Stress Test

StatsCAN data shows widening income gap in Canadian fertility rates; experts cite job security as key factor

30 min Listen to the original Episode page
DemographicsPersonal FinanceCanadian EconomyLabor MarketFertility RatesPublic Policy

Summary

Hosts Roma Lutzu and Mira Raman discuss new Statistics Canada research indicating that the income gap between parents and non-parents is widening, with higher-income women more likely to have children. Guest Janine Rogan, a Chartered Professional Accountant, explains that public sector and unionized workers are more likely to have children due to job security, benefits, and pension contributions. The episode features case studies of individuals delaying parenthood due to financial constraints or prioritizing secure employment over higher pay. Rogan advises lower-income parents to minimize debt, utilize government benefits, and reduce costs through community sharing.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    research from Statistics Canada suggests money is playing an important role in who chooses to become a parent. Women from higher income households are much more likely to have children than women from lower income households. And what's notable is that gap is growing.

    Mira Raman · 0:52

  2. 2
    The decision also impacts a woman's career and her income, as well as the household's overall financial security.

    Roma Lutzu · 1:09

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 2:11

    Introduction and Statistics Canada Research

    Hosts Roma Lutzu and Mira Raman introduce the topic of whether financial security is a prerequisite for having children in Canada. They cite new Statistics Canada research indicating that the income gap between parents and non-parents is widening, with higher-income women more likely to have children.

  2. 2:11 – 7:43

    Case Study: Rachel's Financial Journey

    Rachel, a freelance artist in Toronto, shares her experience delaying parenthood due to low income ($40k/year) and debt. She eventually had a child with partner support, including family help paying off debt and car loans, but faces high childcare costs ($25/hr) that consume her part-time teaching income.

  3. 7:43 – 13:57

    Case Study: Lemise's Job Loss and Security Priorities

    Lemise, a mother in Brampton, Ontario, describes being laid off three months after returning from maternity leave. She prioritizes job security over higher pay, choosing a unionized university role over a higher-paying corporate job to avoid the risk of being fired without cause.

  4. 13:57 – 23:27

    Expert Analysis: Janine Rogan on Income and Security

    Chartered Professional Accountant Janine Rogan discusses the StatsCAN study, noting that public sector and unionized workers are more likely to have children due to job security, benefits, and pension contributions. She highlights the 'second shift' burden on women and how income allows for hiring help.

  5. 23:27 – 30:21

    Advice for Lower-Income Parents and Financial Readiness

    Rogan advises lower-income parents to use secondhand goods, carpool, and trade childcare with community members to reduce costs. She emphasizes filing taxes for benefits like CCMB and Canada Learning Bond, and recommends minimizing high-interest debt and forecasting cash flow for parental leave.

Claims worth verifying

Women from higher income households are much more likely to have children than women from lower income households, and the gap is growing.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·0:52

How to verify: Statistics Canada research cited in the episode; verify via Statistics Canada data releases on fertility rates by income quintile for the period 2026-08-03 to 2026-11-03. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Rachel earns about $40,000 a year as a freelance artist.

Roma Lutzu ·2:46

How to verify: Self-reported by subject Rachel Lutzu in the interview; verify via personal financial disclosure or tax filings if accessible. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Rachel pays $25/hour for a babysitter, totaling $4,500 since June.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·5:48

How to verify: Self-reported by subject Rachel in the interview; verify via personal budget records or bank statements. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Lemise received around $14,000 from employment insurance during her maternity leave.

Mira Raman ·8:27

How to verify: Self-reported by subject Lemise in the interview; verify via Employment and Social Development Canada (ESDC) records. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Lemise was laid off three months after returning from maternity leave.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·8:43

How to verify: Self-reported by subject Lemise in the interview; verify via employment records or HR correspondence. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Public sector workers and unionized workers are slightly more likely to have a child.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·16:35

How to verify: StatsCAN study cited in the episode; verify via Statistics Canada data on fertility rates by public sector employment status. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

This Is Moms at Work did a study showing an increase in moms being laid off while on maternity leave.

Mira Raman ·19:47

How to verify: This Is Moms at Work study; verify via the organization's published reports or press releases. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Canada's fertility rate increased briefly in 2021, concentrated among women in the highest income families.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·15:14

How to verify: StatsCAN study cited in the episode; verify via Statistics Canada fertility rate data for 2026 by income quintile. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Lemise could make $20,000 to $30,000 more in a corporate job than her current unionized university role.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·10:56

How to verify: Self-reported by subject Lemise in the interview; verify via job market salary surveys for marketing/communications roles in Ontario. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Unions help close the wage gap due to transparency.

Mira Raman ·16:59

How to verify: General economic claim; verify via academic literature or Statistics Canada data on wage gaps by unionization status. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the specific Statistics Canada study cited by checking the Statistics Canada website for data on fertility rates by income quintile.
  • Review the Canada Child Benefit (CCMB) and Canada Learning Bond eligibility criteria and application processes via the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) website.
  • Research average childcare costs in Toronto and Brampton using local government or industry reports to validate the $25/hour figure.
  • Check union contract details for public sector vs. corporate employment termination clauses to compare job security protections.
  • Analyze the tax implications of freelance income versus salaried employment for parental leave benefits using CRA calculators.
  • Look for counter-arguments or additional demographic factors (e.g., education level, urban vs. rural) that may influence fertility rates beyond income.
  • Verify Janine Rogan's credentials and any potential conflicts of interest with financial product providers.
  • Review Statistics Canada's methodology for defining 'household income' to ensure accurate comparison with personal financial situations.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Roma Lutzu: How much money do you need to have a kid these days?
0:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): For
0:04
Mira Raman: a growing number of Canadians, deciding whether to have a baby, let alone two or three, isn't just about wanting children. It's about whether they can afford to take that leap.
0:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Welcome
0:15
Roma Lutzu: to Stress Test, a personal finance podcast for millennials and Gen Z. I'm Roma Lutzu, a personal finance editor at the Globe and Mail.
0:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
0:24
Mira Raman: I'm Mira Raman, a personal finance reporter. at The Globe. Today we're asking are people having to choose between having a baby and being financially secure?
0:35
Roma Lutzu: Mira, when my husband and I decided to have kids, we talked about it and we knew it wasn't going to be cheap. We did some basic math, mostly around leave and childcare, and just kind of took the plunge. We figured we would make it work. But in the meantime, life in Canada has gotten way more. expensive.
0:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): New
0:52
Mira Raman: research from Statistics Canada suggests money is playing an important role in who chooses to become a parent. Women from higher income households are much more likely to have children than women from lower income households. And what's notable is that gap is growing.
1:08
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
1:09
Roma Lutzu: would-be The parents are looking at the big picture. Yes, there are the costs of having a baby, diapers, and daycare. but that's only part of the equation. The decision also impacts a woman's career and her income, as well as the household's overall financial security.
1:23
Mira Raman: We'll hear from two mothers who were hit hard by the cost of their first child and are now wondering if they can afford a second.
1:31
Roma Lutzu: And later, I'll speak with chartered professional accountant Janine Rogan about why a steady paycheck might matter as much as a big one. and what it really takes to feel financially ready.
1:42
Mira Raman: That's coming up after the break.
1:49
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): This podcast is brought to you by CPP Investments. For more than 25 years, CPP Investments has been investing the CPP fund to help more than 22 million Canadians in retirement. Learn more at cppinvestments.com.
2:11
Mira Raman: My name is Rachel. I'm 38 and I live in Toronto.
2:15
Roma Lutzu: Rachel is a freelance artist. She and her partner have a six-month-old son, but their journey to I parenthood need a parent who had started years earlier with an unexpected pregnancy when Rachel was 31.
2:26
Mira Raman: For me, it was like a an immediate, well, obviously I'm getting an abortion. Like this isn't even a decision, just because the finances of affording a kid at that particular point in my life was just made no sense. You know, I had a roommate. I wanted to feel
2:43
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): more kind of firm and secure in my own career.
2:46
Roma Lutzu: At the time, Rachel was working odd jobs and earning about $40,000 a year. She figured rent and childcare alone would eat up practically everything she made, and her partner had debt. They knew they wanted children eventually, but first, they needed to grow their earnings.
3:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yeah, I'm glad we waited. We both make more money now, and that's hugely helpful.
3:08
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): It took us a couple more years to get to a place where we felt arguable. arguably ready.
3:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
3:16
Roma Lutzu: Rachel had some pretty firm ideas about what being ready looked like. But now that she's a mom, she's reconsidering whether that was necessary.
3:24
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I was explicit that I needed a two-bedroom apartment minimum.
3:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): And living in Toronto, I have tons of friends who've had babies in one-bedroom one bedroom apartments. And they were always like, you know, you just make it work and it's okay. And da da da. And pre pregnancy, I would kind of nod my head and be like, that's nice for you. I'm absolutely not doing that. Like,
3:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): that just sounds horrible. They'd be like, you know, if we were in Brooklyn, we'd be carrying the stroller up five flights of stairs. And I'd be like, we're not in Brooklyn. But with this baby, the first six months of his life have been very oriental. oriented around our bedroom. We have a nursery for him. We've not gone on it that much.
4:08
Roma Lutzu: They now rent a three-bedroom apartment in Toronto for about $2,900 a month plus utilities. But getting to this point required significant help from both their families.
4:19
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): My partner's family was able to help him pay off the rest of his debt before our son was born. And also my mom was able to come and stay with us when our son was born, in terms of having just some extra support at home while I, you know, get used to my baby and figure out how to take care of him.
4:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Also, my mom helped us pay off our car so that we wouldn't have car payments also coming out of my partner's paychecks. And all of that together was a real kind of like family effort to help us realize parenthood that we knew we wanted in our life. So I'm
4:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I'm so grateful for that. I'm very aware of how much harder parenthood would be for us without those supports and how unfair it is that it is harder for people who don't have that help.
5:11
Roma Lutzu: Even with that support, the day-to-day costs of having a baby are adding. up. Rachel doesn't get maternity benefits as a freelancer, and her partner didn't take parental leave because his employer doesn't offer a top up. So she's kept working part-time, which means paying someone to look after their son.
5:28
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): We are hiring a babysitter. On average I'd say three days a week for three hours at a time for twenty $25 five dollars an hour, just to give me that time and space to do my work. You know, when we look at the practicalities of our budget, I think since June, the total is raking in right now at
5:48
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): $4,500 in terms of babysitter costs since then.
5:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
5:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): yeah, when you look at the budget, you're going, whoa, that's a lot of money to be bleeding. Also, um, today is a day uh we're speaking on a Thursday, and I teach at a school on Thursdays. But we have a babysitter all day today because both of us are working. And it kind of
6:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): basically, my hourly at the school is more or less all going to my babysitter. But for me, as a partial load instructor, it's worth that financial wash just to. stay on the roster and with that seniority.
6:30
Roma Lutzu: Rachel and her partner are now thinking about having a second child. They love being parents, but she knows another baby would stretch their finances even further.
6:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Again, when we just look at the numbers, isn't the most prudent decision. All that we What can kind of do right now in our lives is just to continue to be as like fiscally prudent as possible. we can be and figure out how to make more money, which I think is kind of the boat that a lot of people are in.
6:57
Roma Lutzu: The couple has considered moving somewhere cheaper, but Toronto is home. Their jobs are nearby, and most of their friends live there too. So for now, they're staying put. And despite their financial concerns, they're hoping to try for a second child before she turns forty.
7:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): My son's I said currently six months old. I'm still thirty eight. I don't I don't know how long like again we're kind of like if we can get pregnant again, you just never know. So we will
7:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): see if, you know, the the fertility gods are with us and kind of see what happens. But we I so far love being parents and would love to have like you know, a four-person family.
7:43
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Hi, my name is Lemise. I'm 31 years old and I live in Brampton, Ontario.
7:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
7:48
Mira Raman: you're a longtime stress test listener, you might remember Lemise. She's been on the podcast twice before.
7:55
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
7:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): mean, just recollecting my own trajectory on this stress dress test. When I first started, I talked about being anxious about having a child, financial planning that's required when it comes to children and the lifestyle changes. And then between that episode and the next,
8:09
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
8:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): got pregnant and had my son. Despite all the concerns I had, we kind of like we didn't address all of them, but we had our son. He is the light of our lives. We are so happy. We're so grateful we have him despite By any struggles that we may face. His one smile kind of makes everything just go away, all the bad things.
8:27
Mira Raman: Lemias took a year of maternity leave, during which she received around $14,000 from employment insurance. She was looking forward to getting back to work and earning her full salary again. But then, just three months after returning, something happened.
8:43
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): But then suddenly I just had a call that came up uh out of the blue, and on that call, it was HR and the person I reported to. And they just told me that unfortunately uh the relationship would be terminated. I wasn't giving any cause or anything. It was just framed as a business decision, but it rocked my world. I can't I can't
9:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): even articulate it. It was like the my footing had completely collapsed. Like the carpet was just pulled from under my feet. Everything that gave me validation was from my career, I realized.
9:14
Mira Raman: Lemia spent the next ten months looking for another job. She relied on employment insurance and took out a line of credit to help cover expenses. Her husband also took on a second job.
9:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): He
9:26
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): has a full-time job already, a nine to five, but he picked up a second job frying chicken wings because he wanted me to focus 100% percent on and finding the right job for me instead of picking up any other job. Add offers to work in retail again, um, go back to the mall, and he said you're not doing that.
9:43
Mira Raman: Losing her job also took a toll on how Lamise felt about herself as a mother and a partner.
9:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
9:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): felt constantly guilty, guilty, guilty about everything. I felt guilty about my birthday, I felt guilty about our anniversary, I felt guilty about taking anyone except my son out. And that kind of leached into psychological effects. My husband and I were bickering. We were both unhappy. I was placing a lot of pressure on him. I was placing it on myself. And this little
10:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): boy in front of me, who is happy playing with a tissue box, has no idea the life that his parents have envisioned for him.
10:19
Mira Raman: Eventually she found a role in marketing and communications at a university.
10:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): The way I value a job has changed. Before it was all about the money, the benefits, the luxuries it brings you. And now after becoming a parent and being fired after that, I value job security. I value walking into a workplace and not feeling like I'm going to throw up before I start my day.
10:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
10:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): this job provides me a lot of security because I'm part of a union. There's a lot provided through that. So I know that my days off are protected, the time that I work is protected.
10:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That
10:50
Mira Raman: security came at a price. Lemise says she could be making a lot more money in a corporate job.
10:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): This role is not compensated as generously as it would be in a corporate landscape. And I understand that, but I also understand that there are certain protections a union gives you that a corporate job cannot. So yes, you'll make 20 twenty to 30 thirty K more at the corporate job, but they can fire you whenever they want without cause or with cause, whatever they want to frame it at.
11:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Um but at a union, everything goes through a process. I have someone that's advocating between me and the faculty or between me and the staff and so on forth. So if I have any issues, I have someone to step up for me. And I think that security is a lot more important, whether I make how do I say this? I'd rather be stuck at a sixty, 60,000, seventy 70,000 thousand a
11:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): year paying job, knowing that I'm still gonna. get that money at the end of the day, versus working like a donkey staring at her carrot in front of me for a hundred K and I know they can let me go anytime.
11:49
Mira Raman: And all of this has changed their timeline for having another child. Originally, Lemise and her husband wanted their kids to be about two years apart. So when their son's second birthday approached, she brought it up again.
12:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I just wanted to just get
12:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): away.
12:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): a temperature check here. He's like, Absolutely not. I want another one, but I need more time. And you would think he was the one that birthed the baby. But I get it. We've been through a lot in this time.
12:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
12:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think he's also realizing that we don't have to be in any rush. Like we're the only ones in our friend group that have a kid, so we're good. We're happy. We're fine.
12:25
Mira Raman: Lamy says money still makes her nervous, but she's also learned that a second child doesn't necessarily mean starting from scratch. And that feeling ready is about more than having a bigger paycheck. Here's her message to those in a similar situation.
12:42
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Any parents that are listening, like moms that are listening, dads, like invest in yourselves. It makes you healthier and it makes you a better parent. Like if you're more fulfilled as a person, you will be able to pour back into other people. It's not a bunch of hogwash, like it's very true. So again, like budgeting for me to go to Pilates, for us to see movies, to go to concerts if we can't travel
13:02
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): right now. That's really the major hit. But when it comes to having a child, I've learned so much from having the first one that the second And one, God willing, when the time comes, will we'll be able to tackle it.
13:13
Mira Raman: After the break, Rome. Roma speaks with Janine Rogan, a chartered professional accountant and the author of The Pink Tax, about how financial readiness can look very different from one family to another.
13:29
Roma Lutzu: This podcast is brought to you by CPP Investments. You may not think about your retirement
13:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): every day,
13:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
13:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): while you're hard at work, CPP Investments is working for you by investing and helping grow the CPP Fund for Canadians today and for generations to come. Learn more at cppinvestments.com.
13:57
Roma Lutzu: Calgary-based Janine Rogan is a chartered professional accountant and founder of the Wealth Building Academy. She's also a mom of two. When we spoke, her youngest joined us to say hello.
14:09
Mira Raman: And this is little Miss Adeline. She is one month old. Oh
14:14
Roma Lutzu: my goodness, one month. How's it going?
14:16
Mira Raman: It's going. She's up obviously a lot during the night, but she as long as she's snuggled close to me, she's pretty good.
14:23
Roma Lutzu: Taking me back. I love it. Enjoy every second. Thank
14:26
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you.
14:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Pretty
14:27
Roma Lutzu: soon they'll be calling you from university asking for money.
14:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, exactly.
14:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
14:33
Roma Lutzu: why don't we jump in here and talk about the day's news here? There's a recent StatsCAN study that I want to dig in with you. Uh it came
14:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): out
14:42
Roma Lutzu: last month. I'm always excited when there's official government data that we can talk about. It found that women in higher income families are more likely to have a first baby. than women in lower income families. And that seems obvious. But what's interesting is that that gap has widened substantially in the last decade. And I'm not sure if you also remember reading about a pandemic baby
15:01
Roma Lutzu: bump, but this study found that this was mostly an affluent family phenomenon. So Canada's fertility rate did increase briefly in 2021, but the increase is concentrated among women in the highest income families.
15:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Is how
15:14
Roma Lutzu: having kids increasingly something only wealthier Canadians can afford?
15:19
Mira Raman: I think when you look at the demands
15:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on
15:22
Mira Raman: women
15:22
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
15:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): terms
15:23
Mira Raman: of
15:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): what's going on in their
15:24
Mira Raman: careers, and and you know, obviously we want women to have their choice, whether they want to stay at home or whether they want to go back into the workforce. But for women who are focused on wanting to have a career, I think when you're in that higher income echelon, you have the ability to hire for help. Uh, so whether that's, you know, hiring grocery
15:44
Mira Raman: delivery or a cleaning in your house, I think being able to offload some of that makes it easier or makes it maybe feel easier to have a second kid or to have a first kid to begin with, because we've seen time and time again, right, women are expected to kind of do that second shift. more often than their male
16:04
Mira Raman: counterparts. They they work all day and then they're the ones being called for sick pickups or when there's a PD day, which I have a another child who's in the school system and
16:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there
16:15
Mira Raman: it feels like there's a PD day every single week. Um and when that is kind of more fallen on one parent, I think it can feel overwhelming to then add a second child to that. So how having more income allows them to be able to maybe hire a part-time help or in some cases hire a full-time nanny to be able to kind of run the household as well.
16:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Let's
16:35
Roma Lutzu: go back to the stats-can study. One of the things that I thought was super interesting about it was that they found that public sector workers were slightly more likely to have a child, as well as unionized workers. That suggests that things like job security and stability, benefits, pen. pension, predictable, perhaps more family-friendly working
16:55
Roma Lutzu: condition matter to parents to be. Does that line up with what you're seeing?
16:59
Mira Raman: Absolutely. And we know that unions actually help close the wage gap, regardless, obviously, of whether or not there's kids, because there is that transparency. So when we have unions or government or public sector jobs involved, we know that people are able to contribute to their retirement and have a decent matching
17:19
Mira Raman: policy. We know that the benefits are gonna be fairly strong, maybe compared to some of the smaller companies people might work for in the private sector where they might not have as as much access to benefits. Um, 'cause even like I'm thinking back to my sister and I growing up, we both needed braces and that's a few thousand dollars each.
17:39
Mira Raman: So not having benefits that cover that, that's an additional expense that's put on to parents. Um, I think also the piece about job security and having the ability for that union to kind of advocate on your behalf. Um, in Canada, you can let someone go um without cause just because they're not like a cultural
17:59
Mira Raman: fit. And I think, you know, we have seen especially with the kind of the rise of tech, that happening more and more often. I feel like every other week there's a headline that's like X company has laid off 10% of their workforce. There was the financial company here in Calgary that just did that um within the last month. And when you don't know whether or not
18:19
Mira Raman: that's going to be you and you You um are thinking about having kids or maybe you have been let go and it's taking you a long time to get a job. that can put a lot of financial strain on the family. And that might cause them a little bit of pause. I don't think there's necessarily a right time to have children, but or I think there is a better time. And I think most people would
18:39
Mira Raman: agree, usually when you're employed, um, having some sort of income is important. And then also being able to qualify for EI, you need a certain number of hours to actually be able to get. that EI benefit from the government while you're on maternity or parental leave.
18:56
Roma Lutzu: How would the experience of someone who's on a leave after having a child who's a private sector worker? How would that potentially be more stressful than someone who's a public sector worker?
19:07
Mira Raman: Yeah. So depending on kind of what's mandated in their maybe their benefits or their work package for top-up, um, that can really impact. how much income someone has coming in. Um, I feel like that's a whole other conversation around why we take income away from parents when they're kind of at one of the most vulnerable times in their life with a lot of
19:27
Mira Raman: added expenses. I think there's that. And I think that you can also, I know people say like you can't be fired while you're on maternity leave, and and that is true, but we do also see, I think um, there's an organization. called This Is Moms at Work that did a study to show that there is an increase of of moms actually being laid off while they're
19:47
Mira Raman: on maternity leave. And the companies are kind of just saying like, oh, it's restructuring or it it's not due to the fact that you're on leave, but there is a higher instance of women that are on maternity leave or have just come back from that leave being kind of pushed out of companies. So I think that's obviously definitely a stressful situation, right? That
20:07
Mira Raman: is income that you want. I know for myself, I was passed over for promotion once I told them I was pregnant while I was on leave. And then the year I came back from my leave within a corporation. And um that was super frustrating because then that was, you know, three years of income that could have been earned at a higher, higher level
20:27
Roma Lutzu: And then imagine you're a parent to be and you're weighing that, a mother thinking, Am I going to take more time off to have a second child? How many more years behind am I going to be? And how much is this going to be held against me?
20:39
Mira Raman: Absolutely. And we know that, you know, when women have babies and then they come back from work or come back from leave, pardon me, um, oftentimes their managers look at them differently, right? They they don't ask if they want the opportunity to travel or go on the project that maybe will help them uh and propel them to the next level because they just
20:59
Mira Raman: assume that they're they're busy and it's kind of that um inherent bias that we see in in the workforce. And then, you know, when you're on leave, you're maybe not contributing to your pension or your your retirement um contributions. And so that is also putting you behind both from a government standpoint for CPP, and then
21:19
Mira Raman: also if you have like a private matching RRSP or pay attention within your workforce, you're maybe not contributing to that as well.
21:27
Roma Lutzu: I have uh two kids. Uh one is in rep soccer, the other played very competitive volleyball. They both at time had some tutors, they both at time took music. lessons. Many of the things that's around having kids are very expensive. Do you think
21:46
Roma Lutzu: expectations around parenting have gotten out of hand? There's all this pressure to spend all this money to expose them to all these things. And that's not inherently bad, but it it does make everything around having a child uh significantly more. expensive than it was a generation or two ago.
22:06
Mira Raman: Oh yeah. I think back to like the 90s when I grew up and it was like summers were like go to your friend's house and whoever's friends had parents over would kind of be watching the kids. And but I I do think that there is a lot of expectations that it's like they do genetics and soccer and swimming, and the conversations and and the parent groups I run in are like
22:26
Mira Raman: what activities. is this kid doing for spring summer? And what are they doing for fall? And how can we coordinate? And I think there absolutely is that expectation. And obviously, also when they're young, there is an expectation that you're maybe buying kind of the top of the line things for your kid, uh, especially when they're little. You know,
22:46
Mira Raman: I even think about car seats from a safety perspective, right? If you're not buying the top car seat, then are you doing the best thing for your kid and are are they in the most safe car seat? And I think there absolutely is a marketing perspective here. They've done a really good job, the baby industry and the market and the wedding industry. Marketers have figured out how to play on people's emotion to make sure that, you know,
23:06
Mira Raman: they're able to get, I guess, top dollar from everyone.
23:10
Roma Lutzu: It's obviously also possible to have a child or children if you're not a high earner. What are some pieces of advice you have for people that are that are, you know, hoping to have a family that are want to have a child that are not huge earners?
23:27
Mira Raman: Yeah, I think there are definitely ways of of doing it without, you know, spending, like I said, kind of top dollar on everything. I think, you know, buying stuff secondhand is a fantastic approach because a lot of the stuff doesn't get used and is almost like new when you're when you're looking to buy some of those things. Um so
23:47
Mira Raman: whether it's Facebook Marketplace or a um from a friend or used consignment stores for kids' clothes, I think that those are great ways to reduce uh the costs associated with having kids. But I think also, you know, the big one is leaning on community. Like are there ways that you can carpool or, you know, on
24:06
Mira Raman: PD days, instead of hiring um someone to come and watch your kids, maybe, you know, you find another family where you can kind of trade PD days to to take care of the kids. And oftentimes I at least find when there's, you know, my son with one of his friends, uh, they often go play and and do things and I'm able to
24:26
Mira Raman: answer a couple of emails uh without having to entertain both of them. So I think leaning on community to help with some of those things is also really important and you don't have to necessarily do it all on your own and that can, you know, really reduce the costs, I think. Um, again for s like if we're looking at summer, is there a way that, you know, you can kind of
24:46
Mira Raman: coordinate with another family so that it's not all on you to find eight weeks of of camp for your kid and and see if there's someone that you guys can trade weeks um so that you have a couple of weeks covered. So I would say those would probably be really great places to start. Obviously there are also
25:06
Mira Raman: government benefits that come with lower income individuals. So making sure that you file in your taxes on time so that you can get you know CC CCB, or if you um qualify for the Canada Learning Bond within your RESP, having that available to you can also help with those RESP contributions. So again, you don't have to come up with all of
25:26
Mira Raman: that money on your own.
25:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
25:27
Roma Lutzu: StatsCAN study also found that most Canadians still want kids. So s outside of you know, the emotional uh readiness, the physical readiness, your relationship. stability, you know, or if you decide to do it alone, what are some financial signs that you see that signal someone is ready to have a
25:47
Roma Lutzu: child?
25:48
Mira Raman: Yeah, I think for me and for the people that I speak with, you know, minimizing I think the amount of fixed expenses or fixed costs that people have during a month and I'll really like kind of hone in on on debt outside of like maybe your mortgage and maybe student loans. Like if you have some high interest debt or higher interest debt, I think that can really take a
26:08
Mira Raman: big chunk out of your paycheck and it can financially stress people out, especially when they know that their income could be impacted. So getting rid of that, um paying that off can absolutely um be helpful for people. But I would also say that we do need to also give ourselves a little bit of grace that, you know, the first couple of years, it can be really expensive with
26:28
Mira Raman: daycare and and and and costs associated with that. And so if you have to scale back your retirement contributions a little bit, I think that that's okay. And it's it's not gonna be the end of the world.
26:39
Roma Lutzu: Okay. Any pieces of advice for anyone's that's listening to this pod who's thinking, okay, this is something that I think I want to do, what steps should I take?
26:49
Mira Raman: Well, you know, I'm a big fan of a spreadsheet. So I always really think that getting to getting really intimate and knowing your numbers is important. I think you can kind of forecast out or plan out what you think it will look like. Obviously, understanding that nothing ever goes 100% according to
27:09
Mira Raman: plan. But I think once you know the numbers and you know kind of what you're looking at, it can make it feel less dark. daunting from a financial perspective. And then giving yourself some grace that no matter what, you're probably going to go over your budget in one category or another. You know, you buy the wrong type of diaper or
27:29
Mira Raman: you have to hold a spot in daycare for an additional month and and those costs are Or just something you kinda kind of have to eat. And that is gonna be okay long term.
27:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So,
27:39
Mira Raman: Roma, after hearing from Lemise, Rachel, and Janine, what is the verdict? Can only wealthier Canadians afford to have kids?
27:48
Roma Lutzu: Well, to back up a bit, we should acknowledge that having a child is a huge decision on many levels. Physically, emotionally, mentally. Having more household income, or at least enough money so you don't have to stress, certainly makes things easier.
28:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
28:03
Roma Lutzu: I think what really stood out to me from today's discussions is that it's not just about how much you earn, it's about how secure you feel. And that brings us to my three takeaways. One, a steady paycheck can be as reassuring as a big one. Job security, benefits, and parental leave policies can all make a difference when you're
28:22
Roma Lutzu: deciding whether to have a child. Two, having kids doesn't have to mean buying. everything or doing everything. There's a lot of pressure to spend on the best baby gear, bigger home, and pricey activities. But you can keep costs down by leaning on your community, buying secondhand gear, and being realistic about what your family needs.
28:42
Roma Lutzu: Three, while there's no magic number that means you're financially ready, consider the big costs by planning for lost income during parental leave, child care fees. and higher food and housing costs. But understand that there's also a limit to how much you can prepare. Sometimes having a baby means accepting a little uncertainty, financially and otherwise.
29:03
Mira Raman: That's it for this episode of stress test. This show was produced by Kyle Fulton, Zaro Kozema, and Aditi Roy. Our executive producer is Kieran Rana.
29:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank
29:13
Mira Raman: you to Lemise, Rachel, and Janine for joining us. You can
29:16
Roma Lutzu: find Stress Test wherever you listen
29:19
Mira Raman: to podcasts. If
29:20
Roma Lutzu: you like this episode, please share it with your friends and subscribe so you never miss an episode.
29:25
Mira Raman: Next week on Stress Tests, we're asking: should you trust AI to pick your stocks? We'll speak to young Canadians who are using chatbots to help them build and manage investment portfolios. Until then, find us at theglobandmail.com. Thanks for listening.
29:48
Roma Lutzu: This podcast is brought to you by CPP Investments. The CPP Fund is one of the top performing pension funds in the world. That's something all Canadians can be proud of. Knowing that while you're working hard, the team managing the CPP fund is working hard too. With a long-term focus, they
30:08
Roma Lutzu: bring the expertise needed to help ensure a strong foundation for your retirement. Learn more at cppinvestments.com.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Stress Test

All insights