Benchmark analysts argue battery prices are regional, not global, driven by policy and tariffs rather than manufacturing costs
Summary
Ed Porter and Iola Hughes from Benchmark Mineral Intelligence discuss how battery pricing has fragmented into regional markets due to tariffs, sourcing rules, and logistics. Hughes explains that China's 'anti-involution' campaign and reduced export rebates have ended the era of ultra-low cell prices, while the US market is driven by policy incentives like 48E and 45X. The speakers note that sodium-ion technology has lost momentum with over 1 GWh of projects cancelled in favor of LFP, and that stationary storage is gaining share relative to EVs, particularly in the US data center sector. They conclude that only LFP and NCM chemistries are viable long-term, dismissing hype around solid-state and sodium-ion as noise against continuous improvements in incumbents.
Key takeaways
- 1 Um, I think probably one of the big things is is really around there's no such thing as a global battery price anymore, but ultimately it's really a a conversation of where a cell can legally go that's imping impacting that, and then really rather than the actual cost, the amount of cost to to make that cell.
Iola Hughes · 1:27
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 3:39
No Global Battery Price
Ed Porter and Iola Hughes discuss how battery prices are no longer global, with China at $50-60/kWh, Europe falling, and the US rising due to tariffs and logistics rather than just manufacturing costs.
- 3:39 – 13:32
China's Anti-Involution Campaign and Capacity
Iola Hughes explains that China's 'anti-involution' campaign, lithium price volatility, and reduced export rebates have ended the era of ultra-low cell prices, with utilization rates averaging 50% despite high nameplate capacity.
- 13:32 – 20:33
Sodium-Iron Market Reality
The speakers analyze sodium-ion technology, noting that over 1 GWh of projects were cancelled this year in favor of LFP, and that sodium-ion requires sustained high lithium prices to remain competitive.
- 20:33 – 22:42
Eastern Europe Storage Boom
Bulgaria has installed over 5 GWh of storage this year, overtaking Germany, driven by larger average project sizes exceeding 200 MWh, contrasting with slower growth in Western Europe.
- 22:42 – 26:56
US Manufacturing and Policy Haze
The US 2030 storage cell pipeline has grown from 70 GWh to over 300 GWh, driven by Korean manufacturers like LG pivoting from EV to storage due to policy incentives like 48E and 45X, despite tariff uncertainties.
- 26:56 – 31:07
US Battery Market Dynamics and Data Center Demand
Iola Hughes discusses how Chinese manufacturers face tax credit ineligibility in the US due to licensing deals, while Korean and US firms like Tesla and LG gain ground. She highlights that over 130 GWh of battery capacity is announced alongside US data centers, mostly via off-site PPAs, driven by policy and grid access needs.
- 31:07 – 33:47
Stationary Storage vs EV Market Share and Growth Drivers
Hughes notes stationary storage is gaining attention relative to EVs, with production currently split 2:1 in favor of EVs (2 TWh vs 1 TWh). She projects this ratio to shift to 25% storage by 2030, constrained by grid infrastructure rather than cell supply, unlike EVs which can export to meet demand.
- 33:47 – 36:02
Niche Demand: Drones and Supply Chain Security
The drone sector is identified as a growing niche, with defense drone demand at ~4 GWh in 2025, representing 40% of defense battery use. This segment values high energy density and rapid qualification over cycle life, driving interest in novel chemistries like silicon anodes and lithium-sulfur, alongside US efforts to decouple from Chinese supply chains.
- 36:02 – 38:33
Localization, Oversupply, and Western Manufacturer Challenges
New factory construction is driven by localization policies in the US and Europe (e.g., Hungary, Industrial Accelerator Act) rather than pure economics. Hughes argues Western players like ACC, Verkor, and PowerCo face intense competition from both Chinese imports and domestic Chinese-backed plants, making it difficult to compete on cost.
- 38:33 – 40:21
Cell vs. System Manufacturing and Regional Winners
Building battery systems is easier than cells, leading to different top manufacturers (CATL for cells, BYD for systems in H1 2025). Tesla fell out of the top three system makers globally. Regional winners vary by policy: Tesla, Fluence, LG, and Samsung benefit in the US, while Chinese vertical integrators like CATL, HiTide, and Gotion dominate in markets like Australia.
- 40:21 – 42:42
Contrarian View: LFP and NCM Dominance
Hughes asserts that only LFP and NCM chemistries matter, dismissing hype around sodium-ion, solid-state, and others as noise. She argues new technologies must beat where incumbent tech will be in five years, not today, due to continuous improvements in LFP/NCM and the high barriers of insurance, installation experience, and track records.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| TeslaTSLA | equity | neutral | I think for the first time actually Tesla fell out of the top three. for system manufacturing. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
A storage cell in China costs around $50 to $60 per kilowatt hour.
Ed Porter ·0:10
How to verify: Check Benchmark Mineral Intelligence price surveys or Chinese battery exchange rates for Q3/Q4 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
China's storage cell lines are running above 90% utilization, while half the world's battery factory capacity is idle.
Ed Porter ·0:30
How to verify: Compare CATL's reported utilization rates against global capacity data from Benchmark Mineral Intelligence or IEA. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Lithium prices doubled over the last year, then cooled off.
Iola Hughes ·4:16
How to verify: Review lithium carbonate price indices from Fastmarkets or S&P Global Platts for the 12-month period ending Nov 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
China's export rebate for batteries dropped to 6% in April and will go to zero at the end of the year.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·4:33
How to verify: Check Chinese Ministry of Finance announcements regarding export tax rebates for battery products in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
China has 6 to 6.5 TWh of nameplate cell capacity against expected output of 3.5 TWh.
Ed Porter ·6:29
How to verify: Cross-reference Benchmark Mineral Intelligence's global battery manufacturing capacity database. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
CATL's Zhang Jiwo mine was a significant headline regarding lithium supply.
Iola Hughes ·5:29
How to verify: Search news archives for 'CATL Zhang Jiwo mine' updates in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceOver 1 GWh of sodium-ion storage projects were cancelled this year.
Ed Porter ·14:43
How to verify: Review project cancellation announcements from energy developers or Benchmark Mineral Intelligence's project tracker. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bulgaria installed over 5 GWh of battery storage this year, overtaking Germany.
Iola Hughes ·21:22
How to verify: Check Bulgarian Energy Regulatory Commission (CREC) or European Association for Storage report data for 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The US 2030 storage cell pipeline grew from 70 GWh to over 300 GWh.
Iola Hughes ·24:47
How to verify: Compare US Department of Energy or BloombergNEF battery manufacturing pipeline reports from Jan 2025 vs Nov 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
LG aims for 50 GWh of cell manufacturing capacity in the US by the end of this year.
Iola Hughes ·26:16
How to verify: Check LG Energy Solution's official investor presentations or press releases for 2026 capacity targets. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Licensing CATL technology makes projects ineligible for US tax credits under current guidelines, though deal timing may allow exceptions.
Iola Hughes ·26:56
How to verify: Review US Department of Energy tax credit guidelines for battery components and specific project announcements involving CATL licensing to check for exclusions or waivers based on contract dates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceOver 130 GWh of battery capacity is announced alongside US data centers, with ~80 GWh being off-site PPAs.
Iola Hughes ·28:10
How to verify: Cross-reference public announcements from major US data center developers (e.g., Amazon, Microsoft, Google) and battery manufacturers (e.g., Fluence, Tesla) for project sizes and PPA vs. on-site distinctions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
By 2030, data centers will account for ~30% of US battery storage demand.
Iola Hughes ·29:55
How to verify: Check Benchmark Mineral Intelligence or similar analyst forecasts for US energy storage demand breakdown by sector for 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Current global battery production is split 2:1 between EVs and stationary storage (2 TWh vs 1 TWh).
Iola Hughes ·31:32
How to verify: Compare global EV battery sales data (e.g., from EV Volumes or BloombergNEF) with stationary storage deployment data for the current year. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Chinese EV sales are down ~5% year-to-date domestically, while production continues to grow.
Ed Porter ·32:37
How to verify: Review China Passenger Car Association (CPCA) monthly sales reports and production data for the current year. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Defense drone demand accounted for ~4 GWh of battery demand in 2025, with drones making up 40% of defense battery use.
Ed Porter ·34:03
How to verify: Check Benchmark Mineral Intelligence defense battery market reports for 2026 data on drone-specific battery consumption. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
CATL was number one in cell shipments and BYD was number one in system shipments in H1 2025.
Iola Hughes ·38:59
How to verify: Review H1 2026 global battery market rankings from SNE Research or Benchmark Mineral Intelligence. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceNew battery chemistries must compete with where LFP/NCM will be in five years, not where they are today.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·41:17
How to verify: This is a strategic assertion; verify by comparing cost/performance trajectories of new chemistries (e.g., solid-state) against projected LFP/NCM improvements in industry forecasts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The US was the second-largest market for Chinese cell manufacturers before recent restrictions.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·27:23
How to verify: Review historical export data from Chinese battery manufacturers to the US and market share reports from 2026-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify lithium carbonate spot prices against LME or Asian Metal to assess sodium-ion competitiveness thresholds.
- Check US Department of Energy 48E and 45X tax credit guidelines for specific licensing exclusions affecting Chinese tech transfer deals.
- Review CATL and LG Energy Solution quarterly filings for utilization rates and capacity expansion plans in the US and Europe.
- Analyze European grid connection queues and Bulgarian energy ministry reports to validate storage installation growth claims.
- Compare LFP and NCM cost trajectories from Benchmark Mineral Intelligence or S&P Global Commodity Insights against solid-state development roadmaps.
- Assess defense procurement contracts for drone battery specifications to validate demand forecasts for high-energy-density chemistries.
- Examine US data center PPAs and grid interconnection applications to verify the 130 GWh announced capacity versus actual build-out.
- Look for counter-arguments from sodium-ion developers regarding hard carbon supply chain bottlenecks and potential feedstock diversification strategies.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Ed Porter: I'm your host, Ed Porter. Welcome back to Transmission.
- 0:10
- Ed Porter: There's no such thing as a global battery price anymore. A storage cell in China costs around $50 to $60 per kilowatt hour. In Europe, prices are falling. In the US, costs are going up. Same product, different direction. What sets the price now isn't just what a sell. cell costs to make, it's where that cell is allowed to go. Half the world's
- 0:30
- Ed Porter: battery factory capacity is sitting idle, yet China's storage cell lines are running above 90%. Lithium prices doubled, then cooled, tariffs, tax credits, and sourcing rules are redrawing the map. And sodium iron, the chemistry tip to challenge lithium, has seen projects cancelled. Iola Hughes, head of research at Benchmark Mineral Intelligence,
- 0:50
- Ed Porter: tracks the battery supply chain from the mine to the grid. She's back on transmission to explain what's actually moving the market and why new chemistries like sodium ion don't just have to catch up with today's lithium, but where lithium will be in five years. If you want to see what batteries are earning across GB in Europe right now, ask
- 1:09
- Ed Porter: Co.energy.com. Co. Moto Energy's AI Energy Analyst. It's free at Modoenergy.com. Let's jump in.
- 1:16
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hello,
- 1:16
- Ed Porter: Iola. Welcome back to Transmission.
- 1:18
- Iola Hughes: Thanks for having me, Ed.
- 1:19
- Ed Porter: Well, our pleasure. Two-time guest. Uh so as ever, let's get straight into the detail. What is one thing people get wrong about the global battery market?
- 1:27
- Iola Hughes: Um, I think probably one of the big things is is really around there's no such thing as a global battery price anymore, but ultimately it's really a a conversation of where a cell can legally go that's imping impacting that, and then really rather than the actual cost, the amount of cost to to make that cell.
- 1:44
- Ed Porter: Yeah. So instead of having a number in your head of like a cell is going to cost you forty dollars per kilowatt hour, um and that being like a global phenomenon, it's how it actually moves around the globe and uh how it goes to certain tariffs that will set very different prices for different
- 2:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): things. Exactly. exactly.
- 2:03
- Iola Hughes: Yeah. So I think you know, when we see these uh, you know, surveys or charts out there of like the average battery price and where it's gone and where it's declined over the years, it maybe doesn't show the the full picture of where we really are. Um, like if we looked just in the last month, for example, if we looked at a price within the Chinese market, probably around $50 a kilowatt
- 2:23
- Iola Hughes: hour for an LFP cell, sale. compare that to uh the European market and the US market, even the direction of change month on month is different across each market. So in uh China and Europe, we've seen prices falling a bit recently because of some of the softening in lithium price.
- 2:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): When
- 2:40
- Iola Hughes: it comes to uh the North American market, we've actually seen prices tick up a bit. And that comes down to some of the freight costs that we're seeing there at the moment. So you have that at the surface level. and then you start to add in things like tariffs
- 2:53
- Ed Porter: and
- 2:53
- Iola Hughes: eligibility for various regimes, and then you run into all sorts of
- 2:58
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): other
- 2:59
- Iola Hughes: complications in terms of when it comes to actual price.
- 3:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 3:01
- Ed Porter: we get into the niche of how this actually works. But maybe taking a step back first, right? And we're getting get into that sort of um the specifics of the market. But
- 3:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): i
- 3:11
- Ed Porter: the the bigger picture, it feels like every time there's a news story about batteries. it is batteries have come down in price, right? And we've seen that over the last ten, fifteen years. And there are some crazy numbers out there, right? If you take a very, very large number and take it all the way down to today, you can always make a ninety nine percent reduction. Um but have we got to the end of batteries becoming
- 3:31
- Ed Porter: cheaper? Are we at the point now where we really have sort of whittled out all of the sort of excess costs or is that sort of not happening today?
- 3:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 3:39
- Iola Hughes: think there's still definitely room for improvement. Um, but things are things are ultimately like led a lot more by material prices now than I'd say than innovation. So last year we saw prices kind of bottom out at about 45, even kind of 40 in some instances. And
- 3:55
- Ed Porter: you're talking
- 3:56
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): about a
- 3:56
- Ed Porter: sell there.
- 3:57
- Iola Hughes: A A sell, cell, yeah, dollars a kilowatt hour in China. And that sort of price was really below at actual manufacturing costs and and wasn't that sustainable. This year we had essentially a a trifector of things coming through starting to impact battery prices. So you had an anti involution campaign in China, which essentially is a
- 4:16
- Iola Hughes: campaign to stop the aggressive oversupply in a market, similar to what we've seen in solar. Uh we started to see a lot of movement in the lithium market. So lithium prices essentially more than double. doubled over the last year. They've cooled off a bit now, but um it they continue to be at a pretty elevated
- 4:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 4:33
- Iola Hughes: place. And then you also had changes around the export rebates in China. So previously there was a nine percent export rebate that dropped to six percent in April and at the end of the year it's going to zero. So you have all of these different measures kind of going on at the moment. And it we have seen prices now come up They peaked in around May. We saw prices at around $58
- 4:54
- Iola Hughes: kilowatt hour. Come back down a little bit now. But it's yeah, it's it's certainly not the low-cost environment we had last year.
- 5:01
- Ed Porter: And
- 5:01
- Iola Hughes: where we go from here, lithium price is a big factor, of course.
- 5:06
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We
- 5:06
- Iola Hughes: are seeing lithium prices cool off, and
- 5:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
- 5:09
- Iola Hughes: the lithium market is very sentiment-driven, sentiment driven, I would say. Um, you have things such as conversations around uh downstream demand and inventories driving one one side of the story. You'll have stories such as uh you know exports restrictions from Zimbabwe restricting supply. You'll have specific mines in China. The CATL
- 5:29
- Iola Hughes: Zhang Jiwo mine was a big one that was kind of a constant headline like will it start, won't it start? And that all feeds into this narrative of kind of speculation, sentiment around lithium price. prices. But where we are now with the market, it looks like prices are are cooling off somewhat. Um and you
- 5:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know
- 5:46
- Iola Hughes: that ultimately would would feed into a a positive for for sell prices.
- 5:51
- Ed Porter: Yeah.
- 5:51
- Iola Hughes: Um and we could see prices come down further, but
- 5:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 5:54
- Iola Hughes: sort of decline that we've seen over the last few years isn't necessarily uh what we're looking at now, I would say.
- 6:00
- Ed Porter: Okay. And and maybe there's a kind of couple of bits on that. Um, I suppose let's start with the anti involution. Like uh for someone who doesn't look at this space every day, like how would you describe that to them and what sort of impact is it having?
- 6:12
- Iola Hughes: Yeah, so China has, I mean, huge amount of capacity when it comes to cells. If we think about on a global scale, um currently we're tracking like nameplate capacity of six, six and a half terawatt hours of cell production compared to expected output this year of about three and a half.
- 6:29
- Ed Porter: Yeah.
- 6:30
- Iola Hughes: So vast majority of that is in China as well, particularly when it comes to storage cells so already you have a huge amount of capacity in the Chinese market.
- 6:39
- Ed Porter: Crazy amounts.
- 6:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Crazy amounts.
- 6:41
- Iola Hughes: And when you start to look into those numbers as well, it becomes even more shocking because if you think about CATL being
- 6:47
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know
- 6:47
- Iola Hughes: the largest cell manufacturer in the world, CATL is very popular. public about how their utilization rates are very high, you know, 90% in some cases, once facilities are fully ramped. If CATL, the largest player, is running at 90% capacity, but the average market is running at about 50%,
- 7:04
- Ed Porter: there's
- 7:05
- Iola Hughes: a lot of players out there who are running very, very low utilization rates or even not producing from their facilities. And
- 7:11
- Ed Porter: is that they just can't get the orders?
- 7:13
- Iola Hughes: There's an issue of ultimately what they're producing isn't at the the level the market wants anymore. So you have you know tier two producers who or even tier three producers who are producing sales that they just can't compete with what the CATLs, BYDs of the world are are able to produce.
- 7:29
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 7:30
- Iola Hughes: cost will be one part of it. Yeah, there's there's there's a number of reasons it's just
- 7:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
- 7:35
- Iola Hughes: now ultimately the Chinese government is trying to crack down on that. Um and
- 7:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
- 7:40
- Iola Hughes: started off with this kind of trying to get the industry to work together to stop prices continuing to collapse as they had been doing.
- 7:47
- Ed Porter: Yeah.
- 7:48
- Iola Hughes: Just in the last uh month, we've now seen actually a restriction on on new capacity build-out. Initially it was just looking at the the best market, and then now it's actually been extended to EV E V cell capacity as well. So that's basically saying, you know, if you're expecting expanding, doing a second phase of your facility, or if you're building a new factory
- 8:08
- Iola Hughes: altogether, you can't do that right now. We have too much capacity already.
- 8:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 8:13
- Ed Porter: has that got people like C ATL looking at the tier two providers and saying, Well look, we're just gonna buy you. We're just gonna bring you in. We'll
- 8:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): buy your
- 8:19
- Ed Porter: like right to capacity and then we'll dump the C A ATL T L tech on there and just run this up to ninety percent utilisation.
- 8:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 8:25
- Iola Hughes: think it's an interesting one, like ultimately doing that would you know they they can build a new state of the art facility um where they have you know high level of automation
- 8:36
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
- 8:37
- Iola Hughes: the cell production is very high quality versus buying a an old factory maybe isn't necessarily always obvious to
- 8:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): them.
- 8:44
- Iola Hughes: You know, if you're upgrading a facility that can be pretty expensive.
- 8:47
- Ed Porter: Yeah.
- 8:48
- Iola Hughes: Where we've seen that in the US for example, where we've seen uh retooling of lines from EV to energy storage cells, typically we've heard the the cost of that comes in slightly lower than building a new line. Um, but that's typically if you're just changing, say, the the cell chemistry, but if you were to change the cell format as well, then you're looking
- 9:08
- Iola Hughes: at costs kind of on par with building a whole new line. So there's this uncertainty of whether you'd actually uh want to buy an old factory.
- 9:17
- Ed Porter: Yeah.
- 9:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 9:17
- Iola Hughes: th I think the other point on it as well is you know when we look at what's actually going on in terms of the demand side versus the supply and I think we can talk a lot about this is like if you take the nameplate capacity that exists today, that number is higher than we ever get to in our demand forecast. So already there it looks like there would
- 9:37
- Iola Hughes: be ample uh cell supply.
- 9:39
- Ed Porter: Overcommitted, right?
- 9:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So exactly.
- 9:41
- Ed Porter: And is it a case that like something's got to give that at some point one of these factories will just drop off and will close down because I mean like the the economics of it would suggest that has to happen. Yeah. But unless there's sort of um subsidy or intervention in the market that keeps everyone afloat.
- 9:57
- Iola Hughes: Yeah, I mean there's definitely a lot of parallels that can be drawn from solar industry.
- 10:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 10:01
- Iola Hughes: it does feel like it it's going that way and it it's very hard to understand how all of these facilities can exist in the the current ecosystem. You know, when we look at the numbers like specifically for for best, for example, like this year we're talking expectations are like around a terawatt hour of cell production.
- 10:20
- Ed Porter: Yeah.
- 10:21
- Iola Hughes: Demand this year is probably about four fifty gigawatt hours.
- 10:24
- Ed Porter: That's just such a large gap. Yeah.
- 10:26
- Iola Hughes: And I mean that you know we can start to explain it by a number of reasons. We can go, okay, time lags is a big thing. Typically from a cell being produced to a project coming online, talking like fourteen, fifteen months global average. Um so really we need to look at next year's d demand expectations. And for next year, I think we're looking around six hundred 600 gigawatt hours, but it it
- 10:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's still it still doesn't add up.
- 10:49
- Ed Porter: So looking at 400 gigawatt hours of of battery cells that are going somewhere.
- 10:53
- Iola Hughes: Exactly, exactly. And you know, if you look at any of the supply projections, whether it's it's ours or anyone else out there, the the expectation is that, you know, this year's a terawatt hour and next year will be bigger and bigger
- 11:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
- 11:05
- Iola Hughes: bigger. And that you can you can think of a number of different ways to explain the gap now, but as we get later in the decade, it becomes very hard to explain that kind of sustained gap between one and the other.
- 11:18
- Ed Porter: And I suppose one sort of final point to put on this is that um sometimes when we're talking about sell prices, people hear like sort of whatever 45 goes to 65 and then swings back down to 50. And you think, oh my God, how are people building battery projects globally with such wild swings in sell prices? And it's kind of important to say that yes, sell cell prices are important, but they're not they're not everything about building a battery project. So by the time uh
- 11:38
- Ed Porter: a fully fledged battery project comes to market, you've got connection costs, you've got um the work of putting concrete plints in the ground, et cetera. So it's it feels like um yes, sell prices can move, but they're not everything when it comes to sort of finally deployed systems.
- 11:53
- Iola Hughes: Yeah, no, definitely. And I think that's very like market sensitive as well. Um, so for example, in like the European market, you'll have much higher land costs, interconnection costs. than say in China, where in China the the system price might be a larger share of your project.
- 12:10
- Ed Porter: And
- 12:11
- Iola Hughes: it was actually pretty interesting this year when lithium prices got up to about $25,000 a kick kilo. We started to see a lot of conversations from developers in China around
- 12:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 12:21
- Iola Hughes: know, this is actually gonna have a big impact on our project IRRs.
- 12:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Maybe
- 12:25
- Iola Hughes: we should pause develop. development. And
- 12:28
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 12:28
- Iola Hughes: know, China historically has been by far the largest storage market. I think last year we were about 70% of demand was in China. Year to date, we're probably about 40%. So China's having a pretty weak year. Um, for the first seven months, we were down about uh six, seven percent. It's it's now about 10% up
- 12:49
- Iola Hughes: based on the the full first. three quarters data. But there's definitely been a hesitancy in the market because people are
- 12:55
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): kind
- 12:56
- Iola Hughes: of reacting to that that elevated price. And for those projects in China where the margins are a bit tighter
- 13:01
- Ed Porter: and
- 13:01
- Iola Hughes: there is that high level of sensitivity, um, we see more of an impact than in the US or in Europe where you have
- 13:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
- 13:09
- Iola Hughes: a h kind of wider array of costs
- 13:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
- 13:10
- Iola Hughes: you're facing anyway. It's
- 13:12
- Ed Porter: kind of good news, right? High prices are a cure for high prices. Um it's also the classic pitfall of any battery storage conversation anywhere, which is that if you're European focused or you're US focused, whatever, and somebody says, What's the biggest market? And you say something like Texas, you're already wrong because the answer's always China. Yeah. Uh there's like so forever, forever is the correct answer. Okay. Um we recently had Marek on,
- 13:32
- Ed Porter: who you will know because he talks about uh battery storage a fair amount, and he came on with a view that sodium iron on is going to be a much bigger part of all of this energy storage world um compared to sort of the status quo. What what do you see? Do you think sodium iron has earned a place in in grid storage yet? Or do you think that there are still some big questions that need to be answered?
- 13:51
- Iola Hughes: Yeah, it's um it's probably one of the the biggest things we've been thinking about this year, like trying to trying to get angles from every part of benchmark to have a view on it, whether it's kind of on the upstream of the supply um through to what's actually happening in different end use markets. And where we actually kind of settled, we had almost a everyone got involved and threw their opinions in.
- 14:11
- Iola Hughes: Where we actually ended up settling was that our our near-term view was was too bullish. So we actually reduced our forecast in the near term. And in the in the longer term, we did increase our forecast uh a little bit.
- 14:21
- Ed Porter: Mm-hmm. And this is about like volumes delivered.
- 14:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, exactly. Actually,
- 14:24
- Iola Hughes: what's coming through. And it it's pr it's pretty interesting. So on the on the best side now, we're probably tracking about ten gigawatt hours of projects in the pipeline.
- 14:33
- Ed Porter: All
- 14:33
- Iola Hughes: of those are in China essentially. Um if we look at this year specifically, we've seen over a gigawatt hours of of cancelled projects of sodium iron projects. So
- 14:43
- Ed Porter: these
- 14:43
- Iola Hughes: are batteries that they were gonna are install going to sodium iron and instead they decided they were gonna going do to LFP. So there's
- 14:49
- Ed Porter: like ten 10% percent cancellation rates. Yeah.
- 14:51
- Iola Hughes: There's a there's a movement, quite clear movement of people actually kind of moving away from a sodium iron decision. So things are a lot slower than I think what was anticipated a couple of years ago.
- 15:03
- Ed Porter: And it's 10 gigawatt hours versus the 600 gigawatt hours or so depending on which year you take for the LFP,
- 15:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 15:08
- Ed Porter: 450 or the 600 gigawatt. gigawatter.
- 15:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 15:10
- Iola Hughes: mean we we're in our in our pipeline we're tracking
- 15:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): three and
- 15:14
- Iola Hughes: a half terawatt hours of batteries total.
- 15:17
- Ed Porter: Yeah.
- 15:17
- Iola Hughes: Um and yeah, t 10 gigawatt hours of sodium ion.
- 15:20
- Ed Porter: It's relatively small.
- 15:21
- Iola Hughes: Yeah, it's uh it's uh it's a tiny amount really.
- 15:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So what
- 15:24
- Ed Porter: what um maybe just sort of ask the question in a different way? Like what would you have to see to be a believer? I'm not saying you're not a believer, um, uh, but like if you were to be a believer and just see sodium get to that point where it's sort of challenging LFP for like 50% market share. like what are the stats you would need to see out of a sodium iron project that would make you say, hey, look, like wow, those
- 15:44
- Ed Porter: cycles, uh 20,000 cycles, fantastic. Like
- 15:47
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we
- 15:47
- Ed Porter: can get behind it.
- 15:48
- Iola Hughes: So I I think sodium mine definitely has a place. And we are seeing uh increased interest in certain use cases. So extreme temperature environments is a classic one.
- 15:57
- Ed Porter: Yeah.
- 15:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
- 15:58
- Iola Hughes: Chinese government in their 15th five-year plan, they were like Inner Mongolia, Gobi Desert, those are places. for sodium iron and also flow batteries to go. Data center is another one. There's quite a few people who are working on these kind of hybrid solutions where maybe you'd have some sodium iron batteries, LFP batteries, and you'd cycle your sodium iron battery really hard. Some of the
- 16:17
- Iola Hughes: cycle life stats are getting to a really good place. But I think ultimately to see it take takes significant market share, what we need is continued elevated lithium prices.
- 16:28
- Iola Hughes: And you know, we've done lots of cost analysis on this, and we kind of saw that price point where it it made sense for sodium iron to continue to to grow, was above twenty-five thousand dollars
- 16:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
- 16:41
- Iola Hughes: a kilo, is where you really get sustained investment.
- 16:45
- Ed Porter: Lithium carbonate
- 16:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): price.
- 16:47
- Ed Porter: When it got to like twenty-eight-ish, like six months ago, maybe. And there's been some sort of falling, as you said earlier.
- 16:52
- Iola Hughes: Yeah. So
- 16:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): whenever the
- 16:53
- Iola Hughes: lithium price gets high, everyone gets very excited about sodium iron. There's a you know, you could map the Google hits for sodium iron with the lithium price chart and they'd correlate really well. So the the high price is is definitely uh one thing that will enable it. And ultimately if lithium price is high, it means that the investment into the sodium iron supply
- 17:13
- Iola Hughes: chain is is more sustained.
- 17:14
- Ed Porter: Yeah.
- 17:15
- Iola Hughes: And right now that's the thing that's that's holding it back. So on the cost side, we are starting to see sodium iron at the cell level somewhat approach um LFP. If you were to model like a scaled 30 gigawatt hour facility in China, that doesn't exist at the moment, but hypothetically Synthetically it it could be done.
- 17:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
- 17:34
- Ed Porter: could be a similar level, yeah.
- 17:35
- Iola Hughes: Where the barriers come is particularly on the the anode side. of the battery. So
- 17:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): instead
- 17:41
- Iola Hughes: of graphite for the for lithium ion batteries, use hard carbon most typically. Um the feedstock for that is coconut shells from Indonesia.
- 17:49
- Ed Porter: Okay.
- 17:50
- Iola Hughes: Um, and it it doesn't exist in enough ample uh supply to really fuel the market right now. There's a few people looking at alternative feedstocks, synthetic uh feedstocks, um one's based on pet coke, for example. Um but right now it is entirely tied to this Indonesian coconut supply chain.
- 18:10
- Ed Porter: No way. I I
- 18:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): just I
- 18:11
- Ed Porter: can't believe that the the global transition comes down to Indonesian coconuts. Yeah. Uh I would love that uh to continue to be true just because of the story, but uh yeah, it
- 18:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): sounds like people
- 18:20
- Ed Porter: will find alternatives quite quickly.
- 18:21
- Iola Hughes: Exactly. I mean being able to say like, oh my laptop's running on coconut shells would be
- 18:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's a it's a
- 18:26
- Ed Porter: it's a great story. And and I suppose maybe one thing that you kind of mentioned very briefly in there, but perhaps uh is a bit of a change. So if I go back two, three years, people thought about sodium R and they thought, ah, two to four thousand cycles would be the number. But now it seems like that's perhaps not the case. Are
- 18:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are
- 18:40
- Ed Porter: you seeing better information around cycling rates?
- 18:43
- Iola Hughes: Yeah, so I mean on the surface, yes, some of the specs look look great. Oh
- 18:47
- Ed Porter: hold on specs. So is this like is this a brochure that's been received?
- 18:50
- Iola Hughes: Exactly. exactly. That's the issue, is that it's uh real world. We're still probably lacking quite a lot of that that data. Right. Um yeah, I I think Sodiumine is definitely gonna take some market share the next few years. I think by 2030 we probably have at about 10% of of the best market. Um but it it will really
- 19:10
- Iola Hughes: depend on where the lithium price goes. Because you know, if you're a developer literally looking at your procurement strategy right now and you have the option of a tried and trusted tested LFP cell,
- 19:21
- Ed Porter: you've
- 19:21
- Iola Hughes: got your twenty foot container that's offering you six megawatt hours plus energy density versus taking a bit of a gamble on a sodium ion cell which, you know, based on C ATL specs, maybe three megawatt hours for your 20-foot twenty foot container. Even if the cell level costs or even if the system level costs reach
- 19:41
- Iola Hughes: parity, that has huge implications for your land costs, for yeah, foundations, transportation, like logistics. So there's a lot that needs to happen before it becomes like this is my obvious choice to make.
- 19:55
- Ed Porter: Yeah.
- 19:55
- Iola Hughes: Um, I think the one exception maybe would be if peak energy and GM crash. crack sodium iron and are able to offer this like US solution fully domestic supply chain. But that that's still quite some time off, I think. Yeah,
- 20:13
- Ed Porter: yeah. Um and maybe that that's a really like nice lead into the next question. So we've we've talked a little bit about where batteries are from a cost perspective, from a manufacturing perspective. Obviously, we talked about China, which as I've already said is the correct answer. Uh so we've covered that. Um but where are the most exciting places right now to to be putting batteries? So it feels like um
- 20:33
- Ed Porter: we've kind of we saw five years ago we saw a couple of like big countries or big regions that would deploy a number, but now we're getting uh other areas where it's becoming quite exciting.
- 20:42
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes,
- 20:42
- Iola Hughes: I'm I mean there's there's so many you could choose from, I think. Like uh I think Middle East has been spoken about a lot, Australia there's been a lot going on. Um but I think a bit closer to home probably the the big one is for us being Eastern Europe.
- 20:55
- Ed Porter: Okay.
- 20:56
- Iola Hughes: You know, Europe has historically been a very slow market, um, outside of the UK,
- 21:02
- Iola Hughes: the UK. But yeah, mainland Europe has been very slow. All sorts of problems around interconnections and tariff regimes and that's been holding it back. But really this year we've seen just Eastern Europe. become like this hotspot for storage. Um ye I think year to date in Bulgaria we're probably about
- 21:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think
- 21:22
- Iola Hughes: over five gigawatt hours installed. Compare that to Germany for example, which everyone always talks about as the huge amount of potential there is it's so quickly they've leapfrogged and it's it's really interesting to see what's driving it as these much larger projects than we've typically seen. within Europe. And that's that's a
- 21:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 21:42
- Iola Hughes: know a global phenomenon, I'd say. Like if we look at average project sizes the last few years, probably about 100 megawatt hours in 2023. To this year today, we're over 200. And
- 21:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
- 21:54
- Iola Hughes: it's being driven by these very large projects which are starting to come through.
- 21:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
- 21:59
- Iola Hughes: we like to track gigascale projects, like projects over one gigawatt hour.
- 22:04
- Iola Hughes: And this year alone, we've had I think about 50 come online.
- 22:09
- Iola Hughes: And 35 of them or more are
- 22:13
- Iola Hughes: ex-China, which is pretty interesting to see.
- 22:15
- Ed Porter: Yeah, it's like when stuff gets big enough, uh the blueprint exists, the costs are low enough, like it's going to pop up everywhere.
- 22:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
- 22:22
- Ed Porter: Um, There's no kind of stopping it at that point. Yeah. Uh You can have delayed interconnection. processes, you can have regulations that exist in your Western European countries, but it is going to turn up somewhere. Um, and so yeah, it's just a matter of when you get on board to to make it happen. Yeah, fascinating. You you mentioned at the end of the last question a little bit about the US there. So uh
- 22:42
- Ed Porter: notably absent from your where are the most exciting places in the world to put batteries right now. What would what do you think about the US? Is it is it an exciting space?
- 22:49
- Iola Hughes: Uh Definitely exciting. Um but comes with a lot of challenges. Um, you know, when we speak to developers, particularly at the moment, they just feel like they're in this um kind of haze of policy noise where from day to day, week to week, things are constantly changing. Um, you know, if you're a developer right now in the US market looking to procure,
- 23:09
- Iola Hughes: you're thinking about, you know, where what's the tariff rate right now? Yeah. Currently would be at four 40.9%.
- 23:16
- Iola Hughes: There is the upcoming overcapacity 301 tariffs, which could see that increased up towards 50%. You're thinking about FCC inverter bands, you're thinking about the DOE uh bulk, bulk load um situation, you're thinking about 48E eligibility,
- 23:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're thinking
- 23:34
- Iola Hughes: about 45X situation. So there's so many things going on. at the moment which makes progressing deals quite tricky. And
- 23:44
- Ed Porter: for people outside of the space, that those are sort of policy or um additional charges that are big that are coming on to batteries that that sort of move your Capex number.
- 23:54
- Iola Hughes: Yeah, exactly. And some of you know some of them are supporting batteries being built. Um
- 23:58
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 23:59
- Iola Hughes: 48E is a, you know, an amazing, I'd say, incentive. where you can get up to 50% of your project capex as uh as a tax credit. Um but increasingly there's requirements around sourcing when it comes to to getting that tax credit. For 45X, that's one which cell manufacturers who are
- 24:18
- Iola Hughes: producing cells and and even packs in the US can get. And typically that's something which the cell manufacturer may share some of with. the developer as well. So you you may also be negotiating that. But it's yeah constantly changing what what how you deal with a lot of these policy measures. And
- 24:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 24:36
- Ed Porter: suppose on that topic, like how do you see the kind of US as a growing manufacturing hub if the role of a 48e is to encourage people to build within the US? Is that is that starting to happen?
- 24:47
- Iola Hughes: Yeah. Yeah. I mean if we look at just the the kind of pipeline. So go back to January 2025, uh US best capacity pipeline by 2030 we'd be talking about 70 gigawatt hours. Um we're now over 300 gigawatt hours for for twenty thirty. And you know the players that make up
- 25:07
- Iola Hughes: that mix, they they are, you know, large, significant cell manufacturers who have produced sales cells before, whereas previously it would have been you know, your startups like Frere and name names that never really have progressed anywhere to when it comes to cell manufacturing.
- 25:22
- Ed Porter: And is it is it actual cell manufacturing or is it more like an integration so sort of similar to what Tesla did back in the day with your Panasonic before CATL? Is it is it more sort of integration to make a a battery system or is there genuine cell manufacturing happening in China?
- 25:36
- Iola Hughes: Gen gen Genuine cell manufacturing um the Koreans are really the the big biggest part of it. So, you know, they were really attracted to the US market
- 25:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
- 25:45
- Iola Hughes: we go back quite a few years based on potential for EV growth. Um so they all announced a huge amount of investment into the US, uh, building gigafactories, a lot of them partnering with OEMs to
- 25:56
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do
- 25:57
- Iola Hughes: so. We had various changes to EV policy over the the last 18 months, which essentially you know removed subsidies, which also removed some of the sourcing requirements for domestic batteries. At the same time, we had an increased pressure on the sourcing requirements of energy storage batteries, and we saw this huge
- 26:16
- Iola Hughes: pivot from the players. LG is probably leading at the moment. So by the end of this year, they're looking at about 50 gigawatt hours of cell manufacturing. A lot of that is in ramp-up stage. They've done various deals, such as like exiting some of the OEM partnerships they were in and bringing those back into their own full
- 26:36
- Iola Hughes: ownership structure. Outside of the Koreans, you then have uh various other players who are in the mix. Tesla has recently started producing LFP cells sales for storage, quite low volumes at the moment, and they're just ramping up. Um, You have Ford, which is one of the big ones where there's some contention around still. That's uh an agreement where they're
- 26:56
- Iola Hughes: licensing CATL technology, which under current guidelines would make it ineligible for tax credits. But because of the timing of when the deal was signed, there's potentially that you know they will still qualify and um yeah, some pushback on that at the moment, but a
- 27:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): huge
- 27:14
- Iola Hughes: amount of capacity has essentially kind of arrived in the US in the last 18 months. And that's you know, it's an interesting one when we then think about
- 27:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
- 27:23
- Iola Hughes: we go back a few years, for the Chinese cell manufacturers, the US was their second largest market, right? And increasingly they're being closed out of that. So whilst we have all this capacity continuing to grow in the US market,
- 27:37
- Ed Porter: one
- 27:37
- Iola Hughes: of its biggest customers is is
- 27:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not
- 27:39
- Iola Hughes: going to be there anymore.
- 27:41
- Ed Porter: Yeah, it's it's fascinating. Sort of like names that LG Chem that were so early, or LG, sorry, but so early in the the sort of battery manufacturing, and you saw being a significant share of batteries in sort of the late 2010s, now sort of back as a a major name for manufacturing within the US. I suppose the other big story in the US right now is is obviously data
- 28:00
- Ed Porter: centers. That's something uh if somebody says how many batteries does a data center need, I don't think we have a a locked-in answer. Uh it seems very variable. But what how how do you think about that problem?
- 28:10
- Iola Hughes: Yeah, it's the the the the question of the time, I think. Um we hear we're currently tracking over 130 gigawatt hours of announced batteries alongside data centers. Um of that, it's about uh 80 eighty are PPAs, so they're not. actually on site, but rather you've you've signed an agreement to
- 28:30
- Iola Hughes: procure from a di a battery being built elsewhere. Often that will come from a lot of the big hyperscalers, large tech companies. They'll have some you know greener policies, climate policies in place where they'll be looking to secure from renewables and and bring down some of the the emissions. It really comes to a case by case uh
- 28:50
- Iola Hughes: basis.
- 28:51
- Iola Hughes: I think one thing that maybe is uh overlooked is that this is much more a US story than a global story. So of that pipeline, vast majority of it is in the US. That's where we see a lot of the excitement around it.
- 29:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 29:05
- Iola Hughes: think particularly when it comes to you know Korean players, the Teslas, the fluences of the world, that is where their their focus is for for this narrative.
- 29:15
- Iola Hughes: And they're all trying to offer various solutions for for what they can do at data centers. We saw just in the last week NVIDIA approve three new products for uh for data centers. There was a Tesla one, uh an LG one and and quite interestingly a one from Hitachi as well. Um which doesn't necessarily come up w wet much when you
- 29:35
- Iola Hughes: think of system manufacturers. So lots of people are trying to do a lot in the battery space alongside data centers. But what's actually been built so far, I'd say, is is it more on the the lower end. Um but projections are are pretty ambitious. So by 2030 in the US we're expecting it to account for about
- 29:55
- Iola Hughes: thirty percent of of best demand is is somewhat related to data centers, but elsewhere that's gonna be going much, to much lower. So
- 30:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know
- 30:04
- Iola Hughes: I've spoken I've spoken to some data center developers in uh the APAC market and they're still very it's still very unclear to them like where batteries make sense versus in the US it's
- 30:18
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know
- 30:18
- Iola Hughes: it's almost become int intrinsically tied with the policy measures in place and speed to power and yeah getting getting access to the to the grid. grid.
- 30:27
- Ed Porter: I think that's the fascinating part. Like we we have um been working with a few data centers and large power consumers. And I think it's a really fascinating question around what's the combination of solar, gas, battery, plus whatever grid connection you can get your hands on that gives you the right mix of cost to power your data center with,
- 30:47
- Ed Porter: as you say, time to power. Um if we weren't trying to do this all in such a hurry, uh there would be other options uh for these things, but it but it is it's a fascinating space and it's something that uh we're going to be talking much more about over the next 12 months. Uh so that's exciting. I suppose we've we've kind of gone into the demand side. So let's let's stay there. When you last came on you described
- 31:07
- Ed Porter: the stationary storage world as the little sibling of the EV world. uh, Is this still true? I'm sure I took great personal offense offence to that being uh being more of a battery person than an
- 31:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): EV person.
- 31:16
- Iola Hughes: I think it's now
- 31:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 31:18
- Iola Hughes: in terms of attention, it's maybe the big sibling at the moment.
- 31:21
- Ed Porter: Okay.
- 31:21
- Iola Hughes: Uh in terms of market share, it's it is still still the little sibling somewhat. But um
- 31:26
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
- 31:26
- Ed Porter: does the what does the split look like between the uh number of sales going to EVs versus sales going to stationary storage?
- 31:32
- Iola Hughes: So from On the production side, um, it's about two to one. Um so we're looking at this. year, yeah, over two terawatt hours of EV sales being produced versus one terawatt hours of best sales being produced. Um we have that split staying roughly around around that place. Ultimately the
- 31:52
- Iola Hughes: EV market we we do see being continuing to be the the real driving force there.
- 31:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 31:57
- Ed Porter: is there a direction to it? Does it just sort of is is that two to one, is it moving or is it stationary? Like if if we have the same conversation in 2030, is it the same split then or or not?
- 32:08
- Iola Hughes: We I think by 2030 we're look talking more like 25% best versus the EV side. There's challenges, I think, when it comes to demand on in terms of how fast things can actually be be built out.
- 32:19
- Ed Porter: Yeah.
- 32:19
- Iola Hughes: Um and I think always the best market is just gonna be more constrained by the demand side than
- 32:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on
- 32:25
- Iola Hughes: the EV side. Whereas an
- 32:26
- Ed Porter: EV. provider you can get a charge, like it can go anywhere.
- 32:29
- Iola Hughes: Yeah, yeah, yeah. And you know, we've seen we've seen that really well this year where in China the domestic EV market has been has been pretty weak.
- 32:37
- Ed Porter: Um
- 32:37
- Iola Hughes: sales are are down about five percent year to date. But if we look at Chinese EV production, it's you know continued continue to grow month on month, year year on year, and that ultimately comes down to China exporting those vehicles. So we're
- 32:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): seeing
- 32:51
- Iola Hughes: a a huge amount of growth in the European market, in rest of world markets as well. And Chinese exports is is primarily driving that.
- 33:00
- Ed Porter: Yeah.
- 33:00
- Iola Hughes: Um so that's you know they can offer these cheap vehicles across the world
- 33:06
- Ed Porter: at
- 33:06
- Iola Hughes: a time when there's increased interest 'cause of high oil prices.
- 33:09
- Ed Porter: Yeah.
- 33:10
- Iola Hughes: For the best side, you know, maybe they can push out batteries to rese resear applications. CNI applications, but for large-scale storage, which is ultimately going to be the driver of demand, you do always run into these issues of like, can the grid keep up with
- 33:25
- Ed Porter: what
- 33:26
- Iola Hughes: the cell manufacturers would like
- 33:27
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to sell
- 33:27
- Iola Hughes: to the market? Yeah.
- 33:29
- Ed Porter: And and maybe just to add sort of one more, um, one more name into the mix, right? So um consumers will hold phones, they'll ride a bike, maybe they'll own a three-wheeler. Uh is there another sort of part of that mix outside of uh grid scale batteries and EVs that's like a growing segment you think is interesting and worth worth talking about?
- 33:47
- Iola Hughes: Yeah, I th I think one the one that has been getting more attention um is the the drone space recently. You know, it's it's a tiny share of of demand. So I think in 2025 we tracked defense demand total at as about four gigawatt hours.
- 34:03
- Ed Porter: Um,
- 34:03
- Iola Hughes: and of that, drones make up about uh 40% of defense demand. So it's it's a tiny slither when it comes to the entire pie of
- 34:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): lithium iron
- 34:12
- Iola Hughes: demand, but it's a really interesting one because we're seeing increasingly a lot of like new tech innovations being pointed towards drones applications. You know, getting qualification for some of these can be a lot faster. Um,
- 34:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
- 34:26
- Iola Hughes: maybe you don't care about cycle life if your drone is not gonna last for very long.
- 34:31
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 34:31
- Ed Porter: it's a one flight drone.
- 34:32
- Iola Hughes: Exactly. Um high energy density, so we're seeing some of really like innovative silicon anodes and uh yeah, novel tech being lithium sulfur being used in in these batteries. And then at the same time you also have this supply chain security element of it as well. So in the US they are you know, increasingly putting
- 34:52
- Iola Hughes: pressure around not relying on Chinese batteries. They have certain kind of timelines they want to meet where they stop sourcing any from China. That links in with like the rare earth story as well. So a lot of attention is being paid to them at the moment, both from suppliers who are like, oh this is a great opportunity to get in. I don't need to go through
- 35:12
- Iola Hughes: OEM qualification and compete with CATL. Yeah. Um, and then also governments and and various bodies are also trying to work out how they can secure their supply in a in
- 35:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
- 35:23
- Iola Hughes: non uh yeah exposure
- 35:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): way. Do
- 35:26
- Ed Porter: people want their own supply within their own nation effectively? And so that's kind of uh uh in as much as you have sort of the big suppliers, you almost when every nation wants their own, you have to have then 200 individual. sort of supply chains start popping up for this.
- 35:40
- Iola Hughes: Yeah, exactly.
- 35:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Exactly.
- 35:42
- Ed Porter: Uh fascinating. That's a real mother of mother of invention uh story there going on. Um okay, so maybe uh one final question for me then. So we've talked a little bit about how many cells are being uh produced. In fact, let's make this two questions. And We have um have uh lots more batteries, lots more cells being produced um
- 36:02
- Ed Porter: than are finding their way into markets. Why do we see so many sort of additional factories still coming to market? It feels odd to sort of run headlong into a market that's already oversupplied.
- 36:13
- Iola Hughes: Yeah, I mean, I think two two elements of it. So localization is the big one. Um so you know, people are building in the US, in the European market. A lot of that is being led by by policy. Um, you
- 36:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
- 36:25
- Iola Hughes: starting to see requests. requirements in in the US it's been a for some time now there's been those restrictions on sales, tariffs on sales from elsewhere, and also incentives to to build locally. In Europe, we've seen a few kind of hotspots emerge, places like Hungary, where we've got a lot of cell manufacturing coming through or
- 36:45
- Iola Hughes: in the pipeline there. Um and even in Europe, starting to see increasing rural. rules on sourcing. We've
- 36:52
- Ed Porter: got
- 36:53
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 36:53
- Iola Hughes: Industrial Accelerator Act coming through, which would start to put some pressure on where you're sourcing your system from or your cell from. So we have this ex-China emergence of supply. Southeast Asia is another big one that's that's starting to come through.
- 37:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
- 37:08
- Iola Hughes: lot of those looking to supply into the US market.
- 37:11
- Ed Porter: Is it actually going to be able to compete though? Like we've we've seen the stories of things like North Vault. where the the success rates or the efficiency of each of the lines just wasn't good enough. Are we
- 37:22
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do do
- 37:23
- Ed Porter: we think they can actually get there?
- 37:25
- Iola Hughes: I would I would say when it's you know an established player who's coming into those markets, there's definitely you know they can kind of pick up and take what their expertise Expertises is elsewhere and and do that in a different country. You know, we do
- 37:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'd
- 37:38
- Iola Hughes: say m may mainly really just in the European market now, we do still have a couple of Western cell manufacturers who are slowly ramping up players like ACC and Vercore and Powerco. I think you know they all have very strong relationships with European OEMs, which
- 37:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): can
- 37:54
- Iola Hughes: obviously work in in their favour. Um, but for those players, it it is hard to compete and to
- 38:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know
- 38:02
- Iola Hughes: compete. with both the overseas supply of cells, um, but then e you know, a domestic supply from these established players also grows, it is gonna be a a challenge for them as well.
- 38:13
- Ed Porter: Maybe maybe one sort of final question on the on the the sort of battery and cell side. I think one thing that's kind of often misunderstood is the sort of difference to in the the cells and and the systems. Well people do understand the difference, but they don't understand like why a the the top manufacturer of cells in the world, which would be CATL, isn't necessarily the top manufacturer of
- 38:33
- Ed Porter: systems in the world. So what wh why do we see that sort of split breaking down? Like why why isn't it sort of a one-to-one relationship?
- 38:40
- Iola Hughes: Yeah, I mean I ultimately it comes down that it's to it's easier to build a system than to build a cell. I think that's probably the the best way to think about it. Um And then really the components that you're layering on top of the cell, people start to have preferences for certain name brands, certain relationships, certain non-Chinese relationships, for
- 38:59
- Iola Hughes: example. In the first half of the year, you know, we had CATL as number one for cell shipments and BYD for number one for uh system shipments. So we've got Chinese players at the top. I think for the first time actually Tesla fell out of the top three. for system manufacturing. I think it's another thing where it comes
- 39:19
- Iola Hughes: down really just to like localization and what regions you're looking
- 39:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at. In
- 39:24
- Iola Hughes: the US market, for example, we've you know we've had quite a big presence of players like Sungro and CATL. Increasingly, it's going to be challenging for them to be a part of the US market, which works in the favor of players like Tesla Influence and and LG and Samsung.
- 39:39
- Iola Hughes: versus if we look at like the Australian market, which historically Tesla was was a really, you
- 39:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
- 39:45
- Iola Hughes: it was one of their key markets, they're increasingly being challenged by the Chinese players who are vertically integrating. So be that CATL or the Hythiums or Cornexes of the world, so each market is acting in a slightly different way, dependent again on policy, which is is kind of driving it.
- 40:03
- Ed Porter: I think we started there, didn't we?
- 40:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 40:05
- Ed Porter: think the conversation started there and it's finished there, which
- 40:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
- 40:07
- Ed Porter: which is a lovely sort of circular unintended, but uh let's say we intended it.
- 40:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
- 40:11
- Ed Porter: And it's just that's we'll start through that circular reference. Um okay let's let's end up with a final question then. So what is uh a contrarian view that you hold about energy markets?
- 40:21
- Iola Hughes: So I I think ultimately
- 40:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 40:24
- Iola Hughes: way I see the market evolving in terms of chemistry chemistries is just LFP and NCM
- 40:30
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
- 40:31
- Iola Hughes: everything else is a lot of noise.
- 40:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
- 40:33
- Iola Hughes: So you know, I've been i working in the battery markets for about seven years now, and that entire time there's been,
- 40:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 40:41
- Iola Hughes: know, one moment it's about high manganese cells, next moment it's about sodium iron, next moment it's about yeah, LM LMF M LMFE LMFP and NMX and all of these. chemistries which have made a lot of noise and then not much has actually happened when it comes to either rollout in vehicles or rollout in in storage or other markets.
- 41:01
- Iola Hughes: And I think it's increasingly challenging for new technologies to actually compete in this this world where we continue to see advancements in existing tech. And that's the challenge of like any new tech, is like if we talked about solid state five years ago,
- 41:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we would have
- 41:17
- Iola Hughes: been comparing it to an NCM cell of five years ago. But the reality is you need to compare it to a tech which is five years down the road to get a realistic view of it. So
- 41:29
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not a very
- 41:29
- Iola Hughes: exciting one, but I think the status quo is is
- 41:32
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): winning
- 41:33
- Iola Hughes: out.
- 41:33
- Ed Porter: I think it's underrated, right? People have this perception that they are trying to compete with a static lithium market and that that's the target. And if I can get to that point, then I'm going to be in the door. Um, you mentioned it both here, but also you mentioned it earlier, which is like, okay, you're at cost parity,
- 41:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
- 41:48
- Ed Porter: are the insurers as happy dealing with your tech as as they are with the with the thing you're trying to beat? Uh are the people who are installing it as happy with it? Do they have they got the same experience? Are the owners have they got enough to track record to be able to bring it in as well? So there is a lot of weight that should be given to the sort of incumbent uh
- 42:09
- Ed Porter: nature. Uh and so you really do have to be not only better than it today, but you have to be better than it in five years' time, and significantly better such that someone wants to take a risk to do it. So yeah, it's um I think that's I think it's time and time again, people miss this. So yeah, it's a really good one. Um, Ola, thank you very much for coming on. You've been a wonderful guest, as per usual. and uh hopefully we can get you back on
- 42:29
- Ed Porter: for a third time uh in the next couple of years.
- 42:32
- Iola Hughes: Yeah, thanks for having
- 42:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): me.
More from Transmission
Where The Value Is In European Renewables Today - OX2
Episode discussion: OX2's Ed Porter and Mehmet Energin discuss shifting value in European renewables from generation to financing and operations.
Speakers’ claims: Ed Porter and Mehmet Energin of OX2 argue that Europe's renewable capacity has grown significantly, but grid and storage infrastructure lag, shifting investment value from simple generation to complex financing and active operations. They emphasize that OX2 treats each project as a distinct company, managing 20-30 levers to optimize returns through offtake agreements and financial structuring rather than relying solely on Levelized Cost of Energy (LCOE). The speakers highlight a strategic preference for acquiring stalled projects to bypass lengthy permitting timelines, particularly in Sweden, where greenfield development can take up to a decade. They advocate for a humble approach to market forecasting, using the metaphor of Ayrton Senna to illustrate the risks of being ahead of one's time, and view falling energy prices as a sign of industry success in delivering affordable power.
Germany’s Battery Deadline Comes Before the Grid Rules Do - Kyon Energy
Episode discussion: German battery developers face Dec 31 deadline for FID to avoid grid fees, with realistic deployment forecasts far below queue sizes.
Speakers’ claims: Speakers discuss the urgency of Germany’s December 31st deadline for battery developers to make a Final Investment Decision (FID) to secure a 20-year exemption from capacity-based grid fees under the 'Agnes' reform. Marie Sophie Braun argues that the reported 300 GW of grid connection requests is an unrealistic 'battery tsunami,' forecasting actual deployment at only 50–70 GW by 2040–2060 due to merchant market dynamics that punish overbuild. Keon Energy’s transition from developer to operator is highlighted as a strategy to shape regulatory frameworks and prove storage affordability without state financing. The episode details the critical need for clear Flexible Connection Agreements (FCAs) to ensure debt financeability, contrasting this with the risks of unlimited curtailment. Finally, speakers note regulatory misalignments between Transmission and Distribution System Operators regarding ancillary services and voltage stress.