NZ property values fall for seventh month as election limbo and soft labour data weigh on market outlook
Summary
Nick Goodall and Kelvin Davidson report that the October Cotality Home Value Index showed a national decline of 0.4%, marking seven consecutive months of falling values. They note that while Christchurch and Dunedin remained flat, Auckland and Wellington experienced significant annual drops, with Auckland's median value nearing $1 million. The speakers analyze Q3 labour market data, highlighting an unexpected 0.1% fall in employment that pushed the unemployment rate to 5.7%, the highest since 2015/2016. This soft data reduces the odds of a Reserve Bank of New Zealand OCR hike in December, though Davidson remains slightly inclined towards an increase due to inflation expectations. Finally, they discuss the political uncertainty surrounding pending special votes and the potential impact of housing portfolio changes on supply reforms.
Key takeaways
- 1 put it sort of fifty-one percent odds in favour of an increase. So something like that. I mean it it it it feels as if it it could be a pretty close run thing. Um particularly if we got some some softer sort of incoming figures over the next sort of three or four weeks, you could easily imagine a another hold.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 12:21
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 6:17
October Cotality Home Value Index and Regional Trends
Nick Goodall and Kelvin Davidson discuss the October Cotality Home Value Index, which showed a national decline of 0.4%, marking seven consecutive months of falling values. Christchurch and Dunedin remained flat, while Auckland and Wellington saw significant annual drops of 4.2%, with Auckland's median value nearing the $1 million mark at $1.006m.
- 6:17 – 18:05
Labour Market Data and OCR Implications
The speakers analyze Q3 labour market data, noting an unexpected 0.1% fall in employment that pushed the unemployment rate up to 5.7%. Davidson suggests this reduces the odds of a Reserve Bank of New Zealand Official Cash Rate (OCR) hike on 9 December, though he still leans slightly towards an increase due to inflation expectations.
- 18:05 – 27:36
Political Limbo and Housing Policy Outlook
Goodall and Davidson discuss the uncertainty surrounding the New Zealand election results due to 400,000 pending special votes. They note that while the current coalition is likely to continue, the departure of Chris Bishop from the housing portfolio is a concern, with hopes that his successor will maintain his focus on housing supply and RMA reform.
- 27:36 – 28:55
Sporting Results and Weekend Activities
Nick Goodall discusses the All Blacks' disciplined victory, noting it wasn't a vintage performance despite the scoreline. He mentions potential injuries to Will Jordan and Geordie Barrett and the family's engagement with election results.
- 28:55 – 31:10
Phoenix FC Match and Cricket Update
Goodall recounts Phoenix FC's draw against Auckland FC, describing it as a positive result away from home. He also covers the Black Caps' close One Day International match, which was affected by rain and resulted in a competitive finish.
- 31:10 – 31:58
Closing Remarks and OCR Horizon
The host acknowledges the approaching 9 December Official Cash Rate (OCR) decision as a key upcoming event. He thanks the listeners and co-host, concluding the episode with a call for feedback on election implications.
Claims worth verifying
National property values fell by 0.4% in October, marking seven consecutive months of decline.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·0:49
How to verify: Check the official Cotality Home Value Index (HVI) release for October 2026 on the Cotality website or NZ Property Reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Auckland's median property value is $1.006 million.
Nick Goodall ·3:34
How to verify: Verify against the specific median value data published in the October 2026 Cotality HVI report. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Hastings property values fell 5.6% over the last year, while Lower Hutt fell 5.4%.
Nick Goodall ·4:54
How to verify: Check the regional sub-market data in the October 2026 Cotality HVI report. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Invercargill property values were up 4.3% over the last 12 months.
Nick Goodall ·5:14
How to verify: Verify against the regional sub-market data in the October 2026 Cotality HVI report. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The unemployment rate rose to 5.7% in Q3, up from 5.6%.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·7:51
How to verify: Check the New Zealand Quarterly Employment Survey (QES) for Q3 2026 released by Stats NZ. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Employment fell by 0.1% in Q3, which was unexpected.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·9:10
How to verify: Review the detailed employment figures in the Q3 2026 Quarterly Employment Survey by Stats NZ. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Reserve Bank of New Zealand's Official Cash Rate (OCR) decision is scheduled for 9 December.
Nick Goodall ·6:37
How to verify: Check the Reserve Bank of New Zealand's official monetary policy meeting calendar. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
There are 400,000 special votes pending counting in the New Zealand general election.
Nick Goodall ·18:44
How to verify: Verify the number of special votes reported by the Electoral Commission of New Zealand. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Chris Bishop has departed from the housing portfolio.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·22:09
How to verify: Check the official New Zealand Government ministry website or news releases regarding cabinet appointments post-election. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the October Cotality Home Value Index data and methodology to confirm the 0.4% national decline and regional trends.
- Review the latest Q3 New Zealand labour market data from Stats NZ to confirm the 0.1% employment fall and 5.7% unemployment rate.
- Check the Reserve Bank of New Zealand's monetary policy statements and market expectations for the 9 December OCR decision.
- Analyze the pending special vote counts and potential coalition shifts following the New Zealand general election.
- Assess the impact of Chris Bishop's departure from the housing portfolio on RMA reform and housing supply policies.
- Examine wage growth data to evaluate the risk of second-round inflation and wage-price spirals.
- Compare Auckland's median house price trends with new build supply data to understand the $1 million threshold dynamics.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): The general tone of the October figures was pretty much down everywhere.
- 0:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm here
- 0:17
- Nick Goodall: of research Nick Goodall and I'm joined as per usual by Chief Economist Calvin Davidson. Calvin, I'm not sure what to say about election day, given we're kind of left in limbo at the moment. So I suppose we'll leave that to the end to discuss potential implications for the housing market. So first, let's uh get into the home value
- 0:37
- Nick Goodall: index for October, which you released last week. How did that uh release and conversation to media go?
- 0:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, it's uh continuation of recent In trends. I'm trying not to use that phrase that I've I've I've said before. It it really is
- 0:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we're
- 0:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): just seeing the same. the old things roll on. So minus 0.4% fall at the national level in October.
- 0:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 0:57
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): think that was we might have even had minus 0.4 in September as well. Seven falls in a row, not collapsing, but you know, this this continued drift lower. Main centres, Christchurch kind of flat, Daneting Dunedin kind of flat, um, more of what we've been seeing. Auckland and Wellington down again. So yeah, there's
- 1:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the it's it's just on on repeat cycle. I suppose if anything,
- 1:22
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 1:22
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, you look across the wider results, not just the main centres, you're looking, I guess, the the next tier of towns and cities, provincial markets. There's just a bit of a softer tone, you know, for a while there in certain months. You might have had,
- 1:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
- 1:34
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Invercago Invocago up a bit, Napier up a bit, these sorts of things. The the general tone of of the October figures was was pretty much down everywhere to differing degrees, but it certainly had a sort of weaker feel to it. So I I guess just
- 1:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
- 1:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): certainly no end in sight to this this week patch that we've got. And you look at um economies still, you know, some things are looking better, some things, some things worse. I mean, we'll talk about the labour labor market figures, they're they're not picking up uh just yet. So you know, there's that economic uncertainty out there. We've we've still got this political limbo, I suppose. Um, you know, things going on
- 2:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): globally, cost of living pressures. So, you know, it's difficult to see what what turns this round uh in the next little while either. We were still seeing sales drift lower, still a lot of stock on the market, you know, buyers have the pricing power. Um, but even those buyers that they've they've got to jumped a few hurdles first in terms of satisfying bank criteria and that sort of thing. So it's not as if it's not as
- 2:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): if it's uh you know a free for all for buyers. They've still got to satisfy some of those tests. So there is there's just yeah a continuation of of what we're seeing. There's probably not probably not a huge amount more to say. Obviously we'll w whether the election will come up, but that's just going to presumably uh e extend things for a while yet. We'll get into that sort of holiday shutdown and come
- 2:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): back in the new year. That it's just
- 2:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a continuation. Yeah, it's um
- 2:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): hard
- 2:54
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to see it changing.
- 2:55
- Nick Goodall: Yeah, yeah. No, I I can I can feel the uh pain in your voice in terms of there not being too much to talk about. I suppose the only thing I'd I'd written down was a couple of the actual figures that uh illustrate the situation. You know, when you look at the wider Auckland region, the wider Wellington region, both of them down by 4.2% over the last year. So I'm just focusing
- 3:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on the.
- 3:15
- Nick Goodall: annual figures right now because, yeah, like I say, it's the accumulation of you know multiple months now where values have turned negative, and even prior to that, pretty flat. So I think that that annual figure is now illustrating that. For Auckland overall, that broader region or super city, the median value could now be below $1 million, Dollars not too far away. I think it's
- 3:34
- Nick Goodall: 1.006 one point zero zero six mil. Um, so it's pretty close there. to that million dollar mark, which I don't know, it feels like an a weird backwards milestone, maybe, to say that there the median value will be below a million dollars. Not necessarily a bad thing, of course, for anyone to get into that market. That'll be a good sign, right? That that values are more affordable. It's probably also a reflection of, you know, new um
- 3:54
- Nick Goodall: builds over the last you know what, five, six, eight years um have been at that more affordable end with lots of townhouses being built too. So that will have had a a minor impact, I suppose. In the grand scheme of things, the amount that have been built will be pretty small compared to the total number of properties to really affect that median value. But with values falling at the same time, yeah, that value now looks, you know, much closer
- 4:14
- Nick Goodall: to a million dollars, which, yeah, as I say, as a as a figure itself is often seen as a bit of a milestone one. So to drop below it, I think, will be um a headline in itself if that does occur within the next couple of months. So that's maybe one thing to look to at. look out for. Within the Auckland boundaries, the North Shore down five point two percent over the last year. Auckland City itself, so sort of the
- 4:34
- Nick Goodall: isthmus area, that's down five point one percent. And then if you look at Wellington, that's the broader figure for Wellington was four point two, but Lower Heart itself down five point four percent over the last year. But I think to your point, you know, when you step outside the regions now or to the regions, we are seeing those similar sorts of weaknesses in some parts of the country. I mean Hastings jumped out
- 4:54
- Nick Goodall: to me, it was down five point six percent in the last year, which was a bit of a surprise actually. I didn't think there was such great weakness in some of those regional markets, particularly out in that Hawke's Bay area. So that jumped out. Invercargo is still on the flip side of course up four point three percent over the last 12 twelve months. So that's the one with the sort of stronger performance for that next tier of cities. But as
- 5:14
- Nick Goodall: you sort of touched on, even Invercargle had seen some declines over the last couple of months as well. So yeah, that's the last year. It's still up. But even then more recently has seen a bit more weakness. So yeah, look, it's a it's an interesting one. Um as you said, maybe the most important point is the you know, the um expectation for future isn't really that we'll see any change
- 5:34
- Nick Goodall: to that. We've had some mixed results economically as you mentioned. So yes, there's some reason to be positive. You know, interest rates, there's some big questions, and I think there's some implications on interest rates from the employment data, which we'll touch on in a second. Um, but ultimately, yeah, that balance of power stays with the buyers, supply is still high, likely to remain so. And um, you know, without
- 5:54
- Nick Goodall: any major change to the economy or anything else expected soon, it's hard not to see this continuing on for the next few months. And as you said, then you get into a a slower period over Christmas. where people often wait and hold their activity back until, you know, late January, start of February. So, you know, I don't want to say we're going into that holding period right now, but it's certainly hard to see any dramatic turnaround um in the
- 6:13
- Nick Goodall: short term anyway.
- 6:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
- 6:15
- Nick Goodall: move
- 6:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on.
- 6:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
- 6:17
- Nick Goodall: Yeah, move us on then to that economic data. Um of course we did get the labor market data for Q3. You know, go through all those key high-level figures for the employment data. And as I sort of touched on there, maybe, you know, any influence that had over your expectations for what might what it might mean for the official cash rate decision, which I know it was
- 6:37
- Nick Goodall: what's exactly a month now, 9th of December. So it's still some way away. But of course this will be one of the major data releases a Reserve Bank were waiting to see for to influence their decision next month. So yeah, the data first and then maybe implications of that data.
- 6:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yep. Just a couple of things I'll cover off on the on the home value stuff first, just quickly, as was I suppose um you know you mentioned North Shore there. You know, just a reminder that and and yes there's going to be different qualities of property and different spectrums within each market. It's not as if North Shore's all upper end property, but I think it's probably just a wee reminder in there. We saw Auckland City, you
- 7:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, yes, a lot of apartments there, but also some some very expensive suburbs that the most expensive suburbs in the country. Uh, you know, just a reminder that that the upper end is not always immune. You know, and it's not necessarily sort of myth busting or anything, but you know, good reminder in there that North Shore's down, Auckland City's down. Um, you know, that that that upper end of the market can also feel
- 7:31
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a bit of uh feel a bit of a downturn as well. So good reminder on that. And also, yeah, running through all of this, um, we're not trying to say that. downturns are bad or good or what they they just are what they are. And and a good reminder in there too, that you know, these are great conditions to be a buyer. Not so good for sellers, of course, but there's always two sides and and great conditions to be a buyer. So um
- 7:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yeah, just a a a a couple of uh sort of side issues in there around the labour market. Um yeah, but surprising. Uh so we saw the unemployment rate go up from five 5.6% point six percent to five 5.7. point seven. I think that was the highest since 2015 or 16, something like that. So, you know, we we are running at a fairly high level for unemployment. Um, the decade average is somewhere around four
- 8:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and a half. So we, you know, we there is so-called spare capacity in the labour market. It's definitely in favour of employers at the moment rather than employees. Um, so yeah, a bit of a surprise that that it went up. The the expectation was that it would edge down a little bit. We uh in terms turn of this. there's lots moving parts with labor market figures, of course. So there were there was no surprise that the
- 8:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): working age population went up. You know, that that tends to always be the case, so no surprises there. Um the labor force participation rate went down a little bit. So, you know, people sort of discouraged worker effect that people talk about. If there's not a lot of hiring going on, you maybe you don't actually start looking for work in the first place. You just sort of go, you know, you you you you stay at home, look after the kids, or you
- 8:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): stay in education or whatever it is. So those two things sort of push against each other. You get you get more labor supply through a higher population, but you get reduced labor supply through not as many people participating in the labour force. So those those things sort of offset each other. The the surprise variable or the swing variable was actually a fall in employment,
- 9:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): which people hadn't really anticipated. We had seen monthly filled jobs indicators look a little bit better. Some of the sort of intentions elements to the say business confidence surveys, some of those were looking a little bit better. So yeah, it was a surprise to see employment go down. Wasn't a big fall, but it was something it was 0.1% off the top of my head. But you know, enough to
- 9:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): see the unemployment rate go up. So this this was, I guess, in contrast to previous quarters, maybe where the unemployment rate had gone up because. of a bigger labor force or more people available for work. This was actually about fewer jobs. Now might be a one-off. Who knows? There's some sampling issues in here, and you know, the figures aren't necessarily foolproof.
- 9:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): But yeah, that was a surprise to see employment go down. So I think, yeah, just um like I said earlier in that little chat about home values or house prices, it's uh there is just this uncertainty out there in the economy. and you know that it's certainly not great to have to have employment falling a little bit. Um, as I say, spare capacity still in the labour market, definitely things
- 10:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): in favour of employers at the moment. There's those bigger pools of of workers available. Um, so yeah, it's it's it is just um it does sort of suggest that subdued outlook for the housing market, too. We've still got uh wage growth pretty subdued, which as as you'd anticipate, in a market where employers have got the have got the bargaining power, you'd expect wage
- 10:31
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): growth to be pretty subdued. And it does feed into the the talk about the official cash rate. You know, that the big thing through all of this so pretty much all of this year, I suppose, basically has been second round inflation. What what's uh where will this become embedded? Um, and part of that is to do with with wages. If if workers start to see cost of living going up, start to work
- 10:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): f uh ask for higher wages, you know, it all just becomes sort of self reinforcing. But at the moment, yeah, that that wage pressure isn't really there because unemployment's elevated. Um, you know, it's it's difficult to to negotiate higher pay. So we're not really seeing that come through. So that that aspect of of second round inflation risks just isn't isn't really
- 11:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): there. So yeah, I mean, whoa, chances of an OCR rise in a month. month's time, um, I mean, they've definitely reduced. Uh
- 11:18
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
- 11:18
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I probably still slightly lean towards an OCR rise, and that's partly because um, you know, the labor market figures are so-called lagging. So they're the kind of the last domino in the in the chain. And so you'd you'd anticipate that this was was always some sort of chance. You can have an economic recovery before you get the jobs market turning around. So
- 11:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you know there's there's that sort of element. Inflation itself is expected to to rise pretty sharply in in Q4, the the quarter we're in now. And then keep in mind that last meeting, all of the committee members supposedly said, yep, we're we we think inflation's going to go higher. We've got concerns. That hold last time was more of a timing thing than anything else. Um so
- 11:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you do have those sort of sorts of arguments. But also
- 12:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 12:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): facts can change. And the facts may well have changed since their meeting. And if anything, these labour market figures were softer than than maybe they were anticipating at their last meeting. So yeah, I think it probably does reduce the chances of an OCR rise.
- 12:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): put it sort of fifty-one percent odds in favour of an increase. So something like that. I mean it it it it feels as if it it could be a pretty close run thing. Um particularly if we got some some softer sort of incoming figures over the next sort of three or four weeks, you could easily imagine a another hold.
- 12:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So yeah, uh probably sitting on the fence on that one. If I had to bet I'd probably go for an OCR rise, but I I you just get a sense
- 12:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that you
- 12:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know that that could be pretty close run thing. And if the data that we get in the meantime is pretty soft as well, you'd probably tip it back the other way towards a a hold and you know see how things look in the new year. So but either way, not great numbers. You know, we all want to see jobs growth and we want to see unemployment coming down. So um not good from that front.
- 13:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
- 13:05
- Nick Goodall: I think that's the core, right? Like there it's not good to see our labour market struggling. Most expectation was a a minor drop in the unemployment rate. So from five 5.6 point six to five 5.5, point five or at best holding flat. So the fact it went up is definitely not a good sign. Um, as you say, from an interest rate perspective, the fact that wage growth doesn't look strong. I think um
- 13:25
- Nick Goodall: public sector wage growth was even weaker than um I sorry, pi private sector was weaker than public sector, which was a bit of a surprise. So there haven't been those wage increases either. And I think like you said, that just shows that the employer has the power, not the employee. They can't really go in there and say, I've got more costs, you've got to pay me more. They're kind of just happy they've got a job. Um, so you
- 13:45
- Nick Goodall: know, I think that's obviously not a good sign, have that spare capacity and that the labor market isn't as strong as it could be. And yeah, I understand that, you know, the labour market maybe is working on a lag from the broader economy. So we might see that strength come through in the current quarter we're in and into next year. And and fingers crossed we do so. Um, but yeah, then when you get to the question of what's the Reserve Bank going to do, I mean,
- 14:05
- Nick Goodall: I I tend to agree with you that, you know, because they indicated, you know, that we still need to tighten monetary policy. They still do know it's stimulatory at the moment and they want to get on top of inflation. And yes, we do expect inflation to bounce back up again. It's likely they're still going to go ahead with the lift next month, but totally agree that the chances of it did reduce following
- 14:25
- Nick Goodall: this data. Um Look it's a bit of a wild cut, I suppose, and not expecting you to have any great insight on this one. But I do also wonder about, you know, what what what is going to happen? You know, I still think that the the maybe the greater influence is what's happening in the Middle East. Are we going to see some sort of resolution there? Does that mean petrol prices, you know,
- 14:45
- Nick Goodall: return returned back to some level of normality? Not saying it'll go back to, you know, last year's prices um sooner rather than later I've got no idea, and I don't know if you do on the impact of the midterms last week. Of course a a pretty big flip to the to the blue side, to the Democrat side and and what that means for the war in Iran. Just I I honestly have no idea.
- 15:05
- Nick Goodall: So maybe other people will have greater opinion on that and whether that means there's a stronger likelihood of a resolution. Um dunno, it feels like maybe there should be, but you know, again I I don't know uh American politics and the way it works well enough to know whether that's a a fair assumption or not. But that to me might be something else we watch for over the next month um as to you know
- 15:25
- Nick Goodall: what influence that might have and and and maybe more about you know the confidence that if that ends sooner rather than later that inflation doesn't quite isn't quite as bad as as is expected and also it's not quite as sticky as expected, in which case you don't need to tighten as much as expected. But does that mean they still don't want to get to 3% or 3.25%?
- 15:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): To
- 15:44
- Nick Goodall: know, probably not. I still think they want to get to that level. That's where they seem to think neutral is at. And so, you know, to Kerry Bank's point of view or or their point that they made prior to the previous um decision, you know, do you just get on with it, get it sooner rather than later? You want to get it done before Christmas and and you know, when there's a bigger gap to the next reserve. Bank decision next year and and then you wait and
- 16:04
- Nick Goodall: see how that impacts the market? Maybe so. But um
- 16:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 16:08
- Nick Goodall: dunno, certainly still plenty of uncertainties there. There's no doubt about that. So yeah, who knows where that's gonna go. But yeah, I don't know. I mean, we can talk about the the general election here in New Zealand, of course, shortly. Did you have anything on the American one? I know how f how close you follow politics over there and any other read on the Middle East, or do we
- 16:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): just move
- 16:25
- Nick Goodall: on?
- 16:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Not uh not too close. closely. I've listened to uh a wee bit of commentary and analysis after. I I guess uh but it but dep depends on on who you're listening to uh at so by the sounds of it. I mean I've I've heard some commentary that oh well, um you know it's a so called lame duck president now, so you know, other people can maybe more moderate people can come in and sort of
- 16:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): negotiate with Iran or whatever it is, but uh you know, which which which might soften the crisis, but then um other commentary saying, Yeah, but you know, we've had so called lame duck presidents in the past and and stuff can still happen. You know, there's dis decisions can still be made, that they still have some authority, so you could you could probably overplay that. And also a a
- 17:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): view that
- 17:06
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 17:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): uh uh you know, from the from the middle from some of the re regimes in the Middle East, from their perspective, uh th I think the phrase was, you know, that they they can sniff weakness and um so, you know, uncertainty politically in in America could actually see
- 17:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): some
- 17:22
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of the Middle Eastern regimes sort of push back even harder because wow, you know, those guys are battling away, aren't
- 17:27
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they?
- 17:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): We'll we'll actually push harder and, you know, ask for more things and, you know, maybe do more strikes or whatever. So
- 17:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 17:34
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): don't know. I you know, that probably hasn't added much to the debate, but I don't I I guess the the sense that
- 17:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know
- 17:40
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the politics in America might soften a little bit because uh you know Donald Trump's been being pushed down a bit might not necessarily be true. Um and also it might prompt even even stronger reaction from the Middle East. So um yeah I I don't think we should necessarily assume that it all it all is it's all hunky dory
- 18:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): anytime soon. It it could uh you know in some way ways could even get worse. So we'll see.
- 18:05
- Nick Goodall: Yep, no fair play. And who knows, he's the sort of guy that would be almost more steadfast in uh in his his expectations or his thinking um when he gets pushback from other people. So yeah, unpredictable is certainly a word to say. Um all right mate, well let's move more locally then and to the election on Saturday day and and and through the evening of course with the counting.
- 18:24
- Nick Goodall: Um I as just thought sort of I said at the start right we're a little bit in limbo. There is more waiting. There's, I suppose, continued uncertainty about what government could look like. I think, you know, um intriguing election, no doubt, election results, of course. Um the mostly because, you know, the way that the special votes, which I think there's what,
- 18:44
- Nick Goodall: 400,000 hundred thousand of them, the way they typically seem to go is left, but I've read some stuff that says maybe this time around, you know, as much left as they previously have been, so maybe we can't see as much of a swing currently based on where things are at, of course, there is the chance or opportunity for the current coalition to form a government. So you'd have to say if that's the case, other than the smaller parties within that coalition
- 19:04
- Nick Goodall: getting a higher proportion of uh votes, meaning that maybe they've got a bit more negotiation power um power, um, along with the fact that National have lost some pretty experienced MPs maybe that's the that's the most likely thing that brings more uncertainty as to what does a government look like and who has what position and and what influence could that mean they have
- 19:24
- Nick Goodall: over the broader government and and then which who's get who gets what policies through. Maybe that's the maybe that's the area that we'd focus on most to understand what could happen. And and that's where I think um you know something that you've mentioned in the past with Act wanting to bring back or remove the ring fencing of of losses on a property portfolio. Maybe that's something that could
- 19:44
- Nick Goodall: be brought more to the fore from an election policy or from a um from a political perspective if they've got more control. So maybe that's something they would want to push harder. Not sure it's one of their top policies, but maybe that's something we need to consider. Um otherwise, of course, I think we need to consider the fact that they cannot form a government in their current state because we get some. swings from the specials
- 20:04
- Nick Goodall: and we see Opportunity Party become a negotiator in that role. And so I suppose that's something we need to consider as well. Obviously, a conversation that can they be happy to sit in the cross benches or can we get this hung parliament? I think no one would want a hung parliament to mean we have to go and vote again. Um So let's fingers crossed, hope we don't get there
- 20:24
- Nick Goodall: once the specials are counted uh by Watson. what's it 27th of of November. Um
- 20:30
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah
- 20:30
- Nick Goodall: I don't know I I'm not even sure I've said anything worth talking about in this in those two sentences or few sentences. Um but yeah I think ultimately my central point probably right now in terms of potential impact is likely not too much impact to the housing market um based on the results that we've seen so far. Unless we see a major swing
- 20:50
- Nick Goodall: and I don't think that is really likely, not to say it couldn't happen, um, but it looks like, you know, the current coalition are likely to have the most power in any negotiations. And so my assumption is that we go down that path, and that means less disruption to our current situation of the housing market. Is that is that a fair summary? Do you have anything else
- 21:10
- Nick Goodall: to throw amongst the there? Any other cats amongst the pigeons there?
- 21:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
- 21:14
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I I yeah, it there's so much contingent on on what happens in those special votes, isn't it? I mean, the thing that's frustrating me is is how long it takes to count special votes. I mean, how can that be the case? So I'm sure there's lots of things that justify it, but yeah, it seems a bit strange that
- 21:28
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're gonna do that. You get
- 21:28
- Nick Goodall: on post these days.
- 21:29
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. Yeah. So we we do have email nowadays, like So you know, we're not relying on steamships and stuff. So if it feels like that could be a little bit faster, but like I say, there's probably got good reasons for that. But yeah, no, I I I mean I suppose sometimes I try and make decisions in my life based on what I know and and not worry too much about what I don't know. And what we know now is that you know the way
- 21:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): things stand right now is is it it probably looks like the the current government continues on. Um so you know, that's probably a bit of a working assumption for now, but um, you know, you have to take into account that those specials could change that. So um yeah, we're we're always all waiting in limbo a little bit. I suppose um yeah one thing from the housing market perspective is that you know Chris Bishop's done a pretty good job on
- 22:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): on housing supply and RMA reform and all of these things I think now that that's that's not going to continue at least at least via him so that's that's probably a bit of a shame but you'd hope that the next um you know next person who picks up that portfolio whichever side of the spectrum they're on continues that that reform around
- 22:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): housing supply and you know planning policy, all of those things, because I think most people would agree that's that's been a you know a big a big plus. Um so you know we've seen the way that housing supply has changed and the way that housing affordability's changed. So I think yeah continuation of that kind of work would be would be pretty valued, I would say. So that that's one thing that's perhaps come out of it from a
- 22:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): from a housing perspective. But you'd assume that the next minister that the that that does that portfolio would would continue that on. So um
- 22:55
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah,
- 22:55
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): fingers crossed I suppose.
- 22:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 22:57
- Nick Goodall: I mean that's a great extra point, right? Because I agree that, you know, in the conversations we have out there from all people from different ends of the spectrum and all sorts of different roles, whether they're heavily involved in housing or not so much, I think generally, like you say, there's been a a pretty positive response to the impact that Chris Bishop has had. And as you said, but I think that's because of his, you
- 23:17
- Nick Goodall: know, basically single-minded focus to ensure that we continue to build more property. And I think many people agree that that is one of the best solution solutions for our housing market, for affordability, you know, to m to ensure we continue to find ways to set up the systems to enable more building to occur and more intensification,
- 23:36
- Nick Goodall: intensification to happen as well. And he's certainly been a strong. advocate for that. I think it's generally pretty well accepted on both sides as well. Like that's probably one of the areas where you can see some cross-party agreement. And so, yeah, as you say, let's just hope that whoever does replace him in that role continues on that work, which I think has been generally well received from
- 23:56
- Nick Goodall: people from all across the political spectrum anyway. So yeah, good, good point to end on. And I suppose yeah. disappointment that there's disruption in that space. But yep, fingers crossed we see some continuation. And yeah,
- 24:09
- Nick Goodall: we can only wait and see and and hope for that one. All good, mate. Well, I don't know how it played a part in your uh your weekend viewing, uh, but there was certainly plenty happening on Saturday. Before I tell you about my, I don't know, Super Saturday, but a sports going on there. Um the only other thing I thought we we'd could quickly chat about was, of course, the fact that. this week we do have our pain and gain report being
- 24:29
- Nick Goodall: released on Thursday. Did you want to tease anything from that? Otherwise, you can yeah tell us about how your weekend panned out.
- 24:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, I mean, um there's probably won't be too many surprises in there. It's uh, you know, a bit a bit more pain and a bit less gain for for resellers. No no surprises. I mean that we we know that property values have already fallen a long way, generally, in most parts of the country, and as as time. passes, you know, as as people sell, um, they I suppose they just have to face that reality that they're
- 24:57
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): potentially going to get less than than what they paid depending on on which parts of the part of the country they're in and you know what conditions are like. But yeah, so generally it's it's um you know not as not as good for resellers as it has been, but of course great for buyers. So there's the you know there's always that two sides to the the story. So uh yeah that that report will be public on Thursday. So I'll
- 25:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): wait and see how much coverage that gets. Um, you know, by then people, you know, journalists might be keen to cover something else apart from the election. So um yeah, there might be a bit of property commentary later in the week.
- 25:27
- Nick Goodall: Yeah, yeah, let's let's wait and see. As you say, uh surely, surely we can't have four more days of speculative political angles. Um, so yeah, payton pain and gain should get should get some cover. coverage on there. And I'm sure there'll be some interesting individual transactions. I know you always look at the top and bottom, or yeah, biggest pains and biggest gains. So um that'll feature
- 25:47
- Nick Goodall: as well. Um there'll be some public interest in that as there always is. But yeah otherwise mate, how was your weekend? Did you catch any of the I don't know, there was cricket on Saturday. The I'm gonna talk shortly about the Phoenix and the and the A League Derby against Auckland FC, of course. The All Blacks played Sunday morning. Kiwi League on Saturday night as well, mate. What what filled your weekend
- 26:07
- Nick Goodall: and and uh what's your take on it?
- 26:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Pretty much all of those things uh as as as long as as as well as the sport of uh election tracking as well. So yeah but gee it was it was it was pretty full on um I can't say I paid too much uh attention to the election to be honest uh there was there was competing things on other channels so I kind of figured the election's going to do its thing whether I see it or not. So I focus more on the sports side of it. But
- 26:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yeah it was great. Weather was pretty good round here. We had a an election barbecue at one of the neighbours' places. So um yeah it was it was good. I enjoyed it. And um yeah fit it in the normal kids things, swimming lessons and and and Saturday morning cricket and all those things. So yeah pretty full. It f It felt like um two days definitely rushed by anyway.
- 26:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 26:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): can't say I actually I I I saw the all blacks vaguely Um was kind of odd in the background yesterday morning as we were doing breakfast and and you know normal morning stuff. So um not too much I can really say about that from an uh you know an insight or analytical perspective. But
- 27:03
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 27:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know got the result. The the big one for me on these two is always England, you know England at Twickenham. That's that's always the the number one game. So um
- 27:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah
- 27:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): we'll focus on that one. But no going good. Yourself.
- 27:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 27:16
- Nick Goodall: nice one. Yeah. Well, I mean, we've got the All Blacks have got Wales this week, so you know, I don't want to say it quite as much, but it's probably a bit of a foregone conclusion given their form recently. And then yeah, I grew the two weeks away against England will be huge for them. But yeah, I I got up at at 3 a.m. for that game, and um it was a bit of a strange one. Like obviously that first half much tighter. Fighter Um, and and Scotland deserved to be that close, I think.
- 27:36
- Nick Goodall: Like the discipline from the All Blacks was probably the key problem there. They definitely sorted that discipline out in the second half, and it kind of felt like a bit of a precession, really. It's weird. They didn't feel like the All Blacks played super well, but they played well enough in a couple of patches with a couple of good set pieces as well, and and did the job and and definitely sorted their defence and discipline out to close out the game. But it I don't know, it
- 27:56
- Nick Goodall: didn't feel like it was a vintage performance. I just kind of didn't get go a to bed after that thinking that was a riveting game or anything, which is a weird. feeling given the score line of what was it, 43-21 or something like that. So yeah, a bit of a strange one, but um and a couple of injuries at the end there, which maybe a little bit of mild concern about. But again, hopefully both Will Jordan and and Geordie Barrett are back for that English game and that'll be
- 28:16
- Nick Goodall: okay. Um otherwise, yeah, like you say, we sort of had to have a couple of TVs on and and what and sort of tracking how the election was going, and the kids were certain getting into that. So that was that was an interesting one. They were wanting to know how things were going to go, and then all these questions about, you know, how come National Labour can both have 29% of the vote and then there's different seats. And so that led to some difficult, well, uh
- 28:36
- Nick Goodall: difficult conversations because I just didn't understand it. So I'm not quite sure I still do either. Um, but no, I I I I get it. But uh yeah, so that was on in one room, and then yeah, as I say, the cricket was It on here in Wellington. We didn't obviously get down there. Um, I mean the weather was always gonna going to be a bit tough, and so you knew it was gonna be off and on. And I wanted to be home to watch the the Phoenix game against Auckland FC. I did feel like it was
- 28:55
- Nick Goodall: our definitely our best chance to get a result against them for the first time in the A-League Derby, and and they certainly did that with a draw, which yeah, kind of it did go through sort of a bit of momentum change throughout the game. Sort of at halftime, I thought we deserved to, you know, maybe have have led that game. But then by the end, we were kind of lucky to hold on for a draw because Auckland Orkin shaded the chances at the end of that game. too. So
- 29:15
- Nick Goodall: look, a point away when you haven't managed that in six games so far, away from home. We continued the gap. Uh we've got the top of the table, or certainly from them anyway. So, you know, I think you've got to say you'd take that point at the start of the day. But yeah, there's moments there where I thought, damn, we could have snuck that one as well. So um definitely sets it up for a uh a
- 29:35
- Nick Goodall: brilliant um return game. Uh and and only in a month. month's time I think they play here December nineteen. So um yeah, we'll certainly be looking forward to that one and see if we can get the first win now, not just the first point which we got. So that was good. Kiwis on Saturday night too. Obviously the the um the Kiwi woman team as well, they they got their win earlier. So yeah,
- 29:55
- Nick Goodall: there's plenty of plenty of positivity there and the cricket itself got really close in the end. I mean the black caps only scored a 134. hundred and thirty four. Yet Yet, um you know, potentially if the rain hadn't ruined it right at the end there, had a chance to actually win that one, which would have been mind-boggling if you said that halfway through the game. And I think they were paying upwards of eight or ten bucks at halfway through the match. So yeah, that was an interesting one
- 30:15
- Nick Goodall: and a pity that it had to end on more rain. Um, but at least they made it competitive, and and yeah, no doubt the conditions and pitch and whatnot made it, you know, actual a competition between bat and ball, which you don't get that often these days in in short. form cricket. So even as a one dayer uh certainly changed things up for them. So yeah, um yeah good good weekend though. And as I say, yeah, never never a
- 30:35
- Nick Goodall: bad thing when the sport on. And yeah, my son had his first game of cricket on Saturday morning, which I helped to coach and we I think we all really enjoyed that and yeah, got the kids out yesterday to the swimming pool. So that was a bit of fun too. So no it's been a it's been a good one and the weather was definitely you know touch and go out the weekend. but um still feels like longer days you get the chance to enjoy the day a bit more when
- 30:55
- Nick Goodall: there's more sunlight around or certainly more daylight around anyway. So yeah, it was a good one, mate, and and hopefully just the kind of things to come with uh plenty of activities going on. So yeah, happy days, mate, and uh yeah, plenty of intrigue when it comes to the housing market. So yeah.
- 31:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): For sure. Yeah, yeah, I mean, talking about the next OCR decision on the ninth, so I'm just thinking, geez. there's a lot to do before then. Like, you know, that that's going to be something that that comes onto the horizon pretty quickly. I'm just going, geez, there's there's a bit to do before then. So um, but yeah, good to be busy.
- 31:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 31:25
- Nick Goodall: no, exactly right, mate. All right. Well, uh, we will leave it there, mate. So thanks as per usual for your thoughts and insights as well. Um, yeah, certainly plenty of intrigue going on right now, so good to be able to pick your brain. I just want to say thanks very much for listening to. Please do get in touch with any questions or feedback. King Keen to hear your thoughts, potential implications of the election, of course. And do get in touch and let us know what you think. But that'll do us for today. My
- 31:44
- Nick Goodall: name is Nick. He's Calvin. You've been listening to the Zealand's property market podcast, Matewa.