Federal proposal to fund tribal water infrastructure in Colorado River basin faces political opposition
Summary
The episode discusses a federal settlement proposal aimed at addressing the lack of reliable clean drinking water for approximately half of the homes on tribal land, citing the Hopi people as an example. It highlights the complex dynamics of the Colorado River basin, which supports 40 million people and 30 tribes, noting that while tribes hold legal rights to a quarter of the water, they lack the infrastructure to utilize it. The Navajo Nation's geographic position straddling the Upper and Lower Colorado River divide is identified as a complicating factor for water leasing. Economists argue that the proposed deal could enhance economic efficiency by allowing water to shift from low-value agricultural uses to high-value urban uses. However, Upper Basin states including Colorado, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming oppose the agreement due to fears that it sets a precedent for water transfers to Lower Basin states.
Episode sections
- 0:06 – 4:10
Tribal water access crisis and federal settlement proposal
Discussion on the lack of clean drinking water for half of tribal homes and the proposed federal settlement act.
- 4:10 – 5:14
Colorado River basin dynamics and the Navajo straddle
Overview of the Colorado River's support for 40 million people and 30 tribes, and the Navajo Nation's complicating geographic position.
- 5:14 – 11:35
Political opposition and economic efficiency arguments
Upper Basin states' opposition to the deal and economists' arguments for improved efficiency through water reallocation.
Do your own research
- Verify the text of the Northeastern Arizona Indian Water Rights Settlement Act to confirm funding amounts and specific tribal beneficiaries.
- Check USGS or Bureau of Reclamation data on current Colorado River basin water allocations versus actual usage by tribes.
- Review legislative records for opposition statements from Colorado, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming regarding the settlement.
- Analyze economic studies comparing the value of water in agricultural versus urban sectors in the region.
- Assess the geographic and legal implications of the Navajo Nation straddling the Upper/Lower Colorado River divide.
- Look for independent reports on the current state of drinking water infrastructure on Hopi and other affected tribal lands.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): NPR.
- 0:06
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
- 0:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): is the indicator from Planet Money. I'm Wayland Wong. Across the US, about half of all homes on tribal land do not have access to reliable clean drinking water. Reporter Alex Haker has been covering the issue at Member Station, KJZZ, KJ Zay Z in and Phoenix. Alex, welcome back to the indicator.
- 0:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Hey Wayland, thanks for having me. For 10 tens of thousands of people living on tribal lands here in Arizona, getting water is way harder than just flipping on the faucet. Just ask Marilyn Tiwa.
- 0:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Wow.
- 0:36
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Uh-huh. And this used to be uh mainly for livestock.
- 0:41
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): She's a grandmother in her 80s, and living on the Hopi Reservation, she gets her water by driving five miles each way to a rickety windmill. It pulls under untreated water from underground.
- 0:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): It's like it's a daily thing for us out here to do this, and
- 0:58
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 0:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): know, other people uh just don't realize what we go through.
- 1:02
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): For Marilyn, washing her hands or cooking dinner can mean driving miles and bringing water home in buckets.
- 1:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): But now there's a plan to fix that.
- 1:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A new
- 1:14
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): federal law. would send billions of dollars to help those people get the kind of basic water access that a lot of us take for granted. Still, some neighboring states aren't on board.
- 1:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Today on the show, we look at the multi-billion dollar proposal to help tribes get clean water, how the benefits could go beyond tribal lands by putting a real price tag on water, and the complicated reason why some states are trying to block it.
- 1:42
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Last November, New Mexico became the first state to launch universal free child care. One year later, many families are still on wait lists.
- 1:52
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Oh, I'm sorry, we'd have full capacity, we don't have a spot.
- 1:55
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): How New Mexico is working to keep this ambitious program alive. Listen now to the Sunday story from the Up First Podcast on the MPR. NPR app.
- 2:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Money is one of the biggest sources of stress in our lives, no matter our paycheck.
- 2:09
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
- 2:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): is Fresh Air's Tanya Mosley, and I spoke with journalist Mona Chalaby about how financial secrecy impacts us all.
- 2:16
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I think in this country, language around class is just so stunted. And it allows us to hide because we're not being specific.
- 2:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Listen on the NPR app or wherever you get. fresh air.
- 2:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Happy fall! Yes, the days are getting shorter and colder, and the rain can be a drag. But this is also the perfect time of year to get cozy. LifeKit has lots of ideas so you can embrace the change of seasons with episodes on everything from making soup to exercising outdoors. Listen to the LifeKit Life Kit podcast in the NPR app
- 2:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): or wherever you get your podcasts.
- 2:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): The day's top headlines, local stories from your community, your next podcast binge listen. You can have it all in one place. Your pocket. Download the NPR app today.
- 3:06
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
- 3:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): federal proposal could bring a life-changing pipeline Blind to a part of the country where a third of homes can't flush a toilet or take a shower. Alex, you speak spent some time on the Hopi Reservation to see all these water issues firsthand.
- 3:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, it's this sprawling section of northeastern Arizona with really intense rock features and these vast expanses of desert that look like they go on forever. That's where I met up with Marilyn Tiwa. She's a member of the Hopi Tribal Council and lives in the same village she was born in. And for her, getting water means coming to this windmill to fill up five-gallon.
- 3:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): buckets and then bring them back home in a pickup truck.
- 3:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Us we don't have any indoor plumbing, so we have to, you know, rely on
- 3:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): outside portigeons. So that's uh that hope that one day we'll be able to have all of these facilities that other people have in their homes.
- 3:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): And Maryland's hope is getting close to becoming a reality. That's thanks to the Northeastern. Arizona Indian Water Rights Settlement Act.
- 4:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Okay, that name is kind of a mouthful. So let's take a step back to understand what it would do.
- 4:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Right. So this all has to do with the Colorado River. It is a powerhouse for the West. It's connected to seven states, nearly 40 million people, and 30 federally recognized Native tribes.
- 4:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Tribes in the Colorado River basin have legal access to about a quarter of all the water in the river. but they often don't have the money and infrastructure to use it. So instead, they have to leave it in the river for someone else to use. But there's a way to change that. Tribes can enter a kind of compromise.
- 4:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): And that's what this proposal is all about. Three tribes: the Navajo, Hopi, and San Juan Southern Paiute, would agree to use less water than they might be legally owed, and the federal government would give them a $5 billion check in exchange.
- 4:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): They would use that money to build a huge pipeline that would bring running water to thousands of homes that don't have it.
- 4:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): This deal could be literally life-changing for tens of thousands of people. And after years of work, tribal leaders say they're really close to getting it done.
- 5:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): But there is a catch. Four states are stalling the deal for a very specific reason.
- 5:14
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): You see, over a century ago, the states that use the Colorado River were split into two camps. On one side, you have the upper states, that's Colorado, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming.
- 5:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And the lower states, Arizona, California, and Nevada. Those two groups have a rivalry going back decades. They have huge public disagreements about sharing water to this very day.
- 5:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): And the Navajo Nation is stuck right in the middle. Navajo land does not fall cleanly within state borders. It straddles three states and the invisible line that divides those old rivals.
- 5:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): This deal would give the tribes water and money. It would also let the Navajo Nation lease some of its water from above the line to people below the line.
- 5:57
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, and there's a lot of interest below the line. Fast growing cities in the Phoenix area need. more water, and they would probably be willing to pay Navajo Nation to use some of theirs.
- 6:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So this is where the states Colorado, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming are trying to hit the brakes.
- 6:14
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): They say they're worried about a precedent. Like if Navajo Nation moves their upper state water across the line to their rivals, maybe someone else would try the same thing, cutting into a very precious supply.
- 6:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Supporters of the deal say there's no reason to worry about a precedent because no other tribe sits on both sides of the line. Even so, this concern is stalling the proposal.
- 6:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And that's really frustrating for people like Marilyn Tiwa.
- 6:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): We're at their mercy and you know, begging for something which we are entitled to. And um I just hope that there somebody up there will listen to us and help us out that we get this settlement passed.
- 7:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): But there's something else at play if the settlement deal passes. Economists say it's not just about water rights for these three tribes.
- 7:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): They say there's actually an economic lesson here about. the value of water. Even though it's a really precious resource, it's not always priced like one. We've covered this a couple of times on the indicator. In the Colorado River's case, it's a precious and shrinking resource that a lot of Western states, plus Mexico, rely on. The big thing to note here is
- 7:32
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): that access to the Colorado River is often decided by who started using water first, not who can pay the most. for it, not who is using it the best or most efficiently, just who's been using it the longest.
- 7:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): That often leaves farms as the oldest and most legally untouchable water users. Some of that farming is pivotal. The reason you can eat a salad in the winter all across the country? That's because a huge majority of our nation's winter vegetables are grown with water from the Colorado River.
- 8:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): But big portions of that water are also used to grow stuff like alfalfa hay, which is used to feed cows. That hay takes a lot of water to grow, and cells were relatively cheap.
- 8:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): So, with agriculture using about three quarters of all the water from the Colorado River, that means a lot of the precious resource is being used really inefficiently.
- 8:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Basically, one unit of water can go a lot further when you pipe it to a city. The same amount of water generates more. economic value when it's used by homes and businesses, instead of irrigating a thirsty farm field that produces a relatively cheap crop.
- 8:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Because of those old legal protections, there's not usually a way to get water from an inefficient farm to a more efficient city. I talked about that with Leslie Sanchez, a resource Source economist at UC Davis.
- 8:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): You just get this pent-up supply and this unmet demand and it ends up leading to a lot of system-wide inefficiency in the sense that water is not being directed to where it needs it's needed most.
- 8:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): But if a tribe which holds a big amount of legally protected water suddenly gets the ability to shop that water around, there's a way to move it.
- 9:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Right now, the Navajo Nation is leaving a lot of its water in the river where it's getting used by big farms far away. But if it's given the right to lease that water, now it has a way to move it to the highest bidder.
- 9:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): That would probably be a city who can outbid a big farm because the same unit of water that could be growing inefficient crops can be used more efficiently and more valuably by homes and businesses.
- 9:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Leslie says that's good for the tribes and in a way the whole Colorado River system.
- 9:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): There's only so long that we can hang on.
- 9:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
- 9:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): this like current pattern of water use before
- 9:43
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): either
- 9:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the reservoirs are empty or
- 9:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
- 9:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): something prompts change. Like it becomes too expensive for us collectively to continue down this path.
- 9:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): The tribal water settlement, she says, is a step away from that path and a step towards making the river more efficient.
- 10:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): We reached out to water negotiators and politicians from the states that are standing in the way of the tribal settlement. None agreed to an interview, but in various statements, told us they are committed to finding a path forward and finding a workable solution.
- 10:13
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): For its part, Colorado, in a letter to Congress, said it's focused on the security and certainty of its access to the Colorado River, and the settlement deal needs more work to comply with the law.
- 10:26
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
- 10:26
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): story was reported in collaboration with Mark Alalde from ProPublica. This episode was produced by Julia Ritchie with Engineering by Sophie MacArthur. It was fact checked by Sierra Juarez. Kit and Cannon is the show's editor, and The Indicator is a production of NPR.
- 10:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Two
- 10:41
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): iconic voices, one rare opportunity.
- 10:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I thank you so much for being on our show today. Terry
- 10:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Gross
- 10:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
- 10:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Paul McCartney.
- 10:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I listened listen to your show. I listen to MPR
- 10:52
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): all the time. I'm not just blowing smoke here.
- 10:55
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): A live conversation between one of the world's most influential musicians and one of America's most accomplished interviewers. Monday, November 23rd in New York City, benefiting public media. Tickets and information at why.org/slash events.
- 11:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Scientists know that creativity is good for our brain. brains, but what if it could actually slow down aging? On a new episode of Your Turn with Alice Knobry, we explore the surprising health benefits of engaging with the arts. Listen to your turn on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
More from The Indicator from Planet Money
Three influencer types and how they generate money
Episode discussion: Podcast analyzes three influencer monetization models: hucksters, entertainers, and gurus
Speakers’ claims: The episode explores the creator economy, citing IAB data that 1.5 million US residents are full-time creators. It introduces Stanford Professor Angèle Christin's framework categorizing influencers into hucksters, entertainers, and gurus based on revenue streams. Hucksters rely on brand sponsorships, entertainers chase platform revenue shares through viral content, and gurus monetize directly via subscriptions and merchandise. The hosts note that despite industry growth, a CreatorIQ survey reveals most creators earn under $10,000 annually and face significant burnout.
An inflation scare, workers get their fair share, and Nvidia’s billion-dollar affairs
Episode discussion: NVIDIA CEO resigns amid scandal; CPI rises; stolen wages recovered
Speakers’ claims: The episode reports that October CPI rose 0.4%, exceeding expectations due to food and energy costs, prompting Chicago Fed President Austin Goolsby to express concern over persistent services inflation. It highlights that $960 million in stolen wages were recovered in 2025, with minimum wage violations estimated at $15 billion annually. The segment details the resignation of NVIDIA CEO Jensen Wong following revelations of personal affairs and allegations of facilitating chip sales to China to bypass export restrictions. NVIDIA stock dropped over 11%, wiping out approximately $465 billion in market value.