Michael Humphreys critiques the theological and logical foundations of lucrum cessans as a justification for interest
Summary
Michael Humphreys examines the Catholic theological concept of lucrum cessans (lost profit) as an extrinsic title for charging interest. He traces its origins to Aquinas and Cajetan, arguing that later scholastics logically conflated restitution, indemnity, and sales principles. Humphreys contends that hoped-for profit is not actual wealth and that debt does not constitute a separate economic good. He concludes that lucrum cessans is invalid for voluntary loans because it misapplies the logic of indemnity and sales.
Key takeaways
- 1 Loans are granted for the borrower's sake to restore the lender to their own position, not to generate profit for the lender.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 36:36
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 1:51
Introduction to Lucrum Cessans and Intrinsic Titles
Speaker Michael Humphreys introduces the concept of Lucrum Cessans (profit ceasing) as an 'extrinsic title' in Catholic usury theory. He explains that while leases have an intrinsic title to profit (selling the use of goods), mutuum loans do not, requiring extrinsic justifications for interest.
- 1:51 – 5:12
Extrinsic Titles and Historical Development
The speaker details the development of 'extrinsic titles' from the mid-18th century, citing Pope Benedict XIV and Charles René Billard. He notes that Billard rejected titles based on loan duration as intrinsic, while accepting others like damnum emergens and lucrum cessans.
- 5:12 – 8:25
List of Extrinsic Titles
Humphreys lists accepted extrinsic titles: damnum emergens (actual loss), lucrum cessans (lost hope of profit), periculum sortis (risk of non-repayment), civil title (state law), and poena conventionalis (late fees). He expresses skepticism toward the civil title and periculum sortis.
- 8:25 – 13:43
Aquinas on Restitution and Indemnity
The speaker traces lucrum cessans to Aquinas, who grounded it in restitution for delayed debtors. Aquinas allowed indemnity for avoided losses but prohibited selling hoped-for profit in voluntary contracts, establishing that one cannot sell what one does not possess.
- 13:43 – 22:12
Cajetan's Theory and Criticism
Cajetan attempted to ground lucrum cessans in restitution and the 'potency of money,' arguing that money prepared for trade is more valuable. Humphreys criticizes Cajetan's exception for charitable loans as unjustified and notes criticism from DeSoto and Navarrus.
- 22:12 – 25:19
Shift from Restitution to Sale
Later scholastics shifted the basis of lucrum cessans from restitution to sale, treating hoped-for gain as an actually possessed good. Humphreys identifies this as a break in logic, preferring to view it as 'profit delayed' rather than profit forgone.
- 25:19 – 30:15
Three Principles of Loss
The speaker proposes three distinct principles: 1) Restitution for delayed repayment (profit delayed); 2) Damnum emergens for actual losses caused by delay; and 3) Indemnity contracts to avoid future losses, analogous to shipping costs in sales.
- 30:15 – 31:35
Distinction between indemnity, restitution, and sales logic
The speaker distinguishes indemnity, which covers actual loss to prevent disadvantage, from sales, which are for mutual benefit. He argues that indemnity is specific to loans to ensure the lender is not at a loss, whereas sales allow for charging more to cover disadvantages.
- 31:35 – 33:49
Critique of 'Lucrum Cessans' and expected profit as wealth
The speaker argues that 'hoped-for gain' is not actual wealth possessed, citing Eugene von Bohm-Bawerk. He critiques financial markets for treating expected gains as real wealth, noting that market crashes wipe accounting value but not physical assets like NVIDIA factories or Tesla cars.
- 33:49 – 40:27
Debt and shares as rights attached to real goods, not separate goods
The speaker asserts that debt and shares are rights attached to the underlying company (the real economic good), not separate goods themselves. He warns against counting debt as a new good, which would absurdly imply everyone should maximize debt to increase economic goods.
- 40:27 – 42:45
Historical expansion of 'Lucrum Cessans' by later Scholastics
The speaker claims Cajetan conflated restitution and indemnity into a single principle of loss. He argues later Scholastics expanded this to include any disadvantage, citing Alphonsus Liguori as arguing that one can charge interest even without intending to trade or having money at risk.
- 42:45 – 44:18
Conclusion on voluntary loans and 'Lucrum Cessans'
The speaker concludes that 'Lucrum Cessans' does not apply to voluntary loans or voluntary indemnity. He emphasizes distinguishing between loss to be restored, loss to be indemnified, and loss due to disadvantage, each arising from separate principles.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| NVIDIANVDA | equity | neutral | You know, recently just with NVIDIA, the NVIDIA um stock, you know, crashed |
| TeslaTSLA | equity | neutral | or with Tesla or a hundred other things, is that it's this and then you get headlines of like, oh a million a million dollars worth of of value was wiped from the market. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Lucrum cessans is an 'extrinsic title' used in Catholic usury theory to justify profit from loans that lack intrinsic titles to profit.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·0:37
How to verify: Primary source: Catholic theological texts on usury, specifically works discussing 'extrinsic titles' such as those by Pope Benedict XIV or Charles René Billard. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Pope Benedict XIV discussed extrinsic titles in his encyclical 'Vix Pervenit'.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·3:28
How to verify: Primary source: Encyclical 'Vix Pervenit' (1745) by Pope Benedict XIV, available on the Vatican website or SEC-equivalent religious archives. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceCharles René Billard argued against titles based on loan duration as intrinsic titles.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·4:15
How to verify: Primary source: Works by Charles René Billard on usury, such as 'De Usu Pecuniae' or commentaries on the Summa Theologica. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Elizabeth Anscombe called the title of periculum sortis a 'monstrosity'.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·6:13
How to verify: Primary source: G.E.M. Anscombe's writings on Catholic moral theology, specifically her critiques of usury theory. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Aquinas addressed indemnity in Question 78, Article 2 of the Summa Theologica.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·11:13
How to verify: Primary source: Summa Theologica, II-II, Q. 78, Art. 2, available on the Vatican website or academic theological databases. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Cajetan argued that money prepared for trade has greater 'potency' for profit than idle money.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·16:39
How to verify: Primary source: Cardinal Cajetan's commentary on the Summa Theologica, specifically on usury and restitution. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A 17th-century instruction from the Propaganda Fide condemned the civil title, citing the Council of Vienne.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·7:18
How to verify: Primary source: Decrees of the Congregation for the Propagation of the Faith (Propaganda Fide) from the 17th century, referencing the Council of Vienne (1311-1312). For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
DeSoto criticized Cajetan's exception for charitable loans as unjustified.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·20:25
How to verify: Primary source: Michael DeSoto's 'The Economics of the Catholic Church' or related academic critiques of Cajetan's usury theory. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Eugene von Bohm-Bawerk distinguishes between actual wealth and the accounting valuation of hoped-for gain.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·32:19
How to verify: Search for Eugene von Bohm-Bawerk's economic writings, specifically his theory of capital and interest, in academic databases or his published works like 'Capital and Interest'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Alphonsus Liguori argued that one can take lucrum cessans even without an effectual work to trade.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·41:16
How to verify: Consult Alphonsus Liguori's moral theology texts, such as 'Theologia Moralis', for sections on usury and lucrum cessans. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Cajetan conflated the principles of restitution and indemnity into a single principle of loss.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·40:27
How to verify: Review Thomas Cajetan's commentary on the Summa Theologica (specifically the Secunda Secundae, Question 78) regarding usury and just price. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
NVIDIA stock recently crashed, wiping millions in market value.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·32:51
How to verify: Check NVIDIA Corporation (NVDA) stock price history on financial data providers like Yahoo Finance or Bloomberg for significant drops between 2026-08-16 and 2026-11-16. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceDo your own research
- Read Thomas Aquinas' Summa Theologica, specifically the section on usury (Part II-II, Question 78) to understand the original restitution-based arguments.
- Review Cajetan's commentary on the Summa Theologica to see how he expanded the concept of lucrum cessans.
- Study Eugene von Bohm-Bawerk's 'Capital and Interest' for the Austrian School critique of time preference and the distinction between actual and expected wealth.
- Check René Billard's 'De Usura' for the 18th-century shift in scholastic thought regarding extrinsic titles.
- Research Pope Benedict XIV's encyclicals on usury to understand the historical development of accepted extrinsic titles.
- Analyze the theological arguments of DeSoto and Navarrus regarding the validity of Cajetan's charitable loan exceptions.
- Verify the historical claims about Alphonsus Liguori's stance on interest without intent to trade.
- Compare the scholastic definitions of 'damnum emergens' and 'lucrum cessans' against modern financial definitions of opportunity cost and risk premium.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Hoping Nothing podcast. I'm Michael Humphreys. I'm happy to be talking to you today. This is episode 37, and today we're going to talk a little bit more about Lucrum Seasons.
- 0:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now,
- 0:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Lucrum Seasons or Profit ceasing or profit lossing is uh
- 0:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it's a bit of inside um inside ball among Catholics for
- 0:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 0:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): used usery. to read. And the original kind of logic behind this um is this idea of extrinsic titles.
- 0:36
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So
- 0:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 0:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): within the the logic of usery, usury claims
- 0:43
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 0:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): some sort of title intrinsic to the loan. So by virtue of the loan itself, I can take something more than the return of the principal. So,
- 0:56
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): for example, in the case of a lease, you know, I'm leasing you some goods, so I'm granting you possession alongside the use of the thing for some time.
- 1:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Uh
- 1:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on
- 1:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the one hand, you have to return possession to me inequality.
- 1:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): but then the selling of the use is an intrinsic title that I have to something more and so that that use is that I'm selling to you is is the intrinsic title to some profit. In the Mutum loan, the personally secured loan,
- 1:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): there is no um analogous sort of title intrinsic to the loan.
- 1:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So
- 1:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um that
- 1:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that's sort of the initial logic. Now
- 1:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 1:52
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): through the development of centuries, there came along this theory of extrinsic titles. So a title that is extrinsic to the the loan that gives rise to some sort of claim to some sort of profit or some not necessarily profit, but something more that
- 2:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you can exact. So as in as in a lease, uh you can grant it gratuitously, um so like a library loan, grant granted it for free,
- 2:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um and you're
- 2:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): kind of giving up that claim to the the rent on the use,
- 2:33
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): or like a textbook rental, then you can actually make a claim to that title and exact something.
- 2:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 2:41
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so this is still something due. It's a title, it's a it's a right of some sort. So the claim is that in the Moo Tomb. there are extrinsic titles.
- 2:56
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 2:56
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so one can make a claim for uh an extrinsic title.
- 3:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
- 3:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the thing that I find kind of interesting though is that
- 3:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 3:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the the scholastics didn't really use the term
- 3:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 3:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): extrinsic title as a way to refer to this. This came about uh much later. I haven't really encountered the sort of first instance of this, but uh for example,
- 3:27
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 3:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Benedict the Fourteenth in his uh encyclical Vic Pervenat Pervainet talks about, you know, a title that is not at all intrinsic
- 3:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): but extrinsic. I forget exactly how he phrases that, but um, it's this notion that it is extrinsic to the loan itself.
- 3:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
- 3:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Charles Renee Billard,
- 3:52
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): he also uh makes this distinction between the intrinsic and the extrinsic, and so there are extrinsic
- 4:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 4:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): titles and it even he argues against certain titles because they are
- 4:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 4:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): intrinsic. So for example,
- 4:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 4:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): he argues against the
- 4:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 4:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the claim of a title to
- 4:18
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 4:18
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): something more because of the duration of the loan. So a very long loan requires you to pay something more, but he argues, well, no, that's an intrinsic. title. That goes to the very nature of the loan. And so you can't take something more because that entails you're taking something from the
- 4:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): loan itself, which we have proven to be
- 4:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that there is no title to something more.
- 4:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So that's around you the mid know, eighteen. mid-18th century is where that that sort of thing comes in. And so
- 4:55
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): this notion of extrinsic titles begins to arise. And so um within that there are several different quote unquote extrinsic titles. So for example, there is um
- 5:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): let's see what are the different extrinsic titles? So the ones that are generally accepted are Damum Emergence, which is the loss of something that you actually already possess.
- 5:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Lucrum says
- 5:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): is a loss of something that
- 5:30
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 5:31
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you possess only in hope,
- 5:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,
- 5:33
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): something that you're kind of uh seeking. And this has to do with the the profit that you could have obtained had you not lent.
- 5:43
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 5:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): but that you are on the way to lending, that that becomes a very big concern is that
- 5:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 5:52
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): what sort of condition do you have to be in in order to lend? Besides that, you have curriculum sortus, which is the risk of uh
- 6:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not.
- 6:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): being repaid.
- 6:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And um this one's a really confusing one because I don't
- 6:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know
- 6:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): how it makes any sense to anybody.
- 6:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
- 6:14
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Elizabeth Anscomb called it a monstrosity.
- 6:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
- 6:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think she's
- 6:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 6:20
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): think that evaluation is correct. Um, but besides that, there's also uh what came later was the civil title. So by the very fact that the
- 6:31
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 6:32
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that the uh state allows some sort of minimum interest, you can take
- 6:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
- 6:41
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Some Jesuits argued for the in favor of this in virtue of eminent domain, that in virtue of
- 6:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 6:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): state's eminent domain
- 6:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): they just sort of, you know,
- 6:54
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): take the borrower's money and give it to the lender because they they say so.
- 7:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 7:02
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): notably uh Merkelbach uh argues against this
- 7:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 7:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and others. Uh it's it's an absurd title, honestly. Uh there's an instruction from the propaganda feed
- 7:18
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): from the 17th century, I believe, that uh explicitly condemns
- 7:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it, uh,
- 7:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): citing the Council of VNA,
- 7:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): um, which excommunicates
- 7:30
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 7:31
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): magistrates and other government officials who who enforce usurious loans. So there's that.
- 7:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): But then there's also uh Poene Conventionalis, I think it's called. I'm never good with Latin.
- 7:47
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 7:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): which
- 7:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): is something like a late fee.
- 7:53
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 7:56
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and so it's like you you're defaulting, you you're delayed in repaying, and so you you pay a uh other a late fee. And that's sort of built into the contract, I guess. Uh deduced into the contract, as the jurists say.
- 8:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And that's generally accepted because
- 8:16
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you know delay in the contract is is itself a title to something more.
- 8:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 8:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that kind of brings me to the original sort of
- 8:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 8:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): notion of lucrum saisons. sessions. And starting with kind of Aquinas and then Kajitan, and we'll move from there. And so Aquinas, Aquinas, he doesn't ever use the this terminology that the later scholastics use. He he bases it all in strict principles. And so
- 8:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): he notes that in in
- 8:47
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 8:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): in the case of a delivery. delayed debtor, the debtor may have to repay uh or I should say, in restitution, one can cause a loss of something that one actually possesses
- 9:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 9:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and something one virtually possesses that one was on the way to obtain.
- 9:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And so Aquinas will know, okay, well these two sorts. of possession are
- 9:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): injurable, I would say, and so require some sort of restitution. So
- 9:27
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): he
- 9:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): gives the example of a delayed debtor. So the delayed debtor not only needs to restore the principal, but also potentially something more uh for any sort. of profit that could that that may have been lost uh because of that delay. And it really has to do with the fact that
- 9:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the lender has a right to the thing, to the money, and that right is violated because it is not returned at the at that time. And so because it is violated, if the lender was on the way you know, he was ready to take that money and put it to some trade,
- 10:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): he has lost, lost that opportunity of some sort. And there's some various judgments that could go on in that and how you estimate how much he's owed and so forth.
- 10:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like,
- 10:18
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): did he really lose the opportunity entirely if the if the debtor is delayed by a day?
- 10:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 10:27
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
- 10:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): forth and so on. So there's some prudent judgment there. But the idea is that
- 10:33
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the debtor could owe more than just the return of the principal in virtue of having violated this right to obtain something more.
- 10:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Um And so that that's sort of the ground ground zero for Lucrum Cezanne. Césans is is in this idea of restitution. Now fast forward to the question of on um
- 11:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): on usury. So restitution that's question sixty-two in the second part of the second part. Usury comes uh you know much later in question seventy-eight. 78.
- 11:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
- 11:13
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): in question seventy 78, eight, article 2, response to the first objection, Aquinas is addressing the problem of indemnity.
- 11:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 11:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so indemnity is the idea that you can protect yourself from a loss. So you're avoiding some sort of loss. And
- 11:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Aquinas here says, Well, you can protect yourself, you can deduce into a contract the loss of something that you ought to have. have. And indeed, this might even be a good thing because the lender or the borrower may be avoiding a greater loss than the lender.
- 11:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And so you lose
- 11:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of something, you lose 10 uh 10 bucks, but because you made the loan, it was actually better. He lost only 15 bucks. or he could he would have lost $15. And so by lending to him,
- 12:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 12:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): prevent a loss of $15.
- 12:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
- 12:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): isn't like strictly necessary. He just says, well, this might actually be a benefit of doing this. Is that
- 12:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 12:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know he might
- 12:18
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 12:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): might actually the borrower might lose less than the the the lender does. Um
- 12:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And so
- 12:29
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): great, you can deduce into a contract some loss of something you ought to have.
- 12:36
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): But he goes on to say, well, you can't enter into a contract
- 12:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the profit you could have made
- 12:47
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 12:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): because you ought not to sell something that you do not possess.
- 12:52
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So this this is this brings the and this kind of sets it out. So in the case of restitution you can be restored in something that you do not already possess,
- 13:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
- 13:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you possess only virtually. But in the case of uh indemnity you can't
- 13:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 13:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you can't sell
- 13:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 13:16
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): this sort of loss that you could have made from your money. So
- 13:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 13:22
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): this is kind of where it starts
- 13:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 13:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): from Aquinas. And a lot of the authors, you know, take Aquinas as,
- 13:30
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or
- 13:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): at least the ones I'm reading, I guess, because I'm reading a lot of the commentary tradition. They're they're taking it from Aquinas and trying to, or at least they try to bring Aquinas onto their side. So Kajitan
- 13:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): has there's a lot of time between Aquinas and Cajitan. You know, Aquinas is writing in the 13th century. Kajitan is writing, I think uh late sixteenth century,
- 13:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
- 13:57
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I remember correctly. So between that you have uh people like
- 14:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um I
- 14:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): forget his name, Hostianus, I think. I've probably not pronounced that correct canonist in the 13th century argues in favor of lucrum says from you know uh a legal perspective. You have uh
- 14:18
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Peter of John Olivey, who's arguing uh in favor of lucrum saysans Cezans uh as well
- 14:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in the
- 14:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): 13th thirteenth century.
- 14:28
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 14:29
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): one of the first guys to write a treatise on contracts.
- 14:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 14:34
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): after that you get into the fourteenth century, you get Antonius of Florence and Saint Saints Antonius of Florence and Bernadine of uh Siena. They're both kind of drawing from uh Peter Olivey and drawing some of
- 14:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the the arguments that he has money taking on the nature of capital and so forth to sort of propose these arguments for Luke from Cezans, even though both of them were radically, radically opposed to Usery in general.
- 15:09
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 15:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so that
- 15:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 15:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you get up into the like the 15th fifteenth, um
- 15:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, you have uh various degrees of authors who are arguing for for lucratum says, I believe.
- 15:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
- 15:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): but you really get it with uh Conrad Summonhart,
- 15:30
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 15:31
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): who argues
- 15:32
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 15:33
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): just for straight up Lucrum Lucretum Saisons. says.
- 15:36
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 15:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that one I haven't read as closely because he's not quite as clear. Like his arguments, he doesn't he's not a Thomist.
- 15:43
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 15:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): he's not drawing on Aquinas, though he cites Aquinas in a couple of spots. Um
- 15:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): but after that you kind of get to Cajitan. Now Cajitan is trying to ground it firmly in restitution. So he he so he takes restitution as sort of the basis for all of this. And so he argues that Damum and Emergence is restitution as well.
- 16:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 16:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so Lucrum Cezans is restitution. So it all kind of falls under this single principle of restitution. So when you get to
- 16:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): him,
- 16:22
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): um
- 16:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 16:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): get the development of this idea of
- 16:27
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 16:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the potency of money, which is really kind of a a way of articulating this idea of like, well, there's there's money considered absolutely, and then there's money as capital that has some sort
- 16:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
- 16:40
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): uh I think Olive said like has some sort of seminal quality or power of profit. And so the way that it's kind of said is that. well, money that's sort of prepared for trade is more valuable than money
- 16:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): otherwise.
- 17:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And so Kajitan tries to formalize this by bringing in these ideas
- 17:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of the
- 17:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): potency of money, which has a certain potency for profit. And so money considered absolutely, and then money considered.
- 17:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 17:16
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): with respect to someone, someone who can actually with the skills to make use of
- 17:20
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
- 17:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And so,
- 17:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): um in a particular place and so forth. And so he he comes up with this and he says, Okay, well, the the merchant who has the money, who has the skills and so forth, his money is actually worth more because it's it's laid out for him. And this actually is what justifies taking more
- 17:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): in the case of restitution of a delayed debtor, is because that money's actually worth more to him. And so he loses more value when it's not returned on time. And he draws a parallel to to uh seeds and so forth, but um to kind of you know explain this, so you have like
- 18:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a seed in the bag versus the seed that's you know in the tilled soil and it's kind of
- 18:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 18:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know prepared to be grown.
- 18:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): But uh and so similarly with the seed, if you take the seed that's just in the bag, you only need to return the seed rather than if it's prepared for harvest you know to grow into the harvest, you're gonna have to pay something more uh because of of the the harvest, that it's prepared to the
- 18:31
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): harvest. And so he he goes on, he establishes this, and he says, Well, the the lender who actually
- 18:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 18:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): who decides to take his money out of trade in order to lend does this willingly.
- 18:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
- 18:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the value of his money
- 18:55
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): drops by his own will. He is the cause of it, not the loan. And so he then decides to lend it. And so, in that sort of loan, there's no compulsion, there's no
- 19:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): um sort of need of restitution, there's no justification of restitution. And so there's no lucrum saisons in that case. And so
- 19:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um he
- 19:20
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): pretty much l lays it out from that perspective that there's no no way of establishing lucratum saisons.
- 19:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Except he makes this very odd exception where he says, well, if it's for a charitable intent, so if a a needy borrower comes to you and asks for for a loan, then there is a sort of compulsion there because you're compelled by the obligation of charity
- 19:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): towards your needy neighbor. And so in that case, you can add lucrum sesens because there is a sort of involuntariness, a sort of compulsion, a sort
- 19:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
- 20:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): whatever that introduces uh
- 20:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): back
- 20:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): this idea of restitution that was established by Aquinas. Okay, and so then you can take
- 20:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
- 20:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Now, rightly, in my opinion, he is he's criticized by uh anyone who takes note of this criticizes him for
- 20:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it. Uh
- 20:22
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): DeSoto just, you know,
- 20:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): castigates. him for this. Like it's unbelievable. How could you say this? Uh he DeSoto will note that in Aristotle there's three ways that uh an act can be involuntary. Uh fear,
- 20:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 20:42
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): violence, and what's the third one? Ignorance.
- 20:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
- 20:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): none of which are present. I mean, the worst you can could say is fear, but uh that one's
- 20:53
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 20:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, you're afraid of losing your money. I don't
- 20:56
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know.
- 20:57
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): But basically, um even Navarius, who is very progressive with respect to Lucrum Cezans, also I think castigates him for this. Like, there's no like
- 21:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): there's no compulsion from charity.
- 21:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
- 21:14
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think uh uh one other author I'd read also uh criticized
- 21:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): him. And
- 21:20
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so the I the idea here is that, well, if you take if you take Kajitan at his word,
- 21:26
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 21:26
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): at his argument, excluding this um unjustified exception, then you don't have Lukram From sezons Cezons anymore. And so this this is where you
- 21:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know
- 21:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): up to the top. time of Cadjutan and you know, probably DeSoto, because they're I think they're really trying to follow Aquinas here. That is as far as they're going to
- 21:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): go.
- 21:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Um, is well Cad uh Aquinas established it in restitution. And so from restitution we have to sort
- 21:58
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of um
- 22:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): establish
- 22:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if it
- 22:02
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): can be voluntary.
- 22:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): The issue though then is that later on there's a big shift in the way that people start talking about
- 22:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 22:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): about lucrum sezons. So instead of establishing it in restitution, it's now established in
- 22:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 22:20
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as
- 22:20
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a sort of sale. And so
- 22:22
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 22:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): lucrum says saisons is then reduced down to demum emergency. emergence where you can just take
- 22:29
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 22:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): take uh some sort of loss of a thing that you ought to ought to have.
- 22:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 22:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I like I like Rene Billouard here because
- 22:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): he
- 22:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): he states it most clearly in saying well
- 22:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the hoped for gain is something that you actually possessed.
- 22:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 22:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yeah the like you don't
- 22:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 22:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): don't possess the the gain, that's just hope for. But you actually possess the gain in hope. Like the in hope of it is what you possess.
- 23:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 23:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and so and he establishes that from Aquinas in in the um
- 23:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
- 23:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the case of restitution, that while well you do possess it virtually, um, but then
- 23:18
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 23:18
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Beloir will go so far as it's a good that you possess actually.
- 23:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 23:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it's like this virtual possession becomes you actually possess the virtual possession
- 23:31
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
- 23:31
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): is what it kind of tends towards. And so I see the this real break as a real break in the whole logic of
- 23:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): uh
- 23:41
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to begin with. Because it really sort of shifts the entire superstructure. And so the way that I sort of start thinking about this is in terms of like, well, what are the what are the reasons for taking taking um this anyways? So we have the the case of restitution. Okay.
- 24:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
- 24:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the the issue that Kajitan I think gets himself into is he he wants to make the whole thing restitution.
- 24:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 24:13
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): both Damum Emergens and Lucrum Cezans. But the issue is that restitution is restoring something taken
- 24:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): whereas the case of Damu Emergence, insofar as it
- 24:29
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
- 24:29
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): related by Aquinas,
- 24:31
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): is not restoring a loss of something taken, but it's avoiding a loss.
- 24:40
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So
- 24:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the idea here isn't that the the the borrower
- 24:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): uh you know takes something more than the principal.
- 24:52
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): but that you're avoiding some loss because of what you're doing.
- 25:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So I actually don't think I think this is where Kajitan really goes wrong is trying to establish it in in restitution. Because I think I think there's three principles that Aquinas it really talks about when he when he talks about loss.
- 25:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Um
- 25:20
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and and because of the way that the later scholastics um sort of
- 25:27
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 25:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): shift the the the ground of of Lucrum Cezans to more of a
- 25:36
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 25:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): more
- 25:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of a ground of
- 25:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 25:40
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): like a sale is that they're then they're able to take the the logic of loss and a sale that Aquinas discusses.
- 25:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): But I think I think there's actually three different principles going on. So principle one is is the case of restitution. So retor restoring something taken
- 26:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And that makes sense. Okay, so if you take the principal, you restore the principle.
- 26:09
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 26:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that's just the normal restitution of a mutum loan. Now, if you take the principal and you're delayed, you've taken more than the principal. You've taken away his being on the way to obtain something. And so Aquinas. will note in the Ethics that it doesn't
- 26:29
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): always restitution isn't a matter of you having more
- 26:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and them having less, but them having less than they ought. So the lender ought to be able to go on his way and seek his profit. That is a right he has to licitly seek a profit. And so you're deliberately. your delay violates that right. And so you owe him something in
- 26:55
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): restitution for that, because you've taken that away from him by um not paying him back on time.
- 27:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So that within that framework, that is lucrum says.
- 27:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 27:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
- 27:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I I I like to call it profit delayed rather than profit. profit forgone or profit ceasing.
- 27:18
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 27:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): maybe that's the wrong way to I I try to I I really prefer to to try to use some different language here because there's a conflation of a lot of different things.
- 27:29
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 27:29
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): then if we move to the case of uh dam Gamum um emergence, properly speaking, it's not a case of restitution. Now you can talk about restitution of uh something one ought to have uh as well. So it's like maybe um
- 27:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the idea here is that you don't pay him back on time, so then he suffers some other loss of what he actually has. So he can't pay his own bills because you didn't pay him back on time. That would be an actual loss. So that would be damning emergence grounded in restitution. Now,
- 28:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): if we shift to uh the question of indemnity, this I think is an entirely different principle.
- 28:16
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 28:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): we can talk about um, you
- 28:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
- 28:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Aquinas talks about, you know, deducing this into a contract, so adding this to the agreement. So there's some sort of sort of like secondary contract that's going on. And the idea here is that we're talking about a like a contract of indemnity to avoid a loss. So the whole purpose of
- 28:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): this is
- 28:41
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the teleology of this is that you're avoiding a loss of what you ought to have. And so
- 28:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): one
- 28:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of the ways that you might talk about this in a sale would be like you order something online
- 28:57
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and in addition to them selling you the thing,
- 29:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): they will have you pay for
- 29:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
- 29:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): or pay for the shipping. And so the shipping isn't something
- 29:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 29:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 29:13
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know you receive necessarily necessarily
- 29:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): because it does still need to get to you, but it's not something that
- 29:22
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 29:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it's not like the book. Like the the seller is going to try to get it to you so he can sell you the book, but that's kind of on him.
- 29:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's
- 29:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): not something that you're receiving. because all you're receiving is the book and the idea here well as well is like if a trader travels to a fair can he add the pri the cost of his his transportation
- 29:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
- 29:52
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the price that he sells at the market and so especially in that case it's like
- 29:58
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well
- 29:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I didn't I'm not getting the the shipping the transform transporting.
- 30:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
- 30:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and maybe even someone else is selling the same stuff, you know, a couple of stalls over. He didn't have to ship it
- 30:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): here.
- 30:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 30:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
- 30:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I'm receiving is the thing. And so I think here the
- 30:20
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 30:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the indemnity is is that sort of actual thing. It's not meant to the the the teleology of it is to prevent you from suffering a loss. And so you can add add it to the price of of the thing or as a
- 30:41
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): secondary agreement. So you agree to pay the the shipping costs.
- 30:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
- 30:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And then here the idea is that you're trying to
- 30:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 30:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): cover the the loss of what is your own, and so you your own stuff, and so it's not about sort of this profit which you don't possess, and I think that's why Aquinas talks about it in terms of of selling,
- 31:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): because um the idea here is that you're your
- 31:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you you
- 31:14
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know loss follows ownership
- 31:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
- 31:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so in a sense it's like you're you are
- 31:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 31:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you're taking on that loss to yourself what is their their own you're you're kind of covering them for it and so they're sort of selling you the loss
- 31:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and so um but in the case of the profit
- 31:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): there's no profit that they're they're selling you. Indeed, there never will be because they're lending to you instead. And so that
- 31:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the profit is not part of their their patrimony, part of their their wealth. And I think this is where you know Bilou art goes wrong is talking about the the profit hoped for as an actual good or a good that's actually possessed.
- 32:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 32:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): because that's not how how it works. And uh Eugene Von Bohm actually makes this distinction between
- 32:18
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 32:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the good, the wealth, the thing that actually meets your need versus our sort of valuation or
- 32:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): accounting for how much wealth we have.
- 32:31
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 32:31
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so within the accounting framework, you can talk about the value of hope for gain, but it's not wealth actually possessed. It's not a thing that's actually going to meet your need. I think this is part of the issue of you know what happens in financial markets all the time.
- 32:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): time. You know, recently just with NVIDIA, the NVIDIA um stock, you know, crashed, or with Tesla or a hundred other things, is that it's this and then you get headlines of like, oh a million a million dollars worth of of value was wiped from the market. And it's
- 33:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): like nothing of the actual wealth has changed.
- 33:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Like NVIDIA still has their factories, they still have the chips, they still have the computer components. Tesla still has their factories and their cars and their materials. Yeah, and all the business stuff along with that. And and it it's all there still, it's still functioning, it's still working. It's
- 33:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): this expected for gain. And so there's no issue with how. valuing it that way. But the the issue is when you make that value something more. And this was Bohm's point, because then
- 33:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): if you have something where you have a good and then you have
- 33:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 33:55
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a debt on that good
- 33:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or
- 33:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a debt on a person,
- 34:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um,
- 34:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and count that as a new good,
- 34:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): like you should have as many debts as you possibly can. Like everyone should have as many debts as they possibly can because then you have more economic goods.
- 34:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 34:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): they just multiply. But he he he correctly and
- 34:20
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 34:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): with correct realism says it has to resolve itself down to the thing, the the wealth actually.
- 34:30
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 34:31
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so if you have some sort of debt tied to, you know, a company, ultimately it's the company that's the real economic good. And then the
- 34:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 34:40
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know the shares, the dividends that you're due or the coupons that you're doing. due. That's something sort of on top of
- 34:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 34:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): company, but it's not something as some sort of separate good. It's just a right attached to
- 34:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it. So
- 34:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think that's the way to think of
- 35:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
- 35:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Um
- 35:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and so
- 35:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the the hoped for gain is not a a good that you can sort of
- 35:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 35:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): indemnify
- 35:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
- 35:13
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Aquinas' Aquinas's meaning.
- 35:16
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 35:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so that that's sort of so then you have those two principles there between
- 35:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 35:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): restitution and indemnity. Now there there is the case of
- 35:29
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 35:32
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of the sale
- 35:34
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): where you can charge something more
- 35:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): because
- 35:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of some sort of disadvantage, the seller.
- 35:42
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 35:42
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the issue here is that this is a principle specific to sales, not to indemnity, because
- 35:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): in a sale, the logic is that um it's for the mutual benefit. So I'm giving you my thing in order to receive your thing, and we both benefit from it. We're b we both have some sort of advantage from it. Now, indemnity is
- 36:13
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): different. So
- 36:16
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): in order that I not be disadvantaged, I'm going to sell you my thing essentially.
- 36:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 36:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it's not so it's not for my advantage. It's not for your advantage. It's so that I'm not disadvantaged in engaging in this contract.
- 36:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So
- 36:36
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): um again, like sale versus indemnity versus a loan. And the loan, the logic of the loan is it's really for the sake of the borrower, because there's no intrinsic logic uh for receiving. a profit. So the lender grants the loan for the sake of the borrower, but not that
- 36:56
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): he be um di not that he
- 37:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that he be restored in his own. So it's it's not a source of profit. All it is is that it's for the sake Take of the advantage of the borrower that he be rest that the lender then be restored in his own. so that he doesn't un suffer an undue loss. And that's why indemnity makes perfect sense with the
- 37:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): loan, because it's to say, well, in order to loan, I have to pay X dollars to get you the money. And so that X dollars is a loss to me, but the whole logic of the loan is that I not be at a loss. So
- 37:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 37:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): would you pay for that,
- 37:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 37:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, brokerage fee to sell my stock to get you the the money?
- 37:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 37:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so in the in the sale it's for a mutual advantage. And so there's a possibility that the loan be
- 37:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 37:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): disanbad disad disadvantageous to the seller.
- 38:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So
- 38:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): there's a couple of different
- 38:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 38:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you know possibilities here, and there's all sorts of examples that you might come up
- 38:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): with. Um
- 38:13
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): but
- 38:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 38:14
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, a
- 38:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 38:16
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): someone wants to buy the tools of someone uh who's a workman. So,
- 38:22
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
- 38:22
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you're looking for some blacksmithing tools,
- 38:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and it
- 38:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): would be a great advantage. to you.
- 38:28
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 38:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so I say, Well, you know, if I don't have my blacksmithing tools, I can't do my work. And so,
- 38:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
- 38:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I might be able to get some blacksmithing tools, but I have to order them and it'll be it'll take a week to get here, and so forth and so on.
- 38:43
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 38:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): he says, Well, I really and so the buyer's like, I really need them now.
- 38:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 38:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): he says, Well, it, you know, we're well, if I'm going to sell these to you, then you know, they're usually worth, you know, a hundred dollars. But
- 38:58
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
- 38:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): kinda so I'm not disadvantaged by this because I'm not gonna be able to do any work in the meantime, you're gonna have to pay me a hundred and fifty dollars or something. Maybe that's a little extreme, but that's kind of the idea, is that you kinda kind of have to make up for it because and he says, Yeah, sure, that's great.
- 39:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
- 39:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): because I really need these tools for whatever reason. And so the guy says, Okay, well,
- 39:22
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um,
- 39:22
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you know, I'll sell them to you for 150. That kind of helps me cover my costs while I wait to buy a new new pair so I can keep working.
- 39:30
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 39:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so the idea here is that the later scholastics will use as an excuse to say, well, money is the tool of the merchant, and so you're actually just uh covering his
- 39:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 39:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): loss because he's disadvantaged.
- 39:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
- 39:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): but that's not the logic of the loan. It's the not the logic of indemnity. And so it doesn't apply in that case. You're not trying to make sure he's not disadvantaged, that he can't go out and make the loan.
- 40:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like
- 40:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): if you if you
- 40:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): by all means go make your profit.
- 40:09
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
- 40:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): but you can't put that on the borrower.
- 40:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
- 40:14
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): because it's kind of contrary to the logic of these different contracts.
- 40:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 40:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so those those are the kind of the three three different uh principles that I would see being worked on. So
- 40:27
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 40:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and a lot and it's all conflated together. So Khajitan conflates uh this principle of restitution
- 40:36
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
- 40:36
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the principle of indemnity into a single principle of loss.
- 40:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 40:41
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and then the later scholastics will then go on to say, well, really we're gonna going to bring this whole principle of of selling into
- 40:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it. And
- 40:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so then you get this massive expansion of lucrum saisons to the point where it's not, it's just any disadvantage.
- 41:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And it becomes to the point where you just lose sight of
- 41:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you know what is this loss anymore? And you have like Alphonsus Ligori Liguri who argues that you don't even need an effectual work. will
- 41:16
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to trade. Like
- 41:20
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you don't even have to want to be doing commerce.
- 41:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like
- 41:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): your money isn't out. Your money isn't even out. You have no intention of trading. Your money is not even out to trade. But you can still take lucrum sésans, sessions
- 41:36
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,
- 41:36
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): because it's in some sense your you're disadvantage. disadvantaged. Because you want to profit justly. And so
- 41:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 41:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): part of it is I see that this ultimately leads into just like, well, it's just an intrinsic title. Like, who cares?
- 41:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
- 41:54
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and I think that's exactly where a lot of these go, a lot of the scholastics, schol uh sort of neo scholastics, neotomas go in the 20th century. twentieth century, where it's
- 42:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 42:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): i
- 42:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it's just an intrinsic title. Like, well, you know, I could have lent. My money's worth more. That's what I'm giving him.
- 42:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 42:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): why doesn't he give me more back?
- 42:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 42:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I see that's kind of what
- 42:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 42:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it starts leading towards.
- 42:26
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 42:27
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
- 42:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yeah, I think once we recognize those the three separate principles regarding loss, I think that's where we can then start um
- 42:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): distinguishing different types of situations and being able to identify where and when
- 42:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 42:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): something more can be taken. And
- 42:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 42:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): consequently, Lucrum Lucrim Cezanne's Saisons doesn't work for a voluntary
- 42:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 42:55
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a voluntary
- 42:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 42:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): loan, you know, uh voluntary indemnity. So that that's kind of where I'm at. That's kind of what I'm arguing.
- 43:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 43:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and so I want to distinguish between
- 43:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 43:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you know a loss
- 43:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to be
- 43:14
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): restored restored, either actually or potentially or virtually, and then a loss to be indemnified, so avoiding a loss, and then a sort of disadvantaged,
- 43:29
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 43:29
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a loss that leads to some sort of disadvantage or a disadvantaged advantage loss.
- 43:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 43:34
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so each of these arises from separate principles. So that's kind of where I'm at and that's kind of what I'm aiming for. And so um
- 43:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yeah, thanks for listening.
- 43:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 43:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): one of the things I I will well,
- 43:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'll
- 43:52
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): get into that some other time. But thanks for listening. Uh if you have any questions, comments, concerns, let me know. Um
- 43:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): any
- 43:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): criticisms. I really appreciate it when people
- 44:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 44:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): criticize me because it really helps me helps me think through some of these these issues. So
- 44:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yeah. Have a good day.