Thoughts On Money [TOM]

Speakers argue S&P 500 concentration creates false diversification and investors must define portfolio purpose.

50 min Listen to the original Episode page
Index ConstructionS&P 500Market ConcentrationPassive InvestingPortfolio Strategy

Summary

Trevor Cummings hosts Brett Bonecutter and Ishan Chhabra, authors of 'The Five Hundred That Are Really Ten,' to discuss index construction and market concentration. Ishan Chhabra highlights that the top seven S&P 500 companies account for 33.5% of the index, driven by AI-related thematic correlation rather than true sector diversification. Brett Bonecutter describes the current environment as 'the Great Repricing,' where valuations adjust without a broad crash, emphasizing the business risk of individual holdings. The speakers argue that no index is neutral, as each embodies a specific thesis, and investors must define their portfolio's purpose rather than passively accepting index mandates.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    And I say this in the article as well, but that does inherently mean if you were to invest a million dollars in the S SP P 500, five hundred, three hundred $335,300 and

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 7:51

  2. 2
    A single large-cap holding can dominate portfolio performance; a 5% index weight in a stock dropping 20% results in a 1% total portfolio loss.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 30:11

  3. 3
    Every index construction method embodies a specific thesis or worldview, and no index is agnostic or neutral.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 37:20

  4. 4
    setting up a purpose for why you're investing within a certain portfolio.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 44:17

Episode sections

  1. 0:16 – 2:14

    Introduction and Article Context

    Trevor Cummings introduces guests Brett Bonecutter and Ishan Chhabra, who authored the blog post 'The Five Hundred That Are Really Ten.' Ishan explains the article was inspired by a Wall Street Journal note on the wide performance spread between the S&P 500 and its equal-weighted counterpart, aiming to clarify how indices are constructed and used.

  2. 2:14 – 5:43

    Defining 'The Market' and Index Usage

    The hosts discuss how 'the market' is an undefined term often conflated with the S&P 500, despite the convergence of the S&P, Nasdaq, and Dow. Ishan outlines two primary uses for indices: as a probe for general market sentiment and as a benchmark for performance comparison, noting that benchmarks should vary by investment style.

  3. 5:43 – 6:58

    Equal Weight vs. Cap Weight and October Performance

    Ishan highlights that in October, the equal-weighted S&P 500 rose approximately 6% while the cap-weighted S&P 500 fell about 1%, illustrating the impact of concentration. This disparity shows that broad market indices do not represent the performance of all constituent companies equally.

  4. 6:58 – 10:18

    Top Seven Concentration in S&P 500

    Ishan states that the top seven companies in the S&P 500 account for 33.5% of the index's weight, meaning a $1 million investment in the S&P 500 would have $335,300 invested in just those seven firms. He notes that five or six of these are heavily correlated to the AI trade, challenging the notion of diversification.

  5. 10:18 – 11:58

    Sector vs. Thematic Correlation

    While the S&P 500 shows sector diversification (e.g., Amazon in Consumer Discretionary, Google/Meta in Communication Services), Ishan argues that thematic correlation to the AI trade is the dominant risk factor. He views the October reversal after a September concentration run-up as a consequence of this heavy weighting.

  6. 11:58 – 18:05

    The Great Repricing and Business Risk

    Brett Bonecutter describes the current environment as 'the Great Repricing,' where stock valuations adjust without a broad market crash. He emphasizes that owning individual companies introduces business risk, where non-financial events (e.g., a CEO's personal decisions) can impact stock price, distinct from general market risk.

  7. 18:05 – 28:34

    Indexes as Marketing Products

    Brett likens buying an index-linked fund without understanding its composition to buying a meal replacement shake without reading the ingredients. Ishan adds that ETFs are products with specific tilts (growth, value, momentum), and investors must understand what they are purchasing rather than treating the S&P 500 as a neutral benchmark.

  8. 28:34 – 32:15

    Index Treadmill Risk

    Speaker 2 describes index-linked products as an automated mechanism that places investors on a 'treadmill' with pre-set speed and incline, implying that investors must meet the index's valuation expectations. Speaker 0 illustrates this with a hypothetical scenario where a 5% index holding in a large company drops 20%, causing a 1% portfolio loss, arguing that investors should opt out of companies they view as speculative rather than accepting the index's automatic exposure.

  9. 32:15 – 35:18

    False Diversification Trap

    Speaker 1 highlights the tension between the intuitive belief that owning 500 companies equals diversification and the reality that concentration risk remains. Speaker 2 shares his transition from passive SPY investing to active fundamental analysis, while Speaker 0 uses a grocery store analogy: buying five different types of apples is not a diversified meal, just as buying five stocks in the same sector (e.g., utilities or REITs) creates false diversification and high sensitivity to specific risks like interest rates.

  10. 35:18 – 37:17

    Equal Weight Isn’t Neutral

    Speaker 1 asks Speaker 2 to unpack the claim that equal weighting is not a neutral alternative to cap weighting. Speaker 2 explains that equal weighting introduces a structural tilt toward smaller, less expensive companies and results in higher portfolio turnover, meaning it is not a neutral benchmark but rather a different type of bet with its own risks.

  11. 37:17 – 43:35

    No Neutral Worldview

    Speaker 1 connects the lack of neutral indexes to a philosophical concept from David Bonner’s father, stating that every index has a thesis and a tilt. Speaker 0 expands on this by referencing Tim Keller’s book 'A Reason for God,' arguing that there is no neutral worldview and that investors are always making a wager or placing faith in a specific strategy, requiring them to understand and commit to that philosophy.

  12. 43:35 – 50:02

    Job of the Portfolio

    Speaker 0 asks Speaker 2 to explain the 'job of the portfolio.' Speaker 2 outlines a framework: 1) The Wager (the bet/strategy), 2) The Job (the purpose, such as capital accumulation or cash flow), and 3) The Test (comparing performance against a benchmark while understanding the benchmark's composition). Speaker 0 emphasizes that terms like liquidity and cash flow are critical because investors need access to their money for life events, not just theoretical growth.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
S&P 500indexneutralSo I came across this piece in the Wall Street Journal probably around a month ago, and it said that the uh S P five hundred and its equal weighted counterpart had the widest monthly spread in performance since April two 2009.
SPDR S&P 500 ETF TrustSPYetfneutralyou hear things like maybe SPY, and there's hundreds of others that are exact replicas of the S P five hundred, market cap weighted.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

The S&P 500 and its equal-weighted counterpart had the widest monthly performance spread since April 2009.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·0:32

How to verify: Check historical monthly performance data for the S&P 500 and S&P 500 Equal Weight Index (e.g., S&P Dow Jones Indices or Bloomberg) to confirm the spread magnitude and date range. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

In October, the equal-weighted S&P 500 rose about 6% while the cap-weighted S&P 500 fell about 1%.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·6:10

How to verify: Verify monthly total return data for the S&P 500 and S&P 500 Equal Weight Index for October 2026 using S&P Dow Jones Indices or a financial data provider like Bloomberg or FactSet. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The top seven companies in the S&P 500 make up approximately 33.5% of the index.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·7:51

How to verify: Check the current S&P 500 index composition and weights on the S&P Dow Jones Indices website or a financial data terminal. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Dow Jones Industrial Average is price-weighted.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·13:28

How to verify: Review the methodology documentation for the Dow Jones Industrial Average on the Dow Jones Indices website. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The S&P 500 contains 503 companies.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·13:48

How to verify: Check the current list of constituents on the S&P Dow Jones Indices website. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Nasdaq is price-weighted.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·14:19

How to verify: Review the methodology documentation for the Nasdaq Composite or Nasdaq-100 on the Nasdaq.com website (Note: This claim is factually incorrect as Nasdaq is cap-weighted, but the speaker stated it). For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The S&P 500 has been the number one indicator for economic productivity and growth since 1954.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·10:05

How to verify: Review historical economic literature or S&P Global's historical data on the S&P 500's correlation with GDP/productivity metrics since 1954. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The S&P 500 spent ten years flat.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·24:05

How to verify: Analyze the total return of the S&P 500 index over rolling 10-year periods from 2026 to present to identify periods of flat performance (e.g., 2026-2026 or 2026-2026 depending on start/end dates). For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Nasdaq spent roughly sixteen or seventeen years flat.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·24:25

How to verify: Analyze the total return of the Nasdaq Composite index over rolling 16-17 year periods to identify flat performance windows (e.g., 2026-2026 or similar). For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

In a hypothetical scenario, a stock priced at $80 would get 80% of the weight in a two-stock price-weighted index, while a $20 stock would get 20%.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·16:13

How to verify: Calculate the price-weighted average: ($80 + $20) / 2 = $50. Weight of $80 stock = 80/100 = 80%. Weight of $20 stock = 20/100 = 20%. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The top seven companies make up about 33.5% of the S&P 500.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·6:58

How to verify: Calculate the aggregate market capitalization of the top 7 S&P 500 constituents as a percentage of the total index market cap using S&P Dow Jones Indices data or a financial terminal for the relevant date in October 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The largest company in the world had a CEO involved in an infidelity scandal, and the stock was down 20% year-to-date at the time of the podcast.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·29:27

How to verify: Identify the CEO and company based on news from late 2026; verify the stock's YTD performance for October 2026 using market data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The NASDAQ had 20-year periods recently where the compound annual growth rate (CAGR) was 1%.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·39:54

How to verify: Calculate the CAGR of the NASDAQ Composite Index over various 20-year windows ending in or around 2026 using historical price data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

October 2026 saw the greatest dispersion between a dividend portfolio and the market in 15 years.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·43:07

How to verify: Compare the performance of a broad dividend index (e.g., SPYD or SCHD) against the S&P 500 for October 2026 and compare this dispersion to historical data from 2026-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

A hypothetical investment compounding at 30% a year for 50 years results in a billion dollars from a small initial investment.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·45:14

How to verify: Perform the compound interest calculation: $1,000 * (1.30)^50 ≈ $1.05 billion; verify the math. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Dallas Cowboys defeated the San Francisco 49ers 46-40 in a game 'last week' relative to the podcast date of November 20, 2026.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·40:45

How to verify: Check NFL game results for the week of November 10-16, 2026, for a matchup between the Dallas Cowboys and San Francisco 49ers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Equal-weighting an index increases turnover because smaller market cap companies have lower share prices or fewer shares outstanding.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·36:16

How to verify: Compare the annual turnover rates of the S&P 500 Equal Weighted ETF (RSP) versus the S&P 500 ETF (SPY) using fund fact sheets or financial data providers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Tim Keller’s book 'A Reason for God' opens with the idea that everyone places their faith in something, whether God or elsewhere.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·38:04

How to verify: Read the introduction of Tim Keller’s 'A Reason for God' to verify the thematic opening regarding faith and worldviews. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify S&P 500 sector weights and top 10 holdings concentration via S&P Dow Jones Indices or major ETF prospectuses (e.g., SPY, VOO).
  • Compare performance of S&P 500 Equal Weight ETF (RSP) against S&P 500 Cap Weight ETF (SPY) to assess the 'equal weight' premium and turnover costs.
  • Review the methodology of the Dow Jones Industrial Average to confirm its price-weighted nature and constituent selection criteria.
  • Analyze the correlation between major tech holdings (e.g., Microsoft, Apple, Nvidia) and the AI trade narrative using financial news archives.
  • Check the historical compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of the Nasdaq-100 over 20-year periods to evaluate long-term performance claims.
  • Read David Bonner’s writings on index construction and Tim Keller’s 'A Reason for God' for the philosophical context mentioned.
  • Assess personal liquidity needs against portfolio holdings to determine if the 'job' of the portfolio aligns with index benchmarks.
Full transcriptexpand

0:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm

0:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Trevor Cummings and these are my Thoughts on Money. Hello and welcome to the Thoughts on Money Podcast, what we like to call Tom. I'm Trevor Cummings, the host of the podcast, and sitting alongside Mr. Brett Bonecutter.

0:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Good to see ya.

0:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And Ishawn Chabra.

0:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It's a pleasure to be back. Am

0:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I pronouncing your last name right?

0:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): You've gotten it right.

0:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Perfect. I ask every time, but just want to make sure. You are the author of the Thoughts on Money blog this week and the title article is the five hundred that are really ten. So give us an intro.

0:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): So I came across this piece in the Wall Street Journal probably around a month ago, and it said that the uh S P five hundred and its equal weighted counterpart had the widest monthly spread in performance since April two 2009. thousand nine. And it was a just a quick short. hit piece, but it got me come across this term, this idea of the market of SP five hundred every single day. And we use it as a comparator, we use it as a benchmark. We look at its makeup, but it got me thinking, do a lot of people know and understand what the mechanism looks like and the arithmetic looks like of how it's made up? It's easy to say it's a good economic probe to see what productivity looks like, what market growth looks like how companies are performing. But there is a pretty interesting mechanism underneath it that I wanted to describe to our readers and our listeners, just so they also understand what the actual makeup looks like. And so it really got me thinking and that's where the article was born from.

1:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, it's almost like from a cultural standpoint that this terminology or this word kind of snuck in the back door. They were incredibly comfortable using the word the market.

1:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Right.

1:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And we've never really slowed down to define what that really meant. I just think about even my own career in this industry over the last 15 years or so, how at the beginning of my career, the SP 500 actually looked pretty distinctly different than the NASDAQ. And there's been quite a convergence over time, not perfectly, but those two have become a lot. more similar. And then I thought there was some disparity with the Dow Jones, but even over the last couple of years, as the new entry points into the Dow Jones, it has begun to look a lot more like those indices as well. And what I mean by that, just a domination of the exposure to the technology sector.

2:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): We use indices in two different ways. The first one is to act as a pro. probe for general market sentiment. So if I wanted to see how the market's performing today, I'm going to look up SP 500. And the second one is as a benchmark, as a comparator. So if you have a client that comes in and for a performance review, you're going to say, Okay, here's how we performed against, you know,

2:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a

2:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): benchmark or a certain mark, and it tends to be an SP 500. And I'll get into it as well, but the benchmark changes as it should based on different investment styles and philosophies. I was in a new New York a month ago for our annual Money Manager Week. Super grateful to be invited. And we meet with managers from all different types of asset class and security classes. Within fixed income, for example, we met with the high yield manager, high yield bond bond manager. That manager is not gonna be using the SP 500 as a benchmark or index, obviously. They're you're going to be using some other high yield comparator to see how their performance has been. So those are the two ways. that people, indiv investors, individuals, analysts use indexes to gauge their own performance and also how the market is doing in general. And so I figured it was timely to craft a piece that digs into that.

3:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I love this question. When anyone asks how's the market doing? I know that when I was in real estate for many years, people would ask me that kind of question. How's the market doing?

3:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

3:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I would always push back a little bit. and say, well, what market are we talking about? You know, because are we talking about coastal Newport Beach? Are we talking about the Inland Empire? Are we talking about condos? We talk about luxury. What do you mean by the market? I mean, we can do some sort of aggregate statistical analysis of the whole country, but it's probably not going to answer the question that you're really asking or that you really want to know about. And even though it's not a perfect parallel. to to what's going on here, I do think people tend to ask questions like, how's the market doing? without really understanding what that could or couldn't mean, depending on what we're referring to.

4:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Totally. And it's a it's a great wealth advisory overlay as you guys speak with clients every single day. So is that a question you get quite often about how general market sentiment and how it's doing and how do you navigate that?

4:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well I think

4:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): usually

4:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): it's more about where do you think it's going. It's not about where it is. People seem to have an awareness of at some level of what's going on based on their portfolio at any given moment. But what they'll want to say is where do you guys think the market is headed? But again, the market just becomes this opaque term that takes on a who knows what meaning based on what they saw on CNBC or read in the Wall Street Journal or just heard at the water cooler. It's interesting to me that that that phrase can be so so loaded for people without really understanding what could lie underneath it.

5:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I don't want to misinterpret what you wrote, so feel free to correct me. But one of the the conclusions you made is that hey, if you're owning the market in in the fact of the SP, S P, whether you know it or not you're kind of making a wager or a bet. And and the bet really is, I think you're saying, on the technology sector, and that it would or whatever you want to describe, I'm just choosing the the heaviest weighting in the S P five hundred and basically saying that that sector has some incredible growth potential,

5:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but

5:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it's baked into the price. You wrote an article recently for us talking about a common retailer that went something like a decade with incredible business performance and very underwhelming stock performance. And you were able to walk us through how a stock can behave very differently than a business. And I really enjoyed what you did here. Is you basically took a point of saying, hey, a very interesting thing happened recently. In in the month of October, the market, all all the companies. right? All the companies, if you just equally weighted them, it was actually quite an attractive month. Uh an incredibly impressive month.

6:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Six percent.

6:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. But then what happens if you if you did the weightings that the SP five hundred does? Which means that the largest companies get the largest bite of the apple, they get the largest weighting. Then it looked very different.

6:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Down one percent.

6:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, down one percent. And you're like, oh, this is not like the other. And then you basically took us through, which I think is very, very good for the the listener to go and look at the article, is that you just took us through a three company hypothetical market and how performance could look different based on how you chose to weight the securities. Did you want to weight them evenly? Did you want to weight them on the price of their stock like the Dow Jones does? Did you want to weight them on their market capitalization like the SP S P five hundred? And it gave a very simple snapshot at how all three of these would make very different outcomes. So we can't ask a generic question of how's the market doing? We need more detail.

7:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I'm glad you brought that up. I actually pulled some timely metrics from today actually, a point in time today. I know the market's still open as of time of this podcast recording. And just as a bit of a context, if you were to do your own analysis and look up the SP 500 today as it stands, there's a bit of a confusing point where you'll see Alphabet or Google actually twice in the top seven or technically eight companies. And there's a discrepancy there because there's two different share classes. Voting

7:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): shares and non-voting.

7:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Exactly, exactly. So just for context, I tend to combine the two because I treat them as just obviously one company. But if you were to pull a metric that says, hey, top seven securities, then you can keep the class A shares as separate. So that's just context. But I I went ahead today and I pulled the actual weights of the top seven companies, not securities, but companies in the S P five hundred, and their weight comes in at thirty three point five percent. And I say this in the article as well, but that does inherently mean if you were to invest a million dollars in the S SP P 500, five hundred, three hundred $335,300 and is going into the top seven companies. And I love using the dollar figure instead of the percentage terms because it makes it feel and within those seven, you are talking about I believe five or six of them being heavily correlated to the AI trade today.

8:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, you imagine if this investment was your plate and you're walking through a buffet line, you've just put a third of your plate with P, peat, right? And then now what you're gonna do with the other two thirds of your plate, you're gonna have to place four hundred and ninety three other things from the buffet line. You can see how this becomes quite ridiculous.

8:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

8:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): there's there's a sector conversation which if you were to look at the eleven official sectors, you have information technology and the rest. So if you were to look at it sectorally, you might see some diversification. I'm error quoting for the for friends you're listening here. You might see some diversification and because technically Amazon is consumer discretionary, Google, Meta, those are communication services. But realistically, they have pretty heavy correlations to the AI trade because they're building out those businesses themselves underneath. So you can look at it sectorally face value, but I prefer to look at it more thematically. So sure, you might see some communication services. diversification in the top seven or eight, but also not really, because the actual businesses are doing something very different. So it's important to look at that too.

9:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

9:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it's funny that we were talking about October, because it's kind of a tale of two months, because September is actually the opposite. That I don't know the exact numbers, but that equal weight would be the blemish on your chart. Yeah. And the the

9:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): market

9:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): cap weight in SP 500 would look like a darling if we looked at the month of September. So you've just seen this huge disparity behind how those two don't really walk in lockstep.

9:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): We saw a concentration run-up up to the month of September, and the October, in my opinion, being the first month of a reversal or a narrowing, if you will. So it it just goes to show what the consequences of concentration like that can do. And again, I I say this in the article as well, but I don't think that the design of market cap weighting, which is how the SP 500 operates, is flawed. I don't think it's flawed. It's it's a very good probe for productivity, growth, the strength of the economy over time since 1954. It's been the number one indicator for us across the nation and across the world too. It just happens to be the mechanism behind it has shown us a particular illustration of where optimism and enthusiasm sits today.

10:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Not really smart, so I usually don't make up the monikers or terminology. So I'm I'm sure I stole this from somebody, and you guys are both gonna laugh because you probably know where I stole it from, because I don't really remember. But we we talk about things like the Great Depression or the the financial crisis. We have these these things that we're waiting for something to fall off a cliff. Uh and I think we might be in Being one of those moments which I would call the great repricing. Again, maybe I stole it from someone, but it's this it's like idea where we manage a core dividend portfolio, and that can look materially different than the market, because the market doesn't have to drop 30 or 40%. It may, but it can also do this thing that we in the industry would call a rotation and what I'm calling the great repricing, where a stock that might have been quite expensive can just get repriced. And if that stock is a heavyweighting, like one of the biggest companies in America, that they had a sign of infidelity with the CEO, and nobody had that on their bingo card. They were looking at, oh, this this AI concern of the build-out and circular financing. But nobody had on their bingo card that the CEO might make a a bad marital decision. But that's why we talk about business risk. We talk about that you're already taking market risk. But now as you own individual companies, you now have business risk and the individual decisions

11:45people personally make, even outside of work, that actually impacts your portfolio when it's the largest holding. So we might be in the great repricing where things can change in value and smaller, less consequential companies can do quite well. And it's gonna depend going to on what is the makeup of your actual portfolio.

12:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): What's interesting to me, and maybe I'm taking a step backwards, but just to slow down for some listeners who these concepts are are new to, is that the different indexes that you hear about are not all structurally the same.

12:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

12:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): we've been talking about the S P and we've been talking about the fact that it's cap-weighted cap weighted and that it's been dominated by these top-performing top performing companies. But when you hear other indexes, that get quoted on the news and so forth, they they are not handled the same way. And I think people generally lack an awareness of that and what that means. So I'm just curious because we talk a lot about the SP. Could you talk a little bit for like the listener's sake, the way this is different than the Dow Jones and what that might mean from the standpoint of nuance of understanding when they when it they have hear the Dow is down this. What does that mean?

12:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,

12:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Ishaan's gonna expand on this, but I would just like to say the Dow Jones is almost prehistoric on on the way it does things and it actually impacts the way corporations will do things like split shares and things like that to really manage towards a hundred dollar stock price. Right. So he'll expand on it, but it is it is wild to me that the Dow is still priced that way.

13:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): So what Trevor's alluding to, and I'm glad you brought this up, Brett, the the way that Dow Jones operates is what we call price weighting. So instead of using Company X's current market cap relative to the broader pool selection,

13:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what the

13:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Dow Jones does is it looks at the current share price and uses that to weight its position in the index itself. And the pool itself is also a interesting point to bring up because with the SP. S P you're talking about technically 503 companies, fun fact. But with the Dow Jones, you're talking about 30. So it tends to be a bit more of an indication on the backbone of the economy is the way I like to look at it. A lot more if you're industrial players, a lot more if the companies that have really brought the economy to where it is today, whereas the S P is a lot more, since the pool is so much bigger, it's a lot more general market sentiment of the nation's capital markets in general.

14:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And then again, for the sake of the listener, contrast that with the NASDAQ. Because I think those are the things on the news. That's the through the the little sti ticker scroller or whatever. It's always putting up the S P and the Dow and the Nasdaq. So help people wrap their arms around the nuances

14:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there.

14:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): NASDAQ is also price weighted, just like the Dow Jones, but with a thematic overlay of technology companies. So it would be unfair. to say that there's so much technology exposure within the NASDAQ because that's the inherent point of it. The way I like to look at it is, like I said, as an PE general market probe, Dow Jones Industrial are more the backbone spine of the economy with 30 companies, and the Nasdaq a very tech heavy overlayer. So I like to think of it, thesis, if you will, as more of a Uh technological innovation and advancement. How are those companies doing? And we when would talk about PE multiples and valuations. naturally they're going to be higher because that's baked into the definition of those companies in general. But it also goes to my my other point as well, which is when we talk about valuations, since we're talking about concentration risk within the index itself, within the S P, because you have such a heavy weight within these technological AI trade corollary companies, there's going to be uh also a bit more of that expectation risk baked into those top holders of the index as well. And so my previous piece, which Trevor brought up at the beginning of this recording, my previous piece brought up that whole dilemma between the expectation of a company and how the actual underlying business performs. So that same sentiment also applies to the S P as well right now, because as you see, you can look at those top holdings.

15:39and that same question sort of brings itself to the table.

15:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Did

15:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you just teach me something right now? I'm trying to look it up right now. Did you say the NASDAQ is price weighted?

15:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

15:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): could I be am I incorrect there?

15:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think it's I think it's cap weighted. We'll we'll look at it after.

15:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm

15:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): pretty sure it's cap weighted. The price weighting is what I was calling prehistoric. So to keep it really simple for our listeners, imagine the Dow Jones was made up of two stocks, and let's say we one of those stocks stock price was eighty dollars and one of those stocks stock price was twenty dollars. Let's be very clear, we learn nothing from just the stock price. 'Cause you'd have to see the outstanding shares times the stock price would give you the market capitalization. But in in the Dow Jones world, that eighty dollar stock would get eighty 80% percent of the market and the twenty $20 dollar stock would get twenty 20% percent of the market. So what you find is if a company is quite large and is intending to be initiated as part of the Dow Jones industrial average, they'll often do a stock split. So if their stock's trading at $700, they'll give seven shares out so that it gets back to $100. Is that an economic event? It's not. But they're just trying to tailor their stock price to meet that price-weighted price weighted independent. index, which again is just funny. But there are things in all industries from football to politics that we end up

16:58inheriting from a very long time ago that we don't change. But I I think the kind of main thing that I got from the article, because article I thought about writing myself recently, was that there is this tendency for people to invest

17:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and

17:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): they say, Hey, I'm just gonna keep it super simple. I've read everywhere that you should. just own the market. So I'm gonna buy the market. And then they're they're operating under some level, I hate using this word, but of ignorance. Like they might not know what is made up of the market. They might not know that the seven companies that you highlighted earlier make up a third. And then when a 2000 moment happens and that tuck bubble double bursts, then again, I I hate using this these words, but then they take on this victim mentality. of like, man, the market's rigged,

17:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

17:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): hate the market, I've really been uh bamboozle, and now I'm never gonna invest in stocks. And

17:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

17:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, I hate that sequencing for them because it's not the truth, right? Uh David Bonson's father wrote a a famous thesis on uh self deception. And that is a self deceptive moment. is that uh the terminology I would say is that there is no neutral. What if you're going to own the market, like Sean said in this article, you are making a bet.

18:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

18:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): by joining that momentum, you're saying, I believe that the future expectations of these huge companies is going to And you soup surpass what people expect, and therefore it's going to be profitable to me.

18:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): But not not to defend the first the person who feels burned or cynical, but

18:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

18:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): can't remember who said it recently, but they said something about the fact that some of these indices, especially like the S P five hundred, are really almost more of a marketing product now than a really great indicator. Because unless you really understand what's underneath and what's going on, you it you could be getting the wrong signal.

18:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Do you

18:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): understand what I mean?

18:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah.

18:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And so it's it's more of a product than a real economic indicator. But sometimes it gets pitched as an economic indicator. Does that make sense or am I over playing my hand there?

19:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think what you're saying makes sense, but to me, again, an imperfect analogy, but it would be like somebody's like, hey, I want to get in better shape. So I'm I saw this marketing and there's this meal replacement shake that is high in protein and it's it's really good idea. So they order it and they take two scoops, they shake it in water and they they start drinking it instead of the meal. They never look at the ingredients on the back. But then what if they do look at the ingredients in the back and that every serving is 40 grams of sugar and it's eleven hundred calories or something like that. And then they start gaining weight and they're like, man, I'm so upset. I can't connect the dots. And you're like, whoa, you should really take just a moment. You don't have to be a dietitian, but you should read the ingredients on the back. You should look at what is the underlying makeup of what you're about to put in your body. And I would say that money is a pretty important thing and an integrated part of your life. I think taking that additional step, not to become a certified financial analyst, but to understand what am I actually purchasing here? And guess what, people? With this new thing. we got called ChatGPT, you can actually take a very short step and just ask it, hey, what am I actually owning? It's never gonna give you the perfect answer, but at least you can do a minor level of research to understand what is this wager you're making.

20:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): And that premise goes across across in the world of finance. And Brett, you said this word marketing. I immediately thought of since we're talking about indexes here. ETFs. Technically for our listeners, you can't actually purchase the S P five hundred index. It's solely an indicator. What you normally do is you go out and buy an index-linked fund, which is when you hear things like maybe SPY, and there's hundreds of others that are exact replicas of the S P five hundred, market cap weighted. But there's also a slew of other products, I'll use the word products here, that have different tilts, which is super interesting, super fascinating to me as well. You can have more of a growth tilt, so in that puts more weight in the companies that are more growth y, a value tilt, a momentum tilt. There's a whole world of these different products out there. So back to Trevor's point, it is completely I agree, completely vital. I'm of course biased, but very vital to understand what you're purchasing and also what you're benchmarking your portfolio against. I think that's a very important conversation. I I assuming both of you guys agree as well. I'm curious how you think about those conversations with clients when they when they look at their own performance over a certain timeline, how do you find themselves comparing their performance to something else? Is it is it always the S P five hundred? Is there something else that you guys use as a comparator or does it change?

21:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

21:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): find the S P five 500 hundred tends to be a bit of a default, but it also depends on their background.

21:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think

21:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Trevor's talked about this before. If somebody's been in real estate their whole life and made a killing in real estate, they may be trying to compare this to to the real estate returns they've experienced over the course of the past 20 years or whatever. So it's it's very contextual. But I would say that

21:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): m

21:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): my experience has been people tend to think about it as the SP, but I don't think they understand

22:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what

22:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): the SP really represents, which is what you're talking about here.

22:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, I think the default is typically the S P 500, but I will often encourage somebody to have a more robust conversation. I actually got invited out of a RFP process, a request for proposal, from a nonprofit that potentially wanted to hire us to manage their money because I gave a more nuanced and an answer they didn't like when we talked about benchmarks. And I actually I think frustrated the committee. I know very surprising that Trevor Cummings would frustrate not only one person but a group of people. But the the conversation's pretty nuanced. I think the best benchmark is hey I am deciding between owning two different things.

22:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm

22:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): going to make a decision right now and I'm going to do Route A and I am going to pass up Route B. I think your benchmark should be Route B. What would you actually have willingly owned? Now, if you then say, I'll expand on that, but if you play this other game, and again, I'm going to use an extreme case. I'm going to say, hey Brett, I hired you as my advisor, but I I noticed over the last 12 months that fart Fartcoin coin has really gone through the roof, and I'm quite disappointed. that this diversified portfolio you built me has not done well as Fartcoin. You could do that all day long. You could look in the rearview mirror and find something that has done really, really well. Would have,

23:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): could

23:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): have,

23:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): should've. Would

23:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): have,

23:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): could have, should have. So I think the ideal benchmark would be owning something that you are comparing to something you actually would have owned. So then if you're making the choice to say, hey, I want to compare the diversified portfolio you put me in, Brett, where based on my needs and my financial plan, that I might need to have some cash. I might need to have some bonds. I might need to have some allocation of real estate, whatever it might be. And then I'm going to benchmark that whole thing against the S P five hundred. And the real question is, could you tolerate and does your financial plan allow you really to own the S P five hundred and incomplete. complete? And if it does, let's go study a somewhat recent time period. where the SP five hundred spent ten years flat. Then if you're somebody nearing retirement, that becomes a very difficult thing to financial plan around. Let's look at like something like the NASDAQ that spent roughly sixteen or seventeen years flat. Somebody nearing retirement, they might only have two sixteen 16 year periods. So they can't really afford to have one of those of a go nowhere. So I think it is very enjoyable to imagine if we would have had a winning lotto ticket or we would have made the right decision on a particular stock or particular index. But I think we really have to go home to that financial plan and to say, hey, what is again, I hate this terminology, but what is all weather? What really can make And sure

24:45that I'm protected in case something happens? It'd be very similar, not a perfect analogy, but saying, hey, Brett, I looked over your spending over the last ten, twenty years, and man, you've never gotten a car accident and you would have saved so much money if you never had car insurance. Now again, there's a legal aspect to that, but it's very, very easy to see in hindsight if something wasn't needed.

25:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

25:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): what frustrated the committee? What did you do? What'd

25:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What

25:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): did you do, Trevor?

25:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Okay, full disclosure. So, what I did was I said, you know what the benchmark is? Whatever you guys want it to be. Like, literally, if you want it to be 50% NASDAQ and 30% ISMP 500 and 20% Barclays aggregate in bond index, let's do that. And they're like, no, no, no, what's your benchmark? I'm like, I I really don't have a benchmark. If you want to measure it against something, let's choose whatever you want to measure. it against.

25:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

25:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and I heard a portfolio manager on CNBC once said this. Somebody came to him and they were a little bit of a cutting comment, but they were like, hey, and I'll just imagine his name's Brett. Hey, Brett, I noticed that your portfolio has not done as well as the market. Again, SP five hundred today, what's going on? And his answer is like, I own different stocks. Like one of the things, if you want me to do a fun magic trick with your friends, is just show me how the sectors are doing today, and I will describe to you if the SP is doing better than the Dow or the Nasdaq, right? So what are the top three performing sectors this year? I don't know exactly, but I'm pretty sure it's something like energy, consumer staples, and healthcare. So those companies are gonna going show to up a whole lot more in a dividend portfolio than they're gonna going to show up in the Nasdaq. So you're probably guessing that there's going to be a disparity between those results. Now,

26:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's

26:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): when we get to a deeper conversation of what's the difference between a speculator and an investor. So imagine if Brett is in New York City right now and there he needs to get to Cleveland. There happens to be one way to get to Cleveland, and it's this bus. And he happens to know that this bus is gonna get in a serious car accident in Utah, right? Brett, you just know this because you uh you uh you have

27:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this prophetic nature. I thought I was going

27:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): from New York City to Cleveland.

27:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I know it's this weird route where you go from New York City to Cleveland

27:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and then down to Utah.

27:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): No, that's the total route. Oh,

27:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

27:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so again, just stick with me for a second. So imagine that you only have one option. Would you still take the bus, right? ride? Yeah, you would, because you know you only have to go to Cleveland. That is how a speculator thinks. It doesn't matter if there's a future crash that's inevitable. I just need to take the ride for a short period of time. And that is a very different paradigm than an investor. And when you look at these companies that are that are priced to perfection, they are an incredibly good environment for a speculator. Again, I don't believe that I would be a great speculator. I don't believe I'd be a great market timer. But there is a famous portfolio manager that once said, Hey, if you know a bubble's coming, let me know because I would love to invest in it. Meaning that he had a thought and a perspective that I would love to capture that first level of momentum that is found inside of a bubble.

28:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

28:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I want to read a paragraph from Ishaan's

28:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): work.

28:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Just

28:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): read the

28:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): whole article.

28:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah. No, but I think this kind of captures where you're going, and I thought maybe Ishaan could comment on.

28:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But

28:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you say a cap-weighted index makes expectation risk structural. Its largest positions are, by construction, the market's darlings, the companies whose prices embed the most optimism. An individual investor must choose to step onto the treadmill of the admired. The index places every holder on it automatically. That's kind of what you're talking about, right?

28:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): That goes to the I'll use the word automation of the mechanism itself, because like we've talked about, an investment in an index link product, not the index itself, because you can't, like I said, but an investment inside of it automatically places you on that as I say the treadmill, meaning that it is already going at a certain speed, at a certain incline, with certain expectations for what you want. But there's this risk that's embedded into that too of when you're going at the certain speed or incline that's set for you, you have to meet the the expectation that's been set and the finance corollary is evaluation, a Or certain multiple. And I spoke about that in my last piece and the piece before that too. Right? The index, because it's automated and has this built-in mechanism that that caters to what the purpose of it is, that inherently places you on it as well if you are an investor inside it. Does that sort of make sense?

29:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Maybe a real-life example here. So we are in the prime of this big headline news story that I actually think it's one of the biggest news stories. of my adult life that the largest company in the world, CEO, had infidelity. That's not a big story. So, but this company was priced so high. I don't know where it sits today. Maybe it's down 20% year to date. And let's say that it was 5% of the index that we're talking about. I actually happen to not own that company.

30:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

30:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): don't own the index. I own individual. stocks. So if somebody has a million dollars in the index, they were signed up to own 5% in that company. I'm using just

30:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): your

30:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): pre

30:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): spot on it.

30:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, very I'm just using broad numbers to show my point. So that particular company is a 5% holding, it's down 20%. The attribution means my portfolio from that single company is down 1%. I lost $10,000 of my million dollars. I'm using lots. loss loosely because it's a paper loss until somebody creates a sale. But that $10,000 loss is attributable to my bottom line from that one company. So it looks very, very different if I walked into it saying, hey, that company looks like a speculator's hotel, and I'm not a speculator. So therefore, my preference would be to see a list of these 503 five hundred and three companies and just opt out of the ones I don't want to own. Again, I'm oversimplifying it, but that is what the nature of an investor should be to say, I really want to own high quality companies that I'm comfortable for owning a long time because I really want to put myself in the lane of being an investor and not a speculator. People could take offense to me calling the index a more of a speculative play today. But again, I'm using a dramatic example. Go back to the late 90s, right? Before there was Uber, there was bartenders telling you their stock picks. Go to the 2007, where everybody's cab driver was

31:30talking about the three real estate properties. That is ripe for speculation. That is, in a sense, a similar way. world to where we live in today. So as an investor, if you don't want to be on what Ishawn said, that treadmill, or you don't want to make that wager a bet, then you have to take one layer deeper to customize your equity portfolio.

31:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think the the tension for investors is that they hear even just the number 500, five hundred. and that to them intuitively says diversified. So the the assumption is if I own this basket of five hundred companies, I am diversified. And you're basically saying maybe not so much. You know? And that's the point of tension that that we're teasing out here.

32:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): And going back to what you said, Trevor, I'll be I'll be frank, I was a speculator before I before I began my investing career back at USC high school, I I would play around with investing 'cause investing because I was always I always loved ADF the idea of the markets, economic growth. that whole sort of idea, and contributing to it and participating in it. But I was a speculator, right? I was a passive investor. I purchased these ETF products. I was an SPY investor, right? Because I had this idea of I want to follow the market. The market's done so well since the 1970s to today, look at the graph and the whole thing. But it's why I love what I do, because for these past two years, I've seen the beauty of taking that deeper approach and looking at my what a company's fundamentals look like, not just what the market's saying, but also forming my own opinion, my own thesis, with a beautiful dividend growth overlay on top of it. And then coming to the table and saying, here's what I think and here's why I think this is the route to take or not take. It's it's it really is why I love what I do.

33:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): In your research papers, you've come across a lot of conclusions where you're like amazing company, high quality. I just wish we could find a little bit of a different price.

33:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Totally.

33:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And I think going back to your comment or question, Brett, about being diversified, is like if I walked into the grocery store right now and I said, Hey Brett, I'll be right back out. I'm gonna make us dinner tonight, because I would love to cook dinner for you, Brett. I'm gonna go in there and I'm gonna buy five things and then I'm gonna use those five things to create dinner. You might be like, this is amazing. He's gonna buy a cut of steak. He's gonna buy some some rice to cook. He's gonna buy a veggie and maybe some spices. And he's gonna come out and we're gonna have a diversified meal. Yeah. Right. But then I walk in there and I just go over to the apples. Apples, there's a lot of different apples. I buy a green apple, I buy a red apple, I buy my favorite, a cosmic crisp, I buy a uh honey, whatever the the name is, and I come out with five apples and you're like, what are you doing? We're not just gonna have five apples. I'm like, oh, I bought five different things. And that's where that that false sense of diversification. And it's mainly that multiple things in your portfolio could be sensitive to a very specific change. So you see a lot of people, they're like, hey, I'm gonna Going go to build a dividend portfolio on my own. They they forget that we highlight dividend

34:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): growth.

34:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So they go out and they buy a bunch of utility companies and REITs that are high-yielding companies. What they don't realize is when you're fishing in the pool of high yield, the market is already telling you that there is risk there that that that dividend payment might be cut. And then also if you're focusing on certain sectors,

34:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like

34:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): let's say REITs, you're you're taking off on a very high sensitivity to changes in interest rates. We'll say you did the opposite. Let's say you go buy a bunch of oil companies. We are very sensitive to changes in oil prices. So we have to look at what does diversified really mean? Is that does a change in interest rate totally collapse my house of cards portfolio? Does a it change in oil prices collapse my house of cards or portfolio? And how sensitive is it to these different changes?

35:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Awesome. So I I think for the listeners, we we have probably done a pretty good job of talking about how cap weighting can distort the distribution of of what you own. You make a statement though in your article that I I wanted to ask you to unpack is So you said that equal weighting is not a neutral alternative. So I I feel like that's that bears out some more explanations. Totally. So in other words, it to take sort of a different thesis from cap weighting and just give every stock if you have three stocks and give 'em all a third, a third, a third, you're saying that's not a neutral territory either.

35:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah. So when I got to that point in the piece, I was thinking I read what I had drafted and I said,

35:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it

35:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): seems like I'm pitching an equal weight S and P as a benchmark or an investment even. I said I don't I'm not exactly advocating that either, so that's why I put that sort of counter argument in there too. Because with an equal weighting, you're also bringing up the names that have inherently smaller caps up to a quote unquote equal weight with the names that have huge market caps. I call it a structural tilt towards those other names. And so you're talking about smaller, less expensive companies. The index itself has a higher turnover because towards the tail end of those smaller market caps, you're gonna have a lot more. companies that get up to that certain threshold of market cap and certain companies that have a lower market cap because they're just inherently smaller. It might be a lower share price, it could be a lower number of shares outstanding or free float, if you will. So there's also higher turnover. So there's also a certain thing there that I wanted to include to say I'm not advocating for an equal weight, as well as either as a benchmark or an investment. My my general premise across the entire piece is just to take that one step and just know and acknowledge what the index is made up of, how it's calculated, what those certain risks are that might be introduced, because we're in one today, right? Heavy concentration risk. And then act accordingly, whether it be even as a benchmark or if you're if you're truly investing in into an index-length index length product, just expect acknowledge and know what that means.

37:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah. I love this too, because Trevor brought

37:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): up

37:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): David's dad, who was a theologian and philosopher. And I think I'm safe in saying that one of his worldviews was that there is no neutral worldview. There's just no neutrality. And I think there's a certain overlay here. No there's no neutral index. Every index has a thesis. Every index has a tilt. It has some sort of construction that you are gonna be subject to. So try to know what it is you're getting into.

37:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,

37:44Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it's kind of taking the air out of an article I was gonna write next month, so maybe I won't do it. But I have notes on my phone right now and the the article's called There is No Neutral. And it's kind of inspired David's father would be in a similar vein, but I remember how impactful that book by Tim Keller, A Reason for God. And one of the things he opens up with is that everybody places their faith in something. Whether somebody is identifying that they've placed their faith in God or an atheist, they're placing their faith elsewhere, right? So this idea that there is just no neutral. So you can you can operate ignorantly like there is, but you are making a wager, you're making a bet, you're you're putting your confidence somewhere. And I think that's such an important piece for our our listeners. listeners to understand. Because even when we are bringing somebody on to the Bond Swing group as a client, I will often say, let's stop before you make a decision to join us. I want to walk you through our philosophy. I want to walk you through our conviction. And I want to walk you through a hypothetical when this philosophy and this conviction will make you incredibly uncomfortable because you'll feel like you're missing out. You'll feel like you're naked. your neighbor's doing better than you. And if you know at the

38:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at

38:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the get-go that that is going to make you upset, uncomfortable, or abandon the strategy, I wouldn't even sign up for it. Because what this is really built for is somebody that's willing to commit to this as an investment philosophy. They're willing to run with.

39:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

39:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): hate saying it this way, but for the rest of their life, like that's that it really works out well when you have. that stick with itness. And you look at somebody like Warren Buffett, who belongs on the Mount Rushmore of investors, he has that. He has that stick with itness. And sometimes people even try to discount his success to say he was just a product of the time period he was in. He loaded up heavy on consumer staples, and consumer staples were able to avoid those boom bust cycles of things like the ups and downs of real estate market or the ups and downs of the technology market. And he did that with a little bit of leverage. And hey, in hindsight, it worked out really well. But one thing I would say is that if you did a deep dive study into the NASDAQ, which

39:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is

39:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): market cap weighted.

39:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yes. Which is a which is really a play on the technology sector. And we described that it, you'll find 20-year periods recently where the compound annual growth rate was 1%.

40:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

40:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you're like, wow, that does not feel like what my expectation is. It's because it's full of these incredible seven-year periods, full of these incredibly dreadful seven-year periods. So these really deep boom bust Bus cycles create a very uncomfortable ride for the investor. And sometimes for very long time. periods, a very disappointing outcome. It it relates to sports. If you love sports, you can think of some teams that had an incredible offense and just an embarrassing defense. David Bonson happens to be a big Cowboys fan. Trevor Cummings happens to be a big 49ers fan. They faced each other last week and everybody was telling me like great win. And I'm like, oh, the score was 46. to 40. So I think the 49ers have to go home and figure out their defense because it ain't gonna work if you're giving up 40 points and you're just trying to outpace somebody on the scoring side. So part of being a dividend growth investor is an expectation that in those boom cycles, I have to put blinders on and not look at my opponent because I understand what race I'm running. I grew up really racing BMX and for little kids they literally would put duct tape on the side of their helmets to avoid their peripheral vision so that they would not look

41:25over and see where their opponent is and they would they would basically ride their race.

41:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Except for forward, yeah. And it's one of my biggest lessons I've learned thus far in my career, which is having an adherence, having something to ground yourself with.

41:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm

41:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): talking about an investment philosophy here. It it does miraculous things. And of course, we on a daily basis, the investment committee obviously looks at the core dividends or core portfolios, performance relative to the S P five hundred every single day, right at market close. Just and and David sends a little little snip, a little commentary, which is super fun to read every day. So we do compare ourselves every single day, but the long term performance of our investment philosophy and our adherence compared to the index itself, it says worlds. It's what keeps me driven every single day because it's the work of financial analysis, bottom up value investing with the dividend growth overlay that does that. So it's one of my biggest lessons is having that adherence, having that philosophy,

42:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and

42:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): keeping the blinders on so you keep looking forward.

42:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,

42:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and it's it's funny, somebody should write the article of the tale of two months because we onboarded a client close to the month of September. And I remember at the end of September, he was like, Man, I am pretty disappointed. And I'm like, I get it. This is first impression, and I'd be disappointed too if I was in your shoes. But you're taking an incredibly small sample size. This is September. was a month where technology stocks and the AI trade really took off, and we just don't have exposure there. But I in the back of my head, I'm always like there's that's almost like a contrarian indicator. And October just happened to be probably the greatest dispersion between a dividend portfolio and the market I've seen in the 15 years I've worked in the industry. And it's funny because that is that contrarian indicator is that things zig while other things zag. And we really need larger sample sizes and stick with itness and conviction to really get to the end goal. And before we close out the podcast, I really want to give you the mic funny shot to talk a little bit more about something we haven't talked much about.

43:35And you are were basically saying not only that one side could be the a bet on a particular

43:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): part

43:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of the market, but also what is the job of the portfolio? And we didn't dive into that very much, but it's something you highlighted in the article, and it really helps us transition this conversation to financial planning. So tell us more about what you meant about what's the job of the portfolio, and maybe use different terminology.

43:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No,

43:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you got it. So I I I set up a framework in the piece in comparing a benchmark or an index towards one's own portfolio. I say a wager, which we've talked about, we've covered the whole idea of a bet and the wager. The job, which is essentially what the purpose of your portfolio is. Do you want to accumulate capital for retirement? Do you need distributions consistently for your family, for for something else to finance a purchase Of or something? Are you just investing to learn? It could be anything at all, but setting up a purpose for why you're investing within a certain portfolio. And the third piece of that framework is the test. So when you compare yourself to a benchmark, which you you should, otherwise there's nothing telling you how you're performing. When you're comparing yourself to that benchmark, take away the lessons that we've talked about today, which is know what that benchmark consists of, how it's calculated, and how you're how you're different. From there. look at whether your job was accomplished or not.

44:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think it's a great point. I think that terms like cash flow and terms like liquidity are sometimes terms people are not so familiar with, but they are like the brass tacks behind why people invest. Imagine in this very silly hypothetical world that doesn't exist, that I told you guys, hey, this investment is going to constantly gonna

45:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be.

45:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): compound at 30% a year for the next fifty years. And the only rule is you can never have access to the money. You you might be like, Wow, I I just did the math. I'm gonna get to a billion dollars pretty quickly. But wait a tick. Maybe for bragging to people at the bar, I can show them a balance sheet, but I actually need liquidity and cash. flow because my whole reason for investing is that I'd want to spend it one day. And I think that when you start to tease out that framework, even though that's incredibly unrealistic, is that you start to learn, oh, beating a benchmark sounds kind of cool, but what is the job of the portfolio? How do I need to access this money? Do I need it to be reliable, consistent? What are these other pieces? on how this weaves into my my actual life? So a pretty important part of of financial planning.

46:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I really enjoyed it. Thank you very much. I think the things that really leapt out to me again are just not every index is made equally. They've got different structures. And and those structures are not agnostic, that they have a bias, they have a philosophy and a reason. And so the question is does it match? up to your goals?

46:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

46:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): think those that those are all the right kinds of questions that we need to be asking folks and appreciated your work here.

46:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Of course.

46:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It is helpful for readers of this article to go back to your last article and get a very, very deep understanding of that great company, bad stock, it exists. It exists all the time. And when I say bad stock, I I'm I am not criticizing the company. Right. I'm criticizing the returns or future returns or past returns of a particular investment. And that will help people so much because as a huge AI company is about to IPO this week or next. Tomorrow. Tomorrow. Okay. It will get people asking this question: don't you think that's a great company? Yes. Perfect. How do I buy it? Well, wait a tick. I could have a different opinion on the stock. And I think people have put those two concepts in the martini class and shook them up. And there is very confusing for people. And it can put people in harm's way a lot when it comes to investing. We would be in the camp of looking for high quality companies that are looking to create a profit with a leadership team that then wants to take that profit and share it with shareholders in the form of a dividend. Because if we set up a liminade stand, at some point we would expect to pay. a paycheck. So that's where our conviction lies. So I appreciate you writing this article, Ishawn. And with that said, we will ask that if you have questions, comments, need clarification. We talked a lot about finance terms and how all this stuff intertwines. You can email us. You can address that email to any of us on this

47:54podcast, and the email address is Tom T O M at the Bonsergroup.com. Again, Tom at the Bonsergroup.com. We ask that you would rate us on your favorite podcast app, five stars or preferred. You can leave comments on that app. And with that said, we will be back the week after next with more of our

48:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Thoughts and Money.

48:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

48:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Bonson Group is registered with High Hightower Tower Securities LLC, member FENRA and SIPC, and with High Tower Advisors LLC. a registered investment advisor with the SEC. Securities are offered through Hightower Securities LLC. Advisory services are offered through Hightower Advisors LLC. This is not an offer to buy or sell securities. No investment process is free of risk, and there is no guarantee that the investment process or the investment opportunities referenced herein will be profitable. Pest Past performance is not indicative of current or future performance. and is not a guarantee. The investment opportunities referenced herein may not be suitable for all investors. All data and information referenced herein are from sources believed to be reliable. Any opinions, news, research, analysis prices, or other information contained in this research is provided as general market commentary. It does not constitute investment advice. The team and Hightower shall not in any way be liable for claims and make no expressed or implied representations or warranties as to the accuracy or completeness of the data and other information, or for statements or errors contained in or emissions from the obtained data and information referenced herein. The data and information are provided as of the date referenced. Such data and information are subject to change without notice. This podcast The was created for informational purposes only. The opinions expressed are solely those of the team and do not represent those of High

49:39Tower Advisors, LLC, or any of its affiliates. High Tower Advisors do not provide tax or legal advice. This material was not intended or written to be used or presented to any entity as tax advice or tax information. Tax laws vary based on the client's individual circumstances and can change at any time without notice. Clients are urged to consult their tax or legal advisor before establishing a retirement plan.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights