
The Scout and The Speculator
Will Jarvis
The Scout and The Speculator Podcast offers unparalleled guidance in the Bowman Baseball investing world. Join Jheremy Brown, the Director of 13U and 14U Programs at Perfect Game Baseball, and Will Jarvis, a former financial analyst and life long baseball analytics nerd, as they give you the best insight on how to invest in Bowman Baseball cards. Jheremy has worked with young superstars such as Konnor Griffin, Bobby Witt Jr., Eli Willits, Theo Gillen, and Cooper Pratt among many, many more, and has spent over a decade discovering talent, building relationships, and his knowledge of the baseball world cannot be found elsewhere!
How to Make Money at Card Shows - Buying and Selling
Episode discussion: Speakers discuss negotiation tactics, vendor psychology, and strategic timing for maximizing profits at trading card shows.
Speakers’ claims: Will Jarvis and Jeremy Brown share strategies for buying and selling at trading card shows, emphasizing the importance of relationship building and negotiation psychology. They advise sifting through 'white boxes' for undervalued items and testing vendor fairness by requesting comps on known-value cards. The hosts recommend tracking costs by writing prices on cards and making buyers feel they 'won' to foster loyalty. They also highlight the value of VIP badges for early access and suggest waiting until mid-show to negotiate with vendors holding high sticker prices.
2 Under $10 - 2026 Bowman
Episode discussion: Hosts analyze Daeson Hill and Luis Arana as undervalued Bowman prospects under $10
Speakers’ claims: Will Jarvis and Jeremy Brown discuss two 2026 Bowman cards priced under $10 that they believe have doubling potential. They highlight Daeson Hill, a young left-handed pitcher with high strikeout upside traded to the Blue Jays, noting his physical traits drive demand. They also profile Luis Arana, a shortstop with elite exit velocity metrics suppressed by Roger Dean Stadium's hitter-friendly environment. The hosts argue that Arana's contact skills and defensive grades support his value despite current power limitations. Both players are presented as having significant upside relative to their current market prices.
2 Under $20 - 2026 Bowman
Episode discussion: Speakers analyze two baseball prospects under $20: Koy James and David Shields
Speakers’ claims: Will Jarvis and Jeremy Brown discuss two baseball card investments under $20, selecting Koy James and David Shields. They argue both players have undervalued potential based on advanced statistics and situational factors. The hosts highlight Koy James's power-speed combination and favorable left-handed splits despite a low batting average. They also praise David Shields' elite command and strikeout rates relative to his age and level. The speakers suggest both prospects could double in value due to bad luck masking their true performance metrics.
2 Under $20 - 2025 Bowman Ep 1
Episode discussion: Speakers analyze two 2025 Bowman prospects under $20: Jacob Bresnahan and Emilian Pitre.
Speakers’ claims: Hosts introduce a segment on two 2025 Bowman prospects under $20 expected to double in value. Speaker 1 selects Jacob Bresnahan, a Giants pitcher, citing his physical tools and the Giants' pitcher-friendly environment despite Double-A struggles. Speaker 0 selects Emilian Pitre, a Mets second baseman, comparing his profile to Jeff McNeil and highlighting his speed and contact hitting. Both speakers warn about market volatility, 'trap names,' and the low success rate of prospects making the majors.
Buy/Sell/Hold 2026 Bowman Chrome 11/5/2026
Episode discussion: Hosts recommend buying Jadir Suarez, holding Owen Ayers, and selling Francisco Renteria in 2026 Bowman Chrome.
Speakers’ claims: Jeremy Brown and Will Jarvis analyze the 2026 Bowman Chrome set, recommending a buy for Jadir Suarez due to low pricing and power potential, a hold for Owen Ayers ahead of his MLB debut, and a sell for Francisco Renteria due to inflated DSL stats and physical maturity advantages. The hosts debate whether Renteria's success is aided by his size relative to younger peers and suggest his value may regress in stateside competition. They also note market trends regarding error cards, redemption names, and potential hoarding effects on specific parallels.
Arizona Fall League Buy/Sell/Hold Week 4
Episode discussion: Hosts discuss buy, hold, and sell recommendations for Arizona Fall League prospects Sebastian Walcott, Welbon Francisca, and Yasser Mercedes.
Speakers’ claims: Hosts Will Jarvis and Jeremy Brown analyze three baseball card investments tied to the Arizona Fall League. They recommend buying Sebastian Walcott's 2024 Bowman Auto due to suppressed pricing despite elite status. They advise holding Welbon Francisca to take profits after a price doubling, citing limited upside in the Cleveland market. They recommend selling Yasser Mercedes due to age and poor performance metrics at higher minor league levels.