Speakers compare current market sell-off to 2018, citing Fed policy errors and credit market reflexivity.
Summary
Brent Donnelly and Alfonso Peccatiello discuss a brutal market environment where traditional dip-buying strategies are failing due to bond sell-offs and widening credit spreads. Donnelly criticizes the Federal Reserve's reliance on lagging data and draws parallels to the 2018 rate hike cycle, arguing that a 20% drawdown typically triggers panic rate cuts. Peccatiello highlights how strong fundamentals are being ignored and suggests using dual digital options to bet on negative correlation between equities and the Swiss franc. The speakers describe precious metals and Bitcoin as liquidity proxies currently being sold to cover margin calls, rather than acting as safe havens. Donnelly concludes that while the tone is bearish, he believes most of the downside move is complete and emphasizes survival over directional conviction.
Key takeaways
- 1 Corporate CapEx is a function of credit availability; wider credit spreads reflexively slow CapEx, which in turn slows economic growth, creating a negative feedback loop.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) · 13:22
Episode sections
- 0:04 – 3:17
Introduction and Market Sentiment
Speakers introduce the podcast and discuss the current brutal market environment. They note that traders are conditioned to buy dips, but this behavior may be failing as bonds sell off and there is nowhere to hide.
- 3:17 – 5:55
Fed Policy Credibility and 2018 Parallel
Brent Donnelly criticizes the Fed's inconsistent forward guidance and reliance on lagging data, comparing the current situation to 2018. He argues that a 20% drawdown typically triggers Fed panic and rate cuts, citing Powell's October 2018 comments and subsequent mid-2019 cuts.
- 5:55 – 13:02
Macroeconomic Setup and Carry Trades
Alfonso Peccatiello draws parallels between the current environment and 2016-2018, highlighting strong prior performance in stocks and emerging market carry trades. He notes that just as in 2018, strong fundamentals are being ignored during the sell-off.
- 13:02 – 17:21
Credit Markets and Reflexivity
The speakers discuss how wider credit spreads and tighter financial conditions will reflexively reduce corporate CapEx availability, slowing growth. They argue the market is forcing the Fed to tighten further, potentially leading to a crisis similar to December 2018.
- 17:21 – 21:51
Dollar Dynamics and Repatriation
Donnelly explains a two-step dollar reaction: mechanical buying during equity sell-offs followed by a collapse as US exceptionalism unwinds. Peccatiello suggests capital may repatriate to non-AI exporters like Switzerland, impacting USD/CHF.
- 21:51 – 24:49
Correlation Trading and Dual Digital Options
Peccatiello proposes using dual digital options to bet on negative correlation between the S&P 500 and USD/CHF, arguing that historical zero correlation is broken in a crisis scenario. Donnelly compares this to sports betting on dependent events.
- 24:49 – 29:08
Precious Metals and Bitcoin as Liquidity Proxies
Speakers describe gold, silver, and Bitcoin as liquidity barometers that are currently being sold to cover margin calls. They note these assets have repriced significantly lower and are not acting as safe havens until a crisis moment occurs.
- 29:08 – 32:59
Conclusion and Risk Management
Donnelly expresses less bearishness than the tone suggests, believing 70-80% of the move is done and warning against false confidence from the 2018 analogy. He emphasizes survival and tactical entry over directional conviction.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| US dollarUSD | currency | bullish | nothing has worked. And really there wasn't like a lot of positioning in say, for example, in long dollars, because we came off a long consolidation and off pretty bad levels to be buying dollars. |
| S&P 500 | index | bullish | Then you have had the Federal Reserve that turned hawkish. And back in 18, you said it, right? |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Brent Donnelly traded in 2000 and 2007, experiencing epic rallies in those years which reinforced Pavlovian 'buy the dip' behavior.
Brent Donnelly ·2:25
How to verify: Check Brent Donnelly's biography on Spectrum Markets or his book 'Alpha Trader' for trading history; verify S&P 500 performance in 2000 and 2007 via Yahoo Finance or Bloomberg. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Fed was hawkish in June, dovish in July, hawkish at Jackson Hole, and dovish in October.
Brent Donnelly ·3:37
How to verify: Review Federal Reserve FOMC meeting minutes and press conference transcripts for June, July, September (Jackson Hole), and October 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
November CPI will be negative.
Brent Donnelly ·4:29
How to verify: Check the US Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) CPI release for November 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Powell said in October 2018 that the Fed was a long way from neutral and they were cutting in mid-2019.
Brent Donnelly ·5:17
How to verify: Search Federal Reserve transcripts for October 2026 FOMC press conference; verify Fed rate cuts in mid-2019 via FRED (Federal Reserve Economic Data). For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Backtesting shows that if stocks are down 20%, the Fed will cut rates.
Brent Donnelly ·5:37
How to verify: Perform a backtest using historical S&P 500 data and FOMC meeting dates to check for rate cuts following a 20% drawdown. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
2017 was one of the lowest cross-asset volatility years ever.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·6:19
How to verify: Check the CBOE Volatility Index (VIX) or VVIX historical data for 2026 via CBOE or Bloomberg. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
US tax cuts in 2017 spilled over to growth in the US in 2018.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·6:33
How to verify: Review US GDP growth data for 2026-2026 via BEA (Bureau of Economic Analysis) and correlate with the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act passage date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Turkey carry trade had the highest Sharpe ratio for two years.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·6:43
How to verify: Calculate the Sharpe ratio for USD/TRY or Turkish equity returns over 2026-2026 using historical exchange rate data from Central Bank of the Republic of Turkey. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In 2018, credit issuance was frozen in October, November, and December.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·8:46
How to verify: Check US High Yield and Investment Grade bond issuance data from Bloomberg or S&P Global for Q4 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Powell appeared on January 3, 2019, and signaled a reversal of tightening.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·9:06
How to verify: Search Federal Reserve transcripts for the January 30, 2026 FOMC meeting (note: transcript says Jan 3, likely referring to the market reaction or a specific comment; verify actual meeting date and statements). For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify Federal Reserve meeting minutes and FOMC statements from October 2018 to confirm Powell's comments on further hikes and subsequent rate cuts.
- Check current US Treasury yield curves and credit spread data (e.g., ICE BofA High Yield Index) to assess if credit conditions are tightening reflexively.
- Review historical S&P 500 drawdowns of 20% or more to confirm the Fed's typical response timeline and magnitude of rate cuts.
- Analyze USD/CHF correlation with S&P 500 during recent stress periods to validate the thesis on broken zero correlation.
- Monitor gold, silver, and Bitcoin funding rates and margin call data to determine if they are being sold for liquidity rather than acting as safe havens.
- Read recent Federal Reserve speeches to identify any dissenting opinions or 'civil war' signals among policymakers.
- Assess corporate CapEx announcements and credit availability data for major indices to evaluate the negative feedback loop hypothesis.
- Compare current commodity price trends with 2018 levels to verify the claim that the Fed is ignoring collapsing commodity prices.
Full transcriptexpand
0:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
0:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): macro trading floor.
0:06Alfonso Peccatiello: With me, Alfonso Peccatiello, founder of the Macro Compass, and former head of investments at a large European bank.
0:13Brent Donnelly: And I am Brent Donnelly, president of Spectrum Markets. I've been a portfolio manager, day trader, and market maker at the biggest commercial and investment banks in the United States. I'm also the author of Alpha Trader and the Art of Currency Trading. If you want to know what's going on in markets and where they're going, you found the right podcast.
0:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Hi everyone and welcome back to the macro trading floor with Alf and Brent. Hello by the Dippers people. How are you doing? Uh we were joking with Brent that we are all conditioned to look at the SP going down and saying, oh, but we should absolutely buy this is It a generational opportunity, right? And it was at 7600, at 7500, at 7400, at 7300. And it's like, man, this generational opportunity keeps getting better, right? But it's um it's very tough out there. Uh Brent Yesterday sent me a message, uh, very humble as he is, complaining about the fact that he isn't trading very, very well. Um, and the reality is
1:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
1:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I read him. and I know he's trading okay. And I was joking as well that if I talk to my colleagues in edge funds or like clients of the research, there are three categories: people that have been fired, unfortunately, people that are hiding under the desk, which is the most common category. And then the other categories, people that are still able to hold a conversation about their book and positions, which is brand, Brent, which we which is the best case scenario. It's been brutal out there. I hope you're doing well. Let's try to make some sense of it, Brent.
1:45Brent Donnelly: Yes, it has been kind of a nowhere to hide market because especially with bonds selling off again, there's really been absolutely nowhere to hide. And it's funny the buy the dipper thing. Um, anyone listening to this podcast who's maybe younger should read about Pavlov's research with Doc. dogs. And I feel like that's so much what the market is like. And that's what I'm like too, is when you see stocks down three, four, five percent, you start salivating because you've seen it so many times. And all the times in the past, that behavior was reinforced in a positive way. And, you know, there's times when that's just absolutely not the case. Obviously, people that traded in 2008. And the tricky thing is if you trade in 2000, there were actually some epic rallies in 2000 and also in 2007. So even then that Pavlovian thing kicks in. But yes, it's been a tough time, I think, for a lot of books because the nothing has worked. And really there wasn't like a lot of positioning in say, for example, in long dollars, because we came off a long consolidation and off pretty bad levels to be buying dollars. Like on paper, it looked like bad bad levels buying, you know, say selling euros at 112 didn't feel
3:04very good. And the other thing, so which uh you referenced Alf in my email to you, is I'm a little annoyed with myself because I think. my sort of
3:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
3:17Brent Donnelly: don't know exactly how to describe it, but whatever distaste for the way that the Fed is making monetary policy right now, specifically Waller's comments of late, made me act in probably a non optimal way because I just don't believe what they're saying. Like they were hawkish in June, dovish in July, hawkish at Jackson Hole, dovish in October. It's so I don't feel like the their forward guidance is credible. And then you have a civil war inside the Fed with Waller basically telling wars to eat crap. And all of this is happening. So when you're making monetary policy, there's basically three ways you can make it. You can use real-time data, you can use forecasting, or you can use legging lagging official data. And you know, I don't think it's controversial to say that the third approach is probably
4:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
4:09Brent Donnelly: least effective or the least useful. And that's exactly what Waller's doing. He's looking at the the lagging official data and saying, okay, if it's point three, it's fine, but if it's point four, we we need to hike 50 basis points, which is completely absurd when commodities are collapsing no matter. November CPI will be negative. Uh, and so all of that kind of made me want to fade this move early because I don't think that they're gonna end up being nearly as hawkish. But obviously that was wrong because you know the market needed to price it in fully. And and I actually have made fun of people before
4:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for
4:49Brent Donnelly: playing like the too much is priced Prieston in game. game, but that's exactly the game I've been playing in. And the the stupid thing though, or even stupider thing now, is that
4:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
4:58Brent Donnelly: just believe it even more. So at this point, you then it's just more about risk management and sizing and or staying alive because I do think this all will turn very dramatically. And we have a template for it. It's 2018, right? He's it Powell said in October of 2018 that we're a long way from neutral and they were cutting in mid-2019. You know, so it's there is a template for it. And generally, if you just back test if stocks down 20%, will Fed cut? The answer is yes. So once we get to 20% down, the the Fed will panic and then you know everything will change. But obviously playing that view four days ago or three days ago was was not a good idea.
5:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): No, and now we are at a point where the twenty eighteen parallel I think is quite relevant, uh, Brent. The setup back then was that
5:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
5:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): two 2000 thousand and for a year and a half basically from mid mid-2016 twenty sixteen. to all the way to 2017 and partly in 2018. So almost for two years, people had made a lot of money in stocks. People had made a lot of money in EM carry, a lot of money. I mean, I don't know whether you remember 2017, but it was one of the lowest cross-asset vol years ever. It was the most boring thing I've ever traded in, frankly. Um, people made a lot of money. The sharp of stocks was very, very high. Uh Carry trades were all over the place. In 2018, they also worked to a certain extent in the first half of the year.
6:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There
6:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): were tax cuts in the US in 2017 that spilled over to growth in the US in 2018. Inflation was annualizing a bit above target. Growth was completely fine.
6:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
6:44Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): it really looks like a lot like today. I mean, now we've had a bit more momentum, true, more pushy upside. Absolutely correct, but people have. made a lot of money in EM carry. A lot of money. I mean, the trade in Turkey for two years was the highest sharp. You could just buy uh digitals, roll them over, and print the two sharp. It was like a license to print money, just one example. But if you look at the carry including total return effects pair of, I don't know, Brazil, Mexico, Tsar, you have made a lot of money in these things. So people are conditioned to want to buy the dip in emerging markets if they're not longer. long already. And in stocks, we have had periods of sharp of two or three for the SP 500 lately. Then you have had the Federal Reserve that turned hawkish. And back in 18, you said it, right? I think Powell said we are far from neutral, something like this, implying further hikes were coming. And then the market was like, okay, so if that's what you're doing, then we're gonna start buying dollars and selling rates. And
7:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
7:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): can say the parallel is this is what happened when
7:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
7:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): in summer, basically this year, right? With Walsh turning, more Okish, the data confirming is Oakish turn, core CPI strong, blah, blah.
7:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
7:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): then you're at a point when the market starts selling off. And I remember in 2018, right? Where the first in like in October,
7:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
7:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): started hearing people saying, Yeah, but fundamentals are very strong, nominal growth is very strong going forward, which is an obvious comment. When you see a sell-off which is not aligned with your fundamental view, then you say, Okay, I'm buying the asset that always rewards me, which is stocks. I don't see anything wrong with the economy. It's totally fine. Then comes December, back in November gets worse, like now. The parallel is very similar, also for months. So it's it's quite nice to do it. And then comes December, and everyone is sitting there saying the Federal Reserve will surely not hike rates in December after the SP has gone down and credit spreads
8:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are
8:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): a bit wider. I mean, they must be thinking this. And then Powell just hikes. You know, he basically goes ahead with his tightening of policy. And between December In 15 or 13 and December 22 or something, it's complete mayhem. I remember there are issuers that want to issue bonds and they can't for the whole month of October, November, December, no credit issuance. It's completely frozen. The market takes a proper dump. And only when Pavel shows up on January the 3rd, 2019, saying, sorry, sorry, sorry, we did a mean it. We are taking it back, we are losing financial conditions, then the market goes back up in a straight line. So that's the parallel. And there is a Fed meeting in December, and the market is pricing a twenty-five basis point hike, hundred percent chance. Yes, yes, the fifty basis point uh dream has been taken off, but at least the hike is fully priced. So um, do we get a repeat of that? And it gets much, much worse going into the end of the year? And then if even assuming that that happens, right, Brent, what is the thing that is gonna um rescue it at that point?
9:43Macro doomerism at play here. But uh let's see if we can go along.
9:47Brent Donnelly: So just to continue it a little bit more. So we also had a new Fed chair at that time, and you also had midterms with the Democrats taking a lot of seats at that time. So it there's so many similarities, and interestingly, one reason that I I've been a little bit more bullish just the last couple of days into next week is that Thanksgiving week is one of the best weeks of the year to be long stocks historically. But 2018 was actually down. Uh so there are a lot of parallels. I guess what turns it is simply that uh there's enough deflationary vibes from tightening financial conditions and lower commodity prices that you know they hike just because they said they would in December. And then, you know, they're probably cutting in June or something like that. I mean, that's that's kind of like, I guess that's my base case at this point, because
10:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
10:35Brent Donnelly: you look at real-time data, it's year over year inflation will start to fall later, obviously, but month over month is going to be negative right away. And then I don't know, I just feel like it's gonna going to be hard for them to hike into negative. month over month inflation. And then eventually year over year cools. And then they're probably cutting in 2027. But I guess the real question is: okay, sure, commodity. I mean, if you look at commodity prices and you were just like a naive person that came in here from uh five years ago or 10 years ago and didn't know anything else that was going on, it looks kind of recessionary, like what's going on in a lot. of commodities. And, you know, specifically the China heavy stuff like rebar and iron ore and things like that are looking horrendous. And if you go back to like my one one-legged stool thing for the US, if the one leg of the stool is AI CapEx and it's impossible to issue now or getting more difficult to issue, And people are going to go into more like preservation mode, not like the arms race is kind of over, right? Like it isn't a flex anymore to say we're doing more capex than the other guy. It's
11:51actually bad. So if that was the dominant driver of the US economy and you already have other sectors like housing in the toilet, will consumer spending slow enough? to create a a visible slowdown in 2027? It doesn't seem very far-fetched, honestly. Like if the wealth effect is real and you know, other sectors are already struggling and AI capex growth slows, and that that number, the AI capex number obviously, will still be gigantic, but the rate of change will be slower than you know, we could the actual US. data slow down and jobs growth has been so far above break-even that it's almost incomprehensible. Like if breakeven's 30,000 jobs a month now in the US because of the supply shock from immigration crackdown and all that,
12:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
12:41Brent Donnelly: we're printing 150,000 jobs a month. If you know it's not impossible to believe that we get some zeros or some small negatives pretty quickly as well. So
12:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
12:52Brent Donnelly: guess what does that mean? Long bonds? All roads lead to long bonds.
12:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yeah, I'm I'm thinking about
13:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
13:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): second round effects. Of course, being doomerism, like the Doomerism is easier to deliver when the SP has already sold off 8% from the highs, right? It's always easy to talk about all of this now. But uh the reference reflexivity of this can be quite something. So, an argument I hear that I think is wrong is that CapEx is going to be very strong next year that will support uh nominal growth. Well, CapEx is a function of the availability to deliver the spending. The availability to deliver the spending is a function of can you borrow to do it? If the market is puking in your face and credit spreads are wider, reflexively your CapEx will slow down and that will slow down growth. If you don't want to issue credit, you can always issue stocks, try to issue stocks when the market is down 10% or more at that point. It is in a market where there is the availability of capital, I would say, brand, to lever up and deliver this CapEx, which in turn means lower growth as a result of that. So I think reflexively, if the market really has decided that the Federal Reserve stands. stance has become too tight versus the supply of equities, versus, you know, basically they need to rebalance and tell the Federal Reserve that if they want a continued capex cycle and if they want Goldilocks conditions, they should stop hiking rates. If that's what the market wants to push through.
14:21Actually, Walsh asked for tighter financial conditions. A few meetings ago, he said that financial conditions are still too loose. And to bring down inflation, it's probably necessary to tighten financial conditions a little bit. Well, the market is now giving him what he wants. Next is gonna tell him that hiking in January is wrong. If this gets gets worse, right, it's quite likely that tightening in January is wrong. I saw your piece where you basically came to the same conclusion where between commodity prices and other feedbacks that the Federal Reserve can get, the 27th of January is a far away. This is an air, it's like it's a type of market where a week can look like a lot. The 27th of January is two months to go, right? So I found that that comment correct.
15:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
15:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): it's making
15:09Brent Donnelly: oh, sorry, go ahead.
15:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): No, I was just gonna blubber about correlations now, but that is a a little uh blubber. I wanna leave for last. So let's
15:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay,
15:16Brent Donnelly: yeah, we'll do that last. So the uh the one thing I was gonna say about the Fed, you have a pretty good template in the RBA, right? So the RBA's hike the okay, so just to take a step back, monetary policy in times of war is very difficult. During a supply shock, you you know, the classic sort of anti-hiking view is you can't, you know, rate hikes won't open the Strait of Hormuz is kind of like the the witty way to say that. But the central banks can only really affect the demand side. So if there's a supply shock and inflation becomes a psychological problem, then what you do is you hit the demand side and eventually that fixes the supply side. It's sort of like a brute force method. And the RBA is doing that, and then all of a sudden, so they've been hiking much to the chagrin of. the of the supply shock, you know, haters. And now the employment data there is bad. The AI CapEx story for Australia is bad. They had a failed IPO that was supposed to be the biggest IPO in Australian history, et cetera. And
16:19now we're pricing cuts for the RBA in March. So we've gone from like a pretty aggressive hiking cycle to cuts being priced. And you know, that can easily happen in the US as well. It's just the the truth is like it's fun to make fun of the central banks and and to like pretend that we're smarter than them. But the reality is it's just an extremely difficult situation to have to run monetary policy during a war when you have like absolutely no visibility, you know. apparently it's gonna be over in two weeks, but it might not be kind of situation. It's just really hard to set monetary policy. You see, you look at the backward-looking data and you say, Oh, inflation, you know, is sticky, but you know, is it sticky or is that are you just, you know, driving by looking through the rearview mirror? Um and then if you want to talk, talk a little bit about uh the correlation thing, because I I know what Alf's gonna say because we talked a little bit before he hit record. Um, I I want to just preface
17:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
17:21Brent Donnelly: with a quick comment on the dollar because, and then that'll lead into what you're talking about, Alf. The the dollar is super interesting because the big story for buying dollars for the last few years has been U.S. exceptionalism. There is no alternative, you know, MSCI. world, it became about 75% USA, which is pretty absurd in if you look at GDP and things like that. If you look at earnings, it's not that absurd because US companies make all the money. But, anyways, global investors have just been forced into more and more US equities over time because if you don't hug the benchmark, you get fired. And so this US exceptionalism trade. in theory is unwinding, right? You have AI CapEx story, et cetera, all everything we've been talking about becoming more concerning. But then you have the Fed potentially hiking into that. And when equities go down, there's sort of like a two-step reaction. The first step is that there's mechanical rebalancing Balancing by hedgers by real
18:23money who just have to buy dollars. Like they don't have a choice. And when you have a hawkish Fed on top of that, and then you know the US corporates still keep buying dollars, you just have a ton of dollar demand. But overall, what it creates is less demand for US assets and then a forward concern about how does the US satisfy, you know, the massively negative net investment position. And so this is what happened in 2000. Like as the stock market started selling off, the dollar stayed strong for a while and then it collapsed after that. And so to me, that two-step process is happening now where the dollar first rallies, and then I think it will probably sell off a lot. And but obviously, timing the handoff from dollar buying to dollar selling is that's the challenge. of that of how do you make money. And so I know, Alf, you have an interesting way to look at
19:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that.
19:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): So I have been looking at correlations um a little bit, and the dollar mechanics that Brent is explaining is super interesting. So I see the market here as quite binary. And um my base case, which can be totally wrong, is that this is Q4 2018, and it's gonna be quite hard for anything to stand in the way until we have seen enough deleveraging. A yardstick that I use for deleveraging is that the market likes to inflict the broader amount of pain, and the broader amount of pain is done to people that own the 6040 portfolio. Back in 2018, the 6040 portfolio in September was up 3-4% total return and ended up the year negative eight. Yeah. So that's the type of drawdowns at the 60-40 portfolio that you should expect to inflict enough pay.
20:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
20:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): 60-40 portfolio is still green on the year. Yeah, even after this drawdown, it's actually Be still green. Other types of investments are still up above cash rate, let's say five or six percent year to date performance. So I do believe that it's likely that this gets worse to the point that you know we have to uh maybe drop another 10% from here. Okay. So let's assume that that probability comes to fruition. How do you best position for delivering complexity there? Yeah, if you buy puts here, uh sorry, it's a bit late. You're overpaying for vol. Some people try to be smart and do puts put skew queue, uh like a put spreads, but the skew is expensive as well. If you have, and this is I know that this is only for um very professional investors listening to this, but I think everyone can try to get an idea from what I'm trying to say. If Brent is right and the dollar has rallied so far by tightening conditions and it's led to this worsening of equity markets, which might get worse.
21:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
21:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): capital that has flown to the US over the last two or three years because of AI actually has to get out. And capital has to be repatriated back to the exporters of capital. And if you look for an exporter of capital with no AI, then you will find Switzerland, for example.
21:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
21:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): when you look at dollars we see, you can say, okay, if things get worse, it's likely that the dollar will go down. against Swiss franc as a repatriation and uh AI versus non-AI capital flow story. If you try and combine a dollar Swiss downside option with an SP downside option, let's say you expect that by the end of the year the S B is gonna be down, I don't know, let's make it easy, three, four percent. And the Swiss franc, dollar Swiss franc is gonna be down two. You know, something you adjust it for vol, so of course, you know. uh your your uh dollars with CVU is less aggressive. If you price those things separately, they both trade at about 20% chance, roughly, which makes sense. It's an option with a one standard deviation outcome, and therefore the price should be anywhere between sixteen and twenty percent. If you combine them together in an exotic product called a dual digital option, you effectively are betting on the correlation as well, right? You need that both of these events have to realize for you to be paid. And how market makers price this is they look at the rolling correlations. And the rolling correlation between Swiss and the S P has been zero. So they're effectively saying, look, those two things will behave separately from each other. But if Brent and I are right, they won't. They won't behave separately. They will actually drop at the same time because things get
22:51worse. So you are paying zero correlation for something that will probably be correlated a lot in that scenario. And that means you can have a lot of complexity in this type of trades. This worked very well before tariffs. So you have to imagine a world that will look different in terms of how assets react to each other. Back then, if you bought Euro up SP down trades before
23:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um the
23:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): tariff, they were given to you for free because every time the SP went down, the euro also went down in the past, right? And now you're imagining a world where the SP goes down but the dollar goes down, right? And this can be also one of these cases. Just putting something out there, thinking about correlations and how to use them to unlock complexity.
23:34Brent Donnelly: And if anyone's not familiar with correlation trading, you might be familiar with sports betting. And basically what Alpha is talking about is taking Alabama and the over in uh in a football game. It's that sort of concept where you think if one thing's gonna happen, the other thing's gonna happen. But in this case, it's not priced. And I think it goes to an interesting point too about trading and investing and things like that. Is that I think when you first start out, you tend to be more directional and thinking like, okay, is this thing going to go up or down? And then over time you start to think about the path, and then you start to think about volatility, and then you start to add maybe correlation. And as you go deeper into those things, if you have skill, you can sometimes realize that the market is just completely on drugs at times, where you the backward-looking backward looking correlation makes no sense because some kind of regime change has happened and you can bet on correlation changing in a in a relatively you know
24:35intelligent way through different different ways of of trading. Although it's easier to do when you're an institution, it's hard to do as an individual. Should we talk about gold and and silver and Bitcoin? Or what do you think of
24:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): about the situation
24:49Brent Donnelly: there?
24:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): No, I think we should. Um so this has been a very interesting market where silver and gold have repriced more than a hundred percent of their uh breakout rally, basically, right? And silver is on the way, it seems, to thirty three dollars, which is a level that I remember because that was the very initial breakout from uh September 2020. 2025, which I traded. I don't know why the brain tends to remember these things. Maybe when you made money on a trade, you know, you you tend to remember the numbers. It's like, you know, there is this thing that chemic chemically your brain is set up to forget very bad experiences, right? And tend to overweight for survivorship bias, the good experiences. And uh, it's crazy. Like I remember there was a period in December, January that the market could only talk about precious metals, and now this was a protest trade against fiscal policy. Fiscal policy is probably worse than it was in January this year, and nobody cares. And so these are used just as a liquidity release bulb, right? Where people say this thing is yielding zero percent and it's in my portfolio and
25:54it's bleeding. And I need to get some cash to, you know, pay and defend my portfolio, pay margin. margins. So just dump this momentum liquidity. proxies that I have in the book. And it is becoming uh quite nasty out there. But I'm just trying to one to to ask myself, what what is that changes this narrative? I mean, in my opinion, they will trade pretty correlated to stocks
26:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at
26:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): the end of the day in the short run.
26:20Brent Donnelly: Yeah, and that is makes it very difficult for portfolio construction because
26:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in you
26:26Brent Donnelly: there's really no no safe haven. It, you know, if the new sixty forty was energy and chips, which is what we were being told in July, uh that definitely is not true. And, you know, gold, silver, and Bitcoin are not hedges against anything. They're mostly liquidity barometers until you get to the crisis moment, and then usually that's when gold will finally outperform. But after, you know, we've gone from fifty 5400 four hundred to thirty five. 3500. That's not nothing. And the problem with gold and silver is they're still in the post parabola hangover period where when something goes into a bubble and and goes exponential and then cracks, it's very hard to find buyers after because so many people get burned on those parabola moves. So it's it it all, I suppose, comes down to the Fed and at what point will they blink and are we getting close? Yeah, probably not really yet. Uh but we
27:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): also aren't aren't we? You're making quite
27:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): some statements, huh? You're making quite some statements, Brent. I wanted to reflect on this. I mean, you and I agree basically say, mah, the S P is down eight percent from the top. I'm worse. And then what? Actually, if anything, I have to hope that this continues in in a a way to slow down aggregate demand and get me closer to my inflation target over time. But that is quite a statement that we're talking about an RBA type central bank that doesn't really care about. Well no, wow. Like I agree with you, but I just want to stress it. Wow. I mean, like that would be like in 2019, early, the thing stopped because Powell showed up and said, sorry, sorry, sorry. Literally, pretty much. That was the statement, right? It's like, no, no, no, we did the meeting. didn't mean to tighten conditions this much. What are you guys doing? We're gonna start, you know. He he he played with balance sheet back then. There were other levers, you know, to signal to the market. But if we're saying we're not even close to the discussion point of the Federal Reserve, whether they're doing too much, we are definitely not any close to the point where they turn around and say, Oh, sorry, sorry, we're not liking anymore.
28:23Brent Donnelly: Yeah, I mean, I don't think we're
28:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
28:25Brent Donnelly: the question, I guess. is what do you use as the barometer? Because Nasdaq is down 14%. So
28:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
28:32Brent Donnelly: don't think we're as far as the S P makes it sound. I guess you make it maybe take a blended average or something. But uh yeah, but we're also not at the point. You know, we're we're a good 10% away. And in 2018, that 10% came in the next four weeks. So we'll see. But
28:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
28:48Brent Donnelly: don't know. This I guess this podcast has sounded pretty bearish, but honestly, I am not really as bearish as this podcast sounds. I do feel like we have had an absolutely massive cleanse. And one thing I will say, which is again probably confusing to people listening to this, because I'm now I'm kind of saying something that's the opposite of what we've been saying.
29:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
29:11Brent Donnelly: if it's so obvious that the analogy is so clear that everybody in the market is talking about the analogy, which is kind of the case with 2018, because
29:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
29:22Brent Donnelly: is almost ticks every single box.
29:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
29:24Brent Donnelly: know, a lot of times that does get people sucked into a false, uh, false confidence, a more deterministic view of like this is 2018 all over again. But since markets are probabilistic, you know, all it takes is for Wars to come out and say, hey, what Waller does not speak for the committee. And you know, NASDAQ will be up 5%. And in a time of civil war inside the Fed, you know, that's also possible. I don't think that everyone really agrees with Waller's shock methodology because it's just obviously not a very smart way to conduct policy when you could have you could have hiked in July, you could have hiked in October and if anything, things look worse now than they did then. And now you're talking about going 50. Like it's just nonsense. So there is an opportunity for Wars or somebody to say, hey, you know, this the this person doesn't speak for the committee. We're willing to take incremental steps and yada yada. So I I'm not actually not that bullet or not that bearish. I'm I more think that you know,
30:28seventy to eighty percent of this move is done. And the question is, how can you buy stuff that you like without getting your face ripped off? And that's what I'm trying to do. And so far it's not working. Uh, but I I'm always kind of tactical. I'll stop out if I'm wrong and then say, Okay, now let me try again. And I think ultimately like if you look at six months from now, things that are purchased now will be worth more in six months. But that means nothing if they go down 10 and up 25. You gotta survive the down 10 first.
31:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Watch for path dependencies, my friends. But Brand is right. Of course, you have to be open to the possibility that something comes to the rescue, a low inflation print that makes wash Warsh sound. not so hawkish in December. And then the market is like, okay, we sold whatever it is, percent from that point. We can calm down a little bit and maybe stocks on rally back, but at least the drawdown is over. Um, that is also possible. Yet I think the base case is that the Q4 2018 scenario is absolutely uh something you should have top of your mind. As always, here we don't call directions, just discuss frameworks, try to say. something that might provide you with some, you know, weekend thought, basically.
31:45Brent Donnelly: And to conclude, I want to give a shout out to my niece, Casey, who just got married, and my new friend Jeff Moffat.
31:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): What a nice guy. Okay, guys. Uh, thanks for listening. We'll uh talk back hopefully next week.
32:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
32:00Brent Donnelly: right, thanks, Elf. Thanks, everybody. I'm away next week because it's Thanksgiving. I'm going to Prague.
32:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): You're going to Prague for Thanksgiving.
32:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well, my
32:09Brent Donnelly: son is there, so I'm going to visit my son.
32:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Ah,
32:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): okay. Well,
32:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um,
32:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): you know, happy beers. These guys are
32:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
32:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): think they're drinking the largest amount of per capita beers in Europe or or in the world, actually, or something like that. Do your research. Beer is very good in Prague.
32:24Brent Donnelly: I would not be surprised. All right. Thanks,
32:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): everybody.
32:27Brent Donnelly: Ciao. Bye.
32:28Alfonso Peccatiello: The content provided on the Macro Trading Floor podcast is for general information purposes only. No information or other content provided in this podcast should be considered as investment advice. Seek independent professional consultation in the form of legal, financial, and fiscal advice before making any investment decision. Always perform your own due diligence.