The Jay Martin Show

Jay Martin explains US debt mechanics, Treasury auction metrics, and market vulnerabilities

25 min Listen to the original
US DebtTreasury AuctionsFederal ReserveInterest RatesPrimary DealersForeign DemandMarket RiskMacroeconomics

Summary

Jay Martin discusses the structure of the US debt market, noting that annual interest payments exceed military spending. He details the Treasury auction process, including the role of primary dealers and the distinction between direct and indirect bidders. The speaker outlines four key metrics for assessing auction health: bid-to-cover ratio, tail, indirect share, and dealer share. He highlights vulnerabilities such as rising borrowing costs and shifting buyer demographics from foreign central banks to domestic hedge funds. Warning signs for potential market stress include rising tails, increased dealer participation, and falling foreign demand.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    The interest it paid its lenders last year was $1.1 trillion more than it it's spent on the entire military.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 0:59

  2. 2
    So when a buyer pays a lower price for the same payment, they earn a higher effective return. That return is called the yield. And this is why when countries sell treasuries, prices fall and yields rise.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 2:58

  3. 3
    bids or offers, the ratio is 2.5. It had 2.5 more bids than it needed. Higher means more buyers competed. That's good.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 13:53

  4. 4
    tail is how far the actual auction rate missed the expected rate from the when issued trading. So say the market expected 4% when the auction was announced in and that pre-auction. trading began. And that trading flushed out a 4% rate. But the auction rate came in significantly higher than that. Say three basis points higher, 4.03%. The government therefore had to pay an extra 0.03% more than expected to find enough buyers. And each point zero 01% one percent is called a basis point. So this is a three three-basis basis point tail. A tail means there were fewer buyers than the pre-market trading expected.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 14:13

  5. 5
    The 'Indirect Share' (foreign demand) rose from 51% in 2020 to 68% in 2024 but fell to approximately 58% by 2026, signaling a potential retreat in foreign central bank and fund participation.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 15:33

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 1:39

    Introduction to US Debt and Treasury Auctions

    The speaker introduces the US debt market, noting the national debt exceeds $40 trillion and interest payments ($1.1 trillion) surpass military spending. The focus shifts to understanding Treasury auctions as the mechanism revealing lender behavior, rather than political opinions.

  2. 1:39 – 4:18

    Treasury Mechanics and Yield Dynamics

    Treasuries are explained as loans with fixed interest payments; their market price fluctuates inversely with yield. The speaker clarifies that while the Fed sets the overnight rate, Treasury auction rates are determined by market bidding and influence broader loan costs like mortgages.

  3. 4:18 – 11:35

    The Auction Process and Primary Dealers

    The auction process involves when-issued trading, followed by a bidding period where the Treasury accepts bids from lowest to highest rate, setting a single 'stopout rate' for all winners. Primary dealers, a group of 25 banks, are legally required to bid at every auction to ensure it does not fail.

  4. 11:35 – 13:33

    Bidder Categories and Foreign Demand

    Bidders are categorized into primary dealers (mandatory), direct bidders (voluntary domestic institutions), and indirect bidders (foreign entities like central banks). The speaker highlights that foreign central banks hold treasuries as a liquid, safe store of wealth for dollar reserves.

  5. 13:33 – 16:58

    Four Key Auction Metrics

    The speaker details four metrics to assess auction health: Bid-to-Cover Ratio (demand volume), Tail (difference between auction rate and expected rate), Indirect Share (foreign demand), and Dealer Share (mandatory buying by primary dealers).

  6. 16:58 – 24:42

    Market Vulnerabilities and Warning Signs

    Current vulnerabilities include rising borrowing costs (10-year rate at 5.3% in Oct 2026), shifting buyer demographics from foreign central banks to price-sensitive domestic hedge funds, and untested stress on primary dealers given doubled debt levels. Warning signs for a crisis include rising tails, rising dealer share, falling indirect share, rising long-term rates despite Fed cuts, and Fed direct intervention.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
GoldcommodityneutralFrom 2010 to 2001. 2021, central banks around the world bought an average of about 470 tons of gold each year.
Silvercommodityneutralthe likely winners are the assets that the government cannot print or create more of: things like gold, silver, other hard commodities, and the companies that produce them.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

The US national debt has doubled to more than $40 trillion in about a decade.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:40

How to verify: US Department of the Treasury, 'Debt to the Penny' public data; compare total public debt outstanding in 2026 vs 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the current US national debt total and annual interest payment figures against the US Treasury Department's daily debt estimates (treasury.gov).
  • Check the current list of primary dealers and recent exits (e.g., Citadel, NatWest) via Federal Reserve Bank of New York reports or SEC filings.
  • Review recent Treasury auction results for bid-to-cover ratios, tails, and indirect/direct bidder shares using the US Treasury's auction calendar and results pages.
  • Monitor the 10-year Treasury yield and compare it to Federal Reserve policy rates to assess the shape of the yield curve.
  • Analyze foreign official holdings of US Treasuries using the Treasury International Capital (TIC) data released monthly by the US Treasury.
  • Assess the balance sheets of primary dealers for liquidity stress indicators, particularly during periods of high issuance.
  • Look for counter-arguments regarding the sustainability of US debt from economists like Nouriel Roubini or official Treasury statements on debt management.
  • Check historical data on Treasury auction failures or significant tail spikes to contextualize current market conditions.
Full transcriptexpand

0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Everybody is seemingly an expert on US debt. People will tell you that the US is about to collapse under the weight of its debt, or that it doesn't matter at all because they will grow their way out, or they can just print more currency and it's a non-issue. But most people who have a strong opinion on this can't actually tell you how the United States borrows. So by the end of this video, you're gonna know more than they do. You will know exactly where the debt comes from. and most importantly, you will know how a treasury auction works. Because without understanding that, you can't offer any kind of an intelligent assessment about the health of the US debt markets. So that is what we are going to cover today. As with all things, I like to watch what people do as opposed to what they say. So despite what lenders say, let's watch what lenders do when it comes. to the US debt market. Everybody has an opinion on US debt. The government owes more than $40 trillion and last year spent $2 trillion more than it collected in taxes. And that gap is called the deficit. And the government borrows money to cover it. The interest it paid its lenders last year was $1.1 trillion more than it it's spent on the entire military. But debt is only a problem when lenders decide it's a problem. As long as people keep

1:19lending, the government can keep borrowing. So what matters is not what anybody tells you on TV. What matters is what lenders do with their money and are they still sending it to the United States? Now, there is one place where you can see exactly what they do: the US Treasury auction. This is where the government borrows. It actually happens several times every week, all year long. And every result shows who lent money, how much they lent, and at what interest rate. Now the government borrows by selling IOUs called treasuries. A treasury is a loan to the government. You hand over money today, the government pays you interest every six months, then gives your money back on a set date in the future, whatever the term of that treasury is. Typically, loans of less than a year are called bills, loans of two to 10 years are called notes, and loans of 20 to 30 years are called bonds. But for simplicity, we're gonna call them all bonds because most people do. The interest rate set at these auctions is the starting point for almost every other loan in the economy. For example, banks set 30-year mortgages by taking into account the 10-year treasury rate and then adding a little bit extra to cover their risk. When treasury rates rise, almost every other loan in the economy costs more. Now, one more very important thing you need to know before we dive into

2:39the details of the auction. Once a bond is sold at the auction, its owner can resell it to somebody else at any time. And like anything for sale, its price depends on supply and demand. When lots of owners want to sell, the price falls. When lots of buyers want in, the price rises. But the bond's interest payment never changes. So when a buyer pays a lower price for the same payment, they earn a higher effective return. That return is called the yield. And this is why when countries sell treasuries, prices fall and yields rise. The effective yield. rises. And when the Fed or anybody else buys heavily, prices rise and yields fall. Okay, now let's get into exactly how a treasury auction works. So simply that you would be able to explain this to a five-year-old. That's what we're gonna do here. But before we do, I'm speaking at the Above and Beyond Summit in Scottsdale, Arizona on November 23rd. And I'd love to have you join me. Check out abovebeyondsummit.com. We'll put the link beneath this video, but enter the promo code VR500 to get 500 bucks off your ticket. November 23rd, Scottsdale, Arizona. If you can't make it to Scottsdale, come to my conference, Vancouver Resource Investment Conference, January 24th and 25th. With 11,000 investors,

3:5880 keynote speakers, 350 mining companies, all in Vancouver. BC. And if you can't make Vancouver, we're in Dallas, May 4th and 5th for VRIC Dallas. Just as big, just as awesome, different city. It's gonna be rad. For my events, check out vricmedia.com. You'll find everything there. But if you can join me in Scottsdale next week, I'd love to see you there. AbovebeyondSummit.com, promo code VR500 VR 500 for 500 bucks off of your ticket. Okay. how does a Treasury auction work? Let's get into it. About a week before each sale, the Treasury announces how much money it will need to borrow, for how long, and on what day. So for example, we need to borrow $44 billion next Thursday. Now it mixes short bonds with long bonds. Now, short bonds usually cost less, but they have to be rolled over on a short time frame at whatever the new rate is. Long bonds are the longer-term, safer bet if the interest rate is favorable. But trading begins before the auction actually opens up. As soon as the sale is announced, investors start buying and selling the bonds before they even exist. They agree on a price now, and the money and the bonds change hands once the bonds are actually created. This is called when issues. issued trading. And it's important to remember the price they

5:18agree on tells everybody what interest rate the market expects the auction to produce, right? This is the expected interest rate. That's what you see in the when issued trading. Now keep that rate in mind because it comes back in a minute here. Then the bidding process begins. Bidding opens when the sale is announced and it closes at exactly 1 p.m. New York time on auction day. Now each bid says two things: how many bonds you want to buy and the lowest rate that you'll accept. All right, what's the lowest interest rate you would accept to buy this debt? And how much of the debt do you want to buy? Once all the bids are in, the treasury lines up the bids from the lowest interest rate to the highest. Now, the lowest rates they cost the government the least. So it fills those orders first and it keeps going up the line until it has sold the full amount, whatever it needed to borrow on that day. Now, this is when the rate gets set. The rate on the very last bid needed to finish the sale is called the stopout rate. Once the stopout rate is determined, every winning buyer gets moved up to that same rate. even buyers who asked for less. So for example, let's imagine the Treasury wanted to sell $40 billion and it gets $15 billion in bids

6:37at 4%. It gets $15 billion in bids at 4.05% and 15 billion of bids at 4.1%. So the first two groups they add up to 30 billion, but the Treasury needs another. 10 billion more. So it takes part of that last 4.1 group. That makes 4.1 the stop-out rate. Even the buyers that asked for four, they said we'll take the debt and we only want 4% or 4.05%. They get rewarded with 4.1% because that's the stop-out rate. That's the highest rate that was needed to complete the sale. So you might ask, why would the government pay people more than they asked for? And this is just a way of keeping the auctions orderly. It makes everyone bid honestly, and that actually saves the government money. If buyers only got the exact rate that they bid, then each would ask for a little bit extra. They'd all bid high just to be safe, and the government would end up paying more en masse. With one rate for everybody, each buyer simply bids the lowest rate that they would truly accept. The results from these auctions

7:37are made public with within minutes. And one rule matters more than any other. The Treasury always sells the full amount. It never cancels a sale. If buyers are scarce, the rate just goes up until enough of them show up. So the question is never: will the government find lenders? The question is, how much will it have to pay them? So who's involved? Who's buying? Who are the key bidders? in this process? Now, first of all, the seller is the U.S. Treasury. That's the one that issues the bonds for sale. The Treasury, that's the one that collects taxes and pays the government bills. So when the bills are bigger than the taxes, it borrows the difference by selling bonds, and that's why auctions happen. The Federal Reserve is the one who runs the auction. They're the auctioneer, like the referee. The Fed is America's central bank. It is the only body that can create new dollars. Its New York branch runs the auctions computer system on the Treasury's behalf. Now, by law, the Fed cannot buy bonds directly from the Treasury at an auction. Now, here's a very common point of confusion. The Fed also sets one interest rate, the overnight rate. And this is what makes headlines whenever rates go up or rates go down. This is what banks can charge each other. other for one day loans. They do not set the rate on the treasuries. The auction does that. But the

8:56Fed's rate does have a big influence. That rate sets what investors can earn on safe cash that they could take back tomorrow, take out of the bank tomorrow. So if buyers could earn 4% overnight in a savings account, they're not going to lend to the government for years for less than that. Does that make sense? Okay. That's the seller and the reference. referee. But then the most important pool are the buyers. And there's three groups that bid on treasuries, typically speaking. The most important are called the primary dealers. Think of them as government-appointed buyers. Now, primary appointed buyers have one very important job. They must bid at every treasury auction. Now there's 25 of them today, 16 Sixteen or more. are major foreign banks from Britain, Europe, Japan, and Canada. And nine are American banks like JP Morgan, Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, and the Bank of America. Now, to join, a bank must apply to the Fed and prove it is large and stable enough to trade huge amounts of government bonds every single day. Each dealer must bid for its share at every auction. The auction size divides divided by the number of dealers. At a $44 billion auction, that's about $1.76 billion each. Now these bids must be reasonably competitive, meaning close to the expected rate that was discovered during the when issued

10:16trading section. A dealer that keeps bidding far from that can be suspended or removed from the list. So in practice, dealers bid close to the market, but they end up with what nobody else wants. And that's why a treasury auction can, in theory, never fail, because these 25 primary dealers are accountable for whatever wasn't purchased by anybody else. It's important to note because the number of primary dealers has stayed at about 25 for a decade, but the national debt has doubled from 20 trillion to more than 40. So the amount each dealer must stand ready to buy keeps on growing, but the number of dealers does not. And some firms have decided that it's not worth it. See, there is an advantage to being a primary dealer because you get full visibility on everything that happens in the treasury auction. So you know who is buying, how much they're buying, and how much they're willing to pay. For a big bank that's valuable information that they can trade on. But in 2024, trading giant Citadel. chose not to apply, saying the benefits no longer outweighed the risks and the obligations of buying so much government debt. And then October 2026, the British bank Nat West left the list. They stepped back. Okay, now if the primary dealers are the ones responsible to buy the bonds that nobody else bought, well, who are those other people? Who is everybody

11:35else? The first group are called the direct bidders, and think of them as voluntary American bidders. These are mostly American pension funds, insurance companies, investment funds, and hedge funds that can bid directly in the auction alongside those primary dealers. But unlike primary dealers who must buy any unsold bonds at any price, direct bidders are driven by price. They buy when price suits them. So when rates are high, they'll buy more. And when rates are low, they won't buy much at all. So direct bidders are incentivized by price, and all the buying they do is voluntary. They do not have to take part. The third group are indirect bidders, and these are organizations like foreign central banks, like those of Japan, Saudi Arabia, and many large foreign funds. Now they have to bid through a middleman, which is a primary deal. dealer in this case. That's one of the advantages that primary dealers get because foreign orders have to be put through their system. They get full visibility on who's buying what. Now, this foreign group is important to watch because foreign central banks and funds buy treasuries for a specific reason. When their countries sell goods like oil to the world, they collect US dollars and their central bank. banks need a safe place to keep those dollars, a place that pays

12:54interest, and a place that the asset can be sold quickly. Like it's liquid, and the treasury is very liquid. For decades, that place has been U.S. treasuries. They hold them for years and they don't worry too much about the interest rate because it's a safe haven store of wealth that can be accessed Access fast. That's the reason they hold treasuries. Now, because foreign governments almost always bid as indirect bidders, that third category, the share of bonds that goes to this group is used as a rough measure of how much the rest of the world wants US debt. So how can we tell if the auction is strong or weak and therefore the US debt market is healthy or sick? Minutes after 1 p.m. on auction day, investors can look at four numbers. And we're gonna go through each one right now. The first is called the bid to cover ratio. This is how many dollars were bid for every dollar sold. If the treasury sells 40 billion and gets a hundred billion in bids or offers, the ratio is 2.5. It had 2.5 more bids than it needed. Higher means more buyers competed. That's good. Lower means fewer. That's bad. That means less demand. Number two is the tail. And this is the one that most investors watch most closely. The

14:13tail is how far the actual auction rate missed the expected rate from the when issued trading. So say the market expected 4% when the auction was announced in and that pre-auction. trading began. And that trading flushed out a 4% rate. But the auction rate came in significantly higher than that. Say three basis points higher, 4.03%. The government therefore had to pay an extra 0.03% more than expected to find enough buyers. And each point zero 01% one percent is called a basis point. So this is a three three-basis basis point tail. A tail means there were fewer buyers than the pre-market trading expected. Since tails are so important, let's have a quick look at the 10-year trend. Before 2022, tails were usually small and rare. The pre-market trading usually got it right. In March of 2022, the Fed began raising its rate quickly to fight rising prices. And since then, tails have become larger and far more frequent. The five-year note tailed at the last 15 auctions in a row through August 2026. Okay, the third number you want to watch is the indirect share. We talked about this a little bit already, but we're going to cover it again. This is the percentage of the auction won or bought by indirect

15:33bidders, usually foreign demand. The indirect share of purchases rose from about 51%. in 2020 to 68% in 2024. And since then it's fallen back down to about 58% in 2026. The fourth number is the dealer share. Remember those primary dealers. This is the percentage that the primary dealers had to take. A low dealer share means investors, other investors, direct and indirect bidders, bought almost everything voluntarily. A high dealer share means nobody did, or less people did. And the primary dealers were forced to step in and take a bigger piece of the pie that nobody else wanted. Now the dealer share has actually fallen sharply. In 2014, dealers took about 54% of note auctions. Remember, that's the two to the 10-year 10 year ban. band. By 2025, they were taking just 14%. Investors are now buying almost everything themselves, mostly as direct bidders. So you put all these numbers together and what do you get? A strong auction has a high bid to cover ratio, meaning more

16:38bids than needed, no-tail, meaning that pre-market trading was accurate, predicting what the rate might be, a big indirect share, and a small dealer share. That means strong voluntary demand. and the involuntary buyers, the dealers didn't have to buy too much. And a weak auction is exactly the opposite. So what's my honest take right now? Strong demand, rising price, changing buyers? What's happening in the market today? Is demand for US debt strong or is it cracking? And the honest answer is it's kind of doing both right now. So what would validate demand being strong? Bids still cover each sale. about two and a half times. Dealers are taking less than ever, which means voluntary investors are choosing to buy almost everything themselves. And part of that strength is the price itself. Remember, the voluntary buyers are price driven. They're attracted to higher rates. At 5%, price sensitive Price-sensitive buyers are happy to step in, but they're buying because the rate is high, not because they trust. the debt. So, what are some vulnerabilities? What might say the debt picture is cracking? And I'll point you to three things. Now, first, the price of borrowing is rising. In 2020, the government could borrow it for 10 years at under 1%. In October 2026, its 10-year auction rate hit 5.3%, the

17:57highest since 2000. If you have to pay more to convince people to lend to you, people are getting more concerned. about your ability to pay them back. In addition to bigger and more frequent tales show the government more often has to pay more than the market expected. Now, second, the buyers are changing. Foreign central banks, the steadiest lenders, are taking a smaller share. And in their place are direct bidders, including domestic hedge funds. Now they care mostly about price. They'll buy what when the rate is high enough and they can sell just as fast. But they've stepped in in a major way over the last couple of years in response to higher rates. Now, third, and most importantly, the primary dealers who promise to buy everything, that hasn't been tested at this size, meaning this much debt and this much demand for more lending. If investors were to pull back today, the same 25 or so dealers would have to absorb auctions twice as big as a decade ago. So the weight falling on their shoulders would stress that group out in a way that has not been tested yet. So who's already decided that the risk of US debt is no longer worth it? Most investors keep buying treasuries because everybody else keeps buying treasuries. It's common behavior. A fund manager won't get fired by his firm if he

19:16made the same bet that everybody else is making, even if he's wrong. He can just say we were all doing this. The data looks good. Banks, pension funds, and insurers are often required by regulators to hold safe assets that can be sold quickly, and treasuries still tick that box. But a few very important players have already stepped back, mainly foreign central banks. From 2010 to 2001. 2021, central banks around the world bought an average of about 470 tons of gold each year. From 2022 to 2024, they bought more than a thousand tons every year. And in 2025, the gold held by foreign central banks became worth more than the US Treasuries they hold for the first time since 1996. Part of that is because the price of gold rose, but part of it is a choice. No government can create more gold, and demand for gold is what pushed the price up. Now, China was once America's largest foreign lender, holding about $1.3 trillion in treasuries in 2013. Today it holds less than half of that, about $590 billion, and that number keeps on falling. US debt doesn't become a real problem until lenders start refusing. it at normal prices. And if that happens, you will see that in the auction results first, which is why it's so important to understand how a US Treasury auction

20:36really functions and what numbers you could watch to determine if they're healthy or sick. And if they get sick, you'll know by these five metrics. Number one, you'll see more tails at more auctions across both the short and the long-term bonds and those tails getting bigger. Number two, the dealer share will rise again. Those primary dealers will have to buy more of the pie because the voluntary investors are walking away and not taking a big enough piece. Number three, that indirect share will fall further. That's foreign buyers stepping back and buying less. Again, more falling on the shoulders of those primary dealers. Number four, long-term rates will rise even if the Fed cuts its rate, meaning that lenders are demanding more to lend for years, no matter what the Fed does. If you see the Fed cut the interest rate, but the 10-year treasury goes up, that's smoke. A fire is coming. And the fifth and most glaring is that the Fed starts buying treasuries directly with newly created money on the secondary market because rates have climbed higher than the government can afford to pay. Now that last one matters the most. The dealers guarantee every auction gets sold, but not at what rate? If investors step back, dealers buy at higher rates and then struggle to resell, so rates

21:55keep climbing. At that point, the Fed can create new money to buy the bonds from the dealers, which pushes rates back down. Think quantitative easing or maybe even yield curve control. Now, this happened in March of 2020 when the Fed bought about a trillion dollars of treasuries in a few weeks. It keeps the government funded, but more dollars chasing the same goods pushes prices up and each dollar buys less. This is money creation, this is dollar devaluation, this is the debasement trade that captivated everybody in 2025, and a lot of people thought. fell asleep in 2026. But I promise you it's gone nowhere. So what's the bottom line? Everybody has an opinion on US debt, including myself. And I tend to be a bit more pessimistic than some. So I like to check myself with hard data. The only opinion that matters belongs to the people with the money and whether they're still lending it to the United States. We can determine what's really happening by following. the Treasury auction. Right now, the auctions say that the world is still lending just at a higher price, while foreign central banks quietly swap treasuries for gold. But if the warning signs that we talked about today begin to stack up, the likely winners are the assets that the government cannot print or create more of: things like gold, silver, other hard commodities, and the companies that produce them. What happens at

23:15the treasury market is the only thing that matters when it comes to determining how healthy the US or sick the US debt picture is. Everything else is just noise.

23:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But

23:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): honest question, what did I miss? Let me know in the comments. Now, if you enjoy my content, my name is Jay Martinson, and this is the Jay Martin show I publish here every single Saturday, and I love doing it. If you want to come see me live, I host the Vancouver Resource Investment Conference every January in Vancouver, British Columbia. We gather about 11,000 investors, about 350 mining companies, and I fly in around 80 keynote speakers from around the world to go deep into the world of geopolitics, macrofinance, and commodity investing for two days across six stages. It's a monster of a conference, and I love politics. hosting it. I would love to see you there. Check out vricmedia.com for tickets right now. And if you can't make Vancouver, we're coming to Dallas. VRIC Dallas is May 4th and 5th. Also check out vricmedia.com for tickets. And if you're in Scottsdale next week, above and beyond summit.com, dot com VR vr500 500, get that coupon in there. Save yourself 500 bucks. That's it for today. Thank you so much for watching i love making these videos if you learned something today if you took something away do me a favor click like hit subscribe but most importantly share this video with a friend somebody that you know needs to see it that's all for today I'll see you next week

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights