The Albatross

Doug Pugliese explains how ESOPs enable tax-deferred exits for private business owners via Section 1042

34 min Listen to the original Episode page
ESOPsTax DeferralPrivate EquitySuccession PlanningCorporate FinanceERISA

Summary

Doug Pugliese outlines the mechanics of Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs) as a retirement vehicle and exit strategy for business owners. He explains that ESOPs were established under ERISA in the mid-1970s to provide succession planning and employee benefits. The structure allows owners to defer capital gains taxes by reinvesting proceeds into qualified replacement property under Code Section 1042. Pugliese details the capital structure, involving senior bank loans and seller notes, and the role of an independent trustee in valuing the company. He notes that S-Corp owners can convert to C-Corp status to leverage these tax deferrals, while identifying ideal candidates as firms with stable revenue and moderate growth.

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 1:30

    Introduction and ESOP Overview

    Speaker introduces Doug Pugliese and the concept of an Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP) as a retirement plan that buys owner shares using company debt. The structure allows for tax deferral on proceeds if structured correctly.

  2. 1:30 – 3:52

    Doug Pugliese Background and ESOP History

    Doug Pugliese, formerly a Navy pilot and investment banker at Bear Stearns, now works at Alpha Architect building a practice in qualified replacement property. He explains ESOPs were created under ERISA in the mid-1970s to serve as an exit strategy, succession plan, and employee benefit vehicle.

  3. 3:52 – 8:44

    Congressional Incentives and Code Section 1042

    Congress incentivized ESOPs to help communities and retiring boomers. Code Section 1042 allows business owners to defer capital gains taxes by reinvesting sale proceeds into 'qualified replacement property,' similar to a 1031 exchange for real estate.

  4. 8:44 – 10:28

    Deal Mechanics: Trustee and Valuation

    In an ESOP, a trustee acts as an independent fiduciary for employees to negotiate the purchase price, ensuring it respects Department of Labor limitations and excludes third-party synergies. This protects employees from overpaying.

  5. 10:28 – 14:03

    Capital Structure: Bank Loans and Seller Notes

    Capital comes from a senior bank loan (25-50% of value) and a seller note (promissory note from the owner). The bank loan is an 'outside loan' to the company, which then lends to the ESOP trust ('inside loan'). Seller notes typically have longer maturities (10+ years) than bank loans.

  6. 14:03 – 21:00

    Share Allocation and Tax Deductibility

    Shares are held in escrow until the seller note is repaid. The company makes pre-tax contributions to the ESOP to service debt, which liberates shares for allocation to employees based on payroll proportion. The purchase is effectively tax-deductible through these contributions.

  7. 21:00 – 27:02

    S-Corp vs C-Corp Structures

    S-Corp owners can elect to change to C-Corp status to utilize Section 1042 tax deferral, often selling half the business, waiting five years, and selling the remainder. The debt service acts as a tax shield, mimicking S-Corp benefits.

  8. 27:02 – 33:56

    Ideal Candidates and Bipartisan Support

    Ideal ESOP candidates have smooth revenue, retain talent, and grow moderately (5-10%). Fast-growing tech firms are poor fits due to repurchase obligations. ESOP legislation enjoys broad bipartisan support as it benefits both business owners (tax) and employees (ownership culture).

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
NVIDIANVDAequityneutralAnd if the company has grown in value too fast, you know, an and Nvidia could never afford its repurchase obligation because it would go bust trying to buy out its employees at retirement aid.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Do your own research

  • Review IRS Code Section 1042 requirements for qualified replacement property and holding periods.
  • Consult Department of Labor regulations regarding fiduciary duties and prohibited transactions in ESOPs.
  • Analyze company cash flow stability to ensure ability to service debt without jeopardizing employee benefits.
  • Compare tax implications of S-Corp vs C-Corp structures with a qualified tax advisor.
  • Evaluate the impact of mandatory repurchase obligations on company liquidity and growth potential.
  • Review valuation methodologies used by independent appraisers to ensure fair market value determination.
  • Assess the long-term cultural impact of employee ownership on talent retention and corporate governance.
Full transcriptexpand

0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): One of the stories Ken is fond of telling is how one day after selling the first part of his company to the employees, he did it in several tranches, one day he came down to the warehouse and spotted one of his employees doing donuts in the forklift. And one of the other employees was kind of standing there stupidly laughing at him, you know, enjoying the show. And he said to the employee doing the dundas, donuts, he said, Why are you abusing that guy's forklift? They thought that they were caught doing something naughty with the boss's property. And he was telling them, No, you've just abused your own property.

0:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's

0:43Brent Sullivan: Doug Poulier, say, and that's my terrible Italian accent. He's talking about Ken Baker, an owner who sold his company to his employer. employees. I'm Brent Sullivan. This is the Albatross. And I've got Basis Manhattan coming up. It's a two day event in Manhattan, just about taxable wealth.

0:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

0:59Brent Sullivan: picture an owner with almost everything tied up in one private company. The kids don't want it, and selling to a competitor or private equity just doesn't feel right. There's another buyer, the employees.

1:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): An

1:11Brent Sullivan: employee stock ownership plan, an ESOP, Aesop, is a retirement plan that buys the owner's shares with money the company borrows. And if the deal fits the rules, the owner can defer a lot of tax. Tell us who you are and how you even arrived in the world of ESOP.

1:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): My

1:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): name's Doug Poglisi, and I work at Alpha Architect. Uh Alpha Architect is a quant finance ETF

1:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): shop.

1:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): But I came to the firm to build a practice. in what's known as qualified replacement property. That's the business of helping investors defer their taxes when they exit their businesses through a sale

1:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): to the employees through an eSop structure. And my background before that was I've had a kind of a couple of careers. I was a Navy pilot and a translator in my first life. I then became an investment banker. I worked for a dozen years at Bear Stearns in New York and London and then um had the good fortune to uh to join Alpha Architect to build and launch this business.

2:08Brent Sullivan: So so Congress sets up this incentive structure. And can you tell us like about a little bit more detail about what ESOP is? Why did Congress set this up and and win? What's like the little backstory Story here?

2:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think uh the ERISA uh legislation of the mid mid-70s seventies was the venue for creating the structure known as an ESOP. The name says it all employee stock ownership plan. So an ESOP for a privately or closely held company in the United States is several things. And it does each of those things really well. The first is that it's an attractive exit strategy for a business owner. It's like selling to a third party, only doing so with benefits, typically tax benefits. The next thing that it does is it creates a succession plan or it implements rather a succession strategy for a business, and that's an important thing, particularly in this demographic day and age. We've got a lot of retiring uh boomers. In the process of doing so, or the vehicle for doing so, is the creation of a qualified retirement benefit plan for the employees. And in doing so, you also create something interesting called an ownership mindset or an ownership culture. Employee ownership is a product to uh a productivity enhancement tool. So those four

3:27big overarching goals get accomplished very nicely through an ESOP plan.

3:32Brent Sullivan: On the podcast, we talk about concentrated risk, and usually that's in public markets, but in this instance we're talking about private company ownership, like concentrated risk in like a private company. And essentially, like what you described is we have a situation where we have an owner who's concentrated in this one company. Congress has provided incentives for them to migrate from concentrated private ownership into potentially diversified public ownership. And to do so in a tax-deferred way and maybe help us understand how they get from private concentrated to public diversified, not the deal structure yet, but just the mechanism that allows them to go from private concentrated into public diversified and what the qualifying necessities These are for where they have to land.

4:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think Congress over time recognized how a attractive ASOPs were ultimately for communities, ESOP-owned companies, right? There are 6,600 of these Aesop-owned or employee-owned companies in the country. That growth spawned a number of interesting benefits that were observed. And I think Congress, in an effort to encourage ESOPs further, put in place legislation in the mid-80s to enable business. owners to generate uh a tax deferral through the sale of their stock to the employees. That's under code section 1042.

4:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

4:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): what it does is it essentially says to a business owner who sells his stock to the employees, electing a 1042 sale election, is that if you do so and you purchase something called qualified replacement property, which you can take all of the capital. gains that you would have recognized in the sale of your stock. Often there's very low or zero basis in the stock that's sold to any SOP. These are typically family-owned businesses. They might be third, fourth, fifth generation businesses. So the basis

5:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is

5:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): usually

5:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): very low. And uh and plow that capital gain into the replacement property, much as a 1031 exchange does for real estate sales. sale. And then the business owner will hold that qualified replacement property in his essentially in his estate, not dead yet, but and and as long as he doesn't sell that qualified replacement property, it carries the gain ultimately to his demise or her demise if that's the desired outcome, at which point in time the step up and basis in currently enjoyed eliminates the capital gain tax liability altogether. States like California, where the tax rate is 13.3%, at least today, on capital gains, add that to the 20% maximum capital gains tax rate plus 3.8% ACA surcharge. I mean, you've got a witch's brew of taxes there that starts approaching 38%. That's a big slug of your sale proceeds.

6:24Brent Sullivan: We're talking about somebody who a private business owner. That's obviously the first thing. And then the second thing is that they don't want to exit to a third party. You mentioned like a succession plan for the business itself. So this is an owner who's materially interested in kind of like the character of the business and sustaining uh the nature of it. Can you talk about that just a little bit? Absolutely.

6:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I observe that buying and selling businesses is kind of a bare knuckle business, right? A lot of things can get smashed up in the process of transitioning a business from one owner to the next. I think, for example, third-party competitors coming in and pawing over your intellectual property. And in today's day and age where you could take a photograph of someone's warehouse or a factory floor and dump it into an AI model, you can get all kinds of interesting insights. An ESOP is a very different type of transition, right? You're not exposing yourself to third party scrutiny in the form of competitive buyers or even private equity firms. You are effectively creating a transition strategy on a homegrown basis. And so it it attracts a business owner who doesn't want to go through that rough and table process, particularly knowing how private equity can be a challenging buyer. spire of a of a business and certainly the restructuring that undertake that they undertake afterwards. So this is a path that is perhaps less traveled now. It should be more traveled, but it's certainly a gentler transition. It's I think of it often as like a caterpillar entering the Aesop process and coming out a butterfly at the end. It's it's not a bruising, violent uh process like a normal MA transaction.

8:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): When

8:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I started in this business, I saw more business owners interested in maximizing the very last dollar. Today I see more business owners holistically evaluating these transactions on the broader merits, like the ability to keep their businesses in the US, their manufacturing rooted here in the domestic area and the in the local economy.

8:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um

8:36Brent Sullivan: I want to hear about like sort of the deal mechanics. Could you just walk us through like a let's say a really simple C Corp deal?

8:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

8:44Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): in a normal third-party sale, uh the owners of a business undertake a sale process that in involves involves engaging with third parties, having them come and examine uh confidential information and develop a bid for the business. In an ESOP, what a business owner does is after deciding that that's the path they want to go down, and you don't have to go down the path of an ESOP exclusively, it's an excellent stalking horse to ensure that MA bidders in a third-party sale process behave themselves and it sets a deal floor. for the transaction value. But I digress. In an ESOP, the business owners hire a trustee, the person who's going to act as the trustee, a fiduciary position representing the interests of the employees of the ESOP trust. So the ESOP ownership plan, the employee stock ownership plan, rather, is essentially a trust that the business owner creates managed by a trustee who acts as the third party. or uh arm's length negotiator, independent negotiator on behalf of the employees' interests to negotiate the purchase of the business. So the trustee and the business owner negotiate the sale price, and that sale price has to respect certain uh limitations imposed by the Department of Labor so that the employees don't wind up essentially overpaying. So for example, third third-party party synergies are not

10:04a concept typically incorporated in the transaction value.

10:08Brent Sullivan: There's one interesting element of this, which is just like, you know, where does the capital come from? And so you've got the exiting owner and then the trust that contains their that uh I guess manages or stewards the ESOP plan. Like the capital has to transfer from that plan to the owner that's exiting. There's like lack literally a cash movement. And so like where does the cash come from? Because it doesn't come from employees up front. So can you walk us through the capital chain? Where does it come from? How is it serviced? All that stuff?

10:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So there are two principal sources of capital for the buyout of the business owner. The first is very simply a bank loan. Most smaller middle markets companies, I think of these companies as being in kind of the ten or fifteen million dollar range at the bottom to maybe

10:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): five

10:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): hundred million to a billion at the

10:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): high end. So anything in

10:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): between that range, most of those businesses

10:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): of that size

10:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): aren't able

11:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): to

11:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): really

11:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): generate sizable or highly leveraged cash flow

11:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): based loans like public companies can. So they're borrowing on a senior basis from a bank. The bank will typically lend what they can secure in assets like working capital. and vehicles and land and so forth. So typically a portion of the purchase price comes in the form of a corporate loan, a senior loan, the company has drawn from a bank. So there's a bank financing element to these eSub transactions that provides some component of cash. We typically see the bank loan representing, for the purchase of the shares, representing something in the area of 25 to as much as 50% of the value of the transaction. That bank loan that is drawn by the corporation is then lent to the employee stock ownership trust, essentially. So the bank loan is what is known as the outside loan owed by the company to the bank. The then intercompany An loan or or inside loan is the loan from the company to the employee stock ownership plan for the purpose. purposes of buying the owner's stock.

12:05Brent Sullivan: Let's say that we have an owner that's exiting 50% and they're sourcing capital from a bank. The bank uh makes the outside loan to the business, the business makes the inside loan to the eSOP. And then, but that's probably um, like you said, that's not usually for the full 50% that they're gonna going to exit. So there's the seller's note. Can you just walk me through the seller's note, how that works? That would be a loan from the owner, and essentially they'll get paid out over time. Or help me understand that part one more time.

12:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): The other part of the proceeds can come from either the company having squirreled away money over time that it then injects into the employee stock ownership plan, and there are benefits for doing so, or in the form of a seller note, right? The business owner can be the lender of last resort for the purposes of his or her own buy. buyout. And why not? That's a position that they're very comfortable having had that role essentially since the business was founded. So the business owner will accept typically a seller note or a promissory note from the I I say the company, but it's originated at the ESOP level. It's then through a number of little shifts moved over to the company as an obligation. But that uh that employee stock ownership secondary. subordinated note to the business owner represents the remainder of his or her proceeds.

13:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

13:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): senior loan will typically have a five or seven or eight-year maturity, and the subordinated seller note will typically have 10 or more years of maturity, all by way of design to give the bank senior position your in the capital structure so it doesn't feel like it's competing with the business owner to get proceeds from the loan.

13:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If

13:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the whole thing goes bust, the business owner steps back in and takes resumes control of the company. So but that doesn't happen too often because sorry for this detour, but business owners tend to be very paternal toward these companies. They've uh you know they value their employees very much. They don't typically engage in forcing the business into perfecting liens on a bankruptcy. So it's often a very cooperative relationship in almost every case. So what happens is that the Aesop itself is the legal owner of the shares, and that provides a beneficial ownership interest for the employees on an economic level, but not in terms of the day to day mechanics of that governance. So the ASOP is the owner of the shares. And those shares are held in escrow until the owner is bought out. So they're held in escrow as collateral. for the seller note that the owner has taken back, which means that the owner's role does not necessarily end at the transaction's completion. The owner often remains actively involved in the business.

14:43Brent Sullivan: So the economic interest is transferred to employees, but not necessarily sort of like the managerial oversight. You know, let's say like compensation for each employee is they're not going to be able to see all of that all the way through. That's still a management function. And there's kind of like a um there's a veil between the two, more or less.

15:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And the employees then go through a a period of earning or working off a dead horse, so to speak, to earning that economic allocation of shares. So what happens is those shares are sitting in escrow. As the company injects money into the employee stock ownership plan so that it can then pay back the business owner for the seller note. Mechanically, it might differ a little bit in practice, but that's essentially effectively what's going on. The uh the eSOP can then start allocating those shares that were paid for by that new cash injection as the debt serviced for the business owner, can then start allocating. those shares to the accounts of the planned participants. And in that process, shares start getting allocated to employees. And by the way, they're typically allocated according to the payroll uh proportion that the employee represents. So the CFO is typically the most highly paid employee after the owner. The CFO might get the largest uh allocation of shares per year, followed by the next vice presidents and so forth on down the line.

16:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We

16:03Brent Sullivan: we're always trying to like think about where the cash comes from and where it's flowing to.

16:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

16:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): what's going on here is that as the company runs its business and generates cash flows, the company is making contributions of cash to the employee stock ownership plan on a ta on a pre-tax basis, right? These are The contributions to the plan, just like the employer portion of a 401k contributes cash to the plan in many respects, uh, there's an employer share. Well, in an employee stock ownership plan, it's all employer share. And so that cash contribution effectively liberates shares held in escrow that will go to the employees in the process paying the funds that will buy out the owner. So the nice way to think about that is it ties it up very neatly to think of it. The purchase of the business is tax deductible. You are deducting the entire value of the business through the process of buying it through a qualified plan, right? Every payment goes in on a pre-tax basis. That payment is typically used then to buy out the remaining stake of the owner or even the initial stake of the owner if it's a self-funded uh leveraged ESOP. And so that process is how these become such attractively structured transactions from a tax perspective.

17:17Brent Sullivan: Can you talk us through kind of like the order of payment there?

17:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So typically we will see terms specifying the subordination of the payment to the owner from the seller note so that the seniority of the bank debt service is on everybody's mind, right? The bank is getting serviced first. And often what you'll see. is the seller note for the business owner is often interest only payments for the first couple of years, maybe two years, one year. And that gives the bank a chance to gauge whether the company is going to be able to service the debt well and how well over time and how the business cycle works for the for the um pay repayment of those uh funds. And then the business owner will be entitled to start receiving compensation for or I should say principal payments for the sale of the business on that seller note. What we often see, because banks are profit maximizing organizations, is that after a period of time, typically two, maybe three years, the bank will approach the company and say, Hey, you've been a great customer, you've been servicing this debt very nicely. I'd like to propose to you that we refinance the seller note by taking out a chunk of the seller. note with new loan proceeds from the bank. So the bank tops up its loan to the company. The company then gets a chunk of money that it can use to contribute to the ESOP and buy out a portion or repay a portion of that seller note. Everybody's incentives are

18:41aligned because the employees they want those shares allocated. And the way that happens is by repaying the business owner on the seller note that is owed to him. or her. And so what we see then is that the business owner will typically get bought out by the fifth or sixth year through two, typically two, sometimes three refinancing transactions.

19:01Brent Sullivan: So we have we have like the source of capital is ultimately or it's a bank. It depends on the business's ability to generate cash, to service a loan. If everything goes well, then there are just like sort of smooth ways to transition, you know, essentially the bank's capital to the owner. And then there's this, they've received the capital, and then they have this um incentive structure behind the scenes to uh via 1042, assuming the deal is properly structured and it's a C Corp, not NES Corp. They have all that capital and now they are able to reinvest it into qualified replacement property. And that could be just like public stocks. So again, they went from private concentrated into public diversified. And is that that's kind of like the end-to-end financially, but there's more. So do I have the the end-to-end more or less correct?

19:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh

19:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yes, I mean that that's where it gets really interesting. You've alluded to the fact that a business owner who elects a 1042 42 sale election as a C corporation, if you'd like to go down that path now, is able to essentially defer the capital gains tax bill that he or she would have had upon selling their business. You've got a business owner selling their stock to the employees, exiting what is a widely regarded, at least among institutional thinkers, as the single riskiest piece of paper in the entire investment universe. They grew grow up with this risk, and that's their that's their livelihood. But they're exiting that small concentration. concentrated investment and moving that money without paying taxes on it to I shouldn't say without paying taxes on it. I'm not a tax advisor. These things vary with planning, of course, but generally speaking, they bypass the capital gains, tax liability being realized, move it into a diversified portfolio.

20:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

20:45Brent Sullivan: Doug, like what we've been talking about now has really been about ESOPs in the context of a C Corp. but things are a little bit different with an S Corp. Could you maybe just walk us through how folks think about this, any planning opportunities in with that mindset?

21:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

21:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the S corporation is um a really popular form of uh corporate structure. And um and I think it's important to understand that if you are an S corporation owner and ESOP still represents a very interesting and attractive avenue, particularly for that tax tax-deferred defer to election. election of a 1042 sale. 1042, of course, referring to section 1042 of the code. So if you are an S corporation and you would like to undertake a tax-deferred sale of your securities, you can elect to change your corporate taxation structure on the eve of the transaction. Now, going from S-corp S Corp to C Corp typically requires, again, I'm not an expert to consult an accountant, typically requires a five-year waiting period before you can go back to the C the S-Corp structure. But we find that that period of time doesn't necessarily detract from the efficiency of a newly sold C corporation, ESOP, because the company is leveraged, and that debt service that we talked about in regard to the ability to tax efficiently buy out. the owner, that debt service acts as a tax shield that kind of stands in pretty well for the S Corp structure. So business owners will often sell half of their company after transitioning to a C Corp structure. And then in five years, just before the

22:19expiry of that waiting period, they might sell the other half of the business to the employees. At that time, then the business can convert back to an S Corp. corporation, becoming a tax-free entity. Again, check with your accountant.

22:31Brent Sullivan: Yeah, and it's like everything in planning, which is just like, you know, you need to have like a thoughtful design around this stuff and also just like get ahead of it. And then just have like the longer term in mind and you can get all of these steps right to maximize incentives personally and also for the employees.

23:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

23:03Brent Sullivan: think it's important to think about like why this is in place. And we alluded to this earlier, but why did Congress do this? Like it's not this is not a flippant loophole, you know. This is not something that that that some clever tax engineer like sort of figured out by digging through the code. This was like a deliberate construct from Congress. And maybe you could talk about what changes when employees start to become owners of the business and why Congress, I think, felt so strongly about creating this incentive structure.

23:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So why would Congress do that? Congress is doing that because the magic of capitalism, and I firmly believe this, it gives me a great deal of joy to go to work every day. The magic of capitalism is that it instills or imbues employees with a different alignment of incentives, right? That employee ownership culture that I alluded to is a beautiful thing. Why? Because employee owners, they take their problems home with them at night, right? They chew on things like business owners do in a way that ultimately trickles back to the company and makes it a better company, more productive, more resilient, better able to deal with competition both at home and abroad. It creates that mindset shift. And there's a great story. I think so. In my part of if you don't mind, I'll just share this little tan tangential story here that just kind of exemplifies. that shift. Uh there's a gentleman here named Ken Baker, who is the son of a founder of a business in the southeastern Pennsylvania region called New Age Industries. But one of the stories Ken is fond of telling is how one day after selling the first part of his company to the employees, he did it in several tranches, is one day he came down to the warehouse and spotted one of an employees doing donuts in the forklift uh in the warehouse. And one of the other

24:54employees was kind of standing there stupidly laughing at him, you know, enjoying the show. And of course when Ken walked down and they saw him, everything stopped and they were of course, they felt they were busted. But Ken said something really interesting. He said to the employee doing the donuts, he said, Why are you abusing that guy's forklift? Right, pointing to the other employee who was kind of standing there, uh aiding and abetting, if you will. And and that took those guys by surprise. Here they are, they thought that they were caught doing something naughty with the boss's property. And he was telling them, No, you've just abused your own property. And I think that's the sort of process, evolution in thinking that creates that quiet small employee capitalist capitalists that we're talking about.

25:37Brent Sullivan: This is such like an important thing. I mean, I'm a small business owner, and so I understand this that, like, for better or worse, like I'm thinking about my business constantly. And uh, you know, for worse, it's like, oh wow, it's always weighing on me. I'm just like, oh, you know, like I have to keep this thing going. But uh, and I want it to grow and I want to do all these things. It's like always on my mind. That that's totally different than And showing up to work and not having those concerns 24-7. And um, I think that's the incentive. shift that that happens when you transition from employee to owner. Like, you know, it's the difference between taking care of like a community park as you know for good feelings and community recognition, and taking care of your lawn. You like your lawn is in front of your house, and like it's just a different mindset. There are trade-offs with both mindsets, but it does create a different incentive structure. And one I I'm I'm gathering that Congress felt strongly about. And that's hence all of the incentives that that live inside of like an ESOV.

26:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It's not charity. It is I mean it feels good, but it's not charity, right? What we're doing here is aligning incentives to make these companies stronger, better, wealthier communities, and so forth.

26:42Brent Sullivan: What kinds of companies, and I mean like the nitty-gritty, like the attributes of the companies themselves, what makes them like good candidates for kind of like this transition of ownership from employee into or from owner into employees? Like what are the qualities of a business that like kind of like are most conducive to this arrangement?

27:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): What you first of all need is a company that's capable of servicing debt, a company that can carry debt. And that really requires it to have relatively smooth revenue flow, any kind of a big manufacturer of large capital goods that has a lumpy pipeline might not be able to service debt in a way that the banks might require over time. So I think companies that need to retain talent, you know, their talent walks out the door every day, those kinds of companies benefit through something that vests and holds that ultimate payout out in reserve as deferred compensation for employees. That's an important type of company that wants to be employed. employee owned. So there are a whole host of attributes. Generally speaking, you need to grow. So you have to have growth of kind of somewhere between 5 and 10% a year. You can't be a technology firm, for example, that grows at 50% a year, because that brings up an important aspect of these employee stock ownership plans. And that is that they create a repurchase obligation on the shoulder shoulders of the company to buy out, effectively buy out those employees at retirement age. So it has to be a business that grows moderately, but if it grows too fast, it might be better suited for an IPO exit or some other type of exit because ultimately the company has to buy out its employees. And if the company has grown in

28:21value too fast, you know, an and Nvidia could never afford its repurchase obligation because it would go bust trying to buy out its employees at retirement aid. So manufacturers tend to be about a fifth of all employee stock ownership plans, not surprisingly.

28:38Brent Sullivan: But you made an interesting point, like you were right almost at like at the top of the conversation was that like if there is kind of like this looming or this this interest from private equity that that you could almost come in with an eSOP, like kind of like structuring as a as a baseline or a floor. Could you could you say just a couple more words about that? Because it's super interesting.

28:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I just love the concept of having a whip in one hand while you're dealing with the private equity firm in the other hand who's looking at potentially acquiring your business. Because it's um while it might be a stereotype, it's often very common for business owners to complain that they get retraded by the private equity firm. firms. So They'll come in with a big price and then they'll find reasons in and diligence to lower the price. And if you've got a dual track process where the ESOP is going down the rails alongside the third-party sale to a financial sponsor, that esop uh sets the floor, right? You can set the floor in value and simply tell the private equity firm, hey, if you if you can't meet this minimum price threshold that you yourselves have negotiated with us, if you can't behave and and meet our expectations on value and other terms, we're going the Aesop way.

29:54Brent Sullivan: I mean, could you talk to me about like sort of wealth practices because they have this recurring revenue stream? It tends to grow with the market, it scales, it grows uh somewhat somewhat rapidly, but not too rapidly. Could you talk to me about that? Is that a good fit for this kind of thing?

30:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): There are uh plenty of acquirers in that space now rolling these practices up. Remember, you need to be around a minimum of probably five million dollars in value for a wealth management business, but closer to 10 would be better in terms of your value to justify the expenses, which by the way are much lower than the costs of conducting an auction process. But what's typically happening happening in the wealth medicine space is that business owners, wealth managers are being approached by roll-ups from platform wealth managers who are rolling them into their practices. So anyway, so uh an ESOP is attractive, but I think the better angle for a wealth manager is to examine his or her client base and say, wait a minute, I should be getting in front of my 60 60-something or 50-something business owners and sharing this idea with them because this is value added. They're not typically hearing it from their accountants. They might be hearing it from their attorneys and other advisors. So get in early, have the conversation. It's a very low-cost option for them to explore.

31:08It doesn't cost nearly as much as a third-party third party sale does.

31:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a lot of things.

31:33Brent Sullivan: Like an alignment of incentives, this transition from owners into employees who just want to sustain the business and keep it growing. And that just like gives the legislation that is um, I don't know, I guess manifest via 1042, these incentives. It gives like some longevity to these incentives. It gives a reason for people to rely on them, to think about, like, you know, no guarantees, of course, this kind of thing. But it seems like this is the kind of thing that Congress would like to protect.

31:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It it's the one thing in this crazy world we live in that does not seem to be caught up in the topsy turvy world of internecine rivalry and party um polarity. I think ESOPs have a little bit of something for everybody. On the right, you tend to see an embracing of the benefits, the tax benefits for business owners. On the left, you tend to see the benefits that employees enjoy. Now I don't mean to uh suggest that one can't uh appreciate the opportunity opportunities for the other. I'm just suggesting that this has been legislation that has enjoyed broad bipartisan support ever since it was created uh in the 70s, even earlier, earlier structures in the fifties. So this is legislation that tends to only get better over time, from what we can tell. There continue to be new improvements introduced. And the opportunity I think is really, really attractive for it to continue.

32:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,

32:49Brent Sullivan: Doug, um I really appreciate it. you getting us up to speed on what's going on in Aesop land. This is a powerful planning tool all around, and it seems like it's going to be around for quite a while.

32:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh,

33:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): my pleasure.

33:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

33:01Brent Sullivan: that's the Aesop. It's a powerful exit strategy for private business owners. Thanks again to Doug Pugliese for joining the albatross.

33:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

33:10Brent Sullivan: if you like this kind of thing, come join us at Basis Manhattan, December 3rd and 4th in Manhattan. Manhattan.

33:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

33:16Brent Sullivan: albatross is written and produced by me, Brent Sullivan. Original music is by Paul Roberts.

33:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This

33:22Brent Sullivan: is not investment tax or legal advice. Hire tax counsel for your situation. Head on over to taxalphainsider.com for more about risk and tax management and tax risk management and about recent developments in industry and policy. See you next

33:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): time.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights