Market Misbehavior with David Keller, CMT

Wes Gray distinguishes momentum from trend following and warns against data-mined AI strategies.

39 min Listen to the original
Momentum InvestingTrend FollowingBehavioral FinanceData MiningETFsQuantitative StrategiesProcess ControlAI in Finance

Summary

Wes Gray explains that 'momentum' in academia refers to relative strength, while 'trend following' is time-series based, and he advocates for precise terminology. He attributes the persistence of the momentum factor to human behavioral biases like greed and fear, noting that smooth, compounding gains are superior to sudden spikes. Gray advises investors to align their strategy with their utility function, warning that benchmark-huggers must accept lower exposure while alpha-seekers must tolerate underperformance. He expresses skepticism toward complex regime-switching models and AI-generated strategies, citing data mining risks. Finally, he emphasizes controlling process and costs over chasing outcomes.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Investors must define their utility function: benchmark-relative performance requires blending with the index, while alpha-seeking requires tolerating significant underperformance periods.

    Wes Gray · 21:57

  2. 2
    AI tools lower the barrier to backtesting but increase the risk of 'AI slop'—strategies that are overfitted artifacts of existing data.

    Wes Gray · 29:06

Episode sections

  1. 0:37 – 5:21

    Introduction and Wes Gray's Evolution on Momentum

    Dave Keller introduces Wes Gray, CEO of Alpha Architect, discussing his shift from skepticism to embracing momentum as an evidence-based strategy, contrasting it with efficient market hypothesis views.

  2. 5:21 – 9:13

    Defining Momentum: Relative Strength vs. Trend Following

    Gray distinguishes between 'relative strength' (cross-sectional) and 'trend following' (time-series), arguing that 'momentum' is an imprecise term causing confusion.

  3. 9:13 – 13:23

    Persistence of the Momentum Factor

    Gray attributes momentum's persistence to behavioral biases like greed and fear, noting it exploits biological tendencies to follow winners.

  4. 13:23 – 17:36

    Frog in the Pan: Quality of Momentum

    The speakers discuss preferring 'smooth' momentum over sudden spikes, using the 'frog in the pan' metaphor and citing reflexive economics.

  5. 17:36 – 21:36

    Implementation Constraints and Rebalancing

    Gray explains why Alpha Architect's ETFs use monthly rebalancing due to regulatory, tax, and transaction cost constraints.

  6. 21:36 – 24:45

    Behavioral Hurdles and Benchmarking

    Gray advises investors to align momentum strategy with their utility function, distinguishing between benchmark-relative and alpha-seeking goals.

  7. 24:45 – 28:26

    Regime Switching and Data Mining Risks

    Gray expresses skepticism toward complex regime-switching models, citing data mining risks and the destruction of diversification benefits.

  8. 28:26 – 31:31

    AI and the Rise of 'AI Slop'

    Gray warns that AI tools democratize data mining, leading to 'AI slop'—strategies that are overfitted artifacts of existing data.

  9. 31:31 – 33:28

    Process Control and Bayesian Updating

    Gray argues for focusing on controllable process and costs, noting that statistical confidence requires long out-of-sample periods.

  10. 33:28 – 34:18

    Control vs. Outcome

    The host agrees with Gray's focus on controllable factors, comparing it to focusing on soccer performance rather than outcomes.

  11. 34:18 – 35:46

    Academic Backing and Behavioral Challenges

    The host praises Gray's academic backing of technical analysis and notes Gray's honesty about momentum pitfalls.

  12. 35:46 – 36:47

    Frog in the Pan Analogy

    The host discusses the 'frog in the pan' analogy, confirming it as part of Alpha Architect's methodology for selecting consistent momentum.

  13. 36:47 – 38:50

    Alpha Architect Products and Premium Membership

    The host mentions Alpha Architect and ETF Architect products and promotes his own premium membership for technical analysis resources.

Claims worth verifying

Wes Gray was originally part of the 'religion' that momentum is bogus and never could work.

Wes Gray ·2:56

How to verify: Check Wes Gray's professional biography or interviews where he discusses his academic background at the University of Chicago and his initial skepticism of momentum factors. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Eugene Fama is generally considered an 'anti-momentum guy' in the public domain.

Wes Gray ·3:15

How to verify: Review academic literature or public statements by Eugene Fama regarding the Efficient Market Hypothesis and the momentum anomaly, which he has historically attributed to risk factors or data artifacts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Jegadeesh and Titman's 1993 paper never mentioned the word 'momentum'.

Wes Gray ·5:26

How to verify: Read the abstract or full text of Jegadeesh, N., & Titman, S. (2026). 'Returns to Buying Winners and Selling Losers: Implications for Stock Market Efficiency.' Verify if the term 'momentum' appears in the title or text. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Documentation of momentum strategies exists from 300 years ago, early 1900s, 1960 (Levy), and 1993 (Jegadeesh/Titman).

Wes Gray ·9:16

How to verify: Search historical financial texts for 'momentum' or 'trend' strategies from the 1700s. Verify Murray Levy's 2026 paper 'The Value of Information from Technical Analysis' and the 2026 Jegadeesh/Titman paper for their dates and content. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Momentum is described as the 'greed trade' while value is the 'fear trade'.

Wes Gray ·10:40

How to verify: This is a conceptual claim. Verify by reviewing Wes Gray's book 'Quantitative Momentum' or Alpha Architect's educational materials where he defines these behavioral drivers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Alpha Architect's ETFs, such as Q QMOM, rebalance monthly.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·17:36

How to verify: Check the prospectus or fact sheet for the Alpha Architect Quantitative Momentum ETF (ticker: QMOM) to confirm the rebalancing frequency of its holdings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

AI tools like Claude allow anyone to replicate academic papers and backtest strategies in a day.

Wes Gray ·28:46

How to verify: This is a subjective assessment of AI capabilities. Verify by testing current LLM capabilities to generate code for backtesting or summarize academic papers, noting the ease of use compared to traditional programming. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Simple momentum strategies have a natural anti-correlation to value strategies.

Wes Gray ·26:38

How to verify: Review historical correlation data between momentum factor ETFs (e.g., MTUM) and value factor ETFs (e.g., AVUV) over long periods to verify the negative correlation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Wes Gray used 200 years of data in his history and stated it would take 50 years of out-of-sample data to dramatically update his process.

Wes Gray ·32:11

How to verify: Check the methodology section of Wes Gray's book 'Quantitative Momentum' or Alpha Architect's white papers for data sample sizes and backtesting periods. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Wes Gray co-authored the book 'Quantitative Momentum' with Jack Fogle.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·36:47

How to verify: Check the book cover or publisher information for 'Quantitative Momentum' on Amazon or the SEC EDGAR database for any related filings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

November 2026 is a period of unclear market leadership where momentum models may struggle.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·37:07

How to verify: Review market performance data for November 2026 to assess sector rotation and leadership changes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Alpha Architect and ETF Architect offer ETFs focusing on momentum and value strategies.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·36:47

How to verify: Visit the Alpha Architect or ETF Architect websites to view their current ETF offerings and investment mandates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

The 'frog in the pan' analogy refers to focusing on consistent momentum that compounds over time rather than big jumps.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·36:04

How to verify: Search for academic papers or articles discussing the 'frog in the pan' analogy in the context of momentum investing. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Wes Gray presented on momentum investing at a CMT Association of event in New York.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·34:18

How to verify: Check CMT Association event archives or presentations for Wes Gray's participation in New York. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

The host has a recommended reading list on his website that includes 'Quantitative Momentum'.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·33:52

How to verify: Visit marketmisbehavior.com/readinglist to verify the inclusion of 'Quantitative Momentum'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the distinction between cross-sectional momentum (Jegadeesh & Titman 1993) and time-series momentum in academic literature.
  • Check transaction cost estimates and tax implications for high-frequency rebalancing in taxable accounts versus ETF structures.
  • Review Alpha Architect's ETF prospectuses for specific rebalancing frequencies and turnover ratios.
  • Assess the robustness of regime-switching models by testing them against out-of-sample data to detect overfitting.
  • Evaluate AI-generated strategies for economic rationale rather than relying solely on backtested performance metrics.
  • Compare the performance of 'smooth' momentum screens against simple relative strength screens to verify the 'frog in the pan' hypothesis.
  • Identify periods of unclear market leadership to assess historical drawdowns and behavioral challenges of momentum strategies.
  • Review Bayesian updating principles to understand the data volume required to significantly alter a long-term investment process.
Full transcriptexpand
0:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Welcome to the Market Misbehavior Podcast, hosted by Dave Keller. Dave talks to top market practitioners, money managers, technical analysts, investment strategists, and authors to help you navigate the markets and become a more mindful investor. The content of this podcast should not be considered as a recommendation or
0:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): solicitation to buy or sell any security. All information is intended for educational purposes. only and should not be relied upon for any investment decisions. The host of this podcast, as well as any guests, may hold positions in securities discussed.
0:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Hey there everyone. Dave Keller here with Market Misbehavior, and welcome to our latest episode of the Market Misbehavior Podcast. Today's a really fun one. There are a couple books that I have on my recommended reading list on my website. MarketMisbehavior.com. A couple books focused on momentum investing, and one of those is Quantitative
0:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Momentum by Wes Gray and Jack Vogel. So I'm super excited to share a conversation today with Wes Gray, the CEO of Alpha Architect. We talk about momentum investing, the momentum factor, the difference between trend following and relative momentum, and everything in between. We talk about dealing with drawdowns,
1:17
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): following upside as long as possible, rebalancing and challenges with turnover, all the good things and all the challenging things about momentum. I think no matter whether you use quantitative approaches or you're more of a self directed investor, I think this discussion of trend following and momentum investing certainly will give you some food for thought. So please enjoy
1:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): this great conversation with Wes Gray. of Alpha Architect. Super excited to be speaking today with Wes Gray. Wes is the CEO of Alpha Architect. And Wes, you and I first met a number of years ago. You presented on momentum investing and the momentum factor at a CMT conference. And I never forgot it was one of the first time I heard sort
1:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): of an a really well well-articulated articulated academic justification for what momentum is. and how it works. So I'm excited to have you on the show and and uh welcome.
2:08
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
2:08
Wes Gray: appreciate being here. And uh yeah, great to reconnect. It's been a long time.
2:12
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It's been a while. It's been a while. So, I mean, Wes, let me let me start here. I mean, you have a really interesting, a fascinating career path, to be honest with you. You served in the Marine Corps, then you made the very obvious, you know, career shift of studying finance at the University. of Chicago, um, at you know, sort of the epicenter of quantitative investing, and then eventually
2:32
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): founding Alpha Architect. And I'm I'm curious, as you've sort of spent your career, I think, making a name for yourself, applying, you know, really academic evidence to the markets. What's the biggest thing you've learned about the difference between what should work in theory and what
2:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): is actually able to be implemented in the markets?
2:55
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh,
2:56
Wes Gray: I mean, I think the biggest thing I've learned through my journey, because we could talk about it, is is I was originally part of the religion that momentum is bogus, you know, never could work, like this is crazy. How could this stupid price thing matter? To just, you know, not being religious based. but being
3:15
Wes Gray: genuinely evidence-based and and you know, reading lots of literature, lots of resources, um, and just not being so pigeonholed. Because going back to my University of Chicago days, you know, one of my advisors is Eugene Fama, who obviously is the anti-momentum guy, generally speaking, in the in the public domain.
3:35
Wes Gray: And and it's hard to uh not carry that forward. a little bit. So it took me a while uh to really get my head wrapped around momentum uh as a trading strategy, even as academic discipline, just at a high level. I f I finally got there, uh, but I I think that's the biggest lesson learned is just make sure you're actually being
3:55
Wes Gray: evidence based, not not religious based. You know, even if you think you're an academic and you're trying to be scientific about it. It's it's easy to fall prey to, you know, idea creep and uh get snookered into, you know, one line of thinking.
4:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And I mean, credit to you, Wes, because I think for many in the financial industry, I mean, in in many different roles, th those early mentors that you have in a lot in in some ways inspire you to do really good things in the industry. And and it sounds like that, that's certainly part of it for you. But also a lot of times they can kind of narrow your vision. uh, you know, for better or worse. And so being able to
4:29
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): open up to other possibilities later is not is not as easy as uh as I'm sure people would probably want. So kudos for actually making that, you know, for adapting and recognizing uh something that works. Um, you know, I momentum is certainly where you and I overlap quite a bit. I mean, you you you I think think of the markets in a much more
4:49
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): quantitative lens than I do, but at the end of the day, and this is what I got out of your presentation years ago, is that we're we're still looking at price and we're still looking for signal in that price and and trying to, you know, identify areas of strength. So, I mean, a total rookie question, but we throw around the term like momentum very often. But I'm curious how you,
5:09
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): over your career and at this point, like how do you describe momentum? If someone asks you, like, what is momentum investing? What is the momentum factor? What does that mean for you and how you're trying to play this game every every day?
5:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
5:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): know, that is actually a really good question. Uh, and it's important to highlight because uh a lot
5:26
Wes Gray: of people don't even know this, but like the there's this famous academic paper, uh, the Jigadee S and Tipman 93. They never even mentioned mention the word momentum, right? Like, like momentum is relative strength. And then somewhere along the line, the academics turned it into momentum. Um, but momentum can be a can mean a lot of
5:46
Wes Gray: different things to a lot of different people. So the more appropriate way, which again, I learned the hard way after the fact because I start off as an academic, not as a practitioner, is It's like there's this thing called relative strength that's been around for, I don't know, a gazillion years. And and but now unfortunately it's kind of confused with this term
6:06
Wes Gray: momentum. Because momentum also can be related to trend following, which which which is another thing we'll talk about. So it's it's not really a great idea to call something just momentum. So momentum to me doesn't mean anything. It's really like, well, what do you what do you what aspect of momentum are you talking about? And really we should go back to kind of the practitioner terms of
6:26
Wes Gray: relative. strength momentum. And that type of momentum, as you obviously know, and all your audience already knows, that's just where you look at a point in time and you compare a whole bunch of things together. Which one is relatively stronger? If something's been doing really well, well, we like it. If something's been doing really poorly, we don't like it. So that that
6:46
Wes Gray: that is one definition of momentum, but really that's called relative strength. And now and that would be in that context. Um, and then just to finish that thought, there's a different type of momentum, also price shouldn't be called momentum because it could be confused with relative strength, but that might be like your time series momentum or absolute momentum, uh, and that
7:06
Wes Gray: or trend falling, and that'd be the concept where okay, we're just looking at one asset here. Is this one asset like doing relatively well relative to its history? Great, we like it. Is it trending or does it have momentum? Or oh wait, this thing is doing terrible or it's underperforming T-bills.
7:26
Wes Gray: We should get away from this thing. It it that's also momentum, but but that that's what you know people call trend following, what have you? But the problem is the term momentum, you know, that's just generic because it could mean a lot of different trading strategies. Uh
7:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um, so
7:40
Wes Gray: I've come around to like the uh instead of calling things momentum, I think it's better to call like relative strength because it's pretty clear what you're talking about or trend falling. Pretty clear what we're talking about.
7:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes. But
7:51
Wes Gray: momentum is is a is a is an academic word a lot of people use, but it it's not very precise.
7:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): No, and I and I feel like a lot of people just talk about momentum investing as this thing, but I I think that means a very different things to a lot of different people. And I and I appreciate you sort of hitting that distinction, right? It's sort of like absolute price action, right? Looking at price returns over time and comparing those versus like a relative strength or maybe like a relative momentum where you're looking at
8:17
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): one asset or one data series versus others and making that sort of differentiation. So I have to ask you this, right? Because I I remember reading your book, Quantitative Momentum. It's probably after. I heard you speak, and I thought, this is awesome. I want more. And I remember reading that, and you've had another number of other books on the value factor, on combining the two, which are really well done with uh with Jack
8:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Vogel. And I'm curious, like since you wrote that book on quantitative momentum, it strikes me that rereading that book, a lot of those concepts are still very relevant in 2026, right? Even though the idea of the momentum factor has become much more widespread. How do you, I guess, reconcile
8:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): the fact that it's become more commonly, I mean, the awareness has grown, but the factor's still still relevant. What is it that allows this factor to be persistent, despite the fact that, you know, one could argue maybe it should be like arbed out by
9:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): now?
9:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yeah, so so that's a common.
9:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): uh
9:16
Wes Gray: idea for all these different ideas that quote unquote work. Uh, momentum is particularly interesting, uh, interesting because it has this long history where where people you can find documentation from like 300 years ago of people talking about momentum strategies, and then they talked about it in the early 1900s, right? And then and
9:36
Wes Gray: then uh uh Levy had that paper in nineteen sixty. 1967.
9:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah.
9:40
Wes Gray: And then it re-emerged in 93. And then I haven't been paying attention to the journals the last 10 or 15 years, but I'm sure there's some other new momentum paper. And what's funny is when you read all these things, they all basically say the same thing: relative strength works on average. Does it work all the time? Of course not. Is it does it have insane
10:00
Wes Gray: drawdowns? Is it really painful to hold through thick and thing? Yes, of course. It's miserable existence. But on average, over long periods of time, this stupid idea of buying winners and if you like doing the short side, short, you know, selling the losers tends to work. And so anytime something like that
10:19
Wes Gray: has been an open secret for so long over at this point, centuries, like you start to think it's baked in the cake. And I can make the same argument for value strategies. And in particular, I I usually label the two things it's fear and greed, right? The fear trade is the value trade. Like you're buying junk,
10:40
Wes Gray: you know, fuddy duddy things. It's just like, why would you want to own that? Because AI's taking over. And that's kind of like the fear trade. And then obviously the greed trade is everyone wants to be on. the roller coaster that's already currently moving quickly because it might go even faster. And and hic history actually seems to suggest that that's actually true because
11:00
Wes Gray: humans just like to follow what works. It's like a almost, I think, like a biological thing. So I I feel like momentum is is just the greed trade or the greed sense in human behavior and kind of value or buying junk. or buying low, cheap, you know, things that everyone hates is kind of like the value trade. And in
11:20
Wes Gray: some form or another, you don't have to complicate it. I feel like those two functions of the market, even if Claude, you know, it's already obviously way smarter than all of us combined already. As long as the humans are still involved in like in the end, there's gonna be fear and greed. And I feel like momentum is the way to pick up the greed side of
11:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that.
11:39
Wes Gray: trade. It's just that simple.
11:41
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah. Oh, that's well said. And I love that comment about the human, uh, the human factor, right? I mean, that's still very, still very much the the uh the reality here. And I and I'm and I I would say I the argument I often make is that models are trying to quantify human behavior, right? In the end of the day, that's what we're doing with the momentum factors, trying to quantify buy and sell
12:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): decisions that a bunch of irrational individuals. are probably making.
12:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): If you like the idea of getting a couple of stock ideas to research each month, take a look at Alpha Picks from Seeking Alpha. Their quantitative team uses a data-driven process to select two stocks each month, and members receive sell alerts when a pick no longer meets the services criteria. You can also follow the portfolio
12:26
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): and see how the picks have performed. Right now there's a special offer: fifty dollars off the annual subscription, bringing the first year to four hundred forty-nine dollars. You can find the details at Market Misbehavior.com/slash alpha picks. Inject better ideas into your process at
12:44
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): marketmisbehavior.com/slash Behavior dot com slash alpha picks.
12:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
12:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): there's a concept. in technical analysis, as I'm sure you're aware, um, Wes, where you know the path matters, right? If you have two stocks and one's just kind of in this nice slow, low volatility uptrend, and the other one's kind of flat and then has this huge spike. Those two charts are not the same, right? Because one is showing kind of persistent momentum, Some one is kind
13:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): of sudden momentum. Is that sort of differentiation something that is incorporated in in your process or in a good momentum process in some way? And how do you uh sort of uh you know think about that or how do you how do you quantify those that relationship?
13:23
Wes Gray: Yep. So uh generally speaking, like I'm not saying what we do is correct. There's a million ways, and and the most important part of any process is discipline and sticking to it. So so what I'm about to say is just you know. different ideas, but but if you have your own version and you stick to it and you're
13:43
Wes Gray: comfortable with it and you're willing to stick through it through thick and thin, that's always going to be a better strategy than than anything I say. Right. And so and so generally speaking, like when we're talking about relative strength momentum, it seems to be the case on average, over long periods of time, you know, when you throw the the darts at enough data points. and
14:03
Wes Gray: try to think about the underlying human beings involved. Any strategy that does relative strength where it kind of focuses obviously on like winners, but then amongst winners, to your point, there's different types of winners. There's a winner that went up 100% in a day, and there's a winner that went up, you know, 50 bips a day Hey, for 200 days or what have you. And they're they're
14:23
Wes Gray: both momentum, but they got there very differently. And it's it seems to be the case, and there I think there's good arguments for why, that momentum continuation
14:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
14:33
Wes Gray: on average more gonna likely to be tied to the one that had that slow kind of build up momentum as opposed to like a spike, like a lottery stock uh activity. Um, and so we use this thing called frog in the pan, but you know, people use you know nearness to 52 52-week week high, you know. regression models, it you know,
14:53
Wes Gray: uh idiosyncratic risk adjustment. It doesn't really matter. The idea is is it seems that you just want to kind of avoid like the biotech stock that went up a hundred percent in a day, even though it has a hundred percent return and the other stocks don't. Like whatever system you have that kind of quantifies the difference between like the biotech and you
15:13
Wes Gray: know the other kind of smooth. momentum, it you're gonna get to the same spot in the end. And again, we use the frog in the pan algorithm, which is basically just a day's count of you know, we we want to have a lot of small days as opposed to one huge day, but any method out there that kind of captures that concept, I think is good
15:33
Wes Gray: enough for government work, uh, for lack of a better term.
15:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Wes frog in the pan is up there now with dead. cat bounce for my favorite metaphors to describe price
15:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): action. That's another good one.
15:43
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Uh, we'll keep that one uh for sure. But I like that, right? It's just those little kind of little, you know, those
15:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): little
15:48
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): those little movements that that compound into some interesting movement over time.
15:52
Wes Gray: And the economic logic, because you don't always want to just think about like, oh, what's the back test say? But but one of the things I've become more convinced about, and this is arguable because there might be both. aspects of this but I kind of like the like if you're thinking about through the like the lens of let's call it Eugene Fama like a rational person I do believe that that um
16:12
Wes Gray: there's an under it's an underweight to news right and this underreaction because price action itself is reflexive like actually the Andorle Andorl CEO just said that the other day where he's like we can crush it on on like our firm because we can just raise money in the capital markets at like really cheap prices. That's
16:32
Wes Gray: momentum because it the more momentum, weirdly, the more it funnels back into cheap cost of capital, which gives you more economic advantage, which makes you go even higher. And so it's like this this constant underreaction to positive price action actually does reflectively affect fundamentals in ways that people understand. underreact to.
16:52
Wes Gray: Which so I'm kind of a big believer in the slow frog in the pan momentum because it's a it's a way to mechanically capture this kind of reflexive idea. Whereas the biotech goes up a hundred percent and says, Hey, we discovered a drug. Everyone on the planet knows that and has reacted to that. Like, well, you know, there's no
17:12
Wes Gray: reflexive action. So I think all these all ideas. they're not just gobbledygook uh, you know, back test data mining, which there's obviously some of that too. But uh I do think I I believe in the in the narrative and the the the underpinning economics of why those work better.
17:28
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Um Wes, you and I were speaking just before we got started uh with ETF architect. I know you have a number of um
17:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
17:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): ETFs that are that are that are growing in assets. Q QMOM is the one that comes to mind because I know that was the first one I really looked at after I read quantitative momentum. If I remember right, I think those all monthly rebalance on on the on their holdings. And I'm curious if just at a high level, that's one of those things as a technical analyst always kind of bugs me
17:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): because you're kind of locking into this kind of arbitrary, kind of 30-day 30 day rebalance as opposed to the market. moves so we want to adapt. How do you as a you know with a with a quantitative methodology match or I guess sort of balance that need to react to ch shifts in market dynamics versus the consistency of just doing
18:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): a monthly rebalance when it might just not be the right day of the month to be doing it if that makes sense.
18:21
Wes Gray: Yeah. No, it makes a lot of sense and and if you have the luxury, if you could just build a computer, it didn't pay frictional costs, or didn't pay taxes, or didn't have to deal with all the uh the problems of running an ETF, and I could just set up my interactive brokers account and just roll with it and do momentum,
18:40
Wes Gray: rebalance it every single day and not have to worry about it. You know, arguably that is a better approach, obviously. The just because it intuitively, like you want to always. be chasing the best relative strength in real time. But but unfortunately, there's the reality of of like, you know, we're in a in that particular situation, we're
19:00
Wes Gray: in like a registered fund context. Yeah.
19:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
19:03
Wes Gray: we're also most people are taxable and and you know we're dealing with like large quantities of capital. So it's just there's a lot of trade-offs, unfortunately, that that I got to deal with and a lot of people got to deal with, where I can't just run it in my SMA personal account and like trade it every second of the day. Because it's actually
19:23
Wes Gray: in the end, after taxes, after fees, after chaos, it's actually worse. Um, so yeah, it it's uh I'm not gonna say that like our method is better than other methods, it's just our context and constraints are different than many others, and we're just trying to make the best trade. trade-offs for people as best we can. But you know, unfortunately,
19:43
Wes Gray: we don't, you know, don't operate in a vacuum. Uh, but that would be nice if we could, but we don't.
19:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, and and and I and I think that's a really good point, Wes, because I I know I just know for my fidelity days, there are always trade-offs you have to make. And I mean, for us,
19:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah,
19:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): at that point, it was our size was a huge limiting factor. So there's only so much you could do. You couldn't be very nimble. So a lot of times we couldn't be as tactical as we wanted to, even if we saw opportunities, you do have to operate within the constraints. And and that balance is what makes I think a hopefully a good firm and and and make
20:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): their
20:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): shareholders happy is being able to to manage those trade-offs well. So I appreciate you talking talking through that.
20:20
Wes Gray: And and we it in our case we try because one of the key things with momentum weirdly is turnover. That's the point. Like if stocks are changing a lot, you should have a lot of turnover, which is unfortunate, but that's just true. And so we we've tried to max out as much of that as possible
20:40
Wes Gray: in uh given our our world. But but you know, to the extent you said, you know, like we were talking about, if I didn't have any constraints and I could daily rebalance or even every 30 minutes. rebalance with like some sort of guardrails, and I got my frictional costs way down. I didn't care about taxes. I mean, you could really go crazy and have insane
21:00
Wes Gray: turnover and and theoretically have you know great performance. Um we we try to do the we're we're I would argue we're the most intense amongst those that are stuck in you know ETF mutual fund. world professional management world just because it's more difficult to your point.
21:19
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So you hit on a key um I guess challenge for a lot of investors to you know going into a momentum strategy, the turnover, right? Which often can be a lot higher than in an average uh return. The the drawdowns can a lot of times be a lot more significant, significance certainly, right? When the momentum starts to shift. How
21:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how
21:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): do you I guess how do you suggest or how do you encourage people to overcome, I guess, some of the behavioral hurdles between you know accepting the risks of a behavi of a of a momentum strategy that are they're just kind of baked into I think the models from from the beginning, right?
21:52
Wes Gray: Yeah, I mean I I've learned over the years there there's
21:57
Wes Gray: it's just trade-offs and you got to decide what you want to be when you grow up. So it if you're if you just know are your systems or your incentives are set up where you can't be too far off a benchmark, then obviously you're gonna have to build a product that's 99% benchmark, 1% momentum signal.
22:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
22:16
Wes Gray: you the and that's actually a hard thing to stray off of in reality. Now, to the extent you can kind of be crazy and you're like, I don't really care what the benchmark's doing. are I just want to go purely after the momentum. You can also do that, but but obviously you're accepting you know, you just gotta be
22:36
Wes Gray: able to say to yourself, Hey, when I look myself in the mirror and I'm beating the benchmark by 20 this year, but next year I'm losing to it by 30.
22:46
Wes Gray: Am I gonna hold the path here? Like, you
22:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
22:49
Wes Gray: I'm like Mando, like this is. the way. Am I that guy who's never gonna take off his helmet because this is the way? Or is it like, you know, I'm gonna take my helmet and go like go buy the SP? Like so, you just need to investors just need to think like, like, how much do I care about relative performance to the benchmark? Um, and if that's
23:09
Wes Gray: extremely important to you or your constituents, then you got to be kind of careful with how you build momentum for. portfolios. Where if you're willing to kind of go a little bit nutty and just like, I don't care what the benchmark does, I just want the pure momentum juice because I value the correlation, I value the expected returns, and I'm willing to look like an
23:28
Wes Gray: idiot or a hero at any given point, potentially for years, then you could shift more towards the just whoop it on version. But I there's no right answer because. that's just a utility function uh question.
23:43
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I'm curious. I I'm sure as you've probably noticed, the markets have been, you know, volatile and challenging here in the last couple months, right? We and we've we've certainly seen, you know, quite a leadership rotation from like kind of everything AI leading to all of a sudden a lot of other things starting to starting start to improve. And it strikes me with the with the momentum approach, and you certainly find it with a
24:02
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): lot of technical analysis, kind of trend following strategies. Not that what we do is ever easy, but there are times when the trends seem very straightforward. It seems pretty clear what's working and what's not. And you just want to make sure that you stick with that as long as possible. But then there are periods like this where it feels like a transition and you feel that things that had been working are
24:22
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): starting to not work. And I'm curious how you, having gone through a number of kind of transitional periods like that, how do you think of momentum, you know, not in a very clear cut what's working, what's not market, but more of a transition market. And how do you sort of think about emerging leadership versus not, you know, selling too early out
24:42
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): of leadership that's been working?
24:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
24:46
Wes Gray: So that that's a great question. And the problem is I don't think there's a good answer. Like reality, right? Like and the problem is you could data mine yourself until you're blue in the face. And of course, there's a million papers out there that talk about technical switch. Like, go, you know, you know, you you start off with a long-term signal, but if
25:06
Wes Gray: the volatility spikes, you move to a short-term signal or whatever. There, there's a million of these papers out there, but but the problem is there's they're so susceptible to data mining because there's only so many histories we get a run because we we only live on the planet for one time. It's not like we have like independent samples, and and so so
25:26
Wes Gray: you're already in the data mining. Like if you use any signal, you kind of like all right, I've already back tested the hell out of this thing, and I have economic foundations, which is great, but you know, I've already
25:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know
25:38
Wes Gray: drew. one straw out of it. And it now I'm like, all right, I got one straw, the factor, relative strength. And now I'm going to do another data mine to figure out how to switch between the two. And then people are like, well, let's do two or three of them and average them. And and how did you pick the two or three ideas? Oh, I saw it in an academic paper. You don't think that was already data mined? So so the problem is
25:58
Wes Gray: there's so much hidden data mining in all this stuff. Like weirdly, like the most simple brain dead, like evergreen ideas, they are not perfect. And obviously on the back test, they're never gonna be the best. But we always just gotta think critically about like it is the signal
26:18
Wes Gray: uh of like doing some regime shifting model it like how much is the noise on that? And if I can't get insanely confident of uh on like the potential benefits of that, I also I always gotta remember like what am I giving up? Because one of things that we know, at least in my personal portfolio use, one thing that that I I don't know anything, but
26:38
Wes Gray: like one thing I'm pretty confident about is the natural correlation structure of just pr brain dead momentum strategy uh versus value and other things that I own. owe. And so I I I just just I so for me, I'm like, all right, if I start timing it and now I'm taking my momentum strategy where I know it's probably gonna have an
26:58
Wes Gray: anti-correlation to like what all my value and all my other crap's doing, that's a known benefit at the portfolio level. The minute I say, well, let's instead of doing straight momentum that I understand, let's time it. And I'll go from like a long-term signal and then wait, if it, you know, if something happens, we'll shift to the energy and the value stocks and do a short-term
27:18
Wes Gray: signal. And then all of a sudden, I just collapse this diversification benefit because I probably ended up turning it into a value signal on accident. And so, unless unless something is insanely compelling, there's great economic foundations, there's a million academic papers that have hazed it and they've tested on a million regimes across the world over a thousand
27:37
Wes Gray: years. And it seems to be kind of robust. I just can't get my head wrapped around it. And this is like the timing regime thing. I just I can't, I've not got there yet. Not that I couldn't be convinced, but it's it's not, it's like a low conviction thing, uh, I'd say.
27:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): No, and I appreciate you talking about things like data mining, uh, curve fitting, uh, because I, you know, social media these days is filled with people that have, you know, cracked the code of the market. and they've created some back tests and they've kind of figured it out and and then of course we we kind of know how that usually follows when you when you put real money behind a lot of those strategies so um I think that's well
28:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): said right that looking for robustness looking for you know validation through a lot of different uh different uh different uh tests and and things like that.
28:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
28:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): curious
28:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what's really
28:24
Wes Gray: dangerous now I don't know if you yeah I
28:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean
28:26
Wes Gray: I
28:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): don't
28:26
Wes Gray: know if I mean I'm sure you probably use AI. I'm like a huge like AI nerd. Yeah. I mean I I'm like such a buyer that it's taken over the world at this point because 'cause I just see my own work I'm like, this is this is cheating. It's absolutely insane. And and and now the problem is like the like in the old days, like I feel like like my PhD brain is
28:46
Wes Gray: worthless. Like AI can like literally replicate every academic paper known to man in like a day and do it better find all the i mean it's crazy to me so i i feel like all that that that used to be there used to be a cost to like back test and think care carefully build studies do all the data cleaning now it
29:06
Wes Gray: it's just anybody with Claude can do that which is awesome I think it's great but the but the problem is when there's a low cost to entry and there's probably a low cost to like thinking about stuff, you you just have like the the AI slop. Uh and and now like I just feel like data and backtesting and
29:26
Wes Gray: data mining is just it's a guarantee. It's not even like, is it happening? Maybe it's like I 100% Percent guarantee it's happening. And and if you use those tools,
29:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
29:37
Wes Gray: mean that that's mechanically what. what's going on, and that's not to say they're not great tools, they can't inform what you might do, but you just want to be really, really skeptical of like, oh my god, Eureka, I found a new thing that 200 years of PhDs messing around with data didn't already find. Like, yeah, I'm sure the AI probably just recovered what someone already found,
29:57
Wes Gray: and and you shouldn't believe it's like you know, a Eureka moment,
30:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): approaching all of those. things with healthy skepticism, I don't think is a bad thing at all, Wes. I I would I would tend to agree.
30:09
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I'm a big believer in learning from people who have spent years thinking deeply about markets, investing, and human behavior. That's why my recommended reading list includes books like Thinking Fast and Slow by Daniel Kahneman, Mastering the Market Cycle by Howard Marks, and Atomic Habits by James
30:28
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Clear. But finding time to sit down with the book can be tough. That's where audiobooks can help. You can listen while you're out for a walk, driving, or doing things around the house, and keep learning even when you're away from your desk. If you'd like to explore audiobook editions of these books and much more, check out Audible at
30:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): MarketMisbehavior.com/slash marketmisbehavior.com slash Audible. That's marketmisbehavior.com slash audible, where you can browse what's available and see the current options for memberships.
31:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): My
31:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): my last question is this, right? How how do you differentiate, I guess, between right, 'cause cause any sort of factor um will have periods of of strong performance and then a periods of underperformance, Performance, right? And there are times when the momentum factor has worked remarkably well, and then times when it just does not, you know, sort of under its its average returns. How do you differentiate between a strategy or a factor that's kind
31:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): of temporarily underperforming, but still seems like it has value over the long term versus something whose like underlying edge has just evaporated or has just disappeared?
31:31
Wes Gray: Yeah. So I I don't again, I don't really know the exact answer. The only thing that I know is process and transmission. transparency, process and cost, right? Like the only thing we can use ex ante is understand the process thoroughly, understand the costs, understand the trade-offs, and just
31:51
Wes Gray: place your bets. Obviously, when the casino starts and we're all playing our games out there, you know, ex x post, the results are going to be all over the map. And but but but you never say, like, oh, look. at their results like like let's chase that shiny object or let's chase that shiny object because because you're forgetting like what
32:11
Wes Gray: why did it what what's the ex annie thing like i need to always like what do i control i don't control the market outcome i control my process and i control my cost so it's just you you always got to go back and think like okay and we always want to be like Bayesians we always want to consider market realizations, but we also want to be Bayesians in the sense that, like, wait,
32:31
Wes Gray: I spent I used 200 years of data in this whole history. And yeah, I can take new data and input, but remember statistically, I need to live out of sample for 50 years to actually be able to like update my process dramatically. Right? It's just the facts. And so the problem is. like, okay,
32:51
Wes Gray: that means you're kind of like stuck. Like, if you kind of got your process, you got your system, you got your beliefs. You know, we could do fine-tuned updates out of sample, but we but in order to really have confidence, we should change the system out of sample. If we're thinking through like statistical lens, you know, we need to be around for 50 years. And maybe do some, but I mean, the problem is we don't get to
33:11
Wes Gray: live forever, and you got to like bet on something and stick to. some process. So I I didn't I don't know I don't I don't know really what you can glean from like out of sample short-term results in a super, super volatile world.
33:28
Wes Gray: You know, you just gotta only you can do is control your process and keep your costs down.
33:32
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I love your comments on process. I I tell my 10-year-old son about his soccer team, like stop focusing on things that are out of your control and focus on things that are in your control. And yeah, how we spend our time, what we read, what we watch, what we listen to, how we make decisions. Like, that's all stuff we can actually uh change. So you're speaking my language there, uh, for sure,
33:52
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Wes. This has been awesome. It's great to pick your brain a bit about momentum investing, Wes. Um, congrats on your successes with Alpha Architect. Thank you for writing books like Quantitative Momentum. which is absolutely on my recommended reading list on my website, and I think well deserved. I hope we can continue the conversation down the road. But for now, I say thanks so much for coming on the
34:12
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): show.
34:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
34:13
Wes Gray: honor to be here and uh appreciate what you do for uh educating the communities out there.
34:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
34:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): that was a lot of fun and thanks again, Wes, for joining us uh on the show today. Uh I met, as I mentioned, uh I met Wes years ago at a CMT association of event in New York. Uh and uh it was one of the first times I'd seen an academic uh an academic present on momentum investing and and basically provide academic, I
34:38
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): mean, real-life academic backing for what technical analysts had assumed was true for many, many decades, if not many centuries. And I think uh what I love about Wes's work is he is very open. about the uh opportunities for momentum, right? And you heard him talk about the idea of relative strength, the relative momentum,
34:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): right, and and thinking about how we transition into leading names and how we follow those uh those charts, but also being very honest about the pitfalls, about the challenges, the behavioral challenges of dealing with higher turnover and higher drawdowns. Um, the uh the challenges through its a transition period, right? When the leadership is unclear, momentum models
35:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): often will struggle during those periods. And just thinking about
35:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): avoiding curve fitting, avoiding
35:26
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): data mining, all of those things that maybe cause you to overvalue the success or the the value of a particular uh model. And uh and I appreciate Wes's uh honesty about all of the abilities. above. I mentioned to Wes before we had started the uh discussion that uh when I met him he struck me as very humble and very honest
35:46
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): and I really appreciated that and uh I think that came out in this conversation today. Uh it was a lot of fun. And by the way, that frog in the pan uh analogy, that's a that's a great one. I had not heard that before. I actually had I was gonna ask him about that if he didn't offer it up because I saw a paper where it talked about that approach. And if you didn't quite understand, right, I
36:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean
36:04
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): it's the the frog on the page, just these little kind of blips, right? You wanna you wanna focus on, or at least what he was describing was their approach focuses on stocks kind of demonstrating more consistency in the momentum, which means little movements that compound into big movements over time. Big jumps often are one-off things,
36:24
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): often are not repeatable or sustainable.
36:28
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): And so as a result, stocks showing that consistent momentum way more ideal. And I know that their portfolios, they they sort of uh you know include that as part of their uh methodology. We'll certainly include a link in the description to Wes's book, Quantitative Momentum. That's one of a couple books he wrote with uh Jack Fogle that I think are really well done and and and uh
36:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): uh uh honestly are part of my uh my recommended reading. uh for investors. Uh also links you can learn more about their ETFs, because they do have ETFs uh at uh Alpha Architect and uh ETF Architect uh focusing on momentum and value strategies and combining them in meaningful ways. Thanks again, Wes, for joining us on the show and thanks for some really great
37:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): thoughts about momentum. Uh by the way, if you want to learn more about how we as technical analysts uh discover trends. and focus on relative and absolute momentum and try to recognize leadership through transitional periods, like I would argue, November of 2026 very much is one of. You might be interested in
37:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): our market misbehavior premium memberships. Three great benefits to the premium membership. First off, we will teach you all about technical analysis and behavioral investing with our virtual courses. Second, we will have uh give you access to our members only reports like our morning coffee routine that we put out every morning after the open, our weekly flight plan, our monthly chart review where we apply our
37:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): proprietary market trend models to uh long term uh trends. Finally, you'll have full and immediate access to our brand new member community. It is a really cool space with a lot of our great resources for investors, the opportunity to learn from each other, learn from other local. like-minded individuals. And I'm in there every day answering questions and uh
38:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): sharing some insights and words of wisdom. All of that can be yours today if you go to Market Misbehavior.comslash premium, and we'd certainly love to see some of you join as premium members today. That'll do it for today's episode of the Market Misbehavior Podcast. Special thanks to Wes Gray of Alpha Architect joining us on the show today. Please, if you have suggestions on who else would
38:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): be great to come on as a guest on the Market Misbehavior podcast, drop us a note in the comments section on our YouTube channel. We'd love to hear from you for sure. For market misbehavior, my name's Dave Keller. Reminding you, it's always a good time to own good charts. Take care, folks.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights