Joe Bauernfreund discusses AVI Global and Japan Opportunity Trusts amid AI volatility and valuation shifts
Summary
Joe Bauernfreund outlines the strategies of AVI Global Trust and AVI Japan Opportunity Trust, emphasizing corporate governance engagement and value unlocking. He attributes recent underperformance to a lack of corporate events rather than macro factors, noting improved management receptiveness in Japan. Bauernfreund highlights AVI Global's low AI exposure and specific holdings like Universal Music and Chrysalis, arguing that strong balance sheets and low multiples offer resilience against AI-driven volatility. He predicts a potential US market rollover as earnings growth fails to justify current valuations in a higher interest rate environment.
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 6:24
Market Context and AI Bubble Concerns
Jonathan Davis discusses a brutal week for equity markets, citing the Anthropic IPO and Nvidia's leadership scandal as drivers for a sell-off in tech and commodities. He notes that while volatility has spiked, he cautions against assuming the AI bull market has definitively peaked due to technical factors like capital reallocation.
- 6:24 – 10:37
AVI Global Trust and AVI Japan Opportunity Trust Overview
Joe Bauernfreund introduces his two funds: AVI Global Trust (~£1bn, global value/discount focus) and AVI Japan Opportunity Trust (~£400m, Japanese small/mid-cap activist strategy). He explains the latter's focus on inefficient balance sheets and corporate governance engagement.
- 10:37 – 32:25
AVI Japan Performance and Corporate Activity
Bauernfreund attributes recent underperformance to a lack of corporate events (takeovers) rather than the Fidelity Japan consolidation. He highlights that since summer 2026, two takeover bids have occurred, improving performance, and notes that management attitudes toward shareholder activism have improved significantly over the last decade.
- 32:25 – 33:25
Focus on Business Fundamentals Over Discounts
Speaker_1 argues that managers should focus on analyzing business value rather than fixating on share price discounts, which are outside their control. They cite Universal Music Group as an example where operating performance was strong despite poor share price performance, noting that the controlling shareholder's timeline differs from investors' preferences but interests remain aligned.
- 33:25 – 34:14
Portfolio Volatility and Concentration Risk
The speaker acknowledges that high-conviction, concentrated portfolios can lead to lumpy returns, with recent underperformance caused by specific poor performers. However, they note that these large holdings could also drive significant NAV reversals if sentiment shifts.
- 34:14 – 35:59
AVI Global Trust Discount and Buybacks
Speaker_1 states that AVI Global Trust's ~10% discount is in line with the global growth peer group average of 8-9%. The board has utilized buybacks of 5-7% of shares outstanding annually to manage the discount, balancing the need for trust size to maintain influence in portfolio companies against shrinking the fund.
- 35:59 – 36:38
Portfolio Allocation vs Benchmark
The speaker highlights that AVI Global is benchmark-agnostic, holding only ~10% US exposure compared to the ~70% in the world index, while holding ~30% in Japan (vs 7% benchmark) and ~20% in Korea (vs 1% benchmark). These overweight allocations in Japan and Korea have driven recent outperformance.
- 36:38 – 37:56
Overlap Between AGT and AJOT
Speaker_1 explains that overlaps between AVI Global Trust (AGT) and AVI Japan Opportunity Trust (AJOT) exist because AJOT focuses on small caps, whereas AGT, as a larger fund, targets mid-to-large cap names. This results in 2-3 overlapping companies where opportunities exist in the larger cap space.
- 37:56 – 39:08
Market Sentiment and Valuation Shifts
The speaker observes that when the AI trade struggles, their portfolio of companies with strong balance sheets and low earnings multiples tends to outperform. They believe a shift away from US dominance and AI concentration is likely as interest rates remain higher, forcing investors to reconsider rich valuations.
- 39:08 – 41:18
US Market Valuation and Earnings Growth
Speaker_1 predicts that valuation concerns will eventually dominate investor sentiment, particularly in the US where strong earnings growth has masked overvaluation in specific pockets. They argue that while the US market isn't entirely overvalued due to earnings growth, the excitement around overvalued companies suggests a rollover is imminent.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| NVIDIANVDA | equity | neutral | despite a strong earnings report from the chipmaker Nvidia and a record-breaking IPO by Anthropic, the AI. model builder. |
| S&P 500 | index | neutral | The SP 500 is now down from its peak by around 10%, which is enough to qualify for a definition as a correction. |
| Gold | commodity | neutral | But notwithstanding that, the price of gold has also weakened yet again, so taking its lead more from the commodity sell-off than from the risk assessment that often drives its price higher. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Anthropic raised $80 billion in its IPO and $40 billion in private placement, totaling $120 billion, the highest ever, surpassing SpaceX's 2025 raise.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:12
How to verify: SEC F-1 registration statement for Anthropic's IPO; press releases from Anthropic and financial news archives for SpaceX 2026 funding. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceAnthropic IPO price was $83 per share, peaked above $113, and closed the week at $97.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·2:11
How to verify: Stock exchange records for ANTH (or private placement data if not yet public, though transcript implies public trading); financial news archives for Nov 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThe S&P 500 was down more than 8% in one week, its worst weekly performance, and is down ~10% from its peak, qualifying as a correction.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·0:52
How to verify: S&P 500 historical price data from Yahoo Finance or Bloomberg for the week of Nov 15-21, 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Nvidia lost nearly half its market value, contributed to by the resignation of CEO Jensen Huang.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·2:46
How to verify: Nvidia (NVDA) stock price history; press releases regarding Jensen Huang's resignation from Nvidia or SEC filings (Form 4/8-K). For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceIn Q3 2026, the aggregate earnings growth of the Magnificent Seven was lower than the other 493 S&P 500 companies.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·3:06
How to verify: FactSet data (referenced as FACSEF) or S&P Dow Jones Indices reports for Q3 2026 earnings growth comparisons. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
AVI Global Trust has a market cap of around £1 billion.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·7:38
How to verify: AVI Global Trust (AGT) latest annual report or company website investor relations page. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
AVI Japan Opportunity Trust has a market cap of about £400 million.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·7:57
How to verify: AVI Japan Opportunity Trust (AJOT) latest annual report or company website investor relations page. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
AVI Japan Opportunity Trust grew from ~£200m to ~£360m after absorbing Fidelity Japan assets.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·9:57
How to verify: AVI Japan Opportunity Trust annual reports comparing pre- and post-Fidelity merger AUM; Fidelity Japan fund closure announcements. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
AVI Japan invested 25% of its management fee in shares in AJOT.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·24:18
How to verify: AVI Japan Opportunity Trust Key Investor Information Document (KIID) or annual report detailing discount control mechanisms and fee reinvestment. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Chrysalis holds Smart Pension and Starling Bank as core assets.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·29:53
How to verify: Chryslis Holdings (CHR) annual report or portfolio disclosure; press releases regarding Starling Bank or Smart Pension. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Universal Music Group's operating performance has been good despite poor share price performance.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·32:45
How to verify: Check Universal Music Group's latest annual or quarterly financial reports for revenue/EBITDA growth trends; compare with share price performance data from Bloomberg or Reuters. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
AVI Global Trust trades at a discount of around 10%.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·34:14
How to verify: Check the latest NAV and share price data for AVI Global Trust (AGT.L) on the London Stock Exchange or the company's investor relations page. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The global growth peer group for investment trusts trades on an average discount of around 8-9%.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·34:14
How to verify: Consult the Investment Company Institute (ICI) or AIC (Association of Investment Companies) reports on investment trust discounts and peer group averages. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
AVI Global Trust board has bought back between 5-7% of shares outstanding on average over the last few years.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·34:34
How to verify: Review AVI Global Trust's annual reports or stock exchange announcements for share buyback figures and total shares outstanding over the past 3-5 years. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
AVI Global Trust has approximately 10% exposure to the US, 30% to Japan, and 20% to Korea.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·36:18
How to verify: Check the latest portfolio holdings or regional allocation data in AVI Global Trust's half-year or annual report. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The MSCI World Index (or similar global benchmark) has approximately 70% US exposure, 7% Japan, and 1% Korea.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·36:18
How to verify: Check the regional breakdown of the MSCI World Index or FTSE All-World Index on the MSCI or FTSE Russell websites. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceAVI Japan Opportunity Trust focuses primarily on small cap equities.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·36:38
How to verify: Review the investment objective and policy statement in AVI Japan Opportunity Trust's latest annual report or prospectus. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
AVI Global Trust has 2-3 overlapping companies with AVI Japan Opportunity Trust.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·37:09
How to verify: Compare the top 10 or top 20 holdings of both AVI Global Trust and AVI Japan Opportunity Trust from their latest reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
US earnings growth has been pretty strong, masking some overvaluation.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·39:30
How to verify: Check US corporate earnings growth data (e.g., S&P 500 EPS growth) from S&P Dow Jones Indices or FactSet for the relevant period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the current discount/premium of AVI Global Trust (AGT) and AVI Japan Opportunity Trust (AJOT) against their respective NAVs via the AVI Group website or Morningstar.
- Check the latest annual reports for AGT and AJOT to confirm portfolio holdings, specifically the exposure to Universal Music Group (VIV.PA) and Chrysalis, and the rationale for retaining them.
- Review the corporate governance codes issued by the Japanese Financial Services Agency (FSA) and Tokyo Stock Exchange to assess the regulatory pressure on shareholder returns.
- Analyze the Anthropic IPO prospectus and subsequent private placement details to verify the $120bn capital raise figure and its impact on tech sector liquidity.
- Compare the Q3 earnings growth rates of the 'Magnificent Seven' against the remaining S&P 500 constituents using S&P Dow Jones Indices data.
- Investigate the specific takeover bids mentioned (Share and Technology, Broad Media) and their premium levels relative to NAV at the time of announcement.
- Assess the correlation between US interest rate expectations and the valuation multiples of low-earnings-multiple companies versus high-growth AI stocks.
- Review the buyback history and discount control mechanisms of AGT and AJOT to understand how management fees are utilized to manage the discount.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Welcome to the award-winning Moneymakers Podcast. I'm Jonathan Davis, the founder and host. For more than six years now, we've been providing comment and discussion about all the latest developments in the world of investment trusts, the stock market listed funds often called the City of London's best kept secret.
0:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
0:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): grateful to JP Morgan Asset Management for their continued no-string String support, which enables us to keep the podcast free while preserving our truly important independent editors. editorial principles. Please note that while our comments are well researched and our opinions honestly held, we do not offer individual stock recommendations. It's been a brutal week for the equity markets, where in the US, despite a strong earnings report from the chipmaker Nvidia and a record-breaking IPO by Anthropic, the AI. model builder.
0:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
0:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): SP 500 was down more than 8%, one of its worst weekly performances, and the NASDAQ Index, where many of the big tech companies are located, down by even more. Other markets naturally followed in sympathy with the US sell-off, but most notably in Asia, where some of the picks and shovels for the AI revolution, particularly. in Taiwan and Korea, are located. And those markets sold off also very strongly, dragging down emerging markets overall as a whole. So what's been going on? Well, the Anthropic IPO, which raised $80 billion, that's a huge sum of money, the highest ever, more than SpaceX managed to raise last year. That had much to do with it. That's a huge amount of money, and in addition, at the same time they raised another forty billion dollars in a private placement. So that's 120 billion overall, and that money, if you were going to allocate it to the IPO, had to come from somewhere else. And I think that's one of the explanations why the equity markets have suffered this week with investors shifting their interest from taking money from one place to put it into the anthropic IPO. The anthropic shares did end somewhat higher than. the IPO price, but uh were still down from the immediate post IPO peak of over $113,
2:11which compared to the issue price of eighty-three dollars per share. Finished a week at ninety-seven, but there's no certainty that that trend of reverting towards the issue price is not going to continue this week.
2:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): To
2:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): put some of these numbers in context, we got so used to talking
2:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): about.
2:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): in billions and trillions these days that it's often overlooked quite how significant these sums of money are. The SP 500 is now down from its peak by around 10%, which is enough to qualify for a definition as a correction. While Nvidia, which has been the darling of the stock market for about three years, has now lost nearly half its market value. The scandal surrounding the resing. resignation of its founder and chief executive, Jensen Huang, being a further significant contributor to that decline. Another fact that perhaps was lost in the dramatic headlines this week was the fact that in the third quarter, according to FACSEF, the earnings growth reported by the Magnificent Seven was actually lower in aggregate than the other four 493 hundred and ninety three companies in the SP five 500. hundred.
3:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): At
3:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the same time as all this was going on, we saw significant sell-off in the commodity markets as well, with oil down and copper, which is a significant component in the whole AI revolution, also selling off very sharply. So that in turn has had knock-on effects on the investment trust sector. The investment trust index was down nearly 5%. That's not quite as bad as the US market. But if you look at the composition of the index and how individual stocks fared in that sell-off, you'd see naturally enough the technology trusts well to the fore, but also, as I mentioned, the commodity trusts, BlackRock World Mining off more than 10%, and those Asian emerging market trusts, which have profited hugely from the surge in the share prices of the foundries and memory chip makers which are concentrated in Taiwan and South Korea, as I've mentioned already. So out of the whole universe of investment trust, there's only thirty that I can count that have made a positive return this week, while more than two hundred have fallen in share price terms.
4:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now,
4:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): put this again in some kind of context, these significant market declines are notable. The one we've just witnessed is probably the worst since the immediate post COVID sell-off back in 2020. But it's not often that bear markets actually begin with a dramatic fall like this. So if you're one of those who think that the AI led bull market has run out of steam, which many people now seem to do, there's no certainty that we're going to see a significant straight line decline from here. That isn't really how marketing. markets work. There will be a period of adjustment. And while some of us have been warning about the dangers of the AI bubble for quite a long time, too long, some critics would say, I don't think that the medium-term outlook for this particular trade or this particular sector is that good. However, I just cautioned that because of these technical factors that may have contributed to the decline this week, I don't think we can naturally assume. that we've yet seen the last high in the sector. Could well be wrong about that, but that is just the voice of experience giving an opinion as we head towards the end of the year. What is not in doubt, however, that volatility has spiked up, and it's been good to see that bond yields have also come down a little in response to the equity market sell-off. sell off. That's pretty much as you would expect. as there's typically a flight to
5:40safety. But notwithstanding that, the price of gold has also weakened yet again, so taking its lead more from the commodity sell-off than from the risk assessment that often drives its price higher.
5:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
5:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): week I recorded the podcast on Thursday, and I had the good fortune, perhaps, while this was going on, to talk to an investment manager who has been suffering from the AI-led bull market, by virtue of being less exposed to that than many global investors, but has also not suffered quite as much from the sell-off this week as others who have been more all in on that trend.
6:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
6:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): this week on the podcast, I'm delighted to be joined by Joe Barnfreund, who is the lead manager of two investment trusts, AVI Japan Opportunities Trust, which specializes in the Japanese market, obviously enough, and also AVI Global, which is an investment trust which looks for discount opportunities and other potential gains from a global universe. But has a very distinctive approach to that particular challenge. And of course, you run the investment. company Asset Value Investors, which has recently been sold, but you remain there and will continue to manage your trust in the current way. I think I've summed that up correctly, have I, Joe?
7:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Spot on.
7:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Oh, good lord. So perhaps you could just then give us a brief outline of these two trusts, the market cap, roughly, and we'll go on to talking about their performance. But perhaps you we just quickly summarise summarize the strategy of the two trusts, give me their relative size. sizes, and we'll get into their performance in a moment.
7:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So ABI Global Trust is the larger one of the two. Its market cap is around about a billion pounds. It invests globally as the name suggests. And what it's looking to do is to exploit inefficiencies in stock markets, to identify companies that are trading at discounts to their net asset value, and to buy into good quality assets that we think are going to grow over time, where the discount is going to narrow, and where, in many cases, a bit of shelter engagement or shelter activism may help that value to be unlocked. AVI Japan Opportunities Trust is about £400 million pounds in size. And as the name suggests, it focuses solely on the opportunities in Japan. And in this case, the opportunities really, as far as we're concerned, are primarily amongst small or mid cap companies. We're looking for companies with very inefficient balance sheets. We're looking for companies that have got substantial surplus net cash and other assets such as listed securities and real estate
8:23sitting on the balance sheet that allows us to buy into good quality operating businesses at very, very low implied earnings multiples. And at the heart of the strategy is the idea that utilizing the forces of the corporate governance code and stewardship code that were introduced into Japan over a decade ago, we can be constructive shareholder activists and work with management typically to help unlock a value that is trapped in that. their companies.
8:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay,
8:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so one other bit of kind of general context as far as the Japan Opportunities Trust is concerned. Not so long ago you gained the mandate to uh take on the assets that were previously uh managed by Fidelity, Fidelity Japan. But also more recently you've had one of your regular tender offers where some shareholders have chosen to redeem their shares in the company. Net net, what has been the impact of those two corporate uh events?
9:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
9:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): about a year ago, as you say, the assets of Fidelity rolled over into AJOP that increased the size of the trust by almost fifty percent. Recently, as you say, we have an annual redemption opportunity, which is something we put in place when we launched the trust, the opportunity for shareholders wishing to exit to be able to do so very, very close to NAV, let's that's uh a small amount for costs. And that really has helped keep the discount quite tight over the life of the trust. And so recently, as you say, we had a tender offer, about 10% of shareholders elected to redeem close to NAV.
9:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
9:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): take it together, therefore, the trust is still now bigger than it was before the Fidelity Japan.
9:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Absolutely. Uh Yeah, yeah, it was probably around 200 two hundred million, and it will go to about 360 three hundred and sixty now.
10:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Right. So you're building up some scale, but it is in a small and mid company mandate. So you don't have capacity issues as yet anyway.
10:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
10:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): we don't have capacity issues, definitely not. There is a natural capacity for strategy, but we're some way away from it.
10:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Okay. So you've recently produced some results, and of course, as luck would have it, you've been through a period with AgeRot AJOT where the performance has actually been not as good as it's been in some previous periods. So perhaps you could explain what happened. Was that anything to do with the Fidelity Japan consolidation? I would be interested to know how you actually deployed that money and whether that had an impact on the performance over the most recent period.
10:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): No, I don't think there's a direct impact. It's probably a case of Sod's law. You know, after a period of very strong performance, we were able to grow the trust, we invested the proceeds and that coincided with a period of some lackluster or underwhelming performance. But it's worth framing our strategy and how we've delivered the strong performance over the life of the trust since it was launched in 2018. So the strategy, as I said in the introduction, depends to a great extent on our shareholder activism and our engagement with management. And in many cases, we're looking for either some kind of response from management in terms of how they're managing the business. how they're managing the operations and the ongoing corporate strategy of the company. So can they do different things in order to unlock value? Or we're looking for some kind of corporate event, typically a change of control by way of a privatization or a takeover or a management buyout, which unlocks the value. And both of those outcomes take time to
11:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be
11:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): delivered. They take time in terms of the engagement process, working with management to help them understand what we think they ought to do. Or if there's going to be a takeover activity, we can't just press a button and get a bid from private equity, for example, for one of our companies. So we utilized the proceeds from Fidelity largely to boost our shareholdings in a number of our existing names. And that made us, in some cases, up to 30% shareholders, in one case, up to a 40% shareholder of a company, which puts us firmly in the driving seat. But nonetheless, it still takes time to get corporate activity over the line. And I think the last year up until the summer of 2026 was a period in which we had no corporate activity within the portfolio, so no takeover bids, typically takeover bids. come at a premium that really helps our NIV, of course, particularly so as we run a very concentrated portfolio. But since the summer, we've had two takeover activities, two takeover bids, one at a company
12:38called Share and Technology, which was our largest holding. We received the proceeds a couple of weeks ago from that, and another broad media, which sort of uh a top five portfolio company, again, at a healthy premium to the product. prevailing share price. So over the last four or five months you've seen quite a turnaround in performance. And that's just the nature of the strategy. The performance can be quite lumpy.
13:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes,
13:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I was going to make that point. I think by the nature of the strategy it must be quite lumpy. I was just wondering if you can scale up when you continue to scale up in size, these random factors of when events happen, is that going to make it uh even more volatile? do you think? Is there an argument for that? Because it takes time, as you say, for new positions to bear fruit?
13:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): When I look back over the past eight or nine years, in some cases it's taken us two or three years to achieve what we wanted to achieve, whether that be a revision of the strategy of the company that's unlocked value or whether it's been corporate activity. But on the odd occasion, we've bought into companies. and been fortunate enough to benefit from takeover bids within less than nine or twelve months. So it is very, very hard to predict. But if you think about it in the sense that if we're taking a stake and we want to be in the driving seat, then typically that's going to take a couple of years to achieve,
13:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
13:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): have any likelihood of achieving the outcome. So it could be lumpy.
14:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
14:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): also what we've also faced over the last couple of years is a shift in the market dynamics. So, like the rest of the world, a Japanese market has been dominated by high growth AI related companies to which Hard is not really exposed to. So from a relative basis, relative to the benchmark at least, we've been left behind, not only because we haven't had any corporate activity, but also because the kind the of companies we own have tended not to participate in that rally. So to the extent that we might at some point see that roll over, or perhaps indeed started to see that rollover, that ought to be best time for us on a relative basis.
14:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
14:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think that's borne out by if one looks at the numbers. Obviously the trust operates in the Japanese smaller companies segment where there's two other trusts, Nippon Active Value Fund, which also is very active actively engaged in what I like to call activist investing in Japan, looking to benefit from corporate governance changes, and then the other trust is Bailey Gifford Shin Nippon. Now, over five years the Bailey Gifford Trust has lagged yours by a very large margin, has a completely different strategy, but in the last 12 months it's outperformed you by a significant margin, though still well behind on longer averages. I guess the question to ask is really: has the strategy run in its course, looking for corporate governance activism or however you like to describe it, what you're doing? Can that persist? It has been, as you say, quite a long time since corporate governance reforms are first introduced in Japan. What are the reasons for thinking that that trend still has more to run, given the recent slowdown in performance for both of those trusts, both you and and an AVF?
15:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, it's a very interesting question. And I think the answer is that the reasons to be positive about the strategy going forward is that finally, after a decade or so of having the corporate governance code and stewardship code in place in Japan, we're beginning to see the impact of them on the psyche and the attitudes of management. So when we started a trust back in 2018, when we would approach management of companies and tell them they have to do more for shareholder returns, they have to focus on capital allocation, balance sheet efficiency, returns on equity. They knew that that was what was written in the code and that was the objective of the regulators and the government. But that was not how they had done things for decades. And if they were going to change, they were going to drag their heels in sand. And we were going to have gonna to work hard at forcing them to change. And that's what we've been plugging away at slowly but surely over the past decade, us and others, such as NABF. But today, when we approach companies and we appear on the register and we have meetings with management, their attitude is totally different. They're not resistant to change. They want to hear ideas,
16:47they want to implement some of our suggestions, they want to be transparent and open with us, and they very much have a much more open-minded attitude to what they need to do in order to generate strong shareholder returns. So it's not that it's easy to engage with companies and get the change, but the mindset is much more receptive and welcoming than it was. So to the extent that we can still find lots of companies in Japan that are substantially undervalued. that are operating good quality businesses, that are growing, that are generating free cash flow, that still have hugely strong balance sheets, no debt, surplus cash, the ability to invest in their businesses, in RD, take advantage of other opportunities, Japan is still a very, very compelling opportunity. And to the extent that that can be furthered by the responsiveness and the attitude of management. that still generates a lot of upside for us. And the same actually is being mirrored in the private equity world where there's been a lot of dry powder on the sidelines in Japan over the last few years. Some of it is being put to work now. And we see that in the increasing amount of corporate activity that we're seeing, but there's still a huge amount of appetite for opportunities in Japan from the private equity industry. And that's both a global
18:03the well-known large US, UK, European names, as well as a growing domestic presence in Japan and more broadly across Asia. And they've been plugging away at management as well, trying to encourage them. You don't need to remain public, you can be a private company, it can be good for you, it can be good for employees, and it can be good for the business. And we're seeing that come to the fore as well. And it's those two sides of the coin. really that give me a lot of confidence that the opportunity is not exhausted by any means and there's still a lot to go for. Which other market can you find where so many companies have got such strong balance sheets? And with the end of deflation in Japan and the emergence of inflation now, you're seeing strong economic growth, you're seeing corporates doing well, and valuations still quite cheap.
18:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
18:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): when you're pitching your story to potential investors, are you effectively saying we think we can deliver better returns in the Japanese market overall? Or are you marketing as saying we're doing something different? We're in smaller companies rather than the big companies, and we've got a completely different strategy. So are you selling that on diversification grounds? In other words, is it a better way to pledge a play part? Japan or is it a less risky way to play Japan?
19:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Both, I would say. Look, Japan is certainly among developed markets, the one market that is highly inefficient. Almost 80% of companies in Japan have got only one saleside research analyst covering them. Many companies have got no sell site research. There's a lack of investor interest globally and domestically. In large parts of the market, there are over 4,000. listed companies in Japan. So it's highly inefficient. When you compare that to the US, for example, you know, the number of analysts and investors that are focusing their attention on the US market means that the price discovery mechanism is working very well. That's not the case in Japan. And so what we're saying is that if you want to have an allocation in Japan, it should be active rather than passive, because the opportunities to out outperform an index in Japan are much greater than they are in other markets. We're saying that we're going to generate absolute returns as well, because these companies are undervalued in absolute terms. It's not just about beating the benchmark, it's about generating positive returns. And you see that where we've had takeover bids over the life of the trust, they've come in on average somewhere between fifty 50 and a 100%, hundred percent, sixty 60, seven. 70 percent on average, upside from where we've bought in. So we're seeing that opportunity still. And small cap is the most undervalued part. And the last three or four years, the
20:37large cap topics has outperformed the small cap. That's not the pattern that has existed over the longer term, but it's where investor attention has been focused over the last few years. And to the extent that the small cap is the cheaper opportunity set, we think. there's a good opportunity and a good argument for small cap to outperform large cap going forward.
20:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
20:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): one other factor I was going to ask you about, I'm obviously not an expert in this, but I'm interested in your understanding of this. The corporate governance revolution in Japan, if you like, it's ongoing, isn't it? I mean, there's still other initiatives by the government and by the stock exchange there to, if you like, push things in your direction of improved corporate governance. How significant are those changes? Obviously, they haven't been very helpful in the last period, but uh going forward, is that going to add a bit more momentum to the process?
21:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, look, as you say, there is momentum and there is commitment. It was framed to me when we launched the strategy by a director at the FSA in the following way. He said to me, Look, Japan has been doing things in a certain way for decades. We're now introducing a revision to that approach. We're going to do things differently. It's going to take time to change the mindset, but don't underestimate the long-term commitment to that change once it's implemented. We're now 10 years in. We've seen on a regular basis constant modifications and revisions of the codes, of the stock exchange regulations, all our are tinkering at the edges where the regulators aren't seeing. the kind of improvement or the pace of improvement that they wanted to. So they've been true to their word. And that approach and that journey continues to this day. So there's still a sense that there are too many listed companies in Japan, that there are many companies that don't deserve to be listed, and stock exchange exchanges is targeting companies that aren't doing enough to improve corporate governance, to improve liquidity. to increase the number of shareholders on the register, and just to implement all the measures that they want to see implemented. So that pressure will continue. And that will, to my mind, continue to push companies and management to do more for
22:41shareholders. And this is what this is all about. Because the problem that Japan had was that companies were not historically run in the interests of shareholders, they were run in the interests interest of other states. stakeholders. And this whole corporate governance movement has been designed to at least equate the interest of shareholders with other stakeholders. And that has happened and it's continuing to evolve.
23:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So if you're right about this favorable tailwind and your ability to improve results from companies you invest in, helped by your greater size, I guess there's a couple of questions for shareholders in the investment trust that still remain. One is about the discount. Now you've mentioned that you've got this annual redemption feature, which is pretty unusual to offer a hundred percent redemption every year, I think. And you are confident, therefore, that that is going to keep the discount within reasonable boundaries. How would you define that reasonable boundaries?
23:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, in addition to the annual redemption, the other policy that we have in place is an explicit discount control mechanism.
23:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That
23:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): kicks in at around five percent discount. So when you look back over the past year, you will have seen that we have on occasion bought back shares at that five percent discount level. And our discount has not widened beyond the five percent mark, which is pretty good for shareholders, and particularly so as they know that annually they're gonna going to have the opportunity to exit from those shares if they so wish, close to NAV. So I think it's a pretty robust and rigorous discount control mechanism. It's accompanied by a commitment by AVI to buy shares on a regular basis. We invest 25% of the management fee we receive in shares in ACOP. So we are regular buyers. And of course, we can't stop shareholders from tendering and and redeeming if they so wish. But I think it is important that shareholders know that at very least, whilst we can't control the NEB per se, we can have some influence, a great degree of influence on the discount.
24:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay,
24:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so one final question I guess I put to you before we perhaps move on and talk about your other investment trust, and that is about gearing. Now, at least according to the information sheet I'm looking at just at this moment, you don't have any gearing, net gearing in the trust. And I guess the question would therefore be if you are so confident about your ability to outperform over the future, why have you not put more gearing in?
24:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
24:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): can think of one possible reason, but uh perhaps I'll get you to give me the answer first.
25:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So I think it's just a question of timing. As I mentioned earlier on, we received a takeover bid for our largest company sharing technology a few months ago, and the proceeds were only received in the end of October, beginning of November. So what that's meant is that we received a large inflow of cash around about month end, and that's why you didn't see the gearing. A few days earlier, there would have been something like 11 or 12% gearing.
25:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Okay, and that is in terms of what we can think of as a norm?
25:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So the norm is I would say roughly mid-single mid single digits, yeah, mid to high single digits has been typically the average. gearing.
25:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Okay, so summing that up so far, this relative poor performance over the last period, which has been quite significant, but you're saying that's a matter of timing and some kind of volatility is to be expected, and therefore you're still confident about the future. That message has come across. We'll see how that plays out, obviously.
25:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
25:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): are listening to the Moneymakers podcast. To keep up with every single item of news from the investment trust sector and all the latest share price NAV and discount movements, why not try a subscription to the Moneymakers Circle, our premium content newsletter? You'll find there are in depth independent profiles of more than 200 investment trusts
26:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): and more commentary. Go to moneymakers.co Co for more details. Do please like, subscribe, and share through whatever platform you. you're using. As well as the usual podcast channels, we can also be found on YouTube, TikTok, X, Blue Sky, and most recently on Substack. Visit the website for more details.
26:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
26:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): let's switch now to talking about AVI Global, which as you say at the beginning is it's very interested in discount opportunities. But uh that too, performance has been lovely. lumpy, I think it's fair to say. What have you got to say to shareholders in that particular trust about the recent performance?
26:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, there again, it's suffered from a couple of different directions. Firstly, on a relative basis, indices as we know globally have been dominated by the whole AIC over the last couple of years. And as a value bias uh strategy, AVI Global has not participated to a great extent in the whole AI rally. And therefore it has lagged broad global indices on a relative basis. So that's one headwind. The other headwind really has come more from idiosyncratic or specific situations with a few of our companies. Like AJOP, but slightly less so, AVI ABI Global is also a very concentrated portfolio. The top 10 ten holdings. make up something like 55% of the NAV. So we've got some quite chunky holdings. And we've had a couple of laggards that have held us back and detracted quite a bit from performance over the last 12 months. So two holdings in particular have been the culprits here. One is Bivendi, the French family controlled holding company that has a stake in Universal Music Group, has been a poor performer, suffered both challenging NASA. NAV and also some discount widening. And the other one, familiar perhaps to some of your investment trust investors, is uh Chrysalis, which has also had a tough period. Both of those together detracted something like eight
28:16or nine percent from our NAV and have weighed heavily on our performance. Both, I should say, remain in the portfolio. Over the last few months, we've we've probably added a little bit to to both. We remain pretty convinced that there's substantial upside, particularly so from here. We haven't ditched them by any means. And I think what that means is rather like the case of ABI Japan, the returns could be lumpy going forward. The daily pricing can be what the daily pricing is, but ultimately when there's some kind of corporate activity or some kind of outcome that we think will materialize in the future. or in both cases, there's substantial upside from here.
28:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Okay, so you're saying that this is not a result of faulty analysis on your part into the value inherent in these two positions, but it's again a question of time in order to see that resolved. Is there something that you can do though as a significant shelter to accelerate that recovery in those two cases? Obviously, Vivendi, I imagine, is very difficult to have much influence on. that, but more likely you could do quite a lot with Chrysalis.
29:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
29:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): well you're right. In the case of Chrysalis, we are the largest shareholder and have been busy engaging with the board for a long period of time. And I think where we are actually is in quite a good place. So the board are committed to returning capital when they get proceeds.
29:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
29:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): and that is what you want when you've got a trust languishing on a very wide discount. Now the only challenge really is to sell the assets for at least the carrying values, if not more than the carrying value. And if they can do something like that, then the returns from here, as I say, are extremely, extremely high. There are essentially within in the case of Chrysalis, two core businesses left. One is Smart Penchant and the other is Scarling Bank. You know, we don't know when there's going to be any corporate activity on either of those. There has been some suggestions in the press that there could be some corporate activity in coming months at smart pension. And if the numbers that are being bandied about are realistic, then that makes criticis
30:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): even
30:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): more compelling. You know, if you think Starling Bank is worth anything like the numbers they're talking about. So both those assets need to be sold, and if if they are sold at anything like the NAB, then And there's a lot of upside. In the case of Vivendi, it's controlled by Vincent Bollaret Bolloré and his family. So we don't have the same degree of influence as we do in the case of Chrysalis. But the underlying asset is Universal Music Group that makes up something like 90% of the NAV. Universal Music Group is now trading well below the price that it came to the market at several years ago, albeit that its earnings have increased quite strongly and quite robustly, I should say, over that period. So it's it's become cheaper, it's suffered multiple compressions. compression. It's now trading a mid teens multiple for a business that's growing double digits and owns arguably the finest collection of music royalty rights in the world. So it hasn't been run fantastically well as a public company. There are lots of things that they can do. And Vincent Boderei doesn't seem to be bothered about the discount at which Wivendi Rivendi is trading
31:11at, which is almost fifty percent, to a very, very transparent and liquid NAV. So there again, I think perhaps we've underestimated his desire to see something happen and his desire to see the discount narrow over a relative short period of time. But over the long term, provided Universal can continue to grow and perform well operationally, there's no justification for companies like that trading at fifty 50% percent discounts.
31:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Okay. I mean there is another significant investment trust invested in this company as well, I think.
31:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
31:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I mean one of your strands in AGT, as I recall, is that you do like to look at situations which have significant family ownership or significant uh controlling interests, where your scope for changing their mind is by definition rather limited. And I guess Monsieur Bolloré Bollaret is one of those people, because ultimately you can't force him to change. his position unless he decides to.
32:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Absolutely right. And that is why where we are invested alongside people like Mr. Bolloré and and and other families, the most important focus of our research is not calculating the discount. It's focusing on the underlying business and trying to identify businesses that we think are going to appreciate in value over time. Because that's something that we can analyze and can have a view about. The discount is really out of our control, and it's no point fixating on the discount and trying to argue over the discount's going to go from 50 to 20 just because it should. That's not good enough. So we focus on the business. We want to find good businesses. And despite the fact that the share price performance of Universal Music Group hasn't been good, actually the operating operator performance has been good. Alongside that, we want to make sure that we're invested alongside families who aren't abusing minority shareholders. So whilst Mr. Bodrillet hasn't been in a rush to get the share price up and deliver returns for all shareholders, he hasn't been pilfering at the company, he hasn't been taking advantage of minority shareholders. He's just operating to a different timeline than we might like for the time being. So we have to bear that in mind. But absolutely right. There is an alignment of interest here, and we just have to make sure that that alignment of interest works in our favour over the long term. And it does, in fact, mean that our returns can be lumpy.
33:25In some years, the concentration of the portfolio and the high conviction that has worked in our favour. Over the last couple of years, we've been affected and hurt by a couple of poor performers within the portfolio that have drawn. dragged us down and and held us back. But as I say, you know, at any point in time you could see quite a sharp reversal in that. And given the the size of those holdings in the portfolio, they could have quite a big impact on the NAV going forward.
33:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Okay. So a couple of questions then about AGT and then one question about the world at large I'd like to ask you. As far as AGT is concerned, you have a discount. It's been pretty steady, but it's been steady around ten percent anyway, shall we say something like that, for quite a long time, in fact, for as long as I can remember. Is that a concern to you, given that you obviously have an interest in other things not trading at a discount?
34:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well
34:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
34:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): look, I'd love not to be trading on a discount. But when you're realistic about it and you look at the rest of the sector and you look at the rest of our peer group, we are not outliers in any sense. The global growth peer group within which AVI Global sits is trading on an average discount of around eight or nine percent, so more or less in line with where we are. There are a few trusts on wider discounts, there are a few trusts on narrow discounts. And the board have been fairly consistent in utilizing the buyback powers that they have. So buying back over the last few years on average, somewhere between five and seven percent shares outstanding, and that has helped keep the discount. in a relatively tight range. And I think it's also a question of finding the balance between keeping AVI global of a certain size that allows us to take substantial stakes in some of our portfolio companies and have the influence that we want to have relative to focusing on the discount and shrinking the trust, and then we wouldn't be able to have that an influence.
35:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
35:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think as I say, it's about finding the balance.
35:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay,
35:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I mean I haven't given you the opportunity to talk about the things that have done well in the portfolio. I appreciate that. So perhaps I should give you a chance to do that. I'd also perhaps just like to bracket with that. I think there are a couple of cases in which both AGT and AJOT have a common shell in Japan. So what is the justification for that as well? If you could mention that in passing after you've talked about the great successes in the other part of the pool, portfolio. Virginia.
35:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, your question overlaps, I think, in a number of ways. So the areas in within ABI Global that have done particularly well over the last 12 to 18 months have been Japan and they've been Korea, which has been very volatile, but has been quite a fruitful area for us. What's interesting about AVI Global when you compare it to other global investment trusts is that we make a big deal about being benchmark agnostic and focus. focused on fundamental attractive valuation opportunities rather than trying to mirror the benchmark. The benchmark, the world index, is made up of almost 70% being in the US. We have something like 10% in the US. We've got 30% invested in Japan, the benchmark is seven percent waiting in Japan. The benchmark has one 1% percent waiting in Korea, we have about twenty 20% percent waiting in Korea. So it's a very, very different beast to most other investment trusts. And it's those allocations that we've boosted over the last couple of years that have actually performed the best. Both Japan and Korea have done so. And in the case of Japan, you're right, we have a couple of overlapping situations. As I said, when we spoke about ABI Japan, its focus is primarily on the small cap ed. And with a billion pound trust, it's not appropriate or efficient really for it to focus too low down the cap spectrum. So it's tended to focus on
36:58more mid large cap names. And where there is opportunity for age in that space, we've got overlaps. As you say, there's two or three companies at the moment that are overlapping in both.
37:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And then finally, therefore, on the sort of global picture, obviously I guess your thinking would be that it would be very helpful if the period of American dominance was to come to an end, the dominance of global markets and the very concentrated nature of the S P five hundred in particular. Though of course also in I think Korea there's been a very significant impact from uh AI focused companies, so there is some concentration risk there as well. But in terms of the general outlook of the market against a back backcloth cloth of rising interest rates, or at least not declining interest rates anyway, as some people were expecting, at the start of the year, have you seen any evidence of investor preferences switching away from the US and away from AI towards the kind of things that you are looking at?
37:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think that when you look at the performance of global markets since summer, we've had periods of time. in which the AI trade has come unstuck and has struggled, and during those periods of time, our kind of companies and our kind of markets have tended to do better. So that gives me comfort and confidence that in a larger scale shift in the market sentiment, that yeah, our kind of companies can do well. Certainly on valuation grounds. And typically when you have markets rolling over, it's valuations that are the problem. People, investors, become aware of the fact that they're owning companies at very, very rich valuations and perhaps those aren't justified. When you look at our portfolio, leaving aside the discounts, when you look at the fundamental underlying The lying valuations on an earnings basis, we've got companies with very strong balance sheets and very low earnings. multiples, on top of which there are very wide discounts. That's pretty compelling. And yes, we have seen greater interest in those kind of companies.
38:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Right. So do you think that's what's going to happen? I know it will help you, but do you think it's what's going to happen to the extent you have to bother? How do you read the state of the financial markets at the moment?
39:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, uh putting me on the line here, I think it is going to happen, but I'm not going to tell you when it's going to happen. I think that ultimately valuation matters. And to the extent that we're now in a higher interest rate environment than we have been previously, there has to have been some kind of shift in what the appropriate valuation levels
39:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are.
39:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And at some point that's got to come to the fore of investors' minds. The question of earnings is the tricky bit because what you've seen in the US, for example, is pretty strong earnings growth, which has meant that in some respects some companies have become cheaper and cheaper. And it's not the case that the US entirely is overvalued. There are pockets of overvaluation, but at the moment there's a lot of conviction and excitement about those overvalued companies. So we haven't yet seen the rollover occur, but when it does, I think valuation will come to the fore of investors' minds.
40:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So certainly in uh one of the later innings anyway to use a baseball term, as far as We've
40:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): got to be
40:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): closer. We've got to be closer to the end, haven't we?
40:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): We have. I'm sure that uh many of our listeners will agree with that, but uh as yet hasn't happened. And then there's some signs of it indeed. So I have been talking to Joe Baunfreund, who is the lead manager of both AVI Global and AVI Japan Opportunities Trust. Talking to me. on Thursday.
40:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Thank you for listening to the Moneymakers Investment Trust Podcast, sponsored by JP Morgan Asset Management and independently produced and edited by Moneymakers. If you like what you have heard, do tell your friends and colleagues, and remember to subscribe through your favourite podcast app or at the website so you never miss an episode. And follow us on our social media channels. For more news, commentary, and other investment trust content, don't forget to look at the Moneymakers Circle, available for a modest subscription. All details are at the website money-makers.co. Podcasts are provided for educational purposes only, and nothing you have heard from any speaker should be regarded as constituting investment advice.