Melody Wright warns of data center pushback, housing distress, and systemic PE risk
Summary
Melody Wright argues that massive data center construction is propping up the economy but faces regulatory and political backlash. She highlights severe risks in residential real estate, citing foreclosure levels matching 2007 and builder financial engineering. Wright also describes a 'spider web' of systemic risk connecting private equity firms like Blackstone and Apollo across single-family rentals, data centers, and private credit. The discussion covers declining AI adoption among older demographics and the degradation of service quality due to private equity strategies.
Key takeaways
- 1 of pre-sale foreclosure inventory as we did in September 2007.
Melody Wright · 34:59
- 2 Multifamily rents are firming only in specific 'boom towns' like Abilene, Texas, where median rents are $2,600 compared to the US median of $1,400, highlighting localized bubbles rather than broad market health.
Melody Wright · 50:58
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 6:03
Data Center Construction and Economic Impact
Melody Wright discusses her recent tour of data centers in Texas, highlighting the massive scale of construction and the use of mini power plants. She argues this activity is propping up the economy but notes a slowdown due to community pushback and regulatory issues.
- 6:03 – 11:49
Financial Exposure and Debt Risks
Wright details the enormous capital expenditures involved, citing Oracle's exposure and the use of industrial revenue bonds. She mentions mechanics liens and offloading of debt by banks like ING and HSBC, suggesting fragility in the system.
- 11:49 – 15:11
NVIDIA, Enron, and Political Risks
The speakers discuss the recent scandal involving NVIDIA's CEO, comparing the situation to the Enron collapse. Wright suggests the scandal may be a setup to force regulation and provide an exit for insiders as the AI investment bubble deflates.
- 15:11 – 22:08
AI Adoption and Psychological Impact
Wright argues that AI usage is degrading critical thinking and writing skills, particularly among older demographics. She contrasts this with younger generations who are skeptical of AI, viewing it as 'slop' rather than a transformative tool.
- 22:08 – 29:44
Corporate Stagnation and Systemic Contradictions
The discussion turns to how outsourcing manufacturing has eroded physical innovation, while corporate America focuses on financial engineering. Wright points out the irony of AI hype amidst outdated banking technology and a lack of genuine R&D.
- 29:44 – 31:37
Data Centers and Political Backlash
Melody Wright discusses her September 2025 visit to Washington DC regarding data center opposition from both parties. She asserts that politicians ignored warnings about data centers becoming a major political issue, which will persist through 2028 due to vested defense interests.
- 31:37 – 38:37
Residential Real Estate Slowdown and Foreclosures
Speakers discuss the early stages of a residential real estate slowdown driven by demographics and immigration. Melody Wright cites builder confidence hitting a 2012 low and existing home sales falling to levels not seen since 1995, with foreclosure inventory matching September 2007 levels.
- 38:37 – 42:49
Housing Quality and Labor Issues
The conversation turns to the decline in residential construction quality over the last two decades, attributed to labor shortages and reliance on undocumented workers. Wright contrasts modern builds with older, durable housing, arguing that current political inaction on labor laws perpetuates poor quality.
- 42:49 – 44:44
Home Builder Financial Distress
Melody Wright highlights the precarious position of home builders, citing Lenar's subsidiary Millrose selling homes to rent them out to meet Wall Street targets. She claims builders are overstating inventory health and engaging in spec building rather than contract building.
- 44:44 – 49:41
Private Equity and 'Enshittification'
The speakers discuss how private equity has degraded service quality across sectors like healthcare, HVAC, and hospitality. Wright describes a shift where customer service has vanished, replaced by a focus on cost-cutting and poor user experiences in industries like hotels and airlines.
- 49:41 – 53:22
Commercial Real Estate and Multifamily Crisis
Wright argues that multifamily real estate faces a worse crisis than office real estate due to a massive debt maturity wall with no extension options. She cites rising fraud in multifamily appraisals and the potential for agency securitizations (Fannie/Freddie) to face stress similar to the 2008 single-family crisis.
- 53:22 – 55:03
Private Equity and Credit Exposure
The speakers describe a 'spider web' of exposure in commercial real estate involving Blackstone, Apollo, and Blue Owl. They note that the same firms involved in single-family rentals have moved into data centers and private credit, creating systemic risk across insurance and credit markets.
- 55:03 – 58:15
Labor Market and Political Will
The discussion concludes with views on the labor market, arguing that Americans would work if paid a living wage. Wright criticizes the welfare cliff that disincentivizes work and calls for political enforcement of laws to address illegal labor and wage suppression.
- 58:15 – 59:48
Book Recommendation
Ben Kellaran asks Melody Wright for a book recommendation. Wright suggests '180 Degrees' by Feargus O'Connor Greenwood, describing it as a fascinating read that challenges conventional wisdom and turns perceptions upside down.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| NVIDIANVDA | equity | neutral | tie it in a little bit with the uh recent news around NVIDIA, recent news around anthropic IPO, all the other stuff going on. |
| Meta PlatformsMETA | equity | neutral | So on the one side, let's take Meta BlackRock site in El Paso. |
| AppleAAPL | equity | neutral | probably. the most promising that I've seen is sort of like on a device, you know, like this is something Apple is working on. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Data center opposition was discussed in Washington DC on September 25, 2025, with both red and blue politicians expressing hatred for data centers.
Melody Wright ·29:52
How to verify: Check news archives or political press releases from September 2026 regarding Melody Wright's testimony or meetings in DC on data centers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Builder confidence hit its lowest level since 2012.
Melody Wright ·32:42
How to verify: Check the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) Housing Market Index data for the most recent month reported in the transcript. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Existing home sales in 2024 are the lowest since 1994.
Melody Wright ·33:12
How to verify: Check National Association of Realtors (NAR) Existing Home Sales data for 2026 and compare to 1994 historical data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Pre-sale foreclosure inventory is equal to the level in September 2007.
Melody Wright ·34:59
How to verify: Check Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA) Mortgage Delinquency and Foreclosure Report for current pre-foreclosure inventory levels and compare to September 2007 data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Lenar's subsidiary Millrose sold homes to rent them out to meet Wall Street targets.
Melody Wright ·43:25
How to verify: Check Lenar Corp (LEN) SEC filings (10-Q or 10-K) and earnings call transcripts for mentions of Millrose and rental sales strategies. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceMedian rent in Abilene, Texas is $2,600, compared to a US median of $1,400.
Melody Wright ·51:18
How to verify: Check Zillow Rent Index or Apartment List data for Abilene, TX and US-wide median rents for the relevant period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The multifamily sector faces the largest hard debt maturity wall in the back half of the year with no extension options.
Melody Wright ·51:38
How to verify: Check commercial real estate debt maturity schedules from sources like Trepp or Bloomberg for multifamily loans matting in the current year. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
85% of mortgages are owned by the government.
Melody Wright ·37:42
How to verify: Check Federal Reserve Flow of Funds data or Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) reports on the composition of the mortgage market. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Data center projects will be a hot button political issue for a long time due to vested defense interests.
Melody Wright ·30:12
How to verify: Monitor political discourse, legislative proposals, and local zoning battles regarding data centers in the US through 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Melody Wright recommends the book '180 Degrees' by Feargus O'Connor Greenwood.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·58:33
How to verify: Check the book's publication details and authorship via Amazon, Goodreads, or the publisher's website. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Melody Wright listened to a show with Dave Collin and J. Edward Griffin.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·58:26
How to verify: Search podcast directories or social media for episodes featuring Dave Collin and J. Edward Griffin where Melody Wright is a guest. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Ben Kellaran references a 'CA line' stating 'we'll know we've succeeded when everything Americans believe is a lie'.
Ben Kellaran ·59:03
How to verify: Search for this specific quote attributed to 'CA' (likely referring to a specific commentator or group) in transcripts, social media, or articles. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify existing home sales data via National Association of Realtors (NAR) monthly reports for 2024 projections and historical comparisons to 1994.
- Check foreclosure inventory levels via Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA) reports, specifically comparing pre-sale foreclosures to September 2007 data.
- Review Lenar (LEN) SEC filings (10-K, 10-Q) for details on Millrose subsidiary transactions and 'built for rent' inventory strategies.
- Analyze builder inventory reports from NAR and Census Bureau to assess the impact of withheld certificates of occupancy on reported inventory levels.
- Examine multifamily rent data from CoStar or RealPage to verify Abilene, TX median rents versus US medians and identify other 'boom towns'.
- Assess multifamily debt maturity schedules via Trepp or MSCI to confirm the lack of extension options compared to previous cycles.
- Investigate cross-sector holdings of Blackstone (BX), Apollo (APO), and Blue Owl (OWL) in single-family rentals, data centers, and private credit via their respective SEC filings and investor presentations.
- Compare NVIDIA's recent corporate governance disclosures and any regulatory filings to the Enron case details for factual basis of the comparison claim.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Ben Kellaran: All
0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): right guys, before we get into the show, I want to talk about the first sponsor of the podcast, Axios Fitness. If you guys are looking for a way to get in better shape, looking for a training regimen, looking for nutritional advice, looking for anything along those lines, JD is a great place to go for that. He's an expert on all those things, and he's one of our guys. So if you guys want, he can set you up with a two-week free trial. Just tell him I sent you. If you think it's a good fit, then you can sign up for the $25 a month training club. If you want something more personalized, he's got options there too. So definitely
0:27Ben Kellaran: go check it out. And if you're looking for a way to not be a lazy bum and get your ass in shape, Axios Fitness is a great place to start. Now onto the podcast. Welcome to episode 172 of Contrarian Corner. I'm Ben Kellaran. Today we have a very special return guest to talk with us about uh the insidification of AI, the insidification of people, and uh a bunch of different things where we'll rant on the state of the world, but we'll also get into the residential real estate side of things, commercial real estate. and uh
0:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): different
0:52Ben Kellaran: things going on in the economy because it's been it's been an interesting uh summer and kind of early fall as we're uh since the last time we spoke. So Melody, thanks for coming back on.
1:01Melody Wright: Thanks for having me. It's my pleasure.
1:03Ben Kellaran: Yeah, so I think uh people will be curious to hear about your recent uh data center tour of Texas, what's going on down there, and uh what is kind of the um
1:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
1:13Ben Kellaran: state of things as far as the actual physical build out. I'm sure we can tie it in a little bit with the uh recent news around NVIDIA, recent news around anthropic IPO, all the other stuff going on. So what's uh
1:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
1:25Ben Kellaran: what's the update from the uh Scattered Board on the ground?
1:28Melody Wright: It's just so it it's um it's it's insane. Uh you know, it's I I have a very similar feeling to have what I had when I got back from looking at all the new build residential houses. out there in 2023 when I did a tour across the country. Um, the scale of this is very hard to imagine. But when you're standing in these sites, you can see what's been kind of propping up the economy. I mean, it's all this activity and it's much more than I think people can really wrap their heads around because of all the equipment, all the workers, like, you know, 9,000 workers at peak at Stargo. Stargate Abilene, you know, 5,000 workers to and what and so what a lot of people don't realize that they're doing down in Texas, you know, we've heard a lot about, oh, they're going to connect to the grid and all of our electricity prices are going to go up. But in reality, what's happening in a lot of places is that they're just building these little mini power plants, like gas, natural gas power plants. And so all of these that we went to were that And what they did very sneaky is they um applied for what's called a minor air permit. That's something that like a dry cleaner would use. Um, and you you can't really do that for a power plan. And so, but they got approval and they got started. I mean, you can just see they really just tried to like blunt force, push all this through. Um, and so
2:48it's not just all the equipment, it's not just the workers, it's the uh hotels, it's the restaurants, it's everything around those. And so that stuff is just propping up the economy to some degree. And you can when you're out there looking at just how much activity, which I don't think anybody understands, I think the best way to understand it is let's take what Softbank just did.
3:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
3:09Melody Wright: know, they took a 3.7 billion dollar charge, um, basically, uh c canceled some turbines that they had ordered, which would have powered six Hoover dams. And so right around kind of where we were, a couple of sites would be nine gigawatts of power, which is all that was used last year for AI. And so, you know, you just had to keep asking yourself, like, what is this all for? You know, we know token spend kind of uh month over month token spend really kind of fell off a cliff uh in June, July. We know that Gartner has said uh 13% of people of corporations are seeing a return on investment. If and that's when you asked, you know, the CIOs, the head of sort of technology versus the a CFO, which would probably say it's much less. And so all this is happening. and you're just looking around going, what is this going to be used for?
4:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
4:07Melody Wright: know, I think some of it is defense, um, for sure, like especially one of the big projects, Project Jupiter, that's kind of on the border of Mexico and uh in Texas, New Mexico, right there. Um, but you it's just, it's just it's a gold rush. I uh I so the report that UNICUS research is putting together based on my trip. is called a gold rush gone south because that's really you had all these carpet baggers just kind of go down to the south to these places and just started all this activity. But in reality, you know, once it stops and slows, and what you're seeing out there is it is slowing, has slowed because of all the pushback, the community pushback, as well as kind of what we saw in the elections and the these, you know, regulatory permits. And so if that continues to slow, then we are in for a world of hurt. So I'll stop there to see if there's anything you wanted to pull on. But
5:02Ben Kellaran: yeah, it's uh it is interesting because like the people with a lot of the tech money, like they run around like a swarm Storm of locusts and they don't really give a shit about like
5:12Melody Wright: That's really true. Yes.
5:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like
5:14Ben Kellaran: any anything, really. But um I think there was some skid of uh Kevin O'Leary talking about the Utah data center or
5:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): something. He's like
5:22Ben Kellaran: yeah, he's uh he's a piece of work, but anyway. Um one thing I do think it would be interesting to pull on as far as like the economic side of things and just to give people a sense of the scale, like I don't know for
5:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for
5:35Ben Kellaran: everyone anyone that's in the Boise area, when you drive by the Micron building. build out, what they're doing right now, like it gives you an idea of what is going on. But that's obviously for chips and not exactly data centers. But when you kinda see these things in person, when you get to actually right, see it up close, what do you kind of see there? And then if you could put some actual dollar terms on it so
5:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): people
5:58Ben Kellaran: could understand, I think that would be uh uh um
6:01Melody Wright: absolutely
6:01Ben Kellaran: lead into the rest.
6:03Melody Wright: So yeah, these things are dystopian. Um, and and no, they're not all in the middle of nowhere. Like the vantage data sites that data center sites in San Antonio are plopped down in neighborhoods. I posted on X sort of a community pool and the view to this massive data center and power plant. Like, you know, because there's a ton of new build subdivisions around there. So to your point, the scale is so hard to comprehend, but these sites are 700 acres, a thousand acres, fourteen hundred acres. We also went to Terrafab, which is also going to be a chip plant, you know, and he that's going that's basically they're trying to acquire 9,000 acres there in Grimes County, Texas. It's insane. And but to dollars, okay. So each of these ones that are going to become kind of a pattern. power plant as well, they're about 14 to 16 billion dollars. Um, and so you know, you can and you can uh start to see like that debt. So Oracle is so exposed
7:03here, it's not even funny.
7:04Ben Kellaran: I've
7:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): seen some
7:05Ben Kellaran: different people commenting on the uh default swaps for Oracle. It's
7:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's really
7:09Ben Kellaran: interesting to talk about that. And uh just to throw in an extra note, when she talked talks about acreage, like one square. mile is 640 acres, right? So do do the kind of mental math in your head on like how big this actually is, as far as like okay, parcels and all these different numbers. Like it's it's not like they're putting it on, oh, here's a five-acre plot, like okay, whatever. Right.
7:32Melody Wright: It's I mean, it's so like you know, we were able to get into a lot of sites, drive around them. I encourage everybody to check out the YouTube. videos from the trip. That will give you a sense of scale because there are no words. It's very similar to how I felt when I got back in 23. I could not tell you how many home. I mean, if there were just so many. And then once you have drone footage, and and now what I've noticed is like all these articles about data centers, they use the wrong picture for the site. Like it's not the actual data center site. Like they'll there'll there will be an article.
8:02Ben Kellaran: Someone's using AI to write it.
8:04Melody Wright: Yeah. There so there'll be an article on Meta BlackRock, which is in El Paso. And it's the wrong picture. And it gives you the wrong idea of what's actually happening on the site. So we got a ton of drone footage. But back to the point about how much. So Project Stargate, we've seen several stories. So this is the Oracle backed uh in New Mexico, but right there on the border of Mexico and Texas.
8:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That
8:26Melody Wright: thing was phase one is supposed to be 50 billion once it's fully bit built out, and they say over 30 years, but anyway, it's gonna be 120 billion uh terrafab similar dollars. Um, you know,
8:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know you know
8:43Ben Kellaran: they got their number, right? Exactly. Like
8:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Click flick their fingers, stick
8:46Ben Kellaran: it up in the air.
8:47Melody Wright: And and what they could get debt for, right? And then in and in and the Stargate case, I mean, not Stargate, in the Jupiter case, they're using these industrial revenue bonds from the county. That's a whole that whole project from beginning to end is one soap opera. Um and it's currently delayed. But yeah, that site is so I think that one's 1400 acres. It's massive. But so all this debt out there, it's the site behind when we heard, oh. a mystery seller is trying to offload debt tied to data centers. We found out it was ing. Guess which loan was in there? One was to a Project Jupiter loan. Then we heard uh then just last week, HSBC uh was also offloading data center debt. Yeah,
9:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
9:32Ben Kellaran: think was like a couple weeks before that.
9:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So it's like
9:35Ben Kellaran: there's a lot of people that are heading for the
9:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): exits. And so
9:39Melody Wright: it's all debt tied to all these data centers I just went to. And people are realizing because those delays, so the other thing that people like maybe not really seems intuitive. So those increased costs in diesel alone are making these projects blow their budgets out, right? Because just think about how much when you stand on these sites and you see all this idling heavy equipment, you know, idling trucks, tractors,
10:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
10:05Melody Wright: know, there's cranes, like they are just they are using so much diesel. And so and you can even see on the vantage sites, um, that they are they have what's so a mechanics lien is something. Let's say that you did something for one of these data centers, maybe you installed some fans. Um, if they don't pay you, you can file a mechanics lien at the county. saying this they owe me, you know, fifty thousand dollars. Um, so the title of that property is not clear till that's paid. Well, on the vantage sites, you can see they had several mechanics liens, they've paid them, but the fact that they're already like slow, and this is what we heard. I mean, I'm hearing from all over the industry is that people aren't paying their invoices to a lot of these contractors. So
10:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): all
10:50Melody Wright: of these. big tech Oracle, I mean Oracle is in so much trouble and and they've completely overspunt and their debt, you know, is I I think it was um gun lock. I can't remember who just said he thinks it's going to go to zero. And I would not be surprised. It is so bad. And and they've just, you know, and it's so I it it's hard for us to kind of wrap our heads around because we just keep hearing these deals. Oh, a 20 billion deal, oh a 23 billion, oh 16 billion. But when you really see in this small area hundreds and hundreds of billion in debt for nobody really knows, and you know that actually it's it's not all going to be needed, not any, not the amount that they're building out there. So it just tells you how. fragile the system is. And then of course we can get into what happened as I got back and, you know, what's the soap opera that we've been all witnessing over the past week.
11:49Ben Kellaran: Yeah. No, it's been it's been interesting because I did a little bit of a dive into that with uh another podcast guest, Colonel Towner Watkins. And we were talking about um like this pretty blatantly seems like a political hit. Like I'm not endorsing guys action. actions, but if you look at what the elite have been up to over the last ten years, like stepping out on your wife, if you're like a multi billionaire CEO, like that ranks pretty low on like on that totem pole, right? So again, not endorsing it, but
12:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as
12:16Ben Kellaran: as far as the kind of news reaction, how fast it happened, like it does seem like a obvious political hit. So
12:23Melody Wright: I think it was a setup. Um I think so all of us have known for years that of course he's selling to the Chinese. Um, also, we know that this is circular vendor financing, which is not good. So, all the things to me, though, the way it played out, like I would tend to agree um that this was definitely actually this morning I was getting myself sort of reacquainted with Enron. You you know that NVIDIA took Enron's place on. the exchange. And honestly, the it and this is what I think then I gotta say is these elites, they're not very creative, right? They just you keep using the same play over and over. So it starts as kind of a sex scandal. Like you, you know, our former, our our former, our actual president it was called a rapist, right? Like, so you know, it's it started with the scandal and maybe spy adjacent. And then you know, it just quickly unravels. And then there's the SEC investigation. I encourage every and
13:24and you know, Ken Le was cross close to the president. I encourage everyone to go refresh your memory on that scandal because it is following this same playbook, including the SEC investigation that was uh announced yesterday. So so to your point, do I think this is a hit? For sure. You know, I I started talking at the beginning of the year they were gonna take somebody off the stage. Like somebody would be the fall guy. Yeah, I thought it was gonna be Altman before you know Jensen Wang, but but it
13:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
13:53Ben Kellaran: there's certainly darker skeletons in that closet, I think. But
13:57Melody Wright: oh for sure. But but you can see that the new regime uh we're all being you know, the scare campaign to make us all terrified that AI is gonna kill us and uh, you know, take over app our our apps, our our Microsoft Teams, whatever, um, to usher in regulation. But what I believe is that a lot of these players want this, and you know, and we've heard rumblings of that because they need an out. I mean, Larry Ellison needs an out. And what I think is that these sites will probably be repurposed. You know, we need to shore up the grid. We need to shore up the grid in Texas specifically. And so what you think is that maybe in the future, you know, the government will acquire these sites. They might repurchase some repurpose them for like a robot factory, um, you know, a drone factory, because it will have that. power and and sort of a lot of the systems it needs already. So, but I think that this was a way out for a lot of people because the music has stopped. It's over and everybody knows it's over. It's been a great party, but it's over. And so it's just helping a lot of the people kind of get off um or give them an off ramp, in my opinion.
15:11Ben Kellaran: Yeah. Well, I think it is too um kind
15:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of a
15:14Ben Kellaran: sign that some people want this train going towards a more closed model than open source, right? And if you take out the only guy that's really vocal about pushing for open source in kind of the US tech sector, it's uh
15:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean
15:28Ben Kellaran: not a foregone conclusion, but you look at who they put in, um the CEO chair, it's like, okay, that's just a the I mean puppet for someone else, right? So um
15:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
15:37Ben Kellaran: the thing that's interesting too. about what AI has started to do to um not society, but the way people um kind of use it as a tool.
15:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
15:47Ben Kellaran: is really interesting to see some of the different things across like social media, the way people
15:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): kind
15:52Ben Kellaran: of talk about it. Cause like you can go from seeing an AI generated kind of movie trailer where it's like, wow, that's that's gonna be really cool. And I mean, as
16:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): far
16:02Ben Kellaran: as holiday Hollywood, like I'm not gonna shed any tears for all those people losing their jobs, right? But the the point is, like, there's certain things you can do where it's like, wow, that's incredible. And then there are other things you can do, it's probably 80% of it at least, that's just slop, right? And people use it to turn off their brains. But um, well, what's your kind of take on what AI is gonna do and some of the more kind of psychological um impacts versus just the hard numbers that uh the investment bubble side of things shows.
16:31Melody Wright: Yeah, I think it's already happened to some degree. I mean, the thing that makes me feel at least um sort of like a little better is that our youth, our our young, young really they don't like it and and you know, and they they say slop all the time, and that's how they view it. And you know, of course, the industry's. just done a terrible, terrible um job at marketing itself as something that's but but what I've been noticing
16:58Ben Kellaran: the the marketing campaign of uh yeah we're gonna take your jobs and we might end humanity. That's not that's not very successful.
17:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean
17:05Melody Wright: well let's sign up, guys. Come on, and let me pay for it too, right? Okay,
17:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): let's
17:08Melody Wright: pay sixty dollars a month or whatever. Um
17:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's like
17:11Ben Kellaran: i if they really think that they're gonna make it that far without someone just deciding hey we're gonna go invade San Francisco San Francisco and basically roll it up like
17:21Melody Wright: Yeah. And we've already seen protest at like people going into data center. We'll see all that. Around here they're shooting down flock cameras. So I mean that's already started. Um but you know I think what I've I'm seeing it it's a s a a certain I I think people so a lot of people will use it and they'll get like, you know, excited about certain things, but then they're just like, you know what, I I don't know, this just isn't even worth it, or I can use it for X, Y, and Z. But then there are the other people who have, you know, I I look at it as narcissists, right? Um, looking at yourself in the reflecting pool. And that's what it this is. Like it's it you're talking to yourself. basically, right? Like, and because it's predictive and it's going to predict what you say. And then, and I think people became sort of enamored with that, right? Enamored. And what I've started to see is people that used it for creative processes, be it writing, be it uh, you know, just putting a script together for a YouTube video, um,
18:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): their
18:25Melody Wright: confidence is completely erotic. eroding at like w because they have become so unsure of their own abilities. Um, but I just the other like somebody was pushing you know a genetic AI on me just too a few days ago, and I was just like, you know what? I grew up, so my first job was an executive assistant. Consistent. I can do things so quickly that it it does takes other people a long time to do, right? And I just and and by the way, this person had failed to send me a meeting request for a podcast. And he and he's pushing this on me, right? So I just I think when we stop thinking, we stop. I and I agree with Dave Collum on this. It's like writing is thinking. And if if if we don't use our brain, brains and write, we're not thinking. And so I just I was just laughing because it's like people can't remember anything now. They feel complete, and and that's not everybody. It's just a but it's a certain a certain age group of um, especially men, I have to say, and that that just kind of like they just get so like enamored with new toys, right? Um, and they and so yeah, I think I think that it's uh I I feel I
19:44feel more positive because the youth just don't feel the same way about it. And I think they're gonna be very much like, no, you know, like you're not gonna take all our jobs. Cause like Luke Groman said on Twitter today, well, if you take all of our jobs, um, you know, the elite where they get their wealth is from our debt. Like you know, so if we don't have any money to pay for anything, exactly exactly how are they going to make money, you know? So I I think a lot of this is a psyop too, but I'm definitely seeing, you know, like you say, just a degradation and uh conversation and writing. Like I cannot stand the writing. Like I can't, I mean, I know in less than a second, and I'm like, done. I can't, because the then all sounds the same. And it's snarky. So snarky.
20:30Ben Kellaran: It the the the way they um
20:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
20:35Ben Kellaran: it's it's kind of the same thing as social media, right? Social media will trigger certain emotions to try and keep you on there and doom scrolling. And AI does the same thing where I've had to tell it multiple times, like, hey, like you don't have to be like sycophantic about whatever, just like tell me this and this, this. I don't care what like why you're trying to tell me uh oh you're so smart. Like it like it basically leads off like the answers to some of these things, but just like just like a bunch of
21:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): job.
21:03Melody Wright: You really understand that well.
21:05Ben Kellaran: Like Yeah, it's like
21:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
21:07Ben Kellaran: don't have to kiss my ass before like
21:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
21:09Ben Kellaran: you you give me an answer. Like I just want the answer.
21:11Melody Wright: Right.
21:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But there are
21:12Melody Wright: a lot of people that like that, you know, but go ahead.
21:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No, no.
21:16Ben Kellaran: It is uh I think just the kind of sign of where where we are today as far as the way people behave and the way they act. But uh I I do see a lot of people where they're talking about, oh, no one's gonna be working in ten years. It's like, okay, like it might take out a lot of lawyers, which I think is a good thing because of the documents and like the I mean, just wasted time when they're trying. to bill you and like same thing for certain other white collar professions. But then to go back to the the point you're talking about with okay, what happens to the whole system when
21:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): people
21:48Ben Kellaran: don't have jobs and it's like, all right, like let's see what happens and when you try and outsource an offshore to infinity, like the white collar job is kind kinda of what white collar you call our jobs have been kind of keeping the whole thing together, right? You can't can't do that. after you offshore like the entire manufacturing sector like we did for the last several decades. So and I think that that also ties into the whole immigration piece. It's like, okay, so we're doing H1Bs, we're doing all this fraud and all this other bullshit and you're still trying to take everyone's jobs, so why are we importing them in the first place? It's like, oh, to suppress wages and drive up real estate costs and do all that stuff. So I don't know where you want to take that, but I think it's uh I mean a long long-winded rant is to say like all these things are tied together, and right
22:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
22:37Ben Kellaran: kind of pull one too many blocks out of the Jenga Tower, it's yeah, gonna be um
22:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): kind of
22:44Ben Kellaran: a cascading effect.
22:45Melody Wright: Yeah, yeah. And you know, I think too, so something we've kind of missed out on here. by not um by outsourcing manufacturing is, you know, uh really actually getting better at so China, you know, the their sort of actual physical hardware robots are much more advanced than what we have. Um and I think that that's because they are on the manufacturing floors. They are looking at okay, what are some efficiencies where, you know, and so when we outsourced all that, we also outsourced a ton of our knowledge and creativity around producing things. So to your point, like okay, if we're not gonna do hyper financialization and all the because that's the other thing. So on the one side, let's take Meta BlackRock site in El Paso. On the one side, you know, like 5,000 construction workers, but on the other side, all the advisors and law lawyers that put that deal together, like it's a list this long, you know, and they all got fat fees and paid. And that's the hyper financialization side. You take that away, um, you know, uh the we're gonna be really feeling it. And there will be, you know, there won't be people to buy this stuff. And, you know, I'm a I'm a real believer. So corporate America, I spent decades trying to implement technology. there. They've lost their will.
24:05You know, a lot of that has to do with they just focused on share buybacks, not research and development, not improving processes, not improving technology. So the fact that we're talking about AI taking over the world, if you walk into Wells Fargo Bank, uh Chase Bank, are all these big banks, and if you see what technology they're using, it will make you laugh. It's black. and blue, green and green and black screens. Okay. It's technology from this late sixties, early seventies. So wait, wait, what's gonna happen? You know? And and nobody can figure out those systems because the people that built them are long gone. And so AI can't figure figure those out either.
24:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So my only point as long as you can play
24:46Ben Kellaran: Space Invaders, right?
24:48Melody Wright: Yeah. Right. So I yeah. I just think I there's so many contradictions in the argument. There's just so much and but it's everybody's so excited, either like, oh, there's so much possibility. And then on the other side of it, you know, kind of in the religious, the way that they treat it like a religion, it's like, oh, you know, uh, the end of the world is gonna come. What are we gonna do? You know, that type of thing. And it's just I don't know I go back to the Turk and the Machine, which was, you know, I think in the 1800s. Um, and it was they built what looked like a robot and he played chess, but it was just a human and so lightning chess. And it it actually happened to be, or it's called the mechanical Turk. Um, he would just go around to world's fairs and and so everybody thought it was a robot. I mean, that was a long time ago. You know, I also grew up watching the JetSense. We're not flying around in space. Uh, I mean, are flying around to our jobs
25:48or anything. We don't have robots right now and, you know, maids. So I just think a lot of this is mania and and the madness of crowds. And um, at the end of the day, I see very specific use cases. But, you know, you mentioned the attorney. attorneys, and believe me, I can't stand them. They never actually do work. You do all the work, you tell them what to do and say, and then they just charge you a lot of money and find the case law. But I actually helped, I was an expert witness on a case, and this guy filed the whole complaint, this attorney, based on AI. And he's like, I need, you know, I want you to be a witness. Like, look at the complaint, look at the evidence. And I was like, dude, you don't have a case. Like, this is all wrong. Like, this entire complaint is wrong. Because it would say things like, Oh, they were told they were not eligible for a loan modification. Well, right at the bottom of it, it said, You are eligible to reapply. Like that, the, you know, you've run out of time or something like that. And it's just so
26:49he like. he was not happy. Um, and I haven't really heard from him since, but he had no case, like not so you have to be very careful with that stuff as well. Um, because it just gets so much wrong. It makes up case law, it'll just make up case law, which is crazy, you know. So again, I think we'll have limited use cases, and I think they'll be built, you know, probably. the most promising that I've seen is sort of like on a device, you know, like this is something Apple is working on. It's like a local device. Um, so yeah, I just think we we got really crazy.
27:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
27:30Melody Wright: We got really crazy.
27:32Ben Kellaran: I I think the the type of people to get sucked into it are like the exact type of people that would have a whole bunch of money, be obsessed with technology, be looking for some sort of your utopian in their view, dystopian for everyone else kind of outcome. And I think that's where um they look at and say, hey, look at this tool that could be used for insane amounts of control and other things that would be
28:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
28:02Ben Kellaran: very dystopian. Then we can actually make all the decisions for all the plebs that d shouldn't have a say anything and in all like all the stuff going on anyway. So I mean it's the same impulse behind flock cameras and all the other stuff going on
28:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on
28:16Ben Kellaran: that front, where it's kind of just an extension of the Patriot Act and all the other stuff that we've been doing since we decided to uh turn the Constitution into toilet paper. So right. But well when when you kind of see all these people pushing in the same direction, it's like
28:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
28:35Ben Kellaran: think that's why the data centers are one of the only issues where you see people right
28:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
28:39Ben Kellaran: left where like okay, if these guys want it, if these pricks want it, then it's definitely not gonna be a good thing. 'Cause thing because we've seen what happened with social media rollout, we've seen what happened what's happened with all these things that they've been for. and so I think the impulse is basically like screw these guys like we don't want it so do do you think that's uh somewhere continue to see that pushback ramp up and become like a major political issue in twenty
29:04Melody Wright: yeah I mean it and it is like I mean so this one site I went to in San Antonio because they just pushed all this through without thinking about anything. I was on site for less than 10 minutes, my head was pounding because of the natural gas smell. And then you could also hear the humming, you know, and then the noy the light pollution. Like you when you I mean, these things are freaky at night. Like they look so freaky. Um, and so yeah, it nobody wants and then, you know, some of these sites uh right next to ranches, right? Like, do you really what are we all gonna be ordering our AI? steak versus A one? You know, it's like this cattle uh comes next to this data center. I mean, I don't it it's just so dystopian. So yeah, it's gonna and and honestly, so I got asked to join a very small group last September. So September 25 N DC to talk about what I had seen on the road with both you know red and blue folks saying they hated data centers. Um, and you know, and so I talked to a politician there, and but the party just didn't listen,
30:12right? Like they didn't listen and they really got it wrong. Um, so yeah, it's absolutely going to be an issue now, now though. Um, I believe a lot of these projects will go forward, you know, in one capacity or another, because there's vested defense uh, you know, uh interests there. So, but yeah, I think it's gonna be a hot button issue for a very long time.
30:37Ben Kellaran: Yeah. It is uh it is something too where you look at the narrative around the midterms and what uh some of the politicians are coming out and saying, It's like, oh, we went too hard on immigration, we went too hard on this, too hard on that. We just need to get back to our like standard playbook. of like basically big business handouts, but they're not gonna phrase it that way, right? But um
30:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well,
30:57Ben Kellaran: when you look at what they're saying, it's like, no, you guys got blown out. If I mean you guys wanna talk about voter fraud, like okay, do something about it, right? That's the thing. You guys didn't do anything. You had all three um you had the con.
31:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): rolled
31:11Melody Wright: over.
31:12Ben Kellaran: I mean,
31:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
31:12Ben Kellaran: just didn't didn't do anything, right? Yeah, and so people can say, Oh, Susie Wallace now is out, that's a good thing. It's like, okay, but if Steve Miller doesn't have uh if he if he if they let him go, then maybe like something happens on the immigration front. But until they start enforcing some of these laws on the books, like it's not gonna matter, right? So
31:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
31:31Ben Kellaran: I'm not gonna get my hopes up on a lot of this stuff, but I think that does bring us to an interesting um
31:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): point
31:37Ben Kellaran: on the real estate side where you kinda saw and you kinda mentioned this in twenty twenty three, like what was going on in residential. And a big part of that demand, I'm sure, is driven by uh like the complete open borders, especially in certain parts of the country. But when you kinda see where we're at now, like it does seem like we're in the early stages of a train wreck as far as like residential real estate and there's still a lot of denial. but um
32:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
32:04Ben Kellaran: I look at him like okay if we could get another five years of this where it's like everything seems
32:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to be
32:10Ben Kellaran: coming unglued as far as price, I think that'd be good for the country actually. But I
32:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know uh
32:16Ben Kellaran: people would not uh some people would look at and say, oh like this is a economic disaster. We can't do that. So
32:23Melody Wright: well it's not uh and so yeah no the housing market's falling apart. And and it's you can see so, you know, it I I just cannot even tell you how many people, you know, said we had a housing shortage, and then I went out on the road. And I was like, we have no housing shortage. And I mean, I just battled for years, right? And even up until very recently, but it's now like all of the series are starting to show it. You know, the inventory inventory's is climbing on the existing home. seller side on the new homes. I mean, we just had the builder confidence come in at the lowest since 2012. Which, if you were around in 2012, it was really sad out there for the builders. And so, I mean,
33:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): wasn't
33:05Ben Kellaran: this year? Aren't we gonna set a record for like the fewest home sales in like four decades or something?
33:12Melody Wright: Uh, so last year for existing home sales that it was the lowest since 1995. Okay. And we've increased population by over 20% since then. And this year looks like it's going to be the lowest since 1994. So, because what you're seeing is we kind of we we we entered the year with a little more momentum because rates had been coming down. And then of course, you know, February 28th happens, and then you know, uh rates start climbing.
33:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Rates,
33:39Ben Kellaran: do you still inflation the whole nine years?
33:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
33:41Melody Wright: the whole nine. And you can just look at every series and look at June and July and just see it just boom. You know, it just woof. And so we got pending sales today, which uh somebody said lowest ever. I I haven't verified that yet, but they were down like 16% Percent year over year with the lowest sales since tw 1995. Like what? And so it's just all the prices were stayed floating because the people that were transacting were the ones that could afford it, or they were being subsidi subsidized by the government. But now what you can see in that kind of 750K to 1 million price tier on existing homes, that is where you were seeing the most year over year gains last year. Now you're that's where you're seeing the most year over year. losses. So as they pull back, like those, those big spenders, and you're you're seeing it, I call it the upper or the lower part of the upper K. Um, and we're actually getting defaults. We're actually getting foreclosure sales for the first time since 2019 because of all that COVID intervention. So as those people uh pull back in that higher price tier and you have your foreclosure sales. that's really going to start weighing on prices. And we will have so right now, and people have to take this with a grain of salt. We have the same number
34:59of pre-sale foreclosure inventory as we did in September 2007. The difference is that it takes so much longer to get that thing to foreclosure sale these days post the last crisis, but by Q1 then. this is going to be a problem. Like people will be talking about it. And then and that's really the FHA government subprime. But we saw over the summer the prime books starting to come under stress too. So that'll that'll come through probably the next 12 to 18 months. So this, to your point about five years, like this is just starting. Um and yeah, who's who's coming to save the housing market? And the government. there's only so much they can do and they've done most of it and without breaking the securitization markets, um, which you know, and they're not gonna do that. So yeah, I I tell everybody, look at what they do, not what they say. Um they say a lot, but they don't do anything. So
35:56Ben Kellaran: you
35:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know Well
35:57Ben Kellaran: they they definitely blow a lot of smoke on some of these things and when you kind kinda of see
36:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): where
36:01Ben Kellaran: things are headed, like it does seem like we are kinda at a buyer's strike type moment where there's like right, for someone like me that would eventually want to have house, kids, family, all that stuff, right? A house going from five hundred to four seventy five is not like, Oh, what a great deal. Like buy the dip, right? It's not like cut come back when it's three hundred. Come back when it's
36:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): two fifty.
36:26Ben Kellaran: Come back
36:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): when
36:27Ben Kellaran: it's like three times the average median income, right?
36:31Melody Wright: Correct. Thank you.
36:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes, this is what
36:33Melody Wright: I say. Yes, that's
36:34Ben Kellaran: that yeah. When you kind of look at it because we've made basically a game of inflating these asset prices, like homes by definition are not productive assets, they're not businesses with cash
36:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): flows,
36:49Ben Kellaran: they're I mean four walls. and a roof, right? And when you have kind of the the the way you've structured it, I mean the incentives kind of get you to the outcome we have seen. And yes,
37:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
37:01Ben Kellaran: do you think we're gonna restructure that in some way where people look at it and say, Hey, maybe our entire banking system should not be designed around how much we can lend and lever up the housing sector to do all this stuff, and then it creates a whole bunch. of other perverse incentives like how many people can we import to keep housing prices high to keep the thing going.
37:22Melody Wright: What's interesting is the banks did learn that. You can look at every single one of their balance sheets. And and also Basel three caused that, like that they had to kind of get out a mortgage. But they really they have it's the government. It's the govern government. I mean, eighty 85% five percent of mortgages are owned by the government. So, but yes, to your point, like this is um, I do think, I really do think we will get to a place where we look at this as shelter again, not an investment. You can go into the CPI, it defines housing as an investment. I mean, this is about and and so the thing that it so really what happened in this cycle is property insurance, taxes, electricity, replacement costs, all those things just went through. the roof. And so holding that asset just doesn't make sense anymore. It's too expensive because it isn't about shelter. Uh, but I do think that, you know, once the silver tsunami sort of gets here in you know in force in the in the next several years, that we will start looking at housing as shelter again
38:23and not in and I do hope, I really hope, you know, we don't we don't go and use housing the same way that we've done previously. But in reality, when we're losing that much population, I'm not sure how we could. So
38:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
38:37Ben Kellaran: The other thing too, I think when you look at the build quality of like what's been built in the last 20 years, I mean, but especially the last like handful of years, it's not uh
38:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
38:48Ben Kellaran: mean,
38:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're
38:49Ben Kellaran: not paying people what they could be making somewhere else, so you're not gonna be getting the best and brightest, so you're not gonna be giving people that give a shit. And you see some videos of these builds where it's like, oh, $1.2 million new build house, and like doors don't close, like the sink
39:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Jack Daniel
39:04Melody Wright: bottles, yeah, are outside. Yeah,
39:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's it's
39:08Ben Kellaran: insane what what happens on some of these build sites. But yeah, I think um if you actually made
39:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): some
39:14Ben Kellaran: of these adjustments and um dealt with some of the illegal labor in the sector, I think that would actually be a very good thing for build quality. And long term, like I don't see why we shouldn't go back to trying to build homes and um other buildings to try and make them last for like fifty or a hundred years or more.
39:34Melody Wright: Yeah. The house that I'm in right now was built in nineteen hundred. This thing doesn't move, you know, like and it doesn't even have a foundation. This farmhouse. But it doesn't. I mean it was built so well. Um and yeah, I think uh we have to get back to quality. I mean to your to your beginning of this, you know, the insidification, like it's in everything. It's in error and you know those builder sites, I mean I think I've been on at least a thousand by now. And if you when you look at who's building, I mean, and this was the other thing. It's it's not even that they came, you know, this temporary population boom, uh, necessarily holding up, fully holding up the housing market, but they were definitely the ones fueling the building. I mean, you can't you could definitely see all across the country that who was building these homes and and they were not qualified because you would get uh a a contractor who had a subcontractor who that that person had a subcontractor who that person was picking up people from Lowe's who were sitting outside, you know, no documentation. And so these people just didn't have any skills when they were building these homes. So yeah, it's awful. It really is.
40:44Ben Kellaran: Yeah. Do you think that's something I mean our current political house has no will to actually enforce? some of the laws that are already on the books with this stuff? But do you think there's um someone that will be able to force issue and basically um go to some of these businesses, some of these people and say, Look, if you want to run this playbook, we'll enforce laws in the books and the penalty for that is like five years in prison. So you can I mean, I I think if they make an example of a couple of people, oh
41:14Melody Wright: yeah, it just
41:14Ben Kellaran: ends immediately right
41:16Melody Wright: oh that's all they have to do I mean are just you know in the H1B program like I mean just there's so many small things that they could do just and just say just take one person who's using illegal labor like you say make an example but there's no will to actually do any of that. I mean because both sides want their cheap labor.
41:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean
41:39Melody Wright: they want their cheap labor. And and and they also, like you say, it's about suppressing wages. Um, because you know, God forbid we have wage inflation, but we can have food, house, housing, all that kinds of inflation, but not wages. Oh, no, no, no. God forbid.
41:56Ben Kellaran: That's that's the frustrating part where uh I mean I'm no uh AOC fan, but I think she's going back and forth with Jerome Powell. one time and she's asking, like, well, why is wage inflation a bad thing? Like, isn't that good?
42:08Melody Wright: Right.
42:09Ben Kellaran: It's just
42:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right.
42:09Ben Kellaran: It it is uh it is funny when people frame it that way, is like, oh, when wages start rising, then things really get out of control. It's like, okay, like I guess if you're a bondholder at two and a half percent, I can see why that would be a problem. But for everyone else, like no one really cares like what in interest rate you're gonna be uh clipping. But anyway, the uh the the the other thing too that I want to get into on the inflation side, when you look at the cost to build and you look at the um value of existing homes, where do things stand for the home builders right now? Like are they in uh basically a I mean uh up shit creek without a paddle or like what's uh
42:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what's
42:52Melody Wright: so up that creek. So the funniest thing, it's not funny. We we all have to just start laughing, right? Or we're gonna be crying. But so Lenar, Hunterbrook just called out Lenar, you know, it's one of the biggest home builders in the US. The so they had this little uh kind of side company called uh Millrose, where theoretically it was supposed to just hold land and that was what they filed in their SEC documents. It was just kind of gonna be a like a land bank. Well, what did they do last quarter?
43:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
43:25Melody Wright: to meet their targets. They sold themselves. So it's
43:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they
43:29Melody Wright: sold themselves their homes to rent out to meet their Wall Street delivery target. And so yeah, they're up the creek. They know it. I mean it I I it it couldn't happen to a better bunch of people because I can tell you in in 23, I started listening to their earnings calls, right? And it was just this dog and poney show of we learned our lesson from the great financial crisis. We will not overbuild. Meanwhile, they all pivoted to spec building, which is just building. So typically in the builders, they build once you contract them. You say, okay, I want a home. Um, no, they started building all this spec, you know, built for rent, all this nonsense. And so, yeah, they didn't learn anything. And you know, Lenar got a bailout last time. We'll see what happens. But yeah, no, they are they are so screwed. And if you think that that's really only eight months of inventory that they have out there, that is so BS. Like, I I would say it's at least 25%, if not more. higher. They pull all kinds of tricks where
44:29they don't get their final certificate of occupancy, so it's not completed. I mean, it is, it's it they are in so much trouble. And I gotta tell you how many people told me I was crazy, like so crazy for so long. But yeah, they're they're in a lot of trouble.
44:44Ben Kellaran: Yeah, it is uh it does kind of go back to the point you made about hyper financialization, right? Where a lot of people even for for like even if you just separate the people that are not fundamental investors, the people that are fundamental investors and look at it from like an institutional side,
45:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): most
45:01Ben Kellaran: of them could give a shit about like what the business actually does. It's just the series of Excel inputs and outputs for them, right? And when when you kind of have that across the system, then you get a lot of the things that we've seen just for the last several decades where products, services, the way people behave in business continues to degrade, right? And it's it's frustrating to see because it's really something I mean, the obvious examples are where private equity starts to do some of the things that they do as far as their business practices. But is is there any reason we should have more private equity firms in the US than McDonald's? right
45:40Melody Wright: no it's awful they've they've ruined everything everything a your vet your uh HVAC operators your I mean just I mean medical let's just yeah your dentist your medical complex is and you know and it it's just hotels like this last trip just seeing the degradation of these hotel hotels, they've all been bought by private equity. And you just, you know
46:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that or
46:06Ben Kellaran: the Patel cartel.
46:08Melody Wright: Yeah. Well right. Those for sure. Yeah. Um, but you know, it's used to you'd have teas in the room. You'd have XYZ. Now you don't have any and it just and it's more expensive. And everybody's jerk. They're just jerks, you know. They did there's no hospitality. There's no like, oh, the customer's customer is always right anymore. Now it's the customer's always wrong. And I mean, and people are just rude. And so yeah, it's it's so it's it's it is upsetting. And you know, I'm definitely gonna take a break from traveling for a little while, even though I have to do a little trip in early December. But ooh, woo, that was quite a that was quite an experience. Yeah.
46:50Ben Kellaran: No, I've I've gotten to the point and this kind of goes I mean, I guess a little bit into the recent airport shutdowns and flights being delayed and whatnot, but I have to fly next week to go see family for Thanksgiving. I'm like I have to go through CTAC, which is basically most isolated Cantina these days, and I have to do like all this other stuff. It's like traveling is basically humiliation ritual these days for
47:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the city. It
47:13Melody Wright: really is. Yes.
47:14Ben Kellaran: For going through airports. And it's funny because you look at what
47:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
47:18Ben Kellaran: this is just like the same thing, but for like flying anywhere, you look at what it used to be forty, fifty years ago, and it's like okay, now it's cattle cars and basically it's insane some of the things that uh Yeah,
47:33Melody Wright: like
47:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
47:33Melody Wright: TSA people were like yelling at people. I mean, you
47:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
47:37Melody Wright: a lot of people don't travel a lot. I have, so I know what I'm supposed to do. But the other thing they do is they change. So every airport's different now. You know, usually we all knew. Take your socks off, take your I'm not your socks, your shoes, your belt, you know, put your laptop and your liquids in there, you know, blah, blah, blah. They literally change it all the time now. So you do not know. And then
47:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and then different airports you can do whole
47:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): backpack, other
47:59Ben Kellaran: airports
47:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is it's like chargers,
48:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): laptops, everything you can.
48:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): can't even leave. Yeah,
48:03Melody Wright: yeah. And so you're constantly like you say, you know, and then they'll yell at you if you don't understand. But there's no signs posted. Why not just post a sign that says what you're supposed to do? Nope. You know, and so it it is a humiliation ritual. Even like in Texas, they have the dogs too. I don't know if you have to walk past the dogs. Like, and it's a big freaking dog. It's just it's wild. And and I it I just like you say, I mean, I humiliation ritual is the best way to describe it. And I'm just so done. And but I think that's also, you know, on purpose because it's uh right, we don't have any diesel, like, or or it's really expensive. One or two, you know.
48:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
48:45Ben Kellaran: And
48:45Melody Wright: that's and that's they're really dissuading folks from traveling. That's what you can feel.
48:50Ben Kellaran: Yeah. No, I think it's uh
48:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it is
48:53Ben Kellaran: something too where you see pictures of the past and it's like, okay, why couldn't we have that now? It's like, well, you you look at uh the way people run things these days, it's like, okay, because we
49:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean
49:04Ben Kellaran: basically have lost their way in a lot of these things. So make make make flight attendance attractive again. That's my pitch for uh 2028.
49:12Melody Wright: There you
49:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): go.
49:14Ben Kellaran: You see some of these people as flight attendants. I'm like, okay, there's got to be a weight limit. Like, these aisles are not like that wide. It's like I don't know. It just seems to be uh
49:24Melody Wright: we've lost our minds. We've just lost our minds.
49:27Ben Kellaran: There's there's a lot of people ignoring reality, and I mean you can do that for so long, but you can't ignore the consequences of ignoring reality, I guess. But um, before I let you go, I do want to get into uh some of the commercial real estate side of things too,
49:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): because
49:41Ben Kellaran: that's been interesting to kind of see how that's uh slowed down, at least from what I've seen when I kind of poke around and see what rents are doing kind of in my area. But it's uh
49:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
49:52Ben Kellaran: does seem like there has been no new builds, there's no
49:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um no
49:58Ben Kellaran: rent growth in a lot of different places, and it's uh
50:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean
50:02Ben Kellaran: offices office uh is its own own ordeal, but well, what's kind of the situation on the commercial side?
50:06Melody Wright: Oh man, that's so bad, you know. And multifamily is going to end up being worse than office. Um, office, bunch of trophy property. There's just not much of it, is what I can. But yes, they're taking a bath right now. But multifamily is too. I just posted something from this morning. Um, because you know, in 21, 22. they people could get decent rates, but they get an arm or interest only or something like this. And now all they cannot get refinancing. And we overbuilt multifamily all over the country.
50:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
50:38Melody Wright: as you say, rents, um, rents have recently been firming just a tiny bit, but I think that has more to do with the timing of things, whereas you're your the largest cohort going into multifamily or to rentals are. actually um 65 plus. And I think it's like as they age out of their home, they go into rentals. So I think we'll see that a little bit of that. And then there's firming around these little boom towns that I was telling you about. Like, you know, the average rent our median rent in Abilene, Texas is twenty six hundred dollars in the and that's a city of 130,000 people. If you go like the average the median in the US is 1400. So people have just lost their minds. Um and so, but it is a bloodbath in multifamily right now. And we've got the like what's called a the the largest hard debt maturity wall this uh at the back half of this year that we've ever seen. Um, and that means that so we heard a lot about the maturity wall for a long time, but they had extensions. extension options in all of those. And that was the impetus to extend, extend, extend. But there are no more extension options. So you're just gonna start seeing this. And I mean, there's a story every day. So the real deal did an amazing series on this little
51:55band of criminals in Chicago
51:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): who
51:59Melody Wright: bought up all this multifamily, like inflated appraisal. So there's a multifamily fraud. We're hearing about at least one a week. And so, and I've I've done significant research into these securitizations. So those securitizations on the agency side, Fannie and Freddie, could very well end up being very similar to what happened on the single family residential last time because you have products like interest-only interest only arms, et cetera. So yeah, commercial real estate is amazing. a mess. And then office is, I mean, we we overbuilt, we we so overbuilt and we've done nothing about it. It's just sitting out there vacant. Um, that's going to have to be dealt with. And and you're starting to finally see that cycle through. And then God forbid, when these data centers,
52:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): when Well
52:46Melody Wright: they start slowing or they projects continue to be canceled, like that. that's gonna hit the sector because everybody said industrial wouldn't get hit. It's gonna get hit. So yeah, it's it's not looking good in commercial real estate at all.
53:01Ben Kellaran: Yeah, it is uh
53:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
53:03Ben Kellaran: it is interesting to kind of look at what happened in the building boom, kind of post-COVID and how it's all gonna flush through. But I look at like the data center office, like there's there's so many different things, and we haven't even really talked about how it's all tied to private equity, private credit, insurance. And it's just
53:22Melody Wright: yeah,
53:22Ben Kellaran: there's so many different things where it's this giant spider web and you can like listen to people pick apart just the insurance side for an hour and it's like a complete mess. And they pick apart the private equity and the then private credit, and you
53:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
53:35Ben Kellaran: you start to put together this picture and it's I mean
53:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Blackstone's
53:40Melody Wright: in it all, right? It's in it all. Apollo's in it all. Like it's like it's a spider web and it is massive. But it's like Blue Owl in software, but also data center. You know, like it's
53:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): just
53:53Melody Wright: it's awful. And and and it's the same players that did single family rentals, you know, and then they got into uh data centers. Oh yeah. And it it and I mean it is a massive mess. And so I really don't know how we I'm not really sure it, you know, it's going to be a a very interesting couple of years, put it that way.
54:16Ben Kellaran: Yeah. No, I think uh
54:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
54:19Ben Kellaran: it it's gonna be tough to see how like we I mean run it hot, make our way through this, like do all this stuff and it's like we I mean we talked about all these other things how they tie in but when you look at the country's financial situation too on the debt side of things is like that's not gonna do us any favors and no rates are not gonna I mean
54:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
54:40Ben Kellaran: don't I don't see them coming down much if at all like from um
54:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah like
54:44Ben Kellaran: definitely not a On long term basis like three to five years out like we're definitely either in uh
54:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
54:49Ben Kellaran: don't know eight to ten percent on rates or we're in yield curve control and we're just printing the difference, right? So right. Um
54:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
54:57Ben Kellaran: there anything that we kind of didn't uh didn't make our way around to covering or anything that's uh kind of top mind as we start to finish?
55:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
55:03Melody Wright: I just asked, what are your thoughts on these? Um uh all all these different uh you know issues with say Microsoft Outlook. Apple Pay, uh FAA, you know,
55:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
55:19Ben Kellaran: think I think if we departed a hundred million people and gave Americans jobs in American companies, then a lot of this stuff would not happen. Yeah. I think there's a lot of things where it's like, oh, Americans don't want to do these jobs or it's um we have to bring all these talented people over here. It's like
55:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
55:36Ben Kellaran: mean i if we can't keep on this pattern I don't see any reason why we shouldn't just deport some of these companies, basically. Right.
55:44Melody Wright: You
55:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): guys
55:44Ben Kellaran: are no longer allowed to operate here. Like this is uh not how we do business. But
55:49Melody Wright: people want a living wage. And and if they can get a living wage and they can buy a house and they can, you know, have those creature comforts, they'll do all kinds of jobs. All kinds of jobs. They won't care. Um but you know, we've we've really it the mainstream media has done a really good job at making the certain jobs look like crappy jobs. But in reality, somebody could be very happy doing that job if they are getting paid a living wage that they can do things like, you know, provide for their kids. But if they can't even do that, I mean they're dis I mean around here we have a huge uh gr you know, because we got Appalachia was just um besieged by drugs and things like this. So a lot of people live on benefits. And and many people want to get off them, but the minute they try to go work full time, they get a full time job, like maybe at Wendy's, they can't they can't get the benefits anymore, but they can't afford basic necessities either. And so it really disincentivizes work. So yeah, we've got a lot, a lot of work. to do to turn this around, in my opinion.
56:55Ben Kellaran: Yeah, no, there's uh a lot of things that I think would be a very quick fix. Um, and the problem is political will from our current political system is not there. So
57:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's
57:06Ben Kellaran: it, that's where we're at. And I think the midterms kind of fuck that where it's not uh
57:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
57:11Ben Kellaran: don't think people really want the Democrats, and I mean I definitely don't. Like you're not gonna see me v voting for the We Hate White Men Party, right? But right the the the the Republicans are not exactly following through on what they promised either. So I kind of look
57:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at
57:27Ben Kellaran: and say, hey, like tell both of you guys. So yeah.
57:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
57:32Ben Kellaran: Anyway, um before I let you go, where should uh my leftist leaders look to find you or find your work?
57:37Melody Wright: Sure. So they can vote. find me on X Twitter at M3 underscore Melody and then my Substack, M3 Melody Substack. I really encourage even the free version of that because I take you through how if you know you can do some of this analysis yourself. Um in this data center tour report that's being put together by Unicus Research. If you're a paid subscriber subscriber, you get a significant discount. And I mean this is a massive report. It's it's really uh I think very interesting. But and then I will hopefully be going back to my own YouTube, uh, kind of at the end of the month, M3 Melody YouTube.
58:15Ben Kellaran: Nice, definitely, uh, definitely worth checking out the Substack and all the other places. But um to slide in my traditional closing question, what book should I do my reading list?
58:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh,
58:26Melody Wright: so this is a good one. I just uh uh listened to the show with Dave Collin, um
58:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): G
58:33Melody Wright: J Edward Griffin. I always forget names, I'm terrible, but and someone else. And I'm reading the someone else's book. It's called 180. It is very fascinating. And it's basically just about what you thought you knew. It's not reality at all. So it's a very fun uh interesting read. Uh just it turns things upside down. And I think people a and that's exactly what they say is like when you think reality is this weight, turn it one hundred eighty, and that's really what it is. So yeah,
59:03Ben Kellaran: it's a good one. That's the old CA line is uh we'll we'll know we've succeeded when everything Americans believe is a lie, right?
59:10Melody Wright: Exactly.
59:11Ben Kellaran: That's uh
59:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in a
59:12Ben Kellaran: lot of ways, I think where we are, but it does seem like since twenty twenty a lot of people are starting to wake up on these things.
59:17Melody Wright: Agreed. I think so.
59:19Ben Kellaran: Yeah, well, can't happen fast enough in my opinion. But we'll have to see where things go. It's definitely uh interesting time to um be following real estate, these different markets, they're uh definitely all tied together. And I do get the feeling that uh we might be watching the Titanic, but that's uh I I think enough of the doomerism for me. for today.
59:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But uh
59:40Ben Kellaran: I I I I really do appreciate it coming on. I think people will uh enjoy it. And I think with that will be wrapping up. Thanks
59:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for
59:46Ben Kellaran: stopping by and we'll see you next time.