Anthropic's IPO, AI-driven tech outages, and record art sales dominate Slate Money
Summary
Felix Salmon and Elizabeth Spiers discuss Anthropic's public listing, noting its rapid profitability and the governance tensions between safety and profit. They analyze recent widespread tech outages, attributing systemic fragility to AI-accelerated coding cycles rather than state-sponsored cyberattacks. The episode also covers the record $190 million sale of a Van Gogh painting and the speculative surge in luxury watch prices.
Episode sections
- 0:21 – 5:38
Anthropic IPO and Market Impact
Felix Salmon introduces Anthropic's public listing, ticker 'ANT', and ~$1.5T valuation, contrasting with Ant Group's failed IPO and noting immediate stock volatility.
- 5:38 – 11:27
Anthropic's Financials and Profitability
Speakers discuss Anthropic's rapid path to profitability and cash flow positivity, while Elizabeth Spiers notes declining CapEx in the broader AI sector.
- 11:27 – 14:45
Governance and Corporate Culture Pressures
Elizabeth Spiers worries public listing pressures profit over safety, citing Google; Felix Salmon argues Anthropic's public benefit structure mitigates this.
- 14:45 – 24:06
San Francisco Housing Market and Philanthropy
Felix Salmon highlights the IPO's impact on SF real estate liquidity and potential employee philanthropy pledges distinct from the Giving Pledge.
- 24:06 – 26:50
Tech Outages and FAA Groundstop
Hosts recount major outages including Microsoft Outlook and FAA groundstop, discussing public reactions ranging from memes to conspiracy theories.
- 26:50 – 28:06
FAA System Failure and Underfunding
Speakers attribute the FAA groundstop to the SMART system rollout exceeding outdated infrastructure bandwidth, criticizing underfunding rather than malicious attack.
- 28:06 – 31:45
Tech Outages and AI-Driven Volatility
Speakers link recent outages at Apple, Chase, and Microsoft to AI-generated code and rapid patching, noting interconnected service fragility.
- 31:45 – 34:11
Bending Spoons and Code Simplification
Felix Salmon highlights Bending Spoons acquiring MailChimp to replace complex code with AI alternatives, contrasting with robust legacy COBOL systems.
- 34:11 – 38:43
Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Resilience
Hosts debate outage causes, concluding sophisticated attacks target financial theft rather than infrastructure collapse, benefiting cybersecurity stocks.
- 38:43 – 49:51
Van Gogh Auction and Art Market Dynamics
Elizabeth Spiers discusses the $190M Van Gogh sale, exploring how moral valence and provenance impact art prices uniquely.
- 49:51 – 56:21
Numbers Round: Startups, Toys, and Watches
Segment covers Palamos Industries AI missile startup, 55% adult toy sales in H1 2026, and FP. Jume watch speculation with a $10M+ sale.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| AppleAAPL | equity | neutral | My Apple FaceTime stopped working. |
| MicrosoftMSFT | equity | neutral | Sacha Nadella Nandella said the CEO of Microsoft. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Anthropic is trading under the ticker symbol ANT.
Felix Salmon ·2:10
How to verify: Check NASDAQ or NYSE listings for ticker 'ANT' and company name 'Anthropic'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Anthropic went public at a valuation of about one and a half trillion dollars.
Felix Salmon ·2:43
How to verify: Review the S-1 filing or IPO pricing press release for Anthropic's market capitalization at listing. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceAnthropic's IPO offering price was priced at $83, up from a planned range of $70 to $75.
Felix Salmon ·4:19
How to verify: Check the final IPO price announcement in the S-1 filing or financial news archives from November 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceAnthropic is cash flow positive and profitable.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·6:26
How to verify: Review Anthropic's first quarterly earnings report filed with the SEC after its IPO. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceAnthropic employees have pledged to give 80% of their wealth to charity.
Felix Salmon ·20:14
How to verify: Check press releases or statements from Anthropic founders regarding philanthropy pledges. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The FAA grounded all flights in the US for only the second time since 9-11.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·25:03
How to verify: Search FAA press releases or news archives for a nationwide ground stop event in the week prior to November 21, 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The FAA groundstop was caused by the rollout of a system called SMART.
Elizabeth Spiers ·27:15
How to verify: Review FAA incident reports or news articles detailing the cause of the specific ground stop event. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Russell Vort at the OMB withheld $5 billion in FAA modernization funds.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·27:12
How to verify: Check OMB announcements or news reports regarding the withholding of FAA infrastructure funds in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Apple had an outage affecting FaceTime and other services.
Elizabeth Spiers ·28:21
How to verify: Check Apple's system status page or DownDetector.com for outage reports around the time of the podcast (Nov 2026). For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThree of the top four banks in America had outages.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·28:34
How to verify: Review reports from DownDetector.com or financial news outlets for outage data on major US banks in Nov 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Satya Nadella said AI is helping cyber attackers attack faster and better.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·28:46
How to verify: Search for Satya Nadella's remarks at the Deal Book Summit in Nov 2026 via Microsoft's investor relations page or news archives. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bending Spoons bought MailChimp from Intuit for $3 billion.
Felix Salmon ·32:15
How to verify: Check SEC filings or press releases from Bending Spoons and Intuit regarding the acquisition of MailChimp. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceIntuit bought MailChimp for $13 billion.
Felix Salmon ·32:15
How to verify: Review historical SEC filings or press releases from Intuit regarding the 2026 acquisition of MailChimp. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceCybersecurity stocks have gone up in value significantly.
Elizabeth Spiers ·36:15
How to verify: Analyze stock performance data for major cybersecurity ETFs or companies (e.g., CRWD, PANW) from Jan 2026 to Nov 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A Van Gogh painting sold for $190 million at Sotheby's.
Elizabeth Spiers ·40:06
How to verify: Check Sotheby's auction results for Nov 2026 for the specific Van Gogh lot. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Van Gogh painting was owned by a Jewish family in the 1930s who sold it under duress to Nazis.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·41:06
How to verify: Review art provenance research or news articles from Nov 2026 regarding the specific Van Gogh painting sold at Sotheby's. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The seller of the Van Gogh was an Argentine war criminal who ran a sugar company.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·41:56
How to verify: Research the seller's identity (Blackier family) and their historical background in Argentine media or news archives from Nov 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
55% of toy sales came from adult-only households in the first half of 2026.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·50:33
How to verify: Locate the Bloomberg article or industry report cited by the speaker for H1 2026 toy sales data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify Anthropic's S-1 filing for governance structure details and financial disclosures.
- Check FAA press releases and SMART system documentation to confirm infrastructure causes for the groundstop.
- Review Sotheby's auction records for the Van Gogh sale details, including hammer price and buyer identity.
- Analyze Bending Spoons' acquisition terms and Intuit's MailChimp divestment rationale.
- Assess cybersecurity stock valuations relative to reported threat landscapes and patching failures.
- Examine luxury watch secondary market data for FP. Jume pricing trends versus retail prices.
Full transcriptexpand
0:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hello!
0:11Felix Salmon: And welcome to the very first slate money of the post-anthropic IPO era. I am Felix Salmon of Bloomberg. I'm here with Emily Peck of Axios.
0:23Elizabeth Spiers: Hello, hello.
0:24Felix Salmon: I'm here with Elizabeth Spires from the New York Times.
0:26Elizabeth Spiers: Hello.
0:27Felix Salmon: And Anthropic is a public company now. We are going to talk about what that means. We are also going to talk about the outages. Did you notice a lot of things went down last week? We shall discuss. We are going to talk about art and how it's very unique as an asset class in terms of the moral cruft that attaches to it and the stories that. attach to it. And we have a Slate Plus segment on a very different art form, The Movies, where we start off talking about James Bond and then somehow make a left turn into Digger and Stanley Kubrick and art movies. I think that's worth subscribing to Slate
1:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Plus for
1:07Felix Salmon: just there. Anyway, it's all coming up, and I hope you enjoy it on Slate Money.
1:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): At
1:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Capital One, we don't just use technology, we architect it. Our teams have true end-to-end product ownership, shipping distributed systems at scale right here in downtown Toronto. That's technology at Capital One. Search technology at Capital One Canada.
1:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Right now, Marshall's buyers are still hustling to get amazing new gifts into stores. Like this season's Italian leather handbags. They're in the bag. The latest designer perfumes. Perfection. And the cuddliest of cuddly toys. So soft. Wait! These gourmet chocolates just landed from Europe. Bellissimo. Marshalls, we get the deals. You gift the good stuff. Right up to the last minute.
2:10Felix Salmon: Okay, guys, we need to talk about the new big dog on the stock market. Anthropic. It might be a big dog, but it's trading under the ticker symbol ant.
2:21Elizabeth Spiers: Small but mighty.
2:23Felix Salmon: I'm old enough to remember when Ant Group was going to go public. at a valuation of three hundred billion dollars and everyone was like, Whoa, that's amazing. And people got really excited about it. And then the Chinese government cracked down and it never happened. And the great big ant IPO never happened. Well, now the even bigger ant IPO has happened. Anthropic is public. It went public at a valuation of about one and a half trillion dollars. It immediately popped up to exceed even the valuation of SpaceX. It then did the volatility thing that tech stocks tend to do. But we now have a genuine frontier lab, pure play AI company on the stock market that anyone can just fire up their Robin Hood account and buy. And I feel like this is a really good thing because up until now, the only way to really play the AI trade has been to buy NVIDIA stock, which has been fine on the basis that AI is basically powered by NVIDIA chips, but there are lots of other chips out there. As we know, as we have discussed, NVIDIA is a mildly problematic corporation on a bunch of different levels. And it's good to just have like we make AI
3:42and have that listed on the stock market and give people the opportunity to buy it because the stock market is supposed to represent the economy. And when massive companies like these are private, it creates this issue where, like, you know, a small number of private individuals earn all of the shares and we don't. So it's a good thing, right, Emily?
4:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
4:02Elizabeth Spiers: don't know. I mean, maybe. We're talking on Friday, one day after the company started trading, and already the stock just opened down nearly 10% from yesterday. It's still above the offering price, but you know, it's still not great. 10% is where
4:19Felix Salmon: I mean like they were planning the off offering price at 70 to 75, and then they ended up pricing at 83 because demand was so high. So it was already an elevated price at the IPO price. Yeah. It's still above even the IPO price, which was already elevated. It's not as high as like the 113 initial cross or whatever like we had on Thursday morning. And initial crosses are very interesting auctions, and we can have a total nerd out about like the initial cross on IPO day. But ultimately, what the stock market is saying is that to a first approximation, Anthropic is worth about one and a half billion dollars. It's worth roughly the same as SpaceX. This is a big important company.
5:00Elizabeth Spiers: Yeah. Yeah. It's a big important company. No dispute there. Is it good? It went public. Maybe. It might be that we look back on this, on the the anthropic IPO as sort of like the beginning of the downturn for the air. AI trade, which has been kind of slumpy for the past couple of months at least, even before Jensen Wong's situation, AI trade was kind of falling a little bit, which I feel like is natural because you couldn't have sustained the rate of growth. You know, at some point the baby stops growing two inches a year or whatever. You know what I mean? Like you can't you can't just keep going up, up, up, up forever. So I
5:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean if you
5:38Felix Salmon: look at if you look at the S one though, if you look at Anthropics Financials, it really is going up, up, up, up. It's, you know, doubling every few months kind of thing. It's it has an incredible growth rate for a trillion dollar company. This is the first time ever in the history of humanity we've seen a trillion dollar company with this kind of growth rate. Now, if you're talking about growth rate of share prices, that's something else entirely.
6:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm talking about
6:02Elizabeth Spiers: share prices. And also CapEx. CapEx has started to decline overall for the AI trade. The money going into this into this whole business is slowing. The rate of growth is slowing. Aaron
6:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
6:13Felix Salmon: But the rate of revenues and profits at Anthropic is well, I mean Anthropic is basically profitable now, which it happens happened much more quickly, I think, than most people anticipated. Aaron
6:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
6:24Elizabeth Spiers: How is
6:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
6:25Elizabeth Spiers: profitable now?
6:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
6:26Felix Salmon: it's cash flow positive. It was a rounding error.
6:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So it
6:33Elizabeth Spiers: lost money.
6:37Felix Salmon: And like one of the signals of an IPO is this is the last money we're gonna need. Right? I mean, well, we can borrow money in the debt markets, but the one of the signals you send. when you do an IPO is like this is the final equity round. It's not like you will promise to never raise another equity round, like Elon Musk is famous for going public and then doing equity rounds after that at Tesla. But in general, the idea is like we've finished like burning through money and going through the sort of initial phase of burning money, and now we are very close to actually being. profitable, and we're not going to raise many more money after this.
7:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
7:18Elizabeth Spiers: not sure that's true. First of all, I think there are a lot of companies that do private
7:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): placements
7:22Elizabeth Spiers: after IPOs. And also, I kind of disagree with your overall optimism
7:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): about how
7:28Elizabeth Spiers: they're doing and where they're
7:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): going. I
7:30Elizabeth Spiers: think this morning they opened at $88, um,
7:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
7:33Elizabeth Spiers: we we
7:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): tape on Friday mornings. But
7:35Elizabeth Spiers: this was part
7:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of a larger AI route
7:38Elizabeth Spiers: that's
7:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): been happening. over the last
7:39Elizabeth Spiers: few
7:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): days. And it's
7:40Elizabeth Spiers: it's multifactorial.
7:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's not,
7:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): you know, one thing. It's it's blue tsunami, it's it's turmoiled NVIDIA, it's the perception that AI will have to slow down to some extent because of regulatory concerns, things like that. Aaron
7:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
7:54Felix Salmon: We we talked about this though, right? We talked about the idea that if there is more regulation that could actually be good for these companies and force them to stop competing with each other and better. burning quite as much money. Like, I feel like we're talking on two very different timescales here. I'm talking on the time scale of like, look at I mean, you know, Anthropic is a relatively young company, but look at the history of, you know, Anthropic since it first raised money at a four hundred billion, four hundred million dollar valuation. And like, look at what's happened to AI. We now have clawed code, we have age, you know. agentic AI. We have AI touching almost all of us every day. And we have this incredibly important force in the economy that has already transformed the economy in interesting ways and is going to continue to do so. And now you can sort of buy that on the stock market, versus what you're talking about, which is like the stock is down this morning, which is like a very different thing. kind of
8:50Elizabeth Spiers: I'm talking about a
8:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): bunch of things, not just the stock being down. And also, I think two things. If people wanted to get it on the AI trade, a lot of them are just buying the hyperscalers. I mean, that's the sort of
9:00Elizabeth Spiers: safest way
9:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to do it. And I would argue that SpaceX
9:03Elizabeth Spiers: was kind
9:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
9:03Elizabeth Spiers: an
9:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): AI trade too. But also, I think there's a reason why OpenAI has kicked their IPO to next year. They want to see how this all shakes out because right now it looks very volatile. I think it's a little premature to say that Anthropic is fine now or that they're inevitably gonna experience the kind of growth and early profitability you're talking about.
9:25Felix Salmon: Well it's not early. They've gone quite a few years by burning through many, many billions of dollars. But I do think we're kind of talking past each other here in that what I'm saying is that AI is a profoundly important part of the economy. And now there is a way that you can get exposure, pretty pure exposure to it, more pure than you could by buying Google or Meta or NVIDIA or even SpaceX. And so that that is good just in terms of like price discovery and asset allocation and that kind of stuff. In terms of I'm not I am not saying the stock price will go up. I'm certainly not saying that. And I don't actually particularly care what happens to the stock price. I don't think that the stock price of anthropic is important. I don't think that if AI succeeds in transforming the world in wonderful ways, that necessarily means that Anthropic's share price is going to go up. And I don't think that like a sort of fizzle of the AI revolution and the slowing
10:25down of the AI adoption globally will necessarily mean that anthropic stock price will go down. Like the share prices are very weird things. And as you say, they're multifactorial and they have a bunch of different things going into them. But I just think it's good that these big companies that are really driving an enormous part of the way that the world is changing are now public rather than private. Aaron
10:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell Well,
10:50Elizabeth Spiers: if I were an investor. I would definitely feel that way. I mean, you look
10:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at how long it took Uber to get public and how many investors were sitting
10:57Elizabeth Spiers: around furious
10:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
10:58Elizabeth Spiers: Kalinick
10:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): wasn't doing anything.
11:00Elizabeth Spiers: And
11:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
11:00Elizabeth Spiers: I
11:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
11:01Elizabeth Spiers: think now there's more pressure
11:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for these
11:03Elizabeth Spiers: companies to go public. They can't stay private as long as they could maybe 10,
11:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): 20 years
11:07Elizabeth Spiers: ago. Aaron
11:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
11:08Elizabeth Spiers: One thing I wanted to talk about with Anthropic going public is what this is going to mean for the advancement of AI and for anthropic's culture, which is sort of unique. Um, you know, the New York Times had a story earlier this week, kind of about how they're these reluctant millionaires and they're really devoted to mission. I mean, their whole business story is that this was a breakoff team from OpenAI because they didn't like the direction OpenAI was going. too dangerous, not enough accounting for the safety concerns around generative AI and all of this. But as we have discussed and everyone discusses, being a public company means that you have unique pressures on you to grow, to deliver profits, to do all the things that, I don't know, Felix, that you're maybe not so into, and that could make it harder to. pace the frontier, to take safety into account, things like that. Already we've seen Dario Amade. At first, he wasn't gonna take Middle Eastern investors, for example. And then he was like, it's hard not to take that money. You know what I mean? And we have the previous example, a quarter
12:19century or whenever it was, 20 years ago of Google. They used to say we don't want to be evil, whatever. They went public, that all fell by the wayside. And they're just a public company looking to maximize profits for shareholders like everyone else. So, what will that mean for the AI revolution and
12:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): all
12:36Elizabeth Spiers: the dangers that come with it? I don't know. I feel like that's
12:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a big
12:39Elizabeth Spiers: question mark. And I don't know if it's a good thing that these guys went public.
12:42Felix Salmon: I I think we number one, we kind of already talked about this when the S1 came out. And we talked about the governance structure and the way that it's a public benefit corporation. and not a standard corporation that is run for with fiduciary duties to shareholders. And they've done as much as can possibly be done to address that concern and try to avoid that concern. And we talked about this and we I think ultimately agreed to disagree on the fact that they're trying and it may not be enough, but it's something.
13:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
13:11Elizabeth Spiers: I guess we're
13:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in a crowded
13:12Elizabeth Spiers: field with a lot of players who do not give a fuck at all. And so it makes them look far more responsible. But there's also an interesting Times profile of Dustin Moskowitz, who took a big stake in OpenAI and then backed Anthropic because he felt like OpenAI was being too reckless with their development. And then even now, you know, has reservations about even Anthropic pacing the frontier. And so I think there there have been kind of moving goalposts about what kind constitutes reasonable safety considerations or responsible behavior now that
13:44Felix Salmon: I mean ultimately the if the responsible thing to do with AI is to not do it, then all of the people out there, like you and me who are not doing it, like like we're doing great. We should we should get all of that, you know, Jan Talin then and Dustin Muskovitz Moskowitz money. If you're buying shares in a company, the idea is that you know, especially in the Series A, like Duskin Muskowitz did, then what you want to do is you want to say, I do want you to be at the frontier, because if we don't have someone responsible at the frontier, we're going to have someone irresponsible at the frontier. And then just please try and do the frontier as conscientiously as you can, which I think is it is fair to say that Anthropoc Anthropic
14:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
14:25Felix Salmon: doing. And I think everyone in Anthropic, and I think the early investors in Anthropic are all worried that the frontier is i advancing too quickly. Dario has come out publicly and said we need to like slow down, we need to work on a l our alignment and all of this kind of stuff. And so yeah, this is a known issue. It has been a known issue while Anthropic was a private company. It remains a known issue while Anthropic is a public company. So I don't think anything has really changed on that front. I think what really has changed is the amount of wealth in San Francisco. The two-bedroom apartment selling for $30 million and that kind of thing. The way that the AI boom has been so concentrated in such a tiny town that that it has really transformed San Francisco. out of all recognition and turned San Francisco into this bizarre sort of parallel universe where unless you're worth a hundred billion, a hundred million dollars, you can't even sort of afford to live there.
15:25There are weird like hyperlocal effects of the anthropic IPO because this amount of liquidity coming into a very small geographic area is going to have enormous consequences. But in terms of the sort of global effects of how AI affects the world, I think ultimately my feeling is that the simple fact that AI is a public, that Anthropic is a public company now and wasn't last week doesn't change that much beyond the fact that it's raised $100 billion, Other and than that $100 billion is going to help it fund the next generation or two.
16:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I just don't think
16:02Elizabeth Spiers: you're wrong. I I do. I think going public is very meaningful and having to report your financials every three months and get constant coverage in the press when you stumble, when you're not making the money that you want to make, or every comment that Diario now makes about whatever apocalyptic or doom saying thing affects the stock. So you have the whole financial press kind of like dogging you. I think it becomes like a whole thing. And again, like we saw with Google, like it it will change the company. It will. Like I'd almost bet you five years from now that the leadership has changed, maybe even maybe some of its principles have fallen away. I mean, we saw what happened to OpenAI already. Like this is what happens.
16:45Felix Salmon: OpenAI's principles are all in place, like notoriously.
16:48Elizabeth Spiers: They were a non nonpro if I have this right. they were a nonprofit.
16:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
16:52Felix Salmon: No, that's true. Yeah,
16:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they're OpenAI.
16:54Elizabeth Spiers: Like maybe their quote-unquote principles are the same thing.
16:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh, oh, I thought you meant
16:59Felix Salmon: principles ALS. No, principles L E S. Yeah,
17:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): those have definitely changed.
17:03Elizabeth Spiers: Famously, the principles. Yes. Sam Altman's still there, whatever in charge. I just mean their They're high-minded delusions or goals or whatever. That that falls by the wayside when this money. much is at stake for this many huge players. It just will and does. That's just what happens. And I know we talked about it already,
17:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but I think
17:22Elizabeth Spiers: something very official has happened with going public where it's like your ideals are not gonna last.
17:28Felix Salmon: Just at a minimum. The way that they report the numbers has to be has to conform to standards, which when these companies are private
17:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
17:35Felix Salmon: they're doing dog and pony shows, sometimes they sort of make up their own metrics. and say, well, no, this is the real
17:40Elizabeth Spiers: important metric. And you you can't do that as a public company. That's
17:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): no every
17:45Felix Salmon: most public companies do like pro forma results alongside the gap results. And they like to talk about the pro forma results. Yeah, you can look at
17:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the gap
17:52Felix Salmon: results if you like.
17:54Elizabeth Spiers: They you it's a different type of scrutiny legally if you're doing that as a public company.
17:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
17:59Felix Salmon: And that's a good thing, right?
18:00Elizabeth Spiers: But Yeah. It's a heightened level of scrutiny, but that's what Emily and I are saying. It's going to be different for them.
18:05Felix Salmon: Yeah. That said, I suspect that the anthropic investor relations department is going to be a little bit less solicitous to shareholders than most, precisely because of the governance structure that we talked about last time. Aaron
18:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
18:24Elizabeth Spiers: Did you guys read the New York Times story where they talked about the anthropic employees and how they don't care about money? That when Facebook went public, there were like all these new Ferraris around town in Palo Alto. But the anthropic employees, they don't really care about like flashy cars or expensive wine. And there was a woman in a some restaurant owner saying, We they don't even order the expensive wine. Like they don't even max out the wine budget at dinners when they have dinners. It's so annoying. They weren't millionaires yet. I think it's too soon to sort of estimate. Yes, it's DBD, but and as as Felix was saying before, like even if you have a lot of lot of millions of dollars, you still can just buy like some whatever two-bedroom apartment. Like you're not getting um a McMansion. I don't know. The point of the story in the Times was just that they these folks apparently don't care about money the way perhaps some other startup c company employees have.
19:15Felix Salmon: A lot of them do care about philanthropy though. And this is the first big liquidity event for I mean, is it fair to say it's the first big l liquidity event for effective altruism? I think it probably is. We have Gustin Moskowitz, of course, he was already very rich. Now he's a lot richer, has made a lot of money off this. Probably the most mainstream EA adjacent person in the world is Dustin Moskowitz's employee, Holden Karnowsky, who founded GiveWell, who is married to Daniela Amade and is now like a multi-gazillionaire in his own right. We now have conservatively speaking, hundreds of billions of dollars, which are which have been pledged. Like all of the founders have said we're gonna going to give 80% of our wealth away. to charity. And it's pretty clear from what they've said about that intent that they're not going to give it to the San Francisco opera. They're going to be trying to do it in ways that benefit humanity broadly and in ways that don't involve setting up foundations and doing all of the kind of things that philanthropists have historically done. It's going to be super interesting to see how that money ends up getting spent.
20:26Elizabeth Spiers: Are you talking about the giving pledge? No,
20:28Felix Salmon: I'm not talking about the g the giving pledge is very old school philanthropy one point oh. That was started by Bill Gates and Warren Buffett, and they were just like, let's just pledge to give our money away at some point to something. And it has n ended up being slightly less consequential, let's say, than people had initially hoped. Well, 'cause Well, because
20:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a lot of pe people
20:49Elizabeth Spiers: a lot of them just didn't do it.
20:53Felix Salmon: And a lot of them just they did it in the form of like, well, I've given money to my private foundation or to my DAF or something like that, and then it just kind of sits there and nothing much happens. Or they do the John Paulson thing and just give it all to Central Park. It's the in terms of really ambitious sort of wanting to give away your money to change the world and make the world a better place. I think this is a whole new level. I mean plus the giving pledge was like 50%. And the which is also what the Andrewsen Horowitz partners pledged and also just kind of seemed to have ignored. Whereas this one is 80%. It's much more it seems more real to me anyway.
21:30Elizabeth Spiers: I feel like that makes me more skeptical about it. 80 versus 50, and also just the people we're talking about. I I I don't trust them more. than the people.
21:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh, I'm
21:40Felix Salmon: not saying I trust them more. I'm just saying that I do think it's more likely that they actually go ahead and put this money to use. To I actually spend the money, give it away, rather than just kind of sit on it and promise to give it away in the future. A lot of the giving pledge stuff was like I'll leave a bunch of my money to charity when I die. And I think quite explicitly, most of the OpenAI folks. and m most of the anthropic folks have pushed back against that and they're like, no, we need to be spending this money. Now there's an urgency. Now we we don't have the luxury of waiting until we die.
22:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'll believe it when I see it. Well there aren't they going to cure death or something? No,
22:16Felix Salmon: that's much
22:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): more than that. There's
22:17Elizabeth Spiers: a I think apocryphal rumor that some of the anthropic people have s taken up smoking because they just assume that cancer is gonna going to be cured by the time it's a problem for them.
22:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
22:29Elizabeth Spiers: Or die of lung cancer before any of the top.
22:49Felix Salmon: Optimize Wealth Management was built for those ready for the next level, whether you're an advisor or an investor. It's a platform that recognizes your achievements and gives you what you need to raise your game. Grow your practice or your portfolio through a firm as unique and discerning as you are. Visit OWM.com/slash learnmore to learn more. Optimize Wealth Management for those who want more. You work hard for your business. Let your credit card work harder for you. With the WestJet RBC World Elite MasterCard for Business, unlock up to 100,000 WestJet points. Enjoy silver status for at least a year with benefits like priority boarding, lounge access, and free checked bags. Plus, earn up to six points per dollar on WestJet travel. You'll also earn up to three points per dollar on eligible business purchases, making this the fastest way to earn WestJet. points. Turn business spending into your next adventure. Terms and conditions apply. Visit rbc.com/slash WestJet Business to learn more.
23:47Elizabeth Spiers: For most of the history of professional sports, there was a wall between the game and gambling. Then suddenly it was everywhere. But that wasn't supposed to include the players themselves. Understood the big bet. Find us on CBC Listen or wherever you get your podcasts.
24:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But let's talk about the death by a thousand paper cuts way in which OpenAI is going to kill us all. Emily, what what can you run down the list of outages we've had over the past week? Honestly, I don't know
24:20Elizabeth Spiers: if I can.
24:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay. We have we don't have enough time for that. Well, I guess it
24:24Elizabeth Spiers: all started with
24:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): with
24:26Elizabeth Spiers: the outlook.
24:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Out Outlook?
24:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Outlook outage
24:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on
24:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): last Friday. So a little over a week ago, Outlook went down. I think it went down on Thursday to Friday, prompting just like celebrations in law offices across the land. They declared a snow day. They posted memes. They
24:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): were
24:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): so happy. All the people that have to use Outlook and Teams, which I'm so sorry. for your life, but they had this great time. So it was sort of like funny, ha ha ha.
24:56Elizabeth Spiers: Then just when you were sort of realizing, oh, this is a serious thing that's happening, Friday evening,
25:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we
25:03Elizabeth Spiers: hear, oh, the FAA has grounded all flights in the United States for only the second time since 9-11. And you're like, what? And then you listen
25:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
25:13Elizabeth Spiers: the press conference. of these Trump administration
25:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): people,
25:17Elizabeth Spiers: some wearing a lot of zip, quarter zip fleeces without undershirts on, who previously talked about making sure they look nice for the airport. So that was confusing. And the one guy is saying something along the lines of, don't worry, this isn't a 9-11 event over and over again, which is kind of like when the bank says, Don't worry, your money is safe, and you're like, oh God. Um,
25:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): my
25:41Elizabeth Spiers: Yeah, exactly. My don't worry, this isn't 9-11 t-shirt is raising a lot of questions that have already been answered by my t-shirt. Yeah. Exactly. Um, so that was like, oh God, like
25:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what is
25:53Elizabeth Spiers: happening? And then I was, I think I was at the gym when that was going down, and like people were just like, Oh my god, the outlook caught the outlook caused the planes to they can't. fly. And then other
26:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): people were
26:04Elizabeth Spiers: like, Iran is doing this. And then other people were like, it's the AI.
26:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like,
26:08Elizabeth Spiers: like just you could hear the conspiracy
26:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): theories and
26:11Elizabeth Spiers: the fear like all around. Like it
26:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was.
26:14Elizabeth Spiers: Well, also is it you know, people like Josh Hawley got up and said, The likelihood that this is a coincidence is, you know, it's like just feeding it. Yes,
26:22Felix Salmon: just feeding it. No one knows anything. And like we have these the White House just I don't think they helped very much, but
26:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): did
26:28Felix Salmon: they put out memes? They probably put out memes.
26:30Elizabeth Spiers: They tried to at one point insinuate that it was like a single router in Missouri or something.
26:40Felix Salmon: Yes, in Missouri on a Friday. Like, what? Like, wait until the weekends.
26:45Elizabeth Spiers: I mean just everyone
26:45Felix Salmon: knows.
26:46Elizabeth Spiers: How Harkham's come's Razor with the FAA? There are so many obvious things that could have gone wrong. You
26:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
26:50Elizabeth Spiers: there are they're catastrophically underfunded. Doge fucked would have fucked it up a lot.
26:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
26:55Felix Salmon: it wasn't even
26:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a good thing.
26:57Felix Salmon: It was Russell Wort. This is one of the interesting things. The Congress passed a bill allocating gazillions of dollars to modernizing the FAA. And then Russell Vort at the OMB was like, great, we have these five
27:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): billion dollars. I'm just gonna sit on it and not let you spend it. Sounds like that.
27:15Elizabeth Spiers: So the
27:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): n the the money never made it to the FAA. What did make it to the FAA was the rollout of some system called SMART, which of course it was called SMART because everyone needs a dumb acronym these days, which was all about making air traffic control SMART somehow, but required huge amounts of bandwidth, which the FAA didn't have because as you say, it still runs on old Lake like copper lines. Lions. And then they were like, oh shit,
27:39Felix Salmon: that
27:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): didn't
27:39Felix Salmon: work.
27:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
27:40Felix Salmon: yeah,
27:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
27:41Felix Salmon: mean it
27:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): my
27:42Felix Salmon: my explanation for the plane outage is definitely just
27:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): general cock
27:47Felix Salmon: up incompetence on the
27:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): part
27:49Felix Salmon: of the executive branch
27:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): rather
27:51Felix Salmon: than
27:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
27:51Felix Salmon: malign actions
27:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): from
27:53Felix Salmon: Iran
27:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or North Korea or Russia
27:55Felix Salmon: or anyone
27:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): else.
27:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): So that works itself out. So by Saturday, things air er the the planes are flying again. Things are a little bit back to normal. But then there
28:06Elizabeth Spiers: was more. There was a ch uh now this is where I am not going to be as entertaining. There was a Chase bank outage where some things were down. There was some other stuff. My Apple FaceTime stopped working. Apple had an outage. Yeah, Apple had an outage. And it wasn't just Chase, it was like three of the top four. banks in America had sort of outages. Although, again, we don't really know. A lot of this was just like people reporting
28:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): things to DownDetector.com. And so
28:36Elizabeth Spiers: we're like,
28:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's it's very a lot of companies keep these things relatively quiet. But yeah, like just anecdotally, it seemed like a lot of shit was breaking. Aaron Powell
28:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): A lot of shit was breaking. And Sacha Nadella Nandella said the CEO of Microsoft. which I thought was sort of clarifying at the Deal Book Summit, he just talked about AI is is helping cyber attackers attack a lot faster and better. And at the same time identifying flaws in software that were perhaps already there and companies are racing to patch the flaws and they're perhaps patching not very well and it's leading things to break, which seems like what's
29:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there are a
29:18Elizabeth Spiers: lot of services out there. And it turns out the way that software has been growing and eating the world for the past 20 years is it
29:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): just
29:28Elizabeth Spiers: grows and everyone relies on everyone else. And these services are all deeply interconnected and more and more interconnected every day, and especially now in the age of AI with written code, those kind of calls and degrees to which everyone relies on everyone else is much greater than ever used to be. And those little baby bugs that are being found every day by AI are when you try and patch those bugs, it causes unintended
29:55Felix Salmon: consequences and there are ripple effects. And I think Satya's exactly right. We are just go and this is kind of the same as the thesis of. my book, which is just like we are in a realm now of volatility and unpredictability. And the idea that you can have a digital service that's just incredibly super reliable and will always work. Yeah, I think that's less and less realistic every day.
30:17Elizabeth Spiers: Well, part of part of it too is just there, there's a culture in the tech industry that you ship products before they're perfected and then you fix everything when it really becomes a problem. And the pay patching and updating process for large systems has always been a little bit fragile because of that. And so when you imagine that now, because of AI, that process is sped up so much, you're just deploying updates all the time and you have the same probably, it's just you're getting the bugs at a faster rate because there was never any system built in to make sure that when the updates release that they're close enough. to finished and perfected that those things don't happen. Like I didn't even notice the Apple outage because I feel like every time I get an OS update, it breaks three or four things on my phone and my laptop. And we we've all gotten used to that. But if it accelerates at some exponential amount, because now all of this is being heavily automated by AI, then yeah, it's gonna feel like everything is breaking.
31:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And it's
31:14Felix Salmon: sort it of echoes what's happening in the real world.
31:16Elizabeth Spiers: The I mean not that the these are real world outages, not to be clear. I just mean with harder infrastructure. The same thing has happened in the United States with, you know, our bridges and roads um all sort of starting to break down over, well, lack of maintenance and just aging. And the software infrastructure of our economy and of our country is also, I mean, especially within the government, kind of aging and falling apart also. So
31:45Felix Salmon: it's interesting you say that because one of the more interesting companies in the AI space, and we've talked about it a little bit on this
31:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): show, is
31:56Felix Salmon: Bending Spoons, the Italian company that just bought MailChimp off Intuit. I don't know if you saw that, but like Intuit bought MailChimp for like $13 billion. And they were like, actually, and then they sold it for $3 billion. What after having improved revenues and profitability? Like they grew MailChimp. But the pro the value of the MailChimp just like imploded even after it had grown. So that that's fun little data point. But the basic MO of bending spoons is to buy mature software. companies like MailChimp or whoever that have exactly what you're talking about, which is like years and years of software cruft and just bullshit and complexity, and just rip it all up and literally trash the entire stack, the entire code base, and replace it all with a much simple soup to nuts thing that you've managed to build in ten 10 minutes with a the aid of AI. And we'll see whether it works. But like there is at least one company out there, pending spoons, that is trying to move in the opposite direction and make things less complex. And like, you know, but we will see whether that expands beyond one company in Milan. Aaron
33:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
33:06Elizabeth Spiers: Part of the reason why the government still runs on such outdated systems is that they are more robust in terms of cybersecurity in a lot of cases. And so they've been very slow to replace them until they had systems that they knew were as robust as the old ones were.
33:20Felix Salmon: Yeah. I mean, if your entire system is based on COBOL, I can tell you there aren't a lot of North Korean hackers who know COBOL and can hack it.
33:27Elizabeth Spiers: Yeah. I mean, but that is a real reason why some of these systems have been retained for so long. Because they there's It's not an obvious replacement that is as robust, even though it's robust for exactly the reasons you just articulate. articulated.
33:39Felix Salmon: And if you look at if you look at what happened to the banks, it was super interesting, right? Which is that the actual payment systems and the banks having the money and knowing how much money everyone has and all of that kind of stuff were completely robust and untouched. The only things that was broken was like the little software apps on your phone or whatever that allow you to see what your balance is. Those kind of things. that live on the top but aren't super critical, they can break. But the hardcore like this system cannot break stuff actually didn't break.
34:11Elizabeth Spiers: I also kind of wonder, and maybe it's just like the natural everything is fine in me of it all. I'm like, you know what? It was fine. A lot of things did break over the past week, but like like this is not the apocalypse we were promised. They're It's not a great sample though, because I think it's our job to be in the chaos of the news cycle all the time, and all three of us are just inured to the chaos. So we it has to be like a super high level of chaos for us to start panicking.
34:38Felix Salmon: Okay, so here's here's my question though, because a lot of people were joking about this, but I think some of the people who maybe we thought were joking about it were not joking about it. Which is if there was a state actor who wanted to like attack the digital infrastructure of America
34:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): and go after the planes and go after the banks and go after the Apple services and just generally like make our lives miserable by doing cyber attacky things. There is absolutely no evidence that that happened. But is this what it would look like?
35:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's what
35:12Elizabeth Spiers: Yeah, it
35:13Felix Salmon: wouldn't. It would be more scary
35:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so.
35:14Felix Salmon: somehow, right? I mean,
35:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
35:16Elizabeth Spiers: plane would
35:17Felix Salmon: stop midair or something. I'm
35:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not sure.
35:19Elizabeth Spiers: I mean, we've we've had cyber attacks though, and I think they tend to they're strategically they're designed to erode infrastructure. They're not designed to create an apocalypse, which would have global repercussions, which even our enemies don't want.
35:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Even the cyber attackers don't really want that
35:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): level of
35:36Elizabeth Spiers: No, there's there's a there's an objective to it. They're not just causing catastrophe for fun.
35:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
35:42Felix Salmon: mean the
35:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
35:42Felix Salmon: m the it's interesting to see the most sophisticated cyber attackers out there. The mo the
35:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): biggest exploit they've managed to do, probably ever, to be honest, was hacking Binance and stealing six billion dollars. It's not a major public infrastructure thing. I mean, well maybe when Israel hacks an Iranian nuclear power plant or something. We haven't really so far, the defensive white hats in the cyber community have done a pretty good
36:15Elizabeth Spiers: job of keeping civilization robust to black hat attackers. But if you're in the cybersecurity business right now, you are working really hard and the stock of your company has gone. up in value quite a lot. It's like low-key, a very big part of the AI trade that's still like going strong, or all these cybersecurity stocks. And people were saying that every day now is Y2K, basically. Which again, that's fine. Y2K was fine. Like people worked really hard to avoid a catastrophe. The PHP
36:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): thing was meant to be worse than Y YAY2K. Y2K. And like I was like petrified, my oh god, PHP hits gonna it's broken and it's gonna bring down the entire internet, and then again nothing happened.
36:56Elizabeth Spiers: Yeah. Yeah. The fanfiction site AO3 was down for almost two weeks. That was fine. I mean,
37:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it wasn't fine for me because where am I gonna get my slash fig?
37:05Elizabeth Spiers: Yeah, and where are you gonna publish your we don't know what Felix is writing in fanfiction, but I imagine it's
37:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): yeah, guys. Like write in slate money at slate.com if you've managed
37:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to work out what my
37:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): username is on AO3.
37:27Felix Salmon: You work hard for your business. Let your credit card work harder for you. With the WestJet RBC World Elite MasterCard for Business, unlock up to 100,000 WestJet points. Enjoy silver status. for at least a year with benefits like priority boarding, lounge access, and free checked bags. Plus, earn up to six points per dollar on WestJet travel. You'll also earn up to three points per dollar on eligible business purchases, making this the fastest way to earn WestJet points. Turn business spending into your next adventure. Venture, Terms and conditions apply. Visit rbc.com/slash WestJet Business to learn more. Make
38:02Elizabeth Spiers: the merriest time of the year even more
38:04Felix Salmon: rewarding with cashback from Rackitin. Earn up to 15% cashback Black Friday through Cyber Monday at stores you love like Walmart, Dyson, and Gap. Even better, stack cash back on top of the biggest store sales of the year. So go ahead and buy that party outfit, book your winter getaway, and go nuts stuffing stockings. It all comes with cashback. cash back. And when it's time to redeem your earnings, get it exactly. how you want it. Choose from Interact, PayPal, or check. So make more merry and earn more money. Join for free at racketin.ca or get the Rackettin app. That's R-A-K-U-T-E-N.
38:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So you know what you can't hack? What is completely unhackable and robust to cycle? cyber.
38:49Elizabeth Spiers: Oil paintings.
38:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oil
38:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): paintings.
38:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): In
38:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): a world
38:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): where everything is digital and you want something solid and meaningful, just run off and buy
38:59Elizabeth Spiers: yourself a van Gogh at Sotheby's
39:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for
39:01Elizabeth Spiers: $190 million. Do I have to say it like that? I'm not doing it. We had uh Peter Thel Larsen on this show many years ago, who's Dutch, who knows how to pronounce such things. And he explained that it's actually Van Gogh.
39:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You have
39:14Elizabeth Spiers: to get the that first G is more the H. It's Van Gogh. Anyway,
39:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
39:18Elizabeth Spiers: Americans all call him Van Gogh for reasons. I would love, please, someone write in
39:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): slate
39:24Elizabeth Spiers: money at slate.com and tell
39:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): me what's the sort of equivalent word to etymology, but for pronunciation? Like, where did the pronunciation van Gogh Go come from? Like who came up with it? Like, because it's uniquely American. Like no one in Europe, like the English don't. do it, the Australians don't do it. Like why and how did the Americans adopt that particular pronunciation? I'm fascinated.
39:46Elizabeth Spiers: But yeah, be good to know. Let us know. I think we did it the usual way. We said we're the most powerful and important, so what we say goes, and that's that's just how it happened. But the reason we're talking about this is It's because there was a big painting that got sold at Southernbiz Southerbeers of a chestnut tree, very pretty. I would say medium-sized painting, not that big. But anyway, it sold for a record. $190 million. It was a $165 million hammer price. There was five minutes of bidding, but interestingly, it's not entirely obvious that there were any bids. It was one of those very confusing
40:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): auction things where the the auctioneer is standing at the front of the room saying a lot of words and pointing at various. people and trying to get people to do things and ultimately hammering it down for 165 million, but not clear whether there was a bidding war. And it could have been, and in fact some people think that maybe it was that it just sold to the guarantor, the person who would like said that if no one else bids, I'll bid and there
40:45Elizabeth Spiers: was just
40:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): no other bidder. If that's the case, or even if it isn't, like there does seem to have been a kind of reluctance to build bid on it. Philip Hoffman, who's a big art advisor, gave a quote to someone, I can't remember who, basically saying, like, yeah, this this thing's a bit hairy. And it was hairy for a couple of reasons. One of the reasons is that there was a family called the Fishers back in the 1930s who were Jewish and who owned it and who wanted to leave Germany. because obviously, and the Nazis, as they were wont to do, made them pay a big tax in order to be able to leave the country. And the way they paid that big tax was by selling their van Gogh. And they were like, we sold it under duress, therefore we deserve some kind of restitution. They hadn't bothered to mention this since 1936, but now they came out of the woodwork like three days before. the sale, and they threatened to derail the entire sale before like long negotiations into the night, they finally came to some kind of a settlement and they allowed the sale to go forward. So that made the whole painting feel a bit hairy.
41:55Elizabeth Spiers: And then
41:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the other thing was just the seller was basically an Argentine war criminal. Like this it was this guy who ran this sugar company in Argentina who used company vans to round
42:09Elizabeth Spiers: people up during the junta and m disappear them. And he was brought to trial, but he died before the trial could
42:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): come
42:18Elizabeth Spiers: to any kind of a verdict. So technically still innocent, but no one thinks he was any kind of an angel. And and again, people were like,
42:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): E
42:27Elizabeth Spiers: seems a bit skeevy, I'm not sure about this. The history of a painting and who owned it and w who how it changed hands
42:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): is surprisingly important in terms of how people value it and whether people are willing to buy it, much more than any other asset. And that's the thing I kind of wanted to talk about. Like, why do you think that is?
42:50Elizabeth Spiers: With art, there's a kind of people buy art and they have some sometimes a moral attachment to it, especially if they think it signifies something. What's interesting, the Southern Southern spokesperson tried to defend and what's the name of the Argentine family?
43:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Blackier.
43:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
43:06Elizabeth Spiers: can't read my own handwriting here. Yeah. Because they have bought stuff from that family before. So they felt compelled to defend the the patriarch. patriarch and they said something like, Well, he wasn't technically found guilty of a crime. Because I think they didn't want people to go back and now that the Van Gal painting is the centerpiece of this big piece of discourse and then go evaluate all the other pieces that they've sold from them.
43:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Well I mean
43:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): those
43:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): those pieces are all sold. That's in the past. And I don't then I feel like it's fine to own a painting that used to be owned by a bad person. I don't see what the problem is there.
43:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
43:42Elizabeth Spiers: I don't I was struggling a little bit because I like many people automatically think Nazis bad, Nazi associated anything really bad.
43:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Argentine hunter, bad.
43:53Elizabeth Spiers: Bad. And I was like, Were the is the Argentinian maybe an old Nazi? I don't know. Like it's all all seems awful. And and I think no one would disagree. that if the Nazis confiscated a piece of art from a Jewish family, that family gets to have it back and decide what to do with it. And like that's
44:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): pretty
44:13Elizabeth Spiers: understood.
44:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's
44:14Elizabeth Spiers: settled. That's settled. But this is more like if you sell the art to deal with the Nazis, is that the same thing thing as is confiscation?
44:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
44:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): the interesting question is like basically, did they sell it at a going rate or were they forced to sell it at a discount by a Nazi dealer who sold it to a Nazi and picked up a bargain? And it's really hard to know what like the going rate for a van Gogh was in nineteen thirty six. But like probably maybe there was a little bit of a Nazi discount, but not huge. Also
44:46Elizabeth Spiers: I would I don't know if that matters to me. It's more like they wouldn't have sold it if not for Nazis.
44:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
44:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): they almost certainly would have sold it at some point between like 1936 and now.
44:55Elizabeth Spiers: Yeah, maybe. Maybe. But I don't know. That did seem more questionable than the idea you're saying, like, does the Nazi association taint the art forever? Is a good question. And I'm not sure of the answer. I think it maybe does if you're a rich person and you want to buy something f because you want to brag about it and have a good story to tell about. it. And part of the story you have to tell is like, well, the family that originally owned this didn't want it to be sold to me because of its Nazi associations. That kind of does make it sort of less desirable. Well, there also might be if if you know that there's something like that in the Providence somewhere, some concern that's just purely legal, that it's like, well, what if this opens me up to some challenge from some error? errors that we don't know about now that might come along later and be in a similar situation as the Fisher's? But like you don't want to be like complicit with the Nazis in your art.
45:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well, no, I mean,
45:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): but like I think I think that's the whole point, right? Is that like the Fisher family signed off on it. They're like, we are not gonna make this claim. Whoever buys this is gonna Going own to it free and clear. They don't need to worry about this. There's absolutely no suggestion that victims of the Argentine junter are going to start coming after people who bought this painting and say we want some of the proceeds. And if they do, they'll come after the Pleccio family who got the money. You know? They're not gonna ask for the painting bag. If you know, like most money is just money. If you're an Argentine sugar magnet and you have a stock portfolio and then you sell your stock in the stock market, or your heirs do, then the person who's buying that stock doesn't know that it's coming from you and there's no hair on that stock at all.
46:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's
46:33Elizabeth Spiers: true, but you don't you're not gonna hang your stock on the wall and look at it every day and get bad vibes from it. Like I think there's also like a superstition element that really would not apply to stock sales. And doesn't art and paintings, I mean you would know this a thousand bajillion times more than me, but it's it's a story, it's like a piece of history. And you don't want
46:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): a piece
46:52Elizabeth Spiers: of history on that's tainted by
46:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, I mean I think that's exactly right. That so much of everything that is valuable is storytelling. I mean, this is true of stocks as well. But it's yes, it's true of art and individual paintings have stories associated with them. And the I mean, the reason why the Mona Lisa is the most valuable painting in the world is just because it has reams of lore associated with it. It was stolen and all the rest of it. So storytelling is a large part of value. And when the story behind your Van Gogh like if you are the kind of billionaire who wants a Van Gogh on your yacht, you you have your choice of Van Goghs and then you wind up with the one that is full of people being disappeared in the sugar company bands bans as part of the law. You're like, yeah, that's a bit icky.
47:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Mm Mm-hmm. hmm.
47:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yeah.
47:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): And Elizabeth is right. There is like this kind of moral valence to art. One of the other interesting pieces that was written this week was by Jerry Sultz, the New York magazine art critic, who was complaining about how Jeff Koons, the artist, was selling a bunch of paintings. He sold like a $40 million Picasso and a bunch of other stuff. And he was like morally upset about this. He was like, you shouldn't be selling art. This is great art and this is part of who you are. And it's just like a bad once you've bought it, you shouldn't sell it. It wasn't a completely well-formed argument, but it was an interesting art it was interesting to me that he was making the argument at all. Because yeah, he was basically just saying, art is different. It's not an asset. You can't just buy and sell it like other things. It's special, it's different. And like there's a part of me that likes that. way of looking at art. Aaron
48:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
48:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): That's nice. And I think for a lot of people is I'm sure is true, but the wealthy treat art very much like an asset. Like we've talked about the the rich people who buy paintings and then just put them into storage for like reasons, tax reasons, or
48:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well,
48:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): and also
48:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): because
48:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): they just you know, like if you're an art collector, I can speak from personal experience here, you know, the n amount of art you have rapidly exceeds the number. of walls you have, no matter how many houses you own. You just start becoming addicted to art. And yeah, and but it is also definitely the case that there's a bunch of like weird speculative gut stuff going on where people are buying and selling art from each other and it just stays within goes from one bit of the Geneva Freeport to another bit of the Geneva Freeport. And y you you're like, why are people doing that if they're never going gonna to put it on the wall?
49:14Felix Salmon: Yeah. So I mean, it's definitely treated like an ass. I mean, when things cost over a hundred million dollars, like you can't just say, Oh, it's special and you can't you can't ever sell it. Like it's worth a hundred
49:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): million dollars. And
49:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Exactly.
49:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): This is capitalism.
49:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): God
49:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): damn it.
49:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): You gotta be able to sell your hundred million dollar thing. Like otherwise, why would it be worth a hundred million dollars if you have to have a market? Anyway, you know what I mean. We
49:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): know what you mean. Anyway, should we have a numbers round? I have no idea what my number is. So maybe Elizabeth, you can go first.
49:56Elizabeth Spiers: Sure. My name number is 16, and that's hold a kid named Henries Henry Danderberg's, Dandenbergs. I think. I'm pronouncing this correctly, who dropped out of high school in Latvia to join Y Combinator is. He's their youngest founder. And his company is called Palamos Industries, and it makes AI missile guidance systems. Now my God. In this piece about M and Wired where he says, I think missiles are the coolest thing. A lot of people that have found success in engineering early on have had a passion for blowing stuff up. So yeah, this this whole thing gives me pause.
50:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Emily, what's your number?
50:34Elizabeth Spiers: I think I want to go with 55. 55% of toy sales came from adult only households in the first half of 2026.
50:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Oh, I was looking at that one. That's a wild stat, right?
50:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's It's
50:47Elizabeth Spiers: a wild stat.
50:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Although I think the phrase first half is doing a lot of work there. Like if kids generally get toys at Christmas, that's in the second.
50:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's to
50:57Elizabeth Spiers: be true. So the toys are like um plushies, jelly cats, squishmallows, anything you would get at like Pop Mart, stuff like that, collectibles. Adults like stuff. They like buying this stuff now, and it's increasingly becoming a bigger and bigger share of the market. And teenagers also teens are growing. a segment of the toy market right now. And this isn't a good Bloomberg story that goes deep on the trend. And it comes at a time when I think little kids play with toys less than they used to because they have iPads and phones. And it's just a different world. And I think parents anecdotally sort of know this. And then at the same time, adults like to buy jelly cats and plushies and squishmallows and like knickknacks and things. like Legos that are you know, a thousand dollars to things like that have become more popular. Are
51:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): video games considered part of the toy market?
51:47Elizabeth Spiers: Or is that a separate category? I think that's a separate category. And they're doing well too for the adults, as we all know.
51:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): As we all know, I am resigned to a low number of downloads to Slate Money this weekend because everyone is going to be playing Grand Theft Auto instead. This is what we do, people. We weekend podcasters, we compete against video games. And honestly, when you're up against GTA 6, I mean
52:12Elizabeth Spiers: it's over. It's
52:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): made more
52:14Elizabeth Spiers: money in one day than the new Spider-Man movie has in total.
52:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): My number is 8,680,500, 680,500, which is the number of Swiss francs that someone paid at Phillips in Geneva for a watch called the Chronometre Resonance Regence by Francois Paul June, FP June. And I wrote about this watch, the chronometre chronometra à uh resonance last year. I wrote a big piece in Bloomberg about how I love this watch, and I think it's conceptual. conceptually gorgeous and I think the movement is wonderful and it looks very pretty. He's made there are a lot of it. It's not a unique watch. But this is,
53:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
53:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): guess, a kind of interesting one because it has a slightly different dial than most of the other ones. Anyway, that is the number of Swiss francs that someone paid for this watch. It's over 10 million dollars
53:11Elizabeth Spiers: Wow.
53:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): for
53:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
53:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): watch with no particular proven provenance, with no particular it's not super rare. There are lots of resonances out there. When I wrote my article last year, I was like, yeah, technically it costs you $170,000 if you want to buy it new, but you can't buy it new because you can't get on the list and they won't sell it to you. So if you want to buy it secondhand, it'll probably cost $300,000. And now one sold for ten 10 million. And I'm like, something is happening in well, partly something is happening in the watch world, but something is very much happening in the FP Jun bit of the watch world. And FP June auction prices have been just going completely batshit. And that's kind of interesting to
53:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): me.
53:52Elizabeth Spiers: Do you think your article played a role?
53:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Almost certainly. I will take full credit for this.
53:57Elizabeth Spiers: They should kick back some cash to you.
53:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, whoever sold that resonance, can you like give me ten percent? I would appreciate that.
54:03Elizabeth Spiers: What do you do when you buy a ten million dollar? You don't wear it, do you?
54:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I mean, people do.
54:08Elizabeth Spiers: Interesting.
54:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Like if you go to like watch events, people not only wear these million dollar watches on their wrist, but they even like take them off and allow other people to try them on and all the rest of it. Watch people are really nice. They're much nicer than art people. Aaron
54:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
54:22Elizabeth Spiers: And there's no like Nazi Oh, there probably is some Nazi stuff going on.
54:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
54:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): mean it's Switzerland, right?
54:28Elizabeth Spiers: Yeah.
54:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think that's it for us this week. Thank you for listening. Thank you for emailing us on sleepmoney at Slate.com. Thank you to Jessmine Molly of C Plane Armada for producing. We have a sleep plus segment on what, Emily?
54:45Elizabeth Spiers: Well, speaking of watches, we're gonna talk about James Bond and we are gonna talk about his watches. you guys.
54:51Felix Salmon: Yeah.
54:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): What watch will the new James Bond wear? We will talk about that on Slate Plus. Otherwise, we'll be back next week with more Slate Money.
55:06Felix Salmon: Make the merriest time of the year even more rewarding with cashback from Rackitin. Rackatin. Earn up to 15% cash cashback back Black Friday through Cyber Monday. at stores you love like Walmart, Dyson, and Gap. Even better, stack cash back on top of the biggest store sales of the year. So go ahead and buy that party outfit, book your winter getaway, and go nuts stuffing stockings. It all comes with cash back. And when it's time to redeem your earnings, get it exactly how you want it. Choose from Use Interact, PayPal, or Czech. Check. So make more merry and earn more money. Join for free at racketin.ca or get the Rackettin app. That's R-A-K-U-T-E-N. You work hard for your business. Let your credit card work harder for you. With the WestJet RBC World Elite MasterCard for Business, unlock up to 100,000 WestJet points. Enjoy silver status for at least a year with benefits like priority boarding, lounge access, and free checked bags. Plus, earn up to 6.5%. six points per dollar on WestJet travel. You'll also earn up to three points per dollar on eligible business purchases, making this the fastest way to earn WestJet points. Turn business spending into your next adventure. Terms and conditions apply. Visit rbc.com/slash Westjet Business to learn more.