Guest argues tariffs failed to revive US manufacturing due to high labor costs and complex global supply chains.
Summary
Hosts introduce Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick's claim that tariffs would force manufacturing back to the US, but guest Willy Shih argues this did not happen. Shih illustrates the complexity of global supply chains using furniture and notes that US labor costs are approximately five times higher than China's. Instead of returning to the US, companies shifted production to low-cost countries like Vietnam after tariffs. Shih estimates an iPhone 16 Pro made in the US would cost nearly three times more than current models. He suggests the US should focus on high-value sectors like semiconductors and biotech rather than mass assembly. Finally, Shih advocates for alliance-based sourcing and acknowledges that automation has changed, rather than eliminated, manufacturing jobs.
Key takeaways
- 1 US labor rates are approximately five times that of China.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 4:38
- 2 They were very efficient at mobilizing these huge amounts of labor to do these types of assembly jobs.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 4:54
- 3 For example, when the Trump administration hit China with tariffs, companies like TV manufacturers with operations in China responded by shifting more of their production to Vietnam.
Ricky Mulvey · 5:19
- 4 An iPhone 16 Pro made in the US would cost nearly three times more.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) · 6:23
- 5 It would mean being more strategic about here are the products that we're going to maintain global champion status. These are the things that are really important to make in the US.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 7:03
Episode sections
- 0:06 – 2:39
Tariff Rationale vs. Reality
Hosts introduce Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick's claim that tariffs would force companies to move manufacturing, such as iPhone assembly, back to the US. The guest, Willy Shih, argues this did not happen.
- 2:39 – 4:06
Global Supply Chain Complexity
Willy Shih describes his experience visiting over a thousand factories globally. He illustrates supply chain complexity using furniture, noting hardwood from New Hampshire is shipped to Vietnam for processing, then to China for assembly, before returning to the US.
- 4:06 – 5:19
US Labor Costs and China's Dominance
Shih states the US is a high-cost country with labor rates approximately five times that of China. He explains China's dominance stems from efficient mobilization of massive labor forces for assembly, a model hard to replicate elsewhere.
- 5:19 – 6:49
Tariff Responses and Consumer Costs
Instead of moving production to the US in response to tariffs, companies shifted operations to low-cost labor countries like Vietnam. Shih estimates an iPhone 16 Pro made in the US would cost nearly three times more, reducing consumer choice and affordability.
- 6:49 – 7:53
Strategic Manufacturing Renaissance
Shih argues the US should focus on maintaining 'global champion' status in high-value sectors like jet engines, pharmaceuticals, semiconductors, and biotech, rather than trying to revive mid-20th-century mass assembly jobs.
- 7:53 – 8:52
Alliance-Based Sourcing
For industries where the US cannot lead, Shih suggests building a network of allies across North/South America, Europe, Asia, and Africa to secure critical minerals, labor, and technology, contrasting this with a 'zero-sum' approach.
- 8:52 – 10:57
Automation and Future Jobs
Shih contrasts the post-WWII auto factory jobs with today's automated US factories, noting that while the nature of jobs has changed, this shift represents progress rather than a loss of manufacturing capability.
Claims worth verifying
Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick stated on CBS that companies would move factories to America to avoid tariffs, specifically citing iPhone assembly.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·0:23
How to verify: Search CBS News archives for Howard Lutnick interviews from April 2026 (referenced as 'last April' relative to Nov 2026 release). For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
New Mexico became the first state to launch universal free childcare in November of the previous year.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:24
How to verify: Check New Mexico state government press releases or news reports from November 2026 regarding childcare program launches. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Willy Shih has visited over a thousand factories during his career.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·2:51
How to verify: Verify via Willy Shih's professional biography on Harvard Business School faculty pages or his book 'Where Does My Stuff Come From?' acknowledgments. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
US labor rates are approximately five times that of China.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·4:38
How to verify: Compare average manufacturing hourly compensation data from the US Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) with China's National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) for the relevant period (2026-2026). For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
TV manufacturers shifted production from China to Vietnam in response to Trump administration tariffs.
Ricky Mulvey ·5:19
How to verify: Analyze US Customs and Border Protection trade data for TV imports from Vietnam vs. China between 2026 and 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
An analyst estimated an iPhone 16 Pro made in the US would cost almost three times more than its current price.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·6:23
How to verify: Identify the specific analyst report cited by Shih (likely from a tech news outlet or financial firm) published in 2026-2026 discussing US manufacturing cost premiums for Apple products. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The US withdrew from the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) during Trump's first term.
Ricky Mulvey ·8:27
How to verify: Check US State Department records or White House archives for the date of US withdrawal from the TPP (historically January 2026). For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The episode was fact-checked by Sierra Juarez and produced by Julia Ritchie.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·9:57
How to verify: Check the episode credits on the NPR website or Apple Podcasts listing for 'The Indicator from Planet Money' episode released 2026-11-19. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify US vs China labor cost ratios using Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) data.
- Check iPhone 16 Pro component costs and assembly location data from supply chain analysts like Digi-Times or Counterpoint.
- Review Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick's official statements on tariff impacts.
- Analyze US import data from US Census Bureau to track shifts in manufacturing origin post-tariffs.
- Assess US production volumes in semiconductors and biotech using Semiconductor Industry Association reports.
- Examine automation adoption rates in US manufacturing via Federal Reserve Industrial Capacity Survey.
- Identify potential conflicts of interest for Willy Shih regarding his affiliations with Harvard Business School or industry consultancies.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): NPR.
- 0:06
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
- 0:06
- Ricky Mulvey: is the indicator from Planet Money. I'm Ricky Mulvey
- 0:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): and I'm Adrian Ma. When President Trump instituted tariffs on virtually all our trading partners last year, one of the rationales the administration gave was that it would bring manufacturing jobs back to the U.S. Here's Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick on CBS last April.
- 0:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Everyone in the world sells to us. Our economy is the consumer of the world.
- 0:29
- Ricky Mulvey: Lutnick said that companies want to sell to the US so badly, they'll move their factories to America just to avoid tariffs. And as a result, products that have long been made in places like China will be made in the USA.
- 0:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Screwing in little, little screws to make iPhones. That kind of thing is gonna come to America. It's gonna be automated, and great Americans, the tradecraft of America, is gonna fix them, is gonna work on them, they're gonna be mechanics, there's gonna be
- 0:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Well, that isn't exactly what happened. And it's not where we're going, according to today's guest, Willie Shee, a Harvard professor and author of a new book on supply chains.
- 1:09
- Ricky Mulvey: After the break, Willie explains why we probably won't see iPhones made in America or a revival of the manufacturing jobs of York. But he'll also argue that a different kind of manufacturing renaissance is still possible.
- 1:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Last November, New Mexico became the first state to launch universal free childcare. One year later, many families are still on wait lists. It's just hard to explain to the family that oh, I'm sorry, we'd have full whole capacity, we don't have a spot. sport. How New Mexico is working to keep this ambitious program alive. Listen now to the Sunday story from the Up First
- 1:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Podcast on the MPR app.
- 1:45
- Ricky Mulvey: Two iconic voices, one rare opportunity.
- 1:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I thank you so much for being on our show today.
- 1:51
- Ricky Mulvey: Terry Gross and Paul McCartney.
- 1:54
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I listen to your show, I listen to MPR all the time. I'm not just blowing smoke here.
- 1:59
- Ricky Mulvey: A live conversation between one of the world's most influential musicians and one of America's most accomplished interviewers. Monday, November 23rd in New York City, benefiting public media. Tickets and information at why.org/slash events.
- 2:16
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Happy fall! Yes, the days are getting shorter and colder, and the rain can be a drag. But this is also the perfect time of year to get cozy. LifeKit has lots of ideas. so you can embrace the change of seasons with episodes on everything from making soup to exercising outdoors. Listen to the LifeKit podcast in the NPR app
- 2:36
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): or wherever you get your podcasts.
- 2:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): To understand how global supply chains work, Willie Shee has traveled all over the world. He's sort of like Anthony Bourdain.
- 2:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Well, maybe I'm the Anthony Bourdain of industrial tourism, right?
- 2:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): You know,
- 2:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): my whole career, I've been visiting a lot of factories, it's well over a thousand. And it's given me a unique picture of the world on how supply chains actually work in practice.
- 3:02
- Ricky Mulvey: Even after a pandemic made supply chain a household phrase, he says a lot of people still don't understand the how and why behind them.
- 3:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I asked ask students, for example, where did you get that? And they said, Oh, I got it at Amazon. It's like, no, how did it get to Amazon? Right. So what people don't realize is that a lot of the products that we use every day take a crazy trip around the world.
- 3:26
- Ricky Mulvey: Take furniture, for instance.
- 3:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): But where does the hardwood for that furniture come from? A lot of it comes from forests around my house in New Hampshire. Okay, and they cut it down there. they ship it to Vietnam for sawing into boards, and then they'll send it to China for making into furniture.
- 3:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Before sending it back to the U.S., Willie explores these logistical loop de loops in his new book, Where Does My Stuff Come From? The powerful economics behind global supply chains. His goal was to give the public and policymakers a more nuanced understanding of supply chains. And he was skeptical when the Trump and administration said tariffs would
- 4:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): bring about a boom in manufacturing jobs.
- 4:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Frankly, I never believed it was going to come back. Okay. And it is not coming back.
- 4:12
- Ricky Mulvey: Now, to be fair, he says the tariffs have motivated some car makers like Toyota and Hyundai to invest in plants in the U.S., but the promised job boom hasn't materialized. And on the current path, he doesn't think one is coming. And that's because of one function. fundamental economic fact about making stuff in the US.
- 4:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): The US is and continues to be a high-cost country. In
- 4:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): particular, the cost of labor is high compared to many other countries.
- 4:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): You know, our current labor rate is probably five times that of China.
- 4:44
- Ricky Mulvey: Not to mention that in China, there are entire cities built around factories where hundreds of thousands of people live and work. making everything from electronics and furniture to clothing.
- 4:54
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): They were very efficient at mobilizing these huge amounts of labor to do these types of assembly jobs. And even today, it is hard to replicate that anywhere else in the world.
- 5:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): This efficiency and cost savings when it comes to labor is why Willie says China is essentially the world's factory. And how much companies care about keeping labor costs low is hard to understate.
- 5:19
- Ricky Mulvey: For example, when the Trump administration hit China with tariffs, companies like TV manufacturers with operations in China responded by shifting more of their production to Vietnam.
- 5:29
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): And if you look at the trade lane between Vietnam and the US, there's been huge growth as that production is uh moved to Vietnam.
- 5:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Their response to tariffs wasn't to say, let's move the TV factory to the US. It was let's move it to another country where the cost of labor is relatively low.
- 5:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Right.
- 5:48
- Ricky Mulvey: For products that require a lot of human labor, whether it's assembling TVs or furniture or iPhones, it's just going to be much cheaper for companies to make stuff outside the US. Let's say hypothetically, the US government forced companies to make their products.
- 6:03
- Ricky Mulvey: in the US. On the upside, Americans would get jobs, right? But Willie says there would be a big trade-off. Aaron
- 6:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
- 6:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): The question is how much more are you willing to pay? Okay. Are you willing to pay twice as much
- 6:16
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or
- 6:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): three times as much?
- 6:18
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Because that's how much more the labor is
- 6:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): going to cost.
- 6:20
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Well, labor materials and all the other things.
- 6:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): And just take this as an example. Last year, one analyst estimated that an iPhone 16 Pro made in the US would cost almost three times more. That U.S. price premium would also apply to all sorts of products made here. And not everybody wants to or can pay that.
- 6:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): When you go into Walmart, you're not going to be able to have these selections of relatively inexpensive products. You know, uh, so you can't have it both ways. The
- 6:49
- Ricky Mulvey: manufacturing business. boom of the mid-1900s. Willie says those jobs aren't coming back, and we don't necessarily want them to. But he says a different kind of manufacturing renaissance is still possible in the U.S. So what would that mean?
- 7:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): It would mean being more strategic about here are the products that we're going to maintain global champion status. These are the things that are really important to make in the US.
- 7:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 7:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): that, you know, if we did it better than anybody else, everybody would have to buy from us.
- 7:20
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): And there are examples of these products already, like jet engines, pharmaceuticals, semiconductors. But Willie says the US could also do more to nurture industries like biotech, which produces things like vaccines, advanced therapies, and cutting edge medicines.
- 7:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): If you look at what's going on in that field,
- 7:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): some of
- 7:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): the new things. that are coming along are incredible, right? And what we should be doing is investing to make that next generation of drugs and therapies
- 7:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): and really lead the world in things like that.
- 7:53
- Ricky Mulvey: And for the things the US can't lead in, well, for those, Willie thinks the US basically needs to make friends.
- 8:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think we need to kind of keep cast a wider net of allies that we can source from.
- 8:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Rather than the sort of zero-sum go-it-alone approach, the US could join up with countries in North and South America, Europe, Asia, and Africa, and say, we're going to trade across this block. Through this network, Willie says the US could access most of what we need, whether it's critical minerals, low-cost labor, or specialized technology.
- 8:26
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 8:27
- Ricky Mulvey: what might it look like in practice? Well, it might look like the Trans-Pacific Partnership. During the Obama administration, the U.S. agreed to join the trade pact with 11 other countries, including Japan, Australia, Chile, and Vietnam. But Trump withdrew the U.S. from that deal during his first term in office.
- 8:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Still, Willie says, with the right moves, a manufacturing renaissance in the U.S. could happen, even if it'll look a lot different. than the old one.
- 8:52
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): In the post-World War II period, 1950s, 1960s, you could graduate from high school, you could go down to the autofactory and you could get a good job. But the world has gotten more competitive, it has gotten more complex, right? You walk into factories today,
- 9:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 9:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): newer factories going into the US, you see a huge amount of automation, right? You see different types of jobs.
- 9:15
- Ricky Mulvey: And that's a good thing because it will move US manufacturing forward.
- 9:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): And because we can't go back.
- 9:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): NPR Superfans, listen up because you and a guest could win a trip to NPR headquarters in DC. You'll get to watch a live broadcast of all things considered and have lunch with us. It's free to enter at npr.org/slash giveaway. You can make a donation for more entries and support the NPR network while you're at it.
- 9:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): There's no purchase or donation required, but you do have to be 18 years or older to enter. Find links to the entry page and official rules at npr.org slash giveaway. December 1st is the last day to enter, and good luck.
- 9:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
- 9:57
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): episode was produced by Julia Ritchie and engineered by Debbie Daughtry. It was fact-checked by Sierra Juarez, Caking Kegan Canada. Cannon is our editor and the indicators of production of NPR.
- 10:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
- 10:08
- Ricky Mulvey: Kevin Roos. And I'm Casey Newton. And together we've been
- 10:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): tech journalists for decades.
- 10:13
- Ricky Mulvey: Now we're your hosts of Machine Gods, a new podcast from NPR that makes sense of what AI
- 10:18
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): means for
- 10:18
- Ricky Mulvey: your work, your life, and all
- 10:20
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
- 10:20
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): our futures.
- 10:21
- Ricky Mulvey: Twice a week, we'll be exploring the biggest moves in tech and give you unmatched access to the real Titans. of industry. Listen to
- 10:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Machine Gods from NPR on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
- 10:33
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Money is one of the biggest sources of stress in our lives, no matter our paycheck.
- 10:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
- 10:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): is Fresh Air's Tanya Mosley, and I spoke with journalist Mona Chalaby about how financial secrecy impacts us all.
- 10:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 10:45
- Ricky Mulvey: think in this country, language around class is just so stunted.
- 10:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And it
- 10:49
- Ricky Mulvey: allows us to hide.
- 10:51
- Ricky Mulvey: because we're not being specific.
- 10:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Listen on the NPR app or wherever you get fresh air.
More from The Indicator from Planet Money
We got this economics podcast before GTA VI
Episode discussion: GTA 6 launch highlights rising development costs and industry shift to virtual economies
Speakers’ claims: The episode discusses the upcoming launch of Grand Theft Auto 6, noting its potential as a record-breaking entertainment release. Speakers highlight that development costs have surged to over $1 billion, compared to $265 million for GTA 5, with pre-orders reaching $1.5 billion. The industry has shifted from physical discs to digital codes, leading to the sale of physical collectibles to offset consumer anxiety. Developers are increasingly relying on virtual economies and microtransactions, such as 'shark cards,' which generate significant annual revenue. Despite the game's anticipated success, the broader gaming industry faces challenges including layoffs and high production costs, potentially leading to a shift toward lower-tech experiences.
How a tribal water deal could put a price tag on the Colorado River
Episode discussion: Federal proposal to fund tribal water infrastructure in Colorado River basin faces political opposition
Speakers’ claims: The episode discusses a federal settlement proposal aimed at addressing the lack of reliable clean drinking water for approximately half of the homes on tribal land, citing the Hopi people as an example. It highlights the complex dynamics of the Colorado River basin, which supports 40 million people and 30 tribes, noting that while tribes hold legal rights to a quarter of the water, they lack the infrastructure to utilize it. The Navajo Nation's geographic position straddling the Upper and Lower Colorado River divide is identified as a complicating factor for water leasing. Economists argue that the proposed deal could enhance economic efficiency by allowing water to shift from low-value agricultural uses to high-value urban uses. However, Upper Basin states including Colorado, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming oppose the agreement due to fears that it sets a precedent for water transfers to Lower Basin states.