portfolio rotations during periods of market underperformance.
- Assess the risk management protocols of day trading strategies, specifically the cost of hedging with put spreads versus the potential for gap risk during geopolitical events.
Full transcriptexpand
0:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Welcome to the Money Tree Investing Podcast. Stock market, wealth, personal finance, value stocks. Invest in your life.
0:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hello,
0:11Kirk Chisholm: Smart Manager Podcast listeners. Welcome to this week's show. My name is Kirk Chisholm, and I'll be your host. So today I'm joined with George Papazoff.
0:18George Papazov: Hey, how you doing, Kirk?
0:19Kirk Chisholm: Good, yourself?
0:21George Papazov: I'm doing awesome, man. The day has arrived.
0:24Kirk Chisholm: Yeah, finally here.
0:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Tell
0:26Kirk Chisholm: us a little bit about. your background.
0:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
0:27George Papazov: I've kind of gone through a pretty big transition. I've actually stopped doing the business side of all this stuff.
0:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh,
0:32Kirk Chisholm: you have a podcast as well?
0:34George Papazov: Yeah, I had a podcast. I'm just kind of focusing on trading and doing content for fun. The industry's changed a lot. I started trading in 2001 and then the business in 2012. And the way things have shaped out the last since COVID, it's been crazy. Everyone just wants to gamble. People get into the trading education for the wrong reason. They want to make money. And it's like they're getting in early when they should still be learning. I was on the trading desk, Scotia Capital, and for me it was like purpose driven. I remember in 08, I joined the trading desk, and then people were just getting annihilated with the housing bubble. And I was putting out a podcast or not podcast, but at the time it was a blog. And man, it was so frustrating. Nobody was listening. It was like there's a top here, you know. at least consider some protection. And then I'm on the phone call on the trading desk, people getting blown out, margin calls, dark times.
1:22Kirk Chisholm: I know I've been doing this since 99. I've seen a few of these.
1:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh, you know,
1:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): yeah.
1:27Kirk Chisholm: 99. I was sitting there, the market started to drop, and the manager's like, Oh, good, it's a dip. We can buy. I'm like, I don't think so. This doesn't seem like a dip to me. And it kept going down. He kept saying, bye, bye, bye. I'm like, nope.
1:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): When everyone gets conditioned, they expect a certain dip. And when they start measuring it, six percent drop. This is the buying opportunity. That's when I'm like, we got something to learn
1:48George Papazov: coming up
1:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): here.
1:49Kirk Chisholm: I know we're seeing that now. And it's kind of like uh this buy the dip. The one thing that I struggle with is the whole concept of this time, it's different. In some ways, it is. I hate to say that because of the term itself is just. humorous, but in some ways it is. The markets have changed a lot.
2:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh,
2:06George Papazov: 100%. Yeah. I mean, there's so much retail participation. And I think one of the biggest changes that like people aren't the flew under the radar a little bit is the new Fed chair. Because you look at Bernanke stepping in with a TARP package in 09. They've been involved in the market since it's become like the Fed put. I try to like do a calculation of what the S P should be trading at without the Fed, but it's hard. Too many assumptions.
2:29Kirk Chisholm: There was a chart the other day that actually talked about that. And it was, let me see if I can bring it up. The S P divided by the Fed's balance sheet. And basically since 2008, it's been more or less flat.
2:40George Papazov: Wow. That's crazy.
2:42Kirk Chisholm: So there was a period from 2016 16 to 2020, right around COVID, where it was going up and then it dropped. like a rock, and then it's been flat. And then in the last since 2023, it's been going up. This only goes to 24. But point being is when you see stuff like that, it's like okay. And then you see prior to 2008 and it the SP is normal, but after that, it's just been like basically all Fed balance sheet.
3:09George Papazov: And Look at the
3:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Fed balance sheet, all debt driven, which is great if you have growth. The moment growth falls off. that whole thing.
3:16Kirk Chisholm: According to this, there is no growth.
3:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's
3:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): crazy.
3:18Kirk Chisholm: That's what this shows. I mean, there's no growth. Now, granted, there is, but not broad-based. Yeah,
3:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): there's growth in like earnings and stuff, but valuations are definitely way more stretched. If you're a value investor in today's society, like where's the value?
3:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like
3:30George Papazov: there's
3:31Kirk Chisholm: value has been out of favor for 18 eighteen years, 20 twenty years.
3:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There
3:37Kirk Chisholm: have been some years here and there. but for the most part, it's been out of favor for most of my career, except for like the first few years, 2000, 2001, 2002. Value did okay. But outside of that, there may be one other year. Value performed. It's hard.
3:51George Papazov: Kind of just got to chase that momentum and you know, for the best, protect yourself.
3:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What
3:55Kirk Chisholm: kind of investing do you do?
3:56George Papazov: I do kind of like very passive stuff. I do like ETF based investing. So I do VOO a lot in that and then add a couple. names here and there. But I mostly run options too. I'll run options for extra dividend yield, but in a unique way I do options on the S P 500 futures. I'll run like put spreads and roll them up and out. I have a lot in passive stuff and then the active component is getting on the ES like the S Best and P P500 500 futures trying to ride a leg up but with protection to kind of increase that. So
4:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're
4:27Kirk Chisholm: basically doing you're not doing covered calls, but you're doing kind of a version of that. So you buy the index and then you're selling put spreads. Is that accurate?
4:36George Papazov: Well, actually, I'm buying the put spread. So I'll get the index long and buy the put spread for like a downside protection window, usually about 50 point spread. And that takes away the upside, obviously, Side but it gives you a hedge portion for 50 points. Really, where it unravels is you have to roll quarterly. you roll into the futures early, and then it just gets hit. Like you start selling. That's where it kind of falls apart because you got to keep rolling the 50 points down. Sometimes a drop is more than 50, so you're uncovered. So I buy the put spread to give me the downside protection, and I roll it every 50 points, 50 up.
5:07Kirk Chisholm: So what's your time frame you do it in? The put spread doing like a month?
5:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
5:12George Papazov: like it where delta's around like 70 on. the put. So yeah it's around like three weeks, four weeks, and then I layer them. After two weeks I close it out. Two weeks set an inspiry I don't want that theta burn.
5:23Kirk Chisholm: 70 Delta, you're you're in the money.
5:26George Papazov: Yeah, I'm paying a lot. To
5:27Kirk Chisholm: me that would seem like you'd be losing money consistently with that strategy. It's
5:32George Papazov: not a 70 delta tech The technique because the long is at the lock level. So let's say SP goes up 50 points. Let's use a 7600 as an example. We haven't gotten there. Let's say 7500. So it crosses above 7500. So I'll get long the 7500 put and sell the 7450. So it's very close to market, almost at the money level, as close to the at the money as possible to give me that downside protection. And then if it goes up another 50, I'll roll that spread, sell it, roll it up 50 points. And the offset is the ES being up 50 points is $2,500. On average, it put spreads around 900 to maintain. So you're kind of capping your upside at for $2,500, you're paying $900 for the protection.
6:15Kirk Chisholm: But you have a 50-point spread that's less than 1%. You're losing money as the market goes up, and the downside you have very minimal protection.
6:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
6:26George Papazov: depends. because I layer them. So like let's say this week I'll do one and then next week it'll have, let's say it's gone up. I'll leave it on sometimes depending on what volatility looks like VIX and what my outcome is. And two like the thing to this strategy is it's pretty active. So it's passively designed but you have to adjust
6:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
6:43George Papazov: as soon as you drop below the 50 points. Like I said the worst situation is you open the strategy and it's right away and you're put protection. because you're right, it doesn't give you one to one. You're losing money on the ES dropping and the put spreads not making it up one to one.
6:58Kirk Chisholm: I guess what I'm trying to understand is covered call strategy. You're giving up the upside and you have a minimal protection on the downside, but you're doing it in such a way so you're assuming that it's not going to get called away. That's your assumption.
7:09George Papazov: Exactly. Yeah.
7:10Kirk Chisholm: Let's just say we're doing it a at 30 delta. So you're giving up some upside in the extreme, but for the most part, you're just minting nickels. Right.
7:17George Papazov: You
7:18Kirk Chisholm: know, on the downside, selling covered calls, I get similar strategy selling covered calls, but you're buying put spreads that don't protect you for a big sell-off. You're basically giving up your upside. And I guess what I'm trying to understand is what is the purpose of this? Because if you're not protecting against downside, which is kind of in this market. it's 70 or 80% of the time the market goes up. So you're consistently losing and you're giving up gains. Like, what is it getting you? Like what is the trade-off? Because everything's a trade-off, right? So what is the trade-off you're taking?
7:51George Papazov: Well, the upside is like if you get 100 points on the SP on one single contract, it's $5,000. So you would probably lose a put spread cost base of you know $1,600. on that if you roll and it goes your way. But it is a directional strategy. So it matters when you get in and how you manage it. So that's why
8:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
8:09George Papazov: I'm a day trader. So that's kind of like my passive approach to it. But I day trade futures with order flow. So I find levels in the book that's there's a mismatch, a balance, there's opportunities levels. I use volume profile as well to target certain levels. So it allows me to kind of be find good. levels where I don't the put spread is just protection in the event things go down. I often spend that money and waste it if quote unquote.
8:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
8:36Kirk Chisholm: what you're doing is not for the everyday person. You'd have to really be tied into the mechanics of how the markets are operating to really put on a strategy. You're trying to, as you said, you're day trading.
8:46George Papazov: It's a step up above day trading. It's one of those things where when I'm off the computer, I don't have to. worry about it as much. You'd have to go deep in the weeds, you know, like order flow analysis and really be good at day trading first to run it. It's not everyday strategy for sure.
8:58Kirk Chisholm: So do you worry about the tail risks, the black swan events? Do you worry about that with the strategy? Because if you just buy in the index and you're holding the index for long periods of time, what do you do when the markets get squirrely?
9:10George Papazov: The biggest risk periods are especially with Trump. I've kind of paused the strategy for the last. two and a half months or so because there's been a lot of volatility. Everything he says with Iran is impactful, right? So in those periods, like Friday night to Sunday and the reopen at 6 p.m. Eastern on the Globex reopen, that's the risk. So I do worry about tail risk. And like I said, it's the initiation that's key. So like if you get in, let me just back it a little. So I have a protective stop as well in the future position. So if it's it drops 50 points, you hedge once, you drop another 50 at 100 points, you blow out. But the key here is to get the first 50 points in the book. Because if you start it out and it immediately goes down, your put spreads generating some return, but you have the cost of put spread, the return is low, and you're getting creamed on the yes futures, right? $50 a point. So quarterly, when it the futures kind of cycle and the last quarter expires, you go to the next one, you have to really find a good level to initiate the quarterly strategy. Otherwise, you don't. So I have a protective stop. It's a hundred points. If I haven't locked in a hundred points to the upside yet, there's risk for sure. And I manage it with size.
10:17Kirk Chisholm: So why even bother buying the ES or the VOO? Why not just do the put spreads?
10:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
10:22George Papazov: I guess because they only work on the downside, right? You'll be expiring them quite often. When I worked at Scotia, I moved to sales, kind of work with branches. And I showed them this chart where like this is the upside of the market and this is the downside. And I'd flip it and I'd tell them downsides like this is what you're worried about, small portion, and you're giving up all these gains. So yeah, it just goes down less. And if you're just long a put spread, then you're kind of negative delta, right? Looking the downside. It's more of a protection mechanism than without the long ES. it just becomes kind of a short strategy.
10:53Kirk Chisholm: You're really not that worried about the big moves as a day trader. You're basically picking your spots and you're targeting certain things that make sense. But overall, you're just you're kind of long and strong, and then you just you pick up nickels along the way as much as you can.
11:07George Papazov: And it's like I'm in front of the computer, I only really worry when I step away, you know, and I have notifications, etc. et cetera. It's really like a very bull market strategy. If it's sideways or you're starting to see some downside levels break, you don't hope to have these put spreads get activated because it's not a full hedge. It just gives me peace of mind when I walk away because the moment I'm detached from the chart, I get anxiety, you know, as a day trader.
11:28Kirk Chisholm: Yeah, I would imagine. So what do you do in a bear market? You just take off your long S P position?
11:34George Papazov: I just close it out. If I have to hedge it twice or more, it's a 100 hundred points, five 5,000 thousand a contract loss. I'll just take it out. And then really where the beauty of it is it pairs with the day trading because if it gets to the point where the strategy has to blow out at a loss, the day trading gain is made up for it. I'm already on the short, a lot more active. So then they kind of just go day trading mode, like let's ride this momentum. Like these downside moves are very, very opportunistic for day trading. And I started, like I said, my career started. in 08, 09. This is like excited, eager kid to get into trading. I started with a massive bear market. So it's ingrained in me to kind of always have slightly, how do I say it, slightly questioning outlook on everything. And I always the fear in the back of my mind's always there, right? Like this could always get hit. Like markets sell off at highs. That's what happens. Crashes don't happen from lows, they happen from highs.
12:25Kirk Chisholm: It's interesting how. your investor psychology is colored by when you start. I mean, I started in December of 99. So my bias is risk management because for three years, risk management was all you had to do because the markets went down. And if you lost less, you won, which is
12:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what I
12:45Kirk Chisholm: was being told. And at the time I thought it was a win. You know, markets are down 25 and I'm down 15. That's a win. That's not a win, but in that construct of how people thought it was a huge win. But if somebody had started 1990, all they know is the markets go up.
13:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
13:00Kirk Chisholm: if you started in 2009 and after, markets always go up. They never go down. It was 17 years now that the market's been going up and not going down. That's crazy.
13:11George Papazov: It gets complacent, right? You get rewarded for buying the dip and you don't know you're missing half of the data set, which I would argue is the most important. And really, like starting in a crash has been the entire focus of me on risk management. I always know in the back of my mind what could happen. And you look at a lot of people that got into investing in COVID, all you've had to do since COVID was just buy the dips. I think the market has a way of humbling people out. The only time I'm afraid in the market is when there's nothing to be afraid about. I love that people are scared about AI. you know, like this whole industry, the cap accent. I love it. That's great. It has you have to be scared of something to have upside. It's when the complacency hits, even as a day trader, where you're like, there's a saying like it's too late to be long and too early to be short. Some days you're just on the outside looking in. Like today was a good example. Thing ripped. Couldn't get on board until the pullback. It's so amazing where you start, the brush paints your career for the whole time. I'm actually blessed and happy. Those days were dark on the desk in 09 taking customer calls, but looking at it in hindsight, it was kind of like a blessing to start there. You know, get the hard stuff out of the way.
14:14Kirk Chisholm: I imagine day trading is very stressful. And as you said, it is. There's so many strategies you can use out there, and some are not as stressful. Why not consider other strategies that are maybe less stressful? for you?
14:28George Papazov: Stress isn't really derived from the strategy. If you have a Formula One vehicle in your driveway, that's not stressful. It's when you get behind the wheel that you realize all these buttons do stuff. And it's like, great, now I'm responsible for this two million, three million dollar car. So the stress factor is self-imposed by traders. I think there's a number of things that work, but the biggest one is when you get in with the wrong idea of what the career is going to be like, when you have expectations at the beginning without knowing about it, it becomes a case of what I'm doing isn't what I expected to do. Case in point, you start day trading today, next month you're going to be looking at yachts. This is how we've been conditioned. But really the stress isn't the strategy, it's the operators. So for me, I'm not out here looking to make these big swings and big outsize payoffs. I'm just looking to get into risk managed positions at the right levels. So I can tell you that the days that are stressful are far less than the days that are like become easy for me because I've done it for so long. I have a good structured plan. And we could talk about the plan. I have no like secret sauce. But the days that are difficult are the days where I'll look back and pinpoint where I made the decision to not follow the plan. And as much as as people will make excuses for why things didn't work, at the end of the day, that's how it breaks down. Like
15:47it's not the plan. It's how well did you execute it? I could show you a journal. I have a 14 page journal of market prep and then post market analysis and breakdown that I do every single day for myself. So it's stressful if you get into something that you're not fully understanding how to control and work with as a tool.
16:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): When
16:04Kirk Chisholm: it comes to like risk and stress, like what are you most afraid of in the markets?
16:09George Papazov: Myself. Honestly, Kirk. I know it sounds so cheesy, but it's like when I have five, six winning days, and this just happened yesterday. I have five, six, seven, ten winning days, I kind of get stressed out of the fact that, like, okay, is it the strategy? Is it me overrisking? You start to kind of be skeptical. of it a little bit, right? You have a good run. It's not starting to feel like, oh, anything I touch, like the Midas touch, is turning to gold. Let me increase the size. The stress to me is when I'm actually doing good, to be honest with you. I'm trying to understand, am I deviating from not every winning day is a good day in trading. Sometimes your losing days are good days. So I try to understand: am I running the strategy or am I running away from it and getting lucky? So that to me is the biggest stress. But in terms of like the actual execution, I have a defined point risk per trade. I have exact locations I'm gonna trade. And that's all done pre market. I know exactly what I'm gonna do where, and when it gets there, it almost becomes robotic. It's like sports. You can plan at the end of the day, but the way
17:09that the game goes is its own thing. So I don't want to say I'm not stressed, but I would say it's not as stressful. as people would assume it is if you have strategy, tactic, and your control of yourself. It's cheesy as it sounds.
17:22Kirk Chisholm: When you're trading, do you have targets you shoot for?
17:25George Papazov: Yeah. So I'll explain the strategy if you want.
17:27Kirk Chisholm: Yeah, please do.
17:28George Papazov: It's volume profile base. I look for two things. Number one is location. So in the morning I have locations where I'm willing to put risk on. It's important you find them before the trading day starts because as the day develops, locations that you find intraday might just be you expressing emotion through your trading. When I start the morning, all my levels are set. If the price is not at this level, I have no trade. I literally stay here and I'm like on X. I got two young kids. I'll go play with them in the kitchen for a bit. And then once the level is hit, this is all based on volume profile. So I look at the distribution of volume. I'm looking for areas where there's balance. I'm looking for the market to retest balance areas. And then when it gets out of balance, either a continuation or a failure. Well, these levels will generate trades. And then I wait for price to get in that level.
18:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
18:16George Papazov: this is where the sauce is, I guess, for me, and what I've developed myself to be good at over the last quarter century is order flow. I open up the book, I look at trades, I look at the DOM, the depth of market. level two, the ladder, whatever you want to call it, the vertical ticket. Shout out to CQG. They actually own the trademark for the DOM. They created actually no, it was trading technologies. So I use that basically to find areas where there's buyers moving out, moving into the market if I'm gonna be along. I want to see sellers hitting the book but not getting any lower absorption. There's a number of different order flow concepts that pinpoint the moment. It's like it's time to get long with a three-point stop. Like I use three points on DES, 150 a contract. If I put 20 on, it's scalable risk. 3,000 per trade.
19:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
19:02Kirk Chisholm: if you're looking at that kind of a thing, you're saying 3,000 trade or three point stop. Do you have a target on the upside or does it depend on the trade?
19:10George Papazov: I kind of have the package, but as I fill, like if I get a full fill, sometimes we get you partial. fills, you know, you have an idea of what it should happen, but reality is always different. It's always a unique situation every trade. But yeah, I have a target of four points initial, eight points, twelve points, and then the last is a runner, meaning that I'll scale out and I try to build out the R the risk to reward to be, you know, with a 40% win rate to give me a break-even. break even. Those really big runaway trades, those outsized. profitable days aren't by design. And I don't know when they're gonna happen. People love to ask, like, should I buy today? Like, I honestly don't know. I know there's a level, I know I could get four points, eight points, twelve points. And then it's kind of the market gods plan from there on the runner. I manage the runner to trail up with the stop rather than have a target. So I have an open target on it. To me, the philosophy is get on base, get paid, let the runner do the work for. free. That's the goal.
20:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
20:04Kirk Chisholm: know, if you look at somewhat recent events, like up until February of this year, up till the war started, I would say from September until then, it felt very obvious that anybody could win, right? Everything was going
20:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): up except for
20:17Kirk Chisholm: big tech. But other than that, like everything was going up and everybody felt like a hero. And I knowingly knew that was going on. I was like, this feels really good. I know it's not me. I know it's the market, but damn, it feels good. You know? Yeah,
20:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): yeah, exactly. Don't confuse bulls for brains, right? Yeah.
20:33Kirk Chisholm: And then the war started, everything changed, and the markets have become very different. And virtually everybody I've spoken to on this podcast is in the same boat. They're like, we're treading water up a little, down a little, but basically we're not making any progress this year. The indexes are not indicative of how everybody's doing performing. performance-wise, because it's mostly through semis. But if you're in semis, you're doing great. For a lot of people, it's hard because, you know, I get this question a lot from clients. Why are we not getting similar returns to the index? To sit there and explain the mechanics of the system, you can't. I think one of the challenges, if you're investing in the index, then you don't have clients. But if you're investing in the index, then you're getting similar returns. But if you're not, if you're a value investor, people have been pissed at you for like 20 years because value's been out of favor, even though it's a viable strategy. But at the same time, it's been out of favor. Why not just put it all in big tech and let it ride? You know?
21:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Do
21:30Kirk Chisholm: you ever get tempted by that kind of a thing? Like when you start to see these sectors just blow up and semi companies are going up hundreds of percent. in a year. And do you ever get tempted to to tie into that? It's pretty luring.
21:44George Papazov: Oh, a hundred percent. Right. And I guess the thing that kind of comes to mind there is this whole like I'm always afraid when nobody else is, when all the posts are coming out of semis, did like so fantastic. I think if it's like the trader mindset is in me is when you get into the position, it should still feel risky. You should explain it to 10 people and five of them should think you're nuts. When you get into a position at the tops, if 10 people think, yeah, you should be long, ha ha, then to me that's a big red flag. So I mean, leading up to February was a very interesting market because the one that benefits investors the most is the most challenging for day traders. That perma bid, like on the open, we bid up 30 points. We don't let back more than three. points, and we close 100 points higher. Those are actually very difficult markets to day trade. Because first of all, they happen 30% of the time, right? It's a loosely thrown around number, but on my stat book, around 36% of the time you have these, not recently since the war, but up until then, big follow through days of continuation, and then we go to consolidation. So these kind of big days is so hard for me to jump on board because I'm gonna either pay the top or end up being rewarded for buying the momentum. But at the end of the day, if I get used to buying tops, am I really being rewarded? The PL's there. But the next day I do that, I'm gonna give all that money back. So really
23:04for the temptation, we've been in the markets together a long time. If we combine our years, I don't even want to do
23:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it. We
23:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): both have gray hair, you know what I mean?
23:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm assuming
23:14George Papazov: this is all all we've done our adult working life, right? So I just know what happens when that kind of narrative unfolds. And yes, I do get in moments where I'm like, I should have bought AI like lower. Oh, I should have bought Bitcoin at 60 cents. How about that one? That's the one we should regret the most. You know what I mean?
23:29Kirk Chisholm: Yeah.
23:30George Papazov: I do get in these moments, but then I look back at it and it's like, Look, I've been doing this long enough that I have to credit what I've been doing to be some. of the key to longevity. Let me not change the playbook of something that's worked for so long and really just stick to the guns. It's like, hey, I missed it, but how many companies have been listed that have been delisted and gone bankrupt? There's a selective vice. The only companies that you could see where buying dips would have worked work are they're the ones that are live. What about the Enron? What if you bought the dip there? So I just remind myself that the companies that look great at the moment, it's not a missed opportunity. It's actually information for continuation. So what I'll do when I have these moments of it's a trendy play, I didn't get on board, I'll pull up a chart and I'll say, all right, I missed it. But if I was long, where would I have my stop loss? Where would I want to get out of this trade? And I'll start leveling it on the way up to find entries on the pullback. Missed opportunities don't spark me to take action. They just get me
24:30to take that data set and say, all right, instead of calling it missed the opportunity, this is information. Let me map out this information and put a playbook for when it comes down and get a chance to buy it. But yeah, it's tempting man. It's tough. Those emotions, I know those emotions, if they start sneaking into what I do as day trading, investing is a little different because you have the ability to close things off and then check on it in a week. Day trading is like I'm in a trade and by the end of the day, I'm in cash. The score is settled before the day ends. So it's like I really can't take these emotions and put them in my approach because it's I know what happens. I have the data. I have a $50,000 losing day on NASDAQ. Felt like I missed it, started dumping. I was buying it, I missed the signal to. sell instead. I'm buying it, getting stopped out, buying it, getting stopped out. And then I looked at it. And when the emotion wore off, I'm like, my whole pattern
25:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): was there for the short.
25:24Kirk Chisholm: Yeah. You do this long enough and you get a like a sixth sense of things. You know, this year started off hot. First two months were hot until the war. And it seemed like nothing could go wrong. It was just markets were rotating. Everything was healthy. Like it was just a great time to be in. And then Trump effed it up by starting a war. And everything's been crappy since and just unpredictable. And it's funny because going into the year, I felt like this year, second year of presidential cycle, I thought it'd be a flat year, a lot of volatility. I did think there'd be volatility, but it'd be flat. And we've seen that. Market was up two, three percent, then the war happened, it was down 10. Now it's up 10. Now it's up six, or whatever it is today. But you look at it and like it's all over the place, but the market's not really making progress, it's marking time. Some years it feels like things just go up every day, just goes up a little bit, goes up a little bit, just keeps plugging away. You know, I talk to a lot of investors and traders. There needs to be a certain, I call it a sixth sense, but it needs to be a certain level of wisdom in what
26:24you're doing because there's so many. different ways you can invest. There's tons of different ways you can day trade, tons of different ways you can swing trade or whatever, like all these different strategies. And there's a lot of ways that work. And then there's, of course, there's some that don't. But for the most part, people hear somebody like yourself and like, I'm gonna try that. That sounds awesome. And it doesn't fit with them. And they're
26:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like,
26:45Kirk Chisholm: Well, George is lying, it doesn't work. Well, it does work, it just didn't work for you, right? It's like Warren Buffett. one of the most, if not the most successful investors of modern era. And yet people can't invest like him. You know, like it's because you're not Warren Buffett. And even if you were as as smart as Warren Buffett, although he has faltered a lot in the last 20 years, but even if you were as smart as Warren, like you sitting on your hands for like 10 years is not really a viable strategy for most people.
27:13George Papazov: Warren Buffett's genius. but at the time that he started, too, I remember reading his book, and he said he lended his car out to his friends without insurance and all that. You would go to jail doing that. Like so quick in 2026. Look, for me, with all this, yeah, like strategies work. I think the problem is we try this is day trading related because there's two ways to do this. One way is I'm gonna trust somebody, give them the capital, but if you're gonna do that, like really do it. Like if the index is up and your assets aren't up as much, it's like, well, why isn't my money up? Well, it's because the fund manager is trying to protect you. We're trying to rotate, and I'm rotating around truth social posts, you know. Like one day the war is on. I tell my traders that we have a little community, it's all free. I don't sell anything, I'm solely off of income off trading. We kind of connected and we trade together. And I tell my traders, it's like, guys, I as hard as this day trading job seems, believe me, it's not easier the more money you have. They're having one hell of a time right now. It's like you have to shift and rotate so many assets, but that rotation creates the volatility and order flow that helps day traders. So for me, it's been kind of a good period, but I wouldn't tell anyone to mistake day trading as an easy way to make money. It's the hardest money you'll ever make. The only reason I'm here, Kirk, is because I'm stupid enough to believe I could do it. And like the amount of times I've banged my head off
28:32the keyboard and failed, when I look at all the data set, it was always me. It was always me trying to force things. Comes a point in your trading career where you're like, I'm gonna stop trying to emulate other people and I'm gonna just take information and make my own way. And that's when you start finding out what it's about. But yeah, like managing money right now is probably the most difficult job ever since February, right? Since the war, it's the amount of times I've been in front of the computer setting up a long, and all of a sudden I have a news squawk running that breaks news for me. It's actually called New Squawk. Shout out to them, great platform. They'll be like, Donald Trump says, and I stop, I'm like, cancel all the orders. Like, I don't know what
29:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): he's gonna say.
29:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): You know what I mean?
29:11George Papazov: It's hard to have conviction when you don't really have control. And it's even harder to explain that to client. I may not have control, but the reason your money is with me and I don't manage money, I'm just putting myself in that seat, is there's trust. Like you said, there's a sixth sense. You're trying to make them the most money, but it's the fact that you remember what happened in 1999, what happened in 2009, what happened in 2020. That's really where the value is coming, that experience.
29:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm trying to
29:37Kirk Chisholm: find the that chart here. but I was talking to somebody about
29:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this
29:40Kirk Chisholm: and how in nineteen ninety-nine,
29:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): ninety-eight
29:44Kirk Chisholm: to
29:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): two
29:44Kirk Chisholm: thousand, the Nasdaq surged seventy-five percent. Over the same period, Berkshire lost 18.9%, underperforming the index
29:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): by
29:52Kirk Chisholm: 93.9%.
29:54George Papazov: That's crazy.
29:55Kirk Chisholm: Fairfax Financial, the Berkshire of Canada, lost 64% during that period, underperforming by 139%. And I had to pull a data in because everyone's like, oh, Warren Buffett's out of touch. And what I find interesting is there are certainly long periods where people say that. I mean, you think about Buffett before 2008. Buffett for the last like five or six years has been primarily in cash. That's a long period to underperform the markets. But the challenge is, and I think Warren Buffett has lost as his mojo long ago, you know, 20 years plus. And I think in many ways he got lucky at the beginning because of the timing. He also has a business model that none of us can replicate. If I want to invest a million dollars, I need to borrow a million dollars. I need to pay six, seven percent to borrow that million. Warren Buffett gets paid 6%, 10% to borrow money and to go invest it. We don't have the same business model. So you can't replicate Warren Buffett unless you're investing in Berkshire. His returns and initially were great because he found the right companies at the right time. You think of the 70s, like the
31:03best time to invest was like late 70s. The ratios were insanely low for everything. I think back, I'm like, oh God, I can't wait till we get that again. But you look at 2008, you look at 2000, never even got close to those. Yeah.
31:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): We've never got back down there.
31:17Kirk Chisholm: We were never going back there if we didn't get there in 2000 to 2003 and like in 2008. Like if we're not doing that, we're definitely not getting there now. But it's fascinating because when you think of the psychology of people and you look at this year, like I said, every successful portfolio manager I know, and I mean day trades, I mean portfolio managers with large amounts of money. they're all flat or down a little bit. It's a terrible year. And what I've learned over the years is when things aren't working, you stop doing stuff. Like you just sit in the sidelines. Yeah.
31:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You wait
31:49Kirk Chisholm: until it becomes more clear and things become more normal. Because at times things are gonna work that you're not good at. For whatever reason, like tech is my white whale. I'm great at in a lot of areas, but like big tech. April to May, when semis went straight up and nothing else did. It's really hard to justify that. Some people are just buying the dips all the time. And for me, it's just intellectually I struggle with holding my nose and like buying that.
32:16George Papazov: Well, you know what? That's actually a great sign because that shows responsibility, right? Like obviously, the people who chase tech with missing completely the risk that they're taking along with it. Because remember, just because you're making money doesn't mean you're not taking big risks too. You're just ignoring it. Don't confuse bulls for brains. Or the market's going up and you're doing something, it works. You think you're a genius. It's like when they jump on board these trends, they're going to post these statements. I think this is where you said psychology, it's spot on. People with social media are sharing such selective information that it makes other people feel like they're behind, but it's based on something that's not even the complete picture. Because if you're just recklessly chasing rallies and buying tops, it's gonna work sometimes. It's great to see those results on X and Instagram and people flexing on you. But remember with Bitcoin, you had people who knew nothing about the asset going from Lamborghinis to riding a bicycle in a quick matter, right? So it's like the psychology of today's world is everyone's story is selected. selectively cropped and posted and it's creating urgency that's like a false sense of urgency. Like you don't have to chase a
33:21Kirk Chisholm: we've become a gambling culture. You know, the markets have always been gambling, but it now it seems like retail it's become so easy that retail feels like that they're rock stars. And it never used to be that. You know, the markets were more stable and now you've got memes. meme stocks going to the moon just because you got enough people in there saying we're gonna do this and put 100% of our money in and make it or lose it. It's a struggle because gambling and speculating is a normal part of the markets. People don't like it when the markets go down, but when they go up, nobody cares. Do you think it's different or getting worse?
33:59George Papazov: From my perspective, it's getting worse. From the money management aspect. your clients will never call. Well, they might, a couple, but they'll never call you and say, Great job, you're doing fantastic. Your phone blows up when the market goes down 1%. I think it's getting worse. And I think it's not only getting worse investing-wise, which has always had a component of gambling, right? No matter how much I convince myself I have edge and all that, like the job is still technically putting on risk, and you're gambling, you're taking a shot. But I think it's permeated into like society as a whole. It's slightly border rent here, but look at the trading industry. Prop firms. What was a prop firm back in the day? What you remember it being as a prop firm Kirk is completely different nowadays. Like you have to pay to be at a prop firm. I get it. You used to have to pay for your seat and the data fees, and you had to make a certain threshold just to have the job. But now it's like everyone's paying for a sim account, then they're paying to reset and they're paying all this money. And I've had people I've talked to in my journey that one guy's like, I'm down $30,000 on prop firm reset fees and I've never pulled money out of it. So it's like, all right, well, that's unfortunate. Because if you would have just put that 30K, if you had it into like a passive index, no matter where you put it into, you'd be better off. But that culture goes even deeper. Turn on your TV, sports gambling, sports betting, polymers. polymarket. There's a book for everything. And I don't know what it is. I can't
35:19put my finger on it, but everyone is just taking these gambles that make the job so much harder. Because if you're gambling, you don't have an edge or a strategy, it's not going to work out. These short-term successes will always revert to the mean of loss. So I think gambling gambling's has blown up a lot. And to be honest with you, I don't think it's helping people. They seem to be leaning on it. and finding people who are like them who are over gambling and just hoping for the best and ignoring the advice of people who have been around a long time or they even talk about risk. It's sad.
35:49Kirk Chisholm: You said you're part of a community. Do you find that community helps or hurts? Because I know so far in the last, I don't know, seven months, whatever it is this year, I get on X once in a while because frankly, if there's any news, like I'll follow. certain sites there or certain like subscribers because I know the news is it's as solid as I can get it. There's certain publications you're you don't know if it's true, but you know that at least it's being truthful.
36:15George Papazov: Exactly. You know,
36:16Kirk Chisholm: because Trump might be lying to you and they're reporting that, but at least they're not fake news. They're just reporting what they're hearing. I follow some of those just to see what's going on because I don't watch the news at all.
36:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like I
36:25Kirk Chisholm: never watch the news because it's all B. BS. However, you also, when you're there, you see a lot of garbage there, and you see, you know, there's a lot of flexing and all this stuff, and like I could care less about any of that. And it starts to pollute your mind. But there's like a community or two that I joined briefly because I just want to see what people are talking about. Because they've got those live shows on X, and you just kind of listen to what people are talking about. And I find that most people are just garbage, not garbage people, but like in terms of their points of view, it's just garbage. You know, Bitcoin's gonna go up and they come up with some theory and like, you're an idiot. You have no idea. Like you're just speculating. So do you find the community to be valuable or do you find it to be detrimental to your investing mental health?
37:06George Papazov: I think in 2009, when I saw what happened at the Trade trading Invest, desk? I left to start what was Trade Pro Academy at the time, just since become a free resource. I've shut it down for revenue. I started in 2012. Community was necessary then. It was very hard to connect with people. These days, I think community is becoming let me follow trades. If you're going to community to follow somebody else's trades, no, absolutely not. Like, don't go there. It's you're gonna live not only their problems, but when you get offline away from the computer, you're that's gonna going transpire to into your own problems in life. Again, it's a gambling culture. What they're seeking out of community. is what community is then selling them. They're filling a need. I would say the wrong community will set you back. It doesn't matter if you've done it for five years and you think you've kind of gained market knowledge. Community could really set you back. It could be very frustrating. But I do know for a fact that the market is, in fact, a community. When you go to sell something, you got gotta to find a buyer. When you go to buy something, you got gotta to find somebody to sell it to. So I think being in the right community, which is becoming increasingly hard to find, is great. And I think the things to look for in a community is opinions that help your own analysis, but not signals or trades. Like I think that's where it gets really distractive. But for example, in my community, I'll have a guy that watches bonds. And when he gives me his input on what he thinks the bond market's doing, there's this a correlation to SP. It helps me with that information. So I always say
38:26the community. is great if they put out information, but fall short of giving you decisions because that's the work that we have to do. It's a decision. We can't outsource that to anybody and expect to have any kind of meaningful success. And a lot of those communities, it's like our brains fried, Kirk. Like honestly, I've kind of talked about this with my wife a couple of days ago. It's like, look at what social media has become. We went from 10 minute videos of gold on YouTube to now 30. second short reels. Now we're swiping. The algorithm never ends. Our food gets delivered to our doorstep. Like somebody should almost chew for us. We have all these things that are convenience and we're all looking for shortcut. But I'll tell you in investing, the shortcut is the most expensive. The free community, everything that's marketed towards pay this and then you'll find the way, all that is just a waste of money. I said this in Trade Pro Academy as well. I'm like, I'm not here to teach it. I don't know any better than you, I'm also learning from the market. The market's the real teacher. So if you follow that kind of general guideline, the communities that are ill-intentioned fall off. People who pretend to know better than you. Because nobody knows. At the end of the day, if I knew where the market was gonna go, I wouldn't start a community. I'd be like, Kirk, check out this data. Don't tell anyone, let's throw some money into it. Yeah, you
39:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know what I
39:37George Papazov: mean? And if any one person knew where the market was going to go, you don't think they'd find the money, it'd already be there. If the market one person knew where it was going to go, it would already be there. I think that's kind of the downside of community is we do need a community as traders and investors, but it's become a very predatory industry. And that was one of the biggest reasons for me ending trade pro. I started with the intention to teach people on the phone that I used to listen to getting hurt to get a source of information. And then took like a three-year break from the community, came back, and I'm like, you know what? The games changed to the point where like I don't even want to compete with this. Shut it down. I just focus on my own trading. That's always done well for me. It's just a lonely job. In 2012, when I was trading full-time, and like
40:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): oh,
40:18George Papazov: actually 2016, 2012 was still working for Scotia. But 2016, when I was trading full-time full time by myself, it was lonely, bro. There was nobody to really talk to about it. Think about how much trade. trading's exploded until now from then. It's like now everybody trades, everyone buys some kind of stock. Back then there was nobody. Everyone thought you were nuts. I
40:34Kirk Chisholm: know.
40:34George Papazov: What do you mean you left your job? Like you don't want your pension and all that, you know?
40:38Kirk Chisholm: I had a lot of friends who went that route. It's kind of like when I started, I started in ninety nine December, and then the markets crashed and everybody in our industry left because you had a lot of people going to the industry, 'cause industry because a lot of money there, and then it a crashed crash and everybody left. So it's like the survivors did really well. Then people went into recruiting because hey, everybody's losing their jobs. Let's get into recruiting. And then recruiting dried up at a certain point, like oh three or so. And then they left and then they went into mortgages. And it's like people go hop into these other things. And I always find it fascinating how people kind of like bounce around into different areas and it doesn't work. And then they they'll leave even and go do something else.
41:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I do
41:13Kirk Chisholm: want to ask one question before we we gotta wrap it up here, but why options? Because I know a lot of day traders they'll use just ETFs or futures and they'll do things like that. But why options?
41:23George Papazov: I just touch on one thing you said right before that. Sure.
41:25Kirk Chisholm: Yeah, yeah.
41:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
41:25George Papazov: noticed out careers as well, people who left when I left the trading desk. I'm pretty much the only person that's done the same thing since I left. But the trading remember you asked me earlier on have if you ever felt like chasing the high sometimes just get a little piece Doesn't they pull you in? Well, look at what they did with that career move, right? They chase the next trend, the next big thing. By the time you get into the next big thing, the next big thing's over. You're not on the ground floor anymore. I think when we started with the options thing, it's kind of like takes probably about 10% of my effort. Like my primary is day trading futures, the SP 500. That's like a little passive strategy that I don't really rely on. It's not my bread and butter and core on the options. I just run something on the days where I can't the market's up 50 points and I can't be long because I can't get on board because there's no pullback. Everyone's just lifting offers, competing on the bid, and I can't get in on part of the auction. So that's what the strategy was designed for, is to kind of catch the fallout of some of that. But the daily bread and butter is day trading futures. I use the SP s 500 p 500 call. contract the yes i follow things like the n q contract which is the futures contract dram socks obviously for correlation i look very heavily into intermarket
42:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): correlations for trading setup as well but the core and the bread and butter the thing that consumes 90 of my time on a daily basis is the SP 500 futures options are tough to day trade that's a tough game because the theta right the time burn were they're great to sell, like covered calls in a portfolio. But options day trade.
42:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
42:55Kirk Chisholm: these DTEs, I mean, people are using DTEs now. It's just like pure gambling. I haven't even looked at them. I can't even bother to look at stuff like that.
43:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Look,
43:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): man,
43:04George Papazov: I think when we have our next 2009 moment, we'll do another call again. And as much as I would like to think, like, hey, I'm I told you so would be the message, it would be one of remorse. I'll be sad because nobody
43:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): really heard
43:14George Papazov: the bell ring and I'm trying to put this info out. But it is what it is. And the zero DTE, last thing I'll add is they actually add a fascinating insight into futures trading because you actually get to see positioning based on gamma. You get to see GEX exposure at certain levels, you know, the flip zone for gamma, and you're trying to kind of look in the dealer book. And the only reason the dealer book is even exciting today traders now is because there's so much retail participation on the zero. DTE. So that's part of my level formation is I'll look at gamma, I'll look at exposure on the dealer's book. You're not going to know the dealer's book unless you're the dealer. But these approximations based on retail flow are actually very helpful for levels. So you kind of take that data and use it, even though it's blown up. I don't participate in zero DTE. That data
43:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): and zero DTE DT options are driving futures market way more than it used to be. It's getting pinned at certain levels to the tick with that data. So it's a very useful data set.
44:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
44:09Kirk Chisholm: George, you're going to run here in the inter time, but appreciate you coming to the show. Where can people find more about you?
44:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank
44:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): you, man. This was fascinating. Love connecting with you and being on the show. And I love listening to it as well. I'm also a listener. You guys connect with me. I have a Substack, George Papazov. Everything I do is for free. Substack.com forward slash George Papazov G E. G-E-O-R-G-E-P-A-P-A-Z-O-V. And then on X, X.com forward slash same thing, my full name, George Papazov. I post insights there daily on order flow and day trading futures.
44:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
44:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): check me out there. I don't sell anything. So it's all the interest of just getting that info out and supporting the community. Wendy.
44:48Kirk Chisholm: This is a public service announcement.
44:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Have
44:51Kirk Chisholm: you ever played the lottery? My state advertises that you can't win if you don't play. What they don't tell you is the lottery is a tax on people who are bad at math.
45:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): How
45:01Kirk Chisholm: many lottery winners have you met? Probably none.
45:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
45:05Kirk Chisholm: if you don't like your chances of winning the state lottery, you're definitely not gonna Going like to winning the inflationary lottery.
45:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What?
45:12Kirk Chisholm: The inflationary lottery? Yeah, that's right. Your chances of winning the state lottery might be 1 million to one, but you're guaranteed to win the inflation lottery because it affects everybody. And the prizes stink. But here's what you're gonna win higher prices at the store, shrinkflation of your package goods, and higher costs to heat your home. Who doesn't want to win that lottery? Well, much like the government, I feel bad about all your costs. rising, so I'm going to give you some free money to help out. It's not a lot. It's only 1 million Zim dollars, but it's something. Well, you can't buy anything with it, but it looks good as wallpaper. And if you live in Europe this winter, you might even be able to use it to heat your home.
45:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
45:55Kirk Chisholm: the lottery is a tax on people who are bad at math, then inflation is a tax on people who are bad at economics.
46:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
46:02Kirk Chisholm: I want you to be better at understanding economics. So I'm giving away this free money to all my loyal listeners of the show.
46:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Go to
46:09Kirk Chisholm: money treepodcast.com forward slash free money and follow the instructions to get your free gift.
46:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
46:15Kirk Chisholm: have a large audience and only a limited number of these currencies. So make sure you get yours before they run out.
46:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Go
46:22Kirk Chisholm: to moneytreepodcast.com forward slash free money to get your free podcast. gift today.
46:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
46:30Kirk Chisholm: we're into the panel portion of the show. We have a very own Barb Freeberg. Hey Barb.
46:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Hello, everybody. Well,
46:36Kirk Chisholm: glad to have you. And we also have a very own Doug Hagrin. Hey Doug.
46:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Kurt. Barb. Good to see you again. Well,
46:41Kirk Chisholm: Barb, so tell us uh your thoughts on the interview.
46:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Don't try this at home. Look, kudos to George. He seems to be making a living. I take my hat off to him. But for the average investor, for the person that wants to use investing as a long term tool to create wealth for retirement, for future goals, like sending your kid to college, day trading is not the way to do it. Most people fail. And I appreciated. George was extremely transparent in saying this is not easy. Looking really forward to talking about this topic and what are better ways to end up not only making wealth, but keeping wealth.
47:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
47:32Kirk Chisholm: that's a good perspective, Bart. Doug, what about you? I mean, what are your thoughts on this kind of topic, day trading and whatnot?
47:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): For the most part, I think you can start top down at looking at the best investment managers on the planet. Many of the names we've discussed ad nauseum. Or you look at the people that are talking about just buy the index funds. Why? Because the majority of active managed funds are lagging the SP S P 500. Now, I've said this before, that's fine. if you consider the only thing large cap stocks, because there's plenty of active managers in areas like small caps and international and stuff like that that actually are in bonds that actually do beat the indexes. Indexes only don't work in every aspect. But I think if we use that example and we go back and take a look at the best, smartest minds in the world, most of them in general, are lagging or not necessarily hitting success
48:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on
48:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a regular basis. They are looking for, I liken it to the companies that are behind venture capital. They're going to bet on a ton of losses
48:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
48:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): order to get the diamond in the rough that pays them all back. And it's the same thing with the Vegas whales that are out there gambling, which is obviously a great correlated God. conversation to this today. They are looking for eventually I'll hit big enough that I can absorb these losses. And they are well capitalized and they have massive, deep teams looking at incredible amounts of analysis in ways in which they can look at this when the lights are off, when the day is over. Can a day trader do that? Do they have those resources? Not at all. So they go into it and they look at this and say, Hey, I'm very successful because look what I'm betting into right now. And I keep making money.
49:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
49:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that's all fine and dandy when the markets keep going up. And honestly, I could take a mouse walking across my keyboard and probably buy things that could be positive.
49:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
49:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that's not reality. of how to manage when the tides turn. And I think that's the issue is that positive markets can make day traders feel incredibly brilliant. But that's not what takes the smart money from the dumb money. The best investors in the world are going to show you that it's not just doing well when things are going. in the positive direction. It's how do you manage that through when things turn the other direction? And I think a lot of day traders unfortunately live off of this false reality of thinking that they are smarter than what they really are, because the markets are making everything they do almost in a vacuum chamber of success.
50:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
50:26Kirk Chisholm: point Doug you raised is actually a really important one is the nuance around what people say in reality. And I just want to make this point really quick because I think it's important to understand. There's a lot of influencers and fin fluencers out there and people who make it sound easy. And as Doug said, when the markets are easy, it's easy to make money and it's easy to look like a rock star. This year has actually been one of the top three hardest years that I've experienced in the last 27 years. And it's not because the markets are losing money, because the indexes are up. It's because the nature of the markets are very different than most. Many years the markets just go up. It's easy. You just hopefully you pick better stuff. As Buffett says, you don't know who's swimming naked till the tide goes out. And it's true. When times are easy, everyone looks like a rockstar. rock star. When times are hard, then you figure out who's actually smart and who's not. What I found is that a lot of the conversations are nuanced. So as Doug says, when times are good,
51:26you look good. When times are bad, you're bad. But people aren't advertising that. They're advertising, look what I did. Look at the last 10 years or whatever. Like, well, the last 10 years are pretty easy. It's, you know, we had COVID. I mean, pretty much since 2008, we had COVID. Otherwise, pretty much every year, 2022 is hard. But other than that, every year has been more or less easy. It's just kind of gone up, and everyone looks like a hero. Now, that being said, I'll take the other side of this too, which is there are good people out there. You look at Jack Schwager's books, The Market Wizards, he lists a bunch of people who are successfully, I don't want to call them dates. day trading because that's maybe the wrong word, but they are traders. They're successful traders. I mean, Paul Truder Jones is one of the most well-known and successful traders out there. And he's just doing trading strategies, exactly what these individual day traders are doing. And he's managing billions of dollars. Bruce Covenard, Richard Dennis, you know, Ed Sequoia, Marty Schwartz, Tom Baldwin, Michael Steinhart-like Steinhart, like these are all really successful people in his books. that he talks about with their strategies. So it's not that they don't work or that they work. It's that these people have figured things out as to how to make it work. Now, the other thing to think about is if you are a day trader, just you and your money, you might be able to get away with stuff that somebody like Doug or
52:46myself can't. Because if you're managing a lot of money, you might not be able to do that. Like if I'm managing a billion dollars and I'm trying to invest in penny stocks, I can't do that. I might be able to, but there are limits on penny stocks as to how much I can put in. Because if I've got a billion dollars and I put 1% of it at work, that's what 10 million? So I gotta got put to 10 million in 1% position into one stock. Well, the stock itself may be worth. 10 million if it's a penny stock, or maybe worth 5 million. I can't do that. So there are practical limitations to certain areas. Now, to point out penny stocks, and I don't want to get drawn down on this topic, but when you're in the small and microcap space, there are great opportunities. There really are. And if you're trading, you can actually do reasonably well because the inefficiencies of the system. Because most managers are investing in large cap. In large cap, there's no alpha to be made, generally speaking. You can find the best large cap managers are all kind of doing the same. So there's not a lot of alpha you can generate there, unless you're just putting it all in tech or semis or whatever the heck you're doing. But in the small and microcap space, you can make alpha because you can actually do homework and
53:59there's edges because institutions aren't sitting around trying to make. money there because it's too small. So there are areas in the market like that that you can find that you can take advantage of. High yield bonds, another area you can generate alpha if you know what you're doing. BioCat, another area. Not all areas do that, but there's some areas that are really weird and inefficient. And if you can get them and if you know what you're doing, you can do quite well. So I don't want to be pro or against any of these areas. Everything comes with a nuance. And I think everybody needs to understand that. And let me just give you a real good contraindicator if you're looking to see like when the markets are going to top. My youngest son, who is 14 years old, came in one day a few weeks ago and says, Tell me about the markets. And I was like, okay, you know, after some conversation, what it came out to be was he had seen a video about day trading and was very curious about doing this. And I was like, okay, this is a good indicator the market's probably gonna turn around. It was really sweet that he came in and we talked about it and it was great and we had a great conversation. But the fact that I don't push this on him because I they're young and you try to ease them in when they're interested. But the fact that he's seeing this and he's convinced that this is a good way to make money, everyone else is seeing the same. stuff. And I'm not sure most people have evolved their brain past a 14
55:19year old when it comes to making money. You know, it's like, ooh, easy money, let's do that.
55:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
55:23Kirk Chisholm: just thought I'd share that because he hadn't done it before. Barb, we're seeing a lot of stuff. The dopamine hit is on overdrive for everybody. We got prediction markets, we got day trading, we got all these get rich quick schemes. What about prediction markets? I mean, we're see that's taken off like wildfire. What do you think of those?
55:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I mean, really, give me a freaking break. If you think that is a legitimate long-term way to make money, then you better be super, super rich because odds are you are gonna going to lose over the long term. So think of it as a casino. If you want to do it for fun, I get it. It's fun to have skin in the game when you're watching the election or
56:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): when you're watching a game and you put a few bucks in. I have no problem with that. But don't think about this as a way that I am going to get rich. Don't have this on your phone and start betting on everything. Because when you are betting, you've got to think about who's on the other side of the trade, who's running the platform. And that's the house. So just think Las Vegas and take it from there. And don't be stupid. That's not the way to make long-term wealth.
56:47Kirk Chisholm: Yeah, appreciate that, Barb. Doug, what about you? I know you're insured. interested in prediction markets.
56:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Well, interested has a number of different nuances in its definition. I'm very interested in it because I've been watching kind of the impact that it's had on sports. And anybody that's listened to me here knows that I'm a pretty big college sports fan. And there's definitely been a blurring of the lines, you know, now that we have an NFL team in Vegas and there couldn't be an NFL team. or any sports team in Vegas for pretty much forever because there was this fear of the stigma of having sports be in a town known for gambling when we when it took us decades to really get over the point shaving scandal. Was it Boston College? It took forever to move beyond some of the greatest scandals, eight-men. Eight Men Out and the Black Sox. Gambling at sports. Just put a wall between them. Everything's changed now. The biggest sponsors of sports these days are the predictions markets. The gambling markets started years ago. We have teams in Vegas now. The entire NFL is basically realizes that a lot of its fandom comes from betting. And unfortunately,
58:03you go back to why have we ever had regulations about drugs and alcohol and things like that? It's because there's a real concern about exposure and what that exposure does for the least matured and resilient minds that are out there. And that's not an age-based because obviously there are older people that have addictions and things like that. But one of the most concerning parts when we get into investing, especially, is that we have certainly seen going back the last 10 years or so that a lot of investing has it's always been around some sort of hype. But now as Silicon Valley has really taken the lead in our economy, most of what's gone on in the stock market and the success has been around. technology. You've started to have a difference of view of where that speculation is focused and what that means in terms of access from investment. And there's a huge correlation between things like even crypto, which is supposed to be an alternative currency, but yet it's getting blurred as something that is now. Well, look how I can buy. Bitcoin and Bitcoin's gonna be worth millions of dollars. That's not currency preparation, that is speculation. And there's a lot of
59:22blurring between looking at something fundamentally and looking at something with an ideology. And I think AI is a great example of that, which I'm gonna come back to on the predictions markets, but I want to jump ahead on this, is talking about a gentleman that some people may have heard of. His name is Leopold Ashenbrenner. He is a gentleman who was heavily involved with getting into the AI world. He was a 24-year-old AI researcher, macroeconomist, hedge fund manager. He graduated in 19 with a degree in economics for Columbia. He had significant altruism, and I think that's the it. And who's part of what's called the effective altruism movement, focusing on long long-term term existential risk, specifically rapid. advancement of AI? Between 22 and 24, he joined OpenAI. He rose to work on the prestigious super alignment team. Eventually, they fired him for allegedly leaking confidential memos around the company's AI safety protocols and computing capacity. He countered that the memo was shared with external safety advisors and that the firing firearm was politically motivated. What did he do from there? Well, he created what's called the Situational Awareness Manifesto, and he went and he put together a 165-page thesis about situational awareness the next decade. And it went viral, predicting
1:00:39artificial intelligence would arrive by 2027, US military would soon need trillions of dollars, et cetera. And then he launched a fund backed by massive checks from Silicon Valley, including Strife's Stripes founder. And ultimately, this investment fund hit a staggering $45 billion peak by mid 2026. And it was, you know, heavily leveraged. Explosive run-ups in AI stocks ballooned the fund. We're just talking a couple months ago.
1:01:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:01:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): then guess what happened? July. Abrupt AI market correction triggered a To massive margin call. calls. The fund plummeted 67%, wiping out 35 billion in weeks. To survive, he had to sell his entire public equity portfolio to a single trade block to Ken Griffin and the Citadel. Now, what's happened recently? He's actually re-entered the market. He shifted from long-term equity positions to hundreds of millions of dollars in highly leveraged call options on AI structure, memory chips, alternative energy. Again, investing based on altruism, investing based on this almost religious level fanaticism of belief. But guess what? He is still being deeply insulated within the AI elite. His current portfolio since September 8th, one stock's down 37%, another stocks down 25%, another stocks down 23%, another stocks down 22%, another down 18%, down nine.
1:02:04The only one he's made any money on out of seven stocks is AMD, which is up 9%. His average decline is roughly 18%. And we're talking about someone who reportedly rebuilt exposure through leverage strategies, not just common shares. Once again, already just through this belief in this at such an extreme level is going into investing without it's not based on fundamentals. It's not based on smart deployment of money. It is based entirely on almost this fanaticism of a belief of a religion behind something. And I think that that is something that we're going to see a lot more. I'm pulling all this together. When you look at the younger generations, and again, what they truly believe growing up in Silicon Valley and tech, they are blurring. the lines between investing and gambling. And it's not just happening in the way they look at AI and technology or the way they look at crypto. Let's come back to your question on sports betting.
1:03:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
1:03:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Gen Z and millennial consideration or active use of betting in prediction markets, 32% of Gen Z and 24% of millennials versus 17% of all other US adults. And this is from Northwestern Munich. Mutual. Gen Z investors who redirected investment savings money into sports betting in the past year. Barb, Kirk, take a guess on that number. What do you think it is? A lot. 52%. 52% of Gen Z investors have redirected investment savings money into sports betting, according to Betterment and Yahoo! Finance. Gen Z investors. are treating sports betting as a long-term financial strategy, 26% of them, versus 14% millennials, 6% Gen X, 1% boomers. The share of online betting driven by Gen Z and millennials share. Gen Z accounts for 48% of online betting. Gen Z and millennials combined to make up 88% of online betting. Americans and Gen Z specific. specifically viewing sports betting and prediction markets as an investment. 20% of all Americans, but Gen Z is twice as likely to view it as an investment. And the monthly recovery rate per dollar wager, they recover over 80 cents per dollar. Overall, average
1:04:19across generations is under 75%. That's Bank of America. So ultimately, it has surged. Platforms like Polymarket, CalShi, they recorded a combined trading problem of $60 billion in this year alone. And they're predicted to reach $1 trillion by 2030. Robinhood has now expanded into sports prediction event contracts. They're handled over 16 billion contracts. They're pulling in $156 $56 million just in Q2 of 2026. The comprehensive large-scale large scale financial and gambling data. does not yet track for Gen A, as the oldest members are only entering their mid teens, which is legally barring them from participating. But yet, with online and the access that people have right here these days, and new these new models, you're not just betting against the house barb. You are now looking at the odds and then selling those odds and your bets to each other by. bypassing the house or um the take. To answer your question, Kirk, this is a massive explosion. To me, it's extremely concerning because speculation has always been a form of gambling. Now we are literally taking gambling and calling it speculation.
1:05:31Kirk Chisholm: The stock market for a lot of people is gambling. They don't know what they're doing, they just want to get in on the action. What do people
1:05:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do?
1:05:39Kirk Chisholm: when they gamble in sports? It's gambling. Some people think they're smarter than they are and they've got some edge and people are betting on sports games, but they also fantasy sports, fantasy football, fantasy whatever. Like, okay, gets you in the game, makes you think you're smart. But the reality is, is if you go to the casino, you know what the odds are. We've You've all seen shows, we all read books, we all know what the odds are. You're playing blackjack, you know what the odds are. And I'm not talking about counting cards. Counting cards, you can put the odds in your favor, but let's say you're not counting cards, you know what the odds are. It's simple. You're gonna lose. Maybe you get lucky once in a while, but you're gonna lose. You know, because the odds are against you. You're playing another game, you know what those odds are. You're signing up for basically spending money to have fun. People do that in the casino. To be fair, I go to the casino once a year, just because it's fun. Because if I'm gonna spend 300 bucks on a night out, or now that's like a meal, it's like a lunch. You know, if I'm gonna spend 300 bucks on a night out, I'll just go to the casino for a night and I'll spend money. And maybe I break even and I had a fun night for free, or maybe I come out ahead and I got paid to have a good time. But even if I lose 300 bucks, I would have spent that anyway. And I had a good time. I know I'm cheap, 300 bucks is nothing nowadays, but in general, just pick whatever number you want. You know, Michael Jordan might spend 30 million on a fun night. out. Anyway, the point being is you have to understand what's the old adage. If you don't know who the Rube is at the table, it's you.
1:06:58That's the reality. If you're at the table, whatever game you're playing, prediction markets, sports betting, stock market, if you don't know who the Rube is, it's you. So Doug and I do this all is the time. Barb's in the markets with herself, and we understand the game. We understand what the strengths and weaknesses are in the markets. We understand our strengths and weaknesses. And I have strengths and weaknesses in the markets. I know what they are. That's a strength to me. I know that stop losses is my kryptonite. I know certain stocks are my kryptonite, my white whale, if you will. I stay away from them. Stop losses. I use other ways to prevent losses that aren't stop losses because I understand that stop losses are not. designed. I guess as an individual trader, you could probably get away with it. But if you're managing any real money, you can't. If I put a stop loss on a stock, the stock will just dip down, it'll hit it, and it'll come right back up. I can't leave that out there. You look at institutions managing billions of dollars, they can't do that either. So you have to understand what your strengths and weaknesses are and find ways to support that so that it doesn't become a problem. But if you don't understand yourself, that about yourself, you're just like, hey, everybody's making money, my neighbor made a lot of money. Let me put money in the same thing. It's like, hey, you're probably too late. It's like, oh, well, the Patriots won last week. My buddy won that. So let me put money in the Patriots. Like, that's not really how it works. But when people see the
1:08:18action, why are casinos noisy? Why are the machines buzzing and whirring and bells ringing and and there's bright lights flickering and all these. things? Why does that happen? Because it proves that there's something going on and people want to participate. Why is a stock market? Why are people talking about it on TV? Because they want you to participate. They want you to put your money in there. It's a casino. Now, if you know the rules, the casino edge can be in your favor. And that's why, like buy and hold long-term strategies, puts the edge in your favor. It doesn't mean it's always the best thing to do. Buy and hold is a great strategy over like a hundred years, but it's not a good strategy day to day because the markets aren't doing so hot in the last few weeks. But let's say we go into a massive recession now, buy and hold's not going to do you any favors. If your strategy is I'll just wait it out. What if waiting it out takes you 14 years to get back? Don't think it can happen. It did 2000 to 2014. Market went nowhere or 13, just 14 years. Market went nowhere. It went down a lot and up and bounced around, but basically you didn't make any money if you put January 1st of 2000 to I think it was like July something, 2013. That's when you broke even. Took 14 years. Do you want to wait 14 years? I don't. So if you don't have
1:09:37any sort of risk management. in place, if you don't have anywhere that's going to protect yourself from stupid behavior, then you're gambling. These guys I mentioned, those traders, they're not gambling. They know the odds. They know the probabilities. They know what they're doing. They're successful in managing billions of dollars and making lots of money. So the thing to kind of circle this back is any market you can make money at if you have an edge. Prediction. markets, if you have an edge, was it Trump's script writer or uh speech writer made a bet that this word's gonna appear 14 times and he bet and they said, No, no, no, actually you're not allowed to do that. And they clawed it back. But who are you betting against? I don't play prediction markets, I watch them because it's interesting data for what we do. You know, what's the probability that the Democrats are gonna going to sweep the House and the Senate? That's interesting. Data point. That's good to know. What's the probability that the Fed's going to raise rates? It's a good data point. I'm not betting on it, but it's a good data point. But you know, if you're betting on something where somebody else, and I don't want to say the funny story that I want to say, but let's just say a year ago, women's basketball, there was a bet on certain elements that were going to be thrown on the floor. And I was like, this is hilarious. And somebody did it because it was like, hey, I can make a lot of money on this. The fact that you can influence a prediction market, I don't know how you
1:10:56regulate that. I just don't. I've thought about this. I don't know what the right answer is. I'm against it, but you know, I don't like telling people what to do. I'm not gonna do it. It's not for me. But if people want to spend their money, go ahead. It's fun to you, go ahead. But people need to understand what they're getting sales salts into. And And as both of you said earlier. in the show, the biggest challenge is people are not in control of themselves because betting prediction markets, it's dopamine. And we like dopamine. We like betting. We think we're gonna make lots of money, even though intellectually we know we probably won't, but it could happen. It could happen. No whammies. Come on, no whammies.
1:11:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): My favorite game show.
1:11:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That
1:11:36Kirk Chisholm: was the best show. Whammies were awesome. We You see those when. they got one, it was great.
1:11:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It's back, by the way.
1:11:41Kirk Chisholm: Is it really? I'll have to check it out. As we wrap up here, Barb, what are your thoughts on all these things? Crypto, get rich quick schemes. How should people be thinking about this in terms of investing?
1:11:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I went to a fascinating panel with just last week with Myron Scholes of the Nobel Prize winning fan. fame of the Black Scholes options model and with Terrence Odien, Professor Berkeley, who is an expert in behavioral finance. And the things they talked about in the investing realm was: guess what? Do you think Scholes talked about, yeah, options option strategies? No. The overriding theme for both of their conversations was unless you have an edge or a specialty that you know a lot more than everyone else, and you can be sure that you can make money off of that, most investors are best served with a diversified index. fund portfolio. Now there was consensus on asset allocation. They all felt that a dynamic asset allocation instead of fixed, and when I say that, I mean 60 stock, 40
1:13:06bond, that's fixed. But they were of the mind that when asset prices are very, very highly priced. maybe you want to tone down your equities a little and boost up your fixed assets. Oh, they did talk about prediction markets. And the consensus was no. So if you're looking to make money over the long term, prediction markets aren't going to do it for you. Day trading is likely not going to do it for you. But unless you are a specialist and a niche of the markets, a basic diversified portfolio, investing over not days, weeks, months, but years will get you to your financial goals. And I write about just that on Barbara Friedberg. Personal Finance and on my YouTube channel. See you next time.
1:14:08Kirk Chisholm: Thanks for coming on, Barb. Doug, your thoughts and we can wrap it up here.
1:14:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Buckle up. I think there's some real important things and it's ominous. And this is something that has some of the most data. So I'm just going to continue to go through things. I think it's really important to understand. There's been 30,000 extra bankruptcies in states that have legalized online betting. They've surged 25% to 30% within three to four years of legalization, translating to 30,000 extra bankruptcies. Debt collection spike, states with online betting saw an 8% increase in debt collection placements. 2026 debt relief poll, 38% of millennials, 27% of Gen Z carrying 7,500 or more in unsecured unsecure debt, 65% of Gen Z, 49% of millennials. who regularly admit to gambling say they're doing so out of desperate financial survival strategy to claw their way out of debt. Major academic tracking of 184,000 households found that betting families slashed their net investing by 14%, a highly active subset of bettors. Money is aggressively funneled out of long-term stock brokerage accounts, causing a massive 50% drop in overall household savings. The median bank deposit balance for household in wagering is just 59% of those in comparable non-betting. And young men in particular face a 4% drop in credit card limits and notable spike in high-interest debt consolidation loans up to 10% as they attempt to shuffle gambling
1:15:31debt around. The toll is there. Financial ruin is heavily compounding acute mental health crisis because platforms look at and feel like clean investments. The shame associated with it is immense. Roughly 60% of Gen Z and millennials state they'd rather publicly reveal their exact weight than disclose their true debt load. And in states like Massachusetts, Kirk, state referrals for gambling addiction treatment among young adults, 20s Twenties to 30s, have more than doubled since this went live. Now we take a look at 70 to 79%. of users lose money. 1% eats the lunch of everyone else, 60 million retail losses, 583 million lost on calci alone. It's higher risk than slot machines. People think this is easy. It's being advertised. Medium retail loss rate is around eight percent. If you look at sportsbooks, it's five 5% percent. And casino slot machines, six 6.55%. point five five. So it's terrible. Even worse, more than half are borrowing. 53% of these prediction market traders admit they joined it out of financial stress. They're funding their wagers via credit cards, personal loans, high interest cash advances. They're missing essential bills, 25% of them. And a third of betters confidently assist are coming out ahead. The data shows only
1:16:473% actually break even or beyond that. Now I'm going to come back to investing. U.S. margin debt is at a $1.5 trillion peak, surpassing $1.5 trillion is a massive 50% year over year increase. It now exceeds the nation's total credit card debt. Modern margin debt behaves less like institutional leverage and more like speculative drug. Younger Youthful retail investors using margin accounts today trade high volatility options, meme stocks, and leverage ET. ETFs at rates double Gen X or boomers. On top of that, we've got margin call and forced liquidations. 360,000 accounts wiped out, according to Goldman Sachs. During a single semiconductor market correction, it wiped out 360,000 brokerage accounts, forced margin calls, overwhelmingly belonging to individuals under 35. Investors lost 100%. of principal forced to sell. We are seeing that young investors are not just using standard broker-provided margin accounts.
1:17:4780% of Gen Z and 60% of millennials have actively taken outside debt, high-interest personal loans, cash advances, buy now, pay later platforms, explicitly just to fund volatile stock and crypto trades. The young adults are feeling locked out of home ownership. This high leverage margin trading is a they're now viewing this as a rational survival strategy rather than risk. But ultimately it is a ticking clock. And I think that's the biggest concern and worry that I have is that the trend that we're seeing now is an entire generation is increasingly exposed to financial tools that make speculation look and feel like investing. And whether it's sports betting, prediction markets, options trading, margin, the technology has made it increasingly easy to put money at risk. And now, like you said, Kirk, how do we control that? I mean, you got states that for a long time said gambling was illegal, but yet had the lottery. I mean, talk about conflict of interest. Now, increasingly we are seeing access state to state to state. It's over opening up. Advertising is now allowed. They're aligned together. Just because you have access to investment or place a bet from your phone does not mean you understand that risk you're taking. And I think we have to ask why so many
1:19:03younger people are attracted to these. There's just this feeling that traditional wealth building, you talked about, Barb, it takes too long. They're already behind. And now they they're feel they got to take extraordinary rates. risks to get ahead. But there's an enormous difference between calculator risks to build wealth and then taking risks because you feel you have no other choice. You're hopeless.
1:19:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:19:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that's why financial planning becomes so important. Emergent advisors, that's really the philosophy behind our one plan. We've got to start looking at what you want to accomplish, what resources you have, and the risks you can actually afford to take. The objective here is not to win the next trade or correctly predict the next event. Ultimately, it's to build a financial strategy that gives you the greatest opportunity to accomplish what matters over your lifetime. You don't have to get rich overnight to become wealthy, but trying to get rich overnight can make it a whole lot harder to ever get there. And then I think at the end, that's something I think every generation needs to. to understand. But I mean it guys sound like the old man in the room, but the data is showing that this is more than just myth and oh, you know, shouting at the clouds, oh, the next generation didn't get it. The data is they are so desperate that they are putting themselves in a position of never being able to recover. And that's concerns me.
1:20:22Kirk Chisholm: Where can people find more about you, Doug?
1:20:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): MergentAdvisors.com. You can learn more about the OnePlay. one plan M-E-R-G-E-N-T. M-E-R-G-E-N-T mergent advisors.com. Because the most important thing you can do is smart money plans. It doesn't guess, it doesn't gamble. And ultimately the best way to do it is to make sure that you have a coordination between all the things that matter with all the things you have.
1:20:47Kirk Chisholm: Awesome. Well, I appreciate you coming on the show, Doug. And for reference. since I live in Massachusetts, Massachusetts actually spends marketing dollars to advertise their lottery. And their advertisement is you can't win if you don't play. And by the way, they also provide support if you can't control yourself gambling, but they actually spend state dollars to advertise the lottery.
1:21:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): But it goes to the schools.
1:21:10Kirk Chisholm: Yeah, I know. It sure does. Yeah. So it goes to somebody, it's not the schools. It goes to Massport where all the old politicians go to die and retire.
1:21:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Welcome to the most depressing panel conversation we've had in the entire history of MTI.
1:21:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
1:21:24Kirk Chisholm: it's not depressing. They're just talking about reality. I mean, people understand. It is what it is. But just final point, and we'll wrap it up for me, too. I think one of the biggest challenges we face is the fact that we all agree capitalism is the best system. It's the worst system, except for every other one. There are no great systems. Capitalism's great, but you know, it's not perfect. You know, if you have ruthless capitalism with no rules, you get what we have now, which is gambling and everyone's people can't control themselves. It's like if you just allowed every drug to be allowed and you could use any drug you want. On. We'd have a nation of drug users, and we'd have people that are just useless members of society because they're just drug addicts. Same thing with gambling. There's a ton of vices out there. There's a reason that we've protected people from these vices in the past. It's because they can't control themselves. Or some people said they're bad or they're against God or whatever. You come up with whatever reason you want, but the reality is it's not good. And if you're doing them, look at all the drug users that are basically just they're useless members of society. They're not functioning members of society. And you got all these people who are betting. losing lots of money, destroying their life, their families overbetting. I mean, there's a reason they call them vices. People do the same with alcohol, smoking, like whatever it is. There's lots of different vices out there. And the challenge is we as human beings are not designed to protect ourselves from these
1:22:43vices. Everyone's got a vice. Maybe it's social media. That's a vice. You're wasting countless hours of the day doing useless stuff. I'm not saying you shouldn't do it. I'm just saying it's a vice. And we need to recognize that. And we need to recognize that all these industries are scientifically designed to take your money and your time and your attention. And if you don't realize that, then you might wake up years later and be like, huh, yeah, I spent three years of my life on social media. Where did that go? These things are designed that way. Casinos are designed to take your money. These betting apps are designed to take your money. If you don't know this, if anybody uses these companies, the only one I could think of off the top of my head is DraftKings, but there's a bunch of them. Any of these companies, if you're successful, if you're a winner, a statistical winner, they actually kick you off the platform.
1:23:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
1:23:28Kirk Chisholm: if you know people that are using these things, it's because they're losers. They're losing money. It's not like the old school casinos where they're required to like let you play, whether you're a winner or loser. If you're a consistent winner, they kick you off the platform because they make money off of the losses. It's not just like, you know, the VIG with it used to be. No, if you lose money, they make it. They're the house. So if they get rid of the winners and just keep the losers, they make tons of money. I found that out on Michael Lewis's podcast when he's talking about this. That's crazy. That should be illegal, but they're allowed and there's no regulation and no one seems to care. So for better or worse, that's the society we live in. And I wouldn't be surprised if everyone gets sick of this and just says the hell of it. Let's go back to old school religion where you're not allowed to do anything and you have to show up in church on Sundays and you're ostracizing the community if you don't believe. Maybe we should go back to that. I don't know. I don't know what the right answer is. There's got to be some answer, and this isn't it. Anyway, I just wanted to wrap that up because I think it's an important topic that's gonna come up time and again. But that's the show for this week. Thanks again
1:24:28for joining us in the Money Tree Investing Podcast. My name's Kirk Chisholm, wealth manager of Innovative Advisor Group. We don't just manage your wealth, we make your life better. You can find more about me at innovativewealth.com, and of course, you can find me every week here on the show. We share a lot of the charts in the show. So if you're looking for charts and show notes, check out our show at Moneytree Podcast dot com. Don't forget, do your own research. This show is for informational use only. We're not telling you what to think, merely how to think. but investing. We're also not selling you any products or services, so do not consider this advice. If you're seeking financial advice, give us a call. We take clients selectively, but only if we like you. Have a great week ahead, and remember, no one will care about your money like you do. So invest in your life.
1:25:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank
1:25:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you for listening to the Money Tree Investing Podcast. Visit us at Moneytree Podcast.com
1:25:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for more. free investing resources.