Stuart Weams argues index investing beats active management due to wealth concentration, volatility, and timing risks
Summary
Stuart Weams argues that index funds outperform active management over the long term due to low turnover, tax efficiency, and the statistical reality that a tiny fraction of stocks generate most market wealth. He cites data showing that in developed markets, roughly 2% of stocks created all shareholder wealth between 1990 and 2020, while the majority underperformed cash. Weams highlights that market returns are highly concentrated in a few days, often following sharp declines, making market timing ineffective. He also notes that intra-year volatility is normal and that investor behavior, such as buying high and selling low, further erodes returns compared to a passive strategy.
Key takeaways
- 1 In the same study, 55% of US shares and 57% of non-US shares underperformed cash over their lifetime. In Australia, 43% of shares lost value over their listed life.
Stuart Weams · 5:55
- 2 remarkably, just eight companies, which is just 1%. one percent of the Australian shares studied, accounted for almost forty eight percent of total wealth created. And the stairs was sh the shares were studied over their lifetime, which the median was about eight and a half years.
Stuart Weams · 6:23
- 3 They accounted for contributed about 63% of the SP's total returns in calendar year 23, 55% in 24, 46% in 25%. So far they've only contributed Contribute about 1% of total returns in the 26 calendar year.
Stuart Weams · 8:42
- 4 SP $500 at the beginning of 20, sorry, 2006, it would have grown to over $80,000 by the end of 25, which is the annualized return of about 11%. However, if you missed the best 10 days over that period, over that 20-year period, your investment would be worth $35,000 thirty five thousand instead of $80,000. eighty thousand. So about 6.6%. six point six percent of the return versus eleven percent. So almost half the return is missed if you missed the ten best days. And interestingly, six out of those ten best days occurred within two weeks of the market's 10 worst days.
Stuart Weams · 17:39
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 2:00
Introduction: Indexing vs Active Management
Stuart Weams introduces the premise that index funds outperform active management and stock picking over the long term, citing low turnover and tax efficiency as key advantages. He references SPIVA reports as primary evidence for this consensus.
- 2:00 – 4:00
Behavioral Finance and Personal Discipline
The speaker discusses why investors hold direct shares despite evidence, attributing it to gambling, arrogance, or entertainment. He states he personally follows a rules-based, low-cost market cap indexing strategy for all his investments.
- 4:00 – 11:47
Observation 1: Market Concentration and Wealth Creation
Weams presents data showing that in developed markets, a tiny fraction of stocks (2%) generated all wealth over three decades, while the majority underperformed cash. He illustrates this with Australian and US examples where a handful of stocks drove the majority of index returns.
- 11:47 – 16:19
Observation 2: Normality of Volatility
The speaker argues that intra-year declines of 10-14% are normal and expected, even in positive years. He suggests using dollar-cost averaging to buy more during dips rather than selling, emphasizing that volatility is the 'ticket to the dance'.
- 16:19 – 20:38
Observation 3: Returns Concentrated in Few Days
Data shows most market returns occur in a few days, often shortly after significant declines. Missing the best days drastically reduces total returns, making market timing ineffective and reinforcing the case for staying fully invested.
- 20:38 – 30:49
Investor Behavior and Fee Drag
Morningstar research cited shows investors earn less than funds due to poor timing (buying high, selling low). Weams concludes that active management fails due to concentration risk, timing errors, and fee drag, with active managers consistently underperforming indices.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| S&P 500 | index | neutral | SP $500 at the beginning of 20, sorry, 2006, it would have grown to over $80,000 by the end of 25, which is the annualized return of about 11%. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Index funds tend to outperform active management and stock picking over the long run.
Stuart Weams ·0:20
How to verify: Review SPIVA (S&P Index vs Active) reports published by S&P Dow Jones Indices, available on their website. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
SPIVA reports have published more than 15 years of data, with some reports covering more than 20 years.
Stuart Weams ·1:00
How to verify: Check the SPIVA website for historical report archives and publication dates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Over the 30-year period (1990-2020), just 2% of stocks delivered all returns, amounting to $75 trillion.
Stuart Weams ·5:35
How to verify: Verify against the specific findings of Hendrik Bassenbinder's study cited by the speaker. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary source55% of US shares and 57% of non-US shares underperformed cash over their lifetime in the Bassenbinder study.
Stuart Weams ·5:55
How to verify: Check the detailed data tables in Hendrik Bassenbinder's published research. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In Australia, 43% of shares lost value over their listed life, and 36% outperformed cash.
Stuart Weams ·6:03
How to verify: Cross-reference with Hendrik Bassenbinder's study data for the Australian market subset. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Eight Australian companies (1% of stocks studied) accounted for almost 48% of total wealth created.
Stuart Weams ·6:23
How to verify: Verify against the specific findings of Hendrik Bassenbinder's study for the Australian market. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In FY24, CBA, Westpac, NAB, Goodman, and Wesfarmers contributed two-thirds of the ASX 300's ~12% return.
Stuart Weams ·7:23
How to verify: Calculate the weighted contribution of these five stocks to the ASX 300 index using S&P/ASX 300 total return index data for FY24 (July 2026-June 2026). For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThe Magnificent Seven contributed 63% of S&P 500 returns in 2023, 55% in 2024, and 46% in 2025.
Stuart Weams ·8:42
How to verify: Calculate the total return contribution of the six named stocks (Google, Amazon, Apple, Meta, Microsoft, NVIDIA, Tesla) to the S&P 500 index for each calendar year using S&P Dow Jones Indices data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
JP Morgan data shows the average intra-year decline in the Australian share market (1994-2025) was 14%.
Stuart Weams ·12:01
How to verify: Review JP Morgan Asset Management's 'Investing Through the Storm' or similar market guides for Australian equity volatility statistics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the Hendrik Bassenbinder study data on shareholder wealth generation across 43 markets from 1990-2020.
- Review SPIVA reports to confirm the long-term underperformance of active managers against their benchmarks.
- Check JP Morgan's historical intra-year decline data for the S&P 500 and Australian share market.
- Analyze Morningstar research on investor returns versus fund returns to assess the impact of timing errors.
- Examine the performance attribution of the 'Magnificent Seven' stocks in the S&P 500 for recent years.
- Review Dimensional Fund Advisors' research on the performance of stocks before and after entering the top 10.
- Assess the tax efficiency and turnover costs of your current portfolio compared to a low-cost index fund.
- Consider the median listed life of companies in your target market to understand concentration risk.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hi,
- 0:00
- Stuart Weams: my name's Stuart Weams, and welcome to the Investopoly Podcast. Our goal is to share easy understand, evidence-based holistic insights to help you master the game of building wealth. Okay, today I would like to talk about why indexing works and why it's hard to beat. You know, I've recorded a number of podcasts, and it's really,
- 0:20
- Stuart Weams: I mean, it's common knowledge now, really, that index funds tend to outperform active management. And also that includes stock picking. You know, if you want to go and pick a couple of direct stocks and that's the way that you're going to invest, you want to be careful because the evidence tells us that you're unlikely to beat
- 0:40
- Stuart Weams: the market over long run. And you might beat the market over one or two years, but really we're after consistency and we're after low turnover and we're after low taxation drag. And so indexing works. And there's plenty of research that supports this. In fact, the key bit of published research or analysis is
- 1:00
- Stuart Weams: produced by SP Dow Jones. It's called the Speaver Reports. Speaver S P I V A stands for S P Index versus Active. So that's the acronym. And if you just if you just Google S SP P Speaver reports, it'll take you to the web. webpage. And that's been around for a long time. They've now got more than 15, or they published more than 15 years of
- 1:20
- Stuart Weams: data. And in some of the reports, more than 20 years of data. But there's a lot of other studies that sort of that arrive at the same conclusion that Speva does. So it's not just like this is the only report, but there's, you know, 100 years worth of data and so forth. So it's overwhelming. And that's been, you know, one of the original theses is in in invest options. Vestopoly, my, you know, the
- 1:39
- Stuart Weams: first iteration of the book. And then of course I'll repeat that in Wealth by Design. And I think that's generally accepted, right? That's what happens, right? Rather than explaining why. And I think if you really understand how performance is delivered or how performance is experienced, I guess maybe that might be a better way of
- 1:59
- Stuart Weams: framing it. I think it helps people understand why other alternative strategies might not work, like for example, direct share investing. And it's really funny. Sometimes I come across clients that acknowledge, yes, indexing works, but then still like to have a small holding of direct shares. It's
- 2:19
- Stuart Weams: really in that's a really interesting behavioral behavioural finance observation, I think. And you know, why is that? I think, you know, there's a little bit of gambling involved there. There's a little bit of arrogance, I think, you know, as in I can pick a winning stock. Maybe it's a little bit of entertainment value, you know, but I think it really does come
- 2:39
- Stuart Weams: back to probably gambling. You know, let's see if I can a little bit like why do we buy Tatsloto tickets or Powerball or Oslotto, whatever you want to call it. Because we know that the chance of winning is virtually zero. But I guess we like to dance with the you know potential outcome that firstly you could win. And secondly, if you won, it's gonna
- 2:59
- Stuart Weams: really change your life a lot for the better. But anyway, it's an interesting observation. And I look I I'll be honest, I sometimes think, Oh, gee, that stock looks good or it looks like good value or whatever. But I always eat my own cooking here. So, you know, I have the conversations with the team at Pro Solution. internally and you know they say, oh, we like this stock or what do you think about this? But I'll never buy it. I'll
- 3:19
- Stuart Weams: never invest. 100% of my investments are all rules-based, low-cost market cap indexing. There might be a couple of active funds in there in the emerging markets, but all the ones that I I talk about in this podcast. So I do what I say with my own money. And it is a temptation sometimes because I guess you probably look at the market and you go, gee, Myers Maya's
- 3:39
- Stuart Weams: cheap. You know, it's it's got to t there's got to be a turnaround story there because you're buying it very cheaply. So let's invest it even if it's short term, but you've got to resist that temptation. Stick to the rules, which is what I talk about in Wealth by Design, and have the discipline to do that over very long periods of time helps you produce extraordinary results. Anyway, enough prattling on for me.
- 3:59
- Stuart Weams: Let's get into today's podcast. What I want to do is present a couple of different, a few observations, statistical evidence-based observations, how markets behave. And I think these observations help us understand why indexing works and why active management and or and/or stock picking does not. Okay, so let's start with
- 4:19
- Stuart Weams: the first observation. The first observation in developed markets. So I'm not talking about emerging markets here. And emerging markets. you would think like Asia, so China, Korea, as well as India. They're probably the main kind of emerging markets. Indonesia is in there as well. They're the ones that I'm sort of, but
- 4:39
- Stuart Weams: developed markets, which are really the US market, Canada, Australia, Western Europe, and Japan, and UK. That sort of explains what I'm talking about in developed markets. So in developed Japanese, share markets, it's what you don't own that's going to hurt you. And this is why stock picking or active funds management doesn't
- 4:59
- Stuart Weams: really work. So there was a study by a guy called Hendrik Bassenbinder. It's a bit of a name. He was a finance professor at a university in the US, and he studied more than 64,000 shares across 43 markets.
- 5:15
- Stuart Weams: between 1990 and 2020, so three decades, and measured how much wealth these companies created for their shareholders and compared that to what investors would have otherwise earned if they just invested in cash. And the conclusion is staggering. Over this 30 decade period, just 2% of those companies delivered all
- 5:35
- Stuart Weams: the returns. So the returns amounted to over that time that was delivered delivered by those sixty-four thousand shareholdings was 75 trillion US dollars. And 2% contributed that 75 US trillion. That means that the 98%, the remaining 98% of stocks
- 5:55
- Stuart Weams: generated no more additional wealth than if you had have just invested in cash. And in fact, 55% of US shares and 57%
- 6:03
- Stuart Weams: of non-US shares underperformed cash over their lifetime. And because he deva uh studied many markets, Australia was no different. So 3,000 shares in the study, 43% lost value over their listed life, and 36% outperform only outperformed cash. And
- 6:23
- Stuart Weams: remarkably, just eight companies, which is just 1%. one percent of the Australian shares studied, accounted for almost forty eight percent of total wealth created. And the stairs was sh the shares were studied over their lifetime, which the median was about eight and a half years. Obviously they get acquired or delisted or whatever happens, rather than necessarily the full
- 6:43
- Stuart Weams: 30 year period, but it does show, you know, what's going on in the share market. So let me repeat what I just said at the beginning of this sort of segment. What I said is what you don't invest in will hurt you. So if you go and pick stocks, the problem is that over the next year, only a handful of stocks will probably deliver at least 50%
- 7:03
- Stuart Weams: of the total index's return. And we don't know which stocks they will be. And so if you don't invest in them, you're going to miss that. And that's not an opinion. The evidence tells us that's where the return. returns are coming from. And we can see this more recently in Australia. So if you think back to the 24 financial year, yeah, a couple of years ago, but it's a really good
- 7:23
- Stuart Weams: example. You had just a handful of companies, CBA, Westpac, NAB, Goodman, and West Farmers, which only represented 20%, just less than 20% of the ASX 300 index. But they contributed two two-thirds thirds of the almost 12% return in the 24 financial. year. So two-thirds, about 8% of that
- 7:43
- Stuart Weams: 8% versus 12% was driven really just by those five companies. So if you only held those five companies in that 24 financial year, you would have, you would have killed it. But if you didn't own any of those 20 of those five companies, then chances are you would have materially underperformed. So the question becomes: well, could you identify those five companies?
- 8:03
- Stuart Weams: in advance? Well, if you look at the preceding five years leading into that 24 financial year, they all performed pretty though that they're average performers, right? There was nothing that occurred over that previous five years that would have made you think at the beginning in July 23, at the beginning of the 24 financial year, that you're going to put all your money into these five
- 8:22
- Stuart Weams: companies. Like there was no evidence that that was going to be the case. And it goes back to burn. Bernard Melkie, who wrote Random Walk Down Wall Street in the mid-70s. And the book title is really suggesting that returns are random. That's really the thesis of the whole book, one of the theses of the whole book. And it's completely true. Completely random returns are. So it's hard to know which
- 8:42
- Stuart Weams: of the small handful of companies will outperform over the next year. And we're seeing that concentration in the US market as well. Everyone knows about the Magnificent Seven, which is Google, Amazon, Apple, Meta, Microsoft, NVIDIA and Tesla. They accounted for contributed about 63% of the SP's total returns in
- 9:02
- Stuart Weams: calendar year 23, 55% in 24, 46% in 25%. So far they've only contributed Contribute about 1% of total returns in the 26 calendar year. But you can see that there's again a small number of stocks are driving that particular index as well. And so you might go, well, let's just go large cap. You know, if all those large cap stocks in the US
- 9:22
- Stuart Weams: are really delivering most of the returns, let's do that. Funny enough, Dimensional, a fund manager, an index sort of fund manager, rules-based fund manager, did a study covering almost a hundred years of data, so 1927 to 2025, and found that the stocks that were outside the top 10 that eventually got into the 10 largest
- 9:42
- Stuart Weams: stocks, the time before they were in the 10 largest stocks, the returns were good. But once they got into the 10 largest stocks, the returns were average or below average. And it shows there's, and I mentioned it before, that the top 10 global stocks by decade change a lot, right? And it's hard to see that because we've got things like
- 10:02
- Stuart Weams: Microsoft. and Google and Amazon, Apple, NVIDIA. It's hard to see, you know, how they're not going to be in the top ten maybe five years from now. It's almost inconceivable, really. But if we think about like Google, I mean Google's got a lot of different revenue sources. But you know, five years ago, if you thought no one would be using
- 10:21
- Stuart Weams: Google as a search tool anymore, you'd go, No, it's it's it's not gonna going happen. to But now we have eight AI. And you know that I would imagine most people are using AI in replace of using Google, if not already, will be in the future. So what's the answer then? If we know that we can't pick the best winners over the next 12 months, and we
- 10:41
- Stuart Weams: know that it's likely that only a handful of stocks are going to and deliver most of the index's return, then of course the answer is just own the market. And that's exactly what Jack Bogle said, who is the founder of Vanguard, said rather than trying to find the needle in the haystack, which is, you know, the small handful of stocks that are going outperform, simply just buy the whole haystack. And it's really
- 11:01
- Stuart Weams: good advice. And that's why I'm saying if you make these observations, you really understand how returns behave, then you understand that it's a fool's gain to do stock picking. Because you your the chances, your probability of being right are just so low. And don't forget you get the timing right too. Not only do you have to find those stocks, but you've got to get the timing right. You've got to buy them before the uptick.
- 11:22
- Stuart Weams: Remembering the example of the Australian example, Commonwealth Bank, Westpac, NAB, Goodman, and West Farmers in the 24 financial year. The preceding five years for those stocks weren't that great. So you've got to you've got to buy them just before the upswing, and then you've got to sell them once that upswing has occurred, and then you've got to go and repeat that process and find the next winners. Meanwhile, of course,
- 11:42
- Stuart Weams: you're gonna pay training costs, taxation, all those sorts of things. That the turnover is gonna kill you. So that's the first observation I wanted to share. The next observation I want to share is that volatility is normal. So JP Morgan studied the Australian share market since 1994. So over those 32 years, 23 out of those 32 years
- 12:01
- Stuart Weams: ended in a positive. return in those calendar years. So 72% of the time, if you invest over those 32 years, you would have got a positive result. However, what we're trying to do is measure the intra-year decline, which measures the largest fall in share market from its highest to lowest point during the calendar year, regardless
- 12:21
- Stuart Weams: of where it finished. Like regardless of whether it's a positive or negative year, what happened during each year? The average intra-year decline was 14% average. So that happened, even though 70 more than 70% of the time, once the calendar year played out, ended in a positive return. At some point during that year, you had
- 12:41
- Stuart Weams: an average decline of 14%. And the same observation could be made in the US market as well. So since 1928, the average inter entry year decline is approximately 16%, despite the share market delivering 10% compounding returns over that period of time. And 2025 calendar
- 13:01
- Stuart Weams: year was a good example. By April, the market was down 19%, but by the end of the year, it finished it with a positive of 18%. eighteen percent. So all this data shows us over a 12 twelve month period, whether you're measuring financial. years or calendar years, you're likely to get a positive return seventy to eighty percent of the time. But experiencing an
- 13:21
- Stuart Weams: entry year decline of ten percent is absolutely normal and in fact to be expected. And it shouldn't be something that should be considered as a bad year or a bad sign or a reason to change a your strategy or a reason to sell investments or a reason to stop investing. It's just normal. And in fact, if you use dollar cost
- 13:41
- Stuart Weams: averaging, you're investing every month, you can use it to your advantage. If it drops ten percent, buy more. Invest twice as much that month, bring forward the monthly investing from, you know, the the future month into that month when it occurs. You want to be careful again about being too active with respect to that. But the point is just don't worry about
- 14:01
- Stuart Weams: markets. They will rise and fall. at some point and no one knows when the bottom is and when the top is. So at some point as an investor, you're gonna be in a lost position. So if I invested, for example, in August, it's possible that that investment I made in August might be in a lost position at the moment. Hopefully not too much, but it could be down ten percent.
- 14:21
- Stuart Weams: Whatever. That's fine. That's normal. You should expect it. You can't pick the bottom of each market. So every single time you make an investment, it's going to be in a profit position straight away. I think the first three to four years of owning an investment is the period of time where the returns might not actually reflect the
- 14:41
- Stuart Weams: underlying fundamentals of the investment. So that is, it could be a great investment. It could be a perfect investment, in fact, but it just hasn't had the time to demonstrate that yet. But the longer you hold it, and if it is a fundamentally sound investment, the greater the chance that you'll be happier with the returns. So by 10 years, if I make an investment this year in
- 15:00
- Stuart Weams: 2036, I should be super happy with the results and outcomes because time will let it play out. Because we don't know when mean reversion happens. We don't know when these things occur. But the longer we hold the investment and the more patient we are, the more likely. we'll be satisfied with the outcome. And I should say we haven't had much volatility
- 15:20
- Stuart Weams: recently and returns have been really good in most share markets, particularly over the last three or four years, returns have been above average. So the longer that occurs or happens for, you've got to expect that tomorrow you might wake up and the market's down 20%. I'm telling you this now, so that you're prepared for it. And if that
- 15:40
- Stuart Weams: happened, I would not be surprised at all. And we shouldn't look at that as if it's an abnormal thing. It would be completely normal if that is to happen. What has happened over the last three years is not normal because we haven't had that much volatility. So we shouldn't look at it from a fearful perspective as in, well, of course, we never want our investments to fall, but we shouldn't look at it as
- 16:00
- Stuart Weams: something I'd like to avoid. It's just the ticket to the down. dance. You just need to deal with the volatility. It is what it is. And you've got to write it out just part of investing. And we just have to expect it. But it if it is to occur, if it does drop 20%, let's look at it as an opportunity rather than, you know, something that might have gone wrong within your portfolio. The next
- 16:19
- Stuart Weams: observation I'd like to share with you is that most of the share market's return will come in only a few days in a relatively short period of time, and often typically after substantial declines. And so missing the best six months over a particular period can almost cost you more than
- 16:39
- Stuart Weams: one-third of your total wealth. So Demential did that analysis, and what they looked at is investing a thousand dollars at the beginning of 2001. two thousand and one. And if you had held right through to the end of twenty-five calendar year, you would have had seven and a half thousand dollars. But if you missed the best week between two thousand and one
- 16:59
- Stuart Weams: and twenty twenty five, you would have lost twelve percent of your return. So you would have only had six thousand six hundred. If you missed the best month, you would have lost seventeen percent of your return. The best three months, so really that which is your returns twenty-four percent lower. and the best six months thirty-two percent lower. So remember it's a relatively short period of time.
- 17:19
- Stuart Weams: We're talking about missing the best six months, which is just two percent of a twenty-five year investment period, which is kind of what we're analyzing. So two percent of the time equates to thirty-two percent of the return. And we can see the same data in the US market. So JP Morgan calculated that if you invested $10,000. in the
- 17:39
- Stuart Weams: SP $500 at the beginning of 20, sorry, 2006, it would have grown to over $80,000 by the end of 25, which is the annualized return of about 11%. However, if you missed the best 10 days over that period, over that 20-year period, your investment would be worth
- 17:59
- Stuart Weams: $35,000 thirty five thousand instead of $80,000. eighty thousand. So about 6.6%. six point six percent of the return versus eleven percent. So almost half the return is missed if you missed the ten best days. And interestingly, six out of those ten best days occurred within two weeks of the market's 10 worst days. So what does this all
- 18:19
- Stuart Weams: tell us? It tells us that you can't time markets. No one really knows when re returns will come. Not only, you know, I shared the observations observation that in any particular year it's likely that only a small handful of stocks will deliver most of the return, then it's also likely that those returns are likely to be delivered in only a few days during the
- 18:39
- Stuart Weams: year or maybe a few weeks, but certainly not longer periods of time. And so you don't want to miss out on holding those stocks and you don't want to miss out on being invested every single day of the year. So that you can pick up those returns. Also, we know then that this analysis tells us that if we're going to experience a decline, the worst thing
- 18:59
- Stuart Weams: we can do then is sell after the decline because we know that some of the best days occur within two weeks of a significant decline. And we can look at a decline in the share market as really a cost associated with being a long long-term term investor. So we're we've paid the price in terms of volatility, but if we sell out, we're not going to wait around for the return.
- 19:19
- Stuart Weams: You know, the price, if you like, is the sickness that you feel when you look at your portfolio and it's dropped 20%. The return is hanging around for those much better days that are likely to occur six out of 10 times likely to occur within two weeks following that volatility. So what we really need to do then is reframe.
- 19:39
- Stuart Weams: those declines as an opportunity. And particularly, and something I advocate is regular investing, a lot of our clients do it, which is, you know, invest on a monthly basis. Same reason, you know, regular super contributions are a good idea as well. And same reason if you're going to make additional super contributions, look sometimes waiting into the end of the financial year
- 19:59
- Stuart Weams: to work out how much to contribute is necessary, particularly if you've got some very variability in taxable income. But if you can if you can figure that out at the beginning of the financial year and invest it over the course of the 12 months, you're probably much better off to do that. Because what we can look at is obviously if the share market declines, then you can buy more
- 20:18
- Stuart Weams: units for your dollars than what you would have before the decline, right? You're getting more for your money, and that's dollar cost averaging, and that's the benefit of dollar cost averaging. So the people that are making regular share market investments, when there's downturns, they certainly benefit from lower share prices. And in fact, particularly if they're able to
- 20:38
- Stuart Weams: dial up the amount they're contributing at those times as well. Morningstar did some research, and this really looks at the impact of behavioral finance considerations. So how people behave. when there is a downturn. And so for the 10 years to ending 2025, the average managed fund return over
- 20:58
- Stuart Weams: that period of time was 9.9%. Had a look at what did investors actually earn? And they earned 8.7%. And the reason for that was really the timing of the investors' contributions and withdrawals. That is, that people were confident. when markets were high and they were fearful when markets
- 21:18
- Stuart Weams: were lower. So they were investing more when markets were doing well and they they would divest or invest much less when there was volatility, which is the reverse of what we want to do. And I think if we understand how markets behave, when we go back to the evidence, all the things that I'm talking about today, this is why I think it's so important. If you understand how it works,
- 21:38
- Stuart Weams: then I think that reduces your fear. Look, every time the market drops, it is because of something unique and different and often unexpected. Because if it was expected, it would be already priced into the market. The share prices would always reflect current risks. It's what scares the market or comes out of nowhere or is unpredictable Predictable that will
- 21:58
- Stuart Weams: cause it to fall significantly. So it's always different, right? This time is different. That the headline will be that's what the headline will always be. But what we're doing is we're analyzing and studying markets, how they've behaved over multi decade periods, sometimes up to a hundred years of data. So, yes, while what caused the volatility will be different every
- 22:17
- Stuart Weams: single time, how markets behave is unlikely likely to be different. And so you can take solace in that to say, I'm a regular share market investor, I'm a long term. long-term investor. My portfolio has dropped 20%, absolutely expected, and tells me nothing about what the total return might be over the next 12 months. And I see it as an opportunity to buy more. And
- 22:37
- Stuart Weams: also it doesn't mean that a 20% decline means that I will fail to meet my goals because again we know that's just normal behavior. So therefore the worst thing you can do is divest at that time or stop investing at that time. That is the worst thing you can do. And we can see it from that Morning Star research.
- 22:58
- Stuart Weams: There's a 1.2 percentage point difference between what the market actually delivered and what investors actually earned. And that all comes back down to their own behavior when there was market volatility. Now I'm talking about regular share market investing here, monthly investing. Don't forget an episode in 403, I shared the
- 23:17
- Stuart Weams: evidence around lump sum investing. So we do regular share market investing for current year's surplus cash flow. So that is, if we work out that a client has $5,000 a month of investable surplus cash flow and we decide we want to invest that in the share market, we don't have that cash flow yet, but it'll come each month or each quarter, depending on how
- 23:37
- Stuart Weams: lumpy the the client's income is. And that's a perfectly good strategy using dollar cost averaging. But if you do have a big lump sum, you've got, you know, $200,000 of savings. The evidence tells us that in the long run, you're better off dumping that all in the market in one hit. Go back to episode 403 if you want to learn a little bit more about
- 23:57
- Stuart Weams: that. I acknowledge that's the evidence, but studies don't really reflect the value. of optionality. And what I'm talking about there is that that there could be value in keeping some of that capital aside if the market changes and allocating and investing that in a different way if the market does change.
- 24:17
- Stuart Weams: So we don't mind lump sum investing, but sometimes what we'll do is we'll invest it over the course of 12 twelve to 24 twenty four months, for example, depending on the size, depending on the proportion of that money that relative to the client's total wealth. You know, there's a lot of factors that will go into it. But when I talk about monthly investing, it's really a typically
- 24:37
- Stuart Weams: referring to investing current year's surplus cash flow. Now, as I explained at the beginning of today's episode, it's what you don't invest in that will hurt you in terms of returns in developed share markets. It's a bit different in some other sub-asset classes. So, such as smaller companies and emerging markets, in
- 24:57
- Stuart Weams: those categories, the evidence of active versus passive are weaker. It's still compelling, like still mostly more than 50% of index funds over long periods of time beat active managers, but not to the same extent. And the margin isn't as wide as well in terms of outperformance. And in those markets, it's the reverse is true, I believe.
- 25:17
- Stuart Weams: It's what you do invest in could hurt you. So for example, in emerging markets, there's a lot of stocks in there that you probably don't want to invest in. Maybe some of them are state owned assets or partially state owned assets. And there's some investment considerations that go along with that. But also there could be a whole lot of rubbish in there as well that you just wouldn't want
- 25:37
- Stuart Weams: to take the risk on. So in emerging markets in particular and small c smaller companies the same, you really want to be a little bit more selective about what you're investing in. And so we would take a different approach in those markets and we want to treat them differently than developed markets. And so in those markets we would use probably more factor based
- 25:56
- Stuart Weams: investing. So we'd be reluctant to use traditional market cap indexing where you're just owning the whole market. Instead what we want to try and do is probably pick, let's invest in emerging markets, but let's pick the highest quality 200 or, you know, using some value-based approach and be a little bit more selective. So in those markets, it's what you
- 26:16
- Stuart Weams: do invest in that will hurt you. And that's why you need to be a little bit more selective. So it's really important to understand markets, understand how they behave, and then choose the approach that the methodology, the rules-based methodology that's going to align to those markets and help you and then behave in a way as an investor to help you capture those long-term
- 26:36
- Stuart Weams: returns. Okay, let's pull it all together. Why does index investing work? Why does it beat active fund management? Why does it beat stock picking? Firstly, market concentration, a relatively small number of shares typically generate. most of the index's return in any particular period. And active
- 26:55
- Stuart Weams: managers or individual investors need to pick and own these winners before they provide those returns and then sell them after they're given the returns and find the new winners and do that consistently well, so well that it offsets the taxation and fee drag that it creates. The second reason. is market
- 27:15
- Stuart Weams: timing and asset allocation. So active managers or investors that hold too much cash or are underweight shares during a recovery stage miss risking the strongest days of the market. So remaining fully invested, again, fully invested still means picking up those very or owning those
- 27:35
- Stuart Weams: small number of stocks that are most likely to generate most of the returns. And finally the fee drag. Of course, an active fund manager must earn to earn the same return as the index, must actually outperform to the extent of their fees. So their net of fees, at least then they're delivering the index return. And that's just impossible. And so
- 27:55
- Stuart Weams: the data is over in Australia, over 10 to 15 years, we're talking about eighty 85, five, eighty-eight 88% percent. of active fund managers fail to beat the index. And for global stocks, it's 95 to 96%. That's the evidence, but today we've discussed the reason why. At some point in the future, I haven't got around
- 28:15
- Stuart Weams: to doing it yet. Hopefully, over the next uh couple of weeks or months, I'm gonna do an episode on does index investing influence the market? Because that's one of sometimes you get asked. the question or it's a common question around, well, will indexing continue to work? If everyone indexes, you know, will it still work? That's a better way to put it.
- 28:35
- Stuart Weams: And then also, does factor investing earn a superior return? So sometimes if you use a value fund or a quality fund, they'll charge a higher fee than say just a traditional market cap indexing fund. So what are the impacts on portfolio risk and returns? What does the evidence tell us? So there's a I think they're
- 28:55
- Stuart Weams: all a bit interrelated these episodes. But hopefully what I'm trying to do is help you understand, you know, we've got the evidence. Yes, index beats active or direct stock picking. Today was really about why and understanding market returns, how they're delivered. And then next time we'll talk about, you know, the mechanics of indexing and picking index funds, though. those sorts of things.
- 29:15
- Stuart Weams: Okay, I'll leave it there for today. Until next week, bye for
- 29:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): now.
- 29:19
- Stuart Weams: Before I let you go, I want to let you know I've built a new resource website for podcast listeners at Investopoly.com.au.
- 29:27
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): My
- 29:27
- Stuart Weams: goal is to help you get even more value from the podcast by providing practical tools and resources that help you put the ideas and strategies I discuss into practice. To get access, you need to be a subscriber to my blog. You just need to put in your email address and you'll be sent a code to access the site initially and it will remember you. I'll
- 29:47
- Stuart Weams: be adding more resources over the coming months, including some AI tools. I also have a favor to ask. My average rating on Apple is 4.9 stars from over 560 reviews. On Spotify, I've got a perfect five stars from more than 360 reviews. That makes it the highest rated
- 30:07
- Stuart Weams: Australian finance podcast. And I don't take that for granted. I really appreciate the support. But now I'm asking for the same support for my new book, Wealth by Design. So if you've read the book and got something out of it, would you please leave a review on Amazon? I've got 45 Amazon reviews so far and thank you to everyone that
- 30:26
- Stuart Weams: that's taken the time to share a review. The more reviews it has, it genuinely helps the book become a success. The link is in the show notes. And finally, a shout out to anyone who's running their own business or thinking about starting one. I've got another show for that. It's called Business by Design, co-hosted with Mina. The link is also in the
- 30:46
- Stuart Weams: show notes. Thanks for listening.
More from Investopoly
Q&A - Property vs shares before retirement: sell at a loss?
Episode discussion: Investopoly Q&A: Property vs shares before retirement, selling at a loss
Speakers’ claims: Speakers analyze three listener scenarios involving property and cash balances, contrasting illiquid real estate with liquid shares. A 33-year-old specialist is advised to maintain a cash buffer for maternity leave while considering established land over new townhouses. A 66-year-old retiree with significant property wealth is counseled to gradually diversify into liquid assets as interest rates fall. A 49-year-old couple with negative cash flow commercial property is urged to sell at a loss to fund an ETF portfolio, citing poor risk-adjusted returns in commercial real estate.
Q&A - SMSF property debt before retirement: repay or invest?
Episode discussion: Speakers advise SMSF property investors to hold debt and buy growth ETFs, citing poor risk premiums in commercial real estate.
Speakers’ claims: Speakers analyze an SMSF investor's plan to shift equity into a Perth medical clinic, arguing that a 5.5% cap rate offers no risk premium over government bonds. They advise against repaying the SMSF loan early, recommending instead to use offset accounts and invest in growth ETFs for tax efficiency before pension phase. For a retiree with $8.75m in assets, the speakers suggest a perpetual portfolio with a 3.5% real withdrawal rate and three years of cash reserves. They also caution against selling property in a weak market, suggesting flexibility via offset accounts to time sales better. Finally, they discuss trust tax law changes and contribution splitting to equalize super balances.