Speakers advise SMSF property investors to hold debt and buy growth ETFs, citing poor risk premiums in commercial real estate.
Summary
Speakers analyze an SMSF investor's plan to shift equity into a Perth medical clinic, arguing that a 5.5% cap rate offers no risk premium over government bonds. They advise against repaying the SMSF loan early, recommending instead to use offset accounts and invest in growth ETFs for tax efficiency before pension phase. For a retiree with $8.75m in assets, the speakers suggest a perpetual portfolio with a 3.5% real withdrawal rate and three years of cash reserves. They also caution against selling property in a weak market, suggesting flexibility via offset accounts to time sales better. Finally, they discuss trust tax law changes and contribution splitting to equalize super balances.
Key takeaways
- 1 If cap rates revert to the mean, which is around three percent 3% above the risk risk-free free rate, so the cap rate should be in the nine 9% percents at the moment, what will happen is the value of these commercial properties will fall.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 4:38
- 2 A perpetual portfolio aims to maintain capital base with inflation, spending only the excess return above inflation (e.g., 3.5% real return on a 6.5% nominal return with 3% inflation).
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 22:42
Episode sections
- 0:16 – 11:20
Gary's SMSF property strategy and commercial property risks
Speaker analyzes Gary's plan to shift equity into SMSF, highlighting risks in a Perth medical clinic purchased at a 5.5% cap rate. Speaker advises against rushing to repay the SMSF loan, suggesting interest-only status instead to fund growth ETFs.
- 11:20 – 14:24
ETF selection and offset account usage
Speaker explains that growth ETFs are preferred over income ETFs before pension phase due to tax-free unrealized gains upon transition. Speaker also advises using offset accounts to generate tax-effective cash flow rather than reducing debt prematurely.
- 14:24 – 21:03
Dominic's self-funding strategy and property sale windows
Speaker addresses Dominic's need to self-fund until age 60, recommending drawing from offset accounts rather than selling property in a weak market. Speaker advises creating a time window for sales rather than fixed dates to maintain flexibility.
- 21:03 – 26:09
Retiree withdrawal rates and perpetual portfolio
Speaker discusses a retiree with $8.75m in assets, suggesting a perpetual portfolio approach with a 3.5% real withdrawal rate. Speaker recommends holding three years of living expenses in cash to mitigate sequencing risk while keeping the rest in growth assets.
- 26:09 – 34:31
Trust tax changes and contribution splitting
Speaker advises caution regarding upcoming trust tax laws, suggesting using a company structure if they become law. Speaker explains contribution splitting to equalize super balances and avoid exceeding the transfer balance cap, recommending it as a low-cost strategy.
Claims worth verifying
The Perth medical clinic is trading on a capitalization rate of 5.5%.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:40
How to verify: Property valuation reports or commercial property listings for medical clinics in Perth; compare net income to property value. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Historical mean capitalization rates for commercial property are around 3% above the risk-free rate.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·4:38
How to verify: Historical commercial property yield data from property research firms like CBRE or JLL. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Industrial land values have grown at 10% per annum over the last five to seven years.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·6:17
How to verify: CoreLogic or similar property data providers for industrial land price indices in Australia. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Unrealized capital gains disappear when transferring from accumulation to pension phase in super.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·11:44
How to verify: Australian Taxation Office (ATO) guidelines on superannuation tax, specifically regarding capital gains tax in pension phase. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Income inside super is taxed at 15%.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·12:04
How to verify: ATO tax rates for superannuation funds. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The transfer balance cap is $2.1 million per person.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·28:29
How to verify: ATO website or legislation regarding superannuation transfer balance caps. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Contribution splitting allows moving up to 85% of concessional contributions to a spouse.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·29:39
How to verify: ATO rules on superannuation contribution splitting. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Trust tax changes start on 1 July 2028.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·26:09
How to verify: Australian Federal Budget legislation and ATO announcements regarding trust tax reforms. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The speaker's book 'Wealth by Design' is published on 1 December.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·2:59
How to verify: Publisher website or retailer listings for 'Wealth by Design' by Stuart Weams. For recent events, verify 2026-08-09 through 2026-11-09. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify current 10-year Australian Government Bond yields to assess the risk premium of commercial property cap rates.
- Check historical commercial property capitalization rate trends to evaluate mean reversion risks.
- Review the specific tax treatment of unrealized capital gains versus income in the pension phase of superannuation.
- Confirm current negative gearing rules and any proposed legislative changes affecting investment property cash flow.
- Assess the specific lease terms and tenant quality of the Perth medical clinic to determine intrinsic value.
- Review the latest ATO guidelines on contribution splitting and transfer balance caps for spouses.
- Check the performance and fee structure of growth ETFs versus income-focused ETFs for pre-retirement accumulation.
- Verify the current cash balance requirements and sequencing risk models for perpetual portfolio strategies.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hi,
- 0:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): my name's Stuart Weams, and welcome to the Investopoly Podcast. Our goal is to share easy to understand evidence-based holistic insights to help you master the game of building wealth. Okay, let's get into today's first listener question. It's from Gary. Let me give you a bit of a rundown. So Gary's 56, his wife's 51. Self employed
- 0:20
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): earns an average of 200,000 per year. Home is worth 2.1 million with no debt. There's a Darwin residential investment property. It's worth $770 with $720,000 owing with $400,000 in the offset account generating $700 per week. I'm guessing that because there's a bit of
- 0:40
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): theme here with Gary's situation. So I'm guessing because of the debt, that property must have Are been being purchased relatively recently. Then there's a Perth commercial property. It's a medical investment property. I'm going to assume it's a medical practice that's rented to medicos, of course. The value is 1.4 with about
- 0:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): 1.1 of debt, generates $78,000 per year with 4% increases three years into a 5x5x5 lease. So the yield on that property is only 5.5%. And then finally, there's a commercial property. leased to his business in the self-managed superfund worth about 1.3.
- 1:20
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): The business pays $50,000 in rent. The mortgage is $270,000. And the superfund also receives obviously concessional contributions, always up to the cap. So that'll be nearly $65,000. 65, Well, not nearly, it'll be $65,000 for both of them each year. Proposed strategy is. to use
- 1:40
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the self-managed super fund rent plus concessional contributions to pay down debt aggressively. Withdraw $260,000 from the residential investment property and make non-concessional contributions into super. So really shifting equity into super, that makes sense. Invest the self-managed Self managed super funds rent and contributions, so cash
- 1:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): flow into ETFs. In 2031, sell the residential property and consume and put those proceeds into the self managed super fund and have also thought about selling the Perth property, which is the medical clinic, in 2035, putting the sales into super. So the questions are Does the
- 2:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): sequencing of this plan Can make sense? And would you structure it any differently? Would you leave the debt in the self self-managed managed super? superfund and invest in ETFs? And in terms of ETF selection, I'm considering high growth focused ETFs such as Vanguard VDHG or similar and then transition to some income
- 2:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): focused options to balance out growth more as I uh approach twenty thirty, twenty thirty one. Is this a good strategy? Okay, Gary, there's a lot here and I finished recording the Wealth by Design. So my latest book, Wealth by Design audiobook this morning. So glad to put that behind me and look forward to sharing that with you
- 2:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): guys. I think it's published on 1 December. Pretty sure if you subscribe to Spotify, you'll be able to listen to that. So anyway, good to get that out there. So it's fresh in my mind. There's a few things, a few issues that jump out at me. So firstly, and I can kind of s read between the lines, and I am reading between the lines here, Gary. So if I get this wrong, I
- 3:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): apologize. But my experience tells me that Gary bought his owner-occupied commercial warehouse many years ago. Well, obvious, right? The value is 1.3, the debt is only 270. Let's say he's been aggressively repaying debt. Let's say he bought it for 600, you know, 10 years ago and now it's worth 1.3. I don't know what it is.
- 3:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): but that's probably the story that I'd expect to hear. And so he's taken that confidence in commercial property and thought, well, I'm going to do that again. I'm going to buy a medical clinic in Perth. And he's probably gone to a buyer's agent that's helped him identify it, who's probably been sold, look, the income stream is safe because there's not a lot of other out of work
- 3:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): medical professionals. I totally agree. And the lease is long, so you know, it's a great buy. Now, if you remember the commercial property episode that I did uh more recently, it was episode 412, where I spoke about capitalization rates. Essentially, currently the medical
- 4:18
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): clinic is trading on a capitalization rate about five and a half percent. You can buy a risk-free risk free 10-year ten year government bond. and get five and a half percent. So essentially Gary needs to earn capital growth to justify this investment because he's not been rewarded for the risk. And actually what
- 4:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I said in that episode four twelve, I said that if cap rates revert to the mean, which is around three percent 3% above the risk risk-free free rate, so the cap rate should be in the nine 9% percents at the moment, what will happen is the value of these commercial properties will fall. And I'm pretty confident that's going to happen. What I don't know is when it will
- 4:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): happen, because obviously the tax changes in terms of quarantine, negative gearing, and higher interest rates are supporting these types of investments because these types of investments do throw off more cash flow. So, of course, they're better for borrowing capacity, they're better in higher interest rate environments. And obviously, then the quarantine. negative gearing also pushes more investors into
- 5:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): commercial property. But it's a recipe for disaster. And I guess what Gary's done here is he's used a very small data set, his own experiences, to make financial decisions. I'm surmising you, by the way. It happens often. So I make this estimation with a relatively high degree of confidence that it's correct,
- 5:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): but it's a cautionary. tale, I think, for anyone that if you invest in commercial property, residential property, ETFs, direct stocks, crypto, doesn't matter what it is, if you invest in an asset and have fantastic results over, you know, the 10 years that you've held that asset, be really careful about extrapolating that experience. You have to drill down
- 5:57
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and go, why did it work? Well, why did it work for Gary? Probably because of a couple of things. He probably bought after a period of underperformance into commercial market. And he's got a commercial warehouse. And we know industrial land values have grown at 10% per annum over the last five to seven years. Industrial
- 6:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): land values have gone nuts, and which is unusual, right? So you've got to drill down. I've said a number of times. Measuring performance isn't is enough. Understanding performance.
- 6:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): is what you really need. And so it's a really risky situation. Now I'm concerned. So because Gary's 56, right? If you're 56 and you're going to make a move in terms of make another acquisition, you more than anyone else, say someone that's 36 or 26, you need to be three times
- 6:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): better, three times more confident, three times more prudent. in making sure you're gonna get the right asset. Because what could happen, as I said in this blog, is Gary's equity could be completely wiped out if there's even half as much mean reversion as we might expect. And that's at a time when Gary doesn't need it, right? He wants to retire, he's
- 7:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): preparing for retirement. So, in a way, yes, you still need to go for growth. You still need growth assets, you want growth assets. Gary's probably gonna live going another to 40 years, hopefully, maybe longer. He needs to invest for growth. No, so I'm not saying be more conservative. I'm saying be more diligent. And when will I say quality first, then price?
- 7:26
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Obsess about quality, then price. Would I buy that medical clinic? No, I wouldn't. I'm telling you right now, it's probably one of the last assets I would buy in this market. I've got enough borrowing capacity. I could go and buy it. There's nothing stopping me. If I wanted to buy it, I could go and buy it. And I don't say that to show off. What I'm saying is in this podcast, I always put my money where my mouth is. I
- 7:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): never say or give advice in this podcast. I don't give advice. It's information only, of course. I need to remind you. But I don't I don't do anything like that or at work unless I'm prepared to follow the advice myself. So I'm telling you, this is how I feel about now. I could be wrong. The commercial property market, particularly in Perth, could run another five to seven years and Gary could exit
- 8:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and do well. I'm saying that is entirely possible. But it's also entirely possible that interest rates decline over the next couple of years. Well, we might push the economy into recession. Interest rates decline over the next couple of years. The tax rules don't get completely reinstated. I'll do an episode on this. Don't get completely re reinstated, but get reinstated
- 8:26
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to once again show that residential property is attractive. That then Melbourne and Sydney start to look like attractive markets because people start to lose a little bit of confidence on sort of fringe regional areas. And all of a sudden then those commercial properties blow up. That could happen. And I I think you've got to put that risk on the table just as much as the risk that
- 8:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that market does well. So that's why I mention it it's a bit of a cautionary tale for people that are closer to retirement. The closer you are to retirement, the more quality matters and the more price matters. But I would argue that they are two important ingredients as well. And the same with Darwin property, right? Now the Darwin market is a really interesting market. It's hard to analyze
- 9:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): because it's such a small market. Darwin's population is tiny, really. But in terms of where it is on the cycle, I'm less concerned. I mean, you look at, you know. $700 a week for a 770 property and the yields reflecting kind of where the market is at. So I'm less concerned there in the shorter to medium term. But long term I'd still be concerned because you're not going to get the
- 9:26
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): same returns in Darwin as you might in Perth or, you know, Melbourne, Brisbane, Sydney, of course, price point's going to be different. So it's clear, I think, to me, that Gary's been swayed by a buyer's agent that's in love with selling what's popular, not necessarily what might be right for the client. I'm not saying this buyer's agent is do anything wrong.
- 9:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Maybe they believe what is popular is best for the client, and it probably is in the short term. And it's the easiest way to build a buyer's agent business because if I can go and buy a property for you, and in only 12 months' time you've experienced a lot of growth, I'm going gonna to get referrals, I'm going gonna to get repeat business. If I go and buy a property for you in Melbourne and two years later there's no
- 10:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): growth, that is not good for my business. You have to understand the mechanics here that are really important. Anyway, I'll get off my soapbox now and start talking about the sequencing that Gary has set out in his emails. So the first thing is aggressively repay the loan in the self-managed superfund.
- 10:26
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): No, I wouldn't do that. I'd aggressively avoid repaying the loan in the self-managed superfund. That's not going to move the dial. What Gary needs to do is his investment horizon is really probably 30 to 40 years. I mean, depending on health and whatever. But that's what the decisions he makes today, they're going to play out over the next 30 or 40 years. So you need that
- 10:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): growth. Gary needs more growth assets. So and also the debt relative to the value of the assets not a big deal. And the debt relative to the mortgage and interest cost also isn't that big a deal. I mean the property's positive cash flow. So I'd actually convert the loan to interest only, Gary, so that you don't need to repay anything.
- 11:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And that way you can put all your spare cash, including the positive cash flow from the property and your concessional contributions into high growth assets. Which leads me into the other question that Gary had in terms of does he invest in growth ETFs or does he then tilt towards income focused options? Remembering you want the highest
- 11:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): after tax return. The highest after tax return is going to be one that gives you growth because when you convert into pension phase, which you could do potentially in the next four years and certainly within the next nine, any unrevolution. unrealized capital gains disappear when you transfer your balancing yourself from your super fund from
- 11:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): accumulation to pension. So really what you can do is potentially not pay any capital gains. You don't want income. Sure, income's only taxed at 15% inside super. It's not the tax drag isn't as big outside as it is outside super. But even so, you're just better off not having a tax drag at all. So, Gary Foss, in your
- 12:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): situation, you want to invest in ETFs, they're going to provide most of the return in capital growth and less income. So that's really all growth diversified ETF like G H H Fry, that's the geared one, DHHF, and maybe a bit of GHHF down the track, too, if the market was to drop. I like the idea of
- 12:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): taking the money out of the offset account. You've got money in the offset. account, just to remind people, against the Darwin residential investment property, the loan's $720,000, there's $400,000 in the offset account. That'll probably bring that property to be in positive cash flow. If you've got $200,000 income and that property was bought before budget night, you're going to get some gearing benefits. So why not
- 12:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): get that tax benefit? Particularly if the strategy down the track is to divest of that property and get that money into super, which I don't disagree with. And that's one of the other things Gary has said is sell down and sell per put that money into super. You essentially want to get as much of your wealth inside super, or pretty much all of your wealth inside super, of course. In Gary's situation, he can
- 13:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): have more than four million dollars of combined net wealth inside super and not pay any tax. I mean, And that's is essentially absolutely what he wants to do. So given you've got the exit strategy in terms of moving those assets. inside of super, what you want to do is then is put any capital, which is going to be savings today or future savings tomorrow into super directly.
- 13:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Get it in there now. Right. So really I like the idea of moving money in there and not having too much in offset account. We don't need to worry about debt reduction because our strategy is divest of that property down the track. And then just be careful with the commercial. medical property. Look, I I would probably, you know, if the value of that asset is the same or
- 13:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): more in say, I don't know, maybe when you've got some concessional cap to utilize, non concessional cap to utilize, I should say. So if the value of that asset was the same or more in five years, I'd probably take my money and run and also get that equity into super as well. For all the reasons I described, I'm a bit concerned about that asset. So anyway, Gary
- 14:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and everyone that might be in Gary's situation or similar to it. I hope that answers uh helped you at least uh some way and giving you some pointers in terms of what to think about or what to focus on. Okay, next question is an interesting one and very similar situation to a client that we have. Okay, so Dominique writes My wife and I
- 14:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): are fifty five this year and have one million dollar. dollars in a self marriage superfund in a diverse ETFs, in diverse ETFs. And the self marriage superfund also holds a eight hundred and fifty high yield property with a six hundred thousand dollar loan. We've got twelve million and eight residential properties with three and a half million dollars of debt, including a two
- 14:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and a half million dollar primary place of residence. So really we're looking at equity of eight and a half about six million dollars in the investment portfolio. Together with a million dollars, $1.2 million really in super gives us what seven seven point two million dollars in total net worth. We've got two
- 15:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): teen sons who are likely to enroll in university in the next couple of years. We've developed good money habits over our 20 twenty plus years of marriage, educating ourselves in investing through learning. and podcasts, and now want to enjoy life and spend more on family and lifestyle. Good on you. Of course you should. We've been generating around ten thousand dollars surplus monthly cash flow, and we've
- 15:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): been putting that into our offset accounts against our investment properties. We max out our concessional contributions to have a modest ETF portfolio of $150,000 in our own names. We now have $1.2 million in cash offsets. We are mindful of that many finance experts prediction of a large share market correction, which is
- 15:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): why we've not shoved more into the share market outside of super. We're aware these cash funds could be working harder for us. Question: Given we've five years to self-fund retirement before accessing super at age 60, how would you proceed with self-funding the next five years? How would you sell down the properties in our own names and move
- 16:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): money into super? What would you need to consider to do next? Okay, so really good question. We've got a lot of cash. I mean, it's one of the reasons to build cash in offset accounts, right? So firstly, you got over seven million dollars of net investment assets. You don't really need more growth. Time will do all the heavy lifting. You've you've got yourself
- 16:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): into a great position. So I wouldn't do that. be worried about saying, well, I've got $1.2 million sitting offset. It's not working hard for you. But in fact, it is working very hard for you because it's a risk-free return, 100% risk-free return that you're earning and you might be your mortgage rate might be six and a half percent. That's a good risk-free return. I
- 16:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): don't know if earning 10% in the share market justifies the risk for doing so, particularly in your situation, given it's not going to move the dial in terms of make retirement more attainable. It's already attainable. You can tick that box. Now it's just about, I was gonna say protecting assets, making your existing assets work as hard for you and as efficiently for
- 17:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you, rather than acquiring additional growth assets. So that's fine, put it all in the offset account. How would I attack it? Well, it depends. And it depends on what's going on in the property. market. I think I would describe you as discretionary vendor in that you may need to sell over the next couple of years, say the next five to 10 years, but you know,
- 17:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you've got a bit of time up your sleeve. You don't have to sell, if you like. And I don't think I would want to sell a property in this market. I think if you sell a property in this market, you're going to gonna have to make friends with selling it below its intrinsic value and maybe substantially below its intrinsic value. And I don't think that makes a lot of sense. So I would just fund your lifestyle from offset
- 17:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): account, but I would, if I was sitting in front of you, I'd test to see how comfortable you are in doing that. Because obviously the more you take out of the offset account, the more interest you'll pay next month, and so on and so forth. Now I would try and mathematically get you in a into a position or use mathematics to convince you you should be comfortable to do that. As long as you were
- 18:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): comfortable do that, then that's what I would do. And even if you did that for the next five years, and let's say you had half the amount or even less than half the amount in the offset account, I still wouldn't be worried about it, right? Because you you could as I said, if you go and sell assets, you can take a haircut. If you aren't comfortable with that, then maybe you do need to sell assets. And I would
- 18:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): sell the asset that's easiest to sell in this market. but also the asset that I think has the lowest growth prospects over the next 10 years. That's going to be difficult, sometimes difficult. I mean, it's all subjective, right? But you know, I say the easiest asset. So the asset that has the highest intrinsic demand still there.
- 18:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So, you know, if you're selling, you had an asset that was perfectly in the first home buyer's market, you're not going to sell that asset. But if you have an asset that could be pitched at someone that's going to be less sensitive to interest rates, then that asset might be easier sell in this market. So that's what I'd look at, but it really is mathematically, practically from an execution perspective,
- 19:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that is the consideration. From a wealth accumulation perspective, mathematically the decision is, you know, about future expected returns. So which asset has the lowest future expected returns? But that's how I would manage it. With property, you've got to have a lot of flexibility. So with the property straight, I think I've said this before, you can't just go,
- 19:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): okay, in July 27, we're going to sell asset A. And then in September 28, we're going to sell asset B. The market, the geographical market, the local market just might not be the right time to sell that asset. What you've really got to sell. say is between 2027 and 2030, we're going to sell asset
- 19:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): A. And between 28 and 2032, we're going to sell asset B. Do you know what I mean?
- 19:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): You need to design your strategy to give you a window to sell an illiquid asset rather than arriving at a specific time. So it's really just a case of, I mean, you do need to get the money into super.
- 20:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): The problem is now's not the right time to sell property. No one knows when the right time to sell property will be. It could be next year, it could be in three years' time, could be in five years' time. No one knows. It will probably be sometime over the next five years. So that's why use your offset account, have your flexibility, and then you might what you might end up doing is more
- 20:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): aggressively selling down the portfolio than you otherwise would have. So if it takes you three years, in year four, you might sell an asset, year five, you might sell an asset, year six, you might sell another asset, for instance, to get that money into super. But you do want to get it in there, but obviously you need to maximize after tax returns on your existing investment assets. Anyway,
- 20:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Dominic, that's the sort of thing I'd be thinking about. Thanks for writing in. Thanks for listening. And I'm going to say thanks for sharing the podcast. So I'm just going to make an assumption there. Okay, next question is from an anonymous listener. They just started reading Wealth by Design. I got this email early August. So it's good to start receiving emails from people that might have read or at least started to read the
- 21:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): new book. Anyway, he says just started to read it, but really wants to entice his children to let read it, given it's And probably written more for accumulators than decumulators. And that's true. Anyway, he want wanted to convey his thanks, so thanks so much for the feedback. Okay, here's a summary. He's retired, sixty years old with two point five five million in super,
- 21:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): seventy thirty overall. I don't imagine h the this reader's saying or this list is saying seventy in international, thirty in Australia, or could be seventy 70 in shares and thirty 30 in defensive, doesn't matter. Either way. Two 2.1 point one in pension mode. Currently receives one annual pension payment as it doesn't really need the money. Partner
- 21:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): is still working, still a bit younger, earning $600,000. They've got uh $2.4 million in super and might retire in a year. Read in between the lines, I think these people might be medicos. Family trust with a corporate trustee, mostly invests invest in ETFs, three and a half million, three hundred grand in cash, own their own home worth three. and a half
- 22:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): million with a half share as tenants in common in an apartment with his siblings who will eventually live there. I think the siblings will. No debt. Planning on 40 to 45 years of retirement. That's awesome. Planning maybe maybe passing away at 105, that's good. And wants some help to mitigate
- 22:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): sequencing of return and longevity risk. Okay, question. questions. Given the above net assets, what would you say is a reasonable initial annual portfolio withdrawal rate once partner retires? Well, really, the best way to deal with sequencing and longevity risk is to have a perpetual
- 22:42
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): portfolio. So that is one that maintains Means the capital base maintains with inflation. So if we say long-term inflation is gonna going to be 3%.
- 22:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): then if you spend more than the excess return above 3%, you only spend the excess return above 3%. Then you've got yourself for perpetual portfolio. So normally we do our numbers at sort of 7-ish percent in terms of returns. You might have to provide for some tax there. Let's go 6.5% six and a half percent is kind of a
- 23:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): rough number. There's about 8.75 eight point seven five million. of assets. So if we go six and a half percent, less three percent for inflation. So let's say the return that we're going to spend is three and a half, is about three hundred grand a year. Rough numbers, right? Don't quote me on these things because it's going to depend on type of assets,
- 23:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): return, mix of income and capital growth. Not really mix of income and capital growth, only for tax drag. Look, I don't think, I mean, unless you've got very ambitious. plans, uh, spending plans, I don't think you've got too much sequencing or longevity risk to deal with. The key thing here though is not to be too conservative because you could go, look,
- 23:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I'm worried about running out of money. I'm also worried about market volatility, so I'm going to go really conservative. Remember in wealth by design, and maybe this is the reason why actually it's not necessarily just for accumulators, but in wealth by design, what I say is from an asset allocation perspective, in instead of, you know, the the traditional approach to asset
- 24:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): allocation has been the closer I get to retirement, the less I can stomach capital reductions or capital losses. So the more conservative I'm going to go. But of course, if you go more conservative, you're going to earn a lower return. And that in of itself creates a risk. So what I say in wealth by design is. have three years of living expenses in cash. Now,
- 24:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): if this person, I was gonna say client, if this person wanted to spend, let's say, 300 grand a year, but you know, 100,000 was on travel, then I'd probably only account for $200,000 a year in living expenses. So I'd have $600,000 of their $8 million in cash or defensive assets, and the rest, more than $8 million, would be
- 24:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): invested to maximize total after tax returns. So really you're still going for compounding capital growth. You're still investing in shares mostly or ETFs, of course, but mainly, but mainly to maximize absolute return over the long run. So again, the asset allocation approach is quality first, so are
- 25:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): quality indexes, the most attractive indexes that are high quality. and diversify, you know, don't take massive bets. That's really the best way to go about this. That way you can go all growth on most of your portfolio and then have the confidence that if the market absolutely blew up, it doesn't really matter. You don't need to worry about it because you've got three years of living
- 25:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): expenses that you could draw on before you need to sell anything. And in three years time, whilst maybe not every single geographical market has recovered and is trading above its peaks before the crash, there'll be at least some that will. So even in three years or even much shorter than that, most likely, you'll have something to sell that you're not unhappy to sell at
- 25:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that point. Okay, so that's my commentary around sequencing and longevity. The the next question this listener had was about how you're going gonna to navigate the discretionary trust rules, taxation rules setting changes. Would they roll use the rollover provisions, all those sorts of things? Well the first thing I would say is it
- 26:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): doesn't start until one July twenty eighth. So don't be too quick to react to these changes. They're not even law yet, but don't be too quick to react to them. There's plenty of water to go under the bridge. And I just don't know if it's going to survive. The way it's been written is insane. I think Jim Chalmers is going to get the sack soon. probably, my guess. And you know,
- 26:29
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): maybe these these changes will be unwound or at least lightened up. So just be careful not to overreact. But let's just assume they became law. What would I do? Well, I would probably put it into a company because at least then you can retain the profits inside the company and pay 30% thirty percent tax, but
- 26:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you'll get a credit for that tax. And then you can always drip feed dividends out into your personal name. So I'd have put it in a company and and you and your spouse or partner would then own the shares sort of fifty fifty. You might even potentially play around with different classes of shares and you might have say your children having a class of shares and then maybe your grandchildren
- 27:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): even having a class of shares. share. Oh, I think I can't remember. Oh yeah, you did mid mid-20s, twenties, your children are so maybe they don't have children yet. But there's a a way, potentially use a company there. It's something that we're we're looking at. And of course, you know where to find that information. I'll almost certainly record a podcast about it, but I don't think we need to get there that yet. We're really waiting for that water to go under the bridge
- 27:29
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): first. So that's what I'd talk about. But I probably easiest answer is just keep listening to the podcast. And if it does become a real issue that we're gonna have to deal with, um rest assured, both Mina and I on Business by Design and different podcasts than this one, we'll be talking about it. Okay, let's squeeze in one final question from Angus from Perth.
- 27:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): He's got a question. I'm just gonna paraphrase actually, got a question around contribution splitting. I must have touched on it in episode four 409. hundred and nine. And around equalization of balances. Angus is just sharing the observation that his superbalance is much larger than his wife's. And that's not uncommon where
- 28:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): one spouse takes time off work to look after kids and so forth and then might return to work part-time. Again, it's gonna their super balance is gonna be attracting lower fees. Doesn't really matter if your total super balance is below one of the transfer balance caps. So if your total balance super is below $2.1 million
- 28:29
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): as it is today, in terms of you went plus your spouses, it doesn't really matter if it's all in one person's name or equally across. But if you expect by the time you get to retirement that your total super holdings from a family perspective, you know, you both spouses, is going to exceed one individual transfer balance cap, then you certainly want to
- 28:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): equalize balances. I think it's probably no one knows how much they're going to earn, how much they're going to contribute. I think it probably makes sense just as a planning mechanism to try and equalize it as much as possible. So what can you do? You can contribution split, and this is with respect to concessional contributions. So remember you can make $32,500
- 29:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): thousand dollars of contributions into super and claim a personal tax deduction for those. And that includes employer mandated contributions which are called superannuation guarantee contributions that's the 12.5% your employer has to contribute and then of course you can salary sacrifice or make a personal contribution to take the total contributions up
- 29:29
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to 3200. And then the law says that you can And contribute, you can split those contributions with your spouse, which means that you can move up to
- 29:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): 85% of those contributions, 85% because of the contributions tax. So it's about $27,000 and a half thousand dollars. You can at the end of the financial year, you can ask your super fund to move that amount into your spouse's account. And assuming that you have the same super accounts in terms
- 29:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of both accounts are going to earn the same return after fees and tax. You are mathematically better off to do that because what you're doing is equalizing your balances and giving yourself the greatest chance possible to keep under the transfer balance cap. Remember, it's 2.1 million per person, it's indexed each year. So by the time
- 30:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you get to retirement, it could be two and a half, maybe three million dollars per person, which means that you could put five to six million dollars into. super and not pay any tax. That is a great opportunity. Now, of course, I'm sure successive governments are going to play around with the transfer balance cap. I'm sure things will change, but there's no real cost to doing this. I don't,
- 30:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I don't know, but I'm pretty sure industry funds or super funds don't charge to move these contributions. And if they are, it's a nominal fee. But the benefit to equalize superbalances makes sense. The other thing, which I don't know if I talked about it in the super fund report, I'm gonna have to go back and have a look at it. Maybe I should, is that you
- 30:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, you can have an each way bet. So, you know, one of the one of the big, you can imagine the biggest risk really is is choosing an underperforming super fund or being in an underperforming super fund for too long. So if you had say a million dollars of super between you and your spouse, one way to mitigate that
- 31:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): risk is to use the super report I put together and maybe choose two of the best funds. So you might go Uni Super and Vanguard Super, and you go, well, I don't know which one to choose. They're both pretty good. And I think they are both pretty good, but they both there there are some fundamental differences. Like Unisuper is going to use some active management, Vanguard uses all traditional.
- 31:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): market cap indexing. And so what you might do is say, well, one spouse will go with Unisuper, the other spouse will go with Vanguard. And that's a perfect strategy. Both your balances are even because you get to spread that risk 50-50. So that would be another reason to do it. So yes, I think it makes sense. So you only do it once a year. So after the end of the financial Finance year is completed and the super
- 31:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): superfund fund has recorded all your concessional contributions and finally. finalize that. That's when you can submit a form, or maybe you can do it online now and split your contributions with your spouse. And you can make that split different each year, of course. But yes, I I think Angus, I would take that approach if I was in that position and if my balances were
- 32:18
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): materially uneven between me and my spouse. Okay, I think I'll leave it there for today. Tomorrow the topic is the evidence supports why index investing works. I think we've all been, and certainly myself, I've previously written about well, here is the evidence, and that's why we should do it. But why does index investing work? And
- 32:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think if we really understand how returns are delivered, typically delivered in markets, it helps us understand then, gives us greater context of why investing in direct stocks or using access. active management just doesn't work. So it's sort of it's taking that step further, if you like, and sort of sharing some interesting insights. So I hope that'll be really
- 32:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): interesting for tomorrow. But until then, bye for now. Before I let you go, I want to let you know I've built a new resource website for podcast listeners at Investopoly.com.au. You. My goal is to help you get even more value from the podcast by providing practical tools and resources. that help you put the ideas and strategies I discuss into
- 33:18
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): practice. To get access, you need to be a subscriber to my blog. You just need to put in your email address and you'll be sent a code to access the site initially and it will remember you. I'll be adding more resources over the coming months, including some AI tools. I also have a favor to ask. My average rating on Apple is 4.9 stars
- 33:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): from over 560 reviews. On Spotify I've got a perfect 5 stars from more than 360 reviews. That makes it the highest rated Australian finance podcast and I don't take that for granted. I really appreciate the support. But now I'm asking for the same support for my new book Wealth by
- 33:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Design. So if you've read the book and got something out of it, would you please like leave a review on Amazon? I've got 45 Amazon reviews so far, and thank you to everyone that's taken the time to share a review. The more reviews it has, it genuinely helps the book become a success. The link is in the show notes. And
- 34:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): finally, a shout out to anyone who's running their own business or thinking about starting one. I've got another show for that. It's called Business by Design, co-hosted with Mina.
- 34:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): The link is also in the show notes. Thanks for listening.
More from Investopoly
Q&A - Property vs shares before retirement: sell at a loss?
Episode discussion: Investopoly Q&A: Property vs shares before retirement, selling at a loss
Speakers’ claims: Speakers analyze three listener scenarios involving property and cash balances, contrasting illiquid real estate with liquid shares. A 33-year-old specialist is advised to maintain a cash buffer for maternity leave while considering established land over new townhouses. A 66-year-old retiree with significant property wealth is counseled to gradually diversify into liquid assets as interest rates fall. A 49-year-old couple with negative cash flow commercial property is urged to sell at a loss to fund an ETF portfolio, citing poor risk-adjusted returns in commercial real estate.
Ep 434: Why index investing is so hard to beat
Episode discussion: Stuart Weams argues index investing beats active management due to wealth concentration, volatility, and timing risks
Speakers’ claims: Stuart Weams argues that index funds outperform active management over the long term due to low turnover, tax efficiency, and the statistical reality that a tiny fraction of stocks generate most market wealth. He cites data showing that in developed markets, roughly 2% of stocks created all shareholder wealth between 1990 and 2020, while the majority underperformed cash. Weams highlights that market returns are highly concentrated in a few days, often following sharp declines, making market timing ineffective. He also notes that intra-year volatility is normal and that investor behavior, such as buying high and selling low, further erodes returns compared to a passive strategy.