Timing Research Podcasts

Zac Mannes applies Elliott Wave theory to ratio charts across equities, commodities, and crypto to identify relative strength shifts.

50 min Listen to the original Episode page
Elliott Wave TheoryRatio ChartsGold MiningSemiconductorsFibonacci RatiosETFs vs FuturesSector RotationMarket Structure

Summary

Zac Mannes explains how Elliott Wave theory and Fibonacci ratios can be applied to ratio charts to measure relative strength between asset pairs. He demonstrates this framework using SPY/GLD, GBTC/GLD, and SOX/QQQ, noting that ratio charts smooth out data irregularities found in futures contracts. Mannes analyzes specific wave structures in gold miners (GDX/GLD) and semiconductors, cautioning that individual stock rallies may not confirm broader ratio bottoms. He emphasizes prudent labeling of market moves as corrective bounces until confirmed by a third wave. The episode concludes with educational recommendations for mastering Elliott Wave and a brief look at NASDAQ corrective targets.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Prudent labeling requires assuming a move is a corrective bounce first; relying on a reversal without confirmation leads to disappointment if it is only a bounce.

    Zac Mannes · 13:23

  2. 2
    ETFs are heavily governed by a few names, creating feedback loops where falling names drag others down, explaining deeper fades in ratio charts.

    Zac Mannes · 43:13

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 7:12

    Introduction and Elliott Wave Basics

    Zac Mannes introduces the Elliott Wave framework, explaining motive and corrective wave structures and the role of Fibonacci ratios.

  2. 7:12 – 19:19

    SPY to Gold Ratio Analysis

    Mannes discusses applying Elliott Wave to the SPY/GLD ratio, noting a shift to ETFs to avoid futures data irregularities and detailing a multi-year count.

  3. 19:19 – 21:21

    Bitcoin to Gold Ratio Analysis

    Analysis of the GBTC/GLD ratio, describing a potential fifth wave down targeting a 0.1 ratio driven by Bitcoin weakness or Gold strength.

  4. 21:21 – 28:18

    SOX to QQQ Ratio and Semiconductor Sector

    Examination of the SOX/QQQ ratio, highlighting a blow-off top, breakdown, and specific wave setups on NVIDIA and Micron following a wider flat pattern.

  5. 28:18 – 33:10

    Gold to Silver Ratio Analysis

    Discussion of the GLD/SLV ratio showing Gold's relative strength over Silver and identifying a potential bottoming structure in the ratio.

  6. 33:10 – 39:30

    Sector Rotation Ratios

    Review of sector rotation ratios including XLY/XLP, XLE/RSP, and GDX/Gold, identifying diagonal structures and corrective patterns.

  7. 39:30 – 40:26

    GDX/GLD Ratio and Gold Mining Wave Analysis

    Mannes discusses adding wave setups in July, noting a five-wave move up in the GDX-to-gold ratio and subsequent failures to hold support.

  8. 40:26 – 43:33

    Ratio Chart Reliability and Wave Two Consolidation

    Mannes notes the GDX/GLD ratio remained high and unreliable for confirming a wave two bottom, advising wider consolidation until a third wave confirms.

  9. 43:33 – 45:28

    GDX Chart Structure and Wave C of Four

    Identification of an A-B-C structure within a larger wave four down, suggesting the current action might be a wider flat wave two or expanded flat wave four.

  10. 45:28 – 50:01

    Elliott Wave Education and NASDAQ Analysis

    Recommendation of the 'Elliott Wave Principle' book and analysis of NASDAQ potential corrective bounces toward 7500 or 7600 regions.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
S&P 500indexneutralthen checking in with where we are on those two instruments, Um this is as of last week. Um, So we have a potential. move uh move into a more significant top in the SP 500, um, but having yet to confirm any significant slide or
BitcoinBTCcryptoneutralMoving on, wanted to touch base uh with the Bitcoin to gold ratio. Uh back in uh January 2024, I started showing this chart um as a kind of another true value of Bitcoin where it's expressed instead of dollars in gold, um, and that was calling for.
SPDR S&P 500 ETF TrustSPYetfneutralshifting that we did to SPY to GLD, changed this to GBTC to GLD for some of the same reasons.
SPDR Gold SharesGLDetfneutralshifting that we did to SPY to GLD, changed this to GBTC to GLD for some of the same reasons.
GoldcommodityneutralNot everything needs to be expressed in gold terms or even using such separate sectors. So on April 24th of this year, I debuted a SOX to QQQ QQ ratio, showing it in a normal confluence ratio. confluence region for the fibs
Invesco QQQ TrustQQQetfneutralNot everything needs to be expressed in gold terms or even using such separate sectors. So on April 24th of this year, I debuted a SOX to QQQ QQ ratio, showing it in a normal confluence ratio. confluence region for the fibs
NVIDIANVDAequityneutralNVIDIA, Micron, that lented themselves to uh short wave setup attempts for possible starts to a C wave down off of that high.
Silvercommodityneutralthe gold to silver ratio has also been a very interesting study because mm folks used to tell me quite um uh regularly that gold and silver moved perfectly in tandem.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

Elliott Wave was created in the 1930s by R. Elliott, who noticed recurring fractal patterns of market movement.

Zac Mannes ·0:58

How to verify: Historical records of technical analysis literature; primary source: 'The Wave Principle' by R.N. Elliott. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The basic tenant of Elliott Wave is a five-wave motive structure (1-2-3-4-5) and a three-wave corrective structure (ABC).

Zac Mannes ·1:18

How to verify: Standard Elliott Wave theory textbooks; primary source: 'Elliott Wave Principle' by Frost and Prechter. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Avi Gilbert brought the 'Fibonacci pinball' concept to Elliott Wave, providing specific retracement levels for subwaves.

Zac Mannes ·2:11

How to verify: Elliott Wave Trader educational materials; primary source: Publications by Avi Gilbert or Elliott Wave International. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The speaker started building ratio charts in MotiveWave in August 2016.

Zac Mannes ·7:32

How to verify: Archived posts on Elliott Wave Trader or social media (X/Yahoo) from August 2016; primary source: Zac Mannes' historical posts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The SPY to GLD ratio dropped from highs in the 280s to the 140 region.

Zac Mannes ·9:57

How to verify: Historical price data for SPY and GLD; calculation: SPY price / GLD price over time. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

In December 2024, the speaker switched from SPX/GC futures to SPY/GLD ETFs for ratio analysis.

Zac Mannes ·11:43

How to verify: Archived posts on Elliott Wave Trader or social media from December 2024; primary source: Zac Mannes' posts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

The SPY to GLD ratio hit a low in the 160 region by June 2025.

Zac Mannes ·12:03

How to verify: Historical price data for SPY and GLD; calculation: SPY price / GLD price in June 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The speaker changed the Bitcoin to Gold ratio from crypto futures to GBTC/GLD ETFs.

Zac Mannes ·20:05

How to verify: Archived posts on Elliott Wave Trader or social media; primary source: Zac Mannes' posts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

The SOX to QQQ ratio exhibited a blow-off top and extended past the 200% Fibonacci extension.

Zac Mannes ·21:59

How to verify: Historical price data for SOX and QQQ; calculation: SOX price / QQQ price and Fibonacci extension analysis. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Silver was off approximately 46% while Gold was down about 20-25% from their respective highs.

Zac Mannes ·31:35

How to verify: Historical price data for Silver and Gold; calculation: Percentage decline from peak to the date mentioned (May 2026). For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Zac Mannes added eight new wave setups from a list of 41 candidates posted on June 22, 2026.

Zac Mannes ·39:50

How to verify: Check ElliottWaveTrader.net archives or Zac Mannes' social media/posts for a candidate list dated June 22, 2026, and subsequent updates in July 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

A strong five-wave move occurred in the GDX to gold ratio into August 2026.

Zac Mannes ·40:06

How to verify: Plot the GDX/GLD ratio chart for the period July-August 2026 and count waves using Elliott Wave theory. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

The GDX/GLD ratio had retraced to the 618 level by September 2026.

Zac Mannes ·41:12

How to verify: Plot the GDX/GLD ratio chart and apply Fibonacci retracement tools from the relevant swing low/high to verify the 0.618 level in September 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

GDX reached its 382 retrace while gold (GLD) reached its 618 retrace.

Zac Mannes ·41:31

How to verify: Plot GDX and GLD price charts and apply Fibonacci retracement tools to the relevant swing points to verify the 0.382 and 0.618 levels respectively. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Zac Mannes studied Elliott Wave with Avi and has been friends with him for 20+ years.

Zac Mannes ·46:35

How to verify: Check Zac Mannes' biography on ElliottWaveTrader.net or his professional LinkedIn profile for details on his training and relationship with Avi. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Mannes recommends the book 'Elliott Wave Principle' by Frost and Prechter.

Zac Mannes ·49:02

How to verify: Check the transcript for the book title and authors, and verify the book's existence and authorship via Amazon or publisher catalogs. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Mannes identifies 7500 as the ideal wave two bounce target for the NASDAQ.

Zac Mannes ·47:42

How to verify: Plot the NASDAQ Composite chart and apply Fibonacci retracement tools to the relevant downward swing to see if 7500 aligns with the 0.618 or other retracement levels. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Mannes identifies 7600s as an alternative B wave target for the NASDAQ.

Zac Mannes ·48:03

How to verify: Plot the NASDAQ Composite chart and apply Fibonacci retracement tools to the relevant downward swing to see if the 7600 region aligns with a B wave extension or retracement. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the 'Fibonacci pinball' methodology attributed to Avi Gilbert and its specific retracement levels (38.2%, 50%, 61.8%).
  • Check the SPY/GLD and GBTC/GLD ratio charts using NYSE-traded static ETFs to replicate the data smoothing described.
  • Review the 'Elliott Wave Principle' book by Frost and Prechter for foundational theory on motive and corrective waves.
  • Analyze the GDX/GLD ratio for wider consolidation patterns and confirm if a third wave has materialized before assuming a bottom.
  • Investigate the negative feedback loops in GDX by examining the weightings of top holdings and their recent price action.
  • Compare continuous futures data (SPX/GC) against ETF-based ratios to identify rollover artifacts and back-adjustment irregularities.
  • Look for diagonal structures in blow-off tops that extend beyond 200% Fibonacci extensions before reversing.
  • Check NASDAQ corrective bounce targets at 7500 (wave two) and 7600s (B wave) against current price action for potential C wave down scenarios.
Full transcriptexpand

0:00Zac Mannes: Okay, great. As David said, I'm Zach Manis with Elliott Wave Trader. Along with Garrett Patton, we run the Stockwave service and the metals mining and agriculture. Metals mining and agriculture is kind of a sister service to stockwaves where we just focus on metals, mining, commodity, precious metals, commodities, and agricultural commodities. We approach everything through the lens of Elliot Wave. So I don't know how much of a background your um your your uh participants here today have in Elliot Wave. So I wanted to just go through a crash course in that before I get to the main topic of my presentation today, which is um experiments that I've been doing recently um or the past couple of years of applying Elliot Wave to ratio charts and trying to glean um from that an added edge in terms of what the underlings can be doing. So Elliot Wave is basically was created in the 1930s by R. Elliott, who noticed uh recurring fractal patterns of how the market moves Um in motive waves and then corrective waves in terms of how it that would advance and then how it would retrace. that advancement. The basic uh

1:18tenant is one, two, three, four, five for an advancing wave and an ABC for a retracing wave. There's some more complications from that, but uh that's not what the crux of today is about. Um, those motive waves do um divide into two basic schools: one is impulsive. your stronger trending moves that don't have any overlap, and then diagonals, where all of the subwaves are actually made of corrective ABC patterns, or maybe WXYs. And the wave four is allowed to overlap into the top of wave one, but it doesn't always have to. So it's important just to have a basic understanding of those. two different types of structures because that can give you some ideas of what kind of pattern you're dealing

2:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): with.

2:11Zac Mannes: One of the other things that we focus a lot on is the Fibonacci pinball. And this is probably the biggest advancement to the school of Elliot wave that um our founder Avi Gilbert brought to the table. And that is a recipe for um determining the the waypoints of the subwaves inside a third and then the rest of the fourth and fifth after you have an initial five up and three waves down as a one, two. And with very, very uh significant frequency and and so much that you can set your clock by it. And if you don't have this play out, then you pretty much know that you're dealing. with something else and not an impulsive structure. The wave one inside the wave three is going to come to the three eight two, the.50, or the six one eight. Then you're looking for your normal Fibonacci retracement levels for a wave two. Then the wave three is going to either go to the 100% or the one, two, three, six, normal retracement guidelines for a wave four. And then your fifth of wave three is going to go to either the one, three, eight, two, or the one. six, one, eight. There's some variations within that based on getting a little bit stronger moves for the third and and the sub waves within wave five. But that is very, very um

3:27regular pattern that we see on on a on a basis, so much so that we know that if we're not getting um filling out subwaves in that way, then something else is probably a foot. And then after a normal consolidation for wave four, then we'd look for that fifth wave to go to the 176 or the 200% fib. We also place a lot of emphasis on um nomenclature and making sure that subwaves within that structure, not just the subwaves inside one degree smaller, but even all of the smaller subwaves in that. balance out the equations and match at all degrees. So there's a lot of wave slapping out there, and some of it gives Elliot Wave a bad name. We try and focus on education and how to do it the right way to make sure that we're getting everybody's on the same page. Also, when we focus on that correct nomenclature and the correct degree with wave labeling, it helps within stock

4:29waves and MMA for us to be able to talk about things and people can know that if we're talking about a capital Roman numeral, you know, something in parentheses, then that is the um, then that is a specific degree. And so we can differentiate that in in terms of our um quick messages that we include with our posts. Um I'll put this up at the end. This is a quick QR code with a link to other free information, educational information that we have at Elliot Wave Trader. A lot of uh stuff that Garrett worked hard on as far as educational slides that delve a lot more detail into Elliot Wave. Um, I also think it's important to take a look at a broader context of um the market before we get into some of the things that we're going to talk about. And this is uh a chart of the um stock market going all the way back to really the the early 1800s. Um, and it was at this period of time after the Great

5:31Depression or during the Great Depression that RN Elliott created Elliott Wave and forecast a 70 plus year bull market. Um that has largely played out, although there's certainly room for more extension. And so one of the things that we look for in stockwaves, in addition to seeing what potentially has weakness and to rotate into some short opportunities, but what are those things that have the potential of carrying things a little bit higher or at least lasting, even as other things start to show some signs? of weakness. Benefits of stockwaves. In addition to getting the regular ongoing analysis on hundreds and hundreds of stocks that Garrett and I do, you're also going to get regular special updates from Lynn Alden, where she's combining her unique blend of fundamental analysis. with our Elliott Wave technical analysis. And then we also place a lot of emphasis on our wave setups, where we are trying to distill the Elliot Wave potential from a snapshot in time and assigning some very clearly defined parameters such as support, resistance, invalidation

6:47levels, and target levels, and then updating those as they reach their resistance levels and targets. We also have a request tool that people can use the search system to update, get request specific updates for individual charts. And then we do regular videos and webinars. So we know that. Elliot Wave is based on investor sentiment and that those recurring fractal patterns give us a high probability insights into what to expect. But what if we were to apply that to a chart that was derived from other charts? So I learned how to build ratio charts in motive wave back in August 2016. And I mostly used it just to track the SP by way of gold to build. borrow an ISM from Gartman and also track the SP to VIX ratio. So that true value of gold priced of

7:47the market priced in ounces of gold did not seem like anything really novel vis-a-vis a ratio to apply an Elliott wave count to, but it was it was a start. So this is a chart from back in May 2018, looking for a pretty significant. consolidation as a possible primary degree wave two for the SP to gold ratio. This did get a little bit higher into September and then dropped down into the support region where the green support is as either the A wave and then ended up going and making a higher high. And we'll talk about that a little bit more in a few. minutes. So the ratio chart, it's very important. It does not predict a specific direction for either instrument. It is just a graph of the price of asset one divided by the price of asset two. And it's a study in the relative strength. So if the chart is pointing to is trending upwards or is pointing to a reversal to go to the upside, then that means that asset one

8:53is stronger or going to start to be stronger. If it's pointing down, then asset two is going to be the relatively stronger of the two. That doesn't mean they have to move in opposite directions. They could both be moving down together, just one moves down more than the other, or up together, or they could be moving in opposite directions. Um, so since we started talking about that SP to gold ratio, wanted to spend a little bit more time talking about that. Um, I actually started posting this chart more regularly in stock waves as a way to discuss broader market trends without encroaching on Avi's markets section by posting actual counts on the SP. Um so I've since begun posting. regular Friday beginner circle posts that are viewable to everybody at EWT, discussing a lot of the different ratio charts that I've started to track and as a way of talking about shifting trends and relative strength of different sectors, potential rotation opportunities without giving away too much of the

9:57specific wave counts outside of stock waves and MMA. I also share a lot of those on Yahoo. and on uh X. Uh the ratio did come down from the highs in the 280s, um, all the way down towards the 140 region, um, as we expected for a larger wave two. Um, here is a chart uh that um I um started casting. counting i i shifted this to uh a higher wave one instead of the b wave and then looked for um a bigger wave two retrace from there um just because that fit uh subwave structure a little bit better and this was a bit large for a wave two of a c wave um so as a bigger a b of the a wave um that fit pretty nicely um so we have come down into this A region. Also ended up on other charts that we'll see in just a minute. I increased the degree nomenclature from primary degree to a cycle degree. So that's why it might look a tiny bit different.

11:04But one of the things that that we also focus on a lot is what is the The prudent labeling. And then when we do decide to talk about an alternative count. um, what uh we'll we'll put that in and using some sort of color coding, at least is is what I do. So we did come down into that 140 region, which was originally called for. Um, and that could be just the A wave, but it is possible that that's all of the larger degree wave two that we'll see in just a minute. But I think it's more prudent um to initially look for. just a corrective bounce. Also, uh in December 2024, I switched to using the SPY to GLD ratio instead of SPX to the GC futures because my GC futures that I use in MotiveWave are a continuous and back-adjusted back adjusted chart, and the higher interest rate. environment with the bigger, bigger jumps and gaps between the contract roles was starting to muck around with uh the ratio charts and was just really annoying for uh having to move all the labels on my actual gold chart.

12:20Um so fast forward uh a little bit by June 2025, twenty twenty five, we had gotten all the way down into the 160. one sixty region and then had bounced as a corrective A B C bounce for wave four, but should be getting one more low for the fifth wave of the C wave of that larger A, and potentially that one forty region being all of the consolidation is noted with that green um note there. Um and so then into December 2025, we were creeping lower, but had not yet made a nominal lower low. So still leaving room for that ratio to extend lower for a proper fifth of the C wave. But then into the end of January 2026, not only did we get that sharp final extension down, Um, but we also had a really nice reversal candle. Um, and so remember, while this had now hit the 50% fib region for the larger corrective wave two

13:23as a big ABC down off of this high for a cycle degree wave one and wave two, it was more prudent to still label the primary labeling with looking for just a bigger corrective bounce of a much wider flat. So it if you are bullish on the ratio, the spy to gold ratio, as just a corrective bounce, then if it turns out to be more than that, you're going to be pleasantly surprised. But if you are relying on this being all of the wave two and looking for an impulsive move to the upside to confirm that, and you only get a corrective move, you might be more uh disappointed. So I mentioned that it's important to look at each chart on its own. And I think this is a good juncture to take a look at what the components here looked like at that significant potentially very significant bottom. Um while we could dabble in some bullish potential extensions for the SP, um there was it was the larger degree counted very, very complete off of 2020 lows and off of um 2020. 2023 low from the the uh I think I believe. Um so there was not any clear uh setup for a massive rally um to be starting from the

14:42those higher support levels. Um but on the other hand, gold was topping in a larger uh intermediate degree wave three. inside a larger primary wave three and was set for a large ABC consolidation back towards the 4,000 to 3800 region. So by March, we had faded down from that initial pop off of the extreme low and held a higher low, and then started a nice little reversal spike off of that higher low. So we were looking for at least an ABC up for this larger A wave, and then possibly another consolidation and then a move higher. But a move back up towards the 180s in the ratio. Started filling out nicely as the wave one of that C wave, but then when we popped higher as uh

15:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to

15:39Zac Mannes: the 100% fib extension, it made it more likely that that was all of the C wave of that larger A and that we were already in the B wave consolidation, not getting all the way to 180s, but only getting to a measured move and then fading down. And then again, we had that nice fade. We were into the support zone. Um, but similarly, even though we had reached initial support, um, it was more prudent to first look for a B wave bounce and then the C wave of a wider flat rather than relying on this being all of the B wave in that more bullish green B wave node. So that continued to leak a little bit lower to the 618. That actually, as I discussed on the site, increased increase the potential that this was all of the B wave in green, but we should still. look for just a high bounce first and then coming down to retest that support region or maybe the 764 as a wider flat. So that did turn out to be the low for the ratio right at that 618. And we have filled out very nicely as a an extended C wave all the way up to the 618 retrace. if we're counting this as the larger B wave. It's also possible to count this as an ABC up for wave one,

16:58the wave two, and an ABC for wave three, the wave four, and then a wave five of that primary wave one. So now the way that we would distinguish between those two potentials, they're both looking for a pretty decent fade down from this two. 215 ratio region of the ratio down towards a 1.6 ratio. If that's a clear ABC correction, then that lends itself to being the green one, too. And then we would look for the ratio to be far more bullish in favor of the SP off of that low. Um, if we do get a clear five waves down, then we only be looking for a correct. corrective bounce as the parentheses wave two, and then for gold to continue its stronger run from there as the start of that primary degree C wave to the downside.

17:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

17:53Zac Mannes: then checking in with where we are on those two instruments, Um this is as of last week. Um, So we have a potential. move uh move into a more significant top in the SP 500, um, but having yet to confirm any significant slide or break of support. But there is um some structure that we can look at for potential stair stepping its way down to break some support or at least come down to a more reliable consolidation that might lend itself to more extension. Meanwhile, the gold chart has come down into that 4,000 to 3800 region. We dip below 3800 today. Um, could just be some final extension, or might be trying to head down here towards the 3680 to 3650, where there's some confluence for additional fib support down there. Um, but in terms of looking for the ratio to fall, it looks like there could be some combination of both where we have some potential for weakness in the broad market, but also is set up for gold to turn around significantly and start heading up towards new highs, pointing towards the 6,600 to 7200 region. So definitely not a bad time to come

19:12and join us in the metals mining and agriculture. service to check out some of those setups. Moving on, wanted to touch base uh with the Bitcoin to gold ratio. Uh back in uh January 2024, I started showing this chart um as a kind of another true value of Bitcoin where it's expressed instead of dollars in gold, um, and that was calling for. a C wave down in a larger flat consolidation. It actually ended up getting a fifth wave up and instead of turning down in that larger C, and so looking like more of a bullish move. And so then needing just a corrective consolidation from that move up. I also, similar to shifting that we did to SPY to GLD, changed this to GBTC to GLD for some of the same reasons. So I was having some issues with uh, I think the data feed on CryptoCompare and the gold futures as well. Um, so just using the the two NYSE traded static uh

20:24ETFs um cleaned up a lot of irregularities that the ratio chart was was showing. So as of um even more recently last week, uh this was still stubbornly camped out um as a possible fourth wave setting up for one more low in that larger consolidation. Um today uh it's already heading down nicely off of that fourth wave high, um, can get lower in just the A wave, but this final fifth wave should be an ABC drop that really only needs to get a nominal lower low to be reliable. And that's right around a 0.1 ratio between GBTC and GLD. Um, and remember that can be due to weakness um in Bitcoin or just additional strength, uh relative strength in gold for. that ratio to fall. Not everything needs to be expressed in gold terms or even using such separate sectors. So on April 24th of this year, I debuted a SOX to QQQ QQ ratio, showing it in a normal confluence ratio. confluence region for the fibs

21:41at the top of what a normal fifth wave of a primary degree C wave in a cycle three of a larger diagonal would be. But it was exhibiting signs of a blow-off top, and extreme blow-off tops can get even more extreme. So that first extended towards the 200%. fib extension and the 1764, and then got yet another extension past that towards the 200% fib extension of the C wave. And a little bit past the 200% for that potential cycle degree wave three, but then started to show some more signs of a more significant reversal trying to form. And some initial signs of breaking support. And then when it broke this low, then it's confirmed that we were at least starting to stair step down in more of an A wave of a larger A wave and what would be at a much larger primary degree ABC for a cycle degree wave four that could be very, very

22:48choppy as fourth waves notoriously are. Um, with so allowing plenty of opportunities for significant bounces. Um, but back here in June, um I wrote in my update um when I showed this ratio chart that the sox to Q's is probably has the most aggressive turn down so far, um, but still just a small ABC. And if that is just a wave of something larger, it will need to keep any bounce under. the B wave to be under reliable resistance. And then that projected the A wave of the larger A down towards the mid 0.6's. gonna is gonna have to change because there was a recent split. Um so that uh fortunately the split didn't change the structure of the chart, but it did change the values. Um so by the end of July um we had filled out most of that a wave and we're looking for more of a bounce an

23:53ABC bounce for the B wave inside that parentheses intermediate Media degree A. There's a little yellow A here because the structure was a little bit ambiguous that it allowed for this to be one, two, three, four, and get a fifth wave down of an A wave. But an A B C is a little bit more typical. So um then into the uh August, we had a pretty muted possible C wave fill out, but just shy of the 50% retrace from more of that B wave. And there were some individual setups within the semiconductor sector, SOX and a couple other things like LRCX, NVIDIA, Micron, that lented themselves to uh short wave setup attempts for possible starts to a C wave down off of that high. Um, but also some things that allowed for um consideration of a possible wider. and higher flat if they were going to hold support as a corrective

24:54ABC down for a wider A, B, and C wave up, as noted in that purple.

25:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

25:04Zac Mannes: this is an example of one of those wave setups. This was on SOX itself from August 24th. We had a possible one-two start or A B start to the C wave. to the downside. So put the parameters, what the symbol is, the type of setup that it is, support level, invalidation level, resistance level, target level, a time factor. This is a monthly setup or months as opposed to weeks or years, and a ranking, which is really for a different purpose. But we struggled to hold. a wave two bounce and in resistance and started to look more like that was going to fill out the same purple, white, or flat for that B wave, along with a lot of those other names. So as I said, the official updates come when we hit resistance. So we did hit uh that first resistance at the beginning of September that looked more like only three waves down. So it allowed for corrective bounce. We got the initial corrective bounce that we wanted to see, but then couldn't maintain traction turning down from there.

26:14Um so that did end up breaking over. Um I say support, but that was the support level because it was a setup pointing to the downside.

26:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um

26:26Zac Mannes: but the wave setup that was support was lowered down to 529 from the initial support at 540, in invalidation down at 555. Um, so that was able to uh be uh uh invalidated shortly, uh, right around the same price where it was entered from earlier in August, um, with a plan to attempt. the setup again. And then into October, we did have the wider flat fill out. And while I posted that at the same time we have an RSP chart that can be holding uh normal wave four for support for an attempt at one more high, we have the SOX to cues ratio potentially topping in that wider higher flat for the B wave. We added another wave setup uh short on BE as an adjacent name. Um, and uh we're warning pretty heavily um about some dangers in the semiconductor sector um there.

27:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

27:35Zac Mannes: we certainly know how that has played out. We got a pretty nasty move down after a 1-2, a really nasty drop as a third, bounced a little bit higher than we would have normally liked to see as a wave four, but are working on getting that A. Maybe we should get more of a bounce as a B wave and then continue down as the C wave for the fifth of that C of the larger A wave. Um, Mentioned that the ratio values had to change because. of the, I think it was a three to one split on the socks. So now we're looking down into the 0.19 region uh for that support on the ratio.

28:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh

28:18Zac Mannes: the gold to silver ratio has also been a very interesting study because mm folks used to tell me quite um uh regularly that gold and silver moved perfectly in tandem. And if that were really the case, then this ratio chart shouldn't exist at all. It should just be a flat line. So here we are looking back at uh December of 2024, um, looking for the potential start of a um third wave of a C wave down, some potential for getting. a wider uh alt flat for the B wave if we didn't hold that immediate uh resistance for the wave two. Um but uh continuing its move down as a bigger ABC consolidation from the 2020 extreme highs where the ratio hit uh the 117 region. So we did fill out as that. more awkward alt pattern as a bigger WXY for the B wave up towards the 764, and now have been working on filling out that C wave to the downside and a reversal from there.

29:30So in December, I switched again Um, from instead of looking at the GC to SI futures ratio chart uh to GLD. to SLV, uh, again to smooth out those irregularities that the futures, the continuous charts and back adjusting were causing. Um but it was still dropping nicely in the heart of that uh third wave of the C wave pointing down towards the um now the 5.5 region, um, which if you're going gonna to move the decimal point over one, then that would be closer. to the the 50s, the mid-50s from the previous ratio. By January 26, uh, 26, uh the low actually tagged uh the 450s, the one, two, three, six for the C wave. Um, but there wasn't much in the way of a clear fourth wave. And so we did have an initial bounce, although it was really strong, um, that could have been a fourth, allowing for one more low. So we weren't relying on that drop to the 45 level being all of the the C wave yet. Um, but once it pushed a little bit higher than that four as a possible five waves up, then we could start to look for a corrective consolidation um to look for gold to be the clear

30:49uh

30:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): horse.

30:51Zac Mannes: of choice uh for the moves to come. Uh so after initial consolidation, again, it was two of 50%, but we didn't get five waves up off that low. So we needed to look for a wider flat. Uh, we did fill out that wider flat of and a bigger ABC right down to a 618, and then turned up strongly from there, um, and then have been followed. following through on this nice green wave three with gold showing significant relative strength to silver ever since that extreme bottom uh that we hit in May on 513. Uh what's really interesting is that the metals didn't turn bullish uh on in May. Um, quite the opposite. Um, but while both filled out larger consolidations. lower, gold is down maybe about 25% now. As of last week when I was writing up these slides, it was about 20%. While silver was off a staggering 46%, might even be closer to 50% or more with its lows

31:54today. And that this May 5th, fifth May 13th was actually a B-wave B wave high as we were counting in our LE wave charts on silver itself. So here's the ratio continuing to fill out. We've actually gotten a little pop higher into the three 1382 to 1618 zone for the smaller degree third, and then can get a small fourth and fifth wave, and then another fourth and fifth before we get the actual four and five for a five-wave move. up off of that significant low at that extreme at the 0.45 or 4.5. Oh, here's a more updated chart from today, actually. Um, right into that 1382 to 1618. So looking for a small consolidation now, and then another advance higher with continued strength for gold. Hopefully, now they're both trying to. find some bottoms, and it's just going to be gold stronger to the upside.

32:56And silver can possibly bottom as well in its fourth wave, but might be lagging at least initially until it fills out more of this structure to the upside. Back in March, um I did a presentation for EW Hub and I introduced. uh an LEWE count on the XLY to XLP. And at the time, um, this made one of the strongest arguments, uh, speaking macroeconomically, for the broad market having a little bit of gas left in the tank. Um, here counted as a very large diagonal structure. So again, we said that means that all of the subwaves need to be ABC moves. And this A and B structure didn't look complete. We were missing a fifth wave of a C. So fast forward a little bit.

33:57An ABC move for the fifth. So it tried to start that into July. was holding a higher low as the B wave, but couldn't hang on to that, and instead is filled out as a potentially wider wave four. It still lacks a complete looking structure to the upside, but is starting to get less reliable of getting that one more advance, but certainly still valid, even if it looks a little bit awkward. And we're willing to forgive some of that awkward. structure for some of these ratio charts, keeping in mind that they aren't actual instruments that trade based on their own sentiment. Another ratio chart that uh I thought looked uh good was or that I wanted to start tracking was the XLE to RSP. Um we focus a lot on energy charts. in stock waves and have uh really enjoyed um the run up from 2020 and and 2021 and 22 lows. Um, and a lot of these have filled out some nice

35:02consolidations. Some look more like a fifth wave up, where this is one, two, three, and this is a fourth and a fifth. Um, but others look like this is a big enough consolidation that it's something larger. Um so and that really looks like the case here on the XLE RSP ratio chart, where we have um only three waves up, but also a three-wave consolidation and then a strong impulsive looking reversal that's starting to play really good Fibonacci pinball. So looking like a possible wave one. So we wanted to see consolidation as a wave two. Um, also in this uh beginner circle post from uh March, I introduced LA wave counts also on the XLK and XLU ratio as well. But we're not looking at that today. So into from that March high that did get that strong impulsive looking five waves up right to that red 3.382 fib. We did get a nice deep consolidation. to a 764 fib retrace as that parentheses wave two. It counts as a WXY. It's a little bit unique of a structure that's just where we have only three waves in a we have a proportionate wave that would be a C wave, except the sub waves look like an

36:20ABC inside of it. So that's a valid use for a Y wave, an LA wave, and we were are looking for a turn. up as the subwave one inside the start of that possible parentheses, wave three. So fast forward now to November, and we have a five-wave move up as a leading diagonal for wave one. But we also have a sharp drop, even though it's into between the 50% and 618 fib, so possible for that to have been all of the wave two. Again, with especially when you have a sharp initial drop, it's more prudent to look for a B wave bounce and then a C wave of a wider flat first before looking for a more impulsive uh turn or relying on that being all of the consolidation.

37:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um

37:12Zac Mannes: oh, I thought I had an updated chart. We we have been getting a little bit uh of that bounce. We're probably up here in about the the 2.9 or 0.295 region. Um so maybe that's just an A wave of even higher bounce for the B. Uh the GDX to gold ratio. Um again back in March when I um did a presentation, um the had filled out most of the downside for a larger uh wave four pattern and was due to get at least a fourth and a fifth bounce, if not um starting the uh wave one of the larger fifth wave. So it did start up as just a corrective bounce, um, got a little bit too high um to reliably be um. just a corrective bounce, unless it was going to fill out just the wider flat. So, but only three waves up. So if this was the start of the fifth wave in the miners to gold ratio, then we're looking for a wider and deeper uh correction as the wave two. And then we were looking at this as a diagonal structure.

38:27So that did get the initial decline and then couldn't keep that going. So once that broke here, then it made it far more probable that we were filling out as a wider flat for that parentheses wave four as an awkward uh ending diagonal pattern down. Um ideally looking for at least a double bottom um into. uh with the the March low uh from July. Uh so here we filled out we were pretty close to that double bottom into July 17. Um so it was actually getting a nominally lower low than this wave three, um, but had not yet made it under the A wave. That's not required. You can have an A wave, a B wave, and a C wave where the C wave doesn't actually make a lower low than A. It's called a running flat. Um, not the most common pattern that we look for, but when we see the good wave structure where all the subwaves are accounted for, um,

39:30and we're hitting uh a decent proportion, but we just don't have an actual lower low, then we aren't going to be a stickler for that. So um we were starting to see signs of some individual names trying to form some bottoming signals. Um, and we ended up adding um eight new wave setups from a list of candidates that we posted back on June 22nd um of 41 names that we were looking for for the the big rally to come. Um so we added a lot of those uh on this uh day in July.

40:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): From

40:06Zac Mannes: there, we got a really nice strong five-wave move up in the gold GDX to gold ratio. And into August, a lot of those wave setups that we had posted in July and some or in later in July and early August had gotten numerous updates. And a lot of them were looking for retraces into their support region. We had also raised their initial invalidation levels. Um, a lot of those have did not hold, they came down too quickly into support. And this ratio, as we'll see, had not filled out as much of a reliable ABC that we would like to have seen. Um, and so there's feedback loops that with the metals dragging lower, and so a lot of those did fall under. reliable support. And some of them have even made new lows under their July low in what looks more like a larger A B wave and then the C wave down for the wave four down here, which we'll see in just a minute.

41:06This was into September. In my uh Friday uh beginner circle ratio charts post, um I discussed that now that our GDX and GLD chart um gold has already come down to its 618 retrace. This was talking about uh a possible bullish move in off of the July low. Um, so it was already down to its equivalent 618 retrace. GDX was reaching its 382, 3A2, but the ratio chart was still holding stubbornly very, very high. So it was not reliable at all for all of this wave two. So while we could start to look at bullish cases on some of the individual names and on GDX, this was something that was still giving us some pause. So it's perfectly valid as all of the wave two, but prudent to consider a wider and deeper consolidation until the start of um a third wave confirms more. Um, so while some of the individual names have gotten more clear retraces similar to gold, many can argue for needing more, but we are also coming into another ER

42:13season. So it's not impossible for some drops to happen outside of regular trading hours, trading for GTX. Um, and then I stressed again that each chart on its own, and I and then really stressed the ratio here just does argue. for more of a wave two, um, but it allows for more of a wider bounce as a B wave first. And though shallow, it is a ratio chart, and so not something we should uh independently directly that's independently directly affected by sentiment on its own. And so additionally, I said that it's possible for the ratio to fade more by gold being stronger in the short term than. GDX off the possible lows. But as of course, we ended up fading deeper because uh both gold and uh GDX faded more. Um so far, we are still holding this 618 region, um, even though we're dropping down into what's probably a wider wave two now um from this bounce that that should really have held, but I think it was just because of. negative feedback loops that once a few of the names start falling under their support and then needing to stretch lower for their alt version of this wave four, then they drag some of those others' names with it because you're dealing with ETFs that are um very heavily governed by just a few names.

43:33Uh so here's the chart as of today. Um not yet breaking this the the start to a possible wave three, but more likely that this might still try and and make more attempts at structure uh into this 0.21 to 0.20 region for the wider flat of the wave two. Meanwhile, uh many, many other things look like an expanded flat for the equivalent of the wave four, which technically you could count. that here as well and count one, two, three, a high fourth and a fifth wave. Um, I think I'm gonna leave this as the wave is the one, two start because it looks a little bit cleaner on this chart, um, even though we've moved to that parenthes the wider wave four on uh GDX itself.

44:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um and

44:23Zac Mannes: here's the look at that GDX chart where it has the A. B, and then one, two, three, four, five waves down for the wave C of four. So I went through that a little bit faster than I I intended, but I just wanted to get there before my voice gave out and leave some time for a few questions if there are any. um Otherwise we can possibly pull up a few other charts in uh Motive Wave.

45:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,

45:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I'm I'm not seeing any questions yet, but uh if anyone has any, put them in the chat. And uh if you have any other charts you want to share here.

45:28Zac Mannes: Um I I don't have any slides queued up. Um I guess we can I did the the SPX chart that I showed, um

45:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah,

45:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you saw the question that just came in, right?

45:43Zac Mannes: Yeah.

45:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

45:47Zac Mannes: don't know if I can make that any bigger. Um I can try and switch to uh a motive wave window and show that. Try and share this window. Um is Elliot Wave masterable? Um I think so. We have a number, I mean many of our analysts uh started off as members uh under Avi before we expanded to new services that had that focus on individual areas. Um so uh I I learned uh from reading a book um Elliot Wave Principle by Fr Frost and Prector and studying with Avi. He and I are been friends for 20 plus years now. Um but uh I I think it's certainly masterable. Um

46:52maybe focus on just learning some of the basics first and then uh um going uh here's my updated tab that I've been keeping track of. Um I changed the subwave count on this uh subways for wave five. So um

47:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

47:14Zac Mannes: think that this is just a wave one if we are starting the C wave to the downside. Um and this four could actually be moved over here. Uh so if we are heading lower uh immediately, uh I would like to see a corrective bounce back up towards uh what is that? Let's put some fibs on that. I've been actually tracking the NASDAQ chart much closer because I've been following it along with the semiconductors. Uh so back towards the 7500 region would be the ideal corrective bounce as a wave two. Um, if we are starting a larger C wave to the downside, it is possible. to count this as five waves down. And so that would be an alt of this A wave as five waves. And you could bounce back up towards the 7600s as a B wave. But no real significant support broken yet. And so any corrective bounce needs to either hold 7500 as a wave two or the 7670 region as an alt B wave or we can go back into larger extension mode.

48:44But let me put that um QR code back up because I think that is uh good to check out for more of the educational opportunities or educational resources for Elliewave. So I definitely recommend the Frost and Prechter Prector book. Um but also there's a lot of really good um PowerPoint modules. Not PowerPoint, they're I think they're done as as videos. There we go.

49:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,

49:41Zac Mannes: David, I think that is all my voice is going to allow for today. Um, and I'm also out of charts. Um, if there are no more questions, um, I'll let you let everybody else take a bathroom break.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights