The Daily Brief

Government energy R&D spending remains low relative to GDP despite record nominal outlays, driven by fear rather than sustained strategy

23 min Listen to the original Episode page
Energy R&DIEA DataGovernment SpendingCorporate R&DOla ElectricMarket Tidbits

Summary

The speaker argues that government energy research spending is cyclical and fear-driven, citing IEA data showing that while nominal spending hit a record $32 billion in 2024, it represents only 0.5% of GDP, half the effort relative to economic size seen after the 1970s oil shocks. The correlation between oil prices and research budgets broke in the late 1990s as climate concerns took precedence, shifting focus from nuclear to transport and industry. Corporate R&D in energy is minimal at 0.6% of sales, the lowest of any major industry. The episode also notes Ola Electric's shift to a dealership model to address operational issues and highlights various market tidbits including Fairfax selling IIFL stakes and Amazon's renewable investments.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    The IEA described the crisis at the Strait of Hormuz as the largest supply disruption in oil market history, worse than the 1973, 1979, and 2002 shocks combined.

    Sahidi · 0:43

  2. 2
    The share of government research budgets allocated to energy dropped from 10% in 1981 to less than 2% in 2005, and is approximately 4% today.

    Sahidi · 3:30

  3. 3
    Europe's Innovation Fund, valued at €40 billion, had paid out only €332 million by mid-2025, representing less than 1% of the total, highlighting a gap between announced and actual spending.

    Sahidi · 6:43

  4. 4
    Among the world's 2,000 largest corporate R&D spenders, energy companies spend only 0.6% of sales on research, the lowest of any industry, compared to 13.4% for health/pharma and higher for banks.

    Sahidi · 8:03

Episode sections

  1. 0:41 – 13:13

    The economics of energy research

    The speaker discusses how government spending on energy research is driven by fear of oil shocks, citing the IEA's data on historical budgets. They note that while public spending has hit records, it remains low relative to GDP and is increasingly supplemented by Chinese equipment manufacturers like BYD, whereas India struggles with low R&D investment and a gap between budgeted and actual spending.

  2. 13:13 – 21:01

    Can dealerships fix Ola Electric?

    Ola Electric is shifting from company-owned stores to a dealership model to address high operational costs, poor service quality, and cash flow issues. The speaker analyzes the financial implications of dealer commissions versus store closure savings, compares Ola's performance to competitor Ather, and highlights ongoing regulatory and auditor concerns regarding Ola's financial health.

  3. The segment covers several brief market updates: Fairfax selling its stake in IIFL Finance to fund an IDBI Bank acquisition; a customs dispute involving Xiaomi and Flex; Amazon's renewable energy investments in India; an internal software outage at Apple; and Indian oil majors planning LPG imports from the US.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
AmazonAMZNequityneutralAmazon plans to invest another $7 billion in renewable projects in India by 2030 on top of $4 billion already contracted.
AppleAAPLequityneutralAn internal software update caused widespread outages at Apple, disrupting employee systems stores the App Store and services like iCloud.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

The IEA called the crisis at the Strait of Hormuz the largest supply disruption in oil market history, worse than 1973, 1979, and 2002 shocks combined.

Sahidi ·0:43

How to verify: IEA Crisis Centre reports or press releases from November 2026 regarding the Strait of Hormuz incident; compare with IEA historical crisis data for 1973, 1979, 2002. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Government spending on energy research more than doubled to about $25 billion by 1980 (in today's dollars) after the 1973 oil embargo.

Sahidi ·2:48

How to verify: IEA RD&D database data for 2026-2026; cross-reference with historical government budget documents from member countries. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

By 1998, government energy research spending had fallen to about $11 billion.

Sahidi ·2:51

How to verify: IEA RD&D database data for 1998. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

In 2024, IEA member governments spent a record $32 billion on energy research.

Sahidi ·3:11

How to verify: IEA RD&D database 2026 report; IEA Energy R&D Statistics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

In 1981, IEA member governments spent roughly 1 in 10 research dollars on energy; by 2005 less than 2 in 100; today about 4%.

Sahidi ·3:30

How to verify: OECD Main Science and Technology Indicators database; IEA RD&D share of total R&D statistics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

After the oil shocks, IEA members spent about 0.1% of GDP on energy research; now about 0.5%.

Sahidi ·3:50

How to verify: IEA RD&D expenditure data divided by GDP data for IEA member countries from World Bank or national statistics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The US is the biggest spender at about $11 billion by IEA estimate.

Sahidi ·3:50

How to verify: IEA RD&D database country-specific data for the United States. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

From 1974 to 1998, the correlation between oil prices and research budgets was 0.89.

Sahidi ·4:29

How to verify: Calculate correlation between IEA RD&D spending data and IEA/World Bank oil price indices for 2026-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

In 1974, nuclear power took 3 out of every 4 research dollars; today it gets one-fifth.

Sahidi ·5:10

How to verify: IEA RD&D database breakdown by technology category (nuclear vs. others) for 1974 and 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Over the last decade, transport research grew about six times; hydrogen production 13 times; coal research shrank by 96%.

Sahidi ·5:30

How to verify: IEA RD&D database category trends for transport, hydrogen, and coal from 2026-2026 (excluding US data as noted). For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify IEA 'Energy R&D Investment' historical data tables for nominal vs. GDP-adjusted spending trends.
  • Check Ola Electric's latest quarterly filings for dealer commission structures, store closure costs, and cash flow statements.
  • Review Fairfax Financial Holdings' latest 10-K or press releases regarding the sale of IIFL Finance stakes and IDBI Bank acquisition strategy.
  • Examine European Commission reports on the Innovation Fund's disbursement rates and reasons for low payout percentages.
  • Analyze Bloomberg or Reuters data on corporate R&D intensity by sector to confirm energy sector's 0.6% of sales ratio.
  • Check customs authority records or news reports for details on the Xiaomi-Flex dispute and its impact on supply chains.
Full transcriptexpand

0:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

0:04Sahidi: latest oil shock has brought back a question from the 1970s: who wants the next energy breakthrough? Government research spending surged back then, but eventually faded. Today, Chinese equipment makers drive much of their research while India struggles to keep up. That's our first story. Next, Ola Electric is abandoning its dealer-free strategy after problems with stores and surveys. Welcome back to the daily brief by Seruda, where we cut through the noise to help you understand what's actually happening in the most important stories from business and markets. I'm your host Sahidi, and today is November 19, 2026. Coming to our first story. This year, the world faced its biggest energy scare in half a century. The head of International Energy Agency, or IEA, called the crisis at the state of Hormuz the largest supply disruption in the history of the oil market, worse than the shocks of 1973, 1979, and 2002, all put together.

1:09Into energy research. Within six years, the governments more than doubled what they spent on inventing new ways to make and use energy. They bag nuclear reactors, solar cells, and fuel-efficient engines. But what if it happens again? And if it does, who will do the inventing? To answer that, we looked through five decades of government research budgets, years of companies' accounts, and India's own budget documents. We found that governments spend on energy research when they are scared and pull back when the scare passes. The spending that lasts comes from companies that make and sell energy equipment, like batteries and solar panels. Today most of these companies are Chinese. India has felt the scarce, but it has very few such companies and its government spends little on research. Let's walk through it. The IEA tracks what its members spend on energy research, development and demonstration, or RDND. That includes a Grant to a university lab. testing a new battery chemistry, a national lab improving wind turbine planes or public money for a first pilot plan that captures carbon from a factory chimney. Building that first real-world version before anyone knows if it works at scale is the demonstration part. The IES database goes back to 1974, but it has limits. It counts what governments' budgets, not always what they spend. It covers only the IEA's 32 member countries,

2:28so China and India don't appear. In the US, the biggest spender stopped sending detail figures after 2015, so the IEA now estimates its number. With that in mind, here's what the data tells us. After the 1973 oil embargo, government spending on energy research more than doubled to about $25 billion by 1980 in today's dollars. Then it slipped from slid

2:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the end.

2:51Sahidi: for almost two decades. By 1998, it had fallen to about $11 billion, less than half of its peak. Apart from one year spike in 2009, it took until 2021 to climb back above the 1918 level. In 2024, it hit a record of $32 billion. That sounds like a boom, right? But not quite. Economies and research budgets have grown enormously since. 1980, so a record in absolute terms can still be a modest effort in relative terms. To check, we looked at what share of all government research money goes to energy. The OECD tracks this, and we took the 14 rich countries with a full record since 1981. In 1981, these governments spent roughly 1 in every 10 research dollars on energy. By 2005, they spent less than 2 in 100. a hundred. Today it's about 4. The IEA makes the same point another way. Its members spent about 0.1% of their GDP on energy research after the oil shocks and spent about 0.5% now. Relative to the size of their economies, today's record is half of the old effort. As for who spends that money, the US is still the biggest spender by far. At about $11 billion by the IEA's estimate. which is why what happens in the Washington matters so much. What drives these budgets up and down? For a long time, the answer was simple: the

4:10price of oil. From 1974 to 1998, the two moved almost in lockstep. When oil prices shot up in the late 1970s, research budgets shot up too. When oil prices crashed in 1986, research budgets fell too. In fact, the two moves moved so closely together that the correlation was just 0.89 on a scale where one means they move perfectly in sync. That doesn't prove oil prices cause the spending, but the timing is hard to ignore. After the late 1990s, that link broke. Oil prices kept swinging, but research budgets climbed more steadily because governments had found new worries.

4:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): First,

4:50Sahidi: climate change. Then, after Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022, Europe had to worry about its gas supply, and European spending rose faster than anywhere else. By 2024, oil cost less than it did 10 years earlier. Yet governments spent 50% more on energy research. The worries also change what governments pay for. In 1974, nuclear power took three 3 out of every four research. 4 dollars. Governments felt so sure of it that people talked about electricity becoming too cheap to meter. Then 3 Mile Island and Chernobyl sow the world on it. Today nuclear gets fifth of the money. The biggest slice, about 30%, now goes to how we use energy, transport industry and buildings. Fossil fuels get just 3%. Over the last decade, transport research grew about six 6 times. Hydrogen production research grew 13 times. And coal research shrank by 96%. These category changes exclude the US, which stopped reporting detailed figures after 2015. Spain also changed how it counted EU recovery funds in 2022, which inflates the transport increase. Scare-driven money tends to leave as quickly as it arrives, and some of it already has.

6:03In 2024, governments in the IEA's member countries spend a record of $32 billion on energy research at China and the rest of the world, and public spending comes to roughly $55 billion in 2025. But that figure is already down about 2% from the year before. The IEA estimates partly because of cuts in Washington. The White House proposed roughly half. halving the Department of Energy's research budget for 2026. Congress refused and the final cut came to about 3%. In 2025, the department had already cancelled over $11 billion of clean energy projects and awards in two rounds. Europe has a different problem. It announces far more than it spends. By mid-2025, its innovation fund, worth 40 billion euros, had paid out. just 332 million euros according to the European Code of Auditors, less than 1% of the total. That gap between announcing and spending will come up again when we get to India. Governments

7:03aren't the biggest funders anyway. Take the IEA's latest figures for each source of money, and roughly two-thirds of all the spending on energy research comes from companies. Governments put in about fifth. and startup investors about tenth. Those startup investors have other priorities too. In 2024, AI startups raise nearly three times as much venture money as all energy startups put together. The startup money that does go to the energy has moved to the frontier. The IEA's energy technology perspectives 2026 finds find a recent search into six areas: hydrogen electrolysers, geothermal, advanced. heating and cooling, small nuclear reactors, hydrogen-based fuels, and grid technology. Fusion alone has drawn almost $11 million. A similar rush of venture money came 2 to 3 years before the solar and battery booms. But the IEA finds that none of the today's candidates has everything that made those two take off. So companies carry most of the load, but energy companies as a group spend very little of what they earn on research. Among the world's 2000 biggest corporate research spenders, energy companies spend just 0.6% of their sales on research, the lowest of any industry. Health and pharma companies spend 13.4%. Even banks spend more. China's own statistics show the same pattern at home.

8:23But why? Think about what an oil company or power utility. sells. A barrel of oil or a unit of electricity is the same whoever produces it. So these companies compete on cost, not on new products. Many utilities earn returns that regulators set, which leaves little reward for invention. In any breakthrough in, say grid storage helps every rival as much as the inventor. A drug company can patent a molecule and charge for it. A power company cannot charge more for a better electron. When fuel prices fell in 2025, oil and gas companies even cut their research spending by 4%. So, who invents energy technology today? Mostly the companies that make energy equipment, and most of these companies are Chinese. One comparison captures this. PYD's research budget grew from 0.27 billion euros in 2012 to 6.7. billion euros in 2024 or 6.5% of its sales. The five oil majors spent about the same in 2024 as in 2012, around 3.5 billion euros between them. As we wrote in our BYD story, China put eWays into its high tech development plan in 2001, partly because it depended on imported oil. So the scare came first there too. Then came years of subsidence. subsidies and research grants, then factories and only then companies

9:43that fund research at this scale. A company selling millions of batteries a year has reason to make the next one better and the revenue to pay for it. That revenue matters. When Chinese overcapacity crushed solar prices, solar manufacturers cut their research spending by about 25% between 2022 and 2024. Even battery makers now spend 5% of revenue on research, down from 8% in 2015. Factories pay for research only while they make money. India is not in the IES research data, so we built the picture from Indian sources starting with research of every kind. When we explored why India couldn't build the next Apple or Tesla last year, India's spending was about 0.6% of GDP on research. The government government's newer survey now puts it at 0.84%. Part of that rise comes from counting more companies, and the Indian forum points out that some of the Indian research actually spends abroad. Either way, India spends about a third of the world average. For energy, there's no

10:43official number at all. The best recent attempt studied a study by the Sustainable Futures Collaborative and Tufts University found about 1400. 1,450 crore rupees of public money spread over 1,359 clean energy research projects across six years. Two-thirds of those projects got less than 50 lakh rupees each, enough for a single professor's lab. A typical American grant for similar work runs 20 to nearly 100 times bigger. The Renewable Energy Minister shows the problem most clearly. Over the last eight years, 8 it spent less than half of what it budgeted for research. Its research budget for this year is 46 crore. Its rooftop solar subsidy by comparison gets 22,000 crore rupees.

11:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

11:27Sahidi: same gap between announcing and spending shows up elsewhere. The government flagship 1 lakh crore research fund got 20,000 crore for 2025 to 2026, but the revised estimate. cut that to 3000 crore rupees. If the government is lacking, Indian companies don't fill the gap either. Though nobody collects consistent data across them. Where government data exists, state-owned defense firms like HAL spend far more of their sales on research than state-owned oil and power companies do. That isn't a fair comparison since different firms build their own products, but it does show how little research happens. at India's energy companies, most of which still sell oil, gas, and power, not technology. The 1970s showed that a big NF scare can double energy research budgets in a few years. The last decade showed something different. The research that last comes from companies that build and sell energy hardware, and China built most of those companies. India now wants to make its own solar cells and

12:27batteries. As we have covered last month, China restricted exports of some battery technology in 2025 so Indian companies can no longer simply buy the know-how. They will have to develop it. That leaves three things worth tracking. First, whether this year's hormonoscale lifts research budgets the way 1973 did. The IA's next data release will show the first signs. Second, whether India's government actually spends what water budgets for research this year, starting with 20,000 crore rupees fund. And third, whether India's new battery and solar factories, like Tata Cell Plant, due in 2027, start spending on research the way C ATL and BYD do. And if they do, India's energy labs could finally grow out of its factories. Coming to the second story. In May, an analyst asked Pavish Agarwal, the founder of Ola Electric, whether the company would finally bring in Delos. Its stores, the analyst said, were very good when they opened, but had since got worse. Pavish was adamant he had no such plans. But three months later, on August 6, Ola announced it was

13:33moving to Delos. dealers. Its own stores have already stopped taking new autos, and service is moving to Delos dealers too. By 8th November, 255 dealers were already running 319 Ola stores. The plan is to reach about 450 stores by December, while shutting down most of its own stores by then. Why the sudden change of heart? What was Ola trying to achieve without dealers? And can dealers now fix what broke? Most two-wheelers in India are sold through dealers, usually local business people investing their own. money. But with electric vehicles, Ola wanted to cut out the middleman. An electric scooter is, in a sense, a gadget on wheels. So Ola sold it like a phone. He booked online, took a test ride at a company store, and received new features over the air. For a while, that really worked. By Ola's In own count, nearly one in every two electric two-wheelers registered in India between April and June 2024. was an Ola. By December that year, Ola announced it would expand its company-owned network from about 800 stores to 4000 within the same month, each with a service center. By any measure, that was a bold claim. Perhaps too bold. Ola would learn that running service centers wasn't easy at all. Every store needed staff and spare parts, and all of that was now Ola's responsibility. In financial year 2025, staff

14:52attrition at Ola reached 54%, mainly driven by these stores. By October 2025, a repair took about 9 days on average, far longer than a dealer workshop or independent service center. By then, customers had already been complaining about the both scooters and the service. Questions were also raised about Ola's expansion announcement itself. In April 2020, 2026, SEBI sent Ola and Bavish a show cost notice. It alleged that December 2024 announcement was false and misleading about how many stores had service centers and that Ola's share price rose 8.4% that day. Ola has applied to settle without admitting liability. SEBI has not decided yet. These remain allegations, not a final finding. Ola says it brought Average Repair Town. down to about a day by March 2026, but by then many customers had moved. January to March 2026 was its weakest quarter in at least two years, with 20,256 vehicles 84% below its peak. Ola had also started sharply cutting its own stone network. In August, Ola admitted that a dealer can handle the local details of auto retail, servicing, and stores. much better at scale. A dealer does three things that are hard to manage from a head office. First, a dealer puts up money. When Ola ran its own stores, each scooter on the

16:12showroom floor tied up Ola's money until a customer bought it. Now dealers pay when they order and hold the stock themselves. That makes working capital management easier for Ola. Managing that money is difficult when you're both the manufacturer and the dealer. It's one reason. car companies also sell largely through dealerships. Second, dealers make OLA tax refunds easier to claim. But how? An electric scooter attracts less GST than some of the parts inside it. Say the GST on a scooter when it's sold is 5000, but the GST on its parts is 8,000. The manufacturer can claim the difference, a refund of 3000, rupees, but it must prove that the scooter was sold. When Ola held unsold inventory itself, doing this at scale across states was difficult. Now the first sale is recorded when a dealer buys from Ola, making those refunds easier to claim. Third comes the workshop, which is what Ola's customers felt most. A dealer who owns the business has their own money invested. When scooters sit waiting for repairs, they lose service income and potential customers. When Bavish pitched Ola to dealers in August, he pointed to its very large customer space. Many owners were already passed their three-year warranty, meaning their repairs would be paid service work for dealers. Some rivals never made the same choice. The useful comparison is Aether, which, like Ola, sells only electric two-wheelers. In financial year 2026,

17:32Aether doubled its network to 700 experienced centers. centres. About three three-quarters quarters of its new centers came from dealers. who already operated at Aether stores. The difference shows up in vehicle registrations, measured in the same way for both companies. In October 2024, Ola registered about 2.6 vehicles for everyone registered by Aether. Two years later, that had completely reversed. Between July and September 2026, mostly before OLAS dealership switch started, OLA registered about 41,400 vehicles. against Aether's 89,600 vehicles. To be fair, much of this difference comes down to the products themselves. Ola's scooters had plenty of quality problems. But a dealer who owns the store has a reason to get repairs done quickly. Aether had those dealers and Ola didn't. The dealership switch pulls Ola's finances into two directions. Ola says closing its store should cut costs by about 50 crore rule. but dealers take a commission on every score to score, which reduces Ola's margin.

18:32On Ola's latest second quarter earnings call, an analyst estimated that commission at around 11,000 per vehicle. Management wouldn't confirm that amount but called the arrangement an introductory commission that should fall. Let's do a rough calculation. Ola delivered close to 35,000 vehicles in the July to September quarter. At 11,000 each, dealer commissions would be about 38.5 crore per quarter. But Ola hasn't said whether the 50 crore rupees saving is quarterly or annual. If it's quarterly, Ola comes out roughly 11.5 crore ahead. If it's annual, it's worse off until commissions fall or sales rise. Either way, these are small amounts next to Ola's losses. In July to September, Ola lost 300. R362 crore. In the same quarter, Athar made a small profit of 1.2 crore. Ola's cash and bank balances also fell from 1,542 crore in March to 750 crore in September. In October, Ola raised money from shareholders through a 1,000 crore rights issue, of which 600 crore has come in. There's an auditor's warning worth understanding too. Ola's auditor, BSR,

19:41drew attention to the going concern note where management explains why it believes the company can keep paying its debts. BSR also disagreed about when Ola should record a possible penalty of around 68 crore for missing an investment deadline under the PLI scheme. The auditor believes it belonged in the April to June Gottor quarter instead. Ola's total loss doesn't change. only the quarter in which it appears does. The first signs of Ola's dealership switch looks encouraging. Dealers ordered about 13,500 vehicles from Ola in October, up from roughly 4,000 in September. Production also rose from about 9,200 vehicles in August to 14,100 in October. Ola had already made 5,526 vehicles in the first 11 days of November. But at that pace, November production would probably reach only about 15,000 vehicles against the 20,000 Ola forecast in its own letter. Business is about how quickly you can change course when a long-held assumption proves wrong. Ola has finally pulled that clutch on its belief that it didn't need dealers. But has the change come too late? Dealers are signing up and the market is growing fast. yet Ola has fallen behind its peers, and the hill it has to climb is now much steeper.

21:01And now a few quick tidbits. Number one: Fairfax is selling its entire 13.25 person stake in IAFL finance for about 3455 crore. The sale will help fund. its much larger 52,878 crore acquisition of 60.72% stake in IDBI bank. Meanwhile, Blackstone is investing 5000 crore in IAFL finance for a nearly 16% stake. Number 2. India says Shaw Shoe Me Mi and its former contract manufacturer Flex did not fully disclose royalty agreements while importing phone components. Shoe Mi argues these royalties paid separately to technology partners shouldn't attract custom duties. The dispute could cost Shoe Mi India over $150 million, and the outcome could also affect similar contract manufacturing arrangements in other industries. Number 3. Amazon plans to invest another $7 billion in renewable projects in India by 2030 on top of $4 billion already contracted. It has also announced 4 new wind and solar projects totalling 934 MW. Once these are operational, Amazon's renewable energy portfolio in India will cross 2 GW.

22:19Number 4. An internal software update caused widespread outages at Apple, disrupting employee systems stores the App Store and services like iCloud. Some stores faced problems with sales, repairs, and customer service while employees were logged out of key tools for hours. Apple said many systems have been restored and clarified that the outage wasn't caused by a cyber attack. Number 5. Indian Oil, BPCL, and HPCL will import about 2.75 million tons of US LPG in 2027 through contracts with ArmoCore. Armoco, Chevrin, Total Energies, and Vital. India traditionally depends heavily on the Middle East, which supplied about 90% of its LPG imports in 2025. It now plans to source up to a quarter of its LPG imports from the US in 2027. That's all the news I have for you. Thank you so much for watching and see you in the next

23:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): one.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights