Stuart Weams argues transparency is the third pillar of investing alongside risk and returns, warning against opaque structures.
Summary
Stuart Weams introduces a retirement calculator and argues that transparency is the critical third factor for capital preservation, alongside risk and returns. He contrasts transparent assets like direct property and passive ETFs with opaque structures such as industry super funds and private markets. Weams highlights regulatory concerns from APRA regarding unlisted investments and cites a study on wash trading in crypto. He concludes with a seven-point checklist for identifying transparent investments, emphasizing visible assets, verifiable valuations, and aligned incentives.
Key takeaways
- 1 Passive ETFs align investor and provider interests through scale, where attracting more capital allows index providers to lower fees.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 8:28
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 1:59
Introduction and Retirement Calculator
Stuart Weams introduces the Investopoly podcast and a new online retirement calculator available at Investopoly.com.au. The tool allows users to model variable investment contributions over time to account for changes in household income and expenses, serving as a confidence-building model rather than financial advice.
- 1:59 – 4:57
The Importance of Transparency
Weams argues that while investors focus on returns and risk, transparency is the critical third factor for keeping money safe. He defines transparency as the ability to see and verify components of an investment, noting that problems hide in opaque structures where they cannot be assessed or mitigated.
- 4:57 – 7:25
Direct Property: High Transparency with Transactional Opacity
Direct property is described as highly transparent because it is a physical asset with high visibility and control. However, the buying process can be opaque, particularly in private sales or expressions of interest, whereas auctions provide greater transparency into bidder appetite and pricing.
- 7:25 – 9:48
Passive ETFs vs. Active Funds
Passive ETFs are highlighted for their simplicity and transparency, with clear holdings, straightforward fee structures, and aligned incentives where scale drives lower fees. In contrast, actively managed funds are less transparent regarding decision-making processes, turnover costs, and future fee structures, relying heavily on individual portfolio managers.
- 9:48 – 15:26
Industry Super Funds: The Black Box
Industry super funds are characterized as a 'black box' due to lack of disclosure on manager selection, performance attribution, and non-investment expenses like marketing and union payments. Weams argues that without transparency into these operational decisions, members cannot assess future returns or fee efficiency, though media and analyst scrutiny provide some external accountability.
- 15:26 – 20:47
Opaque Alternatives: Private Credit, Equity, and Crypto
Private credit, private equity, and venture capital are identified as highly opaque due to murky fee structures, related-party transactions, and valuation practices. Weams suggests that sudden wealth recipients often gravitate toward these complex, opaque investments due to ego rather than fundamentals, mistaking complexity for sophistication.
- 20:47 – 24:25
Cryptocurrency and Wash Trading
Cryptocurrency is cited as an example of opacity due to wallet anonymity and lack of counterparty visibility. Weams references a peer-reviewed study published in Management Science in 2023, which estimated that wash trading accounted for over 70% of reported volume on unregulated crypto exchanges, distorting price integrity.
- 24:25 – 31:47
Seven Traits of Transparent Investments
Weams concludes with a seven-point checklist for transparent investments: 1) Visible underlying assets, 2) Independently verifiable valuations via open markets, 3) Clear and ascertainable costs, 4) Aligned incentives, 5) Accountable decision-making, 6) Independent oversight (auditors, regulators, media), and 7) Understandable exit options and liquidity.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| BitcoinBTC | crypto | neutral | They Might a might make a few little mistakes, buy some speculative stocks, buy some really active style. thematic investing ETFs, these buy some Bitcoin, meme coins, whatever it might be, right? |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Transparency is the single biggest way to keep money safe because it allows investors to assess, price in, and avoid potential problems.
Stuart Weams ·3:18
How to verify: Logical deduction based on the speaker's argument; no external verification needed for the opinion itself, but the premise can be tested by analyzing historical investment failures linked to opacity. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Auctions are more transparent than private sales because they reveal bidder appetite and nervousness/confidence levels.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·6:06
How to verify: Real estate market analysis; verifiable by comparing data on final sale prices and bidder participation in auctions vs. private treaties. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Vanguard is a mutual business where scale translates to lower fees for investors.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·8:19
How to verify: Primary Source: Vanguard Group's corporate structure documentation and annual reports confirming its mutual ownership and fee structure policies. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Industry super funds do not disclose detailed information on how investment managers are appointed, terminated, or how internal vs. external manager performance compares.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·10:28
How to verify: Primary Source: Annual reports and Product Disclosure Statements (PDS) of major Australian industry super funds (e.g., AustralianSuper, UniSuper) to check for disclosure on manager selection criteria and performance attribution. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Industry super funds lack disclosure on marketing, sponsorship, and union payment expenses, only providing aggregate figures.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·13:07
How to verify: Primary Source: Annual reports of Australian industry super funds; verify if line items for marketing/sponsorship are broken down by purpose or ROI. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A peer-reviewed study published in Management Science in 2023 estimated that wash trades accounted for more than 70% of reported trading volume on unregulated crypto exchanges.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·22:26
How to verify: Primary Source: Academic journal 'Management Science', Volume 69, Issue 1 (2026), 'Wash Trading: Evidence from Cryptocurrency Markets' by Chen, H., et al. (or similar title/authors from that period). Verify the 70% figure in the abstract or results section. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Regulated crypto exchanges exhibit more normal trading patterns and less wash trading compared to unregulated exchanges.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·22:46
How to verify: Primary Source: The same Management Science study or subsequent regulatory reports from bodies like the CFTC or SEC comparing volume data between regulated and unregulated platforms. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThe lack of transparency in opaque investments increases risk, and sudden wealth recipients often choose them due to ego.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·18:27
How to verify: Psychological/Behavioral Finance literature on 'sudden wealth syndrome' and risk-taking behavior; verifiable by academic studies on inheritance/business sale recipients' investment choices. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Index funds do not participate in price discovery; active buyers and sellers do.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·25:25
How to verify: Financial theory; verifiable by examining market microstructure literature which states that passive funds are price-takers, not price-makers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the specific fee structures and expense ratios of any passive ETFs or active funds discussed, comparing them to benchmark indices.
- Review APRA's published reports on unlisted investments and valuation practices to understand regulatory concerns.
- Check the annual reports of industry super funds for disclosures on external manager appointments, performance attribution, and marketing spend ROI.
- Research the 2023 Management Science study on crypto wash trading to understand the methodology and scope of volume distortion claims.
- Assess the transparency of any private credit or equity opportunities by examining fee waterfalls, valuation methodologies, and related-party transaction disclosures.
- Compare the liquidity terms and exit options of proposed investments against the 'understandable exit options' criterion outlined in the episode.
- Investigate the governance structures of investment vehicles to ensure independent oversight by auditors and regulators.
- Review the investment mandate and decision-making process of any fund manager to check for alignment with the 'accountable decision-making' trait.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hi,
- 0:00
- Stuart Weams: my name's Stuart Weams, and welcome to the Investopoly Podcast. Our goal is to give you easy to understand, evidence-based, holistic insights to help you master the game of building wealth. And just a quick reminder, I promise not to do this every single time, every single introduction. But yesterday I gave you a bit of a heads up. If you go to Investopoly.com.au, we now have
- 0:20
- Stuart Weams: an online retirement calculator. So it's based on an episode we did early last month and it's got a little bit more functionality. It's not going to be appropriate for every single client scenario or every single listener scenario, I should say. But you've got to try and balance usability,
- 0:39
- Stuart Weams: understandability, and still allow it to address at least some complexity. But one of the things that we changed, or I changed, is that you can vary the investment contributions you might. make over time. So, for example, how much you're putting to soup or investing in the share market. And that's really to deal with expected changes
- 0:59
- Stuart Weams: in household income and expenses. So, for instance, if you're, you know, starting a young family, you got to pay for childcare. One spouse or partner might not be working full time, that's a challenging period of time. Your cash flow tends to be compressed. But if you expect that to change, say in seven years' time, you can model that. So, anyway, have
- 1:19
- Stuart Weams: a play around with it. That the general theme of a tool like this isn't to do financial planning. It's really to give you some confidence that you're on track, that if you do X, Y, and Z, you know that you'll be okay and you'll be able to meet your retirement goal. And if you're not on track to work out what you need to do, broadly speaking, and remember it's just a model, it's not a critical
- 1:38
- Stuart Weams: crystal ball, it's not advice, it's information only. But I hope the tool helps listeners. As I said, I'm gonna build more tools like this. So thanks for listening. And please share, by the way. So if you know anyone else that can benefit from the tool, with probably everyone, please do share it. The more the merrier. Okay, let's get into today's episode. Now, when investors consider
- 1:59
- Stuart Weams: investment, almost a hundred percent of investors think. about potential future returns. That's kind of the first thing that they think about, which makes sense, right? You see an advertisement in the paper, you consider something here, a story, of course it tends all those stories tend to be about returns. And then I think fewer investors, maybe only
- 2:19
- Stuart Weams: 20% or so, I don't know, anecdotally, think about risk, you know. So risk really is what is the probability of that. future expected return occurring. But I think very, very few think about an equally important factor, which is transparency. And that's what I want to talk about today because transparency
- 2:39
- Stuart Weams: is really about how much you can see and understand for yourself and how easily you can verify what you're being told. So is it a black box and you've just got to take, you know, the marketing materials or the person on their word? Can you sort of drill down and see each individual component, both positive and negative, to make your own assessment?
- 2:58
- Stuart Weams: Because at the end of the day, problems often hide in the dark. And that's an issue, particularly in when it comes to money and finances and financial services. And if you can't see that potential problem, you can't assess it, you can't price it in, you can't take steps to mitigate it. and you certainly can't avoid it. And that's why
- 3:18
- Stuart Weams: transparency is probably the single biggest way to keep your money safe. And keeping our money safe is, I think, probably at the top of most people's list. Like I've spoken about this before, in terms of risk profile, most people's risk profile, I think, is very, very similar in that I want to earn a
- 3:37
- Stuart Weams: return enough. return to meet my goals, and I'm not shooting for the stars on this, but I just don't want to lose my capital. I've worked hard for my money, I want to invest it wisely, I want a decent return, but I want to take the lowest possible risk in order to achieve that return. And that's how I would describe my own risk profile. Almost 99% Percent of our
- 3:57
- Stuart Weams: clients, and probably ninety-nine 99% percent of listeners listening to this episode. So what I want to do today is discuss a couple of different asset classes to give you an example of what I mean with respect to transparency and how to consider it when looking at an investment opportunity. And then at the end, I'm going to sort of sum it up and say and
- 4:17
- Stuart Weams: sort of highlight what are the common traits that investment should Would have that add to its transparency as a little bit of a sort of checklist, if you like. And again, when you're then looking at or considering making investments, or if you'd potentially get distracted by shiny objects, you know, you see an investment opportunity, you can run the rule over it from a transparency perspective.
- 4:37
- Stuart Weams: Because in terms of keeping your money safe and making informed and educated decisions, that's the key thing. And the whole thesis around Investopoly and now wealth by design, the reason I wrote the book is that I think very few financial mistakes are made because of random bad luck, that it's because something was wrong. And it's
- 4:57
- Stuart Weams: whether you can identify that wrong thing, you need to know what is wrong, but then you need the investment to have enough transparency so you can identify it. Okay, so let's get into it. Let's talk about a couple of different sort of asset classes and investment options. So, firstly, property. You know, I think property is probably one of the most transparent. investments you can own. It's a physical
- 5:17
- Stuart Weams: asset. You can inspect it, you can understand it kind of firsthand. You can you've got considerable control over it, you know, to the extent that tenancy laws allow you
- 5:26
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to control it. So you can improve it, you can change its use, you can occupy, you can put some tenants in it, you can leave it vacant, you can decide when to sell it. So it's one of the few asset classes that are physical. you know, that has a high degree of visibility and control. And I think that's probably the thing that attracts most people to
- 5:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): property, is that it is very transparent and you can really understand it. Probably the only area where transparency might be lacking is through the buying and selling process, particularly the buying process. Now, that's why auctions are so valuable. I think. And I know Victoria's, you know,
- 6:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): tightened some rules around quoting that makes auctions sometimes a little bit harder to run. And that's not, that's actually not going to be in the interest of property buyers. What is in the interest of property buyers is to buy a property at auction because it's so transparent. You can see the other bidders, you can kind of read the room if you like to sort of understand, you
- 6:26
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, the appetite of bidders and how they're bidding, how nervous or confident they are and all those sorts of things. And then you can use that in making your decision. Whereas if you're buying a property through a private sale, expression of interest, that sort of campaign, it's often quite opaque. You don't really have much visibility around is there their genuine
- 6:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): interest from other parties? How many other parties, how likely is it they're going to offer? better terms or a higher purchase price than you? And you know, you've got to almost, I mean, no one takes a real estate agent's on their word, but you know, almost have to to some extent rely on what you've been told. So that's probably the only kind of opaque
- 7:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): thing about investing in direct property. But once you've got it, it's a very, very transparent asset. And remember that that these shortcomings really relate to the transaction rather than the investment itself. And hopefully, you buy an asset, you buy well, high-quality asset, you hold for long term, enjoy compounding capital growth. So the transparent the asset provides is
- 7:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): ideal. The next example of a highly transparent asset is a passive ETF. So an index style ETF, whether it's social market cap indexing or some other factor style indexing. They're simple and they're transparent. You know, you can understand.
- 7:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): what the fund holds, like where it's investing, how they're weighting the stocks within the fund, what the investment methodology is. Fees are very straightforward as well. Typically there'll be one management fee, no performance fees. So and also with respect to fees, you know, we know what the fees are now, but what will they be in the future? Well we
- 7:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know that actually with low cost index funds, the business model for the index provider is scale. They make a very small margin on a very large amount of money. And if you think about Vanguard, for instance, being a mutual business, that scale translates to lower fees. So not only if you're going to buy an ETF and pay 0.3
- 8:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of a percent, and that ETF is successful in attracting money, you've got at least a reasonable amount of confidence that fee is going to. stay at 0.3%
- 8:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): or potentially decline over time and get even more competitive. So, you know, lower and offering lower fees for an ETF provider actually attracts more money. So your interests, both your interests are aligned. Now contrast that with actively managed funds. You know, many charge performance fees, so it's difficult to know what you're actually going to
- 8:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): pay in terms of overall fees. You don't know how buying decisions are going to be made in terms of portfolio construction, what they're going to invest in, how much turnover there might be, because turnover will go to costs and taxation drag. And ultimately, at the end of the day, a small number of individuals will be making those decisions. So the portfolio managers, and you
- 9:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): might know the portfolio who the portfolio manager is today, and they might have a great track record, but who knows that portfolio manager might lead. leave that business or manage a different fund in the future. So these things are quite difficult then to assess in terms of what's going on with inside this fund. How do they make decisions? Who's making the decisions and what are the inherent risks?
- 9:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So really when you contrast ETFs versus managed funds, you can see where the transparency differences are and then how that makes you feel as an investor in terms of confidence. But ultimately there's functional and fundamental differences there because we can really understand what the inherent risks are within those investments. Let's talk about
- 9:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): industry super funds. And this is a big deal for Australia and for investors. Industry super funds are a bit of a black box as far as I'm concerned. You can ascertain what does the fund charge in terms of fees, but it doesn't really tell you. what's going to happen to fees longer term. And the trend in Australia hasn't been really to
- 10:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): achieve scale. And I don't think it will be in the future. I'm going to talk about that in a second. And then you've got it, you can look at historic returns, but you can't really make an assessment around how likely is it to reproduce those returns or something changed change within the fund in terms of the way that they approach things, manage things, or deal with things. that could impact
- 10:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): future returns. So, for example, let's just talk about how they appoint investment managers. So that is that they will go to various investment managers and say in different categories and say manage this portion of our money, for instance. So how do they appoint those managers? Which ones do they terminate? Which managers are underperforming that
- 10:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): they've retained and they haven't terminated, and how long? How do they decide which money to manage internally versus with external managers? And what proportions does that look like? And how have internal managers performed relative to external managers? These are all really important decisions that affect, you know, our assessment of
- 11:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): future likely returns. And look, the reality is most Australians, most superannuation investors just aren't going to investigate these matters themselves, but industry analysts and journalists will. And that's an important part of transparency because if there are weaknesses that need exposing or
- 11:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): concerns that need talking about, the industry and the media will start talking about those sorts of things. So imagine a situation where, you know, one particular industry superfund. super fund gives a such a large mandate to an external manager, or alternatively, that they sack a large external manager and try and do it all in-house.
- 11:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's an important con if if that's going on inside your industry superfund, that's an important consideration. It's not uh necessarily okay, calls for concern I need to take my money elsewhere, but it's just okay, well let's manage that. Let's see how that works. And it could be a positive story to too, right? It could be we're we're going to manage this money in-house and we do that
- 12:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and do that at a lower cost and achieve higher returns. So it could be a great story, in which case it gives us confidence, but we don't have any of that accountability and transparency. And remember, problems tend to live in the dark. I've spoken before about the lack of transparency around unlisted investments and the valuation approaches they use and APRA, the
- 12:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): regulators, has had concerns about that as well. That all just comes down to transparency and creating some additional form of accountability, external accountability, often results in better outcomes for stakeholders. The other thing, you know, that at the end of the day, the expenses that a fund incurs Funding curs is your money, because if they're
- 12:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): able to reduce the cost to run that fund, they can then pass those savings on. to you as a member. Remember, industry super funds love to advertise they're all for members, they're not for profit businesses. That's great as long as they're efficient. But you know, another problem with the transparency around investing your money with an industry superfund is that there's no disclosure
- 13:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): around marketing, sponsorship, and partnerships expenses, and especially those involving unions. So the fund does disclose that. aggregate number, you know, at an aggregate. But you know, how much are they spending on marketing? What's the return on investment? And how does marketing really work, by the way? Because why do you as a member need to pay for
- 13:26
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): marketing dollars for them to attract more members? How does that benefit you? The answer would be probably, and I'm only surmising, is that the more members we have, the more money we manage, the more scale we get, and therefore lower we can. pass on lower fees to members. That's a great story, but it hasn't happened in most circumstances. All they're doing really is
- 13:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): just cementing their own jobs by advertising. They're using your money to do that. Now the problem is that there's just not enough accountability around it. So if we create more transparency, that creates accountability. And all of a sudden there's some onus on super funds to disclose why we're are we paying for these sponsorships? Why are we paying for this marketing and the
- 14:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): promotion? Why did we donate money to this or contribute money to this union movement or whatever it might be? And there could be legitimate reasons for doing that. Let's get it out in the open, interrogate it. And ultimately, what's going to happen is you're going to create a more competitive industry superfund super fund environment, and that's going to lower fees to Australians.
- 14:26
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So that's why transparency is so important is in investments, because it does create that accountability and it's insidious. It might look okay from the beginning or from the outside, but it starts to decay over time. And then it gets to a point where you're in an investment and it's not really performing very well. I mean, ultimately you might take the view to say, oh,
- 14:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): look, it's not going so bad. Like some funds have reduced fees. But I'll be honest, I think the fees should be close to half. If they were really genuinely interested in achieving scale, the fees should be close to half. And the benchmark is Vanguard. Seriously, that is the benchmark. Maybe not in terms of investment returns, although they've been very, very good as well. But in terms
- 15:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of fees, that's kind of the and so that's my probably best example. I've got another one in a second, of how lack of transparency can really be. a big negative when it comes to investing and remembering that our goal is to keep our money safe, not lose our capital. And we need to have all the information at our hands and the market work in our favor to
- 15:26
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): create conditions that is going to keep our money safe and make it work hard for us. Now, some of the most opaque investment options can include things like private credit, private equity, venture capital, all these sorts of things. So private credit is funds that lend money to businesses or property developments that are outside the traditional banking system.
- 15:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So you you invest the money, they use that money to on lend to corporates and obviously charge an interest and then they'll pay you an interest rate in return. But of course, you've got to assess the risk of who they're lending to and you only need a couple of loans to go bad for it to really hurt investors. Private equity invests in unlisted businesses, often with some
- 16:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): sort of exit strategy, could be a listing or a trade sale or something like that. And venture capital is kind of a subset of private equity, which invests in startup businesses. The challenge with all these sorts of options is they certainly lack a lot of transparency around fees, remuneration structures, how are the advisors.
- 16:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): getting paid? So the advisors are not only recommending the investment, but also the advisors that are working within that investment company and the individual companies themselves, related party transactions, valuation practices, it can be very, very murky. And it makes it very difficult then for investors to really assess the
- 16:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): risk and so forth. And of course, don't forget, just like active. actively managed funds, you know, a lot of the decisions rest with only a a handful of individuals. So you're really relying on, you know, maybe five or six people to make some really smart decisions. And sometimes there's one just key lead person making a lot of the decisions. That again kind of adds
- 17:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to the the risk profile. I just don't really understand the attraction associated with those sort of options, private credit and private equity. And the interesting observation I like to share is often I find investors that run into a lump sum of money, quite a sizable lump sum of money. So that could be, you know, people that end up selling their business.
- 17:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So they might not have a lot of money, or they might be okay, relatively speaking, but they might not have huge amounts of money. But then they sell their business because, you know, great, right time, right place, right industry, and end up with 20 million bucks in the bank. Or people that, you know, receive an inheritance. Often I find they're the ones that are probably most attracted to
- 17:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): private credit, private equity, and unlisted investments. And it sort of surprises me because, you know, they I think that attraction is probably driven more by ego than investment fundamentals. I think some of these people think I've got a lot more money than everyone else, so I should be doing things differently. That ETFs are just too simple for me. I need to, you
- 18:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, I've got substantial, I need to be doing something different. And so they mistake complexity with sophistication. And so they think that these more complex investments, more opaque investments, really translate to more, a more sophisticated approach. And a more sophisticated approach maybe yields uh better outcomes. But really with more complexity
- 18:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): often brings less transparency, which actually increases the risk. And I would argue that someone, the more money you have, the more important transparency becomes. Not less. Like if you sell your business for 20 million bucks and get 20 million, that's a situation where you need to make some super, super smart decisions. And so I think part of it is an ego. I think the other
- 18:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): part is that investors that don't receive a lump sum. either through those sorts of situations, inheritance or business sales, investors get to have training wills first before they get to a sizable portfolio. So by that, what I mean is that people might start investing in their 20s or 30s, but they're not investing a lot of money, 10 grand a year, maybe something like that.
- 19:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): They're playing with it a little bit. They Might a might make a few little mistakes, buy some speculative stocks, buy some really active style. thematic investing ETFs, these buy some Bitcoin, meme coins, whatever it might be, right? So they might make a few it's sort of their apprenticeship. They make a few mistakes at the beginning of their investment journey, but they're not big mistakes because they don't have a
- 19:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): huge amount of money. But they learn along the way. And after doing that for ten or fifteen years, they start to really work and get confidence what's working, that you know, a very transparent, rules rules-based, based, evidence evidence-based based approach works. And so then then when they've got, even if they do end up accumulating several millions or maybe tens of millions of dollars, they're not distracted by the
- 19:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): shiny objects. The challenge with people that run into a whole bunch of money is they haven't done that apprenticeship. And I think that's why, because they don't understand it, that's what it sort of attracts them. So for people thinking about, you know, in this podcast I talk about ETFs, transparent, rules-based ETFs, I talk about direct property. I talk about commercial property at times, but I
- 20:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): don't really talk about asset classes outside of that. This is a good reason for it because there is a substantial lack of transparency, but also there's a lack of evidence as well in terms of returns. And I just wanted to sort of share that observation because it it's is kind of interesting. As I said, I think the more money you have, the more important transparency.
- 20:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): is because the more you have or the more there is at risk. And so the more you have to keep safe. Let me give you one final example of how the lack of transparency exists. And every time I write or talk about Bitcoin, I get a bunch of people making comments, you know, pro-Bitcoin people making
- 20:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): comments. And Manny in our office, so we have I mentioned this before, we have lots of conversations. about it. He loves crypto. I mean, he has he's not all in, but you know, he enjoys putting I was going to say investing, but I don't like to use the term investing and crypto in the same sentence. But anyway, so I just put that out there that I have a view, it's okay. People have sometimes very strong views
- 21:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that don't align to mine. That's fine. But just I wanted to use crypto as an example of what happens when there's a lack of trend. transparency and how problems live in the dark when the you know, if there's lack of transparency, that's where problems will go. So obviously the promise around crypto is decentralization. It allows people to transact
- 21:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): with each other without needing intermediaries like the big banks and so forth and the government and so forth. And so while transactions on the blockchain, as far as I understand, are visible and traceable. you can't really identify who owns individual wallets. So you don't know who the counterparties are when looking at transactions, which means you
- 21:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): don't really know, you know, what exchanges are holding. So what sort of what level of crypto exchanges are holding. And then also you can't determine, you know, is it a genuine trade or is it not a genuine trade? And of course, this sort of anonymity will attract people that want to offer. avoid that sort of scrutiny and obviously impacts
- 22:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the integrity of a market. And wash trading is a perfect example of that. So wash trading is when the buyer and seller are the same person or related people. And so they're buy both the buyer and seller. So they're really it's not a genuine trade, it's really market manipulation, if you like. And there was a peer peer-reviewed reviewed study
- 22:26
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): by that was published in Management Science back in 23 that looked at 29 crypto exchanges and estimated that wash trades accounted for more than 70% of reported trading volume on unregulated exchanges. Now, I should say unregulated exchanges, because regulated exchanges, by
- 22:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): contrast, exhibit more normal trading patterns. So the the amount of wash sellings that that's going on isn't as big a deal. But the problem is that you need the whole market to be really regulated to understand or to be able to rely on the fact that everything's genuine. Because of course, wash trading can distort prices and volume. So whilst one
- 23:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): exchange might be great, there could be, you know, another opportunity to do wash trading outside of that that will still impact the value of a particular cryptocurrency. And so I could be doing some transactions. I'll sell some coins for, you know, the market value might be $120. I'll sell them for $140 and I'll buy them
- 23:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): back off myself, for example. And that's how I'm going to influence prices. Now, of course, with something so large as Bitcoin, you know, that that can be difficult to do. But the problem is it's opaque and we don't really know what's going on. And the main point is not an anti-crypto. anti cryptocurrency viewpoint, although I'm not pro crypto. That's not the reason I'm making the point. The reason I'm making the
- 23:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): point is that transparency helps keep our money safe. Transparency helps keep everyone honest and it creates and invites accountability. And you can't have accountability without transparency. And I think the lack of transparency and anonymity that cryptocurrency creates. might be the thing that attracts people to it.
- 24:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): But actually, I think it's the thing that that hurts it the most because it then lacks some form of integrity. And the problem then is, well, if you bring that integrity, then do you destroy the thing that originally made it an alternative to normal currency, which was having some sort of decentralized currency or something along those lines? Okay, so
- 24:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think I've made my point giving you plenty of examples of uh transparent and opaque investments. But let's bring it all together now and talk about the seven attributes that are common amongst these transparent investments. And you can use it as a bit of a checklist. As I say, particularly if you're enticed into some sort of opportunity investment opportunity that's outside of
- 24:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the traditional ones that we talk about on this podcast, you can sort of run the ruler over them. So the first thing is you see what you own, you know what the underlying assets are, you know, whether it's physical property or listed shares, but you know exactly where your money's going. The second one is that valuations are independently verifiable. And
- 25:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the best example of that is transactions that occur in an open and transparent market. Price discovery, which is the process of buying and selling shares. that index funds, I'll talk about this in a few weeks. Index funds don't really participate in price discovery. You might think they do, but they don't. It's all the active buying and individual
- 25:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): buyers and corporations and all these sorts of things that are really doing the price discovery mechanism. That is an important mechanism because if a particular stock or ETF has been traded thousands of times per day, it gives you some level of comfort. that the price really reflects all the available information, uh, risks and opportunities. The third element are
- 25:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): costs are clear and ascertainable. I think, and I would extend that to not only current fees, but you have or you can form a view of how fees might change over the time or whether there's a risk that fees will change over time. The fourth one is incentives are aligned, and this is only going to impact if you have a
- 26:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): counterparty. So, you know, if you've got direct property, you don't really have a counterparty, although maybe the incentives of the managing agent, the person that's managing the asset for you, need to be considered. But the ETF example that I gave you, you know, the success in an ETF is to attract Track more money. And if you can compete on cost, particularly for
- 26:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): homogenous products like an A. ASX 200 fund, being able to offer lower fees, it allows you to attract more money. The more money you have, the higher the dollar value return you're going to make off an ETF. So the goals of the ETF provider and the goals of the investor are very closely aligned. That's ideal. In some other more opaque investments,
- 26:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): sometimes they're at odds with each other because, you know, their the success of a particular manager might be to. charge as much fees as possible or to earn a success fee or to turn the portfolio over, and that might not align with your interests. Number five, decision making is accountable. And this is the thing that I think is the biggest problem in industry super fund
- 27:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): sector, which is ridiculous given there's what, three or four trillion dollars in in the super system. There should be much greater accountability. As said, you can't have accountability without transparency. Number six, there's independent oversight. It's one of the reasons why, you know, most of the money goes into developed stock markets as opposed to emerging markets because
- 27:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): there's not as much independent oversight. So we're talking about audit auditors, regulators, independent parties, analysts, you know, everyone, journalists, And they they're all playing a very important role. Not one by itself is is the holy grail, but put them all together and it creates a lot of oversight. And lastly, number
- 27:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): seven, you understand your exit options. So you know about liquidity, know when you can sell, when you can walk away, all those sorts of things, and how liquid or illiquid an asset is, and how much underlying demand there might be for a particular asset and how you measure that. One of the things that has hurt some people is they end up owning assets. The asset sounds like a great investment option,
- 28:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): but there's actually no market for it. That's not ideal. Now, as I said at the beginning of today's episode, transparency helps you assess risk and mitigate risk and manage risk, but of course, it doesn't guarantee returns. So even the most transparent investments, whether that's a direct property or an ETF, you know, they can have volatility, they can have poor returns. So it really then comes back
- 28:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to what we've spoken about, which is quality. first by quality indexes or quality assets property at attractive prices, but only by those where there's significant transparency because transparency will create accountability or invite accountability, which is going to keep your money safe. And I should say that
- 28:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the lack of transparency doesn't automatically mean every single opaque investment is going to. be a poor investment. I'm sure just like every everything, there's always exceptions that prove the rule. And so I'm sure that there could be investments out there that still will generate really h high quality returns
- 29:04
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): relative to risk, even though they might be opaque. My answer to that though is why take the risk? You don't really need to take the risk. Why take the risk? And it's the same sort of approach to the person. that just sold their money, their business for 20 million bucks and they've got 20 million dollars in the bank. Why take the risk? You've done the heavy lifting, you built the capital pool. Now, if you can just earn eight to
- 29:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): 10% compounding on average over multi-decade periods, you know, if you earn 10%, your your balance is going to double every seven years. What what more do you need? Maintain transparency and take the lowest possible risk to try and achieve those target and reasonable returns. And that's our view at Pro Solution, and certainly our view in the in this
- 29:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): podcast is really absolutely insist on a high degree of transparency. Assets that you can clearly understand what they're investing in, assess the underlying risks of those particular assets, understand what fees you're paying and to whom, and how the investment decisions are made and any other important. factors.
- 30:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Transparency is really one of the best ways, as I said, to keep your money safe. Okay, so I'll leave it there for today. Not sure what I'm going to talk about next week, so it'll be a surprise for both of us. So until then, bye for now. Before I let you go, I want to let you know I've built a new resource website for podcast listeners at
- 30:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Investopoly.com.au. My goal is to help you get easy. even more value from the podcast by providing practical tools and resources that help you put the ideas and strategies I discuss into practice. To get access, you need to be a subscriber to my blog. You just need to put in your email address and you'll be sent a code to access the site
- 30:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): initially and it will remember you. I'll be adding more resources over the coming months, including some AI tools. I also have a phone. favor to ask. My average rating on Apple is 4.9 stars from over 560 reviews. On Spotify, I've got a perfect 5 stars from more than 360 reviews.
- 31:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That makes it the highest-rated Australian Finance podcast, and I don't take that for granted. I really appreciate the support. But now I'm asking for the same support for my new book, Wealth by Design. So if you've read the book and got something out of it, would you please leave a review on Amazon? I've got 45 Amazon reviews
- 31:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so far, and thank you to everyone that's taken the time to share a review. The more reviews it has, it genuinely helps the book become a success. The link is in the show notes. And finally, a shout out to anyone who's running their own business or thinking about starting one. I've got another show for that. It's called Business by Design, co-hosted with
- 31:42
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Mina. The link is also in the show notes. Thanks for listening.
More from Investopoly
Q&A - Property vs shares before retirement: sell at a loss?
Episode discussion: Investopoly Q&A: Property vs shares before retirement, selling at a loss
Speakers’ claims: Speakers analyze three listener scenarios involving property and cash balances, contrasting illiquid real estate with liquid shares. A 33-year-old specialist is advised to maintain a cash buffer for maternity leave while considering established land over new townhouses. A 66-year-old retiree with significant property wealth is counseled to gradually diversify into liquid assets as interest rates fall. A 49-year-old couple with negative cash flow commercial property is urged to sell at a loss to fund an ETF portfolio, citing poor risk-adjusted returns in commercial real estate.
Ep 434: Why index investing is so hard to beat
Episode discussion: Stuart Weams argues index investing beats active management due to wealth concentration, volatility, and timing risks
Speakers’ claims: Stuart Weams argues that index funds outperform active management over the long term due to low turnover, tax efficiency, and the statistical reality that a tiny fraction of stocks generate most market wealth. He cites data showing that in developed markets, roughly 2% of stocks created all shareholder wealth between 1990 and 2020, while the majority underperformed cash. Weams highlights that market returns are highly concentrated in a few days, often following sharp declines, making market timing ineffective. He also notes that intra-year volatility is normal and that investor behavior, such as buying high and selling low, further erodes returns compared to a passive strategy.