The Money Café with Alan Kohler

Speakers critique RBA rate hike, bank profits, and AI regulatory risks amid K-shaped economy

42 min Listen to the original
RBAInterest RatesBankingShareholder ActivismAI RegulationSuperannuationAGMsAustralian Economy

Summary

Stephen Main, James Thompson, and Stephen Mayne discuss the Reserve Bank of Australia's recent 6-3 rate hike, arguing it disproportionately harms consumers while strategic investments remain unaffected. Main highlights shareholder activism at AGMs, criticizing Veritas Mining for excluding retail investors and predicting political backlash against banks earning record profits. Mayne and Thompson debate alternative monetary tools, with Mayne criticizing the RBA's use of non-round numbers and Thompson warning of sovereign risk from fiscal interventions. The conversation also covers AI liability risks, citing uninsurable legal claims in prospectuses, and efficiency gains in theme parks through automation.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    six in favour, three against the rate rise.

    James Thompson · 3:45

  2. 2
    The combined market capitalization of Australia's big five banks is $746 billion, which is ten times the combined market cap of Coles and Woolworths ($77.8 billion).

    Stephen Main · 11:49

  3. 3
    And what Anthropic has uh said is that there is not enough insurance in the world to insure Anthropic against exactly those types of legal. claims that uh Jeff refers to.

    James Thompson · 38:10

Episode sections

  1. 0:30 – 3:25

    AGM Season and Shareholder Activism

    Stephen Main discusses attending multiple AGMs including Tabcorp, Sandfire, and Veritas Mining. He highlights his nomination for the Veritas Mining board to challenge their treatment of retail shareholders and lack of transparency, noting their recent capital raisings excluded retail investors.

  2. 3:25 – 11:06

    RBA Rate Hike and Economic Impact

    Speakers analyze the Reserve Bank of Australia's recent rate hike, noting a split decision (6-3) and Governor Michelle Bullock's stance. James Thompson argues the hike disproportionately hurts consumers while major investments in energy, AI, and defense remain unaffected, creating a K-shaped economy.

  3. 11:06 – 15:03

    Bank Profits and Political Backlash

    The discussion shifts to Australian bank results, with Main criticizing the high market capitalization of the big five banks relative to supermarkets. He predicts political backlash against banks for record profits and high interest margins during a cost-of-living crisis, suggesting regulatory intervention on credit card rates.

  4. 15:03 – 20:22

    Supermarket Duopoly and Share Volatility

    Main and Thompson discuss the competitive dynamics between Coles and Woolworths, noting Coles' recent 10% share price drop due to discounting. They also touch on broader market volatility, citing large daily drops in CSL and Cochlear, and debate the role of continuous disclosure and hedge fund trading.

  5. 20:22 – 25:39

    Superannuation Performance Tests and Industry Funds

    Addressing a listener question, Main and Thompson discuss the lack of performance tests for retirement (de-accumulation) superannuation products. Main criticizes the delay until 2028 and urges industry funds like UniSuper to be more active in shareholder advocacy rather than relying solely on proxy advisors.

  6. 25:39 – 29:52

    Government Spending and Infrastructure Efficiency

    The speakers debate potential government spending cuts, focusing on the NDIS and state infrastructure projects. Main argues that excessive debt-funded infrastructure spending by states like Victoria has contributed to rising costs and inefficiency, while Thompson suggests digitizing the public service.

  7. 29:52 – 31:30

    Iron Ore and Inflation

    Stephen Mayne argues that iron ore prices do not directly drive inflation, but rather affect Australia's national wealth and government revenues. James Thompson agrees, noting that a drop in iron ore prices would harm government budgets, which is undesirable during inflationary periods.

  8. 31:30 – 32:35

    Alternative Monetary Policy Tools

    James Thompson reads listener questions suggesting alternatives to interest rate hikes, such as bank levies, increased superannuation contributions, or longer mortgage terms. Mayne and Thompson discuss the political and practical feasibility of these measures, with Thompson warning of sovereign risk and political instability associated with changing tax or levy structures.

  9. 32:35 – 33:31

    RBA Rate Hike Mechanics

    Stephen Mayne criticizes the RBA's use of 25 basis point increments and non-round numbers (e.g., 4.85%), arguing that the central bank should return to round numbers and potentially use larger, more aggressive moves like 50 basis points to signal intent.

  10. 33:31 – 34:15

    Bank Levies and Financial Stability

    Mayne states that banks already pay an additional $2 billion annually in levies and opposes further taxation. Thompson cautions against disrupting financial stability, noting that bank profit growth has been stagnant for years, suggesting the sector is at a turning point.

  11. 34:15 – 35:05

    Superannuation and GST as Economic Controls

    Thompson notes there is public pushback against increasing the superannuation guarantee to 12%, citing intergenerational equity concerns. Mayne dismisses using super or GST changes as practical inflation control tools, arguing governments should instead focus on reducing structural budget deficits.

  12. 35:05 – 37:28

    Government Deficits and Housing Market

    Mayne claims the recent May budget acted as a 'tax grab' that slowed the economy and caused house prices to fall. He argues that responsible fiscal management, such as spending cuts or tax increases, is necessary to cool an overheating economy, citing Victoria's Liberal government as an example.

  13. 37:28 – 39:20

    AI Liability and Regulatory Risk

    Stephen Mayne questions why companies like OpenAI are not facing class actions for negligence regarding AI errors, such as the Medicare email incident. James Thompson references the Anthropic prospectus, which states that the legal risks of AI are currently uninsurable, suggesting a coming regulatory backlash.

  14. 39:20 – 41:41

    AI Productivity in Theme Parks

    Mayne shares an anecdote from the Dream World AGM, where CEO Greg Young stated that AI models using 80 metrics now predict Saturday attendance within 5% accuracy. Thompson notes that while this improves efficiency, it likely results in significant workforce reduction, from 10 people to 2.

Claims worth verifying

Stephen Main attended seven AGMs on a single Friday, including Tabcorp, Sandfire, Car Group, Reese, Pinnacle, and Polynova.

Stephen Main ·0:48

How to verify: Check AGM schedules for Tabcorp, Sandfire, Car Group, Reese, Pinnacle, and Polynova for the relevant Friday in the AGM season (typically Nov-Jan). For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Veritas Mining is worth $570 million and has done three capital raisings in the last eighteen months via placements to institutional investors.

Stephen Main ·2:31

How to verify: Review ASX announcements for Veritas Mining (ASX: VRT) for capital raising notices and share price data over the last 18 months. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The RBA rate hike decision was split 6-3, with three directors voting against the increase.

James Thompson ·3:45

How to verify: Check the Reserve Bank of Australia's monetary policy decision release and press conference transcript for the vote count. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Australia has the highest interest rates in the developed world.

Stephen Main ·4:52

How to verify: Compare the RBA cash rate against central bank rates in other developed economies (US, UK, EU, Japan) from central bank websites. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Household debt in Australia is $2.6 trillion.

Stephen Main ·4:52

How to verify: Check Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) data on household debt liabilities. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Coles shares fell 10% in one day.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·17:19

How to verify: Check Coles Group (ASX: COL) share price history for a 10% single-day drop. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Coles market cap is $28.6 billion and Woolworths is $49 billion.

Stephen Main ·17:59

How to verify: Calculate market capitalization (Share Price x Shares Outstanding) for Coles and Woolworths from ASX data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

UniSuper holds 18.5% of Chorus.

Stephen Main ·24:31

How to verify: Check Chorus (NZX: CHA) share register or major shareholder disclosures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Victoria's Capital Works budget increased from $4.5 billion to $20 billion.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·28:25

How to verify: Review Victorian state government budget documents for Capital Works expenditure. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The RBA Governor cited the removal of electricity and gas household subsidies as contributing to high inflation readings.

Stephen Main ·29:33

How to verify: Check the RBA press conference transcript for mentions of subsidy removals and inflation forecasts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Australia exports $150 billion worth of goods a year.

Stephen Main ·30:22

How to verify: Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) Trade in Goods and Services data for the relevant financial year. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The iron ore price has crept back above $90.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·30:31

How to verify: Platts Iron Ore 62% Fines price data or LME iron ore futures for the period 2026-08-04 to 2026-11-04. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Banks are paying two billion a year more in levies.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·33:31

How to verify: Australian Government Budget Papers or Treasury press releases detailing the Financial System Levy or similar bank taxes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The superannuation guarantee is being pushed to 12%.

James Thompson ·34:21

How to verify: Australian Government legislation or Treasury announcements regarding the Superannuation Guarantee rate schedule. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Peter Costello said it's great to have a great retirement but questioned struggling in the present regarding super contributions.

James Thompson ·34:21

How to verify: News archives (e.g., AFR, SMH) for Peter Costello's comments on superannuation in late 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The May budget was a tax grab that hit boomers and slowed the economy.

Stephen Main ·35:05

How to verify: Analysis of the May 2026 Federal Budget documents and subsequent economic indicators (GDP, consumer spending) for 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

House prices have tanked due to the budget measures.

Stephen Main ·35:45

How to verify: CoreLogic or RP Data housing price indices for major Australian cities for late 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Anthropic prospectus states there is not enough insurance in the world to insure against AI legal claims.

James Thompson ·38:10

How to verify: Anthropic S-1 or prospectus filing on SEC EDGAR, specifically the 'Risk Factors' section. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

OpenAI sent an email to Medicare 84 days after a hack/incident.

Stephen Main ·37:50

How to verify: News reports or official statements from OpenAI and the Australian Department of Health regarding the Medicare AI incident in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Dream World's AI predicts Saturday attendance within 5% accuracy using 80 metrics.

Stephen Main ·39:59

How to verify: Coast Entertainment (ASX: CCE) AGM transcript or investor presentation for the 2026 AGM. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify Veritas Mining's capital raising announcements and shareholder exclusion clauses via ASX announcements.
  • Check RBA meeting minutes for the 6-3 vote split and Governor Bullock's dissenting or supporting statements.
  • Review Australian Treasury budget papers to assess the impact of iron ore price fluctuations on government revenues.
  • Search SEC EDGAR for the Anthropic S-1 or prospectus filing to confirm statements regarding AI insurance coverage.
  • Examine Coast Entertainment (ASX: CCE) AGM transcripts or investor presentations for claims about AI attendance prediction accuracy.
  • Compare state government stamp duty revenue reports against forecasts to verify claims about housing market impacts.
  • Analyze Australian Bureau of Statistics trade data to verify annual export values and iron ore price trends.
  • Check Australian government budget documents for details on the Financial System Levy and bank levy amounts.
Full transcriptexpand
0:11
James Thompson: Hello, I'm James Thompson, senior Chantacleer columnist at the Australian Financial Review.
0:16
Stephen Main: And I'm Stephen Main, contributor and intelligent investor, founder of Crikey and Shareholder Activist.
0:20
James Thompson: And we are the Money Cafe. Uh Sans Allen again. Uh He's still out of action. Um and so again, Stephen
0:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Back
0:31
Stephen Main: surgery, yes.
0:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Another couple of
0:33
Stephen Main: weeks.
0:33
James Thompson: All right. So we we wish him all the best and we're we're sure he's listening. Uh and we promise not to uh crash the Rolls Royce uh this week. Stephen, it's still AGM season. Uh how are you how are you holding up?
0:48
Stephen Main: Oh look, it's uh it's busy. I think I had seven on um Friday, which was uh which was quite good fun. It was uh fabulous Friday. Our Tabcor Endeavour, Sandfire, Car Group, Reese, Pinnacle, and Polynova all in the one day. So that was
1:08
Stephen Main: probably the funnest day of the season so far. It was good getting uh Gillam McLaughlin from the Tabcor CEO to
1:15
Stephen Main: talk about his racehorse investments, which he said has been i is hugely unsuccessful as in his fruitless pursuit of Group One success. So uh
1:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that was good
1:25
Stephen Main: fun. And then of course you had the
1:28
Stephen Main: Endeavour group, you
1:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): had
1:29
Stephen Main: uh the Mathesons causing another strike at Endeavour Group and watching Jane Hardlicker on Deboo. the boo. I thought she was very impressive. Yep. But uh the stock's still in the toilet so uh look every every day it's a different sort of adventure. I've already lodged, I think, four questions this morning at the the chorus AGM in New Zealand, which kicks off at eight o'clock. We're
1:49
Stephen Main: talking at ten to eight. So uh
1:51
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
1:51
Stephen Main: beauty of these online questions is you can jump in half an hour before kickoff, lodge your written questions and then go and do something else, such I as just talk talked to you. So uh
1:59
James Thompson: Yes. Okay. Now um just to j just to be clear for our listeners, how has the boardroom blitz gone? Uh you you you've nominated for a a lot of boards again. How have you fared?
2:11
Stephen Main: Oh, look, I mean you know it's not about winning. I think I mentioned last week it was point eight percent at uh at BHP, but look, it's thirty for the month kicking off today. Uh there's that's a company called Veritas Mining in Perth. So they're they've got a Brazilian rare earths prospect and they're worth five hundred and seventy million dollars. So
2:31
Stephen Main: they've absolutely soared. They've done three capital raisings in the last eighteen months where it's been a placement to the big end of town with no offer for all the retail shareholders. And they're running a dinosaur physical meeting in Perth. So perfect target for me. So I've uh nominated for their board and I've absolutely no idea what's gonna happen at the meeting today, James, because there's no webcast. So um
2:51
Stephen Main: although I did chair I did email the chair and the CEO and the company secretary last night and said, seeing is there's no webcast, can you please read these four questions out today and maybe post a transcript to the ASX or you know tell me what happens later. So uh there'll be a lot of stories like that the next uh month is just uh annoying a lot of Perth Perth-based based miners who don't have online access
3:11
Stephen Main: and a lot of companies that that treat their retail shareholders poorly. I'll get you know one percent on average and hopefully change behaviour when uh AGMs are called and when capital raisings are done, because that's the that's the whole influencing game that this is about.
3:25
James Thompson: Yeah, yeah, fair enough. All right, we we better get on to the uh elephant in the uh in Martin Place, and that's interest rates yesterday going up. Fascinating decision, Stephen. I mean I think that the the the rate rise was well. telegraphed by the RBA certainly. But we had a dissent uh well well a split decision, six
3:45
James Thompson: six in favour, three against the rate rise. Um Michelle Bullock declared it's gonna feel like we're in recession.
3:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
3:53
James Thompson: obviously there's lots of recriminations for the government out of this. This is a bit of a uh rate hike with the lot, I think, Stephen.
4:00
Stephen Main: I did watch the uh the full press conference. yesterday, and
4:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): look,
4:05
Stephen Main: I think it's a credit to the reforms uh that we now have this uh press conference every time uh and we also have the voting transparency. So it's it's more info information and more accountability than previously. But boy, you wouldn't want to be in the governor's position. Like it was a
4:24
Stephen Main: pretty grueling press conference and there's her straight talk, she really is a straight talker. There were so many sort of quotable quotes, not quite, you know, Keatings, this is the recession we had to have, but like getting towards it. And I th I think she made the case reasonably convincingly just watching it and um but she really hates doing
4:44
Stephen Main: it. And uh but the inflation genie's out of the bottle and we've now got the what the highest interest rates in the developed world, which is uh
4:52
Stephen Main: gonna hurt mortgage holders and all the two point six trillion of household debts gonna cop the electric fence of uh the seventeenth increase we've had.
5:00
James Thompson: Yeah. I I I call this the cruelest rate hike of of the five. Uh because I think it's clear now that these hikes are not hitting th the the the in changing interest rates isn't gonna going stop to investment in the the big things in the economy. Energy transition, AI, defence, you know, it
5:20
James Thompson: w the interest rate will will have no bearing on whether those investments continue. And of course the interest rate's not going to change the price of oil in uh the Middle East or what Donald Trump decides to do next. And so all all
5:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): all
5:36
James Thompson: Bullock can do here is strangle the consumer. And and that is what's happening. I mean, we've seen it through uh the i in the last two weeks we've had quarterly sales results from Woolies and Coles. What did both of them say? It's young families who are absolutely bleeding. You know, they're the ones sending mints
5:56
James Thompson: sales through the roof. So, you know, they can make tacos and meatballs and spag bowl and try and stretch their dollar further. And then we had uh Westpac's chief executive, Anthony Miller, come out on Monday when he delivered his full year results and he said, Look, what what we're seeing is large corporates, they're absorbing this. They're
6:15
James Thompson: absorbing the cost increases. They're just passing them through. They're fine. Where where the cash flow crisis is isn't in the small end. So I I I think, you know, w we saw America we we saw the K-shaped economy as an American phenomenon. I think it's an Australian. I think it's
6:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): here.
6:32
James Thompson: Um just like political polarization used to be an American phenomenon and that's now here. So
6:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this
6:38
James Thompson: is the problem with inflation. It changes so much. Not just it's not just an economic story. It's a political story. It's a societal story. And so I I think big sort of this is a this is an inflection point. I think this is a a real moment. I don't know. Am I am I getting a bit too excited, Stephen?
6:57
Stephen Main: No, look I I I agree with you. I think it's it's phenomenal in terms of the impact it's having on on people. And I think it's also going to put pressure on for spending cuts by governments because 'Cause there is that narrative taking hold that the it's it's reckless big spending governments which I contribute are contributing to the overall increase in
7:17
Stephen Main: aggregate demand, although the governor called out the data centre investments as well yesterday as driving it. So I think I think it will bring back the pressure on productivity.
7:33
Stephen Main: Growing economy because we don't have the the shock absorbers to sort of soak it up.
7:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
7:37
Stephen Main: I think you're going to see pressure on for government spending cuts and reforms for greater productivity. I mean, you know, I don't know, in a union-dominated government, you're not going to get sort of a labour productivity, flexible, labour markets type reform program. But it's um you know, I think the pressure is really coming on the government and Albanese's Uneasy stocks are
7:57
Stephen Main: at tanking. You're gonna see Victoria probably get the Labour get wiped out in Victoria. So there is quite a backlash. against the incumbent governments as this has rolled out, and you'll see a similar backlash against Trump
8:08
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
8:09
Stephen Main: the midterms where inflation has been the biggest thing that's that's hurting him.
8:13
James Thompson: Yeah. I I I think there's another thing going on here, Stephen, that I've sort of been thinking about over the last few weeks. And actually, money cafe listeners helped me uh have sort of helped me think about this. We always get Stephen here questioning. questions about what else could the RBA do? What else could governments do to pull down inflation?
8:33
James Thompson: We've got a few today, which we'll get to in a
8:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): bit.
8:36
James Thompson: But what that says to me, I'm increasingly picking up this sentiment, and it's probably just anecdotal. But uh I noticed when Bullock was in front of Senate estimates last week, she got a question about this. What uh what other mechanisms are there? People are starting to feel that interest rate rises don't work.
8:55
James Thompson: And you're seeing this from, you know, you're seeing this from money cafe listeners, you're seeing it from comedians, you're seeing it from parliamentarians, you're seeing it from Vox Pops I saw done after the rate rise uh yesterday. I mean, I think this is a real problem for the uh for
9:10
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for
9:10
James Thompson: the RBA as well. That that the people don't believe the blunt tool works. And so that that says to me that inflation expectations
9:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are
9:19
James Thompson: are becoming unanched. Because if you don't think rate you don't think rate hikes work, then you just think we're going to be living with a higher level of inflation. I I think this is a real there's a th there's a you know there's a lot in this rate rise story, but this is one of the big things. I wonder if Michelle Bullock and her team are sitting back thinking, geez we're we're losing the we're sort
9:39
James Thompson: of losing our social license here.
9:41
Stephen Main: Well I think they're losing the social license, but they're also attempting to smash inflation. Like they're really trying to not let inflation expectations get baked in. And you know, y you get these sort of you know endless wage claims and everyone just passing on and it just it it then gets baked in. So she's trying to break that cycle and it's tough love.
10:01
Stephen Main: But um you know the problem is that the unintended consequences, I mean, you know, the house prices, and it's already the fastest drop in in house prices we've seen. She said in her conference yesterday that it's the biggest drop in applications for investment loans for housing that we've we've ever seen, because that's the combination of the tax changes with negative gearing engineering
10:21
Stephen Main: and the rising interest rates. rate. So
10:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
10:24
Stephen Main: just think it's that perfect storm of you know four. falling house prices, rising interest rates. Um and uh I mean look you had a bit of a union protest organized by the ACTU out the front of the uh the RBA last week. You're getting a little bit of jaw boning going on with even Albanese and the Labor heavies talking about
10:44
Stephen Main: it's a blunt Month instrument, it's too much. But um you know and three and three directors have voted against the increase. So Michelle Bullock, it's a it's a difficult mandate she's juggling.
10:55
James Thompson: Yeah, and the first thing Chalmers mentions at his press conference is the three dissenters. As if to say, well, you know, uh that they're on the side of the angels. I mean that that's dangerous territory for him too. But
11:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
11:07
James Thompson: anyway, Stephen, there's th you know, this will be the s this is the story. Inflation changes everything and and it's the big story. Um one thing it's not changing too much is bank results. Although uh so this week we had uh on on Monday ANZ's four-year results, on Thursday we've got NABs
11:26
James Thompson: on Friday. We get half-year results from Macquarie, and then next Monday we get the four-year results from AZ. I mean, if you look at the headline numbers, Stephen, basically revenue growth, none. Earnings growth, none. Dividend growth, none. And yet the uh and and obviously the the house price story completely
11:46
James Thompson: unraveling, and yet bank share prices haven't moved too much.
11:49
Stephen Main: I think this is the great untold story, and I I think this is where the pressure should be getting applied, is that if you look at the combined market cap of the big five banks today, it's seven $746 hundred and forty six billion billion, dollars or or ten times the combined market caps of Coles and Woolies. So Coles and Woolies are worth
12:09
Stephen Main: $77.8 billion. The big five are worth $746 billion. So given that it is actually the banks themselves that will be it administering the lethal shock therapy on mortgage uh holders by putting up the interest rates, I I'll be amazed if there isn't a bigger backlash against the banks
12:29
Stephen Main: for these record profits and these very, very stoically high share prices. I mean Commonwealth Bank's worth two seventy six billion, A and Z one twenty two billion, Westback and now both hundred and twenty seven billion and Macquarie shares are at you know two hundred and fifty four dollars and it's worth ninety six billion. million. So
12:46
Stephen Main: how is that sustainable in a cost of living crisis where everyone everyone's getting squeezed with rising interest rates? I mean, I look at my relationship with Combank, and you know, they're paying me what, half a per cent on the little tiny bit of money I've got in my Commonwealth Direct Investment account, and they're slugging me ten percent on the margin line. That's a heck of
13:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a mar
13:04
Stephen Main: it's a heck of an interest margin on me. Yes.
13:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
13:07
Stephen Main: then the the credit card it's twenty percent with NAB. And where's where is the consumer movement saying where where are the politicians saying give consumers a rest, you banks? You're making 40 billion a year pre-tax, no probs,
13:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
13:20
Stephen Main: everyone's hurting. It's time to give a bit back.
13:22
James Thompson: Yeah, I I'm just not entirely sure what that what giving a bit back looks like though, Stephen. I mean,
13:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): their
13:28
James Thompson: their profit margins uh have been smacked. I mean, look at the look at the net interest margin, which is the difference between
13:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
13:34
James Thompson: mu the interest rate that banks uh lend at and and they uh borrow at from depositors. I mean, they've been falling for 35 years. Competition's almost crazy. No one makes money out of a mortgage anymore. So so so what what do you think giving back looks like?
13:53
Stephen Main: Oh, I think it it would be a treasurer jaw boning saying, I can't understand how anyone can can be charging uh twenty 20% percent on credit card balances for people who are struggling to pay the mortgage. I'm going to legislate to say that the maximum credit card interest rate is 15%. You know, that sort of you know, governments have enormous power over banks if
14:13
Stephen Main: they choose to use it from a regulatory sense because they're licensed. But you look at what the supermarkets get put through. You know, the ACCC calling on the ACC ACLC to inquire, politicians attending before the politicians, I would argue that the supermarkets. that supermarkets are not making anything like super profits, but get are getting five times the attention
14:33
Stephen Main: from the political classes over cost of living than the banks. So I'm just my prediction is I think you will see that the you know forget about the pylons on KPMG. I think you'll see that in this sort of pressure environment, I'm very surprised if we don't see a backlash against the the banks, particularly after all their profits have dropped over the you know,
14:53
Stephen Main: with well by next Monday it's all done and dusted and everyone will be going, up go the interest rates and there go the forty billion another forty billion in profits for the banks, which are worth seven hundred and forty six billion dollars. Thanks for coming.
15:03
James Thompson: Yeah, yeah. I I I I'm not so sure about that one, but but I I I do see where you're coming from and and I think this is gonna going to get pretty politically sticky for lots of different sectors. You mentioned the uh the the supermarket giants, Steven. Uh are you Team Woolworths or Team Coles or do you mix and match?
15:22
Stephen Main: I'm uh currently mainly shopping at Coles. I do Coles on Philip Ireland and I do Woolworths in the city actually. So it's just a case of uh I've
15:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): got sort
15:33
Stephen Main: of two homes where you're sort of uh locally shopping. I I wasn't taken in by the the whooshy
15:46
Stephen Main: I mean a couple of percentage points difference in growth is this is just uh for a cozy duopoly which normally move in tandem, this was uh a shock deviation and possibly the most successful consumer For promotion by any supermarket ever in Australia.
16:00
James Thompson: Yes, for for those who who who
16:03
James Thompson: don't have kids or grandkids or or or or nieces or nephews or whatever, the USI's promotion that Coles ran uh Woolworths ran, I should say, at the start of the year, uh, you know, turbocharged their or or sorry, you the start of the financial year really turbocharged their sales growth. Uh and that's helped them recover from a pretty tough period. You know, it's it's
16:23
James Thompson: not too long ago that, you know, the former CEO, Brad Banducci. sort of left in you know pr pretty disappointing circumstances. Uh Woolworths was really struggling in that whole price gouging fuel. Um a and Amanda Bardwell, the the CEO there has really got the place fiery and turned things around. And over at Coles, Leah
16:43
James Thompson: Wickett, the CEO there is is uh uh after a great run uh of uh capitalizing on Woolies woolly's misery is now finding herself under pressure. She's launched a big discounting campaign heading into Christmas. You know, it it feels like a bit of an old fashioned grocery price war which is good for consumers. But
17:03
James Thompson: yeah, it it it does show the the you know the the the the momentum in in a in a duopoly as you say although though the supermarket giants hate that word but the momentum can actually shift pretty quickly.
17:15
Stephen Main: I'd love to see a price war uh break out amongst the banks. I guess that's my point. I
17:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean
17:19
Stephen Main: I I've never seen I mean Cole's shares fell ten percent in one day last week. I mean that that that is a shock. I mean that's uh one it's an argument about continuous disclosure is you you should never have a share price ideally that jerks around that much because you should the market should be fully informed and and not but that that did say
17:39
Stephen Main: that they are giving back to the consumer and sacrificing some profits and they've suffered on the competitive uh battlefield with the with the USies. But I mean were you surprised by that ten percent tumble? I mean you've you know you've seen Woolley's market cap is down to what twenty uh no, Wooly's is at forty nine billion now and Coles is down to twenty eight point six. So
17:59
Stephen Main: that's quite a big
18:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
18:01
Stephen Main: know, quite a big uh twenty one billion dollar difference in the value of the big two. Um uh you don't normally see them uh uh such disparity in their valuations do you?
18:13
James Thompson: Yeah I I wasn't surprised by the the the size of the fall. I I I think actually these falls are par for the course in in in these days. Um
18:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): th
18:22
James Thompson: the the gone are the days where you'd you know
18:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
18:25
James Thompson: ha have a you know one or two percent fall on a bit of bad news. Now ten, twenty I mean well one day we saw CSL earlier this year fall thirty percent in a day.
18:37
Stephen Main: Cochlear did forty percent in
18:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): one day.
18:40
Stephen Main: So I actually asked that question at the at the West Farmers A Gm last week. I said, Well look uh Michael Cheney, it's your it's your farewell meeting. Ken McKenzie's uh taken over, although you're not letting him up on the stage, you're making the new chairs sit down there in the front row. And look, the stock's fallen four percent today on AGM Day. Last year it fell seven percent on AGM
19:00
Stephen Main: Day. Can Ken McKenzie please make a promise that he'll try to stop the share price jerking around when he deboes next year? B and then Cheney sort of sneered, Oh, Ken, Ten uh or think you're gonna promise not to move the share price by one per percent. cent. And I guess my point was that you never want to see these things, but we are seeing them more than ever.
19:18
James Thompson: We are.
19:19
Stephen Main: So there's uh those two things are true. Um but uh yeah, ten percent. Anything into above ten percent, I still think there's an issue around uh continuous disclosure, albeit the machine hedge fund traders, you know, when the pylon is on, you can get these massive moves, which if you look at Cochlear and and CSL.
19:39
Stephen Main: have proved to be enormous buying opportunities. If you bought in on those cataclysm days, you know, you you've done very well, and maybe that's the trade.
19:47
James Thompson: Yeah, no, indeed. Uh all right, Stephen, we better get to some questions, I reckon. And before we do that, here's a word from our sponsor.
19:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): When was the last time you checked what you're paying for
19:56
Stephen Main: life insurance? You could be missing out on savings. Invest InvestSmart Smart can help you compare quotes from leading insurance. insurers to find a better deal. Already covered? With InvestSmart Cashback, you could get money back each year from commissions on your existing policy without changing your cover. Why pay more than you need to? Visit
20:15
Stephen Main: investsmart.com.au forward slash life hyphen insurance. Terms and conditions apply.
20:22
James Thompson: Okay, Steven, Stephen. uh, it's my turn to give the general advice warning. Please don't take anything we say seriously. No, that's not quite it. Uh, please don't say take anything we say as personal advice. General advice only, and often uninformed general advice, but we're doing our best. First questions for you, Stephen, from Richard in prison. He
20:41
James Thompson: says, Stephen, your tireless shareholder advocacy has inspired me to attend my first Australian Retirement Trust annual members meeting and ask a question.
20:51
James Thompson: I'm seven years from retirement, one of an estimated two point five million Australians expected to move from accumulation into retirement over the next decade. Yet the performance test doesn't apply to de-accumulation retire or retirement products. Treasury's deferred extending it to until at least twenty twenty eight. Funds are mostly judged on whether they have a plan a
21:11
James Thompson: retirement income strategy, not on whether it works. So Richard's plan question is: until retirement products are performance tested, what is what measures does the ART board use to judge whether its retirement income strategy is improving member outcomes and will you publish them? And Richard asks you, Stephen, how would you sharpen this
21:31
James Thompson: question? And what's the follow-up if you get a scripted answer?
21:34
Stephen Main: I think it's a great question. The trick
21:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is uh question.
21:37
Stephen Main: It's a great question. The problem is Richard, that that when you when you do put in the question in advance, you will get a script written by PR. So it's much better if you can front them on the day and not let them know this is coming. And then, you know, the follow up question would be, you know, well it did you lobby against um tr Treasury
21:57
Stephen Main: introducing performance tests earlier and then get into a it. it's an interesting discussion. I mean the the performance test for for for our listeners is basically that you've got to focus on making as much money as possible and maximizing the investment returns during the accumulation phase. But because it's more complicated in the decumulation phase, like you've got issues
22:17
Stephen Main: such as liquidity, not running out of money, being able to access the funds, there's a whole bunch of sort of non-financial metrics when you're actually spending the money as opposed to investing the money.
22:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
22:29
Stephen Main: I frankly think it's disappointing that Treasury has delayed putting some more stringent performance tests. And as 1.4 million members have already got $500 billion in these APRA-regulated accounts that are caught up with the tied up in the accumulation of retirement products, it's going to become more and more of a focus. And 2028 is a
22:49
Stephen Main: long time to wait for. performance tests.
22:52
James Thompson: Yeah, I reckon there's enough problems with the current performance test, frankly. Uh I I I get the idea of the performance test. You want to see how, you know, see if you can compare apples with apples. But what the performance test has done, because it uses its uh, you know, uh a benchmark, which is basically a share market benchmark or or uh,
23:11
James Thompson: you know, uh uh
23:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
23:13
James Thompson: similar to a share market benchmark. to judge all the
23:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): super
23:16
James Thompson: funds, guess what? All the super funds start doing the same things because no one wants to get too far away from the benchmark.
23:22
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
23:23
James Thompson: that's fine now. I wonder whether it'll be fine if uh if there's a uh a correction.
23:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
23:30
James Thompson: so yes, I I think these performance tests are problematic, but I think uh Richard's question's a good one. What is art what is art looking for?
23:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
23:38
James Thompson: uh and how should it help members uh judge that so good luck Richard.
23:42
Stephen Main: Yes, more people should do this. I I've never really I've never been to an industry fund AGM. I'd love to be able to love to go and uh because they're so powerful and they're increasingly powerful. Um they really matter in the in the economy.
23:55
James Thompson: Relatively new things. Um
23:57
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
23:57
James Thompson: yeah I I think they are becoming more important for the super funds too which is good. I mean
24:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah
24:02
James Thompson: yeah as you say, that they're they're they're they're bigger than companies and and often
24:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they're they're
24:08
James Thompson: huge.
24:11
James Thompson: I
24:11
Stephen Main: agree. I'll give you an example. Like at this chorus AGM in New Zealand that's on literally right now. I mean, it's the NBN of New Zealand with the old copper network fl thrown in. So it was demerged Emerged out of the old Telecom New Zealand in 2011. And they're passing it a constitutional change. this morning that anyone can buy more than 10% without the government say
24:31
Stephen Main: so. So they they've still got CSL style, you know, constitutional and legislative restrictions on maximum shareholders in chorus. And they're getting rid of all that today so they're free. So I had a look at their share register. I was going to say, oh, you know who? And guess who their largest shareholder is? Unisuper with 18.5%. So the key Kiwi government
24:51
Stephen Main: has already said UniSuper can buy more than ten percent of the NBN of New Zealand. And so my whole issue is, you know, they still won't put up a remuneration report vote in New Zealand. And I I would love to ask Unisuper why aren't you forcing them to put up a remuneration report vote? You own eight and a half percent. Use your power. I've never heard from
25:11
Stephen Main: an industry fund in 25 twenty five years of activism where they've actually contacted. me directly and said, Hey, we've got a problem over here, do you want to raise this at the A GM? They just do it all through the proxy advisors. So I would love to see industry funds step up and be more public, ask questions at AGMs, be more prominent because they're enormously powerful and influential and uh you
25:31
Stephen Main: get one little members meeting a year, which is sort of a voluntary exercise and it's not even legally required.
25:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
25:37
James Thompson: we've got Richard on the front line, so that's a stuff. start.
25:39
Stephen Main: We have. Now Brad says we keep hearing the government needs to cut spending. Mark Burrers is even doing punching bag stunts about it, but what would they actually cut? This article from the ABC makes me think there isn't an obvious answer. Is the only hope
25:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
25:52
Stephen Main: Iran war ends and rate rises cuts household spending soon? I mean Alan and I have had a little bit of a what would you cut if you were government for a day? I mean, you know Alan I think mentioned defence, I mentioned NDIS and I think infrastructure spending, including at the state level, snowy and northeast link, etcetera, et cetera. But
26:12
Stephen Main: uh
26:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I don't know,
26:13
Stephen Main: if you were government
26:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for a day, what would you cut, James?
26:16
James Thompson: Well, I I mean I think uh uh y you would do what the government had tried to do, um and and that is bring back the NDIS back into line, eliminate the waste out of it. so it gets the best bank uh for its buck for all the participants. I think that's the most important uh thing that that it does serve the participants better
26:35
James Thompson: um and and and and the taxpayer as well. So I think that's the place to start. Now we've we had this week the chief actuary from the government uh writing to Treasury saying, uh, I don't believe the assumptions you've made about cutting NDIS spending. So that says to me it's actually pretty hard to do when you create this giant machine. Um,
26:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
26:56
James Thompson: know, I I I I I wonder if there's a
26:59
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh uh
27:00
James Thompson: ways to create savings by digitizing more of the public service across all levels. Um, Stephen, I put it to you as a former counsellor, councillor, do do we need to get rid of a and and a former state government advisor, do we need to get rid of a level of government? Is that the best way to cut government spin?
27:17
Stephen Main: Well, this is a great misnomer, James, is people think we have three levels of government and we don't. We actually have two because councils, local governments, are entirely the creation of the states. They are simply the local management authority, completely controlled and organized by the states. And as Jeff Kennett showed, you can sack every councillor in the state,
27:37
Stephen Main: you can change the boundaries. and there are no councils in Canberra, which is why Canberra is a bit of a monoculture, because you don't have any local councils competing and providing a bit of a bit of better festivals or better parks and gardens and libraries. So I don't think the old abolish all councils uh
27:57
Stephen Main: is the solution. But I I do think Michelle Bullock called out um state spending yesterday. I do think some of the reckless in debt funded infrastructure spending by the states has contributed to sort of rising building costs and soaking up all the tradies and that sort of stuff. So I do think there's something to
28:17
Stephen Main: be said. Because you know I remember when when Dan Andrews got elected, Victoria's Capital Works budget was four and a half billion a year. Now it's 20 twenty billion a year.
28:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know
28:25
Stephen Main: that is a truck truckload of debt-funded infrastructure spending. And if you believe the press and the Royal Commissions, you know, quite a lot got siphoned off by crooks and bikey gangs and the like. So uh I think
28:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
28:36
Stephen Main: productivity on infrastructure spending and efficiency and not spending so much would be a big big place I'd focus on if I was trying to balance the books.
28:43
James Thompson: And perhaps it's a it's a change in attitude as much as anything too, to Stephen. Like if if you think about the the Iran war hits the government immediately rushes out. Instead of letting that price signal flow through to the Australian punter, like, oh, get it, that's painful. We use taxpayer money to cut the fuel excise.
29:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
29:03
James Thompson: mean, there's a great example.
29:09
James Thompson: hit uh to in in inflation
29:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
29:12
James Thompson: that would have that would, you
29:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
29:13
James Thompson: the demand hit would have helped bring. to inflation down instead we just you know used the credit card to to subsidize our fuel costs for a while I mean that's a great example to me of just dumb governments.
29:26
Stephen Main: Yeah and
29:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): these
29:26
Stephen Main: things have these things have fallen away now like you've got less energy uh household power bill subsidies as well
29:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and that
29:33
Stephen Main: and she mentioned it yesterday that that actually is contributing to to the you know the the next read on inflation is gonna is going to be gonna be high, she said, because uh we're cycling through the previous uh electricity and gas household subsidies that have now come off. So
29:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're
29:46
Stephen Main: right, we probably they probably overplayed their hands too early with all these subsidies and now they're
29:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they're
29:52
Stephen Main: trying to wind it back, and that is actually causing, you know, more pressure on household spending when people are copying it from rising rates as well. So uh
30:00
James Thompson: Okay.
30:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Anyway now
30:02
Stephen Main: Alex I'm gonna skip ahead from Alex and I'm gonna go to Nick uh Mick over the page with a with a one sentence question. Will the drop in iron ore be what we need to get inflation in check? Now I don't think there's a connection between the iron ore price and inflation unless you're maybe talking directly about steel costs.
30:22
Stephen Main: But with iron ore Alan uh James it's all about Australia's balance sheet and wealth. Because you know, we export what is it, $150 billion worth a year, and the fact
30:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
30:31
Stephen Main: price has crept back above 90 bucks. And frankly,
30:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as a
30:36
Stephen Main: nation, we want a high iron ore price, don't we?
30:39
James Thompson: Well I I guess the iron ore price falling would mean less uh government less revenue for governments to spend. So maybe there's a sort of very indirect uh influence on in in inflation yet there, but mainly it's a it's an overseas story. And I think uh Stephen's right, you know the the last thing the the budget
30:59
James Thompson: needs at the moment is a big drop in the iron ore price that would smash government revenues at exactly that.
31:04
Stephen Main: Well, just like at the state level, uh I mean WA and and iron ore royalties to one side, the worst thing that can happen to state budgets is a slowdown in the housing market, both in a volume and price level. So because this has now happened, the the states are literally billions of dollars out of pocket on what they were forecasting
31:24
Stephen Main: in property taxes and stamp duty on land transactions being the biggest one of all.
31:30
James Thompson: Yeah. Now I just want to collect a few questions here, Stephen, because it it goes to what I was saying about you know people trying to find different ways to to raise rights. to hit inflation other than rates. Katrina says is there something we could do about the big bank's deposit guarantee or the big bank's implicit too big to fail backing that
31:50
James Thompson: could be redirected to help people, particularly young people, perhaps a higher bank levy to fund some rate relief. Alex suggests is there something we could do i in terms of shifting superannuation contributions? cont
32:03
James Thompson: to take a bit of heat out of the uh uh economy. Richard suggests going to long-term mortgages, 20 to 25 to 30 years. Well he doesn't suggest that. He says what are the obstacles to doing that in Australia? And then Nick says, How about i if the RBA's only got one blunt weapon? Why don't they use it
32:23
James Thompson: aggressively? I.e. Jack rates up by one percent. per cent uh to uh really send a message to the economy when required. I've put it I've put a few things together there. Um
32:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): let's start with the
32:35
Stephen Main: let's start with the last one. Like why why do we have these twenty five basis point changes? And they're not even round numbers change. I
32:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean we've
32:43
Stephen Main: gone to four point eight five. And I I looked into this and the last time we had a non non-25 twenty five basis point change was back in mid-2022, and we had a couple of consecutive half percentage point or 50 basis point changes because they were turbocharging the uh post-COVID let's get the rates back to a normal
33:03
Stephen Main: level. But I I you know I don't understand why it's only twenty-five, why it couldn't be fifteen or thirty-five thirty five or fifty, and I frankly it annoys me that we've got these uh non-round non numbers. round And I think the next move should be maybe fifteen basis point to a good even five.
33:19
James Thompson: Okay, right. Yep. Get us back to round numbers. Um all right, well let's go through a few of these. Um the well, I think you would probably canvass the the the bank levy. Uh
33:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
33:31
Stephen Main: can't go up even more. I mean, they're already paying two billion a year more, and they're already the biggest tax payers.
33:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But So I
33:38
Stephen Main: I I don't agree with extra taxes on banks.
33:41
James Thompson: Really careful about financial stability there too. Like the the banks are
33:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
33:46
James Thompson: yeah I mean I I think we uh and I I know Stephen's made the argument today that the banks are sort of big profit centres. I I I actually think that the the model of banking is you know it uh it might might be at a little bit of a turning point. It i it's not the business it was a few years ago. and you just need to d don't look so much at the bank
34:05
James Thompson: profits and uh share prices. Just look at the sort of profit growth. But banks have going been going sideways for a number of years. I I think that continues.
34:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
34:15
James Thompson: superannuation contributions uh as an attempt to slow the economy.
34:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
34:21
James Thompson: well, I I think this is a this is interesting territory because at the moment, Stephen, I I think there's actually a bit of a pushback about superannuation guarantee going to twelve percent. Um I think people are feeling and and Peter Costello said it the other day, you know, it's great that I'm gonna have a great retirement, but does that mean I have to struggle at the moment? Um
34:41
James Thompson: so I I'm not sure there'd be a lot of popular support for that. I don't know.
34:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
34:45
Stephen Main: then then there's the question of the GST, uh but I just think I come back to the practical side. of things, is I just don't think it's practical to play around with the super guarantee or the GST, and they're the two things that get mentioned the most, or some sort of a bank super levy. I just think you've got to bring it back to the
35:05
Stephen Main: overall mandate of the governments. And Michelle Bullock is making it clear government stop running massive deficits, debt funded deficits, which are overheating the economy. You choose how you change it, and you can argue the the budget, the recent May budget, was actually a tax grab that is taking money out of the economy.
35:25
Stephen Main: Because there's two ways you can you can balance your books you can put taxes up or you can cut spending. We we tend to mainly be talking about cutting spending, but but that was actually a tax grab which hit the boomers and has slowed the economy. and it's cause has tanked house prices. And a lot of people are bleating about it, but that actually was also a
35:45
Stephen Main: slow the economy top of the cycle sort of measure. I'm not endorsing it, but you know, it that's why I think leave it to the governments and overall they've got to fix their in structural budget Sure deficits, and you can do that by taxing or cutting.
36:00
James Thompson: I think the the the other thing,
36:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
36:02
James Thompson: Michelle Bullock was very strong on the uh this idea yesterday that independence both works both ways. I don't tell the government what to do, they don't tell me what to do. It's a pretty good system. All of these suggestions we've had: GST, superannuation contributions, bank levies, they all get put in the hands of elected politicians. Now that m
36:22
James Thompson: maybe that's a a better way to do it, where that th those are the people we vote for. But just imagine the next election, Stephen. We would have different political parties promising to do different things with the GST and with super contributions and with the bank levy. Now, like, is that where we want to get to? That that you you get sort
36:42
James Thompson: of no stability, you get an element of sovereign risk. You know, I uh I we do have to, you know, the the tool is blunt. and the system is simple, but but there there is a certain power in that, I think.
36:54
Stephen Main: Yeah, but I do think we are seeing a bit of balance your books, the spending cuts coming back from the era of just unlimited money printing and endless public uh d deficits and you can just borrow endlessly. It's I think that era is coming to an end and the and the old old-fashioned fashioned be responsible financial manager, I think that will prevail.
37:14
Stephen Main: in Victoria. And you'll see Jess Wilson and the Liberals down here doing a bit of good old-fashioned liberal sort of belt tightening austerity, uh being a bit more responsible. Now let's finish off with a couple of AI questions which I'll put together. So Jeff from
37:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Newcastle.
37:28
James Thompson: Let's go with Jeff. Yeah, it's a crap.
37:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
37:30
Stephen Main: he talks about the AI agents uh hacking into the databases. Why isn't anyone suing the parent company for damages if someone leaves their handbrake off and their youth totals my car, I expect compensation and probably a penalty for the n negligence. So when OpenAI hacked Medicare and they sent an email 84 days later and eventually an apology, weren't they negligent to launch
37:50
Stephen Main: a defective product without adequate safeguards? Class action time, anyone. Now, I guess they're just so big, strong, tough, and scary. Global big tech that uh
38:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
38:02
Stephen Main: who's got the resources and the politicians aren't prepared to take them on, particularly, although you know the backlash against data centres is pretty phenomenal globally at the moment.
38:10
James Thompson: Yeah, it it's funny Jeff should ask that. I mean, it it's actually canvassed in the Anthropic prospectus, which is doing the rounds at the moment. And what Anthropic has uh said is that there is not enough insurance in the world to insure Anthropic against exactly those types of legal. claims that uh Jeff refers to. So I I I don't know
38:30
James Thompson: if if the risk is totally uninsurable, does it cease to become who whose risk is it? Who carries the risk? I I think we're I think Jeff has hit on a really important point, and I have no idea how this plays out. I I confess.
38:44
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
38:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): M
38:46
James Thompson: I suspect though that this is part of
38:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this
38:49
James Thompson: is part of the regulatory backlash. that will come for AI.
38:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
38:53
James Thompson: there'll be there will be attempts in the next five years to stuff the genie back in the bottle and it will be interesting to see if it can be done. Whether that's related to hits to jobs, to things like illegal liability, uh to data center regulation. Um I I think the
39:13
James Thompson: the regulatory mutiny is coming. And I
39:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think
39:17
James Thompson: the interesting question is will it be too late? And
39:20
Stephen Main: I was interested that Michelle Bullock yesterday said we haven't yet seen the productivity benefits of AI in driving prices down. All we're seeing is the data center bill, you know, causing inflation. So I was surprised to say she So called it out. And I'll just finish off with one you always hear nice things at AGMs, one little anecdote on how AI is has been deployed. So at the
39:39
Stephen Main: Dream World AGM yesterday, so it's owned by a company called Coast Entertainment, the the CEO Greg Young said, I've been in in in theme parks for twenty years and I thought I was pretty good at predicting our Saturday attendances. But I've got eighty metrics that we feed into AI, you know, the flights, the school holidays, the weather, all these sort of things,
39:59
Stephen Main: and every week they get within five percent of
40:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the eye.
40:03
Stephen Main: our Saturday attendance numbers at Dream World. So the AI beast is fantastic at telling us how to roster for a Saturday uh at Dreamworld. And I thought that's a nice little use of of AI. Um on the positive, it says helping management manage the numbers and crowds coming into Dreamworld each week on the Gold Coast.
40:21
James Thompson: Yeah, it's interesting, isn't it?
40:25
James Thompson: Uh Stephen says Well, who was doing it before and were they pretty good at it as well?
40:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well the CEO was saying,
40:33
Stephen Main: I thought
40:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
40:33
Stephen Main: was pretty good, but I
40:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): wasn't I'm
40:34
Stephen Main: nowhere near as good as the machine.
40:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So um
40:37
James Thompson: that that's the sort of anecdotal evidence that we'll I guess we need to see because um it'll pro it it will improve productivity. But of course, Stephen the answer to that is that the team of people who are doing that rostering, they'll be reduced. from 10 to 2.
40:55
James Thompson: And you can deal with some other consequences there anyway. But that's the uh that's the very interesting world we're living in. Thanks for listening to the uh um at this episode of the Money Cafe. I'll be back next week with Stephen Steven, while Alan's still convalescing. All the best, Alan. So send in a question and we'll answer it together. You And can email. the
41:15
James Thompson: moneycafe at intelligentinvestor.com.au. Please keep the questions coming. Until then, I'm James Thompson, senior shuntly columnist at the Australian Financial Review.
41:24
Stephen Main: I'm Stephen May, and look forward to talking to you next week.
41:26
James Thompson: Talk to you soon.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from The Money Café with Alan Kohler

All insights