Speakers rank five common mortgage mistakes costing New Zealand investors over $139,000 in lost value or interest.
Summary
Steve McKnight and Andrew Nickel identify five mortgage mistakes that can cost New Zealand investors significantly. Mistake one is bank loyalty, where staying with one lender misses out on cashbacks despite switching costs. Mistake two is accepting a 30-year term without accelerating repayment, which incurs high interest costs. Mistake three involves fixing the entire loan at one rate, ignoring diversification benefits. Mistake four is concentration risk by holding all mortgages with a single bank. Mistake five is mismanaging green or EV loans by paying only minimums during promotional periods.
Key takeaways
- 1 cashback of between four and $5,000. And now there is a cost to moving banks. And generally speaking, that could be, you know, $1,400 to switch banks, just move from one to the other. So you still end up being kind of two and a half to three and a half thousand dollars per. better off.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 0:59
- 2 Cashback clawbacks typically apply if the borrower refinances away from the new bank within three years, making frequent annual switching unviable.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 2:28
- 3 Aggressively paying down debt (e.g., P&I on investment loans) can create opportunity costs by preventing new investments, as seen in a case where a client deferred investing to reduce debt.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 6:35
Episode sections
- 0:08 – 4:52
Introduction and Mistake 1: Bank Loyalty
Steve McKnight and Andrew Nickel introduce the topic of five mortgage mistakes costing investors over $139,000. Mistake number one is staying loyal to one bank, as switching can yield cashbacks of 0.8-1% of the loan amount, though this involves discharge fees and potential clawbacks if refinanced within three years.
- 4:52 – 7:07
Mistake 2: 30-Year Loan Terms and Opportunity Cost
Mistake number two is taking the full 30 years to pay off a 30-year loan. The speakers note that paying an extra $100/week on a $500k loan at 5% saves ~$140k in interest and shortens the term by 8 years. However, they caution that aggressive debt repayment can hinder investment capacity, citing a client who avoided investing due to high P&I repayments.
- 7:07 – 9:09
Mistake 3: Single Interest Rate Term
Mistake number three is fixing the entire mortgage on one term without considering rate fluctuations. The speakers suggest splitting loans into chunks (e.g., 1-year and 5-year fixes) to manage risk, though they note that extreme laddering (e.g., 7 chunks) creates excessive administrative burden.
- 9:09 – 12:24
Mistake 4: Single Bank Concentration Risk
Mistake number four is holding all mortgages with one bank. The speakers describe a scenario where selling one property triggers a credit assessment by the bank holding the other mortgage, potentially forcing the borrower to use sale proceeds to pay down debt on the retained property due to LVR restrictions or income changes.
- 12:24 – 14:43
Mistake 5: Misusing Green/EV Loans
Mistake number five is misusing low-rate green or EV loans (e.g., 1% for 3 years) by paying only minimums. The speakers warn that the rate resets to a higher level (e.g., 6%) after the promotional period, and borrowers should aim to pay off the loan within the asset's useful life (5-10 years) rather than the full loan term.
Claims worth verifying
Switching banks yields cashbacks of 0.8-1% of the loan amount, with a typical cost of ~$1,400 to switch, resulting in a net benefit of $2,500-$3,500.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·0:39
How to verify: Check current mortgage lender promotional terms for cashback percentages and discharge fees; calculate net benefit based on loan size. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Cashbacks are subject to clawbacks if the borrower refinances within three years.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·2:28
How to verify: Review the Terms and Conditions of major NZ lender mortgage cashback offers (e.g., BNZ, ASB, ANZ, Westpac) for clawback clauses. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A $500,000 mortgage at 5% interest over 30 years incurs $466,000 in total interest.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·4:52
How to verify: Use a standard mortgage calculator with inputs: Principal $500k, Rate 5%, Term 30 years, Payment Type Principal & Interest. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Paying an extra $100/week on a $500k mortgage at 5% saves ~$140,000 in interest and shortens the term by 8 years.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·5:12
How to verify: Use a mortgage calculator comparing a $500k loan at 5% for 30 years vs. the same loan with an additional $100/week payment. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
ANZ offers a renovation loan at approximately 2.5% interest.
Steve McKnight ·12:44
How to verify: Check ANZ New Zealand's current mortgage product pages for renovation loan interest rates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify current cashback offers and clawback terms from major NZ banks (ANZ, ASB, BNZ, Kiwibank) via their official websites or comparison sites like Mortgage Plus.
- Check discharge fees and portability policies for existing mortgages by reviewing loan contracts or contacting lenders directly.
- Calculate the net present value of paying down debt versus investing in other assets using current interest rates and expected investment returns.
- Review LVR (Loan-to-Value Ratio) requirements for new lenders to assess if property value drops would block refinancing.
- Assess personal income stability and 'bankability' criteria for new lenders compared to existing lender flexibility during income shocks.
- Compare the total cost of fixed-rate loans versus variable-rate loans over different time horizons using bank calculators.
- Investigate specific terms of 'green' or 'EV' loans, including post-promotional interest rates and repayment schedules, from lender disclosures.
Full transcriptexpand
0:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hello
0:08Steve McKnight: and welcome along to the Property Academy podcast by Opus Partners. I'm your host, Steve McKnight. And I'm Andrew
0:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Nickel.
0:13Steve McKnight: And this is the show that Alps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties so you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're gonna learn the five mortgage mistakes that cost investors $139,000 or more. how to avoid all of them, and the simple strategies to flip each mistake into a saving. Now, I'm not really talking about anything flashy here today, but Andrew, what is mistake number one?
0:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Staying loyal to your bank. And the reason for this is because every time you switch banks, yes, it's a bit of a pain in the butt, but the new bank is generally willing to pay you some money for that inconvenience. And normally a cashback is kind of somewhere between 0.8 to 1% of the loan. So $500,000 mortgage works out to be a cashback of between four and $5,000. And now there is a cost to moving banks. And generally speaking, that could be, you know, $1,400 to switch banks, just move from one to the other. So you still end up being kind of two and a half to three and a half thousand dollars per. better off.
1:16Steve McKnight: And if you just think about where those costs come from, that's because you've got to go and talk to your lawyer to deregister a mortgage, register a new mortgage. There can be discharge fees, there might be lens fees, because you've got to take ASB off as the mortgage or and then you've got to put BNZ on.
1:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): But you know, if you get that two and a half, three and a half thousand dollars, you might think, okay, well, you
1:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
1:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): it's it's a bit of money, but it's not a huge amount of money for the inconvenience. But if you think about it in terms of what you've got to do to earn that money, your salary earner of eighty K a year, that works out to be forty dollars an hour. So your cashback is about a week and a half of work. So
1:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): before
1:56Steve McKnight: tax.
1:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah. So if you think about like the inconvenience, yep, it might be, but not a week and a half worth of work. I
2:03Steve McKnight: think a lot of people though, I know you said that two and a half to three and a half K isn't a lot of money. I think most people would say actually that is quite a lot of money after your costs. Like there's a lot that I'd do for two and a half K to three and a half K, Andrew. And um Oh
2:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
2:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): know.
2:17Steve McKnight: And doing a bit of paperwork and talking to a mortgage advisor, I mean, there are worse things that I would do for two and a half to three and a half grand in my account. Now there are some catches to this though, yeah?
2:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yes. And the main one is clawbacks. So if you refinance your mortgage away from that bank, normally within three years, you'll have to pay back some or even all of that money. So you can't just move your mortgage year to year and expect to be able to keep that money. And I think the best thing you can do here is use a mortgage advisor to handle the paperwork because if you want to make this as hands hands-off off as possible for you, take a bit of pain out of the process, a mortgage broker will take care of the bulk of the work.
2:54Steve McKnight: I suppose the other thing to point out though is you have to be bankable at the other lender, right? And what I mean by that is let's say that three years ago you refinanced to BNZ, and then unfortunately, over the last six months you've lost your job and you're currently hunting around for work. And you think, do you know what? That two and a half to three and a half. K, that would really help me out right now. But when you go and apply to whatever new bank you're going to go to, you're going to need to put in a full mortgage application. Now, unfortunately, if you've just lost your job and you don't have an income, it's unlikely that that new bank is going to say, Yep, I'm going to sign you off. We're going to lend you the money. Here's your cash back. Like you still need to get that mortgage approved by the new bank. Whereas let's say you're with, I can't remember which bank I said, I think it might have been BNZ. Let's say you're with BNZ and you lose your job, they're not going to say, right, yo, you've got to reapply for your mortgage right now. Oh, you don't have any money, we're taking your mortgage away. You're already with them, so you don't need to reapply for the mortgage they've already approved. So there are just a few little things to look out for. The other one would be value drops as well. Just uh talk to us about. that. Yeah,
4:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): so I've seen this a bit over the last wee while someone might have bought a property at the peak of the market, the values have come down, they're still paying their mortgage. They go to refinance it, but all of a sudden they don't meet the L VR criteria. And so whilst their bank might still maintain that mortgage because they're diligently making their payments, a new bank isn't going to take on that mortgage without appropriate security levels.
4:24Steve McKnight: Because of the L VR exemptions around poor portability, and I know that's a bit bit nerdy, but you mortgage advisors out there know all about this, you'd likely be able to move your mortgage, but they wouldn't pay you cash back if your L VR's too high.
4:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, yeah, I mean theoretically, but I don't know. Like if you if you were at a hundred percent L VR now because the value drops, I don't think a new bank's gonna take that on. Even though they can, technically. Well,
4:48Steve McKnight: we've still got four mortgage mistakes to go through. What's number two? on your list?
4:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Number two is taking 30 years to pay off that 30 year loan. Now, if you take out a mortgage at the start and it's 500,000 and you're paying 5% interest rate over the next 30 years, the total interest bill will be $466,000. It's huge, right? You're paying back your mortgage and then again. Now, if on the other hand you pay an extra $100 hundred dollars a week off that mortgage, the repayment term works out to be eight years shorter. And the interest savings on that is about a hundred and forty thousand dollars. And I think what people forget when they're first taking out a mortgage is that your payment today will feel cheaper in the future. And as your income goes up, it's really important that you always adjust that repayment to ensure that that mortgage is paid off as quickly as possible.
5:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
5:37Steve McKnight: let me get this straight. So you're saying that if I take out a half a million dollar loan and I pay an extra a hundred bucks a week, I'm going to be mortgage free in 22 years as opposed to 30 years and going to save about 140 grand worth of interest. Like it's such a large amount of money that like at the start, when you first say take out that mortgage, it's often difficult to find that extra 100 hundred bucks a week. But if you can eventually get it, man, it makes a big difference. Now that actually doesn't mean, especially if we're talking to investors, that doesn't mean that paying off your debt really fast is always the best thing.
6:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
6:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): let me tell you a uh situation that one of our financial advisors was discussing with one of their clients. So their the clients are fifty-three, and so they're really wanting to make sure. they have as little debt as possible when they get to retirement. Now, because they've already paid off their personal mortgage, they thought, okay, if we take out this investment property loan, we want to pay principal and interest, not just the interest. Whilst that's great that they're going to diligently pay down the mortgage, and it sounds good in theory, the repayments with principal and interest were so high that they were put off by actually. investing. And so as a result, they've just parked that idea altogether. Now, again, for most people, we're taught to pay down debt. And so that feels like the right thing to do. But if it's going to get in the way of you actually getting ahead with something else, then you need to kind of weigh up the pros and the cons.
7:07Steve McKnight: Mistake number three is fixing everything on one term without any thought to it. Because let's say that you fixed your mortgage interest rate at five years for 5.8%, which you could do today. And let's say that interest rates basically hold for two years. They don't really do much. But then in year three, they start dropping and they go down to four and a half percent. Well, that can mean that you don't get the benefit of the drops in interest rates. And even if you try and break your interest rate, you might find that you've got to pay a big whopping break fee as well. And so I do caution investors about fixing everything on one term, especially for very long periods, without considering, well, what happens if interest rates drop? Now, there are a couple of alternatives to this. So you might decide that you're going to split your loan up into two chunks and you might fix one at the one year rate, which tends to be lower, and one part of that at the five year rate. So you're splitting your risk a bit. Some people can take that laddering idea of splitting your loan up into lots of different chunks and fixing them for different rates to extremes. We had one investor that we were working with who wanted to split up their loan. I think it was a five hundred thousand dollar loan and split it into seven different portions. I think he did fifty $50,000 thousand dollars on six months and a bit on twelve 12 months and a bit on 18
8:27months. And all of a sudden you've got you log into your Westpac app and you've got seven different loans in there of various amounts with different interest rates, which I mean, if you're an engineer and you're right into it and you're you're like, this is what I want to do to spread as much of my risk. I mean, all power to you, right? But it's a little bit much for me.
8:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It's a lot of admin. And and to be fair, I'm bad enough remembering to fix my interest rates when they're on a one. one-year fix that loan, having all sorts of different chunks.
8:53Steve McKnight: I mean, to be fair though, some people say, is it really that much admin? Like every six months you've got to go into your app and choose a new interest rate. I mean, it's not that much admin, but it's too much admin for me. What is mistake number four?
9:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Having all your mortgages with one bank, i.e., not split banking. Now, back in the good old days. it was very normal just to have everything with one bank and and they were kind of a lot more flexible if you'd sell a property. But nowadays, with the L VR restrictions, banks are way more conscious about the end position. Now, I recently spoke to an investor who had two rentals with the same bank and they were getting to the crossing the finish line part of their their journey where they were selling down properties so they could live off the profits. And their plan was to sell one of the rental properties, pay off that lending, and keep the balance of the money and use that to fund their lifestyle. But the second property, the one that weren't selling, that had dropped in value. And because both mortgages were with one bank, well, the bank wanted to have some of those sale proceeds to pay off some of the loan on that property they were keeping, which meant they had less money for themselves. Now the result is that they're going to run out of cash sooner and have to sell that second rental property sooner. So they're going to miss out on some future growth there.
10:11Steve McKnight: So in this situation though, it was 60 grand, right? So you've sold property A that you're like, yeah, we got 400 grand worth of equity or something like that. We've got all this equity in this property. We're going gonna to sell that. Quit our jobs, darling, and we're going gonna to live off that 400K maybe we'll bang that in a term deposit or a fund or something like that, but that's what we're gonna live off. And then Mr. Banker comes along and says, Well, actually, nah, you're not gonna keep that 400K. I'm gonna take 60 grand of that and I'm gonna force you to pay off the debt on property B. And so then you go, oh, darling, we're still doing pretty good. We've got $340,000 that we can live off, but it's not the $400K that we thought we were gonna have. And if we want to get that 60 grand back, we've got to go sell property B. And so that might be a bit sooner. And so there is a way to avoid that, right?
10:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, if you had those two loans at two different banks, when you sell the property A, this bank with say B and Z, Westpac, who's got your other mortgage, even if that value's dropped, they don't get a say on what you do with the money from property A.
11:13Steve McKnight: And that's pretty obvious why, right? Because if you've got property A at Westpac and you've got property B at B and Z, you sell property A, you've got the money hitting your Westpac account, and two things happen. First of all, B and Z can't then look at you and say, Hey, give us that sixty grand because your money's over in Westpac. But the most important thing is what's called a credit assessment. So if you had both properties at the same bank and you sell one of them, that can trigger a credit assessment where the bank goes and says, Well, can you afford all of this lending? Can you still all afford all of this lending that we've got with you? And if you've just quit your job, so you can spend your 400k in this example, oh, you might not have any income to still be able to afford that other mortgage, which is why they might take your 60 grand and force you to pay off debt. I mean, it's all good stuff in terms of like paying off debt and stuff, but in this case, what do you want? to do with your money? In this situation, it was keep as much as possible so that we can live a wonderful life.
12:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And I think the hard thing is people often don't know that this is going to affect them until they've actually gone and sold the property. And then of course it's too late at that stage because the bank says hey I want all this cash, but you're committed to selling the property. You can't just go and refinance now. It's too late.
12:24Steve McKnight: Now mistake number five is misuse misusing a like EV loan or a cheap green loan. You know how sometimes you can borrow like 50 grand from some of the banks at around 1% for three years? Well, if you do that and you only pay the minimum for those three years, you can borrow 50 grand and it only costs you about $22 a week. It's is very, very cheap. But what you've got to remember is at the end of those three years, like ANZ's got a reno loan at the moment. I think they're about to get rid of that, it's about 2.5%. Well, at the end of those three years, it then goes back up to whatever the current interest rate was. And let's say that your interest rate went up at the end of that to 6% for the remaining couple of decades. Well, that means with 27 years left to pay off that loan, all of a sudden you're a your repayment jumps from 22 bucks a week to 39 bucks a week. Now, to be fair, that's not a massive jump. But what you've got to remember, you're probably not going to own that electric vehicle for all 30 years. And so my view has always been if you've bought this electric vehicle and you are going to keep it for five to 10 ten years, well, you should probably pay off that loan in five to 10 ten years, not the full thirty. And
13:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): it kinda reminds me of like when you go in and you you get something from Smith City and you put it on higher purchase and they give you a year interest free. So many people think, Oh, that's good, I'll pay that off in that year. Now I remember my parents used to always do this. I don't think they ever paid more than the minimum payment and they ended up paying the interest rate that was much higher than the zero 0%. percent. But of course it felt cheap at the time. And in
14:02Steve McKnight: the past 15 minutes, you've learned the five mortgage mistakes that can cost investors 139 grand or more, how to avoid them, and the simple strategies to flip each mistake into a saving. Right? Let's wrap it up there. But please don't forget to rate review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
14:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thanks
14:25Steve McKnight: for listening to the Proppy Property Academy podcast. I'm your host, Step McKnight. And
14:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I'm Andrew Nickel.
14:29Steve McKnight: We're gonna be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics, and insights to help you get the most out of the New Zealand property market. Until next time.