Speakers analyze Nvidia governance risks, AI labor displacement, and Australian corporate governance trends.
Summary
James Thompson and Stephen May discuss the governance risks facing Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang amid the Anthropic IPO, noting his low voting power and the structural disadvantages for retail investors compared to Google. They examine Qantas's 'AI two-step' outsourcing strategy and contrast it with banks' in-house AI development. The hosts also cover Australian corporate governance, highlighting concerns over ANZ's wealth management return and Charter Hall's remuneration protests. Further segments address AI disruption, productivity measurement, and the RBA's independence from fiscal policy.
Key takeaways
- 1 that's right. I mean, I still can't believe this thing only started in twenty twenty one. I mean, at least SpaceX was twenty five years old. At least it had been going since, you know, the the turn of the century. How how can something go from nothing with seven founders who've defected from OpenAI to a valuation of one $1.4 point four trillion dollars? And it's absolutely burning cash, but it's also it's also minting cash. I mean, the at the annualized revenue after the October data is $81 billion on an annualized basis. So it's just growing like topsy. And so people are just making an assessment as to whether the revenue growth is going to be able to justify the eight hundred and ninety five billion dollars of commitments they've made to to buy computing power over the next decade.
Stephen May · 5:40
- 2 Legal protections, exclusive data, and IP are barriers that prevent AI from simply 'knocking everything off,' suggesting a durable competitive advantage for data-rich firms.
Stephen May · 28:15
Episode sections
- 0:11 – 9:07
Anthropic IPO and Nvidia CEO Scandal
Speakers discuss the unprecedented spy scandal involving Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang and the concurrent float of Anthropic, noting Nvidia's role as a cornerstone investor. They analyze the political and corporate governance pressures facing Huang, predicting his potential removal as executive chair.
- 9:07 – 11:55
AGM Season and AFR Valuation
Stephen May highlights the Australian Financial Review's (AFR) strong financial performance and undervaluation within Nine Entertainment, citing specific EBITDA margins. James Thompson acknowledges the franchise's strength and the success of its events business.
- 11:55 – 16:05
Qantas Job Cuts and AI Automation
The hosts discuss Qantas's decision to outsource 850 jobs to Accenture as a precursor to AI automation, describing it as an 'AI two-step.' They contrast this with the major banks' approach of developing in-house AI capabilities through offshore support hubs.
- 16:05 – 22:01
ANZ Wealth Management and Charter Hall REM Vote
James Thompson notes ANZ's new CEO exploring a return to wealth management, while Stephen May expresses concern over conflicts of interest. They also preview the upcoming Charter Hall AGM, highlighting a significant remuneration protest vote against executive bonuses.
- 22:01 – 28:15
Listener Questions on Productivity, Housing, and AI
The hosts answer listener questions, defending the concept of productivity despite measurement challenges. They confirm tax rules allowing negative gearing for new builds and debate whether AI will commoditize digital industries, potentially replicating complex software like Grand Theft Auto within two years.
- 28:15 – 29:06
AI Disruption and Intellectual Property
Stephen Mayne argues that companies with strong data, IP, and legal protections will survive AI disruption, though he acknowledges the scale of disruption will be significant.
- 29:06 – 32:14
Intergenerational Wealth Transfer and Productivity
A listener question proposes tax incentives for intergenerational wealth transfer to boost business investment. Mayne suggests inheritance tax or loosening age pension gifting rules as alternatives, while Thompson notes the difficulty of defining 'productive' assets to prevent gaming.
- 32:14 – 33:21
CPI Measurement and Construction Costs
Mayne clarifies that while home prices are excluded from CPI as investments, the component costs of building (cement, bricks) are included. Thompson adds that rent is included, linking CPI to housing costs.
- 33:21 – 36:41
Mortgage Repayments and Bank Arrears
Thompson explains that fixed repayment amounts remain unchanged unless the borrower adjusts them. Mayne notes CBA's 90-day arrears have risen to 0.8%, the highest in a decade, but banks are avoiding aggressive foreclosures.
- 36:41 – 40:18
RBA Independence and Fiscal Policy
Thompson discusses RBA Governor Michele Bullock's independence from government spending. Mayne suggests she could pressure the government by linking rate cuts to budget surpluses, but Thompson warns against political interference in rate setting.
- 40:18 – 42:40
Corporate Tax, Franking Credits, and Superannuation
A listener argues corporate tax is effectively returned via franking credits to super funds. Mayne disputes this, stating corporate tax is a significant revenue source (second only to income tax) and criticizes cash top-ups for franking credits.
- 42:40 – 43:33
Super Fund Annual Information Meetings
Mayne corrects a previous error, stating super fund annual information meetings are mandatory since 2020. He criticizes them for lacking voting power on directors or remuneration compared to AGMs.
- 43:33 – 45:31
Shareholder Activism at AGMs
Mayne advocates for more professional shareholder activism at AGMs, citing David Kingston as a positive example of engaging in high-quality debate, contrasting with the current 'amateur hour'.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| NVIDIANVDA | equity | neutral | I guess they're sort of combined because Nvidia is one of the cornerstone backers of the Anthropic float. |
| AlphabetGOOGL | equity | neutral | But but if Google's doing the same thing, they're not just getting a share, they're also getting that money back |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Jensen Huang owns about 3.5% of Nvidia's voting stock, making him vulnerable to shareholders unlike Mark Zuckerberg or Elon Musk.
James Thompson ·1:52
How to verify: Check Nvidia's latest proxy statement (DEF 14A) on SEC EDGAR for insider ownership percentages. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceNvidia's market cap fell from $5.8 trillion to $4.2 trillion in five weeks, a $1.6 trillion loss.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·7:45
How to verify: Calculate Nvidia's market capitalization from daily closing prices on a financial data provider (e.g., Bloomberg, Yahoo Finance) for the relevant five-week period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceAnthropic's valuation reached $1.4 trillion.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·5:40
How to verify: Check Anthropic's latest private market valuation reports or IPO prospectus filings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceAnthropic has $895 billion in computing power commitments over the next decade, with $250 billion from Google.
Stephen May ·6:20
How to verify: Review Anthropic's IPO prospectus for details on long-term purchase commitments and related party transactions with Google. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The AFR's publishing division EBITDA was $150 million, with the AFR contributing $75 million at a 50% margin.
Stephen May ·9:27
How to verify: Check Nine Entertainment's annual financial report for segment reporting on Publishing and EBITDA breakdowns. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Qantas is cutting 850 jobs through an outsourcing deal with Accenture.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·12:07
How to verify: Review Qantas's ASX announcements or press releases regarding the Accenture partnership and workforce restructuring. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
ANZ CEO Nuno Matos is exploring buying back into wealth management.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·16:31
How to verify: Check ANZ's investor presentations or recent news articles quoting CEO Nuno Matos on strategic priorities. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Charter Hall faces a significant remuneration protest vote over a $90 million bonus scheme.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·19:24
How to verify: Review Charter Hall's proxy statement (DEF 14A or equivalent) for remuneration reports and proxy advisor recommendations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Howard Marks released a memo questioning the long-term durability of AI companies like OpenAI and Anthropic.
James Thompson ·6:47
How to verify: Search for Howard Marks' latest memo on Oaktree Capital's website or financial news archives. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Stephen Mayne claims companies with great data, IP, and legal protections will prevail against AI disruption because content cannot be easily stolen.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·28:15
How to verify: Check academic or industry reports on AI IP risks and data moats; verify legal precedents on AI training data copyright. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Stephen Mayne states that in Australia, if you gift money away, you must wait more than five years before accessing the age pension.
Stephen May ·29:57
How to verify: Check Services Australia guidelines on age pension gifting rules and deprivation provisions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Stephen Mayne claims CBA's 90-day arrears on its home loan book are up to 0.8%, the highest in close to a decade.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·34:27
How to verify: Check Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA) quarterly financial reports or investor presentations for '90-day arrears' or 'credit impairment' metrics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceJames Thompson quotes analyst Matthew Wilson from Jarden saying 'credit is a bit like a teabag. You only see how good it is when it goes into hot water.'
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·36:17
How to verify: Search for Jarden research notes or articles featuring Matthew Wilson discussing credit cycles and the 'teabag' analogy. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Stephen Mayne states that since 2020, super funds have been forced by law to hold an annual information meeting and answer every question.
Stephen May ·42:40
How to verify: Check ASIC Regulatory Guide 262 or the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 2026 regarding mandatory annual information meetings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Stephen Mayne claims corporate tax is the second biggest revenue source after income tax, bringing in 154 billion, while GST brings in 90-100 billion.
Stephen May ·41:18
How to verify: Check Australian Treasury 'Budget Outcomes' or 'Taxation Expenditure Statements' for corporate tax and GST revenue figures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceStephen Mayne states that Frank Wilson (likely James Thompson's co-host or a referenced figure, text says 'Jeff Wilson' but context implies Thompson or a generic reference, actually text says 'Jeff Wilson' which is likely an ASR error for 'James Thompson' or 'Joe Hockey'? No, text says 'Jeff Wilson'. Wait, text says 'Jeff Wilson and the Superfunds'. This is likely an ASR error for 'Joe Hockey' or 'James Thompson'. Given the context of 'screaming blue murder', it's likely a political figure. However, I must stick to the text. The text says 'Jeff Wilson'. I will note the claim as stated.)
Stephen May ·40:38
How to verify: Search for quotes from 'Jeff Wilson' regarding superannuation tax and franking credits. Note: This is likely an ASR error for a different person, but the claim is about the reaction of super funds to tax changes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceStephen Mayne claims he is a member of Legal Super.
Stephen May ·43:08
How to verify: Check Legal Super member communications or website for member testimonials or disclosures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Stephen Mayne claims Keating era politicians set interest rates.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·39:38
How to verify: Check historical records of Reserve Bank of Australia interest rate decisions during Paul Keating's Prime Ministership (2026-2026) and statements by Keating on monetary policy. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify Jensen Huang's voting power and board composition in Nvidia's latest proxy statement (DEF 14A).
- Check Anthropic's IPO prospectus for revenue commitments or commercial agreements with major cloud providers.
- Review Qantas's latest annual report for details on the Accenture outsourcing contract and AI automation timeline.
- Analyze Charter Hall's AGM voting results regarding executive remuneration and shareholder protest votes.
- Examine Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) data on construction cost components included in CPI calculations.
- Review Commonwealth Bank of Australia's (CBA) latest financial results for 90-day mortgage arrears rates.
- Read Howard Marks' memos on AI sector durability and competitive moats.
- Check ANZ's investor presentations regarding the strategic rationale for returning to wealth management.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hello,
- 0:12
- Stephen May: I'm Stephen May, contributor at Intelligent Investor, founder of Crikey and Shareholder Activist.
- 0:16
- James Thompson: And I'm James Thompson, senior Chantiqueer columnist at the Australian Financial Review.
- 0:20
- Stephen May: And James, we are the Money Cafe. And where do we start? I mean anthropic
- 0:26
- Stephen May: Kensen Wong spy scandal. I
- 0:28
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean,
- 0:28
- Stephen May: I guess they're sort of combined because Nvidia is one of the cornerstone backers of the Anthropic float. But uh have you ever seen a uh an affair or a spy scandal at this scale before? It's just totally unprecedented, isn't it?
- 0:43
- James Thompson: Oh, it's amazing, isn't it? I and you sort of think had a an Australian executive been caught up in something. like this, they would be out on their ear already, of course. They they'd be at least suspended from duty,
- 0:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,
- 0:57
- James Thompson: taking a leave of absence to spend more time with their family, perhaps.
- 1:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
- 1:01
- James Thompson: old Jensen, he's uh he seems to be um he seems to be sort of hunkering down to try and ride this one out. I think that's going to be very difficult. Uh you know, the the board is doing this is. independent investigation. He'll sail through that. Um, those independent investigations done by companies are not worth the
- 1:21
- James Thompson: paper they've written on, as we've seen from KPMG and PWC in our uh own backyard. Um, but I I think given the midterm uh election result was so strong, Stephen,
- 1:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): i
- 1:35
- James Thompson: uh and the anti AI sentiment in the US amongst politicians is so strong. I mean, Huang's going to be called up to congressional inquiry after congressional inquiry, isn't he?
- 1:47
- Stephen May: Yes. And this is where I think he I'll be surprised if he survives.
- 1:52
- James Thompson: Yeah. Uh
- 1:52
- Stephen May: well certainly not as executive chair, because he doesn't it he only owns about three and a half percent. So he's not like Mark Zuckerberg where he
- 1:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): can just go,
- 2:00
- Stephen May: well I control the majority of the voting stock or Elon Musk at SpaceX. So he is vulnerable to the shareholders. And um so I yeah, I I can't see how he survives this. And I I think it'll be an absolute political pylon. It'll be like KPMG and PWC, as you wrote this week.
- 2:20
- Stephen May: Um and there is the occasional board investigation. I mean, Roger Ailes Ayles at at Fox News, he got finished off by uh a the board investigation. although that took the Murdoch boys to actually gang up on him and persuade their father to move against him. Whereas there is no such person inside the um the Nvidia boardroom and no one's ever heard of any of their directors.
- 2:40
- James Thompson: He's
- 2:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 2:41
- Stephen May: executive chair. And so someone's got to step up here.
- 2:44
- James Thompson: I think the uh as we've seen in PwC and KPMG, it's the combination of the political pressure and the pressure. press reporting. And I think that's what's been really interesting. You know, it's story after story after story every day of like new revelations about oh well, you know, NVIDIA was asking about was asking the Department of
- 3:04
- James Thompson: Justice about its investigation into this uh company that Alice Wang is is said to be involved in Mega Speed. You know, in i uh when did Trump know about the these allegations? So I just think the the drum beat is just gonna continue. So I don't know. Uh m I guess my question is does
- 3:23
- James Thompson: Jensen make it to Christmas? I don't know, Stephen, what do you reckon?
- 3:26
- Stephen May: Not in his current role. I mean you'd have to keep him on, you know, as a consultant. It has to be he has to be in the tent still.
- 3:32
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah. But
- 3:33
- Stephen May: he he won't be able to appear publicly. Like this is his problem. He he's in the bunker.
- 3:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): He
- 3:37
- Stephen May: can't he's got to step out and clear the air. So he's gonna have to reveal absolutely everything. How they met, the extent of the affair. I mean the the exposure on the scale of the spy side of things is going to be extraordinary.
- 3:52
- James Thompson: And
- 3:52
- Stephen May: that's why I think it'll just be a massive distraction for him.
- 3:55
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 3:55
- Stephen May: uh it it'll be untenable. And he's so he's too tired to Trump. And Trump's on the nose and the Democrats have got control.
- 4:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 4:02
- Stephen May: they there you go. But um it's still they're still stumping up for Anthropic, along with all the other big tech companies. I mean, what is it, 26 billion that
- 4:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 4:11
- Stephen May: other big techs are putting into the uh anthropic float? Can you I mean it's just amazing. I loved your column this week about it.
- 4:16
- James Thompson: Yeah, this is really interesting, Stephen. Uh I mean obviously Anthropic is like SpaceX before it being directly marketed to Australian investors. Um but I reckon Australian investors start at a bit of a disadvantage, you know.
- 4:34
- James Thompson: I um I I sort of picked up on on what he was saying. You know, if you're an Aussie investor, you put a dollar into SpaceX, you buy a share in the company or you know, in this case, it's 74 Seventy-four US dollars at the midpoint uh of the share offer. But but if Google's doing the same thing, they're not just getting a share, they're also getting that money back
- 4:54
- James Thompson: in revenue. Because uh Anthropic has two hundred and fifty billion dollars US worth of computing power commitments that it's agreed to buy from from Google down the track. And of course it doesn't have enough money to do that. So what does this capital raising that's part of the IPO do? It helps pay for the for for all these computing commitments. So
- 5:14
- James Thompson: you know, the it does raise the question: are Aussie retail investors overpaying? Because they're not like Google, they don't get the share and a revenue stream, they just get the share. Um, so look, maybe this won't matter in the end if Anthropic manages to grow and grow and grow and grow to the sky, um, and everyone will get nice and
- 5:34
- James Thompson: wealthy. But you know, that that there's a lot of ifs involved in
- 5:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 5:39
- James Thompson: that assumption, I think.
- 5:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
- 5:40
- Stephen May: that's right. I mean, I still can't believe this thing only started in twenty twenty one. I mean, at least SpaceX was twenty five years old. At least it had been going since, you know, the the turn of the century. How how can something go from nothing with seven founders who've defected from OpenAI to a valuation of one $1.4 point four trillion dollars? And it's absolutely
- 6:00
- Stephen May: burning cash, but it's also it's also minting cash. I mean, the at the annualized revenue after the October data is $81 billion on an annualized basis. So it's just growing like topsy. And so people are just making an assessment as to whether the revenue growth is going to be able to justify the eight hundred and ninety five billion dollars of
- 6:20
- Stephen May: commitments they've made to to buy computing power over the next decade. You know, and I should point out two 250 hundred and fifty billion US of that is with Google.
- 6:27
- James Thompson: Yeah. There's a great um new memo out uh on on Thursday morning as we're recording Stephen from Howard Marks. You know, he writes these memos that that sort of sum up his thinking on something. His his latest one is a sort of layman's guide to how he's thinking about AI. And he does raise exactly that point, you know,
- 6:47
- James Thompson: open OpenAI AI and Anthropic are what, six or seven years old? I mean, if if they can go from naught to a hundred in six or seven years, what's not to say someone else is going to be started start up pretty soon that can do exactly the same thing and displace them? I think it's a pretty good point as you uh as you consider whether Anthropic is a sort of long term
- 7:07
- James Thompson: investment or a shorter term investment. It It's uh it it's gonna be really interesting. I mean,
- 7:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
- 7:13
- James Thompson: we've seen these wide wild swings in sentiment around AI just in the last week. Bond yields going back up again, talk of a fifty basis point rate hike in the US. The the the
- 7:26
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
- 7:26
- James Thompson: it's a real pressure test for the market, this IPO.
- 7:29
- Stephen May: Yeah, I I I think it'll get away. I mean, we just talk about trillions like this rolls off the tongue now. I mean, NVIDIA's gone from five point eight trillion down to four point two trillion in five weeks. You know, that's that's the fastest loss of one point six trillion in history, just as anthropic's the fastest creation of one point four trillion
- 7:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
- 7:46
- Stephen May: history. So like
- 7:47
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I got my
- 7:47
- Stephen May: email from Comsec a couple of days ago, sprooking it. So they're they're rolling out the the SpaceX playbook of of dialing in Australia's biggest broker, Comsec, open up an international trading account. I've you know my one share in SpaceX uh is closed this morning at a hundred 141 and forty so I'm six bucks up on that with the one thirty five float price. So I'll probably roll in and
- 8:07
- Stephen May: apply for ten or so uh anthropics and just uh turn up at the AGM one day. But uh I'm a bit nervous that um retail was being allocated twenty percent. I mean twenty percent is a big allocation so they really are trying to tap into that global you know millions of retail punters uh are riding the wave so it's an absolute high hype
- 8:27
- Stephen May: machine for somet something which is burning cash. And all the circular payments, I agree they're they're a worry. But
- 8:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
- 8:34
- Stephen May: the instos will pay up, I mean they're raising ninety billion. So there is what you know close to seventy uh sixty four billion from non-big tech investors. And you know they wouldn't pay for firms. Fermos, So there is some sort of judgment out there you'd hope.
- 8:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah. Uh well we'll look all all the talk at the moment's moment, Stephen, is that the uh IPO is oversubscribed, demand's huge, they're talking about raising the valuation.
- 8:58
- James Thompson: My only caution
- 8:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): is
- 8:59
- James Thompson: I'm sure I heard all those exact phrases around Fermos. Exactly.
- 9:05
- James Thompson: So let's see where
- 9:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
- 9:05
- James Thompson: ends up.
- 9:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
- 9:07
- Stephen May: James, I'm uh middle of the AGM season, I do want to mention the AFR because I went along to the to the 10 or 9 or the 9 entertainment AGM last year week, and the CEO Matt Stanton is in his speech, he came out and said, quote, the AFR is a world-class publishing asset that we believe is undervalued by the market. Over the past five years, EBITDA at the AFR has grown by a
- 9:27
- Stephen May: compound average growth rate of 18%. In 2025-26, more than half of the publishing divisions EBITDA came from the AFR at a margin of almost 50%.
- 9:37
- James Thompson: Ugh.
- 9:38
- Stephen May: If you work that out, James, that's uh the the publishing division's EBITDA was 150 million. So the AFR is making 75 million of
- 9:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well,
- 9:49
- Stephen May: it's making three million a week in revenue and it's making one and a half million a week in EBITDA. That's 75 million a year. So I then asked a question as to whether the AFR is worth more than 500 five hundred million. Is it worth more than the whole of Channel 9? Nine? And are you going to do a spin-off? like Domain because the market's not recognising the value? So how did the AFR become this
- 10:08
- Stephen May: duel in the crown at nine entertainment?
- 10:11
- James Thompson: I don't understand why you're standing so surprised, Stephen. Is
- 10:14
- Stephen May: it James Thompson? Is it the Chantacleer Column? I mean, it's just it's a it's extraordinary those numbers though, aren't they? In all seriousness.
- 10:20
- James Thompson: Yeah, no, they that look they they're that they're great numbers and and it's a great franchise. I mean I think uh
- 10:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the you know
- 10:26
- James Thompson: you you can see from the outside the AFR's done some important things. We've we've not not only is the publication good, um uh great, and no just just uh
- 10:39
- James Thompson: and digital newspaper still going pretty strong. Um but but we've built this events business, which has uh been uh a a a real winner for us in recent years. It's it's there's a lot of hard work that goes into that. but it's a great um way of sort of uh you know not just generating revenue, having a a real life
- 10:59
- James Thompson: conversation with our listeners and the in uh our readers, I should say, in the industries that um we write about. So that I think that's been important. Um I thought your question was going to be with margins like that, shouldn't they be paying uh the Chanticleer columnists to
- 11:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
- 11:13
- Stephen May: I I mean I couldn't be too blatant, James. But uh yeah, I did say, you know, it's uh it's never been further ahead of the Australian and um in terms of just its dominance. Because you know, newspapers are still struggling globally. I mean it's not as if uh this is a renaissance for the whole newspaper industry. It's premium business papers around the world, the FT, the Wall Street Journal, the AFR, far.
- 11:33
- Stephen May: they are they are thriving in this premium environment, but you know, the rest are the rest are struggling. So, you know, I pay my eighty five bucks a month for the AFR, get the Sat Day paper, and obviously a lot of other people are doing that too. So um, you know, long live the old media.
- 11:47
- James Thompson: Well yes and and thanks to all our our readers out there. It's um look, it's it's a great place to work and and very lucky to be a small part of it.
- 11:55
- Stephen May: Now we should cover something a bit gloomier as well. The quantus job cut. cuts. So I I went to the AGM last week up in Canberra and
- 12:03
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): no mention of
- 12:04
- Stephen May: it. No mention of job cuts.
- 12:06
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know, just
- 12:06
- Stephen May: they get they
- 12:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): did the speeches
- 12:08
- Stephen May: and then they didn't even do an ASX announcement this week. They just did the staff email. We've done an outsourcing deal with Accenture, eight hundred and fifty jobs to go, outsourcing, and the share price pops six percent and it's now back up to being a fifteen billion dollar company. What did you what did you make of that? Is this the first sign of
- 12:28
- Stephen May: AI, brutal outsourcing, job losses uh from a major corporate?
- 12:32
- James Thompson: No, well it's not the first sign, uh Stephen.
- 12:38
- James Thompson: So Quantas is doing this through a big deal with Accenture uh a and it this is how it sort of works. Basically Quantas cuts eight hundred and fifty workers over the next probably pro call it the next year and and those moves those jobs to an Accenture um uh business over in India.
- 12:58
- James Thompson: So those those jobs have been offshore essentially. And then over the next seven years, basically Accenture and Quantus are gonna work together to automate those roles and bring as much AI as possible Yeah, in in to do those roles. So I think this is the this is what I've called the AI two step that you offshore the jobs first and then you try and
- 13:17
- James Thompson: automate them over time using AI.
- 13:20
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
- 13:20
- James Thompson: I think we've seen, you know, Quinas is the third company to do a big deal with Accenture in the last 12 months. We've seen Telstra do one, we saw Coles do one not that long ago. And I think this is this is the way white-collar Collar jobs uh are going to be eaten by AI in this two-step process, in my view. Um And there's a couple of reasons, a
- 13:40
- James Thompson: couple of things that companies are struggling with. A, the economy is slowing. Obviously, for Kornest, they've got this giant impost from their rising fuel bill. You know, the fuel bill's up another billion dollars. So that that that puts pressure on the bottom line. But the other thing is they know they need to invest a lot in technology, and it's really
- 14:00
- James Thompson: hard to find the money to do that and the speed and expertise to be able to do it. Most Australian companies are big Australian companies are on legacy, old legacy systems that are you know held together with fishing line and and and really need to be rebuilt. That's hard to do yourself. So the the way to do it is you bring
- 14:20
- James Thompson: Accenture in. They in actually are going to invest in the the Qantas tech transformation up front and show. share the savings at the back end. So this is providing a bit of a template for these sort of two forces, you know, one is the slowdown the Australian economy, the other is rising need to deploy
- 14:40
- James Thompson: and invest in AI. Both of those those are hard to do individually. They're really hard to do at the same time. And so I think we'll see more of what uh what Qantas Qinas has done here uh from you know with this this sort of big bang uh outsourcing deal.
- 14:56
- Stephen May: And probably the big the really big one to come is going to be the big banks, I guess, isn't it? Because uh they haven't really they've been a bit sort of uh more cautious than Coles Telstra and Quantus. There's there's some of it coming, but they haven't really gone for it yet, even after all their results in the last uh couple of weeks.
- 15:12
- James Thompson: The big banks are doing a version of this, but it's a DIY. version. So most of them in have invested very heavily in uh in support hubs, they call them in India. So but they've kept those jobs in house essentially. Um so so the the big banks want to develop their own AI
- 15:31
- James Thompson: capabilities, whereas Coles, uh Cornes, Telstra are are more willing to let others into the tent and and you know. I think that's an acknowledgement that they're they've got big, complex businesses that are already running. So being a fast follower is not a bad thing. The banks want to own this. Um but but they are doing the same thing. That they're
- 15:51
- James Thompson: pushing jobs into these offshore hubs and then from there they'll be automated. Much easier to quietly uh reduce jobs in India than it is to to very publicly cut them in. Melbourne or Sydney.
- 16:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
- 16:04
- James Thompson: uh
- 16:05
- James Thompson: but that is how it's that is how it's unfolding. And it it it it I think we can see we've got enough evidence this cornice announcement is uh more evidence that this is actually happening.
- 16:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 16:15
- Stephen May: stay with the banks, A and Z returning to wealth management, I mean I thought we were over this. We had the big banks, they all took over wealth management, you know, Westback Westpac bought B BT T and NAB bought M MLC L C and they were all they were offering everything on the funds management side, and then they all got out of it. Like Lemmings,
- 16:31
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they
- 16:31
- Stephen May: all just follow each other. And what's going on? Nuno Matos, the the the new CEO at ANZ is is is exploring buying back and getting into the wealth business. Are you surprised by that?
- 16:41
- James Thompson: Yeah, I well, he he has flagged this. It's been an interesting sort of um thought bubble he's he's launched uh uh uh over time. But uh you know I was surprised on Monday, you know, I was asking sort of about basically the ANZ story since Nuno Matos arrived has been about cost cutting, it still is,
- 17:01
- James Thompson: uh, but the revenue growth part of it or the growth part of it's coming over the next 18 months. And he immediately said, You know, I've been talking about wealth management,
- 17:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I've
- 17:10
- James Thompson: been saying that the banks need to be involved in this. I'm not joking. I'm We're rarely looking at this. We'll announce our plans relatively soon. And I was a little bit surprised at that. I thought it was, you know, maybe, oh, this is something we might get to eventually. I think this is a key part of Nuno's growth strategy. Um, and I am, you know, a
- 17:30
- James Thompson: little bit surprised
- 17:32
- James Thompson: and maybe I'm personally biased. I spent so much time sitting in the Royal Commission listening to all
- 17:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the horror
- 17:38
- James Thompson: stories. coming out of the bank's wealth businesses and then watching them flee out of those businesses. But you can understand what Nuno's saying. Aging population, everyone or most people are retiring with pretty hefty superbalances. And we do have a
- 17:53
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 17:54
- James Thompson: know, not enough advice uh in in in the country. So
- 17:58
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): y
- 17:59
- James Thompson: the the the industrial logic's there, are the banks the right people to do it? Will the banks be trusted to do it?
- 18:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 18:05
- James Thompson: guess those are the questions I'm not entirely sure of, but Nuno reckons he can find the right model.
- 18:11
- Stephen May: Yeah. Sort of back to the future because they sold out I think to Insignia and then Insignia got got uh bought by a US private equity firm. So I don't know. No, They're all out of it. I just like the idea of of not blurring debt and equity. I'll never forget when C Centro went broke, you know, the big shopping centre company. And and Commonwealth Bank was
- 18:31
- Stephen May: literally the biggest lender and the biggest investor at the same time through their colonial funds management division. So the bank pulls the plug and wipes out all the equity uh managed by Colonial. And for me it's just a fundamental conflict of interest between are you running debt or are you running wealth and equity and investment. So I d I'd prefer they be kept out of it. and would
- 18:51
- Stephen May: rather APRA and Reserve Bank and maybe Jim Charmers just say, look ANZ, this didn't work well last time. What do you think you're doing? Uh maybe leave it to others and just stick to your knitting.
- 19:02
- James Thompson: Yeah, fair
- 19:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): enough.
- 19:04
- James Thompson: Fair enough. Fair enough.
- 19:05
- Stephen May: Now speaking of um uh I I will raise this at the upcoming ANZ uh A AGM GM in December, but I will tell you this uh the A AGM GM season today's gonna going to be huge with charter hall. the property company. They're going to cop a very big remuneration protest vote over a $90 million bonus scheme for the execs that some of the investors reckon they shouldn't have got.
- 19:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 19:24
- Stephen May: 2 30 this afternoon, I've got like 14 AGMs today. But my prediction is the biggest REM debate of the of the AGM season is going to be what happens to Charter Hall today, which is an absolute darling. And the other AGM is little nugget I was going to give you was I was amused that next DC last week announced they were moving
- 19:44
- Stephen May: their November 20 AG. Guess
- 19:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): where
- 19:47
- Stephen May: they're moving away from they're moving away from one of their data centres.
- 19:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yes, I know the answer to this one. They were holding it at at at one of the data centres, weren't they? So
- 19:56
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's
- 19:56
- Stephen May: right.
- 19:56
- James Thompson: Well look yeah the that that charter hall one is really interesting. I actually broke the story around that. Um and have written a couple of things on the the the the share award that um uh some some investors are are up in arms about. There's two recommendations against the REM report from two of
- 20:16
- James Thompson: the proxy advisors, so it'd be really interesting to see what happens there. Um I uh you know, I think it's one that's been, you know, uh the communication hasn't been great from the from the company. Um, but we'll see w whether that translates to uh what that translates to on the floor of the AGM.
- 20:33
- Stephen May: Yes, that should be interesting. I should just tell you uh update I've I've seven board tilts so far this season, James, and
- 20:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 20:39
- Stephen May: I had my worst result yesterday. Point one eight at a company called Green X medals metals in Perth. So I'm I'm averaging only three point two three percent per tilt after seven and I've got uh twenty-four to go over the next fifteen days. So uh three
- 20:56
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): point two three percent doesn't sound too bad to me. Yeah
- 20:59
- Stephen May: well I'm I'd be happy I got I got four point eight yesterday at Digico the uh the the data center owner so that was more like it but geez I was s I was starting to get a big head four point eight and then I looked at the Green X metals and 0.18 point one eight I thought oh geez go back to bed mate that's
- 21:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
- 21:15
- Stephen May: anyway, we'll uh we'll see what happens. But uh
- 21:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What's that
- 21:18
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): old line about you you never want to be in a never want to join a club that uh w wants you to be in it? So you keep the f
- 21:24
- James Thompson: keep
- 21:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): fighting, uh Steven.
- 21:26
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes,
- 21:27
- Stephen May: well it should be good fun. All right, well we should do some questions, uh uh but before we do that, let's have a word from our sponsor.
- 21:33
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): When was the last time you checked what you're paying for life insurance? You could be missing out on savings. InvestSmart can help you compare quotes from leading insurers to find a better deal. Already covered? With InvestSmart Cashback, you could get money back each year from commissions on your existing policy without changing your cover. Why pay
- 21:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): more than you need to? Visit investsmart.com.au forward slash life hyphen insurance. Terms and conditions apply. And
- 22:01
- Stephen May: as always, James. general advice warning: get some real experts to tell you what to do. Don't rely on us before you make any investment decisions. Now, Glenn says, I absolutely hate talk of productivity. It's a poor measure of efficiency. Measure twice, cut once is a wise old adage. Measuring only once is more productive, is it?
- 22:21
- Stephen May: In a mass-produced mass produced throwaway widget, more productive and efficient than a craftsman who builds a lifetime. guaranteed widget. Would increasing speed limits improve productivity? Why not increase all speed limits by twenty Ks an hour?
- 22:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 22:35
- Stephen May: he it's just a bit of a he admits it's a rant from Glenn, but um
- 22:40
- Stephen May: productivity figures are terrible though, James. I mean, how could we not talk about productivity, even if it's it means sometimes workers doing more?
- 22:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Uh but
- 22:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 22:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): think I yes, that that's right. I think I think Glenn does nail the issue with productivity, though. It's such an amorphous idea. Um,
- 22:57
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you know, it the the the basic idea is is is getting more bang for the same buck. Um but but it it is hard to to sort of nail down into things like you know measure
- 23:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): measure twice, cut once. That's a good point. Maybe that isn't uh maybe that isn't productive, or maybe it is, but it's hard to measure directly. Look, but but I I I think you're right, Stephen. We've got to keep banging on about this. We've got to keep banging on about the idea that w we we don't want to be working harder to produce
- 23:31
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): the same amount of output. No one wants that, uh you don't want your kids and your grandkids to have to do twice as much work to produce the same amount of output.
- 23:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): We've gotta improve this. So Glenn, uh yes, uh fair fair enough that you hate the talk of productivity, but the concept of it, the idea of it is central to improving our living standards. And I'm sorry, but until we come up with a better term or a better idea, we better keep banging on about it, because
- 23:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): otherwise this country is gonna get in a worse position. than it is.
- 24:05
- Stephen May: That's you've put him in his place
- 24:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there. No,
- 24:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I I I like uh uh that that the the measure twice cut once is a great uh is a great example of the productivity conundrum Glenn it's a good point. Ryan says I own a small apartment building of four units built Building in the mid mid-1990s nineteen nineties on a block of a 1,080 one thousand eighty met meter square meters on a great beachfront location.
- 24:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Good for you, right? The building occupies only a third of the land footprint. The units were all purchased before the recent tax changes. I was exploring knocking them down and rebuilding a larger, more modern building with more apartments on the land. Do you know whether I can negatively gear the new apartments if I knock the current building down and rebuild?
- 24:44
- Stephen May: And the answer is which
- 24:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Google could have tell you
- 24:47
- Stephen May: or anyone could have tell you. Yes, you can negatively gear with new builds. As long
- 24:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as
- 24:52
- Stephen May: there's at least two. So if you even knock down your own home, as long as you put two dwellings on it, you can negatively gear it. So uh yeah, the changes mainly affect existing units. So if you sold your unit to somebody else, they would w with one of those units you they would not be able to negative negatively gear. But
- 25:12
- Stephen May: if you go and knock them all down and build again. you can. And if your site coverage is only thirty three percent, it does sound like it's an unproductive use of that large parcel of land, Ryan.
- 25:22
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yes. So
- 25:23
- Stephen May: get the productivity of that parcel
- 25:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): working and
- 25:25
- Stephen May: uh Glenn won't be happy but uh go ahead and do it. Although good luck managing construction costs and builders and blowouts.
- 25:32
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes.
- 25:32
- Stephen May: As for getting a permit from council, well Ryan that's
- 25:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a whole new
- 25:36
- Stephen May: game. So what
- 25:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Ryan
- 25:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): that that is one where the general advice warning is i i is flashing red. Get lots of expert advice there.
- 25:44
- Stephen May: Correct. Now Dylan says based on my extensive use of AI over the past two years, I believe profiting in digital and knowledge based industries like software, gaming, finance, engineering, design, etc., will soon become extremely difficult. As AI automates non non-physical physical work and allows competitors to rapidly replicate existing products at near zero marginal cost, these
- 26:04
- Stephen May: sectors face extreme price wars. How can businesses maintain profitability when margins are driven down to the cost of the tokens required for replication? Given this, robust physical assets may be the only viable long-term investments. For context, Dylan wonders if AI will be able to
- 26:24
- Stephen May: replicate a full Grand Theft Auto gas. game within two years. It feels possible, he says.
- 26:31
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah. I heard a great comment the other day, uh Stephen, that that uh about the sort of how good China is at you know infiltrating an industry and and and sort of dominating it, and that was when China enters, As profits leave. And I think it might be similar with AI. Um but but but
- 26:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I I guess you've still got
- 26:53
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 26:54
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): the creative element of of creating the content. Yes, AI can replicate a full grand a grand theft auto game within two years. I I think that's probably is possible.
- 27:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 27:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): we're seeing you know what AI can do to other forms of entertainment, but there is there should be some margin in coming up with the original idea
- 27:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um by
- 27:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): behind that that that bit of content. I guess that's going to be pretty fleeting and competed away if it's if it's replicated. But this is the this is the the problem facing lots of industries, including our own, Stephen, or my own. Indeed. You know, how long will it be before you
- 27:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 27:33
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, someone can replicate the money cafe with with AI? Now, would it have the increase? incredible incise uh judgment of its hosts? I'm not sure, but ma maybe you could pull something like that off quickly.
- 27:46
- Stephen May: Look, I'm I'm still waiting for the I mean most AGMs I'm going to like I did six yesterday, I was usually the only person asking online questions. It surely I reckon by next AGM season there will be
- 27:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
- 27:59
- Stephen May: AI agents lodging these questions.
- 28:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah. you
- 28:02
- Stephen May: know, at at scale. Just like you're getting lots of AI court cases going on, and it's only a matter of time. So um, you know, just trade
- 28:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): them up.
- 28:11
- Stephen May: What's a what's a good question to ask? Go into the system, load up the questions, put it
- 28:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on. You
- 28:15
- Stephen May: know, it's it's it's gonna hit everywhere. But um I still I I'm less pessimistic than Dylan. And I mean, c companies that own great data, great IP. You can't you you can't just steal content. and knock everything off. There are actually l legal protections, intellectual property, the rule of law, exclusive data. There's a whole bunch of things that will will
- 28:35
- Stephen May: prevail. But the disruption is going to be huge, no doubt about it, but um not quite as catastrophizing at the level as uh as Dylan.
- 28:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, fair enough.
- 28:46
- James Thompson: Fair enough.
- 28:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Daniel says we have an aging population with significant assets who are both uncertain about what financial security they'll need for retirement and conservative in their investment decisions. This is meaning that they're reluctant to pass on their wealth to a new generation or to invest in the business and assets that Australia needs to overcome its productivity issues. Could the government help address
- 29:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): this by offering a tax incentive for intergenerational wealth transfer where it's used to start a business or purchase productive advantage? assets. That's a really interesting idea, isn't it, Stephen?
- 29:18
- Stephen May: It is, and I've got a great solution, uh, James. It's called an inheritance tax. And uh if you give your money away to your kids or anyone you like before you die, you pay less inheritance tax. That's that's uh it's done all over the world. I mean you could also have um
- 29:36
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 29:36
- Stephen May: you know that the currently there the there are different rules about gifting your money away and and accessing the age pension. If you wanted to loosen those rules, you could say give all your money away to a a business and then you can go on the pension more easily than at the moment, because the moment it's I think it's more than five years. You've got to
- 29:57
- Stephen May: gotta wait before you can uh
- 29:58
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 29:59
- Stephen May: if you've been gifting away. So I think there are things you can do uh, and I think there is a general problem with the uh the old folk hanging on to their assets for too long and just being too conservative before passing on. So I think something that encourages intergenerational trans transfers more generously, I do
- 30:19
- Stephen May: agree that is a problem which needs to be encouraged. I'm not quite so sure on the model. Well, What how would you do it if you were if you agreed that's a problem. what's the incentive you would tweak there, James, to make that happen?
- 30:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah. Well well I I guess the inheritance tax is a disincentive in a way, isn't it, to or it's an incentive to pass things on. But but I guess Daniel's trying to use the scalpel rather than the sledgehammer here and say, let's find a way of of increasing the investment in business and and and
- 30:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): productive assets. particularly. Now I guess that could be gamed. You know, you could say, Oh, I I'm gonna have a business doing this, like you how would you prove it? What what do you but there'd be ways around that? So look,
- 31:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 31:02
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): don't entirely mind the idea.
- 31:06
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 31:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I I
- 31:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I I I guess the question is how do you get people to release that money or el o older people to release money that earlier?
- 31:16
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um that's
- 31:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): the challenge.
- 31:18
- Stephen May: Well I I I wouldn't want to distinguish between productive assets or businesses because you know, an education is also productive. So grandparents helping out with the school fees or helping your your ki your grandkids buy a home, that you know, that is also a very valuable thing. So I I don't think you can just ring fence it to business and then you'd get your fake businesses being
- 31:39
- Stephen May: set up to uh grab the tax deduction. So I think it just needs to be an overall tax incentive for um for pass downs. And um yeah, I you know I think uh I I agree it's an issue, but um you know how you'd actually structure it it's uh it's quite tricky.
- 31:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
- 31:55
- Stephen May: Now let's go to um uh Nathan from Victoria. Love the pod. Australia's inflation CPI increases seem to be heavily implicated. impacted by construction costs, including for new residential builds. But increases in home prices aren't reflected in the CPI because they're investments in assets. Why does buying a home count as
- 32:14
- Stephen May: investment and get excluded? Well, building a home counts as consumption and gets included. Well, I So think Nathan, it's more just the component parts of building a home like cement and bricks. And you do have to measure all those things with inflation, I think, James, don't you? You can't just exclude construction
- 32:34
- Stephen May: costs. But yeah, he he is right that actual increases in home prices are not part of the CPI, the official CPI measure.
- 32:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, that's right. I mean I think what the RBA is trying to do um i i is is measure the cost of building everything. not just homes but commercial property um infrastructure so so uh they're they're breaking the using the component parts helps capture a a much bigger parcel of activity
- 33:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): than than than just houses
- 33:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um but
- 33:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): yeah you know I I think
- 33:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 33:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): rent is included um so so that th there is some link to to house property prices and housing, you know, d more more direct links to to residential housing in CPI.
- 33:21
- Stephen May: Yeah, that's a fair point. Now I'm gonna jump back to Roberto now. I love the show. I've had multiple interest rate increases on my mortgage, but the repayments haven't moved at all since we first got it. Why aren't the banks adjusting repayments? And is this going against what the RBA is trying to do?
- 33:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think that would suggest, Roberto, you're but you've been paying well over what you the the minimum required. And so y y you have whether you sort of know it or not, and maybe you don't, but but you have s you have chosen to set the level of your payments there and the bank is sort of following your wishes, I I
- 33:57
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): would have thought. You know, you you've said you want to pay back X. Yes, the interest rates increase, but but while unless unl until you change your preferences about repayments, th they're not going to make changes. So
- 34:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's
- 34:09
- Stephen May: right. It's all about being ahead of the game. You're you're years ahead of the minimum. So the banks have a minimum repayment uh uh case and a lot of people will get their their monthly costs go up if they're not on the minimum. But if you're ahead of the game because you've agreed at the start to repay more than the minimum, then the bank will buffer you.
- 34:27
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on
- 34:27
- Stephen May: the way up. Just like they're not cutting your um interest payments on the way down. That's when you actually do get in front. When the cycle switches down and you keep paying the same amount, you've you're
- 34:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): putting
- 34:38
- Stephen May: literally money in the bank to protect you when it goes the other way. So uh but I was interested, James. The CBA and their results said that uh that their their 90 ninety days arrears on their home loan book, which is the big biggest in the country, is now up to point eight percent, which is the highest I think it's been in close to a decade.
- 34:58
- Stephen May: But they're being more gentle in terms of moving against people. That was an interesting comment. That they're not sending in the sheriff, so to speak, and going the heavy. They're actually consciously being quite gentle in allowing point eight percent of their home borrowers to
- 35:17
- Stephen May: fall more than ninety days behind on their repayments and to have not actually had a foreclosure or some sort of an intervention by the bank. So interesting that they're treading warily, but a bit of a worry that uh arrears are ticking up as house prices fall.
- 35:31
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, the arrears are still very low by historical standards and and the loan loss rates
- 35:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 35:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): at at C B CBA, A. you know, I I think we're still well below where we were even pre pre pre COVID. So yeah, but I I think the the the banks do need to be watchful here. Um but they're also I think they've been pretty since the Royal Commission pretty sensitive around foreclosures uh and they k they manage hardship
- 35:57
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): cases very carefully. Um but th that that they they may end up managing a lot more hardship. cases than they've seen in a very long time. I think this we are going into a a credit cycle. Uh uh one of the analysts, Matthew Wilson from Jarden, had a had a great line yesterday that credit is a bit like a teabag. You only see how good
- 36:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): it is when it goes into hot water, and I think we're about to go into hot water.
- 36:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 36:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I I like this question from Tom. He says, Thanks for being my Thursday morning commute. Might be Thursday afternoon. ARVO today, Tom. If the government continues to sidestep sidestep its contribution to inflation through excessive spending, perhaps the RBA needs to take a different approach. Uh the message would be simple: if the government isn't prepared to do its part, the RBA shouldn't be left carrying the
- 36:41
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): burden alone. Such a stance would undoubtedly generate significant media and public attention, potentially forcing a broader policy response and bringing additional tools into the conversation beyond monetary policy alone. Now Stephen, Shobullock's been edging down this path. Edging, you know, I I think she's made the point that she's not getting
- 37:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): a lot of help from uh government spending or productivity. But but there's only so far she can go and she made this point on Melbourne Cup Day. Independence is is highly prized by the RBA, but it goes two ways. I can't tell the government what to do, and the government can't tell me what to do, and that's the way it's got to be. So how does
- 37:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): she how does she walk this tightrope?
- 37:24
- Stephen May: It is an interesting point though, Tom says. Imagine if she said, you know, so it's just round interest rates up to five percent. Okay, so
- 37:31
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): let's go
- 37:31
- Stephen May: up another fifteen basis points. And then she said, Listen, government, I don't I cannot see interest rates falling back below five percent until you are running a cash surplus at the state and federal level because you're just you're just overinflating everything. So you need to go and do your thing and come and talk to me when you've got your budget into surplus, and that's when we might be having a
- 37:51
- Stephen May: rate cut down to five percent. Now I think her board would sack her in about five seconds because don't
- 37:55
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): forget
- 37:55
- Stephen May: that the majority of the board well she does have some tenure, but uh it's it it's she she does report to a board and the majority of those directors are Labour appointees. So she has only a certain amount of wiggle room. Her independence only goes so far. And she also has the dual mandate of managing
- 38:14
- Stephen May: employment. She doesn't have a mandate that says manage the budget. She has a mandate that says keep inflation down and look after employment. And they're the two things that she's focused on. So she would have to cut rates if employment together. ticked up. But you know, Tom's point is right. She could use the bully pulpit more forcefully
- 38:35
- Stephen May: to really pressure governments to uh to do some cutting and uh and stop overheating the economy.
- 38:40
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I disagree, Stephen. And
- 38:42
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): the reason is flip that coin. We do not want to get into a situation where we've got Jim Charmers saying, Hey,
- 38:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): look at
- 38:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): my poll numbers. Look at look at the popularity of this government. Michelle Bullock, you need to cut rates and you need to cut them now.
- 39:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): We don't we don't need Yeah. Well uh you know, we don't we do not want a situation where we've got I mean I think Bullock is essentially right. The independence goes both ways and it matters. So, you know, I I I I think she has to tread a f a a a pretty fine line here because we don't want governments interfering with rate
- 39:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): with interest rate settings. So it it's hard for the central bank to say, Well, you know, here's what here you know, you should cut here and here and here and here. I mean, it's it's slippery slope, isn't it?
- 39:32
- Stephen May: It is. It is amazing to think that it was only back in the Keating era when the politicians were setting setting fiscal
- 39:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): policy.
- 39:38
- Stephen May: Ke Keating was literally you know, he had the reserve bank in his pocket and he was literally setting interest rates. So I think globally now the two things that that democracies have accepted should be independent are the judges, the rule of law, and the central bankers. And it is basically universally accepted. But uh we haven't quite got to central bankers being put in charge of
- 39:58
- Stephen May: fiscal policy yet, Tom. Maybe that's where we'll finish up one day, but uh we have haven't quite got there yet. Now, James says: similar theme, interest rates are a blunt tool, but they are effective for hard-working younger Australians with a mortgage. But what about us boomers? We just keep on spending. Government spending is criticized as being inflationary, but no one talks about the money the government keeps shoveling
- 40:18
- Stephen May: my way. Thanks to Super. For years I was able to reduce the amount of tax I paid, sometimes from 48 cents in the dollar to 15 cents in the dollar. And now taxes paid by Australia's biggest companies are just sent back to me as fully frank dividends, normally via my super fund. And let's be blunt, if the government is giving this tax straight back to me, then we shouldn't be acting as if that tax was ever
- 40:38
- Stephen May: paid in the first place. The government is just a clearinghouse. If anyone tries to touch this sacred cow, I'm sure that Jeff Wilson and the Superfunds super funds will scream blue murder because the government's going after poor pensioners. So We don't get too many. boomers writing in saying, I'm rich and I'm getting richer and the government's letting me get away with it. But uh let's dig down on these on
- 40:58
- Stephen May: these figures. I disagree with James's claim that the hundred and fifty four billion in company tax which the government is projecting to collect this year is not a real number because so much of it goes back via franking credits and these sorts of things. Some of it does go back, but it is still a very
- 41:18
- Stephen May: chunky amount of tax at 30%.
- 41:21
- Stephen May: Our corporate tax is higher than average, and for instance, the GST is only bringing in 90 to 100 billion a year. So corporate tax is the second biggest thing after income tax, which is which is ridiculously high at 380 billion. Um, But franking credits are a bit of a rot, particularly the cash top-ups. Bill Shorten tried that.
- 41:41
- Stephen May: He failed, he lost, and frankling credits have been left forever as one of the great roughts in Australia. Um, and um, but look, well done, James, for being an honest boomer saying the government's been too generous to me.
- 41:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, and I think, well, look, I think over time the the the generosity of uh of super's tax settings
- 42:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): will.
- 42:02
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): get more attention. You know, it's it's got plenty of attention in the last couple of years. I I think that the that there'll be more attention paid to it down the track, particularly as the working population shrinks.
- 42:16
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 42:16
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): if it shrinks even more thanks to AI, well something else is gonna have to give.
- 42:20
- Stephen May: Yes, I agree. Now before we go I actually went just doing to want to do a little correction from last week. One of our listeners has written and in I I mentioned the annual information meetings for super funds and suggested they might have been a voluntary thing. They're actually mandatory. Since 2020, super funds have been forced by law to hold an annual information meeting. And what's interesting
- 42:40
- Stephen May: is that under the law, they have to answer every single question.
- 42:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Wow. So
- 42:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
- 42:46
- Stephen May: you're a member
- 42:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of the Stephen Main Dream
- 42:48
- Stephen May: Super, they have to say whether it's writing back by email, I think, you know, or you know, grouping them into it. But uh if if some of them do get literally hundreds and hundreds of people who who jump on for the annual information meeting. So my beef, I guess, is that you can't elect any of the directors, you don't get a vote on remuneration. It's
- 43:08
- Stephen May: not a real annual meeting where you're actually deciding on
- 43:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the leadership of the
- 43:13
- Stephen May: company. You You're just get just getting information. So there
- 43:16
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are
- 43:16
- Stephen May: limitations to it. So yes, you know, I'm a member of Legal Legal Super Um and their annual information meetings coming up. But if I want to change the directors or criticize the REM, you know, they're just words. Whereas w I prefer AGMs where real stuff actually happens, James.
- 43:33
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): True, but but but I I I guess if you accept that maybe that's a it's a stage staged process, it i it is good that the meetings are now required at least and and you do get to voice those concerns.
- 43:43
- Stephen May: Yes, that's right. And I just you know I I want the industry funds to be more active at AGMs themselves. They do vote, but they tend to do things through their umbrella group, Axie, and through the proxy funds. Oh, I want to see you know Aussie Super turning up at AGMs and speaking from the floor. Just like we've had we've got this David Kingston guy, this wealthy
- 44:03
- Stephen May: ex-investment banker. He is just carving up AGMs all over the country. He he he was at Digico yesterday. I think he's gonna have a crack at Jerry Harvey. He has lifted the quality of debate at AGMs just because he's a rich guy, he enjoys the fun, and he goes along and he's been ripping into all sorts of companies, uh, mainly in Sydney. And I just say, why can't
- 44:23
- Stephen May: we have more professionals like David Kingston turning AGMs into a decent quality professional debate rather than amateur hour or no one, which is what what happens at the moment, because we're just not very engaged at the AGM level, sadly.
- 44:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Well, you've you've long fought a one-man war on that, Stephen. So more power to you.
- 44:43
- Stephen May: More people should get out there. So uh look, I think we we'd better wrap it up, uh James. So uh thanks for listening to this episode of the Money Cafe. I'll be back next week with Intelligent Investor, founder and editor John Addis. Alan is still convalescing after his back surgery, but we'll be back hopefully in early December. So look, send us a question and we'll answer it together, John and I, by
- 45:03
- Stephen May: emailing the Money Cafe at intelligentinvestor.com dot AU. Until then, I'm Stephen Mayne, Main, contributor and intelligent investor, founder of Crikey and Shareholder Activist. And
- 45:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I'm James Thompson, senior Chanticleer columnist at the Australian Financial Review.
- 45:16
- Stephen May: Talk to you soon.