Personal Finance for Long-Term Investors

History of American Retirement: From Industrial Pensions to 401(k)s and FIRE

50 min Listen to the original Episode page
Social Security401(k)Retirement HistoryIndex InvestingFIRE MovementPensionsMedicareERISA

Summary

Jesse Kramer traces the evolution of retirement from pre-industrial family support to the modern self-directed model. He explains how the Industrial Revolution and Great Depression led to Social Security and corporate pensions, while the 1970s saw a shift to 401(k)s and individual responsibility. The episode highlights the rise of low-cost index investing, the FIRE movement, and current challenges like Social Security funding and high-fee annuities.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Social Security trustees project trust fund depletion by the mid-2030s, after which incoming taxes would cover only 80% of benefits.

    Jesse Kramer · 18:35

  2. 2
    The Pension Protection Act of 2006 encouraged automatic enrollment and default investments into target date funds.

    Jesse Kramer · 38:31

Episode sections

  1. 0:23 – 7:37

    Pre-Industrial Retirement and Early Support Systems

    Jesse Kramer explains that before the Industrial Revolution, retirement was a gradual tapering of work. Support relied on family, community poor relief, or almshouses, which carried social stigma.

  2. 7:37 – 10:54

    The Industrial Revolution and Corporate Pensions

    The Industrial Revolution shifted work to rigid factory pace, making older workers less efficient. Employers introduced early corporate pensions to manage morale and retain loyalty.

  3. 10:54 – 21:46

    The Great Depression and Social Security

    The Great Depression destroyed private savings and pensions, leading to the 1935 Social Security Act. This established age 65 as the standard retirement age and created a pay-as-you-go system.

  4. 21:46 – 24:45

    Post-War Prosperity and the Golden Age of Retirement

    From the 1940s to 1970s, rising home ownership and strong economic growth made retirement a period of leisure. Planned communities like Sun City, Arizona, popularized active retirement.

  5. 24:45 – 30:23

    The Collapse of Private Pensions and Rise of 401(k)s

    The Studebaker pension collapse exposed risks of underfunded defined benefit plans, leading to ERISA and IRAs. The Revenue Act of 1978 introduced Section 401(k), shifting risk to employees.

  6. 30:23 – 37:11

    Medicare and Healthcare in Retirement

    Medicare, signed in 1965, eliminated catastrophic healthcare risk for seniors. Part A is funded by payroll taxes, and age 65 remains a key anchor for retirement planning.

  7. 37:11 – 38:31

    Shift to Self-Directed Retirement and Low-Cost Investing

    Since the late 1970s, responsibility for retirement has shifted to individuals. Vanguard launched the first retail index fund in 1976, and brokerages eliminated trading commissions in 2019.

  8. 38:31 – 40:10

    Automatic Investing and Financial Advice Evolution

    The Pension Protection Act of 2006 encouraged automatic enrollment into target date funds. The profession has matured with a rise in fee-only fiduciary advisors.

  9. 40:10 – 41:45

    Conflicts of Interest and Private Equity in 401(k)s

    Kramer identifies perverse incentives in self-directed retirement, such as target date funds favoring in-house products. An August 2025 executive order directed regulators to make private equity easier to offer in 401(k)s.

  10. 41:45 – 42:44

    Rollover Pitches and High-Fee Annuities

    The transcript highlights issues like rollover pitches moving balances to higher-fee IRAs. It criticizes high-fee, high-commission annuities sold through high-pressure tactics.

  11. 42:44 – 45:24

    The Bogleheads and FIRE Movements

    Kramer describes the Bogleheads community and traces the FIRE movement to 'Your Money or Your Life' and Bill Bengen’s 4% rule research, popularized by J.L. Collins’ 2016 book.

  12. 45:24 – 46:43

    Rising Labor Force Participation Among Seniors

    Labor force participation among those over 65 has risen from one in six in the mid-1980s to one in five today, attributed to fewer pensions and the need to build savings.

  13. 46:43 – 47:43

    Current Retirement Landscape Summary

    Kramer summarizes the 2026 landscape: Social Security remains a backbone but faces funding cracks; 401(k)s are the main vehicle; many lack employer plans; and home equity is a major hidden asset.

  14. 47:43 – 49:42

    Demographic Pressures and Savings Inequality

    Median retirement account balances are low despite high averages. The 'peak 65' demographic wave puts pressure on Social Security, while longer lifespans increase the risk of running out of money.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
General Motors CoGMequityneutralI'll go with General Motors. The joke was that by the 2000s, GM was little more than a giant

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

In the late 1800s, there was a 95% chance a person aged 55-65 was still working.

Jesse Kramer ·1:12

How to verify: U.S. Census Bureau historical labor force participation data for the late 19th century. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Dr. Francis Townsend proposed paying $200/month to Americans over 60 who stopped working, funded by a 2% national sales tax.

Jesse Kramer ·12:57

How to verify: Historical records of the Townsend Movement and congressional petitions from 1935-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The average monthly wage in 1935 was $100.

Jesse Kramer ·13:17

How to verify: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics historical wage data or Federal Reserve economic data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Social Security Act of 1935 established age 65 as the standard retirement age.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·14:03

How to verify: Text of the Social Security Act of 2026 (Public Law 74-271). For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Starting in 1937, workers and employers paid a 1% payroll tax on the first $3,000 of annual wages for Social Security.

Jesse Kramer ·14:22

How to verify: Social Security Administration historical tax rate tables. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

In 1950, the ratio of Social Security workers to retirees was 16 to 1.

Jesse Kramer ·17:15

How to verify: Social Security Administration Historical Summary Book or OASDI Trustees Reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Social Security trust funds are projected to be depleted by the mid-2030s.

Jesse Kramer ·18:35

How to verify: Social Security Administration OASDI Trustees Reports (e.g., 2026 or 2026 report). For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Studebaker Corporation closed its South Bend plant in 1963, leading to a pension collapse.

Jesse Kramer ·26:45

How to verify: Historical records of Studebaker Corporation bankruptcy and pension termination filings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

ERISA created the Individual Retirement Account (IRA).

Jesse Kramer ·28:44

How to verify: Text of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 2026 (ERISA), specifically provisions regarding IRAs. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Medicare was signed into law in 1965 as part of the Great Society legislation.

Jesse Kramer ·31:23

How to verify: Public Law 89-97, signed by President Lyndon B. Johnson on July 30, 1965. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Vanguard launched the first retail index fund in 1976.

Jesse Kramer ·37:51

How to verify: Check Vanguard's corporate history or historical prospectus archives for the launch date of the Vanguard 500 Index Fund (VFINX). For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Most major brokerages eliminated trading commissions altogether in 2019.

Jesse Kramer ·38:11

How to verify: Check press releases from major brokerages (e.g., Charles Schwab, Fidelity, E*TRADE) announcing zero-commission trading in early 2019. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Pension Protection Act of 2006 encouraged automatic enrollment and default investments into target date funds.

Jesse Kramer ·38:50

How to verify: Read the text of the Pension Protection Act of 2026 (Public Law 109-280) on Congress.gov or the Department of Labor website. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

An August 2025 executive order directed regulators to make private equity and other alternatives easier to offer in 401(k) plans.

Jesse Kramer ·40:30

How to verify: Search the Federal Register or White House archives for an Executive Order issued in August 2025 regarding retirement plan investments. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Bill Bengen’s research in the early 1990s suggested a 4% withdrawal rate.

Jesse Kramer ·44:04

How to verify: Locate Bill Bengen's 2026 article 'Withdrawal Rates During Retirement' in The Journal of Retirement or similar academic publications. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Trinity study in the late 1990s reached a similar conclusion to Bengen's research.

Jesse Kramer ·44:24

How to verify: Find the 2026 study 'Using Endowment Returns for Optimal Retirement Portfolios' by William Bengen, Michael Kitces, and Michael Steinmann. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

J.L. Collins' book 'The Simple Path to Wealth' was published in 2016.

Jesse Kramer ·44:44

How to verify: Check Amazon or publisher records for the publication date of 'The Simple Path to Wealth' by J.L. Collins. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Only about one in six people over age 65 were working in the mid-1980s.

Jesse Kramer ·45:44

How to verify: Check U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) historical labor force participation data for the 65+ age group for the mid-1980s. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Labor force participation today among people 65 and older has risen to about one in five.

Jesse Kramer ·46:04

How to verify: Check current U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) labor force participation rates for the 65+ age group. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify Social Security trust fund depletion projections in the latest SSA Trustees Report.
  • Check ERISA regulations and Studebaker pension case details for defined benefit plan risks.
  • Review Vanguard’s 1976 prospectus for the first retail index fund to confirm historical claims.
  • Examine the Pension Protection Act of 2006 text for automatic enrollment provisions.
  • Analyze current 401(k) fee disclosures for private equity and alternative asset offerings.
  • Compare fee-only fiduciary advisor costs against commission-based annuity products.
  • Research Bill Bengen’s 1994 study and the Trinity Study for 4% rule assumptions.
  • Check median vs. average retirement account balances using Federal Reserve Survey of Consumer Finances data.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): To
0:01
Jesse Kramer: many of us, the act of retirement feels like a ubiquitous rite of passage, but that has certainly not always been the case. So, how did we get here? And why did we get here? And why does that matter to you listening right now? Today, we're diving into the history of retirement to help explain how the modern retirement landscape came to be.
0:20
Jesse Kramer: Welcome to Personal Finance for Long-Term Long Term Investors, where every episode teaches you personal finance and long-term investment. investing in simple terms. Now, here's your host, Jesse Kramer.
0:32
Jesse Kramer: Welcome to Personal Finance for Long Term Investors, episode 156. I'm Jesse Kramer. I'm a financial planner. I work with retirees and people getting ready for retirement from all across the USA. If you're looking for retirement planning help, learn more at planwithjesse.com. Our review of the week is from Scrambled Eggs, who left a five-star review. on Apple Podcasts and who
0:52
Jesse Kramer: said they always come away with something useful. I'm glad you like this podcast, Scrambled Eggs, and thank you for the rating and review. Please send me an email to jessie at bestinterest.blog and I'll get a super soft t-shirt mailed out to you. Now, on with the episode. Imagine you're in the late 1800s 1900s here in the US. Now, if that's the case, there's
1:12
Jesse Kramer: a 50% chance that you work in agriculture. There's a 20% chance you work in manufacturing and construction, a 15% chance you work in a field that's adjacent to utilities and transportation, a la the railroad system. And there's a 0% chance you work as a podcaster or computer programmer, probably a 0.01% chance you
1:32
Jesse Kramer: work as a financial planner. I'm assuming there were some tax accountants and stuff like that back then. But point is, and perhaps what's most interesting, or at least more interesting, in the late 1800s, if you're between the age of 55 and 65, there's a 95% chance that you're still working. If you're over age 65, there's an 80%
1:52
Jesse Kramer: chance that you're still working. Now, this is 130, 140 years ago. And the idea that a large number, a large proportion of people in their late 50s and in their 60s, the idea that these people would be retired, that's just a non existent idea. The concept of broad retirement across society was a
2:11
Jesse Kramer: brand new idea, just barely growing, and far from a widespread idea in the late 1800s. So, what changed from then until now? How did we get to this point where retirement feels like a given or it feels like a thing that everybody does, that everybody prepares for, that everybody assumes they're eventually going to achieve.
2:31
Jesse Kramer: What changed? How did it change? Why and when did it change for us to get here to where we are today? So we'll work through this episode in a few different acts. And the first act is the pre industrial revolution. Throughout most of history, not just American history, but most of history, there was no single moment in a person's life when
2:51
Jesse Kramer: work simply ended. A typical example in early America, a farmer might gradually hand the heaviest labor to his sons or other heirs. And then that elderly farmer would focus on lighter tasks or management of the farm, giving advice. A crafts person might rely more on apprentices
3:11
Jesse Kramer: as they age. Older women might continue with how. household production and childcare and nursing the sick. And work would taper off, but it would do so in step with the body's physical ability to keep up. It had very little to do with the actual calendar age of a person in common. A common practice throughout much of earlier American history,
3:31
Jesse Kramer: with roots dating back to England and Western Europe, was the practice where an aging parent might transfer their land or their property. or other assets to one of their heirs in exchange for a written promise of future care. It was essentially a private family-based version of a retirement plan, an exchange of property for future support.
3:51
Jesse Kramer: It almost reminds me of the way that annuities are structured today. It's an exchange of an asset right now in exchange for a stream of future support. So it's similar in that way. It's a family-sponsored. insurance product in a way. But what about when someone was truly too feeble to continue working? This is going back again. This is the
4:11
Jesse Kramer: pre-industrial revolution. The first line of support for that person was family. English law, which carried into the colonies here in the USA, made adult children largely legally responsible for supporting their parents who couldn't support themselves. Most older people lived with or very near to their own biological families, and the household or
4:31
Jesse Kramer: the family unit absorbed their care as they aged. When the family was absent or unable to help, though, oftentimes the town would step in through local poor relief or poverty relief. This might have taken different forms. Some people received food or fuel or small sums of money while staying in their own homes. Other elderly people
4:51
Jesse Kramer: would receive a rented room with a neighboring family at the town's expense, so it's community support. As towns grew, these things called an alms house became more and more common. And by the 19th century, many towns or cities or counties operated poor farms, which were a place of stigma, as it were. A lot of our, maybe I'll call
5:11
Jesse Kramer: it American way of thinking, so to speak, dates back to Puritan philosophy. And one aspect of Puritan philosophy is that poverty is less an economic issue, but is actually more of a character flaw caused by vice and laziness and lack of discipline. And of course, that's up for debate. But that is why that mindset still percolates
5:30
Jesse Kramer: through American culture. Getting back to today's episode, for for someone in the 1800s to enter a poor farm or an almshouse alms house, is. it meant publicly surrendering their own independence, sure, but it also meant declaring themselves a bit of a pauper. It meant declaring that they were poor, and therefore admitting their own moral failure. So
5:50
Jesse Kramer: it was a pretty consequential and negative part of growing old back in the day. But there were other societal support systems outside of the almshouse or the poor farm. These systems of relief were almost always strictly local. They were often town and county based. But the incentives drive outcomes, drive behavior. And if
6:10
Jesse Kramer: your town is charged in some way with supporting elderly poor people as they fade out of being able to work, that these towns would often guard against having to support people if they could help it. And they would certainly guard against supporting outsiders. So an old older person's fate depended heavily on whether they belonged to the
6:30
Jesse Kramer: community, and practices like charity from a church, or mutual aid from neighbors, or maybe a military service pension, like the one that was offered to some Revolutionary War veterans, these were early signs of a public retirement support, and these signs would would grow and mature into future programs that are more reminiscent of what we are used to
6:50
Jesse Kramer: today. Now, the word retire itself was part of the lexicon in the 1700s and 1800s, but it had a very specific connotation that mainly dealt with the wealthy. To retire meant to voluntarily withdraw from public life, like the way that George Washington retired to his estate at Mount Vernon, this kind of
7:09
Jesse Kramer: classic idea of a dignified old age. The normal people, the 99%, did not get to retire, certainly not in any sort of dignified way. Instead, they might reach a particular threshold in life when they were no longer physically productive enough to support themselves and had to become dependent on other people. So
7:29
Jesse Kramer: pre-industrial old age was really defined by physical capability. You worked until you couldn't, and then you had to rely on family or charity.
7:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But that
7:38
Jesse Kramer: brings us to. Act Two today, which is when the Industrial Revolution starts to change everything. And as far as when this was, this, you know, the decades, this is the 1870s through probably the 1920s here for Act Two. Retirement as we see it today emerged from a series of events that began with the Industrial Revolution. The work inside of
7:57
Jesse Kramer: factories and mills and forges and manufacturing facilities valued speed. and stamina in its workers. And older workers were increasingly seen as less and less efficient than their younger counterparts. As we already talked about, on the farm, let's say, an aging father could shift to lighter
8:17
Jesse Kramer: physical chores and still contribute to the farm. Not to mention on the farm that the owners would call their own shots about how they worked because farming was a very solopreneurial. pursuit, for lack of a better term. But on the factory floor, there was no sort of gentle slope as one aged. The job was often defined by the pace of the machine
8:37
Jesse Kramer: itself. Even if this is pre Henry Ford, there's still this idea of assembly processes, assembly lines in a manner of speaking. And anyone who couldn't keep up was replaceable. By the early 1900s, there was even a so called so-called efficient. efficiency movement encouraging the managers of these factories to measure every motion that a worker made. And
8:57
Jesse Kramer: older employees often came out looking slower and costlier on paper, regardless of their experience or judgment. And then also, the late 1800s and early 1900s saw certain cultural shifts that moved against the way that elderly people were perceived. Certain circles of medicine even began. framing old age as a
9:16
Jesse Kramer: pathology, almost like a disease, that it was that negative in some circles. So these big changes due to the Industrial Revolution and some cultural changes in the late 1800s presented a problem to employers. To fire a long-serving employee, it was just bad for the rest of the workforce's morale. It kind
9:36
Jesse Kramer: of set this precedent where everyone could see it come. coming. As they aged, they knew they were gonna get the boot out the door. But to keep on an older and inefficient employee was bad for business. And this is where the corporate retirement pension, or at least some sort of corporate business retirement benefit, became one possible solution. So
9:56
Jesse Kramer: railroads and utilities and large manufacturers began to promise a modest income to their workers who reached a certain age or who reached a certain length of service. And this allowed companies to provide a dignified off ramp to their older employees while also rewarding those people for their longtime loyalty and also
10:15
Jesse Kramer: simultaneously discouraging younger workers from quitting or striking or doing anything negative against the company, encouraging them to become longtime employees themselves. This idea of this corporate pension. that some companies began to introduce in the late 1800s, this is one of those first signs of retirement as we know it. And this idea began as a
10:35
Jesse Kramer: management tool for the companies to better manage themselves, to better manage their employees, to ensure that they maintained their efficiency as a business while also not leaving their longtime employees out in the cold. However, a national economic catastrophe would then transform retirement into something far more
10:54
Jesse Kramer: universal. That brings us to Act Three, the Great Depression, and Social Security. So now we're fast forwarding to the 1930s. This next major act in the development of retirement in America was the Great Depression. As with many such changes in the world in general, it took this giant negative event to open our eyes to the reality.
11:14
Jesse Kramer: realities of our society and to influence a sweeping change.
11:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
11:18
Jesse Kramer: Great Depression turned retirement from a privilege enjoyed by a relatively fortunate few into, instead, a national policy goal, and it did so largely by exposing just how fragile older Americans' security had been. Before 1929, most elderly people relied on a combination of
11:38
Jesse Kramer: continuous. continuing to work as long as they possibly could, saving money along the way, and then, for many of them, some continued support from their children. The private pensions that we did mention a minute ago that began in the late 1800s, I mean, they existed, but they certainly weren't widespread. The Great Depression really disintegrated these different
11:58
Jesse Kramer: pillars of support all at the same time. Employment, savings, and support. from children, they all began to fail. Unemployment during the Great Depression reached 25% by 1933, and older workers were often the first ones let go and the last ones rehired. Then, thousands of
12:17
Jesse Kramer: bank failures across the USA wiped out savings. Remember, this is before the FDIC insurance. And then adult children struggling to support their own health. households, had far less money to spare for their aging parents. Many of the employer pension plans that did exist were cut back or collapsed as companies failed, showing workers
12:37
Jesse Kramer: that a private promise was only as good as the company that stood behind that promise. All of these different negative things, all happening all at once, gave rise to a powerful political movement. In 1933, a gentleman named Dr. Francis Townsend proposed paying every American over age 60 a generous
12:57
Jesse Kramer: monthly pension on the condition that they stop working and spend the money quickly. This original proposal was that if someone agreed to immediately stop working over the age of 60, they would begin receiving $200 a month that they must spend within the next 30 days. And for reference, the average monthly wage in 1935. was only $100 per month. So
13:17
Jesse Kramer: this Townsend pension system would pay the elderly people more than double the national monthly wage. These proposed pensions would be funded by a 2% national sales tax. And at one point in 1936, Dr. Townsend was able to deliver petitions to Congress containing more than 10 million signatures in support of his
13:37
Jesse Kramer: Townsend planned. Plant. So public opinion surveys in 1935 found that 56% of Americans favored adoption of the Townsend Plant. Now, the Townsend Plan had some major flaws, some dealing with basic arithmetic, others dealing with economic theory, but the idea itself of a public pension had
13:57
Jesse Kramer: major appeal. And that directly led to the Social Security Act of 1935.
14:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
14:03
Jesse Kramer: Social Security Act of 1935 shaped the modern idea of retirement in many lasting ways. Firstly, it established age 65 as the standard retirement age in the public mind. The centerpiece of the Social Security Act, which is old age insurance, was a contributory system, still is. Starting in
14:22
Jesse Kramer: 1937, the the workers covered by Social Security and their employees, employers each paid a 1% payroll tax on the first $3,000 of their annual wages. Workers who reached age 65 would then receive monthly benefits based on their total covered earnings. At first, coverage was only limited to workers in commerce
14:42
Jesse Kramer: and industry. For uh agricultural workers and domestic workers and government employees and some others were excluded, the system would evolve and expand over time. Because the original Social Security system would take years to build up its funding, the Social Security Act also created this old age assistance program, which provided federal funds to different
15:02
Jesse Kramer: states that paid out a means-tested pension to specifically needy elderly people, and that offered people immediate relief in the late 1930s. And the Social Security Act also established a federal slash staff. state unemployment insurance system, aid to dependent children, and grants for public health and services for disabled
15:22
Jesse Kramer: children. So the Great Depression and the Social Security Act and all these societal changes that occurred established a new expectation: the expectation that ordinary workers should be able to stop working at a predictable age and live on a guaranteed income based on a pension system that nearly everybody. pays into, and that if you pay into it, you would
15:42
Jesse Kramer: get a benefit later in life. That expectation expanded after World War II through employer pensions and broader Social Security coverage, becoming the foundation of retirement as Americans understood it for many decades, and to some extent, as they still understand it today. Let me pause here for a really quick side note about the Social Security system, a
16:01
Jesse Kramer: common misconception. about Social Security and the health of the system today has to do with longevity. The misconception is that back in the 1940s, people didn't live that long. And thus Social Security today wasn't designed for all these people living into their 80s. And while it's true that life expectancy back in the 40s and 50s was lower than it is
16:21
Jesse Kramer: today, the main reason why it was lower then is due to childhood mortality. In other words, if you reached age 65 back in the 1940s, your remaining life expectancy is reasonably similar, or would have been reasonably similar, to someone who reaches age 65 today. It's a little bit longer today, but it's at least similar. Instead, the
16:41
Jesse Kramer: biggest difference, the thing that is putting the most stress on today's social security system, is the ratio of workers to retirees. Social Security is mostly a pay as you go system. Today's workers fund today's retirees. I'll say that again. Today's workers and the contributions they're making week over
17:01
Jesse Kramer: week and month over month, those contributions are what's funding today's retirees who are taking money out of the system. Money that goes into the Social Security pot immediately comes back out of the pot. Somewhere between 70% and 80% of today's social security.
17:15
Jesse Kramer: checks are funded by the same exact money that the rest of us are paying in our 2026 payroll taxes. And this fact means that the ratio of workers to beneficiaries is a very crucial ratio. In 1950, that ratio was about 16 to 1, 16 workers for every one retiree. And that ratio was
17:35
Jesse Kramer: roughly five to one by 1960. It's now on under three to one, and it's heading toward two to one. It's heading toward two workers for every one beneficiary. And yes, longer lives are part of that reason, but the main reason has to do with the very large baby boomer generation. And then after that, the falling birth
17:55
Jesse Kramer: rates that get us toward today. And that shrinks the future workforce. So, in summary, we have more. retirees than ever before, and we have a smaller workforce, or at least not enough people in the workforce paying into the system to fully support the outflows. I suppose you could say that wage inequality might also play a
18:15
Jesse Kramer: role because earnings above the taxable maximum, well, they aren't taxed. So a growing share of national wages actually escape the Social Security payroll tax. That plays a smaller role. too. The system already adjusted once for this fact. In 1983, the amendments to the Social Security system gradually raised the full
18:35
Jesse Kramer: retirement age from 65 to 67. But despite that fact, even so, the trustees have projected, as you might already know, that the combined trust funds behind Social Security will be depleted by the mid-2030s, after which incoming taxes would cover about 80% of the outgoing benefits, meaning that the remaining 20%
18:55
Jesse Kramer: of outgoing benefits would be unfunded, and that would be a bad outcome. We've talked about this idea here before on the podcast, and you might have heard it discussed elsewhere. The idea that Social Security is going to quote unquote collapse in the mid-2030s is just a misunderstanding Understanding of the facts. However, it is true that under current projections, the full promise will not be met. And instead
19:15
Jesse Kramer: of people getting 100% of what they're promised, they'll only get 80% of what they're promised. Again, not a good outcome. Now, there are many different ideas for addressing this issue, and those proposals generally fall into a few different categories. One idea is to raise the retirement age further above age 67 or index it in some way automatically to life
19:35
Jesse Kramer: expectancy. Critics of this idea would point out that longevity gains, they go disproportionately to higher earners. So that a higher Social Security age effectively cuts benefits for lower income workers and people in physically demanding jobs. And really, I guess put another way, here in the United States, people who earn more money
19:55
Jesse Kramer: are more likely to live longer. People who earn less money are likely to die sooner. Thus, increasing the retirement age of social security. Security will disproportionately hurt people who are likely to die sooner, the people who are already earning less money. So, as a social policy, that is a major problem. A second idea to fix the system is
20:15
Jesse Kramer: to raise revenue, to lift or eliminate the cap on taxable earnings, or to increase the 12.4% combined payroll tax for Social Security, or just to add a new revenue source into the system. Now that's unpopular too, because nobody likes paying more taxes. A third idea is just to trim benefits, such as a slowing benefit growth for higher
20:34
Jesse Kramer: earners, or adopting a less generous inflation adjustment like the one that's chained to CPI, or means testing the system. But opponents to this idea see these ideas as eroding the program's universal character, which it's they certainly would. Right now, everybody who pays into Social Security. gets a benefit, but to means test it, which would mean usually
20:55
Jesse Kramer: that higher earning people or wealthier people would get a lesser benefit, would erode the program's universal character. So anyway, there are different ideas for fixing the Social Security system, but all of them have some degree of unpopularity.
21:08
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Here's a quick ad, add and then we'll get back to the show. Some of you ask me about the business of this podcast and my blog. I don't sell protein powder. powders, I don't sell mattresses, I don't push credit card points. Instead, I simply say this. I'm a partner in a fiduciary financial planning firm. I focus on retirement planning, and I'm happy to chat with you about that. If you want to learn more, there are two easy things you can
21:28
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): do. First, go listen to episode 150 of this podcast. I share more in that episode about my practice, my focus, who is a good fit client, and some next steps. Second, you can visit Plan. planwithjesse.com. That's episode 150 or planwithjesse.com. Now, back to the show.
21:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
21:46
Jesse Kramer: let's get back to the history of retirement, and we're going to do that by traveling to Sun City, Arizona. Brings us to Act 4, the golden age of leisure retirement from the 1940s to the 1970s. So Sun City is a city just northwest of Phoenix. It's home to 40,000. permanent residents. Sun City is one of the first
22:06
Jesse Kramer: and most influential planned retirement communities in the United States. It was opened on January 1st, 1960, and the community's first weekend reportedly drew around 100,000 visitors, signaling this very strong demand for a new kind of retirement. The community itself is built around multiple golf courses and recreation centers
22:26
Jesse Kramer: and pools. and clubs. It even has an outdoor amphitheater. Sun City is age restricted, generally requiring at least one resident per household to be at least age 55. In the 2020 census, 76% of Sun City's residents were 65 years old or older. And the real Sun City
22:46
Jesse Kramer: helped popularize the idea of an active retirement, and it kind of recast. the post-retirement years as a time of leisure and recreation and community instead of being a period of decline. So, how did we get from the Great Depression in the 1930s to the opening of Sun City less than three decades later? As we just
23:06
Jesse Kramer: talked about, Social Security is one of the major reasons why. Social Security became a major component of retirement. By 1960, a majority of Americans over age 65 were receiving Social Security benefits. And Social Security didn't make retirement luxurious per se, but it made retirement income predictable and lifelong, and that
23:25
Jesse Kramer: allowed people to start planning around it. For many retirees in the post-World War II era, their house was their largest asset by far. Home ownership rose from about 44% of households in 1940 to over 60%. of households in 1960, which was helped along the way by FHA and VA mortgages and the GI Bill. The United States
23:45
Jesse Kramer: really did go through an economic boom due to World War II itself and the changing global economy after World War II. These positive economic ripples affected everyone, from the young to the retirees. And then private pensions started arriving en masse after World War II. Some rulings in the late 1960s. 1940s made pensions a mandatory subject for
24:05
Jesse Kramer: collective bargaining agreements. Major contracts in the steel and auto industries introduced private pensions starting in 1950. To show you how quickly these pensions grew, in the year 1940, about 15% of private workers had a pension. But by 1960, that amount had almost tripled. Over 40% of private
24:25
Jesse Kramer: workers had a pension. By the time the 1970s rolled around, many of those employees had been enrolled in their private pension for at least a decade, if not more, which made the private pension such an important pillar of retirement in the 70s and 80s and beyond. And let's expand on private pensions a little bit more right here. As we talked about earlier in this episode, the
24:45
Jesse Kramer: earliest private pension plans appeared in the late 1800s, with American Express in 1975 and the railroads in the 1980s introducing pensions for their employees. Then time went on, and by the 1920s, more and more large companies had adopted pensions to build loyalty and discourage unions among their employees. Federal taxes
25:05
Jesse Kramer: helped too. Different tax acts in the 1920s made pensions tax exempt, contributions and earnings deductible for the employers, and that established the these tax advantages that still underpin retirement plans even today. But these pre-depression pensions were quite fragile. Many were underfunded,
25:25
Jesse Kramer: and by the time the Depression hit, it caused numerous pension plans to be cut or abandoned. Then, after World War II, private pensions really exploded very quickly. Certain wage controls during World War II meant that employers weren't necessarily allowed to compete on wages themselves, so instead they competed using benefits.
25:45
Jesse Kramer: Private pensions were a way to attract and retain talented employees. And then the very, very high corporate tax rates of the 40s, 50s, and 60s made it attractive for employers to make deductible pension contributions for their employees. Union pressures were also a major contributor. Robert Lowenstein has this great book called While America
26:05
Jesse Kramer: Aged, which covers a really interesting history of various American pension systems and describes the roles that unions played in the growing pension systems of the 50s and 60s. And from my point of view in retirement planning, pensions are a wonderful thing. However, the private pension system, private pension systems, weren't perfect, far from it.
26:25
Jesse Kramer: There are a few different famous examples. to choose from here, but I'll talk about the Studebaker pension collapse, one of the most famous pension collapses, Studebaker being a very famous car company. In 1963, the Studebaker Corporation closed its main automobile manufacturing plant in South Bend, Indiana. The company's pension
26:45
Jesse Kramer: plan, which was negotiated amongst the United Auto Workers Union, the pension itself had been underfunded. partly because the benefit increases had been granted without enough money set aside to pay for them. And if you look at the history of pensions, that is a recurring theme. The idea that it's very easy to promise your employees
27:04
Jesse Kramer: something that won't come to pass for 10 or 20 or 30 years in the future. You can promise someone the world in order to get a contract signed, but then you have to make sure that. those future pension obligations are funded in some way. The main reason for the Studebaker collapse was that big benefit increases had been promised, but not enough money
27:24
Jesse Kramer: had been set aside to pay for them. And so when the pension plan was terminated, its assets, its limited assets, were distributed via a certain priority list. And those who are already retired from the plan and workers who were age 60 or older with enough service, they received their full promised pension. But then
27:44
Jesse Kramer: about 4,000 workers between age 40 to 60, people with at least 10 years of service in the company, they received a lump sum payout worth only about 15% of their promised benefit. One 15, five, fifteen 15% percent of the benefit. And then another 3,000 workers, most of whom were very young or lacked experience in
28:04
Jesse Kramer: the pension, received absolutely nothing. But those two groups, the 4,000 people who received 15% of their benefit, and the 3,000 people who received nothing, those employees had been paying into the system in some way. But the system was not designed, it was mismanaged, and therefore it couldn't fulfill its promise. And the Studebaker episode
28:24
Jesse Kramer: became a national symbol of broken. pension promises. It fueled years of congressional debates, directly leading to the passage of a very famous act, ERISA, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, which included funding standards and federal pension insurance. ERISA also created the individual retirement account,
28:44
Jesse Kramer: the IRA, and eventually the Roth IRA would follow in 1997. And that would give workers without any sort of workplace plan a way to save for retirement all on their own. Speaking of legislation, another act of legislation would lead us to the next revolution in the American retirement system. This boring piece of law called the Revenue Act of
29:04
Jesse Kramer: 1978 added Section 401K to the tax code. By the early 1980s, employers began using this new system, 401K, 401, to offer tax defensive. tax-deferred savings plans to their employees. These defined contribution plans, not a defined benefit plan, but a defined contribution plan, shifted the investment
29:24
Jesse Kramer: risk and responsibility from the employer to the worker. And over the following decades, many companies would freeze or close their traditional pension and then add in 401ks to become the dominant private investment retirement vehicle. Based on Bureau of Labor Statistics data, only about 10% of today's
29:44
Jesse Kramer: private sector workers have any access to a pension plan, many of whom are grandfathered in, meaning they're a 58-year-old employee who began working at their current corporation in the 90s or something like that. Meanwhile, about three-quarters of Americans have access to a 401k or similar employer plan. Beyond the numbers themselves, the broader more philosophical
30:04
Jesse Kramer: change in retirement planning is that for the better part of the 20th century, many Americans felt that the government and their employer would take care of them in retirement. Whereas for the past 40 years, that idea has been steadily shifting more and more and more to you are responsible for yourself. We'll come back to this idea in a couple of minutes, but
30:23
Jesse Kramer: first I want to talk about another major component of retirement plan. planning that really shifted in the, we'll call it the last third of the 20th century. It's maybe something that we take for granted, but it's Medicare. Before Medicare, many older Americans faced old age without any sort of health coverage. In the early 1960s, about 50%,
30:44
Jesse Kramer: half of senior citizens Your had no health insurance because understandably, private insurers saw them as a very customer. costly risk. President Harry Truman proposed national health insurance in 1945, not just for the elderly, but for everybody, national health insurance for all. But strong opposition defeated that idea. And then
31:03
Jesse Kramer: reformers of Truman's idea then narrowed their focus instead of all Americans, they narrowed their focus to just older Americans, a group whose need for health insurance was much harder to dispute. And that idea, that strategy, succeeded in 1965. As part of the Great Society legislation agenda, President Lyndon Johnson signed
31:23
Jesse Kramer: Medicare into law in 1965. And a fun fact, Harry Truman received the very first printed Medicare card. The original Medicare program had part A, hospital insurance, and part B, medical insurance, and then part C and Part D were introduced in the early 2000s. Before
31:43
Jesse Kramer: 1965, though, as I mentioned before, about half of Americans, age 65 and over had no health insurance whatsoever. So one serious illness could wipe out a retired couple's savings or push them onto family or push them onto charity. And Medicare changed that aspect of retirement in a very big way. It largely removed that catastrophic.
32:03
Jesse Kramer: risk for hospital and physician care. And together, between Medicare and the expansion of Social Security, elderly poverty rates fell from about 35% in 1959 to around 10% in more recent decades. And a quick shout out here to listener Doug, who mentioned after one of my other recent episodes, where I don't
32:22
Jesse Kramer: remember my exact verbiage, but apparently I described Medicare Part A as quote, unquote free. And I used that word, and I use that word today, because Medicare Part A requires no premium payments from the people insured by it. But as Doug very reasonably pointed out, the Medicare system is funded via our tax dollars. So, of
32:42
Jesse Kramer: course, in that way, it's not free at all. There's no such thing as a free lunch. The money always comes from somewhere. And so perhaps this is a bit more of a philosophical and semantic debate than it is a retirement debate. The point being, if you're out there planning for your retirement healthcare and you need to understand how much Medicare Part A is going to cost you, the answer is zero dollars. In
33:02
Jesse Kramer: that specific way, Medicare Part A is quote unquote free. But of course, we all pay for it somehow. We just pay for it out of payroll taxes. That could be an entire interesting socioeconomic episode unto itself about the pro. pros and cons of tax-funded benefits. But for now, we'll stay with the main program here today. In concert with Social Security benefits,
33:22
Jesse Kramer: Medicare's age 65 threshold created this fixed age for many Americans to plan their retirement around age 65. Many Americans who want to retire earlier stay in their jobs, though, mainly to keep employer health coverage until Medicare begins. So bridging that gap whether it's through a spouse's plan or through Cobra
33:42
Jesse Kramer: insurance or through ACA market coverage, is now a standard part of quote unquote early retirement planning. Here's a quick ad, and then we'll get back to the show. I send a free weekly email to thousands of readers that shares two simple things, just two. The first are my new articles and podcasts, so you'll never miss when I publish new content. And the second is my favorite financial content
34:02
Jesse Kramer: from other corners of the internet, so you can see what's been helping me the most.
34:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): But Jesse, I don't want another email.
34:08
Jesse Kramer: I hear you. I make this newsletter short, sweet, and full of essential information, and readers enjoy that. About 85% of newsletter subscribers are engaging with the newsletter more than once a month. They're enjoying it and you will too. You can subscribe for free on the homepage at bestinterest.blog, and you'll get a free PDF of my white paper titled The Step By
34:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the Up.
34:27
Jesse Kramer: Step Guide to Building Your Retirement Paycheck. That's right. A free weekly email that thousands of people like you are already reading, a free white paper to help you plan for retirement, and you can sign up for free at bestinterest.blog. Now, back to the idea of retirement being a little more individualistic and a little less paternalistic. One of the biggest problems,
34:47
Jesse Kramer: depending on your point of view, with post-World War II retirement was that corporate pensions promised a set monthly income for life, and that the employer chose the investments, the employer carried the market risk, the employer absorbed the risk of their retirees living longer than expected. In other words, in addition to all the other various risks associated with running
35:07
Jesse Kramer: a business, you can add in the corporate pension obligations to that list. And those obligations are often subject to market forces outside. of the corporation's control. There are a few good examples here to choose from. I'll go with General Motors. The joke was that by the 2000s, GM was little more than a giant
35:26
Jesse Kramer: pension and a giant healthcare company that just so happened to make cars.
35:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And the
35:31
Jesse Kramer: reason why is because its obligations to hundreds of thousands of retirees was a huge risk and responsibility on it as. a corporation. Retiree health costs played a major role that led up to GM's 2009 bankruptcy. And then in 2012, GM transferred a large share of its
35:50
Jesse Kramer: salaried pension obligations to Prudential through an annuity purchase, one of the largest pension risk transfers ever. The point there being, giant pension systems, or really any pension system, is a risk. on the company itself. So again, if you're the business owner or if you're a shareholder, that's a problem. If you're an employee,
36:10
Jesse Kramer: well, hey, that's the promise that you guys made to us. That's a big philosophical difference. 401k programs shifted this in a major, major way. The corporations could still make contributions for their employees and offer that employee benefit, but the corporation didn't have to do it with any responsibility of fulfilling some future promise because
36:30
Jesse Kramer: the employee would choose how much they want to save. The employee would choose whether and how to invest the money, when to withdraw the money, et cetera, et cetera. Market downturns and poor timing and high fees and early withdrawals, they would all directly reduce the retiree's security. But other than a few circumstances around the 401k plan, like high
36:50
Jesse Kramer: fee funds.
36:51
Jesse Kramer: and different ways in which the employer does have a fiduciary responsibility to be aware of, other than those types of circumstances, the employer has so much less responsibility than when they operated a private pension. That has been the major retirement revolution since the 1980s. And the financial world has responded with various
37:11
Jesse Kramer: tools designed to make self self-directed directed retirement more. manageable. Again, for much of the 1900s, the average retiree thought that the government and their former employer would help them take care of retirement. But starting in the late 1970s and really accelerating in the 90s, 2000s until today, the
37:31
Jesse Kramer: world has shifted. And now we as individuals are ultimately responsible for our retirement. And there are various tools and even you could say some revolutions that have taken place over the last 40 years to help people like us. For example, low cost investing has become widely available. Vanguard launched the first retail index fund in
37:51
Jesse Kramer: 1976, and index investing has grown into probably the main way of investing today. ETFs introduced in 1993 added another low low-cost, cost diversified option. Competition between different fund providers has driven down investing expenses. Most major brokerages eliminated trading commissions altogether in
38:11
Jesse Kramer: 2019. So the fees that once consumed a significant share of investment returns are now a fraction of what they once were. As more and more individual investors and individual retirees have put their money at risk in the market, their options have become better and cheaper. Another recent tool in the self-directed retirement arsenal is
38:31
Jesse Kramer: automatic investing. Things like target date funds offer a single decision portfolio. I did a deep dive on target date funds in episode 137. You can check more out there. But you look at things like the Pension Protection Act of 2006, which encouraged automatic enrollment, automatic contribution increases, and default investments into target date funds.
38:50
Jesse Kramer: Other legislation expanded these features, and now here we are today. Automatic enrollment is a requirement for new 401 plans. These changes rely on behavioral finance research showing that good default options help people save more. And then we have how financial advice itself has expanded and grown and
39:10
Jesse Kramer: matured over the recent decades. There is good free advice everywhere you look. The financial planning profession has grown significantly. Fee only and fiduciary advisors, people who are paid for their advice, rather than being paid through product commissions, have become more and more common. Robo advisors now offer automated portfolio management at low
39:30
Jesse Kramer: costs. Many firms blend digital tools with access to real human planners. There's a bevy of different ways that you can access really good financial. advice. And then the planning tools themselves have become more and more focused on retirement and deaccumulation. As more people have had to figure out retirement on their own and self direct their own retirement,
39:50
Jesse Kramer: more advice and education is being focused on tax efficient withdrawals and Social Security claiming and Roth conversions and Medicare. In effect, different ways to recreate and rebuild the paycheck that a pension once promised. But it's not all sunshine and rainbows in the DIY or retiree landscape. There are some perverse and misaligned incentives due to the
40:10
Jesse Kramer: fact that retirees are now on their own to plan retirement. For example, how about conflicts inside of certain target date funds? Many target date funds are built by asset managers who only pick from their own underlying funds, and that creates a temptation to include weaker and/or pricier. in-house products. Another one, there is a very
40:30
Jesse Kramer: active policy debate about adding private investments, private equity, and other alternatives, quote unquote alternatives, into 401ks. An August 2025 executive order directed regulators to make these alternative assets easier to offer in 401k And
40:45
Jesse Kramer: plans. Now, supporters would say that fewer companies go public today, so it's excluding private markets, it leaves ordinary savers like us outside of the circle where we can't get access to the large part of the economy, where we cannot get access to those private markets. And thus by introducing them into 401ks, professional
41:05
Jesse Kramer: managers can add more diversification. But critics of this idea, myself included, would point to much higher fees in these private investments, limited liquidity, valuations that are very hard to verify, and then limited valuations that are only provided at limited points in time, which makes returns look smoother than they actually are.
41:25
Jesse Kramer: This giant academic debate over whether private equity actually beats public markets after fees. And then, of course, there's the private equity industry's clear interest in reaching out to the trillions of dollars in retirement assets. as their own traditional fundraising flows have slowed down. What other issues do we have? I mean, everything from
41:45
Jesse Kramer: rollover pitches are one, right? The point when someone leaves a job or retires can involve a lot of money because their 401k balance may now be rolled into an IRA. Moving from a very low-cost institutional 401k plan into an IRA that might have some sort of higher advisory fee attached to it. Well, that might not be a good move for every
42:05
Jesse Kramer: retiree. And rules governing these kind of recommendations have gone back and forth. Then we have things like high-fee, high commission annuities. Annuities can be valuable for guaranteed income, but many annuities carry very large commissions and complex features, surrender charges that lock in the annuity owner for years and years and years. These are often
42:25
Jesse Kramer: sold to retirees through. these high-pressure, you know, steak dinner sales settings. But to summarize, the point here is that the self-directed retirement landscape where private pensions no longer exist and instead have been replaced by the 401k program, that self-directed retirement landscape is not necessarily a perfect setup and incentives
42:44
Jesse Kramer: drive behavior, and not all the behavior has been good. But some really cool things have come out of the past 40 years. I think of movements like the Bogleheads. The Bogleheads were started in the late 90s as a small collection of diehard index fund fans who would write to each other on the Morningstar forums. In 2000, the group held its first in-person
43:04
Jesse Kramer: gathering. Those gatherings eventually became the annual Bogleheads conference. In 2006, three well-known Bogleheads published the Bogleheads Guide to Investing, an excellent book. brought the Boglehead philosophy to a much wider audience. Fast forward to today, we have the Bogleheads Forum. They have their own podcast, lots of really good free educational work,
43:24
Jesse Kramer: people who are dedicated to spreading sound investment advice, but also just sound retirement planning advice far and wide. And then I think of things like the fire movement, right? The fire movement, you can probably trace its philosophical origin back to the early 90s, the book Your Money or Your Life. which encouraged people to view money as life energy, to start tracking the money they spend, to
43:44
Jesse Kramer: cut spending that didn't bring real fulfillment, to build up their investments until some of their income began covering their living costs. Then I think of the book The Millionaire Next Door in the mid-90s, which reinforced this idea that wealth comes mostly from frugality and steady saving, not necessarily from high incomes or flashy spending. The idea of a
44:04
Jesse Kramer: self-directed retirement plan also led to research like what Bill Bengen did in the early 90s, his research suggesting that retirees could withdraw about 4% of their portfolio and then adjust up every year for inflation, with very little risk of running out of money over 30 years. Then the Trinity study in the late 90s reached a similar conclusion, and that
44:24
Jesse Kramer: resulting 4% rule gave the fireman. fire movement its core formula, which is that if you save about 25 times your annual spending, you can then live off your investments for the rest of your life. Cheap, diversified index funds, the same tools that Bogleheads championed, made that strategy pretty practical. And then with the internet, fire went viral. Blogs
44:44
Jesse Kramer: like Early Retirement Extreme and Mr. Money Mustache shared personal stories of frugal living and index investing. that led people to retiring in as early as their 30s. And then in 2016, J.L. Collins' book, The Simple Path to Wealth, it popularized FIRE even further. And then countless blogs and podcasts like this one and forums
45:04
Jesse Kramer: online built a much larger community. The point here is that as more workers came of age in the post-pension retirement era, things like the FIRE movement offered them a sense of control. in a world where retirement became more of a do-it-yourself project. Ironically, we started today's conversation with the idea of elderly people who were still
45:24
Jesse Kramer: inside the workforce. That topic is how retirement came to be. And from the late 1800s through the mid-1980s, the share of older Americans in the workforce fell steadily as pensions and Social Security and Medicare and mandatory retirement rewards. rules, it made stopping work at 65 or even as early as 62 both possible
45:44
Jesse Kramer: and also expected. So by the mid-1980s, only about one in six people over age 65 was working or looking for work. That's the low point in the modern era. Only one in six people over 65 was working. But since roughly the mid-90s, that number has started to climb back up. Labor force
46:04
Jesse Kramer: participation today among people 65 and older has risen to about one in five, with fewer pensions, and many people are working longer to build up their savings or to keep employer health coverage until Medicare. The Social Security full retirement age has now risen to age 67. Mandatory retirement was largely abolished. More
46:23
Jesse Kramer: jobs are less physically demanding than they were before. People are healthier and better educated at older ages, and more women are having longer careers. So, point is that now we have a little bit more of older people in the workforce. So, exactly where does that leave us with the retirement landscape as it stands here at the end of 2026? If I had to summarize it,
46:43
Jesse Kramer: I'd say the following: Social Security remains the backbone, at least a backbone for many retirees. Social security provides a large chunk of their income, but Social Security also has some cracks in it that need to be addressed over the next 10 years. For personal savings, the 401k is now the main vehicle. Traditional pensions have largely disappeared in the
47:03
Jesse Kramer: private sector, so most workers are responsible for saving and investing on their own. That said, many people still lack access to a workplace plan. There are tens of millions of private sector employees in the United States. especially at small businesses or in part-time jobs or gig jobs who have no employer retirement plan. And this is where IRAs, individual
47:23
Jesse Kramer: retirement accounts, are vital. Home equity is a major hidden asset for today's average retiree. For many older Americans, their house is worth more than their retirement accounts. So for them, downsizing or somehow tapping into their home equity are increasingly a majority. major part of their retirement plans. Looking across the retiree cohort,
47:43
Jesse Kramer: retirement savings are very uneven. Some households have substantial retirement balances, but many have little or nothing saved at all for retirement. Median balances for retirement accounts are far lower than the average account size, which simply suggests that there are many very, very large retirement accounts that pull the average. up.
48:03
Jesse Kramer: The median retirement account isn't that large. Another interesting fact about today's retirement is that the so-called peak 65 is here. Roughly 4 million Americans are turning 65 years old every year, the largest wave in U.S. history. That puts pressure on Social Security and Medicare, and it puts pressure on the labor market. People are
48:23
Jesse Kramer: living longer and working longer. Retirements of 25 years and 30 years or more, those are common. And so running out of money is a real concern. And so more people than ever are working part time or delaying retirement. And that in a roughly 50 minute nutshell is the roadmap of how we got to today's concept of retirement.
48:43
Jesse Kramer: Thank you for tuning in today. You can subscribe to my weekly email on the homepage at bestinterest.blog. If you love this podcast, please leave me a rating and review. on the Apple Podcast app. And if you're interested in learning more about my financial planning practice, visit planwithjesse.com.
48:57
Jesse Kramer: Thanks for tuning in to this episode of Personal Finance for Long-Term Investors. If you have a question for Jesse to answer on a future episode, send him an email over at its blog, The Best Interest. His email address is Jesse jessie at bestinterest.blog. Again, that's Jesse jessie at bestinterest. bestinterest.blog. Did you enjoy the show?
49:17
Jesse Kramer: Subscribe, rate, and review the podcast wherever you listen. This helps others find the show and invest in knowledge themselves.
49:24
Jesse Kramer: And we really appreciate it.
49:26
Jesse Kramer: We'll catch you on the next episode of Personal Finance for Long Term Investors. Personal Finance for Long-Term Investors is a personal podcast meant for education and entertainment. It should not be taken as financial advice. and it's not prescriptive of your financial situation.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Personal Finance for Long-Term Investors

All insights