Property Apprentice Podcast

NZ property upturn expected as Australia faces tax-driven stagnation and rate hikes

16 min Listen to the original
New Zealand PropertyAustralian PropertyInterest RatesTax PolicyInvestment YieldsEconomic Indicators

Summary

Paul Roberts argues that New Zealand's property market is poised for an upturn driven by strong business confidence, returning migration, and geopolitical safety, contrasting it with Australia's stagnation. He notes the Reserve Bank of New Zealand held interest rates at 2.75%, surprising economists, while the Reserve Bank of Australia raised rates to 4.85%. Roberts attributes Australian market distress to upcoming tax changes, specifically the reduction of the capital gains tax discount and the removal of negative gearing. These policy shifts have stalled sales and forced record rent increases, prompting some Australian investors to seek higher yields in New Zealand. He highlights that first-time buyers now represent 30% of New Zealand mortgages and international student numbers are recovering, signaling underlying demand.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    The Reserve Bank of New Zealand held the Official Cash Rate at 2.75%, contradicting economist expectations of a hike to 3%.

    Paul Roberts · 1:07

  2. 2
    Australia's capital gains tax discount is scheduled to drop from 50% to 30-35% mid-next year.

    Paul Roberts · 6:26

  3. 3
    First-time buyers in New Zealand account for 30% of all mortgages, an unprecedented level.

    Paul Roberts · 14:33

Episode sections

  1. 0:06 – 2:39

    Intro and NZ Interest Rate Decision

    Paul Roberts introduces the episode, contrasting negative media sentiment with positive economic data. He notes the Reserve Bank of New Zealand held the OCR at 2.75%, surprising economists who expected a hike to 3%.

  2. 2:39 – 4:03

    NZ Business Confidence and Political Commentary

    Roberts highlights NZ business confidence at 53%, ranking 8th out of 82 countries globally. He cites the 'Mood of the Boardroom' survey showing the highest economic outlook in nine years, while mocking Prime Minister Chris Hipkins' dismissive comment about the 'smoker room'.

  3. 4:03 – 5:39

    Australia's Interest Rate Hike and Government Spending

    The Reserve Bank of Australia raised its cash rate to 4.85%. Roberts attributes this to historic government spending levels, claiming they are the highest since 1986 (excluding COVID), and contrasts this with NZ's lower rates.

  4. 5:39 – 7:25

    Australian Capital Gains Tax and Negative Gearing Changes

    Roberts explains upcoming Australian tax changes: the CGT discount dropping from 50% to 30-35% and the removal of negative gearing. He argues these changes, rather than the CGT itself, are causing investor distress.

  5. 7:25 – 11:15

    Impact on Australian Rental Market and Development

    Due to the loss of negative gearing, Australian landlords are raising rents at record levels, but sales have stalled. This lack of transaction volume is causing buyer agents and development firms to struggle or fail.

  6. 11:15 – 13:15

    Australian Investor Shift to New Zealand

    Roberts reports an uptick in Australian investors looking at NZ property to find higher yields to balance their Australian portfolios. He notes NZ has already experienced its downturn, making it attractive compared to Australia's current stagnation.

  7. 13:15 – 14:33

    NZ Economic Indicators and Population Trends

    Key indicators for NZ's upturn include international student numbers returning to over 90% of pre-pandemic levels and Kiwis returning from Australia due to job scarcity and high cost of living there. First-time buyers now represent 30% of mortgages.

  8. 14:33 – 16:08

    Geopolitical Stability and Conclusion

    Roberts positions NZ as a safe haven compared to unrest in the UK, France, and the US. He concludes that regardless of the election outcome, NZ is set for a property upturn driven by safety, skilled migration, and investor demand.

Claims worth verifying

The Reserve Bank of New Zealand held the official cash rate at 2.75%, surprising bank economists who expected a hike to 3%.

Paul Roberts ·1:07

How to verify: Check the Reserve Bank of New Zealand Monetary Policy Committee press release and OCR decision announcement for the relevant date in late 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

New Zealand business confidence is at 53%, ranking 8th out of 82 countries globally.

Paul Roberts ·2:59

How to verify: Search for the 'Mood of the Boardroom' survey results published by the New Zealand Institute of Economic Research (NZIER) or similar body, verifying the confidence index and global ranking. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The 'Mood of the Boardroom' survey reports the highest economic outlook in New Zealand in nine years.

Paul Roberts ·3:25

How to verify: Review the latest 'Mood of the Boardroom' survey publication for the specific outlook metric and historical comparison period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Prime Minister Chris Hipkins stated he looks at the 'smoker room' rather than the 'boardroom' when asked about business confidence.

Paul Roberts ·3:45

How to verify: Search news archives or parliamentary records for quotes from Chris Hipkins around the time of the survey release. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Reserve Bank of Australia raised its cash rate to 4.85%.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·4:03

How to verify: Check the Reserve Bank of Australia monetary policy meeting minutes and press release for the rate decision. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Australian government spending is the highest since 1986, excluding the COVID period.

Paul Roberts ·4:27

How to verify: Access Australian Treasury budget documents or historical public expenditure data to compare current spending levels with post-1986 figures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Australia is reducing the capital gains tax discount from 50% to 30-35% effective mid-next year.

Paul Roberts ·5:59

How to verify: Review Australian Federal Budget papers or legislation regarding tax reforms scheduled for implementation in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

New Zealand removed negative gearing in the 2019 tax year.

Paul Roberts ·7:05

How to verify: Check Inland Revenue New Zealand (IRD) tax legislation changes effective April 1, 2019, regarding rental property loss deductions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

First-time buyers account for 30% of all mortgages in New Zealand.

Paul Roberts ·14:33

How to verify: Analyze mortgage lending data from the Reserve Bank of New Zealand or major NZ banks (ANZ, ASB, BNZ, Kiwibank) for the relevant period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

International student numbers in New Zealand are back above 90% of pre-pandemic levels.

Paul Roberts ·13:32

How to verify: Check Ministry of Education or Immigration New Zealand data on international student enrollment compared to 2026 baselines. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the Reserve Bank of New Zealand's OCR decision and the specific date of the 2.75% hold against official RBNZ press releases.
  • Check the 'Mood of the Boardroom' survey methodology and current rankings to confirm New Zealand's business confidence position.
  • Review Australian Treasury data on government spending levels compared to historical records since 1986.
  • Confirm the legislative status and effective dates of the Australian Capital Gains Tax discount reduction and negative gearing removal.
  • Analyze Australian Bureau of Statistics data on rental price growth and dwelling sales volumes to assess market stagnation.
  • Assess New Zealand Immigration data on international student enrollment and net migration flows from Australia to the UK.
  • Review New Zealand Treasury or Reserve Bank data on first-time buyer mortgage shares to verify the 30% claim.
Full transcriptexpand
0:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hi
0:06
Paul Roberts: everyone, Paul here. Just thought I would put a video together because I've had a few people that have uh been coming to me, especially with what's going on with the media, which is all quite neighbor negative, as we uh pretty much tend to expect in New Zealand.
0:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
0:22
Paul Roberts: but I thought I'd put a bit of a spin on it that maybe some of you are not thinking about. Um obviously we've got the election coming up this weekend, and uh there's a few concerns. What happens if this, what happens with that? Well, so let's look at um a few stats, but also
0:41
Paul Roberts: let's compare what we have got. And I think this can be something that we forget a lot. You forget to remember the good stuff. Right. So media does a great job of uh telling us the bad stuff. So let's have a look at the good stuff. So I think obviously with the uh election, there's
1:01
Paul Roberts: um a lot going on. But let's uh and I've done this before where we've looked at
1:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
1:07
Paul Roberts: New Zealand versus Australia or other places in the world. So let's start with last week when we had our Reserve Bank Governor and the Monetary Policy Committee decided to leave the official cash rate at 2.75%, which for some people and a lot of bank economists was a bit of a shock
1:27
Paul Roberts: that they didn't increase it. But most of them were expecting it to increase to you know.25%, know, 0.25% up to 3%. Um, But there is movement there, which they definitely
1:39
Paul Roberts: um outlaid for them to move it further up later in the year. And if we look at the forecast going forward, they are expecting late 28 um for inflation to be back down where it should be, and then reduce it back down after this. So I think we are expecting it to be, you know,
1:59
Paul Roberts: three and a half, three, seven, five, four percent. Um uh at some point, but then it should start to come back. Because yes, inflation is is up a little bit, but if we took that fuel cost out of inflation, it would actually be very, very close to the to the higher end of the band at 3% of
2:19
Paul Roberts: uh uh between the two to three percent threshold that the uh RBMZ has to keep it at. So I think. the Reserve Bank Committee is more focused on people's people keeping people's costs down at the moment and looking at it can inflation at you know as we go forward from here. Now let's look on the other side of
2:39
Paul Roberts: the coin at business confidence. So business confidence is pretty much doing really well. It's it's really high. And a lot of people feel that the current government, you know. hasn't necessarily performed the way they expected, but business confidence is up, which is at the end of the day, the people that employ people.
2:59
Paul Roberts: So without businesses, you can't employ people. So it's at 53%.
3:05
Paul Roberts: On a world-class basis, with what we've got going And on in the in the world at the moment, we're about eighth out of 82 eighty-two countries. So we're doing very, very good. And if we look at the mood of the boardroom, which was a survey that came out recently, it's the highest economic outlook that we've had in
3:25
Paul Roberts: nine years. Now that you've got to say that's a good thing. Unfortunately, um, I think it was last week, we did actually have a comment from uh Chris Hipkins that he was asked, What do you think of the mood of the boardroom? And he said, I don't look at the boardroom, I look at the smoker room. What he
3:45
Paul Roberts: doesn't clearly get is there would be no smoker room without a boardroom.
3:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
3:50
Paul Roberts: but hey, let's move on and let's look at what happened yesterday in Australia. So, yes, we had the Melbourne Cup, Up, which was great. I I got the winner, which was good. Um got 90 bucks. Ooh.
4:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
4:03
Paul Roberts: but also we had the uh Reserve Bank of Australia increase their official cash rate. So their OCR went up to wait for it, 4.85%. So as this 275, there's this 4.85. Now the Labour government there
4:22
Paul Roberts: has continued to spend like there is no tomorrow.
4:27
Paul Roberts: It is currently as of this week, excluding the COVID period, the highest government spending since 1986.
4:39
Paul Roberts: Just let that sink in. Okay, we could have a change of government and similar thing could happen here. I think they would get smashed, and um they have said they won't. So, you know, and and put into perspective, everyone's like, well, what if there's a capital gains tax? There's always going to be a capital gains tax at some point in New
4:59
Paul Roberts: Zealand. There is already one. It's called the Bright Line Test. And it was, it's currently two years, it was five years, it was ten years, it's back to two. Things can get tweaked, you know, discounts can be applied, like in Australia. So things will change and evolve over time. It is just what it is. And I think, you know, at some point there's always gonna there's going to be
5:19
Paul Roberts: one here. And we and we sort of do have one. And you can't have the Brightline test and a capital gains taxes, one or the other. So now let's just remember, let's go back to Australia, the property market over there, due to the tax changes that the government there is bringing in that take effect mid next year. Now let's remember that in Australia
5:39
Paul Roberts: they've always had a capital gains tax. I don't believe that that tax will, you know, it hasn't stopped people from investing in Australia like it wouldn't here. But of course, be careful who you vote for. But due to the capital gains tax um over there, the changes that are coming is currently if you buy a
5:59
Paul Roberts: property, uh, a rental property, and you sell it within a year, you have to pay
6:06
Paul Roberts: 100% of the profit. You pay a portion of that in tax, usually your your income tax rate. But after a year, currently you can deduct that uh amount of tax that you pay, the profit part, um, down to 50%. So if you made 100 grand, you only pay tax on the 50 grand, not the
6:26
Paul Roberts: whole hundred. 100 grand. Now that is changing in Australia come mid next year to be around 30, 35% discount instead of a 50% discount, which is quite a lot. So instead of you getting after a year of 50% discount on the tax that you pay, you you're still you're gonna be paying sort of 75-ish percent or
6:46
Paul Roberts: 70% of the tax um t for the for the government. Now, the kicker over there, that I don't think is so much of an issue. The kicker is negative gearing. So if you remember back, um our previous Labour government got rid of negative gearing back in uh
7:05
Paul Roberts: 2019. I think it was the tax year, 1st of April. Um, and that basically meant that we couldn't offset um any of the losses. from rental income producing stuff against our personal taxable income. So we couldn't do that since 2019. We can't do it now.
7:25
Paul Roberts: I know that ACT is talking about wanting to bring it back. So that's a policy they would like. Of course, coalition talks for that, uh if that ever happens. But in Australia, it has been a fundamental way of retirement is offset as much of your taxable income personal
7:45
Paul Roberts: against rental property. So that has meant that on purpose in Australia, they've all bought really bad negative gear properties. You know, gross returns of three percent is is is a good one, you know. And I think that is where the they're gonna they are coming unstuck because that's no
8:05
Paul Roberts: longer going to be the case come mid next year. So what we're now seeing in Australia is most uh investors are increasing their rents. Does this sound a little familiar? So they're increasing their rents at amounts that have never been seen before. And now, uh so it's the
8:25
Paul Roberts: uh across Australia highest. rental increases ever. And nobody is selling. So, regardless of the capital gains tax discount here or there, I don't think that's so much of the issue because they're used to paying tax on the profit. So, yes, it's been tweaked by 15-ish percent uh in the favor of the
8:45
Paul Roberts: government, but that's not the problem. Like Amanda our accountant, canton has always said, you know. if you didn't invest and there was a capital gains tax, then you get 0% of zero because you didn't do anything. But if you got, let's say it was 30%, if you got 70% of something and you had to pay tax on
9:05
Paul Roberts: 30%, well, at least you got the 70% if you made profit, right? So that's pretty standard with any transaction, really. And obviously, there's the bright Brightline test as well. So I don't think that's ever going to be a thing that people go, no, I'm never going to invest again because of a capital gains tax. But their
9:25
Paul Roberts: yields over there, they've on purpose bought really negative gear properties, which means that, hey, I'm not going to get, I'm going to pay more capital gains tax. But come mid-next mid next year, everything I was offsetting, I can no longer offset.
9:39
Paul Roberts: That is the killer. So it's meant that nobody is selling. Everybody's just sitting back and going, We need Albanese out and we're not going to sell. We're not going to give him any money. And basically, buyers agents, real estate agents are going out of business over there because they're not selling or buying
9:59
Paul Roberts: properties, which means the demand for building more. houses is going out of business. So we've got development companies over there that are going under.
10:09
Paul Roberts: And, you know, overall, I think it's around $80 billion worth of taxes that the government has brought
10:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in.
10:18
Paul Roberts: While they've been on this amazing spending spree, and I did see I was following a Senator Andrew Brown. Bragg, who's the senator over
10:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there.
10:29
Paul Roberts: And he was saying that there was $10 billion worth of spending and there was nothing to show for it. Again, sounds familiar. But you know, Australia's always been called the lucky country. And, you know, as far as we can look back back to the 80s, it's never really had a massive property downturn. So we
10:49
Paul Roberts: do have our ups and downs. We're a smaller country, smaller amount of people.
10:54
Paul Roberts: And you know, Australia is backed by mining. You know, it's just the it just boom, boom, boom. Whereas now I think we are going to see that difference. And a lot of the um media in Australia um are talking about you know the biggest downturn in history. So
11:14
Paul Roberts: this
11:15
Paul Roberts: I think, flipped this round, and this is a positive thing for New Zealand. So let me explain. Debbie and I um recently met with an Australian investor who uh we caught up with, and uh he was over here checking some stuff out and a bit on a holiday.
11:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
11:33
Paul Roberts: and you know,
11:35
Paul Roberts: they um him and also in our three events. we're getting more Australian people coming along. And I think we're going to see an uptick in investors from Australia investing here. Because if you look at it across a portfolio, they can get better
11:54
Paul Roberts: higher yields in New Zealand to balance off their negative stuff in Australia. So I think there is going to be this change of attitude and also this change of investors coming to New Zealand wanting to buy more and more property. So
12:15
Paul Roberts: in one shape or form, if we uh have a capital gains tax in Australia, in New Zealand, we just get used to it. But the returns that they can achieve here are far greater than what they could. get. So for them, they see it it's a different market, it's a different economy. We've already had our downturn. And
12:34
Paul Roberts: regardless of the government makeup after the weekend, business sentiment is really good.
12:41
Paul Roberts: The economy is getting better. We're due for our upturn. Like you look at all of the bank economists, the Reserve Bank governor, everybody's going tick, tick, tick, tick, tick. growth next year, year after, year after. Even Chippey wouldn't be having a capital gains tax. Um, you know, he's not going to make any money if there's no growth. So, you know, they've already
13:01
Paul Roberts: banked that in if they get in, don't forget. And although we still have our election to get out of the way, at some point that too shall pass. And so will Trump's war in Iran.
13:15
Paul Roberts: When we start to see these things get ticked off, it's the starting point of the upturn in the property cycle that we will get over the next few years. We're already seeing international students. Remember, there was like a real
13:32
Paul Roberts: supply of international students a few years ago. We're back at over 90% levels of international students. Now, why do you think that is? And we're also seeing people that Kiwis that left New Zealand go to Australia are coming back. Because if they couldn't get a job, you can't go on the dole, you're not going to get paid. You know, they're not
13:52
Paul Roberts: going to do that if you're a New Zealander. And so, and the cost of living is, you know, the gas prices, power, everything's going up through the roof there as well. So it is cheaper here, whether you like it or not. So none of us, regardless of the election outcome, are going to jump on a plane and go to Australia because
14:12
Paul Roberts: it's the better place. Because it isn't, you know. And I think that we are in this perfect position now where we've got international students back. We're going to see more investors coming. into this market. First-time buyers are at the top of the list of the most
14:33
Paul Roberts: buyers in the New Zealand market at the moment, which is amazing. I think it's like 30% of all mortgages, which is unheard of. And then let's look at everywhere else. So you've got America, you've got Europe, you've and let's think about that. We've got riots in the UK, we've got riots. in France, we've got, you know,
14:53
Paul Roberts: Donald Trump going nuts in us in America, we've got the Iran conflict. Where would you want to send and and we you know we've had riots in Australia as well. Where would you want to send your kids if they were going overseas to, you know, study? New Zealand. It's one of the safest places. And we
15:13
Paul Roberts: don't have that stuff. that the UK and France and parts of Europe are all going through right now. So you would much rather be in New Zealand than America or Australia. And I think it's part of New Zealand's growth that more skilled people will come as well as students simply
15:33
Paul Roberts: for those reasons. So I think in a nutshell, we're actually set for quite a few. amazing years. And none of us, regardless of the election result, are going to jump shit, like I say, to Australia. I think you'll find more people that did that will start coming home.
15:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
15:50
Paul Roberts: I think we need to stop listening to the doom and gloom because we all have the same opportunities in life. And it's time to short sort your future.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Property Apprentice Podcast

Property Apprentice Podcast

41,000 New Homes Consented & 54% Mortgage Repricing Cliff: What’s Next for NZ House Prices? | NZ Property Insights

Episode discussion: NZ hosts discuss mortgage repricing cliff, building consent surge, and regional demographic shifts

Speakers’ claims: Paul and Debbie Roberts analyze three key factors shaping New Zealand's property market: demographic shifts concentrating growth in specific corridors, a looming mortgage repricing cliff affecting over half of borrowers, and a surge in building consents potentially capping capital gains. They highlight that Wellington's population has declined due to public sector job losses, while aging homeowners are freezing migration chains by refusing to sell. The speakers warn that falling mortgage payments have masked rising living costs, and with 54% of mortgages repricing soon, household budgets will face significant pressure. Additionally, an 18% rise in building consents, particularly for standalone houses, suggests supply is outpacing demand, which may limit future price growth.

New Zealand PropertyMortgage RatesDemographics
23 min0 assets10 claims to verify
Property Apprentice Podcast

The $300k First Home Loan Catch, Tiny Home Lending Truths & Who’s Winning NZ Property | NZ Property Insights

Episode discussion: NZ Property Policy Analysis: $300k Income Cap, Tiny Home Lending, and Demographic Ownership Trends

Speakers’ claims: Paul and Debbie Roberts discuss New Zealand's housing policy landscape, focusing on Labour's rent-to-buy scheme and the proposed $300,000 income cap for first-home loans. They critique the affordability of these measures, noting that higher income caps allow larger mortgages that require rigorous stress-testing at 7-7.5% interest rates. The hosts also analyze National's policies on tiny homes and senior housing, warning that tiny homes on wheels are legally vehicles ineligible for standard mortgages. Finally, they examine Stats NZ census data revealing that women outpace men in home ownership under age 70, attributing this to differing investment priorities.

New Zealand PropertyHousing PolicyFirst Home Loans
26 min0 assets9 claims to verify
All insights