PRI experts argue California's grid strain stems from policy mandates rather than demand, highlighting nuclear as a viable alternative.
Summary
Host Brian Hyde interviews Wayne Weingarden and Carrie Jackson of the Pacific Research Institute about California's energy challenges. The speakers contend that the state's 2045 zero-emission mandate forces reliance on intermittent renewables, driving electricity rates to double the national average. They argue that costs are driven by policy restrictions on fossil fuels rather than population growth, which has stagnated. The discussion also covers the lifecycle emissions of renewables versus nuclear power and the emerging interest in Small Modular Reactors (SMRs) by AI companies for data center power.
Key takeaways
- 1 And I I I would add, because you're saying green technologies, and I think we need to be really careful about what we call green and what we don't call green. There's trade trade-offs, offs, and every source has a trade off. Right. If you think about solar, how do does it how do you get solar energy? Well, you need some sort of big machine to dig up stuff out of the earth, then you have to refine that stuff, and then you get energy, and then you have a disposal issue. It sounds a lot like fossil fuels, right? I mean, in terms of the process, and when you think about the lifetime times emissions, and that's really what matters, right? And you're talking about like what happened in California. We we focus very much. on the emissions from California, which you know kill it is important, but it's also the global emissions, right? So that if we send manufacturing overseas, well yeah, you could say California is producing less emissions, but globally it's you know arguably worse. Well, compa
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 10:12
Episode sections
- 0:03 – 2:03
Introduction and Speaker Backgrounds
Host Brian Hyde introduces guests Wayne Weingarden and Carrie Jackson from the Pacific Research Institute, a Pasadena-based think tank. Weingarden is a senior fellow in business and economics, while Jackson has focused on California issues since 2016 and previously worked at Investors Business Daily.
- 2:03 – 10:12
California's Energy Policy and Cost Drivers
Speakers argue that California's 2045 zero-emission mandate forces reliance on intermittent renewables like wind and solar, leading to electricity rates double the national average. They attribute high costs to policy-driven supply restrictions, such as closing fossil fuel plants, rather than demand growth, noting California's population has stagnated or declined.
- 10:12 – 13:20
Lifecycle Emissions and 'Green' Trade-offs
The panel challenges the classification of solar and wind as purely green, citing the environmental costs of manufacturing, mining, and disposal of panels and turbine blades. They assert that nuclear power has fewer lifetime emissions than solar and comparable to wind, while highlighting the massive concrete footprint required for wind turbines.
- 13:20 – 20:28
Small Modular Reactors (SMRs) and Industry Interest
SMRs are described as modular, factory-built reactors that can be sited on existing natural gas or coal plant infrastructure, avoiding new transmission costs. Speakers note that AI companies are contracting for SMRs to power data centers, signaling private sector investment in this technology as a reliable, baseload alternative to renewables.
Do your own research
- Verify California's current electricity rate premiums compared to the national average using EIA data.
- Review the Pacific Research Institute's funding sources and potential conflicts of interest regarding energy policy advocacy.
- Check the lifecycle emissions data for solar, wind, and nuclear power from independent environmental agencies.
- Research the current status and regulatory hurdles for Small Modular Reactor (SMR) deployment in California.
- Investigate specific contracts between AI companies and nuclear developers for data center power supply.
- Analyze California's population growth trends to assess the demand-side argument for energy costs.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:03
- Brian Hyde: Welcome to the Powering America Podcast. I'm Brian Hyde, and today I'm happy to welcome Wayne Weingarden and Carrie Jackson to the show. We are going to be talking about something that's gonna be very relevant to a lot of people, if not now, in the very, very near future. Both of these gentlemen are with the Pacific Research Research Institute. Wayne, I'm gonna have each one of you take just a moment, if you
- 0:23
- Brian Hyde: would, to talk about who you are and what you do. Let's start with you and then carry Carrie, on. I'll offer you that same opportunity.
- 0:29
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Absolutely. And and Brian, we're just so happy to be to be here with you today. Let me just start with you know Pacific Research Institute. We're a pre-market think tank. We're a national think tank that is headquartered in Pasadena, California. We work on a range of issues from healthcare to energy in the environment to to taxes and
- 0:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): homelessness. My personal role, I'm a senior fellow in business and economics. So I cover kind of the world from an economic viewpoint, I would say.
- 0:59
- Brian Hyde: Very good. And and Carrie, if you wouldn't mind telling us a little bit about yourself.
- 1:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I'm also a fellow at Pacific Research Institute, and I have focused on California issues since uh Oh my fellowship began in 2016. Now it's almost a long time. to forget. Before that I was an editorial writer in Investors Business Daily.
- 1:18
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 1:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I put in nearly 30 years. Well, let's be a little more accurate, almost 27 years of living in California. So I have been focused on California issues too over that time. So spent a little time in DC in the mid-90s too, working for a think tank there. So I've been at this for almost longer than I can remember.
- 1:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
- 1:37
- Brian Hyde: know, it's interesting. When I hear anyone say California issues, immediately my mind snaps to energy because it seems like that's what I hear about more often than not is ah, you know, California's struggling, sometimes rolling brownouts and extremely high energy costs. Would either one of you or maybe both of you like to kind of set the stage for us when we talk about some of the struggles that
- 1:57
- Brian Hyde: California has with energy policy? Where's a good place to start?
- 2:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
- 2:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I I think the their target of 2045, when every all retail sales of electricity have to be essentially renewables or carbon-free.
- 2:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
- 2:14
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, they're gonna call it zero emission sources. But the fact is, you're only gonna get really and practically speaking, you're only gonna get wind and solar. There'll be a few other things mixed in there. but I don't think they're gonna make a difference. And so of course now they're cutting back on fossil fuels. We got three plants are gonna be closing at
- 2:34
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the end of the year.
- 2:41
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I'm just thinking of just one right off the top of my head and resent enough for you.
- 2:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Correct.
- 2:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That seems to be not an option coming out of at least the large large-scale scale industry. industrial nuclear. So you know, they have a target, they have a deadline, and you wonder if they're gonna meet
- 2:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it. Yeah.
- 3:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): It's it's very much a, I would say, a a a forced transition in a specific way is is the way to think about it. And I think undoubtedly You know, there's been some great advancements. We talk about solar, we talked about battery back backup systems. What when people say these systems have progressed, it's a hundred percent correct. But it doesn't
- 3:20
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): just because they progress doesn't necessarily A mean that's the answer. B, you know, again, economics per you know perspective, at what cost? And I think that's really where things start to, you know, the wheels start to come off of the wagon. When you're talking about electricity rates that are twice the national average. as we've
- 3:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): increased our share of you know solar and wind, the kind of alternative energies, you've seen just kind of that direct correlation that prices have gone up, you know, pretty right along with it. And
- 3:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you then try to kind of connect that with the statement that the LCOE, right, which is the way we measure kind of the cost of a new facility, is cheaper for solar and wind than other resources. But there's all sorts of caveats that go around that. You know, you don't take into account reliability. You don't take
- 4:13
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): into account that there's lots of new transmission lines you have to, you know, to put down and that costs money. You don't take into account all of the backup battery requirements or natural gas. uh backup generation that's required. So I I think it it if you think with one
- 4:33
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): word, it it's such a complicated system. And we've created a bit of a Rube Goldberg structure. And then people try to, because it's so complicated, come out with one number and try to to basically plan a very complicated system. taking into account only one
- 4:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): goal and not looking at kind of the bigger picture or are there different ways to cut the Gordian knot? And you know, this consequence. And we see it every day with the lack of affordability that that Californians are screaming about.
- 5:06
- Brian Hyde: So I have to ask this just to get my mind around why energy is so expensive in California. Is it a function of is the is demand so high because there are so many people either moving to the state or living within the state? Or is it that technology is advancing at a pace that the demand has has risen, you know, beyond even you know population
- 5:26
- Brian Hyde: growth?
- 5:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): No, it's it's policy driven. I mean I'll let Carrie Jeremy sorry
- 5:32
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): got passionate about this one, but it's completely demand driven. In fact, population in California has stagnated. We've been actually losing when you look look at not international migration and births, right? If you just look at where people choose to live, we've been losing people for you know a decade now. So it's
- 5:52
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): undoubtedly not kind of that just natural demand is outstripping our supply. It's a policy creation where we artificially
- 6:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): inflate the cost of production. We artificially make it more difficult to have generation when you keep shutting down plants at work.
- 6:13
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): That restricts supply. So it's a policy-created imbalance. Now, we've like I said, there's been great progress. We have actually more generation capacity now than we used to. We have a lot more battery back. backup storage and that is supposed to kind of transition these energy systems. So we have lots
- 6:33
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): of solar during the day, it's fine, the sun sets, the batteries are supposed to get you through the rest of the high-end use. And all this works on paper. But if something doesn't go exactly right, that's where kind of issues arise. And I I I'd say one thing that I'll let Carrie get a word in, but the other important thing you were drawing by demand.
- 6:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Remember, lots of people live along the coast, which is very, very temperate. You know, we don't have air conditioning in my house because you don't need it. We just never get that high. So there's a lot of people who live in places where you actually should be drawing less energy because you you just don't need the electricity.
- 7:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, I
- 7:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): well, that was what I was gonna say. You have a state a of thirty 39 million, roughly 39 million, and almost all of them. That's and I shouldn't say almost you do have the inland empires is fairly well fairly populated. But you a big chunk of that 39 million will live within a few miles of the ocean with this Mediterranean climate that doesn't necessarily need to be cooled or warmed that
- 7:32
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): much during any given year. So you know the demand for that power is you know electricity and natural gas is just not going to be, shouldn't be that high, shouldn't affect your prices.
- 7:44
- Brian Hyde: My understanding, too, is that the the green energy policies, while while they may be doing a favor for Mother Earth, also come at a pretty significant cost, and and the efficiency still is catching up. Now, there is another green energy, although some people may, you know, strongly disagree when I suggest nuclear is one of the green energy. greenest energy sources out there.
- 8:04
- Brian Hyde: Let's talk a little bit about the the role that nuclear power could play if California policymakers were to actually give it its proper due.
- 8:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 8:13
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think you can't, it's undeniable that it is
- 8:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): green, it's renewable, it's sustainable, it is reliable, it just keeps going. And you you wonder, and I did, and it finally was explained to me by somebody smarter than me. Well, why? what is what's the pushback on this? Why is nuclear power looked at in the way it is? And apparently people will conflate or have come to conflate it with nuclear weapons, which are obviously
- 8:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): dangerous. And then there was Three Mile Island, I believe in 79, the best of my memory was 79. Yeah, it was 79, because Carter's still in, still in office. It looked like it might be bad. It wasn't that bad. There was a, you know, my recollection, was a small leak. Certainly wasn't on the on the uh the level what we saw in
- 8:55
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): well, and you know, the now I can't remember the name of the everybody knows it except me at the moment, I think.
- 9:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Chernobyl.
- 9:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, okay, thanks, Wayne. He's Wayne's always helpful. Yeah. Chernobyl, yes, which now has a concrete dome around it to protect it. But so people conflate it with you know dangerous you know the risk there. And if you think about it, I can think of I well, I don't think anybody has died in a nuclear power
- 9:20
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): accident commercially in this country. I think one there was one fatality in the military in maybe the 40s or 50s when they were working on nuclear energy for power, for electricity to generate power, and but not in any commercial application. You know, we've been sending men down in mines and holes and
- 9:40
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): mountains, tunnels, and you know, hundreds, maybe thousands, I don't know what the canists in this country have died. I have natural gas in this house. I think it's a great way to, you know, it's a great source of power, but we see places where pipes or where you know the the you have issues, you have leaks, and then the whole
- 10:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): neighborhood goes up.
- 10:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
- 10:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, yet here we have nuclear, which is,
- 10:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
- 10:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): not doesn't have a bad track record, actually has a good one, and you have a lot of resistance to
- 10:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
- 10:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): And I I I would add, because you're saying green technologies, and I think we need to be really careful about what we call green and what we don't call green. There's trade trade-offs, offs, and every source has a trade off. Right. If you think about solar, how do does it how do you get solar energy? Well, you need some sort of big machine to dig up stuff out
- 10:32
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): of the earth, then you have to refine that stuff, and then you get energy, and then you have a disposal issue. It sounds a lot like fossil fuels, right? I mean, in terms of the process, and when you think about the lifetime times emissions, and that's really what matters, right? And you're talking about like what happened in California. We we focus very much. on the
- 10:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): emissions from California, which you know kill it is important, but it's also the global emissions, right? So that if we send manufacturing overseas, well yeah, you could say California is producing less emissions, but globally it's you know arguably worse. Well, comparing nuclear to solar,
- 11:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): right, you actually have fewer lifetime emissions with nuclear than you do with solar. And it's about the same as wind, although wind is not as good of a resource as solar seems to be becoming. So why isn't it a green energy source? I mean, and
- 11:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think that's really important. There are some really very difficult disposal issues that California is going to be hitting in 10, 20, 30 years when all these solar panels need to be safely disposed of because there's dangerous chemicals in there, when all these wind turbine blades blades need to be dealt with. There's all
- 11:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): sorts of green issues that come with that. So I would argue that exactly kind of what Carrie was going, that there is a it's a mental block, it's a mental belief. There are certainly obstacles that need to be overcome. And we we can we talk about some of those, but there are some really exciting things happening in the nuclear
- 12:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): space. It is a safe generation resource. It has some real advantages compared to other sectors, and it needs to be integrated in the right way. Again, just like you know, there's places where solar makes sense, and there's places where nuclear makes sense, and you need to put the right resource
- 12:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): at the right place at the right time. And that's what's missing in California. And that's really, I think, when we're talking about what's the right energy policy, that's really the the outline to it.
- 12:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's really quickly, too. Don't forget about and I know you didn't Wayne, the the amount, the massive amount of concrete that needs to be poured to site or to foot wind turbines. And you know, the the green crowd, if we can go back to that again, doesn't like concrete. And if you talk to people in a concrete business and I've known them, they'll say,
- 12:58
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 12:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, we're not clean necessarily. We do what we can, but you know, there is there is just a process of making this stuff and getting it where it needs to go, you know, that they don't like, but yet they seem to be just fine with, you know, again, massive amounts of this stuff. you know, to cite their particular source that they they
- 13:18
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): they favor.
- 13:20
- Brian Hyde: Tell me about small modular reactors or SMRs. I've heard from a number of people that this appears to be, you know, the biggest breakthrough in nuclear power, probably within within our lifetimes. But for people who are hearing about it for the first time, what do they need to understand about SMRs?
- 13:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well, this
- 13:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): this conversation. caught my eye, and I can't remember how many years ago, probably two or three, maybe more, that I just re I, you know, you run into things, you're working on something else, and you know, you're you're doing some research and you find something, you go, well, that's surprising. I'd like to know more about that. So I started writing a little bit about about these small modular reactors and the They
- 13:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): call backyard nukes, essentially. And, you know, I'm not gonna say everybody's gonna have. a nuclear reactor the size of the refrigerator in the backyard powering their own house. Maybe at some point that turns to be the case, but they're not, you know, right now they're not that small. But these these are reactors that almost essentially you can power a neighborhood instead of an
- 14:18
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): entire region, I guess maybe is that would you say you think that's a fair way to put it line Wayne in the and yes, it is there's a promising future there. And it it's not just one side of the political spectrum that's saying this. There are thoughtful people on both sides saying we need to explore this. This is going to be what's going to be very helpful to us if we can get through the
- 14:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): regulatory process. And
- 14:41
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I I had I've mentioned this to Wayne before. I'm old enough to remember when, well, I've been waiting for nuclear fusion for a long time, coal fusion. and it's just like next year, next year, next yeah. So I've kind of given up on that to be something that's gonna be ready to go. Say with hydrogen. I remember being told not long after I arrived in Washington more than
- 15:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): 30 years ago that hydrogen is gonna be the next great source of power. You can go backyard, take a bucket to the creek, bring it back, pour poured it in whatever system you you have, and then it's gonna, you know, create electricity from the hydrogen. drawing the you know out of the water and and again that's like it's just around the corner but it never happens but I
- 15:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): think the SMRs I mean companies are putting money into this they're investing we're looking at some regulatory
- 15:27
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 15:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): think some regulatory hurdles are probably going to be coming down so I think it's it's it's very promising and if you really want to look into something that's going to be a renewable and reliable and safe
- 15:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we
- 15:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): need to look hard at this.
- 15:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean,
- 15:42
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I would say one of the issues we have with nuclear right now, and and the problem is that if you look at the cost here in the US compared to cost in South Korea, let's say. Right? In South Korea, one, our regulatory burdens are excessive, and that we can address. But they actually continue, it's what they call like the nth of a kind.
- 16:02
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Right. So that they're basically mass producing it. It's the same one. You think Henry Ford, right? You know, you get those types of efficiencies. And that's not what we're doing here in the US. We really have what's really a first of a kind. And that creates one, you're building on site, it becomes very complicated. Interest costs Cars starts piling up
- 16:22
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): and delays inevitably happen. So you you end up with a less efficient kind of nuclear structure. I bring that up with SMRs, is because SMRs is a way to really start getting that end of a kind kind of benefit that you really need to see to really make nuclear more competitive. Because right now, with the regulatory structure,
- 16:42
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): with this idea that they're each plant is is unique, not completely unique. That's why I paused pause for a second, but you
- 16:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
- 16:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): they're they're they they're in. individualized. That is inflating our cost. That makes nuclear more expensive and it creates delays, it's harder to plan with. SMRs gives you that ability to commoditize it a bit. You actually would be producing in a specific plant and and bringing it on site. It The size
- 17:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): of it, you know, I I I get away from the backyard, but you can actually cite some of these SMRs in existing natural gas plants that you're shutting down or coal-fired plants that you're shutting down. And now what you actually get, which is exciting, is you don't need to rewire the grid because you have the transmission lines right there
- 17:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): and you can kind of connect in that, right? The cost of solar is higher than they admit. That's the wrong word. I shouldn't use that word. Is it higher than what what's often recorded because you're not including the transmission lines, right? But you got to site solar where the sun is correct. And that's not necessarily where we live. And so you
- 17:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): get all this infrastructure you have to put down. And oh, by the way, if you're running that infrastructure through fire-prone zones, now you've got Out all of that hardening of the system you have to do, or you're increasing risks, but these SMRs. you can site them right on kind of that facility where they are. They fit right in. You can get the cost down
- 18:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): where
- 18:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): if you again commoditize it and get all those benefits, now it becomes even on the LCOE, the levelized cost of electricity, how they compare costs for different brand new sources, you're actually on par. or cheaper than solar, and you have the reliability. And one
- 18:31
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): thing I think that talks about kind of the potential of SMRs. And I just found this out recently. I should have probably realized it earlier. But a lot of the AI companies, when they're talking about kind of generating their own facilities, they're contracting and looking toward these kind of advanced SMR projects as a way to create.
- 18:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): the energy that they need to power these data centers. So now they're not kind of not just they're not pulling from the grid, they're actually adding to the grid. I don't know the impact of water, but I would imagine there's beneficial impacts there as well. So you actually have a lot of kind of interest in Indies these in some unexpected places,
- 19:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): which could be quite exciting.
- 19:13
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I I think looking when what you're saying the private sector getting in there or these tech companies, I think you're just gonna keep looking at investment and capital where it's flowing in this. I mean, these companies, it's not just the you know, Google who would like to have, or Microsoft or whoever might want to have, you know, a the you know a nuclear or an SM bar
- 19:33
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Are powering their particular data center here or there, but it's the companies who are building these things too. And you're gonna getting investment in these companies because somebody's saying, yeah, we see, you see the future, we see the future, and we're willing to put our money there. And you know, not every investment's going to turn out, but when you see as much as I think we're gonna have been seeing and will be seeing going
- 19:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to these to this particular technology, pay attention. You know, there's something there.
- 19:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): People spend their own money better.
- 20:01
- Brian Hyde: Again, my guest guests today. have been Wayne Weingarden and Carrie Jackson, both with the Pacific Research Institute. Guys, I feel pretty optimistic after this conversation. Thank you so much for joining us on the Powering America podcast.
- 20:14
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Glad to be there or here. Thanks for inviting us.
- 20:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Is there a lightning?