The Money Café with Alan Kohler

Mayne and Addis discuss Anthropic IPO, Nvidia governance, and Australian market monopolies

54 min Listen to the original
IPOsCorporate GovernanceAustralian BanksEV MarketShareholder ActivismAIAviation DuopolyExecutive Pay

Summary

Stephen Mayne and John Addis discuss the Anthropic IPO, with Addis advising against it due to information asymmetry and Mayne noting its high valuation. They analyze Nvidia's governance issues following a 'spy scandal' and leadership changes. The hosts critique the Australian banking oligopoly and aviation duopoly, suggesting government intervention to boost competition. Mayne shares insights from shareholder activism at WAM Listed Investment Companies, highlighting concerns over fees and board independence. They also touch on housing supply, executive pay, and the economic impact of AI.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    The big four Australian banks make approximately $40 billion a year pre-tax, yet they are meant to be a utility sector rather than dominating the stock market.

    Stephen Mayne · 27:23

  2. 2
    At the SEAK AGM, CEO Ian Narev's incentive grant proposal was voted down with 53% against, showing shareholder pushback on executive pay.

    Stephen Mayne · 42:25

Episode sections

  1. 0:11 – 1:53

    Introduction and Podcast Origins

    Stephen Mayne and John Addis introduce themselves and the podcast, discussing the history of Intelligent Investor and their respective roles in the media and investment sectors.

  2. 1:53 – 4:06

    Anthropic IPO and Value Investing Principles

    The speakers discuss the upcoming Anthropic IPO, with John Addis advising against investing in IPOs due to information asymmetry and lack of proven business models, while Stephen Mayne notes the high valuation and cash burn.

  3. 4:06 – 11:36

    Nvidia Governance Scandal and Leadership Changes

    Discussion shifts to Nvidia's recent stock decline due to a 'spy scandal' involving CEO Jensen Huang, the appointment of a new CFO, and concerns over governance, related-party transactions, and sales to China.

  4. 11:36 – 15:22

    Australian Car Retailing and EV Market Dynamics

    John Addis recommends buying cars now due to falling prices driven by competition from Chinese EV makers, noting low retailer margins and the potential for BYD to become the top brand in Australia.

  5. 15:22 – 19:47

    Stephen Mayne's AGM Activism at WAM Listed Investment Companies

    Stephen Mayne details his experience attending nine AGMs for Jeff Wilson's WAM funds, highlighting shareholder activism regarding high fees, lack of independent directors, and conflicts of interest.

  6. 19:47 – 23:27

    Corporate Governance: Founder Control vs. Board Independence

    The hosts debate the tension between backing successful founders like Jeff Wilson or Chris Allison and the need for genuine board independence, noting that retail investor apathy often allows governance issues to persist.

  7. 23:27 – 26:18

    Banking Industry Competition and Consumer Rates

    Addressing listener questions, the speakers criticize the Australian banking oligopoly for high margin loan rates and low savings rates, suggesting government intervention like account number portability or an RBA savings account to boost competition.

  8. 26:18 – 29:24

    Banking Regulation and Consumer Advocacy

    Speakers discuss the lack of a consumer movement in Australia compared to labor and business lobby groups, arguing that regulation has inadvertently protected bank profitability. They note that banks are a utility sector but have become dominant in the stock market, with the big four earning significant pre-tax profits.

  9. 29:24 – 33:03

    Wealth Building for Young Professionals

    A listener asks how to build wealth outside of superannuation given that negative gearing is less effective. Speakers advise against gearing up to buy shares, citing high risk and transaction costs, and instead recommend long-term share investing with low fees and avoiding emotional selling, while noting that property investment loan applications are crashing.

  10. 33:03 – 38:14

    Qantas Offshoring and Aviation Duopoly

    The hosts discuss Qantas offshoring jobs to India, questioning why the government allows this despite protecting domestic airlines from foreign competition. They argue the government has leverage to stop such practices but chooses not to, and suggest that forcing Qantas to divest Jetstar would create genuine competition in the duopoly market.

  11. 38:14 – 41:45

    Tax Policy and Housing Supply

    A listener proposes extending superannuation tax benefits to mortgage repayments to help young Australians. Stephen Mayne likes the targeting but warns it could drive up house prices. John Addis argues the core issue is housing supply, not tax structures, noting that housing prices have historically tracked GDP growth, not outpaced it significantly.

  12. 41:45 – 46:49

    Executive Remuneration and Inflation

    Speakers debate whether high CEO pay contributes to inflation. Mayne cites recent AGM rejections of executive pay packages and high tax rates on LTI grants as checks on pay. Addis argues CEO pay is too small a cohort to impact inflation numbers directly, but their pricing power in monopolies/duopolies does drive inflation.

  13. 46:49 – 50:04

    AI Job Losses and Economic Impact

    A listener asks about the consumption impact of AI-driven job losses. Mayne dismisses the 'catastrophizing' view, citing low unemployment rates in the West. Addis acknowledges the 'tragedy of the commons' risk but remains optimistic, suggesting that universal basic income discussions in Silicon Valley may have anticipated this scenario.

  14. 50:04 – 54:07

    Anthropic IPO Details and Market Implications

    Mayne details the Anthropic IPO, priced at $83 USD per share with a $1.5 trillion valuation, noting it is now in the top 12 companies globally. He compares this rapid value creation to past tech IPOs like Google and Amazon, while Addis argues that waiting for post-IPO information reduces risk significantly.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
AlphabetGOOGLequityneutralof my space exchange. I'll give you I'll give you the counter factual. Like Google, Facebook,
Meta PlatformsMETAequityneutralof my space exchange. I'll give you I'll give you the counter factual. Like Google, Facebook,
AmazonAMZNequityneutralAmazon were all pretty, pretty handy IPOs, weren't they back in the day? So that's the the the the contrary view is that certain big tech stocks have been the best investments ever, and they all IPO'd at one point. And this one is basically floating at a ridiculous big tech vote valuation, unlike all the others, who became
NVIDIANVDAequityneutrallook look at look at Nvidia you know forty three billion in cash flow in the latest results this week and it's still down another three percent uh today because of the great spy scandal Jensen Wong. Wrong. I mean they're sort of two connected stories aren't they really really? 'Cause because uh you've got the the chip
AppleAAPLequityneutralprovider that's been you know the chips uh the the picks and shovels beneficiary of this AI boom with its own scandal, no longer the most valuable company with Apple reclaiming that title.
Anthropicprivate companyneutraluh all sorts of geopolitical things. And then meanwhile Anthropic
OpenAIprivate companyneutralto float, and and if Tropic if Anthropic does get away, you know, you will see OpenAI, I'd say, coming in the next twelve 12 months, and then that will complete the set. Then you know we're done. There's uh all the new trillion dollar stocks and AI are here.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

Anthropic is pricing its IPO at a valuation of one point five to one point six trillion dollars.

Stephen Mayne ·1:56

How to verify: Check the final pricing announcement from the Anthropic IPO prospectus or financial news reports from the week of 2026-11-19. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Nvidia generated forty-three billion in cash flow in its latest results.

Stephen Mayne ·4:06

How to verify: Review Nvidia's most recent quarterly earnings report (10-Q or 10-K) filed on SEC EDGAR. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Nvidia's stock was down three percent on the day of the discussion due to a 'spy scandal' involving Jensen Huang.

Stephen Mayne ·4:06

How to verify: Check historical stock price data for NVDA and news archives for reports on Jensen Huang and Nvidia governance issues around 2026-11-19. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Nvidia gave fifty billion US dollars in guarantees to near-cloud companies.

Stephen Mayne ·6:12

How to verify: Review Nvidia's financial statements and notes on commitments and guarantees in their SEC filings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Jensen Huang owns three point six percent of Nvidia.

Stephen Mayne ·8:34

How to verify: Check Nvidia's latest proxy statement (DEF 14A) filed on SEC EDGAR for insider ownership percentages. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Nvidia stopped reporting Singapore sales separately.

Stephen Mayne ·7:55

How to verify: Compare segment reporting in Nvidia's recent quarterly earnings releases against previous periods. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Nvidia stopped shipping Hopper AI chips to China, which accounted for about two point four billion in sales last quarter.

John Addis ·10:26

How to verify: Review Nvidia's earnings reports for revenue breakdowns by geography and news reports on export restrictions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Eagles has an eighteen percent market share in Australia with margins of about two point eight percent.

John Addis ·12:55

How to verify: Check Eagles' latest annual or half-year financial report for market share data (if disclosed) and profit margins. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Australian car industry margins are falling to zero point seven percent.

John Addis ·13:15

How to verify: Review industry reports from the Automotive Retailers Association of Australia (ARAA) or company financials. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Roger Corbett invested four point three million dollars in WAM Capital eight years ago, which is down fifty-five percent, while receiving three hundred and fifty million in fees.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·16:29

How to verify: Check WAM Capital's financial reports for fee disclosures and Roger Corbett's personal investment disclosures if available, or news reports on his AGM speech. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

There are over a thousand paid unionists in Australia ensuring workers are looked after, but no equivalent consumer movement exists.

Stephen Mayne ·27:03

How to verify: Search for Australian Bureau of Statistics data on union membership density and compare with records of registered consumer advocacy organizations or political parties in Australia. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The big four Australian banks make approximately $40 billion a year pre-tax.

Stephen Mayne ·27:23

How to verify: Review the annual financial reports of Commonwealth Bank, Westpac, NAB, and ANZ for the most recent fiscal year, summing pre-tax profits. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Anna Bly is the Australian Banking Association CEO after being Premier of Queensland.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·28:21

How to verify: Search for Anna Bly's professional biography on the Australian Banking Association website and her political career history on the Queensland Parliament website. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Bank loan applications for investment property are crashing.

Stephen Mayne ·30:01

How to verify: Access Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) housing finance data or major bank lending reports to check trends in investment property loan approvals. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Qantas is worth $15 billion.

Stephen Mayne ·33:25

How to verify: Check the market capitalization of Qantas Airways Limited (QAN.AX) on the ASX at the time of the podcast or in recent filings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Jetstar makes half a billion a year.

Stephen Mayne ·36:44

How to verify: Review Qantas Group's annual report for the operating profit or revenue contribution of the Jetstar division. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Anthropic priced its IPO at $83 USD per share.

Stephen Mayne ·50:04

How to verify: Check the final pricing announcement from the SEC or financial news outlets for the Anthropic IPO. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Anthropic has a $1.5 trillion valuation.

Stephen Mayne ·50:04

How to verify: Calculate the market capitalization based on the IPO price of $83 and the number of shares outstanding (825 million shares sold, plus existing shares) or check the post-IPO market cap reported by financial data providers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Anthropic had $100 billion in retail bids and $400 billion in institutional bids.

Stephen Mayne ·50:04

How to verify: Review the IPO prospectus or underwriting reports filed with the SEC detailing the demand generation for the offering. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Anthropic sold 825 million shares at $83 each.

Stephen Mayne ·50:04

How to verify: Check the final prospectus or press release from the IPO for the exact number of shares sold and the offering price. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Stephen Mayne is a contributor at Intelligent Investor.

Stephen Mayne ·53:34

How to verify: Check the Intelligent Investor website or staff page for contributor listings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Stephen Mayne is the founder of Crikey.

Stephen Mayne ·53:34

How to verify: Check the 'About' page on the Crikey website or corporate registry records for the company's founding. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Stephen Mayne is a shareholder activist.

Stephen Mayne ·53:34

How to verify: Search public records for shareholder activist campaigns led by Stephen Mayne or his associated entities. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

John Addis is the founder of Intelligent Investor.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·53:50

How to verify: Check the Intelligent Investor website's 'About' section or corporate registry records for the company's founding. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify Anthropic's financials and cash burn rate via its S-1 filing with the SEC.
  • Check Nvidia's latest quarterly earnings report for cash flow figures and details on the CFO's comments regarding 'neo-cloud' funding.
  • Review Nvidia's proxy statement (DEF 14A) for CEO ownership percentages and board independence metrics.
  • Analyze Australian Bureau of Statistics data on housing supply versus GDP growth to assess John Addis's claim.
  • Examine ASIC reports or bank annual reports for the 'big four' pre-tax profit figures and executive remuneration disclosures.
  • Check Qantas and Jetstar market share data and route restrictions to evaluate the duopoly claim.
  • Research WAM Listed Investment Companies' AGM voting results and fee structures to assess shareholder activism outcomes.
  • Look up Ian Narev's compensation details and the SEAK AGM voting records to verify executive pay rejections.
Full transcriptexpand

0:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hello,

0:12Stephen Mayne: I'm Stephen Mayne, contributor at Intelligent Investor, founder of Crikey and Shareholder Activist.

0:16John Addis: And I'm John Addis, founder and editor of Intelligent Investor. And we are

0:21Stephen Mayne: We are the Money Cafe, John. And let's start. You are the founder. of Intelligent Investor, which this this podcast is owned by. So you better tell us that that journey. When did you start Intel Investor?

0:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This is

0:35John Addis: gonna be a long podcast. Yes.

0:36Stephen Mayne: Now give us thirty give us thirty seconds introducing yourself to the Money Cafe

0:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): list.

0:41John Addis: I started Intelligent Investor in nineteen ninety eight. I did have a five year break after selling it for the first time in two thousand and four, I think. Been involved ever since. I've done a few other things as well, including buying your business, Stephen, off you about twenty five years ago uh in Crikey. And um I'm also, I should declare, uh a director of share site as well, which would be familiar probably to some of your listeners. So

1:04Stephen Mayne: serial entrepreneur.

1:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Not really I

1:06John Addis: well I wouldn't say that. I wouldn't say that. I mean a serial a serial entrepreneur doesn't do one thing for twenty twenty-five five years.

1:12Stephen Mayne: Yeah, but you know, you've been involved a with lot of start startups ups and you've bought different businesses and uh

1:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): value invest value

1:18Stephen Mayne: investing. I I mean you've just been a doyen decades long run. Great analysis, value investing, stocks to buy, stocks to avoid. So uh and I l what I love about you, John, is you always give a bring a really good governance framework to it. That you do look at value and you have quality of governance, transparency disclosure, you know, the bulldust detector. That's what I

1:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): really

1:40Stephen Mayne: like about it is you've got that skeptical eye, which is sort of part journalism, part analyst.

1:44John Addis: Yeah, that's true. That's true, I think, Stephen. Yeah. But

1:47Stephen Mayne: we shouldn't stop talking about ourselves, I guess. I'm sorry I've just indulged you like that. But there's so much going on, John. Where

1:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do we

1:52Stephen Mayne: start? I mean,

1:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they're about

1:53Stephen Mayne: to

1:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be a little bit more. They start with the anthropic

1:54John Addis: IPO, I think. Yeah.

1:56Stephen Mayne: They're about to price as we speak. And it's it's all everything points to bullish price, raising more money. one point five trillion plus plus plus. And I'm guessing you probably would find it a very difficult thing to invest in.

2:21John Addis: You know, I've I've cast my eye over it. I haven't done a detailed analysis. But in general, if you were to make a commitment as an investor never to buy an IPO, you would probably be better off over the long term by avoiding all of them than trying to choose the ones that are going to work. Because overall, if you're floating a business and you're selling it to investors, then you have more information about why you're selling, and you often don't have that information as to uh there's an information. asymmetry there. So generally I think that value investing rule about generally avoiding floats

2:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um

2:58John Addis: is a good one and it applies especially to anthropic. I think it fails my first test, which is does it have a sustainable, profitable, proven business model? And the answer to that is no. If you can't answer that question, you shouldn't go near this. Except one little exception. except if you're trying to make a little bit of money in a short-term trade.

3:19Stephen Mayne: So get out in the first week. Like I

3:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): did with most

3:22Stephen Mayne: of my space exchange. I'll give you I'll give you the counter factual. Like Google, Facebook,

3:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and

3:26Stephen Mayne: Amazon were all pretty, pretty handy IPOs, weren't they back in the day? So that's the the the the contrary view is that certain big tech stocks have been the best investments ever, and they all IPO'd at one point. And this one is basically floating at a ridiculous big tech vote valuation, unlike all the others, who became big tech in public markets. These guys are coming in and saying, We're already big tech and bias at big tech prices. That's the thing I find challenging. It's something that's burning so much cash and they're saying we're worth one point five, one point six trillion dollars. And um, you know, are we ever gonna make a profit? Well, it's just moving so fast who who could know but the the revenue growth is just exponential and um I'm look look at look at Nvidia you know forty three billion in cash flow in the latest results this week and it's still down another three percent uh today because of the great spy scandal Jensen Wong. Wrong. I mean they're sort of two connected stories aren't they really really? 'Cause because uh you've got the the chip provider that's been you know the chips uh the the picks and shovels beneficiary of this AI boom with its own scandal, no longer the most valuable company with Apple reclaiming that title.

4:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

4:36Stephen Mayne: uh all sorts of geopolitical things. And then meanwhile Anthropic

4:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): trying

4:40Stephen Mayne: to float, and and if Tropic if Anthropic does get away, you know, you will see OpenAI, I'd say, coming in the next twelve 12 months, and then that will complete the set. Then you know we're done. There's uh all the new trillion dollar stocks and AI are here.

4:53John Addis: Yeah, I I think there is a rush on to get these businesses away in the next I mean if they wait a year I'd be surprised. I th I think I think they might move faster than that. But you know, I I'm I'm really not interested in in going into anthropic. I think that it's there's so many red flags and there's such an unreliable business model there. The revenue quality is questionable and from your perspective. point of view, the governance and regulatory risk, it's got a very unusual governance structure, Stephen. Very, very sort of um unusual. The way that this thing is structured is very, very strange. And it makes NVIDIA look um quite quite normal in terms of the governance aspects. And I'd argue that NVIDIA is is equally um equally a a sort of it's got a very, very strange feeling about uh uh that company and how it's been set up completely in

5:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um

5:45John Addis: mirroring uh Jensen Jensen's sort of ambitions for the company. It's just incredible.

5:51Stephen Mayne: Yeah.

5:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

5:52Stephen Mayne: uh Colette Press, she she had her first so she see if she's the former CFO of Nvidia, she's had her first earnings call and she's tried to calm everyone down. And I think that the I thought one of the more interesting points was that she was she added some language to suggest they're not just going to keep throwing money at every single uh neo-cloud thought bubble that walks through the door, and you know, hello thermos and uh and uh and many other similar companies because they've given like fifty billion US dollars in guarantees to near clouds to sort of create the markets, you know, anyone who's gonna talk you. talking up building a data center, well, you'll buy you'll buy our chips eventually. Here's a guarantee to get you help you get you over the line. So I think the CFO is going to bring some more discipline to that. And that's

6:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what

6:37Stephen Mayne: a lot of people are nervous about. But at the end of the day, you can't get away from the just the the cash machine, which is unprecedented in history. Nothing in the

6:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): world. 80% Eighty percent

6:46Stephen Mayne: market share, 80% eighty percent profit margins. It's just it is just a machine like we've never seen. And so they can afford to drop a few tens of billions of dollars.

6:54John Addis: Yeah, it's an unbelievable business. And for the first time, I think in four years, I I am looking at it and thinking this does look quite attractive now, and it's often a good idea to buy companies going through difficult periods. The problem is for the industry is that the Jensen Huang is basically the banker to the entire AI sector. And now that he's not there and they have their CFO coming in, and let's just remark how unusual it is for a CFO to be managing the world's most important technology company. If they are putting a stop to that, what effect do you think that might have on the on the wider industry? Well,

7:27Stephen Mayne: I think it's going to have quite a big effect. Um, but I think the question is also how long is she going to actually be calling the in shots? Because uh they've they've hired Heydrich Hydrick and Struggles, which are one of the big five global records. recruitment firms, and I I think they're definitely going to go outside for a new CEO. So she'll

7:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be

7:44Stephen Mayne: the temporary acting CEO. And then she's actually got her own little governance issues because they stopped reporting on um on Singapore, they used to actually break out Singapore sales. That's

7:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.

7:55Stephen Mayne: The issue's gonna be is was the CFO in on the fix to hide effectively what was a huge massive uh smuggling of a of uh of illegal chips into China, which is uh basically

8:05John Addis: what

8:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they appear to have done.

8:07John Addis: It

8:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): would

8:08John Addis: be remarkable if she didn't know about that. And if you talk about government horror shows, I mean there are now there's still three board members on the NVIDIA board that joined in nineteen ninety-three.

8:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh

8:18John Addis: it's well known that he had sixty direct reports. His two kids work there on over a million dollars a year. Um there wasn't even a chair of the board until last week. You know, there's no

8:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): chair, he was the

8:30Stephen Mayne: executive chair

8:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): with sixty direct reports and the

8:32Stephen Mayne: founder.

8:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But he only owned

8:34Stephen Mayne: three point six percent. That was his problem. So

8:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): he's the the bring back

8:37Stephen Mayne: Jensen campaign. He can't run a proxy fight and just do a do an Elon or a or a Zuckerberg and go, I own all the voting stock, put me on the board now. So he's out, he's done, he's gone, he's gonna

8:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be a good one. You think he's completely. completely done? So

8:58Stephen Mayne: uh he's in he's in

8:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a

8:59Stephen Mayne: world of pain. Um

9:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah.

9:01John Addis: This board investigation that they're doing, the the fact that they rebuffed him so quickly, despite him sort of running the business from the ground up for the past forty years and having the whole thing structured in his own interests in the way he wanted. And yet they've come back. and said,

9:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No,

9:16John Addis: you're not coming back, stay away and shut up. It tells you something about what they found during their supposedly independent investigation. You know, when you hear that phrase you think, yeah, we know what this is about, but I suspect there's a lot more to come out about Megaspeed and maybe some lots of other kind of businesses like that in the Asian region, because it does seem as though they've been selling sailing into China willy-nilly. And this could get a lot worse for him, I think.

9:40Stephen Mayne: I agree. I think there's no coming back. Uh I think this could go as long as sandpaper gate, this one, in terms of uh who knew what when, and uh and uh I don't think that uh Jensen will be I mean he's he could do anything. I mean he could he could just go and buy, you know, twenty five percent of Intel and uh and start competing. So he's got you

10:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know

10:01Stephen Mayne: he's he's worth

10:03John Addis: probably wouldn't advise it but still

10:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): no

10:05Stephen Mayne: but he's got he's got the firepower to w to run one hell of a revenge campaign uh if he wants to. So you know he's it'll be very interesting to see what uh what Jensen does next but I'd just say for the next two years he's gonna be very busy with his

10:19John Addis: investigations,

10:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah.

10:21Stephen Mayne: Mending mending relations with his family. So um yeah look it's a it's a it interesting

10:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

10:26John Addis: news last night came out about they've they've already stopped uh shipping hopper AI chips to China and last year I mean last quarter that was about two point four billion in sales. So not much, but it might be a sign of things to come, I think.

10:37Stephen Mayne: Yes. But the the where Colette Press in the call, she basically said that demand is so strong that we can sell ex China, ex Southeast South East Asia and still have just massive demand. So that the the the the bear case, the hedge fund short sell case was they were desperately selling uh through the back door to China because they couldn't get get enough of their chips away. They they had to go to China to satisfy their orders, but she's come out and said, No no, we can we can live without China because demand is just so ridiculously high everywhere else in the world and you know, obviously particularly in the US. So that, you know, I mean the stock's still down three percent today, but but you know it hasn't crashed um because I think that the that the China chips play isn't fundamental to the cash boom. I think

11:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

11:24Stephen Mayne: know the the the if you've just made forty three billion in the quarter uh you've got a fair bit of momentum haven't you? So

11:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if

11:32John Addis: they can maintain that sales momentum, uh NVIDIA looks very cheap right now.

11:36Stephen Mayne: Yeah. And speaking of cheap John, car cars at the moment, uh car retailing in Australia. Is is it a good time who buy a car or not? I mean, uh I

11:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): reckon

11:45John Addis: it's a great time to buy a car. Absolutely great time to buy a car. Some of Australia's richest families have made their fortune selling cars, and it's it's normally a volume kind of business. You know, you make a small amount of money on some high value uh sales in the in the millions.

12:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh

12:01John Addis: so it's a kind of a pile of. em high, sell them cheap kind of model. But it's been very, very profitable, but it's getting more and more difficult over the past few years. And that's because of the flood of Chinese vehicles into the country and the switch to EVs.

12:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh

12:15John Addis: and the reason why that's happening is because you know the Chinese car market is unbelievably competitive. And the Chinese, you know, a notionally communist country runs a very competitive capitalist system. Whereas over here, where we're supposedly capitalist and we have a much less competitive system. But they are bringing the price wars that they're experiencing China over here because if you are a Chinese car maker, you can make seven or eight times the net profit selling into an overseas market that you can in China. And that's really, really good for Australian consumers. It's so good for Australian consumers. that the car retailers are really, really hurting right now. And I should disclose that one of my major holdings is Eagles, which is um got about an 18% market share in Australia. They make margins of about 2.8% as of last quarter, shows you how small it is. But the industry margins are and 0.7% and they're falling to the point that the um the Airfile AFR came out. I think a couple of weeks ago and announced that the uh the industry body is asking the government to step in

13:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

13:21John Addis: so that no new Chinese brands come into Australia because it's cutting into their margin. So if you want to buy an EV, now is a good time to go and go and get one. The prices are falling um quite considerably. And I bought one 18 months ago, I think it was 34,000 for a BYD dolphin.

13:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's

13:38John Addis: now 28,000. And um just for the record, Stephen, I don't know if you've got an EV, but I I I'm no big fan of EVs, but I thought so I'll try it. And I I think I've done 1750 kilometers

13:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um

13:52John Addis: over the past month, and the cost for my h using a home charger was thirty-two dollars for that. So if you're interested in saving a bit of money and you've got some money in the bank. and you can put in a home charger, now is a great time to go out and buy a car.

14:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well

14:07Stephen Mayne: you and Alan uh are both uh big fans of the EV. He's uh he he's had a similarly good experience and hopefully uh after his back surgery he'll be back driving it soon. But uh I think

14:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we're

14:18Stephen Mayne: expecting him back in in a couple of weeks. But uh I mean it is interesting that in the US, you know, Chinese EVs are basically banned. There's gonna going to be lots of there's lots of protection talk in um into Europe to protect the German car manufacturers in particular. But this is the thing about Australia. I think there's 80 different brands around the world that compete in Australia because we don't have a domestic manufacturing industry to protect. So it's just the retailers lobbying because they might have some old school relationships with the European or the US or the Japanese uh makers. Um, but it's still Australia is doesn't have that protection. protectionist thing and that's why the Chinese market share in Australia is right up there in terms of the um of the w uh of the West and rising. I mean they've gone past Japanese uh car sales haven't they? Which was quite a moment I

15:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think monthly I

15:03John Addis: think BYD now is the according to the monthly sales is the second biggest car um car brand in Australia, new car brand My in Australia and I think Toyota Toyota's is still at the top but in the next six months or so I think BYD will be the biggest brand. Yeah.

15:15Stephen Mayne: no, it's just amazing. So now before we do questions, I pr I I should give you an update on my my fun day in Sydney yesterday. So Yeah,

15:21John Addis: yeah, please

15:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do.

15:22John Addis: I know you had a big day.

15:24Stephen Mayne: Oh geez, I got up at four thour twenty. I was on the six o'clock to Sydney and I got the last flight home. I got home at midnight and I went to nine Jeff Wilson listed investment company AGMs in a row.

15:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

15:36Stephen Mayne: first one was at 8:30 and the last one was at four.

15:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I hope you've

15:40John Addis: got a good psychology, Stephen. I don't know whether I could survive that.

15:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh,

15:44Stephen Mayne: look at it. I ran for five boards and uh so I got I got happy with my votes. I got twenty percent at WAM Research, fourteen percent at WAM Income Income Maximizer, thirteen percent at WAM Microcap, nine point six at WAM Wham strategic value and and 6.9 six point nine at WAM Wham Active. Much better than the usual

16:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): half a

16:02Stephen Mayne: percent. I get running for all these Perth mining companies at the moment. So

16:05John Addis: I was going to say, like, that there's obviously some disquiet amongst the shareholder base at Jeff Wilson's.

16:10Stephen Mayne: Well, a

16:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): little bit, but it was it

16:12Stephen Mayne: was it was a very lively day. You know, the thing the thing that blew me away, Roger Corbett, the former CEO of Woolworths, you know, the Reserve Bank Director, Chairman of Fairfax, he's turned up and he's he's sitting two rows in front of me and he starts speaking and he goes, Look, Jeff, what Wilson, you're a great Australian,

16:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but

16:29Stephen Mayne: what I'm gonna say you won't like. And then he re he reeled off this speech saying that I put four point three million dollars into wham capital eight years ago, and it's down fifty-five percent. And over that time you've taken out three hundred and fifty million in fees. It's it's an absolute catastrophe for me, and we've got to do something about the Australian. structure because you're the executive chair, 100% fund manager, and where are all the independent directors and why hasn't something been done about all this?

16:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.

17:00John Addis: And

17:00Stephen Mayne: so this just set the theme for the day, which was, you know, Jeff Wilson's now on the AFR Rich at 891 million, which I kept mentioning, and he kept saying that they make it up, they make up those numbers, Stephen. And I said, mate, you're taking eighty-five, 85, ninety 90 million a year in fees. from retail investors across all these listed investment companies, and the performance, particularly lately, hasn't been too great, and you should cut your fees. So the whole day was me getting into the independent directors saying, When are you going to cut the fees? When's the contract come up? Why is Jeff the conflicted non-executive chair? Why isn't there a majority of independent directors? Related Well out of party transactions, all this sort of stuff. So it was a it was a nine-part nine part opera, it was a festival of gold. governance discussions with uh Jeff, who just wanted to talk about his campaign to save us all from capital gains tax and thirty percent tax on trust. So he was very upset.

17:52John Addis: And it also helps him avoid the major issue which is, you know, people are paying for our performance and if they're not getting it, they're getting angry. And congratulations on making me feel sorry for Roger Corbett. I never thought I'd that would happen.

18:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But uh

18:08Stephen Mayne: So,

18:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what was his reaction

18:09John Addis: like once she once she sort of raised all of this stuff? How do they deal with it?

18:12Stephen Mayne: Oh, well, at one point he said quote, I take offense at everything you've said today, unquote. So uh but and then yeah, say, look, he wasn't happy, but at other times he was chatty, it blew hot and cold. Like at one point I said, Can you run for the board every year, please? Because you know, so we can vote for you. And he offered me a deal. He said, I'll run for the board every year if you promise not to come to the AGMs.

18:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

18:32Stephen Mayne: I thought, well, that's a because I once actually negotiated a 40% cut in uh Roger Corbett's chairman fee at Fairfax on the floor of the Fairfax AGM. I

18:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): said,

18:40Stephen Mayne: I'll change my vote if you cut your pay by ten percent, Roger. This is like thirteen years ago. And he agreed on

18:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the floor

18:46Stephen Mayne: of the meeting. So I almost did a deal with um Jeff Wilson to not turn up in exchange for him uh putting himself up every year.

18:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um

18:54Stephen Mayne: but we'll see. Uh uh he's made some changes, like he's added another five or six independent directors. But the problem

19:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is he's now got thir

19:01Stephen Mayne: thirty-eight. Well, this is this is the question I I was grilling them all. How do you know, Jeff? Are you independent? You know, and of course, there was no recruitment agency, it was a DIY Wilson Network recruitment process. And one bloke said, I said, Oh, how'd you get on the board? Uh who rang you? He goes, Oh, Jeff rang me. And I said, And how do you know Jeff? He goes, Oh, we used to work together at Potter Partners in 1985 back in Melbourne. And I'm saying, Well, so are you independent, mate? Like uh, you know, are you up for cutting his fees? Uh so all of that sort of scrutiny was uh was it was I was getting accused of being you know pretending I was a barrister or something, and uh so it was uh it was a lot of fun. So I'm glad I

19:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I missed all these other great

19:44Stephen Mayne: AGMs spending the whole day with Jeff Wilson. So uh anyway,

19:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think it might be my idea of

19:48John Addis: fun. Not my idea of fun. It's an interesting question though, like the 'cause you know you can it you can agree with the principles of of corporate governance and having i genuinely independent um non executive directors.

20:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm

20:01John Addis: a big fan of that. But then there are companies where which are so identified with the founder that you're just backing them and who they have on the board is almost irrelevant to it.

20:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

20:13John Addis: you could see that a bit with say Chris Allison and Mineral Resources, which is a corporate governance disaster show. But i that company is largely him. And even though he said he's going to walk away, it it looks as though he's not um and you are really backing him. There's a there's a tension there between what you should do, what the law says you should do, and from an investment perspective, who you're really backing. Because if you have a a board where there is some genuine discussions and aggressive conversations and some proper sort of supervision, you could argue that a founder is actually getting curtailed by those kind of things because this business is theirs, they see it as theirs. and they've done a bloody good job in managing it. So how do you reconcile those two things in your own head from an investment perspective, Steve?

20:57Stephen Mayne: Well you've always got to back the founder. But in the case of Jeff, the issue is that there's conflicts of interest because there's related party transactions. Because he's a hundred percent external manager and he's taking eighty, eighty to ninety million dollars a year in fees. So you you know who's all who's agreeing to that? You know, and some of the fees are a bit higher than you

21:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,

21:14Stephen Mayne: some of the contracts are a bit controversial, they're a bit out of step, bit outdated in terms of contemporary and everywhere else in funds management, fund managers are under massive pressure to cut their fees. But in the listed investment companies, all the retail shareholders are asleep.

21:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You

21:27Stephen Mayne: know, we don't vote. So literally yesterday, only about on average about ten to twelve percent of total issue capital voted, and about six to seven percent of total shareholders. So it's

21:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): just an

21:39Stephen Mayne: inertia it's an inertia game. And so if you've got all this so I just kept saying the management contract rolls every five years. When are you next going to renegotiate one? When are you next going to say no, we're going to go to market and tender it and you know and so we have this whole debate all day about how are you how are you managing Jeff's conflicts? Uh do you get independent advice when you're negotiating to roll the contract? And at the end of the day, none of the directors so far have ever changed any material terms of any of his contracts at any of his 11 L I Cs. And uh so I was putting putting pressure on them that that's got to change because people like Roger Corbett uh have had a quote catastrophic experience, whilst Wam Capital's paid 350 million plus to Jeff Wilson to manage manager. it. He's got

22:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a lot of people. chance to get the game. Roger's out gut

22:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): full and and Jeff's gonna have to do something. So

22:25Stephen Mayne: I was saying Roger for chance. chair. Roger can be the independent chair. Step up, Roger. So um but I think things are gonna change. Like um, I don't think Jeff will be the conflicted executive chair of all nine this time next year. I think after Roger's intervention, I kept saying Roger's intervention is the game changer.

22:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

22:42Stephen Mayne: it'll be interesting to see where it goes. But uh from Jeff's point of view, he just wants to talk about Jim Charmers and capital gain sacks. So uh get behind his campaign.

22:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, nice

22:50John Addis: to

22:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do.

22:50John Addis: deflection.

22:51Stephen Mayne: Anyway, John, um, we better do some questions. But before we do questions, let's have a quick word from our sponsor.

22:59John Addis: When was the last time you checked what you're paying for life insurance? You could be missing out on savings. InvestSmart can help you compare quotes from leading insurers to find a better deal. Already covered, with InvestSmart Cashback, you could get money back each year from commission. commissions on your existing policy without changing your cover. Why pay more than you need to? Visit investsmart.com.au forward slash life hyphen insurance. Terms and conditions apply.

23:27Stephen Mayne: Now, as always, John, we give our general advice warning. This discussion between John and I is only general advice, and if you want real advice, you need to talk to a qualified financial planner. Now, let's start with Brad. Last week you were discussing the banks' interest rates on margin loans and credit cards being a ripoff. I think the big thing

23:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): major banks are

23:48Stephen Mayne: getting away with that needs to be cracked down on is savings accounts. The low base rate of point one percent and having to jump through a variety of hoops to get a proper rate is outrageous. I'd imagine there's a great number of Australians and especially pensioners that are fought, forgetting getting to top up or using. use their card X times each month, which ultimately means money into the bank's pockets rather than the consumer. Thoughts on this process and whether it should be cracked down upon? Well, it is interesting. I do think that the the banks, you know, the big banks with their forty billion dollars a year profit, uh, they're profiting from the lethargy of entangled consumers. And I think it works at both sides. It works on the interest rate on the loan side. And I'm guess there's a lot of people, me included, who are not working hard to get their cash in the bank, delivering a reasonable return. And the banks, frankly, they don't make it easy, do they?

24:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): No, they don't. And I think the government could do something to improve this. Uh, I've been long been a fan of treating bank account numbers like mobile numbers, so you can transport them anywhere, and all your direct debits and all the rest of the stuff that's associated with. your account goes with it. And that would just make switching costs higher. That's that the the banks rely on that inertia to make more money. And if the government allowed bank account number transport, transport ill you could transport your numbers, your bank account numbers easily, then you could switch more easily, and that would improve competition. So I think that's one thing the government could do to improve it. There's also the idea that maybe the RBA set says up a savings account that you could put your money into and you get the same rates that the banks do, or a little bit less. Instead of going through the banks, you can go through the RBA. What what do you think of that idea?

25:22Stephen Mayne: I liked RBA being involved in both. I think that the exit of government owned banks from all the state banks and then the Commonwealth Bank, that was the moment um when it became a a a a cash machine oligopoly. And uh the biggest losers are consumers.

25:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

25:38Stephen Mayne: uh it's yes it's a volume game, you know, because with compulsory super it's just this great big churn where we've got the world's most indebted households and we've got this massive pile of super and the banks are just in between clipping the ticket every which way. And um no name me another stock market in any Western economy, John, where big banks are forty percent of the market.

25:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): It's crazy.

25:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We have the most sense the

25:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): most profitable banking industry in the world and it's the most one of the most consolidated. And that consolidation has been promoted by the regulators. They've allowed every single banking merger to go through. We used to have a competitive banking industry, we don't now. So I think you could force some divestment so we have more banks rather than less, and you could have

26:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

26:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): RBA involvement as you suggested that would make this more competitive. And this is a general thing about the cost of living. I mean, I'm not saying that we should have a you know a socialist economy and all the prices uh prices are regulated. But we could have more competitive industries and there's things that the governments could do. I think we can got we've got a question where we can we can talk about a bit more detail. But banking is a great example of how regulation has actually improved the profitability of the banks. Although

26:43Stephen Mayne: there's also an issue that the the lack of a consumer movement in Australia. I mean, there's still over a thousand uh paid unionists in Australia. ensuring that workers are looked after. There's all sorts of business lobby groups. Who's out there standing up for the consumer? Where's the you know oh you got choice and you got a few things, but but there there there should be a bank consumers movement, a bank consumers organization that's out there lobbying the banks and pushing for you know lower fees. And so I think it's a constituency that's not well served, you know, even politically. I mean, there's a political party for farmers, there's a political party for business, there's a political party for labour. There's no political party for consumers. And I think

27:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

27:22Stephen Mayne: the

27:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): bank

27:23Stephen Mayne: consumers are the bank consumers are the biggest losers in Australia just by dint of the fact that their industry is making uh forty billion a year pre tax just at the big four level. But them it's meant to be a utility. They're meant to be servicing the economy so everyone else can have business, not becoming forty percent of the stock market themselves. Yeah.

27:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um, which is what they've been able to

27:42Stephen Mayne: do with with scale and all that sort of stuff. But look, we're meant to be talking about investment, and best investment you could ever do is long term shareholder in the Commonwealth Bank. You know, and so um, you know, it's still I think it's a it's a machine. Commonwealth bank is the best of them and the biggest of them. And um, I think they've just they've been able to get away with it to a degree degree 'cause

28:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): because the

28:02Stephen Mayne: the regular regulators have let them get to scale. There isn't a consumer movement and um and I agree with Brad that uh a lot of people are getting ripped off on deposits.

28:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Absolutely and that that revolving door between politicians and bank like Anna Bly is the Australian Banking Association CEO after being Premier of Queensland that tells you

28:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): about the relationship. She's left now

28:23Stephen Mayne: but that yeah that's right. So um absolutely right. Is you've got to play both sides. It's like the gambling industry. You can I can give you a dozen names of politicians who've been on the payroll of the the gambling industry, and and the bankers are the same. I mean, you know, you're you're right. Normally it'd be, you know, Chiffley's Light on the Hill back, you know, after the Second World War, the the Labour Party was gonna

28:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be a good thing.

28:44Stephen Mayne: They were gonna they were gonna nationalise the banks, and then fast forward you've got, you know, a Labour left premier from Queensland being the and becoming a millionaire being the long-term CEO of the Bankers Association. So

28:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

28:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): only light that's on now is the one in the chairman's lounge where all the politicians are drinking champagne.

29:00Stephen Mayne: That's

29:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): right.

29:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

29:02Stephen Mayne: I'll let you do the next question, uh

29:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): John.

29:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): All right, this is from Kyle or Kylie. Uh I've gone to uni, bought a house at the peak of the market, lightly underwater, got a well-paying well paying job in finance, paid off my hex, all without any assistance from the bank. of mum and dad. I've done the right things, but feel the lad has been pulled up on my generation to build wealth. Albeit I do realize I'm still in a fortunate position. Now the main pathways are cut off to build wealth like negative gearing

29:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): or funky work with your super. How does a P A Y G employee start to build wealth? Is it gearing up via debt recycling into shares? Particularly interesting in strategies outside super as I'm looking

29:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for.

29:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): to partially retire before I'd be able to access it.

29:41Stephen Mayne: Geez, Kyle, having having having eliminated super, because I mean the two best ways are basically uh capital growth in your house, tax free gain, uh inheritance, obviously, tax free, and uh and super, you know, fifteen percent. But if you're selling us to stay outside there, well, a few few doors have been shut on that one, hasn't it? Because you know property, the investment property. uh side of things really has slowed down. Certainly, the bank bank loan applications for investment in property is uh crashing at the moment.

30:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think that's a good thing though. I mean, I don't think that housing

30:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): should

30:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): be an investment

30:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): class,

30:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I

30:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): think it should be about living,

30:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and

30:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): there's all sorts of unseen hidden costs to having

30:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): um housing as an investment class. So I think actually the government's just changes, which are going to cause some pain, are causing some pain, are generally a good thing. And I think that, say, for example, in in Kyle's position or Kylie's position,

30:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

30:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): know, if you if you have an investment property, that is money that is not going elsewhere that could be put to better use. You could start your own business with that money. You can invest it in some small businesses on the stock market, you can invest it long term in some companies that you like. liked. I'm a big fan of investing over the long term. I know people think it's more risky, but I don't think it is. It doesn't need to be as risky. Um it doesn't need to be more risky than investing in property. So I would say to to Kylie or Kyle that um

31:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

31:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): wouldn't gear up to invest in shares, but I think that generally investing in shares over the long term is a good thing to do. And there are two caveats to that. Make sure your fees are low. So try and avoid the likes of Jeff Wilson. And secondly, don't sell when you most feel like it. Uh, that's the big mistake that people tend to make. It's quite an emotional thing. So you can hang on to housing when it's tumbling because it's just not easy to sell a house and it's quite expensive, and transaction costs are high. It's very easy to sell shares. Just make sure you hang on to them when you most feel like selling when the market crashes and you'll do fine. So that's

31:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.

31:45Stephen Mayne: It's funny actually. Um Roger Corbett yesterday said, you know, what the hell are you doing in small caps? It's been a disaster. And uh it I mean small caps at the moment they are really struggling with the move to indexation, rising interest rates, index investing and stuff. So but I almost felt listening to it all that that there is some great value to be had right now in beaten up small caps. Um because uh it's been an awful area. But as Roger said, you know, he's done so much better, you know, diversified international shares, ETFs. So I I just think I just think Kyle, just avoiding too much debt and risk and concentration, diversification, it's the old things. It's a shame some of the you know the tax has become more punitive. in across the board outside of super.

32:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

32:29Stephen Mayne: I haven't got a new solution um you know outside of super from an after tax point of view. But um I just think um you know don't I'm not so sure about gearing up heavily into shares. Uh generally

32:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a bad

32:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): idea.

32:43Stephen Mayne: Generally a bad idea, exactly. So uh all right, Ben says, love the podcast regarding Quantas' Qantas' decision to offshore approximately 850 jobs to India working with Accenture, why should Qantas benefit from a government protected domestic aviation market while simultaneously accessing cheaper offshore labour to improve its bottom line?

33:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

33:05Stephen Mayne: look, this is a really interesting point, John. The government does say there's a two a two airline policy effectively. Well, the international airlines, so say Singapore. Singapore can't fly, come in and fly Melbourne Sydney, which are one of the most lucrative routes in the world. Doesn't the government have leverage to say, Qantas, you're worth 15 billion. We're protecting you, we're keeping all the foreign airlines out. Part of the bargain here is you can't be a ruthless AI-driven offshore merchant.

33:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

33:33Stephen Mayne: that that's Baden's Ben's point. And I guess it's a bit like the government and banks. They don't, they're not using the regulatory power they have. I mean, it's an incremental thing that Qantas is doing. It's, you

33:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,

33:45Stephen Mayne: it's 850 jobs over three or four years. So I think it's not dramatic enough for the government to be able to come in and go bang, bang, bang, how dare

33:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you? Um,

33:55Stephen Mayne: and there was a lot of reshoring that went on, even by the banks. You know, like I remember ANZ pulled back their their Indian call center. centres and stuff like that. Under pressure, under pressure, you know, the peak of globalisation, all that offshoring that went on. Some of them did come back to Australia because of the regulatory risk of you know banks looking too brutal. So with the likes of Telstra, Corners, banks, anything licensed, um, yes, you've got that sort of license to operate question was does a government come in and go, that's unfair, we're gonna run the regulatory card against you. They have that power with Qantas, they could absolutely decimate the Qantas share price by saying, Singapore, have a go at Melbourne Sydney. I mean quantas shares would from you know fall by thirty percent.

34:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, they there's no

34:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): chance of them doing that.

34:42Stephen Mayne: There's no chance that that's right, exactly right. So I think uh Qantas Quantas is just feeling a bit more confident to um go back to their aggressive, ruthless ways. um, which has always been the conflict culture at Qantas for a long time.

34:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I would say to Ben, if you want to understand the aviation industry, go and read um Joe Aston's The Chairman's Lounge, which explains all of this in great detail in a fascinating kind of way. Um I don't think the government should be getting involved in telling what companies can and can't do with offshoring or redundancies and stuff like that. I'm just against that as a general rule. But I do think there should be more competition in airlines. We're all getting really ripped off by um the duopoly that operates now. And the government's doing nothing about it. And you could say that Singapore would come into the the Golden Triangle as it's as it's called. The problem with that is that you would need to take slots off Qantas Quantas and Virgin and Qantas and Virgin own the company that allocates slots at Sydney Airport. which is where the to chokehold is. So the government could come along and say, You we're taking those slots slots off you and reserving that for a third a third entrant. I think that would be really tough for them to do. Um because it's not just about whether somebody flies the route, it's a frequency that they fly in order to give a similar kind of service. So you need somebody who's going to commit to you know flights every half hour during working hours. And that requires a massive capital investment. I think a better way of addressing this problem is

36:08forcing Qantas to divest Jet Star, and then we'd have a genuine third airline already with slots and we'd have three rather than two competitors that are ripping us off.

36:17Stephen Mayne: I agree, but it's uh too late. It's difficult to unscramble that egg. They've already um

36:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

36:24Stephen Mayne: know it's just an incremental game. I mean but when they started Jet Star, it was a small startup, it was ending into a few routes, and then it it's now making half a billion a year, and it's just it's enormous. It was the one of the cleverest industrial relations Trojan horses in Australian history, because they were gonna go broke with their high cost base and their fifty-four different enterprise agreements with all the different unions, and they just come out and said and said, brutal, different industrial relationship. down in Melbourne, far away from head office, Alan Joyce, you know, qu you know, quibbling over the cost of a teabag, you know, that was the whole culture of don't spend a cent. And now it's just a cash machine, it's it's got a lower cost base, I think, than even Virgin or quite close. But uh um and that's that's the power. But I you know, if a government came in and said demerge it, I think they eh

37:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it

37:13Stephen Mayne: won't happen, but I do agree that's that that would be the solution. But I just don't think we don't have

37:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a divestiture power,

37:18Stephen Mayne: do we?

37:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We

37:19Stephen Mayne: don't have a domestic power. I've long argued that we should have a

37:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): lot of people. Chairman's lounge

37:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): lounge. And they really love that place. and they're not going to do anything to to uh to stop them

37:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): kind

37:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): of things.

37:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I agree.

37:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think we're stuck with the duopoly that's ripping yourself blind.

37:46Stephen Mayne: Yep.

37:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I agree.

37:49Stephen Mayne: Goodness me. Australia,

37:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the land of

37:51Stephen Mayne: duopolies and oligopolies. You go, next question.

37:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): All right, Leanne, my idea for addressing cost of living, housing and An intergenerational wealth qual quality. Would We'd love to hear your opinion. Extend the same tax benefit. benefits of salary sacrifice of your super, making it available for additional mortgage payments, not minimum repayment, but extra payments. Banks can set up a sub account that can't be accessed for redraw until the same age as your super. And if you sell the balance, it must be transferred to a new home or your super. This helps young borrowers reduce reduced debt and is essentially also setting them up for retirement, but in a more practical way. Currently, salary salary sacrifice arrangements only available to those with enough income or wealth to take advantage of it, which seems to favour the well off more than the lower and middle incomes. I know it would help me. What do you think of that idea from Leanne?

38:37Stephen Mayne: Look, it's it's a nice targeted idea to deal with the fact that our working young Australians are over overtaxed taxed and can't afford to get into the housing market. And you

38:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know

38:50Stephen Mayne: uh overload overloaded with hex burdens and and all this sort of stuff. I think the effect of it though is any all of these schemes often end up just driving up house prices because all of a sudden the the purchasing power of people buying houses would be higher because there's a tax break on mortgage repayments uh under this scheme, Lyon Lianne's scheme. And so it would put upward pressure on houses. But I actually quite like it. I think it from a targeted point of view, I do think overtaxed young Australians without the bank of Mum and Dad into this housing market is one of the most unfair things in Australia. And Lianne's proposal would specifically target that cohort. So I I like it from that point of view, but uh the practicalities would be like all these schemes would be would be challenged. challenging.

39:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um

39:40Stephen Mayne: what do you think? I mean, do you like

39:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it? I

39:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): don't know. I mean th there's obviously a problem there. I was at the cinema last night with my eldest son. He's he's twenty five. I'm I'm si I over sixty. I got a ticket for I think fourteen dollars and his is twenty eight and I said, This is mad like I'm the one with all the money. You're the one you're the generation that hasn't got any and I'm paying you're paying twice what I've just bought. Like it seems to symbolize exactly how we've set this system up, and housing is completely central to it. Um I just don't know whether fiddling around with tax laws is the way to address this problem. Uh, it's where you first go, but I just think we need Alan's much better off talking about this stuff. This is his bag, but we need more houses and we need less expensive houses, and supply is the major problem with it. I'd also say that because of the way the tax system has worked, where it does treat housing as an investment class, and actually there's tax benefits for um for you, or there were, to invest in it, it's kind of it kind of rotted our brains to think about how we build wealth through housing. I mean it's just not in over the course of human history, that has not been the way that we've built wealth. I think the longest property series in the world is that street in Amsterdam along one of the most prestigious canals, and there's four or five hundred years of trading history, and house prices have gone up over that

41:03four or five hundred years at GDP, at GDP growth. And that's exactly how it should be. B. You know, we we need a housing sector that grows at GDP, and we don't. It's grown growing much faster. than GDP because we haven't built enough houses to accommodate our increasing population and the fact that households are now smaller than what they were. I think that's the way to address the problem. I think we should have a lot more houses.

41:27Stephen Mayne: I completely agree. And government funded houses too. I mean the old

41:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

41:32Stephen Mayne: know, state state housing, you know, councils used to own housing. So uh I just think I think that that that that is a key to getting supply moving. Now we've only got time for a couple more, John. I'm gonna jump ahead over the page to Stephen, who says, just wanted

41:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to know your

41:45Stephen Mayne: thoughts on whether insanely high executive pay structures in the hundreds of millions with stock options are contributing to inflation and cost of living crisis. We always hear this argument of a wage spiral if we lift workers' pay, but we rarely hear any complaints about CEO remuneration being in. increased at AGMs. Would the cost of house prices and items have been lower with better redistribution of pay to workers and lower CEO salaries starting decades ago? Well, look, I will just say in terms of you you say they're always being increased without complaint at AGMs. Well, yesterday, Stephen, at the SEAK AGM, GM. they had a remuneration strike, which was, I think, you know, 30-something 30 something percent against. And the CEO, Ian Narev, famous for being the Commonwealth Bank CEO, who probably uh helped cause the Royal Commission into the banks, had his incentive grant proposal voted down with 53% against. And then you go all the way across the country to Perth yesterday, and the very colourful company, Mineral Resources, had their proposal for the board to be able to approve. all these termination payouts to executives withdrawn because it was going down. So

42:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a

42:57Stephen Mayne: lot of these industry funds and super they actually have been quite good, I would argue, Stephen, at stopping excessive executive pay. And then I also think there's a problem with the taxing of LTI TI grants and bonuses is quite punitive in Australia by world standards. And I reckon I've I've heard a hundred times plus at AGMs. I've I've this this has been the debate. Why is the CEO selling his shares? Because the tax system is so brutal, I had to sell the shares to pay the tax. Because basically, the moment your free shares vest, you cop your 48.5%, 49% tax bill, even

43:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): though you No,

43:33Stephen Mayne: don't uh sometimes you don't even o actually own the stock. Like it's just sort of an entitlement that's vested to you, but you're still locked up. And so they they actually end up selling the shares. So I'm gonna I'm gonna reject your analogy, Stephen. I'm gonna say that we'd we've got nothing like the problem in the US where pay is just absolutely out of control. And overall, I think our system is working quite well with the remuneration report vote every year. They don't even have that in New Zealand. And so I you know, yes, you can ask. argue the cases, but it'll often get I mean, there's a scandal, there's always going to be scandals. The Murdoch family have taken $2 billion plus from public companies they control this century using a gerrymanded voting structure. Murdoch men have taken two billion. So that is a massive scandal. And it's been written about plenty of times, but that's that's the example of the US system being out of control. And In the US salaries are just a disgrace. In Australia, it's much more

44:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

44:31Stephen Mayne: you know, it's it's acceptable.

44:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I would call it reasonable, but it's not successful.

44:37Stephen Mayne: And you've got the you think tax is tough for the uh for battlers, you know. It it kicks in at what 190,000 or something in the top tax rate. So every dollar, I mean I know they're doing stuff through trusts and super and stuff, but but they're paying a lot. of tax, a lot of these CEOs, a lot of

44:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): tax. I think I I I think I'd agree with that, uh Stephen, but I think Stephen's got a point um in that but I don't think he sorry, I don't think he's got a point in that that it's contributing to inflation. It's not a big enough cohort to really move the numbers. I think of CEO pay like Premier League footballers. Like they're paid outrageously, and some of them are really good, but once you get into that club, your pay goes up no matter how good or bad you are. There's a kind of it's almost like a union effect. Once you join that club, you get a big salary. But I don't think there's enough of them to have an effect on uh the inflation numbers. I think where their impact on inflation is in their decisions. So a lot of them are running government mandated monopolies or duo. duopolies as we as we've discussed. And I think after COVID they learned that they can push through price rises faster than inflation and not get any pushback from the public really, or they get pushback but they can still get away with it, and not any pushback from government. I think they learnt during that In period that they've got a lot more pricing power than what they thought and they're exercising it.

46:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think

46:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): they've

46:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): got

46:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): to that's

46:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do that. Yeah,

46:01Stephen Mayne: I I I agree that. being brutal. And I also think one last one last sympathy for the CEO's union. Um, their salaries are reported or they're reported pre tax. I do think that's a

46:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): bit right.

46:13Stephen Mayne: So the companies they run report net profits. So they always say net profit two

46:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): billion,

46:20Stephen Mayne: and then CEO got five million. No, no, CEO got about two point seven net after tax, and the government actually. had a nice little earner with two point three coming from that five million dollar package. But but look, no violin is small enough to uh to give it give sympathy for overpaid COs. But uh but uh you know thank God we're not a Trumper stand in America with crazy pay is all I would say.

46:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now John, I'll let you

46:43Stephen Mayne: pick I'll let you pick the last question. What do you want to go with?

46:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Okay, I'm I'm um picking this one from Lucia.

46:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

46:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): find it interesting that when talking about AI impact, many people mention job losses, but that's rarely accompanied by talking about consumption impact and therefore company losses. Can you talk about the impact of these job losses on companies and the future economy if all these unemployed people cannot afford to buy anything? What's your view on that, Stephen?

47:07Stephen Mayne: Uh that's the catast Cast catastrophizing view, Lu Lucia. Um I think the political economy will intervene. before that happens. But look, we are seeing more I mean with AI, we're seeing more and more companies reporting these uh big job cuts, you know, from you know polls, Telra. And then of course we've also got this uh the what's this uh

47:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

47:31Stephen Mayne: festival of outages uh at the moment. We go over from Microsoft to um uh Work Workday, Day, I think it was, and Chase banking and then all the US airlines, and Apple had an outage. The league story on the Wall Street Journal this morning is are all these outrageous outages connected? And uh the answer is partly yes, is that AI in the hands of hackers is causing a patch, a patch festival all over the world where governments and every big corporates are trying to patch their systems and systems are going down. So that's one of the downsides of AI. Look, I agree there's gonna be a lot of jobs lost,

48:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but

48:07Stephen Mayne: I don't think it's gonna then go to the other side that we're gonna have a recession because there's twenty percent unemployment and there's no consumers left to buy products off the AI driven companies that survive. But uh that probably sounds a bit unsympathetic for people being uh being uh let go of AI. We haven't quite seen the scale of I mean this the the unemployment rate all over the Western world, you know, it's it is not an apocalypse yet.

48:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's

48:32Stephen Mayne: actually the opposite. It's actually going so it's holding up surprisingly well. US, Australia, less so Europe. But uh where do you sit are you a you a

48:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I I can see the

48:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): like the catastrophizing there and I understand it. Uh uh I I think in if that if that does play out, then there is a kind of tragedy the commons argument. Companies are going to make decisions in their own specific interest, they're not going to make dis decisions in their broader interest. Um, because you need people to buy their products, and if everybody's unemployed, there's going to be nobody to buy their products. It does make me wonder whether Silicon Valley, when they were blabbing on about um universal basic income four or five years ago, they couldn't stop talking about it, whether they were thinking. of this scenario, whether that was in their minds back then, you know that everybody has twenty or thirty grand a year that they can spend. So the thing keeps going if fifty percent of people lose their jobs. I'm generally an optimist. Um I think it's a better way to live than being pessimistic. I understand that this is a huge concern to people, but so far it doesn't seem to be playing out, as you said. I would remain optimistic. I think Australia has been it's we should be optimistic in this country. We've got a lot of things going for us and catastrophizing and worrying about what might happen is something that we're wired to do, but it's generally the worst thing does not happen, and we're best off thinking about the positive things in life and acting in according to that mindset and not worrying too much about the worst possible outcomes,

50:00outcomes 'cause because generally they don't happen. Not saying it won't, but generally they don't.

50:04Stephen Mayne: I think that is a good way to finish. And I will also add, John, that Anthropic has just priced at eighty three US dollars a share. This is the the chief

50:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): villain that's

50:15Stephen Mayne: gonna cause this jobs apocalypse. That's a one point five trillion dollar valuation.

50:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

50:20Stephen Mayne: they said the

50:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): range was

50:21Stephen Mayne: seventy 70 to seventy 78, eight, and they've come in at eighty 83. three. So apparently they had a hundred billion US in retail bids and four hundred billion in sto bids. So they've sold eight hundred and twenty-five million shares at eighty-three dollars each, and they're worth uh one point five US trillion dollars, and they are instantly in the top twelve companies in the world. And they only started

50:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): seven years ago.

50:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): It's been around for six years. Seven

50:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): years ago. Now what

50:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): does that say about uh the abil the like the sustainability of this market? You can grow a company to that valuation in six or seven years.

51:01Stephen Mayne: It tells me that AI is a fast moving place, that there's a few geniuses who've built this business that's doing eighty billion in annualized revenue and it's changing the face of business. I I I I'm more on the positive side with with the anthropic of what an extraordinary founder value creation story. And investors have bought this bought this story like nothing before. We it's just we've never seen anything like it. So they're they're they're surfing

51:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on the

51:24Stephen Mayne: cake tails of big tech in but in the past. People have seen the trillion dollar companies be created, so they accept the thesis that you can start something and then create a huge amount of value relatively quickly and uh

51:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they've

51:34Stephen Mayne: just done it.

51:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): You you mentioned Google and um

51:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): who else did you mention?

51:42Stephen Mayne: Facebook and Amazon.

51:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They were some of the greatest

51:45Stephen Mayne: IPOs to ever ever have backed.

51:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): You could have waited three or four years, maybe f maybe longer, and you have all of that information in the public domain that you could look at and interrogate, much more than you get at an IPO, and still made ninety 95% five percent of the profits you would have made if you bought it at the IPO with a lot less risk. That would be my argument for waiting.

52:06Stephen Mayne: Yeah. Well, I well, I I agree. I mean, you're not exactly getting in at the ground floor with uh anthropic, are you? You're you're

52:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're entering

52:13Stephen Mayne: it at level 92 when it's already valued at one point. And all the smart money, this is the biggest payday. I mean, they will need to all be able to get out, but this is one of the fastest, biggest paydays. I mean, Commalt Commonwealth Bank's got it. a you know, they're they're making hundreds of millions, uh the future funders. Oh,

52:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): actually.

52:30Stephen Mayne: The story now is going to be who's who's in Anthropic, who was smart, who got in, and who's gonna have much better investment returns than people uh, you know, playing around in in struggling Australian small caps or the the few listed companies that are left here, uh with the blizzard of takeovers that are coming along with uh another couple yesterday with Main Farmer and and New Newx.

52:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): York.

52:51Stephen Mayne: I mean we won't get to that, but uh bye jingo, what's left in Australia is uh is being taken over and um and we're all back to talking about AI again with Anthropic's

53:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): incredible RPO.

53:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): So

53:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): let

53:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): to end it here, I'm gonna make a recommendation. If you do want to hear more about AI and a very level headed assessment of anthropic, listen to Joe Walker's podcast with John Hempton, Hampton, Bronte Capital's John Hampton. Hempton. Uh

53:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's really

53:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): fascinating the way he thinks about it. Uh extremely smart person. Uh, and he he knows all of the things that are wrong with it, but he's still quite enthusiastic about it. So go and go and listen to that. Joe Walker's been

53:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): here. Very good.

53:26Stephen Mayne: That's a great way to finish. All right, John. Well, I've got another four I've got tickets to fourteen online AGMs today, and I'm gonna lose another

53:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): three board

53:32Stephen Mayne: kills today.

53:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So I better run. So

53:34Stephen Mayne: thanks Thanks for listening to today's episode of the Money Cafe. I'll be back next week. with James Thompson. So send in a question and we'll answer it together by emailing the MoneyCafe at Intelligent Investor.com.au. Until then, I'm Stephen Main, contributor at Intelligent Investor, founder of Crikey and Shareholder Activist.

53:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

53:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I'm John Addis, founder of Intelligent Investor.

53:52Stephen Mayne: We'll talk to you soon.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights