Hays turnaround, P&G growth, and miner struggles dominate market discussion
Summary
Speakers analyze Hays' operational restructuring and share price surge driven by German fee improvements and cost-cutting. Procter & Gamble reported 4% organic sales growth, though margin pressure persists despite volume gains. UK-listed miners face headwinds from falling commodity prices, a strong dollar, and rising interest rates, contrasting with AI-driven asset narratives.
Key takeaways
- 1 Yeah, so the Hayes have said that they now expect pre-exceptional operating profit in their first half, which is to the end of December, to be at least 35 million. And that is around 40% above where the market was sitting.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 2:00
- 2 Hays is reducing its core country footprint from 31 to 16 and global specialisms from 21 to 6, aiming for £50m in annual structural cost savings.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 3:53
- 3 Procter & Gamble’s laundry division accounts for ~35% of annual sales and was the primary driver of growth.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 15:04
Episode sections
- 1:22 – 10:36
Hays’ turnaround
Hays shares rose nearly 40% following a trading update where pre-exceptional operating profit for the first half is expected to be at least £35m, driven by improved net fees in Germany and cost-cutting measures under new CEO Mark Durnley.
Procter & Gamble reported 4% organic sales growth driven by volume and price increases, but faces margin pressure from inflation and consumer trading down. The company is targeting 1-3% organic sales growth for the full year, with a focus on wallet share expansion.
- 20:24 – 29:06
Why are miners struggling?
UK-listed miners are under pressure due to falling copper and gold prices, a strong US dollar, and rising interest rate expectations. Operational issues at companies like Endeavour Mining and the decoupling of commodity prices from AI narratives are cited as key factors.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gold | commodity | mixed | backward looking numbers. And uh what we're looking at to the at the moment is both a squeeze on the copper price, uh, which is enduring its uh uh longest uh run of weekly declines in two years, uh, as well as gold uh uh dipping below three thousand eight hundred. at one point uh this week as the Fed gets |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Hays shares jumped almost 40% on Wednesday on the back of a surprisingly positive trading update.
Dan Jones ·0:08
How to verify: Check Hays Holdings PLC (HRS.L) share price history for the week of the podcast release date (Nov 2026) and the specific trading update announcement date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Hays expects pre-exceptional operating profit in the first half (to end of December) to be at least £35 million, around 40% above market consensus.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·2:00
How to verify: Review Hays Holdings PLC interim trading statement or press release for the period ending December 2026; compare consensus estimates from financial data providers (e.g., Bloomberg, Refinitiv) for that period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Hays reduced its core countries from 31 to 16 and global specialisms from 21 to 6 under CEO Mark Durnley.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·3:33
How to verify: Check Hays Holdings PLC annual report or investor presentation detailing geographic and operational restructuring under current management. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Hays plans to deliver £50 million per annum of structural cost savings.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·4:13
How to verify: Review Hays Holdings PLC investor presentations or earnings releases outlining the 'Momentum' strategy and cost-saving targets. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Hays aims to return to or exceed £250 million of operating profit through self-help measures.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·7:25
How to verify: Check Hays Holdings PLC long-term guidance or investor day materials regarding operating profit targets. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Procter & Gamble reported 4% organic sales growth in its first quarter update, driven by 2.4% volume increase and pricing.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·13:26
How to verify: Review Procter & Gamble (PG) Q1 FY2027 earnings release or investor presentation for organic sales and volume growth metrics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Procter & Gamble’s gross margin fell about 160 basis points in the first quarter.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·13:45
How to verify: Review Procter & Gamble (PG) Q1 FY2027 earnings release for gross margin percentage change. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Procter & Gamble is targeting 1% to 3% organic sales growth for the full year.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·14:44
How to verify: Review Procter & Gamble (PG) full-year guidance in their Q1 earnings release or investor presentation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Procter & Gamble trades on about 24 times forward earnings, compared to Reckitt at 15 times and Unilever at 17 times.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·18:31
How to verify: Check current valuation multiples (P/E) for Procter & Gamble (PG), Reckitt (RKBT.L), and Unilever (ULVR.L) on financial data platforms as of the podcast date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
FTSE 350 miners were down 8% in the last week and 17% year-to-date.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·20:42
How to verify: Check FTSE 350 Index performance data for the week and year-to-date period surrounding the podcast release date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify Hays' full-year trading update and detailed segmental results for Germany and UK operations.
- Check Procter & Gamble's latest 10-K or annual report for gross margin trends and cost inflation details.
- Review recent copper and gold price forecasts from major banks (e.g., Goldman Sachs, Citi) for 2026-2027.
- Analyze the USD index (DXY) trajectory and Federal Reserve interest rate expectations impacting miner valuations.
- Compare Hays' current EV/EBITDA multiple against its 10-year historical average and peer group (e.g., Adecco, Randstad).
- Assess Procter & Gamble's wallet share data within the fabric and home care category versus competitors.
- Investigate specific operational issues at Endeavour Mining and other struggling UK miners mentioned.
- Review Hays' restructuring plan details and expected timeline for achieving £50m in annual savings.
Full transcriptexpand
0:08Dan Jones: Welcome to the Companies and Markets Show. I'm Dan Jones. This week we look at a company that has just had one of the biggest one day rises for a FTSE 250 stock in recent history, as well as two sectors going in very different directions at the moment. We'll begin with recruiter Hayes, whose shares jumped almost 40% on the back. of a surprise trading update. Kirsty Green is with us to discuss why a moribund jobs market and the looming threat of AI have been no barrier to the stock's progress. After that, we look at Procter
0:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): ⁇
0:38Dan Jones: Gamble, the U.S. consumer goods giant that reported healthily quarterly figures of its own the other week, and whose Two shares like other consumer staples have been lifted by investors seeking safe havens recently. Erin Withy will ask whether the qualities of this quality stock are coming back into fashion. Finally, we'll run the rule over a variety of UK listed miners whose shares have been hit hard this month by falling prices of copper and gold, and this week in particular. Julian Hoffman is with us to talk more about what this means for the likes of Anglo-American Endeavour Endeavor Mining and others. First up today, it is Hayes, a huge share price rise yesterday. The context of this has been a sector, the recruiters which have been beaten up for quite a few years now, due to a number of factors which most people will be aware of. I imagine the jobs market not really doing very well.
1:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There
1:36Dan Jones: have been concerns about AI and what effect that will have. on future openings. There aren't too many people moving jobs at the moment. That said, there have been signs of progress in recent months, and in particular yesterday in this trading update, Kirsty. What do we learn from that? Hayes is in a number of countries, which we'll get to. The main uh progress was in Germany, it seemed, in this trading update.
2:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, so the Hayes have said that they now expect pre-exceptional operating profit in their first half, which is to the end of December, to be at least 35 million. And that is around 40% above where the market was sitting. And the main driver is indeed improved net fees in Germany, which is their largest market. So they've said that they're now expecting modest net fee growth in Germany in the second. quarter, which is a three months to end December. And that's a huge turnaround from the 6% drop that they saw there in the first quarter. And the pickup in Germany really has been driven by strong growth in construction and property sectors for Hayes. Also a return to growth in its technology net fees and new wins for its recruitment services businesses there. But I think. it's fair to say it's not just the German turnaround. They're also making good progress on their cost-cutting strategy. So I think that's also helping to drive the profit-for-profit performance.
3:01Dan Jones: Yeah, that strategy they announced a while back, and it's fairly rigorous, is one way of putting it, fairly severe, might be another way compared with some peers. If you look at that strategy, we'll talk about that a little bit too. to begin with, because we'll get on to the progress on the ground, which I think really surprised people perhaps. But the the way that they're developing these cost cuts seem to be finding favour as well, because the the amount of people they're cutting on one level is quite significant. The number of countries they're retreating from as well.
3:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Um yeah, so I I'd say that Hayes has probably stood out amongst the recruiters. as one of the ones that's doing the most on sort of rationalizing and streamlining the business. Um, so the recruiters generally expanded quite massively in the hiring boom that came just after COVID. Um, and they did a what you could call a flag planting exercise around the world. And then we've had a prolonged Long downturn in hiring markets, and Ames probably, sorry, Hayes has probably been the uh most aggressive there in taking that on. Um so they're going down from 31 to 16 core countries, from 21 global specialisms down to only six. Um, and that's really under the new Chief at Zec, uh Mark Durnley, um, who's driving that forward. They plan to deliver 50 fifty million per annum of structural cost savings uh for the full year.
4:26Dan Jones: There's an interesting note I was reading from Pamuel Liberum the other day as well, suggesting that when you consider these things, because yes, it's all about improving productivity, trying to do more with less would be the uh the way they'd probably say it, or maybe they wouldn't say it that way, but that's the general idea. And you look at these figures and you look at things like the amount of revenue they earn per consultant, for example, per recruiter, that's on the way up. But the note from Pam Muir quite rightly, I think, pointed out that you should maybe consider the amount of fee income you earn per staff cost rather than per earner, because it may be that they're cutting a load of people who aren't so experienced, and therefore pound for pound, you're not getting that boost in productivity. So that's one thing to look out for as well.
5:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, absolutely. Um I think the Pam Muir note mentioned that the sort of net fee income per pound of staff cost has ticked up a little bit, but it's still pretty close to uh 20 year lows there. Um and it's partly possibly because Hayes' own staff are costing more than they did 20 years ago. Um, and also probably a factor of the perm side of the business. So that's permanent hires as opposed to temporary contract hires. So the perm side being weaker than. the temporary side at present. Um, and temp margins tend to be lower, um, not just for Hayes, but for all the recruiters. And what we really need to see is a pickup in permanent hiring markets. Uh, we've seen early glimmers, we're not quite there yet.
5:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
5:53Dan Jones: that seems to be a reflection, doesn't it, of all this uncertainty. If you're a if you're a business, there's gonna going to be an attraction to an extent of hiring more temporary staff, or at least those businesses are going. to be less badly affected because they're going to be not as worried about some of these big issues coming down the line, such as AI, which has affected technology, of course, coding jobs, things like
6:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that.
6:14Dan Jones: The other risks for Hayes, Germany is going quite well. The cost savings plan is in train, but on the ground that given the amount of countries they're in, you need to see a lot of pick. pickups in a lot of different places, one would think, for a medium term expansion, for them to be able to hit their targets, perhaps. Or perhaps those targets are achievable via cost savings. But there are a number of risks still, clearly we are. Although we've seen a big share price bounce, it's not as if the recovery is here and alive and kicking just yet.
6:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, I think that's um totally fair to say that it's too early to call a broad-based recovery in hiring confidence. We've got some strong patches, if you like, across Americas. We've got pickup now in Germany for Hayes. Other European recruiters have also flagged particular bright spots, but on the whole, there's still quite a lot of weakness. There's quite a lot of uncertainty over the French hiring market, obviously, given what's going on there. And I think longer term, you've got structural concerns over AI's impact on the job market. But given all of that, I guess even with all of that, Hayes is still saying it's confident that it can meet its medium term targets through what it sort of terms self help. And that's all part of this big strategy called momentum, where they're aiming to get back up to, I think, 250 million. of operating profit, or in fact exceed two hundred and fifty million of operating profit. That was their previous peak at some point in the future. And they are they believe they can do that through self-help measures, with I guess any kind of big recovery in hiring markets being the icing on top of that.
7:56Dan Jones: Yeah. The benefit for these kind of companies is the operational leverage in the business as well, isn't it? So are they in only the require a small uptick in end markets for them to be able to see a real improvement on the bottom line. Certainly if you're doing cost cutting at the same time, you can see that translating. What do we think overall to cap it up cap it off then? The value of the shares. Clearly they've just had a big leap, but so have estimated earnings as well. So that could be keep kept roughly in line. How do we see the case for the recruiters right now? for Hayes in particular?
8:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, absolutely. I mean, the shares are up uh some 40%. They've pulled back a little bit today, but that suggests that they're doing quite well at holding these gains. Um, obviously recruiter stocks can be volatile. Um, but it looks as if we've seen an upwards re-rating of the multiple Hayes Pays trade on, because if you think of a 39% increase in the share price since the update and full year consensus earnings look like they're moving up by about 20%. So the share price has gone up by more than the earnings estimates. So it looks as if people are willing to pay a higher multiple for those earnings. Um perhaps suggesting there's more confidence in the delivery of its uh restructuring plan. Um, but where it's trading now is it's is trading on around 12 times. It was enterprise value is around 12 times its operating profit, its forward operating profit. So that 12 times is just above its 10-year average of 11 times. So it kind of looks up with events for now. And I think the volatility in these kind of stocks means that if you're not in it already, you maybe wait for a better entry point. If you're a holder, I wouldn't sell. If you th look back at historic share prices,
9:40its all-time high was just shy of five pounds. We're at 74p now. And as a rough guide, if they do hit that 250 million of operating profit, that's three times higher than what the market's looking for this year. Three times the share price would take you just north of two pounds. So um it could be worth holding on if you're in, possibly waiting for a slightly better entry point if you're not
10:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah
10:03Dan Jones: we did highlight them in the summer and earlier in the summer they also had a a bit of a well, quite a steep rise really. They have overdub they have more than doubled since uh June. So there's been quite a big rise in a short period of time, which I think partly speaks to the assumptions one has about the recruiters and the narrative of everyone knows the market is struggling. You get a lot of short interest there. So it doesn't take much of an improvement to see that share price. move. Now it has moved, maybe things are in balance a little bit more. We're going to turn now, though, to our next segment, which is all about the US. And it's our big read, our big feature this week online in print is our annual US special focusing on quality shares. One of those is actually NVIDIA, which we spoke about last week, and clearly there are a lot of questions there about the quality of the company's. earnings and whether it can maintain those. But we're not going to talk about NVIDIA again today. We're going to talk about uh a business which has benefited from the uncertainty dogging the AI trade at the moment, and that is Proctor and Gamble, a business most people will have some familiarity with, even though it is a US share because it owns a number of big brands, which we'll get on to, Erin. But why don't we start by outlining first of all what kind of thing things operationally make the company or have historically made PG a quality share?
11:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Sure. So I think the kind of if you're just looking at purely the financials for PG, they're definitely quality in terms of the return on capital employed. That's around 24%. They've got a 4.2% free cash flow yield. They're a very cash cash-generative generative company and they're quite reliable. in producing these profits. Second point you kind of alluded to, but it certainly has these more defensive characteristics because of the very nature of the business. They make products that are household names, you know, they own Pampers Napis, Gillette Razors, Tide Detergents, which maybe is more familiar to the kind of US customer, but they have this incredible reach and their portfolio spans, you know, many, many brands. I think more than 20 of their brands generate over a billion dollars in annual global sales each. So they have this incredible scale and range of brand recognition. And I think that that lends itself to the idea that, as you said, you know, in moments of kind of economic downturn, investors do look to companies that produce the products that consumers are reliably always going to need. And I think those are the kind of hallmarks of quality that.
12:27Procter and Gamble certainly does embody for investors.
12:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
12:31Dan Jones: shares have rallied in recent weeks with the sector, also on the back of a decent update as well, which we can talk about now. But the the other backdrop to this I should mention is despite that, and despite all the strength of these kind of companies and the brand power, as listeners may know from the UK companies, UK peers, the likes of. Unilever, etc., there have been struggles for these companies too, operationally in recent years because of high inflation, things like that. They've been relying a lot more on prices increasing rather than increasing the volume of sales. Uh what did we learn from the latest update for P and G
13:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, so I think as you rightly point out, Dan, I think in terms of sales growth for these consumer staples, volume growth is always much more highly prized than pricing growth. because it shows that more products are shifting off the shelves, the demand is there. And I think what we've seen in the kind of recent third quarter updates from the sort of UK peers like Unilevo, Rackett, Hallion, and then PG's first quarter update last month is that you know PG actually did relatively well. So they had organic sales growth of four 4%. percent. Um, and what was notable about that was it was driven by kind of half and half, so 2.4 increase in volumes as well as pricing. And that matters for investors because it signals there is demand for the products. And it's not just higher prices that are driving that. But on the flip side, you know, the gross margin did fall about 160 basis points. And I think that kind of speaks to the point that cost savings the company are trying to make have failed in some respects. to offset inflation and these kind of other sort of broader trends where consumers are maybe tightening their belts and trading down to own label products rather than going for the branded option. And that's something that we're seeing, you know, kind of globally across the North American and the European consumer.
14:21Dan Jones: Four-year guidance as well for the year which runs to next summer, their financial year was relatively. cautious, it seems certainly compared with some of the UK peers. Perhaps reflecting some of those headwinds you've just spoken about. Where are its opportunities, perhaps
14:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): when
14:37Dan Jones: you look at the different divisions, where is it performing well? Where
14:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
14:40Dan Jones: where are the issues which may have caused it to be a little bit more cautious in that guidance?
14:44Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, I think I think the guidance is a really interesting point because it certainly was more conservative than some of its peers. So so Procter and Gamble are looking at 1% to 3% organic sales growth, whereas someone like more like Racket are targeting kind of 3.5 to 4.5%. And Racquet and Hallion are interesting because they're more exposed to the sort of cold and flu medicine side of things. But with Procter ⁇ Gamble, the portfolio spans a range of categories, like you said, Dan. So they look at, you know, laundry products like Tide, they've got of course that sort of fabric and home care division. which is about 35% of their annual sales. So that's a really strong area for them. And that is what led a lot of the growth in the first quarter update. I think it was about 4.8% organic sales growth. And then you've got their sort of grooming and healthcare beauty divisions and their kind of baby and feminine care, which are, you know, some of those are a little bit more reliant on pricing, but I think the strength in laundry. is uh, you know, doing a lot for for Procter and Gamble. And it's important to mention as well that because they have this huge range of products, a lot of their products are in a lot of American households, which is their biggest market. But customers don't buy everything exclusively from Procter and Gamble. They might buy the detergent, but I think the opportunity there for the company is to get them to also buy the nappies or the razor blades and just bring those custom customers in to shop
16:04more broadly across the existing portfolio.
16:07Dan Jones: Yeah, they have been good historically. Another reason I think they've been quite well favoured by investors. They have been good at growing that market share quite consistently through the years. The the challenge is to keep doing that clearly in a more difficult environment, which we've seen the past Last few years and probably will for the next few where prices continue to go up. People are very cost conscious.
16:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They've
16:28Dan Jones: got a new chief executive, relatively new. They've got an investor day actually later today. So we don't know the results of that yet. The uh answer to this question might be given then rather than what you're able to say now. But what do we get the sense uh are the priorities of the new chief exec for the business?
16:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think so. Obviously, we've got uh Shailesh Shalesh uh Jajurakar who took over in January. And and like you you've said, because there has been this sense of slightly more sluggish growth in the consumer giant sector, there is a degree of pressure to maybe refresh the strategy, maybe look at some of the areas we've already discussed. For example, how can Procter Gamble increase its wallet share among existing customers? So obviously, clearly one way to grow is attract new customers. But I think the biggest opportunity is, you know, kind of leveraging the brand recognition they already have. and sort of yeah, coming at customers from all sides. There's also talk among analysts that it might not be as simple as the fact that people don't know about Procter and Gamble brands because they do, they have the brand recognition. The question might be more the sort of affordability point for lower income households. How can they kind of maybe change the size of their packet and pricing to maybe have entry? level products that can bring customers in from that side of the spectrum. And I think it was Jeffries that said, you know, even a one percentage point share market share gain in their key categories can translate to as much as, you know, a billion in additional US retail sales. So there's certainly all to play for. And I think that, you know, there should be elements of that that are possibly touched on in in today's investor day.
18:00Dan Jones: Yeah, the size of their the packet always sounds like a warning sign, doesn't it? Some kind of shrinkflation thing. But if it gets other customers in, then it must be working for them. Uh yes, the US clearly the the huge market for them. They're in various countries around the world, China as well, is another one where things have been a little bit volatile, but the figures in the first quarter looked a little bit better, perhaps. Lots of moving parts clearly with a company this size. But when you consider the valuation,
18:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how
18:28Dan Jones: does it look at the moment, given all that we've said?
18:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): So I think as you mentioned earlier, Dan, obviously the shares have uh been on a bit of a rally and I think they kind of currently sit around twelve month highs. When we look at the valuation, they're they're trading on about twenty-four times forward earnings, which is near enough bang on the five five-year year average, uh, and considerably more expensive than the likes of Wreck Wrecket, It, which is around fifteen. 15 times and Unilever about 17. So it's peers across the bot pond are certainly cheaper. And I think to an extent the kind of quality of Procter Gamble justifies some of this. But I think investors would be wise to also think about the forward sales guidance that has come out and the fact that Procter Gambles is definitely on the more cautious end of things. And I think the key question here is whether management are being, you know, it's smart that they're being very pragmatic and conservative, or whether those growth ambitions are actually a bit too modest for the price. And we've certainly seen, you know, Wreckett and Hallian both downgrade their sales guidance in recent months. So maybe there is a case for the new CEO being very prudent and actually just realistic and appreciating the shape of the market at the moment. But I think you know, given given the price, there are definitely more ambitious consumer staple targets this side of the Atlantic at the moment.
19:47Dan Jones: Yeah, uh those turnaround stories this side as well, certainly the likes of Unilever reshaping its business. So
19:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
19:53Dan Jones: different kind of story there in some ways, even though very sort even though it's a very similar company in and others. Equally, you look at conservative guidance and although it's a slightly different business, partially reminds me of something like Next, which is constantly lowballed a little bit and then beaten it a little bit. So it does give some room for maneuver. We'll keep tabs on what the investor day says and we'll keep tabs on PG as well. Today, though, we are going to finish by looking at the miners, the UK listed miners, a variety of them, clearly a large number. We'll will focus on some of the bigger names. The problem for most of them, certainly over the past week, the past month, Julian, is that share prices have been going in the wrong direction. And that to an extent is a reflection of their link to the uh AI trade nowadays, in the case of the copper miners.
20:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yes, it certainly is. It looks like AI is becoming uh an albatross for quite a few industries at the moment. Um it's interesting actually that the decline has been happening for longer than most of us supposed. So the last week uh the F the FTSE three fifty miners were down eight percent, which covers all of the big mining companies on the market.
21:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
21:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): uh for actually for the year to date, it's uh it's more like seventeen percent. So uh it's clear that uh the market's been pricing in a correction for some time. And uh this is actually despite uh most of them achieving uh really quite good uh levels of cash flow generation at the last set of results. Uh but as we all know, those are backward looking numbers. And uh what we're looking at to the at the moment is both a squeeze on the copper price, uh, which is enduring its uh uh longest uh run of weekly declines in two years, uh, as well as gold uh uh dipping below three thousand eight hundred. at one point uh this week as the Fed gets uh all hawkish. So you've got this combination of factors. It's what yeah, there is a a definite sense that uh they've been caught up in someone else's boom, uh, which is now deflating. Uh and on the other side of the coin you have uh a macroeconomic environment that uh means that interest rates are going to go up. As soon as interest rates go up, that means that commodity prices uh come under pressure. So there's a simple equation at work here, um, basically. And uh we are now looking at um you know uh really quite substantial uh discounts to where the where the uh where copper commodities were at one point. Copper's like fifteen percent below the high, uh and gold uh is
22:21is more like thirty percent off the uh peak, which was in uh January this year. So yes, it's uh it's a very complex uh situation and uh yeah I don't think investors are enjoying the ride very much.
22:32Dan Jones: We should talk about gold a little bit more because the copper price has dropped a little bit over the last couple of months, pretty much in line with slightly shakier AI sentiment. There are a lot of other factors in copper as well going into that price, but that is certainly the marginal driver at the moment. The gold price uh as you noted, has been falling for most of the year, though, after that huge rally. It's not really been a defensive asset as people hoped, even during the latest sell-off, partly because I think it's become a m momentum asset over the last few years. Let's talk a little bit more about the US rate impact, the U.S. interest rate impact, because, as you said, the Fed is becoming more hawkish.
23:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Interest
23:14Dan Jones: rates are going. to go up in December, possibly again in January. Possibly there could be a big rise in December. The dollar has been strong as well. And that generally always spells trouble for for gold in particular, as well as uh commodities prices in general.
23:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes,
23:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): absolutely. We the dollar has been on a real run. It's now near a nineteen month high. Uh and that's almost exclusively to do with people pricing in rate hikes. And uh you know, the holding dollars just becomes more more lucrative just because of those macroecroeconomic factors. Also, the gold miners, specifically, if you look back at how production's been been running, there has there is a bit of a gloss of gold coming onto the market. Most of the miners did report uh higher than uh average production over the last uh six months, obviously taking advantage of that uh that real space. spike in the price. Uh and obviously as soon as you get a ramp in production, you're going to get a glut. So um if uh central banks are stopping or winding down their gold buying and going instead into dollars, which is uh what seems to be happening at the moment, then inevitably that causes this. Yeah, it's gonna cause price declines. And you're right as well, people have been treating it as a momentum asset. Uh I mean I th I kind of th always
24:28found the idea that gold was a reliable store of value and increased an increasingly ludicrous proposition. But uh uh yeah, as soon as as soon as those trades go into reverse, they go into reverse quite dramatically. So that's why we've seen these uh 30% declines over the course of this year. But uh yeah, so they're they're they're all linked together, really. But uh it does mean that the individual miners have suffered quite uh
24:54Dan Jones: Yeah. Endeavour mining was one you covered a trading update for this week or the other day. What uh what did we get from that that we don't know already from the way the gold price has been behaving in recent months?
25:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Well it it it shows exactly what the the problem is for the miners in that their cash generation has been excellent because of high prices. or high average prices, but the quality of the operational side of the businesses has been relatively poor. So, you know, Endeavour uh increased its free cash flow uh at its last trading results of uh by 50% to more than a billion dollars, which uh you know is is no is not to be sniffed at. But uh it was on the back of essentially what uh were high prices only, whereas its underlying operations have been a affected by jurisdictional disputes. It had um uh uh subsidence problems at its uh mana mine in Burkina Faso. Uh it means that quite a bit of its individual operations will come in below the production range that they forecast, which was um, you know, at the moment is looking at just over a million ounces, but um that's at the lower end of the range that they've been forecasting. Uh costs have been higher, obviously, because everyone's paying more for diesel. Uh so yeah, you're you're getting this kind of aggregation of factors that are coming together to affect them, but you know that their their operations are costing them more to run at the same time as the price is now
26:20collapsing. So unsurprisingly, investors then take their money out of uh out of the shares.
26:25Dan Jones: We should wrap up by talking. uh about an interesting idea that was floated uh the other week, albeit one that is very much, I think, at the hypothetical stage, and it concerns Anglo-American, which has held up relatively well this year overall, clearly very much exposed to copper, but a lot of some MA restructuring activity going on there, which we won't go into now. But uh at a FT F T conference, the chief exec did float the idea of tech companies taking stakes in miners to shore up supply, which I mean it wouldn't do anything to l unlink them from the AI trade for one thing, but might be something to keep an eye on, perhaps.
27:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
27:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I mean I read this and I thought, yeah, there is one born every minute, isn't there? Uh
27:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
27:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): know, this was somebody prepared to throw money down a deep hole. Um and, you know, obviously the tech uh companies would be the ideal candidates for the next one. I mean it does, in a sense, they confirm the kind of idea that there is a scarcity of minerals in the supply chain, of essential minerals, of rare minerals, those kind of things. But um the the danger for the miners, obviously, is that they get so caught up in AI sentiment that uh it doesn't matter whether they're doing operationally or not. It's the idea that um you know their downstream customers won't be buying quite so much. that will that will drive the the sentiment around shows. I mean in many ways it reminds you of you know the early 2010s when we had the whole sort of China bull bull run on uh things like iron ore and copper. And uh you know if you replace tech companies uh if you replace China with tech companies you've got the s the the the same kind of the the the same kind of sort of general sentiment assuming that just because there is the demand that that will hold up the price. I mean that that really doesn't work like that in commodities. It's a v it's a it's almost a market unto itself really.
28:10Dan Jones: Yeah, absolutely. I mean you think of something like copper and you think of its role, which we've been told for many years and we agree with frankly, you know, the role it will play in the energy transition. And yeah yet that doesn't always translate into price gains. And we've seen this year the price rise until recently was probably driven by AI euphoria and is now coming off a little bit because of that. And I think it just goes to show, as with a lot of these things, that the narratives don't always match up with the share prices, and it's something to keep an eye on. Anyway, that brings us to the end of today's show. We have run out of time, unfortunately. So thank you very much, Julian. Thank you to Erin, to Kirsty. Thank you to our producers, Ella Manning and Johnny Dowling. We'll be back next week with another. Companies and Markets show.