Hosts and guests discuss housing regret, cash flow management, and the financial trade-offs of owning versus renting in Canada.
Summary
The episode examines the financial strain on Canadian homeowners facing falling prices and rising rates, illustrated by a listener's experience with negative cash flow. Certified Financial Planner Jason Heath advises ignoring past purchase prices and focusing on forward-looking cash flow and goals. He argues that renting can be cheaper than owning and that downsizing is a strategic move to improve retirement readiness. The hosts and guests emphasize that negative cash flow in rentals can be viable if principal paydown and appreciation offset costs, though they expect subdued prices for longer.
Key takeaways
- 1 Negative cash flow does not automatically make a rental property a bad investment if principal paydown and capital appreciation provide a decent rate of return.
Roma Luzio · 10:35
- 2 I had to make a bet, I think prices are going to stay uh subdued for for longer than many. of us would hope.
Roma Luzio · 11:09
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 3:25
Introduction and Jane's Story
Hosts introduce the episode's theme of housing regret in Canada, citing falling prices and rising rates. Jane, a 27-year-old, shares her experience buying a Toronto condo in 2021 for $540,000 with a $100,000 down payment, only to become a landlord after a breakup.
- 3:25 – 7:17
Jane's Financial Reality
Jane reports paying approximately $8,000 annually out-of-pocket to cover the shortfall between her $2,250 monthly rent and her total carrying costs. She notes the opportunity cost of her $100,000 down payment, which could have been invested in the stock market.
- 7:17 – 10:23
Jason Heath on Market Context and Decision Making
Certified Financial Planner Jason Heath discusses the pressure on young buyers five years ago, attributing it to recency bias and family influence. He advises homeowners to ignore past purchase prices and focus on forward-looking financial decisions based on current cash flow and goals.
- 10:23 – 17:07
Rental Properties and Downsizing
Heath explains that negative cash flow in rentals can still be viable if principal paydown and appreciation offset costs, though he expects subdued prices for longer. He suggests that downsizing to a more modest home can be a strategic move to improve cash flow and retirement readiness, rather than a failure.
- 17:07 – 25:41
Renting vs. Owning and Long-Term Trends
Heath argues that renting is often cheaper than owning monthly and can be a financially sound choice if savings are invested. He cites US data showing real estate appreciation tracks inflation, suggesting Canadian prices must either fall or stagnate while incomes catch up to return to historical norms.
- 25:41 – 26:25
Advice on housing regret and rental strategy
Rob Kerrick advises homeowners not to focus on purchase price but on current value and future affordability. He notes that renting out a home is viable even if rental income doesn't fully cover expenses, provided the owner can afford the shortfall.
- 26:25 – 27:54
Podcast outro and sponsor read
Roma Luzio concludes the episode, crediting the production team and guests. Rob Kerrick directs listeners to find the show on podcast platforms. Roma Luzio previews the next episode on online gambling. An unidentified speaker delivers a sponsor read for CPP Investments.
Claims worth verifying
Home prices in Canada have fallen from their peaks in the last five years.
Roma Luzio ·0:19
How to verify: Check the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) or Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) historical housing price indices for the period 2026-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jane bought a one-bedroom condo in downtown Toronto for $540,000 in the fall of 2021.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·1:57
How to verify: Verify via public property records in Toronto (e.g., Terrell or local land registry) for a transaction matching the date and price, or cross-reference with Jane's public disclosure if available. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jane pays approximately $8,000 out-of-pocket per year to cover the shortfall on her rental property.
Jane ·3:42
How to verify: This is a personal financial claim; verification would require Jane's personal financial statements or tax filings, which are not public. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceCPP Investments has been investing the CPP fund for more than 25 years.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·1:32
How to verify: Check CPP Investments' corporate history or annual reports on their official website (cppinvestments.com) for founding date and assets under management history. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
US residential home price data is available going back to 1890.
Roma Luzio ·19:34
How to verify: Consult the Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED) or academic research papers (e.g., Robert Shiller's data) for long-term US housing price indices. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Historically, US real estate appreciation has been slightly more than the rate of inflation.
Roma Luzio ·19:59
How to verify: Compare long-term US CPI (Consumer Price Index) data with long-term US residential price indices from sources like the Case-Shiller Index or FRED. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Rob Kerrick states that homeowners should not get hung up on what they paid for their home, but rather on its current worth and future affordability.
Rob Kerrick ·25:48
How to verify: Verify the transcript text at timestamp [25:48] for the exact phrasing of the advice regarding purchase price vs. current value. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Rob Kerrick claims that becoming a landlord is not the end of the world even if rental income doesn't cover all expenses, provided the owner can afford the carrying cost difference.
Rob Kerrick ·26:08
How to verify: Verify the transcript text at timestamp [26:08] for the statement regarding rental income covering expenses and the requirement to know carrying costs. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Rob Kerrick asserts that selling at a loss, downsizing, or returning to renting does not mean failure and can be the smartest financial decision.
Roma Luzio ·26:25
How to verify: Verify the transcript text at timestamp [26:25] for the specific claims about selling at a loss or renting being non-failure outcomes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The podcast episode is titled 'Should you stay or should you sell? A guide to housing regret' and is part 2 of 2.
Roma Luzio ·26:25
How to verify: Verify the episode title and part number in the provided description text. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The podcast is produced by Kyle Fulton, Zara Kozema, and Adidi Roy, with Kieran Rana as executive producer.
Roma Luzio ·26:25
How to verify: Verify the names listed in the transcript at timestamp [26:25] against the production credits. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The podcast is hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company.
Rob Kerrick ·26:40
How to verify: Verify the hosting information in the description text: 'Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company.' For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The next episode will cover the dark side of online gambling and sports betting apps.
Roma Luzio ·27:08
How to verify: Verify the preview text in the transcript at timestamp [27:08] regarding the next episode's topic. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
CPP Investments is a sponsor of the podcast.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·27:21
How to verify: Verify the sponsor read text at timestamp [27:21] mentioning 'CPP Investments' and 'cppinvestments.com'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
CPP Investments describes the CPP Fund as one of the top-performing pension funds in the world.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·27:21
How to verify: Verify the claim in the transcript at timestamp [27:21] against CPP Investments' public marketing materials or annual reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify current Canadian housing price trends and mortgage rate impacts using data from the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) or Statistics Canada.
- Review Jane's specific mortgage terms, interest rate, and property tax obligations to assess the accuracy of the $8,000 annual shortfall claim.
- Compare historical Canadian real estate appreciation rates against inflation and stock market returns to evaluate the opportunity cost argument.
- Research the tax implications of rental income and expenses in Canada to understand the net cash flow impact.
- Consult a Certified Financial Planner to assess personal affordability and forward-looking cash flow needs rather than relying on past purchase prices.
- Investigate the potential for principal paydown and capital appreciation in the specific local market to validate the viability of negative cash flow strategies.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Roma Luzio: For decades, buying a home in Canada was a reliable way to build wealth. Not only did you get a stable place of your own to live, but home prices soared, leaving young adults with plenty of options.
- 0:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): When
- 0:12
- Rob Kerrick: they outgrew their first home, they could sell, take a tidy profit, and use those funds to buy a more suitable place.
- 0:18
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
- 0:19
- Roma Luzio: in the last five years, home prices have fallen from their peaks.
- 0:22
- Rob Kerrick: Meanwhile, interest rates have pushed higher, and so have other costs of homeowners. homeownership. Today, many owners are dealing with a harsh new reality. Rather than helping them move up, that first home can make it harder to move on.
- 0:35
- Roma Luzio: Welcome to Stress Test, a personal finance podcast from Millennials and Gen Z. I'm Roma Luzio, a personal finance editor at the Globe and Mail.
- 0:43
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 0:43
- Rob Kerrick: I'm Rob Kerrick, an all All-around around personal finance guy who still writes occasionally for the Globe. Today we're asking what do you do when the home you bought isn't working out? Do you hold on and wait for prices to recover? Rent the place out and cover the shortfall? Sell and take the loss?
- 0:59
- Roma Luzio: Each option has its own financial and emotional trade-offs, and none of them is the obvious right call. Today, we'll hear from a Toronto woman who bought her first home, only to find herself in a situation she never wanted: becoming a landlord.
- 1:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 1:13
- Rob Kerrick: later, I'll speak with certified financial planner Jason Heath about how much the housing market has changed and what advice he has for young homeowners who want to move but can't sell their homes without losing money.
- 1:25
- Roma Luzio: That's coming up after the break.
- 1:32
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): This podcast is brought to you by CPP Investments. For more than 25 years, CPP Investments has been investing the CPP fund to help more than 22 million Canadians in retirement. Learn more at cppinvestments.com.
- 1:53
- Jane: I'm Jane, I'm 27, and I'm based in the Greater Toron area.
- 1:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): In
- 1:57
- Roma Luzio: the fall of 2021, Jane bought her first home, a one-bedroom one bedroom condo in downtown. Toronto for $540,000. She was still in university, but she saved up a $100,000 down payment by working multiple jobs, living at home, and keeping her expenses very low.
- 2:16
- Jane: And at the time, I thought that buying property young was a pretty responsible financial decision. My parents also owned our family home, so I guess following that traditional immigrant mindset, they always saw a real estate as a very safe investment and a good way for us to build wealth. So naturally I thought buying property as young as possible was one of the probably smartest financial decisions that I
- 2:36
- Jane: could make.
- 2:37
- Roma Luzio: The plan was to graduate and move into the condo with her boyfriend. So in the meantime, she rented it out for eight months.
- 2:43
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 2:44
- Jane: then right when they moved out and I graduated, I thought we were going to move in together. But between that time, we broke up. And so right after I graduated, I figured I would just extend that lease or I would find another tenant and um I would be able to still live with my parents and to save as much money as I possibly could in my early twenties. There was no reason for me lifestyle wise to live there now. Like I didn't know too many people in
- 3:03
- Jane: Toronto.
- 3:04
- Roma Luzio: Jane considered selling, but she had bought close to the peak of the market and her condo was already worth less than what she'd paid for it.
- 3:11
- Jane: I think it would have taken at least a couple of years even just to recover like closing costs and lawyer fees and and property tax and all that stuff. So I would have just taken a massive financial hit, especially at that age, even a couple tens of thousands would have been so much for me. It would have made absolutely no sense.
- 3:25
- Roma Luzio: She decided to keep renting her place out and wait for the market to improve. But five years later, Jane is still a landlord. Her tenant The pays $2,250 a month, including utilities and internet. It helps cover some of her costs, but definitely not all of them.
- 3:42
- Jane: Per year, out of pocket, I believe I'm paying close to $8,000 just to cover like maintenance fees, mortgage, property taxes, utilities bills, all that.
- 3:52
- Roma Luzio: Plus, there's the opportunity cost of having that money tied up in a home that has not appreciated since she bought it.
- 3:58
- Jane: Putting down $100,000 into the down payment, obviously. That was just money that I couldn't access for other opportunities. like investing into the stock market or putting into another business or something like that. Obviously, I kind of wish I had put that $100K into the stock market instead, but I never would have known that information back then. So
- 4:13
- Roma Luzio: owning the property has also impacted how much freedom she has to make other choices.
- 4:18
- Jane: That meant I probably couldn't travel as much because I kind of had to keep a close eye on it. I can't be out of the country for way too long or having career flexibility, knowing that I had. like fixed housing expenses meant I could take some maybe smaller risks just because I knew that out of the year I had to pay at least $8,000 in addition to everything else I was paying.
- 4:38
- Roma Luzio: Jane has a good income that has helped her keep the property as a long term investment, even though the costs of owning it have proved higher than she expected. Still, she admits that if she had to do it all over again, she'd take a different approach.
- 4:51
- Jane: Knowing what I know now, I probably would not buy the condo again, or I would wait a little bit longer just to kind of suss out the housing market just because it was kind of iffy back then. It was uncertain what direction it was going to go. Everyone can say now in my comments, you should
- 5:11
- Jane: have put the money into into the stock market. Um you could have saved the money, you could have invested somewhere else. But at the end of the day, like stock market could have crashed, and then I could have felt very lucky and grateful that I had my money in something that was relatively safer, like in real estate.
- 5:25
- Roma Luzio: This is her advice to young buyers.
- 5:27
- Jane: I think that you have to kind of consider everything and think about whether the property would still make sense financially and lifestyle-wise if you moved away. Um, I would also say run the numbers and like actually do the math, unlike me, as if you could become a landlord tomorrow. So could the rental income cover the mortgage, the condo fees, taxes, insurance, all that stuff? And if not, could you comfortably uh
- 5:47
- Jane: afford whatever happened? I also want to say to those that have already made the decision: negative cash flow doesn't automatically mean a bad investment. I personally find comfort knowing that my mortgage payment still is helping me build equity. Hopefully that's motivational. Hopefully that's helpful. Um, but you know, also on the other side, like equity growth doesn't still
- 6:07
- Jane: automatically make the property worth keeping too. So really doing the math and not kind of falling victim to sunk cost fallacy and feeling like you can't sell the property just because you've already put time and and money and effort into it. So if it financially makes the most sense after you've done the math, you know, like everything else in life, don't be scared to just kind of cut things. off
- 6:27
- Jane: and uh
- 6:29
- Jane: take your uh liquidity elsewhere.
- 6:31
- Roma Luzio: Things are manageable for Jane, but what if you can't afford to wait for the market to recover? After the break, Rob asks certified financial planner Jason Heath how homeowners can decide whether to stay, rent, or sell at a loss.
- 6:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
- 6:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): podcast is brought to you by CPP Investments. You may not think about your retirement every day.
- 6:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
- 6:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): while you're hard at work, CPP Investments is working for you by investing and helping grow the CPP Fund for Canadians today and for generations to come. Learn more at CPPInvestments.com.
- 7:17
- Rob Kerrick: Jason Heath is a certified financial planner and managing director at Objective Financial Partners, a fee-only financial planning firm based in Toronto. To start, Jason, can you set the scene for us five or six years ago when real estate was peaking? How much pressure was on young people to get into the market back then and remembering that the market was getting more expensive by the
- 7:37
- Rob Kerrick: minute?
- 7:38
- Roma Luzio: Huge. I think it was huge five or six years ago. And I think it was, you know, sort of self-imposed. It
- 7:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was, you know,
- 7:45
- Roma Luzio: input
- 7:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): from uh other friends
- 7:48
- Roma Luzio: and and
- 7:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): family
- 7:49
- Roma Luzio: members that were getting
- 7:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): into the
- 7:50
- Roma Luzio: market. It
- 7:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was parents,
- 7:52
- Roma Luzio: you think about baby boomers who were like
- 7:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): really, you know,
- 7:55
- Roma Luzio: pushing
- 7:56
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): young
- 7:56
- Roma Luzio: people to get involved in the market
- 7:58
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): because it had just
- 7:59
- Roma Luzio: been
- 7:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): such
- 8:00
- Roma Luzio: a good
- 8:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): run, I think,
- 8:01
- Roma Luzio: for
- 8:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the the previous generation, right? Aaron Powell So
- 8:03
- Rob Kerrick: let's talk about the kind of financial decision making that was going on then and how much care and effort and time people were putting into choosing their houses. Um do you think that there were optimum conditions back then for making good, long-lasting decisions?
- 8:17
- Roma Luzio: I don't think so. I I think
- 8:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
- 8:19
- Roma Luzio: making any sort of financial decision, Rob, when it's based on uh a place of pressure
- 8:26
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or
- 8:26
- Roma Luzio: tax. time sensitivity introduces problems where somebody might make a decision that is emotional, a decision that's not well thought out, a decision that's based
- 8:36
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on
- 8:37
- Roma Luzio: recency bias, which I think happens a lot with decisions when the market is really running. So personally I get the impression there were a lot of people that that made decisions under pressure and and not really thinking so much about
- 8:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): all
- 8:50
- Roma Luzio: the factors long term and more based on the
- 8:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 8:55
- Roma Luzio: fear of missing out that uh that I think everybody watched as it was happening.
- 8:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 8:59
- Rob Kerrick: we're talking today about people who bought homes that are now a bad fit, but they can't easily be sold. As a financial planner, what do you tell people who are in this situation? What are the options?
- 9:10
- Roma Luzio: Well, look, I I think whether it's real estate, a stock, a business, you know, whatever it is, I think people really need to look forward.
- 9:22
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 9:22
- Roma Luzio: what I mean by that, Rob, is, you know, regardless of what your home was worth when it peaked a few years ago, regardless of what you paid for,
- 9:31
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): regardless of,
- 9:32
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
- 9:32
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): the fact it was meant to be your forever home or or you were gonna flip it and and move to a
- 9:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): bigger
- 9:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): home,
- 9:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think you
- 9:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): sort of have to forget what's in the rear view mirror
- 9:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
- 9:42
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): take a look at where you are
- 9:43
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): currently
- 9:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): and decide, okay,
- 9:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): based
- 9:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): on all
- 9:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 9:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): information I have now about the market, about my ability to afford
- 9:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this
- 9:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): property, about my
- 9:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): debt,
- 9:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): about my intentions,
- 9:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know, what
- 9:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): should
- 9:53
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I do
- 9:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): with this thing? Should I
- 9:55
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): keep
- 9:55
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): it?
- 9:55
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Should
- 9:55
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I rent it out?
- 9:56
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Should I
- 9:57
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): sell it? And I think that's
- 9:58
- Jane: the the way that people need to to focus, you know, sort of looking forward from where you stand today.
- 10:03
- Rob Kerrick: A few years ago, everybody was talking about rental properties. I live in Ottawa, I go visit pr uh family in Toronto, and it was all talk about real estate, real estate, real estate, and rental properties. Uh I haven't heard the phrase rental property in about two years, which is a refreshing change. But if you are the owner of a rental property purchased in the peak of the market, in the heat of
- 10:23
- Rob Kerrick: the moment, and because of higher mortgage rates, your carrying carry-in costs. are not being fully covered. Uh, what is your sense about whether that's worthwhile to keep on with that hoping for the big capital gain at some point in the distant future?
- 10:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
- 10:35
- Roma Luzio: look, I I think that one thing I will say about a rental property, a lot of times people focus on cash flow. And if your property isn't cash flowing positive, it's a, you know, some people think it's a bad investment. That's not necessarily the case. You can have a property that's cash flow negative, but because you're paying down so much principal, and hopefully the capital uh
- 10:54
- Roma Luzio: appreciation, the value, market value of the property is going up, you can have a decent rate of return.
- 11:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
- 11:01
- Roma Luzio: look, market prices can go up for way too long. They can go down for longer than you expected. And um, if
- 11:09
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
- 11:09
- Roma Luzio: I had to make a bet, I think prices are going to stay uh subdued for for longer than many. of us would hope.
- 11:16
- Rob Kerrick: A lot of people when they bought homes back at the peak, they were thinking about how much money I'm gonna make and they were kind of oblivious to the fact that house prices can go down. You were just talking about that they could be down for longer. How does it affect your long term financial health if you sell a house for less than you paid? I mean, it was almost an unimaginable thing five years ago, but now very real for people who bought
- 11:36
- Rob Kerrick: at the peak.
- 11:36
- Roma Luzio: Yeah, for sure. I mean even people that are under underwater who owe more money than uh than their property is worth. So it it definitely has a long term financial impact. It's one of the risks of buying a rental property. It's a big investment. It's a lot different, you know, to to put ten thousand dollars into into a stock and have it go to zero compared to to buying
- 11:56
- Roma Luzio: a five hundred thousand dollar rental property and and having it go, you know, extremely south.
- 12:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 12:03
- Roma Luzio: you know, I I really think that that what people need to to do is uh again, take a look at where they are currently. Do they think there's a better path to financial security and a reduction of some of the stress that comes along with having a a a poor performing investment?
- 12:20
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 12:20
- Roma Luzio: is there a a better path selling, taking your losses, licking your wounds, and sort of moving forward?
- 12:26
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Or
- 12:26
- Roma Luzio: do you keep holding on and keeping holding on introduces other risks like vacancy, like interest rate increases, like repairs, like other things that could put you in a position where if market prices don't turn around, it's kind of like how long can you wait for market prices to improve?
- 12:47
- Roma Luzio: And and how much would you need them to improve to make some of those? risks of waiting worthwhile?
- 12:53
- Rob Kerrick: What about people who are uh who are in a principal residence that has fallen sharply in price and it's no longer a fit? Maybe it's a condo that's too tight and you're starting a family, maybe it's a starter house that you think you've really outgrown. Um, is it could it be a good move to sell that and try to move on? Or should you really just try to tough it out?
- 13:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Aaron Powell Look,
- 13:13
- Roma Luzio: I I think there's a case where for for selling and moving on. You know, the the good thing about prices going down is generally they go down across the the market. It's not like you'd be selling one house that's gone down in value and buying a a condo that's gone up in value. Now if you're doing a downsize, um obviously you know your
- 13:33
- Roma Luzio: property value may have decreased more on a dollar basis. There's a lot of transaction costs to buy and sell. I think that if somebody were going to make a move and do a modest downsize, I think you make it a permanent one as opposed to a temporary temporary one. You know, you take the position that look, this this property was more than we could have afforded. We did it on the
- 13:53
- Roma Luzio: basis that we're hoping for appreciation. We're going to be better able to hit our long-term retirement goals in a more modest home. And and let's make this move for for the long run and sort of improve our cash flow on a go forward basis. So again, I think it it needs to be something that's not knee-jerk, that's intentional, and that is part of a long term longer term plan.
- 14:13
- Rob Kerrick: What you're saying is an interesting idea because you know there's this idea of downsizing at the very end of your uh of your cycle when you're when you're done working and your kids have moved out, but you're saying there might be an argument for going from the big house, the big aspirational house to something more modest. Take the loss and put yourself in a more financially uh viable situation going forward.
- 14:31
- Roma Luzio: Mm-hmm. Yeah, I I think there are probably people that are mid-career in their 40s that that moved to a big home and thought part of their retirement plan would be, you know, significant appreciation and doing a downsize later. And some of those people might need to challenge themselves to say, boy, you know, do we bite off more than we can choose? Should we be moving to a more modest
- 14:51
- Roma Luzio: house, paying down debt more aggressively, freeing up cash flow to contribute to our RSPs and diversify into the stock market instead of just relying entirely on the home we live in and the city that that we're from? So I think there's a a case for that. Somebody sort of reimagining what's the best and easiest way to
- 15:11
- Roma Luzio: get to retirement. And then for those who are are in. into retirement and who thought they were going to downsize, I mean, that introduces a whole other challenge in this type of market.
- 15:21
- Rob Kerrick: How open-minded are people about this idea of fixing a mistake they made? I bought too much house, mortgage rates are going, I can't afford it, or or it doesn't fit me, whatever. They need to get out of it. Are people able to divorce themselves from this idea that homes are magic money machines and that if I just hold on, I'm going to make a lot of money. Are are minds
- 15:40
- Rob Kerrick: adjusting to this more uh tame reality in the housing market?
- 15:46
- Roma Luzio: I think slowly. It it takes a while when you know the last 30 years in a l in a lot of markets, you know, people have just been told that that real estate is is the way to financial security and success.
- 15:58
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 15:58
- Roma Luzio: I'm I'm seeing it starting, but I think there's two things that work against people.
- 16:03
- Roma Luzio: You know, people don't like to sell an investment, and and not that I would ever call a home that you live in an investment. It's just a place where you live. But a lot of people think of it that way. People don't like selling stuff for less than they purchased it for. And there's a lot of people that fixate on if I just get back to to break even. And
- 16:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I I try
- 16:20
- Roma Luzio: to discourage people from focusing on
- 16:22
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on
- 16:22
- Roma Luzio: that, focus on what it's worth today
- 16:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and you know,
- 16:25
- Roma Luzio: best best way forward. But I
- 16:26
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think there's
- 16:26
- Roma Luzio: a also a bit of
- 16:28
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 16:28
- Roma Luzio: pride,
- 16:29
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Rob,
- 16:30
- Roma Luzio: as well, that that some people are subject to that they don't want
- 16:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to,
- 16:35
- Roma Luzio: you know,
- 16:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): make
- 16:35
- Roma Luzio: it seem like they've failed. They don't want to
- 16:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): make
- 16:38
- Roma Luzio: it seem like they've not, you know, kept up with the Joneses and they need to downsize the
- 16:42
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 16:42
- Roma Luzio: big home uh
- 16:43
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
- 16:43
- Roma Luzio: order to move to something more modest. So
- 16:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): again, I think
- 16:45
- Roma Luzio: it's something that people need to challenge themselves on when they're evaluating life goals and and financial. security.
- 16:52
- Rob Kerrick: What are your thoughts on selling a home that no ver no longer fits financially and renting and moving back to renting? Is that is that a bad move? I mean, because you know, renting, although I mean more people are doing it and housing remains expensive for young people, it still does not have a great brand.
- 17:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Mm-hmm. Yeah,
- 17:08
- Roma Luzio: I would agree. I I think it it doesn't have a a great brand, but a lot of that comes from the the
- 17:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): real
- 17:13
- Roma Luzio: estate appreciating. appreciation appreciation we've seen over the last generation. I think
- 17:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that when you
- 17:18
- Roma Luzio: look at the cost of renting, the cost of renting generally is is lower than the cost of owning
- 17:22
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on a
- 17:23
- Roma Luzio: on a monthly basis. If you can um dedicate some of those monthly savings to investing, I think somebody can be a wealthy renter. And there are also markets
- 17:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um and
- 17:35
- Roma Luzio: even individual properties where the rent is relatively low. compared to the purchase price and to the cost of ownership, where there might be a financial arbitrage where a renter can come out ahead financially. I I think, you know, there's other drawbacks to to renting that, you know, you may not be able to decide what color you paint the walls and
- 17:55
- Roma Luzio: whether you do a renovation or even how long you can live there. So there's drawbacks certainly to to that, but from a financial perspective, I'm a financial planner. who's proud to say that, you know, renting is not a financial mistake.
- 18:08
- Jane: It's a financial choice like many others, and there can certainly be a place.
- 18:12
- Rob Kerrick: What about the idea of not giving up on my house? I'm going to move out of it and I'll find somewhere else to live. Maybe I'll move back in with the folks. Maybe I'll rent a place. And I'm going to rent out my place until the market improves. A lot of people think being a landlord is super easy. I mean, there was a this idea that you just bought a rental property. We're talking about that earlier. But what about taking this house that can't sell for
- 18:32
- Rob Kerrick: the price I want and just renting and pushing the sale down the block. Is it is is renting easy? Is that a a solution that you uh you think is worth considering?
- 18:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I look I
- 18:42
- Roma Luzio: think there's a case for it.
- 18:43
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I I think
- 18:44
- Roma Luzio: that if somebody goes in eyes wide open that tenants can sometimes not pay or be problematic and repairs can happen and damage can be done. I think there's a case for doing it. And there might even be a case for somebody,
- 18:55
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 18:56
- Roma Luzio: know, renting out a house that they can't comfortably afford and then moving into something smaller or renting
- 19:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on
- 19:02
- Roma Luzio: their own.
- 19:03
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 19:03
- Jane: I
- 19:03
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think
- 19:03
- Roma Luzio: that's certainly something that people should consider if they're finding their cash flows a little bit tight. But
- 19:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 19:08
- Roma Luzio: I would again be careful about uh doing it on the basis that well, real estate markets always turn
- 19:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): around and
- 19:14
- Roma Luzio: just wait until next spring and and that turnaround, if it doesn't happen, I think the strategy still needs to be a viable
- 19:20
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): one.
- 19:21
- Rob Kerrick: Speaking of the turnaround, um what is your sense of um what kind of price appreciation people should be looking at in the housing market over the next, let's say, ten plus years?
- 19:31
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well, it's
- 19:31
- Roma Luzio: interesting. When you when you look back at
- 19:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 19:34
- Roma Luzio: long-term data and particularly in the US,
- 19:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh there's
- 19:38
- Roma Luzio: research
- 19:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh or
- 19:40
- Roma Luzio: at least uh information available on US residential home prices going back to 1890. The data isn't nearly as robust or as uh long term here in Canada. But um as one might expect, real estate appreciation, residential real estate appreciation has been just slightly more than the rate of
- 19:59
- Roma Luzio: inflation, which kind of makes sense, you know. incomes go up with the rate of inflation or the cost of living. And over time, you know, real estate prices should sort of tie into incomes. And that's where Canada has uh just sort of gone ballistic over the course of the last uh generation, where incomes
- 20:19
- Roma Luzio: and real estate prices have been so far removed. And that's one of the reasons I continue to be sort of negative on on real estate uh markets. Um so I think in a in a normal situation, real estate should go up more or less in line with inflation and cost of living. And there's only two ways that we get back to a long-term trend where that happens in Canada.
- 20:39
- Roma Luzio: It's either real estate prices going down further from where they are here, or at least going sideways while incomes play catch-up. a catch up. Um because I don't think that's going to be income suddenly spiking to justify the cost. of homeownership.
- 20:52
- Rob Kerrick: We know that parents helped their kids buy homes five years ago at the peak of the market. I remember a report from CIBC talking about billions of dollars being transferred by boomers to their to their adult kids to help them get into the market. I'm curious, are you seeing any parents helping their homeowning
- 21:12
- Rob Kerrick: adult children afford their homes with especially like maybe subsidizing mortgage payments or other aspects of homeownership?
- 21:18
- Roma Luzio: It's such a good point, Rob, and I certainly have seen it happen. I've seen it happen where kids do need a secondary level of support. I've seen it happen where kids may not need a secondary level of support, but are not saving for retirement. You know, everything is is going towards just affording, you know, not even so much their
- 21:38
- Roma Luzio: overall. their lifestyle, but the the home that they're in in a lot of cases, where maybe they're being squeezed on their ability to take vacations, certainly squeezed on their ability to save for retirement. So I think you've got a lot of people that are living in homes that they they can't afford. And over the long run, I I think that has other implications too, where you'll have a a lot of people that uh not only
- 21:58
- Roma Luzio: choose to downsize, but need to downsize their home going into to retirement. So um between baby boomers, you know, downsizing and and passing away, um, and people who have no choice but to downsize their own home to retire, that puts a sort of a long term
- 22:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 22:15
- Roma Luzio: emphasis on certain types of sellers that are going to exist in the market over the long term.
- 22:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
- 22:21
- Rob Kerrick: know, there's two tracks that um people who are in unsuitable houses can take. There's the tough it out and there's the take action. Which do you lean towards when you're when you're dealing uh with this kind of thing with clients? Aaron
- 22:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell,
- 22:33
- Jane: you know,
- 22:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 22:34
- Roma Luzio: it's a good question. I I don't think there's a a right answer. I think it's uh look at things objectively, don't use emotion,
- 22:43
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): don't
- 22:43
- Roma Luzio: focus on advice
- 22:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): from
- 22:45
- Roma Luzio: your parents who just happen to buy real estate at the right
- 22:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): time. You know, try to tune out
- 22:51
- Roma Luzio: friends and family. Try to base it on your own situation, try to base that base it on
- 22:56
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): your own goals. Um, again,
- 22:58
- Roma Luzio: toughing it out if it means forgoing
- 23:01
- Roma Luzio: vacations with your kids, if it
- 23:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): means,
- 23:04
- Roma Luzio: you know, having stress with your spouse that may lead to a a divorce down the road. I mean, there's other drawbacks to to toughing it out in the in the conventional sense. that uh may not be worth it. So I think people need to evaluate all their options. That's the best way to approach any financial decision. There's no one size fits all answer,
- 23:25
- Roma Luzio: but certainly I think there's uh a lot of information being thrown at people that uh suggests that the real estate market is gonna magically turn around and again it may not.
- 23:33
- Rob Kerrick: In a sense I feel like young people who go out into the housing market and are really struggling with their houses now It's almost like someone needs to give them permission to think about selling or about moving out and renting it out. Can you do that? Can you give those young people permission to say, my house was a mistake and I need to take action about that right now?
- 23:53
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, I I'm I'm happy to. And as a financial planner, I am uh sitting here and and giving that advice that it's okay to make financial mistakes.
- 24:01
- Roma Luzio: Um, it's okay. to make financial mistakes that are big and small and recover from them. And I've worked with lots of uh very financially successful retired people who look back and recount some of those mistakes, serious mistakes that somehow they found a way to to overcome over time. So I don't think that uh
- 24:21
- Roma Luzio: people need to, you know, stay committed to a particular financial strategy or or decision simply just to to make it it work. It it's okay to make mistakes, it's okay to be honest about them. Uh again, you know, I think it's not a a terrible idea to rent, it's not a terrible idea to sell an investment at a loss. I
- 24:41
- Roma Luzio: think you really need to consider all factors and and again, personalize it to your own situation. Okay, Justin,
- 24:47
- Rob Kerrick: that's great. Is there anything
- 24:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 24:48
- Roma Luzio: want
- 24:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
- 24:49
- Roma Luzio: add? No, look, uh you know, I think that uh hopefully the the one good thing I I think that has come from this downturn in uh real estate prices, obviously there's lots of people who have been impacted in a negative way, which is quite unfortunate. But I think it's taken some of the wind out of the sales uh of the buy real estate because it's the only way to succeed financially, uh,
- 25:08
- Roma Luzio: crowd. Um real estate prices go up and down, as do stock markets, and I think uh people need to have a balance of of both. You need to live in a house that you can afford. You need to uh in invest in in stocks and take advantage of RSPs and TFSAs
- 25:23
- Jane: and you know, don't overcommit. You don't want to have one strategy that that you pursue be the be-all and end all of your financial success. Diversify your financial strategies the same way you would diversify your investments, and I think you're more likely to be successful over the long run, Rob.
- 25:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Rob,
- 25:41
- Roma Luzio: there's plenty of young homeowners out there who feel stuck in a property that no longer works for them. What are your takeaways?
- 25:48
- Rob Kerrick: One, don't get hung up on what you paid for your home. What matters now is what it's worth today, what you could afford, and what makes sense for your future. Two, 2. if you decide to rent your home out and become a landlord, it's not the end of the world. if your rental income doesn't cover all your expenses. But you do need to know how much it's costing you to
- 26:08
- Rob Kerrick: carry your home and whether you can afford to keep paying that difference. 3. It's okay to change your plans and adapt. Selling at a loss, downsizing, or going back to renting doesn't mean failure. Sometimes moving on is the smartest financial decision you can make.
- 26:25
- Roma Luzio: That's it for this. episode of Stress Test. This show was produced by Kyle Fulton, Zara Kozema, and Adidi Roy. Our executive producer is Kieran Rana. Thank you to Jane, Jason, and of course Rob for joining us.
- 26:40
- Rob Kerrick: You can find stress tests wherever you listen to podcasts. If you like this episode, please share it with your friends and subscribe so you never miss an episode.
- 26:48
- Roma Luzio: Next week on Stress Test, we're looking at the dark side of online gambling. Sports betting apps have made it easier than ever to place an online bet. But what starts as a bit of fun can turn into an addiction that can leave you deep in debt. We'll explore the financial toll of online gambling and why young men may be particularly
- 27:08
- Roma Luzio: vulnerable. Until then, find us at theglobeandmail.com. Thanks for listening.
- 27:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): This podcast is brought to you by CPP Investments. The CPP Fund is one of the top-performing pension funds in the world. That's something all Canadians can be proud of. Knowing that while you're working hard, the team managing the CPP fund is working hard too. With a long-term focus, they
- 27:41
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): bring the expertise needed to help ensure a strong foundation for your retirement. Learn more at cppinvestments.com.
More from Stress Test
AI told me to buy this stock. Should I?
Episode discussion: Hosts and guest discuss using AI chatbots for stock research and portfolio management, highlighting benefits and risks.
Speakers’ claims: Hosts Roma Luzio and Rob Kerrick interview 23-year-old investor Manin about his use of ChatGPT for stock research and emotional bias mitigation. Manin shares specific performance figures for holdings like AMD and Intel, though he attributes gains to market conditions rather than AI alone. Kerrick recounts an experiment where AI recommended stock-heavy ETFs, reflecting market bias rather than balanced strategy. The discussion emphasizes the need for hyper-specific prompting and fact-checking AI outputs. Speakers conclude that AI is a useful tool for information synthesis but cannot replace the behavioral coaching of human financial planners.
A baby or financial security: Who can still afford to have kids?
Episode discussion: StatsCAN data shows widening income gap in Canadian fertility rates; experts cite job security as key factor
Speakers’ claims: Hosts Roma Lutzu and Mira Raman discuss new Statistics Canada research indicating that the income gap between parents and non-parents is widening, with higher-income women more likely to have children. Guest Janine Rogan, a Chartered Professional Accountant, explains that public sector and unionized workers are more likely to have children due to job security, benefits, and pension contributions. The episode features case studies of individuals delaying parenthood due to financial constraints or prioritizing secure employment over higher pay. Rogan advises lower-income parents to minimize debt, utilize government benefits, and reduce costs through community sharing.