Monetary Matters with Jack Farley

Rick Rule argues deficits drive commodity supercycle via copper capital crunch and uranium term market shifts

58 min Listen to the original
Precious MetalsCopperNuclear EnergyUraniumMining M&ARoyalty CompaniesCommodity SupercycleCapital Allocation

Summary

Rick Rule explains his rotation from physical silver to silver mining stocks in January 2026, citing better value and leverage in equities despite higher volatility. He highlights a $250 billion capital requirement for the top 10 copper companies to maintain production, predicting a surge in gold and silver byproduct streams as copper firms seek development capital. Rule contrasts political risks in the US with developing nations, noting US permitting is a major hurdle but strategic M&A is increasing. He observes strong cultural demand for precious metals in Asia, contrasting it with Western selling, and discusses how nuclear energy economics and uranium term markets are reshaping financing for mine developers.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    In January 2026, silver stocks were discounting $42/oz in NPV; by the interview date, they were discounting $35-40/oz, indicating improved value and downside shelter in stocks versus physical metal.

    Rick Rule · 2:51

  2. 2
    A presentation at Metals Week London (Oct 2025) estimated the top 10 public copper companies need $250B (constant 2025 dollars) just to maintain production, excluding growth.

    Rick Rule · 5:01

  3. 3
    different problem is that the input costs are increasing between 8% and 10% a year compounded. So 2025's 250%. billion becomes 2030's $375 billion.

    Rick Rule · 5:29

Episode sections

  1. 0:28 – 3:34

    Gold and Silver Stocks vs. Physical Metals

    Rick Rule explains his rotation from physical silver to silver mining stocks in January 2026, citing better value and leverage in stocks despite higher volatility. He categorizes gold as a savings/insurance asset and silver stocks as investments, distinguishing them from speculative junior mining.

  2. 3:34 – 8:31

    Copper Capital Crisis and Streaming Opportunities

    Rule highlights a $250 billion capital requirement for the top 10 copper companies to maintain production, with costs rising 8-10% annually. He predicts a surge in gold and silver byproduct streams as copper companies seek capital, benefiting major streamers like Wheaton Precious Metals.

  3. 8:31 – 16:49

    Royalty Company Valuations and 'Me Too' Risks

    Rule warns that small, tertiary royalty companies are overbidding for exploration-stage assets with no payment history. He advises investors to seek durable competitive advantages, such as First Nations access or strategic ties to arrangers, rather than simply outspending competitors.

  4. 16:49 – 26:32

    Political Risk and Permitting Challenges

    Rule contrasts political risks in the US (bureaucratic/legislative) with developing nations (expropriation/violence), arguing US permitting is a major hurdle. He cites the Resolution Copper project's 28-year permitting delay and the Donlin Gold/Pebble Mine challenges as examples of regulatory and sociological risks.

  5. 26:32 – 30:49

    M&A Trends: Strategic vs. Tactical

    Rule predicts increased M&A in gold/silver mining due to depleted pipelines. He distinguishes strategic acquisitions (operational synergies, e.g., Agnico Eagle) from tactical acquisitions (index inclusion, e.g., Equinox/Orla), noting passive index buying drives the latter.

  6. 30:49 – 34:46

    Asian Gold Demand and Cultural Savings

    Rule observes strong cultural predisposition for gold/silver savings in India and China, contrasting with net selling in North America/Western Europe. He shares anecdotal evidence of young South Asian tech workers in Silicon Valley saving aggressively in precious metals due to housing affordability issues.

  7. 34:46 – 38:34

    Gold Demand Drivers and Currency Dynamics

    Rick Rule argues that gold demand is driven by the global middle class's desire to preserve purchasing power against local currency depreciation, rather than just a bet against the US dollar. He notes that while the US dollar is losing purchasing power, it is expected to outperform other currencies, making gold a hedge against local fiat weakness in countries like India and Nigeria.

  8. 38:34 – 42:19

    Aluminum vs. Copper Substitution and Energy Costs

    Jack Farley asks if aluminum will substitute for copper in solar panels and construction if copper prices rise. Rick Rule responds that substitution is a long-term phenomenon driven by high prices, not an immediate threat. He highlights that aluminum production is energy-intensive, so energy costs and nuclear power adoption will critically influence aluminum's competitiveness and supply constraints.

  9. 42:19 – 46:25

    Nuclear Energy Economics and Uranium Demand in Japan

    Rick Rule discusses the high capital costs of US nuclear plants versus Chinese efficiency, predicting cost equalization through regulatory and technological improvements. He identifies Japan as the near-term 'surprise user' of uranium, citing a massive shift in public opinion post-Fukushima and political will to restart existing nuclear plants, creating immediate demand.

  10. 46:25 – 51:40

    Uranium Term Market and Financing Dynamics

    Rule claims the uranium spot market is illiquid and irrelevant, with transactions shifting to long-term contracts (up to 30 years). This shift allows developers to lock in supply and lenders to require secured offtake agreements, significantly lowering the cost of capital for mine developers like NextGen and enabling projects that were previously unfinanceable.

  11. 51:40 – 58:18

    Uranium Royalty Strategy and M&A Landscape

    The speakers discuss how the term market benefits royalty companies like Uranium Royalty by de-risking project timelines. Rule analyzes Uranium Royalty's acquisition of a soda ash royalty from Orion, noting it was a full-price deal that also secured land ownership. He contrasts Orion's need to sell assets to meet 10-year fund lifecycles with family offices' willingness to hold assets indefinitely.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
GoldcommoditymixedThat's a nuanced question. I regard gold as a savings and insurance asset.
SilvercommodityneutralIn January this year, my physical silver, which had been in my speculative bucket, didn't deserve to be there anymore.
Coppercommoditymixedwhile that same cash flow characterizes copper revenue trades between five and seven times E-bit.
S&P 500indexneutralIf you own the SP 500, more than a third is tech.
US dollarUSDcurrencybearishbelieve that the US dollar will lose and is in the process of losing 75% of its purchasing power. But despite that, I think it'll outperform most other currencies in the world.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

Rick Rule sold physical silver in January 2026 and rotated proceeds into silver stocks.

Rick Rule ·1:28

How to verify: Check Rick Rule's public portfolio disclosures or interviews from early 2026; verify silver price action in Jan 2026 to confirm 'parabolic up move'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Silver stocks were discounting $42/oz in Jan 2026, now discounting $35-40/oz.

Rick Rule ·2:51

How to verify: Calculate the aggregate NPV of future cash flows for major silver stocks and compare to current silver price; check historical stock performance vs silver price. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Top 10 public copper companies need $250B (constant 2025 dollars) to maintain production.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·5:01

How to verify: Locate the 'Metals Week London' presentation from Oct 2026 cited by Rule; verify capital expenditure plans of top 10 copper producers (BHP, Rio Tinto, Freeport, etc.). For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Input costs for copper mining are increasing 8-10% annually compounded.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·5:29

How to verify: Analyze industry cost inflation reports (e.g., from S&P Global, Wood Mackenzie) for mining input costs (energy, labor, materials) over the past few years. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Silver cash flows in streams trade at 15-16x EBITDA; in copper revenue at 5-7x EBITDA.

Rick Rule ·7:47

How to verify: Calculate EBITDA multiples for recent stream/streaming deals involving silver byproducts vs. copper byproducts; compare to industry averages. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Wheaton Precious Metals paid $4.3B for a deal in Feb 2026.

Jack Farley ·6:54

How to verify: Check SEC filings (Schedule 14A or 8-K) for Wheaton Precious Metals transactions in Feb 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

BHP had a higher cost of capital than Wheaton Precious Metals in a recent transaction.

Rick Rule ·7:27

How to verify: Review the specific transaction details between BHP and Wheaton Precious Metals; compare WPM's cost of debt/equity to BHP's. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Resolution Copper deposit has been in permitting for 28 years.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·21:12

How to verify: Check US Bureau of Land Management or Arizona state land department records for the Resolution Copper application date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Pebble Mine spent in excess of $80 million in courts.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·23:49

How to verify: Review legal filings and public records for Pebble Limited Partnership litigation costs. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Chinese citizenry are net buyers of gold; North America/Western Europe are net sellers.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·32:27

How to verify: Compare gold demand data from the World Gold Council for China vs. US/Europe for recent years. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Rick Rule believes the US dollar is losing 75% of its purchasing power but will outperform most other currencies.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·36:01

How to verify: Calculate cumulative US inflation using BLS CPI data from a historical base year (e.g., 2026) to 2026; compare USD performance against a basket of other major currencies (EUR, JPY, CNY) using IMF or Federal Reserve data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Japan's uranium consumption went from second largest to non-existent post-Fukushima, with public opinion shifting from 80% negative to 72-73% positive toward nuclear power.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·44:31

How to verify: Check TEPCO and Japanese government reports on uranium imports post-2026; verify public opinion polls on nuclear energy in Japan via NHK or government surveys from 2026 to 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The contract price for uranium is $100 per pound.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·45:58

How to verify: Check UxC Consulting or S&P Global Commodity Insights for the prevailing uranium contract price in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Sprott Physical Uranium Trust trades 4-5 times the dollar volume of the physical uranium spot market.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·46:34

How to verify: Compare daily trading volumes of SPUT on the TSX with daily physical uranium trade volumes reported by the World Nuclear Association or UxC. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

US nuclear plants cost $30 billion to build, while Chinese plants cost $5.5 billion for the same output.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·43:23

How to verify: Compare construction costs of recent nuclear projects (e.g., Vogtle Units 3/4 vs. Hualong One or EPR projects) using industry reports from the Nuclear Energy Institute or IAEA. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

NextGen can now finance a mine due to term contracts with investment-grade counterparties, whereas it would have had to sell to Rio or Agnico previously.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·48:33

How to verify: Review NextGen's public filings or press releases regarding financing structures and offtake agreements with entities like Duke Power or Tokyo Electric Power. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Uranium Royalty acquired a soda ash royalty from Orion, including fee ownership of land.

Rick Rule ·52:19

How to verify: Check Uranium Royalty's press releases or SEC filings (if public) or news reports regarding the acquisition of the soda ash royalty from Orion. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Orion sold a royalty package within a Cisco for $1 billion.

Rick Rule ·54:44

How to verify: Search for news reports or press releases from Orion or the buyer regarding a $1 billion transaction involving a royalty package. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Agnico Eagle reported that diesel prices could add $80 an ounce to production costs.

Rick Rule ·42:24

How to verify: Check Agnico Eagle's quarterly earnings reports or press releases for statements on diesel cost impacts per ounce of gold production. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Japan has 42-43 nuclear plants, with 17 currently operating.

Rick Rule ·44:43

How to verify: Check the Japanese Nuclear Regulation Authority (NRA) or the Federation of Nuclear Industry Associations for the total number of nuclear reactors and their operational status. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the $250B copper capital requirement figure by checking the Metals Week London Oct 2025 presentation or subsequent industry reports.
  • Calculate cumulative US inflation using Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI data to assess the claim that the USD lost 75% of its purchasing power.
  • Compare nuclear construction costs for US plants (e.g., Vogtle) vs Chinese plants (e.g., Hualong One) using Nuclear Energy Institute or IAEA data.
  • Monitor Japan's Nuclear Regulation Authority (NRA) approvals and TEPCO/Kansai Electric restart schedules to verify the 'surprise user' claim.
  • Check daily trading volumes of Sprott Physical Uranium Trust (SPUT) against physical spot market volumes via World Nuclear Association or UxC.
  • Review financing terms for recent nuclear projects to see if lenders require long-term uranium offtake agreements as a condition for debt.
  • Analyze historical copper price cycles to verify if aluminum substitution occurs only after sustained high prices.
  • Check NPV discount rates for silver stocks vs physical metal prices using current market data from major mining exchanges.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): This episode is brought to you by Sarmaya Partners, who manages the Return to Tangibles ETF Lens Ticker L-E-N-S, the Sarmaya Thematic ETF, built for a return to tangibles. Learn more at SarmayaETF.com and see the show notes for disclosures. Let's get into it.
0:15
Jack Farley: Joined today by very accomplished resource and mining investor Rick Rule of Rick Rick Ruhl Rule Investment Media and Battle Bank. Rick, great to see you once again.
0:26
Rick Rule: Pleasure to be with you, sir.
0:28
Jack Farley: Rick, when we did our interview in the winter of 2026, you made a call saying, I am actually selling a little bit of my silver and I'm rotating into the mining stocks instead. Boy, did that call age well. I just want to give credit on that call. Well, what is your reflection of where we are
0:48
Jack Farley: in gold and silver and the mining stocks? So, not just the absolute level, but the relative attractiveness of the metals to the stocks or the stocks relative to the metals. You know, where are we
0:59
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): have
0:59
Jack Farley: where have we been this year? Where are we right now? And what do you see going forward?
1:03
Rick Rule: That's a nuanced question. I regard gold as a savings and insurance asset.
1:08
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:08
Rick Rule: I think it belongs in a different bucket than the stocks. I save in gold, I invest in high quality mining. stocks and I speculate in juniors, and I consider them three different buckets. In January this year, my physical silver, which had been in my speculative bucket, didn't deserve to be there anymore. I was speculating in
1:28
Rick Rule: it because when I bought it, it was hated. And in January, as you might recall, it was a parabolic up move, which defined it as no longer hated. So I sold it.
1:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): For
1:38
Rick Rule: half the proceeds, I bought the silver stocks, which I thought were priced at a discount to the silver market. The silver stocks as a group haven't done great, but they've done better than silver has. And I'm delighted to say that the subset of silver stocks that I picked has done better than the silver
1:57
Rick Rule: stocks generally on offer. But I need to say that the silver stocks had and still. have, I suggest, a better juxtaposition of price to value than physical silver. They present a different set of risks. An investor who buys physical silver has to follow one variable or two at most. The investors
2:18
Rick Rule: need to pay attention to fundamentals, and the speculators in the small silver stocks need to do all kinds of work. So really the question involves answers that revolve around the participants' tolerance for risk, their tolerance for volatility, and their appetite for work.
2:38
Jack Farley: So now that the mining stocks are down less than the metals, where are you seeing the relative value between both of them?
2:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
2:47
Rick Rule: still see better value in the stocks. In January, I anticipated.
2:51
Rick Rule: that the silver stocks were discounting about $42 an ounce in terms of figuring out the net present value for future cash flows. I think that the silver stocks now are discounting somewhere between $35 and $40 an ounce. So I suggest that there's still better value, more shelter to the downside and more leverage to the
3:11
Rick Rule: upside in the silver stocks than in silver. Following, though, that logic, it's incumbent on
3:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
3:21
Rick Rule: person implementing that strategy to do the work required to determine which silver stocks. That's a different question. For those people who aren't willing to do that, they're better off being in the silver itself. It's really a function of how much work you're willing to do.
3:34
Jack Farley: Rick, since our conversation, I've been doing my own personal research in. into the royalty space. The royalty and streaming model this year really has done a lot of deals. And I think that the pace of deals and the size of the deals is probably among the biggest ever. What have you made of these
3:54
Jack Farley: deals? And also,
3:57
Jack Farley: are you worried that there are so many people in the market now that actually the deals will be slightly less good in the same way that in the 1990s, basically most private equity deals was just an absolute phenomenal deal, whereas now obviously they have so much more competition?
4:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
4:11
Rick Rule: think the small side of the royalty space is getting overbid. I think a lot of people are competing for exploration stage royalties, most of which will never make any payments. And I think that part's overbid. But I think with regards to the streaming deals, you ain't see nothing yet. I think, and this is a very specific call. I think
4:31
Rick Rule: the capital required for the copper business and the fact that byproduct gold and silver cash flows from copper projects are worth more isolated in a precious metal stream
4:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): than
4:43
Rick Rule: they are combined with the other free cash flow from the copper business means that the copper companies are. going to access capital for their development expenditures by selling gold and silver byproduct streams. To put that quantum into perspective,
5:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at
5:01
Rick Rule: Metals Week in London, I think it was October of 2025, a paper was presented which suggests that the 10 largest publicly quoted copper companies in the of world, not the copper industry per se, just the 10 biggest, needed to invest. $250 billion, constant 2025, unescalated dollars,
5:21
Rick Rule: to maintain their copper production.
5:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
5:24
Rick Rule: copper's in a deficit, which is to say that doesn't erase the deficit, nor does it take into account the growth.
5:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
5:29
Rick Rule: different problem is that the input costs are increasing between 8% and 10% a year compounded. So 2025's 250%. billion becomes 2030's $375 billion.
5:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
5:43
Rick Rule: the industry doesn't have the $250 billion. The knock against the streaming business has been that the very large transactions that enabled, say, wheat and precious to grow
5:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was
5:54
Rick Rule: a thing of the past. And that's exactly wrong. It's a thing of the future. I suspect that the need for capital in the copper business will generate so
6:03
Rick Rule: much gold and silver stream volume that even Franco and Wheaton will need to syndicate deals out, which means that the second tier will participate in that. As for the tertiary royalty companies, the guys that are buying royalty packages on exploration projects, I think that sector is
6:23
Rick Rule: overbid.
6:24
Jack Farley: That's very interesting. So background. is that in a lot of copper mines, there is gold and silver as a byproduct. So while these copper companies
6:34
Jack Farley: have gold and silver as part of their revenue, but they can sell those streams to exclusive gold and silver streams that have extremely high margin cash flows, and those cash flows are valued higher. And the three big companies Wheat and Precious, Franco Nevada, and Royal Gold, although there's a lot lots of others as well. I'll say out in the outset,
6:54
Jack Farley: I know you're a big admirer of wheat and precious metals, and I'm a big admirer of wheat and precious metals. So this is coming from two admirers, but did you think that they overpaid for their four point three billion dollar deal in February of this year, given where silver was?
7:07
Rick Rule: I do not. I do not it's worthy to note that that project will have incredible silver flows. I think they paid a fair price. I think the instructive part is that the largest mining company in the world, BHP, had a
7:27
Rick Rule: higher cost of capital than Wheaton Precious. That they could do a transaction that was at once accretive to Wheaton and simultaneously accretive to BHP. that tells you how many more transactions are going to occur in this space. Normally, a company 10 times the size of a different company
7:47
Rick Rule: has a concomitantly lower cost of capital. And that wasn't the case. Gold and silver, particularly silver cash flow, domiciled in a stream, characteristically trades at it 15 or 16 times. EBIT, while that same cash flow characterizes copper
8:07
Rick Rule: revenue trades between five and seven times E-bit. That discrepancy, and there are reasons for it, of course, silver, as an example, is more volatile. But in particular, with the streamer, you don't have to worry about the capital costs, so it's pure cash flow.
8:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
8:21
Rick Rule: That discrepancy between, say, 15 times and six times is such that you can do very large transactions that are beneficial both to the buyer and seller.
8:31
Jack Farley: What do you make of the newer royalty companies that are trying to do royalty deals and successfully have done several in non precious metals? So not gold, not silver. So the copper trying to do copper royalty and copper streaming deals. What do you make of those prospects in theory and then in practice?
8:50
Rick Rule: In theory, I think it's great. In practice, there are too many Me Too companies in the small space. If you're buying a third-tier royalty and streaming company, say a new one or one with less than $250 million market cap, you need to look for a durable competitive advantage. They grow right now by paying more than their competitors in auction. And that's not a viable
9:10
Rick Rule: strategy. If you find a company like Origin or the old EMX, where they grow by creating royalties, that's different. Or nations royalty, where their durable competitive advantage might be the fact that they're First Nations controlled and have better access to
9:28
Rick Rule: royalty or streaming or impact benefit agreement benefits from other First Nations. That's a definable business advantage.
9:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
9:35
Rick Rule: different definable business advantage might be Empress royalty. where they have uh an express tie-in to Endeavor Financial, which is one of the largest arrangers in the space.
9:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
9:47
Rick Rule: the Me Too royalty companies, the people who came into the royalty business, because it's easier to raise capital there, where their definable business advantage is perhaps they're quick, but basically because they prepare they're prepared to outpay, outspend their competition.
10:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
10:03
Rick Rule: outspending your competition is a poor strategy.
10:06
Jack Farley: I was under the belief, Rick, that actually if we were to use the term Me Too royalty companies, that actually there were a lot more of them in the precious metal space than in the copper. I thought in the copper there was technically only four For uh Accora, Altius, Altias, and uh Evolve, and then the
10:26
Jack Farley: Australian one. But you actually named several companies that I've never heard of. So tell me uh
10:31
Rick Rule: well, those are much more agnostic as to commodity, and I would suspect that they're more properly regarded as precious metals royalty companies. I was extending that simply to the whole tertiary crop of royalty companies. I think you're correct. I think that you look to the names that you mentioned as being names that are more specifically.
10:51
Rick Rule: let's just say that they're more generic in terms of their commodity interest.
10:55
Jack Farley: Mm-hmm. That makes sense. What do you make of these companies that focus almost exclusively on non-precious metals, even though actually I think they do have some gold and silver streams? Those, you know, let's Accorus, Altius, and uh Evolve.
11:08
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
11:08
Rick Rule: certainly Achoras Achoris and Altius had the ability to be early movers. Akora
11:16
Rick Rule: basically used a coal royalty
11:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
11:20
Rick Rule: expand into the copper space and the lead and zinc space before it was popular. Altius similarly bought the Canadian Pacific royalty package and, of course, the Voises Bay package, and then later the Chipotle kit package, when everybody else was focused on precious metals. the truth is that
11:40
Rick Rule: the market has correctly come to understand that the royalty business, and to a lesser extent, the streaming business, is a better business, with generally higher returns on capital employed and lower general and administrative charges relative to the revenue stream than the mining business. And the consequence of that is that it's easier to raise money in the royalty and streaming space
12:00
Rick Rule: than it is in any other sector of mining. And the consequence
12:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is a very important thing.
12:03
Rick Rule: of that is that management teams are more attracted to easier to raise money. And I suspect that real mistakes will be made in the royalty space
12:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
12:14
Rick Rule: the future, irrespective of commodity. When you see royalty companies in particular, or streaming companies, acquire financial interests in
12:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): non
12:26
Rick Rule: non-producing producer. projects, you better be very careful about the ability of the management team to understand the exploration and development cycle. And I'm starting to see some management teams who, while they may have that skill, haven't demonstrated it in the past. That'll be challenging for them.
12:45
Jack Farley: Yes. What is your outlook of the percentage of non-producing? projects that can make it to actually getting copper, gold, silver out of the ground? I imagine a lot of it is heavily correlated to commodity prices, but I'm sure there are other inputs that you track as well to formulate your answer to that.
13:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well that's a
13:02
Rick Rule: nuanced question. I'm attracted to the copper price, frankly. But I also believe that capital
13:11
Rick Rule: will accrue to more experienced teams. And so there isn't a one-size-fits-all answer. Certainly projects that appear
13:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
13:24
Rick Rule: be in the lowest cost quartile worldwide with scale and projects that exhibit returns on capital employed in the best quartile, but at least 25%,
13:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are
13:34
Rick Rule: likely to get funded. If you're talking about pre-development stage properties, you know, advanced exploration stage properties, it gets a lot trickier. A lot trickier for a lot of reasons. The skill sets involved in discovering and delineating a deposit are different than the skill sets involved in developing and constructing the project,
13:54
Rick Rule: which are themselves different than the skill sets in producing it. And the idea that a junior company is as an example, a three or four hundred million market cap company can employ all three of those skill sets simultaneously is probably problematic. An incompetent or inexperienced management team
14:14
Rick Rule: can foul up a good project, in and of itself at risk, but that risk manifests itself by their occasional inability to attract the capital necessary to build it. So the question that you pose has a very nuanced answer.
14:30
Jack Farley: Mm-hmm. And so certainly you are a bull on the royalty and streaming business model. And certainly your admiration for and interest in the top performing royalties in that space, certainly that's been evident. But is it fair to say that given how many people are in the space, the so-called Me Too royalties, you're striking
14:50
Jack Farley: a number
14:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
14:50
Jack Farley: note caution. Is that fair to say?
14:53
Rick Rule: Sure.
14:53
Jack Farley: Yeah.
14:54
Rick Rule: Yeah. I mean, listen, I'm attracted to the exploration space, which is highly risky, but I'm on record as saying that 90% of the publicly quoted exploration companies worldwide are valueless. So although I'm hugely attracted to the exploration space, I'm hugely discriminatory.
15:15
Rick Rule: That attraction isn't ubiquitous across the length and breadth of the space. It's rather very concentrated around management teams who I think have the demonstrated expertise to succeed.
15:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Hey everyone, hope you're finding value in my questions. I've got a quick question for you. How much of your portfolio actually depends on the physical world? If you own the SP 500, more than a third is tech. Energy, materials, and precious metals, about 5%. Sarmaya Partners believes the next cycle belongs to tangibles. The energy
15:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and metal sectors have been underinvested and underloved for a decade. They call it a return to tangibles, and Lens Ticker L-E-N-S, the Sarmayer ETF, is an actively managed Manage ETF that they manage to express this view. And active is the point. The team follows the theme across sectors, market caps, and borders as the cycle evolves,
16:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): adding where they see opportunity and trimming themes that look overextended. Miners, energy, precious metals, critical metals, all in one actively managed ticker, Lens. When inflation runs, stocks and bonds can fall together. Lens adds real asset exposure with the potential to diversify both the stock side and the bond side against inflation.
16:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and geopolitical risk. Learn more about the Lens ETF and their full data and comparison, including performance, at SurmayaETF.com. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. The funds, investment objectives, risk charges, and expenses must be considered carefully before investing. This and other important information is contained in the prospectus, which may be obtained at SurmayaETF.com. Please read the prospectus perspectives carefully before investing.
16:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Thanks for listening. Let's get back to today's interview.
16:49
Jack Farley: Rick, what's your view of copper? And what's your reaction when you look at those charts showing a projected deficit based on forecasted demand as well as the lack of supply that's going to come online? As a veteran in the business, you've seen very rosy outlooks of demand is going to go up 10% year over year, and
17:09
Jack Farley: supply is only going to go up 1% year over year. And some of the time it's true, but you've seen some of the time it's
17:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): not true as well. What's your outlook? when analyzing this?
17:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
17:16
Rick Rule: don't look at that much. I pay a lot of attention to
17:22
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
17:22
Rick Rule: study, I think it was a Wood Mackenzie study that suggested that the top corporate companies in the world need to spend $250 billion maintaining production. And when I look at project by project through a company like, say, Freeport's supposed pipeline,
17:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
17:39
Rick Rule: fact that Freeport needs to raise so much money, and I'm not picking on Freeport, I'm just using them as an example. Because the business is so capital intense, it's so cyclical, and involves so much time, it's very difficult for me to see where the copper will come from five years
17:59
Rick Rule: from now, absent a global depression.
18:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
18:03
Rick Rule: not calling for global depression, by the way. I'm just saying that the only way that supply and demand could meet themselves is if demand fell. Because the existing supply deficit, taking no growth at all into account, suggests that 20 or 25 years of underinvestment is going to
18:23
Rick Rule: come home to roost in the next five years. But separate and apart from that, I believe that copper demand grows, perhaps not to the extent that the real copper boosters suggest. I'm a skeptic as an example with some estimates of data center demand. But it needs to be acknowledged
18:43
Rick Rule: that humankind, the material advancement of humankind, requires energy, in particular electrical energy. And generating that energy and transmitting that energy and using that energy requires copper.
18:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): At
18:56
Rick Rule: the bottom of the demographic pyramid, a billion people on Earth have no access to primary electricity. And they want it and they're going to get
19:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
19:05
Rick Rule: And that, without data centers, suggests that the industry is going gonna to be bit by 20 years of underinvestment. in copper. And we're gonna have to accommodate that. And I suspect, absent a synchronized global recession recession or depression,
19:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
19:24
Rick Rule: the way we ration copper in the future will be by price.
19:27
Jack Farley: I totally understand how when there was a depression in the price of copper in 2015 or in 2020, that there was almost you know very little was being spent on greenfield exploration. or even brownfield expansion. But with the copper price so high now, you're saying even now Freeport MacMaran is not spending
19:47
Jack Farley: enough to build out supply.
19:50
Rick Rule: They, I mean, last week made a very important decision, I think, around Baghdad. It makes perfect sense that they wouldn't have expended expanded expanded Baghdad 10 years ago, not because of supply and demand, but rather because the permitting difficulties in the United States and in the state of Arizona loomed large. And it would appear, who knows after this
20:10
Rick Rule: election, but it would appear that the permitting difficulties now are less extraordinary. And Jack, if you dye yourself back five or 10 years, capital markets were less attracted to extractive industries. Some of the largest financial services companies in the world were
20:29
Rick Rule: populated by people who thought that mining was evil. They just didn't want to fund it. I think that same generation of people has come to understand there's a correlation between resource utilization and poverty, a positive correlation. One of the ways that you reduce poverty on a global basis is resource utilization. And so we're coming into,
20:49
Rick Rule: I think, the world, a more favorable climate for regulation and permitting, and separately, a more favorable regime
21:02
Rick Rule: for capital markets. That may change. It's important to note, as by way of example, the best undeveloped Developed copper deposit in the United States, by a country mile,
21:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
21:12
Rick Rule: a deposit called resolution, jointly controlled. by BHP and Rio Tinto. Deep, to be sure, capital intensive to be sure, over a billion tons, over one and a half percent copper in a world where the average mine grade is less than one half of one percent. So three times the average grade worldwide. This thing has been in
21:32
Rick Rule: permitting for twenty Twenty-eight eight years. And you can understand a board of directors being unwilling to commit pre-construction expenditures in the half a billion dollar range when they suspected that their return on capital employed might never occur, or if it did occur, would occur occur 15 years
21:51
Rick Rule: hence. If you think about the net present value of cash flow deferred by 15 years, if you use an 8% eight percent discount, that cash flow disappears from current models.
22:02
Jack Farley: Yeah, so Baghdad is actually not in Iraq. It's a it's an Arizona project, right?
22:08
Rick Rule: Yeah. It probably would be easier to permit in Iraq. You know, let's let's let's get risk put on the page. I have found that one of the riskiest jurisdictions in the world politically is the United States. In fact, the worst experience I've I personally had with political risk was in the People's Republic of California.
22:28
Rick Rule: I've had much, much, much better experience with political risk, even in South Sudan and Congo. It's just that it's a different kind of political risk. People who look like me more than you, old, bald, fat, white males, suspect that political risk that comes from people
22:48
Rick Rule: like themselves, in English,
22:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): violence. by
22:50
Rick Rule: the legislature according to the rule of law, is somehow riskier. But that's not in fact the case. Money that goes to Money Heaven, irrespective of how it goes to Money Heaven, is equally risky. And while I have been treated very, very, very poorly
23:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): by
23:07
Rick Rule: the California legislature, by contrast, I was treated extremely well by the Congolese.
23:13
Jack Farley: What's your view of the kind of mega projects that were to be super expensive to build? You know, whether it's the the Don Lynn gold mine or the Pebble copper mine, I guess those two projects in Alaska, or these super big projects that if they ever came on would be massive, but the market is pricing it as if it's a very low
23:33
Jack Farley: probability.
23:34
Rick Rule: I think Pebble in particular suffers from sociological and political challenges. The management team there chose, I think, to deal with the indigenous people in the courts,
23:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as
23:49
Rick Rule: opposed to dealing with them directly. They felt, I think, that their discussion needed to be had with the U.S. government and the Alaska government, as opposed to with the traditional representatives of only 6,500 people. you will note that at Pebble they spent in excess of $80 million in the courts. I suspect that a fraction of
24:09
Rick Rule: that spent on community development would have achieved
24:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
24:13
Rick Rule: different result.
24:15
Rick Rule: And I suspect going forward that that lesson's learned. But that's going forward. Donlin has a different challenge. I've been to Donlin, it's a long way from anywhere. And so ultimately, I think that the people behind Donlin, in particular Tom Kaplan, will do a very good job with Indigenous people. I think that Tom,
24:35
Rick Rule: who's a good friend of Bob Quittermane, will, if he hasn't already, go there and listen. And they will tailor a package to the benefit of the local people. That won't overcome legitimate environmental challenges. and it won't overcome
24:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
24:54
Rick Rule: infrastructure charges, nor will it overcome the capital intensity of building a project of that scale
25:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
25:01
Rick Rule: an area that's that remote. There will be, I think, with this step, with this new legislative regime, I think that there will be renewed wilderness area permitting challenges.
25:15
Rick Rule: A deposit in Alaska that doesn't have, I would say, insurmountable capital constraints would be the Arctic copper deposit. And it should be noted that when the prior administration couldn't stop that project any other way, the Biden administration
25:35
Rick Rule: decided, despite the request of indigenous people,
25:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
25:41
Rick Rule: not allow the road to obviate access to the deposit. And it could be that type of obstructive bureaucratic interference will now return. That's not a projection on my part, but it's an observation on my part. I think that
26:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
26:00
Rick Rule: Democrats likely feel more beholden to the organized environmental groups than the Republicans felt.
26:12
Jack Farley: That makes sense. Going back to gold and silver, where are the sort of the junior mining plays? I guess kind of the whole strategy there is most of the time to be acquired by a major senior miner. mining stock, someone like Barrick or Newmont. How acquisitive do you think the largest gold and silver mining
26:32
Jack Farley: companies in the world are going to be going forward? As I imagine that has a large impact on those junior mining stocks' fortunes.
26:39
Rick Rule: Extremely acquisitive. The mining industry has for a very long time underinvested and then improperly invested. If you go back to the decade 2000 to 2010, it's important to understand that history too. In that decade, the gold price went up six or
26:59
Rick Rule: sevenfold,
27:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
27:00
Rick Rule: the free cash flow per share of the mining industry declined.
27:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now,
27:04
Rick Rule: it takes real skill to generate reduced cash flows when the selling price of your product goes up six or sevenfold. So there was the misallocation of capital. Subsequent to that, capital became unavailable. So one could say that not just the copper industry, but the gold industry, too, has underinvested
27:24
Rick Rule: or malinvested for 25 years.
27:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
27:27
Rick Rule: consequence of that is that with some exceptions, the development pipelines of the companies relative to their depletion schedules means
27:37
Rick Rule: that never mind to grow,
27:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
27:40
Rick Rule: keep their ground, they're going to have to acquire.
27:44
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
27:44
Rick Rule: separate discussion, I think, involves lateral as opposed to horizontal mergers, tactical mergers. It is a truism today that a lot of the aftermarket volume in uh these equities is passive or index-driven. index driven. And when two smaller companies merge, let's say
28:04
Rick Rule: Equinox takes over Orla, there's no strategic reason to do that. There's no operational synergies. But if you put those two companies together, their resultant size means that they have larger index inclusions, which means that they get passive buying, that every two weeks is a consequence of
28:23
Rick Rule: payroll deduction, they grow. So I think in terms of MA, that you need to look at strategic acquisition, which is where a company buys an asset that leverages their existing inventory, and tactical acquisition, where people buy for the sake of buying and growth. I think both of
28:43
Rick Rule: those are going to occur.
28:45
Jack Farley: So what's the difference between lateral versus horizontal acquisition?
28:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
28:50
Rick Rule: I would suggest that horizontal acquisition is, I guess by definition, where a bigger company buys a smaller company. So I would prefer to make the differentiation between strategic acquisition. Strategic acquisition might be Agniko Eagle buying a deposit in the Abatibi,
29:07
Rick Rule: where because that deposit could feed an existing mill, they don't have to spend the money to build a mill. They save the three or four hundred million dollars involved in infrastructure and mill construction by simply building the mine and then trucking
29:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
29:23
Rick Rule: material to their existing deposit, where there are actual operational synergies from already owned assets. That's a strategic acquisition, irrespective of its horizontal.
29:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
29:37
Rick Rule: tactical acquisition.
29:39
Rick Rule: is, as an example, Equinox acquisition of Orla, or perhaps Oceanics' proposed acquisition of Osgold, where there aren't any operational synergies, but where there may be excess management capacity, or
29:59
Rick Rule: simply
30:01
Rick Rule: the fact that four plus two in this case equals seven or eight as opposed to six.
30:07
Jack Farley: Because you you want the passive buyers to be there, whether it's the Canadian pension plans or some someone else. Your former employer, yes.
30:13
Rick Rule: Yep. Or even just the GDXJ. You know, the the GDXJ is partially liquidity and market cap based. And there's all kinds of passive or index buying that's a consequence. simply of uh index inclusion.
30:29
Jack Farley: I wonder for gold, certainly the gold bulls talk very frequently about the central bank buying of gold, which is a very steady hand, diamond-handed buyer of precious metals and gold for sure. But I wonder certainly it seems to me, just looking at the volumes that the Chinese and Indian
30:49
Jack Farley: investment. investments, the private investment community, is a very, very big player there too. And I'm curious if you have any thoughts on their behavior in terms of the bull market and gold over the past five to ten years, as well as trying to estimate is this demand going to be as strong or may even accelerate or weaken? Just your general thoughts here.
31:09
Rick Rule: I would be tempted to answer that question, but you have me way out over the edge of my skis.
31:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
31:14
Rick Rule: know a bit about the Indian investor because I've observed him or her for a long period of time. One just needs to walk into the Gold Souk in Dubai and see the expatriate Indian workers buying physical gold and silver every two weeks with some portion of their paycheck to understand
31:34
Rick Rule: the cultural predisposition that people on the South Asian subject. subcontinent feel. I'm told that that same sentiment exists in China, but I'm less familiar with it. I notice that the Chinese state is still overtly encouraging gold ownership, while they have
31:53
Rick Rule: prohibited the export of gold and they've also prohibited
31:57
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
31:57
Rick Rule: trading in some certificated or derivative instruments. probably for consumer protection, they continue to encourage private savings in gold. And it would appear, looking at the volumes as an example in the Shanghai Exchange, or the flow of
32:17
Rick Rule: gold, that the Chinese citizenry continue to be retail investors in gold. It would appear, by the way, that the only citizenry on the planet
32:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
32:27
Rick Rule: are net sellers of gold are in North America and Western Europe.
32:33
Jack Farley: Yes.
32:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes.
32:35
Jack Farley: And certainly I mean if you're a bull on India, it's not a crazy speculation to say that, you know, if the Indian economy has a lot more money, that that would be bullish for gold.
32:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
32:45
Rick Rule: think that's a very good observation, frankly, particularly rural India. In rural India there's a millennium long
32:54
Rick Rule: distrust
32:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
32:56
Rick Rule: the Indian government and the
33:00
Rick Rule: cultural habit
33:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
33:02
Rick Rule: saving rather than in fiat currency instruments in gold and silver. And I think those cultural habits are hard to break. I noticed by way of anecdote that my own database, which I monitor as well as a 73 year old can, was exhibiting real
33:22
Rick Rule: growth among young female
33:26
Rick Rule: people of South Asian ancestry. Given that I didn't know what the reason for that was that I was interested, I had an a informal contact where I got hold of six. of these young women
33:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
33:40
Rick Rule: asked them to have a conference call with me so I could understand more about this market, not knowing very many young female South Asians. And some interesting comments came out of this. It's anecdotal, not statistical.
33:53
Rick Rule: But these young women all lived in Silicon Valley, California. They turned out all six to be involved in technology. They were all engineers.
34:03
Rick Rule: They were all making,
34:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): by
34:05
Rick Rule: the standards of somebody sub-30, a lot of money. $150,000, $160,000,000 a year.
34:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They
34:12
Rick Rule: all said jokingly that if they showed up at the wrong building in the morning, they'd got a pay raise. But making $160,000 a year wasn't enough money for them to buy a house in Silicon Valley. So they were living four or five or six to a house, spending fifteen hundred dollars of rent,
34:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
34:27
Rick Rule: being South Asians, saving religiously. And they all said that in their culture, one saved primarily in gold or silver. One of them went so far as to say, Rick, in your culture, your distrust of the government is a hundred years old. In our culture, our
34:46
Rick Rule: distrust of the government is a thousand years old. This is anecdotal, right? It's not statistical. But it was a really eye-opening discussion of me. I
34:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
34:56
Rick Rule: guess I should have, had I thought about it, anticipated it, given my observance of the behavior of expatriate Indian workers in Dubai buying physical gold and silver. But to be told it eloquently was useful.
35:12
Jack Farley: That's really interesting. Yeah. and that's one case, you know, I think a lot of gold bulls talk about the growth of
35:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know
35:20
Jack Farley: fiscal deficits and central bank buying, but I that's a really important point that just the growth and the emergence of the global middle class first in China and now in India is a real driver.
35:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
35:32
Rick Rule: think another thing that you have to consider, my narrative about gold is an American narrative, but that's because I'm American. I subscribe, if you will, to the Doug Casey saying
35:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
35:42
Rick Rule: the U.S. dollar is the worst currency in the world, with the sole exception of all of the others. It is not inconsistent, as Brent Johnson will tell you, to believe that the U.S. dollar continues to be the world's reserve currency, albeit Be with it that hegemony reduced, and for gold to do well too.
36:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
36:01
Rick Rule: believe that the US dollar will lose and is in the process of losing 75% of its purchasing power. But despite that, I think it'll outperform most other currencies in the world. The Indian peasantry isn't necessarily making a call against the US dollar, which is something an American citizen might
36:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do.
36:19
Rick Rule: They're making a call against the maintenance of their purchasing power in rupiah denominated savings products.
36:27
Jack Farley: That's very interesting. You know, Rick, what is a demand for gold among countries that are in Africa? You know, one looks at the growth of the Nigerian economy as well as projections, which you know they're projections, but of like where the how many people are going to be in Nigeria in 2050, and it certainly is a very large number. So
36:47
Jack Farley: I wonder could a similar narrative be true about Africa?
36:52
Rick Rule: I don't know very much about the length and breadth of the citizenry of Nigeria. I know some Nigerians. By the nature of what I do, I would suspect that the people who are interested in dialogue with me have similar viewpoints. The savings habits of the few Nigerians I know are very gold
37:12
Rick Rule: gold-centric. centric. If you want to find a group of people who have no trust for government unless they happen to be in it. That's the Nigerians. For good reason. You know, the idea that the wealthiest country in Africa has the second highest poverty rate in Africa is all about government. It's not about the inherent
37:32
Rick Rule: capabilities of Nigerian people or the carrying capacity of the Nigerian economy. It's all about incredible corruption and mismanagement. And one response to that is probably gold.
37:45
Rick Rule: I suspect
37:47
Rick Rule: that participation among middle-class and upper middle-class Africans will lag the participation that you see in Western countries, because I think the opportunity sets that are in front of them in their own economies are. much higher. When I talk to private Nigerian businessmen about the
38:07
Rick Rule: hurdle rates that they expect before they invest in Nigeria, the opportunities that are available to them, perhaps at higher risk, are better or at least more rewarding
38:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): than
38:20
Rick Rule: the opportunity sets that are available to me. Building out the Nigerian economy might have for a connected person, much higher internal rates of return than precious metals ownership.
38:34
Jack Farley: Rick, I wonder your view of aluminum in the following way, that silver is a very large input into solar panels, but it is being replaced, it is was being replaced by copper in that. So that is a dent into in silver demand. Is that silver demand, you know, silver's gotten so
38:53
Jack Farley: expensive, people are replacing it with copper. I've read that that might be a similar threat to copper. That, you
39:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
39:00
Jack Farley: if copper goes to $10 or $15, the engineers and the construction folks are going to do everything they can to get as much aluminum into the projects and that replace copper with aluminum in the same way that they're doing it with silver. So, you know, the same way copper is a threat to silver. aluminum is a threat to copper. So I wonder your views on this and you know to what
39:20
Jack Farley: degree it dents your bullishness on copper as well as boosts your bullishness for aluminum.
39:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
39:25
Rick Rule: think you need to understand those are very long-term phenomena. The cure for high prices is always high prices. If the copper price does what I think it will do over the next five years, you will have an incentive to find ways to substitute other materials for. copper, and you will have an incentive to find ways to use copper more efficiently. That will happen.
39:44
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
39:44
Rick Rule: it won't happen in the near term. What will happen, I suspect, is that five years from now,
39:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,
39:50
Rick Rule: copper will be as pervasive in financial discussions as AI or the Internet. And that whole discussion will be sowing the seeds of its own destruction, which is to say that the high price will validate the narrative. at the same time that the high price will uh encourage substitution and efficiency. I've
40:10
Rick Rule: observed this a lot in my career, by the way. The cure for high prices is always high prices, and the cure for low prices is always low prices. Investors miss this because their time horizon is limited to a quarter rather than a decade.
40:24
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Mm-hmm. And so what's your view on aluminum and the aluminum mining sector? Is that something you don't traffic that much of?
40:33
Rick Rule: No, I follow aluminum fairly well. There's variability there in the sense that one of the most important contributors to the price of finished aluminum is energy. And I would suspect that countries that are relatively low-cost aluminum producers, an example United the Arab Emirates, if they are slow
40:53
Rick Rule: to adapt nuclear power, as an example, will become inefficient producers going forward? So it's a fairly nuanced discussion. We haven't spent a lot of time in the last 15 years looking for new bauxite supplies because the existing ones were too large. But that's going to come to be a constraint. So
41:13
Rick Rule: I I think that the ability of aluminum to substitute for copper will depend on the energy intensity in the aluminum business and what happens to the price of aluminum. You know, it has its own utility, separate apart from replacing copper. As the world uses more energy and as there's increasing
41:32
Rick Rule: incentive to have, in particular, transportation, but other forms of capital equipment that are lighter.
41:39
Rick Rule: Aluminum has attraction separate and apart from its place in, as example, the long-distance transmission of electricity. There are a lot of interplays. I understand you're looking for a simple declarative statement, but I'm not smart enough to give you one.
41:53
Jack Farley: Or maybe you're you're smart enough to not give me one.
41:57
Rick Rule: Well, that's a that's a charitable response. Aaron
41:59
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
42:00
Jack Farley: So that is a really key point that it's not just about getting the ore out of the ground, it's about processing the ore. And that processing is often very energy intensive, in particular in aluminum. The surge in energy prices this year oil, natural gas, you know, everything. What other knock on effects does that have
42:19
Jack Farley: beyond just aluminum?
42:22
Rick Rule: Oh, I think a
42:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): lot.
42:24
Rick Rule: You know, you're starting to see it show up in the gold business. Agnico Eagle said that next year
42:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
42:31
Rick Rule: diesel prices could add $80 an ounce to their production cost. And the world runs on energy. And whether the big thinkers want to admit it or not, it runs on conventional carbon-based supply. Everything we do is energy intensive. And to the extent that
42:51
Rick Rule: we either underinvest or malinvest in energy sources in the future, we will pay the cost. I believe that the world is beginning to be on the right path with regards to energy. I believe that increased utilization of nuclear power and increased uh investment in and deployment of
43:11
Rick Rule: nuclear power plants will bring down the upfront capital. cost of building nuclear power plants a bunch. And I think that the improved regulatory climate has the ability to do that.
43:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
43:23
Rick Rule: United States, when they turn out a new nuclear power plant, if you include the time cost of money, brings them in at $30 billion a copy. And the Chinese can bring in the same output for five and a half billion dollars. That needs to equalize. But if we do that, if we understand the
43:43
Rick Rule: economic necessity, particularly the poor, of higher access to electricity and we utilize the technological resources that are available to us and marshal the correct financial resources, I think the future in energy is great as long as you define the future 10 or 15 years from now.
44:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
44:00
Rick Rule: you define it five or six or seven years from now, the outlet outlook is not good at all.
44:04
Jack Farley: Where do you see the demand from uranium being used in energy coming from, other than China? Because in the US, people talk and and you know wax poetically about how we should be using a lot more nuclear energy. But in terms of the follow through, at least as a you know a human being waking up going day by day, certainly is moving very, very, very
44:24
Jack Farley: slowly.
44:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
44:25
Rick Rule: all this stuff takes time.
44:27
Rick Rule: But I would say within the next two years,
44:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
44:31
Rick Rule: surprise user will be Japan.
44:35
Rick Rule: Japan's uranium consumption went from being the second largest in the world to being non-existent post Fukushima.
44:43
Rick Rule: And post Fukushima, popular polls about nuclear power in Japan were 80% negative. Those same polls are 72 or 73% positive today. Japan's nuclear fleet is 42 plants, 43 if you include Fukushima, but I don't suspect Fukushima will be rebuilt. And their
45:03
Rick Rule: current operating nuclear fleet is 17 plants. A political will exists among the Japanese, and a political eagerness exists among the Japanese government and Japanese. industry to restart those down plants. They don't need to be built, they don't need to be financed,
45:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they
45:21
Rick Rule: just need to be reopened. And the public will exist to do that. The lowest hanging fruit in the uranium demand space is Japan.
45:34
Jack Farley: And uh
45:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): w
45:36
Jack Farley: what's your outlook on not just the uranium price? but the the uranium mining sector as well?
45:42
Rick Rule: Boy, the uranium mine well uh I guess these are related questions. If you had asked me a question six years ago uh about what restarts or new mine supply would look like, that hundred dollar uranium, because that's the by the way, that's where the contract price is today,
45:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
45:59
Rick Rule: would have said we're not short of uranium, we're just short of twenty $20 dollar uranium.
46:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
46:03
Rick Rule: we have a fourfold increase
46:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
46:05
Rick Rule: the commodity price, and we've seen production decreases.
46:09
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
46:09
Rick Rule: don't know what the incentive price is now. I do know what the permitting challenges are like. And I suspect that any response to the incentive price will occur over time as opposed to quickly. I don't have an opinion on that. It ceases to be a variable.
46:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What
46:25
Rick Rule: I do have an opinion.
46:27
Rick Rule: about is the fact that the market dynamic has changed substantially. The references are all to spot,
46:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
46:34
Rick Rule: the spot market is so illiquid that it's irrelevant. Most days, the Sprat Physical Uranium Trust does four or five times the dollar volume that the spot market does. One could say that the Sprat sprout market has become the spot market.
46:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
46:50
Rick Rule: illiquidity
46:51
Rick Rule: means that increasingly transactions are taking place on the term market.
46:55
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
46:56
Rick Rule: that's an important dynamic. That means that unlike any other commodity on the planet, in the uranium business, a supplier
47:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): can
47:06
Rick Rule: understand the quantity that he or she can sell at the price they can sell it for in terms that go up to 30 years. At the same time,
47:16
Rick Rule: developers who are building nuclear power plants, and more importantly, their lenders, understand that they have the ability to lock in supplies 30 years hence. Increasingly, the lenders, let's say that you're an efficient builder, a Chinese builder or a Saudi builder,
47:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
47:34
Rick Rule: you're building a $7 billion plant that actually costs $7 billion. as opposed to $30 billion in the U.S. And the lenders will lend you $5 billion of the $7 billion. The lenders are increasingly requiring the developers of the plants to lock in enough supplies to amortize
47:54
Rick Rule: the loan. This is hugely, hugely important. It isn't manifested yet in the price of your. uranium companies, but it is beginning to be manifest in their cost of capital, both by way of debt and equity. This is going to be an increasingly important topic of the market going forward.
48:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So the power plant operators who are building the power plants are buying they're buying the uranium at 30 years hence, or the mining companies are selling at 30 years hence, in the former.
48:24
Rick Rule: Yes and yes.
48:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Okay. Yeah.
48:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): For
48:26
Rick Rule: every buyer, there's a seller. This is profound. If you look as an example at NextGen, this is not, by the way, a recommendation of NextGen.
48:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
48:33
Rick Rule: if you look at NextGen, six years ago they would have had to sell that deposit because they couldn't finance building it. Now, NextGen, because they bought some physical uranium and they have a lot of cash on the balance sheet, can enter into a supply contract with Duke Power or the Southern Company or Ontario Hydro or
48:53
Rick Rule: Tokyo Electric Power. They have a credit, an investment grade counterparty. And they can absolutely take that purchase order to the bank to secure the financing necessary to build the mine. Five or six years ago, NextGen would have hold had to sell that mine to Rio or to Camico or
49:13
Rick Rule: to Tech. Now they can at least pretend to build it. There's no other commodity in the world, Jack, where I can tell you with any certainty how much of the product I can sell or at what price. That's really important. A lazy credit analyst or security analyst, say Rick Rule, doesn't have to make up price and volume.
49:33
Rick Rule: And if that price and volume is from an investment grade counterparty,
49:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's
49:38
Rick Rule: that goes an awful long way to in in ensuring the security of capital and will absolutely lower the cost of capital to the issuer and make capital available to issuers like NextGen and Paladin that wouldn't otherwise have been able to attract the capital.
49:57
Jack Farley: So this allows more mines to actually be financed and more supply to actually come online.
50:03
Rick Rule: Correct. And it it allows NextGen as an example to do something else, threaten to build a mine. Six years ago, everybody looked at NextGen and said, listen, they're not going to be able to finance it. They're going to have to sell it. And the Canadian government won't let the project be sold to a non convenian buyer. So the only people they'll be able to sell it to will be Camico. How do
50:23
Rick Rule: you have an auction with one bidder? NextGen gets to say now. no, we don't have to sell
50:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
50:29
Rick Rule: We can build it. And besides Camico, there's Anglotech, which now has the financial capabilities to build it themselves. And
50:38
Rick Rule: Rio has just, well, they're in the process of building an eight or nine billion dollar project, Janssen Lake. And all of a sudden, NextGen NextCen is able to say, no,
50:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there's
50:49
Rick Rule: not one bidder. better. There's a at least two. Us ourselves, we could build
50:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it. If
50:54
Rick Rule: Chemico comes to us for the right price, we'll sell.
50:57
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
50:57
Rick Rule: isn't limited to Chemico any longer because although Rio Tinto may not have, as an example, critical mass in the uranium business, and Anglotech has no mass in the uranium business. If they can prove that they can build the mine, they can sell the offtake. And they can sell the offtake.
51:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
51:15
Rick Rule: volumes and at prices that they can predetermine. And if they're selective, they can do it with investment grade counterparties. The listeners that you have that are interested in this need to understand that concept: investment grade counterparties. If the counterparty is a private trading company
51:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
51:33
Rick Rule: isn't investment grade or doesn't publish their financials, that doesn't count. It's important to note that.
51:39
Jack Farley: Mm-hmm.
51:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
51:40
Jack Farley: I imagine that that
51:43
Jack Farley: the fact that because of
51:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
51:46
Jack Farley: term market existing in uranium and lenders being more willing to finance mines and more supply coming online, that might benefit a company like Uranium Royalty, whose Who's a lot of their value is on whether these projects are going to come online, as well as the uranium price.
52:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
52:01
Rick Rule: absolutely. No, Now understand. I this will take time to play
52:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): out. To
52:05
Rick Rule: the extent that your listeners
52:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): have a
52:07
Rick Rule: three-month timeframe, this is valueless information.
52:10
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Talk
52:11
Jack Farley: about royalty deals. What did you make of uranium's
52:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): deal with sweetwater buying a gigantic and long-lasting soda ash royalty?
52:19
Rick Rule: I think that they had a share price that was, let's say, very full. perhaps not very full on a five-year forward basis, but in a 2026 basis. And they looked at the ability to monetize their market capitalization and lock in
52:39
Rick Rule: a royalty stream where they had no competition for a very long period of time. They paid a very full price. But it's important to note that they got not just mineral, but fee ownership
52:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
52:49
Rick Rule: a huge bit of land. Now, a bunch of that land is at best lizard pasture.
52:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah.
52:55
Rick Rule: But I if I were uranium royalty, I would have done exactly what they did.
52:59
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
52:59
Rick Rule: don't think that they had the ability to monetize their market cap in capital markets because it would have disappeared.
53:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
53:05
Rick Rule: I think that they had the ability to use that premium market capitalization to acquire an asset at a very full price that will pay them over time. If they can.
53:15
Rick Rule: perform the magic of using soda ash and trona cash flow at uranium multiples, they will have hit a longball home
53:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): run.
53:25
Jack Farley: Yes. And the entity from which they bought it is one of the biggest players in the private mining of
53:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
53:33
Jack Farley: private financing space for mines, mine debt, and royalties.
53:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
53:39
Jack Farley: the other company that is of a similar scale is one you used to work at. So obviously you know this space very well. And it occurs to me that a lot of these funds that have invested in private royalties, they've done very well
53:55
Jack Farley: on paper. But to whom are they going They're to sell? Are they going to sell to each other? Or do you expect more of these financings
54:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to basically public
54:01
Jack Farley: companies buy them for private packages?
54:03
Rick Rule: I think I wouldn't say that demand for royalty and streams is limitless. But I get a call every month now from a family office as an example,
54:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or
54:16
Rick Rule: an institutional investor looking for these things. People have paid attention to what I talked about, the demand for streams from the copper business. They've listened to the interview and they've called me up and said, Rick, if you come across one of these, we will pay you to involve us. It's important to note, too, that the vendor of that royalty, Orion, is
54:36
Rick Rule: an extremely good competitor in the space. And they have historically generated royalty and streams and then sold
54:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): them. A
54:44
Rick Rule: bunch of the royalty package within a Cisco was purchased for a billion dollars from Orion.
54:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They are
54:51
Rick Rule: probably the preeminent integrated capital source for junior miners on a global basis.
54:57
Jack Farley: Mm-hmm. And do you expect more packages to be so sold by them and other private funds that you have to return capital to public to public stocks?
55:08
Rick Rule: I think you'll see them sell the public stocks, family offices, sovereign wealth funds to everybody.
55:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh It's
55:14
Rick Rule: important. to note that the Orion's and the Sprouts of the world raise money in 10-year terms from partnerships. But when those partnerships expire, they either have to distribute the assets in kind to the investors who may or may not know how to operate them, or they have to sell them. And that's what Orion has done. Orion's dispositions
55:34
Rick Rule: haven't always just been opportunistic, they've been reflective of the fact that the vehicles who held them, which is to say the other people's money, needs to be paid back. And that necessitates a distribution. The difference between them and the private family offices, who, as an example, have dominated
55:51
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
55:51
Rick Rule: oil and gas mineral interests in the United States, is that they're limitless. They don't have timeframes. I know of some very large royalty packages
56:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
56:02
Rick Rule: have been in private Texas family offices for 50 years and will not be sold as long as that family office is controlled by the family whose surname is on the office door.
56:14
Jack Farley: And these are oil and gas royalties or non-oil gas?
56:17
Rick Rule: Yeah, oil and gas royalties. But I think you're going to see the family offices, among other things, come into the royalty and streaming space, particularly streaming space in size. And when that happens, we'll see less structural need to sell or syndicate packages.
56:31
Jack Farley: That makes sense. Rick, it's been a pleasure. Thank you so much. Tell us about Rick Rural Investment Media as well as Battle Bank.
56:40
Rick Rule: Two things. Rural Investment Media. If you like what I have to say about natural resources and you want to personalize it to your portfolio, you can do that for free.
56:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Go
56:48
Rick Rule: to rural investmentmedia.com. That's my website. and list the natural resource stocks that you own. Sidebar, no crypto, no tech stocks, natural resource stocks, and I will for free rank them one to ten, one being best, ten being worst. I'll comment on individual issues if I think my comments might have value. Separate and apart from that, if for any reason
57:07
Rick Rule: whatsoever you're dissatisfied Satisfied with the service or the products that you receive from your current bank, I suspect that means all of you.
57:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Check out the
57:14
Rick Rule: Battle Bank. Among other things, we pay you interest on your checking account. We allow you to bank in 20 currencies. We allow you to invest your IRA or your solo 401k as long as you see fit. We will buy, sell, or store precious metals for you. More importantly, unlike Like anybody else, we will
57:34
Rick Rule: lend you money secured by your precious metals. So if gold is of interest to you, afford currencies are of interest to you. If interest is of interest to you
57:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
57:43
Rick Rule: you aren't being well satisfied by your current bank, check out Battlebank, battlebank.com.
57:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank
57:49
Jack Farley: you, Rick. Thank you everyone for watching. Please leave a rating and review for Monetary Matters on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Until next
57:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): time.
57:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Thank you. Discloses the f door.
58:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Hope you enjoyed that. Want to say a big thank you to today's sponsor, Lens Ticker L E N S, the Sarmaya Thematic ETF, which gives real asset exposure and the potential to diversify a 60-40 portfolio. Read the perspectives at SarmayaETF.com. Disclosures in the show notes. Thanks for watching.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Monetary Matters with Jack Farley

Monetary Matters with Jack Farley

The Anthropic IPO’s Massive Impact: Forced Passive Buying and a Liquidity Wave for Venture Capital | David Shapiro

Episode discussion: David Shapiro discusses Anthropic IPO liquidity, Nasdaq-100 fast-track inclusion, and private market indexing trends.

Speakers’ claims: David Shapiro analyzes the potential liquidity impact of Anthropic's IPO, highlighting the role of Nasdaq-100 fast-track inclusion in driving passive buying pressure post-lockup. He contrasts this with S&P 500 exclusion dynamics and predicts a structural shift in private markets toward passive indexing, mirroring public market trends. Shapiro also covers valuation stability for Anthropic and OpenAI, OpenVC's index methodology, and the challenges facing private market ETFs.

Venture CapitalPrivate MarketsIndex Investing
59 min2 assets20 claims to verify
Monetary Matters with Jack Farley

The Bond Squeeze | Jan van Eck on >5% Treasury Yields, Semis, Anthropic, and Gold

Episode discussion: Jan van Eck on bond yields, AI infrastructure, and gold as currency

Speakers’ claims: Jan van Eck outlines a macro framework where US fiscal deficits and strong growth drive a 'bond squeeze,' pushing 10-year Treasury yields above 5.25%. He distinguishes between AI semiconductor demand and infrastructure needs, projecting 62GW of compute demand by 2030 while citing China's cheap electricity as a competitive risk. Van Eck discusses private credit resilience, gold's resurgence as a global currency driven by government spending, and the valuation dynamics of Anthropic's IPO. He concludes that despite market concerns, valuations remain reasonable with stable fiscal and monetary policies.

Treasury YieldsAI InfrastructurePrivate Credit
60 min4 assets20 claims to verify
All insights