Step McKnight and Andrew Nicole outline a step-by-step process for New Zealand investors to resolve builder defects and enforce warranties.
Summary
Step McKnight and Andrew Nicole discuss strategies for investors dealing with builders who become unresponsive during construction or post-completion. They emphasize the importance of verifying legal standing through warranties like Stamford, Halo, or Master Build before taking action. The hosts advise documenting defects in writing with photos and setting strict deadlines, utilizing templates from Consumer NZ. They highlight the New Zealand Disputes Tribunal as a cost-effective venue for claims up to $60,000, noting the limit was doubled in early 2026. The episode concludes that lawyers are often unnecessary for smaller disputes, which can be resolved through direct negotiation or tribunal proceedings.
Key takeaways
- 1 Document all defects in writing with photos and set a 14-21 day deadline for resolution, using Consumer NZ email templates for legally referenced communication.
Step McKnight · 5:47
Episode sections
- 0:08 – 1:46
Introduction and Case Study
Step McKnight introduces the topic of dealing with silent builders, presenting a case study of an investor with a new build experiencing kitchen floor lifting and electrical issues, where the developer has been silent for four months.
- 1:46 – 4:27
Challenges of Enforcement and Personal Anecdote
Andrew Nicole explains the difficulty of enforcing warranties when vendors ignore calls, sharing a personal story of a builder who disappeared due to meth addiction, leaving subcontractors unpaid and the job unfinished.
- 4:27 – 5:27
Step Zero: Verify Legal Standing and Warranty
Step McKnight outlines 'Step Zero': confirming legal standing via warranties like Stamford, Halo, or Master Build, noting the specific case involves a two-year defect period under a Stamford warranty.
- 5:27 – 6:38
Step One: Document Defects in Writing
Step One is to put defects in writing with photos and a 14-21 day deadline, recommending Consumer NZ email templates that reference relevant legislation for crucial written evidence.
- 6:38 – 8:39
Step Two: Obtain Evidence and Quotes
Step Two involves getting independent quotes and potentially a builder's report to substantiate the claim value for the Disputes Tribunal, with Nicole warning against inflating quotes to include upgrades.
- 8:39 – 11:11
Step Three: Notify Warranty Company and Risks of Self-Repair
Step Three is sending the paper trail to the warranty company, discussing the risk of fixing problems yourself and sending the bill if the responsible party is insolvent.
- 11:11 – 14:10
Disputes Tribunal and Arbitration Alternatives
McKnight highlights the Disputes Tribunal as a cost-effective option with a claim limit of $60,000, doubled in early 2026, while Nicole compares this to building arbitration for larger disputes.
- 14:10 – 15:30
Conclusion and Lawyer Usage
The hosts conclude that lawyers are expensive and often unnecessary for smaller disputes, encouraging listeners to use underutilized tools like the Disputes Tribunal to force fixes within six weeks.
Claims worth verifying
The investor's property is less than two years old and bought directly from the developer.
Step McKnight ·0:33
How to verify: Check the property settlement date and title records via Land Information New Zealand (LINZ) or the original sale contract. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The developer has been silent for over four months but is still trading and building houses.
Step McKnight ·1:13
How to verify: Search Companies Office New Zealand for the developer's registration status and check their website/social media for active listings or recent construction projects. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
New builds in New Zealand typically have a 12-month defect period and a 10-year warranty period.
Andrew Nicole ·2:06
How to verify: Review the Building (Construction Products and Materials) Regulations 2026 and standard NZ building warranty guidelines from MBIE (Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment). For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The specific case involves a Stamford warranty with a two-year defect period.
Step McKnight ·4:47
How to verify: Obtain the specific warranty document provided at settlement for the property in question, issued by Stamford (now part of QBE Insurance). For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Consumer NZ offers free email templates for addressing poor workmanship, overcharging, and delays.
Step McKnight ·5:47
How to verify: Visit the Consumer NZ website (consumernz.org.nz) and search for 'building disputes' or 'templates' to verify the availability of these resources. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Disputes Tribunal claim limit was doubled to $60,000 in early 2026.
Step McKnight ·11:11
How to verify: Check the Disputes Tribunal Act 2026 and any subsequent amendments or government press releases from early 2026 confirming the limit increase. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Andrew Nicole had a dispute with a builder over $100,000 that went to building arbitration.
Andrew Nicole ·13:05
How to verify: This is a personal anecdote; verification would require Andrew Nicole's public disclosure or legal records if the case was public, but primarily serves as a testimonial claim. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Disputes Tribunal tends to favor consumers in builder disputes.
Andrew Nicole ·12:55
How to verify: Review published Disputes Tribunal decisions on the Ministry of Justice website or academic studies on NZ consumer dispute outcomes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the specific warranty provider (Stamford, Halo, Master Build) and its coverage period for the property in question.
- Check the current monetary limit of the New Zealand Disputes Tribunal for residential disputes.
- Review Consumer NZ's official email templates for defects and poor workmanship to ensure legal references are accurate.
- Assess the builder's solvency and insurance status before pursuing self-repair and claiming costs.
- Compare the costs of building arbitration against traditional court proceedings for claims exceeding tribunal limits.
- Confirm the statute of limitations for warranty claims in New Zealand for the specific defect type.
- Research the specific requirements for submitting evidence to the Disputes Tribunal to avoid procedural rejections.
- Check for any prior disputes or insolvency proceedings against the builder or developer involved.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hello
- 0:08
- Step McKnight: and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opus Partners. I'm your host, Step McKnight. And I'm
- 0:12
- Andrew Nicole: Andrew Nicole.
- 0:13
- Step McKnight: And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties so you can be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're gonna learn what to do when you'll build a Ghost You, the step-by-step process that you can follow, and how to force a fix in just six weeks. So, Andrew, I recently came across a situation where an investor
- 0:33
- Step McKnight: bought a brand new property. It's like less than two years old, and they bought directly from the developer. But now all of a sudden they are starting to see the kitchen floor is just starting to lift off in some places. So that kind of wood veneer that gets put down, that's starting to come up a bit. Their rangehood light, you know how there's
- 0:53
- Step McKnight: usually a light in your rangehood when you're cooking? That's basically dead now. And there are a couple of like electrical problems that they had to get a sparky into fix. And when that electrician came in, Dud said that, oh, some of these materials, they don't really look like they were fit for purpose. Looks like these maybe haven't been installed quite right. And so
- 1:13
- Step McKnight: the developer has gone silent. for over four months. They've not come back to this poor investor. They're still trading by the looks of things. Looks like they're still building houses for other people. But what does somebody do in this situation? Now you get yourself into a fair few disputes. Some of them, actually not all
- 1:32
- Step McKnight: of them, in your own capacity as an investor with with a substantial property portfolio, but often other people's problems. as well. So when someone goes quiet on you, what do you actually do first?
- 1:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 1:46
- Andrew Nicole: so it can be a bit challenging when you've settled a property and this could be a property that you've just bought that's existing or a new build where you've got warranties. If you have an issue and you want to get the vendor, the person that sold the property to be responsible for those, it can be quite a process if they just ignore you. And whilst like with new builds, you've got
- 2:06
- Andrew Nicole: a 12-month defect period and you've got a 10-year warranty period. That's all great on paper. But if they don't return your phone call, well, that becomes quite a challenge.
- 2:17
- Step McKnight: You've got to be able to enforce it, right? Like sometimes we say wording in contracts is only as good as your ability to actually enforce it. Because if you can't make them stick to it, or there's no penalties or provisions for what happens if somebody doesn't stick to a contract, then it's not really worth the
- 2:36
- Step McKnight: paper. It's written on. Not legal advice, but that's what I tend to see in my own portfolio. Has a trade ever ghosted you mid-job or at the end of a job where you're trying to get them to fix something?
- 2:49
- Andrew Nicole: So yes, I actually have had a situation. where I was doing some renovations to Az's properties that were earthquake damaged. And part way through a job, the builder just disappeared. And uh turned out he was cooking meth out of a caravan, and it was a real problem to actually try and uh get that job finished because he'd done
- 3:09
- Andrew Nicole: half of the work, he'd used some subbies, we'd paid him to pay the subies, subbies, and that money hadn't gone. through to them. And so, of course, they wanted to be paid to finish the job, but we'd already paid the money and we weren't prepared to pay it twice.
- 3:23
- Step McKnight: So, what happened in that situation? Because those subbies are probably coming to you saying, Well, look, Mr. Nickel, you need to pay me.
- 3:30
- Andrew Nicole: That was a hard one. So, in that instance, we tried to get the money out of the original builder, he ended up getting arrested. But that wasn't because of us, that was because it was all also stealing money from his parents. He went to jail and the subbies eventually just carried on doing the work and they had just had to bite the bullet.
- 3:46
- Step McKnight: So the difficulty there, right, is if this builder has succumbed to a meth addiction, if he sent all of the money off to the drug dealer, there wouldn't be a paper trail for that either because they'd all be paid in cash. You can't then go to the meth dealer and say, Hey, you need to give us this money back because he'd say, Oh willing buyer, willing seller.
- 4:05
- Andrew Nicole: I think from our perspective, we had the transactions of the money going out. We knew what that was for. And so we weren't prepared to pay twice and we could show that we had made those payments. Our arrangement wasn't w with the subbies. The subbies were employed by him. So as harsh as it sounds, it kind of wasn't our
- 4:25
- Andrew Nicole: problem. We just wanted the job done.
- 4:27
- Step McKnight: Okay. So let's say that you do get into a dispute with a builder or some sort of tradie. Here's the step-by-step process that I'd follow. And I think this counts for all types of building work. This could be if you had an older property and you had a tradie come in doing some renovations. Step zero, I know it usually starts with step one, but
- 4:47
- Step McKnight: step zero, which is like before you get off the ground, you've got to figure out if you actually have a legal leg to stand on. Now, these particular people had what's called a Stamford warranty. Now, Stanford, it's an insurance type product, right? Similar to the Halo Guarantee or the Master Build Guarantee. And these guys reckon
- 5:07
- Step McKnight: there's actually a two year defect period. Now remember, typically in New Zealand, all building work has a one year defect. period where if something goes wrong, the builder's going to come back and fix it. Now, in this case, there was a two year defect period and they were inside that. So it looks like they do have a legal leg to stand on with this builder who's not coming back to
- 5:27
- Step McKnight: them.
- 5:27
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 5:27
- Step McKnight: then I think, okay, now that you've built that foundation, step one is to put it in writing. And what I'm talking about is not just calling them up and saying, hey, you need to come around, but putting in writing photos of those defects and saying, This is what you want to get fixed. And I re I would recommend putting a deadline in there
- 5:47
- Step McKnight: of 14 to 21 days and emailing it off to them and saying, These are the issues. Because until it's in writing, it's just a phone call that they didn't return, Turn right? Whereas once you have it in writing, you can go back and look and see exactly what was sent and consumer NZ, they've got a bunch of free templates,
- 6:07
- Step McKnight: email templates that you can use and that references the relevant legislation depending on what the builder or the subby has done. So if I went to their website right now, there are templates for addressing poor workmanship. There are templates for if the builder charged you a higher amount than their quote. There's a another one for if they charge you higher than an estimate.
- 6:27
- Step McKnight: There's one about delays. Like there's a lot of templates that you can use and maybe have a bit more faith in compared to if you were just talking to AI. But after you've done that, what is step number two?
- 6:38
- Andrew Nicole: Step number two is to get your own evidence. And if you're going to end up going to the disputes tribunal, you need to have some quotes of how you're going to finish the job or fix it. And that's going to be the dollar value for your. claim against whoever it is that you're you're seeking the remedy from. And let's go back to the situation. If there is some poor
- 6:58
- Andrew Nicole: workmanship that you're thinking, okay, I wonder if there's actually more to this than just what I'm saying right now, you might go and get a builder's report and actually check because sometimes things are just faulty. It's not a big deal. We get it fixed. Other times. this could be a sign that there's more underneath that you need
- 7:18
- Andrew Nicole: to be addressing.
- 7:19
- Step McKnight: And the reason this is so important of getting those quotes is that when you do go to the disputes tribunal and you put your application in, you've got to put in a dollar value of your claim. You've got to say, I'm claiming for $24,031, or I am claiming for 16,000 and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And unless you have a
- 7:39
- Step McKnight: way to substantiate that and say, well, this is how I came to the $16,000 or whatever the number happens to be, they're going to laugh you out of the room, right? Like your claim is going to have much less weight to it. And so what you'd want to do is say, well, I've got two different quotes that say this is what is needing to be done and this is what it's going to cost to fix.
- 7:59
- Step McKnight: And so I'm going to claim for the lower amount or the higher. amount of that or the average of the two quotes. That's how you go ahead and say, well, this is how much I'm going to be claiming for.
- 8:09
- Andrew Nicole: And I think it's really important that you don't try and bolster those quotes up. So I did see an instance where one investor had a bit of defects, went through the process of making a claim, but actually thought, oh, yeah, I'm going gonna to try and see if I can get a a an upgrade in or something or other. And I remember when they actually. finally got a payment, it was actually a
- 8:29
- Andrew Nicole: reduced payment because the adjudicator or whoever was looking over the case, they didn't trust the person that was making the claim because they thought they were being a bit sneaky.
- 8:39
- Step McKnight: Interesting. Well, step number three would be to go to the warranty company with the paper trail and send the notice, the report, the quotes, the proof that the builder has ignored you. Things like on the 2nd of September at 3 p.m., I attempted to call you. You did not pick up. The next day at 4 p.m.,
- 8:59
- Step McKnight: I called. I did not get a call back. I sent a text. I sent an email. I got the impression that the builder was potentially ignoring me. Now there is a bit of a catch in this case, right? In that their warranty says the builder fixes things for the first two years and then the warranty kicks in. So there is every chance that the warranty company bounces it back to the builder. But at
- 9:19
- Step McKnight: least if you have a paper trail, then you've got somebody else calling the builder and getting on the case as well, right? Now, one question a lot of people would ask is well, should this person just fix the problems, like hire some traders, pay them, and then send the builder the bill?
- 9:35
- Andrew Nicole: So you can do this, but there's some caveats. to that. So you have to have given the person responsible, so be it the Stanford policy or or the builder, you've got to give them a fair and reasonable amount of time to be able to deal with it themselves because, you know, a builder should be able to fix it cheaper themselves.
- 9:55
- Andrew Nicole: Now, that's not your problem if they just keep ignoring you and you've got a right to have that remedied. So there's a bit of risk here. What a lot of people want to do is get it all dealt with, but if you just go ahead and do it and then send them the bill, you're probably not going to get reimbursed. Well,
- 10:12
- Step McKnight: yeah, the trouble here is you've got to recover the cost, right? This can be like your meth example, where those subbies were in the right. They should have been paid by the guy who was addicted to meth and who had hired them, but they didn't get their money back. because they couldn't recover the cost because this guy didn't have the money and is now in jail. Another good example of
- 10:32
- Step McKnight: that is with landlords when you you might be in the right with your tenant where they might have caused a lot of damage and they might owe you $10,000 to fix that damage. But if they don't have the money, you can be in the right, have spent the money, and still have no way, or very there are limited ways to recover the cost. And that's unfortunately one of those. times where
- 10:52
- Step McKnight: it's not fair, but it's the reality of it. You know, it's not fair that if your tenant owes you money and they don't pay it or they have the opportunity to pay it back very slowly because they don't have the money in their account. Well, that's not fair because they owe you that money. But it's also the reality of it. And there's quite a few things throughout throughout life and investing, whether it's all types of investing and in all
- 11:11
- Step McKnight: types of business, where things might not be fair but it's still the reality. You know, it's not right, but it is the reality of the situation. And if you're finding that it's not fair and the builder is still not returning your phone calls or coming back to you, I think the easiest way is to force it by going to the Disputes Tribunal, which is a highly underutilized
- 11:31
- Step McKnight: part of the New Zealand justice system where you can claim up to $60,000 now, like it was just recently doubled. in early 2026, where you can claim quite a lot of money. You don't need to go in and pay a lawyer. It's relatively cheap to file a claim. I mean, it depends on how big a claim is, but once you've
- 11:51
- Step McKnight: got your quotes, you'll know all about that. But you can file, and the disputes tribunal can order that builder to fix or pay you some money. And I know you've actually sent a number of investors to the Disputes Tribunal. And when I say sent them, said, hey, look, maybe you should go and file in the Disputes Tribunal against whichever builder you're
- 12:11
- Step McKnight: claiming against, as opposed to taking an investor to the Disputes Tribunal.
- 12:15
- Andrew Nicole: Yeah, I think like you said before, it's an underutilized tool for people to very cost effectively have someone hear what their case is. And because that limit's gone up to 60,000 now. rather than go through the traditional court system, which is expensive and slow, you can get someone to adjudicate your
- 12:35
- Andrew Nicole: case in a relatively short, like in a couple of weeks. And $60,000 gives you quite a lot of leeway in terms of the size of the issue that you can take there. And in my experience, the disputes tribunal tend to favor the consumers and you might not have done everything perfectly correct, but there's an expectation that if you go to a
- 12:55
- Andrew Nicole: business and you you use their services, they should be doing the right thing by you.
- 13:00
- Step McKnight: But there are alternatives, right? Because what's the difference between the disputes tribunal and arbitration?
- 13:05
- Andrew Nicole: Yeah, so I had a situation where a builder was trying to claim an invoice against me, which I disputed, and the amount was uh um over the dispute. disputes tribunal amount, it was like about $100,000. And he took me to the building arbitration people, and it was a very quick process. So that was that was good. And I think
- 13:25
- Andrew Nicole: it needs to be, the reason this is a thing is because if people drag out construction workers unfairly, well that can have major flow on effects to other people's jobs. So the government has intentionally made this quite a speedy process. Now, it was quite detailed in terms of the documentation that
- 13:45
- Andrew Nicole: needed to be provided. I used a lawyer for mine purely just because it was it was easier from a time perspective. But if you were doing it yourself, it could actually require quite a bit of work. However, again, like the disputes tribunal, you don't have to use a lawyer and you can represent yourself and you can just go. in there and say, This is my situation,
- 14:05
- Andrew Nicole: here's my documentation, and someone will decide who's right or wrong.
- 14:10
- Step McKnight: So at what point, let's say you're having a dispute with a trade, we haven't gone to arbitrational disputes tribunal yet. At what point would you bring a lawyer into this to try and get it solved?
- 14:21
- Andrew Nicole: The downside of using a lawyer is it can be quite expensive. And usually most of these situations can be sorted out between, you know, just having a conversation or sending a few emails back and forward and meeting in the middle. Yes, I have had a lot of these cases myself, but that's probably just because of the number of transactions I've been involved with and the complexities of some of the things. But in all that time, I
- 14:40
- Andrew Nicole: mean I've only ever had one that went through this this arbitration process. And I tell you what, I did everything I possibly could to sell it beforehand, including trying to meet in the middle. even though I didn't think that that was fair.
- 14:53
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 14:53
- Step McKnight: over the last 15 minutes, you've learned what to do when your build a ghost you, the step-by-step process you can follow, and how to force a fix in just six weeks. Right, let's wrap it up there. But please don't forget to rank review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
- 15:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thanks
- 15:13
- Step McKnight: for listening to the Proppy Property Academy. Podcast. I'm your host, Steph McKnight, and I'm Andrew Neckle. We're gonna be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, texts, and insights to help you get the most out of the news on the property market. Until next
- 15:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): time.
More from The Property Academy Podcast
They Were Turned Down By 4 Banks. Now They Can’t Stop Borrowing
Episode discussion: NZ first-home buyer share hits record 29% as speakers detail leveraging equity and overcoming bank rejections
Speakers’ claims: Steve McKnight reports that first-home buyers accounted for 29% of New Zealand home sales in 2026, the highest share since 2005, with many using deposits under 20%. Speakers present case studies illustrating how investors can leverage equity from owner-occupied homes to fund investment properties, despite initial bank rejections. One client overcame a reduced bank valuation by switching to a lender offering 90% loan-to-value ratios, accepting higher risks. Another couple secured lending after renovating a remote property that four banks had previously rejected. The discussion highlights that mortgage advisors can identify capacity for multiple purchases and that 'Investment Ready' services help borrowers qualify for future loans.
Where The Old Money ACTUALLY Lives In New Zealand
Episode discussion: Podcast ranks NZ suburbs by wealth generation, contrasting stable old money areas with high-growth gentrifying locations.
Speakers’ claims: Host Stephen Knight and guest Andrew Nicole rank New Zealand suburbs into old, new, and brand-new money categories to identify gentrification patterns. They classify Epsom, Stanley Point, and Remuera as old money, noting their stability but lower percentage growth. In contrast, suburbs like Wanaka, Ponsonby, and Arrowtown are identified as new or brand-new money, having experienced significant value appreciation due to population shifts and urban renewal. The speakers argue that investing in gentrifying areas historically yields higher returns than established wealthy suburbs. They provide specific historical sales data and investment growth comparisons to support these classifications.