Money Makers

Andrew McHattie discusses AI sector volatility, investment trust discounts, and manager performance changes

54 min Listen to the original Episode page
Investment TrustsAI SectorCorporate GovernanceDividend PolicyPrivate EquityMarket Volatility

Summary

Andrew McHattie and Jonathan Davis analyze recent market movements, noting Nvidia's 8% share price drop following CEO resignation rumors and a rotation out of AI stocks into quality growth names like Relx and Unilever. McHattie highlights a turnaround in Finsbury Growth & Income's performance and discusses structural changes at BlackRock Greater Europe and BlackRock European Growth and Dividend Trust. The conversation covers crisis situations at River and Mercantile Microcap Trust and Gresham House Energy Storage, while evaluating the long-term performance of Caledonian Investments and dividend sustainability at Schroders Income Growth Trust.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Scottish Mortgage reported a 31.5% net asset value total return for the six months to September 30, significantly outperforming the FTSE All-World Index's 16% return over the same period.

    Andrew McHattie · 14:46

  2. 2
    BlackRock European Growth and Dividend Trust has committed to paying a 4.5% yield on NAV and growing it in absolute terms annually, a specific structural commitment that distinguishes it from peers relying on special dividends.

    Andrew McHattie · 33:15

  3. 3
    then over five years it is ranked 68th out of 218. Over three years it's ranked 139th out of 218.

    Andrew McHattie · 37:15

Episode sections

  1. 0:36 – 4:24

    Nvidia CEO Resignation and AI Sector Impact

    Jonathan Davis discusses the resignation of Nvidia's CEO, Jensen Huang, citing corporate governance concerns and a recent 8% share price drop. Andrew McHattie notes that while Nvidia is central to the AI trade, the market is re-evaluating the sector's costs and risks, adding volatility to AI stocks.

  2. 4:24 – 10:02

    Finsbury Growth & Income Turnaround

    Andrew McHattie highlights a significant performance turnaround for Finsbury Growth & Income, managed by Nick Train, which saw a 12.6% NAV rise in October. The trust has rotated back into favor as capital moves from AI names to quality growth and value stocks like Relx and Unilever.

  3. 10:02 – 19:34

    Linsell Train Investment Trust and Discount Dynamics

    Jonathan Davis and Andrew McHattie discuss Linsell Train Investment Trust, which acts as a leveraged bet on the Linsell Train management company. The trust has swung from a 40% premium to a 15% discount as the firm faced outflows during the quality growth underperformance period.

  4. 19:34 – 26:55

    Gresham House Energy Storage Sale Process

    Andrew McHattie reports that Gresham House Energy Storage (GRID) has initiated a formal sales process for its portfolio, contradicting previous growth plans. The trust trades at an 18.8% discount, and outcomes are uncertain, though past sales of similar assets like Harmony Energy Income suggest potential NAV-level exits.

  5. 26:55 – 31:47

    River and Mercantile Microcap Trust Restructuring

    Andrew McHattie details the crisis at River and Mercantile UK Microcap Investment Company (RMMC), which faces a 13.8% average discount and manager resignations. The board is offering a 50% exit option to investors, with the trust potentially winding down if too many shareholders choose the realization pool.

  6. 31:47 – 33:01

    BlackRock Greater Europe Underperformance

    Andrew McHattie notes that BlackRock Greater Europe is bottom of its peer group for one, three, and five-year NAV performance, returning 8.8% versus a 20.9% benchmark. The trust has recently changed lead managers and announced strategic initiatives to address the underperformance.

  7. 33:01 – 34:45

    BlackRock European Growth and Dividend Trust Restructuring

    Andrew McHattie discusses BlackRock European Growth and Dividend Trust's rebranding, commitment to a 4.5% yield with annual growth, a conditional tender offer, and strategic use of gearing. He views these moves as a reasonable response to sector trends and the trust's poor past performance.

  8. 34:45 – 36:56

    Caledonian Investments Special Dividend and Portfolio Structure

    Jonathan Davis and Andrew McHattie discuss Caledonian Investments (CLDN) paying a £100 million special dividend following the sale of Stonehage Fleming. McHattie notes the trust's persistent wide discount is due to its family control structure and heavy allocation to unquoted shares and private equity.

  9. 36:56 – 38:01

    Caledonian Investments Long-Term Performance Review

    McHattie ranks Caledonian Investments 68th out of 218 over five years and 139th out of 218 over three years across the entire investment trust sector. He describes the trust's performance as cyclical and middling, advising investors to focus on long-term trends rather than short-term fluctuations.

  10. 38:01 – 41:29

    Schroders Income Growth Trust Dividend Sustainability Concerns

    McHattie highlights that Schroders Income Growth Trust (SCF) maintained its 31st consecutive year of dividend growth by dipping into revenue reserves, resulting in a dividend coverage ratio of 0.9x. He questions the sustainability of this practice and whether the 'Dividend Hero' label creates pressure to maintain dividends at all costs.

  11. 41:29 – 44:14

    3i Group Share Buybacks and Action Group Concentration Risk

    McHattie explains that 3i's shift from premium to discount is driven by disappointing growth at its largest holding, Action Group. The trust has launched a £750 million share buyback program extending to May 2027, which McHattie views as standard housekeeping given the significant discount.

  12. 44:14 – 48:03

    Syncona Discount Narrowing and Saba Capital Stake

    Syncona's share price rose 40% despite only a 3% NAV increase, driven by a narrowing discount from over 40% to 26.6%. Factors include positive trial results for Beacon Therapeutics, a targeted capital return, and a 16.4% stake taken by Saba Capital, which McHattie believes added value.

  13. 48:03 – 51:25

    RTW Capital Biotech Strategy and Discount Compression

    McHattie praises RTW Capital (RTW) for its full lifecycle investment approach and recent discount compression from 20-25% to 8%. He notes the trust is formalizing buybacks using a liquidity pool funded by realized gains and holds a 10% stake from Saba Capital, though he considers it a high-risk asset.

  14. 51:25 – 54:15

    Market Outlook and AI Sell-Off Analysis

    McHattie expresses optimism about underlying fundamentals and earnings growth, describing the recent AI sell-off as surprisingly controlled rather than a crash. He acknowledges risks from potential interest rate increases and political events but anticipates a traditional year-end market rally.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
NVIDIANVDAequityneutralshares in NVIDIA which of course had a most spectacular run, are down this week, last few days, by around 8% as we're recording this.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

Jensen Huang resigned as CEO of Nvidia after disclosure about romantic entanglements with employees and a lady suspected by US authorities to be a Chinese spy.

Jonathan Davis ·0:36

How to verify: Nvidia press releases and SEC filings (Form 8-K) regarding executive changes and any related legal disclosures or news reports from US authorities. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Nvidia shares were down around 8% as of the recording date.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·1:13

How to verify: Nvidia (NVDA) stock price history on financial data providers (e.g., Bloomberg, Yahoo Finance) for the week of November 13, 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Finsbury Growth & Income NAV was up 12.6% in October compared to 1.1% for the FTSE All-Share.

Andrew McHattie ·5:47

How to verify: Finsbury Growth & Income monthly fact sheets or NAV announcements for October 2026; FTSE All-Share index performance data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Finsbury Growth & Income's October performance was its best since 2009.

Andrew McHattie ·6:06

How to verify: Finsbury Growth & Income historical performance data and NAV records. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Linsell Train Investment Trust was on a 40% premium rating for years before dropping to a 15% discount.

Andrew McHattie ·11:03

How to verify: Linsell Train Investment Trust historical discount/premium data and NAV announcements. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Scottish Mortgage net asset value total return was 31.5% for the six months to September 30, versus 16% for the FTSE All-World Index.

Andrew McHattie ·14:46

How to verify: Scottish Mortgage half-year results announcement for the period ending September 30, 2026; FTSE All-World Index performance data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Scottish Mortgage's 10-year annualized net asset value return is 19%.

Andrew McHattie ·16:25

How to verify: Scottish Mortgage long-term performance data and annual reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Gresham House Energy Storage discount is 18.8% as of the recording.

Andrew McHattie ·20:23

How to verify: Gresham House Energy Storage share price and NAV announcements for November 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Harmony Energy Income Trust was sold to Foresight Group in mid-2025 at NAV.

Andrew McHattie ·21:22

How to verify: Foresight Group and Harmony Energy Income press releases or regulatory filings regarding the sale transaction in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

River and Mercantile UK Microcap Investment Company had an average discount of 13.8% over the last year.

Andrew McHattie ·28:35

How to verify: RMMC historical discount data and NAV announcements for the 12 months prior to November 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The trust is now called BlackRock European Growth and Dividend Trust and is pushing the dividend up the agenda.

Andrew McHattie ·33:01

How to verify: Check the trust's official website or latest annual report for the name change and dividend policy statement. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The trust will pay out 4.5% of NAV regularly with a commitment to grow it every year in absolute terms.

Andrew McHattie ·33:15

How to verify: Verify the dividend yield calculation against the latest NAV in the trust's interim or annual report and check the board's stated dividend policy. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

The trust has a five-year performance conditional tender offer for up to 25% of shares at a 2% discount.

Andrew McHattie ·33:35

How to verify: Review the trust's announcement regarding the conditional tender offer for specific terms, performance hurdles, and discount levels. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Caledonian Investments paid a special dividend of £100 million, which is 20 pence per share.

Andrew McHattie ·35:11

How to verify: Check Caledonian Investments' dividend announcement or share price data to confirm the per-share amount and total payout. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Caledonian Investments sold Stonehage Fleming for £290 million, completing in June.

Andrew McHattie ·35:31

How to verify: Search for press releases or regulatory filings from Caledonian Investments confirming the sale of Stonehage Fleming and the transaction value. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Caledonian Investments is ranked 68th out of 218 over five years and 139th out of 218 over three years across the entire investment trust sector.

Andrew McHattie ·37:15

How to verify: Access the Association of Investment Companies (AIC) performance tables or data provider like Morningstar to verify the rankings for the specified periods. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Schroders Income Growth Trust's NAV total return was 19%, underperforming the FTSE All Share's 21.3%.

Andrew McHattie ·38:27

How to verify: Check Schroders Income Growth Trust's annual results for the period ending 31 August and FTSE All Share performance data for the same period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Schroders Income Growth Trust paid a dividend of 15.3 pence against earnings of 13.6 pence, resulting in 0.9x coverage.

Andrew McHattie ·39:07

How to verify: Review the trust's revenue account in its annual report to confirm earnings per share and dividend per share figures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

3i Group's NAV was £31.54 for the quarter ending 30 September.

Andrew McHattie ·42:11

How to verify: Check 3i Group's interim or annual results for the period ending 30 September to verify the NAV per share. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

3i Group acquired a larger holding in Action Group, which accounts for three-quarters of the portfolio.

Andrew McHattie ·42:31

How to verify: Review 3i Group's portfolio disclosure in its latest results to confirm the percentage allocation to Action Group and any recent transactions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify Nvidia's corporate governance structure and UK listing rule compliance via the company's latest annual report and corporate governance statement.
  • Check Finsbury Growth & Income's October NAV figures and portfolio holdings in the latest monthly fact sheet to confirm the rotation into Relx and Unilever.
  • Review Linsell Train Investment Trust's premium/discount history and leverage mechanics in the latest annual report to assess the sustainability of the 15% discount.
  • Examine Gresham House Energy Storage's sales process updates and NAV impact in recent board reports to evaluate the uncertainty of the portfolio exit.
  • Analyze Schroders Income Growth Trust's dividend coverage ratio and revenue reserve usage in the latest interim or annual report to assess dividend sustainability.
  • Check 3i Group's share buyback program terms and Action Group's latest financial results to evaluate the impact of the £750 million buyback on the discount.
  • Review Syncona's discount narrowing drivers, including Saba Capital's stake details and Beacon Therapeutics trial results, via recent press releases and NAV updates.
  • Verify RTW Capital's buyback funding source and Saba Capital stake details in the latest quarterly report to assess the risk profile of the discount compression.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Jonathan Davis: Welcome to the award-winning Moneymakers Podcast. I'm Jonathan Davis, the founder and host. For more than six years now, we've been providing comment and discussion about all the latest developments in the world of investment trusts, the stock market listed funds often called the City of London's best kept secret.
0:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
0:18
Jonathan Davis: grateful to JP Morgan Asset Management for their continued no-string String support, which enables us to keep the podcast free while preserving our truly important independent editors. editorial principles. Please note that while our comments are well researched and our opinions honestly held, we do not offer individual stock recommendations.
0:36
Jonathan Davis: So it's been another dramatic week in the investment markets, not least with all the hullabaloo, I think you can call it that, if not worse, about the resignation of Jensen Tuang, Twang, the longstanding CEO of Nvidia, who has who's been forced to resign after disclosure about his romantic entanglements with others, including
0:56
Jonathan Davis: employees and a lady who's suspected by the US authorities at least to be a Chinese spy. That's not been confirmed, of course. However, he's had to go, and he is right at the epicentre of the AI revolution, as many observers have pointed out.
1:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And the
1:13
Jonathan Davis: shares in NVIDIA which of course had a most spectacular run, are down this week, last few days, by around 8% as we're recording this. But others of the Mag 7 and other AI stocks have actually weathered this particular storm pretty well. So I don't know whether I should ask you about that, Andrew, but I mean in terms of
1:33
Jonathan Davis: its wider significance, it may have some bearing on the evolution of what we call the AI trade. Do you have any particular thoughts on that? I dare say you're not an investor in NVIDIA, but you may be invested in an investment trust or two which does have some shares in that company.
1:50
Andrew McHattie: I think so many of us are indirect investors in Nvidia, aren't we? So it does matter and it's worth thinking about. And I must say, I don't think I know very much about the succession plan and what's going to happen. and how that might affect the way in which NVIDIA develops. But of course, it's an important player, and I I'm pretty
2:10
Andrew McHattie: confident actually that there are very seasoned and competent executives that will step in there and it will continue. But it does, I think, just add a bit of fuel to the fire because clearly people have been thinking very carefully about AI and how much it's going to contribute. and how much it's costing. And maybe just when
2:30
Andrew McHattie: stocks were recovering after their sell-off, this has knocked them again.
2:34
Jonathan Davis: Indeed. And of course, one of the issues I think has been given a lot of airing, and quite rightly so, which has an indirect bearing on investment trust as well, which is the importance and in the case of Nvidia, the absence of sound corporate governance practices. You have a CEO who's basically all powerful, he is the founder, been there for more than thirty. years, very dominant personality, very
2:54
Jonathan Davis: flat organization, no chairman or chairwoman for the company, which is slightly remarkable. You wouldn't be allowed to get away with that over here, under our rules. And of course a general feeling that a lot of these tech titans, if you like, companies which have had spectacular success and growing to very, very large companies, are still dominated by their founders, which is not something that tends
3:14
Jonathan Davis: to happen. The very largest companies, the ones that are top of the market regime, by their nature, often are managed by career corporate people rather than by the founder entrepreneurs. However, that's all to play out. In terms of the impact on the sector, almost every global investment trust will have a stake in NVIDIA bas
3:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): because
3:33
Jonathan Davis: of its size. And the specialist technology trusts trust will also be directly involved in there. And so there'll they'll be watching this with, I think, a lot of interest. But I suspect, as you pointed out, people will be put in place to manage it from here, and we'll see whether that does have a wider impact or not. And in particular, on the whether or not, I think a very live issue, whether or not Nvidia continues
3:53
Jonathan Davis: to invest huge amounts of money in many of its customers, which many people feel is a higher risk strategy. That's all to play for. We're going to stick to talking about investment trust this week, and it's been a generally pretty good week for the investment trust sector, notwithstanding all these dramas going on. The investment
4:13
Jonathan Davis: trust index, I think, is up this week quite nicely, and the discount has come back in, had gone out to around 12% back into about just over 11% eleven percent on average across the sector.
4:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
4:24
Jonathan Davis: let's dive in and just talk about some of the companies. that we've been in the news and we're going to start with Finsbury Growth and Income, managed by Nick Train of Lindsayl Train. He's been the manager for many years, and he's been going through a very tough period of performance until the last few weeks when he's suddenly come back into favour. So what do you make of all that, Andrew? And what's the
4:44
Jonathan Davis: news coming out of that particular trust?
4:47
Andrew McHattie: It's been a remarkable turnaround, because you're right, Nick Train of course is a very high-profile investment manager, very well known, well regarded, I would say. And he, of course, has a quality growth strategy that he has been following for years with great success. But that has really fallen out of
5:07
Andrew McHattie: favour over recent times. And that has led to Finsbury growth and income being at the very bottom of its peer growth. group performance table over the last one and three years, really by quite some margin. And of course, this has led to quite a lot of discussion as to whether Nick Trent should stick to
5:27
Andrew McHattie: his guns and maintain the strategy, or whether, in this new world of AI-led technological change, he's out of date. And that's a great question for us all. But he has stuck to his guns, and now because we're seeing a lot of rotation out of those AI names into others,
5:47
Andrew McHattie: his portfolio has benefited enormously. So we've seen a real shift, and in October, the trust's NAV was up 12.6% Point six percent compared to just 1.1% one point one percent from the FTSE All Share. That was actually its best performance since 2009. So there's been a
6:06
Andrew McHattie: big turnaround here.
6:08
Jonathan Davis: It was impressive, you have to say, that the recent continuation vote they had at Finsbury Growth and Income, he got a massive majority voting for continuation. So his message, which has been stick with me for the long term, we've done very well exceptionally in over the past until the last few years. Stick with me and eventually your time. will come again. That's been
6:28
Jonathan Davis: his consistent message, and he's owned up to having poor performance, but he's never going to change his style, he says. It is true that I think at the board's prompting he has made some changes to the portfolio, hasn't he? It's become an even more concentrated now than it was before. So he's doubled down on his bets. I think I'm right about that, am I not?
6:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
6:46
Andrew McHattie: the last thing I would want him to do is to change his strategy and and to abandon it because of course if you're buying his trust, you know what style you're buying. And his argument is that there's such deep value in so many of these great quality stocks, and of course the value has just been getting better as they've underperformed. So it makes complete
7:06
Andrew McHattie: sense to double down. And what has happened is that money has flowed back into a lot of those software platform companies that. were seen as potential companies that were going to suffer as AI grew and grew. So companies like Relx, Experian, Right Move, Sage, London Stock Exchange,
7:26
Andrew McHattie: they've all bounced up very strongly. And now, of course, investors are also coming back to some of the stodgy, Dodgy, boring traditional stocks such as Unilever and Diagio, which they haven't. wanted to own during this big pickup in growth. But it'll be interesting to see just how
7:45
Andrew McHattie: extended this rarely is in Finsbury growth and income because I think it does hinge quite a lot on whether this rotation trade is here to stay.
7:54
Jonathan Davis: Indeed. And it's fair to say that notwithstanding Understanding this significant recovery that we've seen since uh early this year in the share price performance. I mean the shares are still below where they were five years ago. So there's been a bit of income, but not much. It's not really a yield stock. So it has been a long haul. You really have had to be patient. Something
8:14
Jonathan Davis: very similar has obviously happened with people like Terry Smith, who have a very similar sort of strategy, different names in the portfolio, different regional mix, but he's also had five years of poor performance, and a lot of people have pulled out of that particular fund.
8:27
Jonathan Davis: And similarly with Finchberg Orthan income, I mean the board has been very active in buying back shares. I think it's fair to say. They're doing the sort of classic thing that boards are meant to do. I was looking at the numbers just a few minutes ago and I think the share count has come down significantly over the last five years. Looking at end of twenty 2021 twenty one there was about two 225 hundred and twenty five
8:47
Jonathan Davis: million shares out there and now there's well it's less than a 130, hundred and thirty. it's down by almost a half. So they have bought back, the size of the company has shrunk significantly, the managers' fees have come down as a result, pro rata, and so on. But as we say, we don't know whether this trend, this reversal in fortunes is going to continue. What about the discount on this trust, as to say? There have been very positive buybacks.
9:07
Jonathan Davis: What's the story there? Has there been significant movement in the discount?
9:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
9:11
Andrew McHattie: it has fluctuated, but it's currently I think at six and a half percent. which is not really giving me too much of a message either way. It's neither cheap nor expensive. Probably it's about right. So I don't think it's really a discount play, this one. I think it's very tempting, isn't it, during these times of turbulence to really look out for what's happening with
9:31
Andrew McHattie: discounts and to try and pick up some And bargains. But I don't think that's the approach here. I think you have to make a more fundamental decision about where you want your portfolio to be. And this is going to make a fascinating case study in a few years when we can look back and see whether this was the right moment to switch or not. But of course, for many people they want to maintain a
9:51
Andrew McHattie: balanced portfolio. So perhaps the real answer is that you have something with a value perspective. It may be this trust, it may be another one, to balance out some of your growth trusts.
10:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Of
10:03
Jonathan Davis: course, there's another investment trust which has a relationship with Linseltrain, the fund management group for which Nick Train works, which is the manager of Finsby Growth and Income. And that trust is, of
10:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): course,
10:12
Jonathan Davis: Linseltrain Investment Trust, which was originally started when Linseltrain first set up, and they were either forced or chose to give some shares in the management company, which is slightly unusual to this particular trust. And that's been an even worse performer than Finsby. growth and income over the last few years, because effectively it's a geared play on the fortunes of
10:31
Jonathan Davis: Linsel Train as a fund management company. So, I mean, if this is the start of a rotation back into the kind of funds that Linsell Train manages, do you think that's going to have a positive impact on Linseltrain, the investment trust?
10:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
10:44
Andrew McHattie: I think if you follow the argument through, then the answer is yes, it should. And you're right, it's providing you with effectively geared experience. exposure. And what happened here is really interesting that this trust was on a an unusually large premium rating for years, and the board kept warning investors that this might not be
11:03
Andrew McHattie: sustainable, and yet people were still buying this trust on a 40% premium rating because they felt that big stake in the management company was in fact. undervalued within the portfolio as it stood. But of course, what happened was that when markets reversed and this quality growth
11:23
Andrew McHattie: style went out of favor, it meant that Linzel Train started losing funds. They had outflows as a business, and this was bad news for the managers. So we saw that premium completely evaporate on Linzel Linsel Train Investment Trust, and it's now. down at a 15% discount. I could see that
11:43
Andrew McHattie: returning to par. I don't know whether it's going to ever to get back to a big premium rating because I think you know many investors were were bitten by that. So uh once bitten, twice shy, I think.
11:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
11:54
Jonathan Davis: so they have a complicated formula for valuing the stake in Linsel Train, the management company. And without going into all the boring details, but I think the fact that Pontius Pontiels is. are so much higher than they were is going to have a a negative impact on that in terms of compared to where it would be otherwise, and indeed it was when interest rates were very, very low, because it was essentially priced off a bond rather than other things.
12:14
Jonathan Davis: But anyway, something to watch anyway for the future. As you say, potentially a turning point, but uh we'll wait and see about that with interesting ramifications.
12:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Can
12:24
Jonathan Davis: I ask you other are there other trusts that follow a simple similar quality growth style strategy that might be worth mentioning in this context?
12:32
Andrew McHattie: Yes, there have been a number of other trusts that I think investors have been driven towards actually when they've been looking to rotate and they found other things they would quite like to invest in. One of those, I think, is Temple Bar, which of course is well known as having a deep value approach and that has a very strong track record actually throughout the market. cycle under the
12:51
Andrew McHattie: current managers. So that's certainly one I think people have been looking at, although it's on a premium rating, so there's no bargain to be had there. And I think more generally there's some money flowing into the UK equity income sector where there are trusts that are sort of dull but worthy I would say, where you feel that you're buying into quite
13:11
Andrew McHattie: a lot of old economy sectors, including utilities and healthcare and things that are really far remote actually from the AI revolution. And so actually trusts such as STS Income and Growth have seen a bit of a bounce. And I can see maybe this is a time where investors are going to be a bit more attracted by
13:31
Andrew McHattie: things that are not in the news and not leading the way.
13:35
Jonathan Davis: Yes, the other one that immediately comes to mind is midwind, which is interesting, trust, which three years ago changed its manager and appointed Lazars to manage the trust precisely because they have this sort of quality growth strategy. So it was a contrarian call at the time, but it's taken rather longer, perhaps, than they would have hoped for it to show signs of coming back into favour. That has performed better than Finchbury Growth and
13:55
Jonathan Davis: Income, to be fair, but it's basically been flat over the last four years. So that's another one that has a similar strategy, and there's then some uh some of the small smaller company trusts have a similar kind of quality growth approach. So that's something to look out for. Keep tabs on anyway. Let's move on and talk about another trust which is obviously very significant for the investment trust sector, and that
14:15
Jonathan Davis: is our old friend Scottish Mortgage, Ticket SMT, probably more widely owned than any other trust in the whole universe. They put out some results recently. What's the story from there?
14:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We will
14:26
Andrew McHattie: definitely want to. discuss Scottish Mortgage. As you say, a very popular trust. It is one of the large shareholders in Nvidia, as we would expect. And naturally the trust is having a little bit of a bumpy ride this month. But its half year results for the six months to 30th of September were excellent. The net NES
14:46
Andrew McHattie: asset value total return was 31.5%, which is good I think, under any measure, very good in absolute terms, but it absolutely trounced the FTSE All-World Index, which was up 16% over the same period. So virtually double the return. And a lot of the good
15:05
Andrew McHattie: gains came from SpaceX, but also Moderna Anthropic, Taiwan Semiconductor, and a company called Zipline. And I one thing I think was notable there is that quite a lot of the gains came from the private assets. And I remember just a couple of years ago, Scottish
15:25
Andrew McHattie: Mortgage being roundly criticized for having so much of its money in unquoted companies, which was seen as a drag on the returns. They were seen as introducing a lot of risk. But now I think Scottish Mortgage. is really reaping some of the returns there. Now, of course, the tech sell-off over the last couple of weeks has
15:45
Andrew McHattie: stung, and the net assets are down about 10% over the last month. But again, here with Scottish Mortgage, you really don't want it to change. It is the growth flag bearer, I think, and you know what you're getting when you buy this trust. And in spite of all of the ups. and downs we've had, and it has been a really bumpy
16:05
Andrew McHattie: ride for tech actually in the last couple of years, especially, the last 10 years have been so good with this trust. And I think the annualized net asset value return over 10 years for Scottish mortgage is 19%, which is a really superb figure. Putting this trust up there with the very best. I think it's in the
16:25
Andrew McHattie: top five performers. across the entire investment trust industry over that time. So if you're a long-term investor, it's been a great place to have your money.
16:34
Jonathan Davis: It certainly has. And indeed, over the last three years, it's been a spectacular place to have your money. It's done extraordinary well. Came back from that torrid period when it had corporate governance issues and uh many other things to wrestle with, including uh this scepticism about his strategy. So the next big item perhaps on Scottish Modern. Mortgage's agenda is the IPO of Anthropic. You
16:54
Jonathan Davis: mentioned they are now a shareholder in that particular AI model builder. And what are your thoughts about that? We know presumably what it's been valued at more recently, but the IPO, if we believe the media, is going to happen very soon, and it's been scaled down in terms of the valuation that the market's going to put on it, and this week's events probably won't help in that regard either. But
17:14
Jonathan Davis: it's still going to be a mammoth IPO, and Scottish Mortgage has a significant stake, which it only acquired relatively recently, I think.
17:22
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
17:22
Andrew McHattie: it did, and I thought this showed actually the great power that Bailey Gifford have in gaining access to these companies. They weren't coming in at the very, very early stages. They were acquiring this quite late on when there was a lot of demand for it, and many people I think would have liked to have got their hands on. a stake at that point. But Bailey Gifford do have that
17:42
Andrew McHattie: access, and I think that's been a significant advantage across their range of investment trust. But in this case, I think perhaps we need to bear in mind the old adage that it may be better to travel than to arrive. And very often, I think, with these huge IPOs, we find that the aftermarket isn't
18:02
Andrew McHattie: quite as good as anticipated. That a bit of realism creeps in, doesn't it, once all the marketing hype has subsided. So I think we'll see an uplift when Anthropic has its IPO. But of course, trusts tend to have lock-in periods, so they can't sell straight away. And my feeling is we'll have to wait and see how Anthropic performs
18:22
Andrew McHattie: over the first six months or so of its life on the public markets. But quite often. that's a disappointing period after a lot of excitement.
18:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
18:30
Jonathan Davis: of course, if you are a long-term investor, then the strategy becomes, well, do I want to hold this for longer when it's got over this post-IPO dip, which as you say we often see for I think what are well understood reasons. SpaceX would be an example, I think, where the share price has disappointed since IPO. Lots of issues around that. But if you are a company with a strategy like Scottish Mortgage, then you would be
18:50
Jonathan Davis: thinking that if they really think this company has got a good future, and there's obviously lots of doubts swirling around about what that future might look like, they will probably opt to stay with it. But we'll have to wait and see on that one as well. They have reduced their holding in SpaceX a little, I think, haven't they, since the IPO, but they are subject to lockups that prevent them selling all their shares in one go. Which is the other
19:10
Jonathan Davis: flip side of the coin of getting early access, you often are then constrained in how quickly you can unlock
19:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
19:14
Jonathan Davis: unload the shares if you really want to do that. So Scottish Mortgage doing well despite this little recent blip. Let's next talk about another trust which I know is very dear to your heart in particular because we've talked an awful lot about it. That is Gresham House Energy Storage, ticker G R I D or Grid. There's been a significant
19:34
Jonathan Davis: announcement recently about the future of this particular trust, and I think it took some of us by surprise. But perhaps you could explain what the decision has been, and then tell us how you react to it.
19:45
Andrew McHattie: It was a surprise. This announcement came on the 2nd of November and really completely contradicted what had gone before. So the big news was that Gresham House Energy Storage Grid is to undergo a formal sales process to effectively sell its portfolio.
20:03
Andrew McHattie: And this came after further feedback from shareholders, which was obviously quite robust because prior to that the trust had said it was not going to put itself up for sale and it was following a growth plan. But it's now inviting offers for its portfolio, and it's going to be really interesting to see how that turned out. Because
20:23
Andrew McHattie: there is some value here. There was a bit of a pick. pickup in the share price once this news was released, but the discount remaining is still 18.8%. So if a full value is achieved, there's more profit to come, or more recovery to come, let's say. Because it's been a
20:43
Andrew McHattie: bumpy ride. And I do feel that many of the initial hopes for this entire battery storage sector. were not met. And now some investors are losing patience, which is probably what we're seeing here. And we'll have to gauge what the secondary market is going to think about this asset
21:03
Andrew McHattie: value. And the only marker we have really is Harmony Energy Income Trust, which was sold to Foresight Group in mid-2025, and that was sold at NAV, more or less. It was a really good outcome at the time. And my feeling here is that the market has probably
21:22
Andrew McHattie: moved on since that time and that it would be unlikely that this trust would be able to achieve such a good outcome. I've heard other voices say different things. So JP Morgan Casanov, for example, said there was a lot of upside embedded in the pipeline portfolio here. So they felt that a
21:42
Andrew McHattie: price close to NAV would be achievable. So it's going to be great to see how this plays out. And potentially there is some read across to the other remaining battery storage trust, Gore Street, although that one I think is quite different because it has big international exposure and it's following quite a different
22:02
Andrew McHattie: strategy. But that one's on a 32% discount. So eventually, after a couple of months, whenever it is, if we do see Gresham House energy storage go for a good price, that ought to have some kind of read-across.
22:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There
22:14
Andrew McHattie: are a lot of unknowns still here, I think, Jonathan. We really don't know what the outcome will be, whether any decent offers will be received at all. It may not happen. But the one thing we do know is that this battery sector has. really been very successful in generating huge amounts of news, if not the power and profits we originally hoped
22:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for.
22:35
Jonathan Davis: That's a very good way of putting it, yes. I mean, the history of this one is it was launched in 2018 and it did very well for the first four, four and a half years, and then everything went pear pear-shaped shaped when it turned out that the interest rates turned and people started to look more closely at what the grid was capable of. doing in terms of connecting batteries and so on. And then the management and the board came up with
22:55
Jonathan Davis: a kind of recovery strategy after the shares had really fallen off a cliff. And for the last couple of years they've performed very strongly. So if you picked them up a couple of years ago, you would have done exceptionally well. But as you say, this this conundrum or two conundrums I would see. One is the discount is still at 18%. So the market it's strongly suggesting either that there won't be a significant sale or that the
23:15
Jonathan Davis: price that is achieved won't be that significant, or I guess another flavour of that would be it would take a long time to get it all sorted out, which will eat into the potential returns. Or it may be that there are some shelves out there who, as you say, just lost patience, and they may maybe be trying to sell at the wrong time. But the board's clearly doing all the right things, I think I would say. I mean they are talking to
23:35
Jonathan Davis: shelters, Shelders, and if they got the message wrong before, which is what this sort of announcement rather suggests, I don't think it's for lack of effort. It may be more because the Shelders they're talking to have changed their mind. So a very interesting conundrum. I know you're a Shelder, so what are your thinking? You're just going to sit there and see what happens, presumably.
23:53
Andrew McHattie: I think that's right. I think it's best to see how this plays out, because I don't see very much downside to come. There was a bit of a pickup on this news, nude, but not a huge one. Whereas I feel there is potential for a very good outcome here, and you may find actually that you're able to get out at close to NAV. Of course,
24:13
Andrew McHattie: if there is no good bid forthcoming for the entire portfolio, it is possible that once other potential buyers have run the ruler over the portfolio, they may bid for certain parts of it anyway. So you may find there's all sorts of other possibilities here, including a partial exit. So my feeling is
24:33
Andrew McHattie: it's probably not the time to sell out.
24:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
24:36
Jonathan Davis: wonder also, I mean, many of people who bought these renewable energy trusts did so because they wanted the yield, right? And of course, one of one of the things that happened during the crisis for this particular trust is that they stopped stop the dividend at least for a while and tried try to sit down and work out what was the right balance stream. investing in more capacity or paying a dividend. So maybe it's just that the clientele, if you like,
24:56
Jonathan Davis: are no longer quite so interested now that the strategy is a mixture of mainly capital growth and a bit of dividend if you're lucky.
25:02
Andrew McHattie: Yes, this whole sector's been a great case study actually in what happens when interest rates rise, and that completely shifts the investment strategy that these trusts have been really created to follow. And you're right, it's easy. to forget that these were all income vehicles. And that's why people invested. And of course, that has changed. And so perhaps
25:22
Andrew McHattie: investors are feeling it's not what they signed up for, which again comes back to what we were saying before about investment strategies changing and whether fund managers should stick to their knitting and maintain their strategies in a completely consistent manner. And that hasn't been possible here because the market's market shifted. and the interest rate environment has shifted. So I
25:42
Andrew McHattie: think it just feels very uncomfortable on these shifting sands, and you're right, maybe investors are just feeling that it's not what they initially wanted.
25:53
Jonathan Davis: You are listening to the Moneymakers podcast. To keep up with every single item of news from the investment trust sector and all the latest share price NAV and discount movements, one why not try a subscription to the Moneymakers Circle, our premium content newsletter? You'll find there are in-depth independent profiles of more than 200 investment trusts and more commentary. Go to
26:13
Jonathan Davis: moneymakers.co for more details. Do please like, subscribe, and share through whatever platform you're using. As well as the usual podcast channels, we can also be found on YouTube, TikTok, X, Blue Sky, and most recently on Substack. Visit the website for more details.
26:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
26:35
Jonathan Davis: let's move on then and talk about another investment trust. This one is much smaller. Gresham House Energy Storage has a market cap of around 625, 630 million, something like that. Let's talk to something which is a lot, lot smaller, but deliberately so, interestingly, but it's also been on I think what we know. now call euphemistically a journey. It's been on a journey, and that is River and
26:55
Jonathan Davis: Mercantile UK Microcap Investment Company Limited, Ticker R M M C which has had a very volatile history, perhaps by the nature of what it does, but it also has been in the news for corporate reasons as well. So let's just first of all describe what this trust does, and then uh tell us what the latest twist in this saga is.
27:15
Andrew McHattie: So UK microcaps is the market here. So very small companies that are listed in London. And there are not many investment trusts that invest in these. And one problem that they have, of course, is liquidity. So you can't have a huge investment trust trying to buy decent-sized stakes in
27:35
Andrew McHattie: tiny companies because that doesn't work. And for that reason, this investment trust, RMMC, had a particular structure which I always really liked. I thought it was very clever and very suitable for what it did, which was effectively it said that when it had been through a period
27:55
Andrew McHattie: of success and had grown its assets, it would then give you some money back and reduce it back down to a more suitable. size. And I thought that was very sensible because it was giving you money back at the right moment in the market cycle when it had just done well, rather than the opposite, which is more commonly when
28:15
Andrew McHattie: you're getting money back. But things have changed here, and I think there's a perfect storm, unfortunately, around this trust, because in the nature of investing in microcash. microcaps, it's going to trade on a discount rating because they are illiquid, you can't necessarily get out at the market price. And of course, the
28:35
Andrew McHattie: market is much less forgiving of any kind of sizable discount now. So this trust has had an average discount over the last year of thirteen point eight percent, which is just I think considered too wide to be sustainable. And that has attracted Sabah Capital, who's taken a 13.7%
28:54
Andrew McHattie: stake in the trust. Again, that leads us towards some prospects of change. The manager resigned in July, a very well regarded manager, George Ensor, and his co manager, they resigned in July to move to Jupiter. So there's been a lot going on here, and they partly moved.
29:14
Andrew McHattie: I think, because Lion Trust took over the managers River Global. And I think all of those factors taken together means that there's too much uncertainty here, and the board has now decided that they need to act. And so they're offering a 50% exit for investors. Now it's
29:34
Andrew McHattie: up to 50% actually. They're going to create a separate realization process. pool and a continuation pool. And the realization pool they say will take between six and twelve months to realize those assets and give some money back. And then there's one other factor, which is that if too many people opt for the
29:54
Andrew McHattie: realization pool and the remaining assets would be less than 42.5 million pounds, that would be too small for the trust to continue. and they will then propose a window. So that's quite a lot to take in. And to me, Jonathan, it sounds a little bit like the death knell is being rung here.
30:14
Andrew McHattie: And I do feel that this trust may be one now leaving the sector.
30:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes,
30:20
Jonathan Davis: it will all It'll depend, as you say, on the response to this vote, I guess, because our the current market cap is 85 million, and as you've you say, if more than 50% want to take the money effectively, then it will go into wind down. Well, that seems reasonable. Of course we don't know what the negotiations with Saba, for example, among other shelters, has been, and whether they would be happy with taking the
30:40
Jonathan Davis: realization option or not. We don't know what their intentions are towards it, I think, at least I don't know what they are. And the shares are still trading on a discount around 9%, so the market maybe hasn't made up its mind. either about what it thinks is going to happen here.
30:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
30:53
Jonathan Davis: guess it's been a disappointment for Lion Trust, who are trying to get back into the invested trust world and a second trust there and have failed to do so with this particular one so far at least. I mean they have parachuted in a couple of managers for this trust who have a pretty good record at Lion Trust, but it's not entirely the same strategy. So there are question marks there.
31:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
31:14
Jonathan Davis: again, if you were a shelter here, looking at a 9% discount, well I guess people will decide what they want to do. It's a very niche strategy anyway, it's the kind of thing you have in the fringes of your portfolio just to round it out with a bit of excitement.
31:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
31:26
Jonathan Davis: anyway, I think I'd be sorry to see it go. We lost uh microcap trusts, but I can't say that the end of the world will happen if it does disappear. Let's move on then and talk about BlackRock Greater Europe investment trust. This is a trust which does what it says on the tin, invest right across the continent of Europe. The market cap around 500 million,
31:47
Jonathan Davis: managed by BlackRock, obviously, as the name suggests. Now, what's the news from this trust?
31:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
31:52
Andrew McHattie: we've been discussing the quality growth approach, and this is another quality growth trust. And unfortunately, that strategy means it's not performed as well as many would. have hoped. It is bottom of its peer group by NAV performance over one, three, and five years. And the annual
32:12
Andrew McHattie: results it has just announced to the 31st of August showed that in spades, I think, the return from the trust was 8.8%
32:21
Andrew McHattie: against 20.9% from the benchmark. So really quite a poor performance. And it has changed its lead manager, that was at the end of March, to Benjamin Moore, who took over the reins. And since then, the trust says that the performance has picked up. But nevertheless, we're in this
32:41
Andrew McHattie: new era now, aren't we, Jonathan, where underperformance really cannot go unchecked and boards need to react. So what's happened here is that. BlackRock are moving to try to remedy the situation, and a package of strategic initiatives has been announced. So, we're getting another change
33:01
Andrew McHattie: of name. This is now going to be called BlackRock European Growth and Dividend Trust. Most importantly is that word dividend being included there because the trust is really pushing the dividend up the agenda.
33:15
Andrew McHattie: and it's taking on an enhanced dividend. It's going to pay out four and a half percent of NAV on a regular basis, coupled interestingly, with a commitment to grow it every year in absolute terms, which is quite an interesting commitment. I'm not sure how that's going to work really. But the trust did need to do something,
33:35
Andrew McHattie: I think. It's going to have a five-year performance conditional. tender offer as well for up to 25% of the shares at a 2% discount. And it has said it wants to use gearing a bit more strategically, perhaps using derivatives. So I feel here the trust is responding to a
33:55
Andrew McHattie: lot of the current trends in the investment trust sector. It's taking action, it's changing the name to be a bit more. explicit about what it's doing, it's having the conditional tender offer, and it's using the investment trust structure. That's really what the gearing is all about. So that seems like a completely
34:15
Andrew McHattie: reasonable response, and I will be interested to see how that plays out. Certainly this trust I think needed to do something because it was lagging quite badly.
34:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
34:25
Jonathan Davis: of course this means that in its sector. which is a relatively small sector, the Europe sector, it will be the trust paying the highest dividend compared to the others, though JP Morgan European Growth and Income, I think, also has an enhanced dividend approach. So interesting to see what happens there. Let's talk about Caledonian ticket A
34:45
Jonathan Davis: CLDN, C L DN, which is a large family controlled investment. trust, providing, if you like, a kind of endowment policy approach for its family shareholders and outside shareholders as well. What's the news out of this particular trust, which seems to me has always traded on a very wide discount, but you kind of
35:05
Jonathan Davis: know that if you get involved in it, it's always been on a big discount and looks likely to stay that way, I would think.
35:10
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
35:11
Andrew McHattie: so the news here is that the trust is giving some money back to shareholders. It's paying a special dividend equal to £100 million, which is 20 pence per share. And effectively, what it's doing here is sharing the spoils because it made a big asset sale actually from its private holdings, which
35:31
Andrew McHattie: completed back in June. That was a wealth manager called Stonehage Fleming, and it sold that for £290 million.
35:39
Andrew McHattie: So, in line, I think, again, with current trends in the investment trust sector, it's thought about how it wants to allocate its capital. And whilst it really would like to keep it and reinvest, it also recognises that there's an expectation from its shareholder base that some of that money will flow back, hence it's
35:59
Andrew McHattie: paying this special dividend. And I think that's just a way. of allocating its capital. You might think it would want to buy back some more shares on a 32% discount, but as you rightly say, Jonathan, this trust is always on a wide discount. Partly I think because of the control structure and the the family investment, but also because of the
36:19
Andrew McHattie: nature of its portfolio, which has quite a big holding, about a quarter in unquoted shares. and another third in private equity funds as well. So I don't think it's going to be going to a a really narrow discount any point soon.
36:38
Jonathan Davis: So this one sits in the flexible investment sector. So it is competing against, to the extent it's competing at all, against a fairly wide range of trusts, which have got very different strategies. So they're quite difficult to compare if you like. performance. But what has the performance been over the longer term of this trust?
36:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
36:56
Andrew McHattie: if we look back five years, it's okay, is the answer. I don't think it really stands out in either direction. I'm looking at its ranking across the entire investment trust sector, because as you rightly say, comparing it within that flexible sector is difficult. But if you compare it with all investment trusts,
37:15
Andrew McHattie: then over five years it is ranked 68th out of 218. Over three years it's ranked 139th out of 218. So it's not outstanding by any means over this period, but I think the returns are not that bad either. It's in the nature of what it does that the returns are going to be a bit
37:35
Andrew McHattie: cyclical, I would say. So it's going to run hot and cold to some degree. That's how I feel about it. I have written about it at various times over many years, and I think my opinion's probably shifted quite a lot from thinking it's a bit dull to actually thinking it's doing really, really well at the present time. So I would just be
37:54
Andrew McHattie: wary of watching what it does over a very short period and keep your eye on the long term.
38:01
Jonathan Davis: Okay, so let's next talk about Schroeder Income Growth, Ticker SCF. This is a trust that sits in the UK equity income sector.
38:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Tell
38:12
Jonathan Davis: us what you picked up about this particular trust.
38:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
38:15
Andrew McHattie: I did pick out something in particular here, Jonathan, because on the face of it, its annual results to the 31st of August were not special. The NAV total return was 19%.
38:27
Andrew McHattie: just underperforming the FTSE All Share, which was up 21.3%. But there's nothing really notable about that. What I thought was more interesting was that, as usual, for any trust on the AIC Dividend Hero list, the trust was making sure it's made plenty of noise about that,
38:47
Andrew McHattie: saying it's just gone through its 31st year of. dividend growth, which is a tremendous achievement. And of course, that's a big attraction for investors looking to grow their income from their investment trust portfolios. However, the trust did use its revenue reserves for the fourth consecutive year to
39:07
Andrew McHattie: maintain that dividend. So the earnings in the portfolio were 13.6 pence and it paid a dividend. of 15.3 pence. So it was about 0.9 times covered. So it's not that bad. But the trust is having to dip into its revenue reserves. And it blamed actually
39:27
Andrew McHattie: companies spending more money on buybacks rather than increasing their dividends in the UK market, which I have heard from other trusts as well. But it did make me think about the costs. cost of maintaining this dividend record and whether, in fact, boards become quite blinkered when they're on the AIC dividend hero list,
39:48
Andrew McHattie: and that becomes their overriding aim to make sure they stay on that list at all costs. And maybe this trust shouldn't be paying such a high dividend, Jonathan. Its yield isn't that great, to be honest. It's 4.1%. And the trust, I think. is not a bad trust at all, fairly middling over recent times. But I do
40:07
Andrew McHattie: wonder about the sustainability of these higher dividends. I suppose it's just again rather like paying an enhanced dividend, which we've seen so many other trusts do. That's the environment we're in at the moment. But it does feel a little bit uncomfortable to me in terms of the transparency that this trust is really maintaining. a dividend
40:27
Andrew McHattie: it can't really afford.
40:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
40:29
Jonathan Davis: think that's a very important point you make. It's something we've discussed in the past and it turned out to be it was a great marketing sort of coup to put this label on trust that can increase their dividend every year, but sometimes it could become a cross that the trust has to live with, and no one is brave enough to take the risk of coming off that list. There have been a couple of examples who've have done that and then come back later on. But it
40:49
Jonathan Davis: is, I think, a very potent point you make. In terms of where this trust sits in the UK equity income sector, obviously the sector is one of the largest ones we have, and a lot of good names in there, quite significant names with decent size and so on. But this one I always thought is a little bit in the middle, if you like. It's not particularly
41:09
Jonathan Davis: large and it's not a particularly potent performer. So I guess there are some issues in around that which need to be resolved. But we do know I think from looking at history that trusts that do become dividend heroes remain pretty popular with the retail audience at least. Okay, so let's move on then and let's talk about something very different. This is 3i,
41:29
Jonathan Davis: a private equity trust that is the largest company in the investment And trust universe, but has been itself on another volatile journey. Seems to be a theme we keep coming back to this time because it's moved from what was a very persistent and very large premium to a discount. So what's the latest coming out of this particular trust, and why should we
41:49
Jonathan Davis: take any notice of what they're doing?
41:51
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
41:52
Andrew McHattie: you put your finger straight on to the main issue here, which is that big shift in the way in which 3I is rated by the market. But that's changing all of the time, actually, which makes it highly relevant to look at the results. The latest NAV we had actually was for the quarter ending 30th of September, and it was
42:11
Andrew McHattie: £31.54, which was broadly in line with what the market was anticipating. But of course, all eyes were on its holding in action group, which accounts for three quarters of the portfolio. So this is not a diversified portfolio. at all. In fact, 3i again is doubling down on this
42:31
Andrew McHattie: and has acquired a larger holding in Action, which it still has a lot of belief in. And really, the changing the fortunes of the trust down to what's happened at Action Group, the reason why 3i swung from this huge premium to a significant discount was that Action's growth disappointed the
42:51
Andrew McHattie: market, and so investors reassessed their positions quite rapidly. But action is still profitable, it's still growing, and it's not doing badly, it's just not doing quite as well as was previously hoped. But nevertheless, the trust is thinking about what it's doing with its money, it's been putting a bit more into
43:11
Andrew McHattie: action, but it's also now that the shares are on this significant. discount. I think it's about 14% now, but it has been wider than 20%. They're putting a bit more money into share buybacks. Effectively, they're continuing what they've been doing because they already had a share buyback program in place,
43:30
Andrew McHattie: but that's largely exhausted. So they're just putting another 750 seven hundred and fifty million pound buyback in place for the period to. May twenty twenty seven. Effectively there's nothing unusual about this. It's a continuation of their previous policy and it makes good sense to me. I think it's just good housekeeping and it's really
43:50
Andrew McHattie: the board behaving exactly as it should.
43:53
Jonathan Davis: Okay. Well that one will power on. It's not a member of the AIC, C, so if you are looking for information or data about it, you have to go uh to the company's own website or to some other provider. You won't find those numbers on the AIC website. Might be worth just mentioning that. Let's talk next about Syncona, which uh operates in the healthcare sector.
44:14
Jonathan Davis: Tell us what's happening with Syncona.
44:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
44:16
Andrew McHattie: Syncona again is another trust where if you look at the results that have just come out, they don't seem particularly outstanding in themselves, but there are other things going on here. So let's deal with the results first. For the half year to 30th of September, the net asset value was 175.7, which was up by
44:36
Andrew McHattie: 3% over that period. So nothing exciting there at all. But what is interesting is that whilst the NAV was only up by 3% over that six-month six month period, the These shares were up by 40%. because they had a big revaluation. I think to be fair, they were on an enormous discount
44:56
Andrew McHattie: beforehand. It was actually over 40%, and that's come in now to 26.6%.
45:02
Andrew McHattie: So we've seen this discount narrowing. And of course that leads to the obvious question: well, what's driven that? What's what happened? And I think it's two things. Well, maybe three, actually, let's say three. I think, first of all, it's some excellent trial results, some drug trial results from Beacon Therapeutics, which is its
45:22
Andrew McHattie: biggest holding, it's 22% of the NAV, and that was written up actually in this latest quarter. And I think the fact that things are going well there has helped the change in sentiment. There's also the fact that the board is targeting a 200. £250 million capital return in due course. We
45:42
Andrew McHattie: don't know quite how that's coming back or when it's coming back, but again, that's part of the trust current capital allocation plan. And then we have the third factor, which we shouldn't overlook, which is that SABA has taken a stake here. It's taken a 16.4% stake. And I think that has
46:03
Andrew McHattie: been instrumental in driving the price higher. And of course, we've said plenty of things that are critical about Saba, haven't we, over the months? And it's clearly a matter of huge hot debate. But I think in this case we can definitely say it's delivered some additional value for those shareholders. I think it has helped to pump up the
46:22
Andrew McHattie: price here.
46:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
46:24
Jonathan Davis: guess the point to make here is that recently there's been has a particular particularly good period for companies that are operating in the healthcare and particularly in new drug territory. Biotech stocks have recovered very strongly, and Syncona has the worst record of those. I think it's fair to say, it's done pretty much nothing for the last five years until this recent share price movement.
46:44
Jonathan Davis: So I don't know what Saba's Saber's thinking was when they took a stake here, but they maybe just saw a big discount and thought this trust is underperforming and tribute. should be doing a lot better in the current market climate, or whether they had some other insights into this. But it is true that it has performed very poorly for a long time. It had a very strong pair between twenty seventeen and twenty twenty, like a lot of other
47:03
Jonathan Davis: higher risk stocks in that magical low interest rate environment now receding from memory. But it's fallen a long way since then. So is there anything sort of specific about the way the trust operates or the way it's it manages, or is it just a question of it's been looking in the wrong places for the next drugs of the drugs of the future?
47:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
47:21
Andrew McHattie: Syncona's been unusual. It's had a large cash balance that it hasn't invested. And so it hasn't been an ordinary investment trust. But it has, you're right, been a terrible lagard actually in the sector, which accounts for that very wide discount. And I've thought as well about why SABA decided. to take a stake, because it's not
47:41
Andrew McHattie: necessarily that easy to realise any value here. But I think it's possibly a broader sector position than just deciding that Syncona itself is a particularly good place to have its money. I think that that very, very wide discount was just too good to miss. But Sabah Saba has also been investing
48:00
Andrew McHattie: elsewhere in the sector.
48:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Indeed.
48:03
Jonathan Davis: it has. Yeah. Well, let's move on then finally and talk about RTW, which is another biotech company, which has, again, had a volatile history but has been performing pretty well as the market for this particular type of company has improved significantly. Tell us about how they're doing and draw any contrast you like with Syncona.
48:22
Andrew McHattie: Yes, it's a very relevant one to talk about because Sabah has also built a ten 10% percent stake here. And again, I think that's had an impact. So this trust I think is a good trust. I really like it. It's a full life cycle investor. So it sometimes sets up its own companies when it's identified very good
48:41
Andrew McHattie: science and potential good drug candidates, but it creates its own companies to take advantage of that, or it buys at a very early stage, but then it continues. to hold these companies all the way through their life post-IPO, and it has changed character as a result. I remember when it launched and it had a high proportion
49:01
Andrew McHattie: in unquoted companies at that time, but that's really changed, and most of it now is in fact in quoted stocks. So I think the nature of the trust has changed, and of course, the nature of the environment has changed. So it too has responded to its relatively wide discount as
49:21
Andrew McHattie: it was, and it is also buying back its shares. So it's going to buy back another 45 million dollars worth of shares, but also it's going to formalize that process. So it's going to create a separate bucket now of 20% of all of its realized gains. from MA. And of course, we know that
49:41
Andrew McHattie: MA has begun great guns in the biotech sector. There's been a great deal of that happening. So it's going to add more money to its liquidity pool for buybacks or other types of returns for shareholders. Again, I don't think there's anything too radical about that. It's a formalization of the standard
50:01
Andrew McHattie: process that so many investment trusts. have been going through. But I do think that's probably helped the share price rating, which has changed quite a lot. And some of this must also be down to Sabah because the discount has come right in. I remember it being at around the 20 to 25% mark for really an
50:20
Andrew McHattie: extended period. That was quite normal. I felt that was where this trust belonged, but it's come. right in now to 8%.
50:29
Andrew McHattie: And I'm a shareholder here, and I'm thinking maybe this is the point at which I start to trim my position because I think this trust still has 20% in unquoted assets. I would still say it's a relatively high-risk risk investment trust. So I'm not sure it really should be trading at par.
50:51
Jonathan Davis: Right. So there's another one that again is if you're interested in this sector. I mean it has performed well. I think it's fair to say compared to the other peer group that it would be compared with certainly over the last three years it's done very well. I think it's return compound about 27% a year, which puts it on a par with International Biotech Trust and slightly ahead of one
51:11
Jonathan Davis: or two of the others and significantly ahead of worldwide health care and a long way ahead of Syncona and uh has been performing very well. So I think for the reasons you say it might well be worth looking at that one with a view to uh maybe rebalancing a little.
51:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
51:25
Jonathan Davis: that brings us to the end of this week's podcast. Thank you as always, Andrew. It's been a relatively good week for the investment trust sector, despite all this noise in the other side of the Atlantic. Majority of trusts outperforming, discount coming in. As we move towards the end of your year and the Christmas period, traditionally that's always a pretty strong period for the markets. Do you think we're going to see that this year?
51:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
51:45
Andrew McHattie: I'm keeping my fingers crossed for the traditional Santa rally. If you look at the markets statistically, there is quite a high chance of a rally, but of course, there's potential for all kinds of interruptions, including a wounded American president. So I I'm not sure I'm going to fall. forecast what the market's going to do over the next
52:05
Andrew McHattie: month. But I do feel it's a very interesting time for the sector. There are quite a lot of changes occurring, plenty of valuation shifts and things to look at. But I generally feel quite optimistic because I also think this AI sell-off that we've seen has been surprisingly controlled. It could well have been a
52:25
Andrew McHattie: market crash. This really could have been. sunk the market. We may have seen one of those amazing sell-offs that we talk about in historic terms. But it hasn't been like that. I think it's been quite controlled. And that speaks to, I think, some very good underlying fundamentals here. Earnings growth is really good in
52:45
Andrew McHattie: global markets. It's really good in the US. It's good elsewhere. And that is really supporting markets. So I feel quite optimistic about what's to come.
52:54
Jonathan Davis: Very good. Well we will see how that plays out for what it's worth. I think I might agree with you for certainly to the end of the year. But we are facing an environment where it looks like there's going to be further increases in interest rates. So that might act as a bit of a control on where we are. And as you say the risk of some kind of market collapse has not diminished anyway, let's put it that way. But we've all got our eyes
53:14
Jonathan Davis: glued to what's happening in the AI world and what's happening to the markets overall. So thank you. As always, for your time, Andrew. And we will be talking again before Christmas. So looking forward to that.
53:24
Andrew McHattie: Great, thank you.
53:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Thank you for listening to the Moneymakers Investment Trust Podcast, sponsored by JP Morgan Asset Management and independently produced and edited by Moneymakers. If you like what you have heard, do tell your friends and colleagues. and remember to subscribe through your favourite podcast app or at the website so you never miss an episode. And
53:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): follow us on our social media channels. For more news, commentary, and other investment trust content, don't forget to look at the Moneymakers Circle, available for a modest subscription. All details are at the website money-makers.co. Podcasts are provided for educational. purposes only and nothing you have heard from any
54:05
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): speaker should be regarded as constituting investment advice.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Money Makers

All insights