Above the Fray

Bankruptcy as a Mass Tort Resolution Tool Post-Supreme Court Ruling

37 min Listen to the original Episode page
BankruptcyMass TortsSupreme CourtPurdue PharmaLitigation FinanceCorporate LawCredit InvestingRegulatory Risk

Summary

Speakers discuss the impact of the June 2024 Supreme Court ruling that blocked non-consensual third-party releases in bankruptcy, using the Purdue Pharma case as a primary example. Judge Robert Drain and Mark Leitner argue that while this ruling removes a key tool for protecting non-debtor entities, bankruptcy remains essential for organizing creditors and preventing a 'race to the courthouse.' The conversation covers the evolution of plaintiff lawyers, emerging risks in AI and social media, and the importance of analyzing legal defenses and financial engineering strategies like the 'Texas Two-Step.'

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    acknowledged in the settlement agreement itself, you know, the risk that, you know, 3M may not be able to pay on this, right? The bankruptcy risk.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) · 27:15

  2. 2
    Speaker_3 cites Monsanto's Supreme Court win on federal preemption grounds regarding glyphosate as a 'showstopper' defense that eliminated over 100,000 claims, illustrating how legal defenses can drastically alter exposure.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) · 34:44

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 2:00

    Introduction and Guest Bios

    Mark Leitner introduces the topic of mass torts and bankruptcy, welcoming Judge Robert Drain and Mark Leitner (Credit Sights) as guests to discuss the Purdue Pharma case and the role of bankruptcy in resolving mass torts.

  2. 2:00 – 7:05

    Judge Drain's Experience with Purdue Pharma

    Judge Drain discusses the unique nature of the Purdue Pharma case, noting the intense media scrutiny and the involvement of nearly all US state attorneys general, which required him to manage public relations alongside legal proceedings.

  3. 7:05 – 13:49

    Supreme Court Ruling on Third-Party Releases

    Mark Leitner explains the June 2024 Supreme Court ruling that blocked non-consensual third-party releases in bankruptcy, a tool previously used in cases like Purdue Pharma to protect non-debtor entities like the Sackler family.

  4. 13:49 – 16:12

    Impact of the Ruling on Bankruptcy Playbooks

    Mark Leitner (Credit Sights) states that while the ruling removes the option of third-party releases, bankruptcy still serves as a vital collective proceeding to organize creditors and negotiate settlements, even if holdouts remain.

  5. 16:12 – 21:04

    Emotional vs. Financial Resolution in Bankruptcy

    Judge Drain argues that bankruptcy is a financial mechanism, not a substitute for criminal justice or emotional catharsis, though he implemented a non-evidentiary hearing in Purdue to allow victims to speak to the Sacklers.

  6. 21:04 – 26:16

    The 'Texas Two-Step' and Insolvency Strategies

    Judge Drain expresses reservations about the 'Texas Two-Step' strategy of spinning off liabilities into insolvent entities, noting it is primarily a negotiation tactic to force pre-bankruptcy agreements rather than a guaranteed legal shield.

  7. 26:16 – 28:05

    Assessing Settlement Viability and 3M Example

    Mark Leitner (Credit Sights) highlights that victims seek fairness and acknowledgment, while companies must balance settlement size with solvency, citing 3M's acknowledgment of bankruptcy risk in its talc settlement as a key investor consideration.

  8. 28:05 – 31:10

    Governmental Claims and Future Challenges

    Judge Drain notes that governmental entities are often the largest creditors in mass torts like PFAS and opioids, facing massive cleanup costs under current regulations, which complicates resolution strategies.

  9. 31:10 – 32:25

    Evolution of Plaintiff Lawyers

    Speaker_2 notes that the new generation of tort lawyers is more sophisticated and appreciates financial constraints compared to older, more aggressive predecessors like Joe Rice. This shift reflects a learning process for all parties involved in mass torts.

  10. 32:25 – 34:04

    Emerging Mass Tort Areas

    Mark Leitner asks about future mass torts, citing social media harms and AI/copyright issues. Speaker_2 suggests the key issue will be whether legislative liability protection is enacted or if claims will proceed through the court system.

  11. 34:04 – 35:12

    Assessing Mass Tort Exposure for Credit Investors

    Speaker_3 advises investors to analyze the nature of harm, causation science, and existing caseload posture. He highlights that each situation is unique and requires a comprehensive view of the company's defenses and capital structure.

  12. 35:12 – 37:07

    Risks of Financial Engineering in Bankruptcy

    Speaker_2 warns investors to be wary of financial engineering marketed as a solution to mass torts, citing the long-standing legal principle of avoiding fraudulent transfers. He states that bankruptcy is not a panacea but a tool to facilitate settlement.

Claims worth verifying

The Supreme Court ruled 5-4 in June 2024 that the bankruptcy code does not allow non-consensual third-party releases.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·7:21

How to verify: Search US Supreme Court case law for rulings on Purdue Pharma third-party releases issued in June 2026; verify via SCOTUSblog or official Supreme Court records. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Prior to the ruling, the Second Circuit and Third Circuit allowed third-party releases if supported by a supermajority vote, typically above 75% of the class.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·9:27

How to verify: Review Second Circuit bankruptcy case law precedents on third-party releases (e.g., In re A. D. v. Manville) and verify voting thresholds in plan confirmations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

In the Purdue Pharma case, over 90% of voting creditors supported the plan containing the third-party release.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·9:46

How to verify: Access the Purdue Pharma Chapter 11 docket on PACER or the official claims website to view the voting results of the plan confirmation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Chapter 15 bankruptcy implements foreign plans and is used in some foreign jurisdictions to allow third-party releases, such as guarantees in England.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·10:43

How to verify: Review US Bankruptcy Code Chapter 15 provisions and case law involving cross-border insolvency proceedings with UK or other foreign jurisdictions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Sackler family did not file for bankruptcy but sought a release from opioid lawsuits in exchange for contributing billions to the settlement.

Mark Leitner ·7:05

How to verify: Review the Purdue Pharma Plan of Reorganization and Supreme Court opinion to confirm the Sacklers were non-debtor third parties. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

3M acknowledged in its talc settlement agreement the risk that it may not be able to pay the full settlement amount.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·27:15

How to verify: Review the 3M talc settlement agreement filed with the court or press releases from 3M regarding the settlement terms and solvency risks. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Judge Drain presided over the Purdue Pharma Chapter 11 case in the Southern District of New York.

Mark Leitner ·1:16

How to verify: Check US Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York docket for Purdue Pharma Inc. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The 'Texas Two-Step' involves creating an insolvent entity to protect a parent company from liabilities.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·21:33

How to verify: Search legal literature and case law for 'Texas Two-Step' insolvency strategies and their application in mass tort litigation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

A proposed federal fund for asbestos claims in the 1990s failed to pass Congress after lobbying efforts.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·24:16

How to verify: Review legislative history of the 1990s regarding asbestos liability reform bills and congressional records. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Judge Drain implemented a non-evidentiary hearing in the Purdue settlement allowing victims to speak to the Sacklers.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·18:19

How to verify: Review the Purdue Pharma settlement agreement and court orders approving the hearing procedure. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Joe Rice was an incredibly aggressive tort lawyer when Namville started, which may have been to the client's detriment.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·31:10

How to verify: Search for news articles or legal profiles regarding 'Joe Rice' and 'Namville' (likely a misspelling of a law firm or case) to confirm his litigation style and tenure. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The new generation of tort lawyers is more sophisticated and appreciates financial constraints compared to older lawyers who have retired or passed away.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·31:29

How to verify: Review recent legal industry reports or bar association publications on the evolution of mass tort litigation strategies and lawyer demographics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Monsanto won at the Supreme Court on federal preemption grounds related to glyphosate liability.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·34:44

How to verify: Search SEC EDGAR for Monsanto's parent company (Bayer) filings or US Supreme Court case records for 'Monsanto v. United States' or similar glyphosate preemption cases around 2026-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

The Monsanto Supreme Court win eliminated over 100,000 claims.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·34:44

How to verify: Review legal analysis or press releases from Bayer/Monsanto post-Supreme Court ruling detailing the number of claims dismissed or settled as a result of the preemption ruling. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Statute of Elizabeth I dates back to 1492.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·35:12

How to verify: Consult historical legal records or encyclopedias for the 'Statute of Elizabeth I' (13 Elizabeth I c. 5) to verify its enactment date (historically 1571, not 1492). For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Bankruptcy law includes the avoidance of fraudulent transfers, an element dating back to the Statute of Elizabeth I.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·35:12

How to verify: Review US Bankruptcy Code sections on fraudulent transfers (e.g., 11 U.S.C. § 548) and historical legal commentaries linking them to the Statute of Elizabeth. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Review the full text of the June 2024 Supreme Court ruling on non-consensual third-party releases to understand the specific legal reasoning and dissenting opinions.
  • Examine Purdue Pharma's Chapter 11 plan and settlement agreement to see how the absence of third-party releases affected the Sackler family's liability and the settlement structure.
  • Analyze 3M's 10-K filings and talc settlement agreements for explicit disclosures regarding solvency risks and contingent liabilities related to mass tort litigation.
  • Research the 'Texas Two-Step' strategy by reviewing case studies where companies spun off liabilities into insolvent entities, noting court challenges regarding fraudulent transfers.
  • Investigate the current status of legislative proposals regarding liability protection for social media and AI companies to assess future regulatory risks.
  • Check court dockets for ongoing litigation regarding whether notice in a plan binds non-voting claimants to third-party releases post-Supreme Court ruling.
  • Review Monsanto's Supreme Court victory on federal preemption grounds to understand how legal defenses can eliminate large volumes of claims.
  • Assess the capital structure and litigation posture of companies with significant mass tort exposure, distinguishing between legal merits and financial mechanics.
Full transcriptexpand

0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Welcome to Above the Fray, where we cut through the chaos and get to what really matters. No spin. Just smart takes in the story shaping our moment. So settle in, tune out the static, and join us as we go above the fray.

0:16Mark Leitner: Welcome back to Above the Fray, a Fitch Group podcast. Opioids, asbestos, talc, telc, abuse claims, these are all examples of mass torts. Situations where a single product or pattern of conduct harms large numbers of people, and they all have claims against the same company or organization. Over the past few decades, some of the biggest legal liabilities companies face haven't come from a single lawsuit, but from thousands, sometimes hundreds of thousands, of these claims at once. Increasingly, those fights have ended up in bankruptcy court. That raises a hard question. is bankruptcy the right place to resolve mass torts? Today, we're talking about what bankruptcy does well, where its limits are, how a landmark Supreme Court ruling changed the playbook, and what the alternatives look like. To help us unpack this, I'm joined by two guests. First, Judge Robert Green, thank you for joining us, who served as a U.S. bankruptcy judge for the Southern District of New York for over 20 years and presided. over the Purdue Pharma

1:16Chapter 11 case? Before the bench, he was a partner at Paul Weiss for over a decade, and today he's with M3 Partners. Then we have my colleague, welcome back, Mark Leitner, head of legal strategy at Credit Sites and an adjunct professor of bankruptcy law at Arizona State University. Mark also clerked for Judge Drain, so this is a bit of a reunion. How's it feel to be back together?

1:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Great. Excellent.

1:40Mark Leitner: So, Judge Drain, you have worked on mass torts throughout your career in the practice, from the bench, now as a mediator and advisor. You also presided over what was probably the defining case of the era with Purdue Pharma. And really few cases seem to have touched as many constituents from families and victims, states, municipalities, of course. the federal government with the DOJ and the US trustee and the public. When it landed on your docket, was there a moment when you thought, wow, this is going to be a very difficult case? Or was it just another in your very busy lineup?

2:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Well, I was very busy, but I knew this was a unique case. Um, I'd been somewhat following it uh in the news because it was in the news. They had uh the MDL um litigation in Ohio um that was uh

2:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

2:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): getting a fair amount of press. Um and uh I had to learn a lot about it, of course, uh, but I knew that it would be a significant case.

2:43Mark Leitner: Did you feel prepared for kind of the public attention in the the case? I know that there's the balance of this is my job and I'm here to do a job, and then the reality of the engagement and onlookers.

2:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Right. I I had had uh cases that were in the news, um, but more in the financial news. Um so I wasn't uh prepared for the uh

3:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh sort

3:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): of seizure. of the case uh by the news media um and then by uh by others politicians and the like um that uh ensued.

3:25Mark Leitner: Yeah, absolutely. How did you handle that? How did how does how did you approach that?

3:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Well, I mean it it at one level the uh news media is irrelevant to the law.

3:34Mark Leitner: Yes.

3:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Um because

3:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um

3:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): it's hearsay among other things, and you're in your court room and you're deciding the issues before you, and that's based on the evidence that's put before

3:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you.

3:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Um, on the other on another level, however, um, this was a case that involved very actively almost all the attorneys general in the in the country, uh all but two states. Um plus Puerto Rico and and other and territories. Uh so there was a very public element to it as well. At some point in the case, the um lawyers uh started like I thought too much playing to the news, and I tried to rein that in. Um

4:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

4:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I'm not sure how successful that was because it's

4:26Mark Leitner: hard to rein. in lawyers.

4:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Well it's and it's hard to rein it's hard to rein in the news media too.

4:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): For

4:31Mark Leitner: sure.

4:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah. Hurting

4:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): cats at

4:33Mark Leitner: its finest.

4:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): You know, the the news media loves to be the story itself. So um you know I got calls after the case from judges that had uh significant cases of public interest like the the uh uh judge that presided over the in our National Rifle Association case and

4:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um

4:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I th, you know,

4:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you the

4:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): uh bankers bench is very collegial and we

4:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): try

4:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): to catch up pretty quickly with with uh developments,

5:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um,

5:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): not just in the law, but how to how to handle cases like this. Aaron

5:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell

5:04Mark Leitner: A little bankruptcy bench support group. You can commiserate together. I love that.

5:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it. Well,

5:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): and teach each other.

5:11Mark Leitner: Yes, absolutely. So, Mark, in these situations, we always want to have a fly in the wall. And you kind of were a fly on the wall in that you clerked for Judge Strain and you saw in chambers how judges manage these cases with so much scrutiny and so many stakeholders involved. What was your take on it?

5:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yeah. So so you know, I've had the the the true privilege. I worked for four different judges in the course of my career at all levels. of uh the judiciary. So I I I clerked for a judge drain during the great financial crisis, and that was one of the best legal experiences that I could have had. Uh and I had the privilege to work for a judge on uh uh United States Court of Appeals and then on a state high court, and then subsequently after that, a judge in private practice. And one of the things that I constantly almost always almost pinched myself is that judges, you know, really have a commitment to service and doing the right thing. And of course, there's often, you know, reasonable minds can disagree what the right thing is, you know, applying the facts to the governing law and the precedent. Uh, but you know, that's really, in my experience, of all the judges I've met and worked for over the course of my career, that's really at bottom what they do. They really believe that they're civil servants and they're they're trying to come to the right uh result based on what. the law provides. And so that's really to me, you know, the fundamental thing in all this, including in the context of mass torts, whether that's in, you know, a bankruptcy or in a multidistic litigation proceeding or even

6:38in just a regular straight up, you know, party A versus party B proceeding.

6:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So that's

6:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): kind of my general takeaway based

6:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on

6:44Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): my experience.

6:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All

6:45Mark Leitner: right. So for listeners who didn't follow the case closely, here's the issue. The Sackler family who own Purdue, never filed for bankruptcy themselves. But in exchange for contributing billions of dollars to the settlement, the plan of reorganization would have released them from opioid lawsuits, including lawsuits by people who objected to giving that release. That's what's called a non-consensual third-party release, a bankruptcy plan protecting someone who isn't the debtor from claims held by people who didn't agree to it.

7:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): In

7:15Mark Leitner: June 2024, the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that the bankruptcy code doesn't allow that.

7:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So,

7:21Mark Leitner: Judge Jane, I'd be curious to hear from you. What did that ruling change and what did it not change?

7:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Well, it changed the uh law that was in effect in my circuit, the Second Circuit, and most of the other circuits too. There were a couple that uh

7:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): had

7:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): previously decided on this issue as the Supreme Court ended up deciding. But uh the precedent in the Second Circuit and the Third Circuit and a number of other ones was that um in the right uh circumstances uh such a release could be uh imposed uh on those who uh

8:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): did

8:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): not accept it. And uh it grew out of uh the asbestos cases um where there were um significant claims against third parties, not usually at that point at least the owners of the company, like Manville was a public company, but uh insurers. And um uh to access the insurance uh in a mass settlement um that people could could vote on and accept. Um the insurers wanted to make sure that they weren't r then liable thereafter.

8:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Right.

8:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Um that grew in other contexts, uh, like the uh uh Dalcon Con Shield case, H. Robbins, where it was a parent company,

8:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

8:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): or or actually family. that owned it. And there were potential claims over both by the debtor and by third parties that were very closely related. And the court there approved that type of release as well. It was always on a a a sort of supermajority basis. Normally in a bankruptcy case, uh a class is bound. if two-thirds of dollar amount and one half a number of those actually voting vote in favor of the plan. They bind everybody else to the plan. If you're going to have that type of uh release, um it's generally was viewed that it had to be above 75%. And in fact, in in uh uh Purdue of those voting, it was over 90%. percent. Um in fact it was uh much higher than that in the major affected classes. So um that's changed. Uh there cannot be complete finality on those third-party claims. Um but there are still open issues such as if there's a prominent notice in the plan and the disclosure statement for the plan that if you don't vote.

10:03you're bound by the plan. Um lower courts are dealing with that issue now. It hasn't really percolated up to the circuit courts yet. Um there are uh issues about uh what is a third-party claim as opposed to the debtor's claim. Um those are also percolating now through the through the uh circuit courts. And there's uh a subset of cases that have an international connection where uh chapter fifteen of the bankruptcy code is invoked as opposed to chapter eleven, fifteen basically implements the foreign plan or scheme. And it's it's actually fairly common in some foreign jurisdictions to allow some third third-party party releases, for example, of uh guarantees in England that uh

10:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are

10:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): not of the guarantor is not in bankruptcy. That's completely opposed to US law, but under Chapter 15 jurisprudence that's permitted. The foreign courts really don't have the jurisprudence on mass torts that we do because our mass tort bar is much more developed, the case law is much more developed, the practice is much more developed. So they're just coming to deal with that type of uh third-party claim, a a mass tort claim against a parent company or uh insurers or or others. Um I'm not sure whether um that use of chapter 15 fifteen will actually be that productive as far as mass torts are concerned.

11:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

11:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you still you still have to uh negotiate as you always had to with the plaintiffs.

11:44Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Right.

11:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Um in a collective way.

11:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um

11:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): and you try to get as much agreement as you can with them, just as you did before. But as for holdouts, y you have to uh if you're a funder of a plan, accept except that there will be some holdouts and find some other way to negotiate with them or beat them in court or deal with it that way? Aaron

12:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell This

12:06Mark Leitner: may be an unfair question, but in a case like Purdue Pharma, how many plaintiffs' attorneys were there? Were there is it just a a large group given how many

12:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Well, uh Purdue was uh unlike unlike uh the asbestos cases and some of the other Mastword Toward cases, the major plaintiffs in Purdue and this is true for most of the opioid litigation, were governments, state governments, local governments. Um and in that sense, they represented, you know, basically everybody

12:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in the in the

12:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): country. Um there was a plaintiff's bar as well. Um these were hard cases to win if you were an individual plaintiff.

12:48Mark Leitner: Right.

12:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): So it wasn't uh there were a lot of potential claims. The Bardate uh for the case brought

12:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): out

12:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): hundreds of thousands of claims by people, but many of the most of those were not represented. Right. Um there uh was a a firm um that sort of

13:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was

13:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): a pioneer in this area, and they had, you know, maybe fifteen. 15,000 clients, which is a small number actually, when you look at the some of the mastort cases where you have firms that have uh a lot more than that. And and there weren't a lot of other firms yet in that in that uh area. Aaron

13:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell

13:29Mark Leitner: That's a really helpful context. Mark, I'd be curious, given that you are still looking at companies with potential kind of mastwork mastwort obligations at some point. How are you thinking about the Supreme Court decision in Purdue Purdue Pharma and third party releases and kind of looking ahead in terms of what's changed and what hasn't changed?

13:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Well, it complicates the playbook, I think, in terms of the, you know, the menu of options that a company potentially has. Um, as Judge Strain Drain mentioned, you know, prior to the Supreme Court's decision, third third-party party releases, uh were were permitted in a number of circuits, including the Second Circuit, which sits over New York where Judge uh Drain presided. So that particular tool in your toolbox is no longer available. That being said, the bankruptcy process, notwithstanding that, still provides, I think, a very important function, which is it still creates a collective proceeding. It gets people together, it organizes them together in a particular forum. And I think it, you know, potentially can lead to a negotiated outcome, even if there are still a certain number of holdout creditors. Um, so the the way that I view Purdue is not an end-all be all to resolving mass torts in bankruptcy. It just, you know, that last sliver of holdouts you may have to deal with differently, but it still provides a really important function in creating a collective process where you can actually have a counterparty with which to negotiate and try and resolve all these issues together.

14:55Mark Leitner: Yeah, and that makes a lot of sense to me. If you had told me, oh, in these cases where a lot of people have been harmed, we're actually going to use the bankruptcy court as our way to organize and figure out who is owed what and who has to pay what. That seems a little bit counterintuitive to me because bankruptcy. in my mind is is something just totally different as you know a a credit person in general. And so it's interesting when a company has thousands of people saying, you have harmed us, you have harmed us, you know, it's not just the challenge of deciding have they harmed them, who is responsible for that harm, but it's also trying to figure out who gets compensated, how do they get compensated? What is fair, what is not fair, and determining whether the bankruptcy channel is the right way to do that, I think is very much an interesting question. So, Judge Street, I'd be curious to hear from you if someone wants compensation and they're you know pursuing

15:55it through a bankruptcy channel, what can that do that thousands of separate lawsuits can't do, or it in Purdue Pharma, where winning on an individual case may be much more difficult. But also what may people be giving up in return for pursuing that channel?

16:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Well, there are people who have have written and said that, well, for any personal injury case,

16:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

16:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): bankruptcy is not a uh solution. I I I really disagree with that. It's it ultimately is a liability as well. But um there are uh uh differences. Um

16:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

16:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): when I when I taught bankruptcy, I would ask uh the the students, you know, have you ever lent money to someone and they've not paid you back? And how did that make you feel? And you know, I usually get one or two answers and and they invariably say, which is correct. I was really angry. Um, but, you know, banks is sort of part of their business that there's some amount of uh of of loss, that some loans are bad and uh they get angry only if they've really been defrauded. Um, when people have been harmed by by harmful conduct, they're rightfully angry and probably angrier even than um uh you know the the person who made a thousand not alone and didn't get didn't get repaid but from their former best friend. So um bankruptcy doesn't really deal with that level of of uh uh anger. Um frankly, the court system itself,

17:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): when

17:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you get down to it, doesn't really either, the civil court system. Uh people say they want to have their day in court. Um, but if you already know that someone has harmed you,

17:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um

17:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): the day in court is just proving that up again. Um and

17:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

17:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): it can be cathartic, it can also be awful. Um even if you win. So one of the elements of the Purdue settlement, uh, which I kind of stuck my neck out because there's no real basis for it in uh in the the federal uh rules of civil procedure, was to have a hearing where victims, claimants, uh got to speak directly to the lead uh family members. Um it was not an evidentiary hearing. Um the it was part of the settlement, so it it wasn't going to affect

18:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

18:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): outcome of any litigation, so I didn't have to worry about hearsay or anything like

18:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that.

18:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): And um the creditors committee that represented all of these uh individuals um uh as a you know hundreds of thousands of them 30 were were allowed to speak. And it was quite eloquent. It was, you know, very moving. Said this was incredibly important.

18:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Interesting.

18:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Some of their clients said this was more important than any any funding. That has been picked up on in other cases, particularly in the diocesan cases where there's a lot of pain, obviously. I don't know how far you can push that because it does affect how the judge thinks of the case, and it's not an evidentiary hearing, it's not provided, you know, it's not provided for in the in the rules, but it's an attempt to try to give people sort of the equivalent of a victim statement in a sentencing hearing. But this is civil litigation. It's it's really ultimately litigation over how people pay money to resolve this. If you're really looking to fix blame beyond that, it's it's in the criminal justice system. And um I think that was hard for people to understand when uh they uh uh looked at Purdue from the outside. Um and uh

20:01uh

20:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

20:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): that's a in part because people just you know they basically whenever they see a court in action on TV, it's a usually a a uh

20:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a

20:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): criminal proceeding and and uh

20:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um

20:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): the other ones are quite uh

20:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know

20:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): dramatized. Well probably this the the criminal ones are too, but but the uh the the non non-criminal criminal ones can could be pretty pretty unrealistic.

20:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Judge, do you think that bankruptcy in the context of mass torts Purdue, including all the others, gets a bad rap as a process? Um, in other words, people think, oh, they're filing for bankruptcy, they're just gonna try and weasel out of you know these these rightful obligations that that that they owe. Is that do you think it how how how would you respond to

20:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that?

20:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Well, the only way to fairly resolve uh a a situation where the uh obligure doesn't have enough value to pay everyone in full is is a bankruptcy. Um it's the only way to prevent Mr. X from getting uh a hundred percent recovery and Ms. Y to get zero.

21:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): It's the race of the courthouse

21:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): problem.

21:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Right. So in that sense

21:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's

21:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): it's the it's the only ultimate result we have. There have been, as as is pretty well known in in the US, attempts to um create an insolvent entity to protect a parent company. I have grave reservations about that. Um

21:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're

21:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): referring to the Texas two step

21:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): thing. Yeah. That's

21:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): that's very popular in at least in the investor community as a way to try and isolate liabilities.

21:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): It's uh I I think the courts are having a hard time with it too, although it's still available in some circuits. But that's only available ultimately, I think, as a as a means to get people to coalesce pre bankruptcy on an agreement.

21:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): So so is it the idea, Judge, you're saying uh let's uh can we unpack that just a second the the threat of a bankruptcy is a is an organizing feature to get the you know the the group of plaintiffs together to try and come up with a a resolution that is fair and equitable to the victims themselves.

22:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It

22:13Mark Leitner: seems very practical, right? If we're trying to avoid something that's long and drawn out and bogged down in precedent and procedure and all of that, but also maybe not necessarily the best outcome for victims.

22:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Well, it it it depends. The person who's ready for trial and the lawyer that's representing that person hates being called into a conference room with, you know, 50 other lawyers who may not be ready for trial and may not, in

22:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in

22:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): that person's view, be as good a lawyer as as she is. And and uh, you know, so it it is it does tilt the playing field and and I understand that. if you're ready for trial and and or you think you have the best cases and they're trying

22:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to

22:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): uh uh disadvantage you by making a deal with those folks who really don't have great cases, but they have a lot of them. Um so that it it is complicated. Unfortunately there's no real other way to deal with it other than having trials just continue. And there comes a point where even the largest company can't do more than 20 trials a year. So it's a it's a problem that we have because of our very well-developed uh plaintiff's bar and civil tort system. Um MDL uh multi-district litigation is another way to aggregate. but that can be also lengthy.

23:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It

23:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): it's not necessarily comprehensive. It doesn't necessarily unite all the state court cases and the federal court cases together. So all of these areas are unwieldy, but I'm not sure there's any other solution. There was a point in the 90s, nineties, early 90s, nineties, where there was a bill pending in Congress to create a fund to deal with as asbestos best disclaimed justice. claims generally and to channel without having a bankruptcy, just channel all these claims to this super fund basically. And uh I I was they were like second or third generation large asbestos cases and I was represented the the creditors committee in one of them, the the financial creditors. And uh,

24:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,

24:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): it was intriguing our our group, which had, you know, thirteen 13 members they were all like major hedge funds or banks, went down and lobbied.

24:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It

24:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): was incredibly expensive. The three senators each charged about $40,000 for a one-hour meeting of all 13 of them. Um, I'm sure the same thing was going on with the plaintiff's bar. It was basically a catch cow for Congress and the Senate, and nothing came of it. And uh that pretty much leaves you with the uh the civil justice system. And if you're if you're unable to pay,

24:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

24:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): don't think there's any other way to resolve it than go through a bankruptcy case. And that that raises issues. How do you how do you liquidate those claims and do it efficiently and fairly? That's that's a that's a serious issue. Um there's there is a real difference among the plaintiffs in many of these cases. um and the law firms that are representing them. But you can't really say I'm going to pay law firm X's clients more than law firm Y's clients, but that's lurking in the background. And uh

25:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there

25:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): are ways to deal with it. There are ways to like give people the chance to opt out and go to the tort system if they've they think that they can get a bigger slug of money that's reserved for those people that want to opt out. But it's uh um ultimately it's it's fairly rough justice.

25:50Mark Leitner: So Mark, I'd be curious to hear from you. How do we take a step back and think about whether this is a good outcome? You know, what matters beyond just the headline number of company XYZ? is paying out however many hundreds of thousands, millions, billions to,

26:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

26:08Mark Leitner: know, remedy the situation.

26:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like is

26:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): this a good outcome for the the victims themselves?

26:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Or

26:13Mark Leitner: maybe both, to be honest. Right.

26:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,

26:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): look, I mean, uh Judge Jane talked about this before. You know, victims, I mean, compensation is certainly part of it, but uh and and Judge Jane used the the the example of, you know. the victim impact statement uh uh corollary. You know, it I think you know, victims want to feel like they've been, you know, treated fairly in the process, that they've been heard, they've been treated like individuals. You know, uh I you know, in some cases that they want some level of accountability and you know, acknowledgement of their pain. Um, and so, you know, from the the you know, and they're and they're there are, and every person's different, right? But so the those are some of the categories of things that, you know, victims uh, you know, look for often. Um, and then, you know, from the the company's perspective, uh, you know, whether this is a good settlement or not, you know, that I think that's going to just depend on each company and their ability to pay. For example, there are a number of companies in the market right now that have agreed to very large settlements over a large period of time, 3M, for example, and all the parties in that case, for example, acknowledged in the settlement agreement itself, you know, the risk that, you know, 3M may not be able to pay on this, right? The bankruptcy risk. And so, you know, one of the things I tell our clients every time I talk about mass torts is that the plaintiff's bar, and by the way, I have nothing against the plaintiff's bar and they serve a very important function in

27:35our adversarial system of justice. You know, sometimes you don't want to be too good at your job uh because you can't get blood out of a stone. And so, and the plaintiff's bar is very astute and they know this, right? And so there is this kind of dance where they're trying to get as much as they can, but they don't want to, you know, kill the hand that feeds them. And so, you know, that's kind of the analysis from you know an investor's perspective. Say, okay, did they get the better end of that negotiation?

28:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes.

28:02Mark Leitner: absolutely.

28:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So it's

28:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): a very tough balance.

28:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Right. And then there's there's the overlay of uh governmental entities. Um like with uh with uh Forever Chemicals with PFAS, uh like opioids, the uh towns and water districts and states um are, I think, in in many cases the largest creditors and they're faced with under the the Biden era regulation, uh almost impossible cleanup task um and try to figure out how to pay for it. I think in part because of that there have not been

28:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as

28:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): many uh well I think there may only have been one, which I was a a mediator in, uh uh Forever Chemicals bankruptcy, is that there are, you know, that that's more of a governmental issue depending on how the regulations are enforced in the developing science of this area, that could be a huge problem for for many more companies than than uh currently. Aaron

29:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell

29:04Mark Leitner: Yeah. There is this unfortunate balance of the practicality or the reality of financial constraints with the very emotional involvement of victims in so many areas. of these cases. And I'd be curious, Judge Dreen, if you were running uh the world, if you were a benevolent dictator for a day, which is how I run my household, my children refer to me as the benevolent benevolent dictator. What would you change about the system with regards to how it handles mass mess torts? Is it still running through the bankruptcy channel? Would you create, you know, its own new channel? What would you do?

29:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): It's a I I actually think that both the MDL world and the bankruptcy world do a pretty good job. There's no one model for these types of problems. Um each company is different. Um some are so small that they can be resolved easily. Uh some are so large that it's a it's a a totally different approach. Um and uh

30:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

30:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I don't think creating a fund is the way to do it because that just makes it like faceless as well. I mean, there are times when funds work. I mean, I think the uh the World Trade Center fund worked pretty well. They had a you know remarkable person in Ken Feinberg who's trying to allocate it. There are not that many Ken Feinbergs of the world. in the world. And he managed to anger people too, at the same time that people generally thought he can got to the right result. So I think it's a matter of the judges educating themselves, both uh the district courts, judges, and MDLs and the uh the bankruptcy judges on how to how to uh uh deal with these unique situations. It's partly the bar educating itself. You know, the the uh mass tort bar generally doesn't get into being a plaintiff's lawyer thinking about becoming a bankruptcy expert. Um and there was a whole generation of them that learned how to do that in the asbestos

31:10cases and were quite respected. One of them just passed away, Joe Rice He wasn't always that way way and when Namville started, he was like incredibly aggressive,

31:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um,

31:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): maybe somewhat to the client's detriment.

31:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,

31:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): so I think uh the the the better

31:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

31:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): tort lawyers get it and do educate themselves. Uh there's kind of a new generation of them now because those those uh former lawyers have retired or passed away. And but I've I've actually been very impressed by the leaders of the uh plaintiffs' committees that I've dealt with over the last three or four years. Um just their sophistication and uh not not in any way uh cutting corners for their clients, but just appreciating the uh financial constraints. Um there's a there's just a natural urge of a plaintiff's lawyer to say, no one's gonna hold me back from getting a jury trial. And that's totally understandable that, you know, that's why we have juries, but

32:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

32:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you can only do so many of those a year. And your clients are in the hospital, they need to pay their bills and and uh um I think um it's it's just a learning process for for people on all sides of this.

32:25Mark Leitner: Yeah. What are you watching as to kind of the next area of mass torts? And we've had asbestos in the past, we had opioids. Now I know that the forever chemicals, as you mentioned, are becoming very topical. You know, we have social media harms, or Mark and I were talking about AI gone rogue or copyright infringement, all sorts of claims. Are there areas that you're kind of looking at and thinking, uh-oh, uh oh, this this might be the next thing. the next thing?

32:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): No, you you name them all.

32:53Mark Leitner: Yeah. Okay, great. Perfect.

32:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah. I mean, I I think on the on the uh social media and AI,

33:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

33:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): the issue's gonna be, you know, will there be lip protective litig legislation? Um and uh it's it's not as if you can ignore the harms. So the question. is, is there a way to balance them out through legislation or are you still going to go through this court process? And uh one is is uh difficult just because it's difficult to get Congress to agree on anything. Uh the other is very messy. So, you know, it's it's but hopefully both systems

33:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

33:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): continue to be respected and uh people appreciate that um

33:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at

33:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): least in the court system, the uh the courts really don't have any agenda other than to get it right.

33:52Mark Leitner: Absolutely. Mark, just kind of some final thoughts in terms of credit investors looking at trying to assess, underwrite, mass tort exposure, any food for thought or wisdom there.

34:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yeah. I mean, uh, as Judge mentioned, you know, each one of these situations is completely different, sui generis, as we say it in Latin sometimes. Um, and so, you know, you look at the nature and extent of the harm, you know, you look at issues uh like causation and the science behind it, really, you know, it there's a lot of allegations, but did the alleged conduct actually cause the harm, for example? Um, you look at, you know, the possibility. posture of the existing caseload, right? There are some companies that have, you know, I I I picked on 3M earlier, I'll pick on them again. I often joke that they're a um a law firm that uh uh sells some products. Um, right. And and and you look at, you know, does the the company have a showstopper defense? And the the best example that I can think of happened this year when Monsanto won at the Supreme Court on federal preemption grounds related to their glyphosate liability, which was a complete showstopper for like a hundred thousand plus claims. And so each situation in each company and each credit that you're looking at, really, you have to take a comprehensive uh view at that. And then you also have to look at the capital structure and the timing of all those payments. So there's really no one size fits all analysis on that.

35:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): The only thing I'd add to that is that investors. should be wary of financial engineering that that is marketed as saying we're dealing with this problem because um one of the oldest elements of bankruptcy law goes back to the statute of Elizabeth I, the avoidance of fraudulent transfers. And uh 1492. Well

35:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): personal hero

35:33Mark Leitner: personal heroes.

35:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A little

35:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): after that, but not much. Not much. But it it was uh

35:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

35:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): so I

35:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

35:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): that is that's that's an overhang always uh in the analysis too. Um it's not a financial engineering is not a panacea. It's it's just a way maybe to get some parties to settle um and not uh the end of the day. And also how to manage you could you you could turn over your your your

36:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

36:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): the law firm aspect of your business to people that just do that so you can start making post-its and things like that again. But but uh it's not a it's not a a real Eureka moment when someone says, oh we found an answer here.

36:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Aaron Ross Powell

36:15Mark Leitner: Well I appreciate ending on a note where we are warning people about financial engineering because that very much falls in the the wheelhouse of the the credit sites and Fitch teams for a certain that's going to gonna bring us to the end of today's conversation. So much thanks to Judge Dreen for joining us today. I learned a lot. And Mark, of course, thank you for joining as well. If you enjoyed the discussion, be sure to like, subscribe, and join us next week for more sharp analysis on the forces shaping global markets. Until then, stay above the fray.

36:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's a wrap on today's episode. Thanks for spending your time with. us. If you enjoyed it, subscribe, share it with a friend, and leave us a review. Until next time, stay curious, stay grounded, and we'll see you above the fray.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights