Speakers analyze Bitcoin's bear market bottom near $58.5k, miner AI pivots, and MicroStrategy's STRC mechanics.
Summary
Hosts and guests discuss Bitcoin trading around $61,400, with analysis suggesting a potential bear market bottom near $58,500. Speakers attribute current price suppression to miners selling inventory to fund AI infrastructure transitions, contrasting this with historical cycles. The episode covers institutional Bitcoin flows, regulatory risks for AMD, and the rise of open-source AI models. A significant portion details MicroStrategy's preferred stock (STRC), its buyback strategy, and long-term credit market vision.
Key takeaways
- 1 Institutions bought a net $4.11 billion of US spot Bitcoin funds last quarter, more than erasing their net selling over the prior nine months. according to crypto firm Galaxy.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 2:17
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 2:17
Market Open & Headlines
Hosts discuss the Anthropic IPO, AI market jitters, and gold's worst week in eight months. They also mention Citigroup's capital injection and potential government shutdown risks.
- 2:17 – 2:57
Bitcoin & Policy News
Institutional buying of US spot Bitcoin funds erased prior selling, with wealth platforms holding a record share. The Senate passed the Bipartisan Death Bets Act banning prediction markets on death and war.
- 2:57 – 5:30
Market Data & Bitcoin Technicals
Bitcoin trades around $61,400, down 3.6%. Equities are in a losing streak, with the S&P 500 and Nasdaq down 2% and 2.5% respectively. Gold is near $3,500 and oil is around $81-$82.
- 5:30 – 9:08
Geopolitical Summit Analysis
Trump, Xi, and Putin held a trilateral summit in Shenzhen. The declaration focused on UN reform and nuclear risk, omitting Ukraine. Discussion centers on AI chip control and US-China competition.
- 9:08 – 22:30
Commodities & Fed Policy Interview
Tracy Schuchart of NinjaTrader attributes the commodity sell-off to a surging dollar and hawkish Fed signals. He notes central bank gold buying continues despite price drops and warns of ongoing oil supply risks in the Strait of Hormuz.
- 22:30 – 32:12
Anthropic IPO Winners & Losers
The segment analyzes the Anthropic IPO, identifying investment banks and Sam Altman as winners, while Jensen Huang is labeled a loser due to his departure from NVIDIA. NVIDIA's $10B investment is noted as a paper gain.
- 32:12 – 33:45
AI Chip Rental Market Risks
AI chip rental prices are up 45% year-over-year. Stanley Lee of Liquid Compute warns that the market is a debt market with limited standardization, posing risks for lenders if borrowers go bust.
- 33:45 – 38:25
AI Compute Finance and GPU Rental Economics
Speaker 3 compares the emerging compute asset class to aircraft finance, noting that financial infrastructure like liquid relay markets is being built to manage residual value risk. Speaker 0 argues that rising GPU rental prices are driven by tight credit forcing customers into expensive short-term contracts, rather than fundamental supply shortages, creating systemic risk if credit conditions worsen.
- 38:25 – 42:21
AMD Regulatory Risks and Hunterbrook Report
Speaker 1 details a short report by Hunterbrook Media alleging AMD violated US export controls by supplying firmware to blacklisted Chinese server maker IEIT Systems. Speaker 0 highlights that AMD's revenue exposure to China, Hong Kong, and Singapore is significant, and notes the stock fell 7.7% following the report and related regulatory fears.
- 42:21 – 49:29
Open Source AI Models vs. Frontier Labs
Speaker 1 reports that open-weight models captured 72% of token volume on OpenRouter by September 2026, growing 60-fold compared to closed models. Speaker 0 argues that institutional and corporate customers are shifting to open-source models due to lower costs, data privacy benefits, and sufficient quality for non-frontier tasks, threatening the subscription revenue of frontier labs like Anthropic.
- 49:29 – 55:03
Block Bitcoin Payments Report and Tax Advocacy
Janessa Lopez discusses Block's 2026 Bitcoin Payments Report, showing median payments of $13 with 72% in food/drink. She notes that 43% of payments come from Cash App but 57% from external wallets, and highlights that 25% of merchants cite tax complexity as a barrier, prompting Block to advocate for a tax exemption on small crypto payments.
- 55:03 – 1:03:41
Crypto Policy Outlook and Regulatory Strategy
Lopez discusses the rescission of Gensler-era rules on self-hosted wallets and the travel rule, urging agencies to solidify pro-crypto guidance through formal rulemaking before the Congressional Review Act deadline. She identifies crypto tax relief as the most likely bipartisan legislation to pass, while predicting heavy oversight from Democrats in the new Congress.
- 1:03:41 – 1:07:25
Bitcoin Price Action and Bear Market Bottoms
Speaker 0 notes Bitcoin broke below $60k, testing the previous bear market bottom zone of $58,500. He suggests that while the current drawdown is mild compared to historical cycles, a break below $58k could trigger 'max pain' for miners, potentially forcing a capitulation that would set a definitive bottom before the next bull cycle.
- 1:07:25 – 2:03:30
Bitcoin Mining Economics and Bear Market Bottoms
Speaker 0 analyzes Bitcoin mining costs versus price, noting that public miners are operating below cash break-even with costs rising from $50k to $80k post-halving. The speaker argues that while price is under the industry average cost, it remains above the cost of the most efficient miners like Hive, Iron, and BitDeer, suggesting the market is near 'max pain' but not at the absolute bottom due to these low-cost producers.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gold | commodity | neutral | Gold is down about 8% this week, headed for its worst week in eight months, says markets price. in another Fed rate hike. Spot gold is down 1.3% at about $3,575 an ounce, a fifth straight losing session after hitting its lowest since September 2025, as a stronger dollar and higher treasury yields hit silver and platinum. |
| Silver | commodity | neutral | yields hit silver and platinum. |
| BitcoinBTC | crypto | mixed | Institutions bought a net $4.11 billion of US spot Bitcoin funds last quarter, more than erasing their net selling over the prior nine months. according to crypto firm Galaxy. |
| NVIDIANVDA | equity | neutral | The price to rent Nvidia's top AI chips is up about 45% over the past year, according to Silicon Data. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Anthropic's IPO was the largest in history, raising $81.3 billion with a valuation of about $1.5 trillion.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·22:30
How to verify: SEC F-1 registration statement for Anthropic; press releases from investment banks Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceSpot gold is down about 8% for the week, heading for its worst week in eight months, trading around $3,575 an ounce.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·0:46
How to verify: London Bullion Market Association (LBMA) gold price data; Bloomberg commodity indices for the week of Nov 15-20, 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Citigroup underestimated its risky assets by about $35 billion after misrecording trades at a European unit.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·1:09
How to verify: Reuters article citing sources; Citigroup investor relations press releases or SEC filings (e.g., 8-K) regarding the capital injection. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceInstitutions bought a net $4.11 billion of US spot Bitcoin funds last quarter, according to Galaxy.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·2:17
How to verify: Galaxy Digital 'State of Bitcoin' report or quarterly institutional flow data for Q3/Q4 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bitcoin is trading around $61,400, down about 3.6% on the day.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·2:57
How to verify: CoinGecko, CoinMarketCap, or major exchange (Binance/Coinbase) historical price data for Nov 20, 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The 10-year treasury yield is around 5.01%, down four basis points from the previous day.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·3:48
How to verify: US Department of Treasury daily yield curve data; Bloomberg or Reuters bond market feeds. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
WTI crude is trading around $81-$82 a barrel, down about 0.8%.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·4:08
How to verify: ICE WTI futures settlement prices; Bloomberg commodity data for Nov 20, 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Anthropic shares opened at $111.50 and closed at $97.17, trading around $90 the next morning.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·22:50
How to verify: NYSE trading data for ANTH (or ticker used) on Nov 19-20, 2026; company press releases. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
NVIDIA agreed to put $10 billion into Anthropic at the IPO price of $83.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·25:27
How to verify: SEC Form D or investment disclosure filings; press releases from NVIDIA and Anthropic regarding the strategic investment. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThe price to rent Nvidia's top AI chips is up about 45% over the past year, according to Silicon Data.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·32:12
How to verify: Silicon Data research report on AI infrastructure costs; Liquid Compute or similar cloud GPU provider pricing pages. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceNVIDIA B200 rental prices rose from $4.40 to $6.94 per hour between January and November 19, 2026, a 58% increase.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·35:39
How to verify: Check NVIDIA official pricing pages or third-party GPU rental marketplaces (e.g., Vast.ai, RunPod) for historical spot pricing data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceNVIDIA H100 rental prices hit a low of $1.86 on February 5, 2026, and rose to $3.11 by November 19, 2026.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·35:59
How to verify: Verify against historical GPU rental spot prices from major cloud providers or aggregators like Vast.ai. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceHunterbrook Capital disclosed a short position in AMD and published a report alleging AMD supplied firmware to blacklisted IEIT Systems.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·38:45
How to verify: Check SEC Form 13F for Hunterbrook Capital's AMD holdings and Hunterbrook Media's published report. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceA Commerce Department rule effective November 19, 2026, requires licenses for advanced chips shipped to Singapore and four other countries.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·39:24
How to verify: Search the Federal Register for Commerce Department export control rules effective November 19, 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
AMD billed $4.28 billion to Singapore customers in fiscal 2025, representing over 10% of sales.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·39:24
How to verify: Verify against AMD's 2025 Annual Report (Form 10-K) filed with the SEC. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceChina and Hong Kong made up 22% of AMD's revenue in fiscal 2025.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·39:43
How to verify: Verify against AMD's 2026 Annual Report (Form 10-K) filed with the SEC. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceAMD stock closed down 7.7% following the Hunterbrook report.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·41:58
How to verify: Check historical stock price data for AMD (NASDAQ: AMD) for the trading day following the report's publication. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Open-weight models handled 72% of token volume on OpenRouter by the end of September 2026.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·42:41
How to verify: Check OpenRouter's public documentation or blog posts regarding token volume statistics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Block's 2026 Bitcoin Payments Report covers November 1, 2025, through October 15, 2026.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·49:29
How to verify: Access the Block Bitcoin Payments Report published on Block's website or press releases. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bitcoin price fell below $60k to approximately $59,500, down 13% for the week.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·1:03:41
How to verify: Check Bitcoin price data from CoinGecko, CoinMarketCap, or major exchanges for the specified date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Public miner cash costs rose from ~$50,000 to ~$80,000 by year-end 2026 after the halving.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:08:24
How to verify: Check mining cost estimates from public miner 10-K/10-Q filings or industry reports (e.g., CoinShares, CryptoQuant) for 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceBitcoin price is currently ~$59,000-$62,300, which is ~19% below the industry average cash cost of ~$85,000.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:09:05
How to verify: Compare current BTC price on CoinGecko/CoinMarketCap against industry average cost estimates from mining analytics firms. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Mara sold ~40,000 BTC in 2026, roughly five times its mining production.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:10:29
How to verify: Review Mara Holdings' (MARA) quarterly earnings reports and treasury disclosures for 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Spot ETFs bled ~$1.9 billion over seven straight sessions in the current month.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·1:12:12
How to verify: Check daily ETF flow data from Farside Investors or similar trackers for the relevant month in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The network mints ~450 coins per day, worth ~$28 million at $59,000.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·1:12:01
How to verify: Calculate based on the 6.25 BTC block reward (post-2026 halving) or 3.125 (post-2026 halving) times 144 blocks/day; verify BTC price. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
MSCI is under pressure from clients and regulators to remain market neutral, which may delay Bitcoin inclusion in their indices.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·1:41:54
How to verify: Review MSCI's official announcements or regulatory filings regarding index methodology changes and client communications. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceDo your own research
- Verify Galaxy Digital's quarterly institutional Bitcoin flow reports for net buying/selling figures.
- Check Hunterbrook Media's short report on AMD and their disclosed short position for potential conflicts of interest.
- Review Block's 2026 Bitcoin Payments Report for median payment values and merchant adoption metrics.
- Analyze MicroStrategy's (MSTR) SEC filings for STRC dividend rates, buyback volumes, and outstanding share counts.
- Confirm the latest S&P Global Ratings methodology for assigning value to Bitcoin assets in credit assessments.
- Monitor the US Dollar Index (DXY) and Federal Reserve statements for hawkish signals impacting risk assets.
- Verify OpenRouter's token volume data comparing open-weight vs. closed-source AI model usage.
- Check mining company earnings reports (e.g., MARA, RIOT) for AI infrastructure investment expenditures and Bitcoin inventory sales.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Good morning and happy Friday. Welcome into BMTV. I'm Grace Darmington with Sean Hagen. Well, Anthropic made its long-awaited debut yesterday in what was the biggest IPO in history and for that lift everyone was hoping it would do for the AI trade didn't really come yesterday. The AI jitters still in the markets this morning.
0:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, we're seeing a little bit of a sell-off, but we'll we'll see if we can have a continuation of that throughout the market today or if the bulls are gonna come in and take back the reins.
0:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): We'll take a look at that in just a minute. Joining us on today's show, Tracy Schuchart, senior economist at Ninja Trader Live, Janessa Lopez, head of digital assets and emerging tech policy at Block, and Chitanya Jane, head of investor relations at strategy. But let's get your Friday morning started with today's headlines. Gold is down about 8% this week, headed for its worst week in eight months, says markets price. in another Fed rate hike. Spot gold is down 1.3% at about $3,575 an ounce, a fifth straight losing session after hitting its lowest since September 2025, as a stronger dollar and higher treasury yields hit silver and platinum. Sources are selling, telling Reuters that Citigroup underestimated its risky assets by about $35. billion after misrecording trades at a European unit, forcing it to inject capital into that unit. City says it fixed the issue this summer and the unit stayed above regulatory minimums, a setback as CEO Jane Fraser works to get years-long regulatory restrictions lifted.
1:35Congress could be headed for a pre-Christmas government shutdown as divisions over the Iran War and President Trump's demand for $350 billion in new Pentagon spending threaten a funding deal. Federal funding expires after December 11th, and in the Senate, a bipartisan package would need 60 votes to pass as the parties remain far apart. Anthropic shares were down about 10% pre-market after a strong debut vaulted the AI lab into the rank. ranks of the most valuable U.S. companies, but failed to revive enthusiasm for AI stocks. With Anthropic seen as a proxy for the AI trade, a sustained decline could deepen concerns over lofty valuations and massive AI spending. Institutions bought a net $4.11 billion of US spot Bitcoin funds last quarter, more than erasing their net selling over the prior nine months. according to crypto firm Galaxy. Financial advisors and wealth platforms drove half that buying and now hold a record 40.5% of institutional holdings.
2:38And the Senate has passed the Bipartisan Death Bets Act, which would ban prediction markets from listing bets tied to death, terrorism, assassination, and war. Sponsor Senator Adam Schiff. says those bets invite insider trading, and the bill now heads to the House.
2:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
2:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): with that, let's take a look at how your markets are trading this morning. Bitcoin sitting around $61,000. Or I'm sorry, $61,400 down about 3.6% on the day. Uh, The SP fell 2% two percent yesterday. That's it. its Six sixth straight losing seconds. session. The Nasdaq lost two and a half percent yesterday. That's more than 13 below its October record this morning. The SPY down uh three-tenths of a percentage point, and QQQ down about a full percentage point. Uh, the big story remaining, the AI trade here. We mentioned anthropics record-breaking Record breaking IPO failing to lift the broader market here. Shares closed 17% above. their offering price yesterday, but they're down toward $89 this morning. That's down 7%. Over in the bond market,
3:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,
3:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): the 10-year treasury yield around uh 5.01%, down four basis points from yesterday. So easing a bit and turning to commodities, gold around $3,500 announced. an ounce. That's down almost $5. 4% on the day. And in oil, WTI crude trading around $81, $82 a barrel, that's down about eight tenths of a percentage point. Brent crude trading around $90 a barrel, that's down about one and a half percentage points, as concerns about oversupply continue.
4:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
4:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and I think that those concerns about oversupply are really interesting. Obviously, a very different conversation than where we were just a couple weeks ago. And so uh we'll be honest to see if 90 holds, maybe, you know, 90, 93. Um, I think a key level, maybe a 93.1 getting up there. But um, obviously Bitcoin's the main story here. I I think that this weekly close is gonna be quite, quite interesting. We saw a lot of price action uh those last few hours leading into the weekly cut close, the previous two weeks, and I don't expect this week to be much different. Um, you know, sentiments at an all-time low. Um, there's there's, you know, seemingly uh no catalyst on the horizon, and we've just lost several uh moving averages over the past couple of days to weeks. And so uh you want to see Bitcoin find some footing here. It's been trading around that sixty-two thousand dollar range all week. Now this morning kind of taking a turn below that into the sixty-one. 61. So I'd really like to see it reclaim 63, which it started the week at uh by Sunday evening. But only time will tell, and then we'll uh break it down for you on Monday to see what ultimately happened. But this is gonna be a quite important uh weekly close for Bitcoin here.
5:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): All right, let's go to the meeting now that everyone has eyes on. Yesterday, President Trump, China's Xi Jinping, and Russia's Vladimir Putin held their first. three-way summit in Shenzhen, China, meeting behind closed doors after opening remarks for the cameras. Side meetings came first. Xi and Putin met on November 18th. The next day, the Kremlin says Trump and Putin talked for about 40 minutes, with Ukraine the main focus. Trump then met Xi for about an hour. China's readout of that meeting covers trade, Taiwan, and AI, and never mentions Ukraine. The joint result was a four-point declaration, United Nations reform, more refined fuel with no volumes or dates, a warning to the international criminal court, and future talks on nuclear risk. Previous guest of the show and geopolitical strategist Valina Chakarova notes the text says nothing about Ukraine, Iran, Taiwan, or Korea Peninsula. though China says the leaders did discuss Ukraine and Korea in the room. A meeting with Kim Jong-un, which Trump had floated, never came together. According to China's readout, President Trump and Xi Jinping agreed that artificial intelligence should remain under human control
6:43as part of a broader push for cooperation between the two countries. The White House has not released its own account, and neither side mentioned AI chips or expert control, Sean. Aaron
6:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
6:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, look, I think this was a big deal despite being kind of a nothing burger on the surface, right? I mean, it was the first trilateral between these three major world leaders representing major, you know, global superpowers at this time. And you know, I I think that there's implications coming out of this for the Iran front, for the Ukraine front, and obviously uh for the metaverse as well, right? You kind of have these. three uh points of contention. One is is the you know internet level of reality we're all shifting to, i.e. chips. Uh, and then you have two like actual wars happening. And so hopefully we see the wars wind down. You know, certainly that was discussed here. We we see steps being taken in all three fronts. We've just yet to see anything uh officially papered in that direction, but it seems to be on the top of mind for everybody. involved, which hasn't always been the case. You would think that would kind of be the case, but but war does serve a purpose, and so not everyone's always welcome to come to the table. On the chip part, that's gonna be the most interesting to me, right? I mean, we've we've had kinetic wars for all of recorded history, so we kind
7:52of know you know what the end goals may or may not be. Uh with the chips, it's it's a it's a brand new world, right? And so you get this argument of if you're on the pro-America pro America side at least, from our perspective. sitting here in Nashville, Tennessee, uh, you know, you want the US to beat China. So what does that look like, right? Does that look like uh, you know, we give them our chips, even though it's maybe not our front uh frontier level chip quality, uh best of the best chips so they can outcompute us, but it's still better than their domestic market. And then you prevent their domestic market from coming in and eventually competing with our economy. Um uh or maybe uh you know you ban them entirely and and you view it as sort of this existential threat uh where you don't want them training high level compute at all because we need to get to whatever that, you know, uh shiny item is at the end of that AI train. So uh two different ways to cut it. Both are kind of this US superiority race over China. Um and it'll be interesting to see kind of what ends up being the strategic preference here.
8:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): All right, so where do commodities go next? Oil, gold, and bitcoin are all sliding as the dollar surges. Let's bring in our first guest of the day for more, Tracy Schuchart, senior economist at Ninja Trader Live, joins us to break it all down. Tracy, great to see you again and thanks for joining us. So we have oil, copper, gold, bitcoin all falling this month as the dollar is. hits a nineteen month high, this coming ahead of an expected Fed rate hike. How much of the sell off is the Fed in the dollar? And just what is your read on commodities right now?
9:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): So well, obviously I think markets got particularly spooked after Waller brought up maybe we should do fifty basis points. And that's really when we saw uh commodities take another leg down. Uh US dollar 103 plus kind of becoming a wrecking ball uh across global currencies, essentially, particularly emerging markets right now. And so that is a problem. Obviously, that's going to be a problem for precious metals. They're non-yielding assets. And when you have higher yields, a higher dollar, uh, you're going to obviously not uh money flows would be into yielding assets with higher yields than it would be something like um something like gold. So that's what we are seeing there. I mean, they're all kind of it's kind of hard. We need to put them, I think, in buckets of metals versus oil because they're that's kind of different. Obviously, silver's got a dual nature. so it's getting hit on the monetary side with higher dollar, higher yields, but also on the AI capex trade that seems to be falling apart right now because it is also an industrial metal that is highly used in um data centers. And of course, copper,
10:44same things getting hit on h higher yields, higher dollar, and of course the AI CapEx trade that's imploding because of sh sheer amount of copper that you need for those data centers.
10:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
10:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and and copper seems to be kind of flashing a warning sign about this capex cycle for AI. On the gold side, do you see gold flashing a a warning sign as well?
11:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Um warning sign as far as uh
11:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
11:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): know,
11:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
11:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): liquidity and
11:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think this is just. a function of the market. Um, you know, I wouldn't interpret the sell-off really as evidence of the underlying supply and demand fundamentals um suddenly deteriorating. We know central banks are uh buying in mass last two months. It'll be interesting to see what November is last two months. PBOC, the most gold that they've bought in. uh two years. Um, and we know central banks really like and they'll buy anything under uh 4,000. Not that they have a price target, they're kind of impervious to whatever the price is. If they want to buy it, they're gonna buy it. But because of the strengthening dollar, further rate hikes, pushing yields higher, that's gonna create pressure across. um uh uh commodity markets in general, although the impact differs by asset.
12:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And then on the other, on the other shoe, I'd love to get your thoughts on oil as well, right? The the market seems to be um kind of really taking some pressure off oil and also crack spreads as well. Um, in your estimation, is is the market too optimistic that we're gonna see some geopolitical resolution? resolutions
12:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): here?
12:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Um yes. In a word, yes. Um I think we really need to look at um the fact that, you know, yes, we have heard that some more supply is getting through the Strait of Hormuz, but I think it's a mistake to think that just because uh prices have fallen, pollen, that the supply risk has disappeared. Yes, the markets have recovered some barrels through alternate export routes, but those routes have become strategic targets themselves. Now that we have kind of a two front war with the Houthis bombing Saudi Arabia and their oil installations, and particularly the East East-West West Pipeline that has been able to divert uh four 4 million barrels. a day to export. So that risk is still there. Iran doesn't need to destroy millions of barrels of production to create a supply shock. It can disrupt shipping, raise insurance costs,
13:28make buyers question whether the next cargo will arrive. So we, while we have an oil market that where supply is recovering, the infrastructure moving that supply remains very vulnerable.
13:44Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Staying on that topic, Qatar's UCC is negotiating for two major onshore oil fields in Venezuela. And then the UAE's new pipeline around Hormuz is due next year. So even if the straight Foley fully reopens, how much Gulf oil money and supply could move away from Hormuz Hormouths for good?
14:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Um, I think you're gonna see a lot of that move away for from Hormuz to good for good. Um again, you mentioned UAE seeking alternate routes. Um Iraq is opening up a pipeline that has been basically closed for the last 13 years to Turkey. So all of those countries are looking for other export routes and um I did have talked about Qatar before. I think that is very strategic looking at Venezuela because they don't want to be caught in this situation again where basically all of their exports stopped for LNG for a period of time. And that they want to make sure that that doesn't happen again. So I think the Horm Hormo Strait of Hormuz. Hormones will become less impactful than it was to global oil flows. That said, it still does not seem like there's going to be any resolution to that matter anytime soon. And it's not just oil that flows through that strait and oil products. Um there are a lot of other commodities as well.
15:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And you know, I I know that you've had some commentary and analysis on the anthropic IPO, which is the other large item of news this week. Uh you had a piece in in the New York Post where you pointed out there's kind of an odd time to go public. Also the amount of employee or insider shares that are going to be available and liquid right away.
15:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
15:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you know, yesterday we saw uh a sell-off sell off after market hours, they're getting a another bump today. Uh no. notably they they listed about thirty-four percent above their their IPO price uh during their debut. So what has your analysis been thus far? Is is it kind of more or less what you expected and and what are you kind of keeping your eyes on as we move forward?
15:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, I I more or less expected this. I didn't expect us to reach the eighty $83 three dollar initial price overnight, um you know, after hitting a high of 115 yesterday. But it seems, you know, this this IPO is so large, this is the market right now. And we saw a drastic sell-off in AI CapEx names and tech stocks yesterday. And if you, you know, the market has followed Anthropic down and and is bouncing now that we are seeing a bounce uh off those lows, the uh low being eighty. 8347. We're about 92 right now. So we are seeing the tech stocks bounce a little bit with that. But um I this IPO is literally sucking all of the air from the market. Um, and you can, you know, just on an intraday basis watch the two of them move together. I'm sure that will diverge at some point, but. just because of the sheer magnitude of size of this IBO.
16:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And how long do you do see the two um kind of trading together before there's a disjointedness? I mean it seems like this is necessarily going to be the case for for the foreseeable future from from our perspective. I mean, w when do you think we might see finally some some detachment?
17:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think, you know, uh I give it, you know, at least a couple of weeks, a month or two, um just to see. I I think if this anthropic, you know, if we see a bounce in anthropic and it rests assured the market and investors that you know this the uh A capex trade is on some sort of firm footing, we could see money from. flows flow back into those other names. Certainly. That said, there's still a lot of risk, uh particularly in the US, with um uh a new democratically elected Congress coming to power. There are still a lot of questions about that trade. They ran on the platform of, you know, uh, we want to slow down AI, we don't want this. data center build-out uh to go as fast a pace as the administration would like. And so I think the market's really sort of digesting and waiting to see what's gonna happen next year.
18:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
18:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): they're not just sucking all the air out of the market, they're sucking out all the natural gas too, right? I mean, they're they're paying 3.4 three point four billion for their gas fire fired generators for their AI data centers. And you know, uh the IEA says data center power could double by twenty thirty. How how big do you think AI is gonna get for natural gas demand? Uh and what are some of the downstream effects you expect from that?
18:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, it's I think it's gonna be really really huge. I think um I think what the market misreads or people tend to misread in the market in that particular market in the United States is that, you know, we're gonna see a spike in, say, natural gas prices like we've seen in Europe. But uh the US is has a lot of natural gas and it's abundant, it's cheap. And so I don't expect to see uh prices really spike like we've seen in other countries. I think where what's going to be good for US. is in on the LNG side, for one, to export to other countries that are going to need net gas to run their data centers. As well as I think it's going to be really uh a really good opportunity for midstream operators, which are people that build pipelines, because you're going gonna to need to pipe in all of this natural gas. And in some cases, many cases, uh these data centers are building their own pipelines.
19:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I do want to bring it back to Bitcoin here. Given the surge in government debt and oil shocks, you know, we've been talking about that's all the more reason to own hard assets like Bitcoin. Even as we watch it uh fall below where is it, 61,000 today. Um, what's your biggest bull case for Bitcoin from here?
20:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): So yeah, I mean I think biggest uh the big Bitcoin's biggest long-term argument is its monetary scarcity. Um, it's supply is limited. Bullish case rests on continued adoption and demand for assets that aren't issued by a central government. Um, but I think what investors uh or traders and need to really keep in mind, we have to distinguish like the long-term thesis from the way it's trading today. So when we are in periods of tightening liquidity, which we are rising yields and a stronger dollar, Bitcoin behaves much more like a risk asset than a Been safe haven. And that's exactly what we're seeing right now. But the long-term argument uh hasn't changed. And um, I think that um we will see continued adoption. I mean, if you look at Bitcoin transactions, just because prices come down, we haven't seen transactions trail off. In fact, transactions are even uh stronger. So I I think right now you just have to again distinguish the difference between current price action. and a long term thesis.
21:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
21:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Tracy, I know that we have to go, but before you leave, you mentioned the the policy direction of the Fed. Um I I'd love to hear your expectations, right? We hear them talking a big game, maybe a fifty uh point increase in December. Do you expect uh a large increase, maybe only something like twenty-five, 25, and and then is there some continuation into 2027 twenty twenty seven in their hiking schedule in your mind?
21:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, I mean they all sound very hawkish. We read we all read the Fed minutes that that sounded very hawkish. You of course had Waller and Goolsby come out, you know, suggesting that maybe we need to do 50 basis points. Now, I don't think they're gonna do 50 basis points. I think they're going to do 25. Um, and instead of doing 50 and then skipping, say, January, I think they'll um, you know, probably for the next three meetings we'll raise 25. But I I think it's a a lot of big talk from this, but I don't think that you will get all members to uh do a 50 basis point rate hike in this December meeting.
22:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Tracy Schuchart, senior economist at Ninja Trader Live. It was great having you again. Thanks so much for joining us.
22:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Thanks. Thanks for having
22:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): me. Well,
22:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Anthropic, the company behind the AI model, Claude, is now a public company. It priced its shares at $83, raised $81.3 billion in the largest IPO on record, and hit a valuation of about $1.5 trillion. Then the stock opened at $111.50. Now when that much money changes hands that quickly, somebody cleans up and somebody gets left holding the bag. So let's keep score here and take a look at the winners and losers of the Anthropic IPO. First up, the investment bankers. Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley led the 22 banks that took Anthropic public. Together, those banks split a $550 million fee, one of the biggest IPO paydays. on record. And their clients, they got shares at $83 that opened at $111.50. The banks get paid, their friends get paid, everybody wins, except maybe Anthropic.
23:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Maybe. So um like Grace was explaining for for anyone at home that that doesn't know how these work, um, you know, Anthropic wants to list their their initial offering as high as possible so they're not leaving a dollar on the table. This is a fundraising event for the firm, right? They're waking up with cash in their account today from this issuance. The investment bank, of course, is gonna be making money if there's a spread between where it lists and where it closes the day, and they can capture that spread. So, you know, they're they're certainly in this together, but they have very different uh incentives.
24:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Closed at 97.17 yesterday. Today it's uh trading around $90. All right, next winner, Sam Altman. Now he doesn't own a single share of Anthropic, but his biggest rival just raised $81.3 billion, the largest IPO on record. That sets the price tag for AI labs. And when OpenAI eventually goes public, now Mr. Altman has a fresh benchmark. to point to.
24:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
24:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and then you know you also got to think about another Sam, Sam Bankman Freed, who you gotta think about what all of his investments would be worth if you see how frothy things got and what he had his fingers in too. But when it comes to Altman, you know, you know that he's eyeballing this and he's gonna be watching the market probably closer than anybody over the next couple days, because you know, he has investment bankers calling him probably every quarter of an hour to try to do the same thing with his firm. And so we'll see if they take action. Um they seem to have have you know waited quite a bit, uh delayed it to kind of see how this plays out, maybe learn from it. Um, but everyone's expecting this. It's really just a matter of when, not if.
25:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Alright, let's go to our biggest loser now, and that is Jensen Wong. Nvidia agreed to put $10 billion into Anthropic, and on November 19th, that bet paid off with the stock opening 34% above its IPO price. Now, Jensen, he missed it by just one week. He resigned as NVIDIA CEO on November 12th, and the board says he's not coming back.
25:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, you know, very uh peculiar timing. Uh, if you look at uh, you know, some of the the inside baseball of who would want Jensen. in or who would want Jensen out, um and and certainly Anthropic uh would benefit from that. So I'm not pointing any fingers, but uh certainly interesting tea leaves to be read. But is Jensen really that much of a loser? I mean he gets to play a lot more golf. He might go start his own firm, he might pull a Steve Jobs and come back. Um and he still has all of his equity. So uh, you know, you you can't you can't be too much of a loser uh from his perspective.
26:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): He's
26:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): a triple digit billionaire. I think he's okay.
26:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think he's just fine.
26:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): All right, our next winner though, NVIDIA itself, kinda. Nvidia bought about $10 billion of Anthropic stock at the IPO price of $83. By the close, those shares were up about 17%. Now the catch, Google bought just as much, and Anthropic also runs its models on Google. Google's own AI chips. So NVIDIA's biggest new investment is also a customer that's shopping around winning on paper but losing on sales. Yeah,
26:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): well, what I find interesting is Anthropic is basically just porting their models from NVIDIA to other silicon, right? So what used to take months is now taking days because they're actually using their own frontier models to fine-tune uh the the LLMs to be able to run a different silicon. A lot of people miss this point. A lot of casual AI observers uh miss the point that you actually it it matters what chips you're running uh your inference on, and you have to retrain a model to have the same efficiency uh on a different piece of silicone. And so that's one of the reasons that it's been so sticky, uh, these NVIDIA customers. But now that the frontier models are turning are what used to take months. into days of retuning, then they can start to become a lot more agnostic about what chips are in these data centers.
27:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): All right. Our final loser of the anthropic IPO. Who is it?
27:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It's me. It's me. Uh what happened?
27:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): What did Robinhood do to you?
27:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, well, the production the product Yeah. Well, you know, I I tried to request some shares on Robin Hood and Robin Hood decided to only give me one share. So I I own a single share of uh Anthropic. Uh so totally lost out on what was like the most obvious IPO trade of all time. Look, you know, this is not an endorsement of Anthropic. This is not me saying it's a great long term hold. I'm not making any statements like that. What I'm saying is that like we said at the beginning of the show, investment banks make money listing it, knowing there can be a pop. And so, uh, you know, it makes sense to to kind of speculate a little bit and have some fun. You know, don't load up, you know, the truck for these things, but generally it's a pretty safe bet to uh participate. But of course, Robin Hood kneecapped me a bit and uh only allocated me a single measly share. However, I think we should flip this. I think I'm a winner. I I think that um you know I I just can't stop winning and and that's why Robin Hood's algorithm knew
28:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to allocate me
28:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): one share because you know the price sell off so you know it sold off overnight and I think that I was just simply being spared. Um
28:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): it was eighty eighty-three three dollars at about six a.m. today.
28:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, I mean I I have all this mimetic build-up that propels me forward through my path of just winning. You
28:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
28:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I'm like Charlie Sheen, I'm gonna just always winning um and just getting tired of winning. So maybe Robin Hood just had no choice but to spare me.
29:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I'd be scared to log on to X after this. I think producer Spencer kind of did you dirty with that traffic. No one even has to make their own edits now, they just got one ready. to go. It'll
29:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): be good. I know the fellas over at the Bitcoin Bugle have my back, uh, you know, as as kind of a lead podcasting host among the plebs.
29:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): All right, we shall see.
29:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
29:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): right. Well coming up next, AI chip rental prices are surging even for older technology. Could uh that actually be a warning sign of financial stress? We're gonna going to break it down after this break.
29:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): You believe in Bitcoin. So why would you ever sell it? Life happens: an emergency expense, a new home purchase, or a great business opportunity. With SALT, you can access the power of your Bitcoin without selling. Now with rates starting at 7.5%. The original Bitcoin back lender, no collateral losses, no rehypothefication since 2016. Get your exclusive offer at SaltLending.com. forward slash BMTV.
30:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Bitcoin can help diversify how you spend, save, and invest in your business, especially when every swipe of a credit card eats away at your bottom line. Let's say you run a local grocery chain. Most purchases are small, like a
30:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): bag of produce or a gallon of milk, so credit card fees start to add up fast.
30:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): For
30:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Square, you can now accept Bitcoin with zero payment processing fees, no chargebacks, and near instant access to funds.
30:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
30:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you choose how money settles into your account, whether in USD or Bitcoin, instantly and right from your Square dashboard.
30:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Whether
30:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you're aiming for short term goals or planning for the long haul, you can automatically convert a percentage of your daily card sales into Bitcoin, no
30:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): extra steps, no added. complexity. It's a smart, seamless way to build savings in the background, all while keeping your day-to-day cash flow predictable. And when tax time comes, you'll get the paperwork you need right where you find your reports and bank statement. Bitcoin is just another way for you to take control of how your business makes and spends money. Enable Bitcoin payments and conversions in your Square Dashboard. Head to squareup.com/slash bitcoin. to learn
31:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): more. Let's go.
31:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Bitcoin didn't appear out of nowhere. For decades before Satoshi Nakamoto, computer scientists, privacy activists, and heterodox economists tried to build digital money no government could control. Aaron Van Wertom has been writing about Bitcoin since he discovered it in 2013. And three years ago, he told the story behind. its invention. The Genesis Book, 3rd Anniversary Edition, traces the people and projects that paved the way for the first successful peer-to-peer electronic cash system. 333 copies, one exclusive release. Own a limited collector's edition of the Genesis Book. Repackaged, hand And signed, individually numbered, presented in an exclusive Genesis block slip slipcase, case. and built for Bitcoin history collectors. Available now.
32:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Anthropics IPO saw a major success yesterday, but there is a key aspect of the AI finance complex that may be hiding more risk than investors would like. The price to rent Nvidia's top AI chips is up about 45% over the past year, according to Silicon Data. For the AI bulls, that's proof demand is real. Now, Stanley Lee, chief product officer at Liquid Compute and a former high yield credit trader, sees something else. He says the market for these chips is really a debt market, funded by venture capital and private credit. And the big question for lenders is what those chips are worth if a borrower goes bust. Here's what he had to say on the Bloomberg Odlots Oddlots podcast.
32:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know,
32:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): in a lot of the work that we do with a lot of our private credit partners, we're trying to standardize as many of these sort of middle market loans as possible. The most important thing that I would tell anybody who's lending in the space is make sure that you have the right to do that. And also these these compute contracts need to be transferable and assignable. So
33:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): some of them don't, unless it's like specifically spelled out in the covenants.
33:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
33:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): correct. I mean there's no, I wouldn't say there's no, but there's very limited standardization. Okay. Increasingly, lenders are focused on this. And also increasingly the compute buyers who are the inference companies are focused on getting non-disturbance agreements with
33:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): their
33:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): existing lenders because their paranoia is, okay, well, if my operator fails and I have this contract that I signed a year ago where I'm paying 380 per GPU hour, if the current going rate is 430, the lender's not going to honor my contract, they're just going to relay it to someone else. Now, the actual remarketing and reletting is not as complicated as a lot of other commodities because you don't have to ship the GPUs anywhere. You just transfer SSH keys. This can be done and we can do this in like a matter of minutes, for example. Obviously, for larger scale projects, it might take a bit longer. But yeah, I mean, I think this entire ecosystem has been built on the idea of two things that did not exist six to 12 twelve months ago. Number one, that recovery in the compute asset class is reletting the capacity. Reletting the capacity is a lot harder to do operationally. You need the right legal structure in place from the term sheets than it is from an engineering perspective. And also the idea that through the construction of financial markets, derivatives, potential hedges, there are ways to lay off some of this residual value risk. But I think this is why it reminds me so much of there's no perfect an analogy, but I think aircraft finance. is a very interesting analogy. Because when you look at pre and post financial crisis with aircrafts, there were large prepayments that were required to, you know, the Boeings, the Airbuses of the world. Post two thousand and eight, everybody thought, okay, this is not very financeable. What made the asset class financiable was the construction of financial infrastructure
34:44around this, a a liquid relay market, regular appraisals. So I I think compute, you know, what we're focused on building is exactly that financial infrastructure. And I genuinely believe that Silicon Valley should embrace this credit crunch. It obviously is frustrating and it sucks right now. But if you just look at all of these other historical build-outs, nothing is so linear.
35:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All right.
35:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So break this down, Sean. What role does AI silicon currently play in AI finance and what do you think the risks are?
35:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, look, you know, uh it's it's all about the the collateral, right, and and the depreciation schedule. So on this chart, for example, that we pulled together uh for y'all, the orange line is the B two hundred NVIDIA uh chip, which is currently their top chip. It went from about four $4.40 dollars and forty cents an hour when when data data uh you know started in January. Uh and now it's up to about $6.94 as of November 19th, 2026. That's up about 58% since January. The blue line is the H-100. That's the previous generation. It hit a low of 186 on February 5th. Um, and those rental prices have risen to $3.11 now. Normally older chips rent rents fall when the new ones ships, so an older chip getting more expensive is quite unusual. And I think it just kind of shows like that there's bottleneck and some some supply issues. But broadly speaking, you gotta wonder why is this the case, right? Is is this sustainable and is this something normative or or really kind of like what's going on here? And so you know, I I I think that rising rents look like demand for GPU time.
36:23But what Stanley was just arguing in that clip, for example. is that a big part of the rise is actually just reflecting how hard financing has become, right? And I think this more simple read, perhaps, is that we just need to push back on this idea that rents are rising because everyone wants more AI computing power than exists. You know, uh the an A AI company can rent GPUs two ways. Uh One is is a cheaper long longer contract with less paid up front. Um and and then the other would be the short term, uh, you know, with nothing down but this higher rental rate. And so customers are getting pushed into the short term market and they're paying more and the quoted prices are going up. And and then as a result of that, you know, the indexes are are rising partly because money's just harder to get. Uh not just because these GPUs are scarcer or anything fundamental has changed about the GPUs themselves. And so that introduces sort of this complex of potential risk introduction where you have these high rents driven by tight credit that can reverse fast. And then the market for these GPUs is actually fairly thin. So it doesn't take much to kind of just push it around in either direction. So I wouldn't confuse the rents. going up with the viability of durable demand for GPU rentals. And
37:43these prices, given depreciation, should be falling all things equal. And the big risk here is that, you know, if this actually shows credit stress, then demand and spot value for GPUs, it can end up falling. And you know, that's
38:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
38:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, not just falling for the sake of falling and other. oh, I wish it was better, but but that's what's collateralizing the loans to help enable this AI flywheel. So so that that you know, large chunk of the collateral in this larger complex, having that sensitivity and the fragility and the ability um to have this occur, uh, it's it's definitely uh sort of this this systematic risk.
38:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
38:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): this AI boom, not just AI. a technology story anymore, it is increasingly becoming a financing story. Also in the news, a new short report is targeting AMD and its exposure to China. Yesterday, Hunterbrook Media published an investigation titled AMD Has Its Own China Problem. Its affiliated hedge fund, Hunterbrook Capital, disclosed that it is short AMD. The central claim is this I.e. IEIT T systems, which is a Chinese server maker that the Commerce Department blacklisted in March 2025, has kept putting newer AMD firmware into its servers. Hunterbrook counted at least six newer versions since the blacklisting, most recently in an update posted on October 19th. The report also ties three other server sellers to IEIT, including Averiz Averes in California, which AMD lists as a partner for its instinct AI chips. The bigger issue is regulation. A new Commerce Department rule that took effect November 19th requires licenses for advanced chips shipped to Singapore and four other countries. AMD billed $4.28 billion to Singapore customers in fiscal 2025, over 10% of its sales. China and Hong Kong made up another 22%. of revenue. And in January 2027, a separate rule could extend
39:43restrictions to companies that are majority owned by blacklisted firms. Hunterbrook says AMD did not answer its questions.
39:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, look, you know, Hunterbrook is a newsroom with its own hedge fund, right? So, you know, and that fund is short AMD. So its profits uh go up if the stock falls. So you gotta keep that in mind, right? They're they're they're pushing this narrative at the same time as they're shorting the thing. Um, but uh I I think that the claim is still serious, right? Especially uh if you see the new regulations uh and and the new regulatory framework coming out in regards to chips and compute in China. And so the US is blacklisting Listing uh, you know, the Chinese servers and and all of this, and um it it's it's it's it's a concerning picture to see the percentage of of their sales uh by location, which we pulled up on the screen here. You know, Hunterbrook says that that IEIT kept loading newer AMD firmware after um you know these these bans and things, and so at least six different versions too. And so, you know, the latest on October 19th nineteenth, under US rule. rules, a software update counts as an export. And so that's important to note as part of this as well. And based on AMD's 2025 annual filings, customers billed in China and Hong Kong made up seven point seven five billion dollars, which is twenty two percent of its thirty four point six
41:07billion dollars in sales. Singapore was another four point two eight billion dollars, about twelve percent. And so you know when you add that all up, that's a lot for the region, and and that's a lot for you know China and proxies of China uh in total. And so, you know, the the market saw AMD as this clean alternative after the whole Jensen scandal where he was forced to step down um back on the on the twelfth of this month, which seems so long ago, but it's just a few days back. Um and but then
41:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know
41:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): everyone kind of wanted to sidestep and and view them as sort of this safe bet after, you know, the the double oh seven Chinese espionage, all all of that of of the of the Jensen saga, only to find out in AMD's annual filings that about twenty two percent of sales were billed to China, uh in Hong Kong and in Singapore. And and um and so the stock, of course, uh felt this. They closed down seven point 7.7%. Um, and you know, a after falling as much as eleven percent during the days. They did make kind of a a recovery after the initial news came out, but still uh getting hit over the head by this. So the the hedge fund that, you know, their media arms releasing this is certainly making a profit.
42:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think we've lived a full year in the last week. Let's go to tokens now because in AI that's how everyone keeps score. Tokens are the chunks of text a model reads and writes. Oh, and that scorebook scoreboard just flipped. According to OpenRouter, the platform developers used to switch between AI models. OpenWaite models handled 27% of tokens in October 2025. By the end of September 2026, they handled 72%. And then the pie exploded. Weekly volume across Open Routers top models went from about 5 trillion tokens to about 117 trillion in that same stretch. Closed models grew almost tenfold. Open models grew more than 60-fold. The twist is who's doing the work? As of Thursday, Day, eight of Open OpenRouters' Routers' top 10 models are Chinese, led by Tencent and Deep DeepSeek. Sea. And OpenRouter says open models cost about a quarter as much to run. The closed labs still own the quality crown, but developers are voting with their wallets, and cheap and fast is winning, Sean.
43:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, absolutely. And and I I think it's just gonna be this distinction between
43:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
43:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the sustainability of of companies using these subscriptions. It's just a matter of incentives. And I think that this should be pretty plainly obvious for everybody examining it. You know, are the Frontier Labs coming out with great technology? Yes, right. But the open weight models are just a few months behind them. They're very near frontier quality. And keep in mind they don't censor you and they protect your data. And there's free token usage. So you don't have to pay this recurring subscription or pay per token. So you just got to look at the at the incentives here, right? The majority of the revenue for these frontier models isn't retail, right? It's corporations, it's corporate spending, it's institutional spending. And so it's these institutions don't necessarily. necessarily need frontier level compute, right? Somebody like an Eli Lilly probably do. They probably want that, right? Because they're trying to cure cancer. Somebody like uh, you know, uh the Wall Street Journal or Ford Motor Company, they might decide hey, we don't need frontier, we just need something good enough. Or let's say it's uh uh a national insurance agency that wants to help with legal. lead generation optimization and inefficiency or underwriting calculations
44:55and things like this, you know, you're not trying to solve cancer like an Eli Lilly. And and so you just need something good enough to continue to optimize. And these open weight models continue to get better and better and better and better. You don't have to be on the cutting edge. And so now that they're good enough and they're gonna going to continue to get better, and you can custody your own. data, customers' data, clients' data. You don't have to worry about a third-party and counterparty risk on the data front. You don't have to worry about your IP leaking to solve hard math problems. And at the same time, you know, you're not having to pay all of your annual token budget and blow through it in a quarter because you have unlimited compute as long as you know you have your electricity you know, electrical costs. coverage on your servers. So I think that is sort of the elephant in the room. It needs to be addressed. You know, I'm not saying demand goes to zero for these frontier models. I'm just saying there's a structural issue where it's institutional and corporate demand, but the incentives for those customers
45:55are to just to move to open source.
45:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): You know, we started this segment talking about the rising prices of rent for these NVIDIA. chips. Um, meanwhile, customers are looking to spend less. And, you know, I've heard people debate. I mean, maybe you just answered this because you talked about how this will come down to institutional demand. But I think about um, you know, retail. I mean, they're not spending the $200 a month subscription. Honestly, I mean, I would. I use it enough, you know, and like it it the cost it it kind of outweighs the cost. Um, but how important is that having retail in there? And then when you look at a company like Anthropic, uh, does that put even more pressure on Anthropic and these other AI companies to be profitable?
46:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, look, I
46:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean
46:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and that's I think this is the question of that that that prompted my my response the other day of Anthropic needs to be like Amazon, right? Where and anthropic is not going to be able to survive on just trying to sell to corporations. They need to go and they need to cannibalize these corporations. They need to go and they need to replace NVIDIA. They need to go and they need to have their med tech arm go and start to develop things that they can patent and sell or Or or whatnot. So they need to go, they need to try to cannibalize the world. And I think they understand that. And I think that's what they're actually going to do.
47:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think Dario wants it to just be him and the government left.
47:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, or try to do, right? I'm not, you know, no one knows if they're going to be successful. I meant to say that's what they're going to try to do. That will certainly be their aim.
47:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): All right. We're going to take a quick break, but coming up next, Blocks owned Janessa Lopez says: Bitcoin is already buying your coffee. So why isn't it being treated like money yet? Her answer coming up after the break.
47:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Real estate has stored wealth for generations.
47:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
47:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): what happens when absolutely scarce digital money challenges that role? In digital real estate, Leon Wankum explores how Bitcoin is reshaping property, capital allocation, and the future of investing. Digital real estate. Available now.
48:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Think about the last conversation you had. Somebody said something you wanted to remember or follow up on. You didn't. Plod Nopin S provides a hands-free way to capture conversations the moment they happen. No fumbling with your phone, no scrambling to write things down. One press and it's recording. Pin it, strap it, hang it. It's on you and ready when the conversation starts. Then Plod's AI turns your conversation into a transcript showing who said what and a summary of key points and action items.
49:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): How's my rent up thirty percent? My washer ain't thirty percent fixed, but my landlord wants thirty 30% percent more money. Bro,
49:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you know investment firms are buying up all the houses. They got like half a million houses.
49:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): How
49:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): come every time them Wall Street boys crash the economy, they always get to keep the money?
49:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That
49:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): makes
49:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): no sense. That makes no sense. That
49:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): makes no sense.
49:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Block, the company behind Square and Cash App, has released its 2026 Bitcoin Payments Report covering November 1st, 2025 through October 15, 2026. The data shows Bitcoin being used for everyday purchases. The median Bitcoin payment on Square was $13, and nearly two-thirds of payments were under $20. Food and drink made up 72% of them. Larger purchases still carry weight. Payments of $20 or more were just 2% of transactions, but nearly 31% of the total value. Block also found that 44% of payments came from repeat customers. On the merchant side, about one in four cited tax complexity as a barrier, and Block is using the report to push for a tax exemption on small Bitcoin payments. For more on Block's new Bitcoin payments report and its push for that tax exemption on small payments. Joining us now is Janessa Lopez, head of digital assets and emerging tech policy at Block. Janessa, great to have
50:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you. Hi,
50:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): thank you for having me.
50:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So we just ran through some of the insights from that block report. Can you tell us what stood out to you? What were the biggest takeaways and what do you want lawmakers to take away from it?
50:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, thank
50:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you. You went through some of
50:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the really
50:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): key points that I
50:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): would have highlighted myself.
50:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think
50:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): also one of the most interesting insights, in my opinion,
51:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): is
51:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): regarding retention. Customers come back. 86% of repeat payments to the
51:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): same
51:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): merchant happen within 30 days, and 16%
51:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): happened happen
51:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the same day. And so
51:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): although
51:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): adoption is still early, paying with Bitcoin appears to be fitting into familiar routines like
51:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): grabbing coffee
51:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or lunch. So, I mean, we've been faced with a question quite frequently of is anybody actually using their Bitcoin to buy a cup of coffee? And it turns out, yes, some people are. Another interesting finding is where the payments are coming from. Payments aren't just coming from within the block ecosystem. About 43% of payments are from cash. App wallets, but seven
51:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): 57% come from outside Lightning enabled wallets such as Strike, Wallet of Satoshi, Phoenix, and Coinbase. And those external wallets represent 66% of total value, demonstrating that the broader Bitcoin ecosystem is at work here.
51:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And in the report, one thing that stuck out to me was that approximately one in four merchants are citing tax complexity. as the barrier to accepting Bitcoin. Beyond tax exemption, what else, you know, would make it easier for small businesses to say yes at checkout for accepting Bitcoin?
52:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
52:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): thank you for highlighting that. Uh yeah, we also found that a quarter of businesses cited tax and accounting complexity is the reason why that they are not accepting Bitcoin payments currently. I think there's a few other reasons. Um, this was a morning consult um report that we came out with, but volatility was another reason. I think just not understanding the technology, making it easier, that was a friction point. So I think Square being kind of like the first major company to unlock that friction for a way for people to pay and accept Bitcoin easily is happening. but there's still a learning curve. I think there still needs to be more education on how that works. And so we kind of did sort of a grassroots call to action for people who are Bitcoiners and want to use it as money to go to their local square seller and pay with Bitcoin and teach them how to accept it, inform them that they even can accept it. So some square sellers still are at the very early stages of. even knowing this is a capability that they offer on our platform. So things like that. But education, I think, is is the fundamental thing.
53:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
53:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): the House Digital Asset Tax Bill's $10 de minimis rule covers only network fees and doesn't give any relief for actual Bitcoin and crypto payments. What would a workable exemption look like for everyday purchases?
53:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
53:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): that that's really unfortunate because we've been advocating for this as an industry for several years now. Um, just to like zoom out, there is a crypto tax package that's moving through Congress at the moment, one in the House and one in the Senate as part of that. It does include tax and reporting relief for stable coins entirely. And as you mentioned, only a $10 de minimis for gas fees. Nothing. for consumer payments. And so that's a real gap. And that's also an area where the need is massive for people who actually want to use it in their daily lives as a form of payment. So the relief currently in these bills is mostly for active traders, people who are very sophisticated in using digital assets, but doesn't really help those who are wanting to use it in a more casual way. So um that's something we're advocating for still. I think this data really helps make that case even stronger. What has been lacking for policymakers is really just data and I think a push to understand like who is actually using this in that way. Do people want this policy change? Do we need it? Um, Block has been at the forefront of advocating for this. I think they hear from us quite often. often, but they're not really hearing from constituents as much. And I think we need that voice to be a little bit louder for
54:58them to feel the pressure and include that in this tax package.
55:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Aaron Powell
55:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And since early October, regulators have withdrawn proposed rules on self hosted wallets and coin mixing, plus a plan to cut the travel rule uh reporting threshold to 250. With those off the table now, what's the next self-custody or financial privacy fight that you know Bitcoin users should be watching?
55:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, that those were huge actions that were rescinded from Gensler era. Um
55:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
55:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think we should be super hap happy and excited that the current administration is doing something about that. I think now that they've rescinded these really problematic rulemakings and guidances,
55:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
55:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): next step is to try over the next two years to actually secure something through the difficult regulatory process of rulemaking, so that when the next administration comes, if there's somebody who's not very pro-crypto, that they can't just undo it. and overturn it. And I think that's what happened with this guidance that's been overturned. That can happen if something has not gone through the full regulatory rulemaking process. So we're hopeful that over the next year, before the Congressional Review Act gets kicks in, that these agencies will be able to solidify some things. One thing in particular is the FinCEN FINSIN 2019 guidance for custody. of wallets. That essentially says that control, total independent control, is a necessary factor in money transmission. And that's something that we advocated for to be included in the Clarity Act. Obviously, that bill ultimately failed. So those protections were not codified in statute, but we do believe there's a path for FinSN Finston and the Treasury Department to
56:48put that through official rulemaking. So it's not just guidance and that it will be there for the future to come.
56:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Another bill we've had our eye on is the Developer Safe Harbor Bill. It's stalled in September and would have protected Bitcoin developers. When you meet with policymakers in DC, what's the one message you want them to know No and one understand understands about protecting these developers?
57:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, I think this development. developer conversation is evolving now with the development of open source AI. And so I think there's a lot of overlap between what we've been advocating for on the digital assets side for blockchain developers, as well as now open source AI developers. And the argument is the same. I think we want to democratize access. And that's what we stand for as an industry. And also as Americans, I don't think that's necessarily a partisan position, but we it gets a little complicated once you start saying, okay, we do not want permissioned regulations on permissionless networks. And so
57:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
57:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): question then becomes consumer protection. Like, how are you going to guarantee that? Um, that's still lines that are. being drawn and will probably take time for those to clearly be drawn for AI and crypto. Both industries are now facing these issues. But overall, I think that's why it's critically important that we have the agencies at least step up in this next two-year period when we don't expect Congress to do much to help like advance those protections as much as possible. as much as possible.
58:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And Janessa, on that topic of Congress, you know, we we just saw a a large change in the mix-up of who is in Congress and in both the Senate and the House. At the same time, we're seeing, you know, the former champion of this industry, Senator Cynthia Lumis, retiring. Um, you know, so so the digital asset agenda is now resting in this new Congress that had a lot of turnover. Um, you know, Stand with Crypto is saying this might be the most pro-crypto Congress we've seen. Um, but at the same time, you know, the end result is that you know it it seems we're about to get, you know, s um
59:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
59:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Elizabeth Warren in charge of Senate banking again, uh Maxime Waters on the House side, um, who were both there during during previous times where this industry was was persecuted. So do you see um you know the the tides truly changing um and and policy kind of being downstream from that? And where do you think uh is is the strongest bipartisan opening to start to get some Bitcoin policy across the line throughout the next two years?
59:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, great question. I think we are truly at an inflection point. Now that we're operating in a post-Clarity world where crypto has unfortunately become a partisan issue, and the Dems, like you said, have overwhelmingly taken control of Congress. The hope I have for comprehensive market structure legislation moving through Congress like Clarity is very low. I truthfully don't see Democrats who will be taking over the finance committees, like you mentioned, wanting to provide regulatory. clarity for the industry. But I do see them focusing on oversight and hearings. And I think there's going to be a lot of noise and opposition coming from that side of the house. And so while rulemaking and guidance will be happening at the agencies, and I think we've already seen some great amount of positive work come comes from the SEC and the CFTC in particular, I think we'll be really relying on them heavily because now they have the political cover and the urgency to move over the next two years. Now, where I do see opportunity is as it relates to crypto tax. I do see that happening in the near future. I think there's some low-hanging fruit that already has good a good amount of bipartisan support and could get across the finish line, hopefully including into minimis for payments. Um, but ultimately we are
1:00:52resetting come January in this new Congress. And I really see next year as a huge education opportunity, first and foremost.
1:01:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So there's education next year, but you know, in some ways it kind of feels like all the work has to start over when Congress resets. So for Bitcoin users and the small businesses that accept Bitcoin as payment, what can they do to make 2027 the year Bitcoin is treated like money?
1:01:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, like I said earlier, I think their voices are critical and they need to be heard. And I think any opportunity Bitcoiners who truly care about this issue have to contact their representatives federally, whether that's in the House or in the Senate, would make a huge difference that this crypto. at this critical point. Like I said, they're hearing a lot from Bloc and from trade associations and organizations broadly, but what we keep hearing is
1:01:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they're
1:01:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): not hearing it from enough of their constituents, from like the individual users. And so if we could amplify people's voices and create a groundswell of that grassroots movement, I think that's really what we need.
1:02:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:02:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): on that topic of education, um, you know, the the common joke in in Bitcoin land is, you know, the number go up technology is the best marketing mechanism for Bitcoin. Um, do you see this as a sort of price action, Bitcoin trending down over the past several months? Do you see that as an obstacle when when you know we're we're discussing educating whether it's uh politicians on Capitol Hill? or onboarding merchants. Is that something where you know these these conditions make it a little bit more difficult for us to do that right now?
1:02:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I personally don't really think it does from our perspective. We don't focus on the fluctuations of price of Bitcoin. I mean obviously that's been happening since its creation. It doesn't phase us too much as a company, although it is shocking, I think, for people to look at and be a little concerned. For our approach to how we discuss Bitcoin payments in particular, it's not necessarily number go up. It's really just about an open network and creating another opportunity for people to pay however they want to. And so, and also for merchants to utilize another payment rail that has zero fees um through the end of 2027 now. So I think it's an opportunity for people to just have expanded access. And we talk more so about that than the actual price.
1:03:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Of Digital Assets and Emerging Tech Policy for Block. Thanks so much for joining us. It was great having you.
1:03:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank
1:03:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you so much. Bye.
1:03:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
1:03:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): right. Well, we are watching the live price of Bitcoin brought to you by Cash App, and it has fallen below 60K, sitting around 59,500 right now. That's down about 13% this week. Sean, what does this mean? Are we headed toward a new low?
1:03:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, look, uh, obviously did not want to see that 63 level, 62 level. that I've been talking about in the newsletters uh break. We just saw it uh break pretty conclusively here on shorter candles. Uh again, the weekly chart is what's really gonna matter. Um, can it get a bounce here before the weekly close? That's when it starts to become more significant. But nonetheless, you gotta got to remember right now our current bear market bottom is around 58. 58.5. And so you want to see that level certainly hold. Maybe you get a nice double bottom. But there's also kind of the contrarian take of someone like a bin Cowan or someone who's you know, DCAing DCA ing into Bitcoin right now that says, hey, let's just rip the band band-aid aid off. Let's print a max. pain candle below that 58. And you know, it'll probably be eaten up pretty quickly. You probably come back up to these levels, you know,
1:04:58snap back fairly fast. But I know there's a lot of market participants that would like to see us hit, you know, more max pain for miners, have a couple more on-chain metrics uh get hit. Uh not that they have to get hit, not that they owe us uh anything, uh, but sort of like sort of this total refresh and then you can see people being more confident to come in and bid at these levels and and start to build a base heading into that next market. But you know, um either way, I mean we're we're we're pretty much near a bottom zone, right? It's you know whether it goes down uh a bit from here, whether it bounces from here, it's more or less the same bottom. I mean, we're hosting this show today at what we'll retrospectively look back at as the depths of a bear market. So either way, um, you know, probably a good time to stack some coin if if you believe in the in the in sort of the long-term thesis of Bitcoin. Um, and then just HODL. So uh HODL, hold on for dear life. Um, Bitcoin is a volatile asset. It's becoming less volatile. Again, this is you know a
1:05:5950% something, 50-something 50 something percent decrease from top to bottom, from peak to trough. Typically, we see stuff in the 70s and the 80s. So uh relatively mild compared to previous cycles. Uh certainly it's not fun though. Um, and and so you know, we you want to see it turn around here uh you know, post haste. But Bitcoin doesn't give you what what you want, and oftentimes it refuses to start the next cycle until you feel max pain. And and many people think we just have. haven't felt that yet. So uh th for those people, this could be something to kind of get them back on board if if we break under that fifty eight K level here. Um but uh I I do expect the bulls to come in and give some bidding here around that fifty eight fifty eight five level.
1:06:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well let's dive a little bit deeper here because with Bitcoin sliding this month, the pressure is landing on the companies that mine it. So how much does it actually cost? them to produce one coin and what does it mean for price when Bitcoin trades below that line? It's time for chart of the day.
1:07:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, so you know, today's chart of the day is what it actually cost the public miners to produce one Bitcoin. And this is one of those sort of max pain metrics that we traditionally we look at. But this is also why it's been so hard to come out and kind of call a bottom. This cycle for mini metrics has looked very different, right? We didn't get a lot of metrics firing at the top that you would have expected to call a top. And we're also not getting mini firing near these relative lows that you would have expected to mark what would be a bottom. And I think that at least on the bottom side, perhaps that's just because the market looks so different. And one of the places the market looks so different is Bitcoin mining. Uh, you know, and uh notably uh you know, the amount of Bitcoin being sold um throughout the past year or two, as well as this transition to AI from a lot of these data centers that have historically been hosting Bitcoin mining operations. And so with the what this chart looks at is um you know the cost that public miners can produce on Bitcoin versus uh you know what they sell it for. And obviously that spread is the whole mining trade through 2024 and 2026 or 2025, price lived above that line. Uh so you know you you watch the cost climb through 2024 on the visual aid here, and then the having cut their reward in half, and
1:08:24the cost per coin went from about 50. $50,000 to about $80,000 by year end. 2026 is where things began to just break. uh 500. So the public mining sector as a group was mining below the cash break even. Today we're at 62.3 K. That's 70, or I guess you know, since I wrote the uh this chart this morning, uh, you know, right now we're at we're at 50, 59 K. So uh need to update the chart uh next time in real time. Maybe Grockbach can help with that. But you know we're we're probably about 19% under the industry's latest cash cost. And that's the conservative number. The network wide estimates around 85K.
1:09:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:09:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): if you add depreciation, uh and and and most of the big listed miners are gonna be north of that. So price has spent about half of this year under this line. Uh you know, it's historically been a pretty important line in the sand. It crawled back above it in the spring and again late summer, and it lost it both times. Now we're looking at this because historically, the bear market bottoms tend to form lower, where only the most efficient operators are still making money. And that's right where you know we are outside of an important caveat that the cheapest listed producers, Hive, the Deer, Iron, all sit between about 60 and 65k a coin. You know, we're trading on top of the low low-cost cost producers still. So while we're under the industry average, it's certainly not max pain for the miners due to these a fit more efficient operators. And
1:10:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): when
1:10:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the math breaks, miners are usually shutting machines off. You know, the difficulty then will adjust down. We have the difficulty adjustment as part of Bitcoin's code. And then the survivors are just simply getting a bigger slice of that pie. And that's happening right now. Difficulty just dropped 9%. one of the biggest cuts of the year. However, you know, this cycle, the public miners made a different choice. They've been rotating their balance sheets out of Bitcoin and into power and AI infrastructure. Mera, for example, has sold about 40,000 Bitcoins this year, roughly five times what they mined. So right after Q3, they sold 13,600 coins in about six weeks. That's roughly a month. of the entire network's new supply being dumped onto the market by one company. You know, Riot sold more than six times its production last quarter. Uh, you know, BitDeer and Keel went to zero. Core Scientific is you know exiting mining by year-end. So a megawatt leads leased to AI earns about three times what it earns mining. That's been the primary driver. It's just a business decision maximizing uh value for shareholders. Um, and and so what's happening is while they're transitioning, the machines stay on as a placeholder for the power they haven't leased yet. And the coins are getting sold
1:11:28to fund these build-outs. Now, that's a big reason this mining cost grinding has lasted to lasted 280 strings. straight days with price under its cost estimate. That's this is a very long, prolonged grind. Normally you wouldn't see it be lasting this long under that line, and notably uh even longer than the 2018 bear market, uh, which was a bit brutal there for miners. So, you know, miners don't set the price day to day. The whole network does that, and
1:12:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
1:12:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, the whole network only mints about 450 coins a day right now. Roughly $28 million of economic value at today's prices of $59,000 a coin.
1:12:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
1:12:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): contrast that to spot ETFs, right? They bled about $1.9 billion over seven straight sessions this month. That's around 10 times what the network mints per session if you're just comparing these two metrics. And you know, minor inventory, it's finite at the end of the day. right? Mara started the year with about four, fifty, yeah, I think it was fifty-four thousand coins. They're down to roughly twenty. Uh, so you know, Riot was down uh about twenty four hundred by September. And and and you know, the next halving at the same time, we're expecting to land around April of twenty 2028. twenty-eight, and that pushes this cost line up again. So, you know. the survivors will be cheap power, likely with some AI contracts paying the overhead, frankly. With price being about 18%, 19% under the industry's cash and sitting on the on right on top of these low cost producers, you know, that's the zone where cyclical bottoms have typically formed, a little bit lower, perhaps, frankly, just to get the max pain on the minor miner side. And of course,
1:13:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there
1:13:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): is now this gap between uh, you know, the large players uh and and the network average. You know, we've yet to hit the lower, more efficient levels yet as a result of of sort of the the changing and dislocated nature between uh the mining industry, which which that's always existed, but I just think it's been And amplified or magnified now with the with the introduction of AI and the amount of selling that we're seeing and um you know, I think that this pivot to AI and the systematic dumping of coins for the non-forced reasons has caused this time to truly be different. Uh, but you know, the the mining treasuries behind the 2026 corporate selling are a fraction of what they were, right? And and and they're less um, you know, overhead supply is how a base starts to get built. right? They're running out of powder to dump. And so I think that the first confirmation that we should look for to see some sort of reversal in this trend is, you know, the 200-week average, uh, obviously. Right now that's up near 68K. You know, a full confirmation is going to be back above the industry cost, a reclaim of that line, which we're looking at in the chart, which right now would be a reclaim up of 75. 75k. And you know, I I think that, you know, given the price action we're seeing today, it looks like the market is demanding that we hunt for
1:14:34um some more pain, max pain as they call it. Uh quite fitting that it's that it's during the the end of the cryptoverse conference this week that the price is is going out to set a new low. So Uh, you know, this is something Ben Cowan's been been you know kind of uh expressing for for many months. now uh and has gotten a lot of hate for. So uh I guess credit to him for sticking with it and and sticking through. Um but uh I do think it's reasonable for us to expect uh the first half of 2027 to see some sort of turnaround, right? I I I think that um we'll we'll see less structural sellers in the front end of this next leg. And I think that's when we start to see some real momentum. Um You know, the the difficulty adjustment is real. This is a mining uh chart that has, you know, turned out to be fairly uh reliable throughout various cycles. We're pretty close to max pain. This time seems to have been drawn out just because of how different uh the industry has become with AI compute and sort
1:15:34of this strategic uh selling, which has been indifferent. of hash or price. And so now that that inventory has largely been churned through, there's less powder to dump on us as we head into 2027. And also we're starting to hit some of those max pain levels that would be indicative of us finding a true cyclical bottom. So, you know, a lot of pain on days like today where you see the price just kind of continuing to flow. to fall, um, although relatively less than gold. And um, you know, it's it's it's just interesting to look at charts like this and say, look, um, for some reason history loves to repeat, and Bitcoin does tend to be cyclical. Um and just because something like the mining industry had such a huge uh change in and how it's operating and and what it's looking like, it's still hunting out these max pain levels. But the good news is it looks like uh, you know, the the woods is starting to thin out and we've trekked our way through through a good bit of it on the mining side. Maybe a bit more to go, perhaps. Um,
1:16:38but the fog is starting to lift um and and at the same time we're seeing that the majority of this dumpable inventory is in fact eaten through and behind us as we enter 2027, where a lot of other metrics should start to be flipping around the same time.
1:16:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, and you know, not to pour salt in the wound, but we are also headed toward another halving in 2028. So if miners are already struggling at today's prices, does the next halving accelerate the industry's kind of pivot into AI?
1:17:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, look, um, the have the halving would be very good for Bitcoin, right? It's gonna be this supply shock. So um this would be a very bullish thing. That's why we typically set our all-time highs, um, our new all-time highs each cycle sh in short order after the halving. It's because of the supply and demand nature of a scarce asset and the new issuance coming in. That that's that's why we call Bitcoin deflationary by nature. And so um, you know, this past cycle, for example, we actually front ran that for the first time. We set a new all-time all time high before the halving. So that's the the halving is something very bullish. It should have a very positive impact on Bitcoin's price action.
1:17:44Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And you mentioned Mara has sold, I mean, half of its Bitcoin. Um if these companies eventually run out of reserves they're willing to sell, could that, you know, looking ahead to the twenty twenty seven recovery um you were opining on there, um, if they run out of reserves to sell, could that remove a major source of the selling pressure? Yeah,
1:18:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that's exactly the point, right? It's like, it's like they've churned through most of what is sellable, right? So they're selling what's going to be sold, the majority of which has already been sold. A lot of what's left too is accounted for. So this is another interesting point. A lot of what's left on their books is is already attributed to, hey, we're going to use this to make do on convertible notes later. So until those come to maturation, they're not going to be selling these coins in the open market. Um and then another point I want to hit on is like, you know, you we we talk about how there's no boogeyman to point to. Everyone, everyone loved to throw cake at Doquan and SBF. And, you know, you you're a forced seller of Bitcoin and and you and you did this to us. Um and this time around, because there's no obvious, you know, forced selling, everyone I've seen on Twitter recently, uh, and people that generally have very good takes are coming out and saying, hey, Bitcoin's price would be much higher if it wasn't for the treasury companies and just kind of blaming the treasury companies. Well, they're actually all still net buyers, right? They're adding buy pressure to Bitcoin. Um, why are we not talking about these mining companies? Companies that have been in the space forever. Obviously, you know, you you can't knock on them too hard for just. simply pursuing uh increased revenue with AI. I mean, they have a duty to their shareholders, but look at who's actually selling Bitcoin, guys. It's the mining companies. You know, there's they're
1:19:25selling thousands of coins, more you know, to the nth degree, more than are that are being brought online every day. So if you want to point the finger at a forced seller or the reason the Bitcoin price is suffering, you know, maybe we start looking. at who's dumping copious amounts of coins into the open market in a fire sale. And for over a year now, that's been the Bitcoin miners.
1:19:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Good point there. Um as we speak, Bitcoin continue to tick down. It's around $59,070 here, down 5% on the day. But that just means it's a great buying opportunity if you believe in the long-term long term thesis of the coin. And what when you're evaluating your cold storage setup, you shouldn't be looking for a company to tell you their product is bulletproof. You want to be able to see how it works, know that other people could inspect it, and understand how they handle issues when they come up. That transparency is why we are big fans of BitKey. BitKey is open source, which means independent researchers can inspect and test its software. BitKey also maintains a public security update. updates page. When a confirmed bug has been fixed and is safe to disclose, BitKey explains what happens, the potential customer impact, the fix, and whether customers need to take action. That kind of transparency matters when you're choosing how to protect your Bitcoin. Security isn't a promise that nothing will ever happen. It's the work a company does before, during, and after an issue is found. Download BitKey today and use our promo code. BMTV to get 10% off the second generation BitKey. This episode is sponsored by BitKey. Now, with Michael Saylor's strategy currently sitting around 80, ooh, nope, it's 79 now, down more than 80% from its all time high
1:21:06of $543 back on November of 2024. Investors had the opportunity to ask questions to the execs behind the work. world's largest corporate holder of Bitcoin. How did Saylor answer them? Well, we'll take a listen next.
1:21:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Companies
1:21:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): buy up all the
1:21:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): houses.
1:21:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That makes no sense. You
1:21:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): believe in Bitcoin. So why would you ever sell it? Life happens. An emergency expense, a new home purchase, or a great business opportunity. With salt, you can access the power of your Bitcoin without selling. Now with rates starting at 7.5%. The original Bitcoin back lender, no collateral losses, no rehypothication rehypothecation since 2016. Get your exclusive offer. at
1:22:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): SALTLending.com forward slash BMTV.
1:22:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Every year, this community comes together to celebrate, to debate, to build what comes next. And every year, the state stage gets bigger.
1:22:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Sound money center stage. So where do you go to celebrate the next chapter in Bitcoin history? You come home. Nashville, July 2027.
1:22:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Strategy held its Q3 investor QA call yesterday, hosted by Natalie Brunell, where investors sent in their questions. Executive Chairman Michael Saylor explained why a liquid market for stretch, strategy's preferred stock matters to strategy shareholders, and what the company is building for the long run. Let's take a listen.
1:23:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): You've sort of alluded to this in your answers, but I would love for you to just put a highlight again on why a liquid stable market for digital credit should matter to MSTR shareholders. How would you
1:23:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): explain that in a soundbite?
1:23:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): If the company has uh a liquid credit instrument, it has the option to sell 250 million of it in. a single day, capture the spread, and make anywhere from 250 million to 500 million dollars in six hours. Right? That's why. Right. The company can make a hundred million dollars an hour, right? When the credit markets turned positive, uh, when the credit markets were expanding, I think that we we had one day where we sold a billion dollars or or no, we traded a billion, but we issued. 500 million or more. And uh, and so I I I noted in a tweet today, STRC uh traded 600 million dollars yesterday. That was more than every income-bearing preferred stock in the U.S. capital markets this year. It's the single most liquid preferred income-bearing instrument
1:24:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in the
1:24:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): entire world, most likely, but certainly in the US capital markets this year. So being able to combine uh a shelf registration where you can issue it uh instantaneously with a credit instrument uh with a variable dividend rate means,
1:24:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
1:24:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): know, we are in a position to capture the spread. And if you believe Bitcoin's going up 10% a year, or sorry, more than 10% a year, then we could sell hundreds of millions or billions of dollars of this instrument. We never, we never pay the money back. The shareholders get all of the spread on the upside. And it is the most efficient financial tool, you know, maybe one of the most powerful ways to generate shareholders. shareholder value that,
1:25:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
1:25:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): know, has yet to be created. The reason that the company, you know, is the largest holder of Bitcoin in the world is because we created a $21 billion shelf registration, you know, in 2024. And when the cap when the equity capital markets became bullish, we actually issued all $21 billion in like four months, and we captured about uh $14 billion of shareholder value in four months.
1:25:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
1:25:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): know, so we made $14 billion for the company in four months because the equity capital markets were enthusiastic. We have a similar $21 billion type shelf registration on STRC when the credit market. markets expand, the company's in a situation that's similar where the the shareholder value created, if if um you believe the Bitcoin is going up twenty-two percent a year or twenty percent plus a year, when you sell a billion dollars of credit, you probably created two $2 billion dollars of shareholder value. And so the company might very well create twenty $20 to forty $40 billion dollars. billion of shareholder value very rapidly in an expanding credit market. And so that's why it's really important when the demand arrives, and when it arrives, it arrives at the rate of a billion dollars a week. And it might be billions, It it might arrive at the rate of $10 billion in a month. And you have to have the security. security, uh, you have to have the security listed and you have to have all the programs in place. And most importantly, you have to have the capital markets back in structure. You need, you need the programs to manage it, to issue it, to, you know, you need to the
1:27:05programs to manage it, you need uh the USD reserve, you need the cash balances, you need all of the structures that would give uh a credit credit and investor confidence in you.
1:27:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
1:27:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): reason the people bought $21 billion of our equity is because they knew that we believed in Bitcoin and they wanted to invest in Bitcoin. And it took us four years,
1:27:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,
1:27:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): four years of work to build the credibility uh and the trust in the market that they would trust us with the twenty-one 21 billion dollars of equity in a matter of weeks. And the credit business is the same way. You might very well invest years, two, three, four years,
1:27:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
1:27:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): the market's watching you for the four years. But there are people that value they run $50 billion portfolios,
1:27:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
1:27:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): they're looking and they have a zero allocation. And you know, after three years, they might very well look at you and say, Okay, I get it. I understand how they do it, I know they'll back it, I feel safe with. these guys. Go ahead and let's just buy five hundred million dollars of this week this week, and maybe we'll buy a billion next month, and then I'll tell my friends and they'll buy ten billion more. And that's how success happens in the financial markets. It's you work very hard and then it comes very rapidly. But it comes because smart money who have been watching you for years and years and judging your character and your and and your performance under stress and how you handle yourself, they make a decision, they flip a switch. And when they flip that switch, five hundred million dollars moves in thirty seconds. And it's either on or it's off. And when it's on, the most lucrative thing in the world is to create credit on top of capital, right? The central banking model of
1:28:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:28:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): buy a bunch of digital gold and I create a bunch of digital credit on the digital gold. It's it's the best business in the world if you can get it. It's just it's very challenging to create a central bank. The Bank of England did it hundreds of years ago, you know, the and the creature from Jekyll Island, people write about the Federal Reserve and what it took to do it. It's not easy to do it. Some of you have to start your own country. We're very fortunate with the bank of Bitcoin and we've established credibility. And the credibility has to be with the credit investors. It's the credit investors that legitimize a treasury company. It's not the equity investors and it's not the capital investors, although the equity investors. will assign the company a premium if they believe in the credit business. So when a credit investor says, I believe in you, we create obscene amounts of shareholder value. And then the equity investor says, I want to own a part of that treasury business because they they are going to be the biggest player in the market, you know, for as long as
1:29:59I can see. And everybody wants to buy the winner.
1:30:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Mm-hmm. All right.
1:30:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): We're unfortunately running out of time. So for our last question, I really want to focus on looking ahead because clearly you're making decisions maybe in the near term that will pay off in the long term. So can you just talk about what strategy is building and what investors may only appreciate in say three or five or seven years? And what investments in infrastructure or customer relationships matter? most today and the milestones that would show shareholders that those investments are really paying off?
1:30:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I'll go quick and then I'll leave the final word to Fong. Uh first of all, right? Our objective for STRC is we create a digital credit instrument with a duration, you know, four months, three to four months, shrink the duration. get to keep the vol, get the vol below 10, have the instrument pay 10 to 12 percent. And we think, you know, for a three-month duration instrument, 10 to 12 percent for an investment grade instrument with high liquidity, low volatility, is is a whirl beater product, a magic product. And um, so we will continue to try to build liquidity. Like we'd like to see it go. $600 million a day is great.
1:31:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
1:31:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): if we get to $500 million a day consistently or drive it toward a billion dollars a day. Building the liquidity is a big deal. Getting the volatility below $10 and keeping it there is a big deal. And uh and then expanding the AUM there's no reason why we can't grow it from an eight 8 billion or a seven 7 billion to a 10 ten to twenty 20 to forty 40 to eighty 80 to a hundred 100 billion dollar type product. And so that would be enough for the company to be a trillion dollar company. I wouldn't have to come up with any other ideas, but we think that stretch is a platform for other people to build cool things on top of and to be tokenized. And I won't dwell on it, but Fong might have comments on that. And then ultimately we feel like this exercise in ST. STRC is a stepping stone to eventually bring digital money to the market.
1:32:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:32:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): the and the ultimate idea is if you can create a money market, a digital, a one-night, uh, a one-day or two-day credit instrument, one where you could buy it at par and sell it two days later at par and collect 400 basis points more than your normal money market. a zero of all eight percent dividend yielding digital money, we think would also be a very magic product. I think I think there's a market for a three-month instrument that yields 10 to 12%, and there's a market for uh an overnight, a one or two-day instrument that yields seven to eight percent, and in a market where the risk-free rate is four. percent. Both of those require maturity, a lot of capital, a lot of net reserves. You have to start with tens of billions of dollars, and you have to have access to, you know, you have to have a lot of cash, a lot of Bitcoin and capital markets programs to do it.
1:33:09But I think those two things together are enough for the company uh to be, you know. we can go grab 1% of the credit market and we can sell hundreds of billions of dollars of credit. We can create an enterprise that's got a hundred a trillion dollar enterprise value. We create a multi-trillion dollar company just with those ideas. We might not even need the digital money. It might be just the digital credit is enough. And uh so we'll be laser focused on that. uh and and that future, and then helping other people that either want to invest with us or build products on top of
1:33:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): us. That
1:33:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): was Michael Saylor, executive chairman of Strategy. With that, let's take a look at how treasury companies are trading this morning. Strategy down around $80. Uh, that's coming off six straight loose. losing sessions, down six percent today, but down twenty-four percent over the last week. It's preferred stock stretch down over five percent across the last five sessions. Um, trading at $93 today. Taking a look at Strive now, it's at about $15 a share. That's down almost 8% this week. As Strive also coming off several days in the red, six straight to be exact, shedding 28% over that stretch of time. And its preferred shares, SATA also falling down almost 10% over the last five sessions, trading about 14% below its stated $100 value at about $86 per share. Metaplanet also coming off eight straight losing sessions in Tokyo, shedding nearly 24% since it's November. 10th close and setting a new 52-week low as its shares around a dollar down from its all-time
1:34:57high of 13 bucks. And its preferred shares Super League coming off three straight days in the red, trading.
1:35:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
1:35:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): let me pull that one up so we can have something exact here. Okay, it's at $3.39. That stock now down approximately 40%. from its October 21st close of $5.97. So these stocks, Sean, following the trajectory of Bitcoin.
1:35:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, well, that's what they're supposed to do.
1:35:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Right? They're
1:35:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they're they're levered bets on Bitcoin. So everyone loves the advantages that offers to the upside. Side, What's not so fun is what that means on the downside. You know, if this is
1:35:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): just a higher vol expression of Bitcoin price action, which they're engineered to be. I remember Michael Saylor used to have this example of a sales ship where he views the volatility of Bitcoin as energy, as the wind. And he wants to capture as much of it as possible and kind of let it blow him along. Um, now, of course, the wind can change directions. And so now we're seeing. the wind below us back towards shore. And so a lot of value that have been accrued as we sailed off from the bottom of the previous low up to now. You know, Strive, for example, was at $30. MSTR, for example, was up near $140. And now that has obviously uh come back to shore as the winds have changed directly. direction. But again, that's that's sort of by design. If you want to be speculating on these assets, um, it's best to do so with a longer term thesis, and you need to be able to stomach that volatility. Um, you know, just like uh anything in life, if if the outsizer turns on the upside are there, then there's a trade-off somewhere. And that's that you need to be willing to experience. these downswings in the interim as well. And so I don't think this is anything that should be surprising anybody. This isn't something that
1:36:58changes the long-term thesis behind these firms. Um, one thing that's notable too is unlike maybe years past, there's there's no uh mechanism for for forced selling with uh the majority of the firms in the this space now that they've moved over to amplification with production. preferreds. Um, so not something you want to see. Certainly painful for investors, but you know, this is something we've seen before and and we may very well see again in the future.
1:37:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And with Bitcoin trading below strategy's average
1:37:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): cost, how is the world's largest corporate holder of Bitcoin navigating the downturn? Chaitanya Kanye Jane joins us now, head of investor relations at strategy. Uh great to see you and thank you for joining us. So let's let's talk about it. Bitcoin hitting its lowest level since July this week, below Strategy's average cost. And yet,
1:37:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): your
1:37:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): colleague Michael Saylor says seller exhaustion will come long before sailor exhaustion. What is strategy thinking of the of the recent Bitcoin price action right now? And and what what is the company's current outlook?
1:38:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank
1:38:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): you so much for having me. I'm really excited to be here and what a day in the capital markets to be joining you. Um pretty volatile, pretty turbulent. But as you pointed out, you know, our balance sheet is super robust and we are extremely bullish on the future of strategy, on the future of Bitcoin.
1:38:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
1:38:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): what's happening with Bitcoin right now is um it's facing a lot of uncertainty. because of what's happening in the macro markets, uh in the geopolitical landscape, with the war in the Middle East, and with the AI CPEC cycle, and now increasing uncertainty in the AI trade.
1:38:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:38:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): all of that is uh hitting Bitcoin hard. Very clearly, the catalyst in the last one or two weeks that's been negative for Bitcoin is the anthropic. IPO. And that's almost a hundred billion dollar IPO. So we saw this with the SpaceX IPO earlier in the year. We're seeing it now with the anthropic IPO that people who look at Bitcoin as a risk-on asset are potentially selling Bitcoin, they're selling Bitcoin derivatives, and they're going long on the AI trade or anthropic. And what you will see is that there will be a rotation out of the AI trade. into Bitcoin again once there is a slowdown or there is perceived risk in the ecosystem. And eventually the bigger catalyst won't be the AI rotation, but it will be the monetary debasement. And as we all know, as Bitcoiners, the US dollar is designed to inflate. The governments around the world, include including including the US government, are running massive fiscal deficits. There is an impending sovereign debt crisis
1:39:43coming, and the Federal Reserve and other central banks can't hold the rates too high for too long. Once they lower the rates and once they're forced to print money to inflate the debt, everyone will chase Bitcoin again, everyone will chase gold again, and there will be an expansion in the credit markets and the equity markets, and strategy will benefit, Bitcoin will benefit. and the entire Bitcoin ecosystem will benefit. So that's our view on what's causing current um sort of slowdown and the reason for the headwinds. Um, but we are extremely confident about the future and the upcoming tailwinds.
1:40:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And we kind of knew this news was coming. We talked about it with Fong Li months ago, but MSCI will drop strategy. from its indexes after the close November 30th, um, saying it looks more like a fund than an operating company. How do you expect losing that index demand to shape strategy's uh shareholder
1:40:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): base and strategy's access to capital from there?
1:40:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): So we don't think uh it's gonna be a material change to a shareholder base. The decision that MSCI MSEI took was uh in our view very disappointing. They clearly have a lot of prejudice against the Bitcoin uh asset class and the ecosystem. And they think that what strategy does and what other Bitcoin treasury companies do doesn't account to be an operating business. Um, and hence they've classified strategy and other similar businesses as non-operating non operating companies, and they want to exclude us from the indices.
1:41:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But I
1:41:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): it won't be a material impact. The shares that track uh MSCI indices for strategy for MSTR is just about 3% of the outstanding shares. So those shares will be sold by the passive funds that have been tracking MSCI, that will be absorbed by the market fairly easily. MSTR's daily trading volume is in excess of 3% of outstanding shares. So because of the extreme liquidity, in our shares, the selling can be absorbed in a relatively modest manner. But the bigger uh question over here is not the impact to strategy, but it's the role that MSCI plays in the industry because uh an index provider is meant to be market neutral. They're not meant to choose winners and losers between industries, they're not uh supposed to have their prejudices play into how they view the market. They're meant to be market neutral, that's the entire point. And I think what you will see is uh a lot of pressure on MSCI from their clients and from regulators in writing this wrong over time. And the optimistic uh or you know, uh cheerful uh view over here right now is that other index providers don't seem to be taking this negative path. Uh in this index providers like Nasdaq. Russell, they remain very constructive and very optimistic on Bitcoin and the industry. And I think that's uh a
1:42:34very healthy sign. And over time, you'll actually see MSDR enter more indices as we grow bigger and other index providers become more and more progressive and they view the asset class more favorably.
1:42:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And Chaitanya, I'd like to pivot over to the preferred equity side. of the picture as well. You know, for from your perspective as head of investor relations, you know, what what are you seeing in the market behind what's driving the selling and how investors are engaging with these products? You know, you obviously have a whole suite of products, STRC being the most notable, uh, most volume on that side. Right now it's about $93. It's actually L. held up against this Bitcoin sell-off much better than uh it held up sort of at the beginning of the previous recoveries. And so it just seems like it's such this, it's such this new product that sometimes the moves seem to be irrational from an outsider looking in, kind of hard to make sense of. Um and you know, at the same time, strategy was successfully able to bring it back to par recently after spending more than $400. million buying it back over about two weeks. Um, you know, do you expect the buying to step back in here to bring it up to 100? Uh, and and what do you make of sort of the relative strength given the the size of this recent Bitcoin sell-off?
1:43:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
1:43:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): to start off, I appreciate you calling me by my first name, Chaitanya, but I also go by CJ, which is uh a lot easier for a lot of people to uh call me by, so you can always call me CJ. But uh digital credit is
1:44:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
1:44:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): new asset class, it's just two years old, and I think it's still evolving very rapidly. And STRC is a flagship product, and the main intention behind STRC is to strip away the volatility of Bitcoin. and provide a credit instrument that is lower wall, has a greater degree of price stability, and still passes through a very attractive yield tax defer, which is currently at 12%. And we've learned through market cycles in the last 18 months or so on how to deal with that stripping of wall. When we introduced STRC originally, it was a credit instrument paying 9%. And we only held Bitcoin assets on a balance sheet, and we only had an ATM program to sell more STRC into the market. And since then, STRC has evolved a lot. We added a dollar reserve. So we keep both Bitcoin assets and dollar assets because we realize that's better from the perspective of a credit investor to manage the downside.
1:45:15risk. So we have over three years of coverage for dividends through our dollar assets. What we also did is we went from monthly dividends to semi-monthly dividends to daily dividends, increased the frequency of the dividend payout, which uh is very attractive for a lot of retail investors and institutional investors. But perhaps the biggest thing in the mission of stripping the wall is we introduced buybacks. And we now actively have uh been buying back STRC from the market and we've been shrinking the supply outstanding. And you pointed out $400 million over two weeks. But if you actually uh look at a longer period, you'll see we've bought back almost $3 billion over five to six months, and it's gone from $10.5 billion to close to $7.5 billion. And I think the the big big insight over here, or the big lesson for us as the issuer and for investors in either STRC or MSTR or equity investors, is that the credit markets will expand
1:46:15and they will contract at different points in time. And we threw a we went through a big period of expansion for the first six months of this year when credit investors were enthusiastic and all the although Bitcoin was going down, and we issued a lot of STRC. And in the last four or five months, there's been a lot of um headwinds and uncertainty, and the credit markets have contracted, and hence we've just bought STRC back. And that's a natural feature of this product. And I think
1:46:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
1:46:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): other big point, as you as you pointed out, is when Bitcoin crashed to $60,000 or so earlier this year in June, STRC crashed hard. It fell below $80 because the product was less robust then. We didn't have the buybacks, we didn't have guardrails around a USD reserve.
1:47:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:47:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): now it's evolved. And people have understood our commitment to keep it at par and we've been able Being to keep it not exactly at $100, but it's not fallen as hard.
1:47:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:47:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): investors. appreciate that commitment that we have to keep it at par, to remove the wall from the product. And I think you'll see that with time, more and more people will understand what we are trying to do. And we will get better at what we are trying to do. And the wall will come down and you will see an expansion in the credit markets again. And then we'll issue $5 billion, $10 billion, $15 billion of STRC again. buy a lot of Bitcoin with it.
1:47:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:47:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): then there may again be a Bitcoin crash, and STRC may come down again.
1:47:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
1:47:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I think it's just the natural market cycle. And you'll keep see this uh playing out again and again.
1:47:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And you you talk about defending the peg and and you mentioned the sort of uncertainty, not only in the macro environment, but also specifically the credit stress we're seeing in in broader uh in industries and in the credit world. Um, you know, markets are seeing this December Fed rate height as is uh an absolute certainty at this point. It's just a matter of how much. Uh in many firms, like I believe JP Morgan uh put out a piece just the other day saying they're expecting three rate hikes by March. So um, you know, against that backdrop, strategy has decided to hold the STRC dividend at 12% for December, even as rate rates are climbing. So, you know, how how does strategy decide whether 12% is ultimately still enough to keep investors coming to SDRC?
1:48:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yeah, we've been thinking really, really hard about this question as to what is the appropriate dividend rate for STRC, and we've been thinking about it for a really long time. And our conclusion was that yes, in theory, we can increase the dividend rate from 12% to let's say 14%, 16%, 18%. It will bring in marginal demand. So it will push the price up faster, bring it to power faster, and we would then issue more SDRC, create more credit. But it won't be the healthy investor base that we want for SDRC. These will be a bit more risk-on investors that. have perhaps a different mindset. And what we want is to attract the risk-averse investors that want to hold SDRC for the right reason. And after a certain point, the higher the dividend rate goes, the higher the dividend burden for the company becomes, and hence the worse off the coverage ratios become.
1:49:35And it actually introduces more risk to the company. for both the credit investors and more importantly, even for the equity investors, the MSDR investors. It also increases the hurdle rate because what we are doing is we are capturing a spread between Bitcoin's appreciation rate and the cost of SDRC or the dividend rate. And the higher we push the dividend rate, the smaller that spread becomes. And it creates more anxiety for our MSDR investors. So our view is that we want to issue more credit and we want to grow amplification for the benefit of our equity investors, but we want to do it in a healthy, responsible manner. And hence we think 12% is the right ceiling for now for SDRC. And as we spend more time, you know, understanding the market, speaking with investors, our view may change in the future. We may think it's a bit higher or a bit lower. But for now, we think 12% is a sweet spot. And we want to identify, you know, how much demand exists for 12%.
1:50:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:50:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): maybe if it's lower than $7 billion, then we'll keep shrinking SDRC until we reach that point. And then we'll start expanding again from there.
1:50:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): As
1:50:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I mentioned, when the credit markets become enthusiastic again. So that's our view and rationale right
1:50:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): now.
1:50:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): SP S P rates. strategies uh its credit rating B minus below investment grade. With Bitcoin selling off right now, what does that do to strategies credit rating?
1:51:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Um it doesn't change SPU's view much because, and that's that's my um you know personal uh speculation. Let's say I I won't exactly know what their committee ever thinks, but that's because they don't give
1:51:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): us a
1:51:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): lot of credit for the Bitcoin in the first place. The way the credit rating agencies view a Bitcoin treasury company business is on a very, very conservative, archaic manner, and they give the highest risk rating to Bitcoin, which means they,
1:51:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
1:51:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): effect, mark down the Bitcoin assets on a balance sheet down to zero. And that's how they've viewed the credit risk in the first place. So the recent crash in Bitcoin's price won't uh I think force their hand to change the rating. If anything, it will actually continue to prove to them and to the market that we can still access capital markets very easily in a large scale during a Bitcoin bear as well. And that was one of the things they clearly called out in their initial rating report when it came out last year, which was they wanted to make sure that our use of uh convertible debt goes down over time, that we maintain robust cash reserves. And three, we show access to capital markets in a distress Stress scenario or during a Bitcoin bear. And the great thing is that we've shown all three of those things. So perhaps, you know, six months, twelve months, eighteen months later, they might take a more constructive view and they might actually, you know, in our view, look at increasing the rating. But I think the bigger impetus over here will be when there's a change in the Basel norms and the risk weighting for Bitcoin actually becomes better on an
1:52:51international standard. And I think for that, we'll need a lot more advocacy from us, from other groups. And I think we're just getting started over there. So one of the big catalysts for just the Bitcoin world and the financialization of Bitcoin will be the change in baselms over time.
1:53:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And CJ, you know, the the strategy at strategy has has changed through multiple. iterations over the years, right? From when Saylor first discovered this strategy out of necessity during COVID through the convertible note years and now with these prefs. But there's also some some OGs that are still, you know, very much investors in the firm and have sort of have sort of maintained. their thesis and remain directionally long with micro strategy. You know, seasons like this are certainly hard on those folks to see the price coming down of the common. And one of the most common concerns that I hear on forums or on X, for example, is concerns from some of these longer term holders that they feel as though the PrEF is being um you know propped up while the common is being diluted. and and maybe there's not as much uh you know direct support for the common shareholder. What what is your your answer to that? And do you think
1:54:11that their concerns are are being misplaced? And what would your message for those uh holders be?
1:54:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): So to start off, I would say that we are,
1:54:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
1:54:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): always trying to understand what our shareholders are thinking, both institutional and retail. long term, short term investors, old investors, new investors. So we don't take any uh comments or criticism lightly, and we you know want to listen to each one of our shareholders. And yes, we acknowledge that there are increasing concerns right now, and that's very natural. And there were a lot of concerns in the last Bitcoin bear market in 2022. And at that time, we had more debt on a balance sheet than we had Bitcoin on our balance sheet. And you know, that was a bigger cause for concern. And there was more existential risk for strategy at that point. But we came out of it, and we came out of it uh by having a lot of conviction in our strategy and our beliefs and by executing correctly.
1:55:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:55:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I think we're going through a similar period right now where
1:55:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
1:55:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): challenge of this bear market is the credit strategy that we've created is going through a period of volatility. And STRC investors buy STRC because they trust the company to honor the commitment to keep STRC close to power through our various tools that we have at our disposal. So for us, it's extremely important to do right by that promise and honor that commitment and basically do everything in our power to strip the world from Bitcoin and keep STRC close to power. And if we continue to do that and if we continue to honor that commitment, then existing STRC investors will trust us more and we will inspire. more confidence among future STRC investors who haven't even paid attention to strategy yet or who haven't paid attention to Bitcoin yet. But as Bitcoin grows bigger and as strategy grows bigger, there will be more people that will want to invest money in our capital structure. And we want to sell STRC to a lot of those future
1:56:23investors. And then they will look back and they will analyze how did strategy. act in a period of stress and did they honor the commitment of keeping STRC at power or not? And that's the key over here. If we inspire more STRC investors, then we will be able to issue more credit in the future and expand the capital structure and generate value or create value for our common equity investors. and for MSDR investors. So, yes, right now the act of keeping SDRC at par is a bit uh frustrating perhaps for some MSDR investors, but in our view, it's extremely important. And the entire management team is incentivized to grow MSDR value over time. All of us get paid equity in the form of MSDR MSTR and not SDRC. STRC. So our incentives are fully aligned and the last thing I'll say over there is that on a week-on-week basis, every decision we make uh with respect to our trading activities or capital market activities, be it issue MSTR to buy Bitcoin or issue MSTR to buy back STRC, we always make sure that we are doing it in an accretive manner on a net Bitcoin per share basis. So as long as
1:57:38the issuance of MSTR to buy STRC is short term accretive, we aren't necessarily destroying common equity shareholder value in the short term. And more importantly, in the long term, we are creating the optionality of issuing more SDRC and generating a lot of common equity returns. So I think this is just a short phase in the long arc of the company, and we'll get through it. But the way to get through it is to have conventional. conviction and to execute correctly. And we are very optimistic that we'll do that. And our large shareholders are as optimistic as ever. We saw in Q3 all our top institutional shareholders increase their position, all top 15 of them. So, you know, we continue to get the vote of confidence from uh our large investors. But obviously, we also want to make sure that our retail investors, small and large, remain happy and consistent. constructive on the long-term mission of the company.
1:58:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now,
1:58:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): CJ, we appreciate your time with us. But before you go, uh, looks like Bitcoin is gonna be closing our weekly show here around 59k. Obviously, not a great week for Bitcoin. Uh, not a good week in particular for strategy either. So I'm sure a lot of folks will be uh, you know, talking about the downside. I'd like to live, you know, leave on a positive note here and give you the chance to just share what's the silver lining here, right? What what should investors be thinking about? You know, why should they uh be staying positive long term here, especially when it relates to MSTR?
1:59:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Great way to end. Uh, I think what everyone should do is go back and study why you decided to buy Bitcoin in the first place or MSTR and what gave you the conviction. And the most important reason would be because you have long-term conviction in Bitcoin's price potential because Bitcoin is a scarce digital asset that will continue to grow in terms of a dollar. adoption
1:59:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
1:59:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): it has a fixed supply. And Bitcoin will appreciate at 20, 30, 40 percent on an annualized basis over the next 10-20 years, but it will have a lot of volatility in the interim. And that volatility is actually a gift to the long-term faithful investors. And the same applies for MSDR. MSDR MSTR is designed to be amplified Bitcoin. The mission of the company is to grow Bitcoin per share over the long term for MSTR investors to outperform Bitcoin over the long term. And when there is volatility like there is today, it's actually one of the greatest opportunities you may get. So for me personally, I realized I understood Bitcoin really well when I started getting excited when Bitcoin's price fell. And today I'm extremely excited. I'm trying to get my Bitcoin uh purchases going. I'm trying to find intelligent ways of getting more leverage. And the same applies for MSDR as well. I'm actually trying to see if I can uh get some more intelligent leverage on my balance sheet to
2:00:40see if I can increase my MSDR exposure, although I'm already incentivized with MSDR equity from the company. But I think days like these are incredible opportunities, and I think the future for Bitcoin remains extremely. bright. And the future for strategy remains extremely bright. And we're going to go from being a $70 billion company to a hundred billion dollar company to a $500 billion company and then a trillion dollar company. That's that's the mission of the company. And um I couldn't be uh more excited about the future.
2:01:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Glad we could end on a positive note. CJ, appreciate you joining us today and sharing uh the perspective from strategy. strategies side of things. Thank you.
2:01:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank
2:01:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): you so much for having me, Grace and Sean. I look forward to speaking to you again soon.
2:01:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Sure thing. Head of investor relations at strategy. All right, before we go, Sean, Bitcoin sitting here at 594, we'll call it. As we head into the weekend, what's the number you're watching at Sunday's close? So that'll make you feel a little bit more optimistic Monday morning.
2:01:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): If we can get over, you know. sixty-two and a half, sixty-three, somewhere in that range. Uh after the show, I'm gonna go and and and kind of round out my analysis for the week. Uh if you want to hear my my real and granular uh thoughts uh on on what this week has meant for Bitcoin, And what we're looking forward to into this weekly close, and and what it might indicate here moving forward over the short term. Make sure you subscribe to our Substack. That'll be linked in the show's bio, in my bio, uh, on X, certainly. Uh, make sure you're subscribing to that. We put out a newsletter uh once uh once uh once a week there, uh, where I'll give you uh analysis on on technical analysis as well as just some macro uh qualitative analysis of various types. And so if you like what you see on the show, we go much, much, much more in depth on those. And then every month as well, I include one rather large quantitative research piece uh for your enjoyment as well. So uh open to suggestions. I'll answer your comments uh and questions on the Substack as well. So if you want uh to ask anything, if you ever are curious about what we're talking about in the show, hit us up there on Substack on the weekly newsletter. and we'll make sure to respond with some insights.
2:02:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Love that. And we got a great group of guests joining us on Monday morning. CJ Constantinos, the founder and CEO of People's Reserve. Our own Lauren Asmus back with us. He's head of investor relations at UTXO Management. Ryan Rasmussen, head of research at BitWise, and Grant Cardone, founder and CEO of Cardone Capital. Joining us again. In the meantime, enjoy your weekend. Uh, relax, get some sunshine, maybe get off the internet for a little bit, and we will see you back here Monday morning, 9:30 Eastern time. For Sean Hagen, I'm Grace Remington, and this is BMTV.