Sound Investing

Paul Merriman

Weekly podcasts with Paul Merriman. Strategic planning for investing at every stage of life.

Sound Investing

Vanguard vs. DFA & Avantis

Episode discussion: Speaker compares Vanguard, DFA, and Avantis funds, discussing factor investing, portfolio construction, and behavioral risks.

Speakers’ claims: The speaker contrasts Vanguard's traditional index tracking with the factor-based approaches of Dimensional (DFA) and Avantis, noting Avantis's lower expense ratios and ETF structure. He analyzes performance data for various funds, including Avantis Large Cap Value (AVLC) and global equity options, suggesting diversified splits to mitigate concentration risk. The discussion extends to portfolio construction, highlighting Fidelity's low-cost rebalancing services and advising against extreme small-cap value allocations for retirees due to volatility and behavioral risks. Finally, he emphasizes the importance of understanding drawdowns and using systematic fund selection criteria.

Factor InvestingDFAAvantis
1h 11m1 assets24 claims to verify
Sound Investing

Important Research on Adding Value and Profitablity to Your Portfolio

Episode discussion: Speaker compares factor investing vs indexing, cites Avantis study on tilted portfolios and proposes hybrid strategy

Speakers’ claims: The speaker reviews 2026 market performance, noting a divergence between tech stock declines and S&P 500 gains. He compares factor investing providers like Avantis and Dimensional against Vanguard, highlighting Avantis's outperformance in US large and small cap categories. An Avantis study is cited, claiming value and profitability tilts can increase compound annual returns by up to 4.5%. The speaker addresses the psychological challenge of tracking error and proposes a hybrid portfolio strategy for retirees. He concludes by emphasizing the importance of balancing risk-adjusted returns with tax efficiency and psychological comfort.

Factor InvestingAvantisVanguard
51 min8 assets12 claims to verify