Speakers analyze two baseball prospects under $20: Koy James and David Shields
Summary
Will Jarvis and Jeremy Brown discuss two baseball card investments under $20, selecting Koy James and David Shields. They argue both players have undervalued potential based on advanced statistics and situational factors. The hosts highlight Koy James's power-speed combination and favorable left-handed splits despite a low batting average. They also praise David Shields' elite command and strikeout rates relative to his age and level. The speakers suggest both prospects could double in value due to bad luck masking their true performance metrics.
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 0:59
Intro and Koy James Pick
Will Jarvis and Jeremy Brown introduce the episode's theme of two baseball prospects under $20 who they believe will double in value. Jeremy Brown selects Koy James, noting his recent price drop and strong draft performance despite a low batting average.
- 0:59 – 8:00
Koy James Analysis and Valuation
Jeremy Brown highlights Koy James's power-speed combination (19 HR, 35 SB) and low walk rate, arguing his low batting average was due to bad luck (low BABIP). Will Jarvis adds that James's ability to destroy left-handed pitching provides a major league floor.
- 8:00 – 10:36
David Shields Profile and Stats
Will Jarvis introduces his pick, David Shields, a left-handed pitcher for the Kansas City Royals. He emphasizes Shields' extreme command (low walk rate) and advanced age relative to his level, noting he pitched as a 19-year-old in High-A.
- 10:36 – 17:16
Shields' Command and Market Price
The speakers discuss Shields' strikeout-to-walk ratio and his current card price around $16. They argue that his control issues were early-season and have improved, making the current price attractive compared to his potential.
- 17:16 – 20:00
Prospect Comparison and System Context
Jeremy Brown and Will Jarvis compare Shields to teammate Kendry Churio, suggesting Shields will benefit from association with the more hyped, harder-throwing Churio. They praise the Royals' farm system depth.
- 20:00 – 21:14
Closing Remarks
The hosts share a personal anecdote about both prospects playing on the same youth team. Will Jarvis thanks listeners for the podcast's growth and signs off.
Claims worth verifying
Koy James struck out 23% of batters and had a WRC+ of 97.
Jeremy Brown ·0:59
How to verify: Check Koy James's 2026 minor league statistics on MiLB.com or Baseball-Reference for strikeout percentage and wRC+. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Koy James hit 19 home runs and stole 35 bases in his first professional season.
Jeremy Brown ·1:38
How to verify: Verify counting stats (HR, SB) for Koy James in the 2026 minor league season via MiLB.com. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Koy James signed for $2.5 million in the 5th round of the draft.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·5:35
How to verify: Check MLB Draft Lottery results or MLB.com draft coverage for the 2026 draft bonus amounts and round selections for the Washington Nationals. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Koy James has a .302 ISO against left-handed pitchers.
Will Jarvis ·4:04
How to verify: Review Koy James's 2026 split statistics on MiLB.com or Baseball-Reference for ISO vs LHP. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceDavid Shields pitched 180 innings in full-season ball as a 19-year-old.
Will Jarvis ·8:14
How to verify: Check David Shields' 2025 minor league pitching logs on MiLB.com for innings pitched and age. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
David Shields had a 1.88 walks per nine innings rate in High-A.
Will Jarvis ·8:34
How to verify: Verify David Shields' 2026 High-A statistics on MiLB.com for BB/9. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
David Shields had a 2.01 ERA as an 18-year-old in Single-A in 2025.
Will Jarvis ·8:54
How to verify: Check David Shields' 2026 Single-A statistics on MiLB.com for ERA and age. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceDavid Shields' 2025 High-A ERA was 4.01, with a 3.51 FIP and 3.69 xFIP.
Will Jarvis ·9:53
How to verify: Verify David Shields' 2026 High-A advanced pitching metrics on MiLB.com or FanGraphs. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThe High-A league average ERA was 5.10 and walks per nine were 4.8.
Will Jarvis ·16:31
How to verify: Check 2026 High-A league averages on MiLB.com or Baseball-Reference for league-wide ERA and BB/9. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceKoy James's card price dropped from $15-20 to ~$9-10 after September 1st.
Will Jarvis ·6:29
How to verify: Check price history on Prospect Pulse or eBay sold listings for Koy James Bowman cards post-September 1, 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify Koy James's 2026 minor league stats (HR, SB, BABIP, ISO) via MiLB.com or Baseball Reference.
- Check David Shields' 2026 High-A pitching stats (K/9, BB/9, ERA, FIP) via MiLB.com or Baseball Reference.
- Review the Washington Nationals' 2025 draft report for Koy James's signing bonus and draft position.
- Review the Kansas City Royals' 2025 draft report for David Shields' draft position and signing bonus.
- Compare Koy James's left-handed vs right-handed splits to validate the ISO claims.
- Check current market prices for Koy James and David Shields cards on eBay or COMC to verify the <$20 premise.
- Research the Royals' farm system depth and Kendry Churio's hype level to assess the 'halo effect' argument.
- Look for counter-arguments regarding Koy James's injury history and its impact on his draft stock and future performance.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Will Jarvis: Hello, everybody, and welcome back to the Scout and the Speculator podcast. This is Will Jarvis, also known as Jabba Cards, joined as always by Jeremy Brown of Perfect Game Baseball down in Texas. Where in Texas are you today?
- 0:15
- Jeremy Brown: Uh Houston. Houston.
- 0:17
- Will Jarvis: Houston. He sounded very sure of his physical location.
- 0:22
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Anyhow,
- 0:22
- Will Jarvis: today we're bringing you our first episode of the day. We're gonna record a few today, but we are kicking off with a series that people have really liked, and that is two guys under $20 that we think will double next year. And I like Jeremy's pick a lot because it's a guy that he has seen a lot of uh as he grew up,
- 0:42
- Will Jarvis: you know, work through the uh showcase circuit. It And I have a guy I like, and it's
- 0:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 0:49
- Will Jarvis: typical profile of the pitchers I like. and uh I'll get into it a bit more. Jeremy, I'll let you kick it off. Who's your pick? What's his price? And tell us why you think he's gonna double.
- 0:59
- Jeremy Brown: I'm gonna go with Coi James, which you're probably like thinking, what do you mean? Like Coi James is expensive. Like he was expensive, he was expensive for Fret release, he kind of maintained he had a spike afterwards because he had a slower start and never. then he just came right back down. Like I'm looking at a true goal that just did
- 1:19
- Jeremy Brown: 170 base out of six dollars, like refractory sub twenty bucks. And like just jump on over and look at what he did. Like struck out twenty-three percent of the time. So you're like, Oh, all right, like you see the two 220 twenty average. I immediately thought like he must have had a ton of swing and miss and struck out a bunch. It was a twenty three.
- 1:38
- Jeremy Brown: 23% rate, which isn't like horrendous. He had 19 home runs, which we like, stole 35 bags, which we love, plus runner. Like the hit tools was good. He struggled a little bit heading into the draft, but he still got paid really well in the draft. I think the Nationals absolutely destroyed the 25 draft
- 1:58
- Jeremy Brown: with getting probably the best player in the draft with Eli Willis, Willets, signing him on. under slot, getting C-Make, getting Harman, getting um Ethan Petrie, getting Coy James, and there's more, but like I think they did a really good job there. And you look at it, and if if it really bothers you that much that he hit 220, but you ignore everything else that he did, so be it,
- 2:18
- Jeremy Brown: WRC plus of 97. Um, he's just a kid we've seen really for a long time now, and he's a really good athlete.
- 2:26
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There is
- 2:26
- Jeremy Brown: bat to ball skill there. I think his babip was like really low or like
- 2:30
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): he
- 2:31
- Jeremy Brown: had a 253, so babip is batting average on balls in play. You talked about somebody
- 2:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
- 2:37
- Jeremy Brown: the DSL, right, that had one north of like four hundred recently.
- 2:41
- Will Jarvis: Yeah, it
- 2:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was
- 2:41
- Will Jarvis: uh was it Riho?
- 2:44
- Jeremy Brown: Maybe that that sounds right, yeah. So like this you just uh a low Babip, like you're just not getting lucky on some of the stuff you're putting in play. Um, but for where his prices are now, and job and I talk about this a lot, like if you want to go throw five dollars at the dartboard and hope for something, like I I would throw
- 3:04
- Jeremy Brown: five dollars, ten dollars at some Koy James. Um, there's a true blue here that did November fourth, it did eighty 81 one bucks. I know when I bought mine, those are closer to two 220, twenty, two 240, forty uh two 220, twenty. 120 to 140. Like there is a market there for him. He's not in their top 10. I don't think that necessarily obviously dictates anything. If
- 3:23
- Jeremy Brown: you are into just looking at the um face of everything, then sure he's not a top 10 prospect for them. But I'm not really into that. And we're looking at guys that we think can double. Uh next year, do you think we could see him in high A? Probably. Can we see him maybe get to double A late?
- 3:43
- Jeremy Brown: They were aggressive. It'll all depend like being an infielder what they do with all the guys in front of him. Obviously mainly Eli Willitz, Devin Fitzgerald. So there is a good pipeline coming through. I think Coi James will have his moment this year where those six, seven dollar base autos, twenty dollar refractor autos kind of go up from where they are.
- 4:04
- Will Jarvis: Yeah, and I mean I'm looking at his page now. Looks like his ISO was 302 against left handers, which is nuts. Yeah.
- 4:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 4:14
- Will Jarvis: mean, he he's got the profile of a guy, and I can't even count how many guys hang around the majors by being a right-handed right handed hitting, you know, lefty masher. It's not necessarily playing every day.
- 4:26
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
- 4:26
- Will Jarvis: I feel like with that power and being able to destroy lefties, I feel like that gives you a floor of a guy who can play in the majors in some capacity. And it was still one fifty six against righties, which is still good. So it's not like he just did all his damage against lefties. It's more just like he was good against righties and destroyed lefties. And
- 4:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 4:45
- Will Jarvis: think another thing like you said, I mean he's turning twenty over the offseason. off season, Not old. He's probably gonna start in high A.
- 4:52
- Jeremy Brown: Mm-hmm.
- 4:53
- Will Jarvis: And twenty at high A is a great spot to be. There were a lot of guys that were nineteen, twenty in the complex last year, like Jack Wheeler, guy like a little bit, but he basically has no full season ball under his belt at the same age. So I think Coy James is pretty advanced. I know that I had read uh going into his draft year, I think he got hurt
- 5:13
- Will Jarvis: his senior year or something.
- 5:15
- Jeremy Brown: Just
- 5:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): kind of
- 5:15
- Jeremy Brown: struggled and scuffled, yeah.
- 5:17
- Will Jarvis: Yeah, fell fell off draft boards, so there had been some sort of you know hype and pedigree there.
- 5:22
- Jeremy Brown: Yeah.
- 5:23
- Will Jarvis: So I
- 5:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean
- 5:23
- Will Jarvis: I I don't think him discovering something is uh a crazy, crazy risk here.
- 5:29
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 5:29
- Jeremy Brown: like we talked with Bresnahan, like don't look at the round, look at the bonus. He signed for two and a half in the fifth round.
- 5:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like
- 5:36
- Jeremy Brown: he's not overly physical at six foot one eighty five, but to see him put tw well almost twenty home runs out this year in his first year of Pro Bowl, I think is a really good thing. Good sign of things to come. I don't think he's gonna be a forty plus guy ever. Thirty plus, probably not.
- 5:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
- 5:49
- Jeremy Brown: if he can if he can consistently be like a twenty five twenty-five kind of guy, like you're ecstatic with that all day. Even if it's a twenty thirty guy moving forward, like you're very content with that. So
- 5:59
- Will Jarvis: for sure.
- 6:01
- Jeremy Brown: Court Corey James, nice and cheap. has already had some hype, and I think he sells still pretty well on the app. I know you've had success with him before as well. So
- 6:09
- Will Jarvis: yeah, he he does. He's a popular name, he's kind of got that name recognition. I think this isn't a totally off the radar pick here. I think he's a popular sleeper for a lot of guys. And before we move on, um, I have his price chart from probably. Prospect Pulse up in front of me. Like September first he
- 6:29
- Will Jarvis: sold for seventeen dollars. He had been in that fifteen to twenty range basically all season. Um and then basically September first there were a few low sales around ten bucks, and the average price just plummeted a bit. It's still doing like nine bucks. But through September first, which is basically when he stopped playing, he was
- 6:49
- Will Jarvis: doing fifteen to twenty dollars right. regularly.
- 6:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 6:52
- Will Jarvis: I think him dropping, call it thirty, thirty-five percent, I think that's just more a function of him not being the first guy you're gonna buy in the offseason. People forget about him, new product comes out as well. But give me him with that track record for for ten bucks over any of like the tier three Bowman guys, like the Jason
- 7:12
- Will Jarvis: Hortons of the world. Uh I mean if Jason. Horton in two years hits nineteen homers with
- 7:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): thirty
- 7:19
- Will Jarvis: five steals and single A, people will be jumping up and down thrilled. Um I know the other metrics weren't necessarily as great as the counting stats, but I I do think that that needs to be said. So I think for ten bucks it's just not hard to see him getting back to twenty. 20. I think when baseball starts again he will go back to fifteen dollars. And you've
- 7:39
- Will Jarvis: already got half the formula there and
- 7:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): then
- 7:41
- Will Jarvis: he needs to make some things happen and um
- 7:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): your
- 7:45
- Will Jarvis: money from there. Anything else on coy before I dig into my pick here?
- 7:51
- Jeremy Brown: Nope. Let it rip.
- 7:54
- Will Jarvis: Okay, my pick David Shields in the Kansas City Royal system left-handed pitcher 6'2 210 just turned 20 years old in September, so he pitched this whole whole year as a 19-year-old. And you're probably thinking, okay, well, maybe he got some time in single A this past year and he'll start as a 21-year-old
- 8:14
- Will Jarvis: or 20-year-old in A or high A. That would be wrong. He already has what's that, like 180 innings under his belt in full season ball, uh, has an 18-year-old in single A. in 2025. He went out for 18 starts, 72 innings, so he's thrown like four innings a start. 10.17k
- 8:34
- Will Jarvis: per nine, which is good. Not amazing. Obviously, at the MLB level, that's amazing. You'd like to see a little bit more strikeouts, looking at it blindly. But what stands out to me is 1.88 walks per nine. That's ridiculous, and that's literally getting into the territory we talked about with Bob before. where it's like maybe he'd get more strikeouts and like be a little bit better
- 8:54
- Will Jarvis: off if he actually walked a few more guys here and there. Because everything this guy throws is a strike. He induces ground balls. He had a 201 ERA as an 18 year old in single A, which is crazy. This year in high A, the overall numbers took a tiny step Setback, back, but not really when you dig into them. He threw 25 twenty-five starts,
- 9:14
- Will Jarvis: 160. hundred and sixteen innings pitched, so almost five a start there, stretching out a little bit, ten point seven two K's per nine. So the Ks per nine went up by like half a strikeout nine innings, which is nice. It's not huge, but it's nice to see that get better as he moves up a level. And the walks per
- 9:33
- Will Jarvis: nine rose all the way from one 1.88 point eight eight to two 2.16. point one six. Still Still ridiculous. Nuts, just zero reason to worry about him ever having command or control issues. The ERA this year was 401, which isn't great. But at the same time, keep in mind he was 19 in high A. He was the youngest pitcher in high
- 9:53
- Will Jarvis: A. And between him and Kendry Cherio, the Royals have two arms under 20. I guess Shield's just turned 20. That are crazy. And to kind of
- 10:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): put the
- 10:02
- Will Jarvis: four 401 ERA in perspective. He did have a 351 FIP and a 369 X FIP. So the advanced metrics, I don't love using them with pitching, mostly because I don't confidently know what goes into them.
- 10:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
- 10:16
- Will Jarvis: I know it's fielding independent pitching, but whatever. Uh those being half a run lower are or nice. Um just seems like he, if anything, had a little bit of bad luck. But, you know, like I've said before, the guys who don't walk people and show command at that young of an age, I just love their floor. They're guys where I want to get out on them earlier
- 10:36
- Will Jarvis: than, say, an electric arm type. But at the same time, those are the guys that are gonna move through the miners quickly. They're gonna have a really easy time because guys aren't used to just being pelted with strikes. And I don't really care what the conversation is when he's in triple A if it's like, oh. okay, well, he's a three and won't be an ace because he doesn't have the big fastball and the huge case.
- 10:56
- Will Jarvis: Like that's fine. I'll be out of him by then. But he is currently selling for sixteen dollars, which is just ridiculous for a guy that young. No reason to think he won't start at double A next year. He'll be twenty the whole season. So he's even younger than guys like Braylon Dowdy were this past year. And I
- 11:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): don't
- 11:14
- Will Jarvis: know. I I just love the profile. He gets a lot of ground balls. And I'm talking about the strikeouts, like they're bad. But his K minus walk rate this past year was 23.7, which is quite, quite good. Uh year before it was 23.5. So
- 11:30
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there
- 11:30
- Will Jarvis: it's just such a solid profile to me. And he's walked, let's see. He's walked 43 guys. in 180 innings as a professional baseball player. I mean, that's that's a pretty insane number. He's over 200ks in that period. I just really like the floor, and you can obviously argue about the ceiling given the lack of
- 11:50
- Will Jarvis: the elite fastball. But give me those guys to fly through the miners, make noise, get into a top 100 list, and that's when you catch it.
- 11:58
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
- 11:59
- Will Jarvis: You got thoughts on uh David Shields? Also, he's not related to James. Shields.
- 12:04
- Jeremy Brown: He's uh he's long been one of my favorites. So I just went back and looked at up his PG profile and everything.
- 12:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like
- 12:11
- Jeremy Brown: his and again, like I I look at 13-14U for a lot of what I do, and that's kind of what I where I scout and run and everything. And his 14 new year, he threw 24 innings, he struck out 36 and walked four,
- 12:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): had
- 12:25
- Jeremy Brown: a 148 batting average again. against, like, struck out uh strike percentage was hovering at 70% strikes. Like, I do think there's something there where you could go through all of his career statistics within perfect games. So we're tracking him from when he's like 11, 12, 13, 4, all the way up to draft. And like that, what you just said
- 12:45
- Jeremy Brown: is everything he's been his whole life. It's always been strikes. He is able to get his strikeouts because he can't. can mix, he can pitch, he's not gonna blow you away, but it's gonna allow the fastball to play up when he's gonna start pitching backwards on guys. And like you said, he's just turned 20. There's still gonna be more in the tank. If you want to get more out of that body, it's a six two two ten
- 13:05
- Jeremy Brown: frame. Like it's long, it's lean, it's loose, at it's athletic. He is a switch hitter who can do it from both sides of the plate. Like, um I want to say he's a really good golfer, too. Something I remember from him, just like having him come through our stuff and grow up with us. Like, he is somebody I also have a bunch of that I've
- 13:24
- Jeremy Brown: bought that I love. I think he is going to fly through the miners, like you said. Um and the the walks went up this year, but so did his innings. So it's almost like a correlation of like, okay, maybe he got tired towards the end, maybe it was this, that, the other. Like he threw how many more innings was it? Um, that's Daniel
- 13:43
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Ortiz.
- 13:44
- Will Jarvis: It was 75.
- 13:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, it was another 45 innings.
- 13:50
- Jeremy Brown: Yeah, 41. Like, so for it to go up what it went up, like I sure that makes sense. Um, if if he can get into that 90, ninety like call it 93, ninety three, 96, ninety-six right. range consistently, like
- 14:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 14:05
- Jeremy Brown: think you have a demon on your hands, truthfully.
- 14:09
- Will Jarvis: Yeah, and I'm looking at the game logs now just to see if there's anything to the walks. He actually ended the year. He only walked
- 14:19
- Will Jarvis: in his last four, five, six, seven, eight. In his last eight starts, he only walked three guys. Um
- 14:28
- Will Jarvis: To start out the year the control was pretty rough in April and five starts. He had nine walks. Uh continued to have a few three walk starts in May, and then basically from
- 14:42
- Will Jarvis: mid July on, he walked three guys in eight or nine starts. So
- 14:48
- Jeremy Brown: and also like worth noting too, you said a early on, like guess guess where it's really cold early on in the season? Iowa, where Quad Cities is. Like those are some things you just kind of have to consider when you're looking at all that too. Like start of the year, nineteen year old kid, something to prove uh freezing. Like just a lot
- 15:08
- Jeremy Brown: of things. I I would look more of how he ended the year than how he started the year. And I think what how we he end ended it is going to be more of what we get from him moving forward.
- 15:17
- Will Jarvis: Yeah, and I I mean there there's some starts here of you know, there's a five inning, 10k, one walk, five and two thirds, ten K zero walks. I mean, that there's a healthy amount of just dominant outings in here, and it's basically just like a few early on where he got smacked. But you know, looking at his price,
- 15:37
- Will Jarvis: he's kind of set. settled in in that fifteen, sixteen dollar range. He never really spiked at all this year, and I guess that would line up with kind of a rougher start. But it it is pretty rare to see a guy have the same price today as he did in June. And I think that's almost equivalent to the price going up. Cause like we just said with Coy James, like
- 15:57
- Will Jarvis: September first, the price literally hit a wall. Went from fifteen to eighteen bucks down to like nine or ten bucks. And that's been something I think we've noticed all the way through.
- 16:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
- 16:07
- Will Jarvis: most of these guys between the season ending, new product coming out, people just kinda want the new toy or they're just not paying attention to baseball cards. David Shields is literally flat since June. And I'm looking at
- 16:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 16:21
- Will Jarvis: the ERA of four 401 oh one gave me a little pause. The league average uh for that. high A League was uh 510.
- 16:31
- Will Jarvis: The league average for walks per nine was 4.8. He was 14th in the league out of 368 qualified guys. Uh if you had doubled his walks per nine, still would have been above average. His fifth FIP was 23rd twenty-third out of 368 three hundred sixty-eight guys, almost 2.5. two points
- 16:51
- Will Jarvis: lower than the average, and he threw the fifth most innings while being the fifth youngest player in high A. So all of that is just so positive. I think the stats alone are good. But then when you look at it compared to like the rest of the league, they look a lot better. And then you bring in the fact that he's so much younger than all these guys. I mean, do you
- 17:11
- Will Jarvis: think there's any way he doesn't start in double A next year? Is it as twenty a 20 one? 20-year-old?
- 17:16
- Jeremy Brown: I would have to think he will, right? Like he was a re-class up to in high school. Like, despite not having the big stuff, he still said, I'm gonna go out early. And that definitely played into his advantage, being a northeast Pittsburgh, we'll call we'll call Pennsylvania Pittsburgh Northeast for the sake of it, mid-Atlantic, like a
- 17:35
- Jeremy Brown: fresher arm. Like, I'm
- 17:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 17:37
- Jeremy Brown: guessing we're gonna see a tweet where it just says Churio and Shields open at double A, right? Like they don't really have anything left to prove in high A, I don't think, at this
- 17:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): point.
- 17:47
- Will Jarvis: And I I think it's a good point that you're saying, like a press release would say, Oh, we got Shields and Churio coming to double A next year. I think it's great. Obviously, I think Churio is like a little bit more sexy and exciting, and the price reflects that. He's
- 18:01
- Jeremy Brown: he throws harder
- 18:02
- Will Jarvis: three
- 18:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): times.
- 18:03
- Will Jarvis: Call
- 18:03
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it what it is, he
- 18:04
- Jeremy Brown: throws harder.
- 18:05
- Will Jarvis: Yeah, and and he should be. But I I think being associated with Churio and kind of being these two young guys flying through the miners together. I think being associated with Churio is going to help him a lot because people
- 18:16
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are gonna
- 18:17
- Will Jarvis: see a lot of graphics. And a lot of the graphics I know that like the team will pump out to sell tickets, they'll be posting. It'll feature both of them a lot of the time. And I think that that'll get like the house. household name recognition up. Obviously, I think a lot more people saw Churio on social media than Shields, but I think that changes, especially when you're a 20-year-old in double A.
- 18:36
- Will Jarvis: Um, you know, that's when you start seeing the articles where it's like, check out these two Royals pitchers, 20 and under in double A. That's not something we really see. And when people go to see Kendry Kendrichurio Churio, um, I think David Shields Schildz will just get a lot of positive. press by association. Um so that's a good factor and
- 18:57
- Will Jarvis: and the Royals farm system is lights out right now. I think a lot of people will be talking about them. I know in the upper miners there's not a ton of bats, but we're we're talking about on J Bel Gomez. We're talking about uh Zion Rose, Josh Hammond, I I mean that that there's serious
- 19:16
- Will Jarvis: firepower in that system. So I think that it'll be one that features nicely in team rankings and really just no reason not to at least look into uh David Shields. Like I said, it comes with kind of the
- 19:31
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 19:32
- Will Jarvis: side note where it's like okay, this is probably not a guy you want to hold to his debut just because he doesn't really profile. as a guy with that electric fastball where he's gonna go viral like we talked about with Bob, why you'd take Brody Hopkins over
- 19:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
- 19:46
- Will Jarvis: high floor guy. Um, but that's not really the purpose of this. Just wanted to uh kind of state that again. But before we wrap up, you got anything else on David Shields or Cloy James? Noys
- 19:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): out
- 20:00
- Will Jarvis: there?
- 20:00
- Jeremy Brown: Uh they actually both played summer ball together with the Kings. Canes as well. Funnily enough.
- 20:05
- Will Jarvis: Really?
- 20:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 20:06
- Jeremy Brown: they're on the same 14 year team. So
- 20:10
- Will Jarvis: that
- 20:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was a nice team.
- 20:11
- Will Jarvis: Uh
- 20:13
- Will Jarvis: Davy High School in Moxville, USA for Corey. Couldn't
- 20:20
- Will Jarvis: North uh North Carolina.
- 20:22
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
- 20:22
- Will Jarvis: You'll learn something new every day.
- 20:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 20:26
- Will Jarvis: with that being said, I think we're good to wrap up here. We're gonna record a few more today. They'll come out in the next week. Um just gonna be pumping content your way as always. Um please do subscribe to our YouTube channel, the Scout and the Speculator. We've been blown away by the growth, especially in the past week. Uh we set a
- 20:46
- Will Jarvis: new record for listens basically every day this week. It flew past the prior day.
- 20:51
- Will Jarvis: Up to 71 subscribers. We're just both thrilled, blown away, and a little surprised that this many people enjoy listening to what we have to say. I'm very comfortable putting that on uh who Jeremy is and uh giving the credit there. But we love you guys so much. Appreciate all the listeners. And as always, let's go
- 21:11
- Will Jarvis: Mets. See you guys.
More from The Scout and The Speculator
How to Make Money at Card Shows - Buying and Selling
Episode discussion: Speakers discuss negotiation tactics, vendor psychology, and strategic timing for maximizing profits at trading card shows.
Speakers’ claims: Will Jarvis and Jeremy Brown share strategies for buying and selling at trading card shows, emphasizing the importance of relationship building and negotiation psychology. They advise sifting through 'white boxes' for undervalued items and testing vendor fairness by requesting comps on known-value cards. The hosts recommend tracking costs by writing prices on cards and making buyers feel they 'won' to foster loyalty. They also highlight the value of VIP badges for early access and suggest waiting until mid-show to negotiate with vendors holding high sticker prices.
2 Under $10 - 2026 Bowman
Episode discussion: Hosts analyze Daeson Hill and Luis Arana as undervalued Bowman prospects under $10
Speakers’ claims: Will Jarvis and Jeremy Brown discuss two 2026 Bowman cards priced under $10 that they believe have doubling potential. They highlight Daeson Hill, a young left-handed pitcher with high strikeout upside traded to the Blue Jays, noting his physical traits drive demand. They also profile Luis Arana, a shortstop with elite exit velocity metrics suppressed by Roger Dean Stadium's hitter-friendly environment. The hosts argue that Arana's contact skills and defensive grades support his value despite current power limitations. Both players are presented as having significant upside relative to their current market prices.