Alpha Exchange

RBC's Calvasina sets S&P 500 fair value at 8,150, downgrades tech, upgrades healthcare amid AI capex concerns

50 min Listen to the original Episode page
S&P 500 ValuationAI CapExSector RotationFederal Reserve PolicyMarket DrawdownsEarnings SustainabilityGeopolitics

Summary

Lori Calvasina, Managing Director at RBC Capital Markets, outlines a proprietary valuation model placing the S&P 500 fair value at 8,150, derived from a 10% haircut to consensus EPS and base-case macro assumptions. She contrasts the current market with 2022, arguing that strong earnings tailwinds, particularly from the top 10 market-cap stocks, are sustaining equity gains despite rising yields. Calvasina highlights historical concentration in the S&P 500 but notes that net income shares justify current valuations compared to the tech bubble era. Consequently, RBC has downgraded the Technology sector to market weight and upgraded Healthcare to overweight, citing expensive tech valuations and healthcare’s low correlation to AI-driven volatility. The discussion also covers a 'tiers of fear' framework for market drawdowns, noting that aggressive Fed hiking cycles historically cause deeper losses than mild cycles.

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 2:36

    AI Permeation and Macro Takeaways

    Calvasina notes AI themes dominated an energy conference, overshadowing geopolitical concerns. She observes AI permeating financial services, utilities, and industrials, which have become expensive due to the AI trade.

  2. 2:36 – 7:01

    Valuation Model and S&P 500 Fair Value

    Calvasina describes a proprietary model using CPI, Fed policy, and 10-year yields. Applying a 10% haircut to consensus EPS and base-case assumptions (5% yields, 3 Fed hikes), she arrives at an S&P 500 fair value of 8,150.

  3. 7:01 – 11:54

    Comparison of 2026 vs. 2022 Market Dynamics

    The discussion contrasts the current market with 2022. While 10-year yields are high, equity gains are sustained by strong earnings. Calvasina argues earnings are a stronger driver now than in the 2022 sell-off.

  4. 11:54 – 16:55

    Earnings Sustainability and CapEx Cycle

    Calvasina analyzes earnings sustainability, noting CapEx growth is driven by the top 10 market-cap names (hyperscalers). She warns that hedges are rolling off and inventories may need rebuilding at higher prices, risking future estimates.

  5. 16:55 – 21:34

    Index Concentration and Valuation Metrics

    The S&P 500 is historically concentrated (top 10 stocks = 40% of index). Calvasina argues against a 'bubble' classification, noting no significant gap between net income shares and market cap shares compared to the tech bubble era.

  6. 21:34 – 26:23

    Sector Rotation: Tech Downgrade and Healthcare Upgrade

    RBC downgraded Technology to market weight and upgraded Healthcare to overweight. This was driven by expensive tech valuations, decelerating semiconductor earnings, and healthcare’s strong quantitative metrics and low correlation to tech.

  7. 26:23 – 28:53

    Energy Sector Flows and Valuation

    Calvasina notes energy valuations and earnings are good, but flows haven't increased as expected despite the Iran war. She attributes this to the sector being driven by headlines and oil prices rather than long-term conviction.

  8. 28:53 – 50:11

    The 'Tiers of Fear' Drawdown Framework

    Calvasina outlines a four-tier framework for drawdowns: Tier 1 (5-10%), Tier 2 (14-20%, near-miss recession), Tier 3 (14-29%, actual recession), and Tier 4 (~50%, GFC/Tech Bubble).

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
S&P 500indexneutralBut it really is this model that's designed to take all of these different factors and help it express a fair value for the S P 500.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

The S&P 500 fair value is 8,150 based on a model using 5% 10-year yields, 3 Fed hikes, and a 10% haircut to consensus EPS.

Unidentified speaker ·5:04

How to verify: Review RBC Capital Markets' 'Pulse Report' or marketing deck from September 2026 for the specific valuation model assumptions and output.

The top 10 S&P 500 market cap names constitute 40% of the S&P 500 index.

Unidentified speaker ·17:14

How to verify: Check S&P Dow Jones Indices methodology and constituent weightings for the S&P 500 as of late 2026.

The realized correlation of daily returns between XLV (Healthcare) and XLK (Technology) is -40% over the last six months.

Unidentified speaker ·25:19

How to verify: Calculate the correlation of daily total returns for XLV and XLK ETFs over the six-month period preceding November 2, 2026, using financial data providers like Bloomberg or Yahoo Finance.

In the 2021-2022 period, 10-year yields increased by approximately 300 basis points.

Unidentified speaker ·8:56

How to verify: Review US Treasury 10-Year Yield data from the low point in 2021 to the peak in 2022.

Macro variables failed to forecast S&P 500 margins accurately starting around 2015-2016.

Unidentified speaker ·18:16

How to verify: Analyze historical S&P 500 margin data against macro indicators (e.g., CPI, yields) from 2015 to 2016 to identify the breakdown in correlation.

The S&P 500 fair value drops to approximately 7,900 in a stress test scenario with 5.25% 10-year yields and 3.75% inflation.

Unidentified speaker ·6:23

How to verify: Request the specific stress test parameters and outputs from RBC Capital Markets' valuation model documentation.

The S&P 500 is up approximately 13% year-to-date in 2026.

Unidentified speaker ·7:58

How to verify: Check the year-to-date performance of the S&P 500 index for the period ending November 2, 2026.

During the tech bubble peak, the gap between the market cap share and net income share of the top 10 S&P 500 companies was approximately 10%.

Unidentified speaker ·19:55

How to verify: Retrieve historical S&P 500 constituent data for the peak of the tech bubble (approx. 2000) to compare top 10 market cap weights against their aggregate net income contributions.

RBC Capital Markets downgraded Technology to market weight and upgraded Healthcare to overweight in the most recent sector update.

Unidentified speaker ·22:33

How to verify: Review RBC Capital Markets sector strategy reports released prior to November 2, 2026.

ISM New Orders data tends to lead CapEx recovery by a few quarters.

Unidentified speaker ·12:59

How to verify: Analyze historical ISM Manufacturing New Orders data against S&P 500 CapEx growth data to verify the lead-lag relationship.

The S&P 500 is a 15-20 volatility asset, and 5-10% drawdowns occur approximately once a year.

Unidentified speaker ·28:32

How to verify: Calculate the annualized volatility of the S&P 500 using historical price data (e.g., Bloomberg, Yahoo Finance) and count the frequency of peak-to-trough declines between 5-10% over the last 20-30 years.

Since the Global Financial Crisis (GFC), there have been five 'Tier 2' near-miss recession drawdowns (14-20%).

Unidentified speaker ·30:08

How to verify: Identify S&P 500 drawdowns between 14-20% from 2009 to present and cross-reference with NBER recession declarations to confirm they were 'near misses' (no official recession).

The 2018 tariff-driven drawdown was an 18.9% peak-to-trough decline.

Unidentified speaker ·30:32

How to verify: Check historical S&P 500 data for the peak and trough dates in 2018 (typically Oct-Nov 2018) and calculate the percentage decline.

The median drawdown for Tier 3 (recession) events is 27%, and the average is 33%.

Unidentified speaker ·32:09

How to verify: Compile a list of S&P 500 drawdowns during NBER-defined recessions since 1956, calculate the peak-to-trough percentage for each, and determine the median and mean.

There was a ~48% peak-to-trough drawdown in the 1973-1974 period.

Unidentified speaker ·32:44

How to verify: Check historical S&P 500 data for the peak in Jan 1973 and the trough in Oct 1974 to verify the magnitude of the decline.

The 2022 S&P 500 drawdown was 25%.

Unidentified speaker ·33:46

How to verify: Calculate the peak-to-trough decline of the S&P 500 from Jan 2022 to Oct 2022.

The average move in the 2022-2023 Fed hiking cycle was 45-49 basis points per hike.

Unidentified speaker ·37:51

How to verify: Review FOMC meeting minutes and press conferences from 2022-2023 to list the actual basis point changes and calculate the average.

In milder hiking cycles (like 1994-1995), the average move was 25-29 basis points.

Unidentified speaker ·38:05

How to verify: Review FOMC meeting minutes from the 1994-1995 hiking cycle to list the actual basis point changes and calculate the average.

In a split Congress scenario, RBC analysts assigned a neutrality score of 0.09.

Unidentified speaker ·44:05

How to verify: This is an internal RBC survey result; verification would require access to the specific RBC analyst survey data published in October 2026.

Approximately 33% of the S&P 500 reports earnings in the week following the podcast (late October 2026).

Unidentified speaker ·49:30

How to verify: Check the earnings calendar for the S&P 500 companies reporting in the week of late October 2026 and calculate the percentage of the index constituents.

Do your own research

  • Verify RBC Capital Markets' official research reports for the S&P 500 fair value model assumptions, specifically the 10% EPS haircut and P/E multiples implied by 5% yields.
  • Check the latest consensus EPS estimates for the S&P 500 and the top 10 market-cap stocks to assess the sustainability of the earnings tailwinds mentioned.
  • Review the correlation data between the Healthcare Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLV) and the Technology Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLK) over the last six months to validate the diversification claim.
  • Analyze NIPA (National Income and Product Accounts) data to confirm the historical correlation between major market drawdowns and outright corporate profit contraction.
  • Examine RBC Capital Markets' sector rating changes for Technology and Healthcare to understand the specific quantitative metrics and fundamental reasons for the downgrade/upgrade.
  • Review historical Fed hiking cycle data (1994-1995, 2022-2023) to compare the 'smile' shape of mild cycles against the drawdowns seen in aggressive cycles.
  • Monitor energy sector fund flows and oil price movements to assess the 'fickle' nature of investor conviction in the energy sector as described by Calvasina.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Unidentified speaker: I came out at the end of the day and I joked with someone from our commodity strategy team.
0:05
Unidentified speaker: I said, you know, I heard more about AI today than I did about the Iran war.
0:09
Unidentified speaker: That was probably my biggest macro takeaway from that event was they were all talking about how they were powering the data center uh revolution and the AI revolution.
0:19
Unidentified speaker: Um so I do think increasingly, you know, that the technology is permeating just about everything.
0:24
Unidentified speaker: Financial services, right, talk a lot about their AI use cases.
0:29
Unidentified speaker: Um, utilities, for example, very expensive sector in the market, but it got there after it became a pillar of the AI trade.
0:36
Unidentified speaker: Industrial, similarly expensive.
0:40
Unidentified speaker: Hello, this is Dean Curnutt, and welcome to the Alpha Exchange, where we explore topics in financial markets associated with managing risk, generating return, and the deployment of capital in the alternative investment industry.
0:58
Unidentified speaker: I'm joined today by Lori Calvicina.
1:00
Unidentified speaker: She is the head of U.S.
1:02
Unidentified speaker: equity strategy at RVC Capital Markets, a role in which she's advising the firm's clients on allocating capital across sectors, across themes during what can only be called fascinating times in markets and the world.
1:18
Unidentified speaker: Lori, it's great to welcome you back to the podcast.
1:21
Unidentified speaker: Thanks for having me.
1:21
Unidentified speaker: I'm a big fan of the podcast, so it's an honor to be asked.
1:25
Unidentified speaker: I am looking forward to the conversation and just to dive into some of the work you're doing on the portfolio strategy front.
1:32
Unidentified speaker: Again, in an era in which this AI theme is everywhere, but there's so many other cross currents, whether they're rates, crude inflation, the monetary policy response, there's so much going on.
1:45
Unidentified speaker: Let us start with a little bit of framework first.
1:49
Unidentified speaker: So as I prepared for this conversation, I saw you did a piece on financial news, and you were talking about the rates side of things.
2:00
Unidentified speaker: So not where you're extremely focused, but you're taking it as an input into your process.
2:05
Unidentified speaker: You're modeling the path of equities with rates as some part of the input.
2:11
Unidentified speaker: So we saw rates go way up, they've come back down a little bit recently.
2:16
Unidentified speaker: So what I'd love to do is start with just your process of marrying these broad economic indicators like rates, like inflation, to the more markets backdrop of valuations, earnings growth.
2:30
Unidentified speaker: Give us just the big picture of how you bring all these things together in terms of your process.
2:36
Unidentified speaker: It's a great jumping off point, Dean.
2:38
Unidentified speaker: And I'll tell you, there's this one model we have in our weekly Pulse report.
2:42
Unidentified speaker: It's also in my marketing deck for people who meet with me.
2:45
Unidentified speaker: And I've been talking about it, I would say, ad nauseum since June.
2:48
Unidentified speaker: And we've tweaked the assumptions along the way, updated the model, you know, updated some of the assumptions, added a ton of stress tests.
2:55
Unidentified speaker: I can't even keep track of all the stress tests we have in there anymore.
2:58
Unidentified speaker: But it really is this model that's designed to take all of these different factors and help it express a fair value for the S P 500.
3:07
Unidentified speaker: And so what we do on the earnings side, I would say is pretty simple.
3:10
Unidentified speaker: We're leveraging the Bloomberg data on bottom-up consensus EPS, and then we're making some assumptions around that, that our starting point are those bottom-up company level inputs.
3:19
Unidentified speaker: I would say where I've spent more time really modeling things out and noodling over them.
3:23
Unidentified speaker: And I joke, I built this model in my basement in the summer 2022 when I was a little bit short-staffed at work and I was not traveling as much, and I was really just preoccupied with the question of what are the different macro variables that move PE multiples.
3:37
Unidentified speaker: And I have this one PE time series that goes back to 1962, actually goes back to the 30s.
3:42
Unidentified speaker: I start my model in 62.
3:44
Unidentified speaker: But I just did a tremendous amount of testing and tinkering with this and came up with a formula of CPI, the Fed and in CPI, the Fed and 10-year yields as the inputs because in most decades, those have actually had inverse correlations with this PE.
3:58
Unidentified speaker: In the most recent version of the model, I have kicked out the 2010s from the regression analysis that we run because that was just really kind of an abnormal period where you didn't have those inverse correlations.
4:08
Unidentified speaker: I found that dramatically improved the efficacy of the model.
4:11
Unidentified speaker: But essentially, what we do is I'll take RBC house views, I'll take the consensus views as published on Bloomberg, and then in what has become an endless list of stress tests, just my own theory about how all those variables could fit together and what kind of PE it implies based on that historical analysis.
4:28
Unidentified speaker: And so we take that PE and then we marry it up with the earnings estimates and come up with a fair value for the S P 500.
4:35
Unidentified speaker: And the long and short of it is that right now, you know, I'm haircutting consensus EPS by about 10%.
4:40
Unidentified speaker: We last updated this model in September.
4:42
Unidentified speaker: We don't do it every week, but we looked at it and then we said, well, what if the base case is really 10-year yields at 5%, three hikes from the Fed and inflation where the consensus numbers have been in the low twos, RBC is there as well.
4:56
Unidentified speaker: And this is for the midpoint of next year, is kind of our focal point in time at the moment.
5:01
Unidentified speaker: We just took that up a notch and made it a bit worse to 275.
5:04
Unidentified speaker: That PE output, if you marry it up with the consensus earnings, care cut by 10% again, gets you about 8150 and the SP 500 is fair value.
5:13
Unidentified speaker: So that's our official price target right now.
5:15
Unidentified speaker: Normally I look at, you know, a few other models and take the median or the average, but what I've been doing in recent updates is really just sticking with that valuation and earnings model.
5:24
Unidentified speaker: And I joke, you know, I'm not trying to take away the job of my econ team or my rates team.
5:28
Unidentified speaker: I'm not trying to make their forecasts, but I am going out in the field and talking to a lot of people and just trying to listen, what are people reasonably worried about?
5:37
Unidentified speaker: Not just sort of the Armageddon scenario, right?
5:40
Unidentified speaker: But what could reasonably happen that's causing people some stress?
5:43
Unidentified speaker: Let's throw it into the model and see what the fair value is.
5:46
Unidentified speaker: And I initially, early in the summer, was only haircutting that earnings assumption by about 5%.
5:52
Unidentified speaker: That was when there was concern the war would damage the non-AI side of the economy.
5:56
Unidentified speaker: But as we got deeper into the summer, people started to worry, well, maybe those AI numbers are a little bit too frothy.
6:01
Unidentified speaker: Maybe things are going to slow down a little bit worse than what people are anticipating.
6:05
Unidentified speaker: So that other 5% comes from trying to reflect that fear as well.
6:10
Unidentified speaker: Now, of course, yields moved up, right?
6:12
Unidentified speaker: And they've moved back down now, similar to where my base case was back in September.
6:16
Unidentified speaker: But one of our stress tests just adds in another hike, takes inflation up to three, and takes tenure yields up to five and a quarter.
6:23
Unidentified speaker: That math gets you to fair value of about 7,900 in the SP.
6:28
Unidentified speaker: And, you know, if we go on and look at other stress tests, I have some in there that ignore all the macro assumptions and inputs and just take the typical contraction that you see in hiking cycles, you start to get various flavors of a down market over the next 12 months, including one of my stress tests that models in 5.5% on tenure yields and more like six hikes and 375 inflation.
6:49
Unidentified speaker: So we think that what we essentially did with this move in yields that we have recently, and everyone wants to know where the tipping point is on tenure yields.
6:56
Unidentified speaker: I can't give you a single number, but we do think we got close to it, but didn't quite cross it.
7:01
Unidentified speaker: You mentioned 2022.
7:02
Unidentified speaker: What a fascinating year.
7:04
Unidentified speaker: The Fed is vastly behind the curve.
7:07
Unidentified speaker: It didn't even tighten until I want to say May of 2022.
7:11
Unidentified speaker: You still had the policy rate at zero.
7:14
Unidentified speaker: So it had a tremendous amount of catch up to do in a short period of time.
7:18
Unidentified speaker: We were doing 75 basis points at a clip, especially post that 10-year period post the GFC.
7:24
Unidentified speaker: It seemed like that could never happen.
7:26
Unidentified speaker: That's how far behind the curve the Fed was.
7:29
Unidentified speaker: And then what's 2022?
7:31
Unidentified speaker: The bond market and the stock market both sell off in unison a significant amount, right?
7:37
Unidentified speaker: That's a big drawdown over the course of a year in both asset classes.
7:42
Unidentified speaker: What is different from the then versus now?
7:45
Unidentified speaker: You mentioned the 10-year, I think the 10-year yield has gotten as high as 2022, maybe even got higher, but the equity market has found a way to sustain its gains and even add to them.
7:58
Unidentified speaker: I think we're up 13% or so in the SP this year.
8:02
Unidentified speaker: When you look at 2026 versus 2022, give me what's similar and what's different.
8:07
Unidentified speaker: One thing right off the bat that's a little bit different is we had a very different earnings backdrop back then.
8:12
Unidentified speaker: You know, I joke that it's sort of a sliding scale, right, between the pressures on the PE and the tailwinds that we're getting from the earnings environment that are dictating the direction of stock prices, right?
8:22
Unidentified speaker: And we've got these pressures on the PE from rates and inflation.
8:24
Unidentified speaker: We've got this tremendous tailwind from earnings.
8:27
Unidentified speaker: I would argue that tailwind from earnings is much stronger now.
8:30
Unidentified speaker: And I would also frankly argue that sort of the headwind from the PEs on the PEs is probably not quite as bad as it was.
8:38
Unidentified speaker: I'm going to move away from my valuation and earnings model for a minute and just talk 10-year yields.
8:43
Unidentified speaker: And if you think back to 2021, 2022, we had a tremendous, if you sort of look at like that low point in 2021 and go up to 2022, I think it was like a 300 some odd basis point increase in 10-year yields.
8:56
Unidentified speaker: And it was just a massive amount in a hurry.
8:58
Unidentified speaker: If you look at where the numbers have been more recently, it hasn't been nearly that much.
9:02
Unidentified speaker: I mean, it's been, I think, more than 100 basis points.
9:05
Unidentified speaker: I forget the exact numbers we're at, but it's actually similar to the increase in interest rates and tenure yields that we saw in late 2024, which by the way, is one that the market essentially ignored.
9:15
Unidentified speaker: Now, if I go back and I look at, you know, sort of periods in late 23, early 24, when we had much more modest increases in tenure yields than what we had kind of back in 21, 22, we got five and 10% drawdowns in the equity market.
9:31
Unidentified speaker: So post that 2022 episode, which I think was just a very dramatic repricing in terms of magnitude, we kind of had these baby pullbacks in the market.
9:40
Unidentified speaker: And then we had one that the market was able to ignore.
9:42
Unidentified speaker: And this one essentially, it hasn't felt very good, but I would say the market has ignored this, maybe some pain underneath the surface.
9:50
Unidentified speaker: I do think that starting point and the size of the shift matters tremendously.
9:54
Unidentified speaker: I think we also had the Russia-Ukraine war back then.
9:57
Unidentified speaker: We obviously have the Iran war today.
9:59
Unidentified speaker: In some way, those are similar in terms of having that geopolitical shock.
10:03
Unidentified speaker: Geopolitical shocks can tend to depress your PE multiples.
10:06
Unidentified speaker: But again, I think we've just had this tremendous earnings tailwind.
10:10
Unidentified speaker: And frankly, Dean, when I talk to investors about risks going forward, I kind of have four on my list because we are looking for another five to 10% drawdown in here.
10:17
Unidentified speaker: And we talk about the war's gone on longer than anticipated, the midterms that tends to create tremendous volatility if you look at 2018 and 2022.
10:25
Unidentified speaker: And then the interest rate environment, you know, we think is a challenge in here.
10:29
Unidentified speaker: What I have a lot of long-onlies do is dismiss those and say, well, those are all well known, those are all well understood.
10:34
Unidentified speaker: But the fourth one on my list is the one they want to talk about.
10:38
Unidentified speaker: And that's the potential need for 2027 earnings estimates to come in a bit.
10:41
Unidentified speaker: I don't think we're looking at contracting growth, but that's the one that people understand is this pillar of strength that's keeping things afloat.
10:49
Unidentified speaker: They haven't really thought about beyond just the slowdown in the math, what happens if the numbers are too high.
10:55
Unidentified speaker: And so that's the one in my meetings.
10:57
Unidentified speaker: People really want to dig into and explore a bit.
10:59
Unidentified speaker: What happened earlier this year is that realized earnings just had a step function higher.
11:05
Unidentified speaker: There was just a lurch higher in these.
11:07
Unidentified speaker: And so what you can do is look at the overall market and say, actually, the PE came in a little bit.
11:14
Unidentified speaker: And so what some would say, and I think this is where you're going, I'd love for you to run with this a little bit, is that, and I don't want to use this word, but I'll throw it in there.
11:22
Unidentified speaker: People are saying maybe earnings are the bubble.
11:24
Unidentified speaker: It's not a PE bubble, but that these earnings are so high and that perhaps they're just unsustainably high.
11:31
Unidentified speaker: They're so driven by this capex cycle.
11:34
Unidentified speaker: Just as you think about the earnings engine that is the SP, you differentiated 2022 versus 2026 really by earnings.
11:42
Unidentified speaker: There was a slowdown of earnings in 2022.
11:45
Unidentified speaker: And here we're at these sky-high levels.
11:48
Unidentified speaker: So just walk through your thought process on earnings and how we should think about the pathway there.
11:54
Unidentified speaker: I'm going to give you the pro and the con.
11:55
Unidentified speaker: I'm an old debater, so we'll kind of look at it from both sides.
11:58
Unidentified speaker: And I would say a lot of my meetings when we talk about the CapEx cycle, I do try to calm people down a little bit.
12:04
Unidentified speaker: And we have these charts where we look at just year-over-year capex growth and the S P 500.
12:10
Unidentified speaker: And you've been inching above past highs.
12:12
Unidentified speaker: We only have these stats through 2Q.
12:14
Unidentified speaker: We'll see where 3Q is.
12:15
Unidentified speaker: But I tell people, I say, I understand why you're freaking out a little bit about this.
12:19
Unidentified speaker: But we decompose CapEx and we look at the top 10 market cap names rebalanced over time, and then we look at the rest of the index.
12:26
Unidentified speaker: I'm an old small cap strategist, so we also look at the Russell 2000 and the Russell mid-cap index.
12:30
Unidentified speaker: And what we see when we decompose all these numbers is that the SP top 10 market cap names, which is where all your kind of big hyperscalers, AI leaders are sitting, these are the ones who have been driving the overall cycle.
12:42
Unidentified speaker: They are up to those peaks, right?
12:44
Unidentified speaker: And that does look like it might be leveling off just a little bit.
12:47
Unidentified speaker: If you look at the rest of the market, we're in very early days of a CapEx recovery.
12:52
Unidentified speaker: And if you look at the rest of the market and you look at correlations with something like ISM New Orders tends to lead by a few quarters.
12:59
Unidentified speaker: Now, we're seeing a little bit of a stall in that ISM New Order data point, but in general, ISM manufacturing ISM new orders are in their own early stages of a recovery.
13:09
Unidentified speaker: So the question going forward really is the rest of the market going to be able to have this catch up on CapEx?
13:15
Unidentified speaker: The data, I think, bears monitoring, but still looks pretty good.
13:19
Unidentified speaker: One question we do have, right, is how far the Fed is going to push these hikes?
13:23
Unidentified speaker: Because if you go back and we did this big study where we looked at economic indicators and all these, basically everything I like to watch day to day, we looked at it in hiking cycles.
13:32
Unidentified speaker: And you do sometimes tend to see either ahead of the hiking cycle or during a stall in those CapEx indicators, right?
13:38
Unidentified speaker: So we want to make sure the Fed doesn't push things too far and stall that out.
13:42
Unidentified speaker: But there is an opportunity for the rest of the market to catch up and extend things.
13:46
Unidentified speaker: So that's the bull argument.
13:47
Unidentified speaker: I would say kind of the bare argument on earnings is just that if you look back to 2018, 2019 and 2022, 2023, we had tariff one and then we had the Russia-Ukraine war.
14:00
Unidentified speaker: And if you looked at bottom-up consensus earnings estimates in the summer of the prior year to the end of the year in question.
14:06
Unidentified speaker: So for 2018, you're looking like June of 2017 through December of 2018.
14:11
Unidentified speaker: When you look at it on that basis, what we saw was that basically the second half of 2018, the consensus numbers were fine.
14:19
Unidentified speaker: In 2022, the consensus numbers for that year came in just a tiny bit, but were generally fine.
14:25
Unidentified speaker: There were no big problems on the current year numbers of the year in which the crisis occurred.
14:30
Unidentified speaker: Now, if you look at 2019 and you look at 2023, from the summer of 2018 and the summer of 2022, those numbers were steadily drawn down and ended up in a much worse place than where they had been initially.
14:43
Unidentified speaker: What I think that speaks to is this idea, companies are really good at managing through for a few quarters.
14:50
Unidentified speaker: We've gone back and looked at all this data since the GFC.
14:53
Unidentified speaker: That's as far back as the kind of consistent data on this goes.
14:56
Unidentified speaker: And what we tend to see is just a general flattening out of the second half of the year.
15:00
Unidentified speaker: By the time you get to the middle of the year, companies can make it a few more quarters.
15:04
Unidentified speaker: It doesn't really matter what you throw at them.
15:06
Unidentified speaker: Let's put that into context today.
15:08
Unidentified speaker: If you think back, not the last reporting season, because companies, I will give a little bit of shade.
15:14
Unidentified speaker: I think that companies hid from the Iran war issue and how it's impacting them and how they're managing through it.
15:18
Unidentified speaker: We just didn't get a lot of commentary on it.
15:20
Unidentified speaker: You go back two reporting seasons ago after the war broke out, and that conference period in March, we monitor a lot of transcripts.
15:27
Unidentified speaker: You know, we monitored not just SP companies, but Russell companies when the war first broke out.
15:33
Unidentified speaker: Initially, what we were seeing was we've got a few quarters of inventory to run through.
15:38
Unidentified speaker: We've got hedges in place.
15:40
Unidentified speaker: And there was a lot of we can manage through this.
15:41
Unidentified speaker: And when you would see analysts ask companies, how long do you think the war is going to go?
15:44
Unidentified speaker: They would say a few quarters through the end of the summer.
15:47
Unidentified speaker: Guess what, guys?
15:48
Unidentified speaker: We're here.
15:48
Unidentified speaker: And now it's time to talk.
15:50
Unidentified speaker: And so I was a bit irritated in this last reporting season.
15:53
Unidentified speaker: We didn't get more updates.
15:54
Unidentified speaker: We got a few.
15:55
Unidentified speaker: We have started to see, and there's, I can't talk about specific companies, but there was one, you know, food and beverage company that talked for two reporting seasons now that some of their hedges are starting to roll off.
16:05
Unidentified speaker: And we've seen one company.
16:07
Unidentified speaker: I remember saying in the last reporting season, if oil kind of stays below 100, I'm not sure if they were talking Brent or WTI, but we should be able to manage.
16:15
Unidentified speaker: But if it goes over 100 and stays there, it's going to be a problem.
16:19
Unidentified speaker: So we're starting to get a little bit of hints that maybe that time of kind of trueing up to the reality that confronts companies may be here.
16:27
Unidentified speaker: And just think about it this way: the hedges roll off, you have to reset them at higher prices, the inventories get worked down, you have to rebuild them at higher prices.
16:34
Unidentified speaker: We think there's room for some downward estimate revisions just on the basis of that kind of thing.
16:39
Unidentified speaker: And that's one of the reasons why we are modeling in that 10% haircut into our own model.
16:44
Unidentified speaker: You have the benefit of doing this for quite some time.
16:47
Unidentified speaker: You've seen a lot of cycles, and you get a chance to really see how the economy evolves and the market evolves.
16:55
Unidentified speaker: And we've got this benchmark called the S P 500, which is just an incredible benchmark.
17:02
Unidentified speaker: It's very difficult to beat.
17:03
Unidentified speaker: It's incredibly concentrated, more so than we've really ever seen in history.
17:08
Unidentified speaker: If we were having this conversation 20 years ago, maybe the financials were 27% of the SP.
17:14
Unidentified speaker: And now you've got the top 10 stocks, all of which are in some version of tech, are 40% of the SP.
17:21
Unidentified speaker: It's an incredibly concentrated index.
17:24
Unidentified speaker: I'm curious just how that changes the thought process, the analysis, and the conversations with clients, just how top-heavy and concentrated the index has become.
17:35
Unidentified speaker: I'll tell you, Dean, one of the things that we did recently, we talked about methodology at the top of the show.
17:40
Unidentified speaker: I used to do my own kind of top-down version of an S P 500 earnings model.
17:45
Unidentified speaker: It was a lovely model.
17:46
Unidentified speaker: Clients really liked it.
17:47
Unidentified speaker: And I've discontinued it now.
17:49
Unidentified speaker: And I think there's some consternation with me because I did discontinue it.
17:52
Unidentified speaker: But I'll tell you part of the reason why was I think this concentration issue because margins were just getting to a point where I didn't feel like I could be intellectually honest in my ability to predict them and to make assumptions that made sense to me putting into the spreadsheet.
18:07
Unidentified speaker: And I just came to the conclusion.
18:08
Unidentified speaker: And we'd really seen, by the way, that the ability of kind of macro variables to forecast margins had broken down around 2015, 2016.
18:16
Unidentified speaker: And that's when we really started to see an enormous expansion in tech margins relative to the rest of the index.
18:22
Unidentified speaker: And it is in general a secular theme, right?
18:25
Unidentified speaker: This idea of productivity, software, automation, not just benefiting those companies, but benefiting other companies in the index as well.
18:33
Unidentified speaker: I made the decision that we really just had to start looking at this on a company by company basis, right?
18:39
Unidentified speaker: And so that's why we use that bottom-up consensus as our starting point.
18:42
Unidentified speaker: And then we make some adjustments based on that.
18:45
Unidentified speaker: But I do think that concentration has been a problem from that perspective.
18:50
Unidentified speaker: And I do think just as a street community, we're chronically, you know, in the forecasting community, underestimating things.
18:56
Unidentified speaker: And I think that ability to manage that issue, I think has become problematic.
19:00
Unidentified speaker: Now, I will say on the more broader issue of concentration, I started in 2000.
19:07
Unidentified speaker: So, right, smack dab in the middle of the tech bubble as it was imploding.
19:11
Unidentified speaker: I worked for someone who had been a strategist in the 70s.
19:14
Unidentified speaker: And so I heard a lot about kind of prior bubbles that had been in place just by virtue of my entry point.
19:20
Unidentified speaker: And I go back, and you know, one of the reasons I like using this data that goes back to the 60s on my valuation model is it does capture some of those bubble periods that we have in the past and factors that into the analysis.
19:31
Unidentified speaker: In my own work, I have another chart where we look at the net income share of the top 10 market cap names in the S P 500 and the market cap share.
19:40
Unidentified speaker: And just see does the market cap, you know, kind of allocation to those top 10 companies, does it reflect the reality of net income?
19:47
Unidentified speaker: And if you go back to the peak of the tech bubble, I think the gap between the two, where kind of market cap was oversteady the net income was like 10% or so.
19:55
Unidentified speaker: I don't see a gap in that chart right now.
19:57
Unidentified speaker: I have seen a gap at various points over the past few years in that, but it hasn't been as wide as that 10% number.
20:05
Unidentified speaker: And right now there's no gap.
20:06
Unidentified speaker: So the market's really not giving you any kind of premium.
20:10
Unidentified speaker: Now, that could tell us the market is starting to undervalue these companies.
20:13
Unidentified speaker: It could also tell you the market is starting to not believe some of those net income numbers.
20:18
Unidentified speaker: But I do see a big difference in that analysis from the tech bubble days.
20:22
Unidentified speaker: And I would say, you know, I know that people like to throw that word around a lot.
20:26
Unidentified speaker: I do think we have challenges to work through, but I'm just not in the bubble camp because of that.
20:31
Unidentified speaker: When you talk about your start in the industry in 2000, again, the bubble word gets thrown around, but it's very clear that the valuation profile of these top 10, let's say, versus 2000, Cisco, AOL, Intel, they were just much higher in terms of PE than they are today, the equivalent of today.
20:54
Unidentified speaker: But we do have this concentrated index.
20:56
Unidentified speaker: It got that way because these stocks have just done so well.
20:59
Unidentified speaker: That's the market cap waiting scheme of the SP.
21:02
Unidentified speaker: And so where I'd love to turn is on the sameness of those stocks, at least potentially, they're all in the same sandbox of AI.
21:12
Unidentified speaker: And how you think about advising your firm's clients on trying to find diversifiers.
21:19
Unidentified speaker: I know you've just put an overweight on healthcare.
21:22
Unidentified speaker: I think that's a super interesting area to explore.
21:25
Unidentified speaker: So tell us how you think about trying to find those assets or themes or sectors that are just different than this AI theme.
21:34
Unidentified speaker: It's a great starting point.
21:35
Unidentified speaker: And it's getting to be something that's a little bit harder and harder to find, right?
21:38
Unidentified speaker: We do a tremendous energy conference in June at RBC.
21:41
Unidentified speaker: We have really just a great franchise across the bank.
21:43
Unidentified speaker: And I remember I only went to the first day of that conference, but I came out at the end of the day and I joked with someone from our commodity strategy team.
21:50
Unidentified speaker: I said, I heard more about AI today than I did about the Iran war.
21:55
Unidentified speaker: I thought that was probably my biggest macro takeaway from that event was they were all talking about how they were powering the data center revolution and the AI revolution.
22:04
Unidentified speaker: So I do think increasingly the technology is permeating just about everything.
22:09
Unidentified speaker: Financial services talk a lot about their AI use cases.
22:13
Unidentified speaker: Utilities, for example, very expensive sector in the market, but it got there after it became a pillar of the AI trade.
22:20
Unidentified speaker: Industrial, similarly expensive.
22:22
Unidentified speaker: What I think we're trying to do with our work, and I was telling someone earlier today, actually, I said with our overweights and our underweights, I'm not really trying to call every sector, but what I am trying to do is tell you where I have conviction and where I have views.
22:33
Unidentified speaker: And we did pull our technology overweight down.
22:36
Unidentified speaker: We had upgraded it in mid-July.
22:38
Unidentified speaker: I've been market weight a long time prior to that.
22:40
Unidentified speaker: It looked very expensive on our work for a long time, but we got a valuation opportunity, you know, to buy the sector in the middle of the summer.
22:48
Unidentified speaker: And earnings revisions were holding up very nicely.
22:50
Unidentified speaker: And I was hearing from a lot of investors that they thought there was a positioning unwind going on in things like semis and wanted to come back.
22:57
Unidentified speaker: And we got to a point where we thought that there was a reasonable high conviction need to come back in.
23:03
Unidentified speaker: We overweighted it, but we found recently it's gotten expensive again, and semis earnings revisions have started to decelerate.
23:10
Unidentified speaker: So we pulled the overweight off.
23:12
Unidentified speaker: We replaced it with healthcare.
23:14
Unidentified speaker: And what I would say we're seeing there, I don't know that I'm seeing any direct AI read-throughs right now.
23:19
Unidentified speaker: Maybe that's a good thing.
23:21
Unidentified speaker: But if you think about valuations, flows, earnings revisions, sales revisions, all our quant stuff, it all looks very good.
23:29
Unidentified speaker: And then if you go back, I do a survey of our analyst once a quarter.
23:33
Unidentified speaker: So I always joke, I'm not beholden to the analyst, but they are an input into my process.
23:38
Unidentified speaker: And so we do a big survey of them once a quarter.
23:40
Unidentified speaker: We ask a bunch of questions, but the main one is what's your outlook for performance over the next six to 12 months?
23:46
Unidentified speaker: What was interesting there, my analysts in the US worked neutral.
23:50
Unidentified speaker: But if you looked at my global analysts, so bringing in Canada, Australia, London, they were much more bullish at the global level.
23:58
Unidentified speaker: So that at least told me that global investors were going to be looking at this sector.
24:02
Unidentified speaker: And then we had some questions on risk factors.
24:04
Unidentified speaker: And maybe I was wrong a few minutes ago.
24:06
Unidentified speaker: Maybe there is a direct AI read-through here because I had two questions on risks.
24:11
Unidentified speaker: And one, this was for the US analysts specifically.
24:13
Unidentified speaker: And I said, if tenure yields go to 5.5% and stay there for a sustained period of time, what's the outlook implication for your industry?
24:20
Unidentified speaker: Healthcare was one of the better sectors there.
24:22
Unidentified speaker: It wasn't wildly bullish, but it was one of the better scores.
24:25
Unidentified speaker: And then on the AI question, I said, what if the AI theme slows down?
24:28
Unidentified speaker: What are the implications?
24:30
Unidentified speaker: And it's funny, I will say maybe some of my analysts were more neutral, whereas maybe I thought they would be negative, but that was their call.
24:36
Unidentified speaker: But the clear most bullish outlier was the healthcare sector, where our analysts have really come to understood that that sector is starting to serve as a hedge on the AI theme and on tech performance in particular.
24:48
Unidentified speaker: So that all contributed to our upgrade.
24:50
Unidentified speaker: Rarely is anything 100% aligned across all of our indicators, but I will tell you, Dean, it was my team and I sat down when we decided we wanted to downgrade tech.
24:59
Unidentified speaker: And so we need to find something else.
25:00
Unidentified speaker: And it was really the only thing that we thought made sense just looking across the data.
25:05
Unidentified speaker: A lot of other things have hair on it.
25:07
Unidentified speaker: We think industrials is one to watch.
25:09
Unidentified speaker: It's still just very expensive right now.
25:12
Unidentified speaker: My own orientation is to look at diversification from through the lens of just the daily correlation of returns.
25:19
Unidentified speaker: And so if you run the XLV, the healthcare ETF versus the XLK, which is basically the triple Q, that realized correlation of daily returns is negative 40% over the last six months.
25:33
Unidentified speaker: That's remarkably low.
25:34
Unidentified speaker: That's an incredible diversifier.
25:37
Unidentified speaker: And I'm guessing it's a similar setup in something like energy, as you remember, as you just referenced.
25:42
Unidentified speaker: How does energy fit in amidst the war, amidst the gas prices?
25:47
Unidentified speaker: It's historically just unrelated or less related to assets like tech.
25:53
Unidentified speaker: How does that fit into your thinking right now?
25:56
Unidentified speaker: It's interesting.
25:56
Unidentified speaker: You know, it's a very small weight in the S P 500.
25:59
Unidentified speaker: So that's something we always have in the back of our minds.
26:02
Unidentified speaker: If you have any exposure, you're probably doing more than most folks at this point.
26:06
Unidentified speaker: But the reality with energy is we're neutral, but in terms of what we've written, and we actually wrote back in July, not this last batch of sector updates, but two updates ago.
26:16
Unidentified speaker: And I would say our thinking still applies here, which is there's a lot of interesting things going on here, right?
26:21
Unidentified speaker: The valuations still look good.
26:23
Unidentified speaker: I would say more so in large cap than small cap, but generally we see good valuations.
26:27
Unidentified speaker: We see good earnings revisions here.
26:30
Unidentified speaker: The flows we had thought might have taken off a bit more in this sort of second act of the Iran war.
26:36
Unidentified speaker: You know, we had that kind of initial de-escalation over the summer where it looked like things were headed in a good direction, and then it flared back up.
26:42
Unidentified speaker: We would have thought we'd see more better flows to energy, but we haven't seen them there yet.
26:46
Unidentified speaker: Our analysts have been pretty bullish on the sector.
26:49
Unidentified speaker: There's a lot to like in this sector.
26:51
Unidentified speaker: I think at the end of the day, and I think this is expressed through this flow data, it does feel very much like a sector that's driven by war headlines and oil prices.
27:00
Unidentified speaker: And if you think about the earnings revision data point I just mentioned a moment ago, we tend to notice when oil prices move up, you tend to get those upward revisions and oil prices move down, you take tend to get those downward revisions.
27:12
Unidentified speaker: So that's an indicator that feels a little fickle to me.
27:15
Unidentified speaker: So we haven't really had the conviction to upgrade it on a six to 12 month view, but we have said there's a lot that's very interesting and going on here.
27:23
Unidentified speaker: And the other thing we wrote about back in July, and this was after I had come back from doing some international trips, there has been a contingent of people.
27:31
Unidentified speaker: I spend more of my time in the long-only world, but I would say there's been a contingent of people who just haven't been willing to look at energy for multiple years because of very climate type concerns or certain mandates that they have at their fund.
27:44
Unidentified speaker: And I do think one of the legacies of the Iran war has been that people have been forced to look at it again.
27:50
Unidentified speaker: And I do think the industry is doing a good job of telling the more expansive story again.
27:54
Unidentified speaker: I go back to our June conference, but I do think this is one that people who haven't looked at in a long time are able to look at again and consider buying.
28:03
Unidentified speaker: And so I think that is a positive for the space.
28:05
Unidentified speaker: You've done some recent work and you've brought in the band Tears for Fears in this analysis.
28:10
Unidentified speaker: You called it Tears of Fear, meaning just different levels of drawdowns.
28:15
Unidentified speaker: This is really near and dear to my own kind of market study.
28:19
Unidentified speaker: I love thinking about drawdowns, what causes them, how long they take, the damage that's done during them.
28:27
Unidentified speaker: You've got four different tiers.
28:28
Unidentified speaker: One is, I think you called it garden variety, five to ten percent.
28:32
Unidentified speaker: You know, SP is a 15 to 20 vol asset.
28:34
Unidentified speaker: It's going to happen, I think, maybe once a year.
28:37
Unidentified speaker: Nothing really to write home about, but you've talked a little bit more about tier two, which is more significant and rarer.
28:45
Unidentified speaker: So walk us through basically the framework and then maybe the tier two and why you've highlighted that one.
28:52
Unidentified speaker: All right.
28:53
Unidentified speaker: It's a great starting off point.
28:54
Unidentified speaker: And look, I'll say, I'll give you my disclaimer, which is this is designed to keep you calm in times of crisis, right?
29:01
Unidentified speaker: I think sometimes I show this to people for the first time and they recoil a little bit.
29:05
Unidentified speaker: As you mentioned, there's sort of tier, and I'll back up as well.
29:07
Unidentified speaker: This is really based mostly on my lived experience as a strategist.
29:11
Unidentified speaker: Again, starting back in 2000.
29:13
Unidentified speaker: And, you know, it's what I lived through, right?
29:15
Unidentified speaker: What I remember best, what I note.
29:17
Unidentified speaker: And then we drop in some additional historical perspective along the way.
29:21
Unidentified speaker: And so tier one, again, it's the garden variety pullback.
29:23
Unidentified speaker: We have these all the time.
29:24
Unidentified speaker: They don't feel great in the moment.
29:26
Unidentified speaker: But the critical question is, do you think we're going to really risk a recession or not?
29:30
Unidentified speaker: Do you think that there is something massively out of control that can't be contained?
29:34
Unidentified speaker: If the answer to those questions is yes, and you should have that conversation with yourself around, you know, kind of eight, nine percent, if you think the answer to those questions is that things can be contained, you're probably gonna bottom out around 10%.
29:46
Unidentified speaker: And that's where you want to hold your nose and buy.
29:48
Unidentified speaker: If you think things are seriously at risk of spiraling out of control or that there's a real possibility that we're going to have a recession because of whatever has happened, you're probably going into at least tier two.
29:58
Unidentified speaker: And if you link back to the post-GFC world, and I became a small cap strategist in 2007.
30:04
Unidentified speaker: So this is my time on the hot seat, is that post-GFC world.
30:08
Unidentified speaker: But really, since then, we've had five of these.
30:11
Unidentified speaker: And what we've noticed is that if you break 10, you're going to 14, right?
30:16
Unidentified speaker: There's not really anything in between.
30:18
Unidentified speaker: You can hit these air pockets.
30:20
Unidentified speaker: And so we tell people to be prepared for that, right?
30:23
Unidentified speaker: And it's not to say you can go 10.3%, right?
30:25
Unidentified speaker: But you're not going to go to 11 or 12 typically.
30:28
Unidentified speaker: And so the tier two is really the near misses.
30:32
Unidentified speaker: And if you think back to tariffs, that was an 18.9% drawdown peak to trough, recession near miss.
30:38
Unidentified speaker: And we did have for, I think it only lasted about maybe 24 to 36 hours, but there was a real serious belief that the tariffs were going to throw us into a recession that lasted for a little while.
30:48
Unidentified speaker: If you think about others, 2010, 2011, 2015, 16, 2018.
30:53
Unidentified speaker: So 2018 was tariffs one, but we also had tremendous fears around the Fed and policy error that happened then as well.
31:00
Unidentified speaker: If you think back to 2015-2016, it was an industrial recession, an energy recession.
31:05
Unidentified speaker: The consumer bailed us out, so we didn't have an actual recession.
31:08
Unidentified speaker: If you think back to 2010 and 2011, we had the European debt crisis and the US debt downgrade.
31:14
Unidentified speaker: And there was a lot of still apprehension post-GFC that things were still very fragile.
31:18
Unidentified speaker: And the US debt downgrade, we just really hadn't seen anything like that in anyone's lifetime on the street at the time.
31:24
Unidentified speaker: And so those were all things that really it was a crisis of confidence.
31:28
Unidentified speaker: Now, if you think about tier three, tier four, tier three, you're having a recession, right?
31:34
Unidentified speaker: Those tier twos.
31:35
Unidentified speaker: We thought we might, but we didn't.
31:37
Unidentified speaker: Tier three, you actually have one.
31:39
Unidentified speaker: What is the band?
31:40
Unidentified speaker: I think you said tier two is 14 to 29.
31:43
Unidentified speaker: Is that correct?
31:44
Unidentified speaker: Tier three, 14 to tier two is 14 to 20.
31:48
Unidentified speaker: And so if you think about tier three with a recession, I think the mildest one we saw, and we did this study, this is where we bring in some additional historical analysis.
31:57
Unidentified speaker: But I think that one, I think the mildest one we saw was maybe 19 or 20%.
32:01
Unidentified speaker: So it kind of bumps up against that tier two.
32:04
Unidentified speaker: But if you think about the median and average drawdown, it's like 27%, 33%, right?
32:09
Unidentified speaker: You're losing a quarter to a third of your market value.
32:12
Unidentified speaker: Now, some of these morph into the tier four risks, which you saw around the tech bubble implosion, the great financial crisis.
32:19
Unidentified speaker: The rule of thumb there is about 50%.
32:22
Unidentified speaker: It's funny, we did a study on, I don't have a great term for it, but we called it our major drawdown study, where we went back and looked at everything that was worse than 10% since 1956.
32:32
Unidentified speaker: I started in 1956 because I couldn't figure out what drove the pull down in 1955, but we started in the late 50s and we went back and looked at all these other drawdowns, and we actually found another 50% in the 70s.
32:44
Unidentified speaker: I think it was 73, 74, where it was maybe like a 48% peak to trough drawdown.
32:50
Unidentified speaker: So there does seem to be something about kind of losing half the value of the market that holds in the post-Great Depression environment.
32:56
Unidentified speaker: The Great Depression was obviously worse.
32:58
Unidentified speaker: And I'll tell you, Dean, that drawdown study gave me a fascinating stat for the tier three, because tiers of fear we formalized last year heading into that tariff debacle.
33:08
Unidentified speaker: It's kind of a framework we'd used for a long time, but we put it together in a pretty little chart last year in the first quarter.
33:13
Unidentified speaker: This major drawdown study, I did, I've been working on it for months, but we started it right after the Iran war broke out because we wanted to understand the bigger picture context.
33:21
Unidentified speaker: And at any rate, the these drawdowns, we looked at all the ones that were materially worse than 10%, so 11% or more since 1956.
33:29
Unidentified speaker: If you look at the median and average drawdown of those, it's 22 is the median and 26 is the average.
33:36
Unidentified speaker: The one thing in my professional career I have not really been able to figure out how to categorize properly was that drawdown of 2022, which was 25%.
33:46
Unidentified speaker: And it wasn't a recession.
33:47
Unidentified speaker: It felt like a recession because the misery index spiked so much, but we didn't actually have one.
33:52
Unidentified speaker: We had earnings recessions and tech and the rest of the market at various points in time, but it was just a weird one.
33:57
Unidentified speaker: We could never figure out what tier does it belong in.
34:00
Unidentified speaker: Was it its own thing?
34:02
Unidentified speaker: And then we realized it does belong in tier three, because that is that 25% is actually right in line with your average really bad drawdown.
34:10
Unidentified speaker: I know it's a little simplistic, but for me who has noodled over that for a really long time, that was a really insightful realization.
34:18
Unidentified speaker: Because if we go into something like that again, right, you want to have these mile markers in the back of your head.
34:23
Unidentified speaker: And that told me that in 2022, we kind of did what we were supposed to do, if it was just a typical, really bad situation.
34:31
Unidentified speaker: It's so interesting to think about the interaction between stock and bond prices.
34:36
Unidentified speaker: And what I would say is the Fed hiking aggressively, that can be bad for equities for sure.
34:42
Unidentified speaker: 2022 feels like a pretty good example of that.
34:45
Unidentified speaker: But the risk-on-risk-off framework in which we've all spent a lot of time our careers have you know spent a lot of time in, which is rates are going to come down a lot during a big equity risk-off.
34:58
Unidentified speaker: So you get almost the straddle effect.
35:01
Unidentified speaker: Rates go up a lot, that's bad.
35:03
Unidentified speaker: And rates coming down a lot is the result of something that probably is a growth shock or something that's unwelcome to the equity market.
35:12
Unidentified speaker: I wanted to turn to your work on Fed hiking cycles.
35:15
Unidentified speaker: You've done some work there.
35:17
Unidentified speaker: I don't know how much of a Fed hiking cycle we're embarking on here.
35:21
Unidentified speaker: There's a couple of examples of one hiken done.
35:25
Unidentified speaker: Not many, but just so we still have maybe three or so priced in.
35:29
Unidentified speaker: Maybe it's four.
35:30
Unidentified speaker: It's come off a little bit.
35:31
Unidentified speaker: So tell us just in terms of what you've learned in studying previous Fed hiking cycles with respect to the equity market impact.
35:39
Unidentified speaker: This was another rabbit hole we fell down right around when we had liftoff and this current cycle, which I guess is going to end up being the cycle.
35:46
Unidentified speaker: We're certainly baking in a few more into our models.
35:49
Unidentified speaker: I've been doing this a long time, but sometimes when these things happen, I just kind of like to throw out everything I've done before and restart, right?
35:55
Unidentified speaker: And just look at things with fresh eyes.
35:57
Unidentified speaker: And so that's what we did this time around.
35:59
Unidentified speaker: It's interesting.
36:00
Unidentified speaker: The first thing I wanted to understand was if we're only pricing in, you know, if we're only expecting a couple of hikes, how should we think about that in the context of these past hiking cycles?
36:10
Unidentified speaker: Because I think 2022 is so fresh on everybody's minds.
36:14
Unidentified speaker: That's where a lot of people were going to in our meetings, especially when we were having conversations about multiple contraction and like how low PE should go and that sort of thing.
36:23
Unidentified speaker: I'm like, why is everybody just going right back to this?
36:25
Unidentified speaker: This is one of the worst ones that we've had.
36:27
Unidentified speaker: They're not all like this.
36:29
Unidentified speaker: And so we went back and we just picked the mid-90s, the 94-95 hiking cycle.
36:34
Unidentified speaker: We put together a little table and we just went back and we looked at how long did these things go?
36:39
Unidentified speaker: When did the market peak?
36:40
Unidentified speaker: When did the market trough?
36:41
Unidentified speaker: How much did we move in terms of basis points?
36:44
Unidentified speaker: And then I'll tell you, Dean, I ended up, I mean, I'm just sitting there tinkering with data and I just decided to look at the average move in terms of basis points, the number of times the Fed actually did something, and then what was it, you know, in terms of basis points?
36:57
Unidentified speaker: And it was really interesting because it just reminds you that 22 cycle was huge.
37:03
Unidentified speaker: It was massive.
37:03
Unidentified speaker: We were doing all these big chunky hikes.
37:05
Unidentified speaker: Most of them haven't looked like that.
37:08
Unidentified speaker: And the 22-23 one, if you look at a chart of stock price performance against all the hikes, we basically, once the hiking cycle started, it's it's a smile chart, although nobody was happy.
37:17
Unidentified speaker: Believe me, I was there.
37:19
Unidentified speaker: But it was just like a hole or a bowl, right?
37:22
Unidentified speaker: If you just look at the line chart, we dug into this hole.
37:24
Unidentified speaker: It got pretty deep.
37:25
Unidentified speaker: It took us a long time to get out of it, but it was kind of midway through that hiking cycle.
37:29
Unidentified speaker: If you look at the other ones, not 94.95, that actually looked, wasn't as deep, but it looked more like that 2223 one.
37:36
Unidentified speaker: Again, chunkier hikes were happening back then.
37:39
Unidentified speaker: I hadn't been around for that one.
37:40
Unidentified speaker: I didn't realize that until I ran the numbers.
37:43
Unidentified speaker: But the ones that happened in the middle, we had basically like a 10% hit at the beginning, and then you were up for the rest of the hiking cycle.
37:51
Unidentified speaker: And those were more like if the 94.95 and 2223, the average move was like closer to 50, like a high 40, like I think it was like 45 to 49, something like that.
38:01
Unidentified speaker: These others, the average move was like 25 to 29, right?
38:05
Unidentified speaker: So just getting your regular 25 basis point moves for the most part.
38:09
Unidentified speaker: So it was so slower, steadier, milder.
38:12
Unidentified speaker: And so you had an initial shock, you priced it, and then you moved on.
38:16
Unidentified speaker: That kind of sounds to me like the market environment we're in today, especially if you look around tariffs last year.
38:21
Unidentified speaker: People priced it, moved on, and we're talking about 2026 before you were in halfway done with 2025.
38:27
Unidentified speaker: So you've got many reasons that the curve can move.
38:30
Unidentified speaker: Of course, the Fed controls the short rate, they're responding to inflation.
38:35
Unidentified speaker: The back end has been wild recently.
38:38
Unidentified speaker: And I like to say that attribution is an incredibly popular sport on Wall Street.
38:42
Unidentified speaker: We always need to understand the why of why something moved.
38:46
Unidentified speaker: That's why we're here.
38:46
Unidentified speaker: We're trying to understand things.
38:48
Unidentified speaker: And that sell-off in the back end, the rise in 10 and 30 year yields.
38:53
Unidentified speaker: Just got so many takes.
38:55
Unidentified speaker: Is it inflation?
38:56
Unidentified speaker: Is it fiscal irresponsibility?
38:59
Unidentified speaker: Is it crowding out from the hyperscalers?
39:02
Unidentified speaker: Each of these has a different maybe implication for the equity market.
39:06
Unidentified speaker: I'm curious how you've thought about the back end and how it figures into your calculus for equity markets.
39:12
Unidentified speaker: It's something we think about a lot.
39:13
Unidentified speaker: I'm constantly pestering my rate strategy team for their thoughts on that exact question.
39:18
Unidentified speaker: And again, we go back to that model we talked about at the beginning.
39:21
Unidentified speaker: We're plugging in assumptions on tenure yields 12 months from now to try to guess where the equity market is going to be 12 months from now, right?
39:28
Unidentified speaker: It's an input into our process, but it needs to be forward-looking.
39:31
Unidentified speaker: I think the phrase that comes to my mind, everything everywhere all at once.
39:35
Unidentified speaker: If I'm a judge in a debate and I'm watching the rates people discuss this, running my own numbers, talking to clients, I feel like all of these things that have been thrown out there have merits, maybe have mattered at different points in time.
39:47
Unidentified speaker: I think what was interesting about the most recent move down in yields, I was out on the road seeing clients.
39:53
Unidentified speaker: So I wasn't, when that happened, so I wasn't glued to my desk when we kind of had that pop and we came down after the CPI print.
40:00
Unidentified speaker: But normally there are kind of things going on in the fixed income world that reverberate inequities.
40:04
Unidentified speaker: I feel like that's been the story for the last year.
40:07
Unidentified speaker: And so I'm going to the rates team trying to see what's going on.
40:10
Unidentified speaker: And they were pointing the finger at me this time, right?
40:13
Unidentified speaker: Which is, you know, we've got this concern over AI that's developing.
40:16
Unidentified speaker: Maybe there were some risk off flows, and that's driving people back into treasuries.
40:20
Unidentified speaker: So I think the drivers, from what I can tell, are not consistent day to day, that it's a little bit of everything, and you've got to keep an eye on it.
40:28
Unidentified speaker: We thought oil, you know, was frankly really driving yields.
40:31
Unidentified speaker: I threw that into my weekly deck and then the correlation breaks down.
40:34
Unidentified speaker: We're keeping an eye on all of things, but I just think we've got a lot of relationships that are converging.
40:40
Unidentified speaker: I do personally tend to fade the deficit issue, but again, I'm not in the fixed income world, right?
40:47
Unidentified speaker: So I can't really judge how important it is to those investors.
40:51
Unidentified speaker: But I do personally, from my seat, feel like that's not something equity folks tend to focus on all that much in our world.
40:58
Unidentified speaker: And it does seem to be a steady, constant criticism, regardless of what's going on in markets.
41:04
Unidentified speaker: So I'm not sure.
41:05
Unidentified speaker: I think that's the one that I probably fade the most, to be honest, because I just think that concern is always there.
41:10
Unidentified speaker: I'm not sure why it necessarily flared up or would have flared up recently.
41:14
Unidentified speaker: We live in this time of great opportunities, great threats.
41:18
Unidentified speaker: The AI build-out is potentially going to transform the economy, but there's incredible voter dissatisfaction kind of everywhere you look.
41:26
Unidentified speaker: France is something to watch.
41:29
Unidentified speaker: The protests and riots there.
41:31
Unidentified speaker: And in the U.S., it seems to me that we lurch back and forth from one party to the next.
41:36
Unidentified speaker: So we've got these midterms coming in a couple weeks.
41:39
Unidentified speaker: And I follow the betting markets pretty closely on those because they're pretty informed.
41:43
Unidentified speaker: The House incredibly highly probable to go to the Democrats, and now even the Senate, I think, is a two-thirds probability.
41:51
Unidentified speaker: You've talked a little bit about some of the work you've done with your colleagues on midterms.
41:56
Unidentified speaker: So lay that out for us in terms of potential market implications for different outcomes.
42:02
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, so it's a great point to get into right now.
42:05
Unidentified speaker: I feel like equity investors in my world were trying to kind of ignore it for a while, but it's become much more topical.
42:10
Unidentified speaker: In terms of just positioning, and I would say, you know, whenever we have political events, I was a former poly sci major, so I'm always interested in looking at these things on a little bit of a political junkie.
42:20
Unidentified speaker: I think at the end of the day, for the equity market, it comes down to repositioning, right?
42:25
Unidentified speaker: Probably more under the surface than above the surface, right?
42:28
Unidentified speaker: I think at the end of the day, that's what sticks.
42:30
Unidentified speaker: And I also think that you really have to link things to policy.
42:34
Unidentified speaker: And so what we do in our analyst survey, often when we have elections, and we did we've done it twice this year.
42:40
Unidentified speaker: We did it once in back in June, published in July, and then we did another one in September, which we published early October, was we just go to the US analysts and we say, what are the performance outlook implications in these different scenarios?
42:51
Unidentified speaker: I asked about the Democratic sweep, the Republican sweep, and the split Congress scenario where I specified a Republican Senate and a Democratic House.
42:58
Unidentified speaker: I joke we'll get the reverse because that's the only one I didn't ask about.
43:02
Unidentified speaker: But we ask our analysts just to give us plus two to minus two, plus two very bullish, zero is neutral, minus two is very bearish, and you can have a one but no half points.
43:10
Unidentified speaker: And there's a column in the Excel spreadsheet that they fill out where they have to tell me what policy they're thinking about.
43:16
Unidentified speaker: And the policy has to be directly relevant to the industry they cover.
43:20
Unidentified speaker: If you are an energy analyst, do not talk to me about healthcare.
43:23
Unidentified speaker: I will send the survey back to you.
43:24
Unidentified speaker: And I will not tell you what to think, but I will ask you to make that link between something that actually affects your industry.
43:31
Unidentified speaker: And so at any rate, we did this.
43:34
Unidentified speaker: And I would say the results we got in September were pretty similar to what we got in June.
43:39
Unidentified speaker: I don't think there were any huge surprises.
43:42
Unidentified speaker: Generally, a Republican sweep was seen as a modest positive.
43:46
Unidentified speaker: It did not even get up to a 0.5.
43:48
Unidentified speaker: Remember, my scale is plus two to minus two.
43:50
Unidentified speaker: So it was a very modest tilt.
43:52
Unidentified speaker: The Democratic sweep scenario, a very modest negative tilt.
43:56
Unidentified speaker: I would say it was a little bit more modest than what we got in the June survey.
43:59
Unidentified speaker: And then the Democratic sweep, you could not, or the split Congress scenario, you could not have gotten any more neutral.
44:05
Unidentified speaker: It was like 0.09.
44:06
Unidentified speaker: And so that was kind of the modest tilts that may have been why the market was ignoring this or seeming to ignore it at the SP level, you know, a little bit coming into this.
44:15
Unidentified speaker: If you look sector by sector, so the three sectors that are really, I would say, in focus in the sweeps, where you get views on one side or the other.
44:24
Unidentified speaker: The Republican sweep, you're getting positive views on utilities, financials and energy.
44:30
Unidentified speaker: And financials and energy, again, we asked them about their policy views.
44:33
Unidentified speaker: It's really about regulation.
44:35
Unidentified speaker: If you look at the utilities, it's about the AI data center affordability debate.
44:39
Unidentified speaker: We have fantastic analysts there, Steve Dambrizzi, who's done a lot of work on this, and he has some pretty strongly held views there.
44:45
Unidentified speaker: If you look at the Democratic sweep, it's the opposite, right?
44:48
Unidentified speaker: It's kind of negatives for those sectors.
44:50
Unidentified speaker: So those would be the ones and the sweep scenarios that I would keep an eye on.
44:55
Unidentified speaker: And obviously the betting markets, the Republican sweep scenario has faded, the Democratic sweep scenario has increased, but it's kind of leveled out.
45:01
Unidentified speaker: It hit a ceiling, at least on, I think we're watching the poly market data, and that's kind of leveled out.
45:06
Unidentified speaker: Now on the split, most sectors were neutral.
45:10
Unidentified speaker: There's really not that much to see there.
45:12
Unidentified speaker: Again, if people are starting to, you know, anticipate the split, and I think that's where a lot of people have been.
45:16
Unidentified speaker: I'm not totally clear if that's starting to shift, but that really only points you to healthcare with a positive score.
45:23
Unidentified speaker: It really comes from kind of our farm and biotech teams with kind of this idea of legislative gridlock being good for the space.
45:30
Unidentified speaker: So people notice that healthcare data point and they notice those other liens.
45:34
Unidentified speaker: The other one I would call out is that consumer staples in a Republican sweep got a negative score from our team and they cover the whole kind of consumer staples landscape, Nick Modi and his team.
45:45
Unidentified speaker: And it was really looking at things like immigration, SNAP benefits, that sort of thing.
45:49
Unidentified speaker: If you look at the Democratic sweep, we did also see sort of a mild positive from the consumer discretionary team.
45:56
Unidentified speaker: And when we looked at their comments, that had to do with the Iran war and gas prices potentially coming down.
46:03
Unidentified speaker: Again, you have to ask yourself with a Democratic sweep, you'd still have Trump in the White House, the passage of things, right?
46:09
Unidentified speaker: There's still a veto there.
46:10
Unidentified speaker: But I do think that these gut instincts from our analysts are important and could inform how stocks trade in the short term and maybe some headwinds or tailwinds that will be perceived as being there.
46:20
Unidentified speaker: Let's finish with a little exploration on just risks that we should be entertaining.
46:27
Unidentified speaker: So your role has you meeting lots of clients, you're logging lots of frequent flyer miles in the process.
46:34
Unidentified speaker: So you're listening a lot to what institutional clients are telling you, and you have your own framework.
46:40
Unidentified speaker: Put that together for us in terms of the unforeseen or unwelcome types of scenarios that you're hearing that could disrupt what has just been an epic performance for certainly since 2022, but really for a long period of time, this SP 500.
46:58
Unidentified speaker: What are the things that folks cite and your own feelings around things that could pop up?
47:04
Unidentified speaker: So it's funny.
47:05
Unidentified speaker: I don't know that I'm getting a great list of tail risks right now.
47:10
Unidentified speaker: If you look at the AAII data, people have been in a fairly sour mood on that survey.
47:15
Unidentified speaker: And that even though that's a retail investor survey, I think it's a relatively well-educated retail investor.
47:20
Unidentified speaker: And so it often will dovetail with what I hear out on the road.
47:24
Unidentified speaker: And I would say if I think about the mood, I wouldn't say people are crazy bullish right now by any stretch.
47:29
Unidentified speaker: I think that maybe this term sour mood, you know, maybe applies to my last trip out on the road, seeing investors in the US.
47:36
Unidentified speaker: I would say with non-US investors, maybe that last trip, which was not too long ago, I would say maybe a little more concern about things like midterms and AI capex and those sorts of things.
47:48
Unidentified speaker: So I do feel like I'm sensing a little bit of a gap between the US investor and the non-US investor.
47:53
Unidentified speaker: And I think that has to do with the fact that non-US investors do tend to be more macro by nature, even if they're long only stock pickers, they tend to pay more attention to things like political risk and interest rate risk and what their fixed income colleagues are saying down the hall.
48:06
Unidentified speaker: Whereas US investors are more focused on earnings and the bottom-up stock picking and what they're hearing from their companies.
48:12
Unidentified speaker: So I understand that gap.
48:14
Unidentified speaker: I think in terms of, again, what people have really wanted to talk about is the earnings risk.
48:18
Unidentified speaker: I found that non-US investors are a little bit more fretful of it, looks like the consensus numbers already expect growth to slow.
48:26
Unidentified speaker: How much is that going to hurt the market?
48:28
Unidentified speaker: What I say in those conversations, by the way, is that in our work on drawdowns, the major drawdowns, what we really saw pretty clearly was that if you look at like the NIPA corporate profits data, it's not just slowing growth that tends to be associated with those major drawdowns.
48:42
Unidentified speaker: It's outright contractioning growth, right?
48:43
Unidentified speaker: So there's a difference between me cutting a forecast for the middle, you know, trailing 4Q, 2Q, 2,7, cutting it from 21 to 9.
48:52
Unidentified speaker: That's very different from cutting it from plus 21 to minus 5.
48:55
Unidentified speaker: I'm not doing the latter.
48:57
Unidentified speaker: That's what would throw you into more nefarious territory.
49:00
Unidentified speaker: But those are the kind of conversations we're having there.
49:02
Unidentified speaker: Whereas I would say in the US, I get pushback for cutting my bottom-up consensus number by 10%.
49:07
Unidentified speaker: And we're like, yeah, it may be too high, but we don't think it's that too high.
49:10
Unidentified speaker: So I think that battle over where earnings takes us is really where there's some differentiation.
49:17
Unidentified speaker: And one side is right to be worried or not worried, and we're gonna see which one it is.
49:22
Unidentified speaker: When this conversation gets released, my guess is we'll be in the heart of the busiest week for megacap earnings.
49:30
Unidentified speaker: I think it's something like 33% of the SP reports next week.
49:34
Unidentified speaker: So that's gonna be super interesting to evaluate.
49:36
Unidentified speaker: Lori, it's been great to have you back on the podcast.
49:39
Unidentified speaker: Really enjoyed the conversation.
49:41
Unidentified speaker: Well, thanks for having me.
49:42
Unidentified speaker: It was fun as always.
49:44
Unidentified speaker: You've been listening to the Alpha Exchange.
49:47
Unidentified speaker: If you've enjoyed the show, please do tell a friend.
49:50
Unidentified speaker: And before we leave, I wanted to invite you to drop us some feedback.
49:54
Unidentified speaker: As we aim to utilize these conversations to contribute to the investment community's understanding of risk, your input is valuable and provides direction on where we should focus.
50:03
Unidentified speaker: Please email us at feedback at alpha exchange podcast.com.
50:08
Unidentified speaker: Thanks again and catch you next time.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-GGUF:UD-Q4_K_XL. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Alpha Exchange

Alpha Exchange

Meredith Whitney, Founder and CEO, Meredith Whitney Advisors

Episode discussion: Meredith Whitney on K-Shaped Economy, Alternative Lending Vacuum, and Energy Market Risks

Speakers’ claims: Meredith Whitney argues that post-crisis regulations have forced banks to retreat to prime borrowers, creating a vacuum filled by alternative lenders serving 50% of households. She highlights a K-shaped economy where consumers are cutting grocery spending to afford gas, signaling financial strain that may impact political outcomes. Whitney critiques the market's AI concentration and argues that energy stocks are undervalued due to ignored geopolitical risks and persistent inflationary pressures. She also draws parallels between current banking opacity and the pre-2008 era, emphasizing the importance of granular data analysis.

Banking RegulationAlternative LendingConsumer Spending
35 min1 assets7 claims to verify
Alpha Exchange

Bruce Darringer, Founder BSD Strategic Advisors

Episode discussion: Bruce Darringer on scaling hedge funds, operational risk, and AI implementation

Speakers’ claims: Bruce Darringer, founder of BSD Strategic Advisors, discusses the evolution of operational risk management from the 2008 Lehman Brothers collapse to the COVID-19 pandemic, emphasizing the need for robust infrastructure as firms scale. He argues that institutional allocators view operational due diligence as table stakes and warns that asset-liability mismatches are a primary cause of hedge fund failure during stress events. Darringer contrasts founder-led structures with multi-manager models, noting the significant retooling required for the latter. He also addresses scaling challenges, AI implementation strategies, and the operational risks introduced by faster settlement cycles like atomic settlement.

Operational RiskHedge Fund ScalingInvestor Relations
56 min1 assets15 claims to verify
All insights