Dave Hall argues that inflation, taxes, and behavioral biases make the traditional 4% withdrawal rule inadequate for modern retirees.
Summary
Dave Hall discusses why millionaires often feel financially insecure in retirement, citing inflation's erosion of purchasing power and the inadequacy of the traditional 4% withdrawal rule. He argues that taxes frequently become the largest expense for retirees with paid-off homes, making Roth conversions and IRMAA planning critical. Hall advocates for purpose-driven investing, where assets are allocated to specific goals rather than treated as a single pool. He also emphasizes that financial confidence stems from comprehensive planning and behavioral coaching, not just investment returns.
Key takeaways
- 1 Because of inflation continuing to erode at that million dollars, the buying power of a million dollars today is not what it was 10, 20, or 30 years ago.
Dave Hall · 1:41
- 2 Effective retirement planning requires assigning specific purposes to different portions of a portfolio (e.g., safety vs. growth), similar to how a home requires different tools and materials for different rooms, rather than treating all assets as fungible.
Dave Hall · 4:30
- 3 with a little bit of extra income. It's not a gradual increase, it's a cliff. You go over a dollar, you could be paying thousands of extra dollars.
Dave Hall · 9:14
- 4 Far too many people live in underwhelming retirement in an effort to pr preserve the assets, only to give all of that money to children who then go do all the things you should have gone and done because they've they don't have those same worries and concerns that you had during your retirement year.
Dave Hall · 11:55
Episode sections
- 0:09 – 2:21
Introduction and Inflation Impact
Dave Hall introduces the show and the topic of why millionaires feel financially insecure in retirement. He explains that inflation has eroded the buying power of a million dollars compared to 10, 20, or 30 years ago, making it insufficient for a comfortable lifestyle without proper planning.
- 2:21 – 4:30
Behavioral Challenges and Withdrawal Rates
Speakers discuss the difficulty retirees face in transitioning from saving to spending after a lifetime of frugality. Hall notes that many lack a safe withdrawal rate, referencing a shift from the traditional 4% rule to a 4.7% rule, which he argues is flawed because it relies on averages rather than individual circumstances.
- 4:30 – 5:50
Asset Allocation and Purpose-Driven Investing
Hall argues that money often lacks a specific purpose, leading to poor performance. He uses a home-building analogy to illustrate that different funds require different 'tools' (asset classes) to achieve specific goals, rather than treating all money as a single pool.
- 5:50 – 9:34
Market Fear and Tax Burdens
The discussion covers the fear of market crashes and the significant impact of taxes on retirees. Hall identifies taxes as a primary expense for many millionaires, suggesting Roth conversions in early retirement to mitigate future tax liabilities and avoid the IRMAA cliff.
- 9:34 – 14:34
Unpredictable Expenses and Wealth Preservation
Hall advises against worrying about uncontrollable events like politics or long-term care, advocating instead for proactive planning. He distinguishes between preserving wealth for legacy and protecting retirement income, warning against depleting personal funds to bail out children.
- 14:34 – 21:55
Legacy Obligations and Financial Confidence
Referencing the book 'Die With Zero', Hall argues there is no obligation to leave money to children if it compromises one's own retirement security. He concludes that financial confidence comes from comprehensive planning and behavioral coaching, not just asset management or chasing high returns.
Claims worth verifying
The buying power of a million dollars today is significantly less than it was 10, 20, or 30 years ago due to inflation.
Dave Hall ·1:41
How to verify: Check US Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI inflation calculator comparing 1990s/2000s to present. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The safe withdrawal rate has shifted from the traditional 4% rule to a 4.7% rule.
Dave Hall ·3:51
How to verify: Search for recent financial literature or studies citing a '4.7% rule' for retirement withdrawals. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Taxes are often the largest expense for millionaires in retirement, surpassing housing and healthcare.
Dave Hall ·7:15
How to verify: Review IRS data on retiree tax burdens or studies from AARP/Merrill Lynch on retirement expenses. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The IRMAA cliff for Medicare premiums is a 'cliff' effect where a small income increase triggers thousands in extra premiums.
Dave Hall ·9:14
How to verify: Check CMS.gov for IRMAA income thresholds and premium brackets for the current year. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The host holds a Personal Financial Specialist (PFS) designation from the ICPA.
Dave Hall ·18:34
How to verify: Search the ICPA (Institute for Certified Public Accountants) directory for Dave Hall's credentials. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThe book 'Die With Zero' argues there is no obligation to leave money to children if it compromises retirement security.
Dave Hall ·14:34
How to verify: Read 'Die With Zero' by Bill Perkins or review its summary on major book retailer sites. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
AlphaStar Capital Management, LLC is an SEC registered investment advisor.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·21:11
How to verify: Search the SEC Investment Adviser Public Disclosure (IAPD) website for AlphaStar Capital Management. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceRetirement Risk Advisors offers fixed insurance products.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·21:31
How to verify: Check the company's website or state insurance department licensing records for Retirement Risk Advisors. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The speaker predicts a decline in pure asset managers in favor of planners.
Dave Hall ·18:14
How to verify: This is a forward-looking opinion/claim; verify by tracking industry trends in RIA (Registered Investment Advisor) business models over the next 5-10 years. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Social Security COLA increases can push retirees into higher tax brackets or IRMAA cliffs.
Dave Hall ·8:55
How to verify: Calculate Social Security taxation rules and IRMAA thresholds using IRS Publication 915 and CMS guidelines. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceDo your own research
- Verify current inflation rates using the Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI data to assess purchasing power erosion.
- Review IRS Publication 590-B for current Required Minimum Distribution (RMD) rules and age requirements.
- Check Medicare.gov for current IRMAA income thresholds and premium brackets for the relevant tax year.
- Analyze personal tax brackets to determine if Roth conversions are feasible during early retirement years with lower income.
- Consult a fiduciary financial planner to model a purpose-driven asset allocation strategy tailored to specific retirement goals.
- Read 'Die With Zero' by Bill Perkins to understand the author's perspective on legacy obligations versus lifetime enjoyment.
- Review Social Security Administration statements to project future benefits and their taxability.
- Assess healthcare cost projections using the Employee Benefit Research Institute (EBRI) Healthcare Cost Index.
Full transcriptexpand
0:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Welcome to the Retirement Risk Show, the best retirement interviews and advice with Dave Hall. Learn strategies to help you reduce and even eliminate the risks facing your retirement.
0:21Dave Hall: Hello, welcome to today's show. My name is Dave Hall. I am your host. This is the show, where we're we help you navigate the risk you'll face in retirement. If you would like to learn more about what myself and my team can do to help you mitigate the risks that you will face during the longest self-imposed period of unemployment many of you will have in your lifetime, then go to my website, retirementriscadvisors.com. Here you'll be able to get access to our tools, to the webinars we teach, our blogs, as well as our calendar, so you can schedule a no-fee consultation to sit down and learn more about what we can do to help you get safely through those retirement years. For today's show, we're going to be talking about 10 reasons why those retirees with a million dollars may still feel broken broke in retirement. Hard to believe if we look back historically that. most people, if they'd ever thought of having a million dollars going into retirement, they would have assumed they'd hit the lottery. They would have assumed they had plenty of money to get them through the retirement years. What we're finding is that is no longer the case, and I want to cover 10 different topics of why that is. Number one, a million dollars is not what it used to be. Something we all need to remember as we look at money is. that what was a million dollars to us
1:41maybe 10, 20, 30, especially 40 years ago, if you go back when you were a younger individual, is not what it is today. Because of inflation continuing to erode at that million dollars, the buying power of a million dollars today is not what it was 10, 20, or 30 years ago. It also is not what it's going to be 10, 20, or 30 years into the future. As a result, some someone going into retirement with a million dollars is looking at a 20, 30, 40-year future and understanding that maybe what they think they have is not what they have, especially as it relates to lifestyle and what they may want to do with that money. Number two, they've spent their entire life saving, not spending. This is not just millionaires. This is all of us that can end up in this bucket. But if you have a million dollars in retirement, you obviously did something right to accumulate that money. You were setting money aside for most of you anyway. Some of you maybe had a parent pass away and inherited those funds. But for most people, they spent their life saving. They they nickel and dined things. They had a budget. They stood very close to what it was going to require Required to build those assets. As a result, when they get into retirement and now need to flip the switch to turn them on.
2:51it can become very difficult for people to do that. This is why we believe behavioral coaching is so important as part of a well thought out retirement plan, because it gives them the ability to have permission to spend, to be in a position to where they can start liquidating those assets, and it can and it is okay. That was what the purpose was. Many times we will sit down with people, especially during the initial years of the retirement where spending is so high and they get overly concerned that they're they need to go back to work. They can't keep doing this, forgetting that that was the purpose of the money and the plan still works, that everything's gonna be just fine. They need to follow the plan in order to do that. Number three, they don't know how much they can safely spend. Another big problem if you're not doing any type of planning. you have no idea what the distribution rate should be. In our last show, we talked about the 4% rule, which is now the 4.7% rule, and the problems it brings into retirement because it's an average of something that's being calculated based upon facts and circumstances that are not your facts and circumstances. The same thing can happen here as we get into retirement, dealing with the same problem that we don't know what. that number is unless we're doing some type of planning, unless we're putting things in place to where that's being calculated, so then we
4:10can see how the money is going to play out. How's it looking to be able to spend that money as well as the growth that's happening inside of there to get the account to continue to work over those decades of retirement? Number four, money is invested, but it doesn't have a purpose. Something that I talk about all the time. One of the biggest problems I see with retirements out there is that people are not spending the time to figure out what they need their money to do. They assume, because they have money available, that it's all going to be able to work for whatever it is they're trying to accomplish, not realizing that there are different parts of retirement that money needs to do different things for. No different than if you were building a custom home and you were uh laid out the blueprint, you have everything designed, and then your contractor shows up with a a hammer and a shovel. You look at him saying, What what are you doing? He says, Well, I'm building your house. I'm going to use these two tools to make everything happen. That that seems It crazy that you would do that, but that's what many people are trying to do with their the retirement. They're not gonna getting the tools they need and the resources structured correctly to allow them to get the results that they're trying to achieve. As a result, just as with the house, if the wrong tools are used, you're not going to get the same performance. You can also look at it in building a home
5:30that certain dollars need to go to certain things. And most of us are going to allocate accordingly. You're not going to take a million dollar house and then put 900. $900,000 into the bathroom. You've got to have bedrooms and kitchens and living rooms and all these other things. We're going to allocate that money out by job so that we know in the end we're getting the house that we want, that we haven't missed something, that we're ensuring that we have the available resources that we need to make things happen the way that we're expecting them to happen. Number five, they're afraid of the next market. crash. Something that we all struggle with. None of us like to see our money go backwards. We all like to see growth of our portfolios. The those with a million dollars are no different. As a result, many people are always setting out there if they haven't defined a purpose to their money, wondering what is the next, when's the next shoe gonna fall? When are we gonna have the next problem? And what impact is that going to have on
6:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the next one?
6:27Dave Hall: success of my retirement? This is a valid concern for many people if the planning has not been done to lay out the funds correctly to get them in a position where they need to be, because without any planning or guidelines, you don't know what the impact of that's going to be. You don't know how long that downturn may last and what impact it can have in an environment where you're probably by that point on some form of fixed income. You've got Social Security coming in, maybe there's pension, annuity, something else, but you're not really going not wanting to go back to work. You're not getting money from work. As a result, there's very few options to increase that income if things don't work out the way that you'd hoped, but you can end up in a much worse position than what you would expected. Number six, taxes make them feel poorer than their account statements suggest. So much truth to this statement, not only for those who have over a million dollars, but to each of us as we look at our retirement. Taxes become one of the biggest expenses for many retirees. Those who have over a million dollars of saved asset, for many of them, for sure, it's going to be one of their largest
7:35expenses because many of those will have their homes paid for. Therefore, housing's not going to be the expense it was. Healthcare may be getting up there close to it, but taxes typically are going to be the biggest expense. As a result, you go into a position to where you're getting your money out of the account, maybe you're pulling forty or fifty thousand dollars out, putting it with your Social Security, and finding that you still owe ten or fifteen thousand dollars in taxes or more, depending on your situation. and facts and circumstances, all of a sudden that money's making you feel very poor because that's money that you're giving away out of the hard earned assets that you accumulated that you're not seeing any direct benefit from. Doesn't mean that we aren't getting benefit from taxes. There's so many great things that come into our lives because we do pay taxes, but we're not seeing the immediate benefit to our overall retirement. This is why we recommend for so many people to do Roth conversions while you can to get that cost out of the way in the early years of your retirement before taxes go up, before the portfolio gets any bigger, and before your tax situation gets more complex. Unfortunately, as we get into retirement, it can become very complex trying to navigate the various tax situations situation that you have. happen to be in and the income that's sometimes forced upon
8:55you through required minimum distributions or Social Security amounts where you've got a COLA increase, which most of us are very happy for, but that's going to increase your taxes. You happen to be on the the edge of a Irmacliff for the income-related Income related monthly adjustment amount for Medicare. You happen to be on there and you end up with a little bit of extra income. It's not a gradual increase, it's a cliff. You go over a dollar, you could be paying thousands of extra dollars. Taxes are a big deal. That's a big problem for many people, especially if you've accumulated it in a tax-deferred or a taxable bucket. Number seven, they worried about the expenses they cannot predict. This is something that uh unfortunately far too many people spend their lives uh focusing on are the things that they cannot control. If you look even in your own life right now and c contemplate the things that you're worrying about, how many of those can you truly determine the outcome of? Take for example our political situation right now. A lot going on, a lot of uh anxiety out there for a lot of people. Now, yes, your vote can count to helping people in your local community, across the state, uh, maybe across the country, get in positions, but your vote alone is not going to do that. Does not
10:14mean that we shouldn't stop, but it also doesn't mean we should worry about outcomes that we cannot have any control over. We can't change what other people do, the election process they go through. What we've got to do is do a our best to live in accordance with the rules and the guidelines that we have to allow us to enjoy our lives in the best possible manner, realizing that a lot of what you're watching and following on the news, those things are never going to impact you individually. Turn off the news. Get into a position where you're not always worried about these things. Same thing in retirement. Yes, we're going to have some expenses that we don't expect. Many of us are going to have some type of long-term care expense that can be hundreds of thousands of dollars. We don't worry about it. We plan for it. We put ourselves in a position to where we can make better decisions because we were willing to put forth some effort in the beginning to protect ourselves when those things happen. I've shared my story many times about being in Puerto Rico, but getting a concrete home, putting food and
11:15water in our garage, putting money in our house in an effort to prepare for things that I didn't want to have to worry about always happening. Yes, a hurricane's not fun. I don't ever want to go through it again. I have a lot of empathy for those who do, but we don't want to spend our whole lives afraid that that's going to happen and worry and stress without realizing that we can put ourselves in a position where we do not have to do that at the level that unfortunately many people do when they don't put in a plan to help solve those issues. Number eight, they confuse preserving wealth with protecting their retirement. Going back a little bit to what we talked about before with the side of not being willing to spend. Again, if we look at preserving wealth, what is the purpose of that? One of the things that we've got to ask ourselves for each one of us, what are we preserving that for? Far too many people live
12:15in underwhelming retirement in an effort to pr preserve the assets, only to give all of that money to children who then go do all the things you should have gone and done because they've they don't have those same worries and concerns that you had during your retirement year. So when we look at it for ourselves, don't just preserve the assets to preserve the assets. Yes. If we need to protect a future risk, if we need to have money for a future legacy that we're trying to achieve, yes, we want to protect those assets, but not at the cost of our overall retirement success. And true retirement success. is being able to spend the money you want to spend, live the life you want to live, and know that you're doing the best that you possibly can for yourself and the loved ones you care about during those retirement years. It's not giving up on everything that you had for hopes and dreams, for fear you may not have anything left to give to someone else. Retirement is for ourselves. It was designed for us. You save for yourself. Yes, we have children. Yes, we we've raised those children. Yes, we feel an obligation to those children for many of us that have gone through that process, but you hopefully taught them how to fish. You taught them how to get through hard things so that when those come, they can get through them themselves. They don't require you to step in.
13:34One thing I say to people all the time, it's become one of my new mantras is I as look at retirement planning and what we should do. Never give up what you need for what you don't need. Sometimes we're we see parents that are giving up money they need for the retirement to bail out a kid that doesn't necessarily need to be bailed out. When you look at the length of life they have to live, the lessons that come from overextending and getting themselves into bad situations, maybe, that are going to cause some pain. and some heartache. We've all gone through those periods of time. We've all had to learn ourselves from trial and experience. There was nothing about our lives that was meant to be completely easy, or we never would have grown. Let's stop taking those opportunities away from our children by being so concerned about protecting the and preserving the assets that we forget about what retirement is meant to be. Number nine, they were. worry about leaving money to their children. I am a big believer in the book Die With Zero. If you have not read it, I recommend that you go out and read the book. It's going to be hard, especially if you're conservative, it's going to be really hard to get through the first couple of chapters. I will warn you that, because it seems reckless. Some of what's being done and talked about in there seems very reckless, but once you get through and understand the point that's trying to be made and the goals that they're trying to achieve,
14:55you realize that the concepts and the principles that are being taught can apply to each of us to better manage what our retirement should look like. There is no obligation you have to your children. The only exception I guess I would ever make is someone like myself that has disabled children that cannot take care of themselves at some point in time, that can't go out. and work. Therefore, they're going to need extra money that my other children aren't going to need to have. Same thing for yourself. There's no obligation to ruin your retirement, to give everything up, to save all that money just because you feel some obligation to do so. We need to change our mindset. We need to change how we're looking at things. And remember, you gave your children. all those years to get them set. Your parents at some time, I assume, let you go fly. They let you go figure it out. They let you make some mistakes and pay some consequences for those. We need to do the same thing. If not, we're going to create an even worse generation for the next
15:55go-around. If we've got children that have never learned how to do hard things, how in the world are they going to take teach their children how to do hard things? or their grandchildren how to do hard things? And now we've got generations that are dependent upon everybody else to do the hard things. That's not what God created us to do. He created us to do the hard things and make the hard decisions. And part of that is having an appropriate relationship as it relates to your finances with your children, that you're not giving up things you need for things you don't need. Number 10, they have financial assets but lack financial confidence. This is where the importance of planning comes in, folks. This is where most people overlook what should be being done for the retirement because they get too caught up in their mind that retirement planning is just asset management. Why am I going to pay an advisor 1% or 1.5% or whatever the amount needs to be to? manage my assets when I can continue to do it myself and I can get as good a return as they're getting without having to pay that fee? By doing that, we're looking completely at the wrong question and the wrong answer. It's allowing us to make decisions based upon something that that really is not the heart of your retirement. Yes, assets need to be managed, but they need to be managed according to what you're trying to achieve.
17:15and the goals that you have. You don't have to get above average returns to be able to get this retirement that you need. In fact, for most people, that's not going to happen because by driving revenue purpose-driven investing, you're going to need money set aside that may not be as as productive, but it's going to be safe and liquid and available for you when you need that money for short-term hiccups for problems. issues that may be popping in. That's where the power of planning comes. We need to stop worrying about the asset management fee and realize that if we get with advisors that do planning, that's where the money's going to be earned. That's where we get confidence. That's the behavior of coaching. That's what uh is going to bring us to the best possible position long term. I don't know where asset manager managers by in and of themselves. are going to fall. I think as we look out, my prediction would be we're going to see less and less of those. And I know in the various events that I go to where we have planners and people like myself that are focused on getting people into better positions based upon the effort that's put into the planning and decision making, that many of them feel the same way, that they're realizing that the world of just doing asset. management is a thing of the past. That's why I got my personal financial specialist designation with the ICPA. I wanted to
18:34have the highest standard of planning in the country because I realized for myself as I went through my journey after my kidney transplant that I needed more confidence in the decisions I was making. I didn't need confidence in my portfolio return. If I it got 10%, 11%, 8%, 12%. whatever it happened to be, that provided me nothing for the my retirement. How does that tell me if I'm getting through my retirement? How does that tell me what I can spend in retirement? How does that tell me anything about my retirement? The questions I had is what is it going to take to get myself safely through? What type of return do I need in my portfolio to be able to allow this to work? And and how can I do it with the least amount of risk with the highest return, the highest reward there, so that I'm not risking something I need and for something I don't need. And that is where so many of the problems come in, is as people look at returns, they start looking at products and investments they shouldn't be looking at many times that are getting them in a position where they will risk what they need for something they don't need. And I've seen this unfortunate. unfortunately far too many times throughout my life and throughout the lives of the individuals that I've had the opportunity to work with. Folks, today was about those who have a million dollars. You may be there, you may not be there. You've noticed as we've talked through this, these principles don't
19:54just apply to them. It really applies more to them because for some reason in society, we've told ourselves if we get to a million dollars, somehow we're rich. But if you were to ask most people that are there on the doors of retirement with a million dollars, they they may feel fulfilled, but most of them would never tell you that they're rich. The goal is to make sure that we're getting rich through the lives we live, through the knowledge we have, through the confidence we have in regards to what we're doing. If we do that and have appropriate planning and guardrails and rules and policies in place we can get ourselves through retirement in a very effective way and allow us to have the happiness that retirement is meant to bring. Retirement should be the happiest time of our lives, and it can be if we have confidence that the money we have is going to allow us to achieve what we need. Million dollars is still going to get you through retirement. If you have Social Security and other things, that can still be plenty of money to allow you to live a good retirement life. For others, it's not going to be. You're going to need two, three, four, five, whatever it may be based upon your spending and the lifestyle you're trying to achieve.
21:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): My
21:01Dave Hall: name's Dave Hall. If you'd like to learn more about what we can do for you, go to our website, retirementriskadvisors.com. I look forward to seeing each of you back here next week.
21:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Investment advisory services offered through AlphaStar Capital Management LL LLC, an SEC registered investment advisor. SEC registration does not constitute an endorsement of the firm by the SEC, nor does it indicate the advisor has attained a particular level of skill or ability. Fixed insurance products are offered through retirement risk advisors, and Alpha Star Capital Management is not involved with the offer, recommendation, sale, or management of commission-based fixed insurance products. Alpha Office Star Capital or management and retirement risk advisors are separate and independent entities. This is for informational purposes only and is not intended as legal tax or investment advice or a recommendation of any particular security, investment product, or investment strategy.