Slate Money

2026 Midterm Ad Spend, Texas Election Shifts, and AI Regulatory Risks

1h 4m Listen to the original Episode page
Political Advertising2026 MidtermsTexas ElectionsAI RegulationPrivate MarketsLuxury GoodsMedia Industry

Summary

Sarah Fischer reports that $11.87 billion was spent on political ads in the 2026 midterms, a record for a midterm cycle but lower than the previous presidential cycle. She attributes the spending surge to Citizens United and legislative deadlock, noting that local TV received $5.5 billion. Felix Salmon discusses market volatility following the election, highlighting a sell-off in core AI stocks like CoreWeave due to data center moratorium concerns. The hosts also analyze Elon Musk's failed $300 million effort to keep Texas red and the failure of California's Proposition 40 wealth tax.

Episode sections

  1. 0:32 – 7:40

    Political Ad Spend and Efficacy

    Sarah Fischer discusses the record-breaking $11.87 billion spent on political ads during the 2026 midterms, noting it was the highest midterm cycle spend but lower than the previous presidential cycle. She argues that while advertising works for brand awareness, it largely failed to change election outcomes due to strategic missteps by Republicans, such as being caught off guard by the race in Texas and over-indexing on sociocultural issues.

  2. 7:40 – 11:18

    Drivers of Political Ad Inflation

    Fischer identifies three main reasons for the surge in ad spending: the 2010 Citizens United ruling allowing uncapped outside spending, a lack of transparency policies and spending caps compared to other democracies, and the shift of issue advocacy to state-level races due to federal legislative deadlock. Additionally, the expansion of unregulated digital and streaming inventory has increased available ad space.

  3. 11:18 – 13:30

    Local TV and Media Industry Impact

    Approximately $5.5 billion of the political ad spend went to local broadcast television, which Fischer describes as a critical lifeline preventing the industry's terminal decline. She contrasts this with streaming platforms like NextArtegna, which face fewer regulatory constraints on pricing and targeting compared to local broadcasters who must adhere to lowest unit charge rules to ensure political fairness.

  4. 13:30 – 24:48

    Corporate Political Spending and ROI

    The hosts discuss the return on investment for corporate political spending, noting that Democrats rely heavily on small-dollar fundraising while Republicans often depend on large corporate contributions. Fischer cites the pharmaceutical industry's spending during the Obamacare years as an example where billions were spent to avoid worst-case scenarios rather than achieve positive gains, highlighting the difficulty in measuring political ROI.

  5. 24:48 – 25:32

    Market Reaction to Election and AI Backlash

    Felix Salmon describes a volatile market reaction to the 2026 election results, featuring an initial tech sell-off followed by a rebound in big tech stocks (Apple, Microsoft, Google) and a subsequent crash in core AI and data-centric stocks like CoreWeave. This volatility is attributed to calls for data center moratoriums and a crowded hedge fund trade unwinding simultaneously.

  6. 25:32 – 30:55

    Data Center Moratoriums and Regulatory Risk

    The discussion highlights bipartisan opposition to rapid data center expansion, particularly in rural, red-leaning areas like Texas. Speakers argue that while federal regulation may be limited, state and local governments have significant power to slow or block buildouts through permitting and community participation requirements, potentially curbing the AI infrastructure arms race.

  7. 30:55 – 34:27

    Valuation of Private AI Companies

    Salmon points to Hyperliquid as a venue for trading shares of private AI companies like OpenAI and Anthropic, noting their prices have remained relatively flat post-election. The group discusses the potential delay of Anthropic's IPO as a bullish signal, suggesting the company is waiting for a higher valuation rather than being forced to sell due to lack of demand, despite concerns about slowing growth rates.

  8. 34:27 – 35:39

    Texas Election Results and Elon Musk's Strategy

    Sarah Fischer and Felix Salmon discuss why Texas went blue, attributing it to successful urban expansion and housing construction compared to Florida. They analyze Elon Musk's failed $300 million effort to keep Texas red, noting his significant financial and operational investments in the state, including moving Tesla and building Starbase.

  9. 35:39 – 39:27

    Elon Musk's Political Influence and AI/Data Center Backlash

    The hosts discuss Musk's continued influence in the Republican Party, suggesting he will remain active if his business interests, such as SpaceX or Tesla, face regulatory threats. Sarah Fischer links the backlash against AI data centers in Texas to broader populist sentiments similar to those that defeated California's wealth tax proposal.

  10. 39:27 – 42:33

    California Proposition 40 and Wealth Tax Feasibility

    Felix Salmon notes that California's Proposition 40 (wealth tax) failed while Proposition 42 passed, complicating future wealth tax efforts. He asserts that a wealth tax is likely unconstitutional under the current Supreme Court majority and remains unlikely even with a Democratic majority.

  11. 42:33 – 50:20

    Luxury Scotch Packaging and Market Dynamics

    Felix Salmon explains the elaborate packaging of high-end scotch, using a $36,000 50-year-old Glenmorangie as an example. He contrasts scotch's focus on uniqueness and limited barrel availability with bourbon's focus on consistency, explaining why scotch commands higher packaging costs due to lower production volumes.

  12. 50:20 – 55:40

    Scotch vs. Bourbon Production and Pricing

    The discussion highlights that scotch's value is driven by time spent aging in barrels, creating rarity and price correlation with age statements. Felix Salmon shares his personal preference for younger scotches (10-12 years) over older ones and notes the arbitrage opportunity of buying the Glenmorangie in Europe for roughly $34,000 compared to $36,000 in the US.

  13. 55:40 – 57:29

    Salon.com Closure and Digital Media History

    Felix Salmon announces that Salon.com, an early internet magazine founded around the same time as Slate, has ceased operations after going public in 1999 during the dot-com bubble. He contrasts this with Slate, which was owned by Microsoft and never went public, allowing it to survive for 30 years.

  14. 57:29 – 1:04:29

    House Managers as a Luxury Service Trend

    Sarah Fischer reports on the rising trend of hiring house managers in Atlanta, charging around $60/hour or six figures annually. These professionals help wealthy individuals maintain the appearance of an empty, pristine home, performing tasks like errands and organization but excluding deep cleaning like toilet scrubbing.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
Anthropicprivate companyneutralAnd I don't think it's really going to hurt Anthropic or OpenAI, but it would not surprise me if the valuations were lower because they would have to readjust projections of what they're supposed to be building out because that's the sort of what they promised the early stage and later stage VCs. So there would be some justification for the valuation being lower
OpenAIprivate companyneutralAnd I don't think it's really going to hurt Anthropic or OpenAI, but it would not surprise me if the valuations were lower because they would have to readjust projections of what they're supposed to be building out because that's the sort of what they promised the early stage and later stage VCs. So there would be some justification for the valuation being lower

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

More money was spent in the 2026 midterm cycle than any other midterm cycle, but less than the previous presidential cycle.

Sarah Fischer ·3:35

How to verify: Check FEC reports or Center for Responsive Politics data for total spending in the 2026 midterms versus the 2026 presidential election. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

California Democrats spent almost $800 million on elections.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·3:57

How to verify: Review FEC filings and state-level campaign finance reports for California Democratic Party and affiliated committees for the 2026 cycle. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Elon Musk spent $300 million in Texas.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·3:57

How to verify: Check FEC filings for Super PACs or entities associated with Elon Musk for expenditures in Texas during the 2026 election cycle. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

The 2010 Citizens United Supreme Court case allowed outside groups to have uncapped spending.

Sarah Fischer ·7:41

How to verify: Read the Supreme Court opinion in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, 558 U.S. 310 (2010). For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Roughly $5.5 billion of political and issue advocacy advertising went to local broadcast.

Sarah Fischer ·11:24

How to verify: Consult media measurement firms like Nielsen or Kantar Media for local TV political ad spend data for the 2026 cycle. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Democrats are heavily reliant on small-dollar fundraising through ActBlue.

Felix Salmon ·13:57

How to verify: Analyze FEC reports for Democratic candidates and committees to compare small-dollar vs. large-dollar contribution percentages. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Anthropic has $800 billion in spending commitments.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·31:55

How to verify: Review Anthropic's investor updates, press releases, or financial disclosures regarding committed capital or infrastructure spending. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Anthropic's valuation is approximately $1.4 trillion.

Felix Salmon ·31:21

How to verify: Check recent funding round valuations reported by financial news sources like Bloomberg or Reuters for Anthropic. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Elon Musk spent $300 million trying to keep Texas red in the midterm elections and failed.

Sarah Fischer ·36:17

How to verify: Check FEC filings for political expenditures by Elon Musk or his affiliated entities during the 2026 midterm election cycle. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Elon Musk moved his company Tesla from Delaware to Texas.

Sarah Fischer ·36:17

How to verify: Review Tesla's SEC filings or corporate registration documents with the Delaware Division of Corporations and the Texas Secretary of State. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

California's Proposition 40 (wealth tax) failed and Proposition 42 passed.

Felix Salmon ·39:38

How to verify: Check the official California Secretary of State election results for the relevant midterm election cycle. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Salon.com published for 31 years before dying in 2026.

Felix Salmon ·55:40

How to verify: Verify Salon.com's launch date (2026) and current operational status via Wayback Machine archives or company announcements. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

House managers in Atlanta charge $60 an hour.

Sarah Fischer ·57:49

How to verify: Reference the Wall Street Journal article cited by Sarah Fischer regarding the house manager trend in Atlanta. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Sylvester Stallone sold his dog Butkus for $40 before selling the Rocky screenplay.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·59:43

How to verify: Check Sylvester Stallone's autobiography or verified biographical sources for details on his financial history prior to Rocky. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Glenmorangie 50-year-old scotch costs $36,000 in the US and €30,000 in Europe.

Felix Salmon ·44:40

How to verify: Check retail listings for the specific Glenmorangie 50-year-old release on luxury spirits retailers' websites in the US and Europe. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Distillers One of One Auction happens in Scotland every two years.

Felix Salmon ·45:00

How to verify: Review the official website or auction records for the Distillers One of One event to confirm its frequency and location. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Peter Pincus is a ceramicist in Rochester who created 149 vessels for the Glenmorangie packaging.

Felix Salmon ·47:06

How to verify: Search for Peter Pincus's ceramic work and any collaborations with Glenmorangie or Sotheby's regarding the 'Together in Spirit' installation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

BetMGM is an official sports betting partner of the National Hockey League.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·40:38

How to verify: Check the NHL's official partnerships page or BetMGM's press releases for confirmation of the partnership. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify total political ad spend figures via the Center for Responsive Politics or Federal Election Commission databases.
  • Check CoreWeave's stock performance and any news regarding data center moratoriums in Texas or other states.
  • Review the text of California Proposition 40 and 42 to understand the specific provisions that led to their passage or failure.
  • Analyze the valuation trends of private AI companies like OpenAI and Anthropic on platforms like Hyperliquid.
  • Compare local TV advertising rates and regulatory constraints (lowest unit charge) against streaming platform pricing models.
  • Research the constitutional challenges to wealth taxes under the current Supreme Court majority.
  • Investigate the operational history of Salon.com versus Slate to understand the impact of public vs. private ownership on media longevity.
Full transcriptexpand
0:08
Felix Salmon: Hello and welcome to the Blue Nami edition of Slate Money, the guide to the business and finance news of the week from the 30-year-old media organization known as Slate.
0:25
Felix Salmon: I am Felix Sampson. Salmon of Bloomberg. I'm here with Elizabeth Spires of The New York Times. Hello. I'm here with Emily Peck of Axios. Hello,
0:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): hello.
0:34
Felix Salmon: And, of course, we're going to talk about the midterms. We're going to talk with Emily's lovely, amazing, intelligent, and brilliant colleague, Sarah Fisher, about advertising and the role it plays INC, INC, or doesn't INC, INC, play INC, INC, in election results. we're going to talk about the stock market and it's kind of
1:09
Felix Salmon: What's happening there? We have a kind of wild numbers round. It's all coming up, so stay tuned to this week's
1:17
Felix Salmon: Slate Money.
1:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): The betting partner of the National Hockey League is ready for puck drop. Now hockey fans in Alberta can get in on the action from the opening face-off with Goal in First Ten, a betting market where you can call whether a goal will be scored by any team in the first 10 minutes of a game. From pregame to live bets, same-game parlays, player props, and more, BetMGM has over 500 NHL betting markets
1:52
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): to choose from. And the BetMGM app has instant deposit and fast withdrawal PPL options, including Interac e-transfer, Visa, MasterCard, and Apple Pay, and more. Download the BET BetMGM MGM APP AND DON'T MISS A SECOND OF THE OPENING MINUTES. BET MGM, AN OFFICIAL SPORTS BETTING PARTNER OF THE NATIONAL HOCKEY LEAGUE. YOUR HOME FOR HOCKEY BETS ALL SEASON LONG. SEE
2:12
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): BETMGM.COM FOR TERMS. 18 PLUS ONLY, BET RESPONSIBLY. ALBERTA ONLY, SUBJECT TO ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS.
2:17
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): IF GAMBLING IS AFFECTING YOUR MENTAL HEALTH OR WELL-BEING, 211 ALBERTA IS HERE TO HELP. CALL OR TEXT 211 OR VISIT AB.211.CA.
2:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Standard message and data rate. RATES MAY APPLY BET MGM OPERATES PURSUANT TO AN OPERATING AGREEMENT WITH THE ALBERTA EYE GAMING CORPORATION
2:32
Sarah Fischer: Right now, Marshalls buyers are still hustling to get amazing new gifts into stores. Like this season's Italian leather handbags. They're in the bag. The latest designer perfumes.
2:45
Sarah Fischer: Perfection. And the cuddliest of cuddly toys. So soft. Wait! These gourmet chocolates just landed from Europe? Bellissimo. Marshalls, we get the deals. You gift the good stuff. Right up to the last minute.
3:06
Felix Salmon: so we are going to start this week with the intersection of politics and money we have the world's greatest expert on money and politics on the show this week, the one and only Sarah Fisher of Axios. Welcome, Sarah.
3:24
Sarah Fischer: Thanks, Felix. Hi.
3:25
Felix Salmon: Is it true that more money was spent this year on election-y things than ever in the history of humanity on any election on the planet?
3:35
Sarah Fischer: Not true. More money was spent in this midterm cycle than any other. MIDTERM CYCLE BUT LAST PRESIDENTIAL WAS
3:43
Felix Salmon: HIGHER
3:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): THAN
3:43
Sarah Fischer: THIS MIDTERM CYCLE BUT
3:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): IT WAS
3:45
Felix Salmon: INSANE AMOUNTS OF MONEY I SAW THAT THERE WAS LIKE THE CALIFORNIA DEMOCRATS ALONE SPENT LIKE ALMOST 800 MILLION DOLLARS ON GOD KNOWS WHAT BECAUSE THEY WERE ALL GONNA SAIL THROUGH WITHOUT ANY PROBLEM
3:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): WELL NO I MEAN WE FLIPPED FOUR SEATS IN CALIFORNIA
4:01
Sarah Fischer: AND COMPETITIVE PRIMARIES
4:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Felix. Okay, you
4:03
Felix Salmon: flipped four seats for $800 million. Like, Elon Musk spent, what was it, $300 million in a desperate attempt, which failed to stop Texas from going blue. There just doesn't seem to be any limit to, I mean, the total amount of money spent was, what, $11 billion, $13 billion, I've seen AND various numbers floating around. Let's not
4:23
Felix Salmon: get stuck in the specifics. So I just want to like the, the BIG big. PICTURE IS BAZONKER'S AMOUNTS OF MONEY.
4:30
Sarah Fischer: BAZONKER'S AMOUNTS.
4:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): AND
4:32
Felix Salmon: MY QUESTION IS, IS ANY OF IT MAKING ANY DIFFERENCE?
4:36
Sarah Fischer: I'M A BIG BELIEVER THAT ADVERTISING WORKS. AND WHEN YOU EVER, YOU ASK SOMEBODY, HOW MUCH DOES A FOOT LONG SUB COST AT SUBWAY? YOU EXPECT THAT THEY KNOW THE ANSWER COMPANIES IS FIVE INC, DOLLARS INC, INC, INC, BECAUSE INC, THEY'VE INC, SEEN INC, THE AD. IF YOU ASK SOMEBODY, WHAT MOVIES ARE IN THEATERS? People typically know that because
5:09
Sarah Fischer: BILLION. AND IT LARGELY DIDN'T WORK. AND I THINK ONE OF THE OTHER CHALLENGES REPUBLICANS FACED, FELIX, WAS THAT THEY WERE A LITTLE BIT CAUGHT OFF GUARD ABOUT HOW THEY HAD TO MOVE THE MONEY. BECAUSE TYPICALLY REPUBLICANS PUT DOLLARS TOWARDS TOSS-UPS THAT THEY KIND OF EXPECT, STATES LIKE GEORGIA OR NORTH CAROLINA. BUT THIS RACE, I THINK THEY WERE
5:29
Sarah Fischer: VERY MUCH THROWN OFF BY HOW FAR BEHIND THEY WERE IN TEXAS WITH KEN PAXTON, WITH JOHN Cornyn. CORNIN. AND SO THEY HAD TO MOVE A LOT OF MONEY TO STATES THAT THEY DON'T TYPICALLY have to. And that was a core strategy because they got boxed out of broadcast inventory. They had to move into streaming, which is not a bad thing, but it's oftentimes not as
5:49
Sarah Fischer: efficient. And so the problem there in some cases was the strategy.
5:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Was there any scenario where they could have spent the same amount COMPANIES of money INC, INC, and INC, actually INC, INC, had INC, INC, it work? Or was it an issue of what they were spending ad money for?
6:21
Sarah Fischer: REFERENCING FOR EXAMPLE LIKE CROOKED JOE AND WHAT WE CAME TO FIND WAS THAT ULTIMATELY THIS WAS AN ELECTION THAT REALLY MATTERED AROUND THE ECONOMY AROUND TAXES AND ACTUALLY AROUND HEALTHCARE A LOT OF REPUBLICANS ENDED UP SHIFTING SPENDING TO HEALTHCARE IN THE FINAL MONTHS RECOGNIZING THAT WAS A BIG ISSUE I THINK YOU'RE RIGHT THOUGH THAT THEY SPENT SO MUCH TIME AND MONEY IN THE
6:40
Sarah Fischer: PRIMARIES TALKING ABOUT TRUMP THAT THEY TUNED A LOT OF REPUBLICANS OUT AND WE KNOW So THAT REPUBLICANS STARTED TO TUNE OUT AHEAD OF THE GENERAL BECAUSE RATINGS ON FOX NEWS STARTED TO SLIP AND THAT'S our best proxy for understanding conservative engagement in this election cycle, pretty much.
6:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Sarah, I wanted to ask you, like, zooming out even from this election, and you had some of this in your really good deep dive that you shared with us and will share in the show notes. But the explanation for why there is so much money behind these ads, I feel like you you noted, you flicked at Citizens United sort of opening the floodgates. and I think on the planning call
7:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): and I can't remember if this was in your piece we just talked about like the arms race nature of it if my opponent is spending hundreds of millions of dollars I too need to spend hundreds of millions of dollars you mentioned like consultants taking a big cut of the money super PACs being forced to spend more than the candidates themselves like what are all the reasons for all the
7:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): inflation and this like crazy increase year. OVER YEAR? THERE
7:40
Sarah Fischer: ARE THREE REASONS.
7:41
Sarah Fischer: ONE, POLICY. SO YOU MENTIONED THE SUPREME COURT CASE, 2010 CITIZENS UNITED, WHICH SAID THAT OUTSIDE GROUPS HAVE UNCAPPED SPENDING. AND ALONGSIDE THAT, I'D SAY WE HAVE VERY LITTLE POLICY RESTRICTING POLITICAL ADS IN TERMS OF REQUIRED TRANSPARENCIES AND DISCLOSURES, ESPECIALLY COMPARED TO OTHER RESTORNIZED DEMOCRACIES AROUND THE WORLD. WE ALSO DON'T HAVE CAPS IN TERMS OF WHEN YOU
8:01
Sarah Fischer: CAN STOP SPENDING. YOU KNOW IN OTHER PLACES YOU CAN'T MESSAGE AND BUY ADS WITHIN THE MONTH OR TWO WEEKS LEADING UP TO AN ELECTION SO POLICY IS REASON NUMBER ONE REASON NUMBER TWO IS THAT BECAUSE CONGRESS IS SO DEADLOCKED AND BECAUSE SO LITTLE LAWS ARE BEING PASSED A LOT OF ISSUE ADVOCACY SPENT WHICH IS PART OF THAT 11.6 INC, BILLION INC, INC, DOLLAR INC,
8:21
Sarah Fischer: THAT INC, FELIX INC, REFERENCED IS MOVING TO THE STATES AND SO IF YOU'RE A ISSUE GROUP OR CORPORATION
8:45
Sarah Fischer: LEGISLATURE ADVERTISING THIS CYCLE. WE ALSO SAW A HUGE BUMP IN DOWN BALLOT RACES. TYPICALLY A LOT OF THE SPEND IS GOING TO GO TOWARDS FEDERAL CANDIDATES. REMEMBER HOW I JUST SAID REPUBLICANS SPEND 2.1 AND DEMOCRATS SPEND 1.8? THE REST OF IT MOSTLY IS ISSUE ADVOCACY, BUT SOME OF THAT IS THESE DOWN BALLOT RACES AND STATE BALLOT
9:04
Sarah Fischer: MEASURES.
9:05
Felix Salmon: IS THAT BECAUSE THE MONEY IS JUST THERE WHEN IT HASN'T BEEN PREVIOUSLY OR IS IT BECAUSE THERE'S A GROWING AWARENESS THAT ALL OF THIS STARTS WITH DOWN BALLOT RACES OR BOTH?
9:15
Sarah Fischer: THE LAWS AROUND THESE ISSUES ARE NOT BEING PASSED AT A FEDERAL LEVEL. THEY'RE BEING PASSED AT THE STATE LEVEL.
9:19
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): THAT REALLY TRACKS WITH WHAT WE'RE GOING TO TALK ABOUT IN OUR NEXT SEGMENT, SARAH, WHICH IS DATA CENTERS AND ALL THE ACTION ON DATA CENTER MORATORIUMS AND POLICY IS HAPPENING LOCAL AND STATE. SO THAT TOTALLY, YEAH, THAT TOTALLY CHECKS OUT. EVERYONE'S TALKING ABOUT FEDERAL GOVERNMENT'S NOT GOING TO DO ANYTHING. It's all going to happen at the state level and companies are going to have to run around to all the states and do their.
9:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): issue-by-issue, state-by-state lobbying. So that totally tracks that then that would redound onto ad spend. Definitely.
9:46
Sarah Fischer: And then the last one is because you have a lot more inventory. So it used to be that you were capped by broadcast, which is a 24-hour cycle, right? And that has capped inventory. Now that you can put ads on streaming, you can put ads on digital, you have a lot more inventory to be able to. message. And so that, especially with streaming, which is
10:06
Sarah Fischer: completely unregulated and easier to target, gives campaigns a lot more places to put the ads. So it's those three reasons combined that you see a lot more advertising. It's not necessarily that the consultants are pushing it for the cut, although that is a nice little change in their pocket that I'm sure they're very excited about.
10:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Because
10:24
Felix Salmon: if I'm one of the consultants who buys buy, local TV ad spots, you give me, you know, a million dollars to buy an ad spot in Alaska or whatever, I just take 15% of that, right? And then the other 85% goes to the TV station. That's a nice little earner for me every two years. You
10:41
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): should get into it.
10:41
Sarah Fischer: I mean, people feel like, I can't even tell you, when I used to sell ads, I would go to these offices, and these typically, on the Republican side, they're like in Alexandria, Virginia. And these agencies, they're beautiful on the water in Alexandria. They're run by people who have a lot of little P.O. boxes because they firewall for all the different candidates they could represent.
11:01
Sarah Fischer: And they basically make no money on the off years, except for some advocacy stuff. And then they make millions on elections. It's amazing business to see.
11:09
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Speaking of who is this an amazing business for, we had talked about on the prep call the local. TV. That's where all this money is winding up. Is that right, Sarah?
11:18
Felix Salmon: How much is the entire local TV business reliant on election spending these days?
11:24
Sarah Fischer: Political, which includes issue advocacy, advertising, spent this cycle, so roughly $5.5 billion, went to local broadcast.
11:32
Sarah Fischer: So it's a pretty big windfall for them. And if they did not have that, they would be in even more serious. terminal decline than they already are. They basically are staying in business because of elections.
11:43
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Do they view connected TV as a competitor or is it just a totally different media buyer and ad category?
11:50
Sarah Fischer: They do. And that's a big part of, I'm not going to get into it here if you ever want to have an antitrust discussion around NextArtegna, COMPANIES INC, But TENARIS basically SA, TS, DTE ENERGY, one of ES, the ON SEMICONDU reasons COMPANIES that they INC, are TENARIS arguing SA, TS, to DTE the ENERGY, regulators ES, that ON SEMICONDU looked at that deal.
12:21
Sarah Fischer: STREAMERS CAN CHARGE WHATEVER THEY WANT TO THESE CAMPAIGNS, WHEREAS LOCAL BROADCASTERS HAVE TO CHARGE THE LOWEST RATE, AND THE REASON THEY HAVE TO DO THAT IS TO ENSURE THAT NO ONE PARTY GETS CHARGED MORE THAN THE OTHER.
12:30
Felix Salmon: SARAH, LET ME ASK YOU, ALL OF US WHO HAVE LIVED IN AMERICA FOR MORE THAN FIVE MINUTES GET FUNDRAISING TEXTS FROM VARIOUS CANDIDATES SAYING, LIKE, I AM LOSING AND I NEED MONEY,
12:42
Felix Salmon: AND THE IDEA BEHIND I find THAT IS, LIKE, I AM A POLITICALLY ENGAGED PERSON AND I WANT ONE SIDE OR THE OTHER TO win. And I want it so much that I'm willing to donate money to that side that I support for political reasons. How much of the $13 billion or whatever it is that gets spent on these elections
13:03
Felix Salmon: is ideologically intense people donating money because they really want one side to win? and how much of it is much more sort of corporate interests saying like hey if we PUT $100 MILLION INTO THIS CAMPAIGN, THAT IS GOING TO MAKE LIKE A CERTAIN PERCENTAGE MORE LIKELY OUTCOME. AND IF WE GET THAT
13:23
Felix Salmon: OUTCOME, THEN THAT IS GOING TO BE WORTH $3 BILLION TO OUR BUSINESS. AND IT'S JUST LIKE A BUSINESS INVESTMENT TYPE THING.
13:30
Sarah Fischer: VARIES BY THE PARTY. THE DEMOCRATS HAVE ALWAYS BEEN SO HEAVILY ENERGY, RELIANT ES, ON SEMICONDU, SMALL DOLLAR FUNDRAISING ENERGY, ES, ON SEMICONDU, THROUGH ACT FLU. ENERGY, ES, SO ON RELIANT. SEMICONDU, WHEREAS ENERGY, REPUBLICANS HAVE TENDED TO BE MORE RELIANT ON
13:57
Felix Salmon: COMPANIES THAT PUT A COUPLE HUNDRED MILLION DOLLARS IN AND THEN SUDDENLY HIS COMPANIES WERE WORTH HUNDREDS OF BILLIONS OF DOLLARS MORE BECAUSE HE WAS IN THERE WITH TRUMP. IS THE BIG CORPORATE INVESTMENT IN POLITICAL ADVERTISING, EVEN AT THE INSANE AMOUNTS OF MONEY THAT ARE GOING IN RIGHT NOW, IS IT STILL GENERALLY A POSITIVE ROI BUSINESS TO BE IN?
14:16
Sarah Fischer: IT DEPENDS. I THINK ABOUT ALL THE MONEY THAT WAS SPENT DURING, ON HEALTHCARE DURING THE OBAMACARE YEARS. ULTIMATELY A LOT OF HEALTHCARE COMPANIES SPENT BILLIONS AND BILLIONS OF DOLLARS PHARMA, AND THEY DIDN'T GET THE RETURN THAT THEY WOULD HAVE LIKED.
14:29
Felix Salmon: BUT BY THE SAME TOKEN, THEY ALSO MANAGED TO AVOID THE WORST-CASE SCENARIO THAT THEY WERE TRYING TO FIGHT AGAIN.
14:35
Sarah Fischer: CORRECT. THERE'S NO WAY TO TELL. IT'S UNLIKE CONSUMER MARKETING, WHERE YOU CAN HAVE A CLEAR RETURNING INVESTMENT THROUGH A PRODUCT SALE. MOVING VOTES CAN BE A LITTLE BIT AMBIGUOUS AMBEGUOUS. AND And THEN by the way, that's why these consultants make so much money, right? Because it's hard to measure the efficacy.
14:51
Sarah Fischer: BUT WHAT WE DO KNOW IS THAT CORPORATIONS CANNOT AFFORD TO COMPLETELY SIT WASHINGTON OUT BECAUSE IF YOU ARE CAUGHT FLAT FOOTED YOUR BUSINESS COULD BE REALLY RADICALLY UPENDED THE BEST EXAMPLE WE ALWAYS REFERENCE WAS BILL GATES AND MICROSOFT WERE REALLY CAUGHT FLAT FOOTED BY THE JUSTICE DEPARTMENT DURING THE GOOGLE Cased CASE IN THE LATE 90S AND
15:11
Sarah Fischer: IT WAS THAT CASE THAT WOKE UP CORPORATE AMERICA TO WHY YOU really need to start investing in Washington. Gates famously didn't come in the first few depositions in a suit, right? He didn't understand the culture. He didn't understand what he was up against. And then obviously now big tech is more invested in Washington than anyone else in part because of what happened there. So everyone knows that you've got to invest. Everyone's strategies
15:31
Sarah Fischer: are just very different. Some companies, Meta and Google, hire hundreds of lobbyists and are very much on the ground, other companies like TO HAVE VERY LITTLE PRESENCE AND INSTEAD JOIN COALITIONS WHERE THEY DON'T HAVE TO BE LEADING THE CHARGE. IT JUST KIND OF DEPENDS ON HOW VISIBLE AND HOW LOUD YOU WANT TO BE.
15:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): How, I mean, aren't consumers, voters, isn't there backlash to this? I mean, we were seeing in our house, I mean, like 25 dozens of ads a day, like, and not just watching TV. It's every time you want to look at a video, you have to watch, you know. AN AD FROM MIKE LAWLER. EVERY TIME I PICK UP MY MAIL, THERE'S SIX FLYERS GOING BOTH
16:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): WAYS FOR THOSE TWO CANDIDATES. IT'S LIKE INSANE. EVERYONE I KNOW IS LIKE, I HATE THAT GUY, MIKE LAWLER. WHY IS HE TALKING TO ME STILL? WHY AM I STILL SEEING HIS FACE IN THESE ADS? DO YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN? IT JUST SEEMS LIKE IT'S GOING TO BACKFIRE AT SOME POINT. IT'S LIKE, IT'S JUST TOO MUCH. IT'S LIKE I A FLOOD. I think part of that is the way that consultants look at it is, is this effective? And they don't
16:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): really care if it annoys you, if it actually gets you out to vote or gets the candidate name ID. One of the most famous ad tactics is from the 1980s where campaigns went sitting out to voters, usually via direct mail, email that basically tracked your voting history and said, Hi, Emily, I see you didn't INC, ENERGY COMPANIES vote in INC, the ENERGY last INC, ENERGY cycle, COMPANIES but INC, your neighbors did, and
16:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): so on. Yeah, we get that. I've gotten those. That is one of the most effective get-out-the-vote actions.
17:09
Sarah Fischer: PARTICULAR POLICY, THE MORE LIKELY SOMEONE IS TO COME GET OUT THE VOTE. I THINK WHERE REPUBLICANS STRUGGLED, AND WE TALKED ABOUT THIS EARLIER, WAS THE MESSAGING. I THINK THERE WAS AN OVER-INDEXING ON
17:20
Sarah Fischer: SOCIOCULTURAL ISSUES AND ON CHARACTER ISSUES, AS OPPOSED TO JUST TALKING ABOUT THE ECONOMY. AND I THINK ONE OF THE REASONS THEY DIDN'T IS BECAUSE IT'S VERY HARD TO TALK ABOUT THE ECONOMY WITH GAS PRICES BEING ATTRIBUTED DIRECTLY TO THE PRESIDENT'S WAR. SO THEY WERE CAUGHT flat-footed FOOTED ON THE MESSAGING PROBLEM. AND EMILY, TO YOUR POINT ABOUT THIS BEING A HUGE BURDEN ON CONSUMERS, my response to that
17:40
Sarah Fischer: is we are nowhere near Congress passing any laws, let alone federal election laws. And in other places around the world, this is why spending is capped. It's why spending is curbed ahead of the election. It's almost consumer protection as well as protecting the integrity of the elections. We're just never going to, not in my lifetime, I can't see that getting passed.
17:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): That's really frustrating.
17:59
Felix Salmon: Sarah, it's been amazing having you on. Thank you so much. I'm assuming from everything you're saying that, like, all of these lines will just continue going up, right? There is no world in which election spending ever starts going down rather than up.
18:13
Sarah Fischer: You know, it's funny. When I was in political ad sales, the thing we loved was when the presidency and Congress were divided INC, INC, INC, because INC, INC, then INC, there's a tension that is going to require messaging. Or when the House and the Senate are divided,
18:45
Sarah Fischer: I don't see this political ad spend for the foreseeable future for the next few cycles slowing. However, if you're ever in a position where there's just so much uniformity in terms of the party, we definitely see spend slow because there's no point in messaging. It's, you know, uphill battle.
19:01
Felix Salmon: So basically what you're saying is that 2026, which was a midterm election where the White House, the Supreme CORE, Court and both houses of Congress were all controlled by the same party and everyone knew who they wanted to vote for and there was no real. YOU KNOW, WAY THAT A
19:17
Felix Salmon: TV AD WAS GOING TO CHANGE ANYONE'S MIND. THAT'S LIKE THE LOWEST AMOUNT OF POTENTIAL THAT ANYONE HAS EVER HAD FROM ADVERTISING AND EVEN THEN IT WAS LIKE THE SECOND BIGGEST ELECTION EVER AND THE BIGGEST MIDTERM EVER, WHICH MEANS THAT LIKE COME 2028, GOD HELP US ALL.
19:33
Sarah Fischer: Yeah, well, you know what it meant? It was honestly, it was just that 2025 was really rough because 2026 is high because... you're trying to get people into office. You know, in a non-midterm year in 2025, Congress is deadlocked.
19:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh,
19:45
Felix Salmon: sure. We all ignore the odd years.
19:48
Sarah Fischer: But in advocacy, you can't because there's still a lot of cause and appeal messaging. And that $11.6 billion number, Felix, also includes, actually, most of it is like the cause and appeal stuff.
19:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Sometimes the ads do work, right? Every year or every campaign cycle, there does seem to be a few kind of interesting ads. Like I was looking today at the Mississippi Democratic Senator candidate for Senate, Scott Klum, who's got this ad that, what is it? Pick your own protein. He's basically, he's making-
20:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
20:15
Felix Salmon: don't want a new protein. I want a new Senator.
20:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yeah. Yes. Because Cindy Hyde Everpure's Pierce, the Mississippi Republican Senator said something like, well, you know, beef prices are high and she said, well, you could just pick a different protein. And then it was just this like fun ad where the guy, there's a guy at the grill and he says, she, I'll just pick another senator. And then it's just so fun. And like,
20:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I don't know, there's always a few ads where you're like, okay, well, why can't they all just be like this? Or like one ad that everyone remembers, like LINDEN Lyndon Johnson's like Daisy ad or something. Like, why can't the ads be better at least? SARAH THEY'RE SO EXPENSIVE THAT'S THE INSURGENT AGENCIES THAT ARE WORKING WITH THE YOUNGER CANDIDATES FIRST TIME CANDIDATES THEY ARE PRODUCING THE MOST
20:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): INTERESTING STUFF BECAUSE THEY'RE NOT THE OLD SCHOOL GIANT SCHOLARATIC PLACES I WOULD LIKE MORE OF THAT IF WE'RE GONNA HAVE TO LIVE WITH A HUNDRED BILLION DOLLARS WORTH OF ADS OR WHATEVER IT IS YEAH
21:09
Sarah Fischer: I MEAN THOSE CAN BE SO EFFECTIVE SO THOSE ARE AN OUTLIER CATEGORY OTHERS THAT I WOULD PUT IN THAT CATEGORY WOULD BE Joni Ernst, who got into office in Iowa
21:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): by
21:17
Sarah Fischer: saying, I grew up castrating hogs. So when I get to Congress, I will cut pork. I mean, there is
21:23
Sarah Fischer: a lot of good examples of this. But I will say overwhelmingly, you hit on something when you talked about Daisy ad. In political advertising, there's only two emotions that tend to be effective in triggering. One is fear, which is like the LINDEN Lyndon Johnson Daisy ad in 64. AND THE OTHER IS ENTHUSIASM, WHICH IS LIKE THE 1980 RODALD REAGAN WARNING IN
21:43
Sarah Fischer: AMERICA AGAIN. ANYTHING IN BETWEEN DOESN'T TYPICALLY WORK. ANXIOUS ADVERTISING DOESN'T WORK, BUT GETTING PEOPLE ANXIOUS DOESN'T WORK. YOU HAVE TO GET PEOPLE SCARED. SO IF YOU TRY TO DO COMEDY, IT CAN BE MUCH MORE HIT OR MISS. IF YOU LEAN INTO THOSE TWO THINGS, ENTHUSIASM OR FEAR, YOU HAVE A HIGHER LIKELIHOOD OF A HIGHER RETURN ON INVESTMENT.
22:03
Sarah Fischer: Don't ask why, that's just literally what we know to be true.
22:07
Felix Salmon: Sarah Fisher with Axios, thank you so much for coming on.
22:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Thank you, Felix, my favorite topic ever.
22:12
Sarah Fischer: Appreciate you guys.
22:32
Felix Salmon: Thank you for watching!
22:45
Sarah Fischer: She really wants all-wheel drive for added safety on the road. Plus, the heated steering wheel means she can show off her new bracelet.
22:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): The Seltos might be a bit harder of a gift to
22:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): hide.
22:53
Sarah Fischer: I believe in you.
22:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Test drive the all-new Kia Seltos during the Holiday Savings Event. See kia.ca for details. Kia. Movement that inspires.
23:04
Sarah Fischer: Legendary has arrived in Alberta with BetMGM Casino. Sign up to unlock access to over 4,000 casino games, including exclusive slots you can't spin anywhere. else. Survivors ready? The iconic TV show is now an online casino game where you can tap into island fun. BetMGM has also brought The Price
23:24
Sarah Fischer: is Right, Game of Thrones, Family Feud, MGM Millions, and so many more exclusive casino games to Alberta. Get Las Vegas right from And your every time phone you with play, live you dealer can enjoy instant games deposit streaming options and fast from withdrawals. real tables. And every time you play, you can enjoy...
23:41
Sarah Fischer: BetMGM Casino and its legendary library of games are available. Download the BetMGM app. See BetMGM.com for terms. 18 plus, Alberta only. Please play responsibly. Subject to eligibility requirements.
23:55
Felix Salmon: If gambling is affecting your mental health or well-being, 211 Alberta is here to help. Call or text 2-1-1 or visit ab.211.ca.
24:03
Felix Salmon: BET MGM OPERATES PURSUANT TO AN OPERATING AGREEMENT WITH THE ALBERTA EYE GAMING CORPORATION. STANDARD MESSAGE AND DATA RATES MAY APPLY.
24:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I'M SARAH NICOLE FROM THE PAPAYA PODCAST AND EVER SINCE SEPTEMBER IT HAS BEEN NON-STOP BUSY WITH SCHEDULES AND TAKING CARE OF EVERYONE ELSE AROUND ME. AS WOMEN WE TEND TO PUT OURSELVES LAST AND THIS YEAR BEFORE I HIT COMPLETE BURNOUT I LEARNED ABOUT GREENSHIELD HEALTH AND they're making it easier for women to access therapy. So while WE'RE ALL TAKING CARE OF OTHERS, THEY CAN TAKE CARE OF US AND THAT
24:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): MATTERS MORE THAN YOU KNOW. VISIT GREENSHIELD.CA FOR A FREE FIRST HOUR UNTIL NOVEMBER 30TH. THAT'S G-R-E-E-N-S-H-I-E-L-D.C-A FOR A FREE FIRST HOUR UNTIL NOVEMBER 30TH.
24:48
Felix Salmon: Okay, so we need to talk about the markets.
24:52
Felix Salmon: Market reaction to the election was super interesting. It's one of the most interesting reactions I've seen, like, ever. When the results were coming in, there was a broad sell-off, especially in tech stocks, and we can talk about why. Then, on the day after the election, they all kind of went A lot up, or them a lot of them went up, led by the big
25:12
Felix Salmon: spenders, Apple, Microsoft, Google. and then on Thursday, two days after the election, those big spenders broadly stayed up, but then the more sort of core AI stocks, like CoreWeave, more sort of data-centric stocks kind of fell off a cliff. And all of this is related to two big things.
25:32
Felix Salmon: One is that a lot of the people coming into office, especially the incoming governor of Texas. BUT LOTS OF OTHER PEOPLE HAVE BASICALLY CALLED FOR A MORATORIUM ON DATA CENTERS, AND GIVEN THAT SO MUCH OF THE AI TRADE WAS ABOUT LIKE WE ARE GOING TO BE BUILDING DATA CENTERS FASTER AND FASTER UNTIL THE DEATH OF THE UNIVERSE, THAT KIND OF PUT THE KYBOSH ON
25:52
Felix Salmon: THAT TRADE. AND THEN THE SECOND PART OF IT WAS SOMETHING THAT LOOKS VERY SIMILAR TO WHAT WE SAW WITH SITUATIONAL AWARENESS A FEW MONTHS AGO, WHICH WAS BASICALLY JUST THAT THERE WAS AN INCREDIBLY crowded hedge fund trade where they were all in the same stocks, and they were all betting on them going up, and they all deleveraged and tried to get out at the same time, and there was this rush for the exits, and the
26:12
Felix Salmon: stocks went down. But if you put it all together, Emily, what's your sort of verdict? Do you think that this could be the bubble I don't, bursting?
26:22
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I don't, I'm not going to prognosticate, Felix. I don't know. I think some of this was already happening going into the election. Like you saw a lot of the chip stocks were falling off their highs in September. The hedge fund unwinds were already happening ahead of the election. So I feel like the election just sort of a, like a catalyst for that
26:42
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): sell-off that took a day to happen. And we're talking on Friday morning. So I don't know what's going to happen now. The market's just open. and
26:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): it looks like they're up a little bit.
26:53
Felix Salmon: So it was just my general opinion here is that Thursday was noise and Wednesday was real.
26:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Maybe. I think what we learned Wednesday and what we were originally going to talk about today was that the big tech, the so-called hyperscalers, meta Microsoft, Alphabet, were going to be okay. like even if there is a data center pullback, these companies are in they're fine. They're in relatively good shape. It's all those other weird companies like the crypto companies that are now
27:19
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): making data centers that company iron stuff like that, like the chip makers that went up 100% or more over the past year, they're kind of like, okay, this is getting a little crazy. I guess the just the question is just like, do those the troubles for all those little players that became really big do to those sort of like
27:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): spill over and pop the bubble or is it like a more subtle situation? I don't think there's a bubble popping. I think maybe this was some necessary letting a little air out of the bubble because the rate at which the hyperscalers and some of the smaller AI companies were planning on doing data center buildouts already had some problems. You know, one of which was that in a lot of
27:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): places the grids couldn't sustain it. There's Bipartisan Data Center. opposition. And especially when you consider that most of the places where these data centers, the biggest ones were slated to be developed were in rural areas that skewed incredibly red, especially in Texas. So you had a kind of opposition to tech oligarchy coming from the left and
28:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): opposition from the communities that were being EFFECTED affected directly by data centers coming from the right. And I think everybody kind of saw that coming. BUT THE THE SORT OF DEMOCRATIC ROUTE MEANS THAT THERE ARE A BUNCH OF OTHER THINGS THAT ARE KIND OF I THINK SECONDARY IN THE DISCOURSE BUT EQUALLY IMPORTANT AND THERE ARE CONSIDERATIONS AROUND
28:38
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): REGULATION PERMITTING THINGS LIKE THAT THINGS THAT BASICALLY ALL THESE COMPANIES HAVE NOT REALLY HAD TO DEAL WITH UP TO THIS POINT BECAUSE THEY HAVE BEEN ALLOWED TO GO IN AND BUILD THESE DATA CENTERS WITH NO RESISTANCE NO REGULATION AND THEY HAVE BEEN ABLE TO SHOULDER THE COST OF NEGATIVE EXTERNALITIES ONTO OTHER PEOPLE, AND NOW THE
28:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): DEMOCRATIC CONGRESS IS GOING TO COME IN AND KIND OF SAY, ALL RIGHT, YOU GUYS HAVE TO BE RESPONSIBLE FOR SOME OF THIS STUFF, AND WE NEED COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION IF YOU'RE GOING TO PUT A DATA CENTER IN OUR DISTRICTS.
29:09
Felix Salmon: I mean, I don't think that the House of Representatives, even with a 250 seat majority or whatever it is, is going to be able to do anything really in the face of presidential vetoes. I do think the White House is going to probably stay relatively strong on this one, even though there is bipartisan calls for more regulation and a
29:29
Felix Salmon: slowdown and pacing the frontier and all these things. I do think that at the COMPANIES state IN level and at the local level, especially in Texas, but also in Virginia and also in Ohio and also in Georgia, the ABILITY OF GOVERNORS AND THE STATE LEVEL LEGISLATURES TO PUT THE KIBOSH ON THESE DATA CENTER BUILDOUTS IS MASSIVE AND THEY
29:48
Felix Salmon: CAN AND THEY WILL.
29:50
Felix Salmon: AND MY OPINION IS BROADLY IN LINE WITH WEDNESDAY'S MARKET, WHICH IS THIS IS PROBABLY A GOOD THING, THAT WE WERE SPENDING TOO MUCH MONEY ON DATA CENTERS, THAT it was A LOT OF THE MONEY THAT WAS BEING SPENT ON this stuff was being spent just because everyone else was spending money a little bit like we were talking in with Sarah about how like one party needs to spend money just because the
30:10
Felix Salmon: other party is spending money. Like, you know, if you're meta, you need to spend hundreds of billions of dollars on compute because Apple is spending hundreds of millions on compute. And so it's Microsoft, you know, and so if this arms race of spending money, a lot of which and we're seeing this with chip prices and stuff, a lot of which is just price insensitive. If that arms race slows
30:30
Felix Salmon: down a bit, that's good for the economics of AI.
30:35
Felix Salmon: And I think we saw that with the way that some of those big companies have risen in price. And I think we're also seeing it too, like it's very hard in this world of OpenAI and anthropic being private companies to see really what the AI trade is doing. because the AI... TRADE IS SO CONCENTRATED IN THOSE TWO COMPANIES. BUT
30:55
Felix Salmon: WE DO HAVE THIS WONDERFUL THING CALLED HYPERLIQUID WHICH IS A CRYPTO-Y KIND OF WEBSITE WHERE YOU CAN TRADE THE STOCK OF THOSE COMPANIES. AND IT'S THE BEST THING WE HAVE. IT'S NOT PERFECT BUT IT'S NOT BAD. AND IF YOU LOOK AT THE STOCK PRICE OF ANTHROPIC AND OpenAI ON HYPERLIQUID, IT'S BASICALLY FLAT. THEY'RE DOWN A BIT SINCE THE ELECTION BUT NOTHING TOO BAD.
31:15
Felix Salmon: AND PEOPLE ARE TALKING ABOUT MAYBE ANTHROPIC WILL DELAY ITS IPO A LITTLE BIT, BUT
31:21
Felix Salmon: I TAKE THAT AS A BULLISH SIGN, THAT THEY'RE LIKE, NO, WE WANT TO WAIT UNTIL WE CAN GET MORE MONEY, RATHER THAN BEING LIKE, OH, SHIT, NO ONE WANTS TO BUY OUR STOCK. I THINK AT A $1.4 TRILLION VALUATION OR SOMETHING, ANTHROPIC WOULD HAVE NO TROUBLE GETTING I AN IPO OUT THE DOOR.
31:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I MEAN, WE'RE SEEING NOW SOME PUSHBACK ON THE VALUATION. given everything that happened this week. I think that's the big question mark, because Anthropic and OpenAI are such a key part of the AI trade, but we still don't really know how successful, obviously, we don't know how successful the IPO is going to be. And like Anthropic has something like $800
31:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): billion of like spending commitments, I think we talked about last week. LIKE THERE'S SUCH A LIKE A PIVOTAL KIND OF PILLAR IN THE AI TRADE RIGHT AND SO A LOT IS KIND OF HANGING ON HOW WELL THAT IPO DOES AND IF THEY DO SAY LIKE WE'RE NOT GOING TO DO IT THIS YEAR WE'RE NOT
32:11
Sarah Fischer: GOING TO DO BEFORE THANKSGIVING LIKE WE SAID
32:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I THINK THAT WOULD LEAD TO MORE STOCK GYRATIONS WOULD BE MY GUESS COMPANIES ARE UNDER DIFFERENT PRESSURES IF THEY'RE PRIVATE VERSUS PUBLIC AND I THINK PUBLIC SHAREHOLDERS ARE LOOKING AT THE HYPERSCALERS AND THEY DON'T CONSIDER IF THEY SLOW DOWN A LITTLE bit on AI development, they're not as concerned about it because they have other revenue lines, they're big enough to sort of handle the
32:32
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): impact. And I don't think it's really going to hurt Anthropic or OpenAI, but it would not surprise me if the valuations were lower because they would have to readjust projections of what they're supposed to be building out because that's the sort of what they promised the early stage and later stage VCs. So there would be some justification for the valuation being lower
32:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): given all of that.
32:53
Felix Salmon: Yeah, so much of those valuations are a function of growth rates. And, you know, if things are slowing down, then growth rates are slowing down. And it kind of stands to reason that valuations might come down. I don't really think that it's the end of the world if Anthropic is worth $1 trillion rather than TRILLION $2 trillion. DOLLARS, It's still a trillion dollar company, you know, it's still like, why does that even matter?
33:14
Sarah Fischer: One thing I have. BEEN THINKING ABOUT A LOT WITH REGARDS JUST TO GO BACK TO DATA CENTERS AND BACKLASH AND SLOWDOWNS AND ALL OF THIS IS HOW, IF YOU LOOK AT IT ONE WAY, DATA CENTER DEVELOPMENT IS KIND OF LIKE RESIDENTIAL HOUSING DEVELOPMENT IN THAT THIS BIG IMPORTANT INDUSTRY MACROECONOMIC FORCE, THE AI TRADE THAT'S DRIVING
33:33
Sarah Fischer: IT'S THE ECONOMY AND
33:40
Sarah Fischer: HARD TO BUILD STUFF IN THE UNITED STATES. THERE WAS A WHOLE BOOK ABOUT IT, I GUESS. I HAVEN'T READ IT, BUT I'VE SEEN THE DISCOURSE ABOUT ABUNDANCE OR WHATEVER. AND FOR A WHILE, IT LOOKED LIKE DATA CENTER CONSTRUCTION WAS, LIKE, SPECIAL. IT TAKES HOUSES AND APARTMENT BUILDINGS A REALLY LONG TIME TO GET BUILT BECAUSE THERE'S ALL THIS NIMBYISM AND WHATEVER.
33:59
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
33:59
Felix Salmon: not in Texas like in Texas Texas was always
34:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the exception
34:05
Sarah Fischer: I
34:06
Sarah Fischer: was just reading an analysis last week, and Elizabeth just said all the data center development got, like, it went to rural red areas with low regulation on purpose, because they were like, this, I will not encounter the NIMBYs here, we will not have the same problems as housing has, of course, because we figured it all out. And there was almost like a fiscal.
34:27
Sarah Fischer: stimulus to the construction, right? Policymakers in these places were like, we love this. Have a tax break. Don't worry about it. You're good. Build all you want. We don't care. And like immediately are hit with the same backlash that affects the housing market all the time. Like these forces in America are like deep and real and bipartisan,
34:47
Sarah Fischer: actually. Can
34:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
34:48
Felix Salmon: share my mildly facetious?
34:51
Felix Salmon: SOMETHING, EXPLANATION FOR WHY TEXAS WENT BLUE AND FLORIDA STAYED RED?
34:57
Felix Salmon: TEXAS HAS BEEN DOING AN ASTONISHINGLY GOOD JOB OF BUILDING HOUSES FOR PEOPLE AND EXPANDING ITS CITIES, AND CITIES ARE BLUE. AND FLORIDA HAS BEEN DOING A TERRIBLE JOB OF BUILDING. THEREFORE, ALL OF THAT KIND of urban expansion that happened in Texas has not happened. IN FLORIDA.
35:16
Sarah Fischer: I LIKE THAT. I THOUGHT IT WAS MORE LIKE CALIFORNIA EXPORTED ALL ITS QUOTE UNQUOTE WOKE TECH PEOPLE, LIKE THEY'RE NOT REALLY THAT, THEY WEREN'T THAT WOKE BECAUSE THEY LEFT
35:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): CALIFORNIA BUT THEY'RE
35:25
Sarah Fischer: STILL MORE LIBERAL PERHAPS THAN GARDEN VARIETY.
35:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
35:29
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): WOULDN'T CONSIDER THAT A PRIMARY EXPLANATION FOR THE DIFFERENCE BUT IT'S A, THE OTHER THING IS JUST THAT THE INCOMING GOVERNOR IS PRETTY MODERATE, LIKE SHE'S NOT A, SHE'S NOT REALLY PROGRESSIVE.
35:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): And she said something this morning on CNN where she said something like, you know, with the AI stuff and the data center issues, 99% of us are in the same boat. And you can sort of build this bipartisan consensus around the idea that we're all, this is a Texas issue. And on the other side of it TO, are OR, 15 tech guys who have way too much power in
35:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): government.
36:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So can
36:00
Felix Salmon: we talk about the one guy? WHO IS ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THAT? AND HIS NAME IS ELON MUSK. YOU MIGHT HAVE HEARD OF HIM. HE FAMOUSLY MOVED NOT ONLY HIS COMPANY TO TEXAS AND BUILT AN ENTIRE CITY IN TEXAS CALLED, WHAT'S IT CALLED? STAR SOMETHING?
36:17
Sarah Fischer: STAR BASE.
36:17
Felix Salmon: STAR BASE. HE EVEN MOVED HIS COMPANY, TESLA, FROM DELAWARE TO TEXAS. LIKE, HE IS ALL IN ON TEXAS. AND THEN, AS WE DISCUSSED, PUT $300 MILLION INTO TRYING TO KEEP TEXAS RED AND FAILED. AND IF THERE'S, ON THE FACE OF IT, ONE BIG LOSER OUT OF THIS ELECTION, IT WOULD BE ELON, BECAUSE
36:37
Felix Salmon: ALL OF HIS BETS ON, LIKE, I CAN TRUST TEXAS TO BE PRO-ELON SEEM TO HAVE GONE SOUTH AT EXACTLY THE SAME TIME. EMILY, YOU'RE SMILING AS THOUGH YOU'RE FEELING A LITTLE BIT
36:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): OF
36:48
Felix Salmon: SCHODENFREUD SHELDON FREUDER IN
36:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): HERE.
36:49
Sarah Fischer: I was just thinking about that. THE WEEKEND. IT WAS UNRELATED TO WHAT YOU WERE SAYING. YES, ELON MUSK DOES SEEM LIKE KIND OF A LOSER BECAUSE HE SPENT ALL THIS MONEY IN TEXAS AND IT DIDN'T GO HIS WAY AND HE PUT ALL THESE RESOURCES INTO TEXAS AND IT DIDN'T GO HIS WAY. AND ALSO, THERE'S A LOT OF DISCOURSE, POST-ELECTION DISCOURSE ABOUT X.COM WAS A BUBBLE AND NO ONE
37:09
Sarah Fischer: SAW THE BLUE WAVE COMING BECAUSE THEY WERE ALL TALKING TO EACH OTHER AND IT WAS BAD FOR THE TECH INDUSTRY baby. because they were all talking to each other, not thinking about the backlash, spinning up their theories about AI apocalypse, not realizing or thinking about how people might receive said theories, whatever. I don't know. Blue sky is celebrating, you know, the
37:29
Sarah Fischer: usual splintering of the social media. But what I'm saying is in addition to being sort of like a lose for Elon Musk's Texas strategy, it also kind of location. LOW-KEY LOOKS LIKE A LOSE FOR ELON MUSK'S SOCIAL MEDIA STRATEGY AND THE KICKER IS I GUESS THAT HE'S NOT GONNA MAKE THE CYBER TRUCK ANYMORE AND I DON'T KNOW HOW THAT
37:48
Sarah Fischer: RELATES TO ARB BUT I JUST WANTED TO SAY IT.
37:52
Felix Salmon: I'M
37:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): JUST HAPPY NEVER TO SEE THAT THING
37:54
Felix Salmon: AGAIN. IT'S A TRULY UGLY VEHICLE BUT ELIZABETH. I
37:58
Sarah Fischer: FEEL LIKE IT'LL GO UP IN VALUE NOW IF THEY STOP MAKING IT.
38:01
Felix Salmon: NO.
38:02
Felix Salmon: NO?
38:03
Sarah Fischer: Like the existing
38:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): ones?
38:04
Felix Salmon: It's not like
38:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
38:05
Felix Salmon: DeLorean, Emily.
38:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): That's
38:07
Sarah Fischer: what I was going to say. Is it like a DeLorean?
38:11
Felix Salmon: Elizabeth, I need to ask you, where does this leave Elon Musk's influence and power within the Republican Party? Is it gone? Is it still there?
38:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I think it depends on I think it's still there if he still chooses to spend money. But, you know, he's sort of fickle. in the same way that Teal and some of the other big funders have been. He'll dip in and out. You know, he was pretty happy to exit Doge in a very abrupt fashion and then jump back in with money when he saw that maybe that would help. So I think what will drive his
38:41
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): decision to be in politics will be the extent to which Democrats start I think if to he feels hold like him his actual accountable ability to for keep, things you and know, how to that stay plays on into the treadmill the public that he's discourse. on with SpaceX But and also a I potential think he merger might with get Tesla, some backlash if he locally. thinks that's threatening in any way, he'll have to participate with money.
39:09
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): A potential merger with Tesla, if he thinks that's threatened in any way, he'll have to participate with money and, you know, he'll have to be in the process. He can't just check out of it. So I don't think he's going anywhere. I think it's going to be harder for him.
39:22
Sarah Fischer: Yeah, he's going to be okay.
39:24
Felix Salmon: Elon is not going anywhere.
39:27
Sarah Fischer: My one last hot take was that the wealth tax didn't pass in California, but the AI data center backlash was sort of a version of that. That's my, do I have to explain more?
39:38
Felix Salmon: No, I think, I think that's RIGHT. AND THE WEALTH TEXT IN CALIFORNIA THING WE HAVE NOT TALKED ABOUT. AND IT'S, I BELIEVE THE TECHNICAL TERM IS MESSY AS FUCK. THE PROPOSITION 40 FAILED, PROPOSITION 42 PASSED. THAT'S GOING TO MAKE IT MORE DIFFICULT TO DO A WEALTH TEXT IN THE WAY IT SHOULD BE DONE. I THINK WE CAN PROBABLY ALL AGREE THAT THE WAY THE WEALTH TEXT WAS PUT ON THE BALLOT WAS NOT THE WAY BASICALLY, AN IDEAL WEALTH
39:57
Felix Salmon: TEXT ACT SHOULD BE DONE. BUT IN ANY CASE, AS ANA SHEMANSKY SHIMANSKY ONCE OF THIS PARISH HAS NEVER STOPPED TALKING IN MY HEAD, LIKE THIS THING IS NEVER GOING TO HAPPEN. LIKE IT'S JUST THERE'S NO WEALTH ACT THAT WILL EVER PASS THE SUPREME COURT SO LONG AS THE SUPREME COURT HAS ANY KIND OF A REPUBLICAN MAJORITY AND EVEN IF THE DEMOCRATS TAKE THE SUPREME COURT, EVEN THEN
40:18
Felix Salmon: IT SEEMS PRETTY CLEARLY UNCONSTITUTIONAL.
40:38
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): BetMGM, an official sports betting partner of the National Hockey League, is ready for puck drop. Now hockey fans in Alberta can get in on the action from the opening face-off with Goal IN and First Ten, a betting market where you can call whether a goal will be scored by any TEAM IN THE FIRST TEN MINUTES OF A GAME. FROM PRE-GAME TO LIVE BETS, SAME GAME PARLEES, PLAYER PROPS, AND MORE. BET MGM HAS
40:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): OVER 500 NHL BETTING MARKETS TO CHOOSE FROM. AND THE BET MGM APP HAS INSTANT DEPOSIT AND FAST WITHDRAWAL OPTIONS INCLUDING INTERAC E-TRANSFER, VISA, MASTERCARD AND APPLE PAY, AND MORE. DOWNLOAD THE BetMGM BET MGM APP AND DON'T MISS A SECOND OF THE OPENING MINUTES. BET BetMGM, MGM, AN OFFICIAL SPORTS BETTING partner of the National Hockey League. Your home for hockey bets
41:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): all season long. See BetMGM.com for terms. 18 plus only, bet responsibly. Alberta only, subject to eligibility requirements.
41:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): If gambling is affecting your mental health or well-being, 211 Alberta is here to help. Call or text 211 or visit ab.211.ca.
41:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Standard message and data rates may apply. BetMGM BET MGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with the Alberta EYE iGaming GAMING Corporation.
41:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): YOU WORK HARD FOR YOUR BUSINESS. LET YOUR CREDIT CARD WORK HARDER FOR YOU. WITH THE WESTJET RBC WORLD ELITE MASTERCARD FOR BUSINESS, UNLOCK UP TO 100,000 WESTJET POINTS. ENJOY SILVER STATUS FOR AT LEAST A YEAR, WITH BENEFITS LIKE PRIORITY BOARDING, LOUNGE ACCESS, AND FREE CHECKED BAGS. PLUS, EARN UP TO 6 POINTS PER DOLLAR ON WESTJET TRAVEL.
41:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): You'll also earn up to three 3 points per dollar on eligible business purchases. MAKING THIS THE FASTEST WAY TO EARN WESTJET POINTS. TURN BUSINESS SPENDING INTO YOUR NEXT ADVENTURE. TERMS AND CONDITIONS APPLY. VISIT RBC.COM SLASH WESTJET BUSINESS TO LEARN MORE.
42:18
Felix Salmon: but we should move on to really important things like the boxes that bottles of whiskey come in after all of this talk of elections and money and trillions of dollars, we need to talk about something utterly frivolous.
42:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Well, everybody needs a drink anyway, so whenever you're listening to this podcast, pour yourself a glass of whiskey. Pour
42:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yourself a glass of
42:39
Felix Salmon: whiskey.
42:40
Felix Salmon: Emily, are you a whiskey drinker at all?
42:43
Sarah Fischer: I like whiskey. I like brown over white when it comes to liquor, yes. And
42:47
Felix Salmon: then when it comes to whiskey, this is one of the things I learned when I was reporting this story. which we're going to link in the show notes. When it comes to whiskey, it turns out that Americans really fall into one of two camps. There's the majority of Americans who drink whiskey with an E, and then there's the minority of Americans who drink whiskey without an E, like
43:06
Felix Salmon: scotch. The ones who drink scotch don't drink bourbon, and the ones who drink bourbon don't drink scotch. Are you one of the people who just drink both?
43:14
Sarah Fischer: Yeah, I'm a bourbonist. bourbon.
43:15
Felix Salmon: You're a
43:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): bourbon person.
43:16
Sarah Fischer: Yeah.
43:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I'm
43:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
43:17
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): both person. I'm
43:18
Sarah Fischer: a bourbon person. I really like bourbon. Wait, so bourbon is, I like these things, but I am ignorant.
43:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You like these
43:25
Felix Salmon: things, you just can't spell them.
43:27
Sarah Fischer: I can't spell them. I don't understand really. Bourbon is whiskey, but not all whiskey is bourbon. Some COMPANIES whiskey is INC. scotch.
43:34
Felix Salmon: Correct.
43:34
Sarah Fischer: And the whiskey that is scotch comes with an E or no E?
43:37
Felix Salmon: Scotch whiskey has no...
43:57
Sarah Fischer: I like bourbon. That is the end of what I will say. I like your Jim Beam. I like your Maker's Mark. I like that bullet brand
44:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): really
44:04
Sarah Fischer: good.
44:06
Sarah Fischer: I'm not going to spend $36,000 on scotch. I don't know. Felix, did you even try the $36,000? You did. You tried it, right?
44:14
Felix Salmon: I have a little taster at home and I'm trying to save it for when I'm actually going to write about what it tastes like because this story The really wasn't really about what it tastes like.
44:24
Sarah Fischer: But we should say the story is another one. Felix. you're becoming like, this is your little niche is like crazy expensive things. Felix tries them and explains. Felix explains crazy expensive things. We talked about the bread and now it's a scotch that is $36,000 that you're writing about.
44:40
Felix Salmon: Which by the standards of crazy expensive scotch is not that crazy expensive. So the news hook for of my article, it says is this $36,000, 50-year-old Glenn. $36,000, 50-year-old Glenmorangie, which is a scotch. There are lots of scotch whiskeys that are 50, 60, 70 years old, and some of them
45:00
Felix Salmon: sell for much, much more of that. There are bottles of scotch that have sold for like a million dollars. There are bottles on the secondary market, there are bottles that have sold new. There's this auction an that happens in Scotland every two years called the Distillers One of One Auction, where regularly Ray-
45:15
Felix Salmon: bottles sell for more than half a million dollars.
45:18
Sarah Fischer: But what do you do with that? Do people then drink them or they just sit in someone's house?
45:22
Felix Salmon: This is a really good question. And
45:26
Felix Salmon: the answer is that it's a big deal when they are opened, but they do get opened. And these things tend to be extremely limited edition. Sometimes it's just one, sometimes it's 20. the Glenmorangie was a 149, and that seemed quite large in sort of edition size. And the people, if you talk to like Johnny
45:46
Felix Salmon: Fowl at Sotheby's, who's the guy who knows all about this market more than anyone else, he like kind of knows when someone's opened one of these. And he's like, ah, that one's off the market. That has reduced the number outstanding. They do get opened. They generally live in the kind of places that you would expect them to live. ON LARGE MEGA YOTTS AND BIG MEGA
46:05
Felix Salmon: MANSIONS AND THAT KIND OF THING. AND THE THING THAT IS SUPER INTERESTING ABOUT THEM IS THAT THERE ARE VERY EXPENSIVE BOTTLES OF BOURBON AS WELL, BUT THE VERY EXPENSIVE BOTTLES OF BOURBON LOOK LIKE BOTTLES OF BOURBON.
46:21
Felix Salmon: And they're bizarre and weird and unique, and they're full of incredibly elaborate packaging. And so my question was, why? Why would
46:29
Felix Salmon: these companies, like, I can understand why they would put a lot of effort into making a 50-year-old whiskey taste good, but, like, why would you then spend thousands of dollars just on the packaging for the bottle of whiskey?
46:40
Sarah Fischer: Are you going to tell us the answer, or do we have to go, do the listeners have to go read the story?
46:44
Felix Salmon: Elizabeth, I want to ask you, like, when you saw the packaging for these bottles and the kind of... what they looked like, was it intuitive to you that, well, of course, they're going to do this? Or were you like, that doesn't make any sense?
46:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): No, I felt like I got it because it looked like everything's designed for display. And I did actually kind of like the, who was the guy, the ceramicist in your story?
47:06
Felix Salmon: Peter Pincus.
47:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): It looked cool.
47:08
Felix Salmon: He's up in Rochester, lovely guy, Peter and Laurie Pincus, Pinkus, I should say, it's the pair of them who make ceramics. And he made this sort of grid of 149 vessels, which you could put the bottles of whiskey into. And if you ever put those
47:24
Felix Salmon: 149 vessels into the grid, it made this beautiful sort of artwork called Together in Spirit. But he never did, because For insurance reasons, basically, they just couldn't. glenn morringy couldn't afford to have them all in the same place at the same time because it took him three years to make these 149 vessels.
47:42
Felix Salmon: It was really like a three-year project just to make the box that this whiskey came in.
47:47
Sarah Fischer: Is it just like if you're buying a very expensive whiskey, you want to, like Elizabeth is saying, you want to display it, you want to show off how expensive it is, so you have some elaborate design IMPLEMENTATION, sort LAND of SERVICES, DETAILS, around E-MILES, EDITION, it DESIGN, SORT and OF, packaging AROUND IN so you can really talk about it when people come over or stay on your yacht?
48:03
Felix Salmon: THAT'S KIND OF WHAT YOU MIGHT SAY THE FIRST PAST EXPLANATION AND THE REASON I STARTED OFF HERE BY TALKING ABOUT BURBON IS THAT THE FACT THAT DOESN'T HAPPEN IN BURBON KIND OF SHOWS THAT IT
48:15
Felix Salmon: DOESN'T HAVE A HUGE AMOUNT OF EXPLANATICITY POWER. IF THIS MADE PERFECT SENSE IN SCOTCH AND PEOPLE WANTED I TO SHOW OFF WHAT think THEY HAD, WOULDN'T THEY BE DOING that THE SAME THING I IN BURBON? AND THEY'RE NOT. think I THINK THAT, I THINK IT, is true. I don't think it's false. And I think one of the reasons why it doesn't happen in bourbon is because bourbon is much more about consistency,
48:35
Felix Salmon: whereas scotch is much more about uniqueness. So a very expensive bottle of bourbon, a little bit like a very expensive bottle of cognac is made sort of they make the very, very expensive THEM, THE BETTER. one every WHEREAS WITH year. SCOTCH, And IT'S it's pretty ALL ABOUT, much WELL, designed THERE'S THIS to ONE be PARTICULAR the same BARREL WHICH HAS BEEN year SITTING in IN and THE year BACK OF out. THIS And DISTILLERY so you, FOR 75 you YEARS AND WE'RE FINALLY BRINGING IT OUT AND WE'RE PUTTING IT INTO BOTTLES AND LIKE THERE ARE ONLY 20 OF THEM AND THEN
48:55
Felix Salmon: ONCE YOU, ONCE WE'VE BOTTLED THOSE 20 BOTTLES, THAT'S IT. AND IF WE HAD A DIFFERENT BARREL SITTING IN A DIFFERENT CORNER OF THE DISTILLERY, IT WOULD TASTE DIFFERENT AND IT WOULD BE A DIFFERENT BARREL. AND SO I THINK THAT'S A REALLY, REALLY
49:10
Felix Salmon: And if we had a different barrel sitting in a different corner of the distillery, it would taste different, and it would come in a different packaging, and it would cost a different amount of money.
49:18
Felix Salmon: What that does is it allows you to make packaging that is much more expensive because you don't need so many packages. If you are making thousands of vessels for bottles of bourbon, that will cost you a lot of money if they cost thousands of dollars COMPANIES INC, each, whereas INC, INC, INC, if INC, you're INC, INC, only making a couple of dozen, then you can actually afford to make expensive ones.
49:38
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): So Felix, what is...
49:57
Felix Salmon: Every so often, you kind of get invited from the front room to the back room, and then if you're in the back room, people will start pouring you crazy expensive burgundies and Bordeaux and that kind of thing, many of which are not really my jam, to be honest, but yeah, it would almost certainly be one of those, but I can't even tell you what it was, to be
50:17
Felix Salmon: honest.
50:18
Sarah Fischer: And have you
50:19
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): had the expensive scotches?
50:20
Felix Salmon: no like and one of the weird things is i lived in scotland for four years and i kind of got into scotch for a while there. And I would do these things called vertical tastings. You take like a Bowmore or something and you taste it. And this was back when Scotch was vaguely affordable. Like Scotch has gone up in price a lot since I was living there. But you would get like the
50:40
Felix Salmon: five year and the eight year and the 10 year and the 15 year and the 30 year and you would like put them all next to each other and taste them and be able to see how the taste changes as it gets older. AND OBVIOUSLY, THE OLDER IT IS, THE MORE THAT HAS EVAPORATED OVER TIME, THE RARER IT IS, THE MORE EXPENSIVE IT IS. LIKE, THERE'S A VERY STRONG CORRELATION BETWEEN AGE STATEMENT AND PRICE.
51:01
Felix Salmon: BUT JUST MY OWN, LIKE, IDEO-SYNCRATIC TASTE, I DIDN'T GENERALLY LIKE THE OLDER ONES THE MOST. IT WAS OFTEN, LIKE, THE 10- OR 12 12-YEAR-OLDS year olds THAT I LIKED like THE MOST RATHER THAN THE VERY OLD ONES, FOR WHATEVER REASON. And so I was quite lucky. in that regard. You know, I'm also quite lucky in not particularly loving very expensive red wines. The stuff I
51:20
Felix Salmon: like is not super expensive. And so that makes me happy because I can afford to drink the stuff I like.
51:26
Sarah Fischer: Is it like with vodka? I feel like every few years there's an article about how cheap vodka tastes the exact same as expensive vodka.
51:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's
51:33
Felix Salmon: true.
51:34
Sarah Fischer: But is that...
51:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's not the case in whiskey. That's not the case.
51:36
Felix Salmon: No, I mean, expensive whiskey, there is like... genuine connoisseurship around it, and it is very expensive to make, and it does take decades. There's no such thing as a vodka that takes decades to make.
51:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There's
51:47
Felix Salmon: all vodka you can make in a week.
51:49
Sarah Fischer: Wait, why is scotch harder to make and take longer to make?
51:53
Felix Salmon: Because the main ingredient in scotch is time. You put it in the barrels,
51:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and then you just wait
51:59
Felix Salmon: for a lot of time. And eventually the wood, in the barrels imparts the flavor to the liquor, right? The liquor is clear when it goes in the... That
52:09
Sarah Fischer: smoky flavor. When
52:09
Felix Salmon: you say you prefer brown liquor
52:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
52:12
Felix Salmon: white liquor,
52:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
52:14
Felix Salmon: you mean is you like it when people put the white liquor in a wooden barrel, leave it for a few years, and the color and the taste from the wood leaches into the liquor.
52:25
Sarah Fischer: I like a smoky flavor.
52:26
Felix Salmon: And off. often in America, with bourbon, what they do is they char the inside of the barrel. They take a blowtorch to it. And that's where you get your smoky flavor.
52:35
Sarah Fischer: That is very interesting. Thank you for that lesson. I hope the listeners enjoyed it as well.
52:41
Felix Salmon: What I discovered is that there's two main producers COMPANIES of whiskey packaging out there. And then Glenn MORRINGY, Margey, for whatever reason, decided to go with. NEITHER OF THEM AND THEY PICKED THIS RANDOM GUY IN ROCHESTER INSTEAD. BUT THERE IS THIS TINY LITTLE MICRO INDUSTRY OF DESIGNING SUPER SWANKY PACKAGING FOR WHISKEY
53:00
Felix Salmon: BOTTLES OR FOR SCOTCH BOTTLES IN PARTICULAR. AND THE PURPOSE IS TO DO EXACTLY WHAT I WAS SAYING, LIKE, IS TO DISTINGUISH THE ONE BARREL THAT COMPANIES WAS IN INC, ONE INC, CORNER INC, INC, INC, OF THE INC, DISTILLERY INC, INC, INC FROM THE OTHER BARREL THAT WAS IN THE OTHER CORNER OF THE DISTILLERY AND MAKE IT OBVIOUS THAT THEY'RE BOTH
53:33
Felix Salmon: ENERGY COMPANIES
53:34
Sarah Fischer: INC, ENERGY COMPANIES INC, ENERGY COMPANIES INC,
53:58
Felix Salmon: I
53:59
Sarah Fischer: didn't know that either. This is great. I feel like the ingredient is time is something you could say about a lot of other in writing as you learn as you're a daily, like, I'm trying to write something every day. But if you have three days to write something, like you have time to sort of the ingredient is time that the piece is better, you know, like with As
54:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): someone with a
54:17
Felix Salmon: monthly column, I couldn't agree more.
54:19
Sarah Fischer: Yeah, it's a really important ingredient I think
54:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
54:21
Sarah Fischer: month in is so the many, right across amount so of time many to spend levels. Writing writing something. bourbon, apparently, or scotra.
54:33
Felix Salmon: I think when you spend years writing something, like, I feel like things that appear in sort of monthlies are often better written and more conceptually rigorous than, say, books.
54:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I won't tell Robert Caro you said that. but
54:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes. yeah
54:48
Felix Salmon: But yeah, so in any case if you guys want to go out there and buy yourself an expensive bottle of scotch to celebrate whatever it is you're celebrating, let me give you the arbitrage.
55:01
Felix Salmon: The Glenmorangie 50-year-old is $36,000, but if you go to Europe, it's only €30,000.
55:08
Felix Salmon: So my advice is hop on a plane, buy it in Europe, and you can get it for basically the equivalent of about $34,000. which is a bargain.
55:16
Sarah Fischer: But how much does it cost to go to Europe?
55:19
Felix Salmon: You're probably going anyway, right? Yeah.
55:22
Sarah Fischer: Right, of course, of course.
55:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): should we have a number
55:38
Felix Salmon: Should we have a numbers round?
55:40
Felix Salmon: I will start. Why not? My number is 31, which is the number of years that Salon.com published before it died this week. Salon and Slate both started publishing around the same time. They were both the very the original internet
55:59
Felix Salmon: mags. I remember opening up my breath. browser pretty much the first week I arrived in New York in 1997 and going, I need to read the internet. And one of the places I would read would be slate.com. And one of the other ones would be salon.com. And it was a glorious era. And then eventually, of course, salon wound up getting caught up in
56:19
Felix Salmon: the.com bubble. It went public in 1999. We all know how that ended. And it somehow kept limping No. on for decades after the end of the dot-com bubble. It didn't die, but now it has died. And it was the birthplace of so much great journalism and online. It was well before the
56:39
Felix Salmon: era of blogs, but it had a little bit of that sort of proto-blogging sensibility.
56:44
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I wrote my first freelance piece for Ursuline.
56:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What
56:47
Sarah Fischer: was it about?
56:48
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I interviewed Lauren Weisberger right before the Devil Wears Prada came out.
56:52
Felix Salmon: About the book or about something else?
56:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): About the book, yeah.
56:55
Felix Salmon: Did they pay well?
56:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): No.
56:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): The company that owns them now is like a crypto operation or something.
57:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh no. A
57:04
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): few months ago.
57:04
Felix Salmon: So sad. I just hope the archives stay up somehow.
57:07
Sarah Fischer: Well, Slate's still going. Slate's on its 30th year now. They just celebrated.
57:11
Felix Salmon: With the OGs.
57:13
Sarah Fischer: Never went public.
57:14
Felix Salmon: Yeah, Slate never went public. That was the thing. Slate was owned by Microsoft during the dot-com boom. So maybe some tiny little part of Microsoft's bubblicious valuation back in 1999 was like, and they own Slate. Emily, what is your number?
57:29
Sarah Fischer: My number is 60. $60 an hour. That is how much a woman named appropriately, Kim House, charges. of upper middle class and rich people in Atlanta to be their house manager. According to the Wall Street Journal, this is the new, a new job. It's like kind of a house
57:49
Sarah Fischer: cleaner, kind of a house manager, planner slash organizer. And apparently it's all the rage right now among like the rich people with who have jobs and giant homes who can't take care of their homes anymore. It's like more expensive. than a cleaner. They'll like run errands for you. I guess like a housekeeper. I'm not sure, but they're
58:09
Sarah Fischer: called house manager.
58:10
Felix Salmon: Will they like pay the electricity bill? I
58:12
Sarah Fischer: think they would do that. Yes. But I think so. Will
58:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they take out the
58:15
Felix Salmon: trash?
58:16
Sarah Fischer: They will take out the trash, but they will not clean toilets.
58:19
Felix Salmon: Oh.
58:19
Sarah Fischer: Per the story. Like they have boundaries I in that regard.
58:22
Felix Salmon: But will think they hire the person to clean the toilet?
58:25
Sarah Fischer: I think they'll hire and oversee the. people cleaning the toilets who I'm sure do not make $60 an hour. And according to the journal, some of these house managers are making like annual six figures a year. And I mean, it's
58:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how many
58:37
Felix Salmon: houses do they have each
58:39
Sarah Fischer: multiple houses? I don't remember if there was a clear number, but it's multiple you're juggling.
58:44
Felix Salmon: I feel like they should reinvent themselves as a fractional butler.
58:48
Sarah Fischer: Yeah, it could be a fractional butler, but it's more like someone said, it's like a house having a housewife for couples where both are working.
58:55
Felix Salmon: Or a fractional housewife.
58:57
Sarah Fischer: And the journal framed it as like how to make it look like no one lives in your house when you're
59:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not there.
59:02
Sarah Fischer: Because you know how rich people, you go in their houses and everything's like all put away, the counters are clean. And you're like, how does someone, what? Why can't, how?
59:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh, because they have
59:11
Felix Salmon: staff.
59:12
Sarah Fischer: They have staff, exactly, but now, like, if you're not uber, uber rich and you can't have staff, you can hire this one person for like $100,000 a year and they will make it look like you don't live in your house.
59:23
Felix Salmon: You do need the square footage.
59:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They'll
59:25
Sarah Fischer: come in after everyone leaves in the morning and like put everything away.
59:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
59:28
Felix Salmon: other secret to making it look like everything is put away is to have places where everything can go if it's put away.
59:33
Sarah Fischer: Yeah, well, this is in Atlanta where I think there are a lot of really big houses, is my understanding.
59:38
Felix Salmon: I have been. told this, yes.
59:41
Felix Salmon: Elizabeth, what's your number?
59:43
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): My number is 40, and that's dollars, and that's how much Sylvester Stallone sold his dog, Butkus, for when he was broke, right before he sold the Rocky screenplay, and I learned this last night.
59:53
Felix Salmon: He sold his dog?
59:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yes, and then he, after he sold the screenplay, I, he tracked down the owner and bought the dog back, and the owner charged him $15,000 for it.
1:00:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): it. What? And insisted that he be in the movie. Wait,
1:00:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): he
1:00:05
Felix Salmon: sold his dog for $40 because what, he was that broke? And then he was like, I miss my dog, I want it back. And then the owner was like, that'll be $15,000 please. Makes
1:00:13
Sarah Fischer: total sense.
1:00:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes.
1:00:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): He said he was so broke that he couldn't afford to feed the dog and so he was like, I gotta do something. I learned this I'm doing because I went to a screening of Rocky last night at King's Theater in Brooklyn where Sylvester Stallone was on a panel. And this is maybe an apocryphal story, but he repeats it all the time.
1:00:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): And I highly recommend seeing Rocky in a theater with a live orchestra playing the score, which makes all the difference. So good. And I guess they're doing this on a national tour, and I imagine when they do it in Philly, it will be insane. As
1:00:46
Felix Salmon: someone who has recently seen Rocky the movie, I need to ask you this question. because it was a question that someone asked me a couple weeks ago and I was like, that's a good question.
1:00:57
Felix Salmon: When Rocky is training for his big fight, why does he need to get up at four o'clock in the morning? He doesn't have a day job. Why can't he just train during the day like a normal person?
1:01:08
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I don't know. I guess maybe he wants to be at peak energy and I guess you probably have that when you wake up. I don't know.
1:01:16
Sarah Fischer: That's a really good question. I think you just want to get it out of the – you work out in the morning to knock it out, to get it off your plate so you can do other stuff. But his other stuff was just more training, so I don't
1:01:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): know. Also, if you're going to punch big steaks in a meat locker, maybe that's the time when the meat locker is not busy. Yeah,
1:01:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): when
1:01:33
Sarah Fischer: you're running up the stairs and everything, you want to make sure not a lot of people are on the stairs with you.
1:01:38
Felix Salmon: Exactly. YOU COULDN'T GET THAT ICONIC SHOT IF YOU HAD TO DODGE A BUNCH OF STROLLERS OR WHATEVER.
1:01:43
Felix Salmon: I CAN HIGHLY RECOMMEND READING OR WATCHING THE INTERVIEW THAT SILVESTER STILL OWNED WITH LULU FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES. HE HAS A REALLY GREAT STORY. AND SO EITHER READ THAT OR WATCH THE MOVIE OR NEITHER.
1:01:56
Sarah Fischer: WAIT, WHY IS ROCKY SO IN THE DISCOURSE RIGHT NOW? IS IT LIKE AN ANNIVERSARY?
1:02:01
Felix Salmon: HE But HAS HIS AUTOBIOGRAPHY OUT.
1:02:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Ah.
1:02:04
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): And there's a movie coming out called I Play Rocky where it's like a biopic kind of. It's about him selling the Rocky screenplay and then insisting that he star in it. Exactly.
1:02:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They kept on saying
1:02:15
Felix Salmon: this is a good, they bought the screenplay and they're like, this is a great screenplay. We're going to get someone who can act to be Rocky. And he's like, no, I've got to be Rocky. and eventually he managed to persuade them that he would play Rocky even though they were very sceptical. skeptical because they were like, you can't act. And he's like, well, that's not going to stop me.
1:02:31
Sarah Fischer: It's a very rocky story.
1:02:33
Felix Salmon: Okay, I think that's it for us this week. Thank you to all of you guys for listening. Thank you to Jessamyn and Molly for producing. Thank you especially to Sarah Fisher for calling INC, in from an undisclosed location somewhere in lower Manhattan. do keep the emails coming on SLATEMONEYATSLATE.COM AND
1:02:53
Felix Salmon: WE WILL BE BACK NEXT WEEK WITH MORE SLATE MONEY.
1:03:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Now, hockey fans in Alberta can get in on the action from the opening face-off with Goal in First Ten, a betting market where you can call whether a goal will be scored by any team in the first ten minutes of a game. From pregame to live bets, same-game parlays, player props, and more, BetMGM has over 500 NHL betting markets to choose from. And the BetMGM app has instant deposit and
1:03:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): fast withdrawal options, including Interac e-transfer, Visa, MasterCard and Apple Pay, and more. Download the BET BetMGM MGM app and don't miss a second of the OPENING open. MINUTES. BET MGM, AN OFFICIAL SPORTS BETTING PARTNER OF THE NATIONAL HOCKEY LEAGUE. YOUR HOME FOR HOCKEY BETS ALL SEASON LONG. SEE BETMGM.COM FOR TERMS. 18 PLUS ONLY, BET RESPONSIBLY. ALBERTA ONLY,
1:03:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): SUBJECT TO ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS.
1:03:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): IF GAMBLING IS AFFECTING YOUR MENTAL HEALTH OR WELL-BEING, 2-1-1 ALBERTA IS HERE TO HELP. CALL OR TEXT 2-1-1 OR VISIT AB.211.CA.
1:03:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Standard message and data rates may apply. BET BetMGM MGM operates... PURSUANT TO AN OPERATING AGREEMENT WITH THE ALBERTA I-GAMING CORPORATION.
1:04:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): OPTIMIZED WEALTH MANAGEMENT WAS BUILT FOR THOSE READY FOR THE NEXT LEVEL, WHETHER YOU'RE AN ADVISOR OR AN INVESTOR. IT'S A PLATFORM THAT RECOGNIZES YOUR ACHIEVEMENTS AND GIVES YOU WHAT YOU NEED TO RAISE YOUR GAME. GROW YOUR PRACTICE OR YOUR PORTFOLIO THROUGH A FIRM AS UNIQUE AND DISCERNING AS YOU ARE. VISIT OWM.COM SLASH LEARN MORE TO LEARN MORE. Optimize
1:04:26
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): wealth management. FOR THOSE WHO WANT MORE.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with whisperx-large-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-GGUF:UD-Q4_K_XL. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Slate Money

Slate Money

The Nvidia Honeypot Boils Over

Episode discussion: NVIDIA CEO ousting, Anthropic IPO, and state tax debates dominate Slate Money

Speakers’ claims: Felix Salmon and Emily Peck discuss the resignation of NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang amid personal scandals, noting the stock's initial drop and recovery. They analyze the corporate governance implications, contrasting Huang's lack of dual-class stock with other tech founders. The conversation shifts to the rapid pace of market narratives, highlighting Anthropic's upcoming IPO and the resilience of AI sector momentum. Finally, the hosts cover Washington State's new millionaires tax, the legal challenges of wealth taxes, and consumer alerts regarding BMW recalls.

NVIDIAJensen HuangCorporate Governance
55 min1 assets17 claims to verify
Slate Money

Money Talks: Policy That Fights P(doom)

Episode discussion: Justin Hendrix and guests discuss AI safety incentives, regulatory gaps, and rising public opposition to data centers.

Speakers’ claims: Host Elizabeth Spiers interviews Justin Hendrix, CEO of Tech Policy Press, about the conflict between AI safety and competitive market pressures. Hendrix argues that US privacy legislation is fragmented and ineffective, while legislative proposals like the 'Great American AI Act' often miss the mark. The conversation highlights privacy risks in Meta's 'Muse' AI agent and the physical salience of data centers driving local political opposition. Guests note that tech policy is becoming a mainstream 'kitchen table' issue, with researchers warning about recursive self-improvement and the ambiguity of AGI claims.

AI SafetyTech PolicyData Centers
42 min2 assets20 claims to verify
All insights