Dan Pilla explains IRS audit mechanics, record reconstruction, and appeals strategy to minimize tax liabilities.
Summary
Bob Brooks interviews Dan Pilla about strategies for handling IRS tax audits. Pilla argues that audit selection is driven by statistical deviations from national averages rather than fraud indicators. He claims that IRS audit results are incorrect 60-90% of the time and advises taxpayers to aggressively appeal assessments. Pilla also provides guidance on reconstructing missing records and responding to correspondence audits without professional help.
Key takeaways
- 1 that compares every line of your tax return with national and regional statistical averages for a person in your same income category and profession. If any one line of your return is out of sync with the averages, the difference is scored. And the higher the score, the more likely it is you are to be audited.
Dan Pilla · 15:17
- 2 The IRS is shifting towards correspondence audits (mail-based) and away from face-to-face audits for individual returns, requiring taxpayers to submit proof of deductions like charitable contributions or business expenses via mail.
Dan Pilla · 16:54
- 3 Pilla argues that tax professionals advising clients to skip legitimate deductions to avoid 'red flags' are wrong because audit selection is statistical, and skipping deductions guarantees overpayment without guaranteeing audit avoidance.
Dan Pilla · 21:16
- 4 Missing or incomplete records are the single most common problem in audits, particularly among small business owners who prioritize their trade over accounting.
Dan Pilla · 22:47
- 5 reconstructing records. How to reconstruct the lost records or the incomplete records so that you can prove that your deductions are correct, even without a full package of contemporaneous records.
Dan Pilla · 23:26
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 6:33
Introduction and Political Context
Bob Brooks introduces guest Dan Pilla to discuss winning tax audits. Pilla discusses recent state elections in Minnesota, Texas, and Florida, attributing shifts in voting patterns to migration from high-tax coastal states and generational differences in political views.
- 6:33 – 12:00
Legislative Outlook and Taxpayer Assistance Act
Pilla predicts a legislative stalemate but highlights the bipartisan support for the Taxpayer Assistance and Service Act. He urges listeners to contact their US Representatives to pass the bill before the end of the year to expand Tax Court jurisdiction and simplify refund processes.
- 12:00 – 15:00
Defining 'Winning' an Audit
Pilla defines winning an audit as keeping money in one's pocket. He cites IRS data stating 88% of audited taxpayers owe more, but claims IRS audit results are wrong 60-90% of the time, particularly for unreported income claims.
- 15:00 – 16:28
Audit Selection Mechanics
Pilla explains that audits are primarily triggered by a computer program comparing tax return lines to national averages for similar income/profession brackets. He argues that deviating from the average does not prove error, only that the return is statistically unusual.
- 16:28 – 19:14
Responding to Correspondence Audits
Pilla advises taxpayers to remain calm, read the notice carefully, and gather proof (receipts, invoices) for questioned items. He recommends sending responses via certified mail and waiting for further instructions or appeal rights.
- 19:14 – 20:56
Face-to-Face Audits and Professional Help
While correspondence audits are common, face-to-face audits may occur for complex business returns. Pilla suggests seeking counsel for these situations but emphasizes that the book provides step-by-step guidance for the process.
- 20:56 – 22:44
Philosophy on Deductions and Red Flags
Pilla criticizes the advice to avoid legitimate deductions to prevent 'red flags,' arguing that audits are random/statistical and avoiding deductions guarantees overpayment. He stresses the importance of maintaining adequate proof for all claimed deductions.
- 22:44 – 24:48
Reconstructing Records
Addressing the common issue of missing or incomplete records, Pilla explains that the book teaches how to reconstruct lost records to prove deductions, ensuring taxpayers can defend their returns even without perfect contemporaneous documentation.
Claims worth verifying
Dan Pilla has written 14 tax books.
Dan Pilla ·1:17
How to verify: Check the author's bibliography on taxhelponline.com or Amazon for titles authored by Dan Pilla. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Minnesota administration under Governor Mark Walz is responsible for up to $10 billion in fraud through Somali organizations.
Dan Pilla ·2:32
How to verify: Search for Minnesota state audit reports, Attorney General investigations, or news articles from 2026-2026 regarding 'Minnesota fraud administration' or 'Somali organizations fraud'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
43% of Americans under 30 believe socialism is a better economic model than free market capitalism.
Dan Pilla ·5:44
How to verify: Search for the specific study cited by Pilla using Google Scholar or news archives from 2026-2026 referencing 'socialism vs capitalism survey under 30'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Senate passed the Taxpayer Assistance and Service Act unanimously on September 30th.
Dan Pilla ·7:12
How to verify: Check the US Senate legislative history for the 'Taxpayer Assistance and Service Act' around September 2026 for vote counts and dates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
88% of people who go through a tax audit end up owing more money to the IRS.
Dan Pilla ·12:55
How to verify: Search for IRS Statistics of Income (SOI) data or IRS annual reports on audit outcomes and assessment increases. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceIRS audit results are wrong 60-90% of the time.
Dan Pilla ·13:15
How to verify: Search for IRS Office of Inspector General (OIG) reports or Government Accountability Office (GAO) studies on audit error rates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceOver two-thirds of all returns selected for audit are selected by a computer program comparing returns to national averages.
Dan Pilla ·15:17
How to verify: Check IRS publications on 'Discriminant Inventory Function System (DIF)' or 'Unreported Income Program' selection criteria. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Tax Court will have new jurisdiction to hear claims for refund under the Taxpayer Assistance and Service Act.
Dan Pilla ·9:44
How to verify: Review the text of the 'Taxpayer Assistance and Service Act' if passed, or current US Tax Court jurisdiction rules under 26 U.S.C. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the 60-90% error rate claim by checking IRS Statistics of Income (SOI) data on audit outcomes and appeal reversals.
- Review the text of the Taxpayer Assistance and Service Act to understand its current legislative status and potential impact on Tax Court jurisdiction.
- Consult IRS Publication 552 for official guidance on responding to correspondence audits and the appeals process.
- Check IRS Publication 17 for rules on substantiating deductions and the standard of proof required for audits.
- Research the specific computer programs (e.g., DIF scores) used by the IRS for audit selection to understand statistical triggers.
- Verify the definition of 'winning' an audit against IRS regulations on underpayment penalties and interest.
- Look for counter-arguments from tax attorneys regarding the effectiveness of self-representation in Office of Appeals.
- Check for conflicts of interest if purchasing Pilla's book or related materials mentioned in the episode.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Bob Brooks: Well, today, how to win your tax audit. Today we're going to take a look. Stay tuned for Prudent Money.
- 0:21
- Bob Brooks: Good afternoon, this is Bob Brooks and you are listening to the Prudent Money Radio Show. Thanks so much for joining me today. You know I do appreciate it. Well, have you ever been audited? And no one likes the thought of getting audited by the IRS. However, what if I told you that you can not only survive an audit, you can actually
- 0:41
- Bob Brooks: win it? Today IRS expert Dan Pilla is here to talk about winning a tax audit. Dan, always great to talk to you. Uh how how you been doing?
- 0:51
- Dan Pilla: I've been doing well, Bob. How are you? It's good to see you again.
- 0:54
- Bob Brooks: I'm good. I uh you wanna as I was telling you, every once in a while I like to take a break from what we talk about and focus in on one of your books. And and uh today I want to talk a little bit about how to win your tax audit. And uh that I think that was book was written in 2014, maybe.
- 1:10
- Dan Pilla: Yeah, maybe 16 sixteen somewhere in there. So it's a
- 1:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): good one. lot of people. But it's one of
- 1:14
- Bob Brooks: uh fifteen books?
- 1:16
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 1:17
- Dan Pilla: yeah, 14 tax books, Bob.
- 1:19
- Bob Brooks: I'm still pushing for that 15.
- 1:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And uh
- 1:23
- Dan Pilla: maybe I should get busy, huh?
- 1:25
- Bob Brooks: Maybe you should. Taxhelponline.com is where you go to get more information and uh just just great great info. Before we get started, though, and uh I hate to start by getting your blood pressure up on this subject, but talk a little bit about uh you know, I'm just curious as your thoughts about the elections that just happened. Uh, you know,
- 1:45
- Bob Brooks: were you surprised? Were you not surprised? And uh what what is this, what do you think this does to things like tax rates down the road?
- 1:52
- Dan Pilla: Well, that that that's a good question. Uh first of all, as to being surprised, I live in the state of Minnesota, as you know. I was not the least bit surprised that the re uh the Democrats took control of the state. house, both the House and the Senate. The Democrats now control the governor's office, so they've got what we've been calling the trifecta in this state here again, total
- 2:12
- Dan Pilla: Democrat control of the state legislature and the governor's house. Uh the uh former lieutenant governor Peggy Flanagan, who was part of the Walls fraud administration, that is uh you know, you might recall, was in all the papers, but. Bob. You might recall that the uh the the state of Minnesota under the Walls administration
- 2:32
- Dan Pilla: is uh is uh responsible for the the most fraud at a state level in the history of the United States. They think upwards of nine billion, maybe ten billion dollars in fraud, in in in uh in in uh uh fr fr uh uh in money has been siphoned out of the out of the state coffers through fraudulent
- 2:51
- Dan Pilla: organizations, uh mostly Somali, not a hundred percent Somali, but but predominantly Somali organizations, uh so-called social uh social safety net organizations like like uh like uh memory care facilities and daycare facilities and and f feeding children facilities have siphoned upwards of ten $10 billion
- 3:11
- Dan Pilla: dollars off of state revenue right under Governor Walls' nose.
- 3:16
- Dan Pilla: Peggy Flanagan was his lieutenant governor. She was right there side by side with the governor during all of this fraudulent activity. She got elected to the United States Senate. And so, you know, it's it's total, total Democrat, and not just Democrat, but leftist Democrat control of the uh
- 3:36
- Dan Pilla: of the uh uh politics here in the state of Minnesota. That did not surprise me. What did surprise me is what happened in Texas and what happened in Florida. Texas went blue for the first time in you know how many years? You know better than I.
- 3:51
- Dan Pilla: It's it's just it's just incre incredible that they they lost the governor's seat, they lost their state senator seat, especially who they lost. Uh I'm sorry, their their U.S. Senate seat, they lost their U.S. Senate seat, and not just that they lost the seat, but who they lost it to. And and so that is shocking to me. And what happened in Florida. Now it's true that the Florida uh
- 4:11
- Dan Pilla: Republicans held the governor's office and held their uh U.S. Senate seats, but the vote was so close, uh, Bob, that it just it it just astounded me. And what what this evidences to mean me is that the people on the West Coast that are running from the high taxes and the liberal policies in places like California, Oregon, and Washington, they're going to places like
- 4:30
- Dan Pilla: Utah, Texas, and Arizona, and they're bringing their voting habits with them. So the things they're running from, they're voting for in their new states. And exactly the same thing is happening in the Northeast. People are running from the high-tax uh liberal policies in places like Connecticut, New York, and New Jersey. They're going to Florida.
- 4:51
- Dan Pilla: to a you know to a free state, but they're bringing their voting habits with them and they're voting for the same things that drove them out of their home states in the first place. So this is just it's schizophrenic behavior, in my opinion, Bob. But y you know the the problem the problem is education. We've got we've got generations of people in this country,
- 5:10
- Dan Pilla: particularly those that are under forty 40 years of age that do not understand what our government stands for. And then we've got a new generation of people, particularly under 30 years of age, that not only not only don't understand the principles that America stands for, Bob, they hate America.
- 5:27
- Dan Pilla: It's not just that they think that we can introduce these new policies to make Mer America better. They want to, to use Obama's words when he became president, they want to fundamentally change the fabric of America. from a free society to a socialist society. There was a study that was done,
- 5:44
- Dan Pilla: I forget who released it, but you can go to the Google machine and find this easy enough. We are now at the point where 43% of Americans under 30 years of age believe that socialism is a better economic model than free market capitalism. This is the point we've reached, Bob, and they're voting for this stuff. They hate American free market. principles.
- 6:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 6:04
- Bob Brooks: what do you think this does uh to to taxes? I mean, obviously at some point we've got to have positive net revenue coming into the government, which is a
- 6:15
- Bob Brooks: uh a a wish uh that uh but we at some point we need to have that. And the only really if you look at it, you either either pr you have an economic engine that produces it. I don't even know that we can produce enough to cover it. But the taxes are definitely going to have to be a part of that.
- 6:30
- Bob Brooks: What do you foresee as far as taxes go?
- 6:33
- Dan Pilla: Well, in the next two years, I think we're just going to have simply a stalemate. I do not believe that any policies coming out of the uh Democrat-controlled House, the Democrat-controlled Senate at the federal level is going to get uh signed by the president. I I just I I I have a hard time believing that any tax bill will get signed uh come out. coming uh crafted by by those
- 6:52
- Dan Pilla: parties will be uh by that party will be will be uh signed by the president. Now I'll tell you what disturbs me short term. You and I have been talking about the Taxpayer Assistance and Service Act that's been on the drawing board here for the last two years. The Senate, the United States Senate passed that bill unanimously, Bob, September the 30th. They passed it
- 7:12
- Dan Pilla: unanimously. Now it's in the House of Representatives. The House hasn't taken action. At the end of this year, December 31st, the 119th Congress will shut down starting January 8th or 10th, whatever the whatever the startup date is. We'll have a new Congress, right? That'll be the 120th Congress. If that Taxpayer Assistance Service Act is not
- 7:32
- Dan Pilla: passed by the House and sent to the President before December 31st, the whole thing has to start over again. Now, the good news is that there is wild, unprecedented bipartisan support for that bill. As I said, it passed the Senate by a vote of by a unanimous vote. Not one single
- 7:52
- Dan Pilla: leftist Democrat senator voted against that bill. The reason for that is because it's all taxpayers' rights stuff. It has nothing to do with taxing the rich and giving tax breaks to the to the to the poor or favoring this business or punishing that business. It has nothing to do with any of that. There's not a dollar's worth of uh tax increase or
- 8:12
- Dan Pilla: decrease in the taxpayer assistance and service act. It's all about procedure, it's all about administration, it's all about taxpayers' rights. That's why it's got that support. Now, so that said, it's cons it's humanly possible that the new 120th Congress will have the same kind of bar bipartisan support. But what
- 8:31
- Dan Pilla: concerns me is what will be the intention, what will be the to-do list of the new Democrat-controlled Congress. They've given us a hint, right? They want to talk about quote-unquote corruption. Well, who What does does that mean that we're going gonna to have an endless stream of impeachment hearings going forward that's going to gonna take up all the time? of the uh
- 8:51
- Dan Pilla: of the of the Senate and the House? Uh they they they're talking about undoing the uh tariffs, all right. Is the is the president gonna sign on to that? I don't know. Uh they're talking about uh unraveling the Iran war. All right. So if those three things become their priority, are they gonna have time to address the Taxpayer Assistance and Service Act? And and
- 9:11
- Dan Pilla: and you know, it that just remains to be seen. So what I'm doing Bob, is I'm encouraging everybody that I talk to here over the last couple of weeks and going forward to put pressure on their congressman, their US representative, not their senator, their US representative, to get that taxpayer assistance and service act passed
- 9:31
- Dan Pilla: and sent to the president before the end of the year.
- 9:34
- Bob Brooks: Yeah, and that uh that's that's critical, definitely. When you especially when you when you uh just look at all the problems that we have, I mean anything like that's gonna help, uh I would assume.
- 9:44
- Dan Pilla: Oh, yeah, no question about it. And and a couple a couple of important points to the bill, Bob, is is it's given the tax court broader jurisdiction to protect taxpayers' rights. Most specifically, for example, the tax court will have new jurisdiction to hear claims for refund. All right, right now, if you if you paid money to the IRS that you don't
- 10:04
- Dan Pilla: owe, you got to file a lawsuit in the United States District Court to get that back. That's very expensive, very time consuming, very convoluted procedures. Uh it legal fees are
- 10:17
- Dan Pilla: generally very expensive to get that kind of a thing done. In the United States tax court, it's a completely different process. It's simplified, it's streamlined, the judges. know what they're doing in the United States, generally speaking, know what they're doing in the United States tax court. You uh when you file a case in the United States tax court, you immediately get an IRS attorney on the case
- 10:37
- Dan Pilla: that wants to negotiate a settlement, that wants to figure out a resolution. So this'll be so incredibly helpful for taxpayers to uh to to get refunds that uh from the IRS for money they paid they don't owe. Here's another factor that's very, very critical, and that is this. Right now, the way the federal law is, if you if the
- 10:57
- Dan Pilla: IRS has an assessment against you of X dollars, and let's say it's a big dollar assessment, let's say it's 50 grand, and you don't you are a hundred percent convinced you don't owe the 50 grand, that there's a mistake that the IRS made in calculations. All right, well, right now, in order to get redress on that, if you've lost your tax court appeal rights, which you wouldn't be in that
- 11:17
- Dan Pilla: position if you didn't lose them, right? Now you have to pay the full pay in full the full fifty thousand dollars, including all penalties and interests assessed in connection with it, and then file your claim for refund in the United States District Court. You can't partial pay the money and get a refund claim. Under the new tax
- 11:37
- Dan Pilla: court jurisdiction rules, you will be able to make partial payments to get that refund process going down, uh go going get uh get that process moving in certain circumstances. So Bob, that one thing alone is gonna be so helpful for people.
- 11:51
- Bob Brooks: Yeah, so we'll get it get an update in December and see if uh anything is moved. The saga continues.
- 11:57
- Dan Pilla: The saga continues, yes sir, it does. Well
- 12:00
- Bob Brooks: let's let's talk a little bit about how to win your tax audit. They uh A book that Dan has written. You can find out more information about that book and all the other books he has at taxhelponline.com. Uh don't mean to sound like Captain Obvious. What does winning actually mean? I mean, is that as did you win because you got through the uh process without being emotionally
- 12:20
- Bob Brooks: scarred? Did you win because you didn't lose any appendages? I mean, what is does winning actually mean?
- 12:29
- Dan Pilla: Winning means that you keep your money in your pocket where it belongs. All right.
- 12:35
- Dan Pilla: Let me give you some just very general data. About eighty-eight percent of all of the people who go through a tax audit end up owing more money to the IRS as a result of the audit. Might be a little bit of money, two, three, four, five thousand dollars, might be a lot of money, twenty, thirty, fifty grand. right? Depends on the circumstances, depends on the nature of the audit. But
- 12:55
- Dan Pilla: compare that with this other very important statistic. And that is, according to IRS's own data, their audit results are wrong 60 to 90 percent of the time, depending on what kind of issue we're talking about. When the IRS is talking about alleged unreported income, in other words, when they make the claim that the taxpayer had income they didn't report on their tax return, they're
- 13:15
- Dan Pilla: wrong about that upwards of 90% of the time. When it's dollars and when it's tax deduction issues, you're not in, you know, we're going to disallow this deduction, we're going to disallow that deduction. Their error rate is 60 to 70 to 80% of the time. All right. So when when you look at the number of people that owe money after an audit It and the ratio at which those
- 13:35
- Dan Pilla: audit results are wrong, it's obvious that people end up paying money to the IRS they don't owe if they don't understand their appeal rights. And so how to win your tax audit focuses not only how to get through the audit, not only how to how to prove how to prove that your tax return is correct on the front end, but how to appeal these decisions as well. Because this
- 13:54
- Dan Pilla: appeal processes are critical, Bob. When you get your case into the Office of Appeals, you will win your case. And by win, I mean you end up with your money in your pocket most of the time. So if the IRS says you owe fifty grand after you're done with a with a properly presented, properly argued appeal, you might you might owe three grand, you might owe five grand,
- 14:14
- Dan Pilla: you might owe ten grand, but it's not going to be fifty. And that assumes you made a mistake in the first place. And of course, not everybody makes mistakes, right? All It very well could be that you don't owe the IRS anything because your return is done correctly in the first place.
- 14:27
- Bob Brooks: You know, I I think that uh you you in fact you write in the book about a lot about misconceptions. I think that uh and what I've what I've always let me say this, what I always uh loved about that title, how to win your tax audit. If you could have said how to handle your tax audit, how you could have said how to survive. And I think that most people think there's a ninety 90% percent chance I'll
- 14:46
- Bob Brooks: lose, a ten 10% percent chance I'll I'll win, and probably most
- 14:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of the things that I'm gonna
- 14:50
- Bob Brooks: maybe one the bigger misconceptions to get out of their head first that hey, you can win this.
- 14:57
- Dan Pilla: Oh, yeah, absolutely. And here's the reason you need to understand that, Bob. People think that their return was selected for audit because there's a mistake in the return, and the IRS discovered the mistake. That's not the case at all. Over two two-thirds thirds of all the returns that are selected for audit are selected by a sophisticated computer program
- 15:17
- Dan Pilla: that compares every line of your tax return with national and regional statistical averages for a person in your same income category and profession. If any one line of your return is out of sync with the averages, the difference is scored. And the higher the score, the more likely it is you are to be audited. And the reason for that is because the IRS believes just
- 15:36
- Dan Pilla: data-driven data driven now, right? Just data-driven. data driven, the IRS believes that the further away you are from an average, the more likely it is your return is wrong. That doesn't mean the return is in fact wrong. It just means they believe the return is likely wrong. And so that's why those returns are selected for audit. So just because your return is
- 15:56
- Dan Pilla: selected Selective for fraudit audit doesn't mean it's in fact incorrect. And as long as you can prove that the information claims. claimed that the numbers in your tax return are in fact correct, you don't owe the IRS any money. And it doesn't make any difference how far away from the averages you are. Remember, the average is just a composite of the high and low. It's not a reflection of what your
- 16:16
- Dan Pilla: actual expenses happen to be.
- 16:21
- Bob Brooks: The listener who goes out to the mailbox, they they see the the audit notice. What's the very first thing they should do?
- 16:28
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
- 16:28
- Dan Pilla: the very first thing they shouldn't do is panic.
- 16:31
- Dan Pilla: And that's what people do. You know, oh my God.
- 16:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think everybody panic.
- 16:35
- Dan Pilla: I must have made a mistake. Well, you didn't necessarily as I just said, you didn't necessarily make a mistake. But the first thing you need to do, Bob, is sit down carefully read that letter. Carefully read the notice and see what the IRS wants. Now, what's going on today compared to in the old days? And by the old days, I mean like five. years ago, is the IRS is doing more and more correspondence
- 16:54
- Dan Pilla: audits. They're doing fewer and fewer face-to-face audits. So if you get a notice from the IRS that says they're questioning your tax return, most likely it's going to be a correspondence audit, and the letter is going to say, We're questioning, just for example, your charitable contributions. You claimed uh $10,000 in charitable contributions. We want to see the proof. Or if you filed
- 17:15
- Dan Pilla: a business tax return, they may say, uh, you know, you claimed uh ten thousand dollars in advertising expenses on your business tax return, we want to see the proof. At that point, all you gotta do is gather up the information that supports your deduction, your canceled checks, your invoices, your receipts, all the things that you have. The book shows you, Bob,
- 17:34
- Dan Pilla: exactly how to prove the correctness of a deduction. Right? I take you step by step through all the various ways to prove that a deduction is authorized in a particular area. So, based on that information, gather up all the data that you have, photocopy it, clear and sharp copies, write a simple letter of explanation. The book shows you how to
- 17:54
- Dan Pilla: do that, and send it to the IRS and say, okay, you've questioned my charitable contributions or my business expenses. Here's the proof. All right. Now you've sending you
- 18:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the process of the process of the
- 18:02
- Dan Pilla: send that in. Make sure you send it in certified mail so we know that the IRS received it. And now you wait for a response. And if they ask you further questions, you answer the further questions. And if they don't ask you further questions, they'll close the case out. If they don't read your material, which is possible, they'll send you the next notice. And the next notice will carry
- 18:22
- Dan Pilla: appeal rights. The thing people need to do, Bob, and I'm not kidding about this now. Don't panic. Read the letter. The letter will very clearly tell you what the issues are and what you need to do going forward to get it resolved. And then refer to the book, How to Win Your Tax Audit, for step-by-step guidance to get you through it. You
- 18:40
- Bob Brooks: know, I you you talk about panic, and I think that the human nature aspect of it, you can just kind of see it play out. They see the IRS letter, they see the word audit, or and they don't you don't they don't read. the the letter and they go, can't handle the the anxiety, stick
- 18:55
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it in a
- 18:55
- Bob Brooks: drawer, and I'll I'll I'll get to this later. When really, as you said, I and I want to uh really emphasize this is that it it is a it is a simple, as simple as simple can be, a simple process that you go through, and it's it's not as big as we're making it up in our minds to be.
- 19:14
- Dan Pilla: And for the overwhelming majority of cases, that's absolutely true. Now, there could be a situation where the IRS says we want a we want a face-to-face audit, and we've got this whole laundry list of things that we want to look at. This happens in business tax audits. It very rarely happens in individual tax audits. But if you've got a if you've got a business tax return and you've got a you know a
- 19:34
- Dan Pilla: whole page of of income and expense items that you're claiming your income writing off your expenses and so on, and you've got you've got cost of goods and you've got advertising and you've got contract labor and you've got office expenses and supplies and all these various things that show up on a business tax return. And the IRS wants to see every single one of those things. Well, the procedure is
- 19:54
- Dan Pilla: exactly the same. But in a situation like that, you might want to get some counsel, some somebody to help guide you through the process. But Bob, that's what the book is for. How do we to win your tax audit takes you step by step by step through the entire process.
- 20:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
- 20:07
- Bob Brooks: is Bob Brooks, and you are listening to the Prudent Money Radio Show, talking to Dan Pella about one of his books, How to Win Your Tax Audit. If you want more information, taxhelponline.com is the place to go. You know, we we talk about the deductions, the l legitimate deductions, people are scared to take.
- 20:27
- Bob Brooks: take because of fear of attention. And uh you know the the quote unquote red flags. Yeah. Talk a little bit about you know the approach there. You you've got a the of course the big one has to be the home office deduction. You have what's caught what what you feel is legitimate, uh a legitimate
- 20:47
- Bob Brooks: uh reason to to to um uh uh post that deduction. and you don't do it. Talk about uh you know what's your thoughts are on that.
- 20:56
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
- 20:56
- Dan Pilla: let's talk about the philosophy first. It's wrong-headed thinking. All right. A lot of people, including, including frankly, too many tax professionals, uh tax return preparers, will say to people, you know what, you're entitled to claim this deduction. You mentioned the home office, that's a good example. You're entitled to claim this deduction, but I don't think you should do it because you don't want to raise a red flag. Well,
- 21:16
- Dan Pilla: so so okay, so the client says, All right, forget it, forget it, I don't want to raise a red flag. Well, what you've done, the only thing you've done for sure, is you guaranteed that you're gonna pay more taxes than you owe because you haven't claimed deductions you're entitled to. You haven't guaranteed that you're not gonna be audited. Because remember, the audits are are are s selected through this computer program that
- 21:36
- Dan Pilla: I talked about, where they compare the the entries on. your tax return. And you know, you may be off, uh, you may be off, you may not be off. We don't know what the averages are. They don't tell us what the averages are, right? So so you're just simply guessing. So the so we we can't guarantee that you won't be audited. We can guarantee that you'll pay
- 21:56
- Dan Pilla: taxes you don't owe. So what's the point? What I say to that is don't ever do that. Don't ever leave deductions on the table. that you're entitled to claim. Just make sure you got the proof of the entitlement to the deduction. And in the book, I talk about exactly what constitutes adequate, proper proof of a deduction. So I show you, I show you precisely what
- 22:16
- Dan Pilla: you need to do, what records to keep, how to organize the records, and so on. So even if you are audited, Our auditor, you say, you know what, I don't care. I got the stuff. I got the information. I don't have to worry about my deduction being wrongfully disallowed. I've got the records.
- 22:29
- Bob Brooks: But you f talk about uh the the person who keeps what you you refer to as weak records, who uh they're they're they're kind of complete, maybe not all complete. What do you do in a situation like that? You made the deduction and you're like, Yeah, this is all I got
- 22:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
- 22:44
- Bob Brooks: prove that I'm right, even though I know I'm right. Yeah,
- 22:47
- Dan Pilla: yeah, yeah, exactly. And and and I'll tell you, Bob, that's the single most common problem we have. is missing or incomplete records. You know, uh and small business people are are are so guilty of this that they they want to they want to focus on their business. If they wanted to be an accountant and do accounting for a living, they'd have gone to school to be an accountant. But instead, I
- 23:07
- Dan Pilla: want to be a contractor, I want to be a doctor, I want to be a truck driver, I want to be whatever these these things are that these people that these people do for a living that have not. nothing to do with accounting. And so these people typically don't keep proper records or at least not complete records. And that's and that's number one, it's a mistake. And number two, it's the single most common problem. So in the book, I talk about
- 23:26
- Dan Pilla: reconstructing records. How to reconstruct the lost records or the incomplete records so that you can prove that your deductions are correct, even without a full package of contemporaneous records.
- 23:38
- Bob Brooks: Once again, the name of that book is How to Win Your Tax Audit. You can find more information on Dan and everything he's written and what he does at taxhelponline.com. I got a great idea for a way to get to the 15th book.
- 23:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
- 23:54
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): listening. I'm
- 23:55
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): listening.
- 23:56
- Bob Brooks: Your your greatest book, per my opinion, the IRS problem solver, addition. edition to second edition
- 24:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): edition. Well and and and and and and
- 24:06
- Dan Pilla: frankly, Bob, it would be uh it would be ripe to do that because uh because it's been a while since that book was released and it would not be a bad idea to redo it. I'll make it I'll make a note of that.
- 24:17
- Bob Brooks: Please do note it.
- 24:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
- 24:19
- Bob Brooks: Dan, always great to have you on the program.
- 24:21
- Dan Pilla: It's always my pleasure, Bob. Thanks for having me.
- 24:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
- 24:23
- Bob Brooks: is Bob Brooks and you are listening to the Prudence Prudent Money Radio. Show. We are all out of time. Till we do meet again next time. Keep the faith and have a great rest of the
- 24:32
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): day.
- 24:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): That's all the time we have for today. Questions or comments for Bob or to find out more great information like what you've just heard, visit www.prudentmoney.com. Be sure to join Bob Brooks again for the next edition of Prudent Money.
More from Bob Brooks Prudent Money Podcast
The Car Maintenance Money Trap
Episode discussion: Bob Brooks and Tony Joe discuss avoiding unnecessary car maintenance costs by understanding manufacturer schedules and fluid testing.
Speakers’ claims: Bob Brooks and Tony Joe discuss the financial trap of over-maintenance in vehicle upkeep. Tony Joe explains that manufacturer schedules use 'I' (inspect) and 'R' (replace) codes, meaning inspections do not mandate replacement. He recommends oil changes every 3,000 to 5,000 miles in hot climates to prevent bearing damage from fuel dilution. The speakers advise testing brake fluid with litmus paper rather than flushing based on color. They distinguish between flushes and drain-and-refills, noting flushes are beneficial for cooling systems but questionable for transmissions.
Wall Street Maverick with Thomas Jasper
Episode discussion: Thomas Jasper on Risk Management, Lehman Brothers Collapse, and Investment Thesis
Speakers’ claims: Thomas Jasper, author of 'Wall Street Maverick,' discusses lessons from his 50+ year career, emphasizing the difficulty of timing markets and the importance of defining risk tolerance. He recounts his experience at Salomon Brothers during the 1987 crash and explains how interest rate swaps helped the thrift industry manage risk. Jasper details his personal loss with Lehman Brothers, attributing it to flawed risk models and poor relationships with regulators. He also shares a venture capital success story involving a 'Plan B' and criticizes Bitcoin for lacking a clear investment thesis.