Money Tree Investing

College planning expert Brian Safdari argues that higher education is a complex business and families must start planning early to optimize financial aid and avoid debt traps.

1h 13m Listen to the original Episode page
College PlanningFinancial AidHigher Education CostsRetirement PlanningStudent LoansWealth ManagementEducation ROIStrategic Enrollment

Summary

College planning expert Brian Safdari argues that the US higher education system is deliberately complicated to maximize revenue, with tuition costs rising steadily since 1980. He advises families to begin strategic planning in seventh or eighth grade to align academic preparation with student interests and financial goals. Safdari claims that colleges use 'strategic enrollment management' to manipulate rankings and that high-income families can leverage institutional aid and tax strategies to reduce costs. The discussion emphasizes that college planning is inseparable from retirement planning, as both draw from the same family balance sheet. Speakers warn against relying solely on guidance counselors or standardized rankings, advocating instead for proactive, holistic financial and academic preparation.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    He equates college planning with retirement planning, arguing that sacrificing retirement security for college is a strategic error because both draw from the same balance sheet.

    Brian Safdari · 1:09:27

Episode sections

  1. 0:01 – 2:31

    Introduction and Speaker Background

    Kurt Chisholm introduces guest Brian Safdari, a college planning expert. Safdari shares his personal history as a refugee from Afghanistan, his failed attempt at an athletic scholarship due to injury, and his subsequent experience with high debt from attending a local university, which led him to found College Planning Experts in 2005.

  2. 2:31 – 3:59

    The Business of Higher Education

    Safdari argues that the higher education system is a business designed to be complicated, noting that US tuition has never decreased since 1980. He claims the complexity is deliberate, leading families to start too late and miss out on grants and financial aid.

  3. 3:59 – 7:51

    Timing and Academic Preparation

    Safdari recommends starting college planning in seventh and eighth grade to ensure students meet A-G requirements and take rigorous courses like AP or honors classes. He contrasts this with high school counselors who often wait until junior year, which he considers too late.

  4. 7:51 – 18:10

    Identifying Passion Through Assessments

    The discussion shifts to ninth grade, focusing on identifying a student's 'true why' through interests, skills, and values assessments (e.g., Myers-Briggs, StrengthFinder). Safdari warns against choosing majors based solely on interest, citing risks like changing majors, delayed graduation, and poor ROI.

  5. 18:10 – 29:25

    College Fit and Strategic Enrollment Management

    Safdari outlines a proprietary college fit process evaluating academic, social, and financial factors. He introduces 'strategic enrollment management,' claiming colleges use this business strategy to boost rankings, and asserts that proper packaging of a student's profile can yield a 92% acceptance rate into top schools.

  6. 29:25 – 33:55

    Financial Aid and Income Planning

    Safdari explains the 'prior-prior year' tax system for financial aid and the Student Aid Index (SAI). He claims high-income families can use legal income planning strategies, such as business investments, to lower their Adjusted Gross Income (AGI) and qualify for need-based grants like Cal Grants.

  7. 33:55 – 36:28

    Institutional Aid and Strategic Packaging

    Brian Safdari explains that institutional aid is often available to high-income families ($250k+) as a tuition discount to secure long-term alumni relationships. He illustrates this with a case study of a student packaged into a chemical engineering program to leverage diversity goals (female Hispanic engineer), securing $30k in grants.

  8. 36:28 – 39:09

    Workshops and Funding Strategy

    Safdari offers free nationwide workshops on admissions and financial aid, warning that paying tuition after receiving grants can reduce future aid. He directs listeners to collegeplanning.com for consultations and workshops.

  9. 39:09 – 48:25

    Holistic Financial Planning and Timing

    Kurt Chisholm and Doug Agrin discuss how college planning must integrate with family retirement, tax, and liquidity goals. They emphasize that starting planning in 8th or 9th grade allows for better GPA management and financial projection, whereas senior year is too late for deep optimization.

  10. 48:25 – 52:26

    Senior Year Challenges and FAFSA Timing

    Chisholm notes that senior year is the busiest due to emotional distractions and overlapping deadlines. He stresses filing FAFSA immediately on October 1st because grant money is limited and competitive schools require early submission.

  11. 52:26 – 57:43

    Guidance Counselor Limitations and Tools

    Safdari criticizes high school guidance counselors for lacking resources and relying on peer-implemented data from tools like Naviance. He argues counselors are overwhelmed by mental health issues and cannot provide deep, individualized college fit analysis.

  12. 57:43 – 1:00:02

    Rankings Gaming and Selectivity

    Safdari claims U.S. News rankings are gamed by increasing application volume while capping acceptances to lower the acceptance rate, thereby appearing more selective. He cites the book 'Degrees and Pedigrees' as a resource on the reality of education ROI.

  13. 1:00:02 – 1:01:01

    Etymology of Prestige

    Safdari notes the Latin root of 'prestigious' means 'to deceive,' contrasting it with modern social acceptance. He argues that prestige is often a result of business pressures and statistical manipulation rather than educational quality.

  14. 1:01:01 – 1:13:04

    State Demographics and Admissions

    Safdari suggests colleges may adjust admissions difficulty based on state population density, making it easier for out-of-state students from less populous states (e.g., Arkansas) to gain admission to boost rankings, though he notes this is not universal.

Claims worth verifying

Safdari was born in Afghanistan, lived as a refugee for five years, and migrated to the US in 1986.

Brian Safdari ·0:32

How to verify: Public biography on College Planning Experts website or LinkedIn profile of Brian Safdari. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Safdari made the Olympic Development Program (ODP) in 1996 and 1998 and represented the junior US team at the 1998 World Cup in France.

Brian Safdari ·1:12

How to verify: US Soccer Federation historical records or ODP archives for California region 2026-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Safdari graduated with $53,000 in debt from Cal State Northridge after living at home and commuting.

Brian Safdari ·1:52

How to verify: Personal financial disclosure or interview archives; difficult to verify independently without personal records. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Safdari founded College Planning Experts in 2005.

Brian Safdari ·2:12

How to verify: Company incorporation records or 'About Us' page on College Planning Experts website. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Tuition in the US has not decreased since 1980.

Brian Safdari ·2:51

How to verify: National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) data on average tuition and fees at private and public institutions from 1980 to present. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Safdari's firm has a 92% acceptance rate into clients' top three dream schools.

Brian Safdari ·23:15

How to verify: Company marketing materials or case studies from College Planning Experts; requires verification of sample size and definition of 'dream schools'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

High-income families can use business investments to lower Adjusted Gross Income (AGI) to qualify for Cal Grants.

Brian Safdari ·32:31

How to verify: California Department of Education Cal Grant eligibility guidelines and IRS tax code regarding business expense deductions and AGI calculation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Institutional aid can be given to families making over $250,000 a year to secure long-term alumni relationships.

Brian Safdari ·34:11

How to verify: Verify by checking individual college financial aid websites for 'institutional aid' or 'donor preference' policies; consult college admission guides for examples of high-income aid. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

A student named Natalie with a 3.4 GPA received $30,000 in grants from Pepperdine University by being packaged into chemical engineering as a female Hispanic.

Brian Safdari ·35:31

How to verify: Verify by searching Pepperdine University press releases or news archives for 'Natalie' and 'chemical engineering' scholarship; check Pepperdine financial aid policies for demographic preferences. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

FAFSA opens on October 1st.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·49:31

How to verify: Verify by visiting fafsa.gov or the U.S. Department of Education website for the current year's FAFSA opening date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

U.S. News rankings are gamed by colleges increasing application volume while capping acceptances to lower acceptance rates.

Brian Safdari ·59:42

How to verify: Verify by analyzing U.S. News methodology for 'selectivity' (acceptance rate + SAT/ACT scores); compare historical acceptance rates vs. application volume data for specific universities. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The word 'prestigious' comes from the Latin word meaning 'to deceive'.

Brian Safdari ·1:00:02

How to verify: Verify by checking the etymology of 'prestigious' in the Oxford English Dictionary or Merriam-Webster. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Colleges may make it easier for out-of-state students from less populous states (e.g., Arkansas) to gain admission to boost rankings.

Brian Safdari ·1:01:01

How to verify: Verify by comparing admission acceptance rates for in-state vs. out-of-state applicants at universities in states with low population density (e.g., Arkansas, Wyoming) using Common Data Set information. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Naviance data is peer-implemented and biased because accepted students leave the platform.

Brian Safdari ·53:59

How to verify: Verify by reviewing Naviance's user agreement or terms of service regarding data collection; check independent reviews or case studies on Naviance data accuracy. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Middle school grades that transfer to high school can permanently cap a student's GPA.

Kurt Chisholm ·44:25

How to verify: Verify by checking the specific high school's grading policy or state education department rules on middle school course transfers and GPA calculation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Colleges engage in strategic enrollment management to adjust student demographics for political or business needs, such as keeping more students in-state after college.

Brian Safdari ·1:01:41

How to verify: Review university strategic enrollment management reports, state residency data, and public statements from university admissions offices regarding enrollment goals. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

High-income families earning $250,000 to $500,000 often assume they do not need college planning because they won't qualify for financial aid.

Brian Safdari ·1:03:02

How to verify: Survey data from college planning firms or financial advisors regarding high-income family perceptions of aid eligibility. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Federal student loans carry simple interest, meaning interest is calculated only on the borrowed principal, not compounded.

Brian Safdari ·1:05:59

How to verify: U.S. Department of Education Federal Student Aid website, specifically the loan terms and conditions for Direct Subsidized and Unsubsidized Loans. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Federal student loans are forgiven upon the death of the borrower.

Brian Safdari ·1:06:19

How to verify: U.S. Department of Education Federal Student Aid website, section on 'Discharge of Loans' or 'Death Discharge'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The FAFSA uses a 'prior-prior year' income calculation for financial aid eligibility.

Brian Safdari ·1:04:39

How to verify: U.S. Department of Education Federal Student Aid website, explaining the FAFSA application process and income verification rules. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Mergent Advisors offers a free College Money Report that estimates costs and aid for up to three schools.

Brian Safdari ·1:11:11

How to verify: Visit mergentadvisors.net and attempt to access the 'College Money Report' tool to verify its existence and functionality. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Mergent Advisors offers a free Scholarship Estimator and School Comparison Report.

Brian Safdari ·1:11:31

How to verify: Visit mergentadvisors.net and check for the availability of the 'Scholarship Estimator' and 'School Comparison Report' tools. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the claim that US tuition has never decreased since 1980 using the College Board's Trends in College Pricing data.
  • Review the 'prior-prior year' FAFSA rules on fafsa.gov to understand how tax filing impacts aid eligibility.
  • Check the acceptance rates and ranking methodologies of target universities directly on their admissions websites, rather than relying solely on U.S. News rankings.
  • Research the 'Degrees and Pedigrees' book by Christopher L. Cadogan and others for data on education ROI and ranking manipulation.
  • Consult a tax professional to evaluate the impact of income-shifting strategies (e.g., business investments) on Adjusted Gross Income and financial aid eligibility.
  • Review the terms of federal student loans on studentaid.gov, specifically regarding simple interest and death discharge provisions.
  • Assess family liquidity and retirement savings to determine if paying college costs would compromise long-term financial security.
  • Verify the accuracy of Naviance data by cross-referencing with official college admissions statistics, noting potential selection bias in peer-submitted data.
Full transcriptexpand
0:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Welcome to the Money Tree Investing Podcast. Stock market, wealth, personal finance, value stocks. Invest in your life.
0:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hello,
0:12
Kurt Chisholm: Smart Money Tree Podcast listeners. Welcome to this week's show. My name is Kurt Chisholm, and I'll be your host. So today I'm joined with Brian Safdari. How are you doing today, Brian?
0:19
Brian Safdari: Doing good. Thanks for having me, Kurt.
0:21
Kurt Chisholm: Glad to have you on. So brought Brian on. You know, I've had a lot of questions recently about college. You know, we've had a few guests. on, but keep getting more questions. We want to bring on Brian to talk about college. So tell us a little bit about your background.
0:32
Brian Safdari: So first off, I was born in Afghanistan. We were refugees for five years, going through a very dangerous journey to go from Afghanistan to Iran to India. And finally, my parents migrated here in 86. And education represented freedom for my family, which is why we came. to the U.S. And we were blessed to
0:52
Brian Safdari: have the opportunity to come here. And I was five years old, started kindergarten here. And I basically grew up in Northridge, California. Been here in Northridge my whole life. I was a soccer player. My dad played pro soccer and I was chasing my dad's dream. I made the Olympic development program, which is ODP in 96, 98. I
1:12
Brian Safdari: made the France World Cup, went to the World Cup. not the current one that just ended, which was great, but the World Cup in 98 in France, was able to represent the junior US team. And my dream was to play pro soccer and go to college through athletic scholarships. And unfortunately, my senior year I tore my growing muscle, I got injured. And through
1:32
Brian Safdari: the injury I realized that I'm not going to get scholarships. And because of that personal experience I went through, I ended up going to Cal State Northridge, which is close by. But I got into Duke, UCLA, North Carolina University, the top D1 schools. And I found out after graduating with $53,000 in debt,
1:52
Brian Safdari: living at home, commuting, making mistakes on the FAFSA form since my parents were low income. I made all the mistakes there is in this college planning process. And when I graduated, I found out I could have gone to Duke for cheaper than going to Cal State Northridge. And that's what opened my eyes. And in 2005, I
2:12
Brian Safdari: started college planning experts to help other families avoid the mistakes that I made.
2:17
Kurt Chisholm: Why do you think they make the process so complicated? It's one thing I hear about a lot in the this show is that the college process is overly complicated. where it's easy for most people to make mistakes. Why do you think it's that complicated?
2:31
Brian Safdari: Well, anything that the government touches and the process you go through, it's difficult, like taxes and higher education system. And I truly believe it's a business. Since 1980, tuition has not decreased in the US. Gas prices go up and down, mortgages go up and down, home value. values
2:51
Brian Safdari: go up and down, stocks go up and down. But tuition in the US has never gone down since 1980. So it's a business. It's a very profitable business. The more mistakes, the more errors, the way this process is designed, which we can get into like very specifically how they present the process
3:10
Brian Safdari: and when they present this process for a family, it's too late. when families are starting this process, which is why they make a lot of mistakes, which then leads into missing out on a lot of grants and financial aid.
3:23
Kurt Chisholm: It's almost deliberately designed to confuse people. And it's usually people who need it the most. I mean, the people who have money are typically the wisest of the bunch and have access to people to get this kind of advice. And the people without are the ones that get screwed over. And just like you're saying, starting to go through the process
3:43
Kurt Chisholm: myself with my kid, I think one of the biggest challenges is like, where do you start? You have these resources, these guidance counselors and school counselors that are working with like hundreds of students and they're they don't even know who you are. How can people even start this? It's almost overwhelming to even start. Like, how do you even start this process?
3:59
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
3:59
Brian Safdari: usually tell parents, seventh and eighth grade is the best time to get started.
4:03
Brian Safdari: because time is on your side. Time allows you to prepare, plan, strategize, look out for resources. Now today, with ChatGBT and the way AI just captures more info faster, there's a lot more hope for families to utilize search engines, but more
4:23
Brian Safdari: so find experts that are out there that's been there. done it, and that are still doing it, that can make this a lot easier. But typically, like my daughter just started ninth grade. Last year she started working with our top admissions counselors because our counselors have a master's degree in college admissions counseling and they work in the admissions office.
4:43
Brian Safdari: So they come from a real admissions mental background, understanding how colleges admit students versus. high school counselors that are just giving you general information as far as the process. And they don't start till like the junior year is when they start talking about admissions and
5:03
Brian Safdari: applications coming. It's too late when kids are being introduced in the junior year. That's why they make a lot of mistakes. So when I do these workshops all across the country, I have more families today that are understanding you have to start seventh, eighth, ninth grade to get this journey started versus waiting until the junior year.
5:23
Brian Safdari: So I always say parents that are listening to your podcast and are making this effort and listening and learning, implementation, taking that first step in anything is always the difficult part, whether you're working out, whether you're trying to save. money for a house or investments, that first
5:43
Brian Safdari: step is always the hardest step. But when a family makes that first step to go out and find people that can guide them and coach them and provide education and guidance, that's usually the hardest part. But once they get that going, momentum and time really becomes your best friend in this journey.
6:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): When
6:01
Kurt Chisholm: you say like seven seventh, days. eighth, and ninth grade, I mean, that seems kind of early and very few people are thinking in that way. What are people doing? Are people going out and going on college tours in seventh grade? Like what kind of things are people doing at that young age?
6:14
Brian Safdari: So typically seventh and eighth grade, we want to make sure students are not behind in their core classes in school, their A through G requirements, their math, their science, their English classes. If they fall behind and in middle school and the curriculum in middle school, it starts putting them behind in high school. And you have an A
6:34
Brian Safdari: through G requirement. And there are things that are just basic in the admissions process, which is just your transcript and your curriculum, your classes you take in which order, taking more rigorous courses, like starting to take AP courses and honors courses and prepping for that is part of this journey to
6:54
Brian Safdari: get a student really involved in understanding how do you show rigorous and show that you can handle this caliber of academics. Because at college, they want to see are you able to handle the academics and the pressure that goes into college. Right off the bat, just the academic planning alone is a
7:14
Brian Safdari: good place. to get the student to understand why do you do what you do in school? Because a lot of times they go to school, they don't understand why they're taking courses. Why are they taking all these courses? How do these courses translate into the real world when they eventually get to the working force? So we help students and we break it down into the To importance of
7:34
Brian Safdari: how the classes in high school, how does it translate into the real world?
7:39
Kurt Chisholm: So seventh and eighth grade, you really focus on curriculum rigor of the curriculum, making sure they have certain things. What's the next kind of block you focus on once you make sure that's taken care of?
7:51
Brian Safdari: Next thing would be in ninth grade. Typically, what we like to do is everybody just focuses on the academic, the curriculum, and the school stuff, which is important. But the part that students in the year, 21 years and going that I've been doing this, I see a lot of students don't know what's
8:11
Brian Safdari: their true why. So I always tell a student, read the book by Simon Sinek, start with why first. A lot of times they don't know their true why. They know their interest. And you ask a student, what do you want to do? And every six months, their interest changes. So when their interest changes, based on whatever interest they
8:31
Brian Safdari: have, their careers that they might have may change. So a student might tell me, Well, I want to be a nurse. And I ask the first question, Why do you want to be a nurse? Or why do you want to be an engineer or a software engineer? And typically they'll say, It's interesting, or I like it. It's the interest.
8:51
Brian Safdari: is triggered in a human being first. Like when I was growing up, I want to be a motorcycle cop because I would come home and watch chips on TV. For those who maybe are old enough to understand that I was influenced by chips. So I was like, I want to be a hero. I want to help people. I want to be a motorcycle cop. So today kids are influenced around their parents'
9:10
Brian Safdari: jobs, their relatives, their friends, their family. So when they tell me stuff. something, they haven't really thoroughly figured out what they want and what their true why is, they're going off of their interest. So I'll share a story. A couple of years into my practice, I was helping kids get in. And there were four major things I noticed what was happening with my kids
9:30
Brian Safdari: that I got into college. Number one, they were changed Change their majors twice within the first two years in college. And I was wondering, why is the major majors changing? After they told me what they want to do and we got them into their dream college, their colleges changed or their interests changed, which they would come back to me and say, Brian, we changed our majors, which
9:50
Brian Safdari: basically means that it took them maybe a year longer to graduate. Second thing I saw is students came back to us and say, Brian, we're changing our major. I figured out what I want to do, but this is not the right college. Can we switch to another college? Which I helped them and they went to a complete different school that was a better career fit for them. The third thing
10:10
Brian Safdari: I saw are students take just longer to graduate because they were bouncing around so many times and they have no idea why they were at that university. And the fourth thing was very disturbing, which was students graduating, getting a degree in something that there wasn't a good job or income.
10:30
Brian Safdari: Why go to college and get a degree something where it's not going to pay off? If that ROI, that return on investment's not there, why go there? So those four things were happening my first couple of years in practice. So we went back on the drawing board and we said, what's happening with these four instances that's costing time and money and anxiety and
10:50
Brian Safdari: frustration? and confusion for parents and students. And what we realized were two major things that I discovered, which was just because you like something doesn't mean you're good at it. Or just because you're good at something doesn't mean you like it. So we realized the two other key
11:09
Brian Safdari: areas for a student to truly find their passion is understanding their true skill. set and their true values in life. When you can align your interests, your values, and your skills, those three things trigger your passion. And they were doing a lot of these assessments in college. And I started thinking, I'm like, I was
11:29
Brian Safdari: me. I wanted to be a CPA when I went to college because I was good in math and I wanted to be a CPA. But when I went to C CSUN Sun and I started working for a CPA, I didn't want to. do the bookkeeping and the tax returns. I wanted to be more on the creative side and the problem solving of the finance space, which is why I love what I do and
11:49
Brian Safdari: I have such a passion for it, is really helping people find money where they're losing unknowingly and unnecessarily. So those three things, helping a student with their interests, values, and skills. helps them truly see their passion and what careers are in high demand. I have to preface on this,
12:09
Brian Safdari: Kirk. This is so important that just getting a career and going in something that you have a passion doesn't mean your passion is going to pay you or give you a job or a career. But going into something that there's a dynamic need for it is very important. We spend a lot of time in truly making sure a student is going into a career that there's a
12:29
Brian Safdari: true need for it. And once they figure that out and we get that, everything else becomes so much easier. Meaning picking the right colleges that's going to help them get into that career, the connections, the degree, and everything that goes into it, with the college applications, the essays, all that stuff,
12:49
Brian Safdari: everybody does, but everybody puts the cart before the horse, which is they don't really truly help the student find their passion. Because if you don't do that, doesn't matter going into the best strategies to get into the college. And you go to college that the student comes out and goes, that's not what I want to do. And I figured out what I want to do. You
13:08
Brian Safdari: don't want them to come back to you two, three years in college and tell you now they figured out what they want to do. We accelerate that in ninth and tenth grade to help the student truly see their path. It's almost like a if I give you a map, Kirk, if you go on the road and I give you a navigation system, you're gonna look at me and say, what do I do with
13:28
Brian Safdari: this? It's useless. But if I tell you, Kirk, you're gonna put in this address and this is where I need you to go, you put in the navigation, that navigation helps you get there and you trust that navigation. It's the same with college. I can tell a student or parent says, go to college, but if you're going to college, you don't know why you're going there and how that's going to pay off. College is useless.
13:48
Brian Safdari: But when you understand how to utilize these tools, college can be priceless.
13:54
Kurt Chisholm: Yeah, I agree. I think this is one of the biggest challenges. You're asking a ninth or tenth grader what they want to be when they grow up. And I mean, I don't know anybody who knew what they want to be. wanted to be when they grew up at nine or 10. You know, they might have known directionally, like I want to run a business or something like that, or maybe I want to be a doctor. But generally speaking, most kids don't know. That's part of the point of college,
14:14
Kurt Chisholm: is figuring out what they want to be. I assume you have them do certain assessments and figure out where their natural tendencies are and things like that. And then what do you do with that information? Because, like you said, it can change. multiple times. It can, as they grow, they can have certain realizations. Like one of my sons just got a job, so he's figuring
14:34
Kurt Chisholm: out what jobs are about. You know, like
14:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well, you
14:36
Kurt Chisholm: know, he's excited, but let's see how long he's excited for, you know. But absolutely.
14:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): How do
14:41
Kurt Chisholm: you do that? You just have him do like an assessment, or is it an extensive process, or is it pretty quick to figure this out?
14:46
Brian Safdari: Typically, we use like three different assessments. We use like the Myers Myers-Briggs Briggs assessment. you know, that's very popular and has a lot of good track record. We like to do the interest assessment, the skills, the values, and the aptitude or attitude aspect. So there's four different
15:06
Brian Safdari: criteria we use for that.
15:08
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
15:08
Brian Safdari: know, there's a lot of tools out there. High schools have different software programs, program, but I always say that, oh, it's how a administered to guide a student is very important, not just going online and finding a career program. But the ones, the four areas that students and parents should be thinking about, whatever software they use is to make sure
15:28
Brian Safdari: it has the interests assessment, the aptitudes and attitude portion of what careers, based on their personality, they're going to make a good fit, the strengths and very values. So, like we like strengthfinder is really good for the strength side of it. Myers Briggs is really good. So there's many tools there, but we usually
15:48
Brian Safdari: help the student understand how to take each component and bring it together and say, look, you might have interest in going here, but you're not going to gonna have the values here. So I like got a student that likes to help kids and they their interest was in helping kids and working with kids. And we went through the
16:07
Brian Safdari: assessments. And when we went through the monetary side of things, and he goes, Yeah, I want to be a teacher, I want to work with kids and all of that. Then we went through the values assessment. And through the values, money was important for him because money meant that he can have nicer stuff he wanted and he wanted. a certain
16:27
Brian Safdari: quality of lifestyle and places he wanted to live. And we said, okay, if you're going to go here, it's a very rewarding job. I love teachers for what they do, but here's the income you're going to make. And that didn't go well for him. So then we started getting into it. And he wanted to get into working with kids that have learning disabilities
16:47
Brian Safdari: and getting into more of that area than. that just was a higher income. So we started tweaking and changing and adjusting, and we kind of figured out a few Q components he wanted. And we started aligning the interests, values, and skills. And that's how we were able to help a student find those different areas. So, like even my daughter, she's in
17:07
Brian Safdari: eighth grade. And I was like, we were driving one day, and she loves like being an entrepreneur and loves business and all that. And I was telling her something. and she goes, Dad, yeah, that's good, but I don't think I agree to this or that. And it was just the perfect example that I tell parents that you might, as parents, tell your kids what to do, but they might
17:27
Brian Safdari: not listen to you the way they do when they have a mentor or somebody else. So one of the advice I have for parents is have your child work with a mentor or coach versus you saying it, because I just experienced it. 21 years in doing this. My own daughter's like, Brian, Dad, I don't know if this is right. Then Heather, my counselor, had that same
17:47
Brian Safdari: discussion with her and she didn't object to Heather, but she objected to me because I'm dad at the end of the day. A
17:52
Kurt Chisholm: whole lot of truth to
17:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that.
17:56
Kurt Chisholm: I know what that's about. Doesn't matter what you say, you just better coming from someone else.
18:00
Brian Safdari: Yeah, exactly.
18:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
18:03
Kurt Chisholm: So it sounds like seventh, eighth grade curriculum, ninth, tenth grade, do assessments. What comes after that?
18:10
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
18:10
Brian Safdari: once we help the student get their assessments, we show them what type of majors are going to be applicable to those careers. Usually we like to look at two, three different careers that align with their interest interests, values and skills. That leads to two, three different majors.
18:27
Brian Safdari: that may be applicable. So we're not just honing in so deep into one major or one career. So we want to keep our options a little broad and open for now. And with that, it allows us to see what majors would be best and what careers for our students. And then from there, we start doing our college
18:47
Brian Safdari: fit process. So we have a proprietary process on our college fit. With our college fit, we really look at the schools, number one, that have the majors and those career opportunities and the best connections into the workforce within those colleges. So when we're picking colleges, we're having students think about not
19:07
Brian Safdari: just the academic to get the degree, but what kind of connections do these universities have in the working force? in the areas of careers you're looking at? So we want to help students think about college as a connection, as opportunities. You're buying connections and it's an environment that allows you
19:27
Brian Safdari: to find the right mentors and coaches. So we help them look at the colleges and the careers and the schools and the majors. Then we look at 10, 15, 20 colleges that come up. And a lot of students might have, you know, their own assessments in school, like they have like novants or they have some kind of program.
19:47
Brian Safdari: And we start looking at either college board or we have our own software that helps the students really narrow down 10, 20, 30 colleges. At first, I tell parents when you get through this part, you want to make sure the students just filter. colleges based on majors, two, three majors, and
20:07
Brian Safdari: do a search first. That way you get hundreds of schools that may come up first as you filter 4,500 colleges. Then I tell the parents and the students to start really narrowing down the colleges based on academic fit. What's the right academic schools first, then social.
20:27
Brian Safdari: fit is the second big one, which students want to look at, like the weather, people, culture, size, locations. So some families of mine here in California culturally they want their kids to stay local. In California, for example, they don't want to go too far because they're very family oriented. It's a cultural thing. So that has to go
20:47
Brian Safdari: into the picture to understand the family's culture. and what's most important to them. So that's the social fit. Sometimes students will say, Brian, my child wants to go to BU. So I had a student go to Boston University, got a finance degree, came out of BU with a $120,000 income job at B of A,
21:06
Brian Safdari: but didn't want to take it, wanted to come back to California because it was too cold and he wanted to come back to California. So he lost all the connections, came back here, and just went out and started searching for jobs after having a degree. But if he stayed out there, he already had connections. He had done internships in college and had established relationships,
21:26
Brian Safdari: and he was going to get a job right after college. So understanding the weather, the people, the culture, which that takes visiting colleges and doing the college visits and tours really help a student. really look at how do you narrow down the right college fit. So in ninth and tenth grade, we're already helping the
21:46
Brian Safdari: students really have a good vision of what are 10, 20, 30 schools that academically, socially, and financially make a good fit. This is really important because the kids focus so much on the academic and social fit. They get into college, the parents have no clue how much it's going to cost. They get in and then they
22:06
Brian Safdari: get sticker shock and they're like, oh, sorry, honey, we can't go here. It's too expensive. Why spend so much time doing applications and essays and all this work if you have no idea what the net cost is going to cost you in this process? So you have to make sure academically it's the right school, socially and financially
22:26
Brian Safdari: the parents. are not gonna go broke funding that college for the next four years. So that's how we start narrowing the right college fit.
22:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
22:33
Kurt Chisholm: you're doing that, you said ninth, tenth grade.
22:35
Brian Safdari: Yep. Okay. And then that also helps us, Kirk, because when you know 10, 20 schools, we have admissions officers that work for us. Admissions officers know for each school the actual curriculum to follow to be able to get in. at USC is very different than going to Harvard. It's very
22:55
Brian Safdari: different than going to the Cal Poly schools or the UC schools. Different curriculums you have to follow. Everybody knows the stuff, which is get good grades, get test scores, and all of that. But one of the biggest differences why we have a 92% acceptance rate into our top three dream schools is this term called
23:15
Brian Safdari: strategic enrollment management. This is the business side of college that most parents and students don't know. It's not your 4.4 GPA and your test score that's going to get you in. Cause guess what? 20, 40, 50,000 students at UCLA all had a 4.3 and higher. It's really how you market
23:35
Brian Safdari: and package yourself in high school that really will differentiate. yourself. It's almost like the admission scandals that happened with Jerry Singer and Becky and all the varsity blues and all the scandals that happened. They just knew how to utilize the system. Illegally, I tell parents, college is a business, knowing what the
23:54
Brian Safdari: college wants and who they want, your child is wanted, knowing what schools are right for them. That's the magic. Because when you can market and package yourself in ninth, 10th, and 11th grade properly, not just on the academics, but everything else that the college is looking for in your child, like what kind
24:14
Brian Safdari: of recommendation letters did you get? What kind of job shadowing did you do in high school? What kind of leadership did you build? And how do you craft all that and bring it together that the college really wants you? We have pretty much like a blueprint of if we're going to school A and B, here are the curriculum, here are the students that got in,
24:34
Brian Safdari: here's what made them stand out. And that's strategic enrollment management. It's the business side of college of how colleges want to admit families because enrollment management is how colleges want to get ranked higher by the US News Enroll and World report. So understand. understanding the psychology behind the business side of college, we
24:54
Brian Safdari: package and market the student so that they stand out aside from just the typical getting good grades.
25:01
Kurt Chisholm: I still don't understand what Diversity Blues, I think it was Lori Laughlin and
25:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
25:06
Kurt Chisholm: few others like I still don't understand what they did wrong. I mean, people contribute buildings to schools all the time and they happen to get in and what she didn't do it the right way. like it's the same thing. Like still makes me laugh.
25:19
Brian Safdari: They kind of cheated and then bribed and start paying SAT people and kind of
25:23
Kurt Chisholm: my question is this though, like, why is that illegal? If you paid somebody money to get you into a country club, is that illegal? It's not like you're bribing a government. You didn't bribe the government to get something, you didn't bribe the guy or S. You basically paid the school money to get your kid in. Isn't that the whole point? You're paying the school money to get your kid in. Like, I'm not saying it's not illegal. It's just to me, it
25:43
Kurt Chisholm: just seems like it's kind of done anyway, and they just drew a line in a different place.
25:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
25:47
Brian Safdari: have a great point. I started thinking the same because this has always been happening. It's not anything new. When the affluent started trying to write off the money that they paid as a tax deduction.
25:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Well, that's different.
26:00
Brian Safdari: I think it was uh, a, in my opinion, just going through all of it and spent years reviewing everything that happened and how they orchestrated this. Where when the IRS got involved and people were writing off those expenses as a tax write-off, I believe that's why it became such a big thing. And people got
26:20
Brian Safdari: arrested. I think that was the bigger issue, not so much contributing to buildings and endowments and donors, because that always happens. It's just the way they came and they started writing that off. I think it pissed off the IRS and everybody else. And that's why the FBI's got involved with that.
26:37
Kurt Chisholm: They just weren't smart enough to do it right. You just donate a building. Like it's the same thing. Like it's six of one half dozen the other, in my opinion. You're just you're giving money to a school. And look, I'm not belittling the fact that it was a criminal act. Obviously, if they get convicted, it there was something behind it. And I don't have all the details. But to me, it just seems like the whole thing is is a bit
26:57
Kurt Chisholm: corrupt to begin with.
26:58
Brian Safdari: Totally agree.
26:59
Kurt Chisholm: I mean, if I'm going to buy a car, I don't give my tax return and say how much should I pay? But that's what you do with college. Here you go, here's all my financials. What should I pay you?
27:08
Brian Safdari: Totally business. Exactly. You're absolutely
27:10
Kurt Chisholm: Yeah, it's ridiculous. You're kind of laying yourself up there and say, Please help me. take my kid, take all my money. It's interesting. You can't negotiate as much. Okay, so in ninth and tenth grade, you're doing all that. What do you do in eleventh to twelfth grade? What does that look like?
27:26
Brian Safdari: Eleventh and senior year, pretty much the late side, it's more bringing your cards and putting it all on paper, meaning on the college applications. So junior year is really narrowing down your colleges. You have SATACTs, you have just all the remaining A through G requirements. You're doing your final packaging
27:46
Brian Safdari: of your resume for the junior year. You narrow down your schools. We typically like to narrow down to about eight to 10 colleges. We want to make sure we have true safety schools, true target schools, and true reach. I see too many students just applying to 10, 15. schools or 20 schools because their counselors told
28:06
Brian Safdari: them you should apply to more, because if you apply to more, you have a better chance getting in. That's completely the wrong thing to do. You have too many schools on your list. Colleges see that and they go, We're not going to give, we really want you. You have 20 colleges, you're too scattered. And if we give you a spot and you have these many colleges, the chances of you coming
28:26
Brian Safdari: to my school. might be very slim. That actually hurts admission yield, which is one angle that colleges get ranked off. So that's why six to eight, 10 schools max. And we want to make sure we filter it through a true process of what are true safety schools to make sure your child's going to get in, some core schools that are perfect fit
28:45
Brian Safdari: aligned schools for your child, and then have a couple dream schools and reach school. schools. So that way there's no big surprises at the end. Like all these students that I see that apply and they have a 4.7 and they think they're going to get into any school they want. And they get the rude awakening that in the senior year out of 10 schools, they only got into one college. And that
29:05
Brian Safdari: happens with poor planning and not having someone properly guide you. And then you have obviously financials coming that year or the financial aid forms have to start getting prepped. because that's the other big mistake on the financial side when we get into pillar number two, which is financial aid and funding, is they use the prior prior year system, which means if you're
29:25
Brian Safdari: going to college in 2028, they're using the 2026 tax returns. If you're going to college in 2027, they already are using the 2025 taxes that are already done. So understand. understanding the PPY system and planning two, three years in ahead, in conjunction when you're doing the
29:45
Brian Safdari: academic planning and the college selection planning, you have to also be planning around your income and your assets because high-income earners will get grants if you know how to position your finances properly, because college is a business, they know you might give back and become an alumni. So they want middle and high income families. It's just they
30:05
Brian Safdari: don't know how to apply for it. They think the Pell Grant, which is the lowest income grant, is gonna help them. So that's why you wanna start prepping the admissions and finalize that and the financials so that everything comes together by the end of the junior year.
30:19
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Talk about that. Talk about the grants for high-income high income earners, because I think most people they make enough so they can pay for college. but they don't make enough so they can pay all cash necessarily. Talk about the grants for high income earners.
30:31
Brian Safdari: Like you said, the really low income families are going to get a lot of money. And the very, very affluent high families incomes that I have, they can just write a check. So that middle income really gets hurt because they make too much, but not enough to be able to write a check. So the three categories we go after money is merit aid, institution. institutional
30:51
Brian Safdari: aid, and need-based aid. And a lot of times when they hear the term need, they think need means you have to be low income. But you could be need making $200,000 to $300,000 a year because once you submit all your financials, there's this term called SAI. It
31:11
Brian Safdari: stands for Student Aid Index. It's basically a number that the financials, when you fill out the FAFSA and the CSS profile and the different financial aid forms, there's this acronym called SAI, which your income, your assets, and all those go into that equation. It's like a calculator. And that number, the higher the
31:31
Brian Safdari: number, the less money you're gonna to get, the lower that barometer, the more grants you're gonna going to be eligible for. So we wanna help. want to a family understand their SAI two to three years in advance, which is your income, your assets, your home equity, your retirement, your investments, all that go into the equation. But if you know how to position your assets
31:51
Brian Safdari: legally and ethically early, you can bring that SAI down. Like for example, you can make under $200,000 a year and still get the middle income scholarship if you're in California. Most families think if they make under $60,000 a year, there's no scholarships or grants for us.
32:11
Brian Safdari: So there's different income level grants. So I have a family right now. They make $450,000 a year in 2024. In 2025, they started accelerating and I told them they wanted to make more investments into two businesses. So they made some investments in two businesses. And when they made investments
32:31
Brian Safdari: in that business in 2025, their adjusted gross income went from 400K to 160 because they started using income planning strategies that we started advising them in advance. And that helped them get into the territory of Calgrant. Cal Grant. Calgrant Cal Grant in California is anywhere from six,
32:51
Brian Safdari: seven thousand a year at a state school to $14,000, $15,000 per year at a UC or private school. And by planning ahead, a $400,000 income earner was able to get their AGI lower and plan ahead to be able to get more grants and financial aid. So need
33:11
Brian Safdari: need-based, based, merit merit-based, based, and institutional grants
33:15
Brian Safdari: are the three areas where 95% of the money, that's where parents and students need to be focusing on. Unfortunately, so many families spend their time going after private scholarships. Like they go online, they go to scholarships.com or they go to collegeboard.org org and they search for private scholarships.
33:35
Brian Safdari: And it's like just like the wild, wild west. You get millions. of sites out there. You got to do essays and applications. It's like a lottery draw and you spend so much time there to hope that you're going to get five, six hundred dollars if that, but families miss out on those three categories of aid, which just requires a little bit of
33:55
Brian Safdari: planning and you need at least two years of planning in advance to maximize those three categories.
34:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Merit aid, I assume pretty self-explanatory based on how good they are at certain areas. What's institutional aid? I mean, need based, you talked about, but what about institutional aid?
34:11
Brian Safdari: Institutional aid could be a family that makes over $250,000 a year. They have a high net worth, and the school wants to give you money because they know that the alumni, the donors, Owners are or families that have more money and they make more money. They're blessed to have more money and they help the school. and they contribute it back to the school. So they leave a pool of money aside
34:31
Brian Safdari: for high income earners and high asset earners that they know can help and contribute to the future of the college and the history of the school. So they're going to give you $10,000, $20,000 as a tuition discount just to hope that you come to the school because they know long term they're establishing a long-term relationship. and they're
34:51
Brian Safdari: gonna get that return on investment in the long run. So it could be just strictly because you have high income. It could be for talent reasons. It could be so like we have a student, Natalie, 3.4 GPA, Pepperdine was her number one school. She comes to me and says, Brian, we want to get in for biology, and I'm helping her.
35:11
Brian Safdari: And the dad says we're Hispanic, Brian. Can we use the minority card to get in? I said, Jose, all the colleges that Natalie wants to go to are Southern California schools. Being a Hispanic in Southern California, you're really not a minority. So that's not going to help you get in. So we kind of laughed about it. But I said, you know, with Natalie, what we can do is at Pepperdine, that's our
35:31
Brian Safdari: number one school, 3.4 GPA. So what we did was we packaged her to get into the chemical engineering department. Engineering was more predominantly male. We positioned her into engineering. We knew they wanted more female engineers, and she's Hispanic. So she's now a minority, not just because she's Hispanic,
35:51
Brian Safdari: but because she's female Hispanic in engineering. And because of that, we knew schools wanted that. She ended up getting in. She got $30,000 in free money and a pepperdine grant because they wanted her. And that's an institutional aid that they gave because they looked at her that she would make a good fit to the
36:11
Brian Safdari: university. So understanding good fit and aligning your student to become that good fit, that's where the planning nine, 10th, and 11th grade comes in to position the student to be able to get those kind of institutional aid or any of those merit aid at the schools.
36:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
36:28
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): appreciate all the insight. This has been really good. What are some final thoughts you can give us, and where can people find more about you?
36:33
Brian Safdari: So we offer uh nationwide free college planning workshops for families on admissions, financial aid, and funding. Because all three, those intersections of admissions, the right careers, the right packaging on your finances and how you pay it, believe it or not, you don't want to write a check to the college after getting free money
36:53
Brian Safdari: because when you pay the school, right after you get free money, the second year, you can lose a lot of grants. So understanding the proper ways to fund college on a tax-favored basis and tax scholarships, all of those are important. So we do workshops on helping families understand. These are complementary complimentary workshops at
37:13
Brian Safdari: www.collegeplanning www.college.com. experts.com. We have a workshops page there, and you can see the workshops, or you can inquire and ask which areas you're interested in. And we have an inquiry page there. So any family could ask any questions, or they can schedule a one-on-one free consultation where
37:33
Brian Safdari: we can look at the family's concerns, challenges, and see where they're at and where they want to be. And we can guide them and coach them on how to get to their goals.
37:44
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey,
37:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Smart Money Tree Podcast listeners. I know you love the show. I get a lot of love mail and hate mail from people who listen to the show. Personally, I like the former, but I have a thick skin if you are sending the latter. But I need to ask you a favor. We're looking to expand this podcast with a lot more resources and high-end guests. You're gonna love what we have in store for you
38:04
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): in the upcoming months. However, right now, we need your help. I need about five to ten minutes of your time to help influence the direction of the show. We're doing an annual survey of our listeners to understand our audience better. I know you're busy with your life, and so am I.
38:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): My
38:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): kids are going back to school, and that means less time for other things. But
38:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
38:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): you are a listener of the show, I guess. could really use your help to provide some feedback. Now, I'm not the government and I'm not asking you to work for free. So in exchange for your five to ten minutes of your time, I'm going to give you a gift worth over one million Zim dollars. That's right. That's a lot of money. Or at least I think it is.
38:44
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Go
38:44
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): to moneytreepodcast.com Moneytreepodcast.com forward forward slash slash free free money money and and follow follow the the instructions instructions to to get get your your free free gift. gift. That's That's right. right. I'm going to give you a gift worth over one million Zim dollars in exchange for five to ten minutes of your
38:57
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): time.
38:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): So in order to claim your gift, go to MoneyTreePodcast.com forward slash free money and follow the instructions to get your free gift today.
39:09
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
39:09
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): we're into the panel portion of the show. We have a our very own college expert, Doug Agrin. Egrin.
39:13
Kurt Chisholm: A lot of familiarity in this conversation, Kirk. I have actually known Brian for years. I've known him through a number of places that we've crossed paths, been with him with Don Blanton, Money Tracks, Circle of Wealth Network. Kind of he talked about losing money unknowingly and unnecessarily, very much a core philosophy there. And there's a reason Brian's been so
39:33
Kurt Chisholm: successful. I mean, he's done an exceptional job of taking college planning well beyond simply helping kids. get into school or completing financial aid forms. I mean, he's incorporated a much broader philosophy around capital efficiency, identifying money families lose unknowingly and unnecessarily. And when I heard him use that language, I smiled because that's straight out
39:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of that world. I agree with a tremendous amount of what he discussed,
39:57
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but I
39:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): also think there's another dimension that we can add to this conversation. We spend a lot of time talking about getting into the right school, maximizing scholarships, reducing college costs in general, and finding ways to pay for it. But I think from our perspective, and a component that maybe didn't get brought up in the time or in the
40:17
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): focus of the conversation I had with them is what happens to the family's entire financial picture as a result of those decisions. Because the best strategy I feel for paying for college isn't necessarily the best strategy for the family's retirement, taxes, liquidity, or long-term financial security in most of the ways that
40:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): people take and approach it. They look at it in the silo. It's the most pressing thing at hand. They're concerned about the kid. There's a lot of emotion around it. Ultimately, then those decisions percolate up to the top. In many cases,
40:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): can actually have impact on other things the family has lined up for goals in years to come. They're not going to see immediately in that moment unless it's incorporated and blended into one complete, one plan strategy. And I think that's where this conversation gets particularly interesting.
41:09
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Nice. Right now it's just me and Doug today, because we had a scheduling snafu. You know, in your experience, Doug, I mean, right now it's right in the middle of the college season. What are the biggest things that people should be thinking about?
41:20
Kurt Chisholm: Going back to one of the things that you talked about with Brian is that that's going to depend a lot on what the age of the student is and where they are in the process. You've got to, you know, make sure that you're Are spending the proper amount of time looking at the student fit, the academic approach, the career, the
41:40
Kurt Chisholm: cultural, personal fit, internships, and future opportunities. And if your student is a senior, when a lot of families start looking at this, this becomes very, very hard to cram into a short period of time. Just because you now have months instead of years to work on this doesn't mean that you now have to take and
41:59
Kurt Chisholm: reduce any of the amount of work that was there. You just made it that way. much harder to get to a level of depth that's going to be effective and increase the chances of a good outcome. So again, when we're talking student fit, he mentioned talking about this as early as middle school. I don't disagree. If you can get that engagement with
42:19
Kurt Chisholm: your child, I mean, talking to his daughter, great. I'm glad she sees that from that perspective. I've had these conversations with my own kids. in middle school at a high level, but getting them to get extremely in depth at that point, and ultimately more than just kind of touching base and planting seeds, I think is really difficult. But I do
42:39
Kurt Chisholm: think that this is something that is often done too late. And I think that you're gotta be looking at that definitely as early as eighth grade freshman year and really starting to have those in-depth conversations. Because Cause here's the thing the workload is not going to get any better for the student. So if you try to add all of those conversations later, you're asking them when their
42:59
Kurt Chisholm: brain is already hijacked by midterns and social pressures and athletics, and if they're a high achiever, they're probably doing volunteering and now they're working. All of these other things are now on their plate. And I experiencing experience it with my own family, you check. try to get them to say, I need you to work on this. And it's just one more overwhelming thing
43:19
Kurt Chisholm: in an emotional, intellectual house of cards. Now, if you are talking, say, the price optimization and beginning to look at that, this is something that is harder
43:31
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to do further out because ultimately lots of things can change. But you need to really get some basic data in place.
43:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): which means actually having grades. Now, there are kids that are taking college credit or high school credit courses in middle school. So if your child is already taking classes that actually are high school classes that are gonna affect their GPA in college, I'm sorry, in high school, this expedites expedates that conversation.
43:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It needs to happen sooner because to a middle schooler, they that may not see that long. long-term impact, getting good grades now in middle school, that ultimately, if you get a B minus in that class in middle school because you're taking accelerated, but it goes in your high school transcript, guess what? You're never gonna have a 4.0. Those days are gone. So for most kids, though, that's not happening
44:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): till high school. And once you start to get a clarification of what that GPA is gonna going to be, which starts
44:25
Kurt Chisholm: to come together by soft. sophomore year. Then I think it's a really good time to start looking at, okay, what's this going to potentially mean for merit scholarships, institutional grants, need based aid, a family's financial situation can significantly change over the next couple of years. But more often than not, it doesn't. So you can begin to make
44:45
Kurt Chisholm: those projections and start to do some work now as early as, say, freshman. sophomore year, to begin to see, okay, what is college potentially going to cost? What would it be like if I put in FAFSA now and got, as he talked about the student aid index?
44:59
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay,
44:59
Kurt Chisholm: what is that gonna mean? And the schools you're looking at going to, what does that mean in terms of what the net cost? You can see an estimate of that years ahead. And we've got some tools to help with that. Longer term funding solutions. We're talking, are you gonna do going to 529 funding? Are you going to use cash flow? If you save it, that's past
45:19
Kurt Chisholm: money. If you're using cash flow, whether in college, that's current money.
45:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
45:23
Kurt Chisholm: you're going to use loans and borrowing, that's future money. All of which overlap in the cash flow of what you're going to have
45:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to
45:30
Kurt Chisholm: fund your lifestyle right now. And obviously the same thing. The longer the trajectory, the less you have to do.
45:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): If
45:37
Kurt Chisholm: you're trying to cram four years of college, and you're gonna go to an expensive school that's not very generous,
45:42
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and
45:42
Kurt Chisholm: you're trying to do this as a senior, chances are you're either gonna have to extremely
45:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): suppress your
45:48
Brian Safdari: cash
45:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): flow now, which
45:50
Brian Safdari: is hard for
45:51
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): people to do to
45:51
Brian Safdari: change their lifestyle,
45:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or you're gonna have to
45:53
Brian Safdari: spread
45:54
Kurt Chisholm: over the
45:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): four years and
45:55
Brian Safdari: strain
45:55
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): your
45:55
Brian Safdari: cash flow then,
45:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or you're probably gonna going be to
45:57
Kurt Chisholm: looking at borrowing. So the longer
45:59
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you start
45:59
Kurt Chisholm: ahead
46:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
46:00
Brian Safdari: time,
46:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as early as when they're born, obviously. or even before
46:04
Brian Safdari: that.
46:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And if again, never knowing, 18 years, are they going to go to college? What's the college landscape
46:09
Kurt Chisholm: going
46:09
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to be like? This is where
46:10
Kurt Chisholm: those
46:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): funding solutions get deeper as to I'm just going to throw
46:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): in a 529 transfer money off my balance sheet that I'm never going to use again for anything else.
46:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
46:19
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): then ultimately, what if they don't go to college or something else? That inflexibility, in flexibility, that's where you start to talk about are there other options or ways? to do this that can still help with retirement or maybe flexibility if plans change, or maybe heck, 20 years from now, if you've got you know young children or planning to have children, college may be
46:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): completely different than it is today. Lots of things are
46:41
Kurt Chisholm: changing. So that type of flexibility. And then, you know, family wealth, obviously, if you take this money off your balance sheet, it is not available for retirement. You've got to think about the taxation, the liquidity, the risk management, the business capital, legacy.
46:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
46:56
Kurt Chisholm: mean, you can get the first two things exactly right. You know, student fit, price optimization, still make an enormously expensive mistake on the last two.
47:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
47:07
Kurt Chisholm: let's go back to the crux
47:08
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of your
47:09
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): question. What should they be doing
47:10
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right
47:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): now?
47:10
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That question
47:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): generally comes
47:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): up if we're talking about families
47:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): actually actively looking.
47:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for
47:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): college. Obviously,
47:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
47:17
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): this child is a junior or before, it's
47:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): getting all
47:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of those things lined up as much as possible to really try to figure out what's going to be the right the college that the student's
47:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): going to
47:28
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): go to that's affordable for the family, that's going to get them the degree, that's going to walk them
47:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): off
47:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): stage
47:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on
47:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Friday and into grad school or career
47:36
Kurt Chisholm: on Monday without any interruption. And that they're going to have a career trajectory that's going to be able to let them live a life that they may not know that they want. It's one of the conversations we have. It's like, all right, what's your lifestyle look like? What's that child, what's their home life that you financially provide them? Because they
47:55
Kurt Chisholm: may say they want to go this career, but they have a world that they know right now that in most cases those kids don't want to live completely differently.
48:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They might
48:05
Kurt Chisholm: want to go down this career path,
48:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
48:07
Kurt Chisholm: if it's going to mean that reducing their lifestyle
48:10
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
48:10
Kurt Chisholm: a completely different future than they
48:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
48:13
Kurt Chisholm: that's jarring psychologically, and ultimately that's not going to generally work out well.
48:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Or
48:19
Kurt Chisholm: they get into college
48:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
48:20
Kurt Chisholm: they don't like the college because for whatever reason, or the degree doesn't
48:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): work. You got to
48:24
Kurt Chisholm: plan all that stuff.
48:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now, if they're a senior, this game on. And I've got a
48:28
Kurt Chisholm: daughter going
48:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): through this right now. She's gonna
48:30
Brian Safdari: want to get to those final experiences, Kirk. She wants to be able to know that these memories are gonna happen. So she's faced with trying to go to the last football game and wants to make sure, because she plays soccer, that the soccer team, you know, is gonna go to the state championships and she wants to make sure she's doing homecoming Going home coming and a prom. And all that takes time. Well, at the same time, we got scholarships. She's a musician, we got
48:50
Brian Safdari: scholarships for her colleges that are due coming up here by November 8th. And she's got to get a video ready to go to put that in that could be
48:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): anywhere from $2,000 a year off to $25,000 a year off. Or another school is going to be a full-right scholarship. And if she's not putting the time in to do the work to make that look absolutely fantastic,
49:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): who
49:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): knows what she's going to get? You know, the conversations we have is. you better make sure you're doing everything you can to do the best because every other student that's coming to that music program is going to be doing the same thing and they're not going to give all that money to everybody. And what about the private scholarships that are going to be due a bunch in October, November, December, January?
49:31
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Getting your applications in. Ultimately, we've got to file FAFSA right now, October 1st, it started, or maybe CS. CSS profile. Getting all of that done. Now, a lot of people listening might have filed their extensions until October 15th, which we filed an extension, but we got ours done several weeks ago. So October 1st, I wasn't ready to file FAFSA
49:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yet.
49:51
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
49:52
Kurt Chisholm: as soon as those things get filed, getting FAFSA in and making sure that you're getting that in sooner and later, especially if you need money, because grant money goes really, really quickly.
50:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
50:02
Kurt Chisholm: you want to get in earlier. If it's a school that's going to be more competitive, you want to try to get in earlier too to give yourself a better chance. Junior year is one of the hardest years in general for students, Kirk. So much on their plate. And it's one of the most critical, it can be the difference between great GPA outcomes and you've got SATs. And again,
50:22
Kurt Chisholm: going in senior year, you might still be taking or retaking super score in SAT or ACT.
50:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
50:27
Kurt Chisholm: surprisingly, to a lot of families, senior year fall
50:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is,
50:33
Kurt Chisholm: in my opinion, one of the busiest and hardest because there's so many distractions.
50:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
50:39
Kurt Chisholm: at the same time, this is when all the due dates are crunching, crunching, crunching, crunching.
50:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
50:44
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you
50:44
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): want
50:44
Kurt Chisholm: to make sure you're having conversations with your child as early as possible to prepare them because I know my daughter was like senior year, I think it's gonna be the emotion so much easier. She came to me a month ago and said, This may be my hardest semester ever. It's like, yeah. And I still need you to do this, this, this, this, and this on top of your plate. And
51:04
Kurt Chisholm: she's working more. And so I think the organization and mapping that out to follow that checklist, again, it's always easy, right? You know this, Kirk. I know this, Kirk. In planning, it's not just what you have to do, but it's how you line it out to make it easier to take off bite-sized pieces. Because if you try to stuff it all in your mouth all at
51:24
Kurt Chisholm: once, you're gonna choke.
51:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): That's good insight. As a parent with kids of similar age, it's starting to get overwhelming. And as a parent, it's hard not to be overwhelmed with all this stuff. It's hard to not be overwhelmed with all the lack of knowledge of how it all works. You're just kind of thrown into it. Like my kids go into the guidance counselor and they're talking
51:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): them through this stuff in his junior year. And I'm like, I feel like I'm already behind. And
51:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
51:50
Kurt Chisholm: some ways, you are.
51:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yeah. And you and I have talked, but it's like you got to hurry up and wait. And there's a lot of things you can do, but the things you can do are somewhat limited at the same time. Like talk to my kid, and they're like, all right, well, here's how college works and here's the process. I'm like, all right, we're already a month into junior year and they're not even doing anything with them yet. It's almost like everything's done senior year, but then it's like,
52:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): all right, it's too late to plan and do all this stuff. So it's I think it's hard for parents to grasp this and the timing. And frankly, the money part's overwhelming. And the fact that my kid is 16 and he doesn't know what he wants to be when he grows up. Like, I get it. I get it. I didn't either when I was 16.
52:26
Brian Safdari: You mentioned something really important too. And Brian touched on this as well. What you're facing is the norm. I don't know about the school that your children go to compared to other schools, but if you have a large, well-funded school that has a dedicated college and career
52:46
Brian Safdari: department, they're gonna have more tools and more resources than most schools. but it's still lacking. Their focus tends to be: yes, they'll do some webinars where they'll make bring some people in on how to pay for college. And it's usually again just lining things up, make sure you look for schools that are affordable. How
53:06
Brian Safdari: does financial aid work? Basic level stuff, but it's not tailored individual. Then you get into having meetings with them, and in many cases, it's you
53:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
53:14
Brian Safdari: they're bringing. colleges in who are, you know, let's face it, the college representative that comes there is there to do one thing. As Brian said, they're a business. They're there to sell you. They want more kids to apply. Doesn't mean that those kids are going to be the right fit. They're just there to get everybody excited and get more brochures that they can send out. In many cases, get more people to apply. They can reject more. And than they say, look,
53:34
Brian Safdari: we are selective. It's a game to hit that report. That being said,
53:39
Brian Safdari: they use tools like novions and stuff like that, that is not necessarily designed to identify the best fit from an academic, social, financial standpoint. Most of the information put into novions, for example, is peer implemented. It's like going to Reddit. In Students, you know, need to put in what they've
53:59
Brian Safdari: received, if they've made it, if they've been rejected. Again. if they've made it, the students like, see you later. I'm out of here. They're not going in to put that information in. Why? It does no benefit to them. If they got rejected, they're sitting there going, screw this. Why am I going to go in and say blah, blah, blah, blah, blah? So the information that's in there is somewhat
54:19
Brian Safdari: suspect. And then on top of that, it really is there to just more facilitate the steps, like getting fast, like getting transcripts, transferred. Does it actually make sure that it's figuring out and going through the psychological best fit? Not necessarily. And that's a great school, Kirk. Most schools they don't have that budget. Most
54:39
Brian Safdari: schools, it's the guidance counselor. If they're lucky if we've got any certification whatsoever around college planning, and it might just be on how to file FAFSA basics, but their job is to deal with the emotional. growth and well-being of the students that are there. They are inundated with so many more issues planning wise or
54:58
Brian Safdari: issues with their students than going to college. They're trying to keep these kids, especially in whether it's they're actually more teacup than they used to be, or it's just more publicized. Size, We know that mental health is a massive problem right now with everybody, but especially younger generations. generation. And so these guidance counselors are so inundated
55:18
Brian Safdari: with dealing with just that, that there's just no capacity left on their plate to actually get into any depth of college. It's completely something that's on the fringe in terms of their responsibilities. And students suffer for that. So there's definitely not an equity from school to school, and even the best schools are lacking.
55:36
Kurt Chisholm: I
55:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): understand. I mean, there's some schools that have like hundreds of kids they gotta do each year, and just I don't know how they do it. Even with guidance counselors like private schools, there's fewer kids. I mean, I remember when I was growing up, we had a guidance counselor and she was horrible. Horrible. The challenge that I had is so the school I went to, so I went to
55:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Trinity College, and my junior year, there was a ton of kids who applied. Now I went there for hockey. The coach just said, just let me know and I'll get you in. Just don't bail on me. But if you really want to come, like, just let me know and I'll get you in. So I knew I was getting in if I wanted to. And
56:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): the guidance counselor advised me not to go. She's like, you shouldn't go there. She's like, you will never get in. I'm like, the coach told me I'll get in. All you have to do is tell him. She's like, Yeah, but you wouldn't get in. Your academics aren't good enough. And I was just like, why is she giving me so much friction? Like she was fighting me on this. You think guidance council is there to help you? Like, great, let me help you. No, she was like, You don't want to go there. And
56:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I'm
56:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like,
56:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): what the what the F is going on? And and I was really pissed. And she gave me a lot of schools that I didn't want to go to. And it was like some engineering schools. I'm like, I didn't tell you one of engineering. Like, what is wrong with you? And come to find out that there were like eight kids in my class of 55 that end up going to Trinity this
56:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): year. And that was the reason. She was looking at all the other kids, like, oh, we we can't have too many because of this, that, and the other reason. I'm like, hold on a second. This becomes your problem, not a my problem. I don't like that. I was pissed. When I hear all these things, I'm like, there's so many more things that go into this that shouldn't. And this happens in a lot of private schools. too. Like I was on the
57:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): board of my kids' school years ago and used to hear they're like, well, we had too many kids this year, or a bunch of kids got in, and then they none of them went. And like, these are a lot of the problems they deal with. And I get it. It's normal. It's not one school or the other. They all do it. But the reality is like, as a parent or even as a child, like that's a thing to have to deal with. You want to get into a
57:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): school and some adults telling you no, because of a reason that has nothing to do with you. How much of that kind of plays into the whole puzzle, Doug?
57:43
Brian Safdari: It plays in the whole puzzle for the colleges themselves, and it absolutely plays, like you saw, even at the local level. I mean, I go back to the U.S. News and World Reports. I mean, the rankings. The rankings list is completely gamed. People think, oh, it's a better school because on it couldn't be further from the truth. I mean, if anybody wants to read about the truth of it, there's a great book called Degrees. and
58:03
Brian Safdari: Pedigrees. Talks about the reality of education and the impact and the ROI. There's a reason these lists don't change. It's not because schools don't get better at something. And ultimately, at the end of the day, it doesn't mean that that school isn't great at something. Like Brian talked about how they were looking for an opportunity for this
58:22
Brian Safdari: female who wanted to go into engineering who's Hispanic, you know, it's like, look, that school wouldn't have been a great fit. But at that local department, it was because they were looking to increase the headcount of people like her, even under the umbrella of that school. Locally, high schools obviously depends on district
58:42
Brian Safdari: to district, but they're graded on how they are able to achieve no child left behind and they want that blue ribbon and how many kids are performing on their test scores, and then ultimately how many of those kids graduate and how many of those kids go to colleges. And of course, if they're all going to the same college, then they're gonna be graded on the
59:02
Brian Safdari: fact that this is too concentrated. We don't have enough diversity on where we're sending them for different things. And again, if it's inside a state, the state might be putting that pressure on because they're looking to see more kids get into different things and different places. And they're getting pressure because these schools lobby the states hard for different things and they want to make sure that you know the
59:22
Brian Safdari: school's stuggling financially, you know, that we need to get more students here. You go back to those rankings lists. Oh, what does a selective school mean? I've talked about this before, I think, with you. There was a school that wanted to move up the list. So what did they do? They sent out more brochures. They made a huge investment, sent out more brochures. They ended up increasing the number of kids that applied to that
59:42
Brian Safdari: school, which was great for them. But then they still capped it at the same number of students accepted. But now they moved up the US News and World Report's ranking list because they were able to say, look, we were letting in 67% of the kids. But now look at us, we only let in 40%. So that 27% difference in acceptance. Look, we're a more selective school.
1:00:02
Brian Safdari: I remind anyone who's listened to me before: prestigious comes from the Latin word prestigious, prestigious. So I never say it right. I'm not Latin. I'm not from the old Roman Empire. But the point being is that it means to deceive. And now it's been obviously transformed in modern language to mean a higher
1:00:21
Brian Safdari: level of social acceptance and and outcome. But that's not the basis of where the word. comes from. And as Brian said, there's absolutely those business pressures, there's government pressures, there's statistical pressures. That example Brian used, I think was a great one. It's like, yes, they are looking internally at headcount, they're looking at
1:00:41
Brian Safdari: demographics, whether they're legally allowed to do so or not. The States are looking at, hey, obviously, New York doesn't need to fight to get people. I mean, New York. City is one of the largest cities in the world. California doesn't necessarily need at this point to get more people. And of course, New England as a whole, higher concentration
1:01:01
Brian Safdari: population. But you get to places like Arkansas. Arkansas has significant difference in population. They might make it harder for Arkansas students to get into those schools and easier. for students coming from other states. Now that's not always the case. Other states, it's easier if you're in state to get
1:01:21
Brian Safdari: in. But a place like Arkansas, and I'm not saying this is Arkansas, but it's very typical for states like that. They know that if we make it easier for students out of state to get in here, we're going to have a higher probability because there's correlation to students. graduating from those schools
1:01:41
Brian Safdari: and a higher number of them staying in that state after college for their career. So they do these little games in order to either reduce who's coming in or adjust where they're getting them from for their own either political or business needs.
1:02:01
Brian Safdari: And unless you have that information.
1:02:03
Brian Safdari: which is out there with a lot of research. And if you don't have time to do the research, of course it makes sense to work with those that do have time to do the research. And is AI making that a little bit easier? Absolutely. But this comes back to the rub we talk about with wealth planning all the time, Kirk. Just because you have access to more information
1:02:23
Brian Safdari: doesn't necessarily mean that all of the other responsibilities and the time that you had got any more flexible to use it. So now the question is do you have the time to go do that research? Do you have the time to do that research effectively? Is that something you actually want to do? Do you want to become an expert in this? If
1:02:43
Brian Safdari: you do, more information out there is going to make that easier for families. But I still would argue that the majority of families don't have the time or interest to be. experts in it.
1:02:52
Kurt Chisholm: Yeah, I think that's the hardest thing, especially if you kind of want to learn this stuff. It's hard to really dive in and become the expert. Any final thoughts you can leave us with, Doug, and then where can people find more about you?
1:03:02
Brian Safdari: I want to jump to something I think that was hugely important before I wrap this up. I want to come back to the money side of it. Families earning 250, 350, 350,000, 500,000 often assume they don't need college planning because they won't qualify for financial aid. They look at this as a silo and they look at this as one item. It's like,
1:03:22
Brian Safdari: eh, you know what? I'm too successful. This system is designed for people that aren't. But these families have accumulated things, they've done things right. This assumption that it's for financial needs, or I'm sorry, financial need is where financial aid's aid is gonna going to come from. But if you have two to three kids going to college,
1:03:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
1:03:39
Brian Safdari: you're approaching retirement or just want to have the freedom of flexibility, you're looking at spending several hundred thousand dollars in the next five to six years. It's I think it's important that people let that sink in. It's one thing to look at it now and say, okay, you know, I think we can handle that. We'll just space it out, take loans. It's another thing when you think about the
1:03:59
Brian Safdari: fact that many of these people are in a higher income bracket, and that ultimately, means that they're going to be having a much greater after-tax impact of that wealth. Qualifying for financial aid does not mean you don't need a financial strategy. The question isn't necessarily where you can afford to write the tuition checks. It's whether writing those checks is the most effective way to use the
1:04:19
Brian Safdari: capital you've accumulated. Financial aid, one of the things that we've been emphasizing in CPAs that I've worked with in and a webinar. webinars that I've been doing for you know Minnesota CPAs, you can't optimize college costs until you understand what formula you're working with. And then you have to understand how the tax decisions you're making today might affect eligibility in a
1:04:39
Brian Safdari: future year. And then ultimately, you know, you're looking at prior, prior year. You're also looking at how much money out of every paycheck is going to be left available after you're getting a higher amount of taxes taken away. especially if you're in a state where it compounds federal and state taxes. This can be an extremely painful
1:04:58
Brian Safdari: eye-opening realization. And then all of a sudden a lot of these families they start ending up relying on loans. And now, as I said, future dollars are now being constrained because that money is now going out to manage the loans that they may have chosen to pay some as they go, they may have deferred. But it at the end of the day, financial aid optimization is
1:05:18
Brian Safdari: not the same thing as wealth optimization. One of the most overlooked questions of college planning is why we automatically assume that the best way to pay for college is to permanently spend down assets that we've spent years accumulating. And I'm not suggesting that you shouldn't use things like 529s or investments or other investments. They absolutely
1:05:39
Brian Safdari: need to be considered. But there are other approaches that most people aren't aware of that might be the best for their situation. Obviously, one of those is cash flow. Could be brokerage investments. It could be 529 plans. It could be borrowing strategies, whether it's borrowing from traditional student loans, which I know a lot of
1:05:59
Brian Safdari: people are complaining about the interest rates on those. There's not a lot of places to get cheap money now. but guess what? Student loans do allow a couple of benefits that, again, shouldn't just be taken for granted. First of all, the interest on those loans is simple interest. So it's only off the borrowed principal, not compounded. Second of all, the federal loans
1:06:19
Brian Safdari: go away at death. And ultimately, you could be looking at your house or maybe selling assets like a house or borrowing against it. I know it's not as favorable as it used to
1:06:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be.
1:06:27
Brian Safdari: And there's also properly designed insurance-based strategies have been a great benefit to many families. I want to go and emphasize properly designed because there's a lot of different feelings out there, and there's a lot of poorly designed insurance out there. But again, if something happens to someone and you're looking at the risks of mortality, obviously insurance is important.
1:06:47
Brian Safdari: Could that be something in your plan? Maybe. maybe not. That could be another highly beneficial way to look at liquidity to pay for cash flow. And sometimes the best option, Kirk, is combination. What matters is what happens to a family's financial position after they pay for college. Having the money to pay for college doesn't automatically mean
1:07:07
Brian Safdari: spending that money is the best way. When we look through our college funding strategies approach, rather than simply trying to treating college as a savings goal, it starts to open up different things that are critical to look at the fall into six major risks of wealth. You got to think about inflation, tuition, housing, education
1:07:27
Brian Safdari: costs are rising. Your purchasing power is going to decline over decades. Taxation, funding sources, and income timing can greatly affect taxes and aid. eight, You've got withdrawals, conversions, income tax. taxations that all can affect sustainable spending. Market volatility. Countless situations where a 529 or brokerage account has declined
1:07:47
Brian Safdari: when that tuition is due. And if you sell during those downturns, it can magnify retirement sequence risk. Then there's liquidity. Yeah, your assets exist, but I'm working with a family right now, Kirk, that plan to use to sell a couple of houses. They have about five or six. houses. They plan to sell a couple to pay for college. But guess what? Interest
1:08:07
Brian Safdari: rates have gone up. Market isn't moving. So now they don't have that as accessible cash. Families need flexible capital for spending in emergencies, and that never changes whether it's early through college or into retirement. Then there's longevity. College spending reduces assets available for later years. Longevity compounds. everything
1:08:27
Brian Safdari: taxes, market volatility, inflation. You need to make sure that your money could last until 90, 95, or longer. And a dollar spent today is multiple times more dollars lost for the future through opportunity cost. And of course, I mentioned mortality. A parent's death, we are hearing more and more stories of just
1:08:47
Brian Safdari: unexpected, unforeseen deaths that are occurring to people. out there. There's lots of speculation as to why. The reality is it doesn't matter. The parents' death eliminates income expected fund college. And the surviving family also needs that long-term financial security. I want to connect as I wrap up here: the college planning, retirement planning
1:09:07
Brian Safdari: are really dealing with those six same risks to wealth. Think about it. If you're going to be 50 or 55 years, old when your kids go to college, you may have another 30 to 40 years to live out your own lives that you need to fund. So are families making the best decision for the next four years of their
1:09:27
Brian Safdari: child's life at the expense of the next 40 of their own? And that's why I say college planning is retirement planning. It's the same balance sheet, it's the same money, it's the same six risks.
1:09:40
Brian Safdari: And so to summarize this up, one of the challenges, Kirk, in financial services is we've become an industry of specialists. College planners focused on college, investment advisors focused on the portfolio, the insurance professionals focused on protection and capital strategies. And the CPA is focused
1:10:00
Brian Safdari: on accounting, or in many cases, for your family taxes. And each one of them may be doing a tremendous job. But who's making sure the recommendation in one area isn't creating an unintended consequence somewhere else? The biggest financial mistakes aren't always the result of bad advice. In many cases, they're the result of good advice that wasn't coordinated. And that's one of the
1:10:20
Brian Safdari: reasons we developed our one plan approach at merging advisors.
1:10:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We
1:10:23
Brian Safdari: want to start with the family's entire financial picture, understanding understand
1:10:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the family.
1:10:27
Brian Safdari: what matters to them, and then determine how different strategies should work together. Sometimes the answer is insurance. Sometimes it's investment. Sometimes it's cash flow, tax planning, or simply doing nothing different. The strategy should follow the plan. The plan shouldn't follow the product. So at
1:10:47
Brian Safdari: the end of the day, I just want to summarize this up. I encourage families to stop guessing.
1:10:51
Brian Safdari: about what college is actually going to cost. We have some complimentary resources that you can get through us or reach out to us. Info at mergentadvisors.net. Go to our website. You can actually use our free college money report, which will tell you the cost of up to three schools that you put in. It'll tell you
1:11:11
Brian Safdari: what kind of merit aid or need-based aid you're going to get, costs you. nothing. We also have a school comparison report. We also have a school search engine and a scholarship estimator. And all of these are complementary. And these can help families begin evaluating potential college costs and opportunities for scholarships of financial aid. Because before you can make good decisions
1:11:31
Brian Safdari: around how to fund college, you need to also understand what you're actually trying to fund. And once you know that number, then the next question is how to pay for it in a way that works with the rest of your coordinated financial life. And that's where the deeper planning conversation comes in. Go to our website, mergentadvisors.net, M E R
1:11:51
Brian Safdari: G E N T, M E R G E N T Mergent Advisors.net. That way you can learn about our one plan coordinated financial strategy. Use the college money report right there. And if you want to look at any of the other tools I talked about, like Scholarship Estimator, you'll have a way to reach out to us to get access to those as well.
1:12:09
Kurt Chisholm: Awesome. Well, I appreciate you coming on the show, Doug, and sharing your wisdom with us. That's the show for this week. Thanks again for joining us. Money Tree Investing Podcast. My name's Kirk Chisholm, wealth manager of Innovative Advisor Group. We don't just manage your wealth, we make your life better. You can find more about me at innovativewealth.com. And of course, you can find me every week here on the show. Share a lot of charts in the show. so if you're looking for charts and show notes, check out
1:12:29
Kurt Chisholm: our show at MoneyTreepodcast.com. Don't forget, do your own research. This show is for informational use only. We're not telling you what to think merely how to think about investing. We're also not selling you products and services, so do not consider this advice. If you're seeking financial advice, give us a call. We take clients selectively, but only if we like you. Have a great week ahead, and remember, no one will care about your money like you
1:12:49
Kurt Chisholm: do, so invest in your life.
1:12:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank
1:12:52
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you for listening to the Money Tree Investing Podcast. Visit us at Moneytree Podcast.com for more free investing resources.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Money Tree Investing

Money Tree Investing

The Busiest Week Of The Quarter Reveals...

Episode discussion: Midterm election outcomes priced in; tech volatility and recession risks discussed

Speakers’ claims: Kirk Chisholm and Doug Habrin discuss how midterm election results were anticipated by markets, attributing recent volatility to institutional repositioning rather than fundamental shifts. Chisholm highlights sell-offs in AI and chip stocks, warning of recession risks and stagflationary pressures despite resilient labor data. Habrin contrasts current economic resilience with the 1970s, noting U.S. energy independence mitigates oil embargo risks. The speakers also analyze Tesla's Cybertruck production halt, gold market divergences, and big tech's decoupling of revenue from headcount.

Market VolatilityMidterm ElectionsTechnology Sector
53 min4 assets9 claims to verify
Money Tree Investing

The AI Boom Could Create Fortunes

Episode discussion: Speakers debate AI productivity gains, infrastructure investments, and model valuations amid market skepticism.

Speakers’ claims: Alex Chompff argues that AI unlocks massive productivity gains by organizing cognition below the human level, potentially adding trillions to global GDP. He suggests retail investors should focus on AI infrastructure and data centers rather than frontier models, which he claims are likely overvalued and inaccessible. Kurt Chisholm and Barb Friedberg express skepticism about AI valuations, citing the dot-com bubble, high capital expenditures, and AI's limitations in math and data accuracy. The discussion highlights the shift of economic growth to private markets and the reliability of infrastructure providers like AWS compared to model developers.

AI InfrastructurePublic vs Private MarketsValuation Skepticism
1h 27m6 assets20 claims to verify
All insights