The Retirement Risk Show

Guaranteed income reduces retirement risk more than total net worth

18 min Listen to the original
Retirement IncomeSocial SecurityAnnuitiesNet WorthCash FlowRisk ManagementReal EstatePortfolio Withdrawals

Summary

Dave Hall argues that guaranteed income sources like Social Security and annuities are more critical for retirement security than total net worth. He contends that high asset values do not equate to reliable cash flow, citing examples of illiquid real estate investors facing liquidity traps. Hall recommends covering 75-90% of lifestyle needs with guaranteed income to mitigate sequence-of-returns risk and psychological stress. He notes that while Social Security provides inflation-adjusted income, its long-term solvency faces projected depletion around 2030-2034. The episode highlights that 46% of Americans exhaust savings before retirement ends, emphasizing the need for reliable income streams.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Guaranteed income allows retirees to treat remaining assets as reserves for 'shock and aspirational expenses' rather than primary living costs, reducing the risk of depletion during market downturns.

    Dave Hall · 1:48

  2. 2
    between 75 and 90 percent of their lifestyle needs. covered through some form of guaranteed income.

    Dave Hall · 10:46

Episode sections

  1. 0:09 – 2:03

    Introduction and the Net Worth vs. Income Dilemma

    Dave Hall introduces the show and poses a hypothetical choice between having $2 million in assets with no guaranteed income or $1 million with guaranteed income covering lifestyle costs. He argues that guaranteed income reduces long-term uncertainty, allowing other funds to be reserved for 'shock and aspirational expenses'.

  2. 2:03 – 5:22

    Cost of Living Analogy and Las Vegas Cautionary Tale

    Hall uses a relocation analogy to emphasize that cost of living must be assessed before committing assets. He recounts a story from Las Vegas where homeowners from California bought large homes without accounting for high utility costs, leading to financial distress and neighborhood decline.

  3. 5:22 – 6:03

    Net Worth Does Not Pay Bills

    The speaker explains that high net worth does not equate to cash flow, citing real estate investors who lost tenants and income streams. He notes that lenders often require income to support borrowing, meaning illiquid assets cannot always be converted to cash easily.

  4. 6:03 – 7:22

    Social Security as Guaranteed Income

    Social Security is described as top-tier guaranteed income backed by the U.S. government, covering approximately 40% of lifestyle costs. It provides inflation-adjusted payments via COLA, though Hall acknowledges discussions about trust fund depletion around 2030-2034.

  5. 7:22 – 8:47

    Pensions and Annuities Stability

    Pensions are generally stable despite post-2008 market issues, while annuities are backed by insurance companies and state insurance funds. Hall asserts that annuitants have historically not lost payments due to these safety nets.

  6. 8:47 – 10:26

    Rental Income and Portfolio Withdrawals

    Rental income is stable only with tenants but carries vacancy and repair risks. Portfolios provide withdrawals (dividends, interest, or principal sales) rather than true income, introducing volatility and sequence-of-returns risk to retirement sustainability.

  7. 10:26 – 14:26

    Matching Income to Lifestyle Needs

    Hall recommends covering 75-90% of lifestyle needs with guaranteed income. He categorizes expenses into essential (bills, food), discretionary (entertainment, travel), and irregular (roof replacement, vacations), suggesting liquidity for the latter.

  8. 14:26 – 18:22

    Psychological Impact of Running Out of Money

    The speaker cites that 46% of Americans run out of money before retirement ends. He argues that guaranteed income provides psychological comfort and freedom, whereas reliance on portfolio withdrawals creates stress and potential loss of autonomy.

Claims worth verifying

Dave Hall has eight children.

Dave Hall ·3:03

How to verify: Public biographies of Dave Hall or Retirement Risk Advisors website about page. For recent events, verify 2026-08-06 through 2026-11-06. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Social Security is meant to cover about 40% of lifestyle costs.

Dave Hall ·6:03

How to verify: Social Security Administration publications on retirement income replacement rates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-06 through 2026-11-06. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Social Security trust funds are projected to run out around 2030-2034.

Dave Hall ·6:42

How to verify: Social Security Trustees Report published annually by the U.S. Social Security Administration. For recent events, verify 2026-08-06 through 2026-11-06. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Annuity recipients have historically not lost money due to state insurance funds.

Dave Hall ·8:02

How to verify: National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) data on insurer failures and policyholder protections. For recent events, verify 2026-08-06 through 2026-11-06. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

46% of Americans run out of money before retirement ends.

Dave Hall ·14:46

How to verify: Empirical studies on retirement savings depletion rates, such as those by the Employee Benefit Research Institute (EBRI) or Vanguard. For recent events, verify 2026-08-06 through 2026-11-06. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Las Vegas utility costs for a 6,000 sq ft home can reach $800/month.

Dave Hall ·4:23

How to verify: Utility company rate schedules (e.g., NV Energy) and average consumption data for large homes in Las Vegas. For recent events, verify 2026-08-06 through 2026-11-06. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

California has mild temperatures where many homes lack air conditioning.

Dave Hall ·4:23

How to verify: National Weather Service climate data for California vs. Nevada; housing surveys on AC prevalence. For recent events, verify 2026-08-06 through 2026-11-06. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Social Security payments are inflation-adjusted via COLA.

Dave Hall ·6:42

How to verify: Social Security Administration COLA announcements for current and historical years. For recent events, verify 2026-08-06 through 2026-11-06. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

State insurance funds sustain annuity payments if companies fail.

Dave Hall ·8:22

How to verify: State guaranty association statutes and NAIC reports on insurance insolvencies. For recent events, verify 2026-08-06 through 2026-11-06. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Retirees with guaranteed income have more psychological comfort than those relying on withdrawals.

Dave Hall ·15:46

How to verify: Academic research on financial stress and retirement well-being, e.g., studies in Journal of Financial Planning. For recent events, verify 2026-08-06 through 2026-11-06. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify Social Security Trust Fund depletion projections using the Social Security Administration's annual Trustees Report.
  • Check state insurance department regulations and guaranty association coverage limits for annuity providers.
  • Review sequence-of-returns risk studies, such as those from the College of Financial Planning or Vanguard, to understand portfolio withdrawal risks.
  • Analyze personal cost-of-living differences if considering relocation, using tools like the MIT Living Wage Calculator or Bureau of Economic Data.
  • Assess liquidity of real estate holdings by reviewing vacancy rates and lender underwriting standards for rental income.
  • Compare guaranteed income coverage ratios against personal essential and discretionary expense budgets.
  • Investigate historical annuity insurer failure rates and payout continuity statistics through NAIC or industry reports.
  • Evaluate the psychological impact of income volatility by reviewing behavioral finance studies on retirement stress and spending cuts.
Full transcriptexpand
0:09
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Welcome to the Retirement Risk Show, the best retirement interviews and advice with Dave Hall. Learn strategies to help you reduce and even eliminate the risks facing your retirement.
0:21
Dave Hall: Hello, welcome to today's show. My name is Dave Hall. I am your host. This is the show where we have help you safely navigate through retirement. If you would like to learn more about what we can do to help you, go to our website, retirementriscadvisors.com. Here you'll be able to get access to all the educational tools we have available. You'll be able to learn more about how
0:41
Dave Hall: we plan and work with clients, as well as schedule a consultation. You'll have a calendar link there where we can sit down and talk about what needs to be done to get you safely through your retirement. Today we're going to be talking about why reliable income matters more than total net worth. To begin the
1:01
Dave Hall: discussion, I'd like to give you an example and have you think about even as it relates to your own retirement. If you had the opportunity to get $2 million, that's the money you had for your full retirement. With that, though, you had to pay all of the living costs of your retirement, or you had the opportunity to get a million dollars, but
1:21
Dave Hall: had the income coming in to cover your lifestyle costs. Which of those two options would you choose?
1:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now,
1:28
Dave Hall: as we look at them on the surface, we really don't have enough information to determine which of those may be better for each individual based upon your s lifestyle costs or those type of things. may impact which of those decisions that you make. But what it does is brings up a very important aspect of planning that if we take the $2 million, there's a lot
1:48
Dave Hall: more uncertainty to what's going to happen inside of our retirement long term than happens on the other side. If we've got guaranteed income coming in, we have the opportunity to use those other funds for what we call shock and aspirational expenses.
2:03
Dave Hall: A way to look at this in our working years is go back maybe to a time where you moved locations during your working years. Some of you have done that a lot of times like I have. Others maybe have never moved locations. You've stayed where you're at. But generally if you're going into a new location, one of the first questions you're going to ask is how much is it going to cost me to live there? No
2:23
Dave Hall: one's going out and saying how much money do I have and can I live there based upon the assets I have available? It seems almost crazy to think anyone would ask that question. We always want to know what the cost of living is. I saw it when I lived in Puerto Rico, living out of the mainland United States. We had many people coming there all the time, looking at the island
2:43
Dave Hall: as a place to relocate. Locate, One of their first questions was, What is the lifestyle cost as we get here? And why it becomes important because if we don't manage that part right, we may not be able to even stay in the community that we've decided to move to. I saw this uh early in my career when I was living in Las Vegas. Our my wife and I
3:03
Dave Hall: started to have our family. For those of you that uh have followed me for a period of time, you know that I've got eight children. And We realized that we needed to have a bigger home. And so we went out, found a home that was quite large. and what we thought was going to be in a very nice community. It was new development. The new homes were coming in. We had seen other developments like this.
3:23
Dave Hall: Everything looked really good. We got into the home only to find out that a lot of our neighbors had moved in from California. Now, I don't have anything about Californians. I don't have anything about somebody moving from California to Las Vegas where we lived. What I had the issue was the way that the finances worked for many of these people that moved to this neighborhood.
3:43
Dave Hall: Because what they had done is they had taken their homes in California that may have been a thousand or two thousand square feet, sold those homes, made a lot of profit, come to Las Vegas, and were buying much bigger homes, somewhere between anywhere from 3,500 to 6,000 square feet. All of that seemed to make sense, but unfortunately, many of them failed to ask. that
4:03
Dave Hall: very important question how much is it going to cost me to live in this home? And they made a big mistake, especially those that got the largest homes in the neighborhood, because in California, those homes did not have the cost of heating and air conditioning that you were going to have in Las Vegas, especially during those hot summer months. California had such
4:23
Dave Hall: mild temperatures that many people maybe didn't even have an air conditioning. conditioner in their home. Then they got into the neighborhood, had a large 6,000 square foot home, only to find out that the monthly utility cost was as much as $800 per month. And then they had other costs on top of that by having to maintain the homes, the
4:42
Dave Hall: maintenance costs, all of these other things that just increased the amount of spending that they were required to do. As a result, the neighborhood went down for a period of time. People were not taking care of their yards the way that they should. And some of them ended up having to move out of the neighborhood because they did not have the remaining assets needed to
5:02
Dave Hall: be able to continue to cover the lifestyle cost. The same thing can happen to us as we get into retirement. We can get to a position where we think we've got a lot of assets going into retirement, but if we don't have the appropriate amount, we may run out of money before we run out of those retirement years. We may also find ourselves in a situation
5:22
Dave Hall: where we've got net worth that we can't even spend. I see this a lot of time with people who have purchased a lot of real estate over the years. They get into retirement, all of a sudden that they lose a few tenants, and so that income stream that had been coming in consistently goes away. And now they're in a position where they've got a lot of asset. assets, but they don't have an income stream and may not even be
5:42
Dave Hall: able to get an income stream without selling the properties because many times uh lenders do not want to borrow money if there's not some form of income coming in to support uh what that money's getting borrowed too. So we've got to remember that net worth is never going to pay the bills. Also, we should uh understand the difference in the types of income.
6:03
Dave Hall: that is coming in versus what are considered withdrawals. So if we look at most people going into retirement, they're going to have Social Security as a form of income. I've talked about this in the last week's show that we did. We talked about how Social Security is meant to cover about 40% of lifestyle costs. Now, as we look at guaranteed
6:22
Dave Hall: income, this is one that's up to the very top. It's something that's backed. by the United States government. It's been paying now for decades. We expect it to continue to pay for decades. But one of the things that we oftentimes don't take into consideration is that it also is a place that we can get inflation-adjusted income. We've got uh
6:42
Dave Hall: increases that are happening on an annual basis Increases based upon the Cola increases, assuming cost of living is going up. If it's not, then you're not gonna have that income. increase. But it is a great place to have the base of your retirement income coming from. Now there is some discussion that somewhere around 2030, 2034, the Social Security program
7:02
Dave Hall: will run out of trust fund, and at that point, if they do not fix the program, maybe there would have to be a reduction in benefits paid. My belief is that the program will get fixed. So That we'll be able to see that form of income as a pretty steady source of income for retirees for generations to come. What about pension plans? When we look at those, historically they
7:22
Dave Hall: have done quite well and have been pretty stable. Now, there are some funds that did not do well. There was a period of time with the markets going down the way they did, especially after 2008, that many pensions were in trouble with their ability to pay their bills long term and their ability to maintain. the pension promises they made. But as we look at it overall,
7:42
Dave Hall: what we find is that pensions generally are also pretty steady stream of income for many retirees that have them, that they're not overly concerned that that income's not going to continue. Well, what about annuities? So we've got those out there. We talked about those some last week as well. But as we look at the annuities also as something that's backed up not only by the insurance
8:02
Dave Hall: company. companies, but also by the state insurance funds that exist inside of each state. So if we look back historically, annuity, those who are receiving annuity annuity payments have not lost money. They were not put in a position to where they ended up losing those payments that they went away. Maybe the company went out of business, but between the state
8:22
Dave Hall: insurance fund and another company, they were able to help sustain those payments that were coming into
8:27
Dave Hall: the retirement. Well, then we jump to other items such as rent. Rent is something that as long as you have a tenant seems pretty stable, seems pretty consistent. The money's gonna keep coming month after month. But what happens if the tenant moves out? Not only do you lose that income stream, but many times you're also going to have to do a lot of repairs to get it back to a
8:47
Dave Hall: point where r the property can be rented again. So it's not a problem that. you don't have the rent that uh you not a problem that you have rental properties. The problem is if you're using that as the main primary source of retirement income, may have more flexibility there than you would with Social Security or pension or annuity, the way that they're structured from that
9:07
Dave Hall: side. What about our portfolios? Now all of a sudden we're going from a point of income to what we call withdrawals. It's money that's got to come up. out. Now it may be dividends that are being paid out. So you look at it from a stock fund that uh pays dividends each year or each month or each quarter, whatever the case may be, and there may be money coming out of those that you
9:27
Dave Hall: could take out of the account as uh distributions, but it's a withdrawal, not an income. It's not coming in as a form of income. Nor if you've got a certificate of deposit, the interest that's being paid off of there is not. being deemed as a form of income. It's being deemed as a return on the investment that you've had, and then the money that you're taking out would be a withdrawal. That you're
9:47
Dave Hall: using a lot more volatility as we start looking at this structure in what's going on with the long-term success for our retirement. Especially as we look at a form of portfolio, if we don't have interest or dividends or other set amounts coming out of there, now we're just withdrawing down the portfolio through retirement. And again, this is not
10:06
Dave Hall: necessarily a problem because we do want to pull the money out of our assets going into retirement to use for our retirement. That's why we save them. But we need to make sure that we're doing it in a way that matches up with the goals that we have long term, so we don't take ourselves out of retirement because we don't manage the money appropriately.
10:26
Dave Hall: Let's talk a little bit now too about matching income to lifestyle. If we're going to talk about the importance of income, we need to make sure we understand what income we need because we don't want to get too much and we don't want to have too little. And there's general guidelines that we try to use in planning. We we recommend that people have somewhere
10:46
Dave Hall: between 75 and 90 percent of their lifestyle needs. covered through some form of guaranteed income. You may be asking though, Dave, what what is lifestyle? What does that mean? Well, we've got different aspects of lifestyle. We've got the essential spending, which is the key part. That's the things that have to be paid. That's the power bill,
11:06
Dave Hall: that's the food that you're you're putting onto the table. Maybe if you're you've got a mortgage still, deal, it's gonna be the mortgage payment. If you've got a car that you've got a payment on. it's gonna be the car, it's gonna be the insurance, those type of things. So there's gonna be a set amount there, and we definitely want those amounts covered. We want to make sure that if something goes wrong in retirement with a portfolio
11:26
Dave Hall: going down or there ends up being other issues, that there is income to cover that. That's the paycheck, that's the money to cover those uh essential costs that we're gonna going to have. Another part of every one of our lifestyles is discretionary spending, the things that we choose to spend money on, the things that we decide we're going to do above and beyond there.
11:46
Dave Hall: Maybe we're going to go spend some time individually going to shows or plays, something that we like to do as a couple or individually go out with friends to go to these events. That's money that we don't have to spend, but we choose to spend. Maybe we like sports, maybe we like to travel. Whatever the case may be, we're also going to have some discretionary
12:06
Dave Hall: spending. For most people, this can be pretty consistent as well, meaning that many people are gonna have a budget. This is the amount that we use every month for our essential costs, this is the amount that we've got extra available to use for our discretionary expenses, and so many times what happens is that's included, those costs are included as part of the
12:27
Dave Hall: income that's coming in, the guaranteed income as well. And then on top of that, we've got all those irregular expenses, not something that we're necessarily planning to spend money on, but we may be spending money on. And they don't all have to be bad things. Yes, many times there are things that can go wrong that cause us to spend large amounts of money. Maybe it's time
12:47
Dave Hall: for the roof to be replaced on the house and it's gonna cost going to twenty to $20,000 four. $40,000 to do that. Maybe one of the children's got an issue that we're having to step in. But you could also have a time where maybe you decided to take the whole family on a vacation. And so you're trying to figure out how to model out the spending to be able to cover those costs. Those are the large
13:07
Dave Hall: irregular expenses that happen. And for most of us, there are going to be many of those throughout our retirement years. Maybe it's a car purchase or a vehicle purchase there. Maybe it's again large trips that are going to happen, especially during the initial years of retirement. Whatever it may be, the goal is to make sure that you've got the appropriate amount covered of the
13:27
Dave Hall: various expenses you have. Now, typically, when we look at the large irregular expenses, we're gonna use liquidity to help us prepare for those. That's our safety bucket, the money we're setting aside, but it is an important that we understand that these things are going to happen through our retirement and figure out how we're going to handle those. If we go back to the
13:46
Dave Hall: example that we talked about at the beginning of the podcast, again, if we're looking at it from a $2 million standpoint, where you've got $2 million, you've got to cover the living costs, both essential, discretionary, and the larger regular expenses, a lot of stress can be put on that two million dollars. Where if you're on the other side of the coin where you've got
14:06
Dave Hall: your essential and discretionary expenses paid, but you've got a million dollars of assets for all the irregular or shocker aspirational expenses that happen, the outcomes can become much different as you go through the process of those two structures and and with it bring a lot of uh depending on which side you're on, can really have a big cycle.
14:26
Dave Hall: psychological consequence or benefit to your overall retirement. One of the challenges that we see with many retirees that are especially trying to use withdrawals instead of income, trying to use Social Security match with an IRA, a 401k, whatever the case may be, one of the challenges that we see with those individuals is
14:46
Dave Hall: that forty 46% six percent of them of Americans are running out of money before they're running out of retirement. It is the worst thing for most people that they want to have happen. If you survey retirees, ask them what the biggest concern is for many of them. What you're going to find is that that is the biggest concern. We do not want to run out of money before we run
15:06
Dave Hall: out of retirement because that means primarily that we've lost our ability to choose, that we've lost our freedom because now we've got. to go to a family member, our church, uh whatever the government, whoever it may be, to have them help bail us out of that process. And as a result, it can really lead to some psychological issues that that
15:26
Dave Hall: become very damaging for retirees as they go through the process. Where on the other side, when there's guaranteed income coming in and you know regardless of what's going on in the market, regardless of what's going on geopolitically, regardless of what wars or other things may be happening in the world, that those paychecks are going to continue to come in, that that Social Security checks going to
15:46
Dave Hall: continue to come in, or the direct deposit there, that the annuity and the pension payments or whatever else is going on inside of your retirement income structure, that all of that is going to be happening each month after month, year after year, decade after decade. There's a lot more. comfort in regards to the stability of what you
16:06
Dave Hall: put together.
16:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
16:07
Dave Hall: as you look at your own situation, as you can contemplate where you are in your retirement, remember that assets are not income. They're a way that we can convert those assets. There's ways to be able to convert them into income, and that's what we need to do. But the goal of retirement truly is to do just that. Don't think that you can continue to do
16:27
Dave Hall: what you did for the first 20, 30 years of accumulation by being able to just have assets that you could then dollar cost average in that you could build over time when we get into retirement. And the goal is to spin those down, is to use those assets for our lifestyle so that we can enjoy that the retirement that we want. Which, if we do
16:47
Dave Hall: this correctly, we will spend more money, have a better retirement. be able to enjoy life more fully, be able to not be so concerned about the discretionary or large irregular expenses that happen, because we've designed a plan to be able to do that. Folks, that is today's show. Hopefully, uh we better understand now the importance
17:07
Dave Hall: of income, why the portfolio itself is not enough, and some of the sources out there, remembering that different types of income. really should be put at a different uh level of goals in inside of our retirement, how we're going to use those. And those that are more guaranteed are going to take much more precedence versus those that maybe rent that again has a little
17:27
Dave Hall: bit of flexibility versus a portfolio where we're actually taking withdrawals out of it. My name is Dave Hall. I am your host. I look forward to seeing each of you back next week.
17:38
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Investment and advisory services offered through AlphaStar Capital Management LLC, an SEC registered investment advisor. SEC registration does not constitute an endorsement of the firm by the SEC, nor does it indicate the advisor has attained a particular level of skill or ability. Fixed insurance products are offered through retirement risk advisors, and AlphaStar Office Door
17:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Capital Management is not involved with the offer, recommendation, sale, or management of commission-based fixed insurance products. Office store capital management and retirement risk advisors are separate and independent entities. This is for informational purposes only and is not intended as legal tax or investment advice or a recommendation of any particular security,
18:17
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): investment product, or investment strategy.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from The Retirement Risk Show

All insights