Switched On

Biomethane gains economic competitiveness in Europe as gas prices rise and compliance markets expand

35 min Listen to the original Episode page
BiomethaneEuropean Energy PolicyEU ETSRenewable Natural GasCarbon MarketsShipping RegulationsRoad TransportBuilding Heating

Summary

Kathy Gao explains that biomethane is chemically identical to natural gas but distinct in production and incentives, derived from organic waste. She notes that European natural gas prices have surged above €60/MWh, narrowing the gap with biomethane production costs of €70-100/MWh, making it increasingly competitive without subsidies. The market is shifting from subsidy-led growth to demand-driven growth via compliance markets like EU ETS, EU Maritime, and RED3. These policies price emissions and allow biomethane producers to sell environmental attributes based on lifecycle emission reductions. Road transport currently offers the highest premium due to high certificate prices, but growth is capped by regulatory limits on internal combustion engines. Building sector quotas are projected to drive the largest volume growth by 2035, despite uncertainties regarding EU Commission reviews of lifecycle calculation methodologies.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    an example, the same molecule can generate a compliance value of over 200 euro. per megawatt hour in some market, but less than 50 euro per mega hour in other markets. So the price spread is actually quite large.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 5:33

  2. 2
    several several European markets that have the Red Free uh regulations, such as in Sweden and Finland, the penetration of biomethane in the total road transport gas use is over 90%. And it's roughly 80% in in Germany and 60% in the Netherlands already. So this basically means. that, you know, biometh is already very widely used in those road transport markets and the future growth potential is limited.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 20:10

  3. 3
    The EU Commission is reviewing lifecycle greenhouse gas calculation methodologies, which could drastically reduce the carbon intensity scores of biomethane projects, threatening the economics of compliance markets.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 31:35

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 3:09

    Introduction and Biomethane Definition

    The episode introduces biomethane as chemically identical to natural gas but economically distinct due to production methods and incentives. Kathy Gao explains that biomethane is produced from organic waste via microorganisms, purified to replace fossil fuels in power, heat, and transport.

  2. 3:09 – 6:35

    Economic Competitiveness and Market Shift

    Biomethane's green premium is narrowing as European natural gas prices surged above €60/MWh while production costs remain €70-100/MWh. The market is transitioning from subsidy-led growth to demand-driven growth via compliance markets.

  3. 6:35 – 8:30

    Compliance Markets and Value Drivers

    Compliance markets, including EU ETS, EU Maritime, and RED3, put a price on emissions. Biomethane generates certificates based on lifecycle emission reductions, allowing producers to sell environmental attributes for additional revenue.

  4. 8:30 – 12:00

    Lifecycle Emissions and Negative Carbon Intensity

    Biomethane receives credit for avoiding emissions from decomposing organic waste. It can achieve negative carbon intensity scores (e.g., -100g CO2/MJ), generating significant compliance value compared to natural gas's 70-90g CO2/MJ.

  5. 12:00 – 16:20

    Policy Landscape and Sector Differentiation

    Four main policies drive value: RED3 (road transport), EU Maritime (shipping), EU ETS (industry), and national gas blending quotas (buildings). RED3 currently offers the highest compliance value, while EU ETS offers limited value due to free allowances.

  6. 16:20 – 22:44

    Road Transport Penetration and Regulatory Caps

    Road transport offers the highest premium due to high certificate prices (>€400/t CO2). However, growth is capped by existing high penetration in some countries and EU Type-Approval regulations that restrict new internal combustion engine vehicle sales.

  7. 22:44 – 27:17

    Shipping Sector Dynamics and EU Maritime Rules

    EU Maritime regulations cover 20-30% of global shipping emissions. While LNG suffices for targets until 2030, methane slip issues post-2030 will force blending with bioLNG. Surplus certificate trading currently drives adoption more than penalties.

  8. 27:17 – 35:27

    Building Sector Quotas and Policy Uncertainties

    Green gas blending quotas in buildings (e.g., France, Netherlands, Spain, Germany) are projected to drive the largest volume growth by 2035. Key uncertainties include EU Commission reviews of lifecycle calculation methodologies and liquefaction equivalence rules.

Claims worth verifying

The Climate Pledge has over 700 signatories across 62 industries and 49 countries, aiming for net zero by 2040.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:00

How to verify: Check the 2026 Climate Pledge Report available at Amazon.com/sustainability. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Biomethane production costs in Europe are roughly €70-100 per megawatt hour.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·3:35

How to verify: Verify against BNEF EU Biomethane Market Outlook report or industry production cost databases. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

European natural gas prices surged from €30-40/MWh to above €60/MWh in the current year.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·3:15

How to verify: Check European natural gas spot price data from ICE Endex or TTF futures contracts for the relevant period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Total biomethane demand in Europe is expected to double by 2035.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·6:13

How to verify: Verify against BNEF EU Biomethane Market Outlook report projections. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

RED3 road transport certificates trade above €400 per tonne of CO2 in Germany and the Netherlands.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·16:40

How to verify: Check certificate trading platforms or market reports for Germany's and Netherlands' RED3 certificate markets. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

EU ETS carbon prices are roughly €70-80 per tonne of CO2.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·16:40

How to verify: Check EU ETS allowance prices on ICE Endex or EEX platforms. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Biomethane can achieve a carbon intensity score of -100 grams of CO2 per megajoule.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·10:41

How to verify: Verify against lifecycle assessment (LCA) methodologies used in EU certification schemes (e.g., ISCC, REDcert). For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Biomethane penetration in road transport gas use is over 90% in Sweden and Finland.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·20:10

How to verify: Check national energy statistics or transport fuel reports from Sweden and Finland. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

France has legislated a green gas blending quota extending to 2044.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·28:09

How to verify: Check French government legislation or energy ministry announcements regarding the 'quota gaz vert'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The EU Commission is reviewing lifecycle greenhouse gas calculation methodologies and liquefaction by equivalence rules.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·31:15

How to verify: Check European Commission legislative proposals or impact assessments on RED and LCA methodologies. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify current European natural gas spot prices (e.g., TTF futures) against the stated €60/MWh threshold using ICE Endex or Platts data.
  • Check the latest EU ETS allowance prices and free allowance allocation rates for industrial sectors via the European Environment Agency or EU ETS registry.
  • Review the specific RED3 certificate prices in Germany and the Netherlands through national regulatory bodies or commodity trading platforms.
  • Assess the status of EU Type-Approval regulations for internal combustion engines and potential exemptions for e-fuels or biomethane via EUR-Lex.
  • Investigate the EU Commission's ongoing review of lifecycle greenhouse gas calculation methodologies and their potential impact on carbon intensity scores.
  • Examine the penetration rates of biomethane in road transport for Sweden, Finland, and Germany using national energy statistics or industry reports.
  • Analyze the EU Maritime regulation's methane slip requirements and the timeline for bioLNG blending mandates via IMO or EU Commission publications.
Full transcriptexpand

0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): The Climate Pledge, co founded by Amazon and Global Optimism, is a commitment to reach net zero carbon emissions by 2040. Seven years after its launch, the community has grown to more than 700 signatories across 62 industries and 49 countries and territories, reducing emissions, scaling emerging climate solutions, and addressing challenges across operations and value chains. Learn more about the collective impact in the 2026 Climate Pledge Report at AMC. Amazon.com/slash sustainability.

0:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This

0:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): is Kamala Schelling, and you're listening to Switched On, the Bloomberg NF podcast. Today we're bringing you a story of twin molecules. Methane and biomethane are chemically identical. They share the same molecular DNA, but that's where their shared story ends. They're made differently, they're priced differently, and while they are interchangeable when it comes to burning them for fuel, the reasons and incentives

0:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are.

0:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): for choosing one over the other aren't interchangeable at all. For a long time, methane, or natural gas, has been the more popular of the two because it's been cheap and readily available. But things may now be changing, especially in Europe, where concerns about energy security are joining climate targets to give biomethane a big push. And the nature of the biomethane market itself is also changing, moving from a world where it needs policy support to help encourage. its uptake to a market where economics alone could give it the boost it needs. So today we're going to be talking about biomethane, that twin that has long been a wallflower, but could soon be the new bell of the ball. With me in the studio is Kathy Gao, a specialist here at BNEF, to talk about her recent EU biomethane market outlook. BNF clients can find this and other related material by heading to BNEF BNEFGo Go on the Bloomberg Trial. Terminal or at bnef.com. If you'd like to learn more about how BNEF approaches strategy research on the energy transition, including developments in commodity markets, trends across different sectors, and the cross-cutting technologies shaping the future, you can find more information on bnef.com. And if you'd like to speak with a member of our team about becoming a client, email us at sales.bnef at Bloomberg.net. But for now, let's talk biomethane with Kathy.

2:14Kathy, welcome back to Switched Dawn.

2:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Thank you for having me, Kamala.

2:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I want to start this conversation with literally the most basic question. What is biomethane?

2:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, so if you think about, you know, all the stuff that we we've got in the world, like you know, food, organic waste or animal manure, if you break them down uh in a process using microorganisms, you basically get to create something that contains methane, which is basically chemically the same as natural gas, and CO2. And if you then remove the CO2 or purify the whole gas, then you get pretty much something that's chemically identical to natural gas that could be used as a dropping fuel for anything that you use natural gas for, such as power generation, industrial heat, or as a fuel in vehicles.

2:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So if they're molecularly identical, they're definitely not economically identical. How does the price of biomethane compare to that of more standard methane or natural gas?

3:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, it's actually the green premium of biomethane is actually a lot lower than a lot of people would have expected. especially given if you think about the natural gas price this year in Europe. It basically surged from roughly 30 to 40 euro per megawatt hour last year to above 60 euro per megawatt hour this year. And if you think about the cost producing biomethane in Europe, it's roughly between um 70 to 90 or 100 euro per megawatt hour. So if you think about sort of the gap, it's actually not that much. And then the price of biomethane is obviously dependent on the kind of the economic values or compliance value can generate in different markets in Europe.

3:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): That's so interesting. So the premium is getting smaller, not just because the cost of biomethane is falling, but because the price of natural gas has risen quite dramatically this year. Um now your note focuses specifically on Europe. And so to talk about this economic case for biomethane and how it's changing, let's just start with a big picture overview of Europe's biomethane market. How was it changing? Why is it changing? Why did you decide to write this note right now?

4:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, so maybe let's first take a step back and think about why why biomethane has become such a popular topic recently. So I just mentioned sort of the rise of natural gas price and autocommodity auto commodity price in Europe and also across the world. Because of the fact that biomethan is produced locally in Europe, it is considered as actually a strategically important molecule for Europe, not only as uh options for decarbonization, but also as a substitute for those imported natural gas or fossil fuels, supporting energy security and energy resiliency of Europe. So the European biomethan market is actually. quite interesting because it's right now going through a transition. So it's basically shifting from a previously subsidy-led growth towards now a more demand-driven growth by different policies and compliance market, both at EU level and also at the member states level. So um this is really important because those compliance markets can actually change the business model. of how this molecule is being sold in Europe. So instead of relying on a fixed subsidies in the past, a lot of the producers of biomethane in Europe today have to think about which market they want to sell to and which buyer are willing to pay a higher premium for the same molecule. So just to give you

5:33an example, the same molecule can generate a compliance value of over 200 euro. per megawatt hour in some market, but less than 50 euro per mega hour in other markets. So the price spread is actually quite large. And across all these markets or sectors that are um have potential to use biomethane in in Europe today, we actually see road transport being the market that can offer the highest value or premium for this product, followed by shipping or maritime. And if you look at um the total volume growth, we think that the gas blending quotas for the building sector proposed by a lot of countries could potentially drive the largest incremental increase in demand. So overall, we expect the total demand for biomethane to pretty much double in Europe between now and 2035.

6:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

6:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you've mentioned a lot of factors there that are, let's say, providing a tailwind for biomethine. biomethane. Compliance markets. What exactly do you mean when you say compliance markets? Are we talking about carbon markets where you have to pay for emissions?

6:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, so that's a very good question. So basically, compliance market includes basically everything that put a price on your emissions. So that, for example, include uh, you know, the EU ETS, the European uh emission trading market, as as you just mentioned. in the shipping sector there's also a European regulations call for EU maritime which put basically a penalty if the ship owners fail to achieve a certain GHG or greenhouse gas intensity target for the vessels and then for the ones that overachieve the target they can basically sell the surplus so in in denominated in you know euro per tons of CO2 so it basically operate operates similar to the EU ETS market. And in the road transport sector, we also have a similar mechanism under the EU's Renewable Energy Directive or RED 3. So a lot of countries such as um Germany, Netherlands, and some other countries that have legislated the RED 3 um laws domestically, they have a basically a domestic uh certificate trading market for the greenhouse gas. reductions in the road transport sector. So it's again similar concept. And the certificate is denominated in Euro per ton of CO2 reductions, and it's being traded in those markets. So those are all the markets that we

7:54basically talk about or refer to as compliance markets Market that could drive a premium for the environmental attribute or emission reduction delivery. delivered by biomethane and other clean molecules.

8:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I have another question I want to ask you about this green premium. But first, I actually want to ask you a much more basic chemistry question, which is if biomethane is identical to methane, why does it, you know, burning it's going to have the same result? Why does it get credit for being a cleaner fuel? Why does it get credit for not producing carbon output? such that it can generate these um certificates on the carbon markets?

8:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah. So basically the price of biomethane is actually composed of two components. So first is the underlying natural gas value. So as you said, because it it's basically being used to replace natural gas, the minimum value that it contains Contends is pretty much just the natural gas value. But on top of that, because if you use that to replace fossil gas, you can basically generate a certificate for those compliance market, which you can sell to other people and get additional revenue. So that basically generates this sort of compliance value for this kind of green molecule. And the compliance value is actually basically, let's say, for every megawatt hour of biomethan that you use to replace fossil fuel, that basically get to generate a certificate that's closely linked to the carbon emission reduction of the biomethane. So for example, if the biomethan can save um 70 grams of CO2 per megajel, then basically can generate a carbon reduction certificate that's worth that 70 gram of

9:31CO2 in those markets, and that basically creates create additional revenue for the biomethans. So that's why buyers of this molecule. are willing to pay a premium over the underlying natural gas value of this molecule.

9:44Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): That's so interesting. And is the idea of the carbonate saving, is it that this biomass you you mentioned earlier on the various things that can go into making biomethane, right? The manure, the food waste, all these things. Is the idea that if you simply left those to break down on their own, they would generate a bunch of carbon. But actually, we're taking them and we're turning them. that into a fuel. So that's the carbon saved there.

10:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, exactly. So at the whole concept is about the life cycle emission. So for example, if you burn biomethane versus if you burn natural gas, the combustion emission is pretty much the same because it's it's

10:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): chemically

10:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): the same thing. But

10:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): exactly if

10:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you look at the whole life cycle of the fuel, then if you take into account basically the avoid avoided it emission that you can have by breaking down those molecules rather than letting it s just see and release CO two into the air, the life cycle emission of the fuel can actually be very, very low. So just to give you an example, if you think about um natural gas life cycle emissions on just the production side, size. it's roughly between seventy 70 to ninety 90 gram grams of CO CO2 two per megajarve energy. But for for biomethan it it could be as low as negative 100. So you're basically saving for every megajar of biometh that you use to replace natural gas, you can pretty much save you know up to 200 grams of CO2. So that is quite a lot of carbon saving and that's why for some biometh biomethine and with very, very negative um CI score or carbon intensity score, the compliance value that it can generate in a CO2-based certificate market is very large.

11:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): That's amazing. A negative value. One of my favorite things in my job at BNF is occasionally coming across negative numbers where logically speaking, no negative number should exist, like a negative price for electricity, Tresadine, and in this case, a negative carbon intensity value for something. So yeah, I love the idea that you can have something. that now has a negative carbon intensity because it would have produced this much, but ultimately is producing a hundred grams less or whatever. On the policy front, not all policies are going to create the same incentive for buying biomethane. So which mechanisms have you seen creating the biggest value and why do you think those are having the biggest impact?

12:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah. So for other policies that we've just talked about, um, there are basically four main policies that are driving the compliance value or um the premium for biomethans. So the Renewable Energy Directive, the RET for road transport, for EU maritime for the shipping sector, and then the EU ETS for the industrial sector. And there's another one that is not on the EU level, but it's mostly implemented by uh a uh hand. handful of member states in EU, such as Spain, the Netherlands, or the green gas blending mandate that they implement on domestic gas suppliers to blend a certain amount of green gas in into the gas grid. So those are the four main policies that are driving the demand or compliance value for biomethane today. And among out of this, uh we actually see the RED RET regulation creating the highest compliance value so far. for this molecule, uh, with Germany and and the Netherlands already having a operating or liquid certificate trading market for the RET certificates, and other countries like Spain and Italy um starting a similar market uh in upcoming years. And this is followed by a few EU maritimes. Time. So this is uh another policies that basically could potentially create a high value market. approaching the red three compliance value. So this regulation

13:19basically allows shipowners that use more bio LNG than the target greenhouse gas reduction benchmark to generate surplus certificate and sell that in the pooling market to other ship owners. So basically, if you use more bioLNG in your ships, then you can generate a surplus certificate that you sell. And that also creates compliance value for bio. biomethane. The green gas quotas in building, we think it can actually generate very significant demand given the large existing gas use in the building and industrial sectors in those countries. But the per unit compliance value would not be as high as the previous two policies that I just mentioned. And in terms of the EU ETS, which is the last one, we don't think the carbon price over the next five years would be high enough for biomethane to generate a substantial compliance value. Especially because of the fact that a lot of the sectors like steel and cement they're still receiving a lot of free allowances, so they're not really paying the full carbon price that they should be paying.

14:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): The climate pledge, co-founded by Amazon and Global Optimism, is a commitment to reach net zero carbon emissions by 2040. Seven years after

14:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the city of the US

14:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): its launch, the climate pledge has grown to a community of more than 700 signatories across 62 industries and 49 countries and territories. Signatories are transforming operations, investing in decarbonization, accelerating progress toward net zero carbon, and working together to overcome shared barriers across their operations and value chains. The potential impact of that collaborative action. is significant. Once climate pledge signatories reach net zero carbon, we estimate that 2.6 billion metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent emissions will be avoided annually. That equates to removing all gasoline-powered vehicles in the U.S. for nearly three years. Discover more about the collective impact in the 2026 Climate Pledge Report at Amazon.com/slash sustainability.

15:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): The ornaments are on the tree.

15:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Christmas

15:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): tree.

15:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Cookies are in the oven. And friends and family are on the way. It's the most wonderful time. Find the music that brings it all together on iR Radio. Explore the iH Radio Christmas collection. Festive radio stations, holiday playlists, seasonal podcasts like Behind the Christmas hits, and more. Wrapped and ready. Press play on the holidays on the free iHeartRadio app. And at iHearRadio.ca.

15:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

15:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): what's so interesting to me about this whole notion of biomethane is we've already talked about how you have two chemically identical molecules, but depending on where they come from, they have really different values. But now this list of policies you've given me implies that, again, when you take chemically identical, even biomethane molecules, right? They're all CH4, but depending on now where they're going, not just where they come from, they can have radically different values as well. So we're seeing this complete differentiation of this one little molecule. Let's start with road transport, which you mentioned has the highest market value. Why?

16:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah. So basically it's it's all linked to sort of how much the certificate are trading at in those markets. So if you look at the Red Three Road Transport certificate market in the Germany and the Niderland today, the certificate price are traded at above 400 euro per metro ton of CO2 over the last year. So if you compare that to, for example, the EU ETS, which is now roughly between 70-80 80 euro per metro ton CO2, that is basically like a four or five times difference in terms of price per ton of CO2. So that actually is a very, very high price that could actually incentivize the use of low carbon molecule like biomethane. And if we convert that 400 euro per ton of CO2 into how much premiums that you can sell biometh at or the compliance value of biomethane, it translates into around over 300 euro per mega megawatt hour of compliance. value for the biomethan that deliver the deepest the deepest CI reductions such as manual base, as we talk about the ones that have negative 100 gram of CO2 per megajel. And then even for the biometh that have slightly higher carbon intensity, such as the waste-based biomethan, the compliance value is still very high, so is above 100 uh euro per megawatt hours. So those very, very high compliance valued is

17:39basically driving the whole demand for biomethane in those sectors. At the end of the day, uh if you think about what is actually determining the certificate price of the RET three in the road transport market, it really depends on the marginal abatement cost curve of different decarbonization options.

17:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Very quickly, what is the marginal abatement cost curve?

18:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, that's a good question. So it's basically if you think about different decarbonization, for example, EVs or, you know, hydrogens or clean molecules or clean fuels. If you calculate, for example, the dollar per ton of CO2 abatement costs. So you basically calculate if you reduce one ton of CO2, how much more you have to pay by using this technology. So that's the abatement cost. So it's a cost of abating one ton of CO2.

18:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Got it. So if it costs less to produce the biomethane than you will get on the compliance market for using it or buying and using it, then that technology will be picked up and otherwise, no. That makes so much sense. When you talk about these certificate prices, I assume we're talking about essentially a free market, right? It's not like the government is saying, oh, this particular certificate is worth so much. It is these are a simply traded, which shows you how much people value them as. So if road transport then offers such a high compliance value, theoretically speaking, you could just sell tons and tons of biomethane to road transport and everybody would make out like bandits. But obviously that's not the way the world works, right? So what actually limits how big that market can become?

19:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, so that's a very good question. So basically, there are, if you think about how much biomethane. you can use in the road transport, there are two factors, right? So one is basically how much you can use in existing vehicles that can actually run on natural gas. So those would be the existing fleet that could replace fossil gas with biomethane. And then the second one is basically the future growth of the whole fleet that can run on natural gas. So whether we will have more trucks or more cars that could potentially run on a natural gas in the future. So for the first one, we've already discussed that biomethan is a very attractive option right now because it has a pretty low abatement cost compared to other options such as green hydrogen or the hydrated vegetable oil or all the other uh drop-in clean fuels. Biomethan is actually the ones that have the lowest abatement costs. So it basically gets deployed first, and that's what is driving the deployment. of biomethane in the road transport. In fact, actually, we have already seen a pretty high penetration of biometh already in several several European markets that have the Red Free uh regulations, such as in Sweden and Finland, the penetration of biomethane in the total road transport gas use is over 90%. And it's roughly 80% in in Germany and 60% in the Netherlands already. So this basically means. that, you know, biometh is already very widely used

20:30in those road transport markets and the future growth potential is limited. And if you think about the potential growth of the fleet that could run on natural gas in the road transport sector, um there's a couple of regulations on the European level that actually would limit that total addressable market size. For example, there is a EU TELPI telepi emission regulation that's already effective. today. Basically, that regulation is saying that, like, okay, if we want a certain percentage of uh new vehicle cells by 2030 and 2035 to be uh zero emissions on the Telpi, and that means pretty much just electric vehicles. Because if you think about natural gas vehicles or internal combustion vehicles that burn biofuels or e-fuels, if you think about just the telpipe tailpipe emission as we're discussing. we discussed earlier, biofuel, E-fuels, and fossil fuels are the same on the tailpipe level. So if you only regulate on the tailpipe, that means all the carbon reduction benefits that biofuels and e-fuels could have on the life cycle level are not taken into account under those regulations. So that would pretty much limit the potential for new uh vehicles that could actually run on natural gas and fossil fuels to be sold in the European market in the upcoming years. So that pretty much put like a ceiling on the amount of biomethane that could be used in road transport if the total fleet that could run on

21:49natural gas is not growing or stagnating in in the upcoming years.

21:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And that actually gets back to my earlier question of you know burning a molecule of methane is burning a molecule of methane, whether it's bio or not. So yeah, if you're just looking at the tailpipe emissions, it wouldn't make a difference. Um, I want to take these two factors you mentioned. So, first, the share of vehicles that run on natural gas. As an American, we refer to petrol as gas. So there's always this sort of hilarious moment of confusion in the US when you start talking about gas vehicles, because most cars are gas vehicles where I come from. But no, actually, the share of vehicles that run on natural gas is pretty small. So, one, the share of natural gas vehicles. And then two, the policies that make these vehicles eligible to run on biogas or biomethane or bioLNG. Let's talk about those in the context of shipping. Are there a lot of ships that already run on methane and are there policies in place that would encourage them to use biomethane or not?

22:44Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): So basically the only policy right now globally that actually regulate on the shipping sector is the few EU maritime as we all know, the um, you know, the International Maritime Organization or the IMO uh discussions uh has been stalling. Uh there's not much hope to actually set like a global framework for shipping decarbonization. So currently the few EU maritime is pretty much the only policy in place that sets a mandatory carbon emission reduction target for the shipping sector. And the scope of this um regulation is quite interesting. So it's not just about the EU, but also for all ships that are going to or from the EU port. For example, if the ship goes from Shanghai or Singapore to Rotterdam, half of the emission of that voyage also falls under the few EU maritime regulations. So even though it's not like a global framework for decarbonization of the shipping sector, but it basically covers cover roughly 20 to 30% of the global. fuel use if you think about it from that context. So it's actually quite a significant policies for shipping sector decarbonization. So under the EU maritime, actually, there are two mechanisms or ways to comply with the GHG reduction target. So one is basically that it has a penalty system for all ships that fail to meet that carbon intensity target. So that basically means. that if you don't

24:03comply with the certain carbon intensity target over time, you have to pay a penalty. So that forced a lot of ships to blend a certain amount of clean fuels, including biometh, to meet that target. And according to our analysis, if you think about all those different fuels that ships can burn, we think that LNG would remain sufficient for most LNG fuel. fueled vessels to meet that target by 2030. So basically, if you think about all the ships that could run on LNG, it doesn't have a much incentive to shift to bio LNG by 2030 because they can just keep burning LNG and and to meet that target. However, after 2030, because a significant share of those LNG vessels have pretty high methane methan sleep. So that basically means when they burn the fuel. they have some methan leakage to the atmosphere. And that that is also counted as part of the greenhouse gas uh emission. So that would basically drive up the life cycle emissions of those LNG vessels. And those LNG vessels with high methane sleep engines would actually struggle to meet the tighter emission target by 2035. And this would be a main reason why we think that by 2035, a significant amount of those LNG vessels would have to blend a certain amount of bio LNG, uh, you know,

25:22roughly 7 to 10% by 2030 to comply with the carbon intensity target to avoid the penalty. And this is the first mechanism that could drive demand of bioLNG bioenergy in the shipping sector. The second mechanism is more organic. So in addition to the penalty, there is also a surplus trading market, as I just mentioned earlier. That, like if, for example, if you achieve a lower carbon intensity than the target of a specific year, you can generate a surplus credit denominated in euro per ton of CO2. So you can sell that surplus Plus credit to other shipowners. So for example, if you're using a lot of bioenergy in your whole vessels that achieve a lower carbon intensity than the current target, that you can sell that surplus to generate additional revenue. And this is actually the main mechanism that are driving bioenergy adoption today. Because it's even though it's not necessary to use bioenergy to meet the target, a lot of people choose to do so because the credit price is pretty high and that incentivizes incentivized people to kind of basically overachieve compared to the target today.

26:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Canadian women are looking for more, more out of themselves, their businesses, their elected leaders, and the world around them. And that's why we're thrilled to introduce the Honest Talk Podcast. I'm Jennifer Stewart. And I'm Catherine Clark. And in this podcast, we interview Canada's most inspiring women, entrepreneurs, artists, athletes, politicians, and newsmakers, all at different stages of their journey. So if you're looking to connect then we hope you'll join us. Listen to the Honest Talk Podcasts on iArtRadio or wherever you listen to your podcasts.

26:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So if these compliance certificates require what sounds like actually quite a lot of fairly complicated calculation to figure out the value and to push biomethane uptake, I think quotas are probably a relatively blunt instrument where a government just says, Well, you you have to use this much. But you've argued in your report that. quotas are super, super important for uptake of biomethane in building heat. And you actually said that that could be the single largest source of demand in terms of volume. So talk to me about the role that green gas quotas are playing in the building sector.

27:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): For the building sector, actually, if you don't really put any quota, there wouldn't be any demand because currently the building sector is actually not part of the EU emission trading system as you might know. It only currently only covers power generation and industrial. So basically, if you want the building sector to decarbonize, you need to basically put in some sort of quota for the gas supplies to blend in either green gas or adopt any other options to decarbonize the building sector. So currently several European countries have implemented or proposed such a green gas blending quotas, quota domestic. domestically. And the biggest one of them is actually France. So France is pretty much the best example, and the only countries so far in Europe that has legislated such a green gas blending quota. It began implementing such a quota starting from this year and has actually extended the whole kind of quota framework all the way from now to 2044. And this actually gives investors investor a very sort of a long term. long-term kind of policy uncertainty to invest uh more in the biomethan sector because they have the long-term certainty on the demand or revenue. Netherland is another example that it's already progressing on a similar gas blending quota and the quota has passed the lower house and is now waiting upper house for approval. A lot of people expect that it could be passed pretty soon.

28:48Spain as well also proposed such a quota. And the quota in Spain actually have a bigger scope than the ones in the Netherlands and France. And it is designed to cover not just the building sector, but also the industrial gas use. So that pretty much gives a broad kind of basis for the green gas quota to be applied on. Germany, which is currently the biggest gas user in Europe, is also considering a similar quota. And the quota actually not just covers biomethane, but also green hydrogen. So basically, it's setting a certain percentage target to blend biomethane and green hydrogen into the gas grid. And some preliminary discussion actually suggests a very ambitious quota as high as 5% by twenty 2030 thirty and 20% twenty percent by 2035. twenty thirty-five. So that is a very large volume of experience. existing gas use in Germany that you have to replace with biogas and and and hydrogen. Although in Germany it's a still pretty early stage, so the industry's still expecting the first government draft to come out later this year. And this quota, as you mentioned, can actually we think if all of them get implemented to actually drive the largest share of projected biomethane bounds and demands demand in Europe. But yeah, the outlook would really depend on. whether some of those early stage or proposed mandates would actually end up

30:07being adopted.

30:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So something you've mentioned a lot in this last answer is phrases like early stage drafts of policies, waiting to see if things are going to get implemented. So as we move forward, we adjust our outlooks all the time, right? Numbers move up a little bit, numbers move down. But what are you looking for to see that would actually really profoundly change the outlook for biofuels? Are there any policies, anything outstanding that you think are the big uncertainties right now in the European biomethane market?

30:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Um so we I think we have discussed quite a few things that could act actually change around and and still have a lot of uncertainties. For example, the the gas blending quotas in in the building sector that a lot of them are still in the early draft stage. and also the um used vehicle telepi emission standards and right now there's a lot of industry lobby groups trying to lobby against dysregulations and they're currently also reviewing um or maybe including some new rules into this regulation. So that might potentially change the outlook for natural gas vehicle growth in Europe. But I think the biggest uncertainties is actually the review that the European Commission is doing right now on the life cycle greenhouse gas calculation methodology. As we talked about in the beginning, the compliance value of biomethans replacing natural gas really depends on the life cycle emissions calculation of biomethane, that it could actually get a very deep negative carbon intensity score. And this is actually this route ruse right now is actually being reviewed because a lot of people, you know, have the same reaction that you have. had at b in the beginning. Like, how come something could have negative a hundred grams of CO two uh per megajar of CI value? So right now the commission's reviewing those um methodologies and those could actually dramatically change the default emission value for a lot of them, the biomethan

31:55project. For example, the ones that used to get negative a 100s hundreds might end up getting just negative five or something like that in the upcoming um proposal. Um so that would threaten the economics of biomethane in a lot of compliance markets if it actually ends up getting assigned a much higher life cycle emission uh values. And then the other um regulations that the commission is reviewing right now is the liquefaction by equivalence. So basically right now a lot of the biomethan biomethane projects actually injecting the biomethan into the greed. grid. And then the ship owners, for example, whoever that want to bunker that biomethant uh would basically uh draw those gas out from the grid and liquefy them. And then those basically uh environmental certi certificate of biomethan could basically pass through the grid and through the liquefaction system to the end users, which are the ship owners. So that is called basically liquefaction by equivalence. But now they're also reviewing this methodology to see if it makes sense for this to exist. And also, if, for example, if you inject into a grid and draw it out somewhere and liquefy it somewhere else, whether they should assign a higher emission value based on the total gas that are blended into the whole system. So that could also increase the lifecycle Cycle emission value of bioLNG, for example. So a lot of people are lobbying against this potential change. to

33:15this kind of rules around the calculation of life cycle emission and liquefaction emissions could potentially change biomethane's economics and as a result reduce its compliance value in markets such as road transport and shipping. So I would say those are the biggest uncertainties in terms of policies. And ultimately, there is still an open question questions around you know, how EU actually managed to scale up biomethane. biobeth and supply, uh, which I didn't actually cover much in this report yet. But ultimately, if we're forecasting around two times growth in in the market by 2035, we don't really know whether there will be enough supply out there to be able to support this market. And whether there will be enough supply will ultimately determine how much of the compliance value producers would be able to end up capturing. So if for example, supply becomes very tight, then buyers may be willing to pass some more compliance value to the suppliers, and that would drive up the overall price of this molecule in the future.

34:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Kathy, this is so interesting. This topic has so many facets. There's the chemical aspect of it, there's the economic aspect, there's the policy aspect of it. And as you mentioned, there's still so much to talk about and think about. So the issue of scaling up and supply. And I hope when you start doing that. work, we can talk to you again. So thank you so much for coming on and talking today.

34:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, it was great talking to you, Kamala.

34:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Today's episode of Switched On was produced by Cam Gray with production assistance from Kamala Shelling. Bloomberg NAF is a service provided by Bloomberg Finance L. LP and its affiliates. This recording does not constitute nor should it be construed as investment advice, investment recommendations, or a recommendation as to an investment or other strategy. Bloomberg NEF should not be considered as information sufficient upon which to base an investment decision. Neither Bloomberg Finance LP nor any of its affiliates makes any representation or warranty as to the accuracy or completeness of the information contained in this recording and any library. liability as a result of this recording is expressly disclaimed.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights