NZ Property Policy Analysis: $300k Income Cap, Tiny Home Lending, and Demographic Ownership Trends
Summary
Paul and Debbie Roberts discuss New Zealand's housing policy landscape, focusing on Labour's rent-to-buy scheme and the proposed $300,000 income cap for first-home loans. They critique the affordability of these measures, noting that higher income caps allow larger mortgages that require rigorous stress-testing at 7-7.5% interest rates. The hosts also analyze National's policies on tiny homes and senior housing, warning that tiny homes on wheels are legally vehicles ineligible for standard mortgages. Finally, they examine Stats NZ census data revealing that women outpace men in home ownership under age 70, attributing this to differing investment priorities.
Key takeaways
- 1 Tiny homes on wheels are legally classified as vehicles, not real estate, meaning major banks will not issue standard 30-year residential mortgages; funding requires asset finance or unsecured loans at higher rates.
Paul Roberts · 12:58
- 2 lodging a PIN PIM exists for a reason. Your local council still checks over land flow paths, floodplains, and boundary setbacks. If you place a tiny home or secondary dwelling on a site where the public wastewater main is at capacity, you could easily be hit with thousands of dollars in council infrastructure growth charges or civil drainage upgrades.
Debbie Roberts · 13:59
Episode sections
- 0:27 – 1:41
Intro and Policy Overview
Paul and Debbie Roberts introduce three major NZ property developments: election housing promises, deregulated dwellings, and demographic data. They outline Labour's rent-to-buy scheme and the $300k income cap, National's tiny home/granny flat rules, and Stats NZ data showing women outpacing men in home ownership.
- 1:41 – 10:40
Labour's Rent-to-Buy and $300k Income Cap
Debbie details Labour's rent-to-buy policy offering $100/week credits to tenants, which Paul critiques as insufficient for deposit accumulation. They discuss the consensus on raising the first-home loan income cap to $300k, noting it helps dual-income earners but requires rigorous stress-testing of mortgages at 7-7.5%.
- 10:40 – 17:46
National's Tiny Home and Senior Housing Policies
Debbie explains National's expansion of consent-free rules to include tiny homes on wheels and 40sqm garages. Paul warns that tiny homes on wheels are legally vehicles, not real estate, making standard 30-year mortgages unavailable. They also cover National's plan to ring-fence 20% of housing funds for seniors.
- 17:46 – 26:08
Demographic Trends: Women vs Men Home Ownership
Paul presents Stats NZ census data showing Kiwi women outpace men in home ownership across age brackets under 70. Debbie attributes this to women prioritizing stability and pragmatism over speculative investment, while Paul notes men still dominate investment property ownership due to higher average incomes and deposit savings.
Claims worth verifying
Labour and National have both backed raising the household income eligibility cap for first home loans to $300,000.
Debbie Roberts ·0:27
How to verify: Check official election policy documents from the New Zealand Labour Party and National Party released prior to the 2026 election cycle. For recent events, verify 2026-08-06 through 2026-11-06. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Labour's rent-to-buy policy provides a $100 weekly credit towards a deposit for community housing tenants.
Debbie Roberts ·1:41
How to verify: Review Labour Party housing policy announcements or official government press releases regarding the 'Rent to Buy' scheme. For recent events, verify 2026-08-06 through 2026-11-06. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Buying a $700,000 home with a 5% deposit results in a $665,000 mortgage.
Paul Roberts ·5:20
How to verify: Mathematical calculation: $700,000 * 0.95 = $665,000. For recent events, verify 2026-08-06 through 2026-11-06. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
For every public home sold, the government will reinvest proceeds to build three new public houses.
Paul Roberts ·7:44
How to verify: Check National Party housing policy documents or Ministry of Social Development statements regarding the 'Healthy Homes' build ratio. For recent events, verify 2026-08-06 through 2026-11-06. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
580 project information memoranda (PIMs) were lodged in the first six months of the original Granny Flat policy, accounting for $96 million in proposed work.
Debbie Roberts ·13:59
How to verify: Search MBIE (Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment) or local council data for PIM lodgements related to the Unitary Plan or specific granny flat exemptions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-06 through 2026-11-06. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
15% of people on the public housing register are over 65 years old.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·14:49
How to verify: Access Ministry of Social Development (MSD) housing register statistics or Stats NZ data on public housing demographics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-06 through 2026-11-06. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Women's median hourly earnings are 5.2% below men's.
Debbie Roberts ·18:22
How to verify: Review Stats NZ 'Household Labour Force Survey' or 'Income Inequality' reports for the relevant period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-06 through 2026-11-06. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The average age for Kiwi women to have children is 32, and the average first home buyer is 35.
Paul Roberts ·20:47
How to verify: Check Stats NZ birth statistics and real estate agency reports (e.g., Trade Me Property) for average buyer age demographics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-06 through 2026-11-06. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
National plans to legislate employer KiwiSaver matching contributions for staff over 65 starting July 1, 2027.
Debbie Roberts ·16:27
How to verify: Review National Party election policy documents or Employment New Zealand regulations regarding KiwiSaver contribution age limits. For recent events, verify 2026-08-06 through 2026-11-06. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify current mortgage stress test rates against the 7-7.5% figure cited by checking official Reserve Bank of New Zealand (RBNZ) prudential standards or major bank lending criteria.
- Confirm the legal classification of 'tiny homes on wheels' under the New Zealand Building Act and Land Transport Act to determine mortgage eligibility.
- Review Stats NZ census data tables for home ownership rates by gender and age bracket to validate the claim that women outpace men under 70.
- Assess local council infrastructure growth charges and drainage upgrade costs for consent-free developments in specific NZ regions.
- Check the current inventory and waitlist times for social housing in South Auckland and other major metropolitan centers to evaluate the impact of tenant purchase schemes.
- Analyze construction cost indices in NZ to determine if land and infrastructure costs indeed prevent building three new homes for the price of one sold state house.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:06
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Welcome
- 0:06
- Paul Roberts: back to New Zealand Property Insights. I'm Paul Roberts.
- 0:09
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 0:09
- Debbie Roberts: I'm Debbie Roberts. We're the owners of Property Apprentice, helping you to navigate the New Zealand property market with real facts, data, and no hype.
- 0:17
- Paul Roberts: Today we're breaking down three major property developments, spanning election housing promises, senior living regulations, a and new census demographic. data.
- 0:27
- Debbie Roberts: So first up, Labour's promised a new rent-to-buy scheme for Kyanla aura tenants and matched National's pledge to lift the first home loan income cap to $300,000.
- 0:39
- Paul Roberts: Which is great that we've got consensus across that because that's going to allow a lot more first home buyers. We're already up there, but that's going to be a huge amount more, which
- 0:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is great.
- 0:49
- Debbie Roberts: Absolutely.
- 0:49
- Paul Roberts: Second, National is under has unveiled plans to widen consent free granny flat rules to include tiny homes on wheels and ring fence 20% of government funding for pensioner housing.
- 1:02
- Debbie Roberts: That could be a game changer for people wanting to add extra income streams potentially on their own properties, although tiny homes do or tiny homes on wheels. Um you might need to double check with tenancy tribunal. to make sure that that'll be all right. But third up, Stats New Zealand data reveals a surprising trend. Kiwi
- 1:22
- Debbie Roberts: women are now outpacing men into home ownership across every single age bracket under the age of 70. So let's jump into it. Segment one, Labour's Labor's rent to buy policy and the $300,000 first home loan cap. Kicking the this off with Labour's latest election housing
- 1:41
- Debbie Roberts: policy, which is trying to address two distinct challenges: that is, moving public housing tenants into private ownership and helping middle-income earners clear the deposit hurdle. Under their rent-to-buy policy, working Kayanga aura or community housing tenants receive a $100 weekly credit towards their house
- 2:01
- Debbie Roberts: deposit held in trust until they can buy the property at an independently assessed market valuation.
- 2:09
- Paul Roberts: Now,
- 2:10
- Debbie Roberts: on paper,
- 2:11
- Debbie Roberts: we'll
- 2:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): dig
- 2:13
- Debbie Roberts: into this
- 2:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for
- 2:13
- Debbie Roberts: a second. On paper, building a forced savings habit makes great financial sense. But in practical terms, $100 a week amounts to $5,200 a year on an entry-level high. home, that means a family could spend six or seven years accumulating just a modest deposit, during which time the market
- 2:33
- Debbie Roberts: will inevitably move more through an entire price cycle. What's far more immediately impactful for the broader market is the first home loan change. Labor's Match Nationals pledge to lift the household income eligibility cap to $300,000. For years the previous caps of $150,000
- 2:53
- Debbie Roberts: for couples and $95,000 for singles penalized average working families in many major centers. If you had two nurses, teachers, or tradespeople earning $85,000 each, their combined $170,000 income locked them out of that s low deposit state support, despite
- 3:13
- Debbie Roberts: then being the exact debit. demographic who could responsibly service a mortgage. So let's have a chat about this really
- 3:22
- Paul Roberts: great that both Labour and National think uh put in the first home buyer cap up to 300,000 is a good idea. I don't think honestly the $100 a week going towards your deposit, yeah, it's a it's an okay idea. But a lot of Kyango Kyanga Aura houses, you wouldn't be able to split them up because
- 3:42
- Paul Roberts: there's lots of units and there's lots of different. So it what about people that are in um you know a building that is, you know, you you can't split it up, it's owned by Kyango Aura and it's not individually titled. How are you gonna, you know, that disadvantages just those people there. And if they
- 4:02
- Paul Roberts: did. get $5,200 a year and over, say six years, but the property market goes up stronger, so they still need more deposit, and then they decide, well, look, I've had a life change or I'm gonna move to Christchurch or whatever it might be, do they lose all that money?
- 4:19
- Debbie Roberts: Exactly. Like if someone's on a benefit and needs help from Kyangora Kayanga Aura to be in one of the state houses.
- 4:27
- Debbie Roberts: then if they get a job and no longer need to be living in that state house, does that mean
- 4:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah
- 4:35
- Paul Roberts: exactly.
- 4:35
- Debbie Roberts: And it there's lots of potential fish hooks. It sounds really good on the surface, but when you dig into the
- 4:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): thing, lots of things
- 4:41
- Paul Roberts: do sound okay at the beginning, but then when you dig into it it's like, yeah, well, coulda, woulda, shoulda, it doesn't really isn't gonna make a massive difference. And
- 4:50
- Debbie Roberts: it's an extra cost to the taxpayers as well at the end of the day, isn't it?
- 4:54
- Paul Roberts: Yeah, yeah. And I and I j I just I I think the first the the the three hundred thousand dollars
- 4:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 5:00
- Paul Roberts: going up is is great. And I think that should definitely help a lot of people. So, you know, uh that three hundred thousand dollar, you know, it is a a good idea. The first home loan allows buyers to purchase with a five percent deposit. on a say a standard seven hundred thousand dollar purchase. You'll only need to come up with thirty-five grand instead
- 5:20
- Paul Roberts: of the standard, you know, 140-ish if it was 20%.
- 5:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 5:25
- Paul Roberts: so that's a fantastic launch. And I think that banks will actually look
- 5:30
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um,
- 5:30
- Paul Roberts: you know, when you look at the five percent, you're carrying basically six $665,000 hundred and sixty-five thousand dollar mortgage from day one. So you need to make sure that you can afford that. You need to calculate your affordability around that $665,000. Because it's one thing to get the $35,000 as a deposit, but
- 5:50
- Paul Roberts: then you've got to service that mortgage.
- 5:53
- Paul Roberts: And they aren't necessarily going to be testing your mortgage at higher interest rates than today's. So you really need to test your how household cash flow against higher interest rates to ensure that you could survive a financial shock if it happens. Um, you know, because over time, interest
- 6:13
- Paul Roberts: rates do go up and down. And if you're carrying 95% of the debt, uh, and the asset leaves you with virtually no equity cushion if house prices soften. So, you know, it doesn't take much. But I I think we're pretty much on the board that we're going to see property values increase over the next few years. Otherwise, of course, you know,
- 6:33
- Paul Roberts: capital gains tax is never going to work because if there's no if there's no growth, there's no nothing. You can't just go, oh, inflation. Um, what do you think?
- 6:41
- Debbie Roberts: Yeah, exactly. And I also think, you know, this does point out also when we're talking about the Kayan Kayanga Laura Aura first-time loan scheme and all that. sort of stuff, um, like allowing Kayanga Aura tenants to purchase a property, if they're in the Kayung Aura property, it's because they're on, you know, they need
- 7:01
- Debbie Roberts: that financial support. And most of the people that are in the Kayung Aura properties can't afford standard market rents. So how on earth are they supposed to afford a mortgage? Like But
- 7:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
- 7:12
- Debbie Roberts: they don't meet bank lending criteria. the idea of having, you know, part of their weekly payments going towards a house deposit, that's all well and good, but in reality it probably won't work. It's just empty promises, in my opinion. Anyway, getting into a property is only half the battle. Keeping it through those different interest rates
- 7:32
- Debbie Roberts: environments is what matters. And that brings us to Karen McAnalty's Mackinalty's claim that selling off public homes through rent to buy won't reduce overall state housing stock. Can't see how.
- 7:44
- Paul Roberts: What the?
- 7:45
- Debbie Roberts: Can't see how. He claims that for every public home sold, Kayanga Aura will reinvest the proceeds to build three brand new public houses, which is an interesting thing, isn't it? Because again, that's can
- 7:57
- Paul Roberts: we build anyone? Yeah.
- 7:59
- Debbie Roberts: We shouldn't laugh. Listen to us being all cynical. From an a development and financial planning standpoint, the math just doesn't stack up in today's construction climate. If an older state house in a provincial center sells for six hundred or seven hundred thousand, you can't build three modern healthy homes compliant dwellings for two
- 8:19
- Debbie Roberts: hundred to two hundred and thirty dollars apiece A piece once you account for land acquid acquisition, civil infrastructure, council development. contributions as well as building materials. The only way to achieve that density is by redeveloping large suburban land parcels into multi-unit complexes, which requires years of
- 8:39
- Debbie Roberts: consenting and substantial crown debt.
- 8:42
- Paul Roberts: And we already know how Kyangaura handles this in the real world. Existing tenant purchase schemes explicitly exclude major metropolitan centers where social housing demand is at its absolute highest. If Kyanga Aura begins selling off standalone properties in areas like South Auckland, Lower Hutt, Pricechurch, they
- 9:02
- Paul Roberts: deplete the public housing stock in the exact suburbs where the social support wait lists are the longest. So for people listening in, the practical takeaway here is clear. Whether you earn 100,000 a hundred thousand or two hundred and fifty thousand, do not treat a five percent deposit as a silver bullet. Focus on your debt to income ratio, stress
- 9:22
- Paul Roberts: your monthly payments against higher rates. And, you know, when I say a hundred or two hundred and fifty thousand, that could be a couple. Um and ensure you can budget weekly that can handle the rates, the insurance, the maintenance without relying on government subsidies. So it's a great way to get in if you can get in, no
- 9:42
- Paul Roberts: doubt, but make sure you can afford what you're buying.
- 9:45
- Debbie Roberts: Yeah, absolutely. Because like we've always said, just because the bank tells you you can borrow a certain amount of money doesn't mean that you can actually afford that. So, you know, we generally always recommend to our clients that they stress test the cash flow at seven 7% percent interest rate, sometimes even seven 7.5%. and a half percent. And I think that gives you a good safety buffer there.
- 10:05
- Debbie Roberts: Most of the banks are testing your affordability at seven percent at the moment. So, you know, stress testing it a little bit further, I think, is a good idea for your own personal budget. And while Labour's targeting first home buyers and state tenants, the election debate is also focusing heavily on the other end of the demographic curve, which is our
- 10:25
- Debbie Roberts: aging population.
- 10:27
- Paul Roberts: And National's latest housing announcements shift the spotlight directly on seniors, multi-generational living, and expanding consent-free rules to include tiny homes. So let's get into segment two.
- 10:40
- Debbie Roberts: So segment two, National's tiny home expansion and senior housing pipeline. We're looking at National's retirement housing package, and Christopher Luxon has doubled down. on deregulating small scale dwellings. Earlier this year, on January 15th, the coalition rolled out consent-free rules for granny flats up to 70
- 11:00
- Debbie Roberts: square meters. Now National's pledging to expand that framework to include tiny homes, specifically extending the rules to tiny homes on wheels. Crucially, they're also proposing to allow an attached or detached. garage of up to 40 square meters alongside that 70 square meter footprint
- 11:20
- Debbie Roberts: while capping council fees strictly to cost recovery. That garage change is far more important than people realise. Under the initial rules, any garage or storage had to be carved out of the 70 square meter total, leaving families with tiny, you know, 35 square meters. meter living areas.
- 11:40
- Debbie Roberts: That's the average size of bedrooms in some suburbs, isn't it?
- 11:44
- Paul Roberts: It's a hotel room.
- 11:45
- Debbie Roberts: Yes. And that allow, you know, allowing for a dedicated 40 square meter garage makes independent multi-generational living genuinely practical for aging family members. And I like the idea of these tiny homes on wheels as well, because you know, when you think about multi-generation. multi generational living, then it could be the parents
- 12:05
- Debbie Roberts: that live in the in the tiny home on wheels to start with, you know, the grandparents. And then um after they no longer need it, for lack of a better way of saying it, when they no longer need it, then maybe the the kids of the family could use that and move it onto a block
- 12:25
- Debbie Roberts: of land, you know, so they could buy a piece of land, move the tiny home on there until they save up enough money to to build a house for themselves as well. So it just it gives a lot more flexibility to things moving forward.
- 12:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
- 12:38
- Paul Roberts: I think there are a few things to consider here when you're looking at mortgage lending perspectives. Need to be wide away awake car how banks treat these structures. So a tiny homes on wheels is legally a vehicle. It's not real estate. You're not going to get bank funding. It's rented or higher purchase or second tier lending. You can't walk into a major bank
- 12:58
- Paul Roberts: and ask for 80% loan to value ratio mortgage over 30 years as standard residential rates for a dwelling that's sitting on an axle. But if a bank cannot register a mortgage over the physical title of the chattel, you have to fund it by either drawing down usable equity against your primary property or by taking
- 13:18
- Paul Roberts: out an unsecured loan or asset finance at much higher interest rates. So tiny homes on wheels depreciate like caravans, unless they're they are tied entitled to land for, you know, asset to build long term generational wealth, it must be legally affixed to a real property if we're going to get lending
- 13:38
- Paul Roberts: from landing for it.
- 13:39
- Debbie Roberts: And we also have separate building consent exemptions from council infrastructure rules. The MBI data shows that 580 project information memoranda were lodged in the first six months of the original Granny Flat policy, accounting for roughly $96 million dollars in proposed work. But
- 13:59
- Debbie Roberts: lodging a PIN PIM exists for a reason. Your local council still checks over land flow paths, floodplains, and boundary setbacks. If you place a tiny home or secondary dwelling on a site where the public wastewater main is at capacity, you could easily be hit with thousands of dollars in council infrastructure growth charges
- 14:19
- Debbie Roberts: or civil drainage upgrades. Consent free simply means you skip the standard building consent paperwork if you use licensed professionals, it does not give you a free pass to ignore council bylaws or district plan rules.
- 14:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 14:34
- Paul Roberts: on the other side, nationals policy addresses the serious demographic crisis, senior housing. They plan to ring fence at least 20% of the housing flexible fund, specifically for pensioner and senior housing units.
- 14:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 14:49
- Paul Roberts: when you look at the Ministry of Social Development data, 15% of people on public housing register are over 65 years old, a staggering 33% are over 55, with home ownership rates declining over recent decades. New Zealand has a massive wave of Kiwis entering
- 15:09
- Paul Roberts: retirement who do not own a freehold home, are totally reliant on the New Zealand supervision. superannuation to pay market rents. Private retirement villages often require hundreds of thousands of dollars for an occupation right agreement with significant deferred management fees, which is completely out of reach for a
- 15:29
- Paul Roberts: lot of non homeowners. Creating dedicated affordable pension Well, stock is a critical stop older Kiwis from falling into severe poverty. So it definitely needs to be addressed. I mean, if you know, you get into sixty five and you haven't been able to buy a home, you know, it's um yeah, it's
- 15:47
- Debbie Roberts: pretty crippling financially. Because, you know, I mean, the superannuation is based on people living in a mortgage free home. And when you look at the amount that the government superannuation pays, it's actually less than the average rent in New Zealand. So it does make things pretty tough for people in retirement if they don't have a hidem to live in
- 16:07
- Debbie Roberts: that's mortgage free, or at least has a low mortgage on it. And, you know, this ties directly into the KiwiSaver announcement for older workers. From the 1st of July 2027, national plans to legislate that employers must continue paying compulsory matching Kiwi Saber Saver contributions to contributing staff. aged
- 16:27
- Debbie Roberts: over 65, which means if employers continue to work past retirement age, then the employers should continue matching their Kiwi Saber contributions. I think that's fair enough. Why should you be able to opt out of it just because someone's turned a certain age? If they're still contributing, you should too
- 16:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as an
- 16:46
- Debbie Roberts: employer. Under the current law, the moment you turn 65, you're employed. your employer can legally stop their matching 3% contribution or 3.5% at the moment, even if you continue working 40 hours a week. And with thousands of Kiwis working well into their late 60s and sometimes 70s now out of financial
- 17:06
- Debbie Roberts: necessity, retaining that employer contribution provides a direct boost to their retirement savings.
- 17:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
- 17:13
- Debbie Roberts: you've got older family members, or are planning your own retirement transition, looking at secondary dwellings on existing family sections is a legitimate strategy. But just make sure you speak to an independent financial advisor or mortgage advisor to structure the finance and title ownership correctly. While politicians
- 17:33
- Debbie Roberts: debate how these house retirees and first-time buyers, the latest census figures show that home ownership dynamics on the ground are defying traditional assumptions. I love this.
- 17:46
- Paul Roberts: So a fresh analysis of StatsNZ census data shows that women, Kiwi women are now entering the property market earlier and in greater numbers than men across almost every single stage of life. Well done.
- 18:00
- Paul Roberts: So let's take a go to section segment three, why Kiwi Women Are Outpacing Men in Home Ownership.
- 18:06
- Debbie Roberts: Our final segment covers an eye opening analysis of Stats New Zealand census figures published by Staff showing that Kiwi women are consistently outpacing men and buying homes, despite the wage parachute.
- 18:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
- 18:22
- Debbie Roberts: In every so I'll I'll get off my high horse, but you know. In every single age group under 70 years old, women are more likely to own or co own their home than men. What makes this data so remarkable is that it persists despite that gender pay gap, where median hourly earnings for women
- 18:42
- Debbie Roberts: sit five point two percent below men. Now I'm gonna actually say something that could be that could be quite unpopular.
- 18:49
- Paul Roberts: Brace yourself. So
- 18:51
- Debbie Roberts: I think the reason that women sit with their median hourly earnings five point two percent below men is because it tends to be the women that take time off when we have children.
- 19:06
- Paul Roberts: I swear I thought you were gonna say because we buy so much rubbish.
- 19:10
- Debbie Roberts: Yeah, because you guys need more money to pay for all your toys. No, that's not what I'm saying. What I'm saying is, you know, women take time out. It's generally the women. I don't want to say always, because you know, obviously there's lots of stay-at-home dads now too, which I think's great. But you know, when when you take time out from your career, you're immediately at
- 19:30
- Debbie Roberts: a disadvantage. So, you know, there's it's hard to keep pay parity if you've got less experience than a male at the same age, if that makes sense. Because you've got less experience in the workforce. So yeah, I think it would be interesting to compare women that didn't take
- 19:50
- Debbie Roberts: time out with men that don't take time out. But they don't. They just make it sound like it's a sexist thing. And anyway, I digress.
- 19:58
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Get
- 19:58
- Paul Roberts: off your horse.
- 20:00
- Debbie Roberts: Professor Claire Matthews from Mass. Massey University pointed out that women generally exhibit different attitudes towards financial risk and security. In the private rental market, tenants face periodic rent increases, unexpected property sales. Women recognize that home ownership is the ultimate hedge against
- 20:20
- Debbie Roberts: housing instability, giving them total control over their living environment. Because we like having our control, don't we? Yes,
- 20:26
- Paul Roberts: you do.
- 20:28
- Paul Roberts: Mortgage advisors are seeing the exact trend play out in everyday mortgage applications across the country. Michelle from Lone Market noted that she's seen a major influx of single women buying property entirely independently. Demographic data show Kiwi women are having uh children later at an average age of
- 20:47
- Paul Roberts: 32, while the average first home buyer is now 35. What that means, women are using their 20s and 30s to focus on career progression, establish a solid credit history, build substantial Kiwi Silver balances before taking on the big family expense. But the biggest difference is
- 21:07
- Paul Roberts: pragmatism. Advisors consistently report that young women don't get paralyzed waiting for the perfect standalone forever home. on a quarter acre section. They're completely comfortable buying an entry level brick and tile unit, two bedroom townhouse or apartment. They understand that getting onto the ladder, letting time and loan repayments
- 21:27
- Paul Roberts: build equity, beat sitting on the sidelines waiting for the ideal property. And that's exactly what we did. Yeah,
- 21:32
- Debbie Roberts: exactly.
- 21:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Little two
- 21:33
- Paul Roberts: Two-bedroom bedroom state statehouse house we started with, and
- 21:35
- Debbie Roberts: that was the
- 21:36
- Paul Roberts: fleas were jumping.
- 21:37
- Debbie Roberts: Oh it stunk so bad. didn't it? It
- 21:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): did.
- 21:40
- Debbie Roberts: And we smelt the opportunity. Yeah,
- 21:42
- Paul Roberts: literally.
- 21:43
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
- 21:44
- Paul Roberts: So
- 21:44
- Debbie Roberts: it it does match research from Cotality, where Calvin Davidson found that family considerations and having a stable place to call home were rated as critical by forty-two percent of women compared to just thirty-three 33% percent of men. I mean, I can't think of anything worse than having a baby and then getting kicked out of your
- 22:04
- Debbie Roberts: tenancy. You
- 22:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know.
- 22:05
- Debbie Roberts: So I think there is a real stability thing there that is vitally important to women, especially when they start reaching that childbearing age. So if they're interested in having children, not all are. Um men often view property purely through a financial or transactional lens, sometimes trying to pick the bottom of the market or holding out for a property
- 22:25
- Debbie Roberts: with development upside. Women are far more focused on securing stability for their household today. Professor Matthews also noted that relationship breakdowns influence the older statistics. When couples separate, mothers who take on the primary care of children are often determined to retain the family
- 22:45
- Debbie Roberts: home or re re-enter enter the property market quickly to maintain continuity in and schooling and community.
- 22:51
- Paul Roberts: But here's where this data reveals a major contradiction: the investment property sector. While women lead in owner-occupied home ownership, totality data shows men still dominate residential investment property ownership across every single age bracket. Nicole Lewis from Quarter 4 or Q4 highlighted as a very practical reason
- 23:11
- Paul Roberts: for this, saving a 30% thirty percent deposit for investment. an property is significantly harder when fewer women occupy the top income brackets above a hundred thousand dollars.
- 23:22
- Debbie Roberts: Although if you own your own home for longer than the average man, then you know the home can provide that deposit for you.
- 23:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um, Furthermore.
- 23:35
- Paul Roberts: Yeah, once
- 23:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you want to do it.
- 23:37
- Debbie Roberts: no, I'm on a roll.
- 23:40
- Paul Roberts: So in many relationships, uh you have arguments like this, but uh also when both partners contribute equally to building a property portfolio, investment assets are often structured under the higher earning partner's name for tax optimization and servicing capacity, meaning female co-ownership
- 24:00
- Paul Roberts: is unrepresentative in raw data.
- 24:03
- Paul Roberts: But I think most people put it company and you're both shareholders. So don't know that I 100% agree with it.
- 24:10
- Debbie Roberts: Yeah, but it could be like 95% owned by the higher income earner and 5% owned by the small by the lower income earner. I think the fundamental lesson here for every property owner is that practicality and early action win in real estate. You don't need to buy your dream home on day one. Buying a modest,
- 24:30
- Debbie Roberts: manageable property that fits your budget, building equity and having a long-term plan will always outperform trying to time the market. Whether you're buying on your own, with a partner, or building an investment portfolio, making decisions based on uncompromised numbers and personal security is how you build
- 24:49
- Debbie Roberts: sustainable wealth. So if analyzing election housing policies, good lord, I can't wait for this election to be done, granny flat rules and demographic trends has made you realize that you need a clear, customized strategy for your own household, our team at Property Apprentice is here to help.
- 25:07
- Paul Roberts: Join us at our next free online training session, How to Succeed with Property Investing, hosted by Debbie. It's a two-hour two hour practical workshop. packed with market data, lending insights, and you can ask questions too.
- 25:20
- Debbie Roberts: Absolutely. And I'm thinking, based on the latest data, maybe we should also offer some w wealth creating women um segment series or something like that. So let me know in the in the notes below. You know, let it leave us a comment and let us know if you'd be interested in an event specifically targeted. towards women
- 25:40
- Debbie Roberts: in property. How cool would that be? I'll
- 25:42
- Paul Roberts: be on the coffee.
- 25:43
- Debbie Roberts: We could do that. Yeah, you could
- 25:45
- Debbie Roberts: keep me fed and watered. Excellent. All right. So make sure you register for one of our events. Go to website propertyapprentice.co.nz or click on the link below. And we'll see you next time. Thanks
- 25:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for
- 25:59
- Debbie Roberts: listening.
More from Property Apprentice Podcast
41,000 New Homes Consented & 54% Mortgage Repricing Cliff: What’s Next for NZ House Prices? | NZ Property Insights
Episode discussion: NZ hosts discuss mortgage repricing cliff, building consent surge, and regional demographic shifts
Speakers’ claims: Paul and Debbie Roberts analyze three key factors shaping New Zealand's property market: demographic shifts concentrating growth in specific corridors, a looming mortgage repricing cliff affecting over half of borrowers, and a surge in building consents potentially capping capital gains. They highlight that Wellington's population has declined due to public sector job losses, while aging homeowners are freezing migration chains by refusing to sell. The speakers warn that falling mortgage payments have masked rising living costs, and with 54% of mortgages repricing soon, household budgets will face significant pressure. Additionally, an 18% rise in building consents, particularly for standalone houses, suggests supply is outpacing demand, which may limit future price growth.
Why Australian Property Is Shifting (And Why NZ Is Set for an Upturn)
Episode discussion: NZ property upturn expected as Australia faces tax-driven stagnation and rate hikes
Speakers’ claims: Paul Roberts argues that New Zealand's property market is poised for an upturn driven by strong business confidence, returning migration, and geopolitical safety, contrasting it with Australia's stagnation. He notes the Reserve Bank of New Zealand held interest rates at 2.75%, surprising economists, while the Reserve Bank of Australia raised rates to 4.85%. Roberts attributes Australian market distress to upcoming tax changes, specifically the reduction of the capital gains tax discount and the removal of negative gearing. These policy shifts have stalled sales and forced record rent increases, prompting some Australian investors to seek higher yields in New Zealand. He highlights that first-time buyers now represent 30% of New Zealand mortgages and international student numbers are recovering, signaling underlying demand.