Lend Hoping Nothing Podcast Episode 37: Three Principles of Loss & Lucrum Cessans
Episode discussion: Michael Humphreys critiques the theological and logical foundations of lucrum cessans as a justification for interest
Speakers’ claims: Michael Humphreys examines the Catholic theological concept of lucrum cessans (lost profit) as an extrinsic title for charging interest. He traces its origins to Aquinas and Cajetan, arguing that later scholastics logically conflated restitution, indemnity, and sales principles. Humphreys contends that hoped-for profit is not actual wealth and that debt does not constitute a separate economic good. He concludes that lucrum cessans is invalid for voluntary loans because it misapplies the logic of indemnity and sales.
Catholic TheologyUsuryScholasticism
44 min2 assets12 claims to verify