Market Misbehavior with David Keller, CMT

David Keller and Tally Leger discuss semiconductor valuation divergence and dip-buying opportunities

38 min Listen to the original
SemiconductorsMarket AnalysisTechnical AnalysisValuationNVIDIARisk ManagementMacroeconomics

Summary

David Keller interviews Tally Leger, who argues that semiconductor stocks are undervalued relative to growing revenues, citing an unprecedented negative divergence between stock performance and billings. Leger points to historical regression data showing strong forward returns when this ratio falls below one standard deviation, supporting a 'buy the dip' thesis. He highlights NVIDIA's strong earnings and a 3% growth rate in the weekly economic index as fundamental support. Leger also notes that extreme crowding in the semiconductor trade has unwound, making them attractive again after a rotation into software earlier in the year. The discussion emphasizes patience and technical analysis as valid strategies during periods of elevated volatility.

Episode sections

  1. 0:01 – 10:00

    Intro, Guest Background, and Market Outlook

    Dave Keller introduces Tally Leger, Chief Market Strategist at Wealth Consulting Group, noting their shared background in music and independent research. Leger argues that despite elevated VIX and investor anxiety in Q4 2026, the S&P 500 has maintained a steep technical trajectory since October 2022, suggesting patience is a valid strategy as prices have drifted below standard error bands similar to prior market dips.

  2. 10:00 – 20:22

    Semiconductor Fundamentals vs. Stock Performance

    Leger presents a chart comparing the year-over-year performance of S&P 500 semiconductor and equipment stocks against America's semiconductor billings (revenues). He highlights an unprecedented negative divergence where stock performance has fallen sharply while billings continue to grow, suggesting the market is pricing in a CapEx cliff that may not be justified by current data.

  3. 20:22 – 27:26

    Valuation Analysis and Historical Precedents

    Leger displays a regression analysis of the ratio of semi-stocks to billings on a log scale since the late 1980s. He notes the current ratio is below the minus one standard error, a threshold historically associated with strong 12-month forward returns (median returns more than double the sample median), supporting a 'buy the dip' thesis despite the risk of further downside.

  4. 27:26 – 34:40

    Risk Management and Software Rotation

    Leger discusses rotating from semiconductors to software (IGV) earlier in the year, which yielded a 50%+ gain before he took profits due to weakness. He observes that the pendulum has swung back toward semiconductors relative to software, suggesting the extreme crowding in the semiconductor trade has unwound, making them attractive again for nibbling positions amidst panic.

  5. 34:40 – 36:18

    Investment Pillars and Behavioral Focus

    Speaker 1 outlines four pillars of investment analysis: fundamental, technical, macroeconomic, and behavioral. He emphasizes that while many investors cover fundamentals and macro, technical and behavioral aspects are often underappreciated but crucial for risk management and avoiding disasters.

  6. 36:18 – 37:33

    Premium Membership Promotion

    Speaker 1 promotes the Market Misbehavior premium membership, highlighting benefits such as virtual courses, webcasts, member-only reports (morning coffee routine, weekly flight plan, monthly chart review), and access to a member community for 2027.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
NVIDIANVDAequitymixedWe had NVIDIA's earnings this week, markets It's breaking down of sorts.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

The S&P 500 has remained on a steep technical trajectory since October 2022, marking the start of the current cyclical bull market.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·6:49

How to verify: Check S&P 500 price charts from Oct 2026 to Nov 2026; verify cyclical bull market definitions by financial historians or major indices providers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Investors who bought on dips in March 2026 (Iran conflict) and April 2025 (tariff tantrum) were rewarded.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·7:42

How to verify: Check S&P 500 performance from March 2026 and April 2026 to end of Q4 2026; verify news events (Iran conflict, tariff announcements) via news archives. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The divergence between semiconductor stock performance and America's semiconductor billings is unprecedented in the history of the data (1980s-1990s to present).

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·13:51

How to verify: Access semiconductor billing data (e.g., from Semiconductor Industry Association or similar government/industry reports) and compare YoY stock performance vs. billing growth over the specified period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Semiconductor billings are growing over 200%.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·18:14

How to verify: Review recent semiconductor industry billing reports (e.g., from SIA or company earnings reports) for the relevant period to confirm growth rates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

NVIDIA doubled its revenues and earnings, with growth rates over 100%, and raised its outlook.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·18:47

How to verify: Check NVIDIA's Q3 or Q4 2026 earnings press release and SEC filings (10-Q/10-K) for revenue/earnings figures and guidance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Anthropic had a 'blockbuster historic IPO' in Q4 2026.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·19:08

How to verify: Check IPO records for Anthropic in Q4 2026 for valuation, size, and market reception data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

The average and median 12-month forward returns when the semi-stock to billings ratio falls below minus one standard error are more than double the sample median.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·22:30

How to verify: Reproduce Leger's regression analysis using historical data for the ratio of semiconductor stock prices to billings and calculate forward returns. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The weekly economic index shows a 'nice three handle' (3% growth).

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·25:46

How to verify: Check the latest Weekly Economic Index (WEI) data from the Federal Reserve Bank of New York for the relevant period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

IGV (iShares Expanded Tech-Software ETF) gained over 50% from trough to peak in 2026.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·28:27

How to verify: Check IETF price history for IGV in 2026 to calculate the percentage gain from its lowest point to its highest point. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

The software group (IGV) has given back about 15% since its peak.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·28:47

How to verify: Check IETF price history for IGV to calculate the percentage decline from its 2026 peak to the time of the interview. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the current ratio of semiconductor stock valuations to billings using S&P 500 semiconductor and equipment stock indices versus US semiconductor billings data from the Semiconductor Industry Association.
  • Check NVIDIA's latest earnings report for revenue, earnings per share, and guidance updates to confirm the 'double beats' and growth rates cited.
  • Review the 'Weekly Economic Index' from the St. Louis Fed or similar source to verify the 3% growth rate claim.
  • Analyze historical regression data for the ratio of semi-stocks to billings to assess the statistical significance of the 'minus one standard error' threshold and its forward returns.
  • Monitor COT reports or institutional flow data to assess current crowding levels in semiconductor ETFs like SMH or SOXX.
  • Read the latest S&P 500 technical charts to evaluate the 'steep technical trajectory' since October 2022 and current position relative to standard error bands.
  • Consider the impact of potential CapEx cycles in the semiconductor industry by reviewing major chipmakers' capital expenditure guidance.
  • Evaluate the performance of software ETFs like IGV to assess the rotation dynamics and relative valuation shifts mentioned.
Full transcriptexpand

0:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Welcome to the Market Misbehavior Podcast, hosted by Dave Keller. Dave talks to top market practitioners, money managers, technical analysts, investment strategists, and authors to help you navigate the markets and become a more mindful investor. The content of this podcast should not be considered as a recommendation or solicitation to buy or sell any security. All information is intended for educational purposes. only and should not be relied upon for any investment decisions. The host of this podcast, as well as any guests, may hold positions in securities discussed.

0:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Hey there, everyone. Dave Keller here with Market Misbehavior, and welcome to our latest episode of the Market Misbehavior podcast. Today I'm checking in with Tally Leger. Tally is a chief market strategist at the Wealth Consultant. Consulting Group. I met Tally uh years ago in my fidelity days. He had his own independent research shop called Macrovision Research and uh always just really valued his uh independent thinking, data-driven approach, and his respect and understanding for technical analysis and how it fits into a bigger picture investment process. Today I'm asking. Tally about a recent article he wrote on LinkedIn talking about semiconductor stocks and how the valuations look fairly attractive according to Tally's work. I'll show you some of the charts that were highlighted in Tally's article and have the opportunity to ask him questions about some of the justification for his outlook and what might tell him that the outlook is no longer correct. So please enjoy

1:37this really interesting interview. with Tally Leger of the Wealth Consulting Group. I'm super excited to be chatting today with Tally Leger. Tally is the uh chief market strategist at the Wealth Consulting Group. Tally, you and I first crossed paths uh years ago in my fidelity days. You had a firm Macrovision Research, and I remember um, you know, reading your thoughts, uh, chatting with you, and being impressed by sort. of an independent read and a good sense of the market. So I'm really excited to share some of that insight with our viewers today. Thanks for coming on the show.

2:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): A hundred percent. I think it's gonna be an easy conversation for us, Dave.

2:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, we're doing this on anthropic IPO today. We had NVIDIA's earnings this week, markets It's breaking down of sorts. I mean, I don't know. I think we'll I think we'll we'll put two and two together and come up with some interesting thoughts. But before we get to that, we have to start with the most important issue. You studied music uh as an undergraduate, as did I. You majored in music at BU. And what's am I right? You're a French horn player. Is that right?

2:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Absolutely. French French horn. Uh they they called me a brass hole. Can I say that on the

2:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think so?

2:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.

2:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): You

2:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): too, right?

2:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Trumpet player.

2:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah.

2:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I studied trumpet. at Ohio State so

2:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): yeah

2:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so

2:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): my my my key question why do musicians make such great strategists what's the secret do you think

2:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): well so I that was a topic of study for me in my in my graduate work so I went I finished up my undergrad and In and music performance I you know I finished what I started and then I walked across the street literally to the business school and knocked on the door. And they they were crazy and they took me in. But I did this positive transfer of training with the head of that program. And I think this was really more for me than it was for anyone else, but trying to chart a a course and uh justify the the movement. move but i i think there is a positive transfer of training this is the answer to your to your question in in music there's point and counterpoint right and there's there's formations and and patterns and and we learn the same stuff in statistics and uh technical analysis right right up your alley

4:03And so I I think it it's so natural in music theory. They teach you this stuff, and and the language of music, as you know, is inherently mathematical on a few different levels. So there's the written form and there's the rhythm, right? That you you hear. But anyway, all that stuff and that training lends itself very well to finding. same kinds of uh you know reverse and direct patterns and correlations and relationships in the in the macro, micro data and the market data. And so I just, you know, I we're we tend to be visual thinkers anyways. So I I just kind of uh found my my niche and and never looked back. That was a long-winded way of answering your question.

4:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I no, but I think that's really well said, Tally. And I and I would add, I guess, maybe a respect for history, maybe, I guess, is one of them. So we're I sing with the Seattle Symphony Chorale uh now and we're we're performing Mozart's Requiem this week. Uh first concert tonight.

5:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Awesome.

5:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Beautiful piece of music. But you know, when you when you study music and you you learn about Mozart, it's like it's all about understanding that period. It's about you know, sort of knowing what's probably gonna come next, you know, at a certain point in the piece, because you know the the the history, you know the theory, and you sort of understand the patterns. And I feel like that's exactly what we're gonna try to do over the next twenty minutes, talking about the markets is thinking about historical statistical analysis, thinking about relationships and then just trying to, you know, make assumptions about what might what might come next. I I i I think hopefully we're we're both well trained for for what we're doing I would say but but the experience uh is is better than anything tally for for you for sure so give us you know as as we're as we're sort of going through this period you you have uh an article that you wrote recently on LinkedIn I want to bring up in a minute and go through some of the specifics of of the semiconductor space and where we're at but start at a high level for us I mean this is a period where I feel like, you know, the VIX is elevated and I feel like investor anxiety has been elevated for quite some time. It's like the VIX is now kind of recognizing how nervous investors are. When you're looking at the markets here in the fourth quarter of 2026, I mean, do you have reasons, more reasons to be optimistic, more reasons to be cautious at a high level about the equity

6:25space? Because this is a time where I feel like people. are making an argument on both sides.

6:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Absolutely. And so look, I think when we have doubts, and we like to say when in doubt, zoom out. And this is, I think, one of those times. And so when I apply my simple technical and econometric tools to stocks, and let's face it, right? That's probably the most uh popular asset class that we're asked about, even though we're cross-market. But right now, it seems to me that uh despite all the hand-wringing and the concerns right here,

7:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

7:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): stock market, I'm really talking about the SP 500 for simplicity's sake, has remained on a steep technical trajectory since October 2022. And that was really, from my lens, the start of the current cyclical bull market in stocks. And we have been here before, Dave, right? And it was the folks that uh bought on the dips back in March of this year, right? That was the Iran conflict, as well as uh the tariff tangent. tantrum in April of 2025 that were rewarded for their patience and sticking to the plan. And I think in this case, this is I've been saying this a lot, Dave, patience is uh a strategy. And so what I what I show is when I introduced the time trend and its uh uh channel since 2022, we have actually drifted below the minus two standard error here, much like we did those prior two times. And it happened three times before that, beginning in 2022. So there have been a lot of setbacks in in these four short years. It feels like so much time has has

8:22passed. But uh again, I I like to say that it's really time in. the market that matters, not timing. And look, we've got these bargain basement prices, and I think you should be shopping the seasonal sales here, Dave.

8:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): If you like the idea of getting a couple of stock ideas to research each month, take a look at Alpha Picks from Seeking Alpha. Their quantitative team uses a data data-driven driven process to select two stocks each month, and members receive some. sell alerts when a pick no longer meets the services criteria. You can also follow the portfolio and see how the picks have performed. Right now there's a special offer: $50 off the annual subscription, bringing the first year to $449. You can find the details at Market Misbehavior.com/slash alpha picks. Inject better ideas into your process at Market marketmisbehavior.com Misbehaven. slash alpha picks.

9:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It

9:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I mean the reality is, right, and again, speaking of market history, if you look back, the market has successfully recovered from 100% of market corrections, right? I mean, equities have always come back. Uh, and and maybe at some point that that changes, and hopefully you and I are safely retired by that moment. But you know, but but history tells us that generally. speaking, when there's a correction, we get through it. And and it's just navigating that period. I think navigating the emotional experience is is the is the biggest challenge. I'd love to get to um you know some work that you that you shared on LinkedIn uh recently 'cause I think it was really well done um Italian it's really talking about I I think the the key question for most investors right now which is the semiconductor space. And you know we have anthropics IPO right now, obviously you know, one of the you know key uh pieces in the AI stack, but a lot of these names uh across the stack have have struggled here in Q4. You're laying out sort of an argument as to, you know, maybe this is the time to be thinking about valuations and looking where these prices are relative to where they could be. We're we're showing a couple charts here, and it's starting with sort of this relationship between.

10:28performance essentially and billings. Can you tell us a little bit about what particularly we're looking at? Because I think for a lot of people, maybe that's a less familiar way of measuring kind of the fundamental story for these names.

10:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): 100%. So I'll kind of kick it off with you, you were talking about history. And so when you've been doing this for as long as you and I have,

10:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): history.

10:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): is fascinating, man. So we we kind of gravitate to cycle analysis. And this is one of those super cyclical, high velocity, liquid areas of the stock market. And we do cycle on cycle analysis. We've got all the tools. And so I think part of the art of this game is to make sure that you're talking about. the right things at the right time. And I think it takes us a while, we're veterans, but to to kind of hone our craft. And I like to think that we're kind of there. And so this is one of these beautiful examples where you've got the media and your clients freaking out, some more than others. If they're well trained, they don't really care, which is which is great. But but this is one of those times where I think you can be high. impact with good old-fashioned business cycle analysis. And and so we're introducing here, just to describe the chart, some fundamentals with some technicals and historical cycle on cycle analysis. And and I I think a part of the art is to identify the similarities and the differences. And so this is one of those unique opportunities. Dave, where we get to talk about the differences. And so if you look, first of all, the dark blue

12:10line in the chart on the left-hand side, that is SP 500 semiconductor and equipment stocks, right? And so we're showing the year-over-year Every year percent change. And when you're doing this kind of econometric analysis, what we learn is. stocks are basically trending variables, right? They go from the lower left to the upper right of our charts and our screens. That's uh technician talk. But we also like from econometric uh perspectives, we like to detrend these variables to see the patterns and the correlations. And so that's why we take the rate of change. So just think of it like uh a return. as you said. But also there's another nuance here. I introduced a lag, meaning I push the stocks forward by two months. And as you know, as a practitioner, the stock market, and this is a perfect example, super cyclical area of the stock market, they're Their discounting mechanisms for

13:12the outlook for the fundamentals, right? And so that's what we're trying to get our arms around ultimately as investors. This is the holy grail of investing, Dave. And so what's that light thin blue line on the right-hand side? Well, those are America's semiconductor billings. In other words, the revenues for these companies. And and I put a brace in there just to highlight that we have. seen the biggest gap, despite my point about we understand that stocks get ahead of the fundamentals, but this divergence here is literally unprecedented in the history of the data that we're monitoring here. And this this actually this relationship goes uh further back to uh the 1980s and and 1990s. But I I wanted to hone in and really show how the stock market, and it's notorious for this, but it tends to overreact on the upside and on the downside. And this is one of those negative divergences I I really wanted to kind of coax out in the piece because I don't know about you, but this market in our careers, it is moving so fast and it was. just in May, we were talking about irrational exuberance.

14:30And I I personally, this is another piece that I put out. I was kind of flagging extreme crowding in the semiconductor momentum trade. And I switched to software. And that was a great trade. And now the carnage and semis, it's moved so quickly. I I think we're actually as a firm and personally, we started to nibble at these. bar bargain basement prices.

14:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It's uh and I want to ask you a lot more about this, but I mean you you alluded to sort of the time compression, I guess is how I would describe it that we're seeing in the markets. And and I mean, I don't wanna I don't wanna you know color too much about how long you and I have both been doing this. I've been doing this about 26 years. You're welcome to share your own experience, but but I but I mean it it certainly seems to me that as time has gone. on it feels like things are happening a lot more quickly uh and and and you know are you seeing that you see evidence that that sort of compression is happening because because cycles that feel like they should take months are taking weeks and if not days sometimes right

15:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): 100% and and that's that's really the the point and so it's kind of forced me to be much more in the mind market. And so my micro game has gotten so much better. And I mean, NVIDIA is a perfect example. I never had to really cover stocks and individual companies before. But when you're a macro person, it like and it's such a large share of the index, it you really have no choice. And and so I like to think now we're kind of better whole-brained, uh investment strategists as a result.

16:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Over the last 12 months, uh, and honestly, if you go back to like the COVID area, we've had to become experts in medicine, experts in the Strait of Hormuz, which was a body of water I did not even know about until recently. I mean, it the the number of things we have to be fluent in uh seems It to be growing, uh, for sure. You know, continuing on this, and and I and I and again, I guess my question. as we continue to go through this, Tally, is when we have this disconnect between the price of these assets, right? If you look at the performance of semiconductors, obviously it's taken a huge performance hit here recently, but the fundamental story seems fairly robust, particularly in terms of billings. I guess there's two ways you can reconcile that disagreement. One is the fundamental story is somehow not capturing something that investors are appropriately worried about, or investors are just way overreacting on the downside. And I guess how do you know the difference? Because I it sounds like you're making the evidence, the argument that these stocks are now too low, and it makes sense that the long-term fundamental story makes sense. But how do you make that decision as to which one of those is wrong? Does that make sense?

17:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh,

17:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): 100%. well, I think that's uh precisely the right question to be asking. And to be fair, we really don't know the the answer for for certain, but we can take uh an educated guess. And I mean, look, the I uh think history is replete with examples of uh stocks deviating from. their their fundamentals as as discussed. This one really stood out because we've never seen anything like it. And I'm not doing anything crazy with the data here. This is just taking the the difference between semiconductor stocks, that return we talked about in the prior slide. I didn't advance it, and uh the the billings growth that we're seeing in in uh the Americas. And those are growing. I didn't say this before, but I I really got to say it, are growing over 200%. And so what the stocks are telling us, right or wrong, is that they're expecting um a literal imminent CapEx cliff. And what I was rating for before I started buying SMH again, I just did that today, by the way.

18:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

18:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): at a lower price, which was kind of nice. But what what it was telling me, but judges judging by the results from NVIDIA, I'll pause on that one. They had double beats, top and bottom line beats. They they doubled their their revenues and their earnings, meaning the growth rates were over 100% for both, and they raised. their outlook. Their outlook beat the street. That was really the clue I was looking for. And of course, all of that was ratified by this blockbuster historic anthropic IPO. And so, you know, look, we might have some more downside, right? If if you're a technician, you might be more patient than I am. and wait to hit prior resistance and kind of treat it as new new support. Maybe we're we're not quite there, but uh I you know, I I'm not s so falsely precise. I'm I'm kind of I'm willing to to dip a toe and and kind of build a position slowly and just wait and see what happens three to six months out.

19:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): That and it's so funny, uh Tally when you know, before you and I met, I was at Bloomberg and I spent a lot of time uh with hedge funds on trading floors and everything. And there was an urgency and an immediacy to timing things perfectly. Like it was this strive for perfection. Then I went to Fidelity, where you and I first met, and I was taught there was a lot of wiggle room, especially if your horizon is long enough. We want to be focusing less on the flickering ticks of the daily movement. movements and just having more of these kind of thoughts, which is like where are we at relative to where we probably should be based on some valuation. That's why I think your your work really resonated with me. And I should make a note, I meant to mention earlier, we'll definitely include a link to um this article on LinkedIn. I would encourage people to follow your work there because it it's really well, it's thought provoking, really well done, Tally. I'm

20:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): humbled. Thank you.

20:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I appreciate you sharing it. This is another one, and again, it is all sort of a similar theme about, you know, sort of looking where we're at in the cycle. And this is an interesting one because it's a regression analysis. Can you talk through sort of this regression look and where we're at relative to sort of this longer term trend uh in semiconductors?

20:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): So this is a little bit fancier, but it's kind of the basic framework for an historical vent study. And I, you know, this is the the quant facet. of the prism that we use to peer through or look through at at markets. And you know, I uh technical analysis is is part of the the multidisciplinarian approach here, but you got to have a little quant and a little bit of fundamentals. And that's hopefully coming out in the conversation here. But so what what we did here is we looked at uh the the ratio of semi-stocks to to billings. And uh again, I didn't advance or lag anything here, but what I did do a little fancier transformation, I did put it on uh a log scale just to kind of take a shot at normalizing these monthly moves since the late 1980s. I mentioned that earlier. So lots of history, this is really what you're you at. were asking about. And lots of uh cycles to kind of learn from and coax out some clues. But what I want to point out here on the far right hand side,

21:50you look there, we've had one of these kind of classic um negative uh divergences or deviations below the minus one standard error. And so that's that dotted line. I'm not, I'm not saying that it's support. I'm just saying that it's an interesting historical threshold that has had some meaning. And what do I mean by that? Well, I I mean, look, I'm I'm a simple Simon, Dave. I'm just saying okay, well, does this even matter? Why are we showing this to investors? Let's just take a look. So I tested I it. out. I I just measured the 12-month forward returns. Uh, you know, every time we had, and you're going right right there. Every time the the ratio fell below that uh meaningful trigger, what were the 12-month forward returns on the the stocks? And I measured it from those those three regimes. So when you're below, when you're above, and just uh the simple buy. and and hold. And again, just to bring out the numbers here, like we're talking about semis, right? So just the the simple naive strategy of buying and holding is it's been great, 17%, right? Market beating strategy. But I I just thought, look, you know, we we can be active

23:09because we're well informed. And yes, there's plenty of risk in this super cyclical situation. space, but it might be worth it because if you look in the far right hand side, that uh average and median return when you're below the minus one uh standard error is more than double the sample median. And so that's right where we are. I'm willing to take the risk because uh, you know, I'm I'm an aggressive, I'm not as young as I was, but I I'm uh more of an aggressive investor.

23:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,

23:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you know what it's funny, and and with a lot of these charts, I mean you you I think you hit on some really key points, Taler, which I think there are charts that you know that I use and other technical analysts use that are more for timing and more for identifying particular technical configurations that play on fear and greed, play on supply and demand and that relationship. But there are also charts that tell a deeper story and help you dig into. a theme a little bit better. And the charts you're sharing, I think, just help you help give us some context about where we're at right now because it it's so easy to overreact to the headlines as opposed to focus more on the story and how it's evolving. Now you you illustrated a beautiful um uh you know picture there at the end, the histogram showing, you know, Ford forward returns when we're sort of you know, undervalued for lack of a better, better term. And what's happening? But again, you know, those are median returns or average returns of of some sort. So my question always, and I think for a lot of investors is what does the this time is different scenario look like, right? I mean, what if we don't follow the average and things deteriorate? Or I guess the way to ask a different way, what what would it look like, or what would you see or hear that would tell you, okay, this isn't following the playbook. Things are really starting to deteriorate more than I might expect. What would be those signs that would tell is it something from a future earnings

25:00release? Is it some sort of broader signal that that would tell you, uh-oh, this time might be different?

25:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah. Well, to be clear, this time really is different in the sense that the stocks have deviated so far below the fundamentals. Tech technically it's not a valuation concept. It's more of uh how far away are the stocks from their intrinsic value type of concept. But I I would and you know if you were to ask me what's the the one chart I've been looking at the most in these environment in these environments or the these uh these past few weeks? It's the weekly economic index. Why? Well, it's a high frequency macroeconomic indicator that helps me take the pulse of activity across the most important uh sectors of the US economy. And as long as I know that we've got a nice three handle, I'm more inclined to believe that this is one of those buy the

26:08dips moments. Plus, earnings are growing over 30% for the index. And I'm kind of triangulating the company specific earnings and outlooks from those two major players that. I think really kind of help us engage and make the trade.

26:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I'm a big believer in learning from people who have spent years thinking deeply about markets, investing, and human behavior. That's why my recommended reading list includes books like Thinking Fast and Slow by Daniel Kahneman, Mastering the Marketing. Market Cycle by Howard Marks, and Atomic Habits by James Clear. But finding time to sit down with the book can be tough. That's where audiobooks can help. You can listen while you're out for a walk, driving, or doing things around the house, and keep learning even when you're away from your desk. If you'd like to explore audiobook editions of these books and much more, check out Audible at Market MarketMisbehavior.comslash Misbehavior.com. Audible. That's MarketMissbehavior.com/slash audible, where you can browse what's available and see the current options for memberships.

27:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You

27:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): had mentioned earlier, uh Tally, and I remember your piece talking about rotating into software, which ended up being pretty timely, right? Because there's been this sort of, you know, pretty interesting pairs trade in technology. It's like semiconductors versus software. And I think logically that that relationship makes sense. So if this seems to be an interesting time to look at semiconductors, what does that mean for the software space? Because that's been sort of the other big group in tech where I know there's a lot of focus as well.

27:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Oh man. So just I've been talking about this. I I brought this up. I was kind of pitching my case to the investment strategy committee on Tuesday. And, you know, I'm the macro voice there, but that was a phenomenal successful trade. So IGV is how I chose to express it, being the top-down guy that I am. And this year, from Trough to Peak, we had a 50% plus move. And it was a deeply contrarian. one. But for risk management purposes, purely given the success, I just decided recently to, and this is my kind of prudent steward of capital putting my cap on and deciding to protect those gains because uh we did see some s uh some weakness. uh since since the peak. And I I think since then the the group has given back about 15%. So I I think for now that I think was the the right move in terms of locking in the the gains. And we'll we'll allow the given the the

29:07excitement around anthropic and the the kind of existential threat that poses to the SaaS delivery model running run its course and reassess. But I I think there's been, like we said, there's there's been Armageddon basically in semis. So the if you look at, I think the if I'm remembering my chart correctly, if you look at um semis relative to software alongside tech relative to the market, we had after a massive move. in favor of semis up to about May, the pendulum has swung almost back to the zero line. So that was another indicator in my toolkit that I was looking at to say, okay, hey, maybe we should do some switching coolard jets. And I'm I'm okay, you know, kind of nibbling and and kind of dipping a toe here amidst the panic.

30:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Tally, this has been awesome. We'll definitely include a link to the article you wrote on LinkedIn. And again, I'd encourage everyone to follow your work. It's really uh it's independent thought. It's well researched, but has always sort of encouraged me to dig deeper. And I I thank you for that. Thanks for coming on the show today. Look forward to having you back again, but for now, So uh thanks again.

30:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): My pleasure. Thanks, Dave.

30:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well

30:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): it was a lot of fun catching up with uh Tally and I hope you enjoyed uh the conversation. Uh Tally and his team invited me to uh on their podcast earlier this year, and I really had fun talking with them about investor decision making and psychology and how technical analysis fits into the process. And it was a lot of fun to bring uh Tally uh on my show to talk about some of his work in uh in evaluating semiconductor stocks and where they may be in the cycle. I mean, what an interesting time to have this conversation. right? During the week of uh of NVIDIA's earnings, uh the week after Jensen Huang uh leaves as Nvidia's CEO on the day of Anthropics IPO. Um so it was really timely I think to dig into uh into some of these themes. You know a couple a couple observations on on what we talked about and make sure uh you check out the article. I'll include a link to that uh to that LinkedIn article that uh that we use in the discussion. But some of the charts are really interesting. And and I I can't deny, I can't, you know, refute his statistical analysis of where we're at in this cycle, right? I mean, by by that particular valuation metric, for sure it seems like um it certainly appears that semiconductors are fairly undervalued relative to the possibility. And I guess the uh assumption we have to make based on Tally's work is that the strong

31:43revenues, right? You can see sort of that separation on that first chart of like really strong billings as he was uh describing it, which I'm kind of summarizing as generally revenues, versus the price action and just seeing this huge disconnect. And uh, you know, what we have to remember, and I think my what you know, reflecting on my conversation with Tally is that these stocks truly have just become so disconnected from the actual nuts and bolts of what is driving their business, right? And there's no denying that there's been a huge growth in the optimism for AI. What I love about this conversation is really focused on the momentum behind what should be driving their business uh higher, which I think is uh is really helpful. Uh and and again, some of those. uh you know charts showing the mean reversion, showing where we're at relative to kind of the average uh valuation, really, you know, really compelling. And that that idea of billings is one that I've not seen in a lot of places. So I thought that was uh that was pretty helpful.

32:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know,

32:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think Tally had some really interesting answers for those questions about um, you know, what tells you you're wrong. And that is a question I would love to ask I and I and I continue to love to ask. uh strategists that have a particular, you know, investment thesis, a particular point of view. Like what would you see that would tell you you're wrong? And what I've found is when people don't have a good answer for that question, in my opinion, that means it's an underdeveloped thesis, right? I think the way that you can, you know, believe in the the fruits of your labor, right? The The rigor of your investment process is if you've thought through some. different alternative scenarios and and sort of had the devil's uh you know the devil's advocate argument and and sort of uh you know thought through what other scenarios might look like and and help sort of solidify why your thesis makes sense. So I I really appreciated his sort of uh you know discussion about what what other things could how how things could certainly play out. At the end of the day, I think one Italy's of Tally's uh comments was uh was spot on, which is when we have any corrective move, re remember there's there's gonna be a path that the market takes. And if we do see further price deterioration be beyond what we've seen so far, um, you know, we could go much lower. Um, but what may happen is that the valuations just continue to look fairly attractive. And you know, I think

34:00his point is as a technical analyst, we think so much about timing as more of a fundamental strategy. So thinking about like what price can I pay now to participate in these future expected earnings. And when you think of it through that lens, pretty compelling. I would argue, and I think what what Tally pointed out was that there are different uh sort of pillars to the process, right? There's different sort of key parts to our uh, I think a well well-developed developed investment process. I tend to think of it as four key pillars, right? The fundamental, what are these companies doing? The technical, what is the price action telling you about sentiment and supply and demand? I think those two are incredibly important. The third one, which I didn't talk too much about, Tally, this time, but hopefully the next time he's on, we'll dig into a little further, the macro environment. And You mentioned at the end about sort of the macro conditions, but I think the macroeconomic, the geopolitical, that's one you know. important pillar. And then for me, behavioral, a crucial fourth one. And I'm sure if you think about your own investment process and think about the fundamental, the technical, the uh macroeconomic, and the behavioral, one or two of those you probably have pretty well covered, or you read You know, experts that have pretty good processes whose opinion you value. but I bet one or two of those uh could stand to uh to improve. I've spent most of my career

35:20and I continue to this day helping people with two of those in particular, the technical, which I just find is such a great way to manage risk, and I think that can help you avoid disasters much better than some of the others. And then the other one that I think is probably the most underappreciated, but arguably the one that has most. potential impact in a positive way on your process is the behavioral. That's why we call this podcast market misbehavior. It's an acknowledgement that we often misbehave with our finances and uh developing better routines and better insights. Uh, hopefully that helps steer us uh clear of market disruption. Thanks again to Tally Leger joining us from the Wealth Consulting Group. Great to see Tally again and really appreciate it. his uh his insights today on the technology space. By the way, if you want to learn more about some of those ways that we improve our uh our two pillars, the technical and the behavioral, and how we can use them in connection and in complement to the fundamental and the macroeconomic, our market misbehavior premium memberships may be a great opportunity for you to upgrade your investment process going into 2027. Three great benefits to the premium membership. First off, we will teach you all about behavioral and technical investment approaches with our virtual courses and our fantastic library of webcasts, which you

36:38can access. Number two, we have member-only reports like our morning coffee routine, our weekly flight plan, our monthly chart review. They are designed to help inform you and educate you about how we're applying the technical and behavioral toolkit. to the markets every trading day. Finally, you'll have full and immediate access to our brand new member community. We've made a major upgrade. It's a fantastic space, a lot of great content in there, and so many great plans for 2027. I would love for you to be a part of this growing community of like minded investors. Find more info at marketmisbehavior.comslash premium. We'd love to have you join us at premium. as a premium member here today. For now, I say thank you so much for joining us here on the Market Misbehavior Podcast. And remember, it's always a good time to own good charts. Take care, folks.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights