Personal Finance for Long-Term Investors

Kramer contrasts wealth maximization with failure minimization, critiquing 100% stock portfolios for behavioral risks.

39 min Listen to the original Episode page
Retirement PlanningPortfolio ConstructionBehavioral FinanceRisk ManagementAcademic Research

Summary

Jesse Kramer uses engineering analogies to explain how competing financial goals require prioritization. He distinguishes between maximizing lifetime wealth and minimizing retirement failure, arguing that conservative strategies better secure outcomes late in life. The host introduces Scott Cederberg's paper advocating 100% stock portfolios, which Kramer critiques for assuming rational behavior during drawdowns. Speakers discuss Monte Carlo limitations and how underfunded retirees face different trade-offs than those with excess wealth.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Retirement planning must begin by defining the specific problem, as goals like maximizing wealth or minimizing failure often conflict.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 8:22

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 8:02

    Engineering Analogies for Financial Trade-offs

    Jesse Kramer uses his background in aerospace engineering to illustrate how competing goals like cost, schedule, and quality create tensions that require prioritizing one over others.

  2. 8:02 – 10:17

    Defining Retirement Problems and Goals

    The speaker argues that retirement planning must begin by defining the specific problem to solve, noting that goals like maximizing wealth, minimizing failure, or reducing stress often conflict.

  3. 10:17 – 19:11

    Maximizing Wealth vs. Minimizing Failure

    Kramer distinguishes between maximizing lifetime wealth and minimizing the probability of retirement failure, using a basketball analogy to illustrate the trade-offs.

  4. 19:11 – 23:14

    The Cederberg Paper and 100% Stock Portfolios

    The host introduces an academic paper by Scott Cederberg et al. that challenges conventional life-cycle investing by advocating for a 100% stock portfolio throughout life.

  5. 23:14 – 28:05

    Critiques of the Cederberg Paper and Behavioral Risk

    Kramer critiques the Cederberg paper for assuming rational investor behavior during severe drawdowns and questions the relevance of historical international bond data.

  6. 28:05 – 32:47

    Monte Carlo Limitations and Investor Flexibility

    The speaker discusses the limitations of Monte Carlo analysis, which treats outcomes as binary successes or failures regardless of the magnitude of the shortfall.

  7. 32:47 – 35:06

    Risk Tolerance and Underfunding Conundrum

    Speaker 0 argues that individuals with excess wealth have little reason for high risk, whereas underfunded retirees face a dilemma regarding risk and outcomes.

  8. 35:06 – 37:26

    Case Study of Two Families with Divergent Goals

    Two families with similar net worths made different investment decisions based on their primary goals: one prioritized avoiding running out of money, while the other prioritized maximizing charitable giving.

  9. 37:26 – 38:48

    Podcast Outro and Giveaway Details

    The speaker concludes the episode by promoting a giveaway for 'Poor Charlie's Almanac' and providing contact information for the blog and planning firm.

Do your own research

  • Review Scott Cederberg's paper on 100% stock portfolios for claims on international bond underperformance.
  • Evaluate personal risk tolerance and behavioral discipline during multi-year bear markets.
  • Analyze Monte Carlo simulation limitations regarding binary success/failure outcomes.
  • Compare historical inflationary bond data against modern TIPS and short-duration treasury options.
  • Assess individual retirement goals: wealth maximization vs. failure minimization.
  • Review PlanWithJesse.com for potential conflicts of interest regarding the planning firm mentioned.
  • Check bestinterest.blog for additional resources and contact information.
  • Consider the impact of flexibility options like delaying Social Security on retirement outcomes.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): What problem are you solving? It seems like a straightforward question, yet different retirees feel strongly in multiple different directions here. And as you solve one problem, does it create tension against the other problems that are worth solving? We'll dive into that question today and explain why defining your problem is vital for the retirement
0:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): planning process.
0:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Welcome to Personal Finance for Long-Term Long Term Investors, where every episode teaches you personal finance and long term investing in simple terms. Now, here's your host, Jesse Kramer.
0:34
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Welcome to Personal Finance for Long Term Investors, episode 157. I'm Jesse Kramer. I'm a financial planner. I work with retirees and people getting ready for retirement from all across the USA. You can learn more at planwithjesse.com. Plan with Jesse.com. This week's review of the week is from Grants One, who said this is quickly becoming their favorite financial podcast because it's easy to comprehend and it's
0:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): informative. Well, thank you very much for the kind words and the five-star review, Grants One. You can send me an email to jesse at bestinterest.blog, and I'll get a super soft t-shirt sent out your way. And hey listeners, speaking of getting things sent out your way, I'm gearing up for another holiday giveaway. I think that an investment in knowledge pays the best interest, and so I'm gonna send out 25 copies
1:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of Poor Charlie's Almanac. Just a wonderful book that any investor is going to enjoy. It's, you know, the selected wisdom and stories of Charlie Munger's life. Just a great book, Poor Charlie's Almanac. So to enter the giveaway, to get one of the 25 free copies to enter that giveaway, all you have to do is leave a rating and review of this podcast on
1:34
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the Apple Podcasts app, take a screenshot, and then email that screenshot to me. That's it. Now on with the show. I have a couple of fun engineering anecdotes that'll get us in the right mindset today. When we would build and design and test these complex, precise, one-of-a-kind space telescopes in my old job. We did the James Webb Space Telescope. We
1:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): led the assembly integration and test of its primary mirror. The recently launched Roman Space Telescope. My former colleagues did the entire program for that telescope. Really, really cool stuff. But any large project like that can be measured on three competing axes, three competing goals that were constantly in tension with one another. In our case, those three goals
2:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): were cost, schedule, and quality. If the project was on a really tight schedule and if it needed to be immaculate quality, then there's no way to keep the cost down. And if it needed to be low cost and on a fast schedule, well, then you had to just accept the fact that quality was going to suffer. And these same tensions exist in many different lines of work.
2:34
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Maybe you face the same thing in your career. Cost and schedule and quality are competing goals. And it's very hard, some would say impossible, to maximize all three of those axes at the same time. And for that reason, it was important for us as staff engineers to understand which sacrifices a particular telescope program was willing to make. If
2:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a leader needed me to keep my analysis hours to a minimum to keep costs low, I had to know about that. Versus, did I need to make this project my my number one priority for the next six weeks, ensuring that we get to meet the critical design review schedule? Or just how thermally stable do I need to keep this telescope in order to preserve image quality? Versus
3:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): will our customers customer be okay and accepting with a little bit of a degraded on-orbit performance? What's the problem we're solving? Where can we make sacrifices? Where must we hold the line? That's the first kind of engineering anecdote, just a little story that might get you in the mindset for a little bit of today's episode. The second engineering anecdote
3:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): is a little bit more in the weeds. When it came to the nitty-gritty design work, we would often have these. competing budgets. And I kind of say that in quotes, budgets on the telescope. But it's very similar to how your monthly financial budget would attempt or does attempt to divvy up your future financial resources. Our budgets in the engineering world would
3:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): divvy up the telescope resources. For example, there would be a mass budget. Launching things into space is very much a lightweight affair, and we all have. had a duty to keep our mass down. And each of us would have a certain budget to stay within. There would also be a power budget, right? The solar panels on a satellite only
4:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): produce so much wattage. And this one was particularly important for me because my heater systems were one of the main power users on the entire telescope. But you know, the idea of the mass budget, going back to that, is each component would be a lot. allotted a certain amount of mass that they could they would then have to design within. You can't make everything
4:32
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): extremely lightweight, but the idea is you also can't go too heavy. You have to stay within your budget. Similarly, power-wise, listen, we all have to use some power and the telescope in different ways, but it was important for all of us as engineers to know here's No, how much we're allowed to use, but you really can't use any more than that. The most nerdy one would be the optical budget. The way of thinking about this is that
4:52
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): there are lots of little influences on the telescope that might cause the overall system image to be worse than expected. And some of this optical degradation is actually acceptable. It may be like an iPhone image that's just barely out of focus. You know, you could still tell exactly what you're looking at, even if it's just barely out of focus. But eventually, our image
5:12
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): quality could get so poor that the telescope wouldn't actually be doing its job anymore. So we all had to attempt to keep our portion of the optical budget under control. And just like the first anecdote today, the engineering decisions that ensured that we all stayed within our budgets came from understanding the bigger problem that we were
5:32
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): solving. We first First, had to understand the big problem, and then we could go into the minutia
5:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
5:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): our own individual design elements. and our own individual budgets. And we had to understand trade-offs, we had to understand opportunity costs. We had to understand that in some cases, we were accepting a less than ideal scenario to ensure a better overall outcome. What do I mean? So, one version of an ideal design scenario, for me at
5:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): least, right? I was in charge of thermal control of the telescope for a lot of my career. That's what I worked on. And so a perfect world for me might be that I keep the entire optical assembly perfectly uniform in temperature, like down to the tenth of a degree. Whenever any component on the telescope got down below 19.9 degrees Celsius, boom, my heaters would
6:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): turn on and warm up that element. And whenever that component would then warm up to 20.1 degrees Celsius, boom, the heater would turn off. I'd have perfect thermal control and I'd set up the small. these small heaters all over the telescope, and I'd put sensors everywhere. Every square inch of the telescope would have a heater and a sensor so that I could just control everything. I could deliver so much
6:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): thermal control, and I could ensure that the optical error from thermal design was essentially zero. Like the perfect thermally designed telescope. But putting that many heaters on the telescope would probably blow through my mass button. budget. And I know that all those heaters and all those sensors would require way more
6:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): wiring, electrical wiring, than would be reasonable, probably causing a mass issue in and of itself, definitely causing a manufacturing issue and a testing issue to set up all this wiring, the installation of hundreds of individual heaters and wires. And then they'd probably all crosstalk, right? One heater would, you know, the you can't really control. the way that heat
7:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): flows around that easily. So one heater would influence a different part of the telescope, a different sensor. Now you've got crosstalk between heaters and sensors, et cetera, et cetera. And the bigger point here is that in this scenario, that the chief systems engineer of the program, the kind of head technical thinker, would very rightly, justifiably look at me and say, Jesse, I don't
7:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): really need your thermal system to be that perfect. I don't need your thermal system to induce zero optical error. Some error is actually acceptable. And in your quest here, Jesse, to drive your optical error down to zero, you've actually introduced much bigger issues into the system that now need much bigger solutions. So your pursuit of
7:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): this one optimization actually caused bigger problems for us. And of course, listeners, this is not a good thing.
8:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And this
8:02
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): idea brings us back now. I'm going to take it back to retirement and retirement problems and retirement goals, the problems that we're actually solving in retirement planning. And the idea is can we solve all these problems at the same time? I recently posted just a really quick article on this topic and I'll throw it in the show notes. And I was just thinking through the different problems that that I've
8:22
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): come across, the different problems that different retirees want to solve in their retirement. Some people want to maximize their total wealth. Some people want to maximize how much they spend in their retirement years. Some people want to minimize their stress, minimize a probability of failure metric. I just want to minimize my odds of failing. Some people want to make
8:42
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): life as simple as possible. Some people want to minimize how often they think about money. Some people want to smooth their standard of living. They don't want to have to make big adjustments based on something like the stock market. Some people want to protect against the worst case. Some people want to avoid outliving their money. Others want to
9:02
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): avoid dying with too much. Some want to maximize their healthy years. Others want to minimize regret. Some people want to maximize flexibility and optionality. Other people want to leave as big a legacy as possible. Some want to retire as early as possible. Some want to minimize their lifetime taxes. Some want to
9:22
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): protect their surviving spouse. Others want to preserve their independence and their dignity. Now that was a list of what, again, 15, maybe 20 different items. Very different items. Some may be similar, some that could certainly be achieved in roughly the same direction.
9:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
9:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): idea is we all have our rhymes and reasons to do what we do, and your particular reasons might not make sense to your friends and neighbors and family members. They don't have to. We each get to choose. We all want different things from retirement, and our goals might differ. Your individual goals might even conflict with one another, and that's okay. I think
9:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it's important to remember, though, that we often kind of fail in a way. We talk past each other when we fail. to realize how widely our goals may differ and that your goals are going to dictate your smartest path, and my path might look different than yours. Both paths can be correct at the same time, just for different people with different sets of goals. And one of my favorite conflicts in
10:17
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): retirement planning that I'm finally now getting a chance to dive into here on this episode, after kind of mulling it over for years and years, has to do with the difference between the two following. reasonably similar goals, but ultimately different goals. And the first one is maximizing your lifetime wealth. And the second one is minimizing your probability
10:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of failure. These two goals seem related: maximizing your lifetime wealth, minimizing your probability of failure, because you say to yourself, well, if I had another five million dollars, my odds of failing go down to zero. So maxing wealth and minimizing failure. seem like kind of the same thing. And you certainly could make an argument, a good argument, that for most of our lives,
10:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): these two goals might be tied right at the hip. But I would contend that eventually they start to diverge, or at least that they have important differences, and that many retirees get caught up in the fact that they don't recognize those differences, or they think that they're minimizing their probability of failure, when in fact they are still focused on the goal of maximizing their lifetime
11:17
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): wealth. And this can cause a problem. So let's dive in a little bit deeper here. Let's say you're in your 30s or your 40s, you decide to get serious about your personal finances, your saving and investing, smart financial planning, and you have this long-term goal of a successful and well-funded and relaxing retirement. So you read up on these topics, you read all the good books, you listen to the good podcasts, et cetera, et cetera, and you
11:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): decide in your 30s and 40s that a 100% stock portfolio is right for you. And you trim a few things that you're spending money on day to day, you start saving 15, 20% of your salary, maybe even more. Uh, you take advantage of your tax advantage accounts, you're really doing everything right. And so if we pause this little anecdote here, we go back to the two goals that
11:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I mentioned a minute ago: maximizing your lifetime wealth, minimizing your probability of failure. I would say at this point, in this hypothetical journey, financial journey in your 30s and 40s, doing all these things right, it is very, very likely that you are both maximizing your long-term wealth and minimizing your chance of retirement failure at the same time. Because at this
12:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): point, a 100% stock portfolio for this particular person achieves both of these goals. The two goals are not in tension with each other, or at least they're not yet in tension. with each other. When you're a long way off from retirement, perhaps the best thing you can do is to put yourself on the path to retiring with a large nest egg. And this 100% stock portfolio in this case
12:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): probably does that. Awesome. But I would contend that eventually, eventually, the 100% stock portfolio no longer solves both of these problems. It probably will continue to maximize your lifetime wealth. but it no longer minimizes your probability of failure. Now, why is that the case? I think
12:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): maybe it's a little funny, but I think a sports analogy is really going to help us here. And particularly I'm going to use basketball. If you're not a basketball fan, I apologize. I'll do my best to explain it along the way. But I want to imagine that you're a basketball coach and your team is up. You're up by one point, and there's about 10 seconds left in the game, and you have the ball. You're up by one with 10
13:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): seconds left and you have the ball. What do you do? Well, if your goal as a coach is to maximize points, then I would say your action is pretty clear. You need to encourage your team to drive down the court. You need to score. In fact, you probably want to shoot a three-point shot. You want to score as many points as possible. And so the point is you're up by one, there's 10
13:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): seconds left, you have the ball, and if you're maximizing points, you're gonna go score. That's what you need to do.
13:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
13:41
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): there's a problem. And the problem is that going to score, you might fail. Your team might miss your shot. The opposing team might then rebound the ball, they get the ball. And now they still have some time on the clock. And your team, you're only up by one. So now the opposing team has the ball. They're coming down the court toward you. You're playing defense. And if they score on you, well, then your
14:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): one point lead got flipped on its head, it's now a one point deficit. Time is winding down to zero, it's probably too late for your team to recover, and you've literally snatched defeat from the jaws of victory, you know, the opposite of what you want to do. So let's go back to the point where you're up by one with 10 seconds left and you have the ball. If instead of maximizing points, if your goal is
14:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): simply to win the game, which is, I mean, quite obviously what we want to do in sport. sports, we want to win the game.
14:28
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): You play to win.
14:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
14:29
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I don't care if you don't have any wins. You go play to win.
14:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): When
14:34
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you start telling me it doesn't matter, then retire. Get out. Because it matters. And
14:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
14:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): all we want to do is win the game, then your action as the coach would not be to go score more. In fact, your action as the coach is to intentionally not score more. You just want to hold on to the ball. and let the clock wind down to zero. You don't want to do something. You just want to stand there and you'll win the game. And for many different sports, football, basketball, lacrosse, I'm sure there are many
15:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): others. In many of these sports, for most of the individual game itself, for the first quarter, for the second quarter, for the third quarter, for most of the game, the goal of maximizing the points that you've scored coincides perfectly with the goal of
15:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the game.
15:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): winning game. They are one and the same. You don't see teams kind of taking their foot off the gas in the middle of the second quarter. They don't do it. So as sports fans, we're used to seeing, yeah, you go down and you score and you keep your foot on the gas and you go, go, go. But there comes a point in many sports toward the end of their games where the goal of continuing to
15:34
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): maximize your points actually introduces risk of losing. the game. There comes a point where the best strategy to maximize your points starts to conflict with the best strategy of winning the game. And thus you need to ask yourself as the coach: well, do I care about scoring more points or do I just care about winning the game? And the
15:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): answer should be clear. So let's pivot back to retirement and investing. There's no doubt that for any investor, retiree or not, that maximizing their net worth comes from taking more and more risk. Any spreadsheet, any calculator, any retirement planning software package is clearly going to show you that your projected average net worth rises as
16:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you take more and more risk. Therefore, many investors choose to own a very high percentage of, say, stocks, a riskier investment, in their portfolio, maybe even 100% stocks throughout much of their investing life. But eventually, as time goes on, there starts to be a small problem. Because while more risk introduces a higher average
16:34
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): result, a higher average net worth, more risk also introduces a wider range of outcomes. More risk introduces higher highs, it also introduces lower lows. More risk can make you a You're mega millionaire, but it also can increase the odds that you might run out of money before you die. In other words, more investment risk is like that basketball
16:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): coach whose decisions might lead to more points, but also might lead to losing the game. And as you approach retirement, as you move through retirement, you should ask yourself: is your goal to die with the biggest pot of money feasible, or is your goal to simply not lose the game? Those are two different goals, and they require different investment strategies. This is why I would
17:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): contend that diversifying and adding more conservative assets, these ideas belong in many people's portfolios, especially as they grow older, especially as they enter or approach retirement. And more technically speaking, I guess as they approach withdrawals from their portfolio. The main goal of a portfolio, at least in my opinion, is to
17:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): provide as high a probability as possible that the portfolio can meet all future. withdrawal obligations. And some of those future withdrawal obligations might be to help pay for your kids' college, to help pay for your kids' wedding. Some of those obligations are to support you and your spouse during your retirement years. Some of those obligations might be to leave an inheritance to your
17:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): kids or to give a gift to charity after you pass away. And depending on the size of those obligations, you might have to take some risk in order to grow your assets to meet those obligations. But depending on your timeline to those obligations, taking risk might put your ability to meet those obligations at risk. So, as a quick summary of this section,
18:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the idea is that introducing more and more risk to your portfolio can certainly help you achieve the goal of maximizing your lifetime wealth. But there comes a point in life where it does not help you if your goal is. minimizing your probability of retirement failure. The two goals eventually come into tension with one another.
18:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Here's a quick ad, and then we'll get back to the show. Some of you ask me about the business of this podcast and my blog. I don't sell protein powders, I don't sell mattresses, I don't push credit card points. Instead, I simply say this: I'm a partner in a fiduciary financial planning firm. I focus on retirement planning, and I'm happy to chat with you about that. If you want to learn more, there are two easy things you
18:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): can do. First, go listen to episode 150 of this podcast. I share more in that episode about my practice, my focus, who is a good fit client, and some next steps. Second, you can visit planwithjesse.com. That's episode 150 or planwithjessie.com. Now, back to the show.
19:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now,
19:12
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): this seems like a fun time to introduce a bit of a pivot. I'm going to talk about something that some people out there know as the Cedarberg Paper. In 2023, three researchers, including Scott Cederberg, published an academic paper called Beyond the Status Quo: A Critical Assessment of Life Cycle Investment Advice. We will link to this paper in the
19:31
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): show notes. The authors challenge the conventional life cycle investment approach, in which households shift. from stocks toward bonds as they age. This is an investment approach, the life cycle approach, that I certainly think has a lot of merit. It's the investment approach that many of us are familiar with, as reflected in target date funds, right? This is what target date
19:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): funds do. They have a life cycle investment approach. While my approach is technically more influenced by asset liability matching than it is by the life cycle approach, do they do The approach two approaches are very, very similar in nature. The Cedarberg paper, though, suggests that this life cycle investment approach relies too heavily on
20:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the U.S. historical investment record. And really what they're saying is that U.S. historical investment performance has been considerably better than the rest of the world's historical investment performance. And thus, to build a strategy based only on US performance is cherry-picking the really good. data. Instead, the Cedarberg paper builds a data set of asset returns from a bunch of
20:31
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): different developed countries, 38 different developed countries, going back more than a century. And then they use this statistical method called the block bootstrap method to simulate millions of realistic lifetimes of saving and retiring and spending. And in this framework, they compare different common investment strategies, including a target date. fund style
20:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): glide path, and they compare it against simple fixed allocations. And their main finding is that a constant allocation of roughly one-third domestic stocks plus two-thirds international stocks held throughout the entire lifetime, both working years and retirement years, that this approach beats the typical target date
21:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): approach. So that again, that's a 100% stock portfolio.
21:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): One third domestic stocks, two thirds international stocks. They find that that is the optimum portfolio. And under their assumptions, this all equity portfolio, all stock portfolio, it produces more wealth at retirement, it better preserves savings throughout retirement, and it lowers the risk of running out the money, leaving behind a larger
21:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): bequest to your heirs. Candidly, this result flies. in the face of what I've been talking about so far in this episode. I'm talking about the idea that, you know, if we go back to the basketball coach analogy, I'm saying that at some point, if you want to maximize your probability of winning, going to score more points actually puts you at risk. And similarly,
21:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): if you want to minimize your chances of retirement failure, then at some point you can't have an all-risk portfolio. At some point, you need to introduce more conservative assets into your portfolio. Not so, says the Cedarberg paper. They say that if you truly want to minimize, lower the risk of running out of money, that you should stay
22:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): 100% stocks. So the authors of the paper attribute the result mainly due to bonds. Bonds have this poor, long-run, long run real return outside of the USA. So if we look at other countries' bonds, which are included in this study, and if we include those bonds in our retiree portfolios, we don't see the
22:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): same positive effect that US bonds have added to retiree portfolios. We've seen in the international sample that their bonds are especially vulnerable to, no surprise, inflation. In other words, US bonds have been a good investment and a good diversity. diversifier over the sample time period of the study. But for many other
22:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): countries, their domestic bonds have not been a good diversifier. For many other countries, bonds have not been additive or beneficial to retirement portfolios. Now, are there issues with the Cedarberg paper? Are there issues with these findings? There are. The first one is behavioral in nature, right? That the study's results rely on the idea that investment.
23:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): investors stay the course in their 100% stock portfolio throughout severe drawdowns. This is known as a rational choice economic model, where we treat investors as if they will always behave rationally, treating investors as if they could see the future and make a current day decision that they know would end up best for them decades out in the future. However, we
23:34
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know in practice that that while some people are capable of this perfectly rational thinking. most people are not capable of this. And for many investors, the presence of some bonds or some cash or some other diversifiers, something that might be able to act as a buffer investment, something that might be able to act as a stable source of income for near term stock
23:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): market drawdowns, something that might act as a buffer against sequence of returns risk, that something, that diversifier, that bonds or cash or other investment. is the thing that allows those investors to stay the course with the remainder of their assets being in stocks. If someone is in their 60s or 70s or 80s, no longer working, no longer has any labor capital left
24:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to offset their losses. If that person goes through a multi-year bear market in stocks late in their life, the concern is that they'll panic. The concern is that they might sell at the bottom, that they'll suffer some severe lifestyle. disruption. Ultimately, this all-stock, 100% stock decision, might lead to worse long-term outcomes for
24:34
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): these people personally, even if the long-term returns of the investments themselves end up being good. We've talked about this on the show before. We've seen it in real data, where you can have two investors, one of whom technically has a greater return than the other, one of whom certainly has underlying investments, where the investments themselves have a
24:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): greater return than the other. And yet there are times where the portfolio that performs slightly worse, the investments themselves that perform slightly worse, that investor ends up with a larger long-term nest egg. And one reason why it can be sequence of returns, the sequence of the returns themselves leads lead to differing final investment values. And the other major reason is simply
25:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): behavioral investment. in nature. But beyond behavior, another critique of the Cedarberg paper is that a lot of the bond underperformance in the international data, again, this differentiator that really makes the paper what it is, is the bond underperformance in the international data. The criticism is that that data comes from nominal bonds during inflationary episodes, wars,
25:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and hyperinflations. Today's US retiree can buy treasuries and tips, build a tip sladder, and something like that might address exactly the inflation vulnerability that the paper talks about. And if we compare a modern day TIPS ladder or short duration treasury bonds today, if we compare that to how
25:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): German bonds performed in 1920 or how Japanese bonds performed post post-World World War II, we need to ask ourselves huh, are those foreign bonds actually? the right reference class for today's U.S. retiree? Probably not. Either way, there's a great episode of the Rational Reminder podcast, episode 350 of their
26:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): podcast, featuring Professor Cederberg, and we will link that episode in the show notes. I wanted to pivot and talk about the Cedarberg paper simply as an educational point to you listening. Some people out there believe that maximizing long-term wealth and minimizing long-term retirement risk truly are one and the same thing, and they are
26:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): both solved by holding 100% stocks. It's an interesting idea, but I think it asks a lot of us to maintain our very, very best behavior during some very challenging market environments. But at this point in the episode, I wouldn't blame you if you weren't exactly sure what you're supposed to think. So let's let me try to clarify a little bit. I'll start by saying
26:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): your financial goals are probably going to change throughout your life. And for most people, their real goal has to do with a life well lived. So whether their portfolio returns 5% or 7% or 14% or some other number, for most people, it's a secondary goal. That that portfolio return is a secondary goal. Whereas the primary
27:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): goal is just living. a life well lived. In other words, if your portfolio returns 7% per year and you live exactly the life you want to, I think you're going to be really, really happy. And if your portfolio returned 8% per year, and for some other reason, you never felt like you could live the life that you wanted to, I think you're
27:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): going gonna to be not as happy.
27:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Here's a quick ad, and then we'll get back to the show.
27:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Did you
27:38
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): know?
27:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): my written blog, The Best Interest, was nominated for 2022 Personal Finance Blog of the Year, and it's been highlighted in the Wall Street Journal, Yahoo Finance, and on CNBC? I love writing, especially when that writing is to share financial education, and I usually write one or two articles per week. You can read them all at
27:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): bestinterest.blog. Again, the web address is bestinterest.com. bestinterest.blog. Check it out.
28:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
28:05
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): let's talk about a few other similar concepts that we ought to be aware of as we plan out our retirements. The first one I want to talk about is the fact that not all failures are equal. When you're running some sort of retirement projection, maybe it's a Monte Carlo analysis, and there's some sort of probability of failure. We talked a lot about it back on episode 134, all dedicated to Monte Carlo analysis.
28:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Failure in this context is extremely black and white. It's too black and white. You could conceivably pass away, die at age 95 with a net worth of negative $1, and that is considered a failure. Whereas dying at 95 with a net worth of positive $1 is considered a success. They're essentially the same thing, but in the
28:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): black and white world of Monte Carlo analysis, they're treated as total opposites. Similarly, you could have a situation from a Monte Carlo analysis that's a failure, and it's therefore something that you would assume you want to avoid. But if you actually looked at the cash flows underneath the hood, you might find that reducing your spending by a mere 3% per year would turn
29:05
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): this particular failure into a comfortable success with plenty of margin. And the question is, would you be willing to cut your spending by 3% per year to achieve a nice success? I assume that most of you would. But the Monte Carlo tools themselves aren't flexible enough to proactively tell you that unless you go in after the fact and try to model out that flexibility and
29:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): really try to look underneath the hood. Another idea is just that retirees can be flexible. Perhaps you build a financial plan using a guardrails approach. Maybe you kind of enjoy the idea of going back to be a part part-time time employee in retirement. helping people, I don't know, find stuff at a Home Depot store. And that part-time work gives you some flexibility. You can delay
29:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Social Security, and that can be a very natural flexibility lever in your retirement plan, allowing you to turn on Social Security during a period of bad market performance to minimize your portfolio withdrawals and minimize any sequence of returns risk. Another topic here, one of my favorite topics, is this concept of need, ability, and willingness to take on
30:05
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): risk. Your need to take risks relates to the amount of objective investment growth required to meet your financial goals. Understanding need starts with this projected cash flow over your coming decades of life: money coming in, money going out, your projected portfolio withdrawals. Those future portfolio withdrawals dictate your need for risk
30:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): today. Ability to take risk is related to need, although it's it's kind of on the opposite side of the coin. An investor's ability to take on risk is based on their capacity to withstand or recover from losses. So need is a function of required growth. Ability is a function of recovery from loss. In general, the more assets you have, the greater
30:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): your capacity to recover from loss. So more assets equals more ability for risk. That's why certain high risk or concentrated or illiquid assets are only appropriate for investors with excess capital. Those investors are the only ones with the ability to take on that risk. And then for younger or newer investors, the ability to take on risk is
31:05
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): directly proportional to their income and their savings rates. If you have a really long timeline of dollar cost averaging ahead of you, then you have decades to make up for any losses today. So your ability to
31:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): get the cost of the cost of the cost of
31:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): take on risk is quite high. The last one, willingness, need, ability, and willingness to take risk. The last one is willingness, and it's the only subjective measure in this trio. Willingness to take on risk is purely mental. How will you react to the higher volatility that comes with high-risk investments? Are you willing to stomach losses? Willingness really
31:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): is not correlated at all with need or ability. And this fact complicates the act of giving responsible financial advice. For example, if someone's need suggests a lot of risk, but their willingness really can't stomach any risk, how do we square that circle? Willingness really is the personal side of this personal finance topic.
31:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Need and ability are both objective. Willingness is subobjective. Each of you listening, your willingness to take on risk will be. unique and different. When I'm designing a portfolio from the bottom up, I'm primarily concerned with the family's need to take on risk. That family's future cash flows are going to dictate a certain amount of money that they ought to have in lower risk
32:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): investments and a certain amount of money that they ought to have in higher risk investments. But what's often the case is that after this accounting for all the cash flows, there's still some money left over. This is what's known as
32:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the money.
32:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): excess capital. And this is where the willingness to take risk comes into play. These are excess dollars, dollars that they don't technically need. So how much risk does someone want to take with money that they don't technically need? That's a personal and subjective question. Bill Bernstein would say: when you've won the game, stop playing. Someone whose assets
32:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): far exceed their needs has very little reason to take on big risks. since extra wealth adds very little to their life, while a severe loss of wealth is probably going to, it might not affect their ability to achieve their financial goals, but they're going to lose sleep and feel a lot of stress. But the flip side here matters too. Imagine
33:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): someone who's underfunded to reach their goals. They just don't have enough money. They're probably going gonna to run out of money before they die. I had some communication back and forth. with a reader on my blog who was in his mid-70s. And this gentleman sat there in his mid-70s. And if his money was 100% invested in bonds, he could very mathematically, reasonably show that he
33:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): was gonna run out of money by his early 80s. Whereas if instead he invested all of his money in stocks, he would widen his range of outcomes. He would introduce the risk of running out of money at like 77 or 78. but he'd also introduce the possibility of extending his portfolio out to his mid to late 80s. Now that's a pretty interesting conundrum. Do you
33:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): accept your fate that you're gonna run on money in in five years no matter what? But at least you know it's a full five years. Or do you take on a lot of risk that might potentially Intentionally dial down five years to only three years if you have bad market performance? But it also might extend. the five years out to eight or nine years. Now, obviously, this is a very
34:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): hard decision. And it's a decision I hope that we all will never have to face ourselves, will never apply to us. We never want to be in a circumstance where no matter what we do, we know we only have a single digit amount of years left of spending in our retirement plans. But I think this is one very specific example where we see how the introduction of risk widens our range.
34:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of outcomes to the good and also to the bad, and where the reduction of risk narrows our range of outcomes to to one very specific path. And in this particular case, the individual was essentially underfunded no matter what, and that introduces a peculiar philosophical question. If you're underfunded no matter what, But do you simply take on a ton of
34:46
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): risk in an effort to maybe have your money outlive you? So I'm going to end today's episode with an interesting anecdote about two very real conversations I've had over the last couple of years. These are two different families with a lot in common. You know, just good people, smart, kind, hardworking people, pleasant to be around, all the wonderful things. Coincidentally, they've
35:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): saved and invested roughly the same amount of money, we'll say between two and a half and three million dollars in their retirement nest eggs. And also, coincidentally, they both are on roughly similar retirement timelines. In their kind of ideal world, they both want to be retired in the next five ish years. And I would argue, for at least from my point of view, that in both their cases, the
35:26
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): numbers alone, uh, the math supports their goal of being retired in the next five years or so. But then it gets interesting. Hence, I wouldn't be telling you this anecdote if it weren't interesting. The first family has made it clear. to me multiple times that their number one goal is, frankly, a bit of a fear-based goal. They do not want to run out of money. They do
35:46
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): not want to have to go back to work. They jokingly tell me they don't want to become a cashier at Wegmans at age 82 to simply survive. That fear, the feelings that that fear brings them, is the biggest defining feature of our conversations, of our goal setting, of a biggest defining feature of of some of the decisions, the various decisions that we've made together. The
36:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): second family has an equally clear priority. They want to give away as much money as they can to charity and to their children while they live. And they want to give away as much money as they can to charity and their children after they pass away. The point being, their desire to give is the biggest defining feature of our conversations. And this
36:26
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): desire has led to some very specific and unique decisions that we've made for this second family. So despite all that the two families have in common, especially all that they have in common in terms of their current financial situation, these two families have made some important and distinct decisions, some different decisions leading up to their soon-to-be retirements. And I suspect that
36:46
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): those different decisions and the different paths that they're on will only continue. to diverge further as they go through their retirements. And if each of these two families looked at the other one, it would be easy for them to say, Well, wait a second. That family seems to have so much in common with me. And yet they're doing some pretty different things. I just don't get it. This seems
37:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): silly or stupid or wrong. And it would seem that way, but it's not that way. Each family is making a different set of decisions, but still an optimal set of decisions for them on the path toward where they want to end up. They're taking different risks, they're accepting different opportunity costs, but ultimately they're making the right decisions, the
37:26
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): unique decisions, based on their circumstances and their goals. So thank you for tuning in today. Please don't forget about that holiday giveaway. If you want to get a free copy of Poor Charlie's Almanac, please leave a rating and review of this podcast on the Apple Podcast app. Take a screenshot of it, send it to me. And if you've already left me a rating and review in the
37:46
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): past, just go back and find it, take a screenshot, send me an email, and you will be in the raffle for these 25 copies of Poor Charlie's Almanac. You can subscribe to my weekly email on the homepage at bestinterest.blog. And if you're interested in learning more about my financial planning practice, visit Plan planwithjesse.com. with Jessica.
38:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Thanks for tuning in
38:04
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): to this episode of Personal Finance for Long-Term Investors. If you have a question for Jesse to answer on a future episode, send him an email over at its blog, The Best Interest. His email address is Jesse at bestinterest dot blog. Again, that's Jesse at bestinterest.blog. Did you enjoy the show? Subscribe, rate, and
38:24
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): review the podcast wherever you listen. This helps others find the show and invest in knowledge themselves.
38:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): And we really appreciate it.
38:32
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): We'll catch you on the next episode of Personal Finance for Long-Term Investors. Personal Finance for Long-Term Investors is a personal podcast meant for education and entertainment. It should not be taken as financial advice, and it's not prescriptive of your financial situation.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Personal Finance for Long-Term Investors

All insights