Powering America

Bartlett Cleland argues BEAD broadband rollout is stalled by excessive local permitting and redundant regulatory layers.

17 min Listen to the original Episode page
Broadband PolicyFederal RegulationTelecommunicationsInfrastructureRural ConnectivitySatellite InternetGovernment SpendingPermitting Reform

Summary

Bartlett Cleland, a research fellow at the Institute for Policy Innovation, discusses the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program, a $42 billion federal initiative aimed at connecting the 3-4% of U.S. homes without broadband access. He identifies local permitting as the primary bottleneck, citing an ACLP study that estimates 10-20+ permits per project. Cleland suggests administrative solutions, such as using unspent NTIA funds to hire reviewers, and calls for Congress to provide clearer tools to federal agencies like the Forest Service. He argues that redundant permitting processes drive away investment due to high legal costs, hindering economic growth. Finally, he predicts that low earth orbit (LEO) satellite technology will become competitive with wired broadband in rural areas.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Cleland asserts that permitting processes are redundant and excessive, involving multiple agencies weighing in on the same issues.

    Bartlett Cleland · 13:23

Episode sections

  1. 0:03 – 1:19

    Introduction and BEAD Background

    Brian Hyde introduces guest Bartlett Cleland, a research fellow at the Institute for Policy Innovation, to discuss the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program. Cleland outlines his 28-30 year career in technology and public policy, spanning telecom, edge providers, and software.

  2. 1:19 – 7:15

    BEAD Program History and Funding

    Cleland explains that BEAD is a $42 billion federal program passed during the Biden administration to subsidize broadband build-out in the 3-4% of homes without access. The funds are managed by the NTIA within the Department of Commerce to ensure equitable distribution.

  3. 7:15 – 9:33

    Permitting Bottlenecks

    The primary obstacle to BEAD implementation is local permitting, with an estimated 10-20+ permits per project. Cleland cites a study by the Advanced Communications Law and Policy Institute (ACLP) from mid-summer to highlight the excessive number of required approvals.

  4. 9:33 – 13:04

    Administrative Solutions

    Cleland suggests using unspent NTIA funds to hire reviewers or coordinators to manage overlapping jurisdictions. He also recommends Congress provide clear tools to federal agencies like the Forest Service and USDA, and argues that providers should not absorb relocation costs for existing infrastructure.

  5. 13:04 – 15:18

    Redundancy and Economic Impact

    Cleland asserts that permitting processes are redundant and excessive, involving multiple agencies weighing in on the same issues. He argues that these layers drive away investment due to high legal costs, negatively impacting economic growth and job creation.

  6. 15:18 – 17:28

    Future of Rural Connectivity

    Cleland predicts that low earth orbit (LEO) satellite technology will become competitive with traditional wired broadband for rural areas. He notes that satellite technology has advanced significantly in recent years, potentially reducing the need for expensive physical infrastructure in remote locations.

Claims worth verifying

Bartlett Cleland is a research fellow at the Institute for Policy Innovation.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·0:03

How to verify: Check the Institute for Policy Innovation staff directory or website for his current title and affiliation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The BEAD program is a $42 billion federal initiative.

Bartlett Cleland ·5:39

How to verify: Verify the total allocation amount in the BEAD program legislation or the NTIA's official program documentation on the U.S. Department of Commerce website. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

BEAD was passed during the Biden administration to serve the 3-4% of homes without broadband.

Bartlett Cleland ·4:58

How to verify: Cross-reference the passage date of the BEAD program with the Biden administration's timeline and verify the coverage gap percentage using FCC or NTIA broadband deployment maps. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The NTIA is a department within the Commerce Department responsible for distributing BEAD funds.

Bartlett Cleland ·6:16

How to verify: Confirm the organizational structure of the U.S. Department of Commerce and the NTIA's role in broadband deployment via the NTIA website or federal government directory. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Advanced Communications Law and Policy Institute (ACLP) published a study in August estimating 10-20+ permits per project.

Bartlett Cleland ·7:41

How to verify: Search the ACLP website or academic databases for a study published in August (year implied as recent relative to transcript) regarding broadband permitting counts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Amazon named their LEO satellite project 'Leo'.

Bartlett Cleland ·16:06

How to verify: Verify Amazon's satellite project naming conventions through Amazon's official press releases or space division announcements. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Elon Musk is associated with satellite technology advancements mentioned in the context of LEO.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·16:25

How to verify: Correlate Elon Musk's public association with SpaceX and its Starlink LEO satellite constellation through public records or company profiles. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the $42 billion funding amount and current disbursement status in NTIA public reports.
  • Review the specific findings of the Advanced Communications Law and Policy Institute (ACLP) study cited regarding permit counts.
  • Check current NTIA guidance on the use of unspent funds for administrative support or reviewer hiring.
  • Examine existing federal agency regulations (USDA, Forest Service) for broadband permitting requirements.
  • Research current latency and pricing data for LEO satellite providers (e.g., Starlink, Kuiper) versus fixed wireless or fiber in rural areas.
  • Look for counter-arguments from local governments regarding the necessity of permitting for environmental or safety concerns.
  • Assess the legal costs associated with broadband permitting in specific states to validate the claim about investment deterrence.
  • Check for any recent legislative proposals aimed at streamlining federal or state permitting for broadband infrastructure.
Full transcriptexpand
0:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Welcome
0:03
Brian Hyde: to the Powering America Podcast. I'm Brian Hyde, and today I'm joined by Bartlett Cleland. In fact, we welcome him back to the the podcast. He is a research fellow at the Institute for Policy Innovation. And Bart, it's it's great to see you once again. For those getting to meet you for the very first time, take a moment, if you would, and tell us a little bit about who you
0:22
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are. Sure,
0:23
Bartlett Cleland: and happy to be back, Brian. I had a lot of fun last time. So I have spent the easiest way to explain I've spent almost my entire career in technology and public policy. And that goes back about 28 to 30 years now from all different angles. Capitol Hill, administration, activist organization, think tanks,
0:44
Bartlett Cleland: what else, industry associations. So I think about every angle you could have on public policy and technology, I've been there for some amount of that. And what do I mean by technology? It's a pretty broad category. Largely has been in telecom and then what I would call edge providers or internet services, but with a huge emphasis on
1:03
Bartlett Cleland: software.
1:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
1:05
Brian Hyde: right. We've got you here today to talk about an ongoing project. BED is the acronym. And actually I I had to I had to ask Bart beforehand to include clue me because I always like to figure out what those acronyms stand for. So for the record, BEAD stands for
1:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
1:19
Bartlett Cleland: broadband equity access and deployment program.
1:23
Brian Hyde: Okay, and and the the reason I ask him is because he really is an expert on this. And let's let's start with some of the the groundwork that we have to lay here. First of all, why is broadband important? And then let's talk about what this this uh bead BED program purports to do.
1:39
Bartlett Cleland: Sure. So
1:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
1:41
Bartlett Cleland: the importance of broadband, well, I'd suspect anyone listening to your program almost inherently knows, or they don't know, but they absolutely know, and that is that virtually everything they're doing, certainly listening to this podcast, is coming to them over some kind of broadband connection. But it turns out that in the what, what are we at like
2:00
Bartlett Cleland: twenty-five, 25, twenty-eight 28 years now? since the the World Wide Web, we used to capitalize internet and then we capitalize World Wide Web. Now it's just lowercase internet because it's just all all online activity. That online activity, which includes your phone, which includes if you have an alarm system at your home, any phone call you make, hospital records, like you just
2:20
Bartlett Cleland: go through the through everything. Basically, our entire world is running across broadband. at some point, if not completely. So its importance, I'm not sure you can overstate it. It kind of is the backbone of the economy.
2:36
Brian Hyde: No, that that makes sense. I and and you know just as it's become kind of a natural thing, you know, we we don't look around today and and wonder or I guess young people today don't look around and wonder, hey, where did pay payphones phones go? Now us older folks we we do, but this is part of the uh infrastructure of of the future. And so what's the history behind
2:56
Brian Hyde: Bede? In other words, where where does it begin? It's it's not something that just came on the scene yesterday, but talk to me a little bit about the progress that it's made and and what does what what exactly is it to accomplish?
3:10
Bartlett Cleland: Sure. So there has been discussions, uh I you know, goodness, going back to the first expansion of the internet as to how many people weren't had access to the internet. And in those early days, people probably remember it was something of a toy. Like I might equip I might make an equivalent to where AI is today. It's cool, people mess around with it, but it hasn't been embedded
3:30
Bartlett Cleland: in the way they think and do. As we went forward, 10 years, let's say, 15 years, schools were teaching how to be. online, how to be proficient in being online. They were getting lesson plans from online. Hospitals were transferring information online. And this is I I'm talking about past getting past email to where
3:49
Bartlett Cleland: information was on websites. You're uploading documents on websites and whatnot. And so it became increasingly obvious that
3:59
Bartlett Cleland: people, and a lot of this was driven by education, but more broadly. communities and people who had access to broadband tended to have a leg up on those communities and people who didn't. And so the kind of quickly, the number, the percentages were followed, how many homes are connected, and over the years that kept going up and up. And for those of us who
4:19
Bartlett Cleland: believe in market principles, we thought this is exactly what should be happening. There were those who thought more about the electrification of America. So there was this so two schools of thought. The market said, boy, everyone needs broadband because this is really helpful. And the people who favored more of a government push said, oh, everyone should have this because it's really helpful. So it was a question of how we
4:38
Bartlett Cleland: were going to get there. During the Biden administration, the proposal was put forward that for the, I think at that point it was roughly three to four percent of homes communities that didn't have broadband, that the U.S. government would subsidize getting broadband built out. And what did that look like? That meant that industry would
4:58
Bartlett Cleland: bid and they would get the difference in what they in rough measure here. They would get the difference between the market that they could have and then the rest would be subsidized by the government. So it's a it's extraordinarily expensive. You can come up with a million scenarios. but imagine a small town of a couple hundred
5:18
Bartlett Cleland: people on a mountaintop in West Virginia or in Colorado, miles and miles away from any kind of large city. You can imagine the cost of trying to get that cable into the ground is expensive. Perhaps even more expensive over time is putting it up on telephone poles. That costs money. So regardless, it was expensive. So
5:39
Bartlett Cleland: there a natural market was not existing. So Congress voted to allocate $42 billion to the effort to get those communities and people to give them broadband access. And that was passed. Oh degree, if I'm gonna kind of forget the year now, but probably in
5:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well,
5:56
Bartlett Cleland: it's been probably four or five years at least since it passed. And it was handed over to the what's called NTIA. That's a department within the commerce department to figure out how are we going to get that money out to communities in an equitable, whatever that means, an equitable way. And so that's where it was
6:16
Bartlett Cleland: up until the last couple of years, where a lot of states have been saying, Hey, where's the money? We put in these applications. We've got people who it industry that is that have said, yes, we will bid on this area. And they have won those won those bids. Air quotes there for people who aren't watching. And why
6:36
Bartlett Cleland: are we not seeing any further build out from what was already planned by a lot of these folks at industry?
6:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
6:43
Bartlett Cleland: then I'll turn it back to you from there. That takes us up to kind of the contemporary piece we're talking about.
6:48
Brian Hyde: No, that's that's wonderful background. And and I I've got to tell you, one of the common concerns that I have heard about this move to expand broadband, make sure that it's there and it's fast and everything, is that man, this is taking a long time. I mean, it's making the California high-speed rail project look speedy by comparison.
7:06
Brian Hyde: What is it that's bogging this down? What are some of the the roadblocks that they're hitting that that are making it difficult to implement Bede?
7:15
Bartlett Cleland: There are really a couple along the way, but the one that is the current, let's see, we're we're back to Halloween. So I'll
7:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): say
7:21
Bartlett Cleland: the current hobgoblin or the current something, hobgoblins good, gremlin perhaps, is local permitted, which is crazy. Like you think about this giant national program. And it turns out that the local municipalities, whoever whatever level you're dealing with, could be counting. county, could be town, could be state, there's a lot of
7:41
Bartlett Cleland: permits that are required to build out. And in fact, by the estimation of, let's see, I've got to make sure I've got their name right, the Advanced Communications Law and Policy Institute, ACLP, they put out a study middle of this year, or maybe that was yeah, August, something like that, the summer, that if
8:01
Bartlett Cleland: you look at kind of an average. number of permits needed for each project, that you pretty much you end up with 10 permits per project minimal, often more than 20.
8:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
8:15
Bartlett Cleland: what is that? So people think, oh, permits. Well, how hard can that be? Turns out you gotta go through a lot of levels of review and votes, etc., in local communities to get these permits approved. And so each step.
8:27
Bartlett Cleland: just lengthens the amount of time until you can put a shovel in the gr so to speak, shovel in the ground to start the build out. But the municipal and the municipalities along the way, I mean, certainly certainly they want to know what's going on. But a lot of times their time pressure is maybe not the time pressure that was expressed in the original legislation. And
8:47
Bartlett Cleland: so things slow down to their speed.
8:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean
8:51
Brian Hyde: that's a lot of permits. And and I'm thinking I talked to a friend years ago who was telling me about they wanted to do an addition to their home in California. And she explained how many permits had to be signed off on, how much money had to cross this many hands, just to do a very simple addition to their home. I'm sure this is much more complicated given the amount of
9:10
Brian Hyde: area that it has to involve, uh given you know the types of land that it's going to go on, different infrastructure that it might encounter. What can be done to make that permitting process more streamlined without running roughshod over agencies or or authorities that that really are trying to look out for the interests of the
9:30
Brian Hyde: people with within their jurisdiction?
9:33
Bartlett Cleland: So the the great there is actually really good news here, and that is the NTIA that the and if I didn't say Board National Telecommunications and Information Administration, again, subpart of the Department of Commerce, so under the president's authority in the administration. They have money that has not gone out yet. It
9:53
Bartlett Cleland: certainly they can allow states to use some of that money towards the permitting, which would help move things along. And then so what is it what does that mean? So you hire a reviewer or reviewers, depending, to look at the projects, a coordinator. Some of these, some of these permits, they overlap
10:13
Bartlett Cleland: jurisdictions. That's part of the challenge. And that could be federal too. It runs across a federal highway, for example. But then then maybe you're on a state line. So, like in Missouri, lived in Overland Park. Well, Overland Park has the state line going right directly. through a bunch of towns right along the state line there. It could be within a state, but different municipalities within the
10:33
Bartlett Cleland: state who all have some level of autonomy and authority themselves. So just for people to get in their minds, the the you kind of need a coordinator. Some of that money could be used in that way, or even just flat out outsourcing the process. But God bless them, a lot of these county folks, they don't have a like they kind of have one
10:52
Bartlett Cleland: experience and they end up being in this position where they've suddenly got to be an expert in broadband. Like I that seems like something we wouldn't necessarily want to burden every county official with having to be an expert. So maybe you could hire some of that expertise in so that they don't have to spend as much time studying and then being, frankly, I would be very
11:12
Bartlett Cleland: nervous about making the a decision if I wasn't native to the topics. Then there's all kinds of all kinds of other tools. You can think of tons of software about tracking what's getting done, et cetera, that all would help move things along. So that's at the local level with NTIA. Then the Congress can step in here too, because,
11:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as
11:30
Bartlett Cleland: I mentioned, some of these things are federal. So think Forest Service, think USDA, think Department of Transportation. They need some clear tools on what to do in this situation. And that would have to come right out of the NTIA to give them some direction. Again, NTIA in charge of getting this money out and more importantly,
11:50
Bartlett Cleland: the build out of the broadband done. And then the final one is that it doesn't make a whole lot of sense, given that we're giving money to the states
12:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
12:02
Bartlett Cleland: then have. companies bid to build out, that we end up forcing providers to absorb like relocation costs if they're fed for this federal project, if some kind of facilities need to be moved. You need to move the the substation, the the poles, etc. It seems that that should be part of what
12:22
Bartlett Cleland: we're paying for, because that is part of the cost of the broadband being deployed. So they're there the really cool thing is there's a lot of authority in place. There's a lot of ideas out there about how to reduce some of this permitting. It's really a matter of getting eyes on the project and heading the game and driving this forward to get this done
12:41
Bartlett Cleland: before you and I are back doing this in five more years, saying, Hey, how about that bead project?
12:46
Brian Hyde: So this is kind of a subjective question, but but I'd like to get your opinion on this part. Does all of the the permitting authority out there that comes into play for this particular project is it necessary? Are are each one of those levels of of permitting authority are they performing a vital function or is there some redundancy
13:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there? Well
13:06
Bartlett Cleland: the easy the the easiest part of your question is the last part. Is there redundancy? Yes. The
13:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
13:11
Bartlett Cleland: I think the rest to some extent, I'll be as generous as I can. is beauty is in the eye of the beholder. So I think there's some folks who would say, Oh, yeah, we need all of these because they're all for really good purpose.
13:22
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
13:23
Bartlett Cleland: won't even argue with whether it's for good purpose. Forget that it's an environmental review, it's a it's a safety review. These are all swell things. Whether you need to your point, six or seven different agencies weighing in on that, I think most people would say that's probably a bit excessive. That you need multiple jurisdictions to come to the same conclusion
13:43
Bartlett Cleland: on something that's being built. Maybe that's a bit excessive as opposed to working together from the get go to complete the permit as a whole or in tandem. Uh I personally, just my my beliefs in the size of government and use of government, I think we're way we need permit reform broadly. We're running into this issue
14:03
Bartlett Cleland: not just in broadband. This is a huge issue in building out new energy. It's a huge issue in building out data center. Like you just pick the issue for infrastructure building,
14:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
14:13
Bartlett Cleland: it's a problem. And why is that an economic problem for the average American for me? It's because as we don't, as as investment is decreased, our economy does not grow as much. Less jobs, less money. in the community, etc. And so I think we all kind of want to see investment in our community. Now maybe it's different kinds of
14:33
Bartlett Cleland: investment, but we all would like investment.
14:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Too
14:35
Bartlett Cleland: many layers of permitting drives away that investment because it's too expensive. There's lawyers, I guess is the bottom line. There are lawyers at every step of this permitting process who are
14:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well,
14:46
Bartlett Cleland: lawyers we're getting get paid pretty
14:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well.
14:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
14:48
Brian Hyde: there's some job security that maybe we would incentivize now let's not be too hasty and make it make this too easy to to take place.
14:57
Bartlett Cleland: I think that's what like when we're talking about taxes, right? Same thing. Well, we don't want to make it too simple because all of a sudden all the tax repairers are out of job. It's kind of that same mentality, yes.
15:06
Brian Hyde: So is is there any projection as to when this this bead project will be considered complete or is it gonna going to be an ongoing project? you know, as as long as there is expansion in technology?
15:18
Bartlett Cleland: So that's a good question.
15:24
Bartlett Cleland: For this round. And that that just says for what we know now, that's a a that's a complete set. Could Congress continue doing this? Maybe. I frankly find that hard to believe. There was, I mean, listen, and including me, not everyone was so excited about this money, this huge chunk of money being put forward by the federal
15:43
Bartlett Cleland: government to build out in these spaces. I like I
15:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
15:47
Bartlett Cleland: but that but that battle was, you know, the five year ago, six year ago, seven year ago battle. This money is out there now. And I just feel like it would be really hard to get another huge allocation of money. But you raise a good point. What about as technology continues? Does it become more expensive to deliver in these localities where we've
16:06
Bartlett Cleland: built out? Actually, my long-term thinking is it's going to go the other direction. It's going to be less expensive. So think of a couple companies doing low low earth orbit. In fact, Amazon cleverly called theirs Leo, low earth orbit. But Elon Musk, that if the if this and we used to laugh about
16:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
16:25
Bartlett Cleland: well, but for those people. satellites are okay. And there were a lot of problems with satellite connections. In fact, if you're listening to this and you have a satellite connection right now, you're probably like, this guy is crazy. Sis satellite thing is no good compared to what my buddies living in the city are getting. That's yesterday's and today's satellite technology. It's advanced enormously, even in the last few years, and will we'll continue
16:45
Bartlett Cleland: to advance. Long story short, that satellite delivery
16:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
16:50
Bartlett Cleland: at least going to be competitive. I don't know if ultimately it'll be cheaper, but competitive with drilling through rock to get a line out to that village of saying of 400 people.
17:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey,
17:01
Brian Hyde: it's been wonderful visiting with you once again. As always, uh very enlightening conversation. We're talking with Bartlett Cleland. He is a research fellow with the Institute for Policy Innovation. And Bart, thanks again for joining us here on the Powering Empowering American. America podcast. Thank
17:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you,
17:16
Bartlett Cleland: Brian. I appreciate
17:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Powering America

All insights