The NZ Property Market Podcast

Cotality Q3 report shows 16% of NZ resales at loss, highest since 2012, with apartments worst hit

37 min Listen to the original
New Zealand PropertyCotality ReportMacroeconomicsMigrationRisk Assessment

Summary

Nick Goodall and Kelvin Davidson analyze the Cotality Q3 Pain and Gain Report, revealing that 16% of resales resulted in a gross loss, the highest share since 2012. They note that while 84% of sellers made a profit, the median gain of $270,000 is significantly lower than previous peaks. The speakers highlight a stark divergence in hold periods, with profitable sales averaging 10.5 years compared to 4.5 years for losses. Apartments accounted for 48% of loss-making resales, outperforming townhouses and standalone houses in terms of capital erosion. Davidson adds macroeconomic context, citing falling Stats NZ card sales and strong manufacturing PMI, while noting net migration remains below average despite recent increases.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Median gross profit of $270,000 is substantially lower than the peak of $440,000.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 2:16

  2. 2
    gains were made in the third quarter, the median hold period was ten and a half years pretty much, um, as opposed to the losses is about four and a half.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 3:31

Episode sections

  1. 0:34 – 3:31

    Cotality Q3 Pain and Gain Report Overview

    Nick Goodall and Kelvin Davidson discuss the Cotality Q3 Pain and Gain Report, noting that 16% of resales resulted in a gross loss, the highest share since 2012. Despite this, 84% of sellers made a profit, with a median gain of $270,000, highlighting the importance of hold period.

  2. 3:31 – 6:22

    Hold Period and Property Type Performance

    The median hold period for profitable sales was 10.5 years, compared to 4.5 years for losses. Apartments fared worst with 48% of resales recording a loss, followed by townhouses at 22% and standalone houses at 13%.

  3. 6:22 – 11:17

    Market Context and Inflation Adjustments

    Goodall emphasizes that the report measures gross price differences without adjusting for inflation or ownership costs. He notes that while the Property Investors Federation highlighted the real economic hit, the report serves as a simple relativity measure over time.

  4. 11:17 – 14:18

    Macroeconomic Indicators: Card Spending and Manufacturing

    Davidson describes the economic picture as 'patchy,' citing falling Stats NZ electronic card sales (contradicting ANZ/Westpac data) against a strong Manufacturing PMI for 16 consecutive months above 50.

  5. 14:18 – 20:07

    Migration Trends and Housing Demand

    Net migration rose to 22,600 for the year to September, the highest since December 2024. However, Davidson notes this is still below average, and high living costs are suppressing household creation, keeping rental demand subdued despite population growth.

  6. 20:07 – 21:34

    Listing Withdrawals and Regional Differences

    Goodall presents data showing 26% of nationwide listings failed to sell within three months. Wellington had fewer withdrawn listings than Auckland, suggesting greater seller realism in Wellington regarding pricing.

  7. 21:34 – 25:06

    Westpac's Flood Risk Lending Criteria

    Westpac announced it will factor flood and hazard risks into mortgage lending. Davidson views this positively for awareness, noting it may require larger deposits for risky properties but won't necessarily stop lending, with impacts likely to be gradual.

  8. 25:06 – 27:25

    Future Flood Data and Government Maps

    The speakers discuss the upcoming government-controlled New Zealand flood map and the importance of consistent data. They note that while modeling helps, the transition will be difficult for owners of high-risk properties who lacked this information previously.

  9. 27:25 – 28:56

    Flood Data and Risk Disclosure

    Speaker 2 discusses upcoming analysis on how floods impact property demand and value, noting interest from government and banks. They mention that data will be available at city, territorial authority, and property levels via regional councils, local councils, and private models.

  10. 28:56 – 34:52

    Weekend Sports Recap

    Nick Goodall and Kelvin Davidson discuss recent New Zealand sports results, including losses for the All Blacks and Kiwis, and wins for the Black Caps and Phoenix Women. They reflect on the All Blacks' historic loss to Wales and the atmosphere at the stadium.

  11. 34:52 – 35:52

    Personal Weekend Activities

    Nick Goodall shares personal highlights from his weekend, including attending a Flight of the Concords concert, painting a fence, and watching his son play cricket. He also mentions looking forward to the upcoming Black Caps test series at the Basin Reserve.

  12. 35:52 – 36:54

    Podcast Closing and Events

    The hosts conclude the episode, mentioning an upcoming client dinner and their busy schedules. They thank listeners for tuning in and encourage feedback before signing off.

Claims worth verifying

16% of resales in Q3 resulted in a gross loss, the highest share since 2012.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:17

How to verify: Cotality Q3 Pain and Gain Report (published Nov 2026); compare with historical Cotality reports for 2012-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Median gross profit for sellers in Q3 was $270,000.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·2:15

How to verify: Cotality Q3 Pain and Gain Report (published Nov 2026). For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Median hold period for gains was 10.5 years, while for losses it was 4.5 years.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·3:31

How to verify: Cotality Q3 Pain and Gain Report (published Nov 2026). For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

48% of apartment resales recorded a loss in Q3.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·4:07

How to verify: Cotality Q3 Pain and Gain Report (published Nov 2026). For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Stats NZ electronic card sales fell for the second or third consecutive month.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·12:18

How to verify: Stats NZ 'Electronic card spending' release for September/October 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Manufacturing PMI was above 50 for the 16th consecutive month.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·13:58

How to verify: ANZ/MiC Manufacturing PMI release for October 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Net migration was 22,600 for the year to September 2026.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·14:58

How to verify: Stats NZ 'Migration' release for the year ended September 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

26% of listings nationwide failed to sell within three months of being listed.

Nick Goodall ·20:27

How to verify: Cotality data analysis on listing withdrawal/sales velocity (referenced in article on stuff.co.nz or Cotality website). For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Westpac announced it would factor flood and hazard risk into mortgage lending criteria.

Nick Goodall ·21:34

How to verify: Westpac press release or media statement from November 2026 regarding lending criteria changes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Net migration is the highest since December 2024.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·14:58

How to verify: Stats NZ 'Migration' release for the year ended September 2026; compare with historical data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-15 through 2026-11-15. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Review the full Cotality Q3 Pain and Gain Report for methodology on gross vs. net gains.
  • Compare Stats NZ electronic card sales data with ANZ and Westpac consumer spending surveys.
  • Verify net migration figures against Immigration New Zealand official statistics.
  • Check Westpac's updated flood risk lending criteria and deposit requirements.
  • Assess local council flood maps and regional council hazard data for specific properties.
  • Analyze hold period statistics by property type to understand capital accumulation risks.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Almost half of apartments that were resold in the third quarter took a loss.
0:14
Nick Goodall: Brought to you by Cotality for the 16th of November 2026. I'm head of research, Nick Goodall, and today I'm joined as per Pugel usual by Chief Economist Calvin Davidson. Calvin, a not so super Sunday of sports results. yesterday, which I guess we'll uh cover off later on. But first, we released the pain and gain report last week. Do you want to
0:34
Nick Goodall: take us through the key uptakes and how the coverage went?
0:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, um, well, really good coverage, actually. Uh um I suspect there was a sense of of media looking for something different than the election, so maybe uh it came along at just the right time. And yeah, I mean, uh the the overall headline I suppose is is a bit more. pain for bit for resellers, a bit less gain. And and that's been a a trend we've been seeing for a long time, of course, which is
0:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): fully consistent with the falls in values. Uh, you know, in a down market, it is just gonna be a bit more painful for resellers. Uh you know, it's a buyer's market, so people are going to probably sell for a loss a bit more often. So yeah, that's the overall sort of headline numbers, I guess. Um about sixteen percent of resellers in Q3 got a price less
1:17
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): than what they originally paid. So that's our our sort of measure of of pain, or in other words, they took a a gross loss. Uh so yeah, that's that's the highest that loss making share's been since 2012. So, you know, it's been a it's quite a weak market, no s no surprises there. It's been quite a long time since sellers have have seen it as as uh I guess l as less in their
1:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): favour as it is now. Um so yeah, a bit weaker. The I suppose the thing is uh it's on one hand on the other. I mean that is a uh a a painful number for resellers, but also that's still more than four in every five resellers do make some kind of profit. So I suppose, you know, it depends on on which way you want to look at it. Um
1:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and uh yeah and the gains themselves, so so where those gains are actually made, the median gain has fallen as well. So so those gains were made uh a little bit less often, or in other words, losses were made a little bit more often. Um but when those gains were made, uh the size of the gain has come down, so median of 270,000 in Q3.
2:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
2:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so again, depends on which way you want to look at it. That's a lot lower than it used to be. At the peak, it was 440, I think, from memory. Um, so down a lot from there, but still $270,000 in terms of gross profit for people looking from the outside probably still looks pretty significant. So yeah, it's it depends on which way you want to look at it. I suppose
2:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the other thing about this is that it's been it's been a bit of a slow burner. We saw after the GFC that that that loss making percentage rose from pretty much zero in sort of around 2007 to kind of 20-ish percent, 18 to 20% over a period of
2:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): 20 years.
2:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): about two years. You know, this time it's it's gone from pretty much zero to sixteen in what, sort of four or five years. So, you know, it's been we're getting to the same kind of position, but it's just taken a lot longer in this cycle. And I think that's probably to do with um what we've talked about before, you know, there's there's been a sort of degree of protection here for jobs. Uh We haven't seen a lot
3:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of forced selling or mortgagey sales or repayment process problems or anything like that. So, you know, it's a it's been a bit of a slow burner. Um, but you know, we're we're kind of we are getting to a point now that matches, I guess, the low points in in previous cycles. So um so yeah, a bit more pain for resellers. Hold period still very important, of course. Um where those
3:31
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): gains were made in the third quarter, the median hold period was ten and a half years pretty much, um, as opposed to the losses is about four and a half. So you know pretty clear distinction there between, you know, if you hold especially in this cycle, if you've only held for four or five years, well, think back to where that was. That was the the peak for prices. It's going to have been a a difficult period
3:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to hit to have to buy and sell again in such a short period of time. So hold period still matters a lot. I mean apartments fared the worst amongst all of this in terms of of resale losses. Almost half of apartments that were resold in the third quarter took a loss, so 48%.
4:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Um so you know, pretty uh pretty striking number there for apartments. Townhouses are around 22% and houses about 13%. Um so you know, in a relative sense, apartments uh fared the worst in Q3, but they always tend to. Um, you know, we've talked before about how there's uh I guess just less capital gain on offer for apartments. So at any point in the cycle, there the there is going to be a
4:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): greater tendency to sell for a loss, simply because gains haven't accumulated as much. So you know that's always going to be the case. And also I suppose I'd just say about apartments is that the you know it's a smaller segment as well. It doesn't downplay it for those apartment owners, but in terms of the wider market, apartments are still quite a small segment. And actually the number of loss making sales for apartments
4:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): wasn't really that different. Um it was just the percentage share went up to some. extent because other sales have have drifted lower. So we know that overall sales volumes are drifting lower. So um so yeah that kind of pushes up the percentage even if the number of apartment losses hasn't really changed. So you know there's there's a
5:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): few
5:04
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): caveats there. Not not not saying it's been easy for apartments. It hasn't been easy for any property type, but um there are sort of um a few caveats there. So
5:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
5:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): how do I sign it I I mean a I I think it's it's just a sign of the times. I mean, we we know values are down. Um they've they they fell sharply during that 22 and 23 period. They've kind of you know bumbled along, maybe drifted lower in some markets, drifted up a little bit in others, but there there is still that that s um you know that balance is still in favour of buyers at the moment.
5:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So as we as we go through time in this weaken weaker market, just more sellers will have to
5:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh you know.
5:38
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): face that reality and crystallise their losses I guess so it's I think it's probably probably what we're just continuing to see and I think it thinking ahead it's probably we're probably going to see more of it. I mean it doesn't look like values are going to turn around anytime soon. So you know next quarter the one after the one after that just as people progressively need to sell or just want to sell for whatever reason
5:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): they're probably going to be selling into a into a weaker market. So then I think we'll probably see these these pay pain numbers stay like this for a while yet. So it's um so it's not necessarily
6:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a uh
6:08
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): sort of new new way of looking at things or a sign of a fresh collapse or anything like that. I think it's probably more of what we've already seen. You know, values are down, and as time passes, more people just have to sell into that market. So um something that's probably what we're seeing
6:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): now. Yeah,
6:22
Nick Goodall: exactly. And I think, you know, as you said, we got pretty strong coverage through the media. which meant that yeah, there was sort of both of us um covering off different interviews and whatnot. And I think some of the things that popped up for me that it's it's often just worth reiterating these things. You sort of touched on it there, that it's all relative. And so yeah, we are looking at how things are now compared
6:42
Nick Goodall: to the past. That's kind of the point of this. It is, of course, like you say, it's a gross difference in sale prices between purchase and sale. not taking into account any other cost of owning or selling. And so, you know, it is about that relativity, right? Like what percentage now compared to the past, including going back to global financial crisis.
7:02
Nick Goodall: And so that kind of puts that context on it. It is just another measure of how the market's doing. But yeah, I got some sort of questions, right? Like, is this a fresh sign of things really um, you know, not going so well, and and maybe there is this fresh downturn. and it's as you touched on there, it's that's certainly not our interpretation of this. It is just a factor of time going on and and value
7:22
Nick Goodall: growth not really being there for many parts of the market, particularly those larger centres like Auckland and Wellington. So yeah, I think it's worth reiterating that. I think the other thing that was sort of that had popped up in some of the media rounds as well, was you know, this is um on the face value, right? This is not adjusting for inflation um or anything
7:42
Nick Goodall: like that. So it's not the real change in value. And that yeah, if you had an investment in something else, you might have expected some growth to come through um based on inflation as well. And that's certainly not the case in this one. So, you know, I think the Property Investors Federation um spokesperson was out there saying, you know, actually for many people that might have crystallized it as loss, it's even worse than it looks on the face of
8:02
Nick Goodall: it, which is a fair take on that. But as I say, this is about keeping the measure really simple, about understanding relativity over time, which gives us some context, and also across regions in terms of you know what the proportion looks like, but also what the dollar value often looks like as well when you're comparing across different cities or different areas as to what that margin might It be, whether it's a
8:22
Nick Goodall: profit or a loss as well. So yeah, I think those are all important things to to note. note when we're looking at the pain and gain report. It's still a really useful report from that perspective. But we do need to keep some of those things in mind when we're assessing just how bad or how good things are at certain times as well. But yeah, certainly worthwhile checking out the full report.
8:42
Nick Goodall: I mean, you can go and get data for each and every area across the country. We only touched on a few of the high-level high level ones here and now. And as you said, you know, we we'd do it by property type. we do it across all the regions. We also split by owner-occupy and investor, which there wasn't much difference between those two types of owners over time. So it doesn't show that there's you know a whole bunch of investors getting out
9:02
Nick Goodall: now and and getting out even with a massive loss or owner occupyers forced into selling and and taking that loss. But yeah, I think overall it is As a reflection on that time going by, maybe, you know, those people are hitting a realization of look that capital growth isn't necessarily going to come through anytime soon or to any great degree. So if you are sitting there going, I don't really want to sell for less than
9:22
Nick Goodall: I bought, but what's the what's the upcoming period going to look like? Are we going to see much growth in the next year? If we're not, then are we better off just you know moving on?
9:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Are
9:30
Nick Goodall: you going to recycle that money? Are you just downgrading, Grading, you know, to be able to you know, maybe keep your debt lower and moving into a smaller house or a cheaper house. So you're still in the market, but you've just did downgraded your exposure or your uh level of debt as well. Maybe as long as you haven't, you know, got a property worth less than your debt in general, you have been able to increase your equity over
9:50
Nick Goodall: that time or at least not see it reduce, you get out before it gets worse. So I think these are some of the conversations and considerations for some of these owners who, yeah, as we say, most of the time for a loss maker, they've bought somewhere around about their peak. that of the market. They're now having that pretty tough decision right now, but also acknowledging that, yeah, those that are making money probably have for ten years or more. And
10:10
Nick Goodall: they are making, you know, making
10:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): an
10:12
Nick Goodall: adverted commerce, you know, a couple of hundred grand on the face of it, that they can one way or another recycle back into that market as well. Um so yeah, I think those are the core things to probably take note of. But as I say, the details are on the report if anyone wants to go and check that out. But yeah, anything else. jump to mind before we move on to sort of a more external or macroeconomic uh view of the market?
10:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, I think that's pretty much it. I mean, you you made I was just gonna make that little distinction between uh investors versus owner occupiers, and it I suppose, you know, uh I think it was Matt Boy was on on the Ryan Bridge show, wasn't he, talking about the report? And um,
10:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
10:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that it i it's probably true for investors, you know, there's it's not inflation adjusted, so it you know it th can be an even bigger hit if you're an investor selling that that property, there's there's less cash you can withdraw. But I suppose for owner occupies it's a little bit different because yes, you know, you've lost value on your property, but you're presumably you're gonna be buying another one and you've you've you've potentially sort
11:05
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of gained as such on on that next one 'cause it's probably fallen in value too. So I think there's different implications um for for different buyer groups there. But um yeah, it's that's uh uh you've you've probably covered that off anyway.
11:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
11:17
Nick Goodall: No, no, all good, mate. Well, let's look at the sort of there's a few um economic releases out last week. And I think probably as has been the case in the last I don't know, few weeks, few months, it's a bit of mixed results. Um yeah, do you want to run us through, I don't know, just the high level of maybe a couple of these things. The electronic card sales I know came out last week, although um there was some questions about, you know,
11:37
Nick Goodall: how maybe not accurate. but how reflective of the overall market that was compared to some of the bank's own data as well. So maybe give us some info on that. I know the performance of manufacturing index was out last week as well. So take us through that and probably touch on um migration data as well. So yeah, back back to you, mate. What's the what's the gist of all that data?
11:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, it's it's it's just really hard to read at the moment.
11:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
11:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): get some good indicators and some worse ones, and um they have different implications and so. it yeah, this is this is I suppose the reserve bank's conundrum too. Um, you know, is how how strong really is the economy and you know how much inflation pressure might it generate and you know, can it withstand higher rates and these things which I guess they're you know sitting there grappling with all day, every day. Um so
12:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it's probably you know it was just continued contradictions there, really. We so we had electronic card sales from Stats New Zealand, it was down again, and in I guess that would have been October, September, October, whichever the latest date of the year is probably October, I think. Um so uh yeah, that's and that's the second or third monthly fall in electronic card sales in a row. That's kind of you know
12:38
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): spending in the shops uh in many ways. Uh and you know, even less encouraging because it's not adjusted for price changes. So, you know, we know there's inflation in the system right now, particularly for things. like fuel. So if you if you strip so it's already fallen in in nominal or or non-adjusted terms, if you strip price
12:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): effects out, it's going to be an even bigger fall. So yeah, definitely, definitely not great news. There, as you say, it it perhaps contradicted some of the the bank economists we're talking about here. I think ANZ and Westpac both run a uh sort of their own spending numbers from from people on on their credit cards, on the Westpac and A and Z credit cards. And, you know, their numbers weren't quite as weak as maybe what Stats New
13:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Zealand was suggesting. Maybe it suggests A and Z and Westpac if it ones a market share there. Don't know. But um yeah, there's that so that there is yeah, there is a wee bit of contradiction in there. But I think overall, you know, you still think about those electronic car sales figures. It's not surprising that they'd be weak. Yeah. They might not be quite as weak if you if you believe A and Z and Westpac. But
13:38
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): um you know yeah, there's still pressure on households. So it's not necessarily surprising that the numbers would be down. But then um, yeah, performance manufacturing index was was strong again, sixteenth increase in a row in terms of uh manufacturing output. Um the number was so this is a a rise fall mark of fifty. When the number's above fifty, it signals a rise in activity. So yeah,
13:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): sixteenth month
13:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
13:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a row above fifty. So manufacturing's going well. Um to some extent that'll be tied up with the the primary sector, you know, processing milk and and meat and these sorts of things. But um there'll be other manufacturing activity too and getting that ready for export. So there's, you know, the retailing, bit of a struggle, manufacturing doing well. There's this conflicting sort of patterns
14:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): going on. Um and yeah, then the migration numbers. We had a another gentle rise, I suppose you'd call it. There's there's still um there's still a lot of people leaving, still still a lot of you know New Zealand citizens departing the country. But just what's happening at the moment is that we're getting more new arrivals, and that's the thing. It's just creeping higher. The
14:38
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): departures aren't really getting worse, they're still quite high, but they're not getting worse. Uh and so the the the slow uptick for those new arrivals is is meaning that our net balance is slowly rising too. So um yeah, in the year to September we're 22,600 pretty much in terms of overall net migration, driven by just that upward strift for for new
14:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): arrivals to the country or new non-cit non-citizens, I suppose you'd say. Uh so yeah, 22,600, it's it's better than it was a few months ago. Um the highest number since December 2024. twenty four. So there is a there's a bit of an upwards trend there. Um so you'd think, okay, well, that's you know. more workers available, that's a bit more demand for spending, a bit more
15:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): demand for services in the economy. So that's kind of, you know, it could could strengthen things. But then on the other hand, it's still below average. There's still uh you know, the migration numbers aren't really sort of rocketing away. Um there's still there's still uh you know potentially some uh some reduced pressure there on things like housing demand,
15:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): housing rent. So we are starting to see rents maybe turn around a little bit but you know it's nothing sort of significant yet so
15:44
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah
15:44
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I don't know electric card sales still a little bit subdued manufacturing a bit stronger migration if you want to look at it in a positive way it's it's an upwards trend but if you want to look at it in a sort of more subdued way it's still below where it would normally be still lots of people leaving so there's yeah there's I don't know it's it's such a it's such a contradictory sort of picture at the moment.
16:04
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Um so yeah, we'll we'll
16:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): w
16:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): we'll see how I guess it's just watching the data and we know the reserve bank's doing that. Everything's sort of data dependent at the moment. Um, so yeah. Hopefully one day one day we'll get a strong upturn, but it doesn't necessarily seem that we're there just yet.
16:21
Nick Goodall: Yeah. I mean the the word that jumps to mind and I know you've used this in past months is is patchy, right? Like it's just a patchy economic situation right now. Um you can definitely find the good, but you absolutely can find the the bad or the difficult as well. I mean from an economic perspective, as you said, higher migration means, yep, more demand for goods and services and and to produce goods and services, but
16:41
Nick Goodall: also there's questions about productivity as well. So, you know, I still think there's reason to say that the economic economy is still relatively weak. Yes, there might be some signs of improvement, but it's not. storming away. And certainly there's no, I don't know, no real reason to be confident of a strong economic recovery into next year either. So that's my reason for continued caution,
17:00
Nick Goodall: I suppose, as to what contribution that's going to make. The other thing that came up in one of the interviews I did on media last week, I think it was Radio New Zealand
17:08
Nick Goodall: live interview, was just talking about, you know, we've got strong migration growth, or we've got migration growth, and that must be demand for property. So why is it still tough for the investors out there? And and I think, you
17:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
17:18
Nick Goodall: I brought up that something we've spoken about a fair bit, I think, in the podcast. So it won't be news to our listeners, but it is that still lack of household creation where, you know, with with high living costs and things, people are still staying at home longer. They're staying in large inflating situations longer. So that demand for rental property is still relatively subdued. Yes, more people move into the country means they need to live somewhere. So there's
17:38
Nick Goodall: some upward um growth in demand for rental property, but it's not storming away because you know many people will be living more people to a household, and that just means there's not quite that demand while we've got high supply, not just for listed, uh for sale listed properties, but also for rent. Still quite a bit of choice out there. So we talk a lot about buyer
17:57
Nick Goodall: buyers having the power when it comes to buying property. Same thing, I think, on the rental side that those tenants feel like they've got a bit of power because there's quite a bit of choice. They may be, I'm not sure how much negotiation of prices they're doing. Um, but the market is generally gonna be righting itself where, yeah, if that land landlord can't find the tenant, they're gonna have to adjust their price down to attract more people to to come and buy that property.
18:16
Nick Goodall: And as I say, when everyone's dealing with high cost of living, then that's something that's gonna be holding that general demand back as well. And and that's where I think, you know, when people talk to me about potential impact of the election, you know, what are the big policies that could affect housing? And it's like you could talk about the potential taxes or um, you know, building more properties and all those things. And I was like,
18:37
Nick Goodall: well, you know, maybe it comes down to the cost of living. If we can truly get a hold on cost of living, household creation comes back and and movers start moving again, you know, maybe that's the that's the thing that actually changes the housing market, improving both the investment side, but also owner. owner-occupied if we get those changes. So, you know, maybe it's going to be more about, you know, once we do finally get a government and see what the
18:56
Nick Goodall: coalition is and what sort of things have been negotiated in or out of those agreements, um, it really will be what impact they can have on the the living costs, household living costs as to what influence we might actually have on housing. Um, you know, nothing's gonna going be to in the in the short term either. It's we're probably more talking about medium and long long-term term changes here, um, but that's absolutely our I think where we're gonna see some influence is
19:17
Nick Goodall: what happens in that space. And and the question would be that no matter who forms the government, what impact can they really have, particularly in that short term around those high household costs, um for especially for those that are you know impacted globally.
19:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know,
19:29
Nick Goodall: again, whether it's you know things like tariffs that are still playing out, we've got the war in Iran and and high petrol prices as you've spoken about, and we've spoken about at length, you know, these things are generally are out of our control too. So yeah, it doesn't seem like too much is changing anytime soon, that's for sure, regardless of what happens in any negotiations for a new government once we get those special votes counted as well.
19:48
Nick Goodall: So yep, still some still some big question marks on that one. All good mate. Well in terms of just wrapping up other news, I suppose there's a few things that you know we contributed to over the last week or so that I thought we could just at least touch on and also um uh tease maybe for this week as well. But people might have seen that we did some or provided some data to
20:07
Nick Goodall: stuff.codnzed for around withdrawing listings, which I thought was an interesting angle, something we hadn't really looked at in great detail, but it is something that's produced by our analytics team. So yeah, produce some data for an article there looking at the proportion of, you know, properties that are listed for sale that don't sell within three months. And so we tag them and then say what proportion of listings didn't sell. after being
20:27
Nick Goodall: listed. And you know, it was upwards of sort of 26%, I think it was, of all listings nationwide that hadn't sold in the last 12 months. Well had been listed in the last 12 months and hadn't sold within three months of that listing going live. And does change over time. I think you know when the market's going well, that proportion drops away. And when it's not going so well, that proportion increases as well. And just
20:47
Nick Goodall: interesting looking at some of the regional differences, you know, when we talk about some. of those weaker markets, it's certainly, you know, Auckland and Wellington pops up, but Wellington wasn't really in there in that list of high proportion of listings withdrawn. And the main interpretation I gave to that was, you know, maybe there's some more realism in Wellington. And if you know you're not going to sell or not going to sell for the price you want, you don't bother listing in the first place. Um, so it's not
21:07
Nick Goodall: exactly like this measure is perfect for everything. Um Auckham was certainly up there, but Wellington didn't feature in the top 10. So yeah, it's obviously going to reflect some sort
21:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
21:15
Nick Goodall: side sometimes a bit of mindset as well as the actual market performance at the same time. So always a few caveats or things to note with that one. The other one was around Westpac's announcement last week that uh you know they certainly will be adjusting their lending criteria and maybe term of loans and things like that based on potential hazards or
21:34
Nick Goodall: flooding uh out there as well. I know you've sort of, I don't know, you answered a few. media queries on this. You've got an article going this week looking at some of our flooding data and the vulnerability around the country. I don't know how much you want to touch on, maybe not necessarily the article coming this week, but yeah, the chat that you maybe had around um Westpac's decision there, any detail you want to touch on and any interpretation or insight you
21:54
Nick Goodall: wanted to to take from that one before we do a bit of a personal wrap up of the weekend?
21:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, um I actually heard this through the grapevine probably six weeks or so. or something, I guess. Um so but then it it kind of slipped my mind. So yeah, it was it was a good it it all came to light obviously last week. But yeah, um I mean it's seems like a good idea to me. There's this we all know that climate change is happening, there's risks uh to to
22:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): individual properties are are different or different risks around flooding and landslides and things. So you know accounting for that seems to be a pretty good idea to me. And and you know, i if if the only thing achieved is actually getting the information out there, raising people's awareness levels. I mean it it it might the people with uh with so-called risky properties might not be so
22:38
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): pleased, but
22:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
22:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, the next generation it's about making that awareness and, you know, getting that information out there. People can make the best decision around the price they want to pay, insurance availability, what the risks are, you know, as long as you go in with with eyes wide open. that that seems to be um, you know, a pretty good idea to me. So uh yeah, and uh I mean I got I got asked a couple of questions I guess around well, you know, what's this
22:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): gonna do to house prices? That seems to be the the standard thing. And well,
23:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
23:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I mean Westpac's even said it it might be sort of two or three percent of their loan applications could be affected by this. They've also said it doesn't mean there's no finance. You know, they're still going gonna to lend. It's just about assessing that risk and yeah you know, maybe it means um they'll ask for a bigger deposit from the from the person buying the house. So, you know, it doesn't necessarily mean too much in the near term.
23:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It but I mean I'm sure over time, you know, if this spreads out to the other banks. I mean, we don't know what the other banks are already doing behind the scenes. Um, it's just I guess Westpac has has made this public. Um so you know, you'd think there'd be an impact over time. We we expect that just with climate change in general, but I I uh it's gonna be so hard to say, well, you know, overnight house prices are down five percent or whatever, because
23:43
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you you just there's so many other things going on. I s I suspect it's probably more of a a slow burning thing and we'll never know what would have happened anyway. So there's there's that kind of all that kind of discussion around it. But yeah, I mean the bottom line for me is it's if if can anything to to raise awareness about these issues is is great because we know that insurance will might cost
24:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): more in future. It's it's um you know, that's gonna play on household budgets. Um just raising those those awareness levels is really good. So yeah, we got a post coming out this week looking at our
24:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well,
24:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): just uh a h an aggregation, I guess, of our individual flood scores that we've got for every property and just sort of putting that at a TA level and and seeing, saying, okay, where are the the parts of the country that have higher flood risk than others. Um but also being fully aware that so some of the areas that have higher flood risk than others are smaller. So, you know,
24:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that's that's going to be a big issue for those particular areas. But in terms of I guess our wider financial system, insurance system, banking and everything, um, there are markets that have lower risk, but still have a risk and there's a lot more properties there. So um, yeah, that's I guess it's it's just trying to make that distinction and and yeah, a bit of a discussion around the issues, I
24:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): guess. So um
24:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah,
24:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): look out for that. Timely in the sense that, you know, Westpac's just put out their thing, but I guess I guess just for me it's an illustration, this is a growing issue, and you know, anything we can do to get information out there will be be really valuable.
25:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
25:06
Nick Goodall: I couldn't agree more, right? Like the more information that's available to everyone, and hopefully some consistent information. Um, obviously Westpac have got their own provider of that. flooding data and and those hazards that could be um affecting property value or affecting their ability or um I suppose cost to loan, to lend. And that's that's one thing. And I know we've got this
25:26
Nick Goodall: sort of national New Zealand flood map coming next year, which is controlled and managed by the government. So again, there's going to be some consistency that they're hoping that you know everyone will have some um understanding of. And as you said, maybe. make some adjust uh make some decisions accordingly so yes I'll buy it but we're gonna need to make sure that we've got greater
25:46
Nick Goodall: coverage because there are greater risks here. Well we've got some sort of back up back up. Well as
25:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you said you're not going to be as exposed from a loan perspective in case that event happens. So it has to be seen as a good thing. Yes there's gonna be some effect over time and and you know the hard thing I suppose here is you know really useful for anyone that's going to buy these properties in the future Really unfortunate for someone that owns these properties that didn't have this information available to them 20 or 30 years ago, and we had no idea how exposed it
26:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): might be, because it's not always as simple as it's near the coast, it's a chance of flooding. It's like, man, there's some, you know, there's some interesting
26:17
Nick Goodall: um data that comes out of those flood maps that show the weird little basins that there are, and and sometimes it's reflective of drainage and you know and and soil um susceptibility. or or the ability for it to soak up water in a in a fast way as well. So there's all these different factors that affect these flood maps and and some of them are really technical and some of them probably a bit more basic. And it's just
26:37
Nick Goodall: making sure that information is available in everyone's hands to make the right decision off the back of that. So yeah it's gonna take some time. There's gonna be some transition
26:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): um I don't know risk, some transition difficulty as people start to understand and it affects different people in different ways. And yeah, it probably is going to affect some areas, the demand for property in those areas, because fewer people will be willing or able to get the lending available to buy those properties. And I think naturally as demand reduces for certain properties, that means that value growth is
27:05
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): going to be less over time. And maybe if there is a fall in prices, that's going to be greater than areas that aren't as affected over time as well. So yeah, exactly putting a number on that thing, as you say, is very difficult. Um, but certainly there's some pretty good modeling out there as well that can assist with this, particularly when it's tied to things like the Strand Masden project, which we've been a part of over time, a project run by the Otago
27:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): University, looking at the impact of floods on demand for property and value change over time as well, which our data feeds into. So, yeah, look, there's still a lot more to come on all of these things. We know how much interest there is, whether it's from government, through reserve bank, treasury, trying to understand exposure and ensuring that we are protected from that. As well as the banks, the insurance companies, data
27:44
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): companies like ourselves, there's just so much interest here that we need to make sure the information is available to more people. So we've got to see it for a good thing. And then it's a matter of the likes of ourselves and other, you know, other even more experts than us when it comes to flooding data to ensure that we can have that conversation and make that understandable from the end consumer because they're the ones that are. going to be impacted at the end of all
28:04
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): of this as well. So yeah, lots to come look out for that article. It will give you a bit of an idea for your exposure at a city or TA level like you said. But of course that data is generally available down to property level as well. So yep through one way or another hopefully you can get hold of that. You know there's regional council data, there's there's local council information, we've got private models like
28:24
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): ourself. ourselves. Um So just ask more questions. you know, whether it's with real estate agents, if bankers, if brokers, um, insurance companies, just keep asking those questions and and um get
28:33
Nick Goodall: the information into those hands. So, yeah, really important one. Look out for the data. And um, yeah, we'll certainly continue to carry on that conversation, that's for sure.
28:42
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
28:42
Nick Goodall: anything work-wise to cover off before we chat about some disappointments over the weekend, Calvin?
28:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No,
28:48
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): no, there's there's always plenty to do if you a eventually. few events this week coming up, but a travel. So um
28:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah,
28:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): but I wouldn't have it any other way. So it's
28:55
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): great.
28:56
Nick Goodall: Too right. All right, we'll leave it there for the property market and uh economic chat for the week. So if that's all you're here for, thank you very much for listening and we'll um catch you all next week. From a weekend perspective, sporting in particular, Calvin, obviously a tough, difficult, frustrating loss for the All Blacks yesterday morning, and then a very disappointing loss. last night for the Kiwis
29:16
Nick Goodall: and the rugby league grand final against Australia. Black caps in between that disappoint yesterday, and sort of that game fell away from them, but at least they won on on Friday, I guess. Um, you know, a bit of football maybe holding up the the the positivity at this stage with the All Whites getting a couple of wins over the last week and and the Phoenix woman uh getting a nice 3-1 3 1 victory yesterday. But um
29:36
Nick Goodall: how much of it did you catch Calvin and anything else over your weekend that's uh, you know, any highlights you wanted to chat up chat about?
29:43
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, not not too many sort of personal highlights. Uh Christ Show Day on on Friday here, so we had a a three day weekend. Um but yeah, but but a bit of work round the section as per usual, I guess when you're a homeowner that that that comes with the territory. Um but yeah the sport But um yeah yeah, I I I've I was probably most disappointed about the league actually. I I thought thought
30:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you know we had a chance finally to beat Australia. The teams on paper looked pretty even, and you know, in the in the end, it didn't quite go that way. I mean, as for the All Blacks, um, yeah, I find it hard to be too disappointing because I I went to a lot of games when I was in the UK where a Welsh friend of mine I used to work with. Um, you know, we used to go over every year, and at the end of every year, what the All Blacks always won, and there was always this this
30:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): disappointment for them. So uh, and and and it he was the first person I thought. of, sent him a message as soon as I saw the result and he was apparently he was in tears, his his family was in tears. You know, this this uh this is massive for for the Welsh and you know they're such great people so I yeah I find it hard to be too disappointed um that 'cause it's you know the level of uh excitement there would have been would
30:43
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): have been amazing and and Cardiff would have been absolutely pumping. So um yeah I find it hard too hard I f I find it hard to be too disappointed about it. I hope I'm I'm still um we've got to beat the English, but um losing to the Welsh, yeah, seventy three years that not ideal to to lose that record. But um but yeah, we just wanna keep beating the English, that's the thing for me. So uh
31:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so yeah, that's that's uh that's my interpretation anyway.
31:06
Nick Goodall: Yeah, no, I think it's fair. There's a bit of a soft spot for the Welsh, you know, they're similar country to us, they're as passionate and they get the same sheep jokes and whatnot. So you know, yeah, I think I we've think we've we've we've fell an affinity to the Welsh. Um so yeah, I think like I say, it's not quite as bad as losing to the Aussies or South Africans or English. So I suppose there's a little bit of soft spot there. I think you know I got up at 3 a.m.
31:26
Nick Goodall: and so there's you know, you're living that live and it's pretty frustrating, and we just couldn't find a way through, and you've got to give credit to the Welsh for how well they defended. But you know, with the with the uh I don't know lens of the all blacks and us always expecting to win and being better than these teams and like I say, never not losing for 73 years to Wales, you can't help but say, you know, what could we have
31:46
Nick Goodall: done different or better to be a bit more, I don't know, two-dimensional, you know, or multi-dimensional, because we were pretty, you know, standard attack at the end of at the end of that game and could not find a way through. But did we really um you know test them enough and then you start to question some of the selections and you know, would Damien McKenzie have have had an influence? and maybe Richie Muang is still
32:05
Nick Goodall: readjusting to test level after being away both in Japanese club rugby but then also coming back from injury. So maybe he wasn't quite on form. He did some good things, of course, but what's decision making going for him and
32:19
Nick Goodall: Natima at halfback back as well? So yeah, I don't know. There'll be some pretty harsh reviews, I say, going on for the All Blacks. But uh that's notwithstanding how Welsh the W the how well the Welsh played and obviously deserved you know the win. I think the All Blacks will also look at some of their bad defense in that first half, some bad discipline, some not great tackling, some you know
32:39
Nick Goodall: errors and offloads and things like that too. So yeah, decision making as well on attack wasn't wasn't great. So yeah, tough to take in many ways, but also, yep, at least it wasn't one of those big rival teams And man, what a what a um stadium. What a, you know, the the hucker and the response and the lighting. And I don't know if anyone hasn't seen that, but if you haven't,
32:59
Nick Goodall: do go and watch the haka at the very least, because it was it was um heavy heavy display. So well worth it from that perspective. And I know you've been to that stadium, so yeah, I'm sure you were uh yeah, you can you can see and and understand just what that that experience and that atmosphere would have been like.
33:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yeah oh for sure yeah yeah with the roof's on um although I I I I sort of I didn't see the game fully I was watching it with kids and it was breakfast time and and all that so I didn't actually grasp it that it wasn't sold out but um even 6065000 in there and then and the Welsh I don't know there's a they seem to have a natural affinity for singing. I don't know what it was about
33:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): but um you know you fill out up that stadium roof's on every Welsh person singing that anthem. Um it's amazing. So um yeah, it would have been such a good spectacle to be there. But um
33:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah.
33:46
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I
33:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): take it
33:46
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): when I was there the All Blacks always won. So I'll take that. Yeah.
33:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): But uh but yeah, it w it would have been great.
33:52
Nick Goodall: Yeah, no f too right. Yeah, I mean and then the other one on on my mind, yeah, the Kiwis obviously last night Not I actually missed the start of the game. We actually happened to go to the Flight of the Concords concert last night, which I have to say was a heck of a time. It was very funny. You know, even though there's songs which I know so well, they had little change ups and they had plenty of little guest appearances from a few odd people here and there. And
34:12
Nick Goodall: um, yeah, very funny. The whole, I don't know, the interaction obviously between Brett and Jermaine is just unbeaten. And so it was very good, very funny, very entertaining. Um so that was a bit of a highlight of my weekend before you getting home. Uh or even before I got home, obviously checked the score and saw the kiwis weren't doing so well and conceded a few early and then yeah, I'll be honest, I had to turn that off before it ended because I just
34:32
Nick Goodall: I can't I can't handle losing to the Aussies um in a sport that I don't know enough technical stuff to know what we're doing wrong or why it's happening, and so I just kinda yeah, spit the spit the dummy a little bit on that one and and and gave up a little bit too early. So not sure what that says about me, but yeah, very disappointing. Um but I'll leave I'll leave on the positive that the Fly of the Concord. Concords were great and and yeah
34:52
Nick Goodall: certainly uh was well worth getting amongst. But yeah likewise for the rest of the weekend we had uh a little bit of stuff around the house we actually started to paint and stain our fence um a very dark black colour so that looked really cool so nice to make some progress around the house and yeah otherwise had my son's cricket on Saturday which again second week been amazing so yeah really enjoying being part of that and and uh you know
35:12
Nick Goodall: opposition and kids and stuff are really enjoying it and good and nature and parents and coaches from other team too. It's really good. So yeah, huge um huge positive experience going on in the kids' cricket at the moment. So we'll certainly take that as a positive, more so than yeah, the black caps and how they've gone against the Indians. But uh again, they're a bit of a powerhouse and looking forward to the test series starting as well. I should be at the stadium or
35:32
Nick Goodall: the basin reserve, sorry, on uh both Friday and Saturday too. So um, yeah, looking forward to that one. The test that they're at the based in basin the always uh always a good time. So I hope the the weather holds out for us and uh you no doubt see a few of our loyal listeners uh on the embankment around there as well. So yeah, but that's pretty much us for today, Calvin. Anything else on your mind? Otherwise I'll see ya
35:52
Nick Goodall: on Thursday, of course. We've got our client end of year dinner uh this Thursday night. So looking forward to that and seeing no doubt a few of our listeners who will be at that function. But yeah, anything else on your mind before I catch you later in the week?
36:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
36:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that's pretty much it. Uh uh two, three weeks of uh of hectic stuff coming up, and then we'll sort of start to wind down a little bit. But yeah, it's peak period right now, so um, yeah, plenty to do.
36:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
36:14
Nick Goodall: I can one month of yeah, all over the show, and then hopefully from that sort of say mid-December, we get a week of of of relative respite before a genuine holiday uh coming up around that Christmas period. So no looking forward to
36:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it,
36:24
Nick Goodall: mate. And as you said, you wouldn't have any other way than be busy and be out there and talking to people and and analysing all this great data too. So yeah, good times. All right, mate. Well thanks as per usual for your thoughts and insights. Calvin, always appreciate that. Just want to say thanks very much for listening as well. Please do get in touch with any questions or feedback. But that'll do us for today. My name is Nick. He's Calvin. You've been listening to the Zealand's Property
36:44
Nick Goodall: Market Podcast. Matewa mal.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from The NZ Property Market Podcast

All insights